Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ANNEXURE II
BANGALORE-560 034
HOSPITAL, BANGALORE.
2
for a client to seek medical care, and the number one reason for a person to take
Pain is a major economic problem and a major cause of disability that hampers
the lives of many people. There is overwhelming evidence that pain was under treated in
the hospitals. In the last decade alone, numerous studies have continued to prove that pain
is still not adequately treated in all areas of health care. Inadequate pain management can
lead to many consequences affecting the client or family physiologically, emotionally and
with post-operative pain management showed that patients commonly expect moderate to
severe pain in the post-operative period and that the actual pain experience is mainly in
Surgeries are associated with more severe, steady wound pain and the pain on
Bone pain related to orthopaedic surgery is more intense than muscle splitting and
acute pain related to surgery3. Pain management, therefore has received increased
3
attention with the movement toward patients rights and the advent of more sophisticated
means for delivery of pain medication. Type and site of surgery are predictors of severity
and duration of acute pain. There are many ways to manage pain in the post-surgical
Cognitive behavioural measures to relieve pain have been popular for years
Gate Control Theory. These measures include distraction, imagery, relaxation, hypnosis,
massage, music therapy, aromatherapy, prayer and meditation 1. Among the various
measures aromatherapy has been gaining popularity as a simple and easy administrative
mode of alternative therapy for, not only pain but also insomnia, anxiety, depression,
Aromatherapy is defined as the use of essential oils for their expected outcomes that are
measurable1. Evidence shows that this was first used by the Chinese, centuries ago to
enhance their well-being while Egyptians used it for cosmetic, fragrant, medicinal and
spiritual purposes. Studies have shown that it stimulates the immune system, strengthens
your resistance and helps to fight against certain diseases. It can also improve blood
circulation and lymphatic drainage, and so it can also be used to treat a cut or a minor
burn7.
4
was explored by using Lavender essential oil and it showed that there is pain relief
Experts speculate that our sense of smell plays a very important role among other
senses. That means it is incredibly powerful, about 10,000 times stronger than other
senses. Aromatherapy uses this power of smell in a wide range of settings-from health
enhance mood and promote a sense of relaxation. Several clinical studies suggest that
woman by qualified midwives lowered feelings of anxiety and fear, promoted a sense of
well-being and reduced the need for pain medications during delivery7.
In India, the use of aromatherapy and olfactory research is still in its infancy.
Even though India has been famous for botanical medicines from time immemorial, now
its use is restricted only to Ayurvedic clinics, Naturopathy clinics, Beauty therapy and
Holistic Health Centres. It is rarely used in hospital settings. A study done in St. Johns
have severe pain and the wellbeing and comfort using analgesics in these patients is
limited. The constant use of Analgesics has shown to have several adverse effects,
aromatherapy can help to reduce pain, thereby reducing the use of Analgesics and
Considering all the facts described above, the researcher felt that there is a strong
need to incorporate aromatherapy into the nursing practice. So, the researcher has
The investigator has organized the related literature under the following headings
questionnaires. It was found that 53% of patients with previous surgical experience
claimed to have moderate or severe pain post-operatively. Most patients (91%) expected
6
pain of moderate to severe intensity and among them 76% reported to have such pain
levels, 81% were satisfied with pain management while only 8% were dissatisfied3.
patients in a mixed surgical ward at a District General Hospital in the South England.
Pain scores were obtained using a visual analogue scale preoperatively and a taped in-
depth interview was done on fifth postoperative day. The results showed that patients
expected moderate to severe pain after surgery, but the intensity of the pain experienced
emptive analgesia for postoperative pain relief in lumbo-sacral spine surgeries was done
control (n=40) and to the study group (n=40). Pain was quantified using visual analogue
scale (VAS) and verbal rating scale (VRS) post-operatively. Data were analyzed by
Mann-Whitney test. VAS and VRS values at all time intervals were significantly lower in
the study group as compared with the control group. There was also a significant delay in
the first demand for supplemental analgesics in the post-operative period in the study
group12.
analgesia were observed among patients after total abdominal hysterectomy (TAH), total
hip (THR) and knee replacement (TKR) surgery at New England Medical Centre,
7
Boston. Enrolment of 30 patients was based on a convenient sampling method. Data were
collected regarding pain intensity using 0-10 point scale and American Pain Society
Quality Improvement Patient Outcome Questionnaire; and regarding costs and resource
use for services provided by hospital using current financial tracking software. All
analysis was done by mean and standard deviation. The results showed that the main pain
scores were 3.4, 2.7, and 2.0 among TAH, THR and TKR patients respectively. The most
commonly reported adverse effects were abdominal pain (3.8) and dry mouth (3.1) for the
TAH group, whereas insomnia (3.0) and dry mouth (3.0) were the most frequently
Respiratory Rate) and psychological (pain & anxiety levels) components of relaxation
was assessed among 60 clients who are confined to bed in orthopaedic ward at St. Johns
Medical College Hospital, Bangalore. The study used one group pre-test post-test design.
Data were collected using structured interview for baseline information, record of
physiological parameters, visual analogue scale and state trait anxiety inventory. The data
was analyzed by range, mean, standard deviation, paired t test, Mann Whitney test,
Kruskal Wallis test, RMANOVA with Pillars trace and Pearsons product moment
physiological and psychological parameters of relaxation. The mean pain level at pre-
A pilot study on effectiveness of auricular acupuncture (AA) for pain relief after
ambulatory knee arthroscopy (AKA) was done among 20 patients who were selected
randomly before AKA at Ernst Moritz Arndt University, Germany. Pain intensity was
8
assessed on VAS before acupuncture, on discharge from recovery room and during the
follow up examination. Heart rate and blood pressure were recorded before and after AA
procedure, and just before discharge. Statistical analysis was performed using unpaired
Students t-test, Mann-Whiteney test and Chi-square test. The results showed that
Ibuprofen consumption after surgery in the AA group was lower than in the control
group, pain intensity on 100 mm VAS and other parameters were similar in both groups.
after AKA15.
A small scale qualitative study of 6 nurses and midwives who had undertaken a
diploma in aromatherapy in order to find out what changes they had made in their clinical
practice was done in UK. The sample had completed the aromatherapy course between 9
months and 2 years previously. Data were collected using interview which were tape-
recorded and generally lasted for about 40 minutes. Data were analysed using the
procedure outlined by Colaisse and significant statements were clustered into themes.
The findings showed that aromatherapy for treating clients was concentrated mainly on
the effects of massage and the moisturising effect of oil and the practice is mostly
St. Johns Medical College Hospital, Bangalore. The study used one group pre-test post-
test design and samples were selected using purposive sampling technique. Data were
9
parameters, state trait anxiety inventory, perceived stress scale and relaxation rating scale.
Data were analyzed using range, mean, standard deviation, paired t test, Students t-test,
Mann Whitney test, Kruskal Wallis test, RMANOVA with Pillars trace and Pearsons
product moment correlation coefficient correlation. Results showed that there was a
aromatherapy9.
The use of aromatherapy with hospice patients to decrease pain, anxiety and
depression and to promote an increased sense of wellbeing was done in Las Vegas, USA.
The study measured the responses of 17 cancer hospice patients on three different days
aromatherapy. Vital signs as well as levels of pain (using 11-point verbal analogue) were
used to collect data. Results reflected a positive change in B P and pulse, reduction in
pain, anxiety and depression and the sense of wellbeing after both the humidified water
treatment and the lavender treatment. Following the control session there was also slight
improvement in vital signs, depression and sense of wellbeing, but not in pain or anxiety
levels17.
combined with massage on 100 patients in a critical care unit in which 30 patients were
randomly selected into 3 groups. One group received massage plus lavender oil, one
received massage alone and the third rested without any massage or lavender. Data was
obtained using questionnaire to document pain and wakefulness and by measuring heart
rate, blood pressure, and respiratory rate. The study provided no statistics or analysis. The
10
results showed a 50% reduction in pain with lavender oil, 41% reduction in massage only
equivalent control group, pre and post test among 40 patients enrolled in the Rheumatics
Centre, South Korea. The essential oils used were lavender, marjoram, eucalyptus,
rosemary and pepper mint. The data were collected in the form of pain score and
depression score which were analysed using a 2-test, Fischers exact test, t-test and paired
t-test. In the study aromatherapy significantly decreased both pain score and depression
alone, was effective in reducing hemiplegic shoulder pain and improving motor power
was done in 30 stroke patients at College of Oriental Medicines, South Korea. It was a
randomised control trial in which subjects were randomly assigned to experimental group
(n=15) or control group (n=15). Each acupressure session lasted 20 minutes and was
performed twice-daily for two weeks. Shoulder pain and motor power were assessed and
analysed using coefficient of correlation. The pain scores were markedly reduced in both
groups at post treatment compared to pre treatment, the pain scores differed significantly
between the two groups at post treatment and the motor power significantly improved at
The efficacy of acupressure using aromatic lavender essential oil for pain relief
and enhancing physical functional activities among adults with sub-acute non-specific
neck pain done at Telehealth Clinic and The Community Centre, Hong Kong used an
11
experimental study design. In this study a course of 8-session manual acupressure with
lavender oil over a 3-week period was used. Data were assessed on neck pain intensity
(by VAS), stiffness level, stress level, neck lateral flexion, forward flexion and extension
in centimetres, and interference with daily activities. The baseline visual analogue scores
for the intervention and the control groups were 5.12 and 4.91 out of 10, respectively21.
Treatment with lavender aromatherapy in the post anaesthesia care unit in the
gastric banding (LAGB) was determined at New York University Medical Centre, USA.
The study design was a prospective randomized placebo control which was carried out on
54 patients undergoing LAGB in which the patients in study group (n=26) were treated
with lavender oil, while the control group (n=27) received non-scented baby oil.
Numerical rating scores (0-10) were used to measure the pain level at 5, 30 and 60
minutes. Sedation was evaluated using the Observer Assessment of Alertness or Sedation
scales (0-5). Data were analysed using Chi-square, unpaired Students t-test or Fishers
exact tests. The results showed that significantly more patients in the control group
required analgesics for post operative pain (82%) than patients in the experimental group
(46%) (p=0.007). Moreover, the lavender patients required significantly less morphine
post operatively than placebo patients: 2.38 mg vs. 4.26 mg, respectively22.
To compare pain in both experimental and control group after the intervention
Pain:
measured by the investigator, using numeric intensity pain scale (NIPS) and by
Respiratory Rate).
Aromatherapy:
In this study, it refers to the treatment using dry inhalation of the fragrance
patients.
Effectiveness:
Post-operative Patients:
Baseline Variables:
clients.
6.6. Assumption
6.7. Delimitation
The study will be generalised only to clients who have undergone major
The results of the study will help to identify the effectiveness of aromatherapy on
6.9. Hypothesis
There will be an association between pain and selected baseline variables at 0.05
level of significance.
An experimental design using two groups will be used for the study.
7.1.2. Setting:
The study will be conducted in the orthopaedic ward of SJMCH which is a 1200
bedded tertiary care teaching institute. The number of beds in Orthopaedic ward is 58,
routine.
7.1.3. Population:
Clients who are in post-operative period ranging from 2nd to 4th post-operative
day.
Clients who are able to interpret the Numeric Intensity Pain Scale.
Section 1:
any Allergies)
Section 2:
Numeric Intensity Pain Scale (0-10) to assess pain perception and record of
physiological parameters (Blood Pressure, Pulse Rate & Respiratory Rate) will be
Superintendent and Head of the Orthopaedic Unit of SJMCH to conduct the study.
using convenient sampling and randomly assigned to the experimental and the
control group. The detail procedure of the study and assessment of pain using
explained about the use of aromatherapy but nothing will be mentioned about its
study. For experimental group, on the 2nd post-operative day pain, blood pressure,
pulse rate & respiratory rate will be assessed at 8 pm after which a cotton ball
with a drop of lavender oil will be placed under the pillow and kept there till 7
am. Pain, blood pressure, pulse rate & respiratory rate will be assessed again at 7
This will be repeated on 3rd and 4th post-operative days. Pain perception, blood
pressure, pulse rate & respiratory rate of control group will also be assessed at the
(using plain moist cotton). Patients will receive their prescribed dose of oral
percentage, mean and standard deviation; and inferential methods such as t-test,
No.
18
Administrative permission and ethical clearance with regard to the study will be
obtained from the research committee of SJMCH, Bangalore prior to the conduction
of study.
19
LIST OF REFERENCES
Collaborative Care. 5th edn. Missouri: Elsevier Saunders Publishers; 2006: 63-5,
84.
26-07-2009
the patients perspective. Journal of Clinical Nursing. 1997 May; 6(3): 191-201
use and patient satisfaction in an urban teaching hospital. Anaesth Analg. 2002;
94: 130-7.
15. Usichenko T I, Hermsen M et al. Auricular acupuncture for pain relief after
satisfaction of arthritis patients. Taehan Kanho Hakhoe Chi. 2005 Feb; 35 (1):186-
94.
reduction among LAGB patients. Obes Surg. 2007 Jul; 17 (7): 920-5.
22
8 SIGNATURE OF CANDIDATE
9 REMARKS OF THE GUIDE
10.2 SIGNATURE
10.3 CO-GUIDE (IF ANY) Dr. GOURAV SHARMA,
PROFESSOR,
ORTHOPAEDIC DEPARTMENT,
ST.JOHNS MEDICAL COLLEGE
HOSPITAL.
10.4 SIGNATURE
23
DEPARTMENT PRINCIPAL,
DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL-
SURGICAL NURSING,
ST.JOHNS COLLEGE OF NURSING.
11.2 SIGNATURE
12 12.1 REMARKS OF THE
12.2 SIGNATURE