Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 6

Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.


Home About Us Contact Us Get Printed Magazines & E-Books Free FAQ'S in Interviews Advertise With Us

A Unique blog for Oil and Gas Professionals covering topics related to Piping and Process.

Costing of Pipelines - 2

Posted by Ankit Chugh on 5:36 AM 6 Comments

Continued from - Costing of Pipelines - 1

22. Piping Cost Estimation

Piping always represents a sizable part of the total installed cost of any process plant. It may run to 20
percent or even more of the entire cost of the plant, including land and buildings, and may total from
around 10 percent to as high as two-thirds of the cost of the equipment. But piping is usually
complicated and often consists of a myriad of small, rather inexpensive parts. Its estimation can
therefore be a headache to the estimator.

It makes his problem no easier that he is often asked for a reasonable estimate long before the final
plans exist and before the project engineers have any idea how much piping will actually be needed. In
this case, he must not only be an estimator, but he must be able quickly to convert the preliminary flow
sheet into a fair approximation of an actual design to know what his estimate will involve. For this
purpose the ability to make quick and rather accurate free-hand isometric sketches is of inestimable

However, the estimation of the piping need not be arduous if the estimator will make use of the N
system developed by the another during the last several years. This system, first disclosed in Chemical
Engineering (R.A. Dickson, Chem. Eng., November, 1947, pp 121-123) has now been carried much
further and includes most kinds of pipes with which the chemical engineer is likely to be concerned.

The N System of Calculating Piping Costs. This new system of estimating

piping cost is quicker than the piece-by-piece, and more accurate than the finagling-factor, system, the
two methods ordinarily used by estimators.

The first requires picking of each length of pipe with its fittings and valves
and pricing the material and labour costs in detail, then adding them all up for the total cost. The second
consists in taking a percentage of the total cost of a project as the cost of the piping. This percentage the
finagling factor, is supposed to be around 40 percent.

* The author wishes to express his appreciation to the firms listed and to
may others who prefer to remain anonymous, but who helped by furnishing cost data on which the
N-factor tables are based. Specific acknowledgement is made to Armstrong Cork Co., Inc.; Mundet Cork
Corp.; Johns Manville, Inc.; Cooper Alloy Foundry Co.; Taylor Forge and Pipe Works; Andrews Knapp
Construction Co.; Knapp Mills Inc.; The Saran Lined Pipe Co.; The Rie-Wil Co.; and The Duriron Co.

See, for example, Table 10-33 of the N factors. The costs of different sizes of steel Pipe, butt-welded,
schedule 40, black, with fittings and valves as specified, will be to each other approximately as the N
factors. As the table shows, a string of 2-in nominal diameter pipe will cost 1.84 times as much as the
same string in 1 in.

Take, for example, a string of such pipe of 2-in nominal diameter:

Item Unit Cost Total Cost

500 pipe $ 0.23 $ 115.00
7 fittings 7.00 49.00
2 valves 22.00 44.00
$ 208.00
Scroll to Top
The same string in 1-in nominal diameter:

1 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09
Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.html

Item Unit Cost Total Cost

500 pipe $ 0.13 $ 65.00
7 fittings 4.50 32.00
2 valves 11.00 22.00
Search your Query Here
$ 119.00

Hence, 208/119 = 1.84, the N factor for 2-in. pipe in terms of 1 in. pipe as unity.

Not only has the N-factor System been tested thoroughly, but it also shows up satisfactorily over a
period of time. Several checks of this fact have been made. For example, table 10-39 was selected at
random, and comparable strings were figured for 4- and 12-in. pipe, using first the costs of 1935, and Subscribe to our Free
Newsletter & Be Updated
then July, 1949, costs. Despite the fact that the costs of each string had risen approximately 83 per cent Always
from 1935 to 1949, the N factor for 4-in. pipe for 1935 was 0.249, and for 1949; 0.248.
Get all new articles & jobs directly in your inbox. Just
How the N-factor System Is Used: To use the tables, first calculate the cost of the reference sizes of the enter your email address:

strings of pipe in question. Then use the N factors to get the cost of the same string in the required size.

The index of N-factor tables includes 66 materials and weights of piping, You will receive a confirmation email to confirm the
counting some insulated, some bare. If the N system is adopted, this means that prices and costs of
installation of these materials for the reference sizes only need be kept on file, instead of material and
labour cost of every size of every material and wall thickness in common use. (Also as later explained, if
less accurate estimating suffices, data given here can be factored to the date of use by using one of the
available cost variation indexes.).

The tables cover only the cost of putting the strings of pipe together. The costs of burying or supporting
pipelines are easily calculated. Moreover, many times the proposed lines lie on the ground or are
supported on existing structures. These conditions are far too variable to include in any tables of costs.

An example of use: Assure that several strings of pipe of various sizes have been taken from the flow
diagram of a small project involving some additional piping.

The specifications of pipe, fittings and valves are:

Pipe: steel, schedule 40, butt-welded, black, bare

Fittings: forged steel, screwed. 2,000# cold-water pressure

Valves: bronze, screwed ends, 200 # cold-water pressure

Assume that the pipe is to be installed on existing support.

First consult the index of N-factor tables. The specifications of the pipe, fittings and valves in Table
10-33 correspond to those required. The reference size, i.e., the size for which N = 1.00, is 1 in.

Next, calculate the cost of hypothetical string of 1-in. pipe of the required
specifications. (Or take the cost from Table 10-33, giving the cost of the
reference string in July, 1949. Then factor this cost to date of use.)

As in Table 10-33, the installed costs may be found to be:

Per foot of pipe .............................. $ 0.13

Per fitting ....................................... 4.50
Per valve ......................................... 11.00 Find me on Google+
Calculate all the strings taken from the flow diagram as 1-in. pipe, then multiply by the N factor for the
actual size:

Google+ Followers

Scroll to Top

2 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09
Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.html

Piping Guide

For comparison, the total cost of piping calculated by the conventional pieceby - piece system would be
S764, as shown in the following check:

143 have us in circles View all

Get Us EveryWhere!!
Gosto 464 pessoas gostam disto. S o primeiro
entre os teus amigos.

Follow @luckyankit 6,859 followers

Blog Archive
2014 ( 23 )
2013 ( 60 )
2012 ( 79 )
2010 ( 5 )
2009 ( 41 )
November ( 4 )
What Data Are Needed: The N-factor tables were derived by actual calculation of the installed costs of July ( 11 )
typical strings of pipe in all the sizes mentioned in each table, and in all the different weight and June ( 1 )
materials of construction listed in the 66 tables. For uniformity, all have been calculated on the basis of April ( 2 )
Costing of Pipelines - 2
July, 1949, materials and labour costs in the New York area. For each specification the costs so
Costing of Pipelines - 1
calculated for the several sizes have been compared with the cost of one reference size which is taken as
February ( 23 )
1.00. The comparative costs of the other sizes of the same material are then listed as multipliers of the
reference size. In Table 10-1, for example, the sizes range from to 12 in. The reference size is 3 in, and
the N factors (i.e. relative costs compared with that Translate
of the reference size range from 0.320 to 6.730).

Hence, the N factors are all based on the reference size (or in a few cases, two reference sizes) for each Labels
piping specification, and to figure any string of pipe, it is necessary only to figure the cost for the
Piping Design ( 123 )
reference size in that particular specification. Once the cost of the reference size is known, the costs for
Piping ( 97 )
any other size or for several sizes can be determined immediately by multiplying by the proper N factor. Pipelines ( 63 )
This means that it is necessary to keep up-to-date the cost data only for the reference size (or sizes) in PandID ( 59 )
each specification, since the N factors remain constant through an extremely wide range of material and Plumbing ( 43 )
labour cost variations. Process ( 40 )
Layout Engineering ( 38 )
Estimating without Current Data: This means also that it is unnecessary to keep up-to-date data even on
Projects ( 38 )
the costs for the reference strings, if a somewhat lower degree of estimating accuracy can be tolerated
Refinery ( 30 )
than is possible by having up-to-date figures. For this purpose, each of the tables includes as a second
Codes ( 19 )
part (or in some cases, as a second and third part) the detailed calculations for the reference size or sizes
Downloads ( 14 )
for these materials are based on July, 1949 costs. As long as labour and material costs do not change
Pigging ( 13 )
much from July, 1949, these figures can be used directly. But since such costs are not likely to be stated
Jobs ( 10 )
in the future, it is possible to factor them to the date of use by the judicious use of one or more of the
Rigs ( 10 )
available cost indexes, in comparison to the index for July, 1949. Instrumentation ( 6 )
Books ( 3 )
Cost Indexes: Many cost indexes are available monthly in the Survey of Current Business, published by
AutoCad ( 2 )
the U.S. Department of Commerce. Among these are several building cost indexes for various kinds of
labour and for a number of basic materials. The Survey, as well as the magazine Engineering
News-Record, also publishes the ENR Construction Cost Index, which is widely used by estimators in PDMS Articles
dealing with plant and equipment cost variations, although it is intended to cover only heavy
construction costs. Some organisations have successfully applied their own modifications to the ENR
The Database Listing Form
Index in using it to factor plant and equipment costs. The magazine Chemical Engineering regularly
Positioning Radial Nozzles
publishes the comparative equipment cost indexes for process industries compiled quarterly by the PDMS SYNTAX'S
evaluation engineering firm of Marshall and Stevens, together with this firms 1947 industry average, PDMS PSEUDO ATTRIBUTES
covering equipment costs in a wide range of industrial and commercial activities. PDMS Creating & Deleting Elements
PDMS Orientation Commands
None of these indexes applies directly to piping costs and must therefore be used with care. However, Scroll to Top
PDMS Positioning Commands (Piping)

3 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09
Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.html

experience has indicated that such factoring can be sufficiently accurate at least for pre-construction PDMS Positioning Commands (General)

cost estimating. The only indexes that actually deal with piping cost, as far as the author knows, are not PDMS QUERY COMMANDS

so readily available as those mentioned. These are the Handy Indexes of Public Utility Costs, put out for SETTING PDMS ATTRIBUTES

the estate of William W. Handy by Whitman, Requard and Associates, of Baltimore, and Benjamin L. PDMS SYNTAX EXAMPLES

Smith and Associates, of Albany. This compilation is issued every six months and lists several kinds of STRUCTURE, EQUIPMENT & OTHERS
Remaining Commands of PDMS
piping including gas mains and power plant piping.

Table for N System

Pipe: aluminium, Aleoa alloy 618-T6, standard weight, bare, 1/2 to 12

Fittings: aluminium, welding

Valves: and 1" aluminium, screwed, gate; 1 to 12" aluminium, flanged, gate, 125#

Reference size: 3#

Scroll to Top

4 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09
Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.html

Get Notified for new Tutorials: Enter your email

*Check your email to confirm your subscription*
Search Anything Else Your Looking For:

You may also like -

PreStressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe (PCCP) Joints

ASME B31.4: Liquid Transportation Systems for Hydrocarbons, Liquid Petroleum Gas,
Anhydrous ...
Asme B31.8: Gas Transmission And Distribution Piping Systems
Types of Heat Tracing Systems
Concrete, Cement, and Cement-Lined Pipe
Prestressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe (PCCP) Design
PreStressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe (PCCP) Installation Procedure
Sequence of Distillation Column Piping Study
Cement Mortar and Concrete Linings For Pipe
Definition of The Term Design Bases

Scroll to Top

5 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09
Costing of Pipelines - 2 | PIPING GUIDE http://www.pipingguide.net/2009/04/costing-of-pipelines-2.html


vivek saboo

very useful............


Thanks for the article


good one...... thanks...........



Ankit Chugh Mod

Thanks for your comment dear.



Speciality Tubular Products and its Types Material Selection Common

Specifications for Carbon Steel Systems
Avatar I didn't know that there are
many different types of tubular products. It's a Avatar I'll check my collection if i can
good thing that you discussed all these find something helpful for you..

How to do Pump Piping with Layout Types of Expansion Joints with Examples
Avatar These articles are important
Avatar I work in Project control department. for any piping engineer...
My focus is into planning, scheduling. Can we
have posting

Newer Post Piping Guide Older Post

2011 PIPING GUIDE - Designed by Ankit | ToS | Privacy Policy | Sitemap About Us | Contact Us | Write For Us

Scroll to Top

6 of 6 16-07-2014 11:09