Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
9]
Original Article
Department of Recreation, Human Performance and Leisure Studies and Exercise Science and Human Nutrition Laboratory,
Howard University Cancer Centre, 1Department of Medicine, Division of Cardiology, Howard College of Medicine and
Howard University Hospital, 2Department of Internal Medicine, Howard University Hospital, Washington DC, USA,
3
Department of Medical Pharmacology, AUA College of Medicine, Antigua and Barbuda, and Manipal University, Manipal,
Karnataka, India, 4Departments of Behavioural Sciences and Neuroscience and 5Medical Physiology, AUA College of
Medicine, Antigua and Barbuda
Abstract
Background: Hypertensive individuals are known to exhibit greater increases in blood pressure during an isometric handgrip exercise(IHE)
than their normotensive counterparts. Aim: This study tests the hypothesis that, compared to normotensive individuals, prehypertensive
individuals exhibit an exaggerated response to IHE. Materials and Methods: In this study, the effects of IHE were compared in matched
prehypertensive vs. normotensive healthy AfricanAmerican females. Six healthy young adult AfricanAmerican female university students
were screened in a physicians office for blood pressure in the range of prehypertension, systolic blood pressure(SBP) 120139 mmHg and
diastolic blood pressure(DBP) 8089 mmHg. Six young adult AfricanAmerican women were also recruited to serve as a healthy normotensive
control group with SBP119 mmHg and DBP79 mmHg. Cardiovascular fitness was determined by peak oxygen uptake(VO2 peak)
measured during a progressive exercise test. Results: During the handgrip exercise, the prehypertensive group exhibited greater increases
in SBP(from 1396 to 20511mmHg, +48%) than the controls(from 1323 to 1453mmHg, +10%); intergroup difference
P<0.001. The prehypertensive group also exhibited greater increases in DBP(from 772 to 1125mmHg, +46%) compared to the
controls(from 723 to 784mmHg, +8%); intergroup difference P<0.001. The increase in systemic vascular resistance was also greater
in the prehypertensive group(from 171391 to 2807370 dyne.s.cm-5, +64%) than in the controls(from 166880 to 1812169
dyne.s.cm-5, +9%); intergroup difference P<0.05. Conclusion: These results suggest that blood pressure measurements performed during
IHE may be a useful screening tool in evaluating prehypertensive individuals for antihypertensive treatments.
Keywords: Arterial compliance, blood pressure, heart rate, myocardial oxygen demand, systemic vascular resistance
Address for correspondence: Dr.Richard M. Millis, Department of Medical Physiology, American University of Antigua College of Medicine,
Jabberwock Beach Road, Antigua and Barbuda. Email:rmillis@auamed.net
How to cite this article: Bond V, Curry BH, Adams RG, Obisesan T,
DOI: Pemminati S, Gorantla VR, et al. Cardiovascular responses to an isometric
10.4103/1947-2714.185032 handgrip exercise in females with prehypertension. North Am J Med Sci
2016;8:243-9.
blood pressure of 120139 mmHg and diastolic blood Review Board of Howard University, and written
pressure of 8089 mmHg, measured at rest.[4] High total informed consent was obtained from all participants.
peripheral resistance is the most commonly reported
mechanism for the mildly increased blood pressure in Prior to enrollment into the study, the participants
hypertension, which is often accompanied by decreased underwent blood pressure screening in a physicians
arterial compliance.[5] It is unclear whether these changes office at the Howard University Hospital to determine the
occur in prehypertension.[6] presence or absence of prehypertension. Blood pressure
measurements were performed on three separate visits
Aerobic exercise and mental stress have been used during similar times of the day and the participants
as provocation tests to identify individuals with underwent three blood pressure measurements per
prehypertension.[79] However, such exercise testing is visit. After 5min of rest, blood pressure measurements
often not amenable to routine screening in a primary were performed on the left arm in a seated position
care physicians office. Isometric handgrip exercise using a standard sphygmomanometer blood pressure
has been used to demonstrate that heathy young adult cuff and stethoscope. Manual blood pressure recordings
offspring of hypertensive parents had higher resting were performed by a single research investigator using
and postexercise systolic and diastolic blood pressures the same sphygmomanometer, cuff, and stethoscope.
than offspring of normotensive parents. [10] African Participants were assigned to the prehypertension group
American women are reported to have one of the when resting systolic arterial pressure was between
highest prevalence of hypertension in the world with 120 and 139 mmHg and diastolic pressure was between
higher blood pressures than their CaucasianAmerican 80 and 89 mmHg, as defined by The seventh report of
counterparts.[11] Compared with healthy young men, the Joint National Committee on Prevention, Detection,
healthy young women appear to be protected from Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure
high blood pressure by the vasodilator activity of (JNC7).[4] Changes in blood pressure have been reported
estrogens; women are also reported to possess less in normotensive and mildly hypertensive women during
sympathetic influence on their cardiovascular systems the different phases of the menstrual cycle.[14] Thus, all
than men.[12,13] screenings and testing conditions of the study were
performed during the luteal phase of the participants
These findings suggest that young adult AfricanAmerican menstrual cycle.
women are particularly vulnerable to having their
blood pressures go undetected when they are mildly After meeting the screening criteria, the participants
elevated, thereby putting them at risk for developing visited the laboratory on a separate day for subscreening
hypertension. These women are also likely to have measurements of body height and weight, body
morbidity and mortality from cardiovascular disease as composition, and peak oxygen uptake (VO2 peak).
middle and elderly aged adults. The present study was, Physical activity was assessed using the Godin
therefore, designed to determine whether an isometric LeisureTime Exercise Questionnaire.[15] Body height
handgrip exercise is useful for identifying women with and weight were measured using standard laboratory
prehypertension and exaggerated vasopressor responses procedures. Measurement of body composition included
who may be at high risk for developing cardiovascular fat mass measured by a scanner using dual energy
disease. Xray absorptiometry (DEXA, Hologic QDR 4500
DXA System, Hologic, Waltham, MA). Cardiovascular
Materials and Methods fitness was determined by VO2 peak measured during a
progressive exercise test. After screenings, on a separate
Six healthy young adult AfricanAmerican female day, participants entered the laboratory with prior
university students volunteered as study participants instructions to abstain from food for 3h and from exercise
and were screened in a physicians office for for 12h prior to testing. The participants then performed
blood pressure in the range of prehypertension, an isometric handgrip dynamometer exercise test. The
systolic pressure 120139 mmHg, and diastolic procedure of the isometric handgrip exercise test was
pressure 8089 mmHg. Six young adult African explained to all the study participants. Before the test,
American women were also recruited to serve as a they were allowed to rest for 10min. The participants
healthy normotensive control group with systolic were then instructed to perform the isometric handgrip
blood pressure 119 mmHg and diastolic blood exercise under supervision. They were asked to hold a
pressure79 mmHg. All individuals were nonsmokers Smedley handgrip spring dynamometer(Independent
and physically inactive. A subscreening of the Living Products, Peoria, AZ) in their left hand to
participants consisted of age, body weight, body get a full grip of it and compress the handles of the
composition, and cardiovascular fitness. The study dynamometer by exerting maximal effort for a few
was approved by the Human Participants Institutional seconds. The performance of maximal handgrip
blood pressures were also significantly greater in the augmented cardiovascular responses that can be elicited
prehypertension group. by an isometric handgrip exercise. This handgrip exercise
induced greater rise in systolic, diastolic, pulse pressures,
The prehypertension group exhibited greater increases in systemic (arterial) resistance, and heart ratepressure
systemic vascular resistance(from 171391 to 2807370 product (index of myocardial oxygen demand) in the
dyne s cm5, +64%) than the normotensive control prehypertensive subjects. The decrement in strokevolume/
group(from 166880 to 1812169 dynescm5, +9%); pulsepressure quotient(index of arterial compliance) was
intergroup difference P<0.05, as shown in Figure2. The also greater in the prehypertensive subjects.
prehypertension group also had greater increases in the
ratepressure product than the control group(P<0.05). Despite the fact that the physicians office blood pressure
The ratepressure product was also greater in the of the two study groups was significantly different,
prehypertension group during recovery. the two groups were indistinguishable by baseline
measurements of their cardiovascular variables. This
The pulsepressure/strokevolume quotient and arterial might be attributed to whitecoat anxiety and/or
compliance before, during, and after the handgrip laboratory testing stress produced by instruments and
exercise are represented in Figure3. The pulse pressure instructing the subjects, as well as by the unfamiliar
was increased and the pulse-pressure/strokevolume environment of a research facility. Stressinduced
quotient was decreased during the handgrip exercise increases in cardiac output and blood pressure are
in both groups, with greater decrements in the common responses to stress in normotensive individuals
prehypertension group(P<0.05). by the mechanism of betaadrenergic stimulation.[20]
some hypertensive individuals.[33] This finding suggests variables of interest suggest a very low probability of a
that our participants with prehypertension were probably type1 statistical error. However, the small sample size
exhibiting sympathetic vasopressor responses during the cannot rule out the probability of a type 2 statistical
isometric handgrip exercises, quite similar to what has error, which requires further investigation with a larger
been reported for patients diagnosed with hypertension. number of subjects. The results described here should,
therefore, be considered as a preliminary report.
Decreased arterial compliance, measured as the
strokevolume/endsystolic pressure quotient, has
been demonstrated following isometric handgrip
Conclusion
exercise in patients diagnosed with hypertension.[34] We This preliminary report suggests that a single bout of
computed arterial compliance by measuring the area isometric handgrip exercise may reveal exaggerated
under the curve for the decay in aortic pressure during blood pressure responses in a group of healthy young
diastole, which showed a marginally greater decrease adult AfricanAmerican females with physicians office
during the handgrip exercise in the prehypertension blood pressure in the range of prehypertension. Despite
group(P=0.07). We also computed arterial compliance the limitation of small sample size, the differences in
as the strokevolume/pulsepressure quotient. The blood pressure responses between normotensive controls
change in strokevolume/pulse-pressure quotient was and the prehypertension comparison group were highly
statistically more significant than the diastolic pressure significant, similar to previously discussed differences
decay during the handgrip exercise in the group with between groups of normotensive and hypertensive
prehypertension(P=0.018). It is likely, therefore, that subjects. These findings seem to suggest that isometric
arterial stiffness was increased during the handgrip handgrip exercise may be a useful technique for
exercise, with greater stiffness in the prehypertensive identifying subpopulations of prehypertensive subjects
than in the normotensive subjects. Arterial stiffness is for whom the risk of developing chronic hypertension
a component of increased SVR, as well as a structural and cardiovascular disease may be abated by early
property that permits storage of energy to buffer sudden employment of antihypertensive treatments.
increases in arterial pressure. The capacity for energy
storage is very low in a rigid structure such as a lead
Financial support and sponsorship
pipe. Both SVR and stiffness of the arterial system were,
therefore, increasing, becoming more like a lead pipe, in This work supported in part by NIH/NCRR/RCMI
the prehypertensive than in the normotensive subjects Grant No.2G12RR003048 to Howard University.
during the handgrip exercise.
Conflicts of interest
Effect of the isometric handgrip exercise on There are no conflicts of interest.
myocardial oxygen demand
The greater increases in blood pressure and SVR References
observed in the group with prehypertension during
1. KarpinosAR, RoumieCL, NianH, DiamondAB, RothmanRL.
the handgrip exercise were associated with greater High prevalence of hypertension among collegiate football
increases in the ratepressure product. Increased athletes. Cir Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2013;6:71623.
ratepressure product has been reported in healthy 2. Adhikari P, Pemminati S, Pathak R, Kotian MS, Ullal S.
subjects during isometric handgrip exercise.[35] Increased Prevalence of hypertention in boloor diabetes study(BDSII)
myocardial oxygen demand is a key factor in myocardial and its risk factors. JClin Diagn Res 2015;9:IC014.
ischemia and infarction, for which hypertension is 3. DagogoJack S, Egbuonu N, Edeoga C. Principles and
a known risk factor. [35] Our findings suggest that practice of nonpharmacological interventions to reduce
the greater blood pressure and SVR increases in the cardiometabolic risk. Med Princ Pract 2010;19:16775.
prehypertension group in this study were likely to be 4. Chobanian AV, Bakris GL, Black HR, Cushman WC,
GreenLA, Izzo JL Jr, etal. The Seventh Report of the Joint
clinically significant. Increased myocardial oxygen National Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation,
demand during the handgrip exercise may, therefore, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure: The JNC7 report.
reveal those individuals who could benefit from the early JAMA 2003;289:256072.
introduction of antihypertensive treatments. 5. Ferrier KE, Muhlmann MH, Baguet JP, Cameron JD,
JenningsGL, DartAM, etal. Intensive cholesterol reduction
Study limitations lowers blood pressure and large artery stiffness in isolated
systolic hypertension. JAm Coll Cardiol 2002;39:10205.
The major limitation of this pilot study is the small sample 6. KingwellBA, Large artery stiffness: Implications for exercise
size. The highly significant Pvalues for the intergroup capacity and cardiovascular risk. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol
differences in the dependent cardiovascular response 2002;29:2147.
7. Medeiros RF, Silva BM, Neves FJ, Rocha NG, Sales AR, exercise blood pressure response during treadmill testing as
Nobrega AC. Impaired hemodynamic response to mental a predictor of future hypertension in men: A longitudinal
stress in subjects with prehypertension is improved study. Am J Hypertens 2015;28:13627.
after a single bout of maximal dynamic exercise. Clinics 23. AneniE, RobersonLL, ShaharyarS, BlahaMJ, AgatstonAA,
2011;66:15239. BlumenthalRS, etal. Delayed heart rate recovery is strongly
8. SchultzMG, HareJL, MarwickTH, StowasserM, SharmanJE. associated with early and latestage prehypertension during
Masked hypertension is unmasked by lowintensity exercise stress testing. Am J Hypertens 2014;27:51421.
exercise blood pressure. Blood Press 2011;20:2849. 24. Karoline de Morais P, Sales MM, Alves de Almeida J,
9. SchultzMG, OtahalP, ClelandVJ, BlizzardL, MarwickTH, MottaSantos D, Victor de Sousa C, Simes HG. Effects of
Sharman JE.Exerciseinduced hypertension, cardiovascular aerobic exercise intensity on 24h ambulatory blood pressure
events, and mortality in patients undergoing exercise in individuals with type 2 diabetes and prehypertension.
stress testing: Asystematic review and metaanalysis. Am J JPhys Ther Sci 2015;27:516.
Hypertens 2013;26:35766. 25. BrookRD, AppelLJ, RubenfireM, OgedegbeG, BisognanoJD,
10. Garg R, Malhotra V, Dhar U, Tripathi Y. The isometric Elliott WJ, etal. Beyond medications and diet: Alternative
handgrip exercise as a test for unmasking hypertension approaches to lowering blood pressure: Ascientific statement
in the offspring of hypertensive parents. J Clin Diagn Res from the American Heart Association. Hypertension
2013;7:9969. 2013;61:136083.
11. Goldstein KM, Melnyk SD, Zullig LL, Stechuchak KM, 26. Lopes HF, ConsolimColombo FM, BarretoFilho JA,
OddoneE, BastianLA, etal. Heart matters: Gender and racial RiccioGM, Negro CE, KriegerEM. Increased sympathetic
differences cardiovascular disease risk factor control among activity in normotensive offspring of malignant hypertensive
veterans. Womens Health Issues 2014;24:47783. parents compared to offspring of normotensive parents. Braz
12. HartEC, CharkoudianN, WallinBG, CurryTB, EisenachJH, J Med Biol Res 2008;41:84953.
JoynerMJ. Sex differences in sympathetic neuralhemodynamic 27. TanakaS, SugiuraT, YamashitaS, DohiY, KimuraG, OhteN.
balance: Implications for human blood pressure regulation. Differential response of central blood pressure to isometric
Hypertension 2009;53:5716. and isotonic exercises. Sci Rep 2014;25:5439.
13. JoynerMJ, BarnesJN, HartEC, WallinBG, CharkoudianN. 28. Campos L, Bader M, Baltatu OC. Brain renin angiotensin
Neural control of the circulation: How sex and age differences system in cardiac hypertrophy and failure. Front Physiol
interact in humans. Compr Physiol 2015;5:193215. 2012;3:115.
14. DunneFP, BarryDG, FerrissJB, GrealyG, MurphyD. Changes 29. McGowan CL, Notarius CF, McReynolds A, Morris BL,
in blood pressure during the normal menstrual cycle. Clin Sci Kimmerly DS, Picton PE, etal. Effect of angiotensin AT1
1991:81:5158. receptor blockade on sympathetic responses to handgrip in
15. GodinG, ShephardRJ. Asimple method to assess exercise healthy men. Am J Hypertens 2011;24:53743.
behavior in the community. Can J Appl Sport Sci 1985;10:1416. 30. Hamada M, Kazatani Y, Shigematsu Y, Ito T, Kokubu T,
16. HagerH, MandadiG, PulleyD, EagonJC, MaschaE, NutterB, Ishise S. Enhanced blood pressure response to isometric
Kurz A. A comparison of noninvasive blood pressure handgrip exercise in patients with essential hypertension:
measurement on the wrist with invasive arterial blood Effects of propranolol and prazosin. JHypertens 1987;5:3059.
pressure monitoring in patients undergoing bariatric surgery. 31. Alexander T, Friedman DB, Levine BD, Pawelczyk JA,
Obes Surg 2009;19:71724. MitchellJH. Cardiovascular responses during static exercise.
17. Liang YL, Teede H, Kotsopoulos D, Shiel L, Cameron JD, Studies in patients with complete heart block and dual
DartAM, McGrathBP. Noninvasive measurement of arterial chamber pacemakers. Circulation 1994;89:16437.
structure and function: Repeatability, interrelationships and 32. NisellH, HjemdahlP, LindeB, LunellNO. Cardiovascular
trial sample size. Clin Sci 1998;95:66979. responses to isometric handgrip exercise: An invasive
18. Zion AS, Bond V, Adams RG, Williams D, Fullilove RE, study in pregnancyinduced hypertension. Obstet Gynecol
Sloan RP, etal. Low arterial compliance in young 1987;70:33943.
AfricanAmerican males. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 33. Chirinos JA, Segers P, Raina A, Saif H, Swillens A,
2003;285:H45762. GuptaAK, etal. Arterial pulsatile hemodynamic load induced
19. Stergiopulos N, Meister JJ, Westerhof N. Evaluation of by isometric exercise strongly predicts left ventricular
methods for estimation of total arterial compliance. Am J mass in hypertension. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol
Physiol 1995;268:H15408. 2010;298:H32030.
20. Balanos GM, Phillips AC, Frenneaux MP, McIntyre D, 34. Kuznetsova T, Dhooge J, KlochBadelek M, Sakiewicz W,
LykidisC, GriffinHS, etal. Metabolically exaggerated cardiac Thijs L, Staessen JA. Impact of hypertension on
reactions to acute psychological stress: The effects of resting ventriculararterial coupling and regional myocardial work
blood pressure status and possible underlying mechanisms. at rest and during isometric exercise. JAm Soc Echocardiogr
Biol Psychol 2010:85:10411. 2012;25:88290.
21. Fletcher GF, Ades PA, Kligfield P, Arena R, Balady GJ, 35. Muller MD, Gao Z, Mast JL, Blaha CA, Drew RC,
BittnerVA, etal. Exercise standards for testing and training: LeuenbergerUA, SinowayLI. Aging attenuates the coronary
Ascientific statement from the American Heart Association. blood flow response to cold air breathing and isometric
Circulation 2013:128:873934. handgrip in healthy humans. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol
22. JaeSY, FranklinBA, ChooJ, ChoiYH, FernhallB. Exaggerated 2012;302:H173746.