Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Solving for Design Parameters Based on Target Reliability New in Weibull++ and ALTA
For many years, Weibull++ and ALTA users have been This tool has now been extensively redesigned and
relying on the stress-strength analysis tool for situations when expanded in Version 8, giving users the ability to:
they need to estimate reliability by determining the probability
that the strength of the component will exceed the stress Save these analyses in the project for future reference.
expected in the operating environment. Generate a pdf plot to visualize the comparison.
Obtain confidence bounds on the calculated probability.
2 Reliability Edge
Celebrating 20 Years of Empowering the Reliability Professional
Q & A with Pantelis Vassiliou, ReliaSoft President and C.E.O.
Q. What does ReliaSofts 20th Anniversary mean to you? package was the first commercial RCM software with
quantitative optimization engines. And the new Synthesis
A. Its been that long? Looking back, I am really proud of our Platform is the first commercial fully enterprise-capable
significant contributions to the reliability engineering integrated solution for reliability engineering using object -based
community, the products and services that we have provided, reliability modeling methodologies.
and most of all the way we did it that is, by always putting
customers first and providing a customer service experience Q. How would you describe the companys growth over
that is second to none. the last 20 years?
Q. How did ReliaSoft start? A. Our growth has been pursued in a planned and sustainable
fashion. As a result, over the past 20 years ReliaSoft has
A. It all started in 1991. At that time I was student in the Ph.D. grown to a company of more than 125 professionals on four
program in reliability engineering at the University of Arizona. continents with a customer base exceeding 6,000 companies.
During that time, I worked on a project to create an easy-to-use Attendance to Applied Reliability Symposia, which are
PC-based tool to solve for the mixed-Weibull distribution. sponsored and organized by ReliaSoft, has grown to exceed
Eventually, this led to the creation of a general software for 1,000 industry participants per year for all events, and
solving for most forms of the Weibull distribution. The first ReliaSofts Educational Services unit has provided training to
version was pretty much a student project and worked under more than 17,000 engineering professionals from more than
DOS on IBM-compatible PCs. By the end of 1992, the original 4,000 companies and government agencies worldwide.
DOS program was ported to Windows 3.1 and was made
commercially available as ReliaSofts Weibull+ Version 3. It is Q. What sets ReliaSoft apart from others?
interesting to note that, at that time, this was one of very few
engineering/math software packages made available on the A. What sets ReliaSoft apart from others is that we are
newly released Windows 3.1 platform. This single product multifaceted. We not only have the knowledge, experience
started the company. Twenty years later, we are the industry and expertise in reliability, but were also creating the reliability
leader with a full range of reliability solutions that spans 12 software ourselves and educating the users at the same time.
fully integrated software offerings, an extensive training
program in reliability theory and practice, expert consulting Q. What has been the core value of the company that has
services and a worldwide presence. led to its success over the last 20 years?
Q. What is ReliaSofts greatest influence on the reliability A. As a corporate philosophy, we have always valued our
engineering discipline? customers most and assured that they receive the product
quality and service that we would like to receive ourselves. As
A. The greatest influence ReliaSoft has had in this discipline per our mission statement, we work to empower our customers
is that we have provided a centralized location of practical and to apply reliability engineering methodologies in order to
useful tools and education, a one-stop shop for reliability maximize their profitability while assuring the safety, reliability
engineers to help them solve problems and improve their and quality of their products, processes and services.
products and processes. Prior to our company, there were a
few universities and textbooks to educate engineers on I want to take this opportunity to thank our thousands of
reliability, but there were not any really functional tools. We customers for their preference and support over the years,
fulfilled that need in the market early on, and in turn have and to also thank our loyal employees across the globe who
accelerated the industrys growth, as well as our own. have worked hard to take care of our customers in all aspects
of our business.
Q. What are some of ReliaSofts greatest achievements
over the last 20 years? ReliaSoft Customers Celebrate With Us
A. I believe that ReliaSofts unwavering commitment to Meeting and exceeding the expectations of our customers has
continuous investment in research and development and been a central focus of ReliaSofts efforts over the last 20
focus on innovation has produced a history of industry firsts. years. When we asked some of those valued customers and
We developed the first commercial Windows-based reliability partners to help us celebrate this anniversary milestone, we
software (Weibull++), the first commercial Accelerated Testing were overwhelmed by their supportive responses.
Analysis software (ALTA) and the first commercial Reliability
Growth Analysis software (RGA). We also released the first We invite you to review excerpts from their comments on the
commercial FRACAS software, which was also the first next two pages, or visit http://www.ReliaSoft.com/20years to
web-based reliability software (XFRACAS). Our RCM++ see the full remarks.
Please Turn to Page 4
Congratulations to everyone in the ReliaSoft family on your 20th anniversary! I previously had experience with other reliability products
and was very disappointed. I can honestly say that any success I have had in the field of Reliability. In my last four positions can be credited to
the fantastic tools and support at ReliaSoft. Wishing you many more years of continued success! Marty Fox / Hologic
Throughout my professional reliability engineering career, ReliaSoft has been a very supportive partner in the development
ReliaSoft has been a professional partner in providing reliability and application of tools for reliability analysis It is no wonder it
software tools, services, and training that I have used over the past is achieving the popularity it has today both in industry and the
20 years and have improved and honed my reliability skills. Thank academic world Congratulations on a very successful 20 years!
you and congratulations on reaching your 20th year milestone. James MacIntyre / Manitowoc Corp.
Rick Ramirez / ViaSat Corporation
The ReliaSoft suite has provided a comprehensive set of reliability
Congratulations to the ReliaSoft team. Your success is a testament analysis and test support tools with seamless data management across
to your teams ability to develop products that are user friendly and our product life cycle. While selling the value of a reliability program
analytically sound, resulting in a speed to market value proposition. can be a challenge in a non-regulated environment, selling the benefits
Thanks again for your support, mentoring, customer service and and productivity of the ReliaSoft suite to my senior leaders has never
outstanding portfolio of reliability products. been an issue.
Steve Brown / Lennox International Randolph Phillips / Baker Hughes
Congratulations on your remarkable achievements over the past 20 As a head of Global Quality and Technology Executive
years. Your products and support are world class and illustrate your Management, I want to thank you for the good work and the keeping
devotion and dedication to advancing the adoption and successful pace with technological changes in the industry. I am looking forward
implementation of reliability methods. Kudos to a job well done! to seeing more of your products in the decades to come.
Steve & Allise Wachs / Integral Concepts, Inc. Paul Wang / Mitac International Inc.
ReliaSofts MSMT Reliability Foundations Training Seminar provided not only a solid foundation for my reliability engineering career, but
it also yielded the groundwork for my dedication and ability to confidently address my clients reliability challenge Congratulations on
this momentous achievement and I look forward to the next 20 years of working side by side to emphasize and educate the masses on the
importance of reliability engineering. Andrew Foote / Alion Science and Technology Corporation - System Reliability Center
Congratulations on the 20th anniversary of ReliaSoft and the 18 years ago, I was looking for a Weibull analysis software package
value it has brought to the reliability discipline over the years. and stumbled on to ReliaSoft and Weibull++. That began one of the
On a related topic, I have totally enjoyed the format of the best partnerships between a supplier and customer I've ever been part
Applied Reliability Symposium that ReliaSoft has sponsored. This of in my career Congratulations to Pantelis and the team for all
symposium provides a great place for reliability practitioners to their accomplishments over the past 20 years! I can't imagine what
truly share best practices I always go home from this symposium you'll do in the next 20. Thanks and happy 20th anniversary!"
with another tool I have learned."
Stan Stephenson / Halliburton - Duncan Technology Center Dan Farley / Kraft Foods Cheese & Dairy
Over the last 20 years ReliaSoft has led the charge in making reliability, maintainability, and availability analysis accessible to a wide range
of companies and industries Their latest effort, Synthesis, has the potential to create a paradigm shift in the practice of reliability and
maintainability in the industry truly an integrated life cycle analysis tool!!" Edward Pohl / University of Arkansas
Congratulations to ReliaSoft for 20 years of attentive service to
reliability engineering functions in industries across the country
and around the globe! Your products have given not only statistical Congratulations to the folks at ReliaSoft on their 20th anniversary.
tools, but organizational and communication tools to an often Our partnership with ReliaSoft began over 15 years ago. This
cumbersome task Best wishes for the next 20 years of new and relationship has helped John Deere provide highly reliable products
improved products! to our worldwide customers. It is a pleasure working with Pantelis,
Jane Peterson / Woodward Inc. Doug, and the rest of the ReliaSoft crew.
Chuck Noel / John Deere Turf Care
Congratulations to ReliaSoft on your 20th anniversary. ReliaSoft
has been an invaluable partner to ASI for many of those years and Congratulations! Capstone has had a great history with ReliaSoft,
we appreciate all of your support. 20 years of survival in the software and we look forward to many more years! Our employees love
industry is a testament to your continued emphasis on innovation XFRACAS, and cant wait to see the upcoming changes.
and commitment to being leaders in the Reliability field. Keep up the Evan Franke / Capstone Turbine Corporation
good work!
JC Leverette / Andromeda Systems Incorporated It is a pleasure to witness how, in the past 20 years, ReliaSoft
developed from a small software company to a powerful global
corporation and a well-established center of reliability expertise
You and your fellow employees have provided me with tools that Today, ReliaSoft continues to be an undisputed leader in many
did exactly what you said they would, no nonsense sales puffery areas of reliability science and data analysis. Thank you, ReliaSoft,
and excellent support. Your training has been extensive and easily thank you, Pantelis and thank you to all the people who have made
understood. I am a completely satisfied customer! ReliaSoft the success story it is today.
David Payne / Haldex Brake Products Corporation Andre Kleyner / Purdue University
Today, the reliability engineers are tasked with not just spilling out a reliability number because a contract clause asks for it but they are
identifying the weak spots in products, developing qualifications tests, performing accelerated qualification tests, and supporting products
over short and long life cycles. The science and mathematics of these had been known by engineers for a long time but what delayed the
introductions of these methods were the lack of reliable, easy to use, and comprehensive tools sets. ReliaSoft has continued to identify and fill
that gap over the last 20 years. Michael Pecht / University of Maryland
It is great to see ReliaSoft celebrating their 20th anniversary. I I am not surprised that ReliaSoft has capped such an anniversary
have used several of their products for over 12 of those 20 years, with such a crowning achievement as Synthesis. This is one amazing
notably Weibull++ and BlockSim and found them effective and user feat that directly reflects on the vision and integrity that have
friendly Congratulations ReliaSoft on reaching this milestone. continually been behind their successes over the years. Salute!
Aron Brall / NASA Goddard Spaceflight Center Ken Millspaugh / Raytheon Company
During the course of 20 years, ReliaSoft has transformed the Congratulations ReliaSoft on 20 years and I want to wish you many
science of reliability engineering by creating a framework that is more years of continued success. ReliaSofts longevity speaks for itself
practical, coherent and intuitive. This single company, through its and you should also be proud of your role in helping to shape and
trinity of software, training and consulting has positively influenced support the reliability field. I have been associated with ReliaSoft for
the reliability of most of the products we use today and most of the many years and have always appreciated working with you and your
processes we rely upon. I expect nothing less for the next 20 years." employees because of your strong commitment to your customers.
Georgios Sarakakis / Tesla Motors Heres to the next 20 years!
Larry Crow / Crow Reliability Resources
I would like to congratulate ReliaSoft on achieving its 20th
anniversary. I had my first exposure to ReliaSoft during the 1996 As soon as ReliaSoft came out with Weibull++, I became hooked on
RAMS conference. I was impressed during that encounter with the their intuitive, and easy to use, reliability assessment software. I have
focus that you placed on your customers needs. This customer focus utilized many of ReliaSofts suite of tools in my work over the past 20
has been demonstrated numerous times over the years by all of the years within the high tech industry Congratulations for your 20
people with whom I have had the pleasure to interact. years and I am very grateful for your contributions to my career.
James Malm / Deere & Company Jeff Blanchard / Dot Hill Systems
Early on in my career, I looked for a mentor. I not only found that mentor in ReliaSoft, I found an entire organization of dedicated
reliability professionals and a friendship that I am proud to have. Congratulations to ReliaSoft on 20 years of contributions to reliability
knowledge, software tools, and professional education.
Jeffrey P. Lewis / Surgical Specialties Corporation (dba Angiotech)
I have known ReliaSoft since 1995, but as much as I've enjoyed It is not surprising that ReliaSoft is celebrating 20 years in business.
using the software, I have also enjoyed rich learning experiences The products and services they provide are first class. When dealing
from your staff and networked professionals. Your ability to put with ReliaSoft you will get a sense of passion for the technology of
forth industry-leading world class software is rivaled only by your reliability They are sophisticated and one of the friendliest groups
ability to put together teams of the best reliability, engineering and of people Ive had the pleasure to work with. Congratulations and
computer professionals " good luck in the future.
Jim Jauw / Stryker Corporation Jeff Barts / Universal Lighting Technologies
The standard for reliability life data analysisTM
Weibull++is the industry standard for reliability and life data analysis (Weibull analysis)for thousands of companies
worldwide.
Supports all forms of the Weibull distribution along with the exponential, normal, lognormal, generalized
gamma, gamma, logistic, loglogistic, Gumbel and Weibull-Bayesian distributions. The Distribution Wizard
helps you select the appropriate distribution for your data.
Supports rank regression and maximum likelihood estimation for parameter estimation and offers Fisher
matrix, likelihood ratio, beta binomial and Bayesian methods for confidence bounds.
Quickly returns calculated reliability results and automatically generates a complete array of related plots
and reports.
Provides integrated utilities for related analyses, including warranty analysis, reliability block diagrams,
parametric and non-parametric recurrent event data analysis, degradation analysis, non-parametric life data
analysis and reliability test design.
http://Weibull.ReliaSoft.com
Accelerated life testing techniques, in conjunction with powerful quantitative accelerated life data analysis
methodologies, give design and reliability engineers the power to significantly reduce test times, which can provide
faster time to market, lower product development costs, lower warranty costs and many other benefits.
ReliaSoft's ALTA is still the only commercially available software tool designed expressly for quantitative accelerated
life testing data analysis using rigorous scientific analysis methods. The software is available in two versions:
ALTA Standard provides the life-stress relationship models required to analyze accelerated life test data
with 1 or 2 constant stresses.
ALTA PRO offers advanced capabilities for analyzing accelerated life test data with up to 8 simultaneous
stress types where stress is constant or varies with time!
Both versions provide a complete array of utilities for designing accelerated life tests, evaluating the fit of the model,
calculating reliability metrics, generating plots and performing related statistical analyses.
http://ALTA.ReliaSoft.com
Continued from Page 1:New Analysis Capabilities in Synthesis Applications
Target Reliability Parameter Estimator: Allows you to Solve for the Necessary Strength Distribution
solve for the design parameters that would enable a The next step is to use the new integrated Target
component to meet the reliability goal (i.e., determine the Reliability Parameter Estimator to determine how strong the
parameters of the strength distribution that would yield the component needs to be in order to meet a reliability target of
desired probability that strength will exceed stress). at least 99.999%. The next picture shows the results.
Direct Integration with the Test Design Folio: Makes it
easy to design a reliability demonstration test (e.g., a
zero-failure test) to demonstrate that a component has the
desired strength.
Application Example
A design group needs assistance with selecting and
qualifying a steel component for a new product. Their main
concern is the component's ability to withstand the tensile
stresses in its intended application. The circumstances are as
follows: Assuming that beta is similar to the value calculated from
the original 6 specimens (2.732021), the utility calculates that
Reliability Target: The requirement for the component is a the value of eta needs to be 356.417269 Mpa. In other words,
probability of failure of 1 in 100,000 due to tensile loads (or a when the engineers test the remaining 10 specimens and
reliability of 99.999%). analyze the data, an eta of 356.42 Mpa or higher is estimated
to be sufficient to use stress-strength analysis to demonstrate
Stress Distribution: By estimating that the median tensile
the target reliability.
stress is 75 Mpa and the worst case load (99th percentile
case) is 150 Mpa, they obtain a Weibull stress distribution with Design a Reliability Demonstration Test
beta = 2.732021 and eta = 85.767713 Mpa.
The last step is to design a reliability demonstration test
Strength Distribution: The engineers have already tested 6 for the remaining 10 specimens. The Version 8 stress-strength
specimens and they have 10 more available for testing if the folio contains a new quick access icon that automatically
current information is not sufficient to demonstrate the reliability creates a Reliability Demonstration Test (RDT) folio and
target. The first 6 specimens failed at the following tensile populates the test plan with the tensile strength the team
stress levels (in Mpa): 212, 236, 248, 254, 271 and 287. wants to be able to demonstrate. Because the software has
automatically populated all of the inputs required for a
If the current data set is not sufficient to demonstrate the parametric binomial test plan, the analysts simply need to
reliability target, the engineers need to design a reliability specify the sample size (10), the maximum number of failures
demonstration test for the additional 10 specimens. (0) and the value they want to solve for. They select to solve
for the required test time because, in this case, the "time" is
Perform the Stress-Strength Analysis with Available Data the tensile strength that the specimens must experience
The first step is to perform the stress-strength analysis for without failure.
the available data to see if it is sufficient to demonstrate the The results are shown next. The analysis indicates that if
reliability goal. The next picture shows the results. the engineers test 10 specimens at a tensile stress of
307.990113 Mpa and there are no failures, then the desired
strength to achieve the required reliability will have been
demonstrated with a 90% confidence.
Xfmea facilitates analysis, data management and reporting for FMEA, FMECA and related analyses.
Supports the major industry standards, such as SAEJ1739, AIAG and MIL-STD-1629A, for all types of
FMEA/FMECA. Provides extensive capabilities to customize the interface and reports.
Supports Risk Priority Numbers (RPNs) and Criticality Analysis for risk assessment.
Provides a complete set of print-ready reports generated in Microsoft Word or Excel, a variety of
pareto (bar), pie and matrix charts and a flexible query utility.
y Supports related analyses such as Control Plans, Design Verification Plans and Design Review Based on
Failure Mode (DRBFM).
e Allows multiple users to work cooperatively on the analysis and provides numerous ways to leverage the
lessons learned from previous analyses, including copy/paste, import/export, etc.
y
http://Xfmea.ReliaSoft.com
e
RCM++ facilitates analysis, data management and reporting for Reliability Centered Maintenance (RCM)analysis.
r
Supports the Equipment Selection, Failure Effect Categorization and Maintenance Task Selection logic
from the major RCMstandards and allows you to customize the logic to meet specific needs.
r Provides simulation-based calculations to compare maintenance strategies based on cost and average
availability over the life of the equipment and to calculate the optimum interval for preventive
y maintenance.
Provides a complete set of print-ready reports generated in Microsoft Word or Excel, a variety of
pareto (bar), pie and matrix charts and a flexible query utility.
Allows multiple users to work cooperatively on the analysis and provides numerous ways to leverage the
lessons learned from previous analyses, including copy/paste, import/export, etc.
Incorporates FMEA/FMECA capabilities, including Risk Priority Numbers (RPNs), Criticality Analysis,
recommended actions tracking, etc.
http://RCM.ReliaSoft.com
8 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 7:New Analysis Capabilities in Synthesis Applications
Using FMEA to Calculate the Baseline System Reliability New in Xfmea and RCM++
Most reliability engineers have recognized the potential to For example, the FMEA team used an occurrence rating
make more effective use of the valuable product reliability of O = 6 if the probability of failure was estimated to be
knowledge captured in a Failure Modes and Effects Analysis approximately 2 per thousand items. This equates to a
(FMEA). For many years, ReliaSoft's database-driven Xfmea quantitative value of 1/500 or .005. Likewise, a rating of O = 7
and RCM++ software tools have greatly improved an was used when the probability of failure was expected to be
organization's ability to store this information in a centralized around 10 per thousand items, for a quantitative value of
location that enables engineers to search for and extract the 1/100 or .01. And so on throughout the rest of the scale.
data they need. Now, with the transition to the Synthesis
Platform in Version 8, the software provides even more
opportunities to leverage the information from FMEAs.
The Failure Modes and Reliability Analysis (FMRA) is
one of the most versatile new integration features. This new
interface combines data from the system configuration and
FMEAs in order to display all of the assemblies, components
and failure modes that could have an impact on the overall
system reliability in a single hierarchical tree. This provides a
powerful and flexible new tool that can be used to facilitate a
variety of more advanced reliability analyses.
One innovative application for the FMRA is to use the
occurrence ratings from the FMEA's risk priority number
(RPN) calculations to generate a preliminary baseline reliability
estimate for the overall system very early in the development
process. The FMRA also makes it possible to integrate new
and better information as it becomes available, which enables Based on these probabilities, a reliability engineer could
design teams to continue to improve the reliability estimate as easily build a 1-parameter exponential reliability model for
the design matures. each failure cause as follows:
Application Example
A design group wants to start estimating the expected
reliability for a new system but it is too early in the development
process to have data from reliability testing. At this stage, only
the following information is available:
Design FMEA performed by a cross-functional team. This gives a simple failure distribution that can be assumed as
a starting point for each potential failure mode until better
Information about the reliability of some components when information becomes available to model the probability more
used in prior designs. accurately.
Engineering judgment and other design-stage analyses,
such as DOE and physics of failure. Creating the "First Draft" FMRA
The next step is to use the failure distributions defined for
They decide to utilize this information and the new FMRA
the potential failure modes in order to estimate the reliabilities
interface in Xfmea to build an initial reliability estimate based
of the components and subsystems, and then finally to
on the information that is currently available. They will use this
estimate the reliability of the system overall.
baseline calculation as a starting point, and continue to
improve the estimate as better data becomes available. Assuming that any one of the failure modes defined in a
component's FMEA could cause the component to fail (i.e.,
Defining Quantitative Values for FMEA Rating Scales the failure modes are considered to be reliability-wise in
The first step is to define a quantitative value to be series), an initial reliability estimate at any given time can be
associated with each rating in the FMEA occurrence scale. obtained by combining the cause probabilities to get the
The following figure shows the rating scale that was used by reliability of the component, and then combining the probabilities
the cross-functional team when assigning occurrence ratings for components and assemblies until we reach the system
to calculate Risk Priority Numbers (RPNs) in the Design level.
FMEA. As you can see, the rating scale criteria already
includes quantitative values that the team used as a guide
when performing the FMEA.
Please Turn to Page 10
e
Vetting and Revising the "First Draft" FMRA
y
The next and most crucial step is to evaluate the
"first draft" FMRA and make the adjustments necessary to
e
ensure it reflects the best possible estimate of the system
reliability based on the information that is currently available.
= Furthermore, if the calculated baseline reliability is lower
Some (but not all) of the recommendations for "vetting" the
than the required reliability, the engineer can use reliability
automatically generated FMRA include:
importance measures to identify critical components or causes,
=
Discount or eliminate issues from the FMEAs that have no add redundancy to the system by using a parallel configuration
impact on reliability. or perform reliability allocation in order to determine which
Y components need to be improved in order to meet the target.
Incorporate other issues that impact reliability but were not
considered in the FMEAs.
,
Account for "common causes" that may appear multiple
times in the FMEAs but actually all represent the same
failure cause.
Review the occurrence ratings and cross-reference them
against any available data or past experience. If
appropriate, coordinate with the FMEA team when
assigned ratings may need further consideration.
Question the exponential distribution assumption (i.e.,
r constant failure rate) and replace the automatically
generated failure models with more appropriate
distributions when applicable. For example, if beta is
known, you can use a 1-parameter Weibull distribution
r coupled with the stated probability.
If the reliability-wise relationship between failure modes The FMRAs in BlockSim and Xfmea can be synchronized
y cannot be modeled with a simple series configuration, use so that any changes made in one tool can be reflected in the
the built-in synchronization with BlockSim (discussed in other. A case where this would be useful is if the performed
the next section) to define a more appropriate configuration FMEAs are at some point updated with additional failure
(e.g., for parallel redundancy). modes or causes, or if the occurrence ratings for specific
causes are revised. Additionally, as test data becomes
Once the analysis has been updated to consider all of the available, the engineers can update the component failure
data and past experience currently available to improve the distributions in the RBD in BlockSim in order to rerun the
analysis, the FMRA will represent at least a partially data-driven analysis and at the same time have this new information be
starting point that can continue to be updated as the product reflected in corresponding FMEAs that include this component.
design matures. Please Turn to Page 11
10 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 10:New Analysis Capabilities in Synthesis Applications
Building Fault Trees and RBDs from Data in an FMEA New in BlockSim
Another powerful application for the direct integration A cross-functional team has been assembled to evaluate
between Xfmea/RCM++ and BlockSim within the Synthesis the risk in the new design. As part of that effort, they want to
Platform is the ability to automatically build fault trees and/or use the data from the FMEAs to:
reliability block diagrams (RBDs) based on data from FMEAs Build fault trees in BlockSim for the high severity effects of
performed at any level in even the most complex system most concern in order to a) clearly depict all of the "failure
configuration. With the release of Version 8, there are now two paths" in the system that might lead to the particular effect
automated utilities designed to facilitate this data sharing: and b) obtain a preliminary estimate of the probability of
Use the Build Effect Fault Trees from Synthesis utility occurrence.
when you need to calculate the probability of occurrence Build a set of RBDs (i.e., diagrams and subdiagrams) that
and understand the risk associated with particular high represent the entire system configuration and all of the
severity effects that the organization is concerned about. completed FMEAs so the team can identify the components
Automation of this process is particularly useful when that have the biggest impact on the system reliability and
dealing with complex systems where multiple FMEAs are perform other system-level analyses.
performed for different subsystems and components, and
the same severe effect may be present in multiple Quantify Occurrence Probabilities for Failure Modes
locations.
The first step is to assign a quantitative failure probability
Use Build RBDs and Fault Trees from Synthesis when to all of the potential failure modes that have been identified in
you need to build a diagram to represent the entire system the FMEAs.
configuration and all of the FMEAs that have been
performed. You can use these RBDs or fault trees to If information about the failure probability is already
perform a variety of more complex system analyses, available, it can be used to define a statistical model for each
which can be used for reliability importance measures, failure cause. For example, if the engineers already have data
reliability allocation, maintenance planning and more. about the probabilities of failure for known failure modes that
have occurred when the component was used under similar
The following simplified example illustrates both of these circumstances in the past, they can analyze the data in
potential applications. Weibull++ and use the Synthesis Platform to "publish" models
that can be linked from the failure causes in the FMEA.
Application Example
If time-to-failure data is not yet available for all of the
The picture below shows part of a turbofan engine system
components and potential failure modes, the occurrence
configuration that was built in Xfmea to manage the FMEAs
ratings from the FMEA's risk priority number (RPN) calculations
performed for critical assemblies/components. Items identified
can be used as a starting point for those modes.
with a blue "F" icon have a completed FMEA. Overall, there
are more than thirty FMEAs for the system. In this case, the engineers review the criteria used by the
FMEA team when setting the occurrence ratings, and they use
Xfmea to associate a quantitative value with each rating, as
shown next.
BlockSim provides a comprehensive platform for system analysis using the exact system reliability function or discrete
event simulation. The software provides sophisticated and flexible capabilities to model systems using a Reliability
Block Diagram (RBD) or Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) approach... or a combination of both!
Supports all relevant RBD configurations and FTAgates/events, along with advanced capabilities for complex
configurations, load sharing, standby redundancy, phases, duty cycles and more.
Exact reliability results and plots based on the exact system reliability function (using an exclusive algorithm
pioneered by ReliaSoft).
y
Extensive simulation options for analysis of repairable systems with a variety of results and plots to support
decision making, including uptime/downtime, availability, expected failures, spare parts requirements, optimum
e
replacement interval, life cycle cost summaries and throughput estimations.
y Powerful features for determining the optimum reliability allocation strategy, identifying components that may
require improvement and performing what-if analyses to evaluate different scenarios.
e http://BlockSim.ReliaSoft.com
RGA was developed in cooperation with Dr. Larry Crow, the leading authority in the field of reliability growth
r analysis, as well as key development partners in government and industry. The software provides all the tools you
need to plan your reliability growth strategy and analyze data from developmental tests. RGA also applies reliability
growth models for fielded repairable system analysis, which provides optimum overhaul times and other results
r
without the detailed data sets that normally would be required.
y Comprehensive platform for traditional reliability growth analysis using the Crow-AMSAA (NHPP), Duane,
Gompertz, Modified Gompertz, Lloyd-Lipow or logistic models.
Exclusive support for innovative approaches that facilitate reliability growth projections, reliability growth
program planning and multi-phase reliability growth analysis. Also offers an operational mission profile
feature for creating balanced test plans and tracking the actual testing against the plan.
A Design of Reliability Test (DRT) utility for repairable systems and a method for analyzing the system's
reliability behavior over time in order to calculate optimum overhaul times and other metrics of interest.
http://RGA.ReliaSoft.com
12 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 11:New Analysis Capabilities in Synthesis Applications
Build Fault Trees for High Severity Effects The Show Results option in the control panel allows the
analysts to use the fault tree diagram to estimate the
The next step is to open the new Build Effect Fault Trees
probability of an uncommanded shutdown at 3,000 hours, as
from Synthesis utility that is now available in BlockSim 8.
shown next.
This window allows the user to type any text criteria to identify
the effect(s) of interest within the FMEA.
As an example, the "uncommanded engine shutdown"
failure effect appears multiple times across different FMEAs,
and it is a major safety concern. The FMEAs did not
consistently use the exact same terminology to describe every
situation in which an uncommanded engine shutdown might
occur. However, the analysts believe that all instances contain
the word "uncommanded" somewhere within the effect
description. In the new BlockSim utility, they specify Effect
then contains then uncommanded for the filter criteria. The
results are displayed as shown next.
14 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 14:New Analysis Capabilities in Synthesis Applications
Register Now!
International
Applied Reliability Symposium
"Sharing applications, success stories and lessons learned in
reliability and maintainability engineering."
http://www.ARSymposium.org
synthesis
A successful workplace thrives on
teamwork, efficiency and innovative
ideas. Why should reliability
noun (from Greek )
engineering be any different?
1. The combining of separate elements
Created with your business needs or substances to form a coherent
whole.
in mind, Synthesis is an integrated
reliability platform that can unite any 2. The act of combining separate ideas,
beliefs and styles, etc.
or all of ReliaSoft's "best-in-class"
reliability engineering applications into
a powerful, easy-to-deploy, enterprise-capable, integrated reliability solution.
The end result is the ability to maximize the efficiency and effectiveness of
reliability activities, which results in time savings, agility and reductions in
both time-to-market and cost, while maximizing the achieved reliability and
associated ROI. Thats the power of the Synthesis Platform!
http://Synthesis.ReliaSoft.com
Introducing the Synthesis Platform
The Synthesis Platform is the result of a multi-year R&D effort focused on developing the right
processes, analysis tools and IT framework to synthesize discrete reliability activities into a
continuously self-improving reliability program with significant contributions from each activity.
Designed to address the feedback and needs expressed by thousands of reliability practitioners in
virtually every industry, the new platform leverages classical reliability engineering methodologies and
existing best practices coupled with a new and intelligent approach to integration.
The Synthesis Platform eliminates these barriers by providing a structured, flexible and secure
back-end database that promotes information sharing between teams of any size, with related or
different subject matter expertise, and coming from the same or different organizational units.
Finally, engineers with different expertise and responsibilities (and even if they're working in different
departments or facilities across the globe) can take advantage of a centralized and structured framework
to facilitate the transfer of reliability knowledge throughout the product life cycle.
Consider just a few basic examples of the many different ways your organization may choose to
use the Synthesis Platform to facilitate, support and enhance Design for Reliability (DFR) and/or
Asset Performance Management (APM) activities.
Working in Weibull++ and ALTA, reliability engineers analyze available data to quantify the probability
of occurrence for known failure modes. This information is then available in Xfmea where...
The Design FMEA team links directly to available analysis results in their efforts to understand
and reduce the risk in the design. Then the FMEA data is available for BlockSim where...
Design engineers leverage the knowledge recorded in the FMEA to build RBDs and/or fault
trees for critical tasks such as estimating the baseline reliability, identifying critical failure modes,
allocating reliability requirements, evaluating risk and planning maintenance strategies...
This type of collaboration continues throughout all other reliability activities and life cycle stages.
As the body of knowledge improves in each stage, automated feedback mechanisms ensure that
the most up-to-date information continues to be available to all activities, providing a continuous,
self-improving, closed knowledge loop.
Automatically Builds a Reliability Knowledge Repository
At the same time that the Synthesis Platform is facilitating information sharing and collaboration for
ongoing projects, the system is simultaneously building a secure, permission-based and searchable
corporate repository of reliability knowledge.
The data, analysis and lessons learned that are captured by the repository can be accessible to
engineers throughout the organization, providing a huge head start on future projects by making it easy
to reuse and build upon existing information.
This instant access to versatile, organization-wide reliability data provides a strong foundation that will
not only save a tremendous amount of time, it will also greatly improve the outcome of future
projects.
20 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 20:Accelerated Testing with the Inverse Power Law
Probably the most important and widely used model for With this example, if testing were conducted at 4 g of input
mechanical systems is the inverse power law (IPL). acceleration, the expected life would be about 35 hours. This
can be related back to a prediction at the operating conditions
(1 g) to a life of about 10,000 hours. The acceleration factor is
256, or 1 hour at 4 g is equivalent to 256 hours at 1 g.
The most critical factor is n, the life-stressor slope with s Basically, using this data, we can test any number of
being stress applied to the system. A is a convenient components to failure in a few days and get feedback about
mathematical constant; in reality it relates the basic mechanical durability at base conditions without testing for 416+ days. In
strength of the design to resist the stress applied to it. practice though, acceleration factors much above 100 can
prove problematic by producing false failures that would not
More generally, if multiple stressors need to be considered, be seen in the field.
the model is given by:
Adding Up Damage Miners Rule
Most systems and components do not see constant stress
input throughout their service lives. In most cases, there are
low high low periods of loading. Likewise in testing, it may
Since most fatigue testing generally fits a Weibull
not be practical to always run at fixed levels of input. At lower
distribution, it may be best to consider the life being modeled
levels, closer to field conditions, the time required to run until
as the mean or B10 life of the component.
failure may be prohibitive. In these cases, it may be
An important measure often used in life testing is the advantageous to "step" or increase the stress over time. The
acceleration factor (AF), which relates how one cycle or hour problem comes down to analyzing the resulting data and
at an elevated stress level (S ) relates to the usage, or base, relating back to field or base conditions.
level (SBase ).
One way of dealing with these sorts of situations is to use
a damage model. The foundation of most damage models is
that each cycle or hour of stress exposure accumulates
damage leading to eventual failure. One of the most popular,
There are many other life-stress relationships that are and easiest to interpret models is Miners rule.
commonly employed based on the underlying physics of
failure. See references [1] and [3] for more information.
2 3 10 124 0.081
3 5 10 16 0.625
TM
Reliability Business Intelligence
ReliaSoft's Orion eAPI (enterprise Asset Performance Intelligence) software is an enterprise solution for asset
r performance management. This web-based system provides a centralized, searchable knowledge base for asset
performance data, which is integrated with powerful analysis tools for transforming raw data into meaningful
information that supports strategic decisions for your organization.
r Collect raw data from a variety of databases and CMMS/EAM systems (such as SAP, Maximo, Oracle,
Access, SQL Server, etc.).
y
Apply the most effective reliability, availability and maintainability (RAM) analysis techniques including, but
not limited to, Life Data Analysis (Weibull analysis), Root Cause Analysis (RCA), Optimum Preventive
Maintenance Intervals, Spare Parts Forecasting and Reliability Growth Tracking (Crow-AMSAA).
Display and track Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Each user can configure the display to fit his/her
particular needs, and the system can send automated e-mail notifications ("KPI Alerts") when a metric
moves beyond a specified range.
Manage improvement projects to control costs and improve availability.
http://Orion.ReliaSoft.com
22 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 21:Accelerated Testing with the Inverse Power Law
Obviously, this simple tool has limitations but it can be
used surprisingly effectively to aid in developing test plans and
in relating results of similar tests run at different levels. In
general, not all samples in any given fatigue-based test will fail
at the same time. Miners rule is probably best used to predict/
scale either B10 or mean life, much like working with the IPL.
1. You can never have too much data. Run at least two
samples at a minimum of three different stress levels. Run
at least one set as close to the field conditions as possible,
even if you do not have time to run to failure. Bias your
samples towards the end of the range. For more, see [1].
24 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 24:Accelerated Testing with the Inverse Power Law
References
1. W. B. Nelson. Accelerated Testing: Statistical Models,
Test Plans, and Data Analysis, USA: Wiley-Interscience,
1990.
2. H. W. McLean. HALT, HASS & HASA Explained, USA:
ASQ Quality Press, 2000.
3. ReliaSoft Corporation. Accelerated Life Testing Reference,
Tucson, AZ: ReliaSoft Publishing, 2007.
DOE++ facilitates traditional Design of Experiments (DOE) techniques for studying the significant factors that affect a
product or process in order to optimize test plans and improve designs. The software also expands upon standard
methods to provide the proper analysis treatment for interval and censored data a major breakthrough for
reliability-related analyses!
Supported design types include:
http://DOE.ReliaSoft.com
26 Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 26:Increasing Mandrel Life in a Cold Ring Rolling Process
machine (where E502 is the old one and Y522 is the new Obtaining the DOE Model
one). Factor E is the length of the mandrel. Factor F is the
In the first phase of analysis, the solution model was
flatness of the mandrel design. Factor G represents the two
obtained with respect to the life response. By reducing the
new materials used to produce the mandrel.
model terms according to the statistical significance (=5%),
Carrying Out the Experiment the results obtained are shown next.
T H E
source for reliability.
Visit src.alionscience.com
or call 888.722.8737 today.
r
TM
28
2007 Alion Science and Technology Corporation
Reliability Edge
Continued from Page 27:Increasing Mandrel Life in a Cold Ring Rolling Process
However, this combination results in a life of 3,897 pieces per Table 3: Confirmation runs
mandrel. This result for life is very low compared to other
Pressure Speed Machine Length Flatness Material Life Cycle
combinations.
4 2 Y522 130 2 Material2 10,490 7.1 sec
4 2 Y522 130 2 Material2 10,200 8.2 sec
4 2 Y522 130 2 Material2 11,200 7.5 sec
Very short
life=3897 pcs.
= 1123
=9069
Concluding Thoughts
This study is a good application of DOE principles to the
(Note: Observant readers may notice from the figure on reliability analysis of machine equipment. In order to improve
page 27 that curvature was found to be significant in the the life characteristic of the mandrel, process parameters
analysis for the cycle time response. This was not a cause of such as the speed of the machine or the material used to
concern for the purposes of this study because the primary manufacture the mandrel are changed in a systematic manner
objective was to improve the life of the mandrels and it was and also noise factors such as the hardness of the material
only necessary to control the cycle time at reasonable are taken into consideration. Optimization of the process
parameters is done with respect to both life and cycle time
levels.)
responses. By the use of the multiple response optimization
When both of the single-response analyses were found to technique, the life of the mandrel was improved by nearly nine
be inadequate, the team decided to perform a third analysis times while keeping the cycle time at reasonable levels.
that considered both life and cycle time together. This analysis
utilized the multiple response optimization features of DOE++, References
and the next figure shows a plot of the optimal solution. 1. ReliaSoft Corporation. Experiment Design and Analysis
Reference, Tucson, AZ: ReliaSoft Publishing, 2008.
2. ReliaSoft Corporation. Hands On: Reliability DOE with
Covariates. Internet: http://www.weibull.com/hotwire/
issue99/hottopics99.htm, May 2009.
3. ReliaSoft Corporation. Importing Data from Excel Files to
DOE++. Internet: http://www.weibull.com/hotwire/
issue107/hottopics107.htm, January 2010.
4. S. R. Schmidt and R. G. Launsby. Understanding Industrial
Designed Experiments, 4th ed. Colorado Springs, CO: Air
Academy Press, 2005.
ReliaSoft's RENOsoftware employs a visual and intuitive flowcharting approach that allows you to build models to
analyze even the most complex probabilistic scenarios via simulation. You can use RENO for a wide variety of
applications, such as risk analysis, complex reliability modeling, maintenance planning, optimization, operational
research and financial analysis.
Easy to Build Flowchart Models: RENOprovides a full array of definitions and constructs to build
flowchart models, including constants, random variables, equation variables, conditionals, logic gates, result
storage and flag markers.
y Flexible Array of Results with Multiple Display Options: RENOs simulation engine can generate a wide
variety of results, including averages, sums, arrays, min/max values and last values. Results can be displayed
e during the simulation, in spreadsheets, in the flowchart or in graphical plots.
Sensitivity Analysis and Optimizations:RENO allows you to vary one or two constants across simulation
y runs based on the starting, ending and increment values that you specify. In addition, the software can
perform multiple simulation runs automatically to determine the value that minimizes or maximizes a
e specific result.
http://RENO.ReliaSoft.com
=
When actual product reliability data is not available, standards based reliability prediction may be used to evaluate
r design feasibility, compare design alternatives, identify potential failure areas, trade-off system design factors and
track reliability improvement. ReliaSoft's Lambda Predict software facilitates reliability prediction analysis based on the
major published standards, including MIL-HDBK-217, Bellcore/Telcordia and NSWC Mechanical.
r
Makes it easy to build the system configuration from scratch or by importing data from Bill of Materials
files, predefined part libraries or other external data sources.
y
Generates a complete array of calculated results (pi factors, failure rates, MTBFs, etc.) along with graphical
charts and customizable reports.
Offers a full set of supporting tools, including reliability allocation, derating analysis and the ability to
transfer and manage your data via flexible import/export or copy/paste.
Provides exclusive access to PartLibraries.org, which allows you to search and import parts data from
MIL-M-38510, EPRD-97 or NPRD-95 (free to all users) as well as more than 300,000 specific commercial
electronic components (yearly subscription required).
http://Predict.ReliaSoft.com
30 Reliability Edge
For Your Information Bulletin Board
Depending on the software product and ReliaSofts Software Products
your particular needs, ReliaSoft offers a variety
Weibull++ Life Data Analysis
of license options, including single user
8.0.8 17-Dec-12 http://Weibull.ReliaSoft.com
licenses, network licenses, unlimited licenses
(for a site, division or corporation) and rentals. ALTA AcceleratedLife Test Data Analysis
With the release of the Synthesis Platform, 8.0.8 17-Dec-12 http://ALTA.ReliaSoft.com
ReliaSoft has introduced more intelligent and DOE++ Experiment Design and Analysis
flexible network license management options. 1.0.7 8-Feb-11 http://DOE.ReliaSoft.com
For example, standard network licenses are BlockSim System Modeling and Analysis
now self-managing with zero IT overhead, and 8.0.8 17-Dec-12 http://BlockSim.ReliaSoft.com
concurrent network licenses can (at your
RGA Reliability Growth Analysis
option) be either self-managing or managed
7.6.1 24-Feb-11 http://RGA.ReliaSoft.com
through a web interface that no longer requires
a network-installed component to monitor Xfmea Failure Mode and Effects Analysis
usage. You now also have the flexibility to 8.0.8 17-Dec-12 http://Xfmea.ReliaSoft.com
customize concurrent network licenses to your RCM++ Reliability Centered Maintenance
usage profiles. 8.0.8 17-Dec-12 http://RCM.ReliaSoft.com
We have also announced bundled software MPC MSG-3 Maintenance Program Creator
product suites that offer significant savings 3.0.17 24-Apr-12 http://MPC.ReliaSoft.com
over purchasing the same products
independently. For users primarily focused on RENO Probabilistic Event and Risk Analysis
product design and development, we offer the 1.0.11 5-Dec-08 http://RENO.ReliaSoft.com
DFR Essentials Suite (with Weibull++, ALTA Lambda Predict Standards Based Reliability Prediction
Standard, BlockSim Single-Thread and Xfmea). 3.1.1 28-Feb-11 http://Predict.ReliaSoft.com
For equipment operation and maintenance, we XFRACAS Web-based FRACAS
offer the RAM Essentials Suite (with Weibull++, 6.0.18 17-Feb-11 http://XFRACAS.ReliaSoft.com
BlockSim Single-Thread and
Orion eAPI Asset Performance Management
RCM++). Both suites include
1.0.5 25-Jul-12 http://Orion.ReliaSoft.com
intelligent integration
between tools, facilitated by Contact ReliaSoft's Corporate Headquarters
the Synthesis Platform. Phone: +1.520.886.0410 or 1.888.886.0410 (toll free in USA and Canada)
Fax: +1.520.886.0399 E-mail: Sales@ReliaSoft.com or Support@ReliaSoft.com
Doug Ogden
VP Customer Services For a directory of international offices, please visit http://Directory.ReliaSoft.com.