Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

EVALUATION OF THE ANXIOLYTIC EFFECTS OF

CHRYSIN, A PASSIFLORA INCARNATA EXTRACT, IN


THE LABORATORY RAT
CRT Eric (Walter) Browti, CRNA, MSN, ANC, USA
Fort Knox. Kenimby
CPTNeil S. Hurd, CRNA, MSN, ANC, USA
1, i .dHjol lUU

Suzanne McCall
Brooke Army Medical Center, San Antonio. Texas
LTC Thomas E. Ceremuga, CRNA, PhD, ANC. USA
fon Sam thiNon. icxiis

The definitive anxiolytic effects of Passiflora incarnata are ioral component of anxialysis, and catecholamine and cor-
unknown. We studied the potential anxiolytic effects of ticosterone assays were examined to measure the neuro-
chrysin, a Passiflora extract, and the purported modulation hormonal effects of anxiety.
of the benzodiazepine receptor on the GABA^ receptor in No statistical difference was found among groups in cat-
laboratory rats. We hypothesized that chrysin decreases echolamine and carticosterone levels. Midazotam signifi-
anxiety via interaction with the GABA^ receptor in labora-
cantly decreased anxiety compared with control and
tory rats as measured by elevated plus-maze (EPM), corti-
flumazenil plus chrysin groups (P < .05); there was no sig-
casterone, and catecholamine assoys.
nificant difference compared with the chrysin group. These
We randomized 44 mole Sprague-Dawtey rats In a dou-
data suggest that chrysin may have anxiolytic properties
ble-blind, placebo-controlled, between-subjects experi-
simitar to midazolam but to o lesser magnitude at the 2-
mental design. Each animal received an intraperitoneai
mg/kg dose used in this study.
injection of (1) vehicle (DMSO 4%), (2) chrysin, 2 mg/kg,
(3) midazalam, 1.5 mg/kg, or (4) ftumazenil, 3 mg/kg and Key wards: Anxiety, chrysin, elevated plus-maze, Passiflora
chrysin, 2 mg/kg. The EPM was used to evaluate the behav- incarnata.

I
t is estimated thai 19 million adults in the (light or flight). This sympathetic nervous system
United States suffer from some type of anxiety activation results in increased heart and respiratory
disorder, with costs of more than $42 billion a rates, glycolysis, and stimulation of the release of var-
year.' Anxiety disorders are not relegated only to ious neurohormonal mediators. As anxiety results in
the United States, but are ubiquitous across cul- activation of the stress response, prolonged anxiety
tures.^ These anxieties range from mild, sueh as fear and exposure to stressors may lead to fatigue and a
of strange situations (eg, operating room) or public weakened immune system/ predisposing people to
speaking, to severe that may be incapacitating and illness.
result in job loss, Most patients admitted to the operating room for
According to Selye, anxiety, along with many other surgery experience anxiety and subsequent activation
physiological and psychological stimuli, can activate a of the stress response. Factors associated with activa-
stress response, resulting in the release of endocrine tion of the stress response place patients at greater risk
and neurotransmitter mediators. The hypothalamus- for adverse outcomes and predispose them to a more
pituitary axis is activated, resulting in increased secre- complicated anesthetic plan. Anxiety activates the
tion of adrenocortieotropic hormone, which then stress response, resulting in increased neuroendocrine
stimulates the release of corticosteroids from the adre- mediators (elevated catecholatnines and cortisol lev-
nal cortex. The elevated plasma corticosteroid levels els), which may be deleterious to a patient with a ten-
arc modulators in the biological response to stress. uous cardiovascular status, resulting in an adverse
Anxiety-inducing stress also activates the sympathetic outcome or in poor would healing."*^ Reducing pre-
nervous system, stimulating the release of cate- operative anxiety by the administration of anxiolytic
cholarnines (ie, epinephrine and norepinephrine) drugs is an important component of anesthesia
from the adrenal medulla as a response to stressors because it is necessary to decrease patients' distress to

www.aana.com/aanajournal.aspx AANA journal/October 2007/Vo\. 75, No. 5 333


avert physiologic and emotional sequelae of the stress '^ reported that the flavonoid extract, chrysin
response. Benzodiazepines frequently reduce anxiety, (5,7 dihydroxyflavone), is responsible for the anxi-
pain, and cardiovascular activation in the treatment of olytic properties of P incarnata in rodents, with the
chest pain.'' In addition, emotional feelings of well- site of action being the y-aminobutyrie acid (GABA)^
being and decreased anxiety related to surgery have receptor.
been demonstrated to improve patient satisfaction and Although 1 study in humans showed anxiolytic
may decrease recovery time. effects of P incarnata using an observatory tool to
The 3 most common benzodiazepines administered score anxiety,''^ most of the limited investigation of the
preoperatively for anxiolysis are diazepam (Valium), anxiolytic effects of P incarnata has been conducted in
lorazepam (Ativan), and midazolam (Versed), with the rodent model.'^'^^**'^^ The limited number of P
up to 75% of healthy adults'* and children*^ receiving incarnata and chrysin studies regarding anxiety have
midazolam for anxiolysis before surgery. Midazolam is solely examined the behavioral component of anxiol-
primarily used for anxiolysis, amnesia, and to enhance ysis without physiologic confirmation or corrobora-
patient compliance during the preinduetion and tion of these behavioral data. There are no studies in
induction period.^'^'^^ Other medications have been the review of literature about the neurohormonal
used for sedation and anxiety, sueh as barbiturates, stress response (corticosteroid or catecholamine
antihistamines, and over-the-counter supplements. release) in rodents receiving P incarnaia or chrysin.
Furthermore, herbal supplements, such as valerian We investigated the anxiolytic efficacy of chrysin, a
and Passifhra incarnata. are gaining popularity as self- Passiflora incarnaia extract, in rats with the added
medication for anxiolysis. critical examination of neurohormonal modulation
and the interactions with the benzodiazepine receptor
A majority of drugs manufactured for anxiolysis
site on the GABA^ receptor.
have undesirable side effects, such as hypotension,
sedation, and a high potential for addiction and abuse.
Methods and materials
One major benefit of most herbal substances is that
For the study, 44 male Sprague-Dawley rats (Harlan
they do not have a large potential for abuse and addic- Sprague Dawley Laboratories) weighing 200 to 250 g
tion.^^ Many Americans are using herbal supplements were randomized in a double-blind, placebo-con-
in lieu of pharmaceuticals to treat their maladies as irolled, between-subjects experimental design. All
public enthusiasm for alternative herbal medications methods were performed in accordance with Brooke
has increased significantly in recent years. In 1997, Army Medical Center Department of Clinical Investi-
12% of US consumers reported using herbal medica- gations and approved by the Institutional Animal Use
tions, representing a 380% increase since 1990. Committee. Each animal received an intraperitoneai
Although there is a huge increase in herbal supple- injection of one of the following: (1) control (vehicle,
ment use, controls and standardization are lacking. dimethyl sulfoxide IDMSO] 4%), (2) chrysin (Sigma
According to the Dietary Supplement Health and Edu- Chemical Co, St Louis, Missouri), 2 mg/kg solubilized
cation Act of 1994, there is no requirement for evi- in DMSO 4%, (3) midazolam, 1.5 mg/kg, or (4)
dence of efficacy, safety, or quality control standards flumazenil (Sigma Chemical Co), 3 mg/kg, and
for supplements, increasing the risk of adverse effects chrysin (Sigma Chemical Co), 2 mg,/kg solubilized in
related to herbals.^"* In the United States alone, DMSO 4%. The elevated plus-maze (EPM) apparatus
between 1993 and 1998, the Food and Drug Adminis- was used to evaluate the behavioral component of
tration documented approximately 2,600 adverse anxiolysis, and catecholamine and corticosterone
events, including 100 deaths, related to herbal med- assays were used to measure the neurohormonal
ieations. effects of anxiety.
Passiflora incarnata (P incarnala)., also known as All rats were injected intraperitoneally 30 minutes
passionflower, is an herbal supplement that has been before behavioral evaluation with the FPM because
used throughout history for purported anxiolytic and previous studies demonstrated an anxiolytic effect
sedative effects; however, there is a lack of research between 20 and 30 minutes.^^*^*'''' Between the time of
that defines the aetual chemical or chemicals in P injection and testing, each rat was placed back into its
incamata that results in its anxiolysis. In addition, cage to reduce any confounding influences. Animals
there is a large void of data that definitively deseribe were placed on the EPM facing the open arm, and
the pharmacodynamic site that produces the mecha- each experimental session was recorded for 5 min-
nism of action of P incarncita and its resultant behav- utes, tracking animal movements via MotorMonitor
ioral and physiologic effects. Two independent labora- software (Hamilton-Kinder, Poway, California). Each

334 AANA Journal/Oaohei 2007/Vol. 75. No. 5 www.aana.com/aanajournal.aspx


Table. Ratio open arm time-total maze time on with soap and water and dried. All experitnentation
elevated plus-maze per group occurred on a limed schedule between the hours of
1:00 PM and 4 PM to ensure that each treatment group
Ratio open was exposed to similar variability of corticosterone
arm time-total release related to the animals' circadian rhythm. After
maze time testing on the EPM, rodents were decapitated, and
Control {n = 11) 31.98 2.6 trunk blood was obtained and collected in
Chrysin (n = 11) 39.04 3.6 heparinized tubes for plasma corticosterone and eate-
cholamine (epinephrine and norepinephrine) levels
Midazolam (n = 11) 61.34 8.7* and sent to Esoterix Laboratory (Austin, Texas). A 2-
Flumazenil -t- chrysin (n = 11) 34.72 5.0 tailed analysis of variance, with an a of .05 was used
via SPSS 11.0 (SPSS, Chicago, Illinois) to detertiiine if
Data are presented as mean i standard error of the mean and represent the there were any significant differences among the
ratio of time spent on fhe open arm to total time on maze (5 minutes).
groups for EPM, corticosterone, and plasma cate-
' Indicates significant statisticat difference of P < .05. cholamine data. When statistical significance was
found, a posthoc Tukey was used to determine the
location of significance.
Figure. Ratio of open arm time-total time on elevated
plus-maze
Results
Only the midazolam group demonstrated a statisti-
100 n cally significant difference in decreased anxiety (P <
.05) when analyzing the ratio of open arm time-total
maze time in the rodent model when cornpared with
the control and flumazenil plus chrysin groups. How-
ever, no statistical difference was found between the
midazolatn and chrysin groups (Table). No statistical
difference was found among the groups regarding the
catecholamine and corticosterone levels. Although
chrysin did not show a statistically significant differ-
ence compared with the control or flumazenil plus
chrysin groups, the data were suggestive of an anxi-
olytic effect (Figure).
Midazolam showed a statistically significant differ-
Control Chrysin Midazolam Chrysin
4 +ftumazenil
ence compared with the control and flumazenil plus
Treatment groups ehrysin groups, but when compared directly with the
chrysin group, there was no statistically significant
Data are presented as mean t standard error of the mean and represent the difference between the 2 groups in open arm time and
ratio of time spent on the open arm to total time on maze (S minutes). Each ratio of open arm time-total time on the EPM. These
group was composed of u rodents. Drugs were injected 30 minutes before
testing on the elevated ptus-maze.
data suggest chrysin may have an anxiolytic effect
similar to that of midazolam.
* Indicates significant statisticat difference of P < .05.

Discussion
session was also recorded via a video camera, and the The behavioral data suggest that the rats prefer the
videotapes were analyzed by an investigator blinded closed arms to the open arms of the maze. An increase
to the group to vahdaie the MotorMonitor data. The in the percentage of time spent in the open arms
EPM is a widely used instrument to measure anxiety reflects an anxiolytic effect."^^'^** Our findings support
in the rodent model^'"^"^'* and has been validated by Pel- that benzodiazepincs (inidazolam) increase open arm
time in the EPM, reflecting a decrease in anxiety.^^
low et al based on the previous work by Mont-
However, our statistical analysis between the control
gomery." Research on this instrument has supported and chrysin groups did not show a significant differ-
its use as a standard measuretnent of anxiety, specifi- ence. These results do not support the original
cally benzodiazepine-induced anxiolysis in rodents." hypothesis ihat the chrysin flavonoid derived from the
Between testing of each animal, the EPM was cleansed P incamala plant has significant anxiolytic effects at

www.aana.com/aanajournal.aspx AANA Journal/October 2007/Vol. 75. No. 5 335


the dose of 2 mg/kg. It was interesting to note that 9. Johnson TN. Rostami-Hodjegan A, Goddard JM, Tanner MS,
Tucker GT Contribution of midazolam and its !-hydroxy melabo-
there was no significant difference in the time spent in lite to preoperativc sedation in children: a pharmacokinetic-phar-
the open arms of the EPM between the chrysin and macodynamic atialysis. Br j Amiesih. 2002:89:428-437,
midazolam groups. These findings suggest that 10. Hardman J, Limhird L. Gatuhnan & Gilman's The Phannacologic
Basis of Thempeulks. iOlh ed. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill; 2001.
although chrysin does not have the same anxiolytic
11. Stoelting R. Benzodiazepines. In: Pharmacology & Physiology in
response as midazolam, there is a possible trend Anesthetic Practiee. Philadelphia, PA: Lippineotl Williams &
toward an anxiolytic effect compared with the control Wilkins; 1999:126-139.
and flumazenil groups. A dose of 2 mg/kg was used in 12. Dhawan K, Dhawan S, Chhahra S. Attenuation of benzodiazepine
our chrysin group, while previous research studies dependence in mice by a tri-substituted benzoflavone moiety of
Passif]cmi incanuiui Linneaiis: a non-habit forming anxiolytic. J
used doses ranging from 1 to 10 mg/l<g.'^ This may Pharm Pharm Sci. 2003;6:215-222.
indicate that a higher chrysin dose may show signifi- 13. Ang-Lee MK, Moss J, Yuan CS, Herbal medicines and perioperative
cant anxiolytic effects. care. JAMA. 2001;286:208-216.
It was further hypothesized that there would be dif- 14. Sahar R, Kaye AD, Frost EA. Perioperative considerations for the
patient on herbal medicines. Middle East J Aneslhcsiol. 2OO1;16:
ferences found between the chrysin group and the 287-314.
flumazenil plus chrysin group, speculaling that 15. WoUman C, Viola H, Paladini A, Dajas F Medina JH. Possible anx-
chrysin may modulate the benzodiazepine receptor iolytic eflects of chrysin, a central benzodiazepine receptor ligand
site of the GABA^ receptor. This is the same site at isolated from Passr/Itira coerulea. Pharmacol Biochem Behav.
1994:47:1-4.
which midazolam and, in theory, all other benzodi- 16. Zanoli P, Avallone R, Baraldi M. Behavioral characterisation of the
azepines exert anxiolytic effects. ^ Our findings did flavonoids apigenin and chrysin, Fitoterapia. 2000:71(suppl
not show a statistically significant difference between l):S117-S123.
the chrysin and flumazenil plus chrysin groups, indi- 17. Akhondzadeh S, Naghavi HR, Vazirian M, Shayeganpour A,
Rashidi H, Khani M. Passionflower in the treatment of generalized
cating that the site of action may not be the benzodi- anxiety: a pilot doitble-blind randomized controlled trial with
azepine receptor site of the GABA.,^ receptor. oxazepam. J ClfJi Pharm Ther. 2001:26:363-367.
From this work, future research can be designed to 18. Dhawan K, Kumar S, Shamia A. Anti-anxiety studies on extracts of
Passiflova incamata Linneaiis. J Ethnopharmacol 2001;78):165-
answer several questions that have arisen as a result of 170.
these findings. One design would add a group that 19. Soulimani R, Younos C, Jarmouni S. Bousta D, Misslin R, Mortier
combines midazolam and chrysin to evaluate the F Behavioural effects of Passiflora incarnaia L. and its indole alka-
potential synergistic or additive anxiolytic effects vs loid and flavonoid derivatives and maltol in the mouse, j
ELhnophtirmacol. 1997:57:11-20.
either medication alone. This combined group could
20. Falier U. Gower AJ, Gobert J. Resistance of baseline activity in the
then suggest how a patient currently self-medicating elevated plus-maze to exogenous influences. Behav Pharmaioi
with herbal medications containing chrysin may 1992:3:123-128.
respond when given midazolam in the preoperative 21. Lister RG. The use of a plus-maze to measure anxieiy in ihc
mouse. Psychopharmacology (Berl). 1987;92:180-185.
setting.
22. Rosa VP, Vandresen N, Calixto AV, Kovateski Dl-^ Faria MS, Tem-
REFERENCES poral analysis of ihe rat's hehavior in the plus-maze: effecl of mida-
1. Anxiety Disorders of America. Stalistics and Tacts About Anxiety zolam. Pharmacol Bioihem Bfh<jv 2000:67:177-182,
Disorders. Available at: htEp;//www.adaa.org/aboulADAA/Press 23. Shepherd JK, Grewal SS, Fletcher A, Bill DJ, Dourisli CT Behav-
roorri/STATS&Facts.asp. Accessed February 12, 2005. ioural and pharmacological characterisation of the elevated "zero-
2. US Puhlic Health Service. Menial Health: A Report of ihe Surgeon maze" as an animal model of anxiety. Psychophajmacalogy (Berl).
General. Etiology of Anxiety Disorders. Availahle ai: htlp://www. 1994:116:56-64.
surgeongeneral.gov/lihrary/mentalheallh/chapler4/sec2.html. 24. Treit D, Menard J, Royan C. Anxiogenic stimuli in the elevated
Accessed February 12, 2005. plus-maze, Phunnacol Biochem Behav. 1993;44:463-469.
3. Selye H, Further thoughts on "stress without distress." Med Times. 25. Pellow S, Cbopin P. File SF, Briley M, Validation of open:closed
1976;IO4:124-144. arm entries in an elevated plus-maze as a measure of anxieiy in the
4. Kain ZN. Sevarino F, Pincus S, et al. Attenuation of the preopera- rat. J Nciirosd Methods. 1985:14:149-167.
live stress response wilh midazolam: effects on postoperative out- 26. Montgomery KC. The relation between fear induced by novel
comes. Anesthesiology. 2000:93:141-147. stimulation and exploratory behavior. J Comp Physiol Psychol.
5. Weissman C. The metabolic response lo stress: an overview and 1955:48:254-260.
update. Aneuhcsiology. 1990:73:308-327. 27. Kulkarni SK, Reddy DS. Animal behavioral models for testing
6. Huffman JC, Stem TA, The use of benzodiazepines in the ircat- aniianxiety agents. Methods Find Exp Clin Pharmacol 1996:18:219-
meni of chesl pain: a review of the literature. J Emerg Med. 230.
2003;25:427-437. 28. Pellow S, File SE. Anxiolytic and anxiogenic drug effects on
7. Kraft M. Holistic issues in the preoperativc period. In( Aneslhesiol exploratory' activity in an elevated plus-maze: a novel lest of anxi-
din. 2002;40:201-212. eiy in ihe rat. Phannacol Biochem Behav. 1986;24:525-529.
a. Agelink MW, Majewski TB. .A.ndrich J. Mueck-Weymann M. Shori-
term effects of intravenous benzodiazepines on autonomic neuro- AUTHORS
cardiac regulation in humans: a comparison between midazolam, CPT Eric (Walter) Brown, CRNA, MSN, ANC. USA, is a tiurse anes-
diazepam, and lorazepam. Cri( Care Mtvf. 2002;30:997-1006, ihctist at Fort Knox, Kentucky. He was a student in the US Army Grad-

336 AANA journal/Oaoher 2007/Vol. 75. No. 5 www.aana.com/aanajournal.aspx


uaic Program in Anesthesia Nursing, Dwiglii Davit! Ei.senhower Army
Medical Center, Augusta, Georgia, ai ihe lime this paper was written.
CPT Neil S. Hurd, CRNA, MSN, ANC. USA, is a nurse anesthetist
ai Fori Irwin, California, He was a student in the US Army Graduate
Where
Program in Anesthesia Nursing, Dwight David Eisenhower Army Med-
ical Center, Augusta, Georgia, at the time this paper was written. small-towti
Suzanne McCall, is a research assistant in the Department of Clinical
Investigation, Brooke Amiy Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, Texas.
LTC Thomas E, Ceremuga, CRNA, PhD, ANC, USA, is ihe program
meets
director in the US Army Graduate Program in Anesthesia Nursing, Fort
Siim H.uiston, Texas. Email: Thomas.Ceremuga@AMEDD,ARMY. MIL. liigh-tech...
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
A grant irom the AAN.'\ Foundation funded this study. A special thanks
to the Department of Clinical Investigation at Brooke Army Medical
Center, Fort Sam Houston, Texas.

DISCLAIMER
i iic views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not
At the
rcilect the oiiicia! policy or position of the Department of the Army, Come be a CRNA in one of the most beautiftil spots in Virginia!
Department of Defense, or the US Government. Enjoy living in our thriving community located at the foothills
of the Blue Ridge Mountains, in the incredible scenic Northern
Shenandoah Valley. Enjoy working in either the 411-bed Winchester
Medical Center, where you can have a schedule of primarily 10 hour
shifts with no additional call or the 196-bed Warren Memorial
Hospital, where you can have a schedule of primarily 8-hour shifts
with rotating call. Because our surgical services are continuing to
grow, we are seeking additional CRNAs to join our top-notch OR
teams.

ASSISTANCE WITH INTERVIEW EXPENSES!


ASK ABOUT OUR $30,000 SIGN-ON BONUSi
UP TO $15,000 FOR RELOCATION COSTS!

CERTIFIED REGISTERED
NURSE ANESTHETISTS
Routine, general, & orthopedic cases
Full-time, part-time, &
per diem hours available
Virginia RN & CRNA licensure
required upon hire
We're looking for CRNAs with a dedication to excellence that
matches our own. Valley Health is just 70 miles from Washington,
D.C., yet removed from the day-to-day hassles of today's busy
metropolitan areas. We offer a highly competitive salary and an
outstanding benefits package, including on-site child care. We
look forward to telling you more. For prompt consideration, apply
online at www.valleyhealth.jobs or call one of the numbers
listed below.

Office of Nurse Recruitment, Valley Health


1840 Amherst Street, Winchester, VA 22601
(866) 387-2770, (866) 715-8441, or (866) 715-8442

WvalleyHealth
EOE

www.aana.com/aanajournal.aspx AANA Journal/October 2007/Vol. 75, No. 5 337

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi