Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1
2 1 BACKGROUND
The Battle of Vimy Ridge was the rst instance in The Canadian Corps plan of attack outlining the four objective
which all four Canadian divisions participated in a bat- lines Black, Red, Blue, and Brown
tle together, as a cohesive formation.[12] The nature and
size of the planned Canadian Corps assault necessi-
tated support and resources beyond its normal operational sitions on the top of the ridge and eventually forced the
capabilities.[13] Consequently, the British 5th Infantry Di- German troops holding the southwestern portion of Hill
vision and supplementary artillery, engineer and labour 145 to withdraw.[22][Note 4]
units reinforced the four Canadian divisions already in On the morning of 10 April, Canadian Corps comman-
place. The 24th British Division of I Corps supported der Lieutenant-General Julian Byng moved up three fresh
the Canadian Corps along its northern ank while the brigades to support the continued advance.[24] The fresh
XVII Corps did so to the south.[14] The ad hoc Gruppe units leapfrogged units already in place and captured the
Vimy formation, based under I Bavarian Reserve Corps third objective line, including Hill 135 and the town
commander General der Infanterie Karl Ritter von Fas- of Thlus, by 11:00 am.[25] By 2:00 pm both the 1st
bender, was the principal defending formation with three and 2nd Canadian Divisions reported capturing their -
divisions responsible for manning the frontline defences nal objectives.[26] By this point the Pimple, a heav-
opposite the Canadian Corps.[15] ily defended knoll west of the town of Givenchy-en-
The attack began at 5:30 am on Easter Monday, 9 April Gohelle, was the only German position remaining on
1917. Light eld guns laid down a barrage that ad- Vimy Ridge.[22] On 12 April, the 10th Canadian Brigade
vanced in predetermined increments, often 91 metres attacked and quickly overcame the hastily entrenched
(100 yd) every three minutes, while medium and heavy German troops, with the support of artillery and the 24th
howitzers established a series of standing barrages against British Division.[27] By nightfall on 12 April, the Cana-
known defensive systems further ahead. [16] The 1st, 2nd, dian Corps was in rm control of the ridge.[27] The Cana-
and 3rd Canadian Divisions quickly captured their rst dian Corps suered 10,602 casualties: 3,598 killed and
objectives.[17] The 4th Canadian Division encountered a 7,004 wounded.[28] The German Sixth Army suered an
great deal of trouble during its advance and was unable to unknown number of casualties, and around 4,000 men
complete its rst objective until some hours later.[17] The became prisoners of war.[29]
1st, 2nd, and 3rd Canadian Divisions captured their sec- Although the battle is not generally considered Canadas
ond objective by approximately 7:30 am.[18][19][20] The greatest military achievement, the image of national
failure of the 4th Canadian Division to capture the top unity and achievement imbued the battle with consider-
of the ridge delayed further advances and forced the 3rd able national signicance for Canada.[30][31] According
Canadian Division to expend resources establishing a de- to Pierce, the historical reality of the battle has been re-
fensive line to its north.[21] Reserve units from the 4th worked and reinterpreted in a conscious attempt to give
Canadian Division renewed the attack on the German po- purpose and meaning to an event that came to symbol-
2.1 Selection 3
Imperial War Graves Commission had awarded Canada At the outset, members of the commission debated where
eight sitesve in France and three in Belgium to build Allwards winning design.[37] The jurys assess-
on which to erect memorials.[35][Note 5] Each site rep- ment was that Allwards submission was best suited to
resented a signicant Canadian engagement, and the a low hill rather than to a continuous and lofty blu
Canadian government initially decided that each battle- or cli like Vimy Ridge.[40][38] The commission com-
eld be treated equally and commemorated with iden- mittee initially recommended placing the monument in
tical monuments.[35] In September 1920, the Canadian Belgium on Hill 62, near the location of the Battle of
government formed the Canadian Battleelds Memori- Mont Sorrel, as the site provided an imposing view.[32][43]
als Commission to discuss the process and conditions This ran counter to the desires of Prime Minister William
for holding a memorial competition for the sites in Lyon Mackenzie King who, while speaking in the House
Europe.[37] The commission held its rst meeting on 26 of Commons of Canada in May 1922, argued in favour
November 1920 and during this meeting decided that of placing the memorial at Vimy Ridge.[40] Kings posi-
the architectural design competition would be open to all tion received the unanimous support of the House and,
Canadian architects, designers, sculptors, and artists.[36] in the end, the commission selected Vimy Ridge as the
The jury consisted of Charles Herbert Reilly representing preferred site.[44] The government announced its desire
the Royal Institute of British Architects, Paul Philippe to acquire a more considerable tract of land along the
Cret representing the Socit centrale des architectes ridge after the commission selected Vimy Ridge as the
franais and Frank Darling representing the Royal Archi- preferred location for Allwards design.[45] In the inter-
tectural Institute of Canada.[38] Each jury member was a val between the 1st and 2nd session of the 14th Canadian
leader in the architectural eld; Reilly was training stu- Parliament, Speaker of the Canadian House of Commons
dents in design and development of war memorials, and Rodolphe Lemieux went to France to negotiate the acqui-
Cret had been selected by the United States to design na- sition of more land.[45] On 5 December 1922, Lemieux
tional monuments in Europe.[38] Interested parties sub- concluded an agreement with France in which France
mitted 160 design drawings, and the jury selected 17 sub- granted Canada freely and for all time the use of 100
missions for consideration, commissioning each nalist to hectares (250 acres) of land on Vimy Ridge, inclusive of
produce a plaster maquette of their respective design.[39] Hill 145, in recognition of Canadas war eort.[46] The
The jury recommended in a 10 September 1921 report to only condition placed on the donation was that Canada
the commission that two of the designs be executed.[40] In use the land to erect a monument commemorating Cana-
4 2 HISTORY
dian soldiers killed during the First World War and as- site.[51][47] Allward moved to Paris in 1925 to supervise
sume the responsibility for the maintenance of the memo- construction and the carving of the sculptures.[52] Con-
rial and the surrounding battleeld park.[46] struction commenced in 1925 and took eleven years to
complete.[53] The Imperial War Graves Commission con-
currently employed French and British veterans to carry
2.2 Memorial construction out the necessary roadwork and site landscaping.[52]
While awaiting the rst delivery of stone, Simson noticed
that the battleeld landscape features were beginning to
deteriorate.[47] Seeing an opportunity to not only preserve
a portion of the battleeld but also keep his sta occu-
pied, Simson decided to preserve a short section of trench
line and make the Grange Subway more accessible.[47]
Labourers rebuilt and preserved sections of sandbagged
trench wall, on both the Canadian and German sides of
the Grange crater group, in concrete.[47] The workforce
also built a new concrete entrance for the Grange Sub-
way and, after excavating a portion of the tunnel system,
installed electric lighting.[47]
forced Allward to relent and incorporate the names of quiries by November 1934.[61] The Legion presumptu-
the missing on the memorial walls.[58] The task of in- ously announced that the memorial would be unveiled on
scribing the names did not begin until the early 1930s Dominion Day, 1 July 1936, even though the government
and employed a typeface that Allward designed for the still did not know when it would be completed.[61]
monument.[47] For event planning purposes, the Legion and the gov-
ernment established areas for which each was responsi-
ble. The government was responsible for selection of
2.3 Pilgrimage and unveiling
the ocial delegation and the program for the ocial
unveiling of the memorial. The Legion was responsi-
ble for the more challenging task of organizing the pil-
grimage. For the Legion this included planning meals,
accommodations and transportation for what was at the
time the largest single peacetime movement of people
from Canada to Europe.[62] The Legion took the posi-
tion that the pilgrimage would be funded by its members
without subsidies or nancial aid from Canadian taxpay-
ers, and by early 1935 they had established that the price
of the 3-week trip, inclusive of all meals, accommo-
dation, health insurance, and sea and land transportation
would be CA$160 per person ($2,779.18 as of 2016).
Indirect assistance came in a number of forms. The gov-
ernment waived passport fees and made a special Vimy
passport available to pilgrims at no extra cost.[63] The gov-
ernment and private sector also provided paid leave for
their participating employees.[61] It was not until April
1936 that the government was prepared to publicly com-
mit to an unveiling date, 26 July 1936.[61] On 16 July, the
ve transatlantic liners, escorted by HMCS Champlain
and HMCS Saguenay, departed the Port of Montreal with
approximately 6,200 passengers and arrived in Le Havre
on 24 and 25 July.[Note 8][64][65] The limited accommoda-
tion made it necessary for the Legion to lodge pilgrims in
nine cities throughout northern France and Belgium and
employ 235 buses to move the pilgrims between various
locations.[64]
Special passport issued by Canada for the 1936 Vimy pilgrimage
attended by Canadian Prime Minister Brian Mulroney in patchwork repairs, replace damaged stones with ma-
and at least 5,000 people.[86][87][88] Subsequent smaller- terial from the original quarry in Croatia, and correct
scale ceremonies were held at the memorial in 1997 and all minor displacement of stones caused by the freeze-
2002.[89][90] thaw activity.[91] Underlying structural aws were also
corrected.[94]
2.6 Restoration and rededication Queen Elizabeth II, escorted by Prince Philip, Duke of
Edinburgh, rededicated the restored memorial on 9 April
2007 in a ceremony commemorating the 90th anniversary
of the battle.[95] Other senior Canadian ocials, includ-
ing Prime Minister Stephen Harper, and senior French
representatives, Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin
among them, attended the event, along with thousands
of Canadian students, veterans of the Second World War
and of more recent conicts, and descendants of those
who fought at Vimy.[96] The crowd attending the reded-
ication ceremony was the largest crowd on the site since
the 1936 dedication.[96]
the towns of Vimy and Neuville-Saint-Vaast. The site is The Breaking of the Sword is located at the southern cor-
one of the few places on the former Western Front where ner of the front wall while Sympathy of the Canadians for
a visitor can see the trench lines of a First World War the Helpless is located at the northern corner.[112] Collec-
battleeld and the related terrain in a preserved natural tively, the two groups are The Defenders and represent
state.[101][102] The total area of the site is 100 hectares the ideals for which Canadians gave their lives during the
(250 acres), much of which is forested and o limits to war.[112] There is a cannon barrel draped in laurel and
visitors to ensure public safety. The sites rough terrain olive branches carved into the wall above each group,
and buried unexploded munitions make the task of grass to symbolize victory and peace.[111][113] In Breaking of
cutting too dangerous for human operators.[103] Instead, the Sword, three young men are present, one of whom is
sheep graze the open meadows of the site.[104] crouching and breaking his sword.[112] This statue repre-
sents the defeat of militarism and the general desire for
The site was established to honour the memory of the
Canadian Corps, but it also contains other memorials. peace.[114] This grouping of gures is the most overt im-
age to pacism in the monument, the breaking of a sword
These are dedicated to the French Moroccan Division,
Lions Club International, and Lieutenant-Colonel Mike being extremely uncommon in war memorials.[115] The
Watkins. There are also two Commonwealth War Graves original plan for the sculpture included one gure crush-
Commission cemeteries on site: Canadian Cemetery No. ing a German helmet with his foot.[52] It was later de-
2 and Givenchy Road Canadian Cemetery.[105][106] Be- cided to dismiss this feature because of its overtly mili-
yond being a popular location for battleeld tours, the taristic imagery.[52] In Sympathy of the Canadians for the
site is also an important location in the burgeoning eld Helpless, one man stands erect while three other gures,
of First World War battleeld archaeology, because of its stricken by hunger or disease, are crouched and kneeling
preserved and largely undisturbed state.[107] The sites in- around him. The standing man represents Canadas sym-
terpretive centre helps visitors fully understand the Vimy pathy for the weak and oppressed.[116]
Memorial, the preserved battleeld park, and the history The gure of a cloaked young woman stands on top and
of the Battle of Vimy within the context of Canadas at the centre of the front wall and overlooks the Douai
participation in the First World War.[108] The Canadian Plains. She has her head bowed, her eyes cast down, and
National Vimy Memorial and Beaumont-Hamel New- her chin resting in one hand. Below her at ground level
foundland Memorial sites comprise close to 80 percent is a sarcophagus, bearing a Brodie helmet and a sword,
of conserved First World War battleelds in existence and draped in laurel branches.[112] The saddened gure
and between them receive over one million visitors each of Canada Bereft, also known as Mother Canada, is a
year.[109] national personication of the young nation of Canada,
mourning her dead.[112][Note 9] The statue, a reference to
traditional images of the Mater Dolorosa and presented
3.1 Vimy memorial in a similar style to that of Michelangelo's Piet, faces
eastward looking out to the dawn of the new day.[117]
Unlike the other statues on the monument, stonemasons
carved Canada Bereft from a single 30 tonne block of
stone.[117] The statue is the largest single piece in the mon-
ument and serves as a focal point.[117] The area in front of
the memorial was turned into a grassed space, which All-
ward referred to as the amphitheatre, that fanned out from
the monuments front wall for a distance of 270 feet (82
m) while the battle-damaged landscape around the sides
and back of the monument were left untouched.[118]
The twin pylons rise to a height 30 metres above the
memorials stone platform; one bears the maple leaf for
Canada and the other the eur-de-lis for France, and both
symbolize the unity and sacrice of the two countries.[111]
At the top of the pylons is a grouping of gures known
Left-front view showing an entire aspect of the Memorial collectively as the Chorus.[92] The most senior gures rep-
resent Justice and Peace;[119] Peace stands with a torch up-
Allward constructed the memorial on the vantage point of raised, making it the highest point in the region.[120] The
Hill 145, the highest point on the ridge.[110] The memorial pair is in a style similar to Allwards previously commis-
contains many stylized features, including 20 human g- sioned statues of Truth and Justice, located outside the
ures, which help the viewer in contemplating the structure Supreme Court of Canada in Ottawa.[121] The remainder
as a whole. The front wall, normally mistaken for the rear, of the Chorus is located directly below the senior gures:
is 7.3 metres (24 ft) high and represents an impenetrable Faith, Hope and Truth on the eastern pylon; and Honour,
wall of defence.[52] There is a group of gures at each Charity and Knowledge on the western pylon.[122] Around
end of the front wall, next to the base of the steps.[111]
3.2 Moroccan Division Memorial 9
signicant territorial gains.[130] The Moroccan Division, in the successful disarming of 3 tonnes of deteriorated
which was part of the XXXIII Army Corps, quickly ammonal explosives located under a road intersection on
moved through the German defences and advanced 4 the site.[136]
kilometres (4,400 yd) into German lines in two hours.[131]
The division managed to capture the height of the ridge,
with small parties even reaching the far side of the ridge, 3.5 Visitors centre
before retreating due to a lack of reinforcements.[5] Even
after German counter-attacks, the division managed to The site has a visitors centre, staed by Canadian stu-
hold a territorial gain of 2,100 metres (2,300 yd).[131] The dent guides, which is open seven days a week.[137] Dur-
division did however suer heavy casualties. Those killed ing the memorial restoration, the original visitors centre
in the battle and commemorated on the memorial include near the monument was closed and replaced with a tem-
both of the divisions brigade commanders, Colonels porary one, which remains in use today.[138] The visitors
Gaston Cros and Louis Augustus Theodore Pein.[132] centre is now near the preserved forward trench lines,
close to many of the craters created by underground min-
ing during the war and near the entrance of the Grange
3.3 Grange Subway Subway.[139] Construction of a new educational visitors
centre is expected to be completed by April 2017, in ad-
The First World Wars Western Front included an ex- vance of the 100th anniversary of the battle.[140] The new
tensive system of underground tunnels, subways, and CA$10 million visitor centre is a public-private partner-
dugouts. The Grange Subway is a tunnel system that is ship between government and the Vimy Foundation.[141]
approximately 800 metres (870 yd) in length and once In order to raise funds the Vimy Foundation granted nam-
connected the reserve lines to the front line. This permit- ing rights in various halls of the visitor centre to sponsors,
ted soldiers to advance to the front quickly, securely, and an approach which has met some level of controversy due
unseen.[133] A portion of this tunnel system is open to the to the site being a memorial park.[141]
public through regular guided tours provided by Canadian
student guides.[134]
The Arras-Vimy sector was conducive to tunnel excava-
tion owing to the soft, porous yet extremely stable nature
4 Sociocultural inuence
of the chalk underground.[133] As a result, pronounced
underground warfare had been a feature of the Vimy
sector since 1915.[133] In preparation for the Battle of
Vimy Ridge, ve British tunnelling companies excavated
12 subways along the Canadian Corps front, the longest
of which was 1.2 kilometres (1,300 yd) in length.[135]
The tunnellers excavated the subways at a depth of 10
metres to ensure protection from large calibre howitzer
shellre.[135] The subways were often dug at a pace of four
metres a day and were often two metres tall and one metre
wide.[133] This underground network often incorporated
or included concealed light rail lines, hospitals, command
posts, water reservoirs, ammunition stores, mortar and
machine gun posts, and communication centres.[135]
The Canadian National Vimy Memorial site has consider- Canadian Corps on Vimy Ridge surrounding the memo-
able sociocultural signicance for Canada. The idea that rial, though the memorial was still several years away
Canadas national identity and nationhood were born out from completion.[150] The memorial has been the subject
of the Battle of Vimy Ridge is an opinion that is widely re- of stamps in both France and Canada, including a French
peated in military and general histories of Canada.[33][34] series in 1936 and a Canadian series on the 50th anniver-
Historian Denise Thomson suggests that the construc- sary of the Armistice of 11 November 1918.[151] The
tion of the Vimy memorial represents the culmination Canadian Unknown Soldier was selected from a cemetery
of an increasingly assertive nationalism that developed in in the vicinity of the Canadian National Vimy Memo-
Canada during the interwar period.[142] Hucker suggests rial, and the design of the Canadian Tomb of the Un-
that the memorial transcends the Battle of Vimy Ridge known Soldier is based upon the stone sarcophagus at
and now serves as an enduring image of the whole First the base of the Vimy memorial.[152] The Never Forgot-
World War, while expressing the enormous impact of war ten National Memorial was intended to be a 24-metre
in general,[143] and also considers that the 2005 restora- (79 ft) statue inspired by the Canada Bereft statue on the
tion project serves as evidence of a new generations de- memorial, before the project was cancelled in February
termination to remember Canadas contribution and sac- 2016.[153] A 2001 Canadian historical novel The Stone
rice during the First World War.[143] Carvers by Jane Urquhart involves the characters in the
The Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada rec- design and creation of the memorial.[154] In 2007, the
ognized the importance of the site by recommending memorial was a short-listed selection for the Seven Won-
its designation as one of the National Historic Sites of ders of Canada.[155] The Royal Canadian Mint released
Canada; it was so designated in 1996, and is one of only commemorative coins featuring the memorial on several
two outside of Canada.[144] The other is the Beaumont- occasions, including a 5 cent sterling silver coin in 2002
Hamel Newfoundland Memorial, also in France. Re- and a 30 dollar sterling silver coin in 2007. The Sacrice
membrance has also taken other forms: the Vimy Foun- Medal, a Canadian military decoration created in 2008,
dation, having been established to preserve and promote features the image of Mother Canada on the reverse side
Canadas First World War legacy as symbolized by the of the medal.[156] A permanent bas relief sculpted image
victory at the Battle of Vimy Ridge, and Vimy Ridge of the memorial is presented in the gallery of the grand
Day, to commemorate the deaths and casualties during hall of the Embassy of France in Canada to symbolize the
the battle.[145] Local Vimy resident Georges Devloo spent close relations between the two countries.[157] The memo-
13 years until his death in 2009 oering car rides to Cana- rial is featured on the reverse of the Frontier Series Cana-
dian tourists to and from the memorial at no charge, as dian polymer $20 banknote, which was released by the
a way of paying tribute to the Canadians who fought at Bank of Canada on 7 November 2012.[158]
Vimy.[146][147]
The memorial is not without its critics. Alana Vincent
has argued that constituent parts of the monument are in
5 See also
conict, and as a result the message conveyed by the mon-
ument is not unied.[148] Visually, Vincent argues there is World War I memorials
a dichotomy between the triumphant pose of the gures
at the top of the pylons and the mourning posture of those
gures at the base. Textually, she argues the inscription 6 Notes
text celebrating the victory at the Battle of Vimy Ridge
strikes a very dierent tone to the list of names of the
[1] It is not possible to remove the names of those whose
missing at the base of the monument.[149] bodies have been discovered or identied since the con-
struction of the memorial. As a result, several individ-
uals are commemorated on both the memorial and by
a headstone.[1] Although 11,285 names appear on the
memorial, only 11,169 are commemorated as missing.
The memorial is regularly the subject or inspiration of [4] German records indicate that the defending German units
other artistic projects. In 1931, Will Longsta painted withdrew because they had fully run out of ammunition,
Ghosts of Vimy Ridge, depicting ghosts of men from the mortar rounds, and grenades.[23]
12 7 CITATIONS
[5] The eight sites were Vimy, Bourlon Wood, Le Quesnel, [23] Sheldon 2008, p. 309.
Dury, and Courcelette in France and St. Julien, Hill 62
(Sanctuary Wood), and Passchendaele in Belgium.[36] [24] Campbell 2007, p. 179.
[6] Critical approval included Group of Seven artist A. Y. [25] Campbell 2007, pp. 179181.
Jackson providing a supporting position in a letter pub-
[26] Campbell 2007, p. 182.
lished by Canadian Forum.[42]
[27] Nicholson 1962, p. 263.
[7] The government was acting on behalf of a request by the
Imperial War Graves Commission which was tasked with [28] Moran 2007, p. 139.
commemorating all killed and missing Commonwealth
soldiers and was, as a result, prepared to share in the cost [29] Gibbs, Philip (11 April 1917). All of Vimy Ridge
of the memorial.[58] Cleared of Germans (PDF). The New York Times. The
New York Times Company. Retrieved 14 November
[8] The ships were SS Montrose, SS Montcalm, SS Antonia, 2009.
SS Ascania and SS Duchess of Bedford.[61]
[30] Inglis 1995, p. 1.
[9] Dancer turned model Edna Moynihan served as the
model with the statue itself being carved by Italian Luigi [31] Vance 1997, p. 233.
Rigamonti.[47]
[32] Pierce 1992, p. 5.
[2] Farr 2007, p. 147. [36] Canadian Battleelds Memorials Committee. Veteran
Aairs Canada. 25 March 2007. Retrieved 12 January
[3] Rose & Nathanail 2000, pp. 396397, Fig. 14.3. 2008.
[6] Tucker 1996, p. 68. [39] Design Competition. Veteran Aairs Canada. 25
March 2007. Retrieved 22 May 2013.
[7] Tucker 1996, p. 8.
[40] Borestad 2008, p. 33.
[8] Boire 1992, p. 15.
[41] Vance 1997, p. 67.
[9] Samuels 1996, pp. 200202.
[42] Borestad 2008, p. 32.
[10] Sheldon 2008, p. 149.
[43] Hucker 2007, p. 283.
[11] Victoria Cross List Tells Heroic Deeds (PDF). The New
York Times. The New York Times Company. 21 August [44] Vance 1997, pp. 6669.
1916. Retrieved 17 September 2009.
[45] Inglis 1995, p. 61.
[12] Cook 2007, p. 120.
[46] Canada Treaty Information. Department of Foreign
[13] Nicholson 1962, p. 229. Aairs and International Trade. 26 February 2002.
Archived from the original on 21 September 2013. Re-
[14] Turner 2005, p. 39. trieved 4 January 2008.
[21] Hayes 2007, pp. 202203. [53] The Battle of Vimy Ridge Fast Facts. VAC Canada
Remembers. Veterans Aairs Canada. n.d. Retrieved 22
[22] Godefroy 2007, p. 220. May 2013.
13
[54] Picard, Andra (May 2006). Restoring Loss at Vimy. [86] Inglis 1995, p. 92.
Canadian Architect. Business Information Group. Re-
trieved 1 August 2009. [87] Doyle, Patrick (10 April 1992). Vimy Ridge 'sacrice'
forged unity PM declares. Toronto Star. p. A3.
[55] Brandon 2006, p. 9.
[88] Inglis 1995, p. 107.
[56] Brandon 2003, p. 206.
[89] MacGregor, Tom (1 September 1997). Return To The
[57] Design and Construction of the Vimy Ridge Memorial. Ridge. Legion Magazine. Royal Canadian Legion.
Veterans Aairs Canada. 12 August 1998. Retrieved 22
May 2013. [90] Ceremony marks 85th anniversary of Vimy Ridge bat-
tle. Canadian Press. 7 April 2002.
[58] Duy 2008, p. 197.
[91] Smith 2008, p. 52.
[59] Vincent 2014, p. 99.
[92] Valpy, Michael (7 April 2007). Setting a legend in
[60] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 40. stone. The Globe and Mail. Toronto. Retrieved 22 May
2013.
[61] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 42.
[93] Hucker 2007, p. 288.
[62] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 41.
[94] Smith 2008, p. 53.
[63] MacIntyre 1967, p. 197.
[95] Bell, Bouseld & Tooli 2007, p. 140.
[64] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 45.
[96] Kennedy, Tom (9 April 2007). National News. CTV Tele-
[65] Reynolds 2007, p. 68.
vision Network.
[66] John Mould Diaries : Return to Vimy. Archives of On-
[97] Siekierska, Alicja (31 March 2017), Toronto photographer
tario. n.d. Retrieved 4 January 2010.
to open exhibition to commemorate battle of Vimy Ridge,
[67] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 46. Toronto Star, retrieved 1 April 2017
[68] Brown & Cook 2011, pp. 37-38. [98] Prime Minister to travel to France for the 100th anniver-
sary of the Battle of Vimy Ridge. Prime Minister of
[69] Cook, Tim (2 April 2017). The event that recast the Bat- Canada. Government of Canada. 24 March 2017. Re-
tle of Vimy Ridge. Toronto Star. Toronto. Retrieved 8 trieved 31 March 2017.
April 2017.
[99] Franois Hollande et Bernard Cazeneuve conrment leur
[70] Evans 2007, p. 126. venue Vimy le 9 avril, Le Voix du Nord, 25 March 2017,
retrieved 1 April 2017
[71] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 47.
[100] Deachman, Bruce (22 March 2016), Governor Gen-
[72] Morton & Wright 1987, p. 221. eral, French ambassador unveil Vimy centenary memorial
[73] Bell, Bouseld & Tooli 2007, p. 139. stamps, Ottawa Citizen, retrieved 4 April 2017
[74] Foot, Richard (4 April 2007). Vimy memorial had a tur- [101] Rose & Nathanail 2000, p. 216.
bulent history of its own. The Vancouver Sun. Vancou-
[102] Lloyd 1998, p. 120.
ver. p. A4.
[103] Annual Report 20072008 (PDF). Commonwealth War
[75] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 51.
Graves Commission. 2008. p. 16. Archived from the
[76] Brown & Cook 2011, p. 52. original (PDF) on 14 June 2011. Retrieved 10 January
2010.
[77] Duringer 2007, p. 293.
[104] Turner 2005, p. 7.
[78] Duringer 2007, p. 300.
[105] CWGC :: Cemetery Details Canadian Cemetery No. 2,
[79] Duringer 2007, p. 294. Neuville-St. Vaast. Commonwealth War Graves Com-
mission. n.d. Retrieved 13 March 2009.
[80] Duringer 2007, p. 297.
[106] CWGC :: Cemetery Details Givenchy Road Cana-
[81] The Canadian Unknown Soldier. After the Battle. Battle dian Cemetery, Neuville-St. Vaast. Commonwealth War
of Britain Intl. Ltd. (109). ISSN 0306-154X. Graves Commission. n.d. Retrieved 13 March 2009.
[82] Duringer 2007, p. 298. [107] Saunders pp. 101108
[83] Inglis 1995, p. 76. [108] Interpretive Centre at the Canadian National Vimy
[84] Inglis 1995, p. 79. Memorial. Veterans Aairs Canada. 22 March 2007.
Archived from the original on 13 November 2007. Re-
[85] Inglis 1995, p. 80. trieved 14 November 2009.
14 7 CITATIONS
[109] Canadian Battleeld Memorials Restoration Project. [134] Turner 2005, p. 90.
Veterans Aairs Canada. 19 January 2007. Retrieved
13 March 2009. [135] Barton, Doyle & Vandewalle 2004, p. 200.
[110] Brandon 2003, p. 12. [136] Beaver, Paul (14 August 1998). Obituary: Lt-Col Mike
Watkins. The Independent. London. Retrieved 26 April
[111] Brandon 2006, p. 10. 2009.
[112] Hucker 2007, p. 282. [137] Visitor information. Veterans Aairs Canada. n.d. Re-
trieved 10 February 2016.
[113] Hopkins 1919, p. 188.
[138] New Visitor Education Centre For Vimy. Veterans Af-
[114] Bolling 2003, p. 310. fairs Canada. 25 November 2015. Retrieved 10 February
[115] Prost 1997, p. 316. 2016.
[117] Duy 2008, p. 194. [140] Vimy Ridge Memorial in France to get visitor centre.
Global News. 14 May 2013. Retrieved 10 February 2016.
[118] Hucker 2008, p. 46.
[141] Crawford, Blair (11 January 2017), Corporate branding
[119] Brandon 2006, p. 13. will be 'subtle' and 'tasteful' at new Vimy Ridge centre in
France, Ottawa Citizen, retrieved 17 March 2017
[120] Nicholson 1973, p. 33.
[142] Thomson 19951996, pp. 527.
[121] Brandon 2006, p. 12.
[143] Hucker 2007, p. 280.
[122] Vincent 2011, p. 59.
[144] Vimy Ridge National Historic Site of Canada. Parks
[123] Victoria Cross (VC) Recipients. Veterans Aairs Canada. 9 September 2000. Retrieved 2 April 2017.
Canada.
[145] Mission. Vimy Foundation. n.d. Retrieved 9 February
[124] Trouillard, Stphanie (6 May 2015). Grande Guerre : la 2016.
Division marocaine qui n'avait de marocaine que le nom
[Great War: the Moroccan Division is Moroccan in name [146] Harris, Kathleen (13 November 2009). "'Grandpa of
only] (in French). France 24. Vimy' gives rides for sweets. London Free Press. Sum
Media Corp.
[125] Inauguration du monument la Division marocaine lev
la cote 140, plateau de Vimy, route de Neuville-Saint- [147] Arsenault, Adrienne (10 February 2009). Au revoir to
Vaast Givenchy-en-Gohelle (Pas de Calais), le 14 juin the grand-pre of Vimy. Canadian Broadcasting Com-
1925 [Inauguration of the Moroccan Division raised on hill pany. Retrieved 10 February 2009.
140, Vimy Ridge, Road Neuville-Saint-Vaast in Givenchy-
en-Gohelle (Pas de Calais), 14 June 1925] (in French), [148] Vincent 2014, pp. 5860.
Paris: Berger-Levrault, 1926
[149] Vincent 2014, pp. 5960.
[126] Monument aux morts de la division marocaine [War
memorial of the Moroccan division]. Lens-Livin Tourist [150] Will Longstas Menin Gate at midnight (Ghosts of
Menin Gate)". Australian War Memorial. n.d. Retrieved
Information and Cultural Heritage Oce. n.d.
11 January 2010.
[127] Forgotten Heroes North Africans and the Great War
19141919 (PDF). Forgotten Heroes 1419 Foundation. [151] Bister, Mick (March 2011). The 1936 'Vimy Ridge' Is-
p. 10. Archived from the original (PDF) on 19 October sue (259). Journal of the France and Colonies Philatelic
2014. Society.
[128] Vincent-Chaissac, p. 33. [152] Designing and Constructing. Tomb of the Unknown
Soldier. Veterans Aairs Canada. 5 May 2000. Re-
[129] Das 2011, p. 316. trieved 8 January 2010.
[130] Simkins, Jukes & Hickey 2002, p. 48. [153] Parks Canada backs out of controversial 'Mother Canada'
war memorial project in Cape Breton. National Post. 5
[131] Doughty 2005, p. 159. February 2016. Retrieved 8 February 2016.
[132] HISTOIRE : La bataille de l'Artois du 9 mai au 22 juin [154] Cavell 2015, pp. 6869.
1915 avec l'attaque du 2e Rgiment de marche du 1er
Etranger [HISTORY: The Battle of Artois from 9 May to [155] Vimy Memorial, France. Canadian Broadcasting Com-
22 June 1915 with the attack of the 2nd Regiment of the pany. n.d. Retrieved 7 January 2010.
1st Foreign Legion] (in French). Fdration des Socits
d' Anciens de la Lgion trangre. n.d. [156] New military medal to honour combat casualties. Cana-
dian Broadcasting Company. 29 August 2008. Retrieved
[133] Rose & Nathanail 2000, p. 398. 7 January 2010.
15
[157] Embassy of France in Canada, virtual visit. Embassy of Campbell, David (2007). The 2nd Canadian Divi-
France in Canada. January 2004. Retrieved 10 January sion: A 'Most Spectacular Battle'". In Hayes, Ge-
2010. orey; Iarocci, Andrew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy
Ridge: A Canadian Reassessment. Waterloo: Wil-
[158] Twenty Dollar Bill. CTV. n.d. Retrieved 6 May 2012.
frid Laurier University Press. pp. 171192. ISBN
0-88920-508-6.
Brandon, Laura (2003). Canvas of War. In Fabijani, Tony (2003). Croatia: Travels in Undis-
Busch, Briton Cooper. Canada and the Great covered Country. University of Alberta. ISBN 0-
War: Western Front Association Papers. Montreal: 88864-397-7.
McGill-Queens University Press. pp. 203215.
ISBN 0-7735-2570-X. Farr, Don (2007). The Silent General: A Biogra-
phy of Haigs Trusted Great War Comrade-in-Arms.
Brandon, Laura (2006). Art or Memorial? : The Solihull: Helion & Company Limited. ISBN 978-
Forgotten History of Canadas War Art. Calgary: 1-874622-99-4.
University of Calgary Press. ISBN 1-55238-178-1.
Godefroy, Andrew (2007). The German Army at
Brown, Eric; Cook, Tim (Spring 2011). The 1936 Vimy Ridge. In Hayes, Georey; Iarocci, An-
Vimy Pilgrimage. Canadian Military History. Lau- drew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy Ridge: A Canadian
rier Centre for Military Strategic and Disarmament Reassessment. Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University
Studies. 20 (2): 3354. Press. pp. 225238. ISBN 0-88920-508-6.
16 8 REFERENCES
Hayes, Georey (2007). The 3rd Canadian Di- Nicholson, Gerald W. L. (1973). We will remem-
vision: Forgotten Victory. In Hayes, Georey; ber ...": Overseas Memorials to Canadas War Dead.
Iarocci, Andrew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy Ridge: A Ottawa: Minister of Veterans Aairs for Canada.
Canadian Reassessment. Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier
University Press. pp. 193210. ISBN 0-88920- Pierce, John (Spring 1992). Constructing Mem-
508-6. ory: The Vimy Memorial (PDF). Canadian Mil-
itary History. Laurier Centre for Military Strategic
Hopkins, J. Castell (1919). Canada at War, 1914 and Disarmament Studies. 1 (12): 414. Archived
1918: A Record of Heroism and Achievement. from the original (PDF) on 5 March 2009. Re-
Toronto: Canadian Annual Review. trieved 2 February 2009.
Hucker, Jacqueline (2007). The Meaning and Sig- Pedersen, Peter (2012). ANZACS on the West-
nicance of the Vimy Monument. In Hayes, Ge- ern Front: The Australian War Memorial Battleeld
orey; Iarocci, Andrew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy Guide. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Ridge: A Canadian Reassessment. Waterloo: Wil- Prost, Antoine (1997). Monuments to the Dead.
frid Laurier University Press. pp. 279290. ISBN In Nora, Pierre; Kritzman, Lawrence; Goldhammer,
0-88920-508-6. Arthur. Realms of memory: the construction of the
Hucker, Jacqueline (2008). Vimy: A Monument French past. New York: Columbia University Press.
for the Modern World. Journal of the Society for pp. 307332. ISBN 0-231-10634-3.
the Study of Architecture in Canada. Society for the Reynolds, Ken (2007). ""Not A Man Fell Out and
Study of Architecture in Canada. 33 (1): 3948. the Party Marched Into Arras Singing": The Royal
Guard and the Unveiling of the Vimy Memorial,
Humphries, Mark Osborne (2007). "'Old Wine in
1936. Canadian Military History. 17 (3): 5768.
New Bottles: A Comparison of British and Cana-
dian Preparations for the Battle of Arras. In Hayes, Reynolds, Ken (2008). From Alberta to Avion:
Georey; Iarocci, Andrew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy Private Herbert Peterson, 49th Battalion, CEF.
Ridge: A Canadian Reassessment. Waterloo: Wil- Canadian Military History. 16 (3): 6774.
frid Laurier University Press. pp. 6585. ISBN 0-
88920-508-6. Rose, Edward; Nathanail, Paul (2000). Geology and
Warfare: Examples of the Inuence of Terrain and
Inglis, Dave (1995). Vimy Ridge: 19171992, Geologists on Military Operations. London: Geolog-
A Canadian Myth over Seventy Five Years (PDF). ical Society. ISBN 0-85052-463-6.
Burnaby: Simon Fraser University. Retrieved 22
May 2013. Samuels, Mart (1996). Command or Control?:
Command, Training and Tactics in the British and
Lloyd, David (1998). Battleeld tourism: pilgrimage German Armies, 18881918. Portland: Frank Cass.
and the commemoration of the Great War in Britain, ISBN 0-7146-4570-2.
Australia and Canada, 19191939. Oxford: Berg
Saunders, Nicholas (2002). Excavating memories:
Publishing. ISBN 1-85973-174-0.
archaeology and the Great War, 19142001. An-
MacIntyre, Duncan E. (1967). Canada at Vimy. tiquity. Portland Press. 76 (291): 101108.
Toronto: Peter Martin Associates. Sheldon, Jack (2008). The German Army on Vimy
Moran, Heather (2007). The Canadian Army Ridge 19141917. Barnsley (UK): Pen & Sword
Medical Corps at Vimy Ridge. In Hayes, Georey; Military. ISBN 978-1-84415-680-1.
Iarocci, Andrew; Bechthold, Mike. Vimy Ridge: A Simkins, Peter; Jukes, Georey; Hickey, Michael
Canadian Reassessment. Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier (2002). The First World War: The Western Front,
University Press. pp. 139154. ISBN 0-88920- 19171918. Osprey Publishing. ISBN 978-1-
508-6. 84176-348-4.
Morton, Desmond; Wright, Glenn (1987). Winning Smith, Julian (2008). Restoring Vimy: The Chal-
the Second Battle: Canadian Veterans and the Return lenges of Confronting Emerging Modernism. Jour-
to Civilian Life, 19151930. Toronto: University of nal of the Society for the Study of Architecture in
Toronto Press. Canada. Society for the Study of Architecture in
Canada. 33 (1): 4956.
Nicholson, Gerald W. L. (1962). Ocial History of
the Canadian Army in the First World War: Cana- Thomson, Denise (Winter 19951996). National
dian Expeditionary Force 19141919 (PDF). Ot- Sorrow, National Pride: Commemoration of War in
tawa: Queens Printer and Controller of Stationary. Canada, 19181945. Journal of Canadian Studies.
Retrieved 1 January 2007. 30 (4): 527.
17
9 External links
Ocial website
10.2 Images
File:1936_Vimy_pilgrimage_passport.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b1/1936_Vimy_pilgrimage_
passport.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: Canadian War Museum Artifact Number: 19900069-002 Original artist: Government
of Canada
File:Canadian_Battlefields_Memorials_Commission_-_Design_Comp.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/
commons/2/24/Canadian_Battlefields_Memorials_Commission_-_Design_Comp.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: Veterans
Aairs Canada [1] Original artist: n.d.
File:Canadian_Forces_emblem.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/9b/Canadian_Forces_emblem.svg Li-
cense: CC-BY-SA-3.0 Contributors:
Canadian_Forces_Flag.svg Original artist: Canadian_Forces_Flag.svg: User:R-41
File:Commons-logo.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/4/4a/Commons-logo.svg License: PD Contributors: ? Origi-
nal artist: ?
File:Folder_Hexagonal_Icon.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/4/48/Folder_Hexagonal_Icon.svg License: Cc-by-
sa-3.0 Contributors: ? Original artist: ?
File:Ghosts_of_Vimy_Ridge.jpeg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/34/Ghosts_of_Vimy_Ridge.jpeg Li-
cense: Public domain Contributors: Canadian House of Commons Collection, (AN: O-4714) Original artist: William Longsta
File:HM_King_Edward_VIII_unveiling_the_figure_of_Canada_on_the_Vimy_Ridge_Memorial.jpg Source: https:
//upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/HM_King_Edward_VIII_unveiling_the_figure_of_Canada_on_the_Vimy_Ridge_
Memorial.jpg License: Public domain Contributors: This image is available from Library and Archives Canada under the reproduction
reference number PA-148880 and under the MIKAN ID number 3224327
Original artist: Cdn. Govt. Motion Pict. Bureau/National Film Board of Canada
File:Hitler_touring_Vimy_Memorial_in_June_1940.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a0/Hitler_touring_
Vimy_Memorial_in_June_1940.jpg License: ? Contributors:
Deutsches Nachrichtenbro, approx 2-5 June 1940
Facts in Review, German Library of Information, 10 June 1940
The Legionary, Royal Canadian Legion, 1964
Original artist:
Heinrich Homann
Nazi German Ministry of Public Enlightenment and Propaganda
File:Maple_Leaf_(from_roundel).svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fc/Maple_Leaf_%28from_
roundel%29.svg License: CC-BY-SA-3.0 Contributors:
Roundel_of_the_Royal_Canadian_Air_Force_(1946-1965).svg Original artist: Roundel_of_the_Royal_Canadian_Air_Force_(1946-
1965).svg: F l a n k e r
File:People_icon.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/37/People_icon.svg License: CC0 Contributors: Open-
Clipart Original artist: OpenClipart
10.3 Content license 19