Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Internal Medical Clinic I, Centre of Extracorporeal Therapy and Autoimmunity (CETA), University of Bonn,
Bonn, Germany
Abstract: Plasmapheresis is a well-accepted treatment suffering from HTG. The expected mortality of the collec-
option in severe hypertriglyceridemia-induced pancreatitis tive was 25%. Plasmapheresis was started after an average
(HTGP). The rationale behind this approach is the deple- 16.3 h (SD 6.7 h) after onset of symptoms. No mortality
tion of triglycerides and the reduction of inflammatory occurred. Apheresis was statistically equally effective with
cytokines. The time span between onset of clinical symp- both devices. A median of 3 sessions reduced the TG level
toms and start of plasmapheresis might have an important to normal and correlated with patients improvement.
impact on mortality. Hyperviscosity of patients plasma During follow up, three patients developed a pancreatic
represents another special challenge for the applied sepa- pseudocyst requiring surgical intervention without further
ration technology. The procedures can be performed either complication. Key Words: Hypertriglyceridemia, Pan-
by centrifugal device (CFD) or membrane based (MBS) creatitis, Plasmapheresis.
units. The present study reports the outcome of 10 patients
405
406 H Zeitler et al.
for Apheresis (ASFA) therefore suggests it as a the Balthazar score (15) as defined; Grade A: Normal
Grade 2C indication (10,11). The procedure can be pancreasnormal size, sharply defined, smooth
performed either with centrifugal device (CFD) or contour, homogeneous enhancement, retroperitoneal
with membrane based separation (MBS) units. The peripancreatic fat without enhancement; Grade
hyperviscous plasma in HTGP represents a special B: Focal or diffuse enlargement of the pancreas,
challenge for the applied separation technology. contour may show irregularity, enhancement may
Data comparing both methods with respect to treat- be inhomogeneous but there is no peripancreatic
ment efficacy and patient outcome are therefore of inflammation; Grade C: Peripancreatic inflammation
great interest. The present study retrospectively with intrinsic pancreatic abnormalities; Grade D:
analyzes the results for 10 patients suffering from Intrapancreatic or extrapancreatic fluid collection;
HTGP who underwent either CFD or MBS based Grade E: Two or more large collections of gas in the
plasmapheresis. pancreas or retroperitoneum.
Information was gathered on demographic data,
patients family history of dyslipidemia, and patients
PATIENTS AND METHODS
history of dyslipidemia, medical treatment, diabetes,
Patients arterial hypertension, alcohol consumption, smoking
This observational retrospective study analyzes 10 and former episodes of pancreatitis. Patients charac-
patients admitted at the Emergency Unit, Medical teristics on admission are summarized in Table 1.
Clinic I University of Bonn from 2009 to 2014. All Plasmapheresis was performed either with a centrifu-
patients experienced the diagnosis of HTGP and gal device using a Cobe Optia (Gambro, Lund,
were treated by plasmapheresis. The diagnosis of Sweden) or as a membrane plasma separation (MPS)
HTGP was based on patients clinical symptoms performed by Octonova (Diamed Medizintechnik,
(upper abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting) and was Cologne, Germany) using a Plasmaflo filter OP-05W
confirmed by biochemical and radiological examina- (L), a polyethylene hollow fiber membrane. The
tions. Biochemical analyses performed were: choles- filter allows blood flow rates of 80130 mL/min,
terol, triglycerides, lipase, alpha amylase, CRP, GOT, with plasma filtration rates of 2040 mL/min, and a
GPT, yGT, calcium, potassium, magnesium, red blood transmembranous pressure (TMP) maximum of
cell counts, creatinine, glucose and HbA1c. The diag- 45 mm Hg. The anticoagulation of the centrifugal
nosis was confirmed by ultrasonic and abdominal procedure was performed with a combination of acid
computer tomography (CT) according to the Atlanta citrate monohydrate solution (Fenwal ACD-A
classification (12). CT was performed in general Fenwal Europe sprl, Mont Saint Guibert, Belgium)/
within 72 h after onset of symptoms to diagnose the heparin combination. The extracorporeal system was
complexity of pancreatic damage. primed with ACD-A and 2500 IU heparin. When
All patients were classified for disease severity apheresis started, another bolus of 2500 IU heparin
according to the APACHE II (13) and the Ranson was given into the arterial inflow line. The ratio of
score (14). The grade of pancreatitis was verified ACD-A to plasma was in general a maximum of 1:8
by computer tomography severity index based on 1:10, and could be adapted to the blood flow with
Apa, APACHE II score; Assoc. Dis., associated disorder; Balt, Balthazar score; BG, blood glucose mg/dL; Ca, serum calcium mmol/L; Chol,
cholesterol mg/dL; CRP, C reactive protein mg/L; DF, diet failure; DL, dyslipidemia; DM, diabetes mellitus; Lip, lipase U/L; na, not available;
NODM, new onset of diabetes mellitus; Ran, Ranson score; RI, renal impairment; TG, Triglycerides mg/dL.
Time from onset of symptoms until start of plasmapheresis in hours, numbers of plasmapheresis sessions; AE, adverse events of
plasmapheresis; BP, low blood pressure; PV%, percentage part of the exchanged plasma volume per treatment; TG%, percentage decrease
of triglyceride level per treatment; Unit 1, centrifugal device (CFD); Unit 2, membrane based plasma separation (MBS).
lower rates of 1:151:20. To protect the patient from plasmapheresis treatment are summarized in Table 2.
hypocalcemia, continuous 10% calcium gluconate For each patient, data were recorded concerning time
infusion was added to the venous bloodline. As vas- to onset of apheresis and the clinical symptoms, the
cular access a Shaldon catheter was used in all MPS number of plasmapheresis sessions the exchanged
treated patients, whereas five patients of the CFD volume, the replacement procedures, complications
group could be treated by peripheral vascular access. and adverse effects of apheresis, hospitalization
CFD allows lower blood flow rates of 5080 mL/min days, as well as any other clinical events during the
and, depending on inflow rate, plasma flow rates of hospitalization.
2040 mL/min. In MPS the extracorporeal system
was primed with 5000 IU heparin. During treatment Data analysis
a heparin based continuous infusion of 600 All statistical analyses were performed using the
1000 IU/h depending on blood/plasma flow rates and Statistical Package for Social Sciences, version 22.0
TMP (<45 mm Hg), was performed. The exchanged (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA). Descriptive statistics have
plasma volume was adapted to the patients clinical been used to characterize the study population. Non-
situation. In general, 0.71.0 equivalents of the calcu- parametric statistics, the Spearmans-Rho rank corre-
lated plasma volume was intended to be exchanged. lation (rs) and the MannWhitney U-test were used.
As a replacement solution 5% albumin was chosen. The clinical and technical parameters related to
The TG levels were measured before and after each extracorporeal treatment groups were compared
procedure. Plasmapheresis was continued until a TG using the MannWhitney U-test. A P-value of 0.05 or
level below 500 mg/dL was achieved. Clinical data of less was considered statistically significant.
onset of symptoms (18).The decrease of TG results in stitution. The advantage of CFD is that lower blood
a rapid lowering of the abdominal pain and patients flow rates allow treatment via peripheral veins.
nausea. In our collective a reduction of TG to Avoiding a central venous access might be preferable
<500 mg/dL required three apheresis sessions in for some patients, especially since only two to three
nearly all patients. An increased rate of plasma sessions have to be performed. The role of heparin in
exchange volume results in a progressive loss of the treatment of HTGP is controversial (20). Heparin
coagulation factors when the chosen substitute is 5% stimulates the release of endothelial lipoprotein
albumin and not fresh frozen plasma. In our experi- lipase into the circulation and causes a rapid reduc-
ence an exchange of 7080% of patients plasma tion of the TG level by converting them into free fatty
results in a 50% reduction of coagulation factors. acids. Recently published data from Nasstrm et al.
Hence, patients bleeding risk increases, especially show that flesh frozen plasma (FFA) are involved in
since the initial treatment requires intensive the inflammatory process of HTGP (21,22). Heparin
anticoagulation to avoid system clotting. Gubensek may worsen the condition and is not recommended
et al. described intestinal bleedings as a side effect of as a mono-treatment of HTGP (23). A rapid deple-
apheresis (19). Bleeding into the inflamed pancreatic tion of the lipoprotein lipase storage retards the TG
tissue leads to additional organ damage, which can clearing rate and has been reported in patients under
cause the formation of pancreatic pseudocysts. In our hemodialysis (22). These effects of heparin were not
collective the clinical outcome was not different seen under TG depletion during plasmapheresis.
between the MBS patients and the CFD group. Although early start of plasmapheresis leads to a fast
As mentioned above the chosen substitute during control of the acute clinical situation, the late onset
plasmapheresis in our collective was 5% albumin. In complications like pancreatic pseudocyst formation
rare cases of patients with genetically proven Apo were not prevented in three patients. These patients
CII or LCAT deficiency the substitution of fresh underwent successful surgical interventions. The
frozen plasma during or after plasmapheresis might benefit of apheresis was questioned by one study
be beneficial as it corrects the dyslipidemia (3,4). published in 2004 by Chen et al. where an improved
Due to the potential infection risk of fresh frozen outcome among HTGP patients treated with plasma-
plasma, its use should be reserved for rare clinical pheresis vs. conventional treatment was not seen
conditions where lipid disorders are genetically (24). Finally, the answer to this question requires
proven. In the future, genetic testing of lipid disorders randomized double blind controlled studies, which
might allow a better individualized treatment deci- might be, in our opinion, ethically problematic
sion. In the absence of genetic testing our study according to recent published data supporting the
therefore has some clinical limitations. Plasmapher- benefit of plasmapheresis in this high risk patient
esis in HTGP is a special challenge because it collective (7,1619,23,25).
requires adequate anticoagulation due to plasma
hyperviscosity, especially during the first apheresis
session, when the excessive TG levels can occlude the REFERENCES
extracorporeal system. Gubensek et al. reported that
1. Kyriakidis AV, Raitsioz B, Sakagianni A et al. Management of
in 10% of procedures the plasma filter had to be acute Severe Hyperlipidemic Pancreatitis. Digestion 2006;73:
replaced and in up to 3% the filter was clotted (19). In 25964.
our collective the combined ACDA/heparin during 2. Berglund L, Brunzell J, Goldberg AC et al. Treatment options
for hypertriglyceridemia: from risk reduction to pancreatitis.
CFD, as well as the continuous anticoagulation with Best Pract Res Clin Endocrinol Metab 2014;28:42337.
heparin, prevented system clotting sufficiently. Com- 3. Watts GF, Mitropoulos KA, al-Bahrani A et al. Lecithin
paring CFD with MBS, no statistical differences con- cholesterol acyltransferase deficiency presenting with acute
pancreatitis: effect of infusion of normal plasma on triglyceride
cerning efficacy and safety of therapy were seen. rich lipoproteins. J Intern Med 1995;238:13741.
Therefore, a treatment decision can be made based 4. Gan SI, Edwards AL, Symond CJ et al. Hypertriglyceridemia
on the availability of the apheresis device in the induced pancreatitis: a case based review. World J
Gastroenterol 2006;12:197202.
medical center. Episodes of low blood pressure at the 5. Zheng C. Updates on apolipoprotein CIII: fulfilling promise as
end of apheresis sessions were seen in four patients a therapeutic target for hypertriglyceridemia and cardiovascu-
treated with CFD compared to only one patient in lar disease. Curr Opin Lipidol 2014;25:359.
6. Kawakami A, Yoshida M. Apolipoprotein CIII links
the MBS group. Hypotonic blood pressure might dyslipidemia with Artherosclerosis. J Atheroscler Thromb
be triggered by the ACDA anticoagulation enhanc- 2009;16:611.
ing hypocalcemia that already pre-exists due to pan- 7. Lennertz A, Parhofer KG, Samtleben W et al. Therapeutic
plasma exchange in patients with chylomicronemia syndrome
creatitis. The symptoms subsided promptly under complicated by acute pancreatitis. Ther Apher 1999;3:227
additional calcium gluconate infusion and fluid sub- 33.
8. Escobar J, Pereda J, Arduini A et al. Cross talk between oxi- 17. Furuya T, Komatsu M, Takahashi K et al. Plasma exchange for
dative stress and pro-inflammatory cytokines in acute pancrea- hypertriglyceridemic acute necrotizing pancreatitis: report of
titis: a key role for protein phosphatases. Curr Pharm Des two cases. Ther Apher 2002;6:4548.
2009;15:302742. 18. Syed H, Bilusic M, Rhondla C et al. Plasmapheresis in the
9. Deng LH, Xue P, Xia Q et al. Effect of admission treatment of hypertriglyceridemia-induced pancreatits; a com-
hypertriglyceridemia on the episodes of severe pancreatitis. munity hospitals experience. J Clin Apheresis 2010;25:22934.
World Gastroenterol 2008;14:455861. 19. Gubensek J, Buturovic Ponikvar J, Marn Pernat B et al.
10. Stefanutti C, Labbadia G, Morozzi C et al. Severe Treatment of hyperlipidemic acute pancreatits with plasma
hypertriglyceridemia related acute pancreatitis. Ther Apher exchange: a single centre experience. Ther Apher Dial 2009;13:
Dial 2013;17:1307. 3147.
11. Al Humoud H, Alhumoud E, Al Hilali N. Therapeutic plasma 20. Sleth JC, Lafforgue E, Servais R et al. A case of
exchange for acute hyperlipidemic pancreatitis: a case series. hypertriglyceridemic induced pancreatitis in pregnancy:
Ther Apher Dial 2008;12:2024. value of heparin. Ann Fr Anesth Reanim 2004;23:8357.
12. Banks PA, Bollen TL, Dervenis C et al. Classification of acute 21. Nasstrm B, Olivecrona G, Olivecrona T et al. Lipoprotein
pancreatitis -2012: revisions from the Atlanta classification and lipase during continuous heparin infusion: tissue stores
definitions by international consensus. Gut 2013;62:10211. become partially depleted. J Lab Clin Med 2001;138:20613.
13. Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP et al. APACHE II: a 22. Nasstrm B, Stegmayr B, Gupta J et al. A single bolus of low
severity of disease classification system. Crit Care Med weight heparin to patients on hemodialysis depletes lipopro-
1985;13:81829. tein lipase stores and retards triglyceride clearing. Nephrol
14. Ranson JH. Ethiological and prognostic factors in human Dial Transplant 2005;20:11729.
acute pancreatitis: a review. Am J Gastroenterol 1982;77:6338. 23. Ewald N, Kloer HU. Severe Hypertriglyceridemia: an indica-
15. Balthazar EJ, Robinson DI, Megibow AJ. Acute pancreatitis: tion for apheresis? Artheroscler Suppl 2009;10:4952.
value of CT in establishing prognosis. Radiology 1990;174: 24. Chen JH, Yeh JH, Lai HW et al. Therapeutic plasma exchange
3316. in patients with hyperlipidemic pancreatits. World J
16. Ramirez-Bueno A, Salzar-Ramirez C, Cota Delgado F et al. Gastroenterol 2004;10:22724.
Plasmapheresis as treatment for hyperlipidemic pancreatitis. 25. Stefanutti C, Morozzi C, Perrone G. The lipid and lipo(a)
Eur J Intern Med 2014;25:1603. apheresis techniques. Updating. G Chir 2012;33:44449.