Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Chinese migrants to California during the 1800s. Three of the sources deal
directly with the newspapers of California and how they chose to represent
readership. The last article deals with the Chinese response to these
Taken together these articles demonstrate that the press can have a
significant impact on the beliefs and practices of people and that can have
The first article deals with how Chinese people were portrayed in four
the case that from 1849-1869 Chinese immigrants were desirable due to the
labor shortage needed to build the railroads.1 But when the transcontinental
competition led to the belief that Chinese workers were taking away jobs that
should go to white workers first.2 It did not help that Chinese workers were
willing to work for less, which depressed wages for all workers.3
1 Herman B. Chiu and Andrew Taylor Kirk, Unlimited American Power: How Four
California Newspapers Covered Chinese Labor and the Building of the
Transcontinental Railroad, 18651869 American Journalism (2014):509.
2 Herman B. Chiu and Andrew Taylor Kirk, Unlimited American Power, 521
3 Ibid., 521.
Nate Sloat 2
What is interesting is that in the mountain areas that interacted with the
largely indifferent. In most cases when the progress of the railroad was
stated, there was no mention of who was building it, and definitely not
the railroad, but not wanting to acknowledge that an inferior race (in their
When the Chinese did make it into the paper, it was not for the right
press was sure to report it, and generally put the migrant in a negative light.
What is significant is that names were still not used but rather referred to the
about Chinese immigrants, that they were dirty criminals and spreaders of
strike.7 It was believed that they could learn new tasks faster, and master
create separate teams of each race and would pit them against each other to
4 Ibid., 516.
5 Ibid., 519.
6 Ibid., 519.
7 Ibid., 510.
8 Ibid., 510.
Nate Sloat 3
see which could build the railroad the fastest.9 Which probably contributed to
even if the stereotypes are positive, they still make attempts to lump certain
groups together and show how that group is different from the white
east coast ones. In How the Other Half Lives, Riis describes Chinese workers
as being incredibly clean but they are also very likely to smoke opium.10
However, nowhere in any of the sources from the West coast is opium
very easy to add in, if readers associated opium with Chinese workers. There
is also no mockery of Chinese accents like there is in How the Other Half
Lives.11 It seems unlikely that Chinese immigrants to the east and west coast
would have different speech patterns, and so would receive such criticism
and Riis book of 10 years, but that should not be able to account for these
significant differences.
9 Ibid., 510.
10 Jacob Riis, How the Other Half Lives (London: Penguin Books, 1997), 92.
12 Ibid., 94.
Nate Sloat 4
The article also discusses how there are phases to assimilation for any ethnic
group to become accepted American citizens. That initially the Irish were
Chinatowns quickly and so did not have as many interactions with whites,
and in some cases that interaction were actively discouraged.14 There was
Americans since the vast majority of migrants were men and did not bring
wives or other woman with them. Also, the issue that the rate of migration
increased so quickly that in the minds of many, it reached the point of being
a threat far faster than it had with other migrant groups and prevented
assimilation.15
They helped to establish some of the stereotypes that are seen in other
Including the constant influence of immigrants from the East coast who had
not interacted with Chinese migrants. The first cartoons titled Pacific
Chivalry has a Chinese migrant being pulled back by his braid by a white
man labeled California while swinging a cat of nine tails. In the background
15 Herman B. Chiu and Andrew Taylor Kirk, Unlimited American Power, 522.
Nate Sloat 5
migrants typically do and the jobs they are taking away. Also in the
Extra Taxes to Yellowjack.16 This demonstrates not only that there was
hostility from individual workers, but also that the legal systems were
had to pay the tax until it was struck down by a Chinese led lawsuit in Lin
Sung v. Washburn.18
are used to stereotype Chinese men so that they are more easily identifiable
to political comic viewers. There are several telescopes, each with separate
words printed on the side, including capitalist, the press, politicians, and
workingman, who are all watching the arrival of Chinese workers. There is
also a poster with several statements indicating the evil of the Chinese labor
and how it is going to bring down the trade unions. The rest of the image is
filled with strikers who are all trying to strike for higher wages.19 This image
18 Ibid., 32.
19 Thomas Nast, The Comet of Chinese Labor Harpers Weekly, June 13, 1870.
Nate Sloat 6
depicts the very one sided prospective of east coast people on the Chinese;
they were seen primarily as strike breakers, who would accept lower wages
The last Comic is Every dog has his day! shows an interaction between a
Native American and a Chinese migrant. The bottom of the comic states
Pale face fraid you crowd him out, as he did me. It draws upon the idea
that America is a nation of immigrants, but that there were Native Americans
here before they arrived and, as immigrants, they saw little reason not to
chronology of American racism. With the most recent racial policies at the
top showing Californian protests, and the Chinese exclusion act. Then
towards the bottom it states the older periods of racism, like the anti-
there is an African American, given some ape like features that are typical of
the cartoons from the time, with writing stating, My day is coming.20 This
comic clearly demonstrates that in the minds of the artist, America does not
have a Chinese problem in particular, but rather it has a problem with any
immigrant group or anyone who does not fit in immediately with the status
immigrant and varied its political stance on other issues, but initially was pro
20 Thomas Nast, Every dog Has His day Harpers Weekly, February 8, 1879.
Nate Sloat 7
democrat. The irony of this paper was that the three brothers who were first
migrant who had been a part of a coup attempt against the Prussian
government.21 It is clear that neither of these groups had much respect for
magazine was not exclusively anti-Chinese but also took shots at many
Mormons, Mexicans, and Africans, though there were very few in California.22
1877, the magazine gave up its party affiliations believing that government
corruption and inaction would not pass the immigration policies that the
magazine wanted. Thereafter, the magazine took shots at both parties and
often times politics in general.23 This enabled the magazine to place blame
upon the government for the Chinese immigration problem rather than
reflecting upon the Californian role in the issue. For instance they published a
comic titled The Three Troublesome Children, which pointed out Uncle
21 Nicholas Sean Hall, The Wasp's Troublesome Children: Culture, Satire, and the
Anti-Chinese Movement in the American West California History (2013): 45.
23 Ibid., 46.
Nate Sloat 8
Sams lack of interest in the problem of Chinese immigrants and that the
The article also discussed how the magazine often times mocked the
political parties whose main two aims were anti-immigrant and anti-
monopoly. They called for the railroads to fire all Chinese Americans and
were often depicted in cartoons as taking violence into their own hands.25
The magazine often times mocked the actions that the party took, but
approved of the ends they tried to achieve. One cartoon titled The Chinese
Must Go! But Who Keeps them? mocks how the WPC led by Denis Kearney
would preach, but would not act, to end the immigration.26 That the workers
Chinese cigar workers for their cigar box company.27 What this does
important part of the economy of California and that they had become well
enough engrained into society that they would be difficult to remove.28 Often
24 Ibid., 48.
25 Ibid., 56.
26 Ibid., 60
27 Ibid., 59.
28 Ibid., 61.
Nate Sloat 9
times even when boycotts of Chinese good were attempted, the Chinese
could stay within their enclaves and be able to sustain themselves for the
most part.29
An interesting point that is illustrated by the article is the push and pull
increased job opportunities from the railroads and the gold mines as the
main cause of immigration. However, just as important were the push factors
for Chinese immigration; in the wake of the opium wars (1839-1842 and
Empire.30 To pay for this, the Chinese government enforced high taxes upon
What this illustrates is that even before coming to China, the Chinese were
already the victims of white imperialism. Their situation then was not so
different from the European workers that were pushed to leave their own
in America, and for many Californians this was an indication that California
should support similar policies against the Chinese as were being instituted
against African Americans in the south. The third article helps to illustrate
some of these practices and the Chinese immigrants reaction to them, often
31 Ibid., 52.
Nate Sloat 10
times looking at the city of San Jose where the Chinese migrants could not
naturalize and could not earn the right to voteintimidation was not needed
to take away the ballot. Chinese Americans were not allowed to own property
Towns.32 So, the Chinese just rented the land from sympathetic whites and
carried on, or became sharecroppers.33 When that did not work San Jose also
However, they connected to the sewer anyway and it was of a higher quality
Jose, especially arson. The first three China Towns in San Jose were all burned
down which forced the local Chinese population to take preventative action.35
In response, they built two more Chinatowns and in these later towns, they
built their own fire hydrant system with their own fire department.36 They
also built a fence with barbed wire around the China town to deter white
33 Ibid., 33.
34 Ibid., 31.
35 Ibid., 31.
36 Ibid., 31.
37 Ibid., 31.
Nate Sloat 11
themselves, especially with .38 caliber bullets, used in handguns for self-
defense.38
repeated efforts to push them out and that the Chinese migrants were here
to stay. When the laws became particularly harsh they engaged in a number
of court cases to protect their freedoms.39 Being organized into local districts
they were able to come together as a community to fund the legal process.40
Often times, they found much more success at the State Level then they did
at the federal level; there were still a number of laws that passed despite
1880.42 This disdain for interracial marriages was reiterated in Wasp, which
made a cartoon illustrating the children from mixed race couples would be
deformed and ape like.43 This only further deterred any possibility of the
Chinese migrants integrating into American society, even though they were
38 Ibid., 33-34.
39 Ibid., 32.
40 Ibid., 30.
41 Ibid., 30.
42 Ibid., 30.
not able to have many Chinese children in America, since there were very
A key point of contrast between the different sources is the perspective that
is generated by the east coast comics created by Thomas Nast and the other
west coast sources. The west coast sees the Chinese as a much more hostile
force that is invading the country and is disrupting the American way of life.
This is primarily because the west coast experienced a much larger influx of
Asian workers than the East coast did; the east coast comics certainly
indicated that the problem was largely imagined. As one pastor stated, the
Chinese scare, is the greatest humbug that has ever been enacted.45 The
and that the Chinese people are victims of American hostility rather than the
aggressors in the situation. They implied that the Californians have to share
in the blame for any violence that results from white aggression. The east
coast comics are also much more reflective upon past immigration issues,
coast has experienced a majority of the immigration over the course of the
nations history and probably did not see it as a serious problem. There is
also a difference in the industries that the Chinese immigrants are involved
in, such as the Chinese Americans on the east coast that were primarily used
44 Ibid., 52.
45 Ibid., 54.
Nate Sloat 13
There is also the idea that, as people move west, they are no longer
Americanizes people to fit the cultural norms. So, rather than having the
that makes the Chinese immigration situation more significant and explains
themselves as white and everyone else as others whereas on the east coast,
especially in the big cities, people held onto their unique European culture.
Therefore on the east coast it was easier to keep that idea of America as a
nation of immigrants if one was from the west coast, and that the Chinese
The articles all deal with the idea of what does it mean to be an
and ideas that shape what characterizes an American. This era in American
with them a distinct culture and practices that change the American identity.
It is interesting that like all immigrant groups there is a period before they
are fully accepted into American society, when they can be considered on an
equal footing with the other ethnic groups. What does make this transition
more difficult for Asian immigrants is that they are more physically
identifiable as immigrants. It also fits into the classroom trend that the white
Nate Sloat 14
there are growing cultural differences between these groups, there are still
the twentieth century, Americans were all tied together not by cultural
homogeneity but through ideology. Through the new ideas of patriotism, duty
gender. That through the state there could be a new idea of what it meant to
of the Chinese immigrant to America during the 1860s to 1880s. They faced
racist actions in many forms, and they had to read about it in the
newspapers of California. But the articles also help to demonstrate that there
were cultural differences between the east and west coast in their perception