Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 254

Rules for the Classification of

Naval Ships

PART C - Machinery, Systems and


Fire Protection
Chapter 1

NR 483.C1 DT R01 E November 2011

Marine Division
92571 Neuilly sur Seine Cedex France
Tel: + 33 (0)1 55 24 70 00 Fax: + 33 (0)1 55 24 70 25
Marine website: http://www.veristar.com
Email: veristarinfo@bureauveritas.com
2011 Bureau Veritas - All rights reserved
MARINE DIVISION
GENERAL CONDITIONS
ARTICLE 1 5.4. - The Services of the Society cannot create any obligation bearing on the Society or constitute any
1.1. - BUREAU VERITAS is a Society the purpose of whose Marine Division (the "Society") is the classi- warranty of proper operation, beyond any representation set forth in the Rules, of any Unit, equipment or
fication (" Classification ") of any ship or vessel or structure of any type or part of it or system therein col- machinery, computer software of any sort or other comparable concepts that has been subject to any sur-
lectively hereinafter referred to as a "Unit" whether linked to shore, river bed or sea bed or not, whether vey by the Society.
operated or located at sea or in inland waters or partly on land, including submarines, hovercrafts, drilling ARTICLE 6
rigs, offshore installations of any type and of any purpose, their related and ancillary equipment, subsea 6.1. - The Society accepts no responsibility for the use of information related to its Services which was not
or not, such as well head and pipelines, mooring legs and mooring points or otherwise as decided by the provided for the purpose by the Society or with its assistance.
Society.
6.2. - If the Services of the Society cause to the Client a damage which is proved to be the direct
The Society: and reasonably foreseeable consequence of an error or omission of the Society, its liability to-
prepares and publishes Rules for classification, Guidance Notes and other documents (Rules); wards the Client is limited to ten times the amount of fee paid for the Service having caused the
issues Certificates, Attestations and Reports following its interventions (Certificates); damage, provided however that this limit shall be subject to a minimum of eight thousand (8,000)
publishes Registers. Euro, and to a maximum which is the greater of eight hundred thousand (800,000) Euro and one
1.2. - The Society also participates in the application of National and International Regulations or Stand- and a half times the above mentioned fee.
ards, in particular by delegation from different Governments. Those activities are hereafter collectively re- The Society bears no liability for indirect or consequential loss such as e.g. loss of revenue, loss
ferred to as " Certification ". of profit, loss of production, loss relative to other contracts and indemnities for termination of oth-
1.3. - The Society can also provide services related to Classification and Certification such as ship and er agreements.
company safety management certification; ship and port security certification, training activities; all activi- 6.3. - All claims are to be presented to the Society in writing within three months of the date when the Serv-
ties and duties incidental thereto such as documentation on any supporting means, software, instrumen- ices were supplied or (if later) the date when the events which are relied on of were first known to the Client,
tation, measurements, tests and trials on board. and any claim which is not so presented shall be deemed waived and absolutely barred. Time is to be in-
1.4. - The interventions mentioned in 1.1., 1.2. and 1.3. are referred to as " Services ". The party and/or its terrupted thereafter with the same periodicity.
representative requesting the services is hereinafter referred to as the " Client ". The Services are pre- ARTICLE 7
pared and carried out on the assumption that the Clients are aware of the International Maritime 7.1. - Requests for Services are to be in writing.
and/or Offshore Industry (the "Industry") practices.
7.2. - Either the Client or the Society can terminate as of right the requested Services after giving
1.5. - The Society is neither and may not be considered as an Underwriter, Broker in ship's sale or char- the other party thirty days' written notice, for convenience, and without prejudice to the provisions
tering, Expert in Unit's valuation, Consulting Engineer, Controller, Naval Architect, Manufacturer, Ship- in Article 8 hereunder.
builder, Repair yard, Charterer or Shipowner who are not relieved of any of their expressed or implied
obligations by the interventions of the Society. 7.3. - The class granted to the concerned Units and the previously issued certificates remain valid until the
date of effect of the notice issued according to 7.2. here above subject to compliance with 2.3. here above
ARTICLE 2 and Article 8 hereunder.
2.1. - Classification is the appraisement given by the Society for its Client, at a certain date, following sur- 7.4. - The contract for classification and/or certification of a Unit cannot be transferred neither assigned.
veys by its Surveyors along the lines specified in Articles 3 and 4 hereafter on the level of compliance of
a Unit to its Rules or part of them. This appraisement is represented by a class entered on the Certificates ARTICLE 8
and periodically transcribed in the Society's Register. 8.1. - The Services of the Society, whether completed or not, involve, for the part carried out, the payment
2.2. - Certification is carried out by the Society along the same lines as set out in Articles 3 and 4 hereafter of fee upon receipt of the invoice and the reimbursement of the expenses incurred.
and with reference to the applicable National and International Regulations or Standards. 8.2. Overdue amounts are increased as of right by interest in accordance with the applicable leg-
2.3. - It is incumbent upon the Client to maintain the condition of the Unit after surveys, to present islation.
the Unit for surveys and to inform the Society without delay of circumstances which may affect the 8.3. - The class of a Unit may be suspended in the event of non-payment of fee after a first unfruitful
given appraisement or cause to modify its scope. notification to pay.
2.4. - The Client is to give to the Society all access and information necessary for the safe and efficient ARTICLE 9
performance of the requested Services. The Client is the sole responsible for the conditions of presenta- 9.1. - The documents and data provided to or prepared by the Society for its Services, and the information
tion of the Unit for tests, trials and surveys and the conditions under which tests and trials are carried out. available to the Society, are treated as confidential. However:
ARTICLE 3 clients have access to the data they have provided to the Society and, during the period of classifica-
3.1. - The Rules, procedures and instructions of the Society take into account at the date of their tion of the Unit for them, to the classification file consisting of survey reports and certificates which
preparation the state of currently available and proven technical knowledge of the Industry. They have been prepared at any time by the Society for the classification of the Unit;
are not a standard or a code of construction neither a guide for maintenance, a safety handbook copy of the documents made available for the classification of the Unit and of available survey reports
or a guide of professional practices, all of which are assumed to be known in detail and carefully can be handed over to another Classification Society, where appropriate, in case of the Unit's transfer
followed at all times by the Client. of class;
Committees consisting of personalities from the Industry contribute to the development of those docu- the data relative to the evolution of the Register, to the class suspension and to the survey status of the
ments. Units, as well as general technical information related to hull and equipment damages, are passed on
3.2. - The Society only is qualified to apply its Rules and to interpret them. Any reference to them to IACS (International Association of Classification Societies) according to the association working
has no effect unless it involves the Society's intervention. rules;
the certificates, documents and information relative to the Units classed with the Society may be
3.3. - The Services of the Society are carried out by professional Surveyors according to the applicable
reviewed during certificating bodies audits and are disclosed upon order of the concerned governmen-
Rules and to the Code of Ethics of the Society. Surveyors have authority to decide locally on matters re-
tal or inter-governmental authorities or of a Court having jurisdiction.
lated to classification and certification of the Units, unless the Rules provide otherwise.
3.4. - The operations of the Society in providing its Services are exclusively conducted by way of The documents and data are subject to a file management plan.
random inspections and do not in any circumstances involve monitoring or exhaustive verifica- ARTICLE 10
tion. 10.1. - Any delay or shortcoming in the performance of its Services by the Society arising from an event
ARTICLE 4 not reasonably foreseeable by or beyond the control of the Society shall be deemed not to be a breach of
contract.
4.1. - The Society, acting by reference to its Rules:
reviews the construction arrangements of the Units as shown on the documents presented by the Cli- ARTICLE 11
ent; 11.1. - In case of diverging opinions during surveys between the Client and the Society's surveyor, the So-
conducts surveys at the place of their construction; ciety may designate another of its surveyors at the request of the Client.
classes Units and enters their class in its Register; 11.2. - Disagreements of a technical nature between the Client and the Society can be submitted by the
surveys periodically the Units in service to note that the requirements for the maintenance of class are Society to the advice of its Marine Advisory Committee.
met. ARTICLE 12
The Client is to inform the Society without delay of circumstances which may cause the date or the 12.1. - Disputes over the Services carried out by delegation of Governments are assessed within the
extent of the surveys to be changed. framework of the applicable agreements with the States, international Conventions and national rules.
ARTICLE 5 12.2. - Disputes arising out of the payment of the Society's invoices by the Client are submitted to the Court
5.1. - The Society acts as a provider of services. This cannot be construed as an obligation bearing of Nanterre, France.
on the Society to obtain a result or as a warranty. 12.3. - Other disputes over the present General Conditions or over the Services of the Society are
5.2. - The certificates issued by the Society pursuant to 5.1. here above are a statement on the level exclusively submitted to arbitration, by three arbitrators, in London according to the Arbitration
of compliance of the Unit to its Rules or to the documents of reference for the Services provided Act 1996 or any statutory modification or re-enactment thereof. The contract between the Society
for. and the Client shall be governed by English law.
In particular, the Society does not engage in any work relating to the design, building, production ARTICLE 13
or repair checks, neither in the operation of the Units or in their trade, neither in any advisory serv- 13.1. - These General Conditions constitute the sole contractual obligations binding together the
ices, and cannot be held liable on those accounts. Its certificates cannot be construed as an im- Society and the Client, to the exclusion of all other representation, statements, terms, conditions
plied or express warranty of safety, fitness for the purpose, seaworthiness of the Unit or of its value whether express or implied. They may be varied in writing by mutual agreement.
for sale, insurance or chartering. 13.2. - The invalidity of one or more stipulations of the present General Conditions does not affect the va-
5.3. - The Society does not declare the acceptance or commissioning of a Unit, nor of its construc- lidity of the remaining provisions.
tion in conformity with its design, that being the exclusive responsibility of its owner or builder, 13.3. - The definitions herein take precedence over any definitions serving the same purpose which may
respectively. appear in other documents issued by the Society.
BV Mod. Ad. ME 545 k - 17 December 2008
RULES FOR THE CLASSIFICATION OF
NAVAL SHIPS

Part C
Machinery, Systems and Fire Protection

Chapters 1 2 3 4

Chapter 1 MACHINERY
Chapter 2 ELECTRICAL INSTALLATIONS
Chapter 3 AUTOMATION
Chapter 4 FIRE PROTECTION, DETECTION AND EXTINCTION

November 2011
C HAPTER 1
M ACHINERY

Section 1 General Requirements


1 General 19
1.1 Application
1.2 Additional requirements
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
1.4 Definitions
2 Design and construction 19
2.1 General
2.2 Materials, welding and testing
2.3 Vibrations
2.4 Operation in inclined position
2.5 Ambient conditions
2.6 Power of machinery
2.7 Astern power
2.8 Safety devices
2.9 Fuels
3 Arrangement and installation on board 21
3.1 General
3.2 Floors
3.3 Bolting down
3.4 Safety devices on moving parts
3.5 Gauges
3.6 Ventilation in machinery spaces
3.7 Hot surfaces and fire protection
3.8 Communications
3.9 Machinery remote control, alarms and safety systems
4 Tests and trials 22
4.1 Works tests
4.2 Trials on board

Section 2 Diesel Engines


1 General 23
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
1.3 Definitions
2 Design and construction 25
2.1 General
2.2 Materials and welding
2.3 Crankshaft
2.4 Crankcase
2.5 Cylinder overpressure gauge

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 3


2.6 Scavenge manifolds
2.7 Systems
2.8 Starting air system
2.9 Cooling system
2.10 Control and monitoring
3 Arrangement and installation 31
3.1 Starting arrangements
3.2 Turning gear
3.3 Trays
3.4 Exhaust gas system
4 Type tests, material tests, workshop inspection and testing, certification 32
4.1 Type tests - General
4.2 Type tests of engines not admitted to an alternative inspection scheme
4.3 Type tests of engines admitted to an alternative inspection scheme
4.4 Material and non-destructive tests
4.5 Workshop inspections and testing
4.6 Certification

Section 3 Pressure Equipments


1 General 39
1.1 Principles
1.2 Application
1.3 Definitions
1.4 Classes
1.5 Applicable Rules
1.6 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction - Scantlings of pressure parts 43
2.1 General
2.2 Materials
2.3 Permissible stresses
2.4 Cylindrical, spherical and conical shells with circular cross-sections subject to
internal pressure
2.5 Dished heads subject to pressure on the concave (internal) side
2.6 Dished heads subject to pressure on the convex (external) side
2.7 Flat heads
2.8 Openings and branches (nozzles)
2.9 Regular pattern openings - Tube holes
2.10 Water tubes, superheaters and economiser tubes of boilers
2.11 Additional requirements for fired pressure vessels
2.12 Additional requirements for vertical boilers and fire tube boilers
2.13 Bottles containing pressurised gases
2.14 Heat exchangers
3 Design and construction - Equipments 65
3.1 All pressure vessels
3.2 Boilers and steam generators
3.3 Thermal oil heaters and thermal oil installation
3.4 Special types of pressure vessels
3.5 Other pressure vessels

4 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


4 Design and construction - Fabrication and welding 69
4.1 General
4.2 Welding design
4.3 Miscellaneous requirements for fabrication and welding
4.4 Preparation of parts to be welded
4.5 Tolerances after construction
4.6 Preheating
4.7 Post-weld heat treatment
4.8 Welding samples
4.9 Specific requirements for class 1 vessels
4.10 Specific requirements for class 2 vessels
4.11 Specific requirements for class 3 vessels
5 Design and construction - Control and monitoring 81
5.1 Boiler control and monitoring system
5.2 Pressure vessel instrumentation
5.3 Thermal oil heater control and monitoring
5.4 Control and monitoring requirements
6 Arrangement and installation 85
6.1 Foundations
6.2 Boilers
6.3 Pressure vessels
6.4 Thermal oil heaters
7 Material test, workshop inspection and testing, certification 85
7.1 Material testing
7.2 Workshop inspections
7.3 Hydrostatic tests
7.4 Certification

Section 4 Steam Turbines

1 General 88
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction 88
2.1 Materials
2.2 Design and constructional details
2.3 Welded fabrication
2.4 Control, monitoring and shut-off devices
3 Arrangement and installation 91
3.1 Foundations
3.2 Jointing of mating surfaces
3.3 Piping installation
3.4 Hot surfaces
3.5 Alignment
3.6 Circulating water system
3.7 Gratings
3.8 Drains
3.9 Instruments

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 5


4 Material tests, workshop inspection and testing, certification 92
4.1 Material tests
4.2 Inspections and testing during construction
4.3 Certification

Section 5 Gas Turbines


1 General 94
1.1 Application
1.2 Definition of rated power
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction 95
2.1 General
2.2 Materials
2.3 Stress analyses
2.4 Design and constructional details
2.5 Welded fabrication
2.6 Control, monitoring and shut-off devices
3 Arrangement and installation 98
3.1 Foundations
3.2 Joints of mating surfaces
3.3 Piping installation
3.4 Hot surfaces
3.5 Alignment
3.6 Gratings
3.7 Drains
3.8 Instruments
4 Material tests, workshop inspection and testing, certification 98
4.1 Type tests - General
4.2 Material tests
4.3 Inspections and testing during construction
4.4 Certification

Section 6 Gearing
1 General 100
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design of gears - Determination of the load capacity of cylindrical
gears 103
2.1 Symbols, units, definitions
2.2 Principle
2.3 General influence factors
2.4 Calculation of surface durability
2.5 Calculation of tooth bending strength
2.6 Calculation of scuffing resistance

6 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


3 Design of gears - Determination of the load capacity of bevel gears 121
3.1 Symbols, units, definitions
3.2 Principle
3.3 General influence factors
3.4 Calculation of surface durability
3.5 Calculation of tooth bending strength
3.6 Calculation of scuffing resistance
4 Design and construction - except tooth load capacity 131
4.1 Materials
4.2 Teeth
4.3 Wheels and pinions
4.4 Shafts and bearings
4.5 Casings
4.6 Lubrication
4.7 Control and monitoring
5 Installation 133
5.1 General
5.2 Fitting of gears
6 Certification, inspection and testing 133
6.1 General
6.2 Workshop inspection and testing

Section 7 Main Propulsion Shafting


1 General 135
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction 135
2.1 Materials
2.2 Shafts - Scantling
2.3 Liners
2.4 Stern tube bearings
2.5 Couplings
2.6 Monitoring
3 Arrangement and installation 141
3.1 General
3.2 Protection of propeller shaft against corrosion
3.3 Shaft alignment
4 Material tests, workshop inspection and testing, certification 141
4.1 Material and non-destructive tests, workshop inspections and testing
4.2 Certification

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 7


Section 8 Propellers
1 General 143
1.1 Application
1.2 Definitions
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction 145
2.1 Materials
2.2 Solid propellers - Blade thickness
2.3 Built-up propellers and controllable pitch propellers
2.4 Skewed propellers
2.5 Ducted propellers
2.6 Features
3 Arrangement and installation 148
3.1 Fitting of propeller on the propeller shaft
4 Testing and certification 150
4.1 Material tests
4.2 Testing and inspection
4.3 Certification

Section 9 Shaft Vibrations


1 General 152
1.1 Application
1.2 Submission of documentation
2 Design of systems in respect of vibrations 152
2.1 Principle
2.2 Modifications of existing plants
3 Torsional vibrations 152
3.1 General
3.2 Documentation to be submitted
3.3 Definitions, symbols and units
3.4 Calculation principles
3.5 Permissible limits for torsional vibration stresses in crankshaft, propulsion
shafting and other transmission shafting
3.6 Permissible vibration levels in components other than shafts
3.7 Torsional vibration measurements
4 Bending vibrations 156
4.1 General
4.2 Documentation to be submitted
4.3 Calculation principles
4.4 Bending vibration measurements
5 Axial vibrations 157
5.1 General
5.2 Documentation to be submitted
5.3 Calculation principles
5.4 Axial vibration measurements

8 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Section 10 Piping Systems
1 General 158
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
1.3 Definitions
1.4 Symbols and units
1.5 Class of piping systems
2 General requirements for design and construction 160
2.1 Materials
2.2 Thickness of pressure piping
2.3 Calculation of high temperature pipes
2.4 Junction of pipes
2.5 Protection against overpressure
2.6 Flexible hoses and expansion joints
2.7 Valves and accessories
2.8 Sea inlets and overboard discharges
2.9 Control and monitoring
3 Welding of steel piping 174
3.1 Application
3.2 General
3.3 Design of welded joints
3.4 Preparation of elements to be welded and execution of welding
3.5 Post-weld heat treatment
3.6 Inspection of welded joints
4 Bending of pipes 176
4.1 Application
4.2 Bending process
4.3 Heat treatment after bending
5 Arrangement and installation of piping systems 177
5.1 General
5.2 Location of tanks and piping system components
5.3 Passage through watertight bulkheads or decks
5.4 Independence of lines
5.5 Prevention of progressive flooding
5.6 Provision for expansion
5.7 Supporting of the pipes
5.8 Protection of pipes
5.9 Valves, accessories and fittings
5.10 Additional arrangements for flammable fluids
6 Bilge systems 180
6.1 Principle
6.2 Design of bilge systems
6.3 Drainage arrangements of vehicle and ro-ro spaces and ammunitions storages
fitted with a fixed pressure water-spraying fire-extinguishing system
6.4 Draining of machinery spaces
6.5 Draining of dry cofferdams, dry fore and after peaks and dry spaces above fore
and after peaks, tunnels and refrigerated spaces
6.6 Bilge pumps
6.7 Size of bilge pipes
6.8 Bilge accessories
6.9 Bilge piping arrangement

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 9


7 Ballast systems 182
7.1 Design of ballast systems
7.2 Ballast pumping arrangement
8 Scuppers and sanitary discharges 183
8.1 Application
8.2 Principle
8.3 Drainage from spaces below the bulkhead deck or within enclosed
superstructures and deckhouses on or above the bulkhead deck
8.4 Drainage of enclosed vehicle and ro-ro spaces situated on the bulkhead deck
8.5 Drainage arrangement of vehicle and ro-ro spaces or ammunitions spaces fitted
with a fixed pressure water-spraying fire-extinguishing system
8.6 Arrangement of discharges from spaces below the margin line
8.7 Arrangement of discharges from spaces above the margin line
8.8 Summary table of overboard discharge arrangements
8.9 Valves and pipes
8.10 Arrangement of scuppers
8.11 Additional requests for citadels
9 Air, sounding and overflow pipes 186
9.1 Air pipes
9.2 Sounding pipes
9.3 Overflow pipes
9.4 Constructional requirements applying to sounding, air and overflow pipes
10 Cooling systems 189
10.1 Application
10.2 Principle
10.3 Design of sea water cooling systems
10.4 Design of fresh water cooling systems
10.5 Design of oil cooling systems
10.6 Control and monitoring
10.7 Arrangement of cooling systems
11 Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) systems 192
11.1 Application
11.2 Principle
11.3 General
11.4 Design of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) filling and transfer systems
11.5 Arrangement of fuel oil, bunkers and JP5-NATO (F44) tanks
11.6 Design of fuel oil tanks and bunkers and JP5-NATO (F44) tanks
11.7 Design of fuel oil heating systems
11.8 Design of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) treatment systems
11.9 Design of fuel supply systems
11.10 Control and monitoring
11.11 Construction of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) piping systems
11.12 Arrangement of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) piping systems
12 Lubricating oil systems 196
12.1 Application
12.2 Principle
12.3 General
12.4 Design of lubricating oil tanks
12.5 Control and monitoring
12.6 Construction of lubricating oil piping systems

10 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


13 Hydraulic systems 197
13.1 Application
13.2 Principle
13.3 General
13.4 Design of hydraulic systems
13.5 Design of hydraulic tanks and other components
13.6 Control and monitoring
13.7 Construction of hydraulic oil piping systems
14 Steam systems 199
14.1 Application
14.2 Principle
14.3 Design of steam lines
15 Boiler feed water and condensate systems 200
15.1 Application
15.2 Principle
15.3 Design of boiler feed water systems
15.4 Design of condensate systems
15.5 Control and monitoring
15.6 Arrangement of feed water and condensate piping
16 Compressed air systems 202
16.1 Application
16.2 Principle
16.3 Design of starting air systems
16.4 Design of control and monitoring air systems
16.5 Design of air compressors
16.6 Control and monitoring of compressed air systems
16.7 Materials
16.8 Arrangement of compressed air piping systems
16.9 Compressed breathable air systems
17 Combustion air and exhaust gas systems 204
17.1 General
17.2 Design of combustion air and exhaust systems
17.3 Materials
17.4 Arrangement of combustion air and exhaust piping systems
18 Oxyacetylene welding systems 205
18.1 Application
18.2 Definitions
18.3 Design of oxyacetylene welding systems
18.4 Arrangement of oxyacetylene welding systems
19 Certification, inspection and testing of piping systems 207
19.1 Application
19.2 Type tests
19.3 Testing of materials
19.4 Hydrostatic testing of piping systems and their components
19.5 Testing of piping system components during manufacturing
19.6 Inspection and testing of piping systems

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 11


Section 11 Steering Gear
1 General 211
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
1.3 Definitions
1.4 Symbols
2 Design and construction -
Requirements applicable to all ships 213
2.1 Mechanical components
2.2 Hydraulic system
2.3 Electrical systems
2.4 Alarms and indications
3 Design and construction -
Requirements for ships equipped with a single rudder 219
3.1 Application
3.2 General
3.3 Strength, performance and power operation of the steering gear
3.4 Control of the steering gear
3.5 Availability
4 Design and construction -
Requirements for ships equipped with several rudders 220
4.1 Principle
4.2 Synchronisation
5 Design and construction -
Requirements for ships equipped with thrusters as steering means 220
5.1 Principle
5.2 Use of azimuth thrusters
5.3 Use of water-jets
6 Arrangement and installation 221
6.1 Steering gear room arrangement
6.2 Rudder actuator installation
6.3 Overload protections
6.4 Means of communication
6.5 Operating instructions
7 Certification, inspection and testing 222
7.1 Type tests of hydraulic pumps
7.2 Testing of materials
7.3 Inspection and tests during manufacturing
7.4 Inspection and tests after completion

Section 12 Thrusters
1 General 223
1.1 Application
1.2 Definitions
1.3 Thrusters intended for propulsion
1.4 Documentation to be submitted

12 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


2 Design and construction 224
2.1 Materials
2.2 Transverse thrusters and azimuth thrusters
2.3 Water-jets
2.4 Alarm, monitoring and control systems
3 Testing and certification 226
3.1 Material tests
3.2 Testing and inspection
3.3 Certification

Section 13 Refrigerating Installations


1 General 227
1.1 Application
2 Minimum design requirements 227
2.1 Refrigerating installation components
2.2 Refrigerants
3 Instrumentation 227
3.1 Thermometers in refrigerated spaces
4 Installations related to preservation of ships victuals 228
4.1 Victuals chamber
4.2 Instrumentation

Section 14 Turbochargers
1 General 229
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
2 Design and construction 229
2.1 Materials
2.2 Design
2.3 Monitoring
3 Arrangement and installation 230
3.1 General
4 Type tests, material tests, workshop inspection and testing,
certification 230
4.1 Type tests
4.2 Material tests
4.3 Workshop inspections and testing
4.4 Certification

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 13


Section 15 Tests on Board
1 General 231
1.1 Application
1.2 Purpose of shipboard tests
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
2 General requirements for shipboard tests 231
2.1 Trials at the moorings
2.2 Sea trials
3 Shipboard tests for machinery 231
3.1 Conditions of sea trials
3.2 Navigation and manoeuvring tests
3.3 Tests of diesel engines
3.4 Tests of gas turbines
3.5 Tests of electric propulsion system
3.6 Tests of gears
3.7 Tests of main propulsion shafting and propellers
3.8 Tests of piping systems
3.9 Tests of steering gear
4 Inspection of machinery after sea trials 235
4.1 General
4.2 Diesel engines

Appendix 1 Check of the Scantlings of Crankshafts for Diesel Engines


1 General 236
1.1 Application
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
1.3 Principles of calculation
1.4 Symbols
2 Calculation of alternating stresses 238
2.1 Calculation of alternating stresses due to bending moments and shearing forces
2.2 Calculation of alternating torsional stresses
3 Calculation of stress concentration factors 241
3.1 General
4 Additional bending stresses 242
4.1
5 Calculation of the equivalent alternating stress 242
5.1 General
5.2 Equivalent alternating stress
6 Calculation of the fatigue strength 242
6.1
7 Calculation of shrink-fit of semi-built crankshafts 243
7.1 General
7.2 Minimum required oversize of shrink-fit
7.3 Maximum permissible oversize of shrink-fit

14 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


8 Acceptability criteria 243
8.1

Appendix 2 Plastic Pipes


1 General 244
1.1 Application
1.2 Use of plastic pipes
1.3 Definitions
2 Design of plastic piping systems 244
2.1 General
2.2 Strength
2.3 Requirements depending on service and/or location
2.4 Pipe and fitting connections
3 Arrangement and installation of plastic pipes 248
3.1 General
3.2 Supporting of the pipes
3.3 Provision for expansion
3.4 External loads
3.5 Earthing
3.6 Penetration of fire divisions and watertight bulkheads or decks
3.7 Systems connected to the hull
3.8 Application of fire protection coatings
4 Certification, inspection and testing of plastic piping 249
4.1 Certification
4.2 Workshop tests
4.3 Testing after installation on board

Appendix 3 Independent Fuel Oil Tanks


1 General 250
1.1 Application
1.2 Documents to be submitted
1.3 Symbols and units
2 Design and installation of tanks 250
2.1 Materials
2.2 Scantling of steel tanks
2.3 Installation

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 15


16 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011
Part C
Machinery , Systems and Fire Protection

Chapter 1

MACHINERY

SECTION 1 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS


SECTION 2 DIESEL ENGINES
SECTION 3 PRESSURE EQUIPMENTS
SECTION 4 STEAM TURBINES
SECTION 5 GAS TURBINES
SECTION 6 GEARING
SECTION 7 MAIN PROPULSION SHAFTING
SECTION 8 PROPELLERS
SECTION 9 SHAFT VIBRATIONS
SECTION 10 PIPING SYSTEMS
SECTION 11 STEERING GEAR
SECTION 12 THRUSTERS
SECTION 13 REFRIGERATING INSTALLATIONS
SECTION 14 TURBOCHARGERS
SECTION 15 TESTS ON BOARD
APPENDIX 1 CHECK OF THE SCANTLINGS OF CRANKSHAFTS FOR DIESEL
ENGINES
APPENDIX 2 PLASTIC PIPES
APPENDIX 3 INDEPENDENT FUEL OIL TANKS

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 17


18 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011
Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 1

SECTION 1 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS

1 General any oil fired boiler or fuel oil unit, or


gas generators, incinerators, waste disposal units, etc.,
1.1 Application which use oil fired equipment.

1.1.1 Part C, Chapter 1 applies to the design, construction, 1.4.2 Machinery spaces
installation, tests and trials of main propulsion and essential Machinery spaces are all machinery spaces of Category A
auxiliary machinery systems and associated equipment, and all other spaces containing propulsion machinery, boil-
boilers and pressure vessels, piping systems, and steering ers, fuel oil units, steam and internal combustion engines,
and manoeuvring systems installed on board classed ships, generators and major electrical machinery, oil filling sta-
as indicated in each Section of this Chapter. tions, refrigerating, stabilising, ventilation and air condition-
ing machinery, and similar spaces, and trunks to such
1.2 Additional requirements spaces.

1.2.1 Additional requirements for machinery are given in: 1.4.3 Fuel oil unit
Fuel oil unit is the equipment used for the preparation of
Part D, for the assignment of the service notations
fuel oil for delivery to an oil fired boiler, fuel cell systems or
Part E, for the assignment of additional class notations. equipment used for the preparation for delivery of heated
oil to an internal combustion engine, and includes any oil
1.3 Documentation to be submitted pressure pumps, filters and heaters dealing with oil at a
pressure of more than 0,18 N/mm2.
1.3.1 Before the actual construction is commenced, the
Manufacturer, Designer or Shipbuilder is to submit to the For the purpose of this definition, inert gas generators are to
Society the documents (plans, diagrams, specifications and be considered as oil fired boilers and gas turbines are to be
calculations) requested in the relevant Sections of this considered as internal combustion engines.
Chapter.
1.4.4 Dead ship condition
The list of documents requested in each Section is to be
Dead ship condition is the condition under which the main
intended as guidance for the complete set of information to
propulsion plant, boilers and auxiliaries are not in opera-
be submitted, rather than an actual list of titles.
tions due to absence of power.
The Society reserves the right to request the submission of Note 1: Dead ship condition is the condition in which the entire
additional documents to those detailed in the Sections, in machinery installation, including the power supply, is out of opera-
the case of non-conventional design or if it is deemed nec- tion and the auxiliary services such as compressed air, starting cur-
essary for the evaluation of the system, equipment or com- rent from batteries etc. for bringing the main propulsion into
ponent. operation and for the restoring of the main power supply are not
available.
Plans are to include all the data necessary for their interpre-
tation, verification and approval.
Unless otherwise stated in the other Sections of this Chapter 2 Design and construction
or agreed with the Society, documents for approval are to
be sent in triplicate if submitted by the Shipyard and in four 2.1 General
copies if submitted by the equipment supplier. Documents
requested for information are to be sent in duplicate. 2.1.1 The machinery, boilers and other pressure vessels,
associated piping systems and fittings are to be of a design
In any case, the Society reserves the rights to require addi-
and construction adequate for the service for which they are
tional copies when deemed necessary.
intended and shall be so installed and protected as to
reduce to a minimum any danger to persons on board, due
1.4 Definitions regard being paid to moving parts, hot surfaces and other
hazards.
1.4.1 Machinery spaces of Category A
Machinery spaces of Category A are those spaces and The design is to have regard to materials used in construc-
trunks to such spaces which contain: tion, the purpose for which the equipment is intended, the
working conditions to which it will be subjected and the
internal combustion machinery used for main propul-
environmental conditions on board.
sion, or
internal combustion machinery used for purposes other 2.1.2 Propulsion machinery and related auxiliaries are to
than main propulsion where such machinery has in the be so designed and installed as per availability depending
aggregate a total power output of not less than 375 kW, of the service notation of the ship in Part D and to be fixed
or by the Owner in Part E, Chapter 3.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 19


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 1

Table 1 : Inclination of ship

Angle of inclination (degrees) (1)


Installations, components Athwartship Fore and aft
static dynamic static dynamic
Main and auxiliary machinery 15 22,5 5 7,5
Safety equipment, e.g. emergency power installations, emergency
fire pumps and their devices
22,5 (2) 22,5 (2) 10 10
Switch gear, electrical and electronic appliances (3) and remote
control systems
(1) Athwartship and fore-and-aft inclinations may occur simultaneously.
(2) In ships for the carriage of liquefied gases and of chemicals the emergency power supply must also remain operable with the
ship flooded to a final athwartship inclination up to a maximum of 30.
(3) Up to an angle of inclination of 45 no undesired switching operations or operational changes may occur.

2.2 Materials, welding and testing 2.5 Ambient conditions

2.2.1 General 2.5.1 Machinery and systems covered by the Rules are to
be designed to operate properly under the ambient condi-
Materials, welding and testing procedures are to be in
tions specified in Tab 2, unless otherwise specified in each
accordance with the requirements of NR216 Materials and
Section of this Chapter.
Welding and those given in the other Sections of this Chap-
ter. In addition, for machinery components fabricated by 2.5.2 The full propulsion capability of the ship is to remain
welding the requirements given in [2.2.2] apply. available under the following temperature conditions unless
other specification:
2.2.2 Welded machinery components
air: from 15 to +35C
Welding processes and welders are to be approved by the water: from 2 to +30C.
Society in accordance with NR216 Materials and Welding,
Chapter 5. Table 2 : Ambient conditions
References to welding procedures adopted are to be clearly AIR TEMPERATURE
indicated on the plans submitted for approval.
Location, arrangement Temperature range, in C
Joints transmitting loads are to be either:
In enclosed spaces between 0 and +45 (2)
full penetration butt-joints welded on both sides, except On machinery components, boilers
when an equivalent procedure is approved according to specific
In spaces subject to higher or
local conditions
full penetration T- or cruciform joints. lower temperatures
On exposed decks between 25 and +45 (1)
2.3 Vibrations
WATER TEMPERATURE
2.3.1 Special consideration is to be given to the design,
construction and installation of propulsion machinery sys- Coolant Temperature, in C
tems and auxiliary machinery so that any mode of their Sea water or, if applicable, sea
up to +32
vibrations shall not cause undue stresses in this machinery water at charge air coolant inlet
in the normal operating ranges. (1) Electronic appliances are to be designed for an air tem-
perature up to 55C (for electronic appliances see also
2.4 Operation in inclined position Part C, Chapter 2).
(2) Different temperatures may be accepted by the Society
2.4.1 Main propulsion machinery and all auxiliary machin- in the case of ships intended for restricted service.
ery essential to the propulsion and the safety of the ship are,
as fitted in the ship, be designed to operate when the ship is 2.6 Power of machinery
upright and when inclined at any angle of list either way
2.6.1 Unless otherwise stated in each Section of this Chap-
and trim by bow or stern as stated in Tab 1.
ter, where scantlings of components are based on power,
The Society may permit deviations from angles given in Tab the values to be used are determined as follows:
1, taking into consideration the type, size and service con- for main propulsion machinery, the power/rotational
ditions of the ship. speed for which classification is requested. This
Machinery with a horizontal rotation axis is generally to be power/rotational speed should take in account the most
fitted on board with such axis arranged alongships. If this is stress-inducing propulsion system configuration mode.
not possible, the Manufacturer is to be informed at the time for auxiliary machinery, the power/rotational speed
the machinery is ordered. which is available in service.

20 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 1

2.7 Astern power Suitable demountable openings are to be foreseen in decks


and bulkheads for the purpose of disembarking main
2.7.1 Sufficient power for going astern is to be provided to machinery whose maintenance is intended to be carried out
secure proper control of the ship in all normal circum- ashore.
stances.
Easy access to the various parts of the propulsion machinery
Note 1: Attention is to be paid to maximum stopping distance and
to minimum astern thrust, which may be imposed by the ship spec-
is to be provided by means of metallic ladders and gratings
ification. fitted with strong and safe handrails.
For main propulsion systems with reversing gears, controlla- Spaces containing main and auxiliary machinery are to be
ble pitch propellers or electrical propeller drive, running provided with adequate lighting and ventilation.
astern is not to lead to an overload of propulsion machinery.
During the sea trials, the ability of the main propulsion 3.1.2 In machinery spaces of Category A, electric switch-
machinery to reverse the direction of thrust of the propeller board, cabinet or junction box and electric equipment of
is to be demonstrated and recorded (see also Ch 1, Sec 15). essential services are to be located above the level corre-
sponding to the lowest generating line of the propeller shaft.
2.8 Safety devices In machinery spaces without propeller shaft this level is cor-
responding to the lowest generating line of the output shaft
2.8.1 Where risk from overspeeding of machinery exists, of main or auxiliary prime mover installed.
means are to be provided to ensure that the safe speed is
not exceeded.
3.2 Floors
2.8.2 Where main or auxiliary machinery including pres-
sure vessels or any parts of such machinery are subject to 3.2.1 Floors in engine rooms are to be made of steel,
internal pressure and may be subject to dangerous overpres- divided into easily removable panels.
sure, means shall be provided, where practicable, to protect
against such excessive pressure.
3.3 Bolting down
2.8.3 Main turbine propulsion machinery and, where
applicable, main internal combustion propulsion machin- 3.3.1 Bedplates of machinery are to be securely fixed to the
ery and auxiliary machinery shall be provided with auto- supporting structures by means of foundation bolts which
matic shut-off arrangements in the case of failures, such as are to be distributed as evenly as practicable and of a suffi-
lubricating oil supply failure, which could lead rapidly to cient number and size so as to ensure a perfect fit.
complete breakdown, serious damage or explosion.
Where the bedplates bear directly on the inner bottom plat-
The Society may permit provisions for overriding automatic ing, the bolts are to be fitted with suitable gaskets so as to
shut-off devices. ensure a tight fit and are to be arranged with their heads
See also the specific requirements given in the other Sec- within the double bottom.
tions of this Chapter.
Continuous contact between bedplates and foundations
along the bolting line is to be achieved by means of chocks
2.9 Fuels of suitable thickness, carefully arranged to ensure a com-
plete contact.
2.9.1 Fuel oils employed for engines and boilers are, in
general, to have a flash point (determined using the closed The same requirements apply to thrust block and shaft line
cup test) of not less than 60C. bearing foundations.
For ships assigned with a restricted navigation notation, or
Particular care is to be taken to obtain a perfect levelling
whenever special precautions are taken to the Societys sat-
and general alignment between the propulsion engines and
isfaction, fuel oils having a flash point of less than 60C but
their shafting (see Ch 1, Sec 7).
not less than 43C may be used for engines, provided that,
from previously effected checks, it is evident that the tem-
3.3.2 Chocking resins are to be type approved.
perature of spaces where fuel oil is stored or employed will
be at least 10C below the fuel oil flash point at all times.
Fuel oil having flash points of less than 43C may be 3.4 Safety devices on moving parts
employed on board provided that it is stored on an open
deck. 3.4.1 Suitable protective devices are to be provided in way
of moving parts (flywheels, couplings, etc.) in order to avoid
injuries to personnel.
3 Arrangement and installation on board

3.1 General 3.5 Gauges

3.1.1 Provision shall be made to facilitate cleaning, inspec- 3.5.1 All gauges are to be grouped, as far as possible, near
tion and maintenance of main propulsion and auxiliary each manoeuvring position; in any event, they are to be
machinery, including boilers and pressure vessels. clearly visible.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 21


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 1

3.6 Ventilation in machinery spaces The second means for communicating orders is to be fed by
an independent power supply and is to be independent of
3.6.1 Machinery spaces are to be sufficiently ventilated so other means of communication.
as to ensure that when machinery or boilers therein are
Where the main propulsion system of the ship is controlled
operating at full power in all weather condition, including
from the navigating bridge by a remote control system, the
heavy weather, a sufficient supply of air is maintained to the
second means of communication may be the same bridge
spaces for the safety of personnel and the operation of the
control system.
machinery, without exceeding the temperature values under
Tab 2. The engine room telegraph is required in any case, even if
the remote control of the engine is foreseen, irrespective of
Special attention is to be paid both to air delivery and
whether the engine room is attended.
extraction and to air distribution in the various spaces.
The ventilation is to be so arranged as to prevent any accu- For ships assigned with a restricted navigation notation these
mulation of flammable gases or vapours. requirements may be relaxed at the Societys discretion.

Machinery air intake is to be ducted from an open space;


the size and fittings of ducts are to be such as to satisfy the
3.9 Machinery remote control, alarms and
machinery flow, pressure and quality requirements for safety systems
developing maximum continuous power.
3.9.1 For remote control systems of main propulsion
machinery and essential auxiliary machinery and relevant
3.7 Hot surfaces and fire protection alarms and safety systems, the requirements of Part C, Chap-
ter 3 apply.
3.7.1 Surfaces, having temperature exceeding 60C, with
which the crew are likely to come into contact during oper-
ation are to be suitably protected or insulated. 4 Tests and trials
Surfaces of machinery with temperatures above 220C, e.g.
steam, thermal oil and exhaust gas lines, silencers, exhaust 4.1 Works tests
gas boilers and turbochargers, are to be effectively insulated
with non-combustible material or equivalently protected to 4.1.1 Equipment and its components are subjected to
prevent the ignition of combustible materials coming into works tests which are detailed in the relevant Sections of
contact with them. Where the insulation used for this pur- this Chapter and are to be witnessed by the Surveyor.
pose is oil absorbent or may permit the penetration of oil, In particular cases, where such tests cannot be performed in
the insulation is to be encased in steel sheathing or equiva- the workshop, the Society may allow them to be carried out
lent material. on board, provided this is not judged to be in contrast either
Fire protection, detection and extinction is to comply with with the general characteristics of the machinery being
the requirements of Part C, Chapter 4. tested or with particular features of the shipboard installa-
tion. In such cases, the Surveyor entrusted with the accep-
3.8 Communications tance of machinery on board and the purchaser are to be
informed in advance and the tests are to be carried out in
3.8.1 At least two independent means are to be provided accordance with the provisions of NR216 Materials and
for communicating orders from the navigating bridge to the Welding relative to incomplete tests.
position in the machinery space or in the control room from All boilers, all parts of machinery, all steam, hydraulic,
which the speed and the direction of the thrust of the pro- pneumatic and other systems and their associated fittings
pellers are normally controlled; one of these is to be an which are under internal pressure shall be subjected to
engine room telegraph, which provides visual indication of appropriate tests including a pressure test before being put
the orders and responses both in the machinery space and into service for the first time as detailed in the other Sec-
on the navigating bridge, with audible alarm mismatch tions of this Chapter.
between order and response.
Appropriate means of communication shall be provided 4.2 Trials on board
from the navigating bridge and the engine room to any
other position from which the speed and direction of thrust 4.2.1 Trials on board of machinery are detailed in Ch 1,
of the propellers may be controlled. Sec 15.

22 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

SECTION 2 DIESEL ENGINES

1 General Where the licensee proposes design modifications to com-


ponents, the associated documents are to be submitted by
the licensee to the Society for approval or for information
1.1 Application purposes. In the case of significant modifications, the lic-
ensee is to provide the Society with a statement confirming
1.1.1 Diesel engines listed below are to be designed, con- the licensors acceptance of the changes. In all cases, the
structed, installed, tested and certified in accordance with licensee is to provide the Surveyor entrusted to carry out the
testing, with a complete set of the documents specified in
the requirements of this Section, under the supervision and
Tab 1.
to the satisfaction of the Societys Surveyors:

a) main propulsion engines 1.3 Definitions


b) engines driving electric generators, including emer- 1.3.1 Engine type
gency generators In general, the type of an engine is defined by the following
characteristics:
c) engines driving other auxiliaries essential for safety and
navigation when they develop a power of 110 kW and the cylinder diameter
over. the piston stroke
All other engines are to be designed and constructed the method of injection (direct or indirect injection)
according to sound marine practice, with the equipment the kind of fuel (liquid, gaseous or dual-fuel)
required in [2.4.4], and delivered with the relevant works the working cycle (4-stroke, 2-stroke)
certificate (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1, [4.2.3]).
the gas exchange (naturally aspirated or supercharged)
Engines intended for propulsion of lifeboats and compres- the maximum continuous power per cylinder at the cor-
sion ignition engines intended for propulsion of rescue responding speed and/or brake mean effective pressure
boats are to comply with the relevant Rules requirements. corresponding to the above-mentioned maximum con-
tinuous power
Other procedures proposed or accepted by the ship Owner
will be also considered on a case by case basis. the method of pressure charging
the charging air cooling system (with or without inter-
In addition to the requirements of this Section, those given cooler, number of stages, etc.)
in Ch 1, Sec 1 apply.
cylinder arrangement (in-line or V-type).

1.2 Documentation to be submitted 1.3.2 Engine power


The maximum continuous power is the maximum power at
ambient reference conditions [1.3.3] which the engine is
1.2.1 The Manufacturer is to submit to the Society the doc-
capable of delivering continuously, at nominal maximum
uments listed in Tab 1 for engine type approval.
speed, in the period of time between two consecutive over-
Plans listed under items 2 and 3 in Tab 1 are also to contain hauls.
details of the lubricating oil sump in order to demonstrate Power, speed and the period of time between two consecu-
compliance with Ch 1, Sec 1, [2.4]. tive overhauls are to be stated by the Manufacturer and
agreed by the Society.
Where changes are made to an engine type for which the
Note 1: Power corrections are to be made in accordance with ISO
documents listed in Tab 1 have already been examined or
3046 standard.
approved, the engine Manufacturer is to resubmit to the
Society for consideration and approval only those docu- The rated power is the maximum power at ambient refer-
ments concerning the engine parts which have undergone ence conditions [1.3.3] which the engine is capable of
delivering as set after works trials (fuel stop power) at the
substantial changes.
maximum speed allowed by the governor.
If the engines are manufactured by a licensee, the licensee The rated power for engines driving electric generators is
is to submit, for each engine type, a list of all the drawings the nominal power, taken at the net of overload, at ambient
specified in Tab 1, indicating for each drawing the relevant reference conditions [1.3.3], which the engine is capable of
number and revision status from both licensor and licensee. delivering as set after the works trials [4.5].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 23


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Table 1 : Documentation to be submitted

No I/A (1) Document Document details


1 I Engine particulars as per the Society form "Particulars of
diesel engines" or equivalent form
2 I Engine transverse cross-section Max inclination angles, oil surface lines, oil suction strum
position
3 I Engine longitudinal section Max inclination angles, oil surface lines, oil suction strum
position
4 I / A Bedplate or crankcase, cast or welded Design of welded joints, electrodes used, welding
For welded bedplates or cranks, welding details and sequence, heat treatment, non-destructive examinations
instructions
5 A Thrust bearing assembly (2)
6 I / A Thrust bearing bedplate, cast or welded. Design of welded joints, electrodes used, welding
For welded bedplates or cranks, welding details and sequence, heat treatment, non-destructive examinations
instructions (2)
7 I / A Frame/column, cast or welded with welding details and Design of welded joints, electrodes used, welding
instructions (3) sequence, heat treatment, non-destructive examinations
8 I Tie rod
9 I Cylinder cover, assembly
10 I Cylinder jacket or engine block (3) (4)
11 I Cylinder liner (4)
12 A Crankshaft, details, for each cylinder number
13 A Crankshaft, assembly, for each cylinder number
14 A Thrust shaft or intermediate shaft (if integral with engine)
15 A Coupling bolts
16 A Counterweights (if not integral with crankshaft), with Bolt fastening instructions
associated fastening bolts
17 I Connecting rod
18 I Connecting rod, assembly (4) Bolt fastening instructions
19 I Crosshead, assembly (4)
20 I Piston rod, assembly (4)
21 I Piston, assembly
22 I Camshaft drive, assembly
23 A Material specifications of main parts of engine, with Required for items 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 18, 21,
detailed information on: including acceptable defects and repair procedures
- non-destructive tests, and Required for items 4, 7, 9, 10, 11, 21 and for injection
- pressure tests pumps and exhaust manifold
24 A Arrangement of foundation bolts (for main engines only)
25 A Schematic layout or other equivalent documents for
starting air system on the engine (5)
26 A Schematic layout or other equivalent documents for fuel
oil system on the engine (5)
27 A Schematic layout or other equivalent documents for
lubricating oil system on the engine (5)
28 A Schematic layout or other equivalent documents for
cooling water system on the engine (5)
29 A Schematic diagram of engine control and safety system List, specification and layout of sensors, automatic con-
on the engine (5) (see also [2.10]) trols and other control and safety devices
30 I Shielding and insulation of exhaust pipes, assembly
31 A Shielding of high pressure fuel pipes, assembly Recovery and leak detection devices
(see also [2.7.2])
32 A Crankcase explosion relief valves (6) Volume of crankcase and other spaces (camshaft drive,
(see also [2.4.4]) scavenge, etc.)
33 I Operation and service manuals
34 I Data sheet for torsional vibration calculations Inertia and stiffness
35 I Bearing load calculation or oil film thickness calculation
(1) A = to be submitted for approval, in four copies
I = to be submitted for information, in duplicate.
Where two indications I / A are given, the first refers to cast design and the second to welded design.
(2) To be submitted only if the thrust bearing is not integral with the engine and not integrated in the engine bedplate.
(3) Only for one cylinder.
(4) To be submitted only if sufficient details are not shown on the engine transverse and longitudinal cross-sections.
(5) Dimensions and materials of pipes, capacity and head of pumps and compressors and any additional functional information are
to be included. The layout of the entire system is also required, if this is part of the goods to be supplied by the engine Manufac-
turer.
(6) Required only for engines with cylinder bore of 200 mm and above or crankcase gross volume of 0,6 m3 and above.

24 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

1.3.3 Ambient reference conditions 2.3 Crankshaft


The power of engines as per [1.1.1], items a), b) and c) is to
be referred to the following conditions: 2.3.1 Check of the scantling
barometric pressure = 0,1 MPa The check of crankshaft strength is to be carried out in
relative humidity = 60% accordance with Ch 1, App 1.
ambient air temperature = 45C Other methods accepted by the ship Owner will be consid-
sea water temperature (and temperature at inlet of sea ered on a case by case basis.
water cooled charge air cooler) = 32C.
2.4 Crankcase
In the case of ships assigned with a navigation notation
other than unrestricted navigation, different temperatures 2.4.1 Strength
may be accepted by the Society.
The scantling of crankcases and crankcase doors is to be
The engine Manufacturer is not expected to provide the designed to be of sufficient strength, and the doors are to be
above ambient conditions at a test bed. The rating is to be securely fastened so that they will not be readily displaced
adjusted according to a recognised standard accepted by by an explosion.
the Society.
2.4.2 Ventilation and drainage
1.3.4 Same type of engines
Two diesel engines are considered to be of the same type The ventilation of crankcases, or any other arrangement
when they do not substantially differ in design and con- which may produce an inrush of air, is in principle prohib-
struction characteristics, such as those listed in the engine ited, unless the crankcase protection is in accordance with
type definition as per [1.3.4], it being taken for granted that that required for dual fuel engines as per Ch 1, App 2,
the documentation concerning the essential engine compo- [2.1.2].
nents listed in [1.2] and associated materials employed has Vent pipes, where provided, are to be as small as practica-
been submitted, examined and, where necessary, approved ble. If provision is made for the forced extraction of gases
by the Society. from the crankcase (e.g. for detection of explosive mix-
tures), the vacuum in the crankcase is not to exceed
2 Design and construction 2,5.104 MPa.
Where two or more engines are installed, their vent pipes
2.1 General and lubricating oil drain pipes are to be independent to
avoid intercommunication between crankcases.
2.1.1 Operating conditions
Lubricating oil drain pipes from the engine sump to the
Attention is to be paid to the specific operating conditions drain tank are to be submerged in the latter at their outlet
of the engine (e.g. continuous operation at low load) which ends.
may be imposed by the ship specification.
2.4.3 Warning notice
2.2 Materials and welding A warning notice is to be fitted, preferably on a crankcase
door on each side of the engine, or alternatively on the con-
2.2.1 Crankshaft materials
trol stand.
In general, crankshafts are to be of forged steel having a ten-
sile strength not less than 400 N/mm2 and not greater than This warning notice is to specify that whenever overheating
1000 N/mm2. is suspected in the crankcase, the crankcase doors or sight
holes are not to be opened until a reasonable time has
The use of forged steels of higher tensile strength is subject elapsed after stopping the engine, sufficient to permit ade-
to special consideration by the Society in each case. quate cooling of the crankcase.
The Society, at its discretion and subject to special condi-
tions (such as restrictions in ship navigation), may accept 2.4.4 Crankcase explosion relief valves
crankshafts made of cast carbon steel or cast alloyed steel of a) Diesel engines of a cylinder diameter of 200 mm and
appropriate quality and manufactured by a suitable proce- above or a crankcase gross volume of 0,6 m3 and above
dure having a tensile strength as follows: are to be provided with crankcase explosion relief
between 400 N/mm2 and 560 /mm2 for cast carbon steel valves in accordance with the following requirements.
between 400 N/mm2 and 700 N/mm2 for cast alloyed b) Engines having a cylinder bore not exceeding 250 mm,
steel. are to have at least one valve near each end, but over
eight crankthrows, an additional valve is to be fitted
2.2.2 Welded frames and foundations
near the middle of the engine. Engines having a cylinder
Steels used in the fabrication of welded frames and bed- bore exceeding 250 mm, but not exceeding 300 mm,
plates are to comply with the requirements of NR216 Mate- are to have at least one valve in way of each alternate
rials. crankthrow, with a minimum of two valves. Engines
Welding is to be in accordance with the requirements of Ch having a cylinder bore exceeding 300 mm are to have at
1, Sec 1, [2.2]. least one valve in way of each main crankthrow.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 25


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

c) Additional relief valves are to be fitted on separate m) Valves are to be provided with suitable markings that
spaces of the crankcase, such as gear or chain cases for include the following information:
camshaft or similar drives, when the gross volume of
name and address of manufacturer
such spaces is 0,6 m3 or above. Scavenge spaces in
open connection to the cylinders are to be fitted with designation and size
explosion relief valves.
month/year of manufacture
d) The free area of each relief valve is not to be less than
45 cm2. approved installation orientation.
e) The combined free area of the valves fitted on an engine Note 1: The total volume of the stationary parts within the crank-
is not to be less than 115 cm 2 per cubic metre of the case may be discounted in estimating the crankcase gross volume
crankcase gross volume. (See [2.4.4], Note 1). (rotating and reciprocating components are to be included in the
gross volume).
f) Crankcase explosion relief valves are to be provided
with lightweight spring-loaded valve discs or other
quick-acting and self closing devices to relieve a crank- 2.5 Cylinder overpressure gauge
case of pressure in the event of an internal explosion
and to prevent any inrush of air thereafter. 2.5.1 Means are to be provided to indicate a predeter-
g) The valve discs in crankcase explosion relief valves are to mined overpressure in the cylinders of engines having a
be made of ductile material capable of withstanding the bore exceeding 230 mm.
shock of contact with stoppers at the full open position.
h) Crankcase explosion relief valves are to be designed 2.6 Scavenge manifolds
and constructed to open quickly and to be fully open at
a pressure not greater than 0,02 MPa. 2.6.1 Fire extinguishing
i) Crankcase explosion relief valves are to be provided For two-stroke crosshead type engines, scavenge spaces in
with a flame arrester that permits flow for crankcase open connection (without valves) to the cylinders are to be
pressure relief and prevents passage of flame following a connected to a fixed fire-extinguishing system, which is to
crankcase explosion. be entirely independent of the fire-extinguishing system of
j) Crankcase explosion relief valves are to be type tested in the machinery space.
a configuration that represents the installation arrange-
ments that will be used on an engine. 2.6.2 Blowers
The purpose of type testing crankcase explosion valves is: Where a single two-stroke propulsion engine is equipped
to verify the effectiveness of the flame arrester with an independently driven blower, alternative means to
drive the blower or an auxiliary blower are to be provided
to verify that the valve closes after an explosion
ready for use.
to verify that the valve is gas/air tight after an explosion
to establish the level of overpressure protection pro- 2.6.3 Relief valves
vided by the valve.
Scavenge spaces in open connection to the cylinders are to
Where crankcase relief valves are provided with be fitted with explosion relief valves in accordance with
arrangements for shielding emissions from the valve fol- [2.4.4].
lowing an explosion, the valve is to be type tested to
demonstrate that the shielding does not adversely affect
the operational effectiveness of the valve. 2.7 Systems
k) Crankcase explosion relief valves are to be provided
with a copy of the manufacturer's installation and main- 2.7.1 General
tenance manual that is pertinent to the size and type of In addition to the requirements of the present sub-article,
valve being supplied for installation on a particular those given in Ch 1, Sec 10 are to be satisfied.
engine.
Flexible hoses in the fuel and lubricating oil system are to
The manual is to contain the following information:
be limited to the minimum and are to be type approved.
description of valve with details of function and
design limits
2.7.2 Fuel oil system
copy of type test certification
Relief valves discharging back to the suction of the pumps
installation instructions or other equivalent means are to be fitted on the delivery
maintenance in service instructions to include test- side of the pumps.
ing and renewal of any sealing arrangements
In fuel oil systems for propulsion machinery, filters are to be
actions required after a crankcase explosion.
fitted and arranged so that an uninterrupted supply of filtered
l) A copy of the installation and maintenance manual fuel oil is ensured during cleaning operations of the filter
required in i) above is to be provided on board the unit. equipment, except when otherwise stated in Ch 1, Sec 10.

26 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

a) All external high pressure fuel delivery lines between 2.10 Control and monitoring
the high pressure fuel pumps and fuel injectors are to be
protected with a shielded piping system capable of con- 2.10.1 General
taining fuel from a high pressure line failure.
In addition to those of this item, the general requirements
A shielded pipe incorporates an outer pipe into which given in Part C, Chapter 3 apply.
the high pressure fuel pipe is placed forming a perma-
nent assembly.
2.10.2 Governors of main and auxiliary engines
The shielded piping system is to include a means for Each engine, except the auxiliary engines for driving elec-
collection of leakages and arrangements are to be pro- tric generators for which [2.10.5] applies, is to be fitted with
vided for an alarm to be given in the event of a fuel line a speed governor so adjusted that the engine does not
failure. exceed the rated speed by more than 15%.
If flexible hoses are used for shielding purposes, these
are to be approved by the Society. 2.10.3 Overspeed protective devices of main and
auxiliary engines
When in fuel oil return piping the pulsation of pressure
with peak to peak values exceeds 2 MPa, shielding of In addition to the speed governor, each
this piping is also required as above.
main propulsion engine having a rated power of 220kW
b) For ships classed for restricted navigation, the require- and above, which can be declutched or which drives a
ments under a) may be relaxed at the Societys discre- controllable pitch propeller, and
tion.
auxiliary engine having a rated power of 220kW and
above, except those for driving electric generators, for
2.7.3 Lubricating oil system which [2.10.6] applies,
Efficient filters are to be fitted in the lubricating oil system
when the oil is circulated under pressure. is to be fitted with a separate overspeed protective device so
adjusted that the engine cannot exceed the rated speed n by
In such lubricating oil systems for propulsion machinery, fil- more than:
ters are to be arranged so that an uninterrupted supply of fil-
tered lubricating oil is ensured during cleaning operations 12% in case of mechanical device,
of the filter equipment, except when otherwise stated in Ch
15% in case of electrical device.
1, Sec 10.

Relief valves discharging back to the suction of the pumps Equivalent arrangements may be accepted subject to special
or other equivalent means are to be fitted on the delivery consideration by the Society in each case.
side of the pumps.
The overspeed protective device, including its driving
The relief valves may be omitted provided that the filters mechanism or speed sensor, is to be independent of the
can withstand the maximum pressure that the pump may governor.
develop.
2.10.4 Governors for auxiliary engines driving
Where necessary, the lubricating oil is to be cooled by electric generators
means of suitable coolers.
a) Auxiliary engines intended for driving electric genera-
2.7.4 Charge air system tors are to be fitted with a speed governor which pre-
vents any transient speed variations in excess of 10% of
a) Requirements relevant to design, construction, arrange- the rated speed when the rated power is suddenly
ment, installation, tests and certification of exhaust gas thrown off or specific loads are suddenly thrown on.
turbochargers are given in Ch 1, Sec 14.
b) At all loads between no load and rated power, the per-
b) When two-stroke propulsion engines are supercharged manent speed variation is not to be more than 5% of the
by exhaust gas turbochargers which operate on the rated speed.
impulse system, provision is to be made to prevent bro-
ken piston rings entering turbocharger casings and caus- c) Prime movers are to be selected in such a way that they
ing damage to blades and nozzle rings. meet the load demand within the ships mains and,
when running at no load, can satisfy the requirement in
item a) above if suddenly loaded to 50% of the rated
2.8 Starting air system
power of the generator, followed by the remaining 50%
after an interval sufficient to restore speed to steady
2.8.1 The requirements given in [3.1] apply. state. Steady state conditions (see [2.10.4], Note 1) are
to be achieved in not more than 5 s.
2.9 Cooling system Note 1: Steady state conditions are those at which the envelope of
speed variation does not exceed 1% of the declared speed at
2.9.1 The requirements given in Ch 1, Sec 10, [10] apply. the new power.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 27


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Figure 1 : Limiting curves for loading 4-stroke diesel engines step by step from no load to rated power
as a function of the brake mean effective pressure

100

90

80
Load increase referred to rated power [%]

70

60
Limiting curve for
3rd load step
50

40
Limiting curve for
2nd load step
30

20
Limiting curve for
1st load step
10

0
0.6 0.8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6 1,8 2,0 2,2 2,4
Mep at rated power of diesel engine [MPa]

d) Application of the electrical load in more than 2 load 2.10.5 Overspeed protective devices of auxiliary
steps can only be allowed if the conditions within the engines driving electric generators
ships mains permit the use of those auxiliary engines In addition to the speed governor, auxiliary engines of rated
which can only be loaded in more than 2 load steps power equal to or greater than 220 kW driving electric gen-
(see Fig 1 for guidance) and provided that this is already erators are to be fitted with a separate overspeed protective
allowed for in the designing stage. device, with a means for manual tripping, adjusted so as to
This is to be verified in the form of system specifications prevent the rated speed from being exceeded by more than
to be approved and to be demonstrated at ships trials. 15%.
In this case, due consideration is to be given to the
This device is to automatically shut down the engine.
power required for the electrical equipment to be auto-
matically switched on after blackout and to the 2.10.6 Use of electronic governors
sequence in which it is connected
a) Type approval
This also applies to generators to be operated in parallel
and where the power is to be transferred from one gen- Provisions are to be made for controlling the engine
erator to another, in the event that any one generator is speed in case of failure of the electrical supply.
to be switched off. Electronic governors and their actuators are to be type
e) When the rated power is suddenly thrown off, steady approved by the Society.
state conditions should be achieved in not more than 5s.
b) Electronic governors for main propulsion engines
f) Emergency generator sets must satisfy the governor con-
If an electronic governor is fitted to ensure continuous
ditions as per items a) and b) even when their total
speed control or resumption of control after a fault, an
emergency consumer load is applied suddenly.
additional separate governor is to be provided unless
g) For alternating current generating sets operating in par- the engine has a manually operated fuel admission con-
allel, the governing characteristics of the prime movers trol system suitable for its control.
are to be such that, within the limits of 20% and 100%
A fault in the governor system is not to lead to sudden
total load, the load on any generating set will not nor-
major changes in propulsion power or direction of pro-
mally differ from its proportionate share of the total load
peller rotation.
by more than 15% of the rated power in kW of the larg-
est machine or 25% of the rated power in kW of the Alarms are to be fitted to indicate faults in the governor
individual machine in question, whichever is the lesser. system.
For alternating current generating sets intended to operate The acceptance of electronic governors not in compli-
in parallel, facilities are to be provided to adjust the gov- ance with the above requirements will be considered
ernor sufficiently finely to permit an adjustment of load by the Society on a case by case basis, when fitted on
not exceeding 5% of the rated load at normal frequency. ships with two or more main propulsion engines.

28 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

c) Electronic governors for auxiliary engines driving elec- 2.10.7 Summary tables
tric generators
Diesel engines installed on ships without automation nota-
In the event of a fault in the electronic governor system tions are to be equipped with monitoring equipment as
the fuel admission is to be set to zero. detailed in Tab 2 and Tab 3 for main propulsion, in Tab 4 for
Alarms are to be fitted to indicate faults in the governor auxiliary services and in Tab 5 for emergency services.
system.
The alarms are to be visual and audible.
The acceptance of electronic governors fitted on
engines driving emergency generators will be consid- The indicators are to be fitted at a normally attended posi-
ered by the Society on a case by case basis. tion (on the engine or at the local control station).

Table 2 : Monitoring of main propulsion slow speed diesel engines

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm Main Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Control Stand by Stop
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication
down down Start
Fuel oil pressure after filter (engine inlet) local
Fuel oil viscosity before injection pumps or fuel oil tempera- local
ture before injection pumps (for engine running on heavy fuel)
Fuel rack position local
Leakage from high pressure pipes where required H
Lubricating oil to main bearing and thrust bearing pressure L (4) local
LL X
Lubricating oil to cross-head bearing pressure when separate L (4) local
LL X
Lubricating oil to camshaft pressure when separate L (4) local
LL X
Turbocharger lubricating oil inlet pressure local
Lubricating oil inlet temperature local
Thrust bearing pads or bearing outlet temperature H local
Main, crank, cross-head bearing, oil outlet temp H
Cylinder fresh cooling water system inlet pressure L local (3)
Cylinder fresh cooling water outlet temperature or, when com- H local
mon cooling space without individual stop valves, the common
HH X
cylinder water outlet temperature
Piston coolant inlet pressure on each cylinder (1) L local
Piston coolant outlet temperature on each cylinder (1) local
Piston coolant outlet flow on each cylinder (1) (2) L
Speed of turbocharger local
Scavenging air receiver pressure local
Scavenging air box temperature (detection of fire in receiver) local
Exhaust gas temperature local (5)
Engine speed / direction of speed (when reversible) local
H X
Fault in the electronic governor system X
(1) Not required, if the coolant is oil taken from the main cooling system of the engine.
(2) Where outlet flow cannot be monitored due to engine design, alternative arrangement may be accepted.
(3) For engines of 220 KW and above.
(4) Audible and visual alarm.
(5) Indication is required after each cylinder, for engines of 500 kW per cylinder and above.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 29


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Table 3 : Monitoring of main propulsion medium or high speed diesel engines

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm Main Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Control Stand by Stop
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication
down down Start
Fuel oil pressure after filter (engine inlet) local
Fuel oil viscosity before injection pumps or fuel oil tempera- local
ture before injection pumps (for engine running on heavy fuel)
Fuel rack position local
Leakage from high pressure pipes where required H
Lubricating oil to main bearing and thrust bearing pressure L (2) local
LL X
Lubricating oil filter differential pressure H local
Turbocharger lubricating oil inlet pressure (4) local
Lubricating oil inlet temperature local
Cylinder fresh cooling water system inlet pressure L local (1)
Cylinder fresh cooling water outlet temperature or, when com- H local
mon cooling space without individual stop valves, the common HH X
cylinder water outlet temperature
Cylinder fresh cooling water, expansion tank level L local
LL X
Scavenging air receiver pressure local
Scavenging air box temperature (detection of fire in receiver) local
Exhaust gas temperature local (3)
Engine speed / direction of speed (when reversible) local
H X
Fault in the electronic governor system X
(1) For engines of 220 kW and above.
(2) Audible and visual alarm.
(3) Indication is required after each cylinder, for engines of 500 kW per cylinder and above.
(4) If without integrated self-contained oil lubrication system.

Table 4 : Monitoring of diesel engines used for auxiliary services

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Control Stand Stop
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication
down down by Start
Fuel oil pressure local
Fuel oil leakage from pressure pipes H
Lubricating oil pressure L local X (1)
Pressure or flow of cooling water, if not connected to main system L local
Temperature of cooling water or cooling air local
Cylinder fresh cooling water, expansion tank level L local
LL X
Engine speed local
H X
Exhaust gas temperature local
Fault in the electronic governor system X
(1) Not applicable to emergency generator set.

30 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Table 5 : Monitoring of emergency diesel engines

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Control Stand Stop
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication
down down by Start
Fuel oil leakage from pressure pipes H
Lubricating oil temperature (1) H local
Lubricating oil pressure L local
Oil mist concentration in crankcase (2) H local
Pressure or flow of cooling water (1) L local
Temperature of cooling water or cooling air local
Engine speed local
H X (1)
Fault in the electronic governor system X
(1) Not applicable to emergency generator set of less than 220 kW.
(2) For engines having a power of more than 2250 kW or a cylinder bore of more than 300 mm.
Note 1: The safety and alarm systems are to be designed to fail safe. The characteristics of the fail safe operation are to be evalu-
ated on the basis not only of the system and its associated machinery, but also the complete installation, as well as the ship.
Note 2: Regardless of the engine output, if shutdowns additional to those above specified except for the overspeed shutdown, they
are to be automatically overridden when the engine is in automatic or remote control mode during navigation.
Note 3: The alarm system is to function in accordance with AUT notation, with additional requirements that grouped alarms are to
be arranged on the bridge.
Note 4: In addition to the fuel oil control from outside the space, a local means of engine shutdown is to be provided.
Note 5: The local indications are to be provided within the same space as the diesel engines and are to remain operational in the
event of failure of the alarm and safety systems.

3 Arrangement and installation Regardless of the above, for multi-engine installations


the number of starts required for each engine may be
reduced subject to the agreement of the Society and
3.1 Starting arrangements depending upon the arrangement of the engines and the
transmission of their output to the propellers.
3.1.1 Mechanical air starting
b) The main starting air arrangements for main propulsion
a) The total capacity of air receivers of each propulsion or auxiliary diesel engines are to be adequately pro-
line is to be sufficient to provide, without replenish- tected against the effects of backfiring and internal
ment, not less than 12 consecutive starts alternating explosion in the starting air pipes. To this end, the fol-
between ahead and astern of main engines of the revers- lowing safety devices are to be fitted:
ible type, and not less than 6 consecutive starts of main An isolating non-return valve, or equivalent, at the
non-reversible type engines connected to a controllable starting air supply connection to each engine.
pitch propeller or other device enabling the start with-
A bursting disc or flame arrester:
out opposite torque.
- in way of the starting valve of each cylinder, for
The number of starts refers to the engine in cold and direct reversing engines having a main starting
ready-to-start condition (all the driven equipment that air manifold
cannot be disconnected is to be taken into account).
- at least at the supply inlet to the starting air man-
A greater number of starts may be required when the ifold, for non-reversing engines.
engine is in warm running condition. The bursting disc or flame arrester above may be omit-
When other users such as auxiliary engine starting sys- ted for engines having a bore not exceeding 230 mm.
tems, control systems, whistle etc. are connected to the Other protective devices will be specially considered by
starting air receivers of main propulsion engines, their the Society.
air consumption is also to be taken into account. The requirements of this item c) do not apply to engines
For multi-engine propulsion plants, the capacity of the started by pneumatic motors.
starting air receivers is to be sufficient to ensure at least c) Compressed air receivers are to comply with the
3 consecutive starts per engine. However, the total requirements of Ch 1, Sec 3. Compressed air piping and
capacity is not to be less than 12 starts and need not associated air compressors are to comply with the
exceed 18 starts. requirements of Ch 1, Sec 10.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 31


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

3.1.2 Electrical starting all of these starting, charging and energy storing
devices are to be located in the emergency genera-
a) Where main internal combustion engines are arranged tor space; these devices are not to be used for any
for electrical starting, at least two separate batteries are purpose other than the operation of the emergency
to be fitted. generating set. This does not preclude the supply to
The arrangement is to be such that the batteries cannot the air receiver of the emergency generating set from
be connected in parallel. the main or auxiliary compressed air system through
the non-return valve fitted in the emergency genera-
Each battery is to be capable of starting the main engine tor space.
when in cold and ready to start condition.
d) Where automatic starting is not required, manual start-
The combined capacity of batteries is to be sufficient to ing, such as manual cranking, inertia starters, manually
provide within 30 min, without recharging, the number charged hydraulic accumulators, or powder charge car-
of starts required in [3.1.1] b) in the event of air starting. tridges, is permissible where this can be demonstrated
as being effective.
b) Electrical starting arrangements for auxiliary engines are
to have two separate storage batteries or may be sup- e) When manual starting is not practicable, the require-
plied by two separate circuits from main engine storage ments of items b) and c) are to be complied with, except
batteries when these are provided. In the case of a single that starting may be manually initiated.
auxiliary engine, one battery is acceptable. The com-
bined capacity of the batteries is to be sufficient for at 3.2 Turning gear
least three starts for each engine.
3.2.1 Each engine is to be provided with hand-operated
c) The starting batteries are only to be used for starting and turning gear; where deemed necessary, the turning gear is to
for the engines alarm and monitoring. Provision is to be be both hand and mechanically-operated.
made to maintain the stored energy at all times.
The turning gear engagement is to inhibit starting opera-
d) Each charging device is to have at least sufficient rating tions.
for recharging the required capacity of batteries within 6
hours. 3.3 Trays

3.1.3 Special requirements for starting 3.3.1 Trays fitted with means of drainage are to be provided
arrangements for emergency generating sets in way of the lower part of the crankcase and, in general, in
way of the parts of the engine, where oil is likely to spill in
a) Emergency generating sets are to be capable of being order to collect the fuel oil or lubricating oil dripping from
readily started in their cold condition at a temperature the engine.
of 0C. If this is impracticable, or if lower temperatures
are likely to be encountered, provision acceptable to
the Society shall be made for the maintenance of heat- 3.4 Exhaust gas system
ing arrangements, to ensure ready starting of the gener-
ating sets. 3.4.1 In addition to the requirements given in Ch 1, Sec 10,
the exhaust system is to be efficiently cooled or insulated in
b) Each emergency generating set arranged to be automati- such a way that the surface temperature does not exceed
cally started shall be equipped with starting devices 220C (see also Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.7]).
approved by the Society with a stored energy capability
of at least three consecutive starts. 3.4.2 Pressure losses in the exhaust ducting are to comply
with the limits stated by the engine manufacturer.
The source of stored energy shall be protected to pre-
clude critical depletion by the automatic starting sys-
tem, unless a second independent means of starting is
4 Type tests, material tests, workshop
provided. In addition, a second source of energy shall inspection and testing, certification
be provided for an additional three starts within 30 min-
utes, unless manual starting can be demonstrated to be 4.1 Type tests - General
effective.
4.1.1 Upon finalisation of the engine design for production
c) The stored energy is to be maintained at all times, as fol-
of every new engine type intended for installation on board
lows:
ships, one engine is to be presented for type testing as
electrical and hydraulic starting systems shall be required below.
maintained from the emergency switchboard A type test carried out for a particular type of engine at any
place in any manufacturers works will be accepted for all
compressed air starting systems may be maintained
engines of the same type (see [1.3.4]) built by licensees and
by the main or auxiliary compressed air receivers
licensors.
through a suitable non-return valve or by an emer-
gency air compressor which, if electrically driven, is In any case, one type test suffices for the whole range of
supplied from the emergency switchboard engines having different numbers of cylinders.

32 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Engines which are subjected to type testing are to be tested 4.2.2 Stage A - Internal tests (function tests and
in accordance with the scope specified below, it being collection of operating data)
taken for granted that:
During the internal tests the engine is to be operated at the
the engine is optimised as required for the conditions of load points considered important by the engine Manufac-
the type test turer and the relevant operating values are to be recorded
the investigations and measurements required for reli- (see item a)).
able engine operation have been carried out during pre-
liminary internal tests by the engine Manufacturer The load points may be selected according to the range of
the documentation to be submitted as required in [1.2] application (see Fig 2).
has been examined and, when necessary, approved by
the Society and the latter has been informed about the If an engine can be satisfactorily operated at all load points
nature and extent of investigations carried out during without using mechanically driven cylinder lubricators, this
pre-production stages. is to be verified.

4.1.2 At the request of the Manufacturer, an increase in For engines which may operate on heavy fuel oil, their suit-
power and/or mean effective pressure up to a maximum of ability for this is to be proved to the satisfaction of the Soci-
10% may be accepted by the Society for an engine previ- ety.
ously subjected to a type test without any further such test
being required, provided the engine reliability has been a) Functional tests under normal operating conditions
proved successfully by the service experience of a sufficient Functional tests under normal operating conditions
number of engines of the same type. include:
For the purpose of the acceptance of the above perfor-
mance increase, the Manufacturer is in any case to submit 1) The load points 25%, 50%, 75%, 100% and 110%
for examination and, where necessary, approval, the docu- of the maximum continuous power for which type
mentation listed in [1.2] relevant to any components requir- approval is requested, to be carried out:
ing modification in order to achieve the increased
performance. along the nominal (theoretical) propeller curve
and at constant speed, for propulsion engines
4.1.3 The Society reserves the right to impose additional
requirements or grant dispensations to the following type at constant speed, for engines intended for gen-
test programs. erating sets.

2) The limit points of the permissible operating range.


4.2 Type tests of engines not admitted to an
alternative inspection scheme These limit points are to be defined by the engine
Manufacturer.
4.2.1 General
Engines which are not admitted to testing and inspections The maximum continuous power P is defined in [1.3.2].
according to an alternative inspection scheme (see NR216
b) Tests under emergency operating conditions
Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.2]) are to be type tested in the
presence of a Surveyor in accordance with the requirements For turbocharged engines, the achievable continuous
of [4.2]. output is to be determined for a situation when one tur-
The type test is subdivided into three stages, namely: bocharger is damaged, i.e.:
a) Stage A - Preliminary internal tests carried out by the for engines with one turbocharger, when the rotor is
Manufacturer. blocked or removed
Stage A includes functional tests and collection of oper-
ating values including the number of testing hours dur- for engines with two or more turbochargers, when
ing the internal tests, the results of which are to be the damaged turbocharger is shut off.
presented to the Surveyor during the type test. The num-
ber of testing hours of components which are inspected 4.2.3 Stage B - Type approval tests in the presence
according to [4.2.5] is to be stated by the Manufacturer. of the Surveyor
b) Stage B - Type approval test During the type test, the tests listed below are to be carried
The type approval test is to be carried out in the pres- out in the presence of the Surveyor and the results are to be
ence of the Surveyor. recorded in a report signed by both the engine Manufac-
c) Stage C - Inspection of main engine components. turer and the Surveyor.
After completion of the test programme, the main engine
For engines not yet adequately experienced in service the
components are to be inspected.
scope of test will be agreed on a case by case basis.
The engine Manufacturer is to compile all results and mea-
surements for the engine tested during the type test in a type Any departures from this programme are to be agreed upon
test report, which is to be submitted to the Society. by the engine Manufacturer and the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 33


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Figure 2 : Power/speed diagram

Overload power
110 106,6

110 100
3 3a
Maximum continuous power

100 3 2
1 90
4
90
% 80
00 1 Range of continuous operation
e = 1 00%
80 rq
u =15
To .p.e
b. m 6
9 70 2 Range of intermittent operation
Power (%)

70
3 Range of short-time
2 overload operation
60
60
1 4 Nominal propeller curve

7 50
50
10

40 40

30
30
8 11
4
Rotational Speed (%) 100 103,2

a) Load points 5) Test at minimum permissible speed at 90% of torque


The load points at which the engine is to be operated T, corresponding to load point 5 in the diagram in
according to the power/speed diagram (see Fig 2) are Fig 2.
those listed below. The data to be measured and recorded 6) Tests at part loads, e.g. 75%, 50%, 25% of maxi-
when testing the engine at various load points are to mum continuous power P and speed according to
include all necessary parameters for engine operation. the nominal propeller curve, corresponding to load
The operating time per load point depends on the engine points 6, 7 and 8 in the diagram in Fig 2; and tests at
characteristics (achievement of steady-state condition) the above part loads and at speed n with constant
and the time for collection of the operating values. governor setting, corresponding to load points 9, 10
Normally, an operating time of 0,5 hour per load point and 11 in the diagram in Fig 2.
can be assumed. b) Tests under emergency operating conditions
At the maximum continuous power as per the following These are tests at maximum achievable power when
item 1) an operating time of two hours is required. Two operating along the nominal propeller curve and when
sets of readings are to be taken at a minimum interval of operating with constant governor setting for speed n, in
one hour. emergency operating conditions as stated in [4.2.2] b).
1) Test at maximum continuous power P: i.e. 100% c) Additional tests
output at 100% torque and 100% speed, corre-
sponding to load point 1 in the diagram in Fig 2. Test at lowest engine speed according to the nomi-
nal propeller curve.
2) Test at 100% power at maximum permissible speed,
corresponding to load point 2 in the diagram in Fig 2. Starting tests for non-reversible engines, or starting
and reversing tests for reversible engines.
3) Test at maximum permissible torque (normally
110% of nominal torque T) at 100% speed, corre- Governor tests.
sponding to load point 3 in the diagram in Fig 2; or Testing of the safety system, particularly for over-
test at maximum permissible power (normally 110% speed and low lubricating oil pressure.
of P) and speed according to the nominal propeller For engines intended to be used for emergency services,
curve, corresponding to load point 3a in the dia- supplementary tests may be required to the satisfaction
gram in Fig 2. of the Society. In particular, for engines intended to
4) Test at minimum permissible speed at 100% of drive emergency generating sets, additional tests and/or
torque T, corresponding to load point 4 in the dia- documents may be required to prove that the engine is
gram in Fig 2. capable of being readily started at a temperature of 0C.

34 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

4.2.4 Evaluation of test results f) reverse running for direct reversing engines
The results of the tests and checks required by [4.2.3] will g) testing of speed governor, overspeed device and lubri-
be evaluated by the attending Surveyor. Normally the main cating oil system failure alarm device
operating data to be recorded during the tests are those
h) testing of the engine with one turbocharger out of
listed in [4.3.4].
action, when applicable
In particular, the maximum combustion pressure measured
i) testing of the minimum speed along the nominal (theo-
with the engine running at the maximum continuous power
retical) propeller curve, for main propulsion engines
P is not to exceed the value taken for the purpose of check-
driving fixed pitch propellers, and of the minimum
ing the scantlings of the engine crankshaft, according to the
speed with no brake load, for main propulsion engines
applicable requirements of Chapter 1, Appendix 1.
driving controllable pitch propellers or for auxiliary
The values of temperatures and pressures of media, such as engines.
cooling water, lubricating oil, charge air, exhaust gases,
The tests at the above-mentioned outputs are to be com-
etc., are to be within limits which, in the opinion of the Sur-
bined together in working cycles which are to be repeated
veyor, are appropriate for the characteristics of the engine
in succession for the entire duration within the limits indi-
tested.
cated.
4.2.5 Stage C - Inspection of main engine In particular, the overload test, to be carried out at the end
components of each cycle, is to be of one hours duration and is to be
Immediately after the test run as per [4.2.3], the compo- carried out alternately:
nents of one cylinder for in-line engines, and two cylinders at 110% of the power P and 103% of the speed n
for V-type engines, are to be presented for inspection to the
at 110% of the power P and 100% of the speed n.
Surveyor.
The following main engine components are to be inspected: The partial load tests specified in item c) are to be carried
out:
piston removed and dismantled
along the nominal (theoretical) propeller curve and at
crosshead bearing, dismantled
constant speed, for propulsion engines
crank bearing and main bearing, dismantled
at constant speed, for engines intended for generating
cylinder liner in the installed condition sets.
cylinder head and valves, disassembled
For engines intended to be used for emergency services,
control gear, camshaft and crankcase with opened cov-
supplementary tests may be required, to the satisfaction of
ers.
the Society. In particular, for engines intended to drive
Where deemed necessary by the Surveyor, further disman- emergency generating sets, additional tests and/or docu-
tling of the engine may be required. ments may be required to prove that the engine is capable
of being readily started at a temperature of 0C, as required
4.3 Type tests of engines admitted to an in [3.1.3].
alternative inspection scheme In the case of prototype engines, the duration and pro-
gramme of the type test will be not lower than the one spec-
4.3.1 General ified in this paragraph.
Engines for which the Manufacturer is admitted to testing
and inspections according to an alternative inspection 4.3.3 In cases of engines for which the Manufacturer sub-
scheme (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.2]) and mits documentary evidence proving successful service
which have a cylinder bore not exceeding 300 mm are to experience or results of previous bench tests, the Society, at
be type tested in the presence of a Surveyor in accordance its discretion, may allow a type test to be carried out in the
with the requirements of the present [4.3]. presence of the Surveyor according to a programme to be
agreed upon in each instance.
The selection of the engine to be tested from the production
line is to be agreed upon with the Surveyor. In the case of engines which are to be type approved for dif-
ferent purposes and performances, the programme and
4.3.2 Type test duration of the type test will be decided by the Society in
The programme of the type test is to be in general as speci- each case to cover the whole range of engine performances
fied below, P being the maximum continuous power and n for which approval is requested, taking into account the
the corresponding speed. The maximum continuous power most severe values.
is that stated by the engine Manufacturer and accepted by
4.3.4 During the type test, at least the following particulars
the Society, as defined in [1.3.2].
are to be recorded:
a) 80 hours at power P and speed n
a) ambient air temperature, pressure and atmospheric
b) 8 hours at overload power (110% of power P) humidity in the test room
c) 10 hours at partial loads (25%, 50%, 75% and 90% of b) cooling raw water temperature at the inlet of heat
power P) exchangers
d) 2 hours at intermittent loads c) characteristics of fuel and lubricating oil used during the
e) starting tests test

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 35


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

d) engine speed 4.3.5 Inspection of main engine components and


e) brake power evaluation of test results
The provisions of [4.2.4] and [4.2.5] are to be complied
f) brake torque
with, as far as applicable.
g) maximum combustion pressure
h) indicated pressure diagrams, where practicable 4.4 Material and non-destructive tests
i) exhaust smoke (with a smoke meter deemed suitable by
the Surveyor) 4.4.1 Material tests
j) lubricating oil pressure and temperature Engine components are to be tested in accordance with Tab
6 and in compliance with the requirements of NR216 Mate-
k) cooling water pressure and temperature rials.
l) exhaust gas temperature in the exhaust manifold and, Magnetic particle or liquid penetrant tests are required for
where facilities are available, from each cylinder the parts listed in Tab 6 and are to be effected in positions
m) minimum starting air pressure necessary to start the mutually agreed upon by the Manufacturer and the Society
engine in cold condition. Surveyor, where experience shows defects are most likely to
In addition to the above, for supercharged engines the fol- occur.
lowing data are also to be measured and recorded: The magnetic particle test of tie rods/stay bolts is to be car-
turbocharger speed ried out at each end, for a portion which is at least twice the
air temperature and pressure before and after turbo- length of the thread.
charger and charge air coolers For important structural parts of engines, in addition to the
exhaust gas temperatures and pressures before and after above-mentioned non-destructive tests, examination of
turbochargers and cooling water temperature at the inlet welded seams by approved methods of inspection may be
of charge air coolers. required.

Table 6 : Material and non-destructive tests

Material tests (1) Non-destructive tests


(Mechanical properties
Engine component Magnetic particle or
and chemical composi- Ultrasonic
tion) liquid penetrant

1) Crankshaft all all all


2) Crankshaft coupling flange (non-integral) for main power if bore > 400 mm
transmissions
3) Coupling bolts for crankshaft if bore > 400 mm
4) Steel piston crowns (2) if bore > 400 mm if bore > 400 mm all
5) Piston rods if bore > 400 mm if bore > 400 mm if bore > 400 mm
6) Connecting rods, together with connecting rod bearing all all if bore > 400 mm
caps
7) Crossheads if bore > 400 mm
8) Cylinder liners if bore > 300 mm
9) Steel cylinder covers (2) if bore > 300 mm if bore > 400 mm all
10) Bedplates of welded construction; plates and transverse all all all
bearing girders made of forged or cast steel (2) (3)
11) Frames and crankcases of welded construction (3) all
12) Entablatures of welded construction (3) all
13) Tie rods all if bore > 400 mm
14) Shafts and rotors, including blades, for turbochargers (4) (see Ch 1, Sec 14)
15) Bolts and studs for cylinder covers, crossheads, main if bore > 300 mm if bore > 400 mm
bearings and connecting rod bearings; nuts for tie rods
16) Steel gear wheels for camshaft drives if bore > 400 mm if bore > 400 mm
(1) In addition, material tests may also be required, at the Societys discretion, for piping and valves for starting air lines and any
other pressure piping fitted on the engines.
(2) For items 4), 9) and 10), it is implicit that as well as for steel parts, material tests are also required for parts made of other mate-
rials which are comparable to steel on account of their mechanical properties in general and their ductility in particular: e.g.
aluminium and its alloys, ductile and spheroidal or nodular graphite cast iron.
(3) Material tests for bedplates, frames, crankcases and entablatures are required even if these parts are not welded and for any
material except grey cast iron.
(4) Turbocharger is understood as turbocharger itself and engine driven compressor (incl. "root blowers", but not auxiliary blowers).

36 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

Table 7 : Test pressure of engine parts

Parts under pressure Test pressure (MPa) (1) (2)


1 Cylinder cover, cooling space (3) 0,7
2 Cylinder liner, over the whole length of cooling space 0,7
3 Cylinder jacket, cooling space 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
4 Exhaust valve, cooling space 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
5 Piston crown, cooling space (3) (4) 0,7
6 Fuel injection system
a) Fuel injection pump body, pressure side 1,5 p (or p + 30, if lesser)
b) Fuel injection valve 1,5 p (or p + 30, if lesser)
c) Fuel injection pipes 1,5 p (or p + 30, if lesser)

7 Hydraulic system
Piping, pumps, actuators etc. for hydraulic drive of valves 1,5 p
8 Scavenge pump cylinder 0,4
9 Turbocharger, cooling space 0,4 (but not less than 1,5p)
10 Exhaust pipe, cooling space 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
11 Engine driven air compressor (cylinders, covers, intercoolers and aftercoolers)
a) Air side 1,5 p
b) Water side 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
12 Coolers, each side (5) 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
13 Engine driven pumps (oil, water, fuel, bilge) 0,4 (but not less than 1,5 p)
(1) In general, parts are to be tested at the hydraulic pressure indicated in the Table. Where design or testing features may call for
modification of these testing requirements, special consideration will be given by the Society.
(2) p is the maximum working pressure, in MPa, in the part concerned.
(3) For forged steel cylinder covers and forged steel piston crowns, test methods other than hydrostatic testing may be accepted,
e.g. suitable non-destructive tests and documented dimensional tests.
(4) Where the cooling space is sealed by the piston rod, or by the piston rod and the shell, the pressure test is to be carried out after
assembly.
(5) Turbocharger air coolers need to be tested on the water side only.

Where there is evidence to doubt the soundness of any 4.5 Workshop inspections and testing
engine component, non-destructive tests using approved
detecting methods may be required. 4.5.1 General
Engines of a cylinder diameter not exceeding 300 mm may In addition to the type test, diesel engines are to be sub-
be tested according to an alternative survey scheme. jected to works trials, which are to be witnessed by the Sur-
veyor also when an Alternative Inspection Scheme has been
4.4.2 Hydrostatic tests granted.

Parts of engines under pressure are to be hydrostatically For all stages at which the engine is to be tested, the rele-
tested at the test pressure specified for each part in Tab 7. vant operating values are to be measured and recorded by
the engine Manufacturer.
The following parts of auxiliaries which are necessary for
operation of engines as per [1.1.1] a), b) and c): In each case all measurements conducted at the various
load points are to be carried out at steady operating condi-
cylinders, cylinder covers, coolers and receivers of inde- tions.
pendent air compressors
The readings for 100% of the rated power P at the corre-
water, oil and air coolers (tube bundles or coils, shells sponding speed n are to be taken twice at an interval of at
and heads) not fitted on the engine and filters least 30 minutes.
independently driven lubricating oil, fuel oil and water At the discretion of the Surveyor, the programme of trials
pumps given in [4.5.2], [4.5.3] or [4.5.4] may be expanded
pressure pipes (water, lubricating oil, fuel oil, and com- depending on the engine application.
pressed air pipes), valves and other fittings
4.5.2 Main propulsion engines driving propellers
are to be subjected to hydrostatic tests at 1,5 times the max- Main propulsion engines are to be subjected to trials to be
imum working pressure, but not less than 0,4 MPa. performed as follows:

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 37


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 2

a) at least 60 min, after having reached steady conditions, 4.5.6 Parameters to be measured
at rated power P and rated speed n The data to be measured and recorded, when testing the
b) 30 min, after having reached steady conditions, at engine at various load points, are to include all necessary
110% of rated power P and at a speed equal to 1,032 of parameters for engine operation. The crankshaft deflection
rated speed is to be verified when this check is required by the Manu-
c) tests at 90% (or normal continuous cruise power), 75%, facturer during the operating life of the engine.
50% and 25% of rated power P, carried out:
4.5.7 Testing report
at the speed corresponding to the nominal (theoreti-
cal) propeller curve, for engines driving fixed pitch In the testing report for each engine the results of the tests
propellers carried out are to be compiled and the reference number
and date of issue of the Type Approval Certificate (see
at constant speed, for engines driving controllable
[4.6]), relevant to the engine type, are always to be stated;
pitch propellers
the testing report is to be issued by the Manufacturer and
d) idle run enclosed with the testing certificate as per [4.6].
e) starting and reversing tests (when applicable)
f) testing of the speed governor and of the independent 4.6 Certification
overspeed protective device
4.6.1 Type Approval Certificate and its validity
g) testing of alarm and/or shutdown devices.
After the satisfactory outcome of the type tests and inspec-
Note 1: After running on the test bed, the fuel delivery system is to
be so adjusted that the engine cannot deliver more than 100% of tions specified in [4.2] or [4.3], the Society will issue to the
the rated power at the corresponding speed (overload power can- engine manufacturer a "Type Approval Certificate" valid for
not be obtained in service). all engines of the same type.

4.5.3 Engines driving electric generators used for The Society reserves the right to consider the test carried out
main propulsion purposes on one engine type valid also for engines having a different
cylinder arrangement, following examination of suitable,
Engines driving electric generators are to be subjected to trials
detailed documentation submitted by the Manufacturer and
to be performed with a constant governor setting, as follows:
including bench test results.
a) at least 60 min, after having reached steady conditions,
at 100% of rated power P and rated speed n 4.6.2 Testing certification
b) 45 min, after having reached steady conditions, at a) Engines admitted to an alternative inspection scheme
110% of rated power and rated speed
Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
c) 75%, 50% and 25% of rated power P, carried out at 1, [4.2.3]) are required for components and tests indi-
constant rated speed n cated in Tab 6 and Tab 7.
d) idle run
b) Engines not admitted to an alternative inspection
e) starting tests scheme
f) testing of the speed governor ( [2.10.5]) and of the inde- Societys certificates (C) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
pendent overspeed protective device (when applicable) 1, [4.2.1]) are required for material tests of components
g) testing of alarm and/or shutdown devices. in Tab 6 and for works trials as per [4.5].
Note 1: After running on the test bed, the fuel delivery system of Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
diesel engines driving electric generators is to be adjusted such that 1, [4.2.3]) are required for non-destructive and hydro-
overload (110%) power can be produced but not exceeded in ser- static tests of components in Tab 6 and Tab 7.
vice after installation on board, so that the governing characteris-
tics, including the activation of generator protective devices, can be In both cases a) and b), the Manufacturer is to supply:
maintained at all times.
a) the following information:
4.5.4 Engines driving auxiliary machinery engine type
Engines driving auxiliary machinery are to be subjected to
rated power
the tests stated in [4.5.2] or [4.5.3] for variable speed and
constant speed drives, respectively. rated speed
Note 1: After running on the test bed, the fuel delivery system of driven equipment
diesel engines driving electric generators is to be adjusted such that
overload (110%) power can be produced but not exceeded in ser- operating conditions
vice after installation on board, so that the governing characteris- list of auxiliaries fitted on the engine
tics, including the activation of generator protective devices, can be
fulfilled at all times. b) a statement certifying that the engine is in compliance
with that type tested, except for modifications already
4.5.5 Inspection of engine components notified to the Society. The reference number and date
After the works trials, engine components as per [4.2.5] are of the Type Approval Certificate are also to be indicated
to be inspected by the Surveyor. in the statement.

38 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

SECTION 3 PRESSURE EQUIPMENTS

1 General 1.2 Application

1.2.1 Pressure vessels covered by the Rules


1.1 Principles
The requirements of this Section apply to:
1.1.1 Scope of the Rules all fired or unfired pressures vessels of metallic con-
The boilers and other pressure vessels, associated piping struction, including the associated fittings and mount-
systems and fittings are to be of a design and construction ings with maximum allowable pressure greater than
adequate for the service for which they are intended and is 0,5 bar above atmospheric pressure with the exception
to be so installed and protected as to reduce to a minimum of those indicated in [1.2.2]
any danger to persons on board, due regard being paid to all boilers and other steam generators, including the
moving parts, hot surfaces and other hazards. The design is associated fittings and mountings with maximum allow-
to have regard to materials used in construction, the pur- able pressure greater than 0,5 bar above atmospheric
pose for which the equipment is intended, the working con- pressure with the exception of those indicated in
ditions to which it will be subjected and the environmental [1.2.2].
conditions on board.
So these Rules apply to pressure equipment for the fol- 1.2.2 Pressure vessels not covered by the Rules
lowing requirements: Among others the following boilers and pressure vessels are
be safe in sight of pressure risk not covered by the Rules and are to be considered on a case
by case basis:
be safe in sight of other risks, moving parts, hot surfaces
a) boilers with design pressure p > 10 MPa
ensure capability of propulsion and other essential ser-
vices. b) pressure vessel intended for radioactive material

Pressure equipment means pressure vessels, piping ( Ch c) equipment comprising casings or machinery where the
1, Sec 10), safety accessories and pressure accessories. dimensioning, choice of material and manufacturing
rules are based primarily on requirements for sufficient
1.1.2 Overpressure risk strength, rigidity and stability to meet the static and
dynamic operational effects or other operational charac-
Where main or auxiliary boilers and other pressure vessels
teristics and for which pressure is not a significant
or any parts thereof may be subject to dangerous overpres-
design factor. Such equipment may include:
sure, means are to be provided where practicable to protect
against such excessive pressure. engines including turbines and internal combustion
engines
1.1.3 Propulsion capability steam engines, gas/steam turbines, turbo-generators,
Means are to be provided whereby normal operation of compressors, pumps and actuating devices
main boilers can be sustained or restored even through one
d) small pressure vessels included in self-contained
of the essential auxiliaries become inoperative. Special con-
domestic equipment.
sideration is to be given to the malfunctioning of:
the source of steam supply
1.3 Definitions
the boiler feed water systems
the fuel oil supply system for boilers 1.3.1 Pressure vessel
the mechanical air supply for boilers. Pressure vessel means a housing designed and built to
contain fluids under pressure including its direct attach-
However the Society, having regard to overall safety consid- ments up to the coupling point connecting it to other equip-
erations, may accept a partial reduction in propulsion capa- ment. A vessel may be composed of more than one
bility from normal operation. chamber.

1.1.4 Tests 1.3.2 Fired pressure vessel


All boilers and other pressure vessels including their associ- Fired pressure vessel is a pressure vessel which is com-
ated fittings which are under internal pressure are to be sub- pletely or partially exposed to fire from burners or combus-
jected to appropriate tests including a pressure test before tion gases or otherwise heated pressure vessel with a risk of
being put into service for the first time (see also Article [7]). overheating.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 39


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

a) Boiler limiting devices, which either activate the means for


Boiler is one or more fired pressure vessels and associ- correction or provide for shutdown or shutdown and
ated piping systems used for generating steam or hot lockout, such as pressure switches or temperature
water at a temperature above 120C. switches or fluid level switches and safety related mea-
surement control and regulation devices.
Any equipment directly connected to the boiler, such as
economisers, superheaters and safety valves, is consid- 1.3.5 Design pressure
ered as part of the boiler, if it is not separated from the The design pressure is the pressure used by the manufac-
steam generator by means of any isolating valve. Piping turer to determine the scantlings of the vessel. This pressure
connected to the boiler is considered as part of the cannot be taken less than the maximum working pressure
boiler upstream of the isolating valve and as part of the and is to be limited by the set pressure of the safety valve, as
associated piping system downstream of the isolating prescribed by the applicable Rules. Pressure is indicated as
valve. gauge pressure above atmospheric pressure, vacuum is
b) Thermal oil heater indicated as negative pressure.
Thermal oil heater is one or more fired pressure vessels 1.3.6 Design temperature
and associated piping systems in which organic liquids a) Design temperature is the actual metal temperature of
(thermal oils) are heated. When heated by electricity the applicable part under the expected operating condi-
thermal oil heater is considered as an unfired pressure tions, as modified in Tab 1. This temperature is to be
vessel. stated by the manufacturer and is to take in account of
the effect of any temperature fluctuations which may
1.3.3 Unfired pressure vessel
occur during the service.
Any pressure vessel which is not a fired pressure vessel is an
b) The design temperature is not to be less than the tem-
unfired pressure vessel.
peratures stated in Tab 1, unless specially agreed
a) Heat exchanger between the manufacturer and the Society on a case by
A heat exchanger is an unfired pressure vessel used to case basis.
heat or cool a fluid with an another fluid. In general
1.3.7 Volume
heat exchangers are composed of a number of adjacent
chambers, the two fluids flowing separately in adjacent Volume V means the internal volume of a chamber, includ-
chambers. One or more chambers may consist of bun- ing the volume of nozzles to the first connection or weld
dles of tubes. and excluding the volume of permanent internal parts.

b) Steam generator 1.3.8 Boiler heating surface


A steam generator is a heat exchanger and associated Heating surface is the area of the part of the boiler through
piping used for generating steam. In general in these which the heat is supplied to the medium, on the side
Rules, the requirements for boilers are also applicable exposed to fire or hot gases.
for steam generators, unless otherwise indicated.
1.3.9 Maximum steam output
1.3.4 Safety accessories Maximum steam output is the maximum quantity of steam
than can be produced continuously by the boiler or steam
Safety accessories means devices designed to protect
generator operating under the design steam conditions.
pressure equipment against the allowable limits being
exceeded. Such devices include: 1.3.10 Toxic and corrosive substances
devices for direct pressure limitation, such as safety Toxic and corrosive substances are those which are listed in
valves, bursting disc safety devices, buckling rods, con- the IMO International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code
trolled safety pressure relief systems, and (IMDG Code), as amended.

Table 1 : Minimum design temperature

Type of vessel Minimum design temperature


Pressure parts of pressure vessels and boilers not heated by hot gases
Maximum temperature of the internal fluid
or adequately protected by insulation
Pressure vessel heated by hot gases 25oC in excess of the temperature of the internal fluid
Water tubes of boilers mainly subjected to convection heat 25oC in excess of the temperature of the saturated steam
Water tubes of boilers mainly subjected to radiant heat 50oC in excess of the temperature of the saturated steam
Superheater tubes of boilers mainly subjected to convection heat 35oC in excess of the temperature of the saturated steam
Superheater tubes of boilers mainly subjected to radiant heat 50oC in excess of the temperature of the saturated steam
Economiser tubes 35oC in excess of the temperature of the internal fluid
For combustion chambers of the type used in wet-back boilers 50oC in excess of the temperature of the internal fluid
For furnaces, fire-boxes, rear tube plates of dry-back boilers and other
90oC in excess of the temperature of the internal fluid
pressure parts subjected to similar rate of heat transfer

40 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

1.3.11 Liquid and gaseous substances substances listed or not in the IMDG Code
a) liquid substances are liquids having a vapour pressure at design pressure p, in MPa
the maximum allowable temperature of not more than design temperature T, in C
0,5 bar above normal atmospheric pressure
actual thickness of the vessel tA, in mm
b) gaseous substances are gases, liquefied gases, gases dis-
volume V, in litres.
solved under pressure, vapours and also those liquids
whose vapour pressure at the maximum allowable tem- 1.4.2 Pressure vessel classification
perature is greater than 0,5 bar above normal atmo-
Pressure vessels are classed as indicated in Tab 2.
spheric pressure.
1.4.3 Implication of class
1.3.12 Ductile material
The class of a pressure vessel has, among others, implica-
For the purpose of this Section, ductile material is a material
tion in:
having an elongation over 12%.
design
1.3.13 Incinerator material allowance
Incinerator is a shipboard facility for incinerating solid gar- welding design
bage approximating in composition to household garbage
efficiency of joints
and liquid garbage deriving from the operation of the ship
(e.g. domestic garbage, cargo-associated garbage, mainte- examination and non-destructive tests
nance garbage, operational garbage, cargo residue, and thermal stress relieving.
fishing gear), as well as for burning sludge with a flash point
above 60C. See Tab 24.
These facilities may be designed to use the heat energy pro-
duced. 1.5 Applicable Rules
Incinerators are not generally pressure vessels, however 1.5.1 Alternative standards
when their fittings are of the same type than those of boilers
a) Boilers and pressure vessels are to be designed, con-
the requirements for these fittings apply.
structed, installed and tested in accordance with the
applicable requirements of this Section.
1.4 Classes
b) The acceptance of national and international standards
as an alternative to the requirements of this Section may
1.4.1 Significant parameters
be considered by the Society on a case by case basis.
Pressure vessels are classed in three class in consideration
of the: c) In particular composite wrapped cylinders are to be
designed, constructed, installed and tested in accor-
type of equipment: pressure vessel or steam generator dance with a Standard to be accepted by the Society on
state (gaseous or liquid) of the intended fluid contents a case by case basis.

Table 2 : Pressure vessel classification

Equipment Class 1 Class 2 Class 3


Steam generators or boilers p > 3,2 and V > 2 or if not class 1 or class 3 p V 5 or
p V > 20 and V > 2 V2
Pressure vessels for toxic substances all
Pressure vessels for corrosive substances p > 20 or if not in class 1
p V > 20 or
T > 350
Pressure vessels for gaseous substances p > 100 or V > 1 and p V > 100 all pressure vessels which
p V > 300 and not in class 1 are not class 1 or class 2
Pressure vessels for liquid substances V > 10 and p V > 1000 V 10 and p > 100 or all pressure vessels and heat
and p > 50 1 < p 50 and p V > 1000 exchangers which are not
class 1 or class 2
Pressure vessels for thermal oil p > 1,6 or T > 300 if not class 1 or class 3 p 0,7 and T 150
Pressure vessels for fuel oil, lubricating p > 1,6 or T > 150 if not class 1 or class 3 p 0,7 and T 60
oil or flammable hydraulic oil
Whatever type of equipment tA > 40 15 < tA 40
Note 1: Whenever the class is defined by more than one characteristic, the equipment is to be considered belonging to the highest
class of its characteristics, independently of the values of the other characteristics.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 41


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

1.6 Documentation to be submitted Table 4 : Information and data to be submitted


for boilers and steam generators
1.6.1 General
Documents mentioned in the present sub-article are to be
No Item
submitted for class 1 and class 2 and not for class 3, unless
the equipment is considered as critical. 1 Design pressure and temperature
2 Pressure and temperature of the superheated steam
1.6.2 Boilers and steam generators
The plans listed in Tab 3 are to be submitted. 3 Pressure and temperature of the saturated steam

The drawings listed in Tab 3 are to contain: 4 Maximum steam production per hour
the constructional details of all pressure parts, such as 5 Evaporating surface of the tube bundles and water-
shells, headers, tubes, tube plates, nozzles walls
strengthening members, such as stays, brackets, opening 6 Heating surface of the economiser, superheater and
reinforcements and covers air-heater
installation arrangements, such as saddles and anchor- 7 Surface of the furnace
ing system,
8 Volume of the combustion chamber
as well as the information and data indicated in Tab 4. 9 Temperature and pressure of the feed water
1.6.3 Pressure vessels 10 Type of fuel to be used and fuel consumption at full
The plans listed in Tab 5 are to be submitted. steam production
The drawings listed in Tab 5 are to contain the construc- 11 Number and capacity of burners
tional details of:
pressure parts, such as shells, headers, tubes, tube 1.6.4 Incinerators
plates, nozzles, opening reinforcements and covers
strengthening members, such as stays, brackets and Incinerators are to be considered on a case by case basis,
reinforcements. based on their actual arrangement, using the applicable
requirements for boilers and pressure vessels.
Table 3 : Drawings to be submitted
for boilers and steam generators Table 5 : Drawings, information and data to be
submitted for pressure vessels and heat exchangers
No A/I Item
1 I General arrangement plan, including valves
and fittings No A/I Item

2 A Material specifications 1 I General arrangement plan, including nozzles


and fittings
3 A Sectional assembly
4 A Evaporating parts 2 A Sectional assembly
5 A Superheater 3 A Safety valves (if any) and their arrangement
6 A De-superheater 4 A Material specifications
7 A Economiser 5 A Welding details, including at least:
8 A Air heater typical weld joint design
9 A Tubes and tube plates welding procedure specifications
10 A Nozzles and fittings post-weld heat treatments

11 A Safety valves and their arrangement 6 I Design data, including at least design pressure
and design temperatures (as applicable)
12 A Boiler seating
13 I Fuel oil burning arrangement 7 A For seamless (extruded) pressure vessels, the
manufacturing process, including:
14 I Forced draft system
a description of the manufacturing process
15 I Refractor or insulation arrangement with indication of the production controls
16 A Boiler instrumentation, monitoring and control normally carried out in the manufacturer's
system works
17 A Type of safety valves and their lift, discharge details of the materials to be used (specifi-
rate and setting cation, yield point, tensile strength, impact
strength, heat treatment)
18 A Welding details, including at least:
details of the stamped marking to be
typical weld joint design
applied.
welding procedure specifications
post-weld heat treatment 8 I Type of fluid or fluids contained
Note 1: A = to be submitted for approval in four copies Note 1: A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate. I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.

42 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2 Design and construction - Scantlings 2.2 Materials


of pressure parts
2.2.1 Materials for high temperatures

2.1 General a) Materials for pressure parts having a design temperature


exceeding the ambient temperature are to be selected
2.1.1 Application by the Manufacturer and to have mechanical and metal-
lurgical properties adequate for the design temperature.
a) In general, the formulae in the present Article do not Their allowable stress limits are to be determined as a
take into account additional stresses imposed by effects function of the temperature, as per [2.3.2].
other than pressure, such as stresses deriving from the
static and dynamic weight of the pressure vessel and its b) When the design temperature of pressure parts exceeds
content, external loads from connecting equipment and 400C, alloy steels are to be used. Other materials are
foundations, etc. For the purpose of the Rules these subject of special consideration by the Society.
additional loads may be neglected, provided it can rea-
sonably be presumed that the actual average stresses of 2.2.2 Materials for low temperatures
the vessel, considering all these additional loads, would
Materials for pressure parts having a design temperature
not increase more than 10% with respect to the stresses
below the ambient temperature are to have notch toughness
calculated by the formulae in this Article.
properties suitable for the design temperature.
b) Where it is necessary to take into account additional
stresses, such as dynamic loads, the Society reserves the 2.2.3 Cast iron
right to ask for additional requirements on a case by
Cast iron is not to be used for:
case basis.
a) class 1 and class 2 pressure vessels
2.1.2 Alternative requirements
b) class 3 pressure vessels with design pressure
When pressure parts are of an irregular shape, such as to p > 0,7 MPa or product pV > 1000, where V is the
make it impossible to check the scantlings by applying the internal volume of the pressure vessel in litres
formulae of this Article, the approval is to be based on other
means, such as burst and/or deformation tests on a proto- c) Bolted covers and closures of pressure vessels having a
type or by another method agreed upon between the manu- design pressure p > 1 MPa, except for covers intended
facturer and the Society. for boiler shells, for which [3.2.4] applies.

Table 6 : Permissible stresses K for carbon steels intended for boilers and thermal oil heaters

Carbon steel T (C) 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
t 15 mm 133 109 107 105 94 77 73 72
Rm = 360 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 128 106 105 101 90 77 73 72
Grade HA
40 mm < t 60 mm 122 101 99 95 88 77 73 72
t 15 mm 133 127 116 103 79 79 72 69
Rm = 360 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 133 122 114 102 79 79 72 69
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 133 112 107 99 79 79 72 69
t 15 mm 152 132 130 126 112 94 89 86
Rm = 410 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 147 131 124 119 107 94 89 86
Grade HA
40 mm < t 60 mm 141 120 117 113 105 94 89 86
t 15 mm 152 147 135 121 107 95 88 84
Rm = 410 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 152 142 133 120 107 95 88 84
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 152 134 127 117 107 95 88 84
t 15 mm 170 164 154 139 124 111 104 99
Rm = 460 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 169 162 151 137 124 111 104 99
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 162 157 147 136 124 111 104 99
2
Rm = 510 N/mm
t 60 mm 170 170 169 159 147 134 125 112
Grades HB, HD

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 43


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.2.4 Valves and fittings for boilers design temperature T above 200C and copper-nickel
a) Ductile materials are to be used for valves and fittings fittings with design temperature T exceeding 300C.
intended to be mounted on boilers. The material is to
2.2.5 Alternative materials
have mechanical and metallurgical characteristics suit-
able for the design temperature and for the thermal and In the case of boilers or pressure vessels constructed in
other loads imposed during the operation. accordance with one of the standards considered accept-
able by the Society as per [1.5], the material specifications
b) Grey cast iron is not to be used for valves and fittings
are to be in compliance with the requirements of the stan-
which are subject to dynamic loads, such as safety
dard used.
valves and blow-down valves, and in general for fittings
and accessories having design pressure p exceeding
0,3 MPa and design temperature T exceeding 220C. 2.3 Permissible stresses
c) Spheroidal cast iron is not to be used for parts having a 2.3.1 The permissible stresses K, in N/mm2, for steels, to be
design temperature T exceeding 350C. used in the formulae of this Article, may be determined
d) Bronze is not to be used for parts having design temper- from Tab 6, Tab 7, Tab 8 and Tab 9, where Rm is the ultimate
ature T exceeding 220C for normal bronzes and 260C strength of the material, in N/mm2. For intermediate values
for bronzes suitable for high temperatures. Copper and of the temperature, the value of K is to be obtained by linear
aluminium brass are not to be used for fittings with interpolation.

Table 7 : Permissible stresses K for carbon steels intended for other pressure vessels

Carbon steel T (C) 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
t 15 mm 133 117 115 112 100 83 78 77
Rm = 360 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 133 114 113 108 96 83 78 77
Grade HA
40 mm < t 60 mm 130 108 105 101 94 83 78 77
t 15 mm 133 133 123 110 97 85 77 73
Rm = 360 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 133 131 122 109 97 85 77 73
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 133 119 115 106 97 85 77 73
t 15 mm 152 141 139 134 120 100 95 92
Rm = 410 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 152 134 132 127 114 100 95 92
Grade HA
40 mm < t 60 mm 150 128 121 112 112 100 95 92
t 15 mm 152 152 144 129 114 101 94 89
Rm = 410 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 152 152 142 128 114 101 94 89
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 152 143 139 125 114 101 94 89
t 15 mm 170 170 165 149 132 118 111 105
Rm = 460 N/mm2
15 mm < t 40 mm 170 170 161 147 132 118 111 105
Grades HB, HD
40 mm < t 60 mm 170 167 157 145 132 118 111 105
2
Rm = 510 N/mm
t 60 mm 189 189 180 170 157 143 133 120
Grades HB, HD

Table 8 : Permissible stresses K for alloy steels intended for boilers and thermal oil heaters

Alloy steel T(C) 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 475 500 525 550 575 600
0,3Mo t 60 mm 159 153 143 134 125 106 100 94 91 89 87 36
1Cr 0,5Mo t 60 mm 167 167 157 144 137 128 119 112 106 104 103 55 31 19
2,25Cr 1Mo (1) t 60 mm 170 167 157 147 144 137 131 125 119 115 112 61 41 30 22
2,25Cr 1Mo (2) t 60 mm 170 167 164 161 159 147 141 130 128 125 122 61 41 30 22
(1) Normalised and tempered
(2) Normalised and tempered or quenched and tempered

Table 9 : Permissible stresses K for alloy steels intended for other pressure vessels
Alloy steel T(C) 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 475 500 525 550 575 600
0,3Mo t 60 mm 159 159 153 143 133 113 107 100 97 95 93 38
1Cr 0,5Mo t 60 mm 167 167 167 154 146 137 127 119 113 111 110 59 33 20
2,25Cr 1Mo (1) t 60 mm 183 174 167 157 154 146 140 133 127 123 119 65 44 32 23
2,25Cr 1Mo (2) t 60 mm 174 174 174 172 170 157 150 139 137 133 130 65 44 32 23
(1) Normalised and tempered
(2) Normalised and tempered or quenched and tempered

44 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.3.2 Direct determination of permissible stress where:


The permissible stresses K, where not otherwise specified, Rm,T : Minimum tensile strength at the design tem-
may be taken as indicated below. perature T, in N/mm2
a) Steel: e) Aluminium and aluminium alloys:
The permissible stress is to be the minimum of the val- The permissible stress is to be the minimum of the val-
ues obtained by the following formulae: ues obtained by the following formulae:

R m ,20 R m ,T
K = ----------- K = ---------
2 ,7 4
R S ,M IN ,T R e ,H
K = ----------------
- K = --------
-
A 1 ,5
S where:
K = ----A-
A Re,H : Minimum yield stress, in N/mm2
where: f) Additional conditions:
Rm,20 : Minimum tensile strength at ambient tem- In special cases the Society reserves the right to
perature (20C), in N/mm2 apply values of permissible stress K lower than those
specified above.
RS,MIN,T : Minimum between ReH and Rp 0,2 at the
In the case of boilers or other steam generators, the
design temperature T, in N/mm2
permissible stress K is not to exceed 170 N/mm2.
SA : Average stress to produce creep rupture in
For materials other than those listed above the per-
100000 hours, in N/mm2, at the design tem- missible stress is to be agreed with the Society on a
perature T case by case basis.
A : Safety factor taken as follows, when reliabil-
ity of RS,MIN,T and SA values are proved to the 2.4 Cylindrical, spherical and conical shells
Societys satisfaction: with circular cross-sections subject to
1,6 for boilers and other steam genera- internal pressure
tors
2.4.1 Cylindrical shell thickness
1,5 for other pressure vessels
a) The minimum thickness of cylindrical, spherical and
specially considered by the Society if conical shells with circular cross-sections is not to be
average stress to produce creep rupture less than the value t, in mm, calculated by one of the
in more than 100000 hours is used following formulae, as appropriate. Cylindrical tube
instead of SA. plates pierced by a great number of tube holes are to
In the case of steel castings, the permissible have thickness calculated by the applicable formulae in
stress K, calculated as above, is to be [2.4.3], [2.4.4], [2.4.5] and [2.9.2].
decreased by 20%. Where steel castings are a) The thicknesses obtained by the formulae in [2.4.3],
subjected to non-destructive tests, a smaller [2.4.4] and [2.4.5] are net thicknesses, as they do not
reduction up to 10% may be taken into con- include any corrosion allowance. The thickness
sideration by the Society. obtained by the above formulae is to be increased by
b) Spheroidal cast iron: 0,75 mm. See also [2.4.7].

The permissible stress is be to the minimum of the val- 2.4.2 Efficiency


ues obtained by the following formulae:
a) The values of efficiency e to be used in the formulae in
R m ,20 [2.4.3], [2.4.4] and [2.4.5] are indicated in Tab 10.
K = -----------
4 ,8
R S ,M IN ,T
Table 10 : Efficiency of unpierced shells
K = ----------------
-
3
Case e
c) Grey cast iron: Seamless shells 1
The permissible stress is obtained by the following formula: Shells of class 1 vessels (1) 1
R m ,20 Shells of class 2 vessels (with partial radiographic
K = ----------- 0,85
10 examination of butt-joints)

d) Copper alloys: Shells of class 2 vessels with actual thickness 15mm


0,75
(without radiographic examination of butt-joints)
The permissible stress is obtained by the following formula:
(1) In special cases the Society reserves the right to take a
R m ,T factor e < 1, depending on the welding procedure
K = --------- adopted for the welded joint.
4

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 45


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.4.3 Cylindrical shells pD


t = -------------------------------------------
a) When the ratio external diameter/inside diameter is ( 2 K p )e cos
equal to or less than 1,5, the minimum thickness of For the meaning of the symbols, see [2.4.3].
cylindrical shells is given by the following formula: D is measured in way of the large end of the cone and
pD is the angle of slope of the conical section of the shell to
t = -------------------------
( 2 K p )e the pressure vessel axis (see Fig 1). When exceeds
where: 75, the shell thickness is to be taken as required for flat
heads, see [2.7].
p : Design pressure, in MPa
D : Inside diameter of vessel, in mm b) The minimum thickness of shells having thickness
exceeding 1/6 of the external diameter in way of the
K : Permissible stress, in N/mm2, obtained as
large end of the cone is subject of special consideration.
specified in [2.3]
c) Conical shells may be made of several ring sections of
e : Efficiency of welded joint, the value of
decreasing thickness. The minimum thickness of each
which is given in [2.4.2].
section is to be obtained by the formula in a) using for D
b) The minimum thickness of shells having ratio external the maximum diameter of the considered section.
diameter/inside diameter exceeding 1,5 is subject of
d) In general, the junction with a sharp angle between the
special consideration.
conical shell and the cylindrical or other conical shell,
2.4.4 Spherical shells having different angle of slope, is not allowed if the
a) When the ratio external diameter/inside diameter is angle of the generating line of the shells to be assem-
equal to or less than 1,5, the minimum thickness of bled exceeds 30.
spherical shells is given by the following formula: e) The shell thickness in way of knuckles is subject of spe-
cial consideration by the Society.
pD
t = -------------------------
( 4 K p )e 2.4.6 Minimum thickness of shells
For the meaning of the symbols, see [2.4.3]. Irrespective of the value calculated by the formulae in
b) The minimum thickness of shells having ratio external [2.4.3], [2.4.4] or [2.4.5], the thickness t of shells is not to
diameter/inside diameter exceeding 1,5 is subject of be less than one of the following values, as applicable:
special consideration. for pressure vessels: t = 3 + D/1500 mm
for unpierced plates of boilers: t = 6,0 mm
2.4.5 Conical shells
for boiler cylindrical tube plates: t = 9,5 mm.
a) The following formula applies to conical shells of thick-
ness not exceeding 1/6 of the external diameter in way No corrosion allowance needs to be added to the above
of the large end of the cone: values.

Figure 1 : Conic shells

DE DE

D D

radiused

t
t

CONE / CYLINDER CONE / CYLINDER


SOLID KNUCKLE WELDED KNUCKLE

CONE / CONE CONE / CONE


SOLID KNUCKLE WELDED KNUCKLE

D D

radiused

t t

46 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.4.7 Corrosion allowance 2.5.3 Required thickness of solid dished heads


The Society reserves the right to increase the corrosion a) The minimum thickness of solid (not pierced) hemi-
allowance value in the case of vessels exposed to particular spherical, torispherical, or ellipsoidal unstayed dished
accelerating corrosion conditions. The Society may also heads, subject to pressure on the concave (internal)
consider the reduction of this factor where particular mea- side, is to be not less than the value t, in mm, calculated
sures are taken to effectively reduce the corrosion rate of by the following formula:
the vessel.
pD C
t = ------------
2K e
2.5 Dished heads subject to pressure on the
concave (internal) side where:
C : Shape factor, obtained from the graph in Fig
2.5.1 Dished head for boiler headers 3, as a function of H/D and t/D.
Dished heads for boiler headers are to be seamless. For other symbols, see [2.4.3].
2.5.2 Dished head profile b) The thickness obtained by the formula in item a) is net
The following requirements are to be complied with for the thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
determination of the profile of dished heads (see Fig 2 (a) ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
and (b)). be increased by 0,75 mm. See also [2.4.7].

a) Ellipsoidal heads: 2.5.4 Composed torispherical heads


H 0,2 D a) Torispherical heads may be constructed with welded
where: elements of different thicknesses (see Fig 4).
H : External depth of head, in mm, measured b) Where a torispherical head is built in two sections, the
from the start of curvature at the base. thickness of the torispherical part is to be obtained by
the formula in [2.5.3], while the thickness of the spheri-
b) Torispherical heads:
cal part may be obtained by the formula in [2.4.4].
RIN D
c) The spherical part may commence at a distance from
rIN 0,1 D the knuckle not less than:
rIN 3 t 0,5 (RIN t) 0,5
H 0,18 D where:
where: RIN : Internal radius of the spherical part, in mm
RIN : Internal radius of the spherical part, in mm
t : Knuckle thickness, in mm.
rIN : Internal knuckle radius, in mm
H : External depth of head calculated by the fol- 2.5.5 Minimum thickness of dished heads
lowing formula (see Fig 2 (b)): Irrespective of the values calculated in [2.5.2] and [2.5.3],
the thickness t of dished heads is not to be less than:
H = RE [(RE 0,5 D) (RE + 0,5 D 2 rE)] 0,5

3 + DE / 1500 mm for normal pressure vessels


where:
RE : External radius of the spherical 6 mm for boiler pressure vessels.
part, in mm
No corrosion allowance needs to be added to the above
rE : External knuckle radius, in mm. values.

Figure 2 : Dished head profiles

t
t
b

r r
IN E
2t

R R
IN E

a
D
D

(a) ELLIPSOIDAL HEAD (b) TORISPHERICAL HEAD

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 47


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 3 : Shape factor for dished heads

3,5

2,5 -0.5
d.(t.D)
=5.0
2
=4.0

1,6 =3.0
t/D
0.002
0.005
0.01
0.02 1,2 =2.0
0.04
1
0,9

0,8 =1.0

0,7

0,6 =0.5

0,5
0,18 0,2 0,3 0,4 0,5 H/D

Figure 4 : Composed torispherical head 2.5.6 Connection of heads to cylindrical shells


The heads are to be provided, at their base, with a cylindri-
0,5(RIN.t)0,5
cal skirt not less than 2t in length and with a thickness in no
case less than the Rule thickness of a cylindrical shell of the
same diameter and the same material, calculated by the for-
mula given in [2.4.3] using the same efficiency factor e
Slope 1/9 adopted for calculation of the head thickness. Fig 5 and Fig
t
rIN 6 show typical admissible attachments of dished ends to
cylindrical shells.
In particular, hemispherical heads not provided with the
above skirt are to be connected to the cylindrical shell if the
DE latter is thicker than the head, as shown in Fig 5.
RIN Other types of connections are subject to special consider-
ation by the Society.

48 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 5 : Typical attachment of dished heads to cylindrical shells

t t

s
(a) rIN (b) rIN
2t
2t

t
t

s
rIN
2t 2t rIN
(c) (d)

t1
t1 t1
t

t
t1
rIN
t1 3t 1,5t
1,5t 4t
rIN
(e) (f)
St

Types shown in (a), (b) and (c) are acceptable for all pressure vessels.

Type shown in (d) is acceptable for class 2 and class 3 pressure vessels.

Types shown in (e) and (f) are acceptable for class 3 pressure vessels only.

Figure 6 : Connection of hemispherical head 2.6 Dished heads subject to pressure on the
to the cylindrical shell convex (external) side
2.6.1 The calculation of the minimum thickness is to be
performed according to a standard accepted by the Society.
In addition, the thickness of torispherical or ellipsoidal
heads under external pressure is no to be less than 1,2 times
the thickness required for a head of the same shape subject
to internal pressure.

2.7 Flat heads


2.7.1 Unstayed flat head minimum thickness
a) The minimum thickness of unstayed flat heads is not to
be less than the value t, in mm, calculated by the fol-
R IN
lowing formula:
100p 0 ,5
t = D -------------
CK

where:

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 49


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

p : Design pressure, in MPa b : Effective half contact width of


2 the gasket, in mm, calculated as
K : Permissible stress, in N/mm , obtained as
specified in [2.3] follows:

D : Diameter of the head, in mm. For circular b = 0,5 N for N 13 mm, and
section heads, the diameter D is to be mea-
sured as shown in Fig 7 and Fig 8 for various b = 1,8 N 0,5 for N > 13 mm
types of heads. For rectangular section where N is the geometric con-
heads, the equivalent value for D may be tact width of the gasket, in mm,
obtained from the following formula: as indicated in Fig 8(o)
0 ,5
a
D = a 3 ,4 2 ,4 --- m, y : Adimensional coefficients whose
b
values are given in Tab 11,
a and b being the smaller and larger side of depending on the type of gasket.
the rectangle, respectively, in mm
The adoption of one of the above-mentioned heads is
C : The values given below, depending on the subject to the Societys approval depending upon its
various types of heads shown in Fig 7 and use. Types of heads not shown in Fig 7 and Fig 8 are to
Fig 8: be the subject of special consideration by the Society.
Fig 7(a) : C = 400 for circular heads
b) The thickness obtained by the formulae in a) is net
Fig 7(b) : C = 330 for circular heads thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
Fig 7(c) : C = 350 for circular heads ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
be increased by 1 mm. See also [2.4.7].
Fig 7(d) : C = 400 for circular heads and
C = 250 for rectangular heads
2.7.2 Stayed flat head minimum thickness
Fig 7(e) : C = 350 for circular heads and
C = 200 for rectangular heads For the minimum thickness of stayed flat heads, see
[2.12.3].
Fig 7(f) : C = 350 for circular heads
Fig 7(g) : C = 300 for circular heads Table 11 : Coefficients m and y
Fig 7(h) : C = 350 for circular heads and
C = 200 for rectangular heads Type of gasket m y
Fig 8(i) : C = 350 for circular heads and Self-sealing, metal or rubber (e.g. O-ring) 0 0
C = 200 for rectangular heads
Rubber with cotton fabric 10 0,88
Fig 8(j) : C = 200 for circular heads
Rubber with reinforcing fabric with or
Fig 8(k) : C = 330 for circular heads without metal wire:
Fig 8(l) : C = 300 for circular heads - 3 layers 18 4,85
Fig 8(m) : C = 300 for circular heads - 2 layers 20 6,4
Fig 8(n) : C = 400 for circular heads - 1 layers 22 8,2
Fig 8(o) : C = value obtained from the fol- Synthetic fibre with suitable binders:
lowing formula, for circular - 3,0 mm thick 16 3,5
heads:
- 1,5 mm thick 22 8,2
100
C = ------------------------------- Organic fibre 14 2,4
1 ,9 Fh
0 ,3 + ---------------
pD
3 Metal spiral lined with synthetic fibre:

where: - carbon steel 20 6,4

h : Radial distance, in mm, from the - stainless steel 24 9,9


pitch centre diameter of bolts to Synthetic fibre with plain metal lining:
the circumference of diameter - copper 28 14,0
D, as shown in Fig 8(o)
- iron 30 16,8
F : Total bolt load, in N, to be taken
as the greater of the following - stainless steel 30 20,0
values F1 and F2: Solid metal:
F1 = 0,785 D p (D + m b) - copper 38 28,7
F2 = 9,81 y D b - iron 44 39,8

with: - stainless steel 52 57,5

50 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 7 : Types of unstayed flat heads (1)


t t

t2
t
3t 0 r
3t 0
r = 0,2t 0,5t
D t0 D t1 D
t0
t1
t1

(a) (b) (c)


t t t

t1 D t1 D t1 D

(d) (e) (f)


t t

t1 D t1 D

(g) (h)

Figure 8 : Types of unstayed flat heads (2)


t t t

D
t1 D t1 D

t1

(j) (k)
(i)
t1 t
t

t1 D
D t1

(l) (m)
D h
D
N
t
t

t1 t1

(n) (o)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 51


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.8 Openings and branches (nozzles) Figure 9 : Reinforcement by increasing the


wall thickness of the main body with opening
2.8.1 Nozzles thickness
a) The thickness eb , in mm, of nozzles attached to shells rs d s1
and headers of boilers is not to be less than:
d
e b = -----E- + 2 ,5
25
Af
where dE is the outside diameter of nozzle, in mm. 30

ers
The thickness of the nozzle is, however, to be not less
than the thickness required for the piping system
attached to the vessel shell calculated at the vessel
design pressure, and need not to be greater than the
thickness of the shell to which it is connected.

dos
dis
b) The thickness of the nozzle attached to shells and head-
ers of other pressure vessels is not to be less than the
Ap
thickness required for the piping system attached to the
vessel shell calculated at the vessel design pressure, and
need not be greater than the thickness of the shell to
which it is connected. Figure 10 : Reinforcement by set-through
c) Where a branch is connected by screwing, the thickness and full penetration welded branch
of the nozzle is to be measured at the root of the thread.

2.8.2 Nozzle connection to vessel shell dob


a) In general, the axis of the nozzle is not to form an angle dib

bo
greater than 15 with the normal to the shell.
b) Fig 30, Fig 31, Fig 32 and Fig 33 show some typical rs
acceptable connections of nozzles to shells. Other types
Afb
of connections are to be considered by the Society on a

b1
rb
Afs

ers
case by case basis. 30

2.8.3 Openings in shells


rb1

a) In general, the largest dimensions of the openings in


shells are not to exceed: erb s1 so
for shells up to 1500 mm in diameter DE:
1/2 DE , but not more than 500 mm

dos
dis
for shells over 1500 mm in diameter DE:
Ap
1/3 DE , but not more than 1000 mm,
where D E is the vessel external diameter, in mm.
Greater values may be considered by the Society on a
Figure 11 : Reinforcement by welded on branch
case by case basis.
b) In general, in oval or elliptical openings the ratio major
diameter/minor diameter is not to exceed 2. dob
2.8.4 Openings compensation in cylindrical shells dib
a) Compensation methods
For cylindrical shells with openings, the efficiency of the
bo

main body is to be satisfied by one of the following Afb


methods: Afs rs
ers
b1
rb

by increasing the wall thickness of main body com-


pared with that of the cylindrical shell without open-
ing: see Fig 9 erb s1 so
by branches which have been provided with a wall
thickness of that required on account of the internal
pressure: see Fig 10 and Fig 11
dos

by reinforcing pads or rings analogous to increasing


dis

the wall thickness: see Fig 12 and Fig 13


by a combination of previous reinforcement. Ap

52 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 12 : Opening with reinforcing pad d) Isolated opening reinforcement


The reinforcement of isolated openings as indicated in
Fig 9 to Fig 13 are to be in respect with:
Afp rp d rp Ap K
Afs

erp
erp

------- --- 0 ,5
Af p

where:
rs ew0,7erp

ers
ers

K : Permissible stress in the shell, in N/mm 2

ew
Af : Total area of cross section (wall and branch

dis
dis

and pad)
Ap Ap : Total area under pressure p.
In Fig 9 to Fig 13, lrs , lrb and lrbi are effective lengths for
calculation of efficiencies and compensation, equal to:
b) Definitions for shell:
Effective lengths lrs required for calculation of efficiency l rs = m in ( ( D + e r s )e rs, l s1 )
and of compensations is to be taken as:
for external branch projection:
l rs = min ( Dt a ,l s 1) l rb = min ( ( d ib + e r b )e r b, l b1 )
where: for internal branch projection:
D : Outside diameter, in mm l rbi = m in ( 0, 5 ( d ib + e r b )e r b, l b2 )
ta : Available thickness, in mm
e) Condition of isolated openings
ls1 : Transition length, in mm, according to Fig 9 Full case
and Fig 10
Adjacent openings are to be treated as isolated
c) Basic calculation openings if the centre distance P , in accordance
The required wall thickness without allowance of a with Fig 16, is not less than:
cylindrical shell is determined with the following for-
d i b1
--------
- + e r b1 --------
d i b2
- + e rb 2
mula (see [2.4.3]): 2 2
----------------------------- + ----------------------------- + 2 ( d i s + e r s )e r s
pD cos 1 cos 2
t = -------------------------
( 2 K p )e For variable definition see Fig 14 and Fig 15.
With the available thickness ta , we obtain the available Simplification
efficiency ea and the maximum diameter dobmax of an - For openings without branch:
unreinforced opening when the average stress of the
erb = 0 and = 0
main body is equal to the permissible stress K:
- For openings with nozzles perpendicular to
pD i shell:
e a = -------------------------
( 2K p )t a
The openings are to be treated as isolated open-
l ings if the centre distance P in accordance with
d obm a x = 2 ----rs- l r s
ea Fig 16 is not less than:
where: d d i b2
ib1
--------
- + e r b1 + --------
- + e rb2 + 2 ( d i s + e rs )e r s
Di : Internal diameter of the main body, in mm 2 2

Figure 13 : Opening with reinforcing pad and full penetration branch


p
p

er
er
p
er
erb

s
s

er

er
er

erb erb
erb dib dib
is
is

is

d
d

dib

a) set through welded branch b) set in welded branch c) set on welded branch

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 53


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 14 : Angle definition Figure 16 : Load diagram


for cylindrical shell with oblique branch for cylindrical shell with adjacent branches




d
 

ib
   

e rb
 




ers





45 




dis

area I area II


   

Figure 15 : Angle definition

for cylindrical shell with non-radial branch


dib erb

erb 
ers




45
: Circumferential direction
dis

a
b : Longitudinal direction.

f) Adjacent openings
d) In the case of non-compensated openings (for this pur-
Where the condition of isolated openings is not fulfilled, pose, flanged openings are also to be considered as
the compensation is to be calculated, using Fig 16, as non-compensated), the head thickness is not to be less
per the following formula: than that calculated by the formula in [2.5.3] using the
greatest of the shape factors C obtained from the graph
Ap K
------ --- 0 ,5 in Fig 3 as a function of:
Af p
H/D and t/D or H/D and d(t D)0,5,
2.8.5 Openings in dished heads where d is the diameter of the largest non-compensated
opening in the head, in mm. For oval and elliptical
a) The openings in dished heads may be circular, elliptical openings, d is the width of the opening in way of its
or oval. major axis.

b) The largest diameter of the non-compensated opening is e) In all cases the diameter D of the head base, the head
not to exceed one half of the external diameter of the thickness t and the diameter d of the largest non-com-
head. pensated opening are to be such as to meet the follow-
ing requirements:
c) The opening is to be so situated that its projection, or its the position of non-compensated openings in the
reinforcement projection in the case of compensated heads is to be as shown in Fig 17
openings, is completely contained inside a circle having
its centre at the centre of the head and a diameter of for flanged openings, the radius r of the flanging (see
0,8 D, D being the external diameter of the head (see Fig 17) is not to be less than 25 mm
Fig 17). However, a small reinforced opening for drain- the thickness of the flanged part may be less than the
age may be accepted outside the indicated area. Rule thickness.

54 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 17 : Openings on dished heads 2.8.7 Compensation criteria


In the evaluation of the area A, the following is also to be
> 0,1 D taken into consideration:
> 0,1 D
a) The material that may be considered for compensating
t
an opening is that located around the opening up to a
distance l from the edge of the opening. The distance l,
in mm, is the lesser obtained from the following formu-
r d2
lae:
H

d1 l = 0,5 d
l = (2 RIN t)0,5
2t

where:
d : Diameter of the opening, in mm
D
RIN : Internal radius of the spherical part, in mm,
in the case of hemispherical or torispherical
Not less than
the diameter of heads
the smaller opening In the case of ellipsoidal heads, RIN is to be
calculated by the following formula (see Fig
2 (a):
4 4 2 2 32
[ a x ( a b )] -
R IN = ------------------------------------------------
4
a b
where;
a : Half the major axis of the ellipti-
cal meridian section of the
head, in mm
b : Half the minor axis of the above
section, in mm
x : Distance between the centre of
the hole and the rotation axis of
2.8.6 Opening compensation in dished heads the shell, in mm.

a) Where openings are cut in dished heads and the pro- b) In the case of nozzles or pads welded in the hole, the
posed thickness of the head is less than that calculated section corresponding to the thickness in excess of that
by the formula in [2.5.3], the openings are to be com- required is to be considered for the part which is subject
pensated. to pressure and for a depth h, in mm, both on the exter-
nal and internal sides of the head, not greater than:
b) Fig 30, Fig 31, Fig 32 and Fig 33 show typical connec-
tions of nozzles and compensating rings. (dB tB)0,5

c) The opening is considered sufficiently compensated where dB and tB are the diameter of the opening and the
when the head thickness t is not less than that calcu- thickness of the pad or nozzle, in mm, respectively.
lated in accordance with [2.5.3] and using the shape- c) The area of the welding connecting nozzle and pad
factor C obtained from the graph in Fig 3 using the reinforcements may be considered as a compensating
value: section.

A d) If the material of reinforcement pads, nozzles and col-


---- ( t D )
0 ,5

d lars has a permissible stress lower than that of the head
t
material, the area A, to be taken for calculation of the
instead of: coefficient C, is to be reduced proportionally.
d(t D)0,5
2.8.8 Openings in flat end plates
where:
The maximum diameter of an unreinforced opening in a flat
A : Area, in mm 2, of the total transverse section end plate is to be determined from the equation:
of the compensating parts
2
t : Actual thickness of the head, in mm, in the er h
d m a x = 8e r h 1.5 ------
2
-1
zone of the opening under consideration. ec h

d) When A/t > d, the coefficient C is to be determined where:


using the curve corresponding to the value:
erh : Actual thickness of the flat end, in mm
d(t D)0,5 = 0 ech : Required calculated thickness of the flat end, in
e) If necessary, calculations are to be repeated. mm.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 55


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.8.9 Opening compensation in flat end plate b) Add to it the full sectional area of that part of the branch
Reinforcement of branch openings is to be achieved by taking that projects inside the boiler (if any) up to a distance lb
account of locally disposed material, including the attach- from the inside surface of the flat end plate
ment welds, in excess of the minimum requirements for end
c) Add to it the sectional area of the fillet welds
plate and branch thickness as shown in Fig 18. The branch
thickness is to be increased where required. Compensation is d) Add to it the area obtained by multiplying the difference
to be considered adequate when the compensating area Y is between the actual flat end plate thickness and its thick-
equal to or greater than the area X requiring compensation. ness calculated for the part of the end plate under con-
Area X is to be obtained by multiplying 25% of the inside sideration by the length ls
radius of the branch by the thickness of the flat end plate, e) Add to it the area of the compensating plate (if any)
calculated for the part of the end plate under consideration. within the limits of reinforcement shown in Fig 18.
Area Y is to be measured in a plane through the axis of the
Where material having a lower allowable stress than that of
branch parallel to the surface of the flat end plate, and is to
the flat end plate is taken as compensation, its effective area
be calculated as follows:
is to be reduced in the ratio of the allowable stresses at the
a) For that part of the branch which projects outside the calculation temperature. No credit is to be taken for the
boiler, calculate the full sectional area of the branch up to additional strength of material having a higher allowable
a distance lb from the actual outer surface of the flat end stress than that of the flat end plate
plate and deduct from it the sectional area that the branch
Welds attaching branches and compensating plates are to
would have within the same distance if its thickness were
be capable of transmitting the full strength of the reinforcing
calculated in accordance with equation given in [2.4.3]
area and all other loadings to which they may be subjected.
Note 1: The compensating plate is required only in cases where
area Y would otherwise be less than area X.
2.8.10 Covers
Figure 18 : Compensation for branch in flat end plate a) Circular, oval and elliptical inspection openings are to
be provided with steel covers. Inspection openings with


a diameter not exceeding 150 mm may be closed by


blind flanges.
b) The thickness of the opening covers is not to be less
than the value t, in mm, given by the following formula:

p C 0 ,5
t = 1 ,22 a -------
K

 where:




a : The minor axis of the oval or elliptical open-



 

ing, measured at half width of gasket, in mm


b : The major axis of the oval or elliptical open-
ing, measured at half width of the gasket, in


mm



C : Coefficient in Tab 12 as a function of the
 ratio b/a of the axes of the oval or elliptical
 
opening, as defined above. For intermediate
  values of the ratio b/a, the value of C is to be
ecp : Thickness calculated in accordance with equa- obtained by linear interpolation.
tion in [2.8.1] for the part under consideration
For circular openings the diameter d, in mm, is to be
ecb : Thickness calculated taking efficiency = 1 used in the above formula instead of a.
lb : The smaller of the two values:
c) The thickness obtained by the formula in item a) is net
2,5 erep and (2,5 eb + erp)
thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
ls : The greater of the two values: ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
(erep + 75) and (dib / 4) be increased by 1 mm for classification purpose. See
Area Y is not to be less than area X. also [2.4.7].

Table 12 : Coefficient C for oval or elliptical covers

b/a 1,00 1,05 1,10 1,15 1,20 1,25 1,30 1,40 1,50 1,60
C 0,206 0,220 0,235 0,247 0,259 0,271 0,282 0,302 0,321 0,333
b/a 1,70 1,80 1,90 2,00 2,50 3,00 3,50 4,00 4,50 5,00
C 0,344 0,356 0,368 0,379 0,406 0,433 0,449 0,465 0,473 0,480

56 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Table 13 : Coefficient m

d/s 0,30 0,35 0,40 0,45 0,50 0,55 0,60 0,65 0,70 0,75 0,80
m 0,137 0,175 0,220 0,274 0,342 0,438 0,560 0,740 1,010 1,420 2,060

Figure 19 : Hole pattern in cylindrical shells

S
=

2.9 Regular pattern openings - Tube holes m : Coefficient depending upon the ratio d/s, as
obtained from Tab 13. For intermediate values
2.9.1 Definition of d/s, the value of m is to be obtained by linear
Openings may be considered as regular pattern openings interpolation.
when not less than three non isolated openings are dis- The value of e actually used is to be the smallest calculated
posed in regularly staggered rows in longitudinal or circular value for either longitudinal, diagonal or circumferential
direction of a shell. rows of holes.
In such a case, instead of a direct calculation of the com-
pensation of openings, the thickness of the shell could be 2.9.3 Welded shells with tube holes and efficiency
factor of different hole patterns
calculated by application of applicable formulae given in
[2.4], [2.5] with a reduced efficiency e as indicated in Where shells have welding butts and/or different groups of
[2.9.2] and [2.9.3]. hole patterns, the value to be assumed for the efficiency e in
the formulae is the minimum of the values calculated sepa-
This requirement apply for pressure vessels and for boiler.
rately for each type of welding (as per [2.4.2]) and for each
2.9.2 Efficiency factor of tube holes in cylindrical configuration of holes (as per [2.9.1]).
tube plates
2.9.4 Rectangular section headers
The efficiency factor e of pipe holes in cylindrical shells
pierced by tube holes is to be determined by direct calcula- a) For seamless type headers of rectangular section design,
tion or by another suitable method accepted by the Society. the wall thickness t, in mm, in way of corner fillets and
In the case of cylindrical holes of constant diameter and the thickness t1, in mm, of any drilled wall is not to be
radial axis, the efficiency factor e may be determined by the less than those given by the following formulae, as
following formula (see Fig 19): appropriate (see Fig 20):
0 ,5
1 100 pM 1
---------------------
e = ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- t =
K
s
----------- ( 1 ( 0 ,5 sin2 ) ) + m sin 2
sd 100 pM 2 0 ,5
t1 = ---------------------
where: eK
s : Pitch of the hole row considered, in mm where (see also Fig 20):
d : Diameter of holes, in mm. The hole diameter d t : Wall thickness at the corners, in mm
may be reduced by the amount Y/ecp where Y is
t1 : Thickness of drilled wall, in mm
the compensating area, in mm2, of nozzle and
welds and ecp the calculated unpierced shell p : Design pressure, in MPa
thickness, see [2.8.9] and Fig 18 K : Permissible stress, in N/mm2, obtained as
: Angle between the axis of hole row considered specified in [2.3]
and the axis of the cylinder ( = 0 if the hole a : Internal half width of the header, in a direc-
row is parallel to the cylinder generating line; tion parallel to the wall under consideration,
= 90 for circumferential hole row) in mm

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 57


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 20 : Rectangular section headers

2a
?

s d 2b

b : Internal half width of the header, in a direc- b) The thickness obtained by the formulae in a) is net
tion normal to the wall under consideration, thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
in mm ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
c : Distance between the axis of the hole row be increased by 1,5 mm. See also [2.4.7].
considered and the centreline of the header
wall, in mm 2.10 Water tubes, superheaters and
e : Efficiency factor of holes in the wall, deter- economiser tubes of boilers
mined by the following formulae:
sd 2.10.1
e = ----------- for d < a
s
a) The thickness of tubes of evaporating parts, economisers
s 0 ,67d and superheaters exposed to gases which are subject to
e = ------------------------ for a d < 1 ,3 a
s internal pressure is not to be less than the value t given
s 0 ,33d by the following formula:
e = ------------------------ for d 1 ,3a
s
pd
where: t = ----------------- + 0 ,3
2K + p
s : Pitch of the holes, in mm, of the
longitudinal or diagonal row where:
under consideration. For a stag- p : Design pressure, in MPa
gered pattern of holes the pitch
of the diagonal row is to be con- K : Permissible stress, in N/mm 2, obtained as
sidered specified in [2.3]
d : Diameter of the holes, in mm d : Outside diameter of tube, in mm.
M1 : Coefficient to be calculated by the following However, irrespective of the value calculated by the for-
formula: mulae in item a), the thickness t of tubes is not to be less
a 2 + b 2 ab than the values given in Tab 14.
M 1 = ------------------------------
50
b) The values of t determined by the above-mentioned for-
M2 : Coefficient (to be taken always positive) to mula are to be considered as theoretical values for
be calculated by one of the following for- straight tubes, not taking account of the manufacturing
mulae, as appropriate: tolerance. Where the tubes are not sized precision
For a non-staggered pattern of holes: tubes, the thickness calculated by the formula in item a)
is to be increased by 12,5% to take into account the
1 3
b 2 --- a 2 a b + --- c 2 manufacturing tolerance. For bent tubes, the thickness
2 2
M 2 = ------------------------------------------------- of the thinner part in way of the bend is not to be less
50
than that given by the formula.
For a staggered pattern of holes:
1 c) Whenever abnormal corrosion and erosion may occur
b 2 --- a 2 a b during service, the corrosion constant of 0,3 in the for-
2
M 2 = --------------------------------- cos mula may be increased to the satisfaction of the Society.
50
where is the angle between the axis of the d) The thickness of tubes which form an integral part of the
diagonal row of the holes under consider- boiler and which are not exposed to combustion gases
ation and the axis of the header, in the case is to comply with the requirements for steam pipes (see
of a staggered pattern of holes. Ch 1, Sec 10, [14]).

58 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Table 14 : Minimum thickness of water tubes b) When the end is supported in its centre by an uptake,
the minimum thickness t, in mm, is to be calculated
Minimum thickness in mm of tubes subject to with the following formula:
internal pressure of cylindrical boilers and pR
water tube boilers having the feed water system t = 0 ,77 --------I
Outside K
diameter, Closed type, if Open type, not
equipped with suitable equipped with suitable where:
in mm
devices for reducing devices for reducing p : Design pressure, in MPa
the oxygen concentra- the oxygen concentra-
tion in the water tion in the water K : Permissible stress, in N/mm2, obtained as
specified in [2.3]
< 38 1,8 2,9
RI : Radius of curvature at the centre of the end
38 - 48,3 2,0 2,9
measured internally. RI is not to exceed the
51 - 63,5 2,4 2,9 external diameter of the shell.
70 2,6 3,2 c) The thickness obtained by the formula in item b) is net
76,1 - 88,9 2,9 3,2 thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
101,6 - 127 3,6 ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
be increased by 0,7 mm. See also [2.4.7].

2.11 Additional requirements for fired d) For ends supported by an uptake at their centre, the cor-
pressure vessels ner radius measured internally is not to be less than 4
times the end thickness or 65 mm, whichever is the
lesser and the inside radius of curvature on the flange to
2.11.1 Insulation for headers and combustion
uptake is not to be less than twice the end thickness or
chambers
25 mm, whichever is the lesser.
Those parts of headers and/or combustion chambers which
are not protected by tubes and are exposed to radiant heat 2.12.3 Supported flat head
or to high temperature gases are to be covered by suitable
a) Breathing space
insulating material.
Stays are to give breathing space around the furnace
2.11.2 Connections of tubes to drums and tube tube connections and tube nests and equally divide
plates the unstayed areas. Breathing space between fur-
nace tube and tube nests are to be a minimum of
Tubes are to be adequately secured to drums and/or tube 50 mm or 5% of the shell outside diameter, which-
plates by expansion, welding or other appropriate proce- ever is the larger, but need not be more than
dure. 100 mm.
a) Where the tubes are secured by expanding or equiva- Breathing space between furnace tube and shell
lent process, the height of the shoulder bearing the tube, depends on the thickness of the plate of the type of
measured parallel to the tube axis, is to be at least 1/5 of end and of the dimensions of the boiler but is to be
the hole diameter, but not less than 9 mm for tubes nor- not less than 50 mm or, for bowling hoop furnaces
mal to the tube plate or 13 mm for tubes angled to the tubes, not less than 75 mm.
tube plate. The tubes ends are not to project over the
other face of the tube plate more than 6 mm. b) The thickness of stayed flat heads, or of heads supported
by flanges, is not to be less than the value t, in mm,
b) The tube ends intended to be expanded are to be par- given by the following formula:
tially annealed when the tubes have not been annealed 0 ,5
by the manufacturer. 100p
t = D -----------------------------------------
-
C C1 K ( 1 + C 2 B 2 )

2.12 Additional requirements for vertical where:


boilers and fire tube boilers B : Ratio of the thickness of the large washer or
doubler, where fitted, to the thickness of the
2.12.1 General plate:
The scantlings of the shells of vertical boilers and fire tube B = t1 / t
boilers are to be determined in accordance with [2.4]. The value of B is to be taken between 0,67
and 1
2.12.2 Ends of vertical boilers
K : Permissible stress, in N/mm2, obtained as
a) The minimum thickness of the dished ends forming the specified in [2.3]
upper part of vertical boilers and subject to pressure on
C : C = 1 when the plate is not exposed to flame
their concave face is to be determined in accordance
with [2.5]. C = 0,88 when the plate is exposed to flame

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 59


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

C1 : C1 = 462 when the plate is supported by In the parts of the flat heads between the stays and
welded stays the boundaries, where flat heads are generally sup-
ported by flanges or shapes, or connected to other
C1 = 704 for plates supported by flanges or parts of the boiler:
equivalent
D is the diameter, in mm, of the largest circle which
C2 : C2 = 0 when no doublers are fitted can be drawn through not less than three points of
support (stay centres or points of tangency of the cir-
C2 = 0,85 when a complete doubling plate cle with the contour line). To this end, the contour of
is fitted, adequately joined to the base plate. the part under consideration is to be drawn at the
The value of D is to be in accordance with the following beginning of the flanging or connection curve if its
provisions: inside radius does not exceed 2,5 times the thick-
ness of the plate, or, where such radius is greater, at
In the parts of the flat heads between the stays: the above-mentioned distance (of 2,5 times the
thickness of the plate) from the ideal intersection
D is the diameter, in mm, of the largest circle which
with other surfaces (see Fig 21).
can be drawn through the centre of at least three
stays without enclosing any other stay, where the c) When applying the formulae for calculation of thickness
stays are not evenly spaced (see Fig 21), or of heads covered by this sub-article, the position of plates
in the most unfavourable condition is to be considered.
D = (a2 + b2)0,5 where the stays are evenly spaced,
d) Where various types of supports are provided, the value
considering the most unfavourable condition
of C1 should be the arithmetic mean of the values of C1
where: appropriate to each type of support.
e) The thickness obtained by the formulae in a), is net
a : Distance between two adjacent rows of
thickness, as it does not include any corrosion allow-
stays, in mm
ance. The thickness obtained by the above formula is to
b : Pitch of stays in the same row, in mm. be increased by 1 mm. See also [2.4.7].

Figure 21 :

 > "

= =

>

Key:
1 : Boundaries of areas supported by individual stays
2 : To establish the area supported by bar stays or stay tubes in boundary rows, the boundary of the loaded area is to terminate at the
centre of the associated main circle
3 : Main circles, diameter b
4 : Bar stays
5 : Stay tubes
6 : Termination of boundary areas where stay tubes are situated in the boundary rows only.

60 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.12.4 Flat tube plates d) Tube plates not supported by stays


a) Flat tube plates in tube bundles Flat tube plates which are not supported by stay tubes
The thickness of the parts of flat tube plates contained in (e.g. in heat exchangers), are subject of special consid-
the tube bundle and supported by stay tubes is not to be eration by the Society (see also [2.14]).
less than the value t, in mm, given by the following for-
e) Stay and stay tube scantling
mula:
The diameter of solid stays of circular cross-section
p 0 ,5
t = s ------------ is not to be less than the value d calculated by the
2 , 8K
following formula:
where: 0 ,5
d = pA
-------
p : Design pressure, in MPa K
K : Permissible stress, in N/mm2, obtained as
specified in [2.3] where:
s : Pitch of stay tubes, taken as the greatest d : Minimum diameter, in mm, of the stay
mean pitch of the stay tubes supporting a throughout its length
quadrilateral portion of the plate, in mm.
A : Area supported by the stay, in mm2
Moreover the spacing of tube holes (diameter d) is to be
such that the minimum width, in mm, of any ligament K : K = Rm / 7
between the tube holes is to be not less than: Rm : Minimum ultimate tensile strength of the
for expanded tubes: stay material, in N/mm2.
(0,125 d + 12,5) mm The cross section of tube stays is to be equivalent to
for welded tubes: that of a solid stay supporting the same area, whose
- for gas entry temperatures greater than 800C: diameter is calculated by the above formula.
(0,125 d + 9) mm, but need not exceed 15 mm Stays which are not perpendicular to the supported
- for gas entry temperatures less than or equal to surface are to be of an adequately increased diame-
800C: ter depending on the component of the force normal
(0,125 d + 7) mm, but need not exceed 15 mm. to the plate.
Moreover the calculated thickness of tube plates is to be Where articulated stays are used, articulation details
not less than the following: are to be designed assuming a safety factor for artic-
12 mm where the tubes are expanded into the tube ulated elements not less than 5 with respect to the
plate when the diameter of the tube hole does not value of Rm and a wear allowance of 2 mm.
exceed 50 mm, or 14 mm when the diameter of the The articulation is to be of the fork type and the
tube hole is greater than 50 mm, or clearance of the pin in respect of the holes is not to
6 mm where the tubes are attached to the tube plate exceed 1,5 mm. The pin is to bear against the jaws
by welding only. of the fork and its cross-sectional area is not to be
b) Flat tube plates of combustion chamber in vertical boilers less than 80% of the cross-sectional area of the stay.
The width of material around the holes is not to be
Where tube plates contained in the tube bundle are simul-
less than 13 mm.
taneously subject to compression due to the pressure in
the combustion chamber, their thickness, as well as com- Where stays are flanged for joining to the plate, the
plying with the requirements in item a) is not to be less thickness of the flange is not to be less than one half
than the value t, in mm, given by the following formula: the diameter of the stay.
p ls 1 For welded connections of stays to tube plates, see
t = ----------------------------------
-
Fig 37.
1 ,78 ( s 1 d )K
where: f) Stay and stay tubes construction
l : Depth of the combustion chamber, in mm In general, doublers are not to be fitted in plates
s1 : Horizontal pitch of tubes, in mm exposed to flame.
d : Inside diameter of plain tubes, in mm. As far as possible, stays are to be fitted perpendicu-
For the meaning of other symbols, see item a). larly to the supported surface.
c) Tube plates outside tube bundles Long stays in double front boilers and, in general,
For those parts of tube plates which are outside the tube stays exceeding 5 m in length, are to be supported at
bundle, the formula in [2.13.3] is to be applied, using mid-length.
the following coefficients C1 and C2: Where the ends of stay tubes are of increased thick-
C1 = 390 ness, the excess material is to be obtained by forging
C2 = 0,55 and not by depositing material by means of welding.
Doublers are only permitted where the tube plate does After forging, the ends of stay tubes are to be stress
not form part of a combustion chamber. relieved.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 61


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

g) Gusset stays Figure 22 : Ogee ring


Tube plate may be supported by gussets stays with full
penetration welds to plate and shell.
The general shape and the scantling are to be in accor-
dance with a standard accepted by the Society. furnace
h) Girders
Where tops of combustion chambers, or similar struc-
shell dA
tures, are supported by girders of rectangular section
associated with stays, the thickness of the single girder
or the aggregate thickness of all girders, at mid-length, is ogee ring
not to be less than the value t determined by the appro-
priate formula below, depending upon the number of ~ 45

t
stays.
In case of an odd number of stays:
pL ( L s )l n + 1

50
t = ------------------------2- -------------
0 ,25R m a n
In case of an even number of stays:
pL ( L s )l n + 2
t = ------------------------2- ------------- t

t
0 ,25R m a n + 1
where: DA
p : Design pressure, in MPa
a : Depth of the girder plate at mid-length, in
mm
L : Length of girder between supports, in mm t
s : Pitch of stays, in mm
p : Design pressure, in MPa
n : Number of stays on the girder
DA : Inside diameter of boiler shell, in mm
l : Distance between centres of girders, in mm
dA : Inside diameter of the lower part of the fur-
Rm : Minimum ultimate tensile strength of the
nace where it joins the ogee ring, in mm.
material used for the plates, in N/mm2.
The above formulae refer to the normal arrangement 2.12.5 Fire tubes
where:
a) The thickness of fire tubes subject to external pressure in
The stays are regularly distributed over the length L. cylindrical boilers is not to be less than the value t, in
The distance from the supports of the outer stays mm, calculated by the following formula:
does not exceed the uniform pitch s.
pd
When the tops of the combustion chambers are con- t = ------------------- + 1 ,8
0 ,15R m
nected to the sides with curved parts with an exter-
nal radius less than 0,5 l, the distance of end girders where:
from the inner part of the side surface does not p : Design pressure, in MPa
exceed l.
d : Outside diameter of tube, in mm
When the curvature radius mentioned under item
Rm : Minimum ultimate tensile strength of the
just above exceeds 0,5 l, the distance of the end
girders from the beginning of the connection does tube material, in N/mm2.
not exceed 0,5 l. The minimum acceptable thickness is given in Tab 15.
In other cases a direct calculation is to be made using a b) The values of t determined by the above-mentioned for-
safety factor not less than 5, with respect to the mini- mula are to be considered as theoretical values for
mum value of the tensile strength Rm. straight tubes, not taking account of the manufacturing
i) Ogee rings tolerance. Where the tubes are not sized precision
tubes, the thickness calculated by the formula in a) is to
The thickness of ogee rings connecting the furnaces to
be increased by 12,5% to take into account the manu-
the shell in vertical auxiliary boilers (see Fig 22), where
facturing tolerance. In the case of bent tubes, the thick-
the latter support the weight of the water above the fur-
ness of the thinner part in way of the bend is not to be
nace, is not to be less than the value t, in mm, given by
less than that given by the above formula.
the following formula:
0 ,5 c) Whenever abnormal corrosion and erosion may occur
t = [ 1 ,02 10 3 p DA ( D A d A ) ] +1
during service the corrosion constant of 1,8 in the for-
where: mula may be increased to the satisfaction of the Society.

62 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Table 15 : Minimum thickness of fire tubes E : Elastic modulus, in MPa, at design tempera-
ture T, in C, and equal to:
Nominal outside diameter Lowest nominal thickness t E = 208800 93,4 T
d 88,9 3,00 b) Stiffeners
88,9 < d 114,3 3,15 Stiffeners welded to furnaces tubes according to a stan-
114,3 < d 139,7 3,50 dard accepted by the Society may be considered as pro-
viding effective stiffening (reduction of L in upper
139,7 < d 168,3 3,99 formulae).

2.12.6 Furnaces general points 2.12.8 Corrugated furnace tubes


a) Thermal design of furnace tubes. The minimum thickness of corrugated furnace tubes, in
mm, is to be determined by:
The heat input for a given furnace tube inside diameter
is not to exceed a value compatible with the chosen pD E
t = -------------------
-
design temperature. Burners with a fixed firing rate are 0, 26R m
not to be used for heat inputs exceeding 1 MW per fur- where:
nace tube. DE : External diameter of the furnace, in mm, mea-
b) The minimum thickness of furnaces is to be calculated sured at the bottom of the corrugation.
for elastic buckling and plastic deformation in accor- This formula apply for Fox and Morisson type furnaces
dance with the requirements of a Standard for pressure tubes. The scantling of furnaces of other types and the use
vessels subject to external pressure accepted by the of stiffeners are to be especially considered by the Society.
Society.
c) However, the minimum thicknesses of furnaces and 2.12.9 Hemispherical furnaces
cylindrical ends of combustion chambers of fire tube The minimum thickness t, in mm, of hemispherical furnaces
boilers are to be not less than the value t given by the is not to be less than the value given by the following equa-
appropriate formulae in [2.12.7], [2.12.8] and [2.12.9]. tion:
d) The thickness of furnaces is not to be less than 8 mm for pD
t = ----------E
plain furnace and 10 mm for corrugated furnace and the 120
stays are to be spaced such that the thickness does not
exceed 22 mm. 2.13 Bottles containing pressurised gases
e) All the thicknesses obtained for furnaces by the formu-
lae in [2.12.7], [2.12.8], [2.12.9] and [2.12.4] are net 2.13.1 General
thicknesses, as they do not include any corrosion allow- a) The following requirements apply to bottles intended to
ance. The thicknesses obtained by the above formulae contain pressurised and/or liquefied gases at ambient
are to be increased by 1 mm. See also [2.4.7]. temperature, made by seamless manufacturing pro-
cesses.
2.12.7 Plain furnace tubes b) In general, such bottles are to have an outside diameter
a) Plain furnace tube not exceeding 420 mm, a length not exceeding
The minimum thickness t of plain cylindrical furnaces is 2000 mm and capacity not exceeding 150 litres (see
to be not less than the greater value, in mm, obtained also [3.4.1]).
from the following formulae: c) For bottles exceeding the above capacity and dimen-
B 0, 12D u sions, the following requirements may be applied at the
t = --- 1 + 1 + ---------------------------------- discretion of the Society.
2 ( 1 + 5D L )B
0, 6 0, 4
t = D [ ( LS 2 p ) ( 2, 6 E ) ] 2.13.2 Cylindrical shell
where: The wall thickness of the cylindrical shell is not to be less
than the value t, in mm, determined by the following for-
pD S 1 mula:
B = ----------------------------------------------------
2R S, M IN , T ( 1 + 5D L )
pH DE
S1 : Safety factor, equal to 2,5 t = -------------------
-
2K + pH
L : Unstayed length of furnace, in mm
where:
u : Departure from circularity, in %, equal to:
pH : Hydrostatic test pressure, in MPa. This pressure
2 ( D m ax D m in ) is to be taken as 1,5 times the setting pressure of
u = ------------------------------------- 100
D m ax + D m in the safety valves with the following exceptions:
u is to be taken as 1,5% for plain furnace 25 MPa for CO 2 bottles
tubes for refrigerants, the value of hydrostatic test
S2 : Safety factor for buckling, equal to: pressure is given in Part E, Chapter 8
3 for u 1,5% DE : Outside diameter of tube, in mm
4 for 1,5% < u 2% K = RS,MIN / 1,3

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 63


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

RS,MIN : Value of the minimum yield strength (ReH), or a) Hemispherical ends: the thickness of the ends is to be
0,2% proof stress (Rp 0,2), at the ambient temper- not less than the thickness calculated for spherical shells
ature, in N/mm2. In no case is the value RS,MIN to in accordance with [2.4.4]
exceed: b) Convex ends: see Fig 23
0,75 Rm for normalised steels c) Concave base ends: see Fig 24
0,90 Rm for quenched and tempered steels.
d) Ends with openings: see Fig 25
2.13.3 Dished heads e) Other types of ends are to be specially considered by
Dished ends are to comply with the following requirements: the Society.

Figure 23 : Dished convex ends


 

 
 
 

 
 



 




 
   

 

          
 

Figure 24 : Dished concave ends Figure 25 : Heads with openings


0,5 D E



h1

t1
t2

r
h2


t3



t1 > 1,7 t t2 > 2 t t3 > 2 t


h1 > 6 t h2 > 0,12 DE r > 0,075 DE  
      

64 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

2.14 Heat exchangers c) Where fitted, superheaters which may be shut-off from
the boiler are to be provided with at least one safety
2.14.1 Scantlings valve; such valve(s) cannot be considered as part of the
boiler safety valves required in item a).
a) Vessels are to be designed in accordance with the appli-
cable requirements stated in [2.4] and [2.5]. d) In the case of boilers fitted with a separate steam accu-
mulator, safety valves may be fitted on the accumulator
b) Tubes are to be designed in accordance with [2.10.1].
if no shut-off is provided between it and the boiler and if
c) Tube plates are to be designed in accordance with a the connecting pipe is of a size sufficient to allow the
standard accepted by the Society. whole steam production to pass through, without
increasing the boiler pressure more than 10% above the
2.14.2 Thermal oil heat exchangers design pressure.
The provisions of [2.14.1] apply also to thermal oil heat
3.2.2 Relieving capacity of safety valves
exchangers. However, irrespective of the thickness obtained
by the formula in [2.10.1], the tube thickness of oil fired
and exhaust fired thermal oil heaters is to be not less than a) The relieving capacity of each safety valve Q, in kg/h, is
the values indicated in Tab 16. to be determined by the appropriate formula below in
order that:
Table 16 : Minimum thickness of QW
thermal oil heat exchanger tubes
saturated steam:
Outside Minimum thickness, in mm, of tubes C A ( 10 P + 1.05 )
Q = ------------------------------------------------------
diameter, subject to internal pressure of oil fired and 100
in mm exhaust fired thermal oil heaters
superheated steam:
< 63,5 2,4
C A ( 10 P + 1.05 ) v
70 - 89 2,9 Q = ------------------------------------------------------ ----
100 vS
> 89 3,6
where:

3 Design and construction - W : Maximum steam production, in kg/h, as


defined by the maximum power of the heat-
Equipments ing equipment; otherwise the value of W is
to be based on evaporating capacities (refer-
3.1 All pressure vessels ring to evaporating surfaces of the boiler
concerned) less than the following:
3.1.1 Drainage 14 kg/(mh) for exhaust gas heated boil-
a) Each air pressure vessel is to be fitted with a drainage ers
device allowing the evacuation of any oil or water accu- 29 kg/(m2h) for oil fired boilers
mulated in the vessel.
60 kg/(m2h) for water walls of oil fired
b) Drainage devices are also to be fitted on other vessels, boilers
in particular steam vessels, in which condensation water
A : Aggregate area, in mm 2, of the orifices in
is likely to accumulate.
way of the seat of the valve, deducting the
obstructions corresponding to the guides
3.2 Boilers and steam generators and the conformation of the valve in full lift
position
3.2.1 Safety valve arrangement
p : Maximum working pressure of the boiler or
a) Every steam boiler and every steam generator with a other steam generator, in MPa. For super-
total heating surface of 50 m 2 and above is to be pro- heated steam safety valves, P is to be the
vided with not less than two spring loaded safety valves pressure at the superheater outlet
of adequate capacity. For steam boilers and steam gen- C : Coefficient with the following values:
erators having heating surface less than 50 m2, only one
safety valve need be fitted. C = 4,8 for ordinary safety valves, i.e.
where the valve lift is at least 1/24 of the
b) Where a superheater is an integral part of the boiler, at internal diameter of the seat
least one safety valve is to be located on the steam drum
and at least one at the superheater outlet. The valves fit- C = 10 for high lift safety valves, i.e.
ted at the superheater outlet may be considered as part where the valve lift is at least 1/12 of the
of the boiler safety valves required in item a), provided internal diameter of the seat
that their capacity does not account for more than 25% C = 20 for full lift safety valves, i.e.
of the total capacity required in [3.2.2], unless specially where the valve lift is at least 1/4 of the
considered by the Society. internal diameter of the valve

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 65


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Higher values of coefficient C may be where it is not possible to fit the safety valves
admitted for safety valves of approved type directly on the superheater headers, they are to be
and having undergone, in the presence of mounted on a strong nozzle fitted as close as practi-
the Surveyor or according to a procedure cable to the superheater outlet. The cross-sectional
considered as equivalent by the Society, area for passage of steam through restricted orifices
capacity tests with conditions of pressure of the nozzles is not to be less than 1/2 the aggregate
and temperature comparable to those of the area of the valves, calculated with the formulae of
plant considered. In such a case, coefficient [2.3.2] when C 10, and not less than the aggregate
C is to be, as a rule, taken as 90% of the area of the valves when C > 10
resulting value from the capacity test
safety valve bodies are to be fitted with drain pipes
v : Specific volume of saturated steam at the of a diameter not less than 20 mm for double valves,
pressure corresponding to the superheater and not less than 12 mm for single valves, leading to
outlet the bilge or to the hot well. Valves or cocks are not
to be fitted on drain pipes.
vS : Specific volume of superheated steam at the
temperature corresponding to the super- d) Exhaust pipes
heater outlet.
the minimum cross-sectional area of the exhaust
b) When the safety valves are fitted at the superheater out- pipes of safety valves which have not been experi-
let. Their relieving capacity is to be such that, during the mentally tested is not to be less than C times the
discharge of safety valves, a sufficient quantity of steam aggregate area A
is circulated through the superheater to avoid damage. the cross-sectional area of the exhaust manifold of
c) The orifice diameter in way of the safety valves seat is safety valves is to be not less than the sum of the
not to be less than 40 mm. Where only one safety valve areas of the individual exhaust pipes connected to it
need be fitted, the orifice minimum diameter is not to silencers fitted on exhaust manifolds are to have a
be less than 50 mm. Valves of large relieving capacity free passage area not less than that of the manifolds
with 15 mm minimum diameter may be accepted for
boilers with steam production not exceeding 2000 kg/h. the strength of exhaust manifolds and pipes and
associated silencers is to be such that they can with-
d) Independently of the above requirements, the aggregate stand the maximum pressure to which they may be
capacity of the safety valves is to be such as to discharge subjected, which is to be assumed not less than 1/4
all the steam that can be generated without causing a of the safety valve setting pressure
transient pressure rise of more than 10% over the design
in the case that the discharges from two or more
pressure.
valves are led to the same exhaust manifold, provi-
sion is to be made to avoid the back pressure from
3.2.3 Miscellaneous safety valve requirements
the valve which is discharging influencing the other
a) Safety valves operated by pilot valves valves
The arrangement on the superheater of large relieving exhaust manifolds are to be led to the open and are
capacity safety valves, operated by pilot valves fitted in to be adequately supported and fitted with suitable
the saturated steam drum, is to be specially considered expansion joints or other means so that their weight
by the Society. does not place an unacceptable load on the safety
valve bodies.
b) Safety valve setting
safety valves are to be set under steam in the pres- e) Steam generator heated by steam
ence of the Surveyor to a pressure not higher than Steam heated steam generators are also to be protected
1,03 times the design pressure against possible damage resulting from failure of the
heating coils. In this case, the area of safety valves cal-
safety valves are to be so constructed that their set-
culated as stated in [3.2.2] may need to be increased to
ting may not be increased in service and their spring
may not be expelled in the event of failure. In addi- the satisfaction of the Society, unless suitable devices
tion, safety valves are to be provided with simple limiting the flow of steam in the heating coils are pro-
vided.
means of lifting the plug from its seat from a safe
position in the boiler or engine room
3.2.4 Other requirements
where safety valves are provided with means for reg-
Access arrangement
ulating their relieving capacity, they are to be so fit-
ted that their setting cannot be modified when the a) Boilers are to be provided with openings in sufficient
valves are removed for surveys. number and size to permit internal examination, clean-
ing and maintenance operations. In general, all pressure
c) Safety valve fitting on boiler
vessels which are part of a boiler with inside diameter
the safety valves of a boiler are to be directly con- exceeding 1200 mm, and those with inside diameter
nected to the boiler and separated from other valve exceeding 800 mm and length exceeding 2000 mm, are
bodies to be provided with access manholes.

66 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

b) Manholes are to be provided in suitable locations in the Allowable water levels


shells, headers, domes, and steam and water drums, as
applicable. The net (actual hole) dimension of ellipti- a) In general, for water tube boilers the lowest permissible
cal or similar manholes is to be not less than 300mm x water level is just above the top row of tubes when the
water is cold. Where the boiler is designed not to have
400mm. The net diameter of circular manholes
fully submerged tubes, when the water is cold, the low-
(actual hole) cannot be less than 400 mm. The edges of
est allowable level indicated by the manufacturer is to
manholes are to be adequately strengthened to provide
compensation for vessel openings in accordance with be indicated on the drawings and submitted to the Soci-
[2.8.4], [2.8.6] and [2.8.9], as applicable. ety for consideration.
b) For fire tube boilers with combustion chamber integral
c) In pressure vessels which are part of a boiler and are not
with the boiler, the minimum allowable level is to be at
covered by the requirement in item a) above, or where
least 50 mm above the highest part of the combustion
an access manhole cannot be fitted, at least the follow-
chamber.
ing openings are to be provided, as far as practicable:
head holes: minimum dimensions: c) For vertical fire tube boilers the minimum allowable
220mm x 320mm (320 mm diameter if circular) level is 1/2 of the length of the tubes above the lower
tube sheet.
handholes: minimum dimensions: 87mm x 103mm
Steam outlets
sight holes: minimum diameter: 50 mm.
a) Each boiler steam outlet, if not serving safety valves,
d) Sight holes may only be provided when the arrangement integral superheaters and other appliances which are to
of manholes, head holes, or handholes is impracticable. have permanent steam supply during boiler operation, is
to be fitted with an isolating valve secured either
e) Covers for manholes and other openings are to be made directly to the boiler shell or to a standpipe of substan-
of ductile steel, dished or welded steel plates or other tial thickness, as short as possible, and secured directly
approved design. Grey cast iron may be used only for to the boiler shell.
small openings, such as handholes and sight holes, pro-
vided the design pressure p does not exceed 1 MPa and b) The number of auxiliary steam outlets is to be reduced
the design temperature T does not exceed 220C. to a minimum for each boiler.

f) Covers are to be of self-closing internal type. Small c) Where several boilers supply steam to common mains,
opening covers of other type may be accepted by the the arrangement of valves is to be such that it is possible
Society on a case by case basis. to positively isolate each boiler for inspection and main-
tenance. In addition, for water tube boilers, non-return
g) Covers of the internal type are to have a spigot passing devices are to be fitted on the steam outlets of each
through the opening. The clearance between the spigot boiler.
and the edge of the opening is to be uniform for the
whole periphery of the opening and is not to exceed d) Where steam is used for essential auxiliaries (such as
1,5 mm. whistles, steam operated steering gears, steam operated
electric generators, etc.) and when several boilers are
h) Closing devices of internal type covers, having dimen- fitted on board, it is to be possible to supply steam to
sions not exceeding 180mm x 230mm, may be fitted these auxiliaries with any one of these boilers out of
with a single fastening bolt or stud. Larger closing operation.
devices are to be fitted with at least two bolts or studs.
e) Each steam stop valve exceeding 150 mm nominal
i) Covers are to be designed so as to prevent the disloca- diameter is to be fitted with a bypass valve.
tion of the required gasket by the internal pressure. Only
continuous ring gaskets may be used for packing. Feed check valves

Fittings a) Each fired boiler supplying steam to essential services is


to be fitted with at least two feed check valves con-
a) In general, cocks and valves are to be designed in nected to two separate feed lines. For unfired steam gen-
accordance with the requirements in Ch 1, Sec 10, erators a single feed check valve may be allowed.
[2.7.2].
b) Feed check valves are to be secured directly to the
b) Cocks, valves and other fittings are to be connected boiler or to an integral economiser. Water inlets are to
directly or as close as possible to the boiler shell. be separated. Where, however, feed check valves are
secured to an economiser, a single water inlet may be
c) Cocks and valves for boilers are to be arranged in such a
allowed provided that each feed line can be isolated
way that it can be easily seen when they are open or
without stopping the supply of feed water to the boiler.
closed and so that their closing is obtained by a clock-
wise rotation of the actuating mechanism. c) Where the economisers may be bypassed and cut off
from the boiler, they are to be fitted with pressure-limit-
Boiler burners
ing type valves, unless the arrangement is such that
Burners are to be arranged so that they cannot be with- excessive pressure cannot occur in the economiser
drawn unless the fuel supply to the burners is cut off. when cut off.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 67


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

d) Feed check valves are to be fitted with control devices 3.3.2 Thermal oil heater design
operable from the stokehold floor or from another a) Heaters are to be so constructed that neither the sur-
appropriate location. In addition, for water tube boilers, faces nor the thermal oil becomes excessively heated at
at least one of the feed check valves is to be arranged so any point. The flow of the thermal oil is to be ensured by
as to permit automatic control of the water level in the forced circulation.
boiler.
b) The surfaces which come into contact with the thermal
e) Provision is to be made to prevent the feed water from oil are to be designed for the design pressure, subject to
getting in direct contact with the heated surfaces inside the minimum pressure of 1 MPa.
the boiler and to reduce, as far as possible and neces-
c) Copper and copper alloys are not permitted.
sary, the thermal stresses in the walls.
Drains d) Heaters heated by exhaust gas are to be provided with
inspection openings at the exhaust gas intake and out-
Each superheater, whether or not integral with the let.
boiler, is to be fitted with cocks or valves so arranged
that it is possible to drain it completely. e) Oil fired heaters are to be provided with inspection
openings for examination of the combustion chamber.
Water sample The opening for the burner may be considered as an
a) Every boiler is to be provided with means to supervise inspection opening, provided its size is sufficient for this
and control the quality of the feed water. Suitable purpose.
arrangements are to be provided to preclude, as far as f) Heaters are to be fitted with means enabling them to be
practicable, the entry of oil or other contaminants which completely drained.
may adversely affect the boiler. g) Thermal oil heaters heated by exhaust gas are to be fit-
b) For this purpose, boilers are to be fitted with at least one ted with a permanent system for extinguishing and cool-
water sample cock or valve. This device is not to be ing in the event of fire, for instance a pressure water
connected to the water level standpipes. spraying system.
c) Suitable inlets for water additives are to be provided in
3.3.3 Safety valves of thermal oil heaters
each boiler.
Each heater is to be equipped with at least one safety valve
Marking of boilers having a discharge capacity at least equal to the increase in
a) Each boiler is to be fitted with a permanently attached volume of the thermal oil at the maximum heating power.
plate made of non-corrosive metal, with indication of During discharge the pressure may not increase above 10%
the following information, in addition to the identifica- over the design pressure.
tion marks (name of manufacturer, year and serial num-
ber): 3.3.4 Pressure vessels of thermal oil heaters
the design pressure The design pressure of all vessels which are part of a ther-
mal oil system, including those open to the atmosphere, is
the design temperature to be taken not less than 0,2 MPa.
the test pressure and the date of the test.
3.3.5 Equipment of the expansion, storage and
b) Markings may be directly stamped on the vessel if this drain tanks
does not produce notches having an adverse influence
For the equipment to be installed on expansion, storage and
on its behaviour in service.
drain tanks, see Ch 1, Sec 10, [13].
c) For lagged vessels, these markings are also to appear on
a similar plate fitted above the lagging. 3.3.6 Marking
Each thermal oil heater and other pressure vessels which
3.3 Thermal oil heaters and thermal oil are part of a thermal oil installation are to be fitted with a
installation permanently attached plate made of non-corrosive metal,
with indication of the following information, in addition to
3.3.1 General the identification marks (name of manufacturer, year and
serial number):
a) The following requirements apply to thermal oil heaters
in which organic liquids (thermal oils) are heated by oil Heaters
fired burners, exhaust gases or electricity to tempera- - maximum allowable heating power
tures below their initial boiling point at atmospheric - design pressure
pressure.
- maximum allowable discharge temperature
b) Thermal oils are only to be used within the limits set by
- minimum flow rate
the manufacturer.
- liquid capacity
c) Means are to be provided for manual operation. How-
ever, at least the temperature control device on the oil Vessels
side and flow monitoring are to remain operative even - design pressure
in manual operation. - design temperature
d) Means are to be provided to take samples of thermal oil. - capacity.

68 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

3.4 Special types of pressure vessels 3.5.2 Other requirements


a) Access arrangement
3.4.1 Seamless pressure vessels (bottles)
The access requirements for boilers stated in [3.2.4] are
Each bottle is to be marked with the following information:
also applicable for other pressure vessels.
name or trade name of the manufacturer
b) Corrosion protection
serial number
Vessels and equipment containing media that might
type of gas lead to accelerated corrosion are to be suitably pro-
capacity tected.
test pressure c) Marking
empty weight Each pressure vessel is to be fitted with a perma-
test stamp. nently attached plate made of non-corrosive metal,
with indication of the following information, in
3.4.2 Steam condensers addition to the identification marks (name of manu-
a) The water chambers and steam spaces are to be fitted facturer, year and serial number):
with doors for inspection and cleaning. - the design pressure
b) Where necessary, suitable diaphragms are to be fitted - the design temperature
for supporting tubes. - the test pressure and the date of the test.
c) Condenser tubes are to be removable. Markings may be directly stamped on the vessel if
d) High speed steam flow, where present, is to be pre- this does not produce notches having an adverse
vented from directly striking the tubes by means of suit- influence on its behaviour in service.
able baffles. For smaller pressure vessels the indication of the
e) Suitable precautions are to be taken in order to avoid design pressure only may be sufficient.
corrosion on the circulating water side and to provide
an efficient grounding. 4 Design and construction -
Fabrication and welding
3.5 Other pressure vessels
3.5.1 Safety valves arrangement 4.1 General
a) General 4.1.1 Base materials
Pressure vessels which are part of a system are to be a) These requirements apply to boilers and pressure vessels
provided with safety valves, or equivalent devices, if made of steel of weldable quality.
they are liable to be isolated from the system safety
devices. This provision is also to be made in all b) Fabrication and welding of vessels made of other mate-
cases in which the vessel pressure can rise, for any rials are to be the subject of special consideration.
reason, above the design pressure. 4.1.2 Welding
In particular, air pressure vessels which can be iso- a) Weldings are to be performed in accordance with weld-
lated from the safety valves ensuring their protection ing procedures approved by the Society.
in normal service are to be fitted with another safety
device, such as a rupture disc or a fusible plug, in b) Manual and semi-automatic welding is to be performed
order to ensure their discharge in case of fire. This by welders qualified by the Society.
device is to discharge to the open. c) The conditions under which the welding procedures,
Safety devices ensuring protection of pressure ves- welding equipment and welders operate are to corre-
sels in normal service are to be rated to operate spond to those specified in the relevant approvals or
before the pressure exceeds the maximum working qualifications.
pressure by more than 5% d) Both ordinary and special electric arc welding processes
where two or more pressure vessels are intercon- are covered in the following requirements.
nected by a piping system of adequate size so that
no branch of piping may be shut off, it is sufficient to 4.1.3 Cutting of plates
provide them with one safety valve and one pressure a) Plates are to be cut by flame cutting, mechanical
gauge only. machining or a combination of both processes. For
plates having a thickness less than 25 mm, cold shearing
b) Heat exchangers
is admitted provided that the sheared edge is removed
Special attention is to be paid to the protection against by machining or grinding for a distance of at least one
overpressure of vessels, such as heat exchangers, which quarter of the plate thickness with a minimum of 3 mm.
have parts that are designed for a pressure which is
below that to which they might be subjected in the case b) For flame cutting of alloy steel plates, preheating is to be
of rupture of the tubular bundles or coils contained carried out if necessary.
therein and that have been designed for a higher pres- c) The edges of cut plates are to be examined for lamina-
sure. tions, cracks or any other defect detrimental to their use.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 69


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.1.4 Forming of plates - 15 mm for steels having Rm between 460 N/mm2


a) The forming processes are to be such as not to impair and 510 N/mm2 as well as for steels 0,3Mo,
the quality of the material. The Society reserves the right 1Mn0,5Mo, 1Mn0,5MoV and 0,5Cr0,5Mo.
to require the execution of tests to demonstrate the suit- Cold forming is not allowed for steels 1Cr0,5Mo and
ability of the processes adopted. Forming by hammering 2,25Cr1Mo.
is not allowed.
Weld reinforcements are to be carefully ground
b) Unless otherwise justified, cold formed shells are to
smooth prior to forming.
undergo an appropriate heat treatment if the ratio of
internal diameter after forming to plate thickness is less A proper heat treatment is to be carried out after
than 20. This heat treatment may be carried out after forming, if the ratio of internal diameter to thickness
welding. is less than 36, for steels: 460 N/mm2, 510 N/mm2,
0,3Mo, 1Mn0,5Mo, 1Mn0,5MoV and 0,5Cr0,5Mo.
c) Before or after welding, hot formed plates are to be nor-
malised or subjected to another treatment suitable for After forming, the joints are to be subjected to X-ray
their steel grade, if hot forming has not been carried out examination or equivalent and to a magnetic parti-
within an adequate temperature range. cle or liquid penetrant test.
d) Plates which have been previously butt-welded may be Refer to Fig 26 for definition of thickness to be taken
formed under the following conditions: in account.
Hot forming
After forming, the welded joints are to be subjected 4.2 Welding design
to X-ray examination or equivalent. In addition,
mechanical tests of a sample weld subjected to the 4.2.1 Main welded joints
same heat treatment are to be carried out. a) All joints of class 1 and 2 pressure parts of boilers and
Cold forming pressure vessels are to be butt-welded, with the excep-
Cold forming is only allowed for plates having a tion of welding connecting flat heads or tube sheets to
thickness not exceeding: shells, for which partial penetration welds or fillet welds
- 20 mm for steels having minimum ultimate ten- may be accepted.
sile strength Rm between 360 N/mm2 and 410 Fig 26 show examples of acceptable welding for class 1
N/mm2 and 2 pressure vessels.

Figure 26 : Example of acceptable joints and thickness to be considered


for forming and post-weld heat treatment

#
?

 "
* $
)
)

.
*

!
'
-

& %

Key
1 : Nozzle (set in); 2 : Flange; 3 : Nozzle (set on); 4 : Reinforcing plate; 5 : Non-pressure part;
6 : Pad (set in); 7 : Pad (set on); 8 : Manhole frame; 9 : Flat plate.

70 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

b) Joints of class 3 pressure vessels are also subject to the b) If the joint is to undergo radiographic examination, the
requirement in a), however connection of dished heads thickness of the thicker plate is to be reduced to that of
to shells by lap welds may be accepted. Fig 27 shows the thinner plate next to the joint and for a length of at
some acceptable details of circumferential lap welds for least 30 mm.
class 3 pressure vessels.
Figure 27 : Example of acceptable lap-joints
t
4.2.2 Shell longitudinal and circumferential welds

t
Longitudinal and circumferential joints are to be welded
from both sides of the plate. Welding from one side may be t1
allowed only when there is evidence that the welding pro-
cess permits a complete penetration and a sound weld root.
If a backing strip is used, it is to be removed after welding t 3 t1 1,5 t1
and prior to any non-destructive examination. However, the (a)
backing strip may be retained in circumferential joints of
class 2 vessels, having a thickness not exceeding 15 mm, t
and of class 3 vessels, provided that the material of the

t
backing strip is such as not to adversely affect the weld.
t1
4.2.3 Plates of unequal thickness

a) If plates of unequal thickness are butt-welded and the 1,5 t1 4 t1


difference between thicknesses is more than 3 mm, the (b)

thicker plate is to be smoothly tapered for a length equal


to at least four times the offset, including the width of
the weld. For longitudinal joints the tapering is to be (c)
made symmetrically on both sides of the plate in order Details (b) and (c) may be used only for pressure vessels having
to obtain alignment of middle lines. internal diameter less than 600mm.

Figure 28 : Types of joints for unstayed flat heads (1)

(a) (b)

t t
t

(c) (d)

(D)

(e) (f)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 71


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.2.4 Dished heads b) For torispherical ends made of parts assembled by weld-
a) For connection of a hemispherical end with a cylindri- ing, no welded joint is normally admitted along a paral-
cal shell, the joint is to be arranged in a plane parallel to lel in the knuckle nor at a distance less than 50 mm
that of the largest circle perpendicular to the axis of the from the beginning of the knuckle.
shell and at such a distance from this plane that the
tapering of the shell made as indicated in [2.5.6] is 4.2.5 Welding location
wholly in the hemisphere.
The location of main welded joints is to be chosen so that
these joints are not submitted to appreciable bending
stresses.

Figure 29 : Types of joints for unstayed flat heads (2)

25
20
3mm

3mm

Tipe of joint permitted


r = 5mm only if welded in flat position.
10 mm Shell to be bent over the
head before welding.

(g) 25 (h)

shell to be bent over the head


1.5t before welding
t

(i)
t
t

(j) (k)

72 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 30 : Types of joints for nozzles and reinforced rings (1)

 

   








       

    !  



  


     

 

%&"'()* +()*


 , -#  
"

 # 
, &    #
 
$ 
      , .
 
# 
 
 


 # 
    #

, /
 

   





 # 
 # 0


 # 
  #

   )1.2

 #

Figure 31 : Types of joints for nozzles and reinforcing rings (2)

t t
is the greater

is the greater
t/3 or 6 mm

t/3 or 6 mm
whichever

whichever

t t

t
See sketch (a)
(e) (f)
t t

90

t
(g)

90

(h) (i)

(j)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 73


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.2.6 Accessories and nozzles ensure an adequate distribution of loads on pressure


a) Attachment of accessories by welds crossing main parts; such doubling plates are to have well rounded
welds or located near such welds is to be avoided; corners. Attachment of accessories such as ladders and
where this is impracticable, welds for attachment of platforms directly on the walls of vessels such that they
accessories are to completely cross the main welds restrain their free contraction or expansion is to be
rather than stop abruptly on or near them. avoided.
b) Openings crossing main joints or located near main d) Welded connections of nozzles and other fittings, either
joints are also to be avoided as far as possible. with or without local compensation, are to be of a suit-
c) Doubling plates for attachment of accessories such as able type, size and preparation in accordance with the
fixing lugs or supports are to be of sufficient size to approved plans.

Figure 32 : Types of joints for nozzles and reinforcing rings (3)

t t
To be used only for nozzles of
small thickness and diameter

t t

t
t

0,7 t
(k) (l)
t t
t/3 or 6 mm

t/3 or 6 mm

t t

whichever whichever
is the greater is the greater

(m) (n)
t t
t/3 or 6 mm

t/3 or 6 mm

t t

whichever
whichever
is the greater is the greater

0,7 t
(o) (p)

74 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 33 : Types of joints for nozzles (4)

t t

t Remove by mechanical
(q) (r) means after welding

(s) Remove by mechanical


means after welding

Note: Where preparations of Fig 33 are carried out, the shell is to be carefully inspected to ascertain the absence of lamination.

Figure 34 : Types of joints for flanges to nozzles


t

t or 5 mm
(a) whichever
is greater

(b)
t

t
t

(c) t or 5 mm t or 5 mm
whichever whichever
is greater is greater
(d)
1,5t or 6 mm

1,5t or 6 mm
whichever

whichever
is greater

is greater
t

1,5t or 6 mm
(e) (f) whichever
is greater

t or 5 mm
whichever
is greater
t

(g)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 75


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 35 : Types of joints for tubesheets to shell (1)

0-3 mm
0,7 t

t
t

0,7 t

(a) (b)
t/3 or 6 mm
whichever is greater
t

(c)

Figure 36 : Types of joints for tubesheets to shells (2)

When (t1 - t2 ) > 3mm When (t1 - t2 ) > 3mm


4 0,7 t 4
1 1
t1

t1
t2
t2

0,7 t

(d) (e)

When (t1 - t2 ) > 3mm


4 a 70
1
t1
t2

60

a = t/3 or 6 mm (g)
whichever is the greater

(f)
Preparation shown on sketches (d), (e)
and (f) are to be used when the joint is
t

accessible from outside only

Any conventional full


penetration welding

(h)

76 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Figure 37 : Type of joints for stays and stay tubes

1,5 mm
1,5 mm 1,5 mm
a = d/4 1,5 mm a = d/5

40

d
d

a
a (b) (c)
(a)

6 mm 6 mm

a = d/3 1,5 mm a = d/5 1,5 mm

a
a
d

d
t t
t1 > 0,75 t t1 > 0,75 t

t1 /3 t1 /3

(d) (e)
t + 3 mm 3 mm
t

(f) t

(g)

4.2.7 Connections of stays to tube plates 4.3.2 Cleaning of parts to be welded


a) Where stays are welded, the cross-sectional area of the a) Parts to be welded are, for a distance of at least 25 mm
weld is to be at least 1,25 times the cross-section of the from the welding edges, to be carefully cleaned in order
stay. to remove any foreign matter such as rust, scale, oil,
b) The cross-sectional area of the end welding of welded grease and paint.
stay tubes is to be not less than 1,25 times the cross-sec- b) If the weld metal is to be deposited on a previously
tional area of the stay tube. welded surface, all slag or oxide is to be removed to
prevent inclusions.
4.2.8 Type of weldings
Fig 28, Fig 29, Fig 30, Fig 31, Fig 32, Fig 33, Fig 34, Fig 35, 4.3.3 Protection against adverse weather
Fig 36 and Fig 37 indicate the type and size of weldings of conditions
typical pressure vessel connections. Any alternative type of a) Welding of pressure vessels is to be done in a sheltered
welding or size is to be the subject of special consideration position free from draughts and protected from cold and
by the Society. rain.
b) Unless special justification is provided, no welding is to
4.3 Miscellaneous requirements for be performed if the temperature of the base metal is less
fabrication and welding than 0C.

4.3.1 Welding position 4.3.4 Interruption in welding


If, for any reason, welding is stopped, care is to be taken on
a) As far as possible, welding is to be carried out in the
restarting to obtain a complete fusion.
downhand horizontal position and arrangements are to
be foreseen so that this can be applied in the case of cir- 4.3.5 Backing weld
cumferential joints. When a backing weld is foreseen, it is to be carried out after
b) When welding cannot be performed in this position, suitable chiseling or chipping at the root of the first weld,
tests for qualification of the welding process and the unless the welding process applied does not call for such an
welders are to take account thereof. operation.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 77


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.3.6 Appearance of welded joints 4.5 Tolerances after construction


a) Welded joints are to have a smooth surface without 4.5.1 General
under-thickness; their connection with the plate surface The sizes and shape of vessels are to be checked after weld-
is to be gradual without undercutting or similar defects. ing for compliance with the design taking into account the
tolerances given below. The Society reserves the right to
b) The weld reinforcement of butt welds, on each side of stipulate smaller values for these tolerances for vessels sub-
the plate, is not to exceed the following thickness: jected to special loads.
2,5 mm for plates having a thickness not exceeding Any defect in shape is to be gradual and there is to be no
12 mm flat area in way of welded joints.
Measurements are to be taken on the surface of the parent
3 mm for plates having a thickness greater than
plate and not on the weld or other raised part.
12 mm but less than 25 mm
4.5.2 Straightness
5 mm for plates having a thickness at least equal to
The straightness of cylindrical shells is to be such that their
25 mm.
deviation from the straight line does not exceed 0,6% of
their length, with a maximum of 15 mm for each 5 m of
4.4 Preparation of parts to be welded length.

4.5.3 Out-of-roundness
4.4.1 Preparation of edges for welding a) Out-of-roundness of cylindrical shells is to be measured
a) Grooves and other preparations of edges for welding are either when set up on end or when laid flat on their
to be made by machining, chipping or grinding. Flame sides; in the second case, measures of diameters are to
cutting may also be used provided that the zones dam- be repeated after turning the shell through 90 about its
aged by this operation are removed by machining, chip- axis and out-of-roundness is to be calculated from the
ping or grinding. For alloy steel plates, preheating is to average of the two measures of each diameter.
be provided, if needed, for flame cutting. b) For any transverse section, the difference between the
maximum and minimum diameters is not to exceed 1%
b) Edges prepared are to be carefully examined to check of the nominal diameter D with a maximum of:
that there are no defects detrimental to welding. (D + 1250) / 200, D being expressed in mm.
For large pressure vessels, this limit may be increased by
4.4.2 Abutting of parts to be welded a maximum of 0,2% of the internal diameter of the ves-
sel. Any possible out-of-roundness within the above
a) Abutting of parts to be welded is to be such that surface limit is to be gradual and there are to be no localised
misalignment of plates does not exceed: deformations in way of the welded joints.
10% of the thickness of the plate with a maximum of 4.5.4 Irregularities
3 mm for longitudinal joints
Irregularities in profile of cylindrical shells, checked by a
10% of the thickness of the plate plus 1 mm with a 20 gauge, are not to exceed 5% of the thickness of the
maximum of 4 mm for circumferential joints. plate plus 3 mm. This value may be increased by 25% if the
length of the irregularity does not exceed one quarter of the
b) For longitudinal joints, middle lines are to be in align- distance between two circumferential seams, with a maxi-
ment within 10% of the thickness of the thinner plate mum of 1 mm.
with a maximum of 3 mm.
4.6 Preheating
c) Plates to be welded are to be suitably retained in posi-
tion in order to limit deformation during welding. The 4.6.1
arrangements are to be such as to avoid modification of a) Preheating, to be effectively maintained during the
the relative position of parts to be welded and misalign- welding operation, may be required by the Society
ment, after welding, exceeding the limits indicated when deemed necessary in relation to a number of cir-
above. cumstances, such as the type of steel, thickness of the
base material, welding procedure and technique, type
d) Temporary welds for abutting are to be carried out so of restraint, and heat treatment after welding, if any.
that there is no risk of damage to vessel shells. Such
welds are to be carefully removed after welding of the b) The preheating temperature is to be determined accord-
vessel and before any heat treatment. Non-destructive ingly. However, a preheating temperature of approxi-
testing of the corresponding zones of the shell may be mately 150C is required for 0,5Mo or 1Cr0,5Mo type
steel, and approximately 250C for 2,25Cr1Mo type
required by the Surveyor if considered necessary.
steel.
e) Accessories such as doubling plates, brackets and stiff- c) These requirements also apply to welding of nozzles, fit-
eners are to be suitable for the surface to which they are tings, steam pipes and other pipes subject to severe con-
to be attached. ditions.

78 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.7 Post-weld heat treatment Boilers and steam generators for thicknesses higher than
20 mm or, depending upon the type of steel, for lower
4.7.1 General thicknesses as required for class 1 pressure vessels.
a) When post-weld heat treatment of a vessel is to be car- Applications at temperatures less than the ambient tempera-
ried out, such treatment is to consist of: ture and/or steels other than those indicated above are to be
heating the vessel slowly and uniformly up to a tem- the subject of special consideration by the Society.
perature suitable for the grade of steel Stress relieving heat treatment is not to be required when
maintaining this temperature for a duration deter- the minimum temperature of the fluid is at least 30C higher
mined in relation to the actual thickness tA of the than the KV-notch impact test temperature specified for the
vessel and the grade of steel steel; this difference in temperature is also to be complied
slowly cooling the vessel in the furnace down to a with for welded joints (both in heat-affected zones and in
temperature not exceeding 400C, with subsequent weld metal).
cooling allowed out of the furnace in still air. Pressure vessels and pipes of class 3 and associated parts
are not required to be stress relieved, except in specific
b) As far as possible, vessels are to be heat treated in a sin-
cases.
gle operation. However, when the sizes of the vessels
are such that heat treatment requires several operations, 4.7.3 Heat treatment procedure
care is to be taken such that all the parts of the vessels The temperature of the furnace at the time of introduction of
undergo heat treatment in a satisfactory manner. In par- the vessel is not to exceed 400C.
ticular, a cylindrical vessel of great length may be
treated in sections in a furnace if the overlap of the a) The heating rate above 400C is not to exceed:
heated sections is at least 1500 mm and if parts outside 220C per hour if the maximum thickness is not
the furnace are lagged to limit the temperature gradient more than 25 mm, or
to an acceptable value. (5500 / tA)C per hour, with a minimum of 55C per
hour, if the maximum thickness tA , in mm, is more
4.7.2 Thermal stress relieving than 25 mm
Upon completion of all welding, including connections of
b) The cooling rate in the furnace is not to exceed:
nozzles, doublers and fittings, pressure vessels of classes 1
and 2, boilers and associated parts are to be subjected to an 280C per hour if the maximum thickness is not
effective stress relieving heat treatment in the following more than 25 mm, or
cases: (7000 / tA)C per hour, with a minimum of 55C
Pressure vessels of classes 1 and 2 containing fluids at a per hour, if the maximum thickness tA , in mm, is
temperature not less than the ambient temperature, more than 25 mm.
where the thickness exceeds that indicated in Tab 17 Unless specially justified, heat treatment temperatures and
duration for maintaining these temperatures are to comply
Table 17 : Thermal stress relieving with the values in Tab 18.

Thickness (mm) above which Table 18 : Heat treatment procedure


post-weld heat treatment
is required Time per
Grade
25 mm of Minimum
Unfired pressure Grade Temperatures
Boilers maximum time
vessels thickness
Rm = 360 N/mm2 Grade HA 14,5 14,5 Carbon steels 580-620C 1 hour 1 hour
Rm = 410 N/mm2 Grade HA
0,3Mo 620-660C 1 hour 1 hour
Rm = 360 N/mm2 Grade HB 20 30 1Mn 0,5Mo
Rm = 410 N/mm2 Grade HB 1Mn 0,5MoV
20 38 0,5Cr 0,5Mo
Rm = 360 N/mm2 Grade HD
Rm = 410 N/mm2 Grade HD 1Cr 0,5Mo 620-660C 1hour 2 hours

Rm = 460 N/mm Grade HB


2 20 25 2,25Cr 1Mo 600-750C (1) 2 hours 2 hours
Rm = 510 N/mm2 Grade HB (1) The temperature is to be chosen, with a tolerance of
20C, in this temperature range in order to obtain the
Rm = 460 N/mm2 Grade HD 20 35 required mechanical characteristics
Rm = 510 N/mm2 Grade HD
4.7.4 Alternatives
0,3Mo 20 20
1Mn 0,5Mo
When, for special reasons, heat treatment is carried out in
conditions other than those given in [4.7.2], all details
1Mn 0,5MoV
regarding the proposed treatment are to be submitted to the
0,5Cr 0,5Mo
Society, which reserves the right to require tests or further
1Cr 0,5Mo ALL ALL investigations in order to verify the efficiency of such treat-
2,25Cr 1Mo ment.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 79


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

4.7.5 Execution of heat treatment 4.8.2 Mechanical tests of test plates


Furnaces for heat treatments are to be fitted with adequate a) The tensile strength on welded joint is not to be less
means for controlling and recording temperature; tempera- than the minimum specified tensile strength of the plate.
tures are to be measured on the vessel itself. The atmo- b) The bend test pieces are to be bent through an angle of
sphere in the furnaces is to be controlled in order to avoid 180 over a former of 4 times the thickness of the test
abnormal oxidation of the vessel. piece. There is to be no crack or defect on the outer sur-
face of the test piece exceeding in length 1,5 mm trans-
4.7.6 Treatment of test plates versely or 3 mm longitudinally. Premature failure at the
Test plates are normally to be heated at the same time and edges of the test piece is not to lead to rejection. As an
in the same furnace as the vessel. alternative, the test pieces may be bent through an angle
of 120 over a former of 3 times the thickness of the test
When separate heat treatment of test plates cannot be
piece.
avoided, all precautions are to be taken such that this treat-
ment is carried out in the same way as for the vessel, specif- c) The impact energy measured at 0C is not to be less
ically with regard to the heating rate, the maximum than the values given in NR216 Materials for the steel
temperature, the duration for maintaining this temperature grade concerned.
and the cooling conditions. d) The test piece for macrographic examination is to per-
mit the examination of a complete transverse section of
4.7.7 Welding after heat treatment the weld. This examination is to demonstrate good pen-
a) Normally, welding after heat treatment is only allowed etration without lack of fusion, large inclusions and sim-
if: ilar defects. In case of doubt, a micrographic
examination of the doubtful zone may be required.
the throat of welding fillets does not exceed 10 mm
the largest dimension of openings in the vessel for 4.8.3 Re-tests
the accessories concerned does not exceed 50 mm. a) If one of the test pieces yields unsatisfactory results, two
similar test pieces are to be taken from another test plate.
b) Any welding of branches, doubling plates and other
accessories on boilers and pressure vessels after heat b) If the results for these new test pieces are satisfactory
treatment is to be submitted for special examination by and if it is proved that the previous results were due to
the Society. local or accidental defects, the results of the re-tests may
be accepted.
4.8 Welding samples
4.9 Specific requirements for class 1 vessels
4.8.1 Test plates for welded joints
4.9.1 General
a) Test plates of sufficient size, made of the same grade of The following requirements apply to class 1 pressure ves-
steel as the shell plates, are to be fitted at each end of sels, as well as to pressure vessels of other classes, whose
the longitudinal joints of each vessel so that the weld in scantlings have been determined using an efficiency of
the test plates is the continuation of these welded joints. welded joint e greater than 0,90.
There is to be no gap when passing from the deposited
metal of the joint to the deposited metal of the test plate. 4.9.2 Non-destructive tests
b) No test plate is required for circumferential joints if a) All longitudinal and circumferential joints of class 1 ves-
these joints are made with the same process as longitu- sels are to be subject of 100% radiographic or equiva-
dinal joints. Where this is not the case, or if there are lent examination with the following exceptions:
only circumferential joints, at least one test plate is to be for pressure vessels or parts designed to withstand
welded separately using the same welding process as external pressures only, at the Societys discretion,
for the circumferential joints, at the same time and with the extent may be reduced up to approximately 30%
the same welding materials. of the length of the joints. In general, the positions
c) Test plates are to be stiffened in order to reduce as far as included in the examinations are to include all
possible warping during welding. The plates are to be welding crossings.
straightened prior to their heat treatment which is to be for vessels not intended to contain toxic or danger-
carried out in the same conditions as for the corre- ous matters, made of carbon steels having thickness
sponding vessel (see also [4.7.6]). below 20 mm when the joints are welded by
approved automatic processes at the Societys dis-
d) After radiographic examination, the following test cretion, the extent may be reduced up to approxi-
pieces are to be taken from the test plates: mately 10% of the length of the joints. In general,
one test piece for tensile test on welded joint the positions included in the examinations are to
include all welding crossings.
two test pieces for bend test, one direct and one
reverse for circumferential joints having an external diame-
ter not exceeding 175 mm, at the Societys discre-
three test pieces for impact test
tion, the extent may be reduced up to approximately
one test piece for macrographic examination. 10% of the total length of the joints.

80 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

b) Fillet welds for parts such as doubling plates, branches 5 Design and construction - Control
or stiffeners are to undergo a spot magnetic particle test
for at least 10% of their length. If magnetic particle tests
and monitoring
cannot be used, it is to be replaced by liquid penetrant
test. 5.1 Boiler control and monitoring system
c) Welds for which non destructive tests reveal unaccept- 5.1.1 Local control and monitoring
able defects, such as cracks or areas of incomplete Means to effectively operate, control and monitor the oper-
fusion, are to be rewelded and are then to undergo a ation of oil fired boilers and their associated auxiliaries are
new non destructive examination to be provided locally. The functional condition of the fuel,
feed water and steam systems and the boiler operational
4.9.3 Number of test samples status are to be indicated by pressure gauges, temperature
a) During production, at least one test plate for each 20 m indicators, flow-meter, lights or other similar devices.
of length (or fraction) of longitudinal weldings is to be
tested as per [4.8.2]. 5.1.2 Emergency shut-off
Means are to be provided to shut down boiler forced draft
b) During production, at least one test plate for each 30 m or induced draft fans and fuel oil service pumps from out-
of length (or fraction) of circumferential welding is to be side the space where they are located, in the event that a
tested as per [4.8.2]. fire in that space makes their local shut-off impossible.
c) When several vessels made of plates of the same grade
5.1.3 Water level indicators
of steel, with thicknesses varying by not more than 5
mm, are welded successively, only one test plate may a) Each boiler is to be fitted with at least two separate
be accepted per each 20 m of length of longitudinal means for indicating the water level. One of these
joints (or fraction) and per each 30 m of circumferential means is to be a level indicator with transparent ele-
welding (or fraction) provided that the welders and the ment. The other may be either an additional level indi-
welding process are the same. The thickness of the test cator with transparent element or an equivalent device.
plates is to be the greatest thickness used for these ves- Level indicators are to be of an approved type.
sels. b) The transparent element of level indicators is to be
made of glass, mica or other appropriate material.
4.10 Specific requirements for class 2 vessels c) Level indicators are to be located so that the water level
is readily visible at all times. The lower part of the trans-
4.10.1 General parent element is not to be below the safety water level
For vessels whose scantlings have been determined using an defined by the builder.
efficiency of welded joint e greater than 0,90, see [4.9.1]. d) Level indicators are to be fitted either with normally
closed isolating cocks, operable from a position free
4.10.2 Non-destructive tests from any danger in case of rupture of the transparent
All longitudinal and circumferential joints of class 2 vessels element or with self-closing valves restricting the steam
are to be subjected to radiographic or equivalent examina- release in case of rupture of this element.
tion to an extent of 10% of each weld length. This examina-
5.1.4 Water level indicators - Special requirements
tion is to cover all the junctions between welds. for water tube boilers
This extension may be increased at the Society's discretion a) For water tube boilers having an athwarships steam
depending on the actual thickness of the welded plates. drum more than 4 m in length, a level indicator is to be
For actual thickness 15 mm, this examination can be fitted at each end of the drum.
omitted. In this case, the value of the efficiency should be as b) Water tube boilers serving turbine propulsion machin-
indicated in Tab 10. ery are to be fitted with a high-water-level audible and
visual alarm (see also Tab 20).
4.10.3 Number of test samples
5.1.5 Water level indicators - Special requirements for
In general, the same requirements of [4.9.3] apply also to fire tube boilers (vertical and cylindrical boilers)
class 2 pressure vessels. However, test plates are required
a) For cylindrical boilers, the two water level indicators
for each 50 m of longitudinal and circumferential weldings
mentioned in [5.1.3] are to be distributed at each end of
(or fraction).
the boiler; i.e. double front cylindrical boilers are to
have two level indicators on each front.
4.11 Specific requirements for class 3 vessels b) A system of at least two suitably located and remote
controlled gauge-cocks may be considered as the equiv-
4.11.1 For vessels whose scantlings have been determined
alent device mentioned in [5.1.3] for cylindrical boilers
using an efficiency of welded joint e greater than 0,90, see
having a design pressure lower than 1 MPa, for cylindri-
[4.9.1].
cal boilers having a diameter lower than 2 m and for
Heat treatment, mechanical tests and non-destructive tests vertical boilers having height lower than 2,3 m. Gauge-
are not required for welded joints of other class 3 vessels. cocks are to be fixed directly on the boiler shell.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 81


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

c) Where level indicators are not fixed directly on the boiler 5.1.7 Temperature control devices
shell, but on level pillars, the internal diameter of such Each boiler fitted with a superheater is to have an indicator
pillars is not to be less than the value dN given in Tab 19. or recorder for the steam temperature at the superheater
Level pillars are to be either fixed directly on the boiler outlet.
shell or connected to the boiler by pipes fitted with cocks
secured directly to the boiler shell. The internal diameter 5.1.8 Automatic shut-off of oil fired propulsion and
of these pipes dC is not to be less than the values given in auxiliary boilers
Tab 19. The upper part of these pipes is to be arranged so
that there is no bend where condense water can accumu- a) Each burner is to be fitted with a flame scanner designed
late. These pipes are not to pass through smoke boxes or to automatically shut off the fuel supply to the burner in
uptakes unless they are located inside metallic ducts hav- the event of flame failure. In the case of failure of the
ing internal diameter exceeding by not less than 100 mm flame scanner, the fuel to the burner is to be shut off
the external diameter of the pipes. Fig 38 shows the automatically.
sketch of a level pillar arrangement. b) A low water condition is to automatically shut off the
fuel supply to the burners. The shut-off is to operate
Table 19 : Minimum internal diameters dN and dC
before the water level reaches a level so low as to affect
Internal diameter of the boiler dN (mm) dC (mm) the safety of the boiler and no longer be visible in the
gauge glass. Means are to be provided to minimise the
D>3m 60 38 risk of shut-off provoked by the effect of roll and pitch
2,30 m D 3 m 50 32 and/or transients. This shut-off system need not be
D < 2,30 m 45 26 installed in auxiliary boilers which are under local
supervision and are not intended for automatic opera-
Figure 38 : Level pillar arrangement tion.
c) Forced draft failure is to automatically shut off the fuel
cock supply to the burners.
d) Loss of boiler control power is to automatically shut off
the fuel supply to the burners.

5.1.9 Alarms
Any actuation of the fuel-oil shut-off listed in [5.1.8] is to
operate a visual and audible alarm.

level 5.1.10 Additional requirements for boilers fitted with


pillar automatic control systems
a) The flame scanner required in [5.1.8], item a) is to oper-
ate within 6 seconds from the flame failure.

boiler shell b) A timed boiler purge with all air registers open is to be
initiated manually or automatically when boilers are fit-
ted with an automatic ignition system. The purge time is
based on a minimum of 4 air changes of the combustion
chamber and furnace passes. Forced draft fans are to be
operating and air registers and dampers are to be open
before the purge time commences.
cock
c) Means are to be provided to bypass the flame scanner
control system temporarily during a trial-for-ignition for
5.1.6 Pressure control devices a period of 15 seconds from the time the fuel reaches
a) Each boiler is to be fitted with a steam pressure gauge so the burners. Except for this trial-for-ignition period, no
arranged that its indications are easily visible from the means are to be provided to bypass one or more of the
stokehold floor. A steam pressure gauge is also to be burner flame scanner systems unless the boiler is locally
provided for superheaters which can be shut off from controlled.
the boiler they serve. d) Where boilers are fitted with an automatic ignition sys-
b) Pressure gauges are to be graduated in units of effective tem, and where residual fuel oil is used, means are to be
pressure and are to include a prominent legible mark for provided for lighting of burners with igniters lighting
the pressure that is not to be exceeded in normal ser- properly heated residual fuel oil. In the case of flame
vice. failure, the burner is to be brought back into automatic
c) Each pressure gauge is to be fitted with an isolating cock. service only in the low-firing position.
d) Double front boilers are to have a steam pressure gauge e) An alarm is to be activated whenever a burner operates
arranged in each front. outside the limit conditions stated by the manufacturer.

82 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

f) Immediately after normal shutdown, an automatic 5.3.2 Flow control and monitoring
purge of the boiler equal to the volume and duration of a) A flow indicator of the thermal oil is to be provided.
the pre-purge is to occur. Following automatic fuel valve
b) The flow detection is to be representative of the flow in
shut-off, the air flow to the boiler is not to automatically
each heated element.
increase; post-purge in such cases is to be carried out
under manual control. c) The flow detection is not to be based on a measurement
of the pressure-drop through the heating element.
g) Propulsion and auxiliary boilers associated with propul-
sion machinery intended for centralised, unattended d) Oil fired or exhaust gas heaters are to be provided with
operations are to comply with the requirements of Part a flow monitor limit-switch. If the flow rate falls below a
C, Chapter 3. minimum value the firing system is to be switched off
and interlocked.
5.2 Pressure vessel instrumentation 5.3.3 Manual control
5.2.1 At least the temperature control device on the oil side and
flow monitoring are to remain operative in manual operation.
a) Pressure vessels are to be fitted with the necessary
devices for checking pressure, temperature and level, 5.3.4 Leakage monitoring
where it is deemed necessary. Oil tanks are to be equipped with a leakage detector which,
b) In particular, each air pressure vessel is to be fitted with when actuated, shuts down and interlocks the thermal oil
a local manometer. firing system. If the oil fired heater is on stand-by, the start-
ing of the burner is to be blocked if the leakage detector is
5.3 Thermal oil heater control and monitoring actuated.

5.3.1 Local control and monitoring 5.4 Control and monitoring requirements
Suitable means to effectively operate, control and monitor the
operation of oil fired thermal oil heaters and their associated 5.4.1 Tab 20, Tab 21, Tab 22 and Tab 23 summarise the
auxiliaries are to be provided locally. The functional condi- control and monitoring requirements for main propulsion
tion of the fuel, thermal oil circulation, forced draft and flue boilers, auxiliary boilers, oil fired thermal oil heaters and
gas systems is to be indicated by pressure gauges, tempera- exhaust gas thermal oil heaters and incinerators, respec-
ture indicators, flow-meter, lights or other similar devices. tively.

Table 20 : Main propulsion boilers

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
X = function is required, R = remote Boiler Auxiliary
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Fuel oil
Fuel oil delivery pressure or flow L
Fuel oil temperature after heater or viscosity fault L+H local
Master fuel oil valve position (open / close) local
Fuel oil input burner valve position (open / close) local
Combustion
Flame failure of each burner X
Failure of atomizing fluid X 5
Boiler casing and economizer outlet smoke tempera- H
ture (in order to detect possible fire out-break) HH X
Air
Air register position local
General steam
Superheated steam pressure L+H local
X
Superheated steam temperature H local
Lifting of safety valve (or equivalent: high pressure X
alarm for instance)
Water level inside the drum of each boiler L+H local (1)
LL X
X
(1) Duplication of level indicator is required

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 83


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Table 21 : Auxiliary boilers

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
X = function is required, R = remote Boiler Auxiliary
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Water level L+H local
LL X
Circulation stopped (when forced circulation boiler) X X
Fuel oil temperature or viscosity (2) L+H local
Flame failure X X
Temperature in boiler casing (Fire) H
Steam pressure H (1) local X
(1) When the automatic control does not cover the entire load range from zero load
(2) Where heavy fuel is used

Table 22 : Thermal oil system

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
X = function is required, R = remote System Auxiliary
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Thermal fluid temperature heater outlet H local X (1)
Thermal fluid pressure pump discharge H local X
Thermal fluid flow through heating element L local
LL X (1)
Expansion tank level L local
LL X (2)
Expansion tank temperature H
Forced draft fan stopped X X
Heavy fuel oil temperature or viscosity H+L local
Burner flame failure X X
Flue gas temperature heater outlet H
HH X (2)
(1) Shut-off of heat input only
(2) Stop of fluid flow and shut-off of heat input

Table 23 : Incinerators

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Incinerator Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Flame failure X X
Furnace temperature H X
Exhaust gas temperature H
Fuel oil pressure local
Fuel oil temperature or viscosity (1) H+L local
(1) Where heavy fuel is used

84 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

6 Arrangement and installation 6.2.7 Hot surfaces


Hot surfaces with which the crew are likely to come into
contact during operation are to be suitably guarded or insu-
6.1 Foundations
lated. See Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.7.1].
6.1.1 For boilers and pressure vessels bolting down to their 6.2.8 Registers fitted in the smoke stacks of oil fired
foundations, see Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.3.1]. Where necessary, they boilers
are also to be secured to the adjacent hull structures by suit-
Where registers are fitted in smoke stacks, they are not to
able ties.
obstruct more than two thirds of the cross-sectional area of
Where chocks are required to be fitted between the boilers gas passage when closed. In addition, they are to be pro-
and their foundations, they are to be of cast iron or steel. vided with means for locking them in open position when
the boiler is in operation and for indicating their position
6.2 Boilers and degree of opening.

6.2.1 Thermal expansion 6.3 Pressure vessels


Means are to be provided to compensate thermal expansion
of boilers. 6.3.1 Safety devices on multiple pressure vessels
Where two or more pressure vessels are interconnected by
6.2.2 Minimum distance of boilers from vertical a piping system of adequate size so that no branch of piping
bulkheads and fuel tanks may be shut off, it is sufficient to provide them with one
a) The distance between boilers and vertical bulkheads is safety valve and one pressure gauge only.
to be not less than the minimum distance necessary to
provide access for inspection and maintenance of the 6.4 Thermal oil heaters
structure adjacent to the boiler.
6.4.1 In general, the requirements of [6.2] for boilers are
b) In addition to the requirement in a), the distance of boil- also applicable to thermal oil heaters.
ers from fuel oil tanks is to be such as to prevent the
possibility that the temperature of the tank bulkhead
may approach the flash point of the oil. 7 Material test, workshop inspection
c) In any event, the distance between a boiler and a verti-
and testing, certification
cal bulkhead is not to be less than 450 mm.
7.1 Material testing
6.2.3 Minimum distance of boilers from double
bottom 7.1.1 General
a) Where double bottoms in way of boilers may be used to Materials, including welding consumables, for the construc-
carry fuel oil, the distance between the top of the dou- tions of boilers and pressure vessels are to be certified by
ble bottom and the lower metal parts of the boilers is the material manufacturer in accordance with the appropri-
not to be less than: ate material specification.
600 mm, for cylindrical boilers 7.1.2 Boilers, other steam generators, and oil fired
750 mm, for water tube boilers. and exhaust gas thermal oil heaters
In addition to the requirement in [7.1.1], testing of materials
b) The minimum distance of vertical tube boilers from
intended for the construction of pressure parts of boilers,
double bottoms not intended to carry oil may be
other steam generators, oil fired thermal oil heaters and
200 mm.
exhaust gas thermal oil heaters is to be witnessed by the
6.2.4 Minimum distance of boilers from ceilings Surveyor.

a) A space sufficient for adequate heat dissipation is to be 7.1.3 Class 1 pressure vessels and heat exchangers
provided on the top of boilers. In addition to the requirement in [7.1.1], testing of materials
b) Oil tanks are not permitted to be installed in spaces intended for the construction of class 1 pressure parts of
above boilers. pressure vessels and heat exchangers is to be witnessed by
the Surveyor.
6.2.5 Installation of boilers on engine room flats This requirement may be waived at the Societys discretion
Where boilers are installed on an engine room flat and are for mass produced small pressure vessels (such as accumu-
not separated from the remaining space by means of a lators for valve controls, gas bottles, etc.).
watertight bulkhead, a coaming of at least 200 mm in
height is to be provided on the flat. The area surrounded by 7.2 Workshop inspections
the coaming may be drained into the bilge.
7.2.1 Boilers and individually produced class 1 and
6.2.6 Drip trays and gutterways 2 pressure vessels
Boilers are to be fitted with drip trays and gutterways in way The construction, fitting and testing of boilers and individu-
of burners so arranged as to prevent spilling of oil into the ally produced class 1 and 2 pressure vessels are to be
bilge. attended by the Surveyor, at the builder's facility.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 85


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

7.2.2 Mass produced pressure vessels b) The test pressure may be determined as a function of a
Construction of mass produced pressure vessels which are pressure lower than p; however, in such case, the setting
type approved by the Society need not be attended by the and characteristics of the safety valves and other over-
Surveyor. pressure protective devices are also to be determined
and blocked as a function of this lower pressure.

7.3 Hydrostatic tests 7.3.4 Hydraulic test procedure

7.3.1 General a) The hydraulic test specified in [7.3.1] is to be carried out


after all openings have been cut out and after execution
Hydrostatic tests of all class 1, 2 and 3 pressure vessels are
of all welding work and of the heat treatment, if any. The
to be witnessed by the Surveyor with the exception of mass
vessel to be tested is to be presented without lagging,
produced pressure vessels which are built under the condi-
paint or any other lining and the pressure is to be main-
tions stated in [7.2.2].
tained long enough for the Surveyor to proceed with a
complete examination.
7.3.2 Testing pressure
a) Upon completion, pressure parts of boilers and pressure b) Hydraulic tests of boilers are to be carried out either
vessels are to be subjected to a hydraulic test under a after installation on board, or at the manufacturers
pressure pt defined below as a function of the design plant. Where a boiler is hydrotested before installation
pressure p: on board, the Surveyor may, if deemed necessary,
request to proceed with a second hydraulic test on
pt = 1,5 p where p 4 MPa board under a pressure at least equal to 1,1 p. For this
pt = 1,4 p + 0,4 where 4 MPa < p 25 Mpa test, the boiler may be fitted with its lagging. However,
the Surveyor may require this lagging to be partially or
Pt = p + 10,4 where p > 25 MPa entirely removed as necessary.
b) The test pressure may be determined as a function of a c) For water tube boilers, the hydraulic test may also be
pressure lower than p; however, in such case, the setting carried out separately for different parts of the boiler
and characteristics of the safety valves and other over- upon their completion and after heat treatment. For
pressure protective devices are also to be determined drums and headers, this test may be carried out before
and blocked as a function of this lower pressure. drilling the tube holes, but after welding of all appendi-
c) If the design temperature exceeds 300C, the test pres- ces and heat treatment. When all parts of the boiler
sure pt is to be as determined by the following formula: have been separately tested and following assembly the
boiler is to undergo a hydraulic test under a pressure of
K 100 1,25 p.
p t = 1 ,5 --------
-p
K

where: 7.3.5 Hydraulic tests of condensers

p : Design pressure, in MPa Condensers are to be subjected to a hydrostatic test at the


following test pressures:
K100 : Permissible stress at 100C, in N/mm 2
Steam space: 0,1 MPa
K : Permissible stress at the design temperature,
in N/mm2. Water space: maximum pressure which may be devel-
oped by the pump with closed discharge valve
d) Consideration is to be given to the reduction of the test
increased by 0,07 MPa. However, the test pressure is not
pressure below the values stated above where it is nec-
to be less than 0,2 MPa. When the characteristics of the
essary to avoid excessive stress. In any event, the gen-
pump are not known, the hydrostatic test is to be carried
eral membrane stress is not to exceed 90% of the yield
out at a pressure not less than 0,35 MPa.
stress at the test temperature.
e) Economisers which cannot be shut off from the boiler in
any working condition are to be submitted to a hydrau-
7.4 Certification
lic test under the same conditions as the boilers.
7.4.1 Certification of boilers and individually
f) Economisers which can be shut off from the boiler are to produced pressure vessels
be submitted to a hydraulic test at a pressure determined
as a function of their actual design pressure p. Boilers and individually produced pressure vessels of
classes 1, 2 and 3 are to be certified by the Society in accor-
7.3.3 Hydraulic test of boiler and pressure vessel dance with the procedures stated in Part A.
accessories
7.4.2 Mass produced pressure vessels
a) Boilers and pressure vessel accessories are to be tested
at a pressure pt which is not less than 1,5 times the Small mass produced pressure vessels of classes 1, 2 and 3
design pressure p of the vessels to which they are may be accepted provided they are type approved by the
attached. Society in accordance with the procedures stated in Part A.

86 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 3

Table 24 : Pressure vessel certification

Drawing / Calculation Material testing Hydraulic test


Class
Manufacturer The Society Manufacturer The Society Manufacturer The Society
1 X review X witness + X witness
workshop inspection
2 X review X review X witness
3 X X review X witness
Note 1:
Certificates of the Manufacturer and the Society to be issued for all cases for pressure vessels covered by the Rules of the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 87


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

SECTION 4 STEAM TURBINES

1 General All listed plans are to be constructional plans complete with


all dimensions and are to contain full indication of the types
of materials employed.
1.1 Application
2 Design and construction
1.1.1 Propulsion turbines and turbines for essential
services

The requirements of this Section apply to: 2.1 Materials

a) all propulsion turbines 2.1.1 Rotating components

b) turbines intended for auxiliary services essential for a) Rotors, shafts and discs of turbines are to be of forged
safety and navigation. steel. In general, the forgings are to have minimum ten-
sile strength Rm within the limits in Tab 2.
1.1.2 Auxiliary turbines driving generators
b) Rotors of small turbines may be built of special cast
In addition to the requirements contained in this Section, steels.
auxiliary turbines driving electric generators are to comply
c) Turbine blades are to be built of corrosion-resistant
with those of Part C, Chapter 2. materials.

1.2 Documentation to be submitted 2.1.2 Static components


The casings and diaphragms of turbines are to be built of
1.2.1 For propulsion turbines and turbines intended for forged or cast steels capable of withstanding the pressures
driving machinery for essential services, the plans and data and temperatures to which they are subjected. Cast iron
listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted. may be used for temperatures up to 300C.

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted

No A/I (1) ITEM


1 I Sectional assembly
2 A Rotors and discs, revolving and stationary blades for each turbine
3 A Fastening details of revolving and stationary blades
4 A Casings
5 A Schematic diagram of control and safety devices
6 I General specification of the turbine, including an operation and instruction manual
7 I Maximum power and corresponding maximum rotational speed, and the values of pressure and temperature at
each stage
8 A Material specifications of the major parts, including their physical, chemical and mechanical properties, the data
relevant to rupture and creep at elevated temperatures, when the service temperature exceeds 400C, the fatigue
strength, the corrosion resistance and the heat treatments
9 I Distribution box
10 A Strength calculations of rotors, discs and blades and blade vibration calculations
11 A Where the rotors, stators or other components of turbines are of welded construction, all particulars on the
design of welded joints, welding conditions, heat treatments and non-destructive examinations after welding
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.

88 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

Table 2 : Limits of Rm b) For main propulsion machinery with reverse gearing,


controllable pitch propellers or an electrical transmis-
STEEL Rm limits (N/mm2) sion system, astern running is not to cause any over-
loading of the propulsion machinery.
Carbon and carbon-manganese steel 400 < Rm < 600
Alloy steels for rotors 500 < Rm < 800 c) During astern running, the main condenser and the
ahead turbines are not to be excessively overheated.
Alloy steels for discs and other forgings 500 < Rm < 1000

2.2.5 Interlock
2.2 Design and constructional details
The simultaneous admission of steam to the ahead and
2.2.1 Rotors and stators astern turbines is to be prevented by interlocks. Brief over-
a) All components of turbines are to be free from defects lapping of the ahead and astern valves during manoeuvring
and are to be built and installed with tolerances and may be permitted.
clearances such as to allow thermal expansion and to
minimise the distortions of casings and rotors in all 2.2.6 Turbine exhaust
expected service conditions.
a) Sentinel valves or other equivalent means are to be pro-
b) Particular care is to be devoted to preventing condensa-
vided at the exhaust end of all turbines. The valve dis-
tion water from accumulating in the blade spaces of the
charge outlets are to be clearly visible and suitably
casings. Adequate drain tubes and cocks are to be
guarded, as necessary.
arranged in a suitable position, in the lower parts of the
casings. Cocks are to be easy to operate. b) Where, in auxiliary steam turbines, the inlet steam pres-
c) When labyrinth packings are used, the steam supply sure exceeds the pressure for which the exhaust casing
pipes to the sealing system are to be so arranged that and associated piping up to the exhaust valve are
condensed steam may not enter the turbine. designed, means to relieve the excess pressure are to be
provided.
d) Particular attention is to be paid to the connection of
pipes to the turbine stators in order to avoid abnormal
loads in service. 2.2.7 Water accumulation prevention

e) Smooth fillets are to be provided at changes of section a) Non-return valves or other approved means are to be fit-
of rotors, discs and blade roots. The holes in discs are to ted in bled steam connections to prevent steam and
be well rounded and polished. water returning into the turbines.

2.2.2 Bearings b) Bends are to be avoided in steam piping in which water


a) Turbine bearings are to be so located that their lubrica- may accumulate.
tion is not impaired by overheating from adjacent hot
parts. 2.2.8 Steam strainers
b) Lubricating oil is to be prevented from dripping on high Efficient steam strainers are to be provided close to the
temperature parts. inlets to ahead and astern high pressure turbines or alterna-
c) Suitable arrangements for cooling the bearings after the tively at the inlets to manoeuvring valves.
turbines have been stopped may also be required, at the
discretion of the Society. 2.2.9 Emergency arrangements

2.2.3 Turning gear a) In single screw ships fitted with compound main turbine
installations the arrangements are to be such as to
a) Main propulsion turbines are to be equipped with turn- enable safe navigation when the steam led to any one of
ing gear for both directions of rotation. The rotors of the turbines is cut off. For this purpose the steam may be
auxiliary turbines are to be capable of being turned by
led direct to the low pressure (L.P.) turbine and either
hand.
the high pressure (H.P.) or medium pressure (M.P.) tur-
b) The engagement of turning gear is to be visually indi- bine can exhaust direct to the condenser.
cated at the control platform.
b) Adequate arrangements and controls are to be provided
c) An interlock is to be provided to ensure that the turbine for these emergency conditions so that the pressure and
cannot be started up when the turning gear is engaged. temperature of the steam do not exceed those which the
turbine and condenser can safely withstand.
2.2.4 Astern power for main propulsion
a) The main propulsion turbine is to have sufficient power c) Ships classed for unrestricted service and fitted with a
for running astern. The astern power is considered to be steam turbine propulsion plant and only one main
sufficient if it is able to attain astern revolutions equiva- boiler are to be provided with means to ensure emer-
lent to at least 70% of the rated ahead revolutions for a gency propulsion in the event of failure of the main
period of at least 30 minutes. boiler.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 89


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

2.3 Welded fabrication b) The speed increase of turbines driving electric genera-
tors - except those for electrical propeller drive - result-
2.3.1 The manufacturers requirements relative to the weld- ing from a change from full load to no-load may not
ing of turbine rotors or major forged or cast pieces, where exceed 5% on the resumption of steady running condi-
permitted, are to be readily identifiable when the plans are tions. The transient speed increase resulting from a sud-
submitted to the Society for approval. Requirements relative den change from full load to no-load conditions is not
to fabrication, welding, heat treatments, examinations, test- to exceed 10% and is to be separated by a sufficient
ing and acceptance will be stipulated on a case by case margin from the trip speed.
basis. 2.4.2 Overspeed devices
In general, all weldings are to be carried out by qualified a) Each main and auxiliary turbine is to be provided with an
welders in accordance with qualified welding procedures overspeed protective device to prevent the rotational speed
and using approved consumables. from exceeding the maximum rotational by more than
15%. The device is to be actuated by the turbine shaft.
b) Where two or more steam turbines are coupled to the
2.4 Control, monitoring and shut-off devices same gear wheel, the Society may accept the fitting of
only one overspeed device for all the coupled turbines.
2.4.1 Governors
c) For turbines driving electric generators, the overspeed
a) Turbines for main propulsion machinery equipped with protective device mentioned in a) is also to be fitted
controllable pitch propellers, disengaging couplings or with a means for manual tripping.
electrical transmission systems are to be fitted with a d) Where exhaust steam from auxiliary systems is led to
speed governor which, in the event of a sudden loss of the main turbine, provision is to be made to cut off the
load, prevents the revolutions from increasing to the trip steam automatically when the overspeed protective
speed given in [2.4.2]. device is activated.

Table 3 : Main propulsion turbine

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Turbine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Indica- Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Control Stop
tion down down by Start
Main turbine speed local
H X
X
Main turbine axial displacement X local X
Main turbine vibration H local
Lubricating oil
Supply pressure local
L X (2)
Level of gravity tank L (1) local
(1) Sensor to be located near the normal level
(2) This is not to prevent astern operation for braking

Table 4 : Auxiliary turbine

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Turbine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Indica- Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Control Stop
tion down down by Start
Overspeed H local X
Rotor displacement X local X
Vibration H local
Lubricating oil supply pressure L X
Lubricating oil level in gravity tank L

90 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

2.4.3 Rotor axial displacement 3 Arrangement and installation


A quick-closing valve is to be provided which automatically
shuts off the steam supply in the event of axial displacement 3.1 Foundations
of the rotor beyond the permissible limits stated by the man-
ufacturer. The device controlling the valve is to be actuated 3.1.1 Foundations of turbines and connected reduction
by the turbine shaft. gears are to be designed and built so that hull movements
do not give rise to significant movements between reduc-
tion gears and turbines. In any event, such movements are
2.4.4 Bearing lubrication failure
to be absorbed by suitable couplings.
a) Main ahead turbines are to be provided with a quick-
closing valve which automatically shuts off the steam 3.2 Jointing of mating surfaces
supply in the event of a dangerous reduction in oil pres-
sure in the bearing lubricating system. 3.2.1 The mating flanges of casings are to form a tight joint
without the use of any interposed material.
b) This arrangement is to be such as to ensure the admis-
sion of steam to the astern turbine for braking purposes.
3.3 Piping installation
2.4.5 Shut-off arrangement
3.3.1 Pipes and mains connected to turbine casings are to
a) Arrangements are to be provided for shutting off the be fitted in such a way as to minimise the thrust loads and
steam to the main turbines by a suitable hand trip moments.
device controlling the steam admission valve situated at
the control platform and at the turbine itself. 3.4 Hot surfaces
b) Hand tripping for auxiliary turbines is to be arranged in 3.4.1 Hot surfaces with which the crew are likely to come
the proximity of the turbine overspeed protective into contact during operation are to be suitably guarded or
device. insulated. See Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.7].

c) The hand trip device is any device which is operated


manually irrespective of the way the action is per- 3.5 Alignment
formed, i.e. mechanically or by means of external
3.5.1 Particular care is to be taken in the alignment of tur-
power.
bine-reduction gearing, taking account of all causes which
d) The quick-closing valves are also to be manually opera- may alter the alignment from cold conditions to normal ser-
ble at the turbine and from the control platform. vice conditions.
When a structural tank is fitted in way of the turbine or gear-
e) Re-setting of the quick-closing valve device may be ing foundations, the expected tank temperature variations
effected only at the turbine or from the control platform are to be taken into account during alignment operations.
with the control valves in the closed position.
Propulsion turbines are to be fitted with indicators showing
f) Where the valves are operated by hydraulic oil systems the axial movements of rotors with respect to casings and
fitted for automatic operation, they are to be fed by two the sliding movements of casings on the sliding feet.
pumps: one main pump and one standby pump. In any
event, the standby pump is to be independent. In spe- 3.6 Circulating water system
cial cases, at the Societys discretion, a hand-operated
pump may be accepted as a standby pump. 3.6.1 The circulating water system with vacuum ejectors is
to be so arranged that water may not enter the low pressure
g) The starting up of any turbine is to be possible only turbines.
when the quick-closing devices are ready for operation.

h) A quick-closing device is to be provided which auto- 3.7 Gratings


matically shuts off the steam supply in the event of an
increase in pressure or water level in the condenser 3.7.1 Gratings and any other structures in way of the slid-
ing feet or flexible supports are to be so arranged that tur-
beyond the permissible limits.
bine casing expansion is not restricted.

2.4.6 Summary Tables


3.8 Drains
Tab 3 and Tab 4 summarise the minimum control and mon-
itoring requirements for main propulsion and auxiliary tur- 3.8.1 Turbines and the associated piping systems are to be
bines, respectively. equipped with adequate means of drainage.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 91


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

3.9 Instruments hydrostatic tests (see [4.2.4])


safety valves (see [4.2.5])
3.9.1 Main and auxiliary turbines are to be fitted with calli-
pers and micrometers of a suitable type for verifying the thermal stability test of rotor (see [4.2.6])
alignment of rotors and pinion and gear-wheel shafts. rotor balancing and overspeed test (see [4.2.7] and
This check is to be performed to the Surveyors satisfaction [4.2.8])
at the time of installation. shop trials (see [4.2.9]).

4.2.2 Welded fabrication


4 Material tests, workshop inspection
Welded fabrication and testing is to be attended by the Sur-
and testing, certification veyor, as may be deemed necessary by the Society.

4.1 Material tests 4.2.3 Turbine blades


When turbine blades are calculated using a permissible
4.1.1 Parts to be tested stress K > Rm/4, all turbine rotor blades are to be checked by
The materials for the construction of the parts listed in Tab 5 dye penetrants or other equivalent method.
are to be tested in compliance with the requirements of
NR216 Materials. 4.2.4 Hydrostatic tests
Magnetic particle or liquid penetrant tests are required for a) Turbine and nozzle casings are to be subjected to a
the parts listed in Tab 5 and are to be effected in positions hydrostatic test at the greater of the following test pres-
mutually agreed upon by the manufacturer and the Surveyor, sures:
where experience shows defects are most likely to occur.
b) 1,5 times the working pressure
For important structural parts of the turbine, in addition to
the above-mentioned non-destructive tests, examination of c) 1,5 times the starting pressure
welded seams by approved methods of inspection may be d) However, the test pressure is not to be less than
required. 0,2 N/mm2.
Where there is evidence to doubt the soundness of any tur- e) The turbine casings may be temporarily subdivided by
bine component, non-destructive tests using approved diaphragms in order to obtain different pressure values
detecting methods may be required. for the various stages, if necessary.

4.1.2 Special auxiliary turbines f) Where it is not possible to perform hydrostatic tests, the
In the case of auxiliary turbines with a steam inlet tempera- manufacturer may submit to the Society, for consider-
ture of up to 250C, the extent of the tests stated in Tab 5 ation, alternative proposals for testing the integrity of
may be limited to the disc and shaft materials. turbine casings and the absence of defects therein.
g) For the bodies of quick-closing, safety, manoeuvring
4.2 Inspections and testing during and control valves, the test pressure is to be 1,5 times
construction the maximum allowable working pressure of the boiler
(approval pressure). The sealing efficiency of these
4.2.1 Inspections during construction valves when closed is to be tested at 1,1 times the work-
The following inspections and tests are to be carried out in ing pressure.
the presence of the Surveyor during the construction of all h) Intermediate coolers and heat exchangers are to be sub-
turbines which are indicated in [1.1.1]. jected to a hydrostatic test at 1,5 times the working pres-
material tests, as required (see [4.1]) sure.
welded fabrication (see [4.2.2]) i) Pressure piping, valves and other fittings are to be sub-
non-destructive examination of turbine blades (see jected to hydrostatic tests in compliance with the nor-
[4.2.3]) mal requirements for these items.

Table 5 : Material and non-destructive tests

Material tests Non-destructive tests


Turbine component (mechanical properties and Magnetic particle or Ultrasonic or X Ray
chemical composition) liquid penetrant examination
Rotating parts (turbine rotors, shafts, stiff
and flexible couplings, bolts for cou-
all all sample
plings and other dynamically stressed
parts, integral pinions and gears)
Stationary parts (castings and plates for spot as agreed between the
all
casings) Manufacturer and the Surveyor
Blades sample sample sample
Piping and associated fittings as required in the appropriate as required in the appropriate as required in the appropriate
section of the Rules section of the Rules section of the Rules

92 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 4

4.2.5 Safety valves 4.2.9 Shop trials


Where turbines are subjected to a trial run at the factory, the
All valves required in [2.4] are to be tested at their setting
satisfactory functioning of the control, safety and monitor-
pressure in the presence of the Surveyor, as specified by the
ing equipment is to be verified during the trial run. Such
turbine manufacturer.
verification is in any event to take place not later than the
commissioning of the plant aboard ship.
4.2.6 Thermal stability test of rotors
In general, propulsion steam turbines are to be subjected to
Solid forged and welded rotors of propulsion turbines are to a works trial under steam but without load, up to the service
be subjected to a thermal stability test where the service rotational speed, as far as possible. In the course of the
temperature exceeds 400C. This test is to be carried out works trials, the overspeed devices for both main and auxil-
after heat treatment and rough machining or at a later stage iary turbines are to be set.
of fabrication, in accordance with a procedure approved by
the Society. 4.3 Certification

4.2.7 Balancing of rotors 4.3.1 Turbines required to be certified


For turbines required to be certified as per [1.1.1], Societys
Finished rotors, complete with all fittings and blades, are to certificates (C) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1, [4.2.1])
be dynamically balanced in a balancing machine of appro- are required for material tests of rotating components and
priate sensitivity in relation to the size of the rotor. Normally blades listed in Tab 4 and for works trials as per [4.2.1]. Pro-
this test is to be carried out with the primary part of the flex- vided the manufacturer has a quality assurance system
ible coupling, if any. accepted by the Society, a reduced number of inspections
and tests in the presence of the Surveyor may be agreed.
4.2.8 Overspeed test of rotors
4.3.2 Turbines not required to be certified
Finished rotors, complete with all fittings and blades, are to
For turbines not required to be certified as per [1.1.1], man-
be subjected for at least 3 minutes to an overspeed test at
ufacturers certificates including details of tests and inspec-
the greater of the following values:
tions carried out at the shop are to be submitted. The
5% above the setting speed of the overspeed tripping acceptance of these turbines is, however, subject to their
device satisfactory performance during dock and sea trials.

15% above the maximum design speed. 4.3.3 Type approved turbines
For mass produced turbines which are requested to be type
The Society may waive this requirement provided that it can approved by the Society, the tests and trials on a prototype
be demonstrated by the manufacturer, using an acceptable are to be carried out in the presence of the Surveyor as
direct calculation procedure, that the rotor is able to safely stated in [4.3.1]. The minimum required attendance of the
withstand the above values of overspeed and that rotors are Surveyor at the production tests and trials will be agreed
free from defects, as verified by means of non-destructive between the manufacturer and the Society on a case by
tests. case basis.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 93


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

SECTION 5 GAS TURBINES

1 General 1.1.3 Type approval


Turbines intended for propulsion and essential services are
to be type approved by the Society. Other procedures
1.1 Application agreed with the Owner will be considered on a case by
case basis.
1.1.1 Propulsion turbines and turbines for essential
services
1.2 Definition of rated power
The requirements of this Section apply to:
1.2.1 For the definition of rated power, refer to ISO 2314
a) all propulsion turbines standard.

b) turbines intended for auxiliary services essential for


safety and navigation.
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
1.3.1 For propulsion turbines and turbines intended for
1.1.2 Turbines for auxiliary generators driving machinery for essential services, the plans listed in
In addition to the requirements contained in this Section, Tab 1 are to be submitted.
auxiliary turbines driving electric generators are to comply The listed constructional plans are to be complete with all
with the applicable requirements of Part C, Chapter 2 of the dimensions and are to contain full indication of the types of
Rules. materials used.

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted

No A/I (1) ITEM


1 I Sectional assembly
2 A Detailed drawings of rotors, casings, blades, combustion chambers and heat exchangers (2)
3 A Material specifications of the major parts, including their physical, chemical and mechanical properties, the
data relevant to rupture and creep at elevated temperatures, the fatigue strength, the corrosion resistance and
the heat treatments (2)
4 A Where the rotors, stators or other components of turbines are of welded construction, all particulars on the
design of welded joints, welding procedures and sequences, heat treatments and non-destructive examina-
tions after welding (2)
5 I General specification of the turbine, including instruction manual, description of structures and specification
of the properties of fuel and lubricating oil to be used
6 I Details of operating conditions, including the pressure and temperature curves in the turbine and compressor
at the rated power and corresponding rotational speeds, and details of permissible temporary operation
beyond the values for the rated power
7 A Diagrammatic layout of the fuel system, including control and safety devices, and of the lubricating oil system
8 A Cooling system layout, if applicable
9 I Where applicable, background information on previous operating experience in similar applications
10 I Maintenance and overhaul procedures
11 A Stress and temperature analysis in blades, rotors and combustion chamber (2)
12 A Life time calculation of hot and high stress parts (2)
13 A Blade and rotor vibration analysis (2)
14 A Details of automatic safety devices together with failure mode and effect analysis (2)
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.
(2) As an alternative, the Society may, on a case by case basis, consider reviewing a number of selected packages relative to important
and critical parts of the turbine, where all the design, construction, inspection, testing and acceptance criteria used by the manu-
facturer are clearly described, provided the Quality Assurance system of the manufacturer is approved and certified by the Society.

94 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

2 Design and construction 2.4 Design and constructional details


2.4.1 Rotors and stators
2.1 General a) All components of turbines and compressors are to be
free from defects and are to be built and installed with
2.1.1 Operating conditions tolerances and clearances in order to allow thermal
expansion and to minimise the distortions of casings
Attention is to be paid to the specific operating conditions
and rotors in all expected service conditions.
of the turbine (e.g. continuous operation at low load) which
may be imposed by the ship specification. b) Adequate drain tubes and cocks are to be arranged in a
suitable position, in the lower parts of the casings.
Cocks are to be easily operated.
2.1.2 Operation of propulsion turbines in case of
flooding c) Suitable protective devices are to be provided in order
to prevent heat, noise or possible failure of rotating parts
Propulsion turbines are to remain operative in the flooding
from causing injury to personnel. If, to this end, the
conditions defined in Ch 1, Sec 1, [2.1.2]. The turbine whole gas turbine is enclosed in a protective covering,
enclosure may be used for this purpose.
the covering is to be adequately ventilated inside.
d) Particular attention is to be paid to the connection in the
2.2 Materials casings of pipes to the turbine stators in order to avoid
abnormal loads in service.
2.2.1 Approved materials e) Smooth fillets are to be provided at changes of sections
of rotors, discs and blade roots. The holes in discs are to
a) Gas turbine materials are to fulfil the requirements
be well rounded and polished.
imposed by the operating conditions of the individual
components. In the choice of materials, account is to be 2.4.2 Access and inspection openings
taken of effects such as creep, thermal fatigue, oxidation
a) Access to the combustion chambers is to be ensured.
and corrosion to which individual components are sub-
Means are to be provided to inspect the burner cans or
ject when in service. Evidence of the suitability of the
combustion chamber without having to remove the gas
materials is to be supplied to the Society in the form of
generator.
details of their chemical and mechanical properties and
of the heat treatment applied. Where composite materi- b) Inspection openings are to be provided to allow the gas
als are used, their method of manufacture is to be turbine flow path air to be inspected with special equip-
described. ment, e.g. a bore-scope or similar, without the need for
dismantling.
b) Turbine blades are to be built of corrosion and heat-
resistant materials. 2.4.3 Bearings
a) Turbine bearings are to be so located that their lubrica-
tion is not impaired by overheating from hot gases or
2.3 Stress analyses adjacent hot parts.
b) Lubricating oil or fuel oil is to be prevented from drip-
2.3.1 Calculation
ping on high temperature parts.
a) The manufacturer is to submit the results of calculation c) Suitable arrangements for cooling the bearings after the
of the stresses on each rotor under the most severe ser- turbines have been stopped are to be provided, if neces-
vice conditions. sary to prevent bearing cooking.
b) Fatigue analysis on each rotor, taking into account the d) Roller bearings are to be identifiable and are to have a
stress concentrations, is also to be submitted. life adequate for their intended purpose. In any event,
their life cannot be less than 40000 hours.
c) The results of previous in-service experience on similar
applications may be considered by the Society as an 2.4.4 Turning gear
alternative to items a) and b) above. a) Main propulsion turbines are to be equipped with turn-
ing gear or a starter for cranking. The rotors of auxiliary
The calculations and analyses (see also [1.3.1]) are to be turbines are to be capable of being turned by hand.
carried out in accordance with criteria agreed by the Soci-
b) The engagement of the turning gear or starter is to be
ety. Data on the design service life and test results used to
visually indicated at the control platform.
substantiate calculation assumptions are also to be pro-
vided. c) An interlock is to be provided to ensure that the main
turbine cannot be started up when the turning gear is
2.3.2 Vibrations engaged.

The range of service speeds is not to give rise to unaccept- 2.4.5 Cooling
able bending vibrations or to vibrations affecting the entire The turbines and their external exhaust system are to be
installation. Calculations of the critical speeds including suitably insulated or cooled to avoid excessive outside tem-
details of their basic assumptions are to be submitted. perature.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 95


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

2.4.6 Air supply 2.4.12 Emergency operation


a) The air intake ducting is to be equipped to prevent a) In installations with more than one propeller and con-
extraneous substances from entering the compressor nected shafting and more than one turbine, the failure of
and turbine. any gas turbine unit connected to a shafting line is not
to affect the continued, independent operation of the
b) Measures are to be taken to control the salinity of the
remaining units.
combustion air, to meet the manufacturers specifica-
tion. b) In installations with only one propeller and connected
shafting, driven by two or more main turbines, care is to
c) Cleaning equipment is to be provided to remove depos-
be taken to ensure that, in the event of one of the tur-
its from compressors and turbines.
bines failing, the others are able to continue operation
d) Means are to be provided to prevent the formation of ice independently.
in the air intake.
c) Ships classed for unrestricted service and fitted with
only one propeller and connected shafting driven by a
2.4.7 Turbine exhaust arrangement
gas turbine are to be provided with means to ensure
a) The gas exhaust arrangement is to be designed in such a emergency propulsion in the event of failure of the main
way as to prevent the entrance of gases into the com- turbine.
pressor.
b) Silencers or other equivalent arrangements are to be 2.5 Welded fabrication
provided in the gas exhaust, to limit the airborne noise
at one metre distance from the turbine to not more than 2.5.1 The manufacturers requirements relative to the weld-
110 dB (A) in unmanned machinery spaces and not ing of turbine rotors or major forged or cast pieces, where
more than 90 dB (A) in manned spaces. permitted, are to be readily identifiable by the Society in the
plans submitted for approval.
2.4.8 Multi-turbine installations In general, all weldings are to be carried out by qualified
Multi-turbine installations are to have separate air inlets and welders in accordance with qualified welding procedures
exhaust systems to prevent recirculation through the idle using approved consumables.
turbine.
2.6 Control, monitoring and shut-off devices
2.4.9 Fuel
a) Where the turbine is designed to burn non-distillate 2.6.1 Control and monitoring arrangement
fuels, a fuel treatment system is to be provided to For each main propulsion system, the associated control
remove, as far as practicable, the corrosive constituents and monitoring equipment is to be grouped together at
of the fuel or to inhibit their action in accordance with each location from which the turbine may be controlled.
the manufacturers specification.
2.6.2 Governors and speed control system
b) Suitable means are to be provided to remove the depos-
its resulting from the burning of the fuel while avoiding a) Propulsion turbines which may be operated in no-load
abrasive or corrosive action, if applicable. conditions are to be fitted with a control system capable
of limiting the speed to a value not exceeding 10% of
2.4.10 Start-up equipment the maximum continuous speed or another figure pro-
a) Gas turbines are to be fitted with start-up equipment posed by the manufacturer.
enabling them to be started up from the "shutdown" b) Turbines for main propulsion machinery equipped with
condition. controllable pitch propellers, disengaging couplings or
an electrical transmission system are to be fitted with a
b) Provisions are to be made so that any dangerous accu-
speed governor which, in the event of a sudden loss of
mulation of liquid or gaseous fuel inside the turbines is
thoroughly removed before any attempt at starting or load, prevents the revolutions from increasing to the trip
restarting. speed.
c) In addition to the speed governor, turbines are to be fit-
c) Starting devices are to be so arranged that firing opera-
ted with a separate overspeed protective device, with a
tion is discontinued and the main fuel valve is closed
means for manual tripping, adjusted so as to prevent the
within a pre-determined time when ignition is failed.
rated speed from being exceeded by more than 15%.
d) The minimum number of starts is to be such as to satisfy
d) The speed increase of turbines driving electric genera-
the requirements of Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1].
tors -except those for electrical propeller drive- resulting
e) The arrangement is to be such as to grant redundancy of from a change from full load to no-load is not to exceed
sources of energy for turbine starting. 5% on the resumption of steady running conditions. The
transient speed increase resulting from a sudden change
2.4.11 Astern power from full load to no-load conditions is not to exceed
For main propulsion machinery with reverse gearing, con- 10% and is to be separated by a sufficient margin from
trollable pitch propellers or an electrical transmission sys- the trip speed. Alternative requirements may be consid-
tem, astern running maximum power is to be such as not to ered by the Society on a case by case basis based on the
cause any overloading of the propulsion machinery. actual turbine design and arrangement.

96 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

2.6.3 Monitoring system c) The starting up of any turbine is to be possible only


The main operating parameters (pressure, temperature, rpm, when the quick-closing devices are ready for operation.
etc.) are to be adequately monitored and displayed at the
control console. 2.6.6 Automatic temperature controls
2.6.4 Emergency shut-off The following turbine services are to be fitted with auto-
a) An emergency push-button shut-off device is to be pro- matic temperature controls so as to maintain steady state
vided at the control console. conditions within the normal operating range of the main
b) Any shut-off device provided in pursuance of the above gas turbine:
is to shut off the fuel supply as near the burners as possi-
a) lubricating oil supply and discharge
ble.

2.6.5 Quick-closing devices b) fuel oil supply (or, alternatively, automatic control of
fuel oil viscosity)
a) Re-setting of the quick-closing device may be effected
only at the turbine or from the control platform with the c) exhaust gas in specific locations of the flow gas path as
fuel supply control valve in the closed position. determined by the manufacturer.
b) When the devices are operated by hydraulic oil systems
fitted for automatic operation, they are to be fed by two 2.6.7 Indicators, alarm and shutdown
pumps: one main pump and one standby pump. In any
event, the standby pump is to be independent. In spe- Tab 2 indicates the minimum control, monitoring and shut-
cial cases, a hand-operated pump may be accepted as a down requirements for main propulsion and auxiliary tur-
standby pump. bines.

Table 2 : Main propulsion and auxiliary turbines

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
X = function is required, R = remote Turbine Auxiliary

Indica- Slow- Shut- Stand


Identification of system parameter Alarm Control Stop
tion down down by Start
Control system failure X
Automatic starting failure X
Mechanical monitoring of gas turbine
Speed local
X
H X
Rotor axial displacement (not applicable to roller local
bearing) H X
Vibration H local
Performed number of cycle of rotating part H
Gas generator monitoring
Flame and ignition failure X X
Fuel oil supply pressure L local
Fuel oil supply temperature H local
Cooling medium temperature H local
Exhaust gas temperature or gas temperature in specific local
locations of flow gas path (alarm before shutdown) H X
Pressure at compressor inlet (alarm before shutdown) local
L X
Lubricating oil
Turbine supply pressure local
L X
Differential pressure across lubricating oil filter H local
Bearing or lubricating oil (discharge) temperature H local

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 97


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

3 Arrangement and installation c) Propulsion turbines are to be fitted with indicators


showing the axial movements of rotors with respect to
casings and the sliding movements of casings on the
3.1 Foundations sliding feet. Such indicators are to be fitted in an easily
visible position. This requirement does not apply to tur-
3.1.1 Foundations of turbines and connected reduction bines fitted with roller bearings.
gears are to be designed and built so that hull movements
do not give rise to significant movements between reduc-
3.6 Gratings
tion gears and turbines. In any event, such movements are
to be absorbed by suitable couplings. 3.6.1 Gratings and any other structures in way of the slid-
ing feet or flexible supports are to be so arranged that tur-
3.2 Joints of mating surfaces bine casing expansion is not restricted.

3.2.1 The mating flanges of casings are to form a tight joint 3.7 Drains
without the use of any interposed material.
3.7.1 Turbines and the associated piping systems are to be
equipped with adequate means of drainage.
3.3 Piping installation
3.8 Instruments
3.3.1 Pipes and mains connected to turbine and compres-
sor casings are to be fitted in such a way as to minimise the 3.8.1 Main and auxiliary turbines are to be fitted with calli-
thrust loads and moments. If flexible hoses are used for this pers and micrometers of a suitable type for verifying the
purpose, they are to comply with the requirements in Ch 1, alignment of rotors and pinion and gear-wheel shafts, when
Sec 10, [2.6]. necessary.
At the time of installation on board, this check is to be per-
3.4 Hot surfaces formed in the presence and to the satisfaction of the Sur-
veyor.
3.4.1 Hot surfaces with which the crew are likely to come
into contact during operation are to be suitably guarded or 4 Material tests, workshop inspection
insulated. See Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.7].
and testing, certification
3.5 Alignment 4.1 Type tests - General
3.5.1 4.1.1 Every new turbine type intended for installation on
board ships is to undergo a type test whose program will be
a) Particular care is to be taken in the alignment of turbine-
agreed on a case by case basis with the Society and the
reduction gearing, taking account of all causes which
Owner.
may alter the alignment from cold conditions to normal
service conditions.
4.2 Material tests
b) When a structural tank is fitted in way of the turbine or
gearing foundations, the expected tank temperature 4.2.1 The materials for the construction of the parts listed in
variations are to be taken into account during alignment Tab 3 are to be tested in compliance with the requirements
operations. of NR216 Materials.

Table 3 : Material and non-destructive tests

Material tests Non-destructive tests


Turbine component (mechanical properties and Magnetic particle or Ultrasonic or X Ray
chemical composition) liquid penetrant examination
Rotating parts (compressors and turbine rotors, shafts,
stiff and flexible couplings, bolts for couplings and other all all all
dynamically stressed parts, integral pinions and gears)
Stationary parts (castings for casings intended for a tem-
spot as agreed between
perature exceeding 230C and plates for casings
all the Manufacturer and
intended for a temperature exceeding 370C or pres-
the Surveyor
sure exceeding 4 Mpa)
Blades sample sample sample
Piping and associated fittings as required in the as required in the as required in the
appropriate section appropriate section appropriate section
of the Rules of the Rules of the Rules

98 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 5

Magnetic particle or liquid penetrant tests are required for 4.3.4 Balancing of rotors
the parts listed in Tab 3 and are to be effected in positions Finished rotors, complete with all fittings and blades, are to
mutually agreed upon by the manufacturer and the Sur- be dynamically balanced in a balancing machine of appro-
veyor, where experience shows defects are most likely to priate sensitivity in relation to the size of the rotor. Normally
occur. this test is to be carried out with the primary part of the flex-
ible coupling, if any.
For important structural parts of the turbine, in addition to
the above-mentioned non-destructive tests, examination of 4.3.5 Overspeed test of rotors
welded seams by approved methods of inspection may be Finished rotors, complete with all fittings and blades, are to
required. be subjected for at least 3 minutes to an overspeed test at
Where there is evidence to doubt the soundness of any tur- the greater of the following values:
bine component, non-destructive tests using approved 5% above the setting speed of the overspeed tripping
detecting methods may be required. device
15% above the maximum design speed.
4.3 Inspections and testing during The Society may waive this requirement provided that it can
construction be demonstrated by the manufacturer, using an acceptable
direct calculation procedure, that the rotor is able to safely
4.3.1 Inspections during construction withstand the above overspeed values and that rotors are free
from defects, as verified by means of non-destructive tests.
The following inspections and tests are to be carried out in
the presence of a Surveyor during the construction of all tur- 4.3.6 Shop trials
bines which are indicated in [1.1.1]. For on-board trials see For shop trials, see Ch 1, Sec 2, [4.5], as far as applicable.
Ch 1, Sec 15, [3.4].
Material tests as required (see [4.2]) 4.4 Certification
Welding fabrication (see [4.3.2]) 4.4.1 Type approval certificate and its validity
Subject to the satisfactory outcome of the type tests and
Hydrostatic tests (see [4.3.3])
inspections specified in [4.2] or [4.3], the Society will issue
Rotor balancing and overspeed test (see [4.3.4], [4.3.5]) to the turbine manufacturer a "Type Approval Certificate"
valid for all turbines of the same type.
Shop trials (see [4.3.6]).
4.4.2 Testing certification
4.3.2 Welding fabrication a) Turbines admitted to an alternative inspection scheme
Welding fabrication and testing is to be attended by the Sur- Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
veyor, as may be deemed necessary by the Society. 1, [4.2.3]) are required for components and tests indi-
cated in Tab 3 and tests and trials listed in [4.3.1]. How-
4.3.3 Hydrostatic tests ever, the shop trials are to be witnesses by a Surveyor.

Finished casing parts and heat exchangers are to be sub- b) Turbines not admitted to an alternative inspection
jected to hydrostatic testing at 1,5 times the maximum per- scheme.
missible working pressure. If it is demonstrated by other Societys certificates (C) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
means that the strength of casing parts is sufficient, a tight- 1, [4.2.1]) are required for material tests of rotating com-
ness test at 1,1 times the maximum permissible working ponents and blades listed in Tab 3 and for works trials as
pressure may be accepted by the Society. Where the hydro- per [4.3.3], [4.3.4] and [4.3.6].
static test cannot be performed, alternative methods for ver- Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec
ifying the integrity of the casings may be agreed between 1, [4.2.3]) are required for the other items listed in Tab 3
the manufacturer and the Society on a case by case basis. and for trials described in [4.3.2], [4.3.5].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 99


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

SECTION 6 GEARING

1 General methods for the design of bevel gears could be taken into
consideration by the Society.
1.1 Application Additional requirements for gears fitted to ships having an
ice notation are given in NR467 Rules for Steel Ships, Part E,
1.1.1 Unless otherwise specified, the requirements of this Chapter 8.
Section apply to:
reduction and/or reverse gears intended for propulsion 1.2 Documentation to be submitted
plants with a transmitted power of 220 kW and above
1.2.1 Documents
other reduction and step-up gears with a transmitted Before starting construction, all plans, specifications and
power of 110 kW and above. calculations listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted to the Soci-
ety.
The provisions of Article [2] apply only to cylindrical invo-
lute spur or helical gears with external or internal teeth. 1.2.2 Data
The provisions of Article [3] apply only to bevel gears The data listed in Tab 2 or Tab 3 and in Tab 4 are to be sub-
(straight or oblique teeth). Application of other specific mitted with the documents required in [1.2.1].

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted for gearing

Item Status of the


Description of the document (1)
No. review (2)
1 A Constructional drawings of shafts and flanges
2 A Constructional drawings of pinions and wheels, including:
a) specification and details of hardening procedure:
core and surface mechanical characteristics
diagram of the depth of the hardened layer as a function of hardness values
b) specification and details of the finishing procedure:
finishing method of tooth flanks (hobbing, shaving, lapping, grinding, shot-peening)
surface roughness for tooth flank and root fillet
tooth flank corrections (helix modification, crowning, tip-relief, end-relief), if any
grade of accuracy according to ISO 1328-1 1997
3 A Shrinkage calculation for shrunk-on pinions, wheels rims and/or hubs with indication of the minimum and
maximum shrinkage allowances
4 I Calculation of load capacity of the gears
5 A / I (3) Constructional drawings of casings
6 A Functional diagram of the lubricating system, with indication of the:
specified grade of lubricating oil
expected oil temperature in service
kinematic viscosity of the oil
7 A Functional diagram of control, monitoring and safety systems
8 I Longitudinal and transverse cross-sectional assembly of the gearing, with indication of the type of clutch
9 I Data form for calculation of gears (4)
10 I Detailed justification of material quality used for gearing calculation (ML, MQ, or ME according to ISO 6336-5)
(1) Constructional drawings are to be accompanied by the specification of the materials employed including the chemical compo-
sition, heat treatment and mechanical properties and, where applicable, the welding details, welding procedure and stress
relieving procedure.
(2) Submission of the drawings may be requested:
for approval, shown as A in the Table
for information, shown as I in the Table.
(3) A for welded casing, I otherwise
(4) The forms are given in Tab 2, Tab 3 and Tab 4.

100 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 2 : Data to be submitted for cylindrical gears

Values
Symbol Unit Description
Pinion Wheel
a mm Operating centre distance
bB mm Common face width (for double helix gear, width of one helix)
Q Gearing quality class according to ISO 1328-1 1997
bS mm Web thickness
sR mm Rim thickness
Rm,rim N/mm2 Ultimate tensile strength of the rim material
B mm Total face width of double helix gears, including gap
ds mm Shrinkage diameter
mn mm Normal module
n deg or rad Normal pressure angle at reference cylinder
deg or rad Helix angle at reference cylinder
x Addendum modification coefficient
z Number of teeth
P kW Transmitted power
n rpm Rotational speed
da mm Tip diameter
a0 mm Tip radius of the tool
hfp mm Basic rack dedendum
HRC Rockwell hardness
RZf m Mean peak-to-valley flank roughness of the gear pair
RZ m Mean peak-to-valley roughness of the gear pair
Re,s N/mm 2 Minimum yield strength of the shaft material
40 mm2/s Nominal kinematic viscosity of oil at 40C
pr mm Protuberance of the tool
q mm Material allowance for finish machining
dext mm External shaft diameter
dint mm Internal shaft diameter
l mm Bearing span
ZE N1/2/mm Elasticity factor

Table 3 : Data to be submitted for bevel gears

Values
Symbol Unit Description
Pinion Wheel
Q Gearing quality class according to ISO 1328-1 1997
sR mm Rim thickness
ds mm Shrinkage diameter
b mm Common face width (for double helix gear width of one helix)
mmn mm Mean normal module
n deg or rad Normal pressure angle
m deg or rad Mean helix angle
z Actual number of teeth
deg or rad Pitch angle
xh Addendum modification coefficient
xs Thickness modification coefficient
haP mm Addendum of the basic rack tooth profile
hfP mm Dedendum of the basic rack tooth profile

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 101


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Values
Symbol Unit Description
Pinion Wheel
a0 mm Cutter edge radius
rc0 mm Cutter radius
P kW Transmitted power
n rpm Rotational speed
HRC Rockwell hardness
RZf m Mean peak-to-valley flank roughness of the gear pair
RZ m Mean peak-to-valley roughness of the gear pair
Re,s N/mm 2 Minimum yield strength of the shaft material
40 mm /s 2 Nominal kinematic viscosity of oil at 40C
pr mm Protuberance of the tool
q mm Material allowance for finish machining
dext mm External shaft diameter
dint mm Internal shaft diameter
l mm Bearing span
ZE N /mm
1/2 Elasticity factor

Table 4 : General data to be submitted for bevel and cylindrical gears

Condition of use Tick the box


with hydraulic coupling
Diesel engine with elastic coupling
Main gears (propulsion) with other type of coupling
Turbine
Electric motor
Gears intended for ahead running
Gears intended for astern running only
Other intermittent running
Gears with occasional part load in reverse direction (main wheel in reverse gearbox)
Idler gears
Shrunk on pinions and wheel rims
Otherwise
Arrangement
Single gear
without quill shaft (1)
Dual tandem gear
with quill shaft (1)
with 3 planetary gears and less
with 4 planetary gears
Epicyclic gear
with 5 planetary gears
with 6 planetary gears and more
Machining
No modification
Central crowning fma
Central crowning fma + fsh
Helix correction
Helix correction + crowning
End relief
Maximum base pitch deviation of the wheel
With optimum profile correction
(1) A quill shaft is a torsionally flexible shaft intended to improve the load distribution between the gears.

102 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Material Pinion Wheel


St Wrought normalized low carbon steels
Normalized low carbon steels / cast steels
St (Cast) Cast steels
GTS (Perl.) Black malleable cast iron (perlitic structure)
GGG (Perl.) Nodular cast iron (perlitic structure)
GGG (Bai.) Cast iron materials Nodular cast iron (bainitic structure)
GGG (ferr.) Nodular cast iron (ferritic structure)
GG Grey cast iron
V Through-hardened wrought steels Carbon steels, alloy steels
V (cast) Through-hardened cast steels Carbon steels, alloy steels
Eh Case-hardened wrought steels
IF Flame or induction hardened wrought or cast steels
NT (nitr.) Nitrided wrought steels/nitrided steels Nitriding steels
NV (nitr.) /nitrided through-hardening steels Through-hardening steels
NV (nitrocar.) Wrought steels, nitrocarburized Through-hardening steels
(1) A quill shaft is a torsionally flexible shaft intended to improve the load distribution between the gears.

2 Design of gears - Determination of l : Bearing span, in mm


the load capacity of cylindrical gears mn : Normal module, in mm
n : Rotational speed, in rpm
2.1 Symbols, units, definitions P : Transmitted power, in kW
pr : Protuberance of the tool, in mm
2.1.1 Symbols and units
q : Material allowance for finish machining, in mm
The meaning of the main symbols used in this Article is
specified below. Q : Gearing quality class according to ISO 1328-1
1997
Other symbols introduced in connection with the definition
Rm,rim : Ultimate tensile strength of the rim material, in
of influence factors are defined in the appropriate sub-arti-
cles. N/mm2
a : Operating centre distance, in mm Re,s : Minimum yield strength of the shaft material, in
b : Effective face width, in mm (for double helix N/mm2
gear, b = 2 bB) RZ : Mean peak-to-valley roughness of the gear pair,
bB : Common face width, in mm (for double helix in m
gear, width of one helix) RZf : Mean peak-to-valley flank roughness of the gear
bS : Web thickness, in mm pair, in m
B : Total face width of double helix gear, including sR : Rim thickness, in mm
gap, in mm T : Transmitted torque, in kN.m
d : Reference diameter, in mm u : Reduction ratio
da : Tip diameter, in mm v : Linear speed at pitch diameter, in m/s
db : Base diameter, in mm x : Addendum modification coefficient
dext : External diameter of shaft, in mm z : Number of teeth
dint : Internal diameter of shaft, in mm zn : Virtual number of teeth
df : Root diameter, in mm a : Transverse profile angle at tooth tip
ds : Shrinkage diameter, in mm n : Normal pressure angle at reference cylinder
dw : Working pitch diameter, in mm t : Transverse pressure angle at reference cylinder
Ft : Nominal tangential load, in N tw : Transverse pressure angle at working pitch cyl-
F : Total helix deviation, in m inder
h : Tooth depth, in mm : Helix angle at reference cylinder
hfp : Basic rack dedendum, in mm b : Base helix angle
HB : Brinell hardness, in N/mm2 : Transverse contact ratio
HRC : Rockwell hardness : Overlap ratio
HV : Vickers hardness, in N/mm 2 : Total contact ratio
k : Gear axial position on shaft with respect to the 40 : Nominal kinematic viscosity of oil at 40C, in
bearings mm2/s

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 103


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

a0 : Tip radius of the tool, in mm 0, 5 ( Q i 5 ) 0, 5 0, 5


F i = 2 ( 0, 1 d i + 0, 63 b B + 4, 2 )
F : Tooth root bending stress, in N/mm 2
60 P
FE : Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress, in T i = ------- ----
2 n i
N/mm 2
P 60
F t = ----- ------------- 10
6
FP : Permissible tooth root bending stress, in N/mm2 n1 d1
H : Contact stress, in N/mm 2
n d wi
H,lim : Endurance limit for contact stress, in N/mm2 v i = ------------i --------
60 10 3
HP : Permissible contact stress, in N/mm2
Subscripts: 2.2 Principle
1 for pinion, i.e. the gear having the smaller number of
teeth 2.2.1
2 for wheel. a) The following requirements apply to cylindrical involute
spur or helical gears with external or internal teeth, and
2.1.2 Geometrical definitions provide a method for the calculation of the load capac-
In the calculation of surface durability, b is the minimum ity with regard to:
face width on the pitch diameter between pinion and the surface durability (contact stress)
wheel. the tooth root bending stress.
In tooth strength calculations, b1 and b2 are the face widths The cylindrical gears for marine application are to com-
at the respective tooth roots. In any case, b1 or b2 are not to ply with the following restrictions:
be taken greater than b by more than one module mn (in 1,2 < < 2,5
case of width of one gear much more important than the
< 30
other).
sR > 3,5 m n
For internal gear, z2, a, d2, da2, db2, x2 and dw2 are to be
The relevant formulae are provided in [2.4] and [2.5].
taken negative.
The influence factors common to the formulae are given
z in [2.3].
u = ----2-
z1
b) Gears, for which the conditions of validity of some fac-
Note 1: u > 0 for external gears, u < 0 for internal gears. tors or formulae are not satisfied, will be given special
tan consideration by the Society.
tan t = --------------n-
cos c) Other methods of determination of load capacity will be
given special consideration by the Society. Any alterna-
zi mn
d i = --------------- tive calculations are to comply with the international
cos
standards ISO 6336.
d bi = d i cos t

2a 2.3 General influence factors


d w 1 = -------------
1+u
2.3.1 General
2au General influence factors are defined in [2.3.2], [2.3.3],
dw 2 = ------------------
1+u [2.3.4], [2.3.5] and [2.3.6]. Alternative values may be used
d fi = d i + 2 m n x i 2 h fPi provided they are derived from appropriate measurements.

h i = 0,5 ( d ai d fi ) 2.3.2 Application factor KA


d b1 + d b2 The application factor KA accounts for dynamic overloads
cos tw = --------------------- from sources external to the gearing (driven and driving
2a
machines).
sin b = sin cos n
The values of KA are given in Tab 5.
zi
z ni = --------------------------------------- 2.3.3 Load sharing factor K
cos ( cos b )
2

The load sharing factor K accounts for the uneven sharing


d of load on multiple path transmissions, such as epicyclic
cos a i = -----bi-
d ai gears or tandem gears.
z z The values of K are given in Tab 6.
= ------1- ( tan a1 tan w t ) + ------2- ( tan a2 tan w t )
2 2
2.3.4 Dynamic factor KV (method B)
b sin
= ------------------- The dynamic factor KV accounts for the additional internal
mn
dynamic loads acting on the tooth flanks and due to the
= + vibrations of the pinion and the wheel.

104 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 5 : Application factor KA Table 6 : Load sharing factor K

Type of installation KA Type of gear K


Main gears Diesel with hydraulic coupling 1,05 Dual tandem without quill shaft (1) 1,15
(propulsion) engine with elastic coupling 1,30 gear with quill shaft (1) 1,10
with other type of coupling 1,50
Epicyclic with 3 planetary gears and less 1,00
Turbine 1,05 gear with 4 planetary gears 1,20
Electric motor 1,05
with 5 planetary gears 1,30
Auxiliary Diesel with hydraulic coupling 1,00
gears engine with 6 planetary gears and more 1,40
with elastic coupling 1,20
(1) A quill shaft is a torsionally flexible shaft intended to
with other type of coupling 1,40
improve the load distribution between the gears.
Electric motor 1,00

Table 7 : Dynamic factor KV

Resonance domain Factor KV


N NS KV = N (Cv1 BP + Cv2 BF + Cv3 BK) + 1
N > 1,50 KV = Cv5 BP + Cv6 BF + Cv7
Note 1:
BP : Non-dimensional parameter taking into account the effect of tooth deviations and profile modifications:
c f pb, eff
B P = --------------------------
-
KA ( Ft b )

with:
c : Single stiffness defined in Tab 9
fpb,eff : Effective base pitch deviation, in m, equal to: fpb,eff = fpb y
with fpb defined in Tab 14 and y defined in Tab 15
Bf : Non-dimensional parameter taking into account the effect of tooth deviations and profile modifications:
Bf = BP
Bk : Non-dimensional parameter taking into account the effect of tooth deviations and profile modifications:
c C a
B k = 1 ---------------------
-
KA Ft b

with:
1 Hl im 2
C a = ------ -----------
- ( 18,45 ) + 1,5

18 97

When material of the pinion is different from that of the wheel: Ca = 0,5 (Ca1 + Ca2)
Cv1 : Factor for pitch deviation effects: Cv1 = 0,32
Cv2 : Factor for tooth profile deviation effects:
if 1 < 2 : Cv2 = 0,34
if 2 < : Cv2 = 0,57 / ( 0,3)
Cv3 : Factor for cyclic variation effect in mesh stiffness:
if 1 < 2 : Cv3 = 0,23
if 2 < : Cv3 = 0,096 / ( 1,56)
Cv5 : Factor: Cv5 = 0,47
Cv6 : Factor:
if 1 < 2 : Cv6 = 0,47
if 2 < : Cv6 = 0,12 / ( 1,74)
Cv7 : Factor:
if 1 < 1,5 : Cv7 = 0,75
if 1,5 < 2,5 : Cv7 = 0,125 sin[ ( 2)] + 0,875
if 2,5 < : Cv7 = 1

The calculation of the dynamic factor KV is defined in Tab 7, nE1 : Resonance speed, in rpm, defined
where: by the following formula:
N : Resonance ratio, i.e. ratio of the pinion speed to
the resonance speed: 30000 c
n E 1 = ---------------- ---------
-
N = n1 / nE1, with: z 1 mre d

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 105


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

with: intermediate range, when 1,15 N 1,50


mred : Reduced mass of gear pair, in This field is normally to be avoided. Some alternative
kg/mm and more precise calculation could be accepted and
special consideration will be given by the Society
In case of external gears, estimated
calculation of mred is given in Tab 8 supercritical range, when 1,50 < N.

c : Mesh stiffness, in N/(mmm). The lower limit of resonance NS is defined as follows:


For gears with 30, the calcula- if Ft KA / b 100 N/mm:
tion of c is detailed in Tab 9. Ns = 0,85
The value of N determines the range of vibrations: if Ft KA / b < 100 N/mm:

subcritical range, when N NS F t KA


N s = 0,5 + 0,35 -------------
main resonance range, when NS < N < 1,15 100b

This field is not permitted

Table 8 : Estimated calculation of reduced mass mred

Gear rim Rim ratio mred , in kg/mm


2
(df 1 + da1 )
d a 1 + d f -1 2 ----------------------------------------
m red = --- -------------------- -
sRi = 0 1 qi =1 4
8 2d b1 1 1
4 ----- + ---------------2
1 2 u

2
d a 1 + d f 1 2 ( d f1 + d a 1 )
2 ( dfi 2 s R i ) m red = --- --------------------
- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
sRi 0 q i = -------------------------------------
- 8 2d b1 1 1
d f i + d ai 4 -----------------------------
4
+ ---------------------------------------
4
-2
( 1 q1) 1 ( 1 q2) 2 u
Note 1:
i is the density of gearing material ( = 7,83 106 for steel)

Table 9 : Mesh stiffness c (method B)

Specific load c , in N/(mm.m) (1)


Ft KA / b 100 N/mm c = c (0,75 + 0,25) = cth CM CR CB cos (0,75 + 0,25)
F t KA b
Ft KA / b < 100 N/mm c = c ( 0,75 + 0, 25 ) = c t h CM C R CB cos -----------------
- ( 0, 75 + 0, 25 )
100

(1) When < 1,2: c may be reduced up to 10% in case of spur gears.
Note 1:
c : Single stiffness, in N/(mm.m)
cth : Theoretical mesh stiffness, in N/(mm.m), equal to:
1
ct h = --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0 ,15551 0 ,25791 0,11654 x 0,24188 x
0, 04723 + ----------------------- + ----------------------- 0,00635 x 1 0, 00193 x 2 ----------------------------1 ----------------------------2 + 0, 00529 x1 + 0, 00182 x2
2 2

z n1 z n2 z n1 zn 2
where the following limitations are to be verified:
x1 x2, and
0,5 x1 + x2 2,0
For internal gears, zn2 should be replaced by infinity
CM : Measurements correction factor, equal to:
CM = 0,8
CR : Gear blank factor:
for solid disc gears (sR = 0):
CR = 1,0
otherwise:
ln ( b s b )
C R = 1 + ---------------------- s R 5m n
-
5e
with the following limitations:
0,2 bs / b 1,2 and sR / mn 1
CB : Basic rack factor, equal to:
h fP
C B = 1 + 0,5 1,2 ------
- [ 1,0 0,02 ( 20 n ) ]
m n
When pinion basic rack dedendum is different from that of the wheel, CB = 0,5 (CB1 + CB2).

106 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.3.5 Face load distribution factors KH and K F The calculation of the initial equivalent misalignment
(method C) Fx is defined in Tab 11.
The face load distribution factors, KH for contact stress and
KF for tooth root bending stress, account for the effects of The calculations of the running-in allowance y and the
non-uniform distribution of load across the face width. running-in factor are defined in Tab 12.

a) The values of KH are given in Tab 10. They apply only The calculation of the mesh misalignment due to defor-
to gears with: mations of shafts depends on the constant of the pinion
wheel, case, wheel shaft and bearings of stiff con- K and the distance s of the pinion. They are defined in
struction Tab 13.
pinion on a solid or hollow shaft with an inner
b) KF is to be determined using the following formula:
diameter ratio not exceeding 0,5 and located sym-
metrically between the bearings 1
---------------------------------------------------
2
1 + h bB + ( h bB )
no effect of clearances K F = K H
no external loads acting on the pinion shaft.
Note 1: Gears for which the above conditions are not satisfied will where b/h is the smaller of bB1/h1 and bB2/h2 but is not to
be given special consideration by the Society. be taken lower than 3.

Table 10 : Face load factor for contact stress KH

Calculated face width Factor KH


F y c
-1
bcal 2F m b 2F y c
---------------- -------- = -1
---------------- KH = ------------------ 2
2F m b b F y c Fm b

F y c bcal Fm b F y c
-<1
---------------- -------- = 0,5 + --------------
->1 -<2
K H = 1 + ----------------
2F m b b F y c 2 Fm b
Note 1:
bcal : Calculated face width, in mm
Fm : Mean transverse tangential load, in N:
Fm = Ft KA KV
Fy : Effective misalignment after running-in, in m:
Fy = Fx y = Fx
where:
Fx : Initial equivalent misalignment. Estimated values are given in Tab 11
y , : Running-in allowance, in m, and running-in factor, respectively, defined in Tab 12
c : Mesh stiffness, in N/(mmm):
c = 0,85 c
c being the mesh stiffness defined in Tab 9.

Table 11 : Initial equivalent misalignment Fx

Helix modification Fx , in m (1) Default estimated values of fma


None Fx = 1,33 fsh + fma fma = F
Central crowning with C = 0,5 fma Fx = 1,33 fsh + 0,5 fma fma = 0,5 F
Central crowning with C = 0,5 (fma + fsh) Fx = 0,665 fsh + 0,5 fma fma = 0,5 F
Helix correction Fx = 0,133 fsh + fma fma = 0,5 F
Helix correction plus central crowning Fx = 0,133 fsh + 0,5 fma fma = 0,5 F
End relief Fx = 0,931 fsh + 0,7 fma fma = 0,7 F
(1) The misalignment Fx is to be taken greater than Fx,min = 0,005 Fm / b
Note 1:
fsh : Mesh misalignment due to deformations of shafts, in m:
l s d1
2
F d 2
f s h = -----m- 0,023 B + K --------------------
- 0,3 + 0,3 -----B
b 4 d 1
d ext
where:
B* :
Transmitted torque factor depending on k, percentage of input torque transmitted in one gear mesh:
for spur and single helical gears: B* = 1 + 2 (100 k) / k
for double helical gears: B* = 0,5 + (200 k) / k
K : Constant of the pinion defined in Tab 13
s : Distance of the pinion, in mm, as shown in Tab 13
fma : Mesh misalignment due to manufacturing deviations, in m.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 107


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 12 : Running-in allowance y and running-in factor

Material y , in m Limitations
y Fx and 0
St, St (cast), GTS (perl.), GGG (perl.), 320 320
y = -------------- F x = 1 -------------- if 5 m/s < v 10 m/s: y 25600 / H, lim
GGG (bai.), V, V (cast) H, li m H, l im
if 10 m/s < v: y 12800 / H, lim
if 5 m/s < v 10 m/s: y 45
GGG (ferr.), GG y = 0,55 F x = 0,45
if 10 m/s < v: y 22
Eh, IF, NT (nitr.), NV (nitr.),
y = 0,15 F x = 0,85 y 6
NV (nitrocar.)
Note 1: H, lim is defined in [2.4.9].
Note 2: When material of the pinion differs from that of the wheel: y = 0,5 (y1 + y2) and = 0,5 (1 + 2)

2.3.6 Transverse load distribution factors KH and with:


KF (method B)
ZH : Zone factor, defined in [2.4.4]
The transverse load distribution factors, KH for contact
stress and KF for tooth root bending stress, account for the ZE : Elasticity factor, defined in [2.4.5]
effects of pitch and profile errors on the transversal load dis- Z : Contact ratio factor, defined in [2.4.6]
tribution between two or more pairs of teeth in mesh.
Z : Helix angle factor, defined in [2.4.7].
The values of KH and KF are given in Tab 14.
2.4.3 Single pair mesh factors ZB and ZD
2.4 Calculation of surface durability The single pair mesh factors ZB for pinion and ZD for wheel
account for the influence on contact stresses of the tooth
2.4.1 General flank curvature at the inner point of single pair contact in
The criterion for surface durability is based on the contact relation to ZH. These factors transform the contact stress
stress (hertzian pressure) H on the pitch point or at the determined at the pitch point to contact stresses, consider-
inner point of single pair contact. ing the flank curvature at the inner point of single pair con-
tact.
The contact stress H , defined in [2.4.2], is not to exceed
ZB and ZD are to be determined as follows:
the permissible contact stress HP defined in [2.4.8].
a) for spur gears ( = 0):
2.4.2 Contact stress H
ZB = M1 or 1, whichever is the greater, with:
The contact stress H , in N/mm2, is to be determined as fol-
lows. tan t w
M 1 = ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
for the pinion: d a 1
-------
2
2 d a 2 2 2
1 ------- ------- 1 ( 1 ) -------
d b1 z1 d b2 z2
H = Z B H 0 K A K K V K H K H
ZD = M2 or 1, whichever is the greater, with:
for the wheel:
tan t w
M 2 = ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
H = Z D H0 KA K K V K H K H
d
-------
a 2
2
2 d 2
2
1 ------- ------- a 1
1 ( 1 ) -------
d b2 z2 d b1 z1
where:
ZB , ZD : Single pair mesh factors, respectively for pinion b) for helical gears:
and for wheel, defined in [2.4.3] if 1:
KA : Application factor (see [2.3.2]) ZB = ZD = 1
K : Load sharing factor (see [2.3.3]) if < 1:
KV : Dynamic factor (see [2.3.4])
ZB = M1 (M1 1) or 1, whichever is the greater
KH : Face load distribution factor (see [2.3.5])
ZD = M2 (M2 1) or 1, whichever is the greater.
KH : Transverse load distribution factor (see [2.3.6])
Note 1: For gears with 1, a specific analysis of the decisive
contact stress along the path of contact is necessary.
Ft u +1
H0 = Z H Z E Z Z ------------
- ----------------
d1 b u Note 2: For internal gears, ZD = 1.

108 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 13 : Constant of the pinion K and distance of the pinion s

Constant K Constant K
Arrangement (1)
with stiffening without stiffening (2)

T
0,48 0,8

/2 /2

T
0,48 0,8

/2 /2

T 1,33 1,33

 s

0,36 0,6

/2

0,6 1,0

/2
(1) The following limitation is to be verified except when helix correction is applied:
s / l < 0,3
(2) No stiffening is assumed when d1 / dsh < 1,15 or when the pinion is keyed or shrinked to the shaft.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 109


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 14 : Transverse load factors KH and KF

Factors KH and KF Limitations

c ( fpb y )
2 K H = K F = ---- 0,9 + 0,4 -----------------------------
- -2 K H 1
------------
2 FtH b Z

2 ( 1 ) c ( f pb y )
> 2 K H = KF = 0,9 + 0,4 ---------------------- ------------------------------ - KF 1
-------------------------------------
F tH b 0,25 + 0,75

Note 1:
c : Mesh stiffness, in N/mm.m, defined in Tab 9
fpb : Larger value of the base pitch deviation of pinion or wheel, in m.
0,5 0 ,5 ( Q i 5 )
Default value: f pb = 0,3 ( m n + 0,4 d bi + 4) 2

In case of optimum profile correction, fpb is to be replaced by fpb / 2


y : Running-in allowance, in m, defined in Tab 15
FtH : Determinant tangential load in transverse plane, in N:
FtH = Ft KA KV KH

Table 15 : Running-in allowance y

Material y , in m Limitations

St, St (cast), GTS (perl.), GGG (perl.), 160 if 5 m/s < v 10 m/s: y 12800 / H,lim
y = -------------- fpb
GGG (bai.), V, V (cast) H, lim if 10 m/s < v: y 6400 / H,lim
if 5 m/s < v 10 m/s: y 22
GGG (ferr.), GG y = 0,275 fpb
if 10 m/s < v: y 11
Eh, IF, NT (nitr.), NV (nitr.), NV (nitrocar.) y = 0,075 fpb y 3
Note 1: fpb is defined in Tab 14 and H,lim is defined in [2.4.9].
Note 2: When material of the pinion differs from that of the wheel: y = 0,5 (y1 + y2).

2.4.4 Zone factor ZH a) for spur gears ( = 0):


The zone factor ZH accounts for the influence on the hert-
4
zian pressure of tooth flank curvature at the pitch point and Z = --------------
3
transforms the tangential force at the reference cylinder to
normal force at the pitch cylinder.
b) for helical gears:
ZH is to be determined as follows:
for 1:
2 cos b cos tw
ZH = --------------------------------------------
- 1
( cos t ) sin tw
2 Z = -----

2.4.5 Elasticity factor ZE for < 1:


The elasticity factor ZE accounts for the influence of the
4
metal properties (module of elasticity E and Poissons ratio Z = -------------- ( 1 ) + -----
3
) on the hertzian pressure.

For steel gears: ZE = 189,8 N1/2/mm. 2.4.7 Helix angle factor Z


Note 1: Refer to ISO 6336-2 for other materials. The helix angle factor Z accounts for the influence of helix
angle on the surface durability, allowing for such variables
2.4.6 Contact ratio factor Z as the distribution of the load along the lines of contact.
The contact ratio factor Z accounts for the influence of the
Z is to be determined as follows:
transverse contact ratio and the overlap ratio on the specific
surface load of gears.
1
= ----------------------------
Z is to be determined as follows: cos ( 2,

110 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.4.8 Permissible contact stress HP These factors are to be determined as follows:


The permissible contact stress HP , in N/mm 2, is to be deter- a) Lubricant factor ZL
mined separately for pinion and wheel, using the following
4 ( 1 ,0 C ZL )
formula: Z L = C ZL + -----------------------------------
134 2
1 ,2 + ----------
H ,li m
40
HP = ------------
- ZN T ZL ZV ZR ZW ZX
SH
where:
where: CZL : Constant for lubricant factor, equal to:
H,lim : Endurance limit for contact stress, defined in for H,lim < 850 N/mm 2:
[2.4.9] CZL = 0,83
ZNT : Life factor for contact stress, defined in [2.4.10] if 850 N/mm 2 H,lim 1200 N/mm2:
ZL, ZV, ZR: Lubrication, speed and roughness factors, H ,li m
respectively, defined in [2.4.11] C ZL = ------------
- + 0 ,6357
4375
ZW : Hardness ratio factor, defined in [2.4.12] if H,lim > 1200 N/mm2:
ZX : Size factor for contact stress, defined in [2.4.13] CZL = 0,91
SH : Safety factor for contact stress, defined in b) Speed factor ZV
[2.4.14].
2 ( 1 ,0 CZV )
Z V = C ZV + -----------------------------------
-
2.4.9 Endurance limit for contact stress H,lim 32
0 ,8 + ------
v
The endurance limit for contact stress H,lim , in N/mm2, is
the limit of repeated contact stress which can be perma- where:
nently endured. CZV : Constant for speed factor, equal to:

The values to be adopted for H,lim are given, in N/mm2, CZV = CZL + 0,02
with the following formula, in relation to the type of steel c) Roughness factor ZR
employed and the heat treatment performed:
CZ R
3
---------
H,lim = A x + B ZR = -
R Z10

where: where:
A, B : Constants determined in Tab 16 RZ10 : Mean relative peak-to-valley roughness for
the gear pair, in m, equal to:
x : Surface hardness HB or HV, in N/mm 2. The lim-
itations xmin and xmax on surface hardness are 10 1 3
R Z10 = R Zf --------
indicated in Tab 16. r e d

Special consideration will be given to other values of H,lim , red : Relative radius of curvature, in mm, equal to:
depending on the material category and specification of the
steel employed. 0,5 d b1 d b2 tan w t
re d = -------------------------------------------------------
d b1 + d b2
2.4.10 Life factor for contact stress ZNT db being taken negative for internal gears
The life factor ZNT accounts for the influence of limited ser- RZf : Mean peak-to-valley flank roughness for the
vice life on the permissible contact stress. gear pair, in m, equal to:

Some values of ZNT are given for information in Tab 17. R Zf 1 + R Zf 2


R Zf = ------------------------
-
2
The value of ZNT to be used will be given special consider-
ation by the Society, depending on the equipments arrange- CZR : Constant for roughness factor, equal to:
ment and use. if H,lim < 850 N/mm 2:
CZR = 0,15
2.4.11 Lubricant factor ZL , speed factor ZV and
roughness factor ZR if 850 N/mm 2 H,lim 1200 N/mm2:
The lubricant factor ZL accounts for the influence of the type H ,l im
C ZR = 0 ,32 ------------
-
of the lubricant and the influence of its viscosity, the speed 5000
factor ZV accounts for the influence of the pitch line veloc-
if H,lim > 1200 N/mm2:
ity, and the roughness factor ZR accounts for the influence
of the surface roughness on the surface endurance capacity. CZR = 0,08

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 111


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 16 : Constants A and B and limitations on surface hardness HB or HV

Quality (1) A B (N/mm2) Hardness xmin (N/mm2) xmax (N/mm2)


ML 1,000 190 HB 110 210
St MQ 1,000 190 HB 110 210
ME 1,520 250 HB 110 210
ML 0,986 131 HB 140 210
St (cast) MQ 0,986 131 HB 140 210
ME 1,143 237 HB 140 210
ML 1,371 143 HB 135 250
GTS (perl.) MQ 1,371 143 HB 135 250
ME 1,333 267 HB 175 250
ML 1,434 211 HB 175 300
GGG MQ 1,434 211 HB 175 300
ME 1,500 250 HB 200 300
ML 1,033 132 HB 150 240
GG MQ 1,033 132 HB 150 240
ME 1,465 122 HB 175 275
ML 0,963 283 HV 135 210
V (carbon steels) MQ 0,925 360 HV 135 210
ME 0,838 432 HV 135 210
ML 1,313 188 HV 200 360
V (alloy steels) MQ 1,313 373 HV 200 360
ME 2,213 260 HV 200 390
ML 0,831 300 HV 130 215
V (cast, carbon steels) MQ 0,831 300 HV 130 215
ME 0,951 345 HV 130 215
ML 1,276 298 HV 200 360
V (cast, alloy steels) MQ 1,276 298 HV 200 360
ME 1,350 356 HV 200 360
ML 0,000 1300 HV 600 800
Eh MQ 0,000 1500 HV 660 800
ME 0,000 1650 HV 660 800
ML 0,740 602 HV 485 615
IF MQ 0,541 882 HV 500 615
ME 0,505 1013 HV 500 615
ML 0,000 1125 HV 650 900
NT (nitr.) MQ 0,000 1250 HV 650 900
ME 0,000 1450 HV 650 900
ML 0,000 788 HV 450 650
NV (nitr.) MQ 0,000 998 HV 450 650
ME 0,000 1217 HV 450 650
ML 0,000 650 HV 300 650
NV (nitrocar.) MQ 1,167 425 HV 300 450
ME 1,167 425 HV 300 450
(1) The requirements for each material quality are defined in ISO 6336-5.

112 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 17 : Life factor ZNT 2.4.13 Size factor ZX


The size factor ZX accounts for the influence of tooth dimen-
Number of
Material ZNT sions on permissible contact stress and reflects the non-uni-
load cycles NL
formity of material properties.
St, St (cast), NL 105 or static 1,6
ZX is in general equal to 1.
GTS (perl.), NL = 5 107 1,0
GGG (perl.), The value of ZX to be used will be given special consider-
GGG (bai.),V, NL = 109 1,0
ation by the Society depending on the material.
V (cast), Eh, IF NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0
NL 10 or static5 1,3 2.4.14 Safety factor for contact stress SH
GGG (ferr.), GG, The values to be adopted for safety factor for contact stress
NL = 2 106 1,0
NT (nitr.), NV (nitr.) SH are given in Tab 18.
NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0
NL 105 or static 1,1 Table 18 : Safety factor for contact stress SH
NV (nitrocar.) NL = 2 106 1,0
Type of installation SH
NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0
Main gears single machinery 1,25
(propulsion)
2.4.12 Hardness ratio factor ZW duplicate machinery 1,25
The hardness ratio factor ZW accounts for the increase of the Auxiliary gears 1,20
surface durability in the following cases:
a) Surface-hardened with through-hardened wheel 2.5 Calculation of tooth bending strength
if HB < 130: 2.5.1 General
0 ,15
3 The criterion for the tooth root bending strength is based on
Z W = 1,2 ---------
R ZH the local tensile stress at the tooth root in the direction of
the tooth height.
if 130 HB 470:
The tooth root bending stress F , defined in [2.5.2], is not to
H B 130 3 0,15 exceed the permissible tooth root bending stress FP defined
Z W = 1,2 ------------------------ ---------
1700 R ZH
in [2.5.8].
if HB > 470:
2.5.2 Tooth root bending stress F
0,15
3
--------
ZW =
R ZH
- The tooth root bending stress F is to be determined as fol-
lows:
where:
Ft
: Equivalent roughness, in m, equal to: F = --------------
-Y Y Y Y Y K K K K K
RZH b mn F S B D T A V F F
0 ,33 0 ,66
R Z f1 ( 10 red ) ( R Zf 1 R Zf 2 ) where:
R ZH = ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0,33
-
( 40 v 1500 )
YF : Tooth form factor, defined in [2.5.3]
red being the relative radius of curvature YS : Stress correction factor, defined in [2.5.4]
defined in [2.4.11].
Y : Helix angle factor, defined in [2.5.5]
b) Through-hardened pinion and wheel with pinion sub-
stantially harder than the wheel (in that case, the hard- YB : Rim thickness factor, defined in [2.5.6]
ness factor is to be applied only to the wheel) YDT : Deep tooth factor, defined in [2.5.7]
if HB1 / HB2 < 1,2: KA : Application factor (see [2.3.2])
ZW = 1,0 K : Load sharing factor (see [2.3.3])
if 1,2 HB1 / HB2 1,7: KV : Dynamic factor (see [2.3.4])
HB KF : Face load distribution factor (see [2.3.5])
Z W = 1 + 0,00898 ----------1 0,00829 ( u 1,0 )
HB 2
KF : Transverse load distribution factor (see [2.3.6]).
if HB1 / HB2 > 1,7: When a shot peening treatment of the tooth root is applied
ZW = 1,0 + 0,00698 (u 1,0) according to a process agreed by the Society, a reduction of
the bending stress F (depending on the material category,
Note 1: In any cases, ZW 1
but without being over 10%) could be taken in consider-
Note 2: If u > 20, u = 20 is to be taken. ation only for carburized case-hardened steel gears.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 113


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.5.3 Tooth form factor YF (method B) H : Parameter defined by the following formulae:
The tooth form factor YF takes into account the effect of the for external gears:
tooth form on the nominal bending stress, assuming the 2 E
load applied at the outer point of a single pair tooth contact. H = ----- --- ------- ---
zn 2 mn 3
In the case of helical gears, the form factors are to be deter- for internal gears:
mined in the normal section, i.e. for the virtual spur gear
2 E
with the virtual number of teeth zn. H = ----- --- ------- ---
z n 2 m n 6
YF is to be determined separately for the pinion and the
E : Parameter defined by the following formula:
wheel, using the following formula:
sp r a0
- ( 1 sin n ) --------------
E = --- mn h fP tan n + -------------- -
h Fe
- cos Fen 4 cos n cos n
6 ------
mn
Y F = ------------------------------
- spr : Residual fillet undercut, in mm:
s Fn 2
------- cos n spr = pr q
m n
The parameters of the virtual gears are defined as follows:
where:
Fen : Load direction angle:
hFe : Bending moment arm, in mm: Fen = en e
for external gears: e : Parameter defined by the following formula:
h Fe 1 d en 0,5 + 2 tan n x
------- = --- ( cos e sin e tan Fen ) ------
- e = -------------------------------------------------
- + in v n inv e n
mn 2 mn zn

1 G fPv with inv, involute function, equal to:


--- z n cos --- ------------ --------
2 3 cos mn inv = tan
for internal gears: en : Form factor pressure angle:
d bn
h Fe 1 d en cos e n = -------
------- = --- ( cos e sin e tan Fen ) ------
- den
mn 2 mn
dbn : Virtual base diameter, in mm:
1 G fP v
--- z n cos --- 3 ------------ -------
- dbn = dn cos n
2 6 cos mn
with:
sFn : Tooth root chord at the critical section, in mm:
dn : Virtual reference diameter, in mm:
for external gears:
d
d n = ----------------------2 = m n z n
s Fn G f Pv ( cos b )
- = z n sin --- + 3 ------------ --------
------
mn 3 cos mn den : Parameter defined by the following formula:
for internal gears: 2
d a n d b n d cos cos n
2 2 2
2z d bn
d e n = ------ ----------------------------- ------------------------------------ ( n 1 ) + ---------
s Fn G f Pv z 2 z 4
- = z n sin --- + ------------ -------
------ -
mn 6 cos mn with:
fPv : Fillet radius at the basic rack, in mm: dan : Virtual tip diameter, in mm:
dan = dn + da d
for external gears:
n : Virtual transverse contact ratio:
fPv = a0

for internal gears: n = ---------------------
-
( cos b )
2

1,95
( x 2 + h f P m n a0 m n )
fPv = a0 + m n ------------------------------------------------------------------
z
- 2.5.4 Stress correction factor YS (method B)
3,156 1,036 2
The stress correction factor YS is used to convert the nomi-
G : Parameter defined by the following formula: nal bending stress to local tooth root stress, assuming the
load is applied at the outer point of a single pair tooth con-
f Pv h f P tact. It takes into account the influence of:
G = -------
- ------- + x
mn mn
the bending moment
: Parameter defined by the following formula: the proximity of the load application to the critical sec-
2G
tion.
= -------- tan H
zn YS is to be determined as follows:
This transcendental equation is to be calculated 1
--------------------------------------

by iteration Y S = ( 1 ,2 + 0 ,13L )q s 1 ,21 + ( 2 ,3 L )

114 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

where: 2.5.7 Deep tooth factor YDT

s Fn The deep tooth factor YDT adjusts the tooth root stress to
L = ------
-
h Fe take into account high precision gears and contact ratios
within the range 2,05 < n 2,5 (where n is defined in
with sFn and hFe defined in [2.5.3]
[2.5.3]).
qs : Notch parameter:
YDT is to be determined as follows:
s Fn
q s = --------
- if n > 2,5 and Q 4: YDT = 0,7
2 F

with sFn defined in [2.5.3] if 2,5 < n 2,5 and Q 4: YDT = 0,666 n + 2,366

Note 1: The notch parameter should be within the range: otherwise: YDT = 1,0
1 qs < 8

F : Radius of root fillet, in mm: 2.5.8 Permissible tooth root bending stress FP

fPv 2G
2
The permissible tooth root bending stress FP is to be deter-
------F- = -------- + ---------------------------------------------------------------
-
mn mn cos ( z n cos 2 2G ) mined separately for pinion and for wheel, using the follow-
ing formula:
2.5.5 Helix angle factor Y
FE
F P = ------
- Y d Y NT Y r e lT Y R re l T Y X
The helix angle factor Y converts the tooth root stress of a SF
virtual spur gear to that of the corresponding helical gear,
taking into account the oblique orientation of the lines of where:
mesh contact.
FE : Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress,
Y is to be determined as follows: defined in [2.5.9]

if 1 and 30: Y = 1 / 120 Yd : Design factor, defined in [2.5.10]


if 1 and > 30: Y = 1 0,25 YNT : Life factor for tooth root bending stress, defined
in [2.5.11]
if > 1 and 30: Y = 1 / 120
YrelT : Relative notch sensitive factor, defined in
if > 1 and > 30: Y = 0,75
[2.5.12]
2.5.6 Rim thickness factor YB YRrelT : Relative surface factor, defined in [2.5.13]
The rim thickness factor YB is a simplified factor used to de-
YX : Size factor for tooth root bending stress, defined
rate thin rimmed gears. For critically loaded applications,
in [2.5.14]
this method should be replaced by a more comprehensive
analysis. SF : Safety factor for tooth root bending stress,
defined in [2.5.15].
YB is to be determined as follows:
for external gears: 2.5.9 Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress FE
- when sR / h 1,2: The endurance limit for tooth root bending stress FE is the
YB = 1,0 local tooth root stress which can be permanently endured.

- when 1,2 > sR / h > 0,5: The values to be adopted for FE are given, in N/mm2, with
the following formula, in relation to the type of steel
h
Y B = 1,6 ln 2,242 ---- employed and the heat treatment performed:
s R
FE = A x + B
Note 1: sR / h 0,5 is to be avoided.

for internal gears: where:


- when sR / mn 3: A, B : Constants determined in Tab 19
YB =1,0 x : Surface hardness HB or HV, in N/mm2. The lim-
- when 3 > sR / m n > 1,75: itations xmin and xmax on surface hardness are
indicated in Tab 19.
m
Y B = 1,15 ln 8,324 ------n- Special consideration will be given to other values of FE,
sR
depending on the material category and specification of the
Note 2: sR / h 1,75 is to be avoided. steel employed.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 115


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 19 : Constants A and B and limitations on surface hardness HB or HV

Material Quality (1) A B (N/mm2) Hardness xmin (N/mm2) xmax (N/mm2)


ML 0,910 138 HB 110 210
St MQ 0,910 138 HB 110 210
ME 0,772 294 HB 110 210
ML 0,626 124 HB 140 210
St (cast) MQ 0,626 124 HB 140 210
ME 0,508 274 HB 140 210
ML 0,700 154 HB 135 250
GTS (perl.) MQ 0,700 154 HB 135 250
ME 0,806 256 HB 175 250
ML 0,700 238 HB 175 300
GGG MQ 0,700 238 HB 175 300
ME 0,760 268 HB 200 300
ML 0,512 16 HB 150 240
GG MQ 0,512 16 HB 150 240
ME 0,400 106 HB 175 275
ML 0,500 216 HV 115 215
V (carbon steels) MQ 0,480 326 HV 115 215
ME 0,566 404 HV 115 215
ML 0,846 208 HV 200 360
V (alloy steels) MQ 0,850 374 HV 200 360
ME 0,716 462 HV 200 390
ML 0,448 234 HV 130 215
V (cast, carbon steels) MQ 0,448 234 HV 130 215
ME 0,572 334 HV 130 215
ML 0,728 322 HV 200 360
V (cast, alloy steels) MQ 0,728 322 HV 200 360
ME 0,712 372 HV 200 360
ML 0,000 624 HV 600 800
MQ, > 25HRC lower 0,000 850 HV 660 800
Eh MQ, > 25HRC upper 0,000 922 HV 660 800
MQ, > 35 HRC 0,000 1000 HV 660 800
ME 0,000 1050 HV 660 800
ML 0,610 152 HV 485 615
IF MQ 0,276 580 HV 500 570
ME 0,542 474 HV 500 615
ML 0,000 540 HV 650 900
NT (nitr.) MQ 0,000 840 HV 650 900
ME 0,000 936 HV 650 900
ML 0,000 516 HV 450 650
NV (nitr.) MQ 0,000 726 HV 450 650
ME 0,000 864 HV 450 650
ML 0,000 448 HV 300 650
NV (nitrocar.) MQ 1,306 188 HV 300 450
ME 1,306 188 HV 300 450
(1) The requirements for each material quality are defined in ISO 6336-5.

116 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.5.10 Design factor Yd Table 21 : Slip-layer thickness


The design factor Yd takes into account the influence of load
Material (mm)
reversing and shrink fit prestressing on the tooth root
strength. GG, Rm = 150 N/mm 2 0,3124
Yd is to be determined as follows: GG, GGG (ferr.) Rm = 300 N/mm 2 0,3095
for gears with occasional part load in reverse direction, NT, NV 0,1005
such as main wheel in reverse gearboxes: Yd = 0,9 St, Re = 300 N/mm 2 0,0833
for idler gears (driven and driving tooth for each cycle St, Re = 400 N/mm 2 0,0445
i.e. alternating load): Yd = 0,7
V, GTS, GGG (perl. bai.), Re = 500 N/mm 2 0,0281
for shrunk on pinions and wheel rims:
V, GTS, GGG (perl. bai.), Re = 600 N/mm2 0,0194
Yd = 1 T / FE
V, GTS, GGG (perl. bai.), Re = 800 N/mm2 0,0064
with:
FE : Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress V, GTS, GGG (perl. bai.), Re = 1000 N/mm 2 0,0014
(see [2.5.9]) Eh, IF 0,0030
: Tangential stress induced by the shrinkage at
the tooth root diameter. 2.5.13 Relative surface factor YRrel T
The relative surface factor YRrel T takes into account the
The maximum equivalent stress induced by the shrink-
dependence of the root strength on the surface condition on
age in the inner diameter of the rim is not to exceed
the tooth root fillet (roughness).
80% of the yield strength of the rim material.
The values to be adopted for YRrel T are given in Tab 22 in
otherwise: Yd = 1,0
relation to the type of steel employed.
2.5.11 Life factor YNT They are valid only when scratches or similar defects
The life factor YNT accounts for the influence of limited ser- deeper than 12 Ra are not present.
vice life on the permissible tooth root bending stress.
Table 22 : Relative surface factor YRrel T
Some values of YNT are given in Tab 20 for information.
YRrelT
Table 20 : Life factor YNT Material
Rz < 0,1 0,1 Rz 40
Number of V, V (cast),
Material YNT
load cycles NL GGG (perl.),
1,120 1,674 0,529 (Rz + 1)0,1
St, St (cast), GTS (perl.), NL 103 or static 2,5 GGG (bai.),
GGG (perl.), Eh, IF
NL = 3 106 1,0
GGG (bai.), V, St 1,070 5,306 4,203 (Rz + 1)0,01
V (cast), Eh, IF NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0
GG, GGG (ferr.),
1,025 4,299 3,259 (Rz + 1)0,0058
NL 103 or static 1,6 NT, NV
GGG (ferr.), GG,
NL = 3 106 1,0 Note 1:
NT (nitr.), NV (nitr.)
NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0 Rz : Mean peak-to-valley roughness, in m:
Rz = 6 Ra with Ra : Arithmetic mean roughness.
NL 10 or static
3 1,1
NV (nitrocar.) NL = 3 10 6 1,0 2.5.14 Size factor YX
NL = 1010 0,85 up to 1,0 The size factor YX takes into account the decrease of the
strength with increasing size.
The value YNT to be used will be given special consideration
by the Society depending on the equipments arrangement Table 23 : Size factor YX
and use.
Material Normal module YX
2.5.12 Relative notch sensitivity factor Yrel T St, V, V (cast), mn 5 1,00
The relative notch sensitivity factor YrelT indicates the extent GGG (perl.),
5 < mn < 30 1,03 0,006 mn
to which the theoretically concentrated stress lies above the GGG (bai.),
fatigue endurance limit. GTS (perl.) mn 30 0,85

YrelT is to be determined as follows: mn 5 1,00


Eh, IF,
5 < mn < 25 1,05 0,01 mn
1 + 0,2 ( 1 + 2 q s ) NT, NV
Y rel T = ------------------------------------------------------------
- mn 25 0,80
1 + 1,2
mn 5 1,00
where:
GG,
qs : Notch parameter, as defined in [2.5.4] 5 < mn < 25 1,075 0,015 mn
GGG (ferr.)
: Slip-layer thickness, in mm, defined in Tab 21. mn 25 0,70

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 117


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

The values to be adopted for YX are given in Tab 23 in rela- fl,Max : Maximum flash temperature along the path of
tion to the type of steel employed and the value of the nor- contact, in C, defined in [2.6.3].
mal module mn. The flash temperature should be calculated on at least ten
points along the path of contact and the maximum of these
2.5.15 Safety factor for tooth root bending stress SF values has to be used for the calculation of maximum con-
The values to be adopted for the safety factor for tooth root tact temperature.
bending stress SF are given in Tab 24.
2.6.3 Flash temperature fl
Table 24 : Safety factor for tooth root bending stress SF The flash temperature fl at any point along the path of con-
tact, in C, is calculated with the following formula:
Type of installation SF 0, 5
0 , 75 v
Main gears single machinery 1,80 fl = m X M X J X G ( X w Bt ) ----------
0, 25
a
(propulsion) duplicate machinery 1,60
where:
Auxiliary gears 1,40
m : Mean coefficient of friction, defined in [2.6.4]
XM : Thermo-elastic factor, in KN3/4s1/2m1/2mm,
2.6 Calculation of scuffing resistance
defined in [2.6.5]
2.6.1 General XJ : Approach factor, defined in [2.6.6]
The following calculations are requested for equipment run- XG : Geometry factor, defined in [2.6.7]
ning in supercritical domain, i.e. when N > 1,5 (see [2.3.4]). X : Load sharing factor, defined in [2.6.8]
The criterion for scuffing resistance is based on the calcula- w Bt : Transverse unit load, in N/mm, defined in [2.6.9].
tion of the flash temperature method. According to this
method, the risk of scuffing is assessed as a function of the 2.6.4 Mean coefficient of friction m
properties of gear material, the lubricant characteristics, the An estimation of the mean coefficient of friction m of com-
surface roughness of tooth flanks, the sliding velocities and mon working conditions could be used with the following
the load. formula:
The interfacial contact temperatures are calculated as the w B t 0,2
sum of the interfacial bulk temperature of the moving inter- m = 0,6 ------------------------
- XL XR
v g C r e lC
face and the fluctuating flash temperature of the moving
faces in contact. where:

The maximum value of the interfacial contact temperature w Bt : Transverse unit load, in N/mm, defined in [2.6.9]
reduced by oil temperature is not to exceed 0,8 times the vgC : Sum of tangential velocities in pitch point, in
scuffing temperature reduced by oil temperature: m/s:
(B,Max oil) 0,8 (S oil) vgC = 2 v sin wt

where: with v not taken greater than 50 m/s


relC : Transverse relative radius of curvature, in mm:
B,Max : Maximum contact temperature along the path
of contact, in C, defined in [2.6.2] u
re l C = --------------------2 a sin w t
( 1 + u)
oil : Oil temperature, in C
XL : Lubricant factor, given in Tab 25
S : Scuffing temperature, in C, defined in [2.6.11].
XR : Roughness factor, equal to:
Additionally, the difference between the scuffing tempera-
ture and the contact temperature along the path is not to be R z f1 + R z f 2 0,25
X R = -----------------------
-
below 30C: 2

(S B,Max) 30C
Table 25 : Lubricant factor X L
Other methods of determination of the scuffing resistance
could be accepted by the Society. Type of lubricant XL (1)
Mineral oils XL = 1,0 oil 0,05
2.6.2 Contact temperature B
Water soluble polyglycols XL = 0,6 oil 0,05
The maximum contact temperature B,Max along the path of
contact, in C, is calculated as follows: Non water soluble polyglycols XL = 0,7 oil 0,05

B,Max = Mi fl,Max Polyalfaolefins XL = 0,8 oil 0,05


Phosphate esters XL = 1,3 oil 0,05
where:
Traction fluids XL = 1,5 oil 0,05
Mi : Interfacial bulk temperature, in C, defined in
[2.6.10] (1) oil is the dynamic viscosity at oil temperature oil.

118 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.6.5 Thermo-elastic factor XM KA : Application factor (see [2.3.2])


The thermo-elastic factor XM accounts for the influence of K : Load sharing factor (see [2.3.3])
the material properties of pinion and wheel:
c : Mesh stiffness, in N/(mm.m) (see Tab 9)
0 ,25
Er
XM = 1000 -----------
- Cai : Tip relief of pinion or wheel, in m
BM
: Parameter of the point on the line of action,
where:
defined in Tab 26
Er : Reduced modulus of elasticity, in N/mm2:
A : Parameter of the lower end point of the path of
2 contact, defined in Tab 26
E r = ---------------------------------------------------------------
( 1 1 ) E1 + ( 1 2 ) E2
E : Parameter of the upper end point of the path of
E1, E2 : Moduli of elasticity of pinion and wheel mate-
contact, defined in Tab 26.
rial, in N/mm2
1, 2 : Poissons ratios of pinion and wheel material Table 26 : Parameter on the line of action
BM : Mean thermal contact coefficient, in
Nmm 1/2m1/2s1/2K1, equal to: Point
BM = (BM1 + BM2) / 2 A : Lower end point of z tan a 2
the path of contact A = ----2- ----------------
- 1
BMi : Thermal contact coefficient of pinion material z 1 tan w t

(i = 1) and wheel material (i = 2), given in AU: Lower end point of AU = A + 0,2 sin b
Nmm 1/2m1/2s1/2K1 and equal to: buttressing effect
BMi = (0,001 Mi Mi cMi)0,5 AB : Intermediate point AB = 0,5 (A + B)
An average value of 435 Nmm 1/2m1/2s1/2K1 between A and B
for martensitic steels could be used when B : Lower point of single tan a 1 2
pair tooth contact B = ----------------
- 1 -----------------------
thermo-elastic coefficient is not known tan w t z 1 tan w t
Mi : Heat conductivity of pinion material (i = 1) and C : Point with parameter C = 0
wheel material (i = 2), in Ns1K1 equal to 0
Mi : Density of pinion material (i = 1) and wheel M : Intermediate point M = 0,5 (A + E)
material (i = 2), in kgm3 between A and E
cMi : Specific heat per unit mass of pinion material D : Upper point of single z tan a 2 2
(i = 1) and wheel material (i = 2), in Jkg1K1. pair tooth contact D = ----2- ----------------
- 1 + -----------------------
z 1 tan w t z 1 tan w t

2.6.6 Approach factor XJ DE : Intermediate point DE = 0,5 (D + E)


between D and E
The approach factor XJ takes empirically into account an
increased scuffing risk in the beginning of the approach EU : Upper end point of EU = E 0,2 sin b
path, due to mesh starting without any previously built up buttressing effect
oil film. The approach factor at any point should be calcu- E : Upper end point of tan a 1
lated according to the following formula: the path of contact E = ----------------
-1
tan w t
when pinion drives the wheel:
- for 0: 2.6.7 Geometry factor XG
XJ = 1 The geometry factor XG is calculated according to the fol-
- for < 0, provided that XJ 1: lowing conditions:
C eff C a2 3 for external gear pair:
- -----------------
X J = 1 + ---------------------
50 E A 0 ,5 0,5
0,5 ( 1 + ) (1 u ) -
X G = 0,51 X ( u + 1 ) ---------------------------------------------------------------
when wheel drives the pinion: (1 + ) ( u )
0 ,25 0,25

- for 0:
for internal gear pair:
XJ = 1
0,5 0,5
for > 0, provided that XJ 1: 0 ,5 (1 + ) (1 + u )
- X G = 0,51 X ( u 1 ) ---------------------------------------------------------------
0 ,25 0,25
-
(1 + ) (u + )
C eff C a1 3
- -----------------
X J = 1 + ---------------------
50 E A where:

where: X : Angle factor, equal to:


Ceff : Optimal tip relief, in m: X = 1,22 (sin wt)0,25 (cos wt)0,5 (cos b)0,25
KA K Ft
C eff = ------------------------------- : Parameter of the point on the line of action,
b cos t c defined in Tab 26.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 119


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.6.8 Load sharing factor X X,m : Load sharing factor for profile modification:

The load sharing factor X accounts for the load sharing of for < AB , provided that X,m 0:
succeeding pairs of meshing teeth. It is defined as a function
C a 2 1 1 2 C a 2 A
of the value of the parameter in the line of action, increas- X , m = 1 -------
- --- + --- + --- -------- ------------------
C e f f 3 3 3 C e f f B A
ing at the approach path of transverse double contact.
for AB < B , provided that X,m 1:
for narrow helical gears ( < 2) with unmodified profiles:
C a 1 1 1 2 C a 1 A
X = X,u Xbut X , m = 1 -------
- --- + --- + --- -------- ------------------
C e f f 3 3 3 C e f f B A
for narrow helical gears ( < 2) with profile modification:
for B D:
X = X,m Xbut X,m = 1
for wide helical gears ( 2) with unmodified profiles: for D < DE , provided that X,m 1:

1 C a 2 1 1 2 C a 2 E
X = ----- X but X , m = 1 -------
- --- + --- + --- -------- ------------------
C e f f 3 3 3 C e f f E D

for wide helical gears ( 2) with profile modification: for DE < , provided that X,m 0:

X = X,wm Xbut C a 1 1 1 2 C a 1 E
X , m = 1 -------
- --- + --- + --- -------- ------------------
C e f f 3 3 3 C e f f E D
where: X,wm : Load sharing factor for profile modification:
Xbut : Buttressing factor: for < AB , provided that X,wm 0:

for < AU: C a 2 1


X , w m = 1 ------- - -----
C e f f
A ( 1 )Ca 1 + ( 3 + 1 )C a 2 A
- (X
X but = X b utA -------------------- 1) - ------------------
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------
AU A but A 2 ( + 1 )C e f f B A

for AU EU: for AB DE , provided that X,wm 1:

Xbut = 1 1 ( 1 ) ( C a 1 + C a 2 )-
X , w m = ----- + ----------------------------------------------
2 ( + 1 )C e ff
for EU < :
for DE < , provided that X,wm 0:
E
X but - ( X butE 1 )
= X b utE ------------------- C a 1 1
E EU X , w m = 1 ------- - -----
C e f f
Note 1: Xbut is to be taken equal to 1 if Cai Ceff ( 1 )Ca 2 + ( 3 + 1 )C a 1 E
- --------------------
+ -----------------------------------------------------------------
2 ( + 1 )C e f f E D E
XbutA , XbutE : Buttressing factors at, respectively, lower and
Ceff : Optimal tip relief, in m (see [2.6.6])
upper end points of the path of contact:
Cai : Tip relief of pinion or wheel, in m
XbutA = XbutE = 1 + 0,3 , provided that
i : Parameter of any point on the line of action,
XbutA = XbutE < 1,3 given in Tab 26.

X,u : Load sharing factor for unmodified profiles: 2.6.9 Transverse unit load w Bt
for < B: The transverse unit load wBt is calculated according to the
following formula:
Q 2 1 A
X , u = -------------- + --- -----------------
-
15 3 B A F
w Bt = K A K V K H K H K ----t
b
for B D:
where:
X,u = 1
KA : Application factor (see [2.3.2])
for D < : KV : Dynamic factor (see [2.3.4])

Q 2 1 E KH : Face load distribution factor (see [2.3.5])


X , u = -------------- + --- -----------------
-
15 3 E D KH : Transverse load distribution factor (see [2.3.6])
Note 2: Q to be used is to be, as a minimum, equal to 7. K : Load sharing factor (see [2.3.3]).

120 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

2.6.10 Interfacial bulk temperature Mi 3 Design of gears - Determination of


The interfacial bulk temperature Mi may be suitably aver- the load capacity of bevel gears
aged from the two overall bulk temperatures of the teeth in
contact, M1 and M2 . The following estimation could be
3.1 Symbols, units, definitions
used in general configurations:
Mi = oil + 0,47 XS Xmp fl,m 3.1.1 Symbols and units
The meaning of the main symbols used in this Article is
where:
specified below.
oil : Oil temperature, in C
Other symbols introduced in connection with the definition
XS : Lubrication system factor: of influence factors are defined in the appropriate sub-arti-
for spray lubrication: XS = 1,2 cles.
av : Virtual operating centre distance, in mm
for dip lubrication: XS = 1,0
avn : Virtual operating centre distance, in mm
for meshes with additional spray for cooling
purpose: XS = 1,0 b : Effective face width, in mm
de : Outer pitch diameter, in mm
for gears submerged in oil, provided suffi-
cient cooling: XS = 0,2 dext : External diameter of shaft, in mm

Xmp : Multiple mating pinion factor: dint : Internal diameter of shaft, in mm


dm : Mean pitch diameter, in mm
3+n
X m p = --------------p- ds : Shrinkage diameter of the wheel, in mm
4
np : Number of mesh in contact dv : Virtual reference diameter, in mm
dva : Virtual tip diameter, in mm
fl,m : Average flash temperature on the path of con-
tact, in C. dvan : Virtual tip diameter, in mm

The average temperature should be calculated dvb : Virtual base diameter, in mm


on at least ten equidistant points on the path dvbn : Virtual base diameter, in mm
line of contact between A and E. dvf : Virtual root diameter, in mm

2.6.11 Scuffing temperature S dvn : Virtual reference diameter, in mm


Fmt : Nominal tangential load, in N
The scuffing temperature S may be determined according
to the following formula: F : Total helix deviation, in m

S = 80 + (0,85 + 1,4 XW) XL (SFZG 1)2 gv : Length of path of contact, in mm


gvn : Length of path of contact, in mm
where:
haP : Basic rack addendum, in mm
XW : Structural factor given in Tab 27
hfP : Basic rack dedendum, in mm
XL : Lubricant factor given in Tab 25
hv : Virtual tooth depth, in mm
SFZG : Load stage where scuffing occurs, according to
HB : Brinell hardness, in N/mm2
gear tests, such as Ryder, FZG-Ryder, FZG L-42
or FZG A/8 3/90. HRC : Rockwell hardness
HV : Vickers hardness, in N/mm2
Table 27 : Structural factor XW k : Gear axial position on shaft with respect to the
bearings
Material XW
l : Bearing span, in mm
Through-hardened steel 1,00
lbm : Length of the line of contact, in mm
Phosphated steel 1,25
lbm : Length of the line of contact, in mm
Copper-plated steel 1,50
met : Outer transverse module, in mm
Bath or gas nitrided steel 1,50
mmn : Mean normal module, in mm
Hardened carburized steel, with austenite content 1,15
mmt : Mean transverse module, in mm
less than 10%
n : Rotational speed, in rpm
Hardened carburized steel, with austenite content 1,00
between 10% and 20% P : Transmitted power, in kW
Hardened carburized steel, with austenite content 0,85 pet : Transverse base pitch, in mm
above 20% pr : Protuberance of the tool, in mm
Austenite steel (stainless steel) 0,45 q : Material allowance for finish machining, in mm

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 121


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Q : Gearing quality class according to ISO 1328-1 In tooth strength calculations, b1 and b2 are the face widths
1997 at the respective tooth roots. In any case, b1 or b2 are not to
rc0 : Cutter radius, in mm be taken greater than b by more than one module m mn (in
case of width of one gear much more important than the
re : Outer cone distance, in mm
other).
Re,s : Minimum yield strength of the shaft material, in
a) General geometrical definitions
N/mm 2
rm : Mean cone distance, in mm z
u = -----2
z1
Rm,rim : Ultimate tensile strength of the rim material, in
z i m mn
N/mm 2 - + b i sin i
d e i = ---------------
cos m
RZ : Mean peak-to-valley roughness, in m de1 de2
r e = ----------------
- = ----------------
-
RZf : Mean peak-to-valley flank roughness, in m 2 sin 1 2 sin 2
sR : Rim thickness, in mm rm = re 0,5 b
T : Transmitted torque, in kNm de1 de2
m e t = ------
- = ------
-
u : Reduction ratio z1 z2
uv : Virtual reduction ratio rm m e t
m m t = -------------
re
vmt : Linear speed at mean pitch diameter, in m/s
zi mm n
xh : Addendum modification coefficient d m i = ---------------
-
cos m
xS : Thickness modification coefficient
b) Geometrical definitions of virtual cylindrical gears in
z : Number of teeth transverse section (suffix v)
zv : Virtual number of teeth
zi
z v i = -------------
zvn : Virtual number of teeth cos i
n : Normal pressure angle zv 2
u v = ------
-
zv 1
vt : Virtual transverse pressure angle
tan
m : Mean helix angle tan v t = ---------------n-
cos m
vb : Virtual base helix angle
sin vb = sin m cos n
: Pitch angle
dm i
v : Virtual transverse contact ratio d v i = -------------
cos i
vn : Virtual transverse contact ratio
av = 0,5 (dv1 + dv2)
v : Virtual overlap ratio
dvai = dvi + 2 haPi
v : Virtual total contact ratio
dvbi = dvi cos vt
40 : Nominal kinematic viscosity of oil at 40C, in
mm/s dvfi = dvi + 2 mmn xhi - 2 hfPi
a0 : Tip radius of the tool, in mm hvi = 0,5 (dvai - dvfi)
F : Tooth root bending stress, in N/mm pet = mmt cos vt
FE : Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress, in 2 2 2 2
g v = 0, 5 ( d v a 1 d v b 1 + d v a 2 d v b2 ) a v sin v t
N/mm
gv
FP : Permissible tooth root bending stress, in N/mm v = ------
-
pet
H : Contact stress, in N/mm b sin
v = -----------------m-
H,lim : Endurance limit for contact stress, in N/mm mm n
HP : Permissible contact stress, in N/mm. v =
2
v + v
2

Subscripts: if v < 1:
1 for pinion, i.e. the gear having the smaller number of
b
v
teeth -
l bm = ---------------------------
2
v ( 2 v ) ( 1 v )
2 2 2

cos v b v
2 for wheel.
if v 1:
3.1.2 Geometrical definitions
b v
In the calculation of surface durability, b is the minimum l bm = ----------------------------
cos v b v
face width on the pitch diameter between pinion and
wheel. lbm = l cos vb

122 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

c) Geometrical definitions of virtual cylindrical gears in 3.3.2 Application factor KA


normal section (suffix vn)
The application factor KA accounts for dynamic overloads
z vi from sources external to the gearing (driven and driving
z vni = --------------------------------------------
-2
cos m ( cos vb ) machines).

dvni = mmn zvni The values of KA to be used are given in Tab 5.


avn = 0,5 (dvn1 + dvn2)
3.3.3 Load sharing factor K
dvani = dvni + 2 haPi
The load sharing factor K accounts for the uneven sharing
dvbni = dvni cos n of load on multiple path transmissions, such as epicyclic
gears or tandem gears.
g v n = 0,5 ( d van1 d vbn1 + d van2 d vbn 2 ) a vn sin n
2 2 2 2

The values of K to be used are given in Tab 6.


v
v n = -----------------------
-
( cos vb ) 2
3.3.4 Dynamic factor Kv
d) Definitions of transmissions characteristics The dynamic factor KV accounts for the additional internal
60 P dynamic loads acting on the tooth flanks and due to the
T i = ------- ----
2 n i vibrations of the pinion and wheel.
P 60
F m t = ----- ------------ 10
6
The calculation of the dynamic factor KV is defined in Tab
n 1 d m1
29, where:
n d m 1 n d m 2
v m t = ---------1 -------- = --------2- -------- N : Resonance ratio, i.e. ratio of the pinion speed to
60 10 3 60 103
0, 5 ( Q i 5 )
the resonance speed:
0, 5
F i = 2 ( 0,1 d vi + 0,63 b + 4 ,2 )
N = n1 / nE1, with:

3.2 Principle nE1 : Resonance speed, in rpm, defined


by the following formula:
3.2.1
30000 c
n E 1 = ---------------- ---------
-
a) The following requirements apply to bevel spur or heli- z1 mre d
cal gears with external teeth, and provide a method for
the calculation of the load capacity with regard to: where:

the surface durability (contact stress) mred : Reduced mass of gear pair, in
kg/mm. Estimated calculation of mred
the tooth root bending stress.
is given by the following formula:
The bevel gears for marine application are to comply
2

2
with the following restrictions: dm1 u
m re d = ----------- ---------------------- ---------------2
8 ( cos n ) 1 + u 2
1,2 < v < 2,5
m < 30 : Density of gearing material, equal to:

sR > 3,5 mmn = 7,83 106 for steel


The relevant formulae are provided in [3.4] and [3.5]. c : Mesh stiffness, in N/(mm.m):
The influence factors common to the formulae are given c = 20 CF Cb
in [3.3].
CF and Cb being the correction fac-
b) Gears, for which the conditions of validity of some fac- tors for non average conditions
tors or formulae are not satisfied, will be given special defined in Tab 28.
consideration by the Society.
c) Other methods of determination of load capacity will be Table 28 : Correction factors CF and Cb
given special consideration by the Society. Any alterna-
tive calculations are to comply with the international Conditions Factors CF and Cb
standards ISO 6336. if Fmt KA / be 100 N/mm CF = 1
if Fmt KA / be < 100 N/mm CF = (Fmt KA / be) / 100
3.3 General influence factors
if be / b 0,85 Cb = 1
3.3.1 General if be / b < 0,85 Cb = (be / b) / 0,85
General influence factors are defined in [3.3.2], [3.3.3], be : Effective face width, the real length of contact
[3.3.4], [3.3.5] and [3.3.6]. Alternative values may be used pattern. When be is not supplied, be = 0,85 b
provided they are derived from appropriate measurements. could be used.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 123


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

The value of N determines the range of vibrations: intermediate range, when 1,25 N 1,50
subcritical range, when N 0,75 This field is normally to be avoided. Some alternative
and more precise calculation could be accepted and
main resonance range, when 0,75 < N < 1,25 special consideration will be given by the Society
This field is not permitted supercritical range, when 1,50 < N.

Table 29 : Dynamic factor KV

Resonance domain Factor KV


N 0,75 KV = N (CV1 Bp + CV2 Bf + CV3) +1
N > 1,50 KV = CV5 Bp + CV6 Bf + CV7
Note 1:
Bp : Non-dimensional parameter taking into account the effect of tooth deviations and profile modifications:
cf p, ef f
B p = -------------------------
-
KA ( Fm t b )

with:
c :
Single stiffness, in N/(mmm):
c = 14 CF Cb , with CF and Cb defined in Tab 28
f, : Effective base pitch deviation, in m:
f, = f y
with fpt defined in Tab 30 and y defined in Tab 31
Bf : Non-dimensional parameter taking into account the effect of tooth deviations and profile modifications:
Bf = Bp
CV1 : Factor for pitch deviation effects:
Cv1 = 0,32
CV2 : Factor for tooth profile deviation effects:
if 1 < 2:
CV2 = 0,34
if 2 < :
0,57
C V2 = --------------------
0,3

CV3 : Factor for cyclic variation effect in mesh stiffness:


if 1 < 2:
CV3 = 0,23
if 2 < :
0,096
C V3 = -----------------------
1,56

CV5 : Factor equal to: CV5 = 0,47


CV6 : Factor:
if 1 < 2:
CV6 = 0,47
if 2 < :
0,12
C V6 = -----------------------
1,74

CV7 : Factor:
if 1 < 1,5:
CV7 = 0,75
if 1,5 < 2,5:
CV7 = 0,125 sin[ ( 2)] + 0,875
if 2,5 < :
CV7 = 1

124 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

3.3.5 Face load distribution factors KH and K F 3.4 Calculation of surface durability
The face load distribution factors, KH for contact stress and
KF for tooth root ending stress, account for the effects of 3.4.1 General
non-uniform distribution of load across the face width. The criterion for surface durability is based on the contact
stress (hertzian pressure) H on the pitch point or at the
a) The calculation of KH is to be defined according to the
inner point of single pair contact.
mounting conditions of pinion and wheel:
neither member cantilever mounted: The contact stress H , defined in [3.4.2], is not to exceed
the permissible contact stress HP defined in [3.4.9].
KH = 1,575 / Cb
one member cantilever mounted: 3.4.2 Contact stress H
KH = 1,650 / Cb The contact stress H is to be determined as follows:
both members cantilever mounted:
H = H 0 K A K K V K H K H
KH = 1,875 / Cb
where C b is the correction factor defined in Tab 28 where:
KA : Application factor (see [3.3.2])
b) KF is to be determined using the following formula:
K : Load sharing factor (see [3.3.3])
KF = KH / KF0 , with:
KV : Dynamic factor (see [3.3.4])
KF0 : Lengthwise curvature factor. It is to be taken
above 1,0 and below 1,15 considering the KH : Face load distribution factor (see [3.3.5])
following formula: KH : Transverse load distribution factor (see [3.3.6])
0, 279 -
----------------------------
log ( sin m ) F mt uv + 1
r c0 H0 = Z M B Z H Z E Z L S Z Z K -------------------
- --------------
-
K F0 = 0, 211 -----
- + 0, 789 d v 1 l bm uv
rm
with:
3.3.6 Transverse load distribution factors KH and ZM-B : Mid-zone factor, defined in [3.4.3]
KF
ZH : Zone factor, defined in [3.4.4]
The transverse load distribution factors, KH for contact
stress and KF for tooth root bending stress, account for the ZE : Elasticity factor, defined in [3.4.5]
effects of pitch and profile errors on the transversal load dis- ZLS : Load-sharing factor, defined in [3.4.6]
tribution between two or more pairs of teeth in mesh. Z : Helix angle factor, defined in [3.4.7]
The values of KH and KF are given in Tab 30. ZK : Bevel gear ratio factor, defined in [3.4.8].

Table 30 : Transverse load factors KH and KF

Factors KH and KF Limitations


v c ( f pt y ) v
v 2 - 0, 9 + 0, 4 ------------------------------
K H = K F = ----- - - KH 1
------------------
2 Fm t H b 2
v ZL S
2 ( v 1 ) c ( f pt y ) v
v > 2 K H = K F = 0, 9 + 0, 4 ---------------------------
- ------------------------------- - KF 1
----------------
v Fm t H b v Y

Note 1:
c : Mesh stiffness, in N/mm.m, defined in [3.3.4]
f : Larger value of the single pitch deviation of pinion or wheel, in m.
0 ,5 0 ,5 ( Q 5 )
Default value: f p t = 0,3 ( m m n + 0,4 d b i + 4 ) 2 i

In case of optimum profile correction, fpt is to be replaced by fpt / 2


y : Running-in allowance, in m, defined in Tab 31
f : Determinant tangential load at mid-face width on the reference cone, in N:
F = F KA KV KH

Table 31 : Running-in allowance y

Material y , in m Limitations
St, St (cast), GTS (perl.), GGG (perl.), 160 if 5 m/s < v 10 mm/s: y 12800 / H,lim
-------------- f p t
GGG (bai.), V, V (cast) H , lim if 10 m/s < v: y 6400 / H,lim
if 5 m/s < v 10 mm/s: y 22
GGG (ferr.), GG 0,275 fpt
if 10 m/s < v: y 11
Eh, IF, NT (nitr.), NV (nitr.), NV (nitrocar.) 0,075 fpt y 3
Note 1: fpt is defined in Tab 30 and H,lim is defined in [3.4.10].
Note 2: When material of the pinion differs from that of the wheel: y = 0,5 (y1 + y2)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 125


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

3.4.3 Mid-zone factor ZM-B 3.4.8 Bevel gear factor ZK


The mid-zone factor ZMB accounts for the difference of The bevel gear factor ZK is an empirical factor which
contact pressure between the pitch point and the determi- accounts for the difference between bevel and cylindrical
nant point of load application. gears loading.
ZMB is to be determined as follows: ZK is to be determined as follows:

tan vt ZK = 0,8
Z M B = -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
2 2
d va1 d va2 3.4.9 Permissible contact stress HP
- 1 F 1 -------
-------- - 1 F 2 -------
--------
2 Z v1 2 z v2
d vb 1 d vb 2 The permissible contact stress HP , in N/mm2, is to be deter-
where F1 and F2 are defined according to the following con- mined separately for pinion and wheel, using the following
ditions: formula:

if 0 v < 1: H , l im
HP = ------------- Z NT Z L Z V Z R Z W Z X
SH
F1 = 2 + (v 2) v
where:
F2 = 2 v 2 + (2 v) v
H,lim : Endurance limit for contact stress, defined in
if v 1:
[3.4.10]
F1 = v
ZNT : Life factor for contact stress, defined in [3.4.11]
F2 = v
ZL, ZV, ZR: Lubrication, speed and roughness factors,
respectively, defined in [3.4.12]
3.4.4 Zone factor ZH
ZW : Hardness ratio factor, defined in [3.4.13]
The zone factor ZH accounts for the influence on the hert-
zian pressure of tooth flank curvature at the pitch point. ZX : Size factor for contact stress, defined in [3.4.14]
ZH is to be determined as follows: SH : Safety factor for contact stress, defined in [3.4.15].

cos vb 3.4.10 Endurance limit for contact stress H,lim


Z H = 2 ---------------------------
-
sin ( 2 vt ) The endurance limit for contact stress H,lim , in N/mm2, is
the limit of repeated contact stress which can be perma-
3.4.5 Elasticity factor ZE nently endured.
The elasticity factor ZE accounts for the influence of the The values to be adopted for H,lim are given in [2.4.9] in
metal properties (module of elasticity E and Poisson's ratio relation to the type of steel employed and the heat treat-
) on the hertzian pressure. ment performed.
The values of ZE to be used are given in [2.4.5].
3.4.11 Life factor for contact stress ZNT
3.4.6 Load-sharing factor ZLS The life factor ZNT accounts for the influence of limited ser-
The load-sharing factor ZLS accounts for load sharing vice life on the permissible contact stress.
between two or more pairs of teeth. Some values of ZNT are given in Tab 17 for information.
ZLS is to be determined as follows: The value of ZNT to be used will be given special consider-
if v > 2 and v > 1: ation by the Society depending on the equipments arrange-
0, 5
ment and use.
2 1, 5 4-
ZLS = 1 + 2 1 ------- 1 -----
2
v v 3.4.12 Lubrication factor ZL , speed factor ZV and

roughness factor ZR
if v 2: The lubricant factor ZL accounts for the influence of the type
ZLS = 1 of the lubricant and the influence of its viscosity, the speed
factor ZV accounts for the influence of the pitch line veloc-
otherwise, an alternative calculation should be supplied
ity, and the roughness factor ZR accounts for the influence
and will be given special consideration by the Society.
of the surface roughness on the surface endurance capacity.
3.4.7 Helix angle factor Z These factors are to be determined according to the formu-
The helix angle factor Z accounts for the influence of helix lae of [2.4.11], using the following parameters:
angle on the surface durability, allowing for such variables vmt : Linear speed at mean pitch diameter, in m/s. It is
as the distribution of the load along the lines of contact. to replace v in the calculation of ZV
Z is to be determined as follows: red : Relative radius of curvature, in mm:
1 a v sin t uv
Z = -------------------- - ---------------------
re d = ------------------------ -
cos m cos v b ( 1 + u v ) 2

126 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

3.4.13 Hardness ratio factor ZW 3.5.3 Tooth form factor YFa


The hardness ratio factor ZW accounts for the increase of the The tooth form factor YFa takes into account the effect of the
surface durability. This factor is to be determined according tooth form on the nominal bending stress, assuming the
to the formulae of [2.4.12], using the following parameters: load applied at the outer point of a single pair tooth contact
vmt : Linear speed at mean pitch diameter, in m/s. It is of the virtual cylindrical gears in normal section.
to replace v in the calculations YFa is to be determined separately for the pinion and for the
red : Relative radius of curvature, in mm, as defined wheel, using the following formula:
in [3.4.12] hFa
6 --------- - cos F a n
uv : Virtual reduction ratio. It is to replace u in the mmn
YFa = ------------------------------------------
calculations. SF n 2
---------- cos n
mm n
3.4.14 Size factor ZX
where:
The size factor ZX accounts for the influence of tooth dimen-
sions on permissible contact stress and reflects the non-uni- hFa : Bending moment arm, in mm:
formity of material properties. hFa dv a n
- = 1
--------- --- ( cos a sin a tan F a n ) --------- -
ZX is in general equal to 1. mmn 2 mmn
G a0
The value ZX to be used will be given special consideration z v n cos --- ------------ ---------
-
3 cos m m n
by the Society depending on the material.
sFn : Tooth root chord at the critical section, in mm:
3.4.15 Safety factor for contact stress SH
sF n G a 0
The values to be adopted for the safety factor for contact - = z v n sin --- + 3 ------------ ---------
--------- -
mmn 3 cos m m n
stress SH are given in Tab 18.
G : Parameter defined by:
3.5 Calculation of tooth bending strength a0 hf P
G = ---------
- ---------
- + xh
m m n mmn
3.5.1 General
: Parameter defined by:
The criterion for tooth root bending stress is based on the
local tensile stress at the tooth root in the direction of the 2G
= ------------ tan H
tooth height. zv n
The tooth root bending stress F , defined in [3.5.2], is not to This transcendental equation is to be calculated
exceed the permissible tooth root bending stress FP defined by iteration
in [3.5.8]. H : Parameter defined by:
3.5.2 Tooth root bending stress F 2 E
H = ------- --- ---------- ---
The tooth root bending stress F is to be determined as fol- z v n 2 mm n 3
lows: E : Parameter defined by:
Fm t
F = -----------------
- Y Y Y Y Y K K K K K
b mm n Fa Sa LS K A V F F E = --- x s m m n h fP tan n +
4

where: s pr a0
- ( 1 sin n ) --------------
-------------- -
cos n cos n
YFa : Tooth form factor, defined in [3.5.3]
YSa : Stress correction factor, defined in [3.5.4] spr : Residual fillet undercut, in mm:

Y : Contact ratio factor, defined in [3.5.5] spr = pr q

YLS : Load sharing factor, defined in [3.5.6] The parameters of the virtual gears are defined as follows:
YK : Bevel gear factor, defined in [3.5.7] Fan : Load direction angle:
KA : Application factor (see [3.3.2]) Fan = an a
K : Load sharing factor (see [3.3.3]) a : Parameter defined by:
KV : Dynamic factor (see [3.3.4]) o, 5 + 2 ( tan n x h + x s )
a = -------------------------------------------------------------------
- + inv n inva n
KF : Face load distribution factor (see [3.3.5]) zv n
KF : Transverse load distribution factor (see [3.3.6]). with inv, involute function, equal to:
When a shot-peening treatment of the tooth root is applied inv = tan
according to a process agreed by the Society, a reduction of
an : Form factor pressure angle:
the bending stress F (depending on the material category,
but without being over 10%) could be taken in consider- d v bn
cos a n = ---------
ation only for carburized case-hardened steel gears. dvan

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 127


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

3.5.4 Stress correction factor YSa 3.5.8 Permissible tooth root bending stress FP
The stress correction factor YSa is used to convert the nomi- The permissible tooth root bending stress FP is to be deter-
nal bending stress to local tooth root stress. mined separately for pinion and for wheel, using the follow-
ing formula:
YSa is to be determined as follows:
FE
F P = ------
- Y d Y NT Y r e IT Y R re I T YX
1
------------------------------------------- SF
1 , 21 + ( 2, 3 ) L a
Y S a = ( 1, 2 + 0, 13 L a ) q s
where:
where: FE : Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress,
defined in [3.5.9]
sF n
L a = ------
- Yd : Design factor, defined in [3.5.10]
h Fa
YNT : Life factor for tooth root bending stress, defined
with sFn and hFa defined in [3.5.3] in [3.5.11]
qs : Notch parameter: YreIT : Relative notch sensitivity factor, defined in
[3.5.12]
s Fn
q s = --------
- YRreIT : Relative surface factor, defined in [3.5.13]
2 F
YX : Size factor for tooth root bending stress, defined
with sFn defined in [3.5.3] in [3.5.14]
Note 1: The notch parameter should be within the range: SF : Safety factor for tooth root bending stress,
1 qs < 8 defined in [3.5.15].

F : Fillet radius at contact point of 30 tangent, in 3.5.9 Endurance limit for tooth root bending stress FE
mm: The endurance limit for tooth root bending stress FE is the
local tooth root stress which can be permanently endured.
F a0 2G
2
--------- - + ---------------------------------------------------------------
- = ---------
mm n m m n cos ( z vn cos 2 2G ) The values to be adopted for FE are given in [2.5.9]] in rela-
tion to the type of steel employed and the heat treatment
performed.
3.5.5 Contact ratio factor Y
The contact ratio factor Y converts the load application at 3.5.10 Design factor Yd
the tooth tip to the decisive point of load application. The design factor Yd takes into account the influence of load
reversing and shrink fit pre-stressing on the tooth root
Y is to be determined as follows:
strength.
if v 1: Yd is defined in [2.5.10].
0, 75 0, 75
Y = 0, 25 + ------------- v ------------- 0, 375 3.5.11 Life factor YNT
v v
The life factor YNT accounts for the influence of limited ser-
if v > 1: vice life on the permissible tooth root bending stress.

Y = 0,625 Some values of YNT are given in Tab 20 for information.


The value YNT to be used will be given special consideration
Note 1: A minimum of 0,625 should always be taken for Y. by the Society depending on the equipments arrangement
and use.
3.5.6 Load sharing factor YLS
3.5.12 Relative notch sensitivity factor YreIT
The load sharing factor YLS accounts for load sharing
between two or more pairs of teeth. The relative notch sensitivity factor YreIT indicates the extent
to which the theoretically concentrated stress lies above the
YLS is to be determined as follows: fatigue endurance limit.

Y L S = Z LS
2 YreIT is to be determined according to [2.5.12].

3.5.13 Relative surface factor YRreIT


3.5.7 Bevel gear factor YK
The relative surface factor YRreIT takes into account the
The bevel gear factor YK accounts for the difference dependence of the root strength on the surface condition on
between bevel and cylindrical gears loading. the tooth root fillet (roughness).
YK is to be determined as follows: The values to be adopted for YRreIT are given in Tab 22 in
relation to the type of steel employed.
2
1 l bm b- They are valid only when scratches or similar defects
YK = --- - -------
+ -------
2 2 b l bm deeper than 12 Ra are not present.

128 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

3.5.14 Size factor YX 3.6.3 Flash temperature fl


The size factor YX takes into account the decrease of the The flash temperature fl at any point along the path of con-
strength with increasing size. tact, in C, is calculated with the following formula:
The values to be adopted for YX are given in Tab 23 in rela- 0, 5
0, 75 vm t
tion to the type of steel employed and the value of normal fl = m X M X J X G ( X w B t ) ------------
0, 25
-
module mmn. rm

where:
3.5.15 Safety factor for tooth root bending stress SF
The values to be adopted for the safety factor for tooth root m : Mean coefficient of friction, defined in [3.6.4]
bending stress SF are given in Tab 24. XM : Thermo-elastic factor, in KN3/4s1/2m1/2mm,
defined in [3.6.5]
3.6 Calculation of scuffing resistance XJ : Approach factor, defined in [3.6.6]
3.6.1 General XG : Geometry factor, defined in [3.6.7]
The following calculations are requested for equipment run- X : Load sharing factor, defined in [3.6.8]]
ning in supercritical domain i.e. when N > 1,5 (see [3.3.4]).
wBt : Transverse unit load, in N/mm, defined in
The criterion for scuffing resistance is based on the calcula- [3.6.9].
tion of the flash temperature method. According to this
method, the risk of scuffing is assessed as a function of the 3.6.4 Mean coefficient of friction m
properties of gear material, the lubricant characteristics, the
surface roughness of tooth flanks, the sliding velocities and An estimation of the mean coefficient of friction m of com-
the load. mon working conditions could be used with the following
formula:
The interfacial contact temperatures are calculated as the
sum of the interfacial bulk temperature of the moving inter- w Bt 0, 2
face and the fluctuating flash temperature of the moving m = 0, 06 ------------------------
- XL XR
v g C re l C
faces in contact.
where:
The maximum value of the interfacial contact temperature
reduced by oil temperature is not to exceed 0,8 times the wBt : Transverse unit load, in N/mm (see [2.6.9])
scuffing temperature reduced by oil temperature:
vgC : Sum of tangential velocities in pitch point, in
(B,Max oil) 0,8 (s oil) m/s:
where: vgC = 2 vmt sin vt
B,Max : Maximum contact temperature along the path with the maximum value of vmt equal to 50 m/s
of contact, in C, defined in [3.6.2]
relC : Transverse relative radius of curvature, in mm:
oil : Oil temperature, in C
: Scuffing temperature, in C, defined in [3.6.11]. u tan 1 tan 2
re l C = ------------------------------------------ r sin v t
tan 1 + u tan 2 m
Additionally, the difference between the scuffing tempera-
ture and the contact temperature along the path is not to be XL : Lubricant factor, given in Tab 25
below 30C:
XR : Roughness factor:
(s B,Max) 30C
0 , 25
Other methods of determination of the scuffing resistance R z f1 + R z f 2
-----------------------
-
XR =
2
could be accepted by the Society.

3.6.2 Contact temperature B 3.6.5 Thermo-elastic factor XM


The maximum contact temperature B,Max along the path of The thermo-elastic factor XM accounts for the influence of
contact, in C, is calculated as follows: the material properties of pinion and wheel.
B,Max = Mi + fl,Max The values to be adopted for XM are given in [2.6.5] in rela-
where: tion to the gear material characteristics.
Mi : Interfacial bulk temperature, in C, defined in
3.6.6 Approach factor XJ
[3.6.10]
fl,Max : Maximum flash temperature along the path of The approach factor XJ takes empirically into account an
contact, in C, defined in [3.6.3]. increased scuffing risk in the beginning of the approach
path, due to mesh starting without any previously built up
The flash temperature is to be calculated on at least ten oil film.
points along the path of contact and the maximum of these
values has to be used for the calculation of maximum con- The values to be adopted for XJ are given in [2.6.6] in rela-
tact temperature. tion to the gear material characteristics.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 129


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 32 : Parameter on the line of action

Point

tan tan a 2
A : Lower end point of the path of contact A = --------------2 ----------------
- 1
tan 1 tan v t

AU : Lower end point of buttressing effect AU = A + 0,2 sin vb


AB : Intermediate point between A and B AB = 0,5 (A + B)

tan a 1 2 cos
B : Lower point of single pair tooth contact B = ----------------
- 1 -------------------------1-
tan v t z 1 tan v t

C : Point with parameter equal to 0 C = 0


M : Intermediate point between A and E M = 0,5 (A + E)

tan tan a 2 2 cos


D : Upper point of single pair tooth contact D = -------------2- ----------------
- 1 + --------------------------1
tan 1 tan v t z 1 tan v t

DE : Intermediate point between D and E DE = 0,5 (D + E)


EU : Upper end point of buttressing effect EU = E 0,2 sin vb
tan a 1
E : Upper end point of the path of contact E = ----------------
-1
tan v t

Note 1:
: Transverse tip pressure angle of pinion and wheel, in rad:
cos vt
cos ai = -------------------------------------------------------
-
1 + 2 hf0i ( cos i ) d m i

3.6.7 Geometry factor XG where:


The geometry factor XG is calculated according to the fol- KA : Application factor (see [3.3.2])
lowing formula:
KV : Dynamic factor (see [3.3.4])
0, 5 tan 0, 5
( 1 + ) 1 + --------------1
1 1 0, 25 tan 2 KH : Face load distribution factor (see [3.3.5])
XG = 0, 51 X -------------- + -------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------
tan 1 tan 2 tan 0, 25
0, 25
(1 + ) 1 -------------1- KH : Transverse load distribution factor (see [3.3.6])
tan 2
K : Load sharing factor (see [3.3.3]).
where:
X : Angle factor, equal to: 3.6.10 Interfacial bulk temperature Mi
X = 1,22 (sin vt)0,25 (cos vt)0,5 (cos vb)0,25
The interfacial bulk temperature Mi may be suitably aver-
: Parameter of the point on the line of action, aged from the two overall bulk temperatures of the teeth in
defined in Tab 32. contact, M1 and M2. An estimation of Mi , given in
[2.6.10], could be used in general configurations.
3.6.8 Load sharing factor X
The load sharing factor X accounts for the load sharing of 3.6.11 Scuffing temperature
succeeding pairs of meshing teeth. It is defined as a function
of the value of the parameter in the line of action, increas- The scuffing temperature S may be determined according
ing at the approach path of transverse double contact. to the following formula:
The values to be adopted for X are given in [2.6.8].
S = 80 + (0,85 + 1,4 XW) XL (SFZG 1)2
The parameter of the line of action to be used is given in
Tab 32. where:

XW : Structural factor given in Tab 27


3.6.9 Transverse unit load wBt
The transverse unit load wBt is calculated according to the XL : Lubricant factor given in Tab 25
following formula:
SFZG : Load stage where scuffing occurs, according to
Fm t gear tests, such as Ryder, FZG-Ryder, FZG L-42
w Bt = K A K V K H K H K ------
-
b or FZG A/8 3/90.

130 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

4 Design and construction - except 4.2.3 Tooth tips and ends


tooth load capacity a) All sharp edges on the tips and ends of gear teeth are to
be removed after cutting and finishing of teeth.

4.1 Materials b) Where the ratio b/d exceeds 0,3, the ends of pinion and
wheel are to be chamfered to an angle between 45 and
4.1.1 General 60 degrees. The chamfering depth is to be at least equal
to 1,5 mn.
a) Forged, rolled and cast materials used in the manufac-
turing of shafts, couplings, pinions and wheels are to 4.2.4 Surface treatment
comply with the requirements of NR216 Materials.
a) The hardened layer on surface-hardened gear teeth is to
b) Materials other than steels will be given special consid- be uniform and extended over the whole tooth flank
eration by the Society. and fillet.

4.1.2 Steels for pinions and wheel rims b) Where the pinions and the toothed portions of the
wheels are case-hardened and tempered, the teeth
a) Steels intended for pinions and wheels are to be flanks are to be ground while the bottom lands of the
selected considering their compatibility in service. In teeth remain only case-hardened. The superficial hard-
particular, for through-hardened pinion / wheel pairs, ness of the case-hardened zone is to be at least equal to
the hardness of the pinion teeth is to exceed that of the 56 C Rockwell units.
corresponding wheel. For this purpose, the minimum
tensile strength of the pinion material is to exceed that c) Where the pinions and the toothed part of the wheel are
of the wheel by at least 15%. case hardened, the thickness of the hardened layer after
finish grinding is to be at least equal to the following
b) The minimum tensile strength of the core is not to be value:
less than:
T = 0, 5 m n + 1, 1 ( 0, 7 )
750 N/mm2 for case-hardened teeth
Thickness of the hardened layer for case hardening is
800 N/mm2 for induction-hardened or nitrided the depth, measured normally to the tooth flank surface,
teeth. where the local hardness falls below the value of 52,5
HRC (550 HV).
4.2 Teeth d) Where the pinions and the toothed portions of the
wheels are nitrided, the hardened layer is to comply
4.2.1 Manufacturing accuracy with Tab 33.
a) The standard of accuracy of teeth of propulsion machin- e) The use of other processes of superficial hardening of
ery gearing is to correspond to that of quality class 4 as the teeth, such as flame hardening, will be given special
defined by ISO 1328-1 1997. A lower standard of accu- consideration, in particular as regards the values to be
racy (i.e. ISO quality class higher than 4) may be adopted for H,lim and FE.
accepted for auxiliary machinery gearing and for partic-
ular cases of propulsion machinery gearing of auxiliary
Table 33 : Characteristics of the hardened layer
ships subject to special consideration by the owner. for nitrided gears
b) Where the quality class of the gear is indicated by the
gear Manufacturer according to another Standard Minimum
accepted by the Society, the corresponding accuracy of thickness of Minimum hardness
Type of steel
teeth is to be to the satisfaction of the Society. hardened layer (HV)
(mm) (1)
c) Mean roughness (Ra) of shaved or ground teeth is not to
Nitriding steel 0,6 500 (at 0,25 mm depth)
exceed 0,7 m.
Other steels 0,3 450 (surface)
d) Wheels are to be cut by cutters with a method suitable
(1) Depth of the hardened layer to core hardness.
for the expected type and quality. Whenever necessary,
When the grinding of nitrided teeth is performed, the
the cutting and grinding is to be carried out in a temper-
depth of the hardened layer to be taken into account is
ature controlled environment.
the depth after grinding.

4.2.2 Tooth root


4.3 Wheels and pinions
Teeth are to be well faired and rounded at the root. The fillet
radius at the root of the teeth, within a plane normal to the 4.3.1 General
teeth, is to be not less than 0,25 m n.
Wheel bodies are to be so designed that radial deflections
Profile-grinding of gear teeth is to be performed in such a and distorsions under load are prevented, so as to ensure a
way that no notches are left in the fillet. satisfactory meshing of teeth.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 131


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

4.3.2 Welding M : Bending moment on the shaft, in Nm


a) Where welding is employed for the construction of Kd : Coefficient having the following values:
wheels, the welding procedure is to be submitted to the for solid shafts: Kd = 0
Society for approval. Welding processes and their quali-
fication are to comply with NR216 Materials. for hollow shafts, Kd is equal to the ratio of
the hole diameter to the outer shaft diame-
b) Stress relieving treatment is to be performed after weld- ter.
ing.
Where Kd 0,3: Kd = 0 may be taken.
c) Examination of the welded joints is to be performed by
Note 1: The values of dS, T and M refer to the cross-section of the
means of magnetic particle or dye penetrant tests to the
shaft concerned.
satisfaction of the Surveyor. Suitable arrangements are to
be made to permit the examination of the internal side Note 2: In correspondence of keyways dS shall be increased by
of the welded joints. 10%.
As an alternative to the above given formula, the Society
4.3.3 Shrink-fits may accept direct strength calculations showing that the
a) The shrink fit assembly of wheel body and shaft is to be equivalent stress represented in a diagram average stress vs.
designed with a safety factor against slippage of not less alternate stress falls below the lines defined by the points
than 2,8 Ka . having coordinates:

For different type of drives the value to be adopted will ( R m ;0 ), ( 0 ; fa 1, 5 )


be specially considered. and
b) The shrink fit assembly of wheel rim and body is to be
( 0, 8 Rs ;0 ) , ( 0 ; 0, 8 R s )
designed with a safety factor against slippage of not less
than 5. where fais the pure alternate bending fatigue limit for a sur-
Note 1: The manufacturer is to ensure that the maximum torque vival probability not less than 80%.
transmitted during the clutch engagement does not exceed the
nominal torque by more than 20%. 4.4.3 Quill shafts

c) The shrink-fit assembly is to take into account the ther- The minimum diameter of quill shafts subject to torque only
mal expansion differential between the shrunk-on parts is not to be less than the value dQS, in mm, given by the fol-
in the service conditions. lowing formula:
1
---
4.3.4 Bolting 27000 T 3
dQ S = 7 ,65 + ---------------- -----------------4
R S ,m i n 1 Kd
The bolting assembly of:
rim and wheel body RS,min and Kd being defined in [4.4.2].
wheel body and shaft,
4.4.4 Bearings
is to be designed according to Ch 1, Sec 7, [2.5.1]. a) Thrust bearings and their supports are to be so designed
The nuts are to be suitably locked by means other than as to avoid detrimental deflections under load.
welding. b) Life duration of bearings L10h calculated according to
ISO 281-1, is not be less than 40000 hours. Shorter
4.4 Shafts and bearings durations may be accepted on the basis of the actual
load time distribution, and subject to the agreement of
4.4.1 General the owner.
Shafts and their connections, in particular flange couplings
and shrink-fits connections, are to comply with the provi- 4.5 Casings
sions of Ch 1, Sec 7.
4.5.1 General
4.4.2 Pinion and wheel shafts Gear casings are to be of sufficient stiffness such that mis-
The minimum diameter of pinion and gear wheel shafts is alignment, external loads and thermal effects in all service
not to be less than the value dS, in mm, given by the follow- conditions do not adversely affect the overall tooth contact.
ing formula:
4.5.2 Welded casings
1 1
---
28000 2
170000 2 6
1
---
3 a) Carbon content of steels used for the construction of
dS = 10 ,2 + ---------------- T + ----------------------------- M -----------------4 welded casings is to comply with the provisions of
R S ,m in 412 + R s ,mi n
1 Kd
NR216 Materials.
where: b) The welded joints are to be so arranged that welding
RS,min : Minimum yield strength of the shaft material, in and inspection can be performed satisfactorily. They are
N/mm 2 to be of the full penetration type.
T : Nominal torque transmitted by the shaft, in Nm c) Welded casings are to be stress-relieved after welding.

132 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

Table 34 : Reduction gears / reversing gears

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Main Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by start
Lubricating oil temperature local
Lubricating oil pressure local
L (1) x
Oil tank level local
(1) May be omitted in case of restricted navigation notation

4.5.3 Openings 4.6.3 Filtration


Access or inspection openings of sufficient size are to be a) Forced lubrication systems are to be fitted with a device
provided to permit the examination of the teeth and the which efficiently filters the oil in the circuit.
structure of the wheels.
b) When fitted to gears intended for propulsion machinery
or machinery driving electric propulsion generators,
4.6 Lubrication such filters are to be so arranged that they can be easily
cleaned without stopping the lubrication of the
4.6.1 General machines.
a) Manufacturers are to take care of the following points:
reliable lubrication of gear meshes and bearings is 4.7 Control and monitoring
ensured:
4.7.1 Gears are to be provided with the alarms and safe-
- over the whole speed range, including starting,
guards listed in Tab 34.
stopping and, where applicable, manoeuvring
- for all angles stated in Ch 1, Sec 1, [2.4]
5 Installation
in multi-propellers plants and a transient black-out,
provision is to be made to ensure lubrication of
gears likely to be affected by windmilling. 5.1 General
b) Lubrication by means other than oil circulation under 5.1.1 Manufacturers and shipyards are to take care directly
pressure will be given special consideration. that stiffness of gear seating and alignment conditions of
gears are such as not to adversely affect the overall tooth
4.6.2 Pumps contact and the bearing loads under all operating condi-
a) Gears intended for propulsion or other essential services tions of the ship.
independent gearbox are to be provided with at least 2
lubricating pumps, so arranged as to maintain a suffi- 5.2 Fitting of gears
cient lubrication of the gearbox in the whole speed
range in case of failure of one pump. At least one of the 5.2.1 Means such as stoppers or fitted bolts are to be
pumps is not to be mechanically driven by the gearbox. arranged in the case of gears subject to propeller thrust.
One of the two lubricating pumps could be a common However, where the thrust is transmitted by friction and the
one for the two gearboxes if they are located in the relevant safety factor is not less than 2, such means may be
same compartment. omitted.
b) In the case of gears having a transmitted power not
exceeding 375 kW one of the pumps mentioned in a) 6 Certification, inspection and testing
may be a spare pump ready to be connected to the
reduction gear lubricating oil system, provided disas- 6.1 General
sembling and reassembling operations can be carried
out on board in a short time. 6.1.1
c) Provisions are to be made to maintain a sufficient lubri- a) Inspection and testing of shafts and their connections
cation of the gearbox in: (flange couplings, hubs, bolts, pins) are to be carried out
black-out conditions, and in accordance with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 7.
in any operating conditions mentioned in the ship b) For inspection of welded joints of wheels, refer to
specification. [4.3.2].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 133


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 6

6.2 Workshop inspection and testing 6.2.4 Verification of cutting accuracy


Examination of the accuracy of tooth cutting is to be per-
6.2.1 Testing of materials
formed in the presence of the Surveyor. Records of mea-
Chemical composition and mechanical properties are to be surements of errors, tolerances and clearances of teeth are
tested in accordance with the applicable requirements of to be submitted at the request of the Surveyor.
NR216 Materials, Ch 2, Sec 3 for the following items:
pinions and wheel bodies 6.2.5 Meshing test
rims
a) A tooth meshing test is to be performed in the presence
plates and other elements intended for propulsion gear of the Surveyor. This test is to be carried out at a load
casings of welded construction. sufficient to ensure tooth contact, with the journals
located in the bearings according to the normal running
6.2.2 Testing of pinion and wheel forgings
conditions. Before the test, the tooth surface is to be
a) Mechanical tests of pinions and wheels are to be carried coated with a thin layer of suitable coloured compound.
out in accordance with:
NR216 Materials, Ch 2, Sec 3, [5.6] for normalised b) The results of such test are to demonstrate that the tooth
and tempered or quenched and tempered forgings contact is adequately distributed on the length of the
teeth. Strong contact marks at the end of the teeth are
NR216 Materials, Ch 2, Sec 3, [5.7] for surface-
not acceptable. In case the test is carried out at full load,
hardened forgings.
the contact pattern shall meet with the one requested
b) Non-destructive examination of pinion and wheel forg- under Ch 1, Sec 15, Tab 1.
ings is to be performed in accordance with NR216
Materials, Ch 2, Sec 3, [5.8]. c) In case of helix modification or crowning the tooth
meshing test is to be performed before these corrections
6.2.3 Balancing test will be carried out.
Rotating components, in particular gear wheel and pinion
d) A permanent record of the tooth contact is to be made
shaft assemblies with the coupling part attached, are to
for the purpose of subsequent checking of alignment fol-
undergo a static balancing test.
lowing installation on board.
Propulsion gear wheels and pinion shaft assemblies having
a speed in excess of 150 rpm are also to undergo a dynamic 6.2.6 Hydrostatic tests
balancing test after finish machining; the residual imbal-
ance shall be as small as possible and anyway, is not exceed a) Hydraulic or pneumatic clutches are to be hydrostati-
the Grade 2,5 according to ISO 1940. cally tested before assembly to 1,5 times the maximum
working pressure.
Auxiliary gear wheels and pinion shaft assemblies are also
to undergo a dynamic balancing test after finish machining, b) Pressure piping, pumps casings, valves and other fittings
when n d > 1,5 E9; the residual imbalance shall not are to be hydrostatically tested in accordance with the
exceed the Grade 2,5 according to ISO 1940. requirements of Ch 1, Sec 10, [19].

134 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

SECTION 7 MAIN PROPULSION SHAFTING

1 General 2 Design and construction

1.1 Application 2.1 Materials

1.1.1 This Section applies to shafts, couplings, clutches and 2.1.1 General
other shafting components transmitting power for main pro- The use of other materials or steels having values of tensile
pulsion. strength exceeding the limits given in [2.1.2], [2.1.3] and
[2.1.4] will be considered by the Society in each case.
For shafting components in engines, turbines, gears and
thrusters, see Ch 1, Sec 2, Ch 1, Sec 4, Ch 1, Sec 5, Ch 1, 2.1.2 Shaft materials
Sec 6 and Ch 1, Sec 12, respectively; for propellers, see In general, shafts are to be of forged steel having tensile
Ch 1, Sec 8. strength, Rm, between 400 and 800 N/mm 2.
For vibrations, see Ch 1, Sec 9.
2.1.3 Couplings, flexible couplings, hydraulic
couplings
1.2 Documentation to be submitted Non-solid-forged couplings and stiff parts of elastic cou-
plings subjected to torque are to be of forged or cast steel,
1.2.1 The Manufacturer is to submit to the Society the doc- or nodular cast iron.
uments listed in Tab 1 for approval. Rotating parts of hydraulic couplings may be of grey cast
Plans of power transmitting parts and shaft liners listed in iron, provided that the peripheral speed does not exceed
Tab 1 are to include the relevant material specifications. 40m/s.

Table 1 : Documentation to be submitted

No Document (drawings, calculations, etc.)


1 Shafting arrangement (1)
2 Thrust shaft
3 Intermediate shafts
4 Propeller shaft
5 Shaft liners, relevant manufacture and welding procedures, if any
6 Couplings and coupling bolts
7 Flexible couplings (2)
8 Sterntube
9 Details of sterntube glands
10 Oil piping diagram for oil lubricated propeller shaft bearings
11 Shaft alignment calculation, see also [3.3]
(1) This drawing is to show the entire shafting, from the main engine coupling flange to the propeller. The location of the thrust
block, and the location and number of shafting bearings (type of material and length) are also to be shown.
(2) The Manufacturer of the elastic coupling is also to submit the following data:
allowable mean transmitted torque (static) for continuous operation
maximum allowable shock torque
maximum allowable speed of rotation
maximum allowable values for radial, axial and angular misalignment
In addition, when the torsional vibration calculation of main propulsion system is required (see Ch 1, Sec 9), the following data
are also to be submitted:
allowable alternating torque amplitude and power loss for continuous operation, as a function of frequency and/or mean
transmitted torque
static and dynamic stiffness, as a function of frequency and/or mean transmitted torque
moments of inertia of the primary and secondary halves of the coupling
damping coefficient or damping capability
properties of rubber components
for steel springs of couplings: chemical composition and mechanical properties of steel employed.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 135


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

2.1.4 Coupling bolts Q : in the case of solid shafts: Q = 0


Coupling bolts are to be of forged, rolled or drawn steel. in the case of hollow shafts: Q = ratio of the
In general, the value of the tensile strength of the bolt mate- hole diameter to the outer shaft diameter in
rial RmB is to comply with the following requirements: the section concerned
R m RmB 1,7 R m where Q 0,3, Q = 0 is to be taken
Hollow shafts whose longitudinal axis does
R mB 1000 N/mm2.
not coincide with the longitudinal hole axis
2.1.5 Shaft liners will be specially considered by the Society
in each case
Liners are to be of metallic corrosion resistant material com-
plying with the applicable requirements of NR216 Materials F : F = 95 for main propulsion systems pow-
and with the approved specification, if any; in the case of ered by diesel engines fitted with slip type
liners fabricated in welded lengths, the material is to be rec- coupling, by turbines or by electric motors;
ognised as suitable for welding. F = 100 for main propulsion systems pow-
ered by diesel engines fitted with other type
In general, they are to be manufactured from castings.
of couplings
For small shafts, the use of liners manufactured from pipes k : Factor whose value is given in Tab 2 depending
instead of castings may be considered. upon the different design features of the shafts.
Where shafts are protected against contact with seawater For shaft design features other than those given
not by metal liners but by other protective coatings, the in the Table, the value of k will be specially
coating procedure is to be approved by the Society. considered by the Society in each case
2.1.6 Sterntubes n : Speed of rotation of the shaft, in r.p.m., corre-
sponding to power P
Sterntubes are to comply with the requirements of Pt B, Ch
8, Sec 2, [6.7]. P : Maximum continuous power of the propulsion
machinery for which the classification is
requested, in kW as defined in Section 1, 2.6.
2.2 Shafts - Scantling The scantling of the shafting is made on this
2.2.1 General basis power, a verification of the fatigue stress is
made on a basis of a life factor corresponding to
For the check of the scantling, the method given in [2.2.2]
10 h at 110% PMC
and [2.2.3] or [2.2.4] apply for intermediate shafts and pro-
peller shafts. The direct stress calculation method as per Rm : Value of the minimum tensile strength of the
[2.2.4] should rather be applied. shaft material, in N/mm2. Whenever the use of a
steel having Rm in excess of 800 N/mm2 is
The scantling of the propulsion shafting is to be done for the
allowed in accordance with [2.1], the value of
power determined as per [2.2.4]. The fatigue strength is to
Rm to be introduced in the above formula will
be verified for the duration of the trial with power up to
110%. be subject to special consideration by the Soci-
ety, but in general it is not to be taken higher
2.2.2 Intermediate and thrust shafts than 800 N/mm2. In cases of stainless steels and
The minimum diameter of intermediate and thrust shafts is in other particular cases, at the discretion of the
not to be less than the value d, in mm, given by the follow- Society, the value of Rm to be introduced in the
ing formula: above formula will be specially considered.
13 The scantlings of intermediate shafts inside tubes or stern-
P 560
- -----------------------
d = F k ----------------------------- tubes will be subject to special consideration by the Society.
n ( 1 Q 4 ) R m + 160
Where intermediate shafts inside sterntubes are water lubri-
where: cated, the requirements of [2.4.7] are to be applied.

Table 2 : Values of factor k

For intermediate shafts with For thrust shafts external to engines


In way of axial bearing,
Integral coupling Shrink fit Radial bores, Longitudinal On both sides of
Keyways where a roller bearing is
flange coupling transverse holes slots thrust collar
used as a thrust bearing
1,00 (1) 1,00 1,10 (2) 1,10 (3) 1,20 (4) 1,10 1,10
(1) Value applicable in the case of fillet radii in accordance with the provisions of [2.5.1].
(2) After a distance of not less than 0,2 d from the end of the keyway, the shaft diameter may be reduced to the diameter calculated
using k = 1,0. Fillet radii in the transverse section of the bottom of the keyway are to be not less than 0,0125 d, d being the
diameter as calculated above using k = 1,0.
(3) Value applicable in the case of diameter of bore not exceeding 0,3 d, d being as defined in (2).
(4) Value normally applicable in the case of slot having length not exceeding 1,4 d and width not exceeding 0,2 d, d being as
defined in Note (2), however to be justified on a case by case basis by the Manufacturers.

136 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

2.2.3 Propeller shafts 2.3 Liners


The minimum diameter of the propeller shaft is not to be
less than the value dP, in mm, given by the following for- 2.3.1 General
mula: Metal liners or other protective coatings approved by the
Society are required where propeller shafts are not made of
13
P 560 corrosion-resistant material.
- -----------------------
d P = 100 k P -----------------------------
n ( 1 Q 4 ) R m + 160
Metal liners are generally to be continuous; however, dis-
where: continuous liners, i.e. liners consisting of two or more sepa-
rate lengths, may be accepted by the Society on a case by
kp : Factor whose value, depending on the different
case basis, provided that:
constructional features of shafts, is given below.
they are fitted in way of all supports
The other symbols have the same meaning as in [2.2.2].
the shaft portion between liners, likely to come into
For the calculation of dP, the value of Rm to be introduced in contact with sea water, is protected with a coating of
the above formula is generally to be taken not higher than suitable material with characteristics, fitting method and
600 N/mm 2. thickness approved by the Society.
In cases of stainless steels and in other particular cases, at 2.3.2 Scantling
the discretion of the Society, the value of Rm to be intro-
The thickness of metal liners fitted on propeller shafts or on
duced in the above formula will be specially considered. In intermediate shafts inside sterntubes is to be not less than
general, the diameter of the part of the propeller shaft the value t, in mm, given by the following formula:
located forward of the forward sterntube seal may be gradu-
ally reduced to the diameter of the intermediate shaft. d + 230
t = -------------------
32
The values of factor kP to be introduced in the above for-
mula are to be taken as follows: where:
d : Actual diameter of the shaft, in mm.
kP = 1,26, for propeller shafts where:
Between the sternbushes, the above thickness t may be
- the propeller is keyed on to the shaft taper in com- reduced by 25%.
pliance with the requirements of [2.5.5]
The shrinkage induced equivalent stress in the liner is not
kP = 1,22, for propeller shafts where: exceed 70% of liner yield strength; a calculation in this
- the propeller is keyless fitted on to the shaft taper by respect is to be submitted.
a shrinkage method in compliance with Ch 1, Sec 8,
[3.1.2], or the propeller boss is attached to an inte- 2.4 Stern tube bearings
gral propeller shaft flange in compliance with
[2.5.1] 2.4.1 General
- the sterntube of the propeller shaft is oil lubricated The bearings are to be so designed and lubricated as to
and provided with oil sealing glands approved by withstand the continuous operation of the propulsion plant
the Society or when the sterntube is water lubricated at the minimum rotating speed mentioned in the ship speci-
and the propeller shaft is fitted with a continuous fication.
liner.
2.4.2 Oil lubricated aft bearings of antifriction metal
The above values of kP apply to the portion of propeller a) The length of bearings lined with white metal or other
shaft between the forward edge of the aftermost shaft bear- antifriction metal and with oil glands of a type approved
ing and the forward face of the propeller boss or the forward by the Society is to be not less than twice the rule diam-
face of the integral propeller shaft flange for the connection eter of the shaft in way of the bearing.
to the propeller boss. In no case is the length of this portion b) The length of the bearing may be less than that given in
of propeller shaft to be less than 2,5 times the rule diameter (a) above, provided the nominal bearing pressure is not
dP obtained with the above formula. more than 0,8 N/mm2, as determined by static bearing
The determination of factor kP for shaft design features other reaction calculations taking into account shaft and pro-
than those given above will be specially considered by the peller weight, as exerting solely on the aft bearing,
Society in each case. divided by the projected area of the shaft.
For the length of the propeller shaft between the forward However, the minimum bearing length is to be not less
edge of the aftermost shaft bearing and the forward edge of than 1,5 times its actual inner diameter.
the forward sterntube seal:
2.4.3 Oil lubricated aft bearings of synthetic rubber,
kP = 1,15 is to be taken in any event. reinforced resin or plastics material
a) For bearings of synthetic rubber, reinforced resin or plas-
2.2.4 Direct stress calculation method tics material which are approved by the Society for use
Shaft dimensions may be approved on the basis of docu- as oil lubricated sternbush bearings, the length of the
mentation concerning fatigue considerations, or other bearing is to be not less than twice the rule diameter of
methods to be accepted by the society. the shaft in way of the bearing.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 137


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

b) The length of the bearing may be less than that given in 2.5 Couplings
(a) above provided the nominal bearing pressure is not
more than 0,6 N/mm2, as determined according to 2.5.1 Flange couplings
[2.4.2], item b).
a) Flange couplings of intermediate and thrust shafts and
However, the minimum length of the bearing is to be the flange of the forward coupling of the propeller shaft
not less than 1,5 times its actual inner diameter. are to have a thickness not less than 0,2 times the rule
diameter of the solid intermediate shaft and not less
Where the material has proven satisfactory testing and than the coupling bolt diameter calculated for a tensile
operating experience, consideration may be given to an strength equal to that of the corresponding shaft.
increased bearing pressure.
For hollow shafts, however, the flange does not need to
have a thickness higher than 1,5 the shaft wall thickness
2.4.4 Water lubricated aft bearings of lignum vitae
or antifriction metal or higher than the bolt diameter, which is greater.

Where the bearing comprises staves of wood (known as The fillet radius at the base of solid forged flanges is to
be not less than 0,08 times the actual shaft diameter.
"lignum vitae") or is lined with antifriction metal, the length
of the bearing is to be not less than 4 times the rule diame- The fillet may be formed of multi-radii in such a way
ter of the shaft in way of the bearing. that the stress concentration factor will not be greater
than that for a circular fillet with radius 0,08 times the
2.4.5 Water lubricated aft bearings of synthetic actual shaft diameter.
materials In case the shaft or non-integral coupling diameter in
a) Where the bearing is constructed of synthetic materials way of the fillet is larger than the minimum required
which are approved by the Society for use as water Rule diameter, the above fillet radius is not to cause a
lubricated sternbush bearings, such as rubber or plas- stress in the fillet higher than that caused in the solid
tics, the length of the bearing is to be not less than forged flange as above.
4 times the rule diameter of the shaft in way of the bear- Fillets are to have a smooth finish and are not to be
ing. recessed in way of nuts and bolt heads.
b) For a bearing design substantiated by experimental data b) Where the propeller is connected to an integral propel-
to the satisfaction of the Society, consideration may be ler shaft flange, the thickness of the flange is to be not
given to a bearing length less than 4 times, but in no less than 0,25 times the rule diameter of the aft part of
case less than 2 times, the rule diameter of the shaft in the propeller shaft. The fillet radius at the base of the
way of the bearing. flange is to be not less than 0,125 times the actual diam-
eter.
2.4.6 Oil lubrication system The strength of coupling bolts of the propeller boss to
For oil lubricated bearings, provision for oil cooling is to be the flange is to be proved by means of suitable calcula-
made. tions.

A gravity tank is to be fitted to supply lubricating oil to the c) Non-solid forged flange couplings and associated keys
sterntube; the tank is to be located above the deepest subdi- are to be of a strength equivalent to that of the shaft.
vision waterline. They are to be carefully fitted and shrunk on to the
shafts, and the connection is to be such as to reliably
Oil sealing glands are to be suitable for the various sea resist the vibratory torque and astern pull.
water temperatures which may be encountered in service.
d) For couplings of intermediate and thrust shafts and for
2.4.7 Sterntube water system the forward coupling of the propeller shaft having all fit-
ted coupling bolts, the coupling bolt diameter in way of
For water lubricated sterntube bearings, means are to be the joining faces of flanges is not to be less than the
provided to ensure efficient water circulation. In the case of value dB, in mm, given by the following formula:
bearings lined with "lignum vitae" of more than 400 mm in
diameter and bearings lined with synthetic materials, means d 3 ( R m + 160 ) 0 ,5
d B = 0 ,65 -------------------------------------
-
for forced water circulation are to be provided. In the case nB DC Rm B
of bearings of synthetic materials, water flow switch are to
where:
be provided.
d : Rule diameter of solid intermediate shaft, in
The water grooves on the bearings are to be of ample sec- mm
tion such as to ensure efficient water circulation and be
scarcely affected by wear-down, particularly for bearings of nB : Number of fitted coupling bolts
the plastic type. DC : Pitch circle diameter of coupling bolts, in
mm
The shut-off valve or cock controlling the water supply is to
be fitted direct to the stuffing box bulkhead or in way of the Rm : Value of the minimum tensile strength of
water inlet to the sterntube, when this is fitted forward of intermediate shaft material taken for calcu-
such bulkhead. lation of d, in N/mm2

138 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

RmB : Value of the minimum tensile strength of For main propulsion systems powered by diesel
coupling bolt material, in N/mm2. Where, in engines fitted with couplings other than those men-
compliance with [2.1.1], the use of a steel tioned in (a): the mean torque above increased by
having RmB in excess of the limits specified 20% or by the torque due to torsional vibrations,
in [2.1.4] is allowed for coupling bolts, the whichever is the greater.
value of RmB to be introduced in the formula
is not exceed the above limits. 2.5.2 Shrunk couplings

e) Flange couplings with non-fitted coupling bolts may be Non-integral couplings which are shrunk on the shaft by
accepted on the basis of the calculation of bolt tighten- means of the oil pressure injection method or by other
means may be accepted on the basis of the calculation of
ing, bolt stress due to tightening, and assembly instruc-
shrinking and induced stresses, and assembly instructions.
tions.

To this end, the torque based on friction between the To this end, the force due to friction between the mating
surfaces is not to be less than 2,5 times the total force due to
mating surfaces of flanges is not to be less than 2,5 times
the transmitted torque and thrust.
the transmitted torque, assuming a friction coefficient
for steel on steel of 0,18 unless a surface treatment of The values of 0,14 and 0,18 will be taken for the friction
mating surfaces have been done in order to ensure a coefficient in the case of shrinking under oil pressure and
higher friction coefficient to be justified. In addition, the dry shrink fitting, respectively.
bolt stress due to tightening in way of the minimum
cross-section is not to exceed 0,8 times the minimum In addition, the equivalent stress due to shrinkage deter-
yield strength (ReH), or 0,2 proof stress (Rp 0,2), of the bolt mined by means of the von Mises-Hencky criterion in the
material. points of maximum stress of the coupling is not to exceed
0,8 times the minimum yield strength (ReH), or 0,2% proof
The mating surfaces are to have a smooth finish (e.g. stress (Rp0,2), of the material of the part concerned.
Ra1,6), and are be thoroughly cleaned and degreased
prior to assembly. The transmitted torque is that defined under item e) of
[2.5.1].
Transmitted torque has the following meanings:
For the determination of the thrust, see Ch 1, Sec 8, [3.1.2].
For main propulsion systems powered by diesel
engines fitted with slip type or high elasticity cou-
2.5.3 Other couplings
plings, by turbines or by electric motors: the mean
transmitted torque corresponding to the maximum Types of couplings other than those mentioned in [2.5.1]
continuous power P and the relevant speed of rota- and [2.5.2] above will be specially considered by the Soci-
tion n, as defined under [2.2.2]. ety.

Figure 1 : Details of forward end of propeller shaft keyway

0,2 d o
4t
t r

r3
do A-A

2t

r2
C B A B-B

r
r 0,0125 d o
r1 < r2< r 3
r1
C-C

C B A

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 139


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

2.5.4 Flexible couplings The distance from the large end of the propeller shaft
cone to the forward end of the key is to be not less than
a) The scantlings of stiff parts of flexible couplings sub-
20% of the actual propeller shaft diameter in way of the
jected to torque are to be in compliance with the
large end of the cone.
requirements of Article [2].
Key securing screws are not to be located within the first
b) For flexible components, the limits specified by the one-third of the cone length from its large end; the
Manufacturer relevant to static and dynamic torque, edges of the holes are to be carefully faired.
speed of rotation and dissipated power are not to be
exceeded. b) The sectional area of the key subject to shear stress is to
be not less than the value A, in mm2, given by the fol-
c) Where all the engine power is transmitted through one lowing formula:
flexible component only (ships with one propulsion
d3
engine and one shafting only), the flexible coupling is to A = 0 ,4 --------
d PM
be fitted with a torsional limit device or other suitable
means to lock the coupling should the flexible compo- where:
nent break. d : Rule diameter, in mm, of the intermediate
In stiff transmission conditions with the above locking shaft calculated in compliance with the
device, a sufficiently wide speed range is to be pro- requirements of [2.2.2], assuming:
vided, free from excessive torsional vibrations, such as Rm = 400 N/mm2
to enable safe navigation and steering of the ship. As an
dPM : Actual diameter of propeller shaft at mid-
alternative, a spare flexible element is to be provided on
length of the key, in mm.
board.

2.5.5 Propeller shaft keys and keyways 2.6 Monitoring


a) Keyways on the propeller shaft cone are to have well 2.6.1 General
rounded corners, with the forward end faired and pref-
In addition to those given in this item, the requirements of
erably spooned, so as to minimize notch effects and
Part C, Chapter 3 apply.
stress concentrations.
When these constructional features are intended to 2.6.2 Propeller shaft monitoring
obtain an extension of the interval between surveys of For the assignment of the propeller shaft monitoring system
the propeller shaft in accordance with the relevant pro- notation, see Pt E, Ch 5, Sec 2.
visions of Pt A, Ch 2, Sec 2, [6.6], they are to be in com-
pliance with Fig 1. 2.6.3 Indicators
The local indicators for main propulsion shafting to be
Different scantlings may be accepted, provided that at
installed on ships of 500 gross tonnage and upwards with-
least the same reduction in stress concentration is
out automation notations are given in Tab 3. For monitoring
ensured.
of engines, turbines, gears, controllable pitch propellers and
The fillet radius at the bottom of the keyway is to be not thrusters, see Ch 1, Sec 2, Ch 1, Sec 4, Ch 1, Sec 6, Ch 1,
less than 1,25% of the actual propeller shaft diameter at Sec 8 and Ch 1, Sec 12, respectively.
the large end of the cone.
The indicators listed in Tab 3 are to be fitted at a normally
The edges of the key are to be rounded. attended position.

Table 3 : Shafting of propulsion machinery

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Main Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by start
Temperature of each shaft thrust bearing H X
Temperature of each intermediate shaft radial plain H
bearing
Temperature of stern tube bearings (1)
Sterntube oil gravity tank level L
Clutch lubricating oil temperature H X
Clutch oiltank level L
(1) applies only to oil lubricated stern tube bearings and not to external bearings

140 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

3 Arrangement and installation 3.3.2 Required information


The following items should be, as minimum, included in
the documentation for submission:
3.1 General
geometrical description of the shaft model, length,
diameters, and density of material, positions of bearings
3.1.1 The installation is to be carried out according to the
instructions of the component Manufacturer or approved hydrodynamic propeller forces (horizontal and vertical
documents, when required. shear forces and bending moments)
buoyancy effect of propeller, depending on the different
3.1.2 The installation of sterntubes and/or associated non- loading cases of the vessel
shrunk bearings is subject to approval of procedures and expected bearing reactions, for cold, hot static and
materials used. dynamic conditions
slope boring evaluation, (slope in the aft sterntube bearing
3.1.3 The joints between liner parts are not to be located in should normally not exceed 50% of the bearing clearance)
way of supports and sealing glands. bearings influence coefficients table
Metal liners are to be shrunk on to the shafts by pre-heating expected shaft stresses and moments
or forced on by hydraulic pressure with adequate interfer- optimal bearing offsets
ence; dowels, screws or other means of securing the liners
gap and sag values.
to the shafts are not acceptable.
where coupling is ensured by a shrunk coupling, posi-
tion and value of the displacement of its centre of grav-
3.2 Protection of propeller shaft against ity for open shaft conditions
corrosion thermal expansion of the gearbox or the main engine
between cold (20C) and warm conditions (50C)
3.2.1 The propeller shaft surface between the propeller and gear wheel reactions, forces and moments, in different
the sterntube, and in way of propeller nut, is to be suitably machinery conditions
protected in order to prevent any entry of sea water, unless
concerning the coupling conditions (bending moments
the shaft is made of austenitic stainless steel.
and shear forces) between the intermediate shaft for-
ward flange and the Main engine flange, the engine
3.3 Shaft alignment manufacturer diagram should be submitted as in order
to verify if the above mentioned coupling conditions are
3.3.1 In general, the shaft alignment calculations and the situated inside the allowed working condition area,
shipyards shaft alignment procedures indicating the pro- both in dynamic and cold conditions
posed alignment method and alignment verification after manufacturers allowable bearing loads
installation (such as gap and sag, jack-up, laser or strain alignment procedure.
gauges, etc.), for cold, hot static and dynamic conditions,
are to be submitted to the Society for information. 3.3.3 Alignment requirements
However, for the following alignment installations, the cal- The alignment of the propulsion machinery and shafting
culations have to be submitted for the Societys review: and the spacing and location of the bearings are to be such
as to ensure that the loads are compatible with the material
a) Propulsion shafting installations, where the shaft diame- used and the limits prescribed by the Manufacturer.
ter is 350 mm or greater in way of the aftermost stern
The alignment is to be checked on board by the Shipyard by
tube bearing.
a suitable measurement method.
b) Propulsion shafting installations, incorporating two or
more engines. 4 Material tests, workshop inspection
c) Propulsion shafting installations, with one or even no and testing, certification
shaft line bearing, inboard of the forward stern tube
bearing, where the shaft diameter is 200 mm or greater 4.1 Material and non-destructive tests,
in way of the aftermost stern tube bearing. workshop inspections and testing
d) Propulsion shafting installations, incorporating power
4.1.1 Material tests
take-off or power take-in units.
Shafting components are to be tested in accordance with
e) Propulsion shafting installations, where a slope boring Tab 4 and in compliance with the requirements of NR216
should be introduced at the aft stern tube bearing. Materials.
f) Propulsion shafting installations, with bearings with off- Magnetic particle or liquid penetrant tests are required for
sets from a reference line. the parts listed in Tab 4 and are to be effected in positions
mutually agreed upon by the Manufacturer and the Surveyor,
g) Propulsion shafting installations with turbines. where experience shows defects are most likely to occur.
The Society may also require the above calculation in the Ultrasonic testing requires the Manufacturers signed certifi-
case of special arrangements. cate.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 141


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 7

4.1.2 Hydrostatic tests 4.2 Certification


Parts of hydraulic couplings, clutches of hydraulic reverse 4.2.1 Testing certification
gears and control units, hubs and hydraulic cylinders of
Societys certificates (C) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1,
controllable pitch propellers, including piping systems and
[4.2.1]) are required for material tests of components in
associated fittings, are to be hydrostatically tested to1,5
items 1 to 5 of Tab 4.
times the maximum working pressure.
Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1,
Sterntubes, when machine-finished, and propeller shaft lin- [4.2.3]) are required for hydrostatic tests of components
ers, when machine-finished on the inside and with an over- indicated in [4.1.2] and for material and non-destructive
thickness not exceeding 3 mm on the outside, are to be tests of components in items of Tab 4 other than those for
hydrostatically tested to 0,2 MPa. which Societys certificates (C) are required.

Table 4 : Material and non-destructive tests

Material tests Non-destructive tests


Shafting component (Mechanical properties and Magnetic particle or
chemical composition) Ultrasonic
liquid penetrant
1) Coupling (separate from shafts) all all all
2) Propeller shafts all all all
3) Intermediate shafts all all all
4) Thrust shafts all all all
5) Cardan shafts (flanges, crosses, shafts, yokes) all all all
6) Sterntubes all
7) Sterntube bushes and other shaft bearings all
8) Shaft liners all all
9) Coupling bolts or studs all if diameter 40 mm
10) Flexible couplings (metallic parts only) all
11) Thrust sliding-blocks (frame only) all

142 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

SECTION 8 PROPELLERS

1 General 1.2.8 Rake and rake angle


The rake h is the horizontal distance between the line
1.1 Application connecting the blade tip to the blade root and the verti-
cal line crossing the propeller axis in the same point
1.1.1 Propulsion propellers where the prolongation of the first line crosses it, taken
The requirements of this Section apply to propellers of any in correspondence of the blade tip. Aft rakes are consid-
size and type intended for propulsion. They include fixed ered positive, fore rakes are considered negative.
and controllable pitch propellers, including those ducted in The rake angle is the angle at any point between the tan-
fixed nozzles. gent to the generating line of the blade at that point and
1.1.2 Exclusions a vertical line passing at the same point. If the blade
generating line is straight, there is only one rake angle; if
The requirements of this Section do not apply to propellers
it is curved there are an infinite number of rake angles.
and impellers in rotating or bow and stern thrusters, which
are covered in Ch 1, Sec 12.
1.2.9 Skew angle at tip of blade
The skew angle at the tip of blade is the angle on the pro-
1.2 Definitions
jected blade plane between a line starting at the centre of
1.2.1 Solid propeller the propeller axis and tangent to the blade midchord line
A solid propeller is a propeller (including hub and blades) and a line also starting at the centre of the propeller axis
cast in one piece. and passing at the outer end of this midchord line as mea-
sured.
1.2.2 Built-up propeller
A built-up propeller is a propeller cast in more than one 1.2.10 Skewed propellers
piece. In general, built up propellers have the blades cast The skewed propellers are propellers whose blades have a
separately and fixed to the hub by a system of bolts and skew angle other than 0.
studs.
1.2.11 Highly skewed propellers and very highly
1.2.3 Controllable pitch propellers skewed propellers
Controllable pitch propellers are built-up propellers which
The highly skewed propellers are propellers having blades
include in the hub a mechanism to rotate the blades in
with skew angle between 25o and 50o. The very highly
order to have the possibility of controlling the propeller
skewed propellers are propellers having blades with skew
pitch in different service conditions.
angle exceeding 50o.
1.2.4 Nozzle
A nozzle is a circular structural casing enclosing the propeller. 1.2.12 Leading and trailing edges
The leading edge LE of a propeller blade is the edge of the
1.2.5 Ducted propeller blade at side entering the water while the propeller rotates.
A ducted propeller is a propeller installed in a nozzle.
The trailing edge TE of a propeller blade is the edge of the
1.2.6 Geometry of propeller blade opposite the leading edge.
For all the geometrical definitions of propeller, see Fig 1.
1.3 Documentation to be submitted
1.2.7 Blade areas and area ratio
The projected blade area AP is the projection of the 1.3.1 Solid propellers
blade area in the direction of the propeller shaft.
The documents listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted for solid
The developed blade area AD is the area enclosed by the propellers intended for propulsion.
connection line between the end points of the cylindri-
cal profile sections turned in the propeller plane. All listed plans are to be constructional plans complete with
The expanded blade area AE is the area enclosed by the all dimensions and are to contain full indication of types of
connection line between the end points of the devel- materials employed.
oped and additionally straightened sections.
1.3.2 Built-up and controllable pitch propellers
AO : Disc area calculated by means of the propeller The documents listed in Tab 2, as applicable, are to be sub-
diameter mitted for built-up and controllable pitch propellers
B : Developed area ratio equal to: B = AD / AO. intended for propulsion.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 143


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

Figure 1 : Description of propeller

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted Table 2 : Documents to be submitted


for solid propellers for built-up and controllable pitch propellers

Nr A/I (1) ITEM Nr A/I (1) ITEM


1 A Sectional assembly 1 A/I Same documents as requested for solid pro-
pellers
2 A Blade and hub details
2 A Blade bolts and pre-tensioning procedures
3 I Rating (power, rpm, etc.)
3 I Pitch corresponding to maximum propeller
4 A Data and procedures for fitting propeller to thrust and to normal service condition
the shaft
4 A Pitch control mechanism
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
5 A Pitch control hydraulic system
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate

144 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

1.3.3 Very highly skewed propellers and propellers where:


of unusual design
f : Material factor as indicated in Tab 3
For very highly skewed propellers and propellers of unusual
=D/H
design, in addition to the documents listed in Tab 1 and Tab
2, as applicable, a detailed hydrodynamic load and stress H : Mean pitch of propeller, in m. When H is
analysis is to be submitted (see [2.4.2]). not known, the pitch H0.7 at 0,7 radius from
the propeller axis, may be used instead of H.

2 Design and construction D : Propeller diameter, in m


MT : Continuous transmitted torque, in kN.m;
where not indicated, the value given by the
2.1 Materials
following formula may be assumed for MT:

2.1.1 Normally used materials for propeller hubs P


M T = 9 ,55 ----
and blades N

a) Tab 3 indicates the minimum tensile strength Rm (in P : Maximum continuous power of propulsion
N/mm2), the density (in kg/dm3) and the material fac- machinery, in kW
tor f of normally used materials.
N : Rotational speed of the propeller, in rev/min
b) Common bronze, special types of bronze and cast steel : Density of blade material, in kg/dm3, as
used for the construction of propeller hubs and blades indicated in Tab 3
are to have a minimum tensile strength of 400 N/mm2.
B : Expanded area ratio
c) Other materials are subject of special consideration by
h : Rake, in mm
the Society following submission of full material specifi-
cation. l : Developed width of blade section at 0,25
radius from propeller axis, in mm
2.1.2 Materials for studs z : Number of blades
In general, steel (preferably nickel-steel) is to be used for Rm : Minimum tensile strength of blade material,
manufacturing the studs connecting steel blades to the hub in N/mm2
of built-up or controllable pitch propellers, and high tensile
brass or stainless steel is to be used for studs connecting R=D/2
bronze blades.
b) The maximum thickness t0.6, in mm, of the solid propel-
ler blade at the section at 0,6 radius from the propeller
Table 3 : Normally used materials axis is not to be less than that obtained from the follow-
for propeller blades and hub ing formula:
0 ,5
D 3
Rm 1 ,5 .10 6 . 0 ,6 .MT + 18 ,4 . . ---------- .B.l.N .h
2
Material f
100
Common brass 400 8,3 7,6 t 0 ,6 = 1 ,9 f ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
l0 ,6 z R m
Manganese brass (Cu1) 440 8,3 7,6
Nickel-manganese brass (Cu2) 440 8,3 7,9 where:
Aluminium bronze (Cu3 and Cu4) 590 7,6 8,3
0,6 = D / H0.6
Steel 440 7,9 9,0
H0.6 : Pitch at 0,6 radius from the propeller axis, in
m
2.2 Solid propellers - Blade thickness
l0.6 : Developed width of blade section at 0,6
radius from propeller axis, in mm.
2.2.1
c) The radius at the blade root is to be at least of the
a) The maximum thickness t0.25, in mm, of the solid propel- minimum thickness required in that position. As an
ler blade at the section at 0,25 radius from the propeller alternative, constant stress fillets may also be consid-
axis is not to be less than that obtained from the follow- ered. When measuring the thickness of the blade, the
ing formula: increased thickness due to the radius of the fillet at the
root of the blade is not to be taken into account. If the
0 ,5
D 3 propeller hub extends over 0,25 radius, the thickness
1 ,5 .10 6 ..M T + 51.. ---------- .B .l.N .h
2
100
t 0 ,25 = 3 ,2 f -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
calculated by the formula in a) is to be compared with
l z Rm the thickness obtained by linear interpolation of the
actual blade thickness up to 0,25 radius.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 145


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

d) As an alternative, a detailed hydrodynamic load and d) As an alternative, a detailed hydrodynamic load and
stress analysis carried out by the propeller designer may stress analysis carried out by the propeller designer may
be considered by the Society. The hydrodynamic analy- be considered by the Society. The hydrodynamic analy-
sis is to be carried out according to recognized tech- sis is to be carried out according to recognized tech-
niques (e.g. lifting line, lifting surface, panel methods). niques (e.g. lifting line, lifting surface, panel methods).
For stress analysis the blade is to be modelled as a canti- For stress analysis the blade is to be modelled as a canti-
lever subject to centrifugal and hydrodynamic forces; lever subject to centrifugal and hydrodynamic forces;
more complex blade models are also accepted. The more complex blade models are also accepted. The
safety factor resulting form such calculation is not to be safety factor resulting form such calculation is not to be
less than 7,5 with respect to the minimum ultimate ten- less than 7,5 with respect to the minimum ultimate ten-
sile strength of the propeller material Rm. Lower values, sile strength of the propeller material Rm. Lower values,
up to a minimum of 6,5 may be considered, when the up to a minimum of 6,5 may be considered, when the
load hypothesis for the calculation take in account mar- load hypothesis for the calculation take in account mar-
gin for: gin for:

full load end of life displacement full load end of life displacement
sea state
sea state
hull fouling
hull fouling doubts on ship resistance and global propulsion effi-
doubts on ship resistance and global propulsion effi- ciency.
ciency. A fatigue strength analysis of the propeller is to be car-
ried out. It should take in account the stress variation in
A fatigue strength analysis of the propeller is to be car- the blade during rotation.
ried out. It should take in account the stress variation in
the blade during rotation. 2.3.2 Flanges for connection of blades to hubs
a) The diameter DF, in mm, of the flange for connection to
2.3 Built-up propellers and controllable the propeller hub is not to be less than that obtained
pitch propellers from the following formula:
DF = DC + 1,8 dPR
2.3.1 Blade thickness where:
a) The maximum thickness t0.35, in mm, of the blade at the DC : Stud pitch circle diameter, in mm
section at 0,35 radius from the propeller axis is not to be dPR : Nominal stud diameter.
less than that obtained from the following formula:
b) The thickness of the flange is not to be less than 1/10 of
D
3 0 ,5 the diameter DF.
1 ,5 .10 . 0 ,7 .M T + 41 . ---------- B .l 0 ,35 .N h
6 2
100
t 0 ,35 = 2 ,7 f ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2.3.3 Connecting studs
l 0 ,35 z R m
a) The diameter dPR, in mm, at the bottom of the thread of
the studs is not to be less than obtained from the follow-
where: ing formula:
0,7 : D/H0.7 D- 3 0 ,5
4 , 6 .10 7 . .M + 0 ,88 . . ----- .B.l 0 ,35 .N .h 1
2
0, 7 T
10
H0.7 : Pitch at 0,7 radius from the propeller axis, in d PR = ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
n PR z D C R m ,PR
m. The pitch to be used in the formula is the
actual pitch of the propeller when the pro-
peller develops the maximum thrust. where:
h1 = h + 1,125 D
l0.35 : Developed width of blade section at 0,35
radius from propeller axis, in mm. nPR : Total number of studs in each blade
Rm,PR : Minimum tensile strength of stud material,
b) The maximum thickness t0.6, in mm, of the propeller
in N/mm2.
blade at the section at 0,6 radius from the propeller axis
is not to be less than that obtained from the formula in b) The studs are to be tightened in a controlled manner
[2.2.1], item b), using the value of l0,35 in lieu of l. such that the tension on the studs is approximately 60-
70% of their yield strength.
c) The radius at the blade root is to be at least 3/4 of the
c) The shank of studs may be designed with a minimum
minimum thickness required in that position. As an
diameter equal to 0,9 times the root diameter of the
alternative, constant stress fillets may also be consid-
thread.
ered. When measuring the thickness of the blade, the
increased thickness due to the radius of the fillet at the d) The studs are to be properly secured against uninten-
root of the blade is not to be taken into account. tional loosening.

146 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

2.4 Skewed propellers tS0,9 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of skewed pro-


peller blade at the section at 0,9 radius from
2.4.1 Skewed propellers the propeller axis
The thickness of skewed propeller blades may be obtained
: Skew angle.
by the formulae in [2.2] and [2.3.1], as applicable, provided
the skew angle is less than 25o. b) As an alternative, a detailed hydrodynamic load and
stress analysis carried out by the propeller designer may
2.4.2 Highly skewed propellers
be considered by the Society. The hydrodynamic analy-
a) For solid and controllable pitch propellers having skew sis is to be carried out according to recognized tech-
angles between 25o and 50o, the blade thickness, in niques (e.g. lifting line, lifting surface, panel methods).
mm, is not to be less than that obtained from the follow- The stress analysis is to be carried out by a FEM method.
ing formulae: The safety factor resulting form such calculation is not to
1) For solid propellers: be less than 8 with respect to the minimum ultimate ten-
tS0,25 = t0,25 (0,92 + 0,0032 ) sile strength of the propeller material Rm.

2) For built-up and controllable pitch propellers: Lower values, up to a minimum of 6,5 may be consid-
tS0,35 = t0,35 (0,90 + 0,0040 ) ered, when the load hypothesis for the calculation take
in account margin for:
3) For all propellers:
full load end of life displacement
tS0,6 = t0,6 (0,74 + 0,0129 0,0001 2)
tS0,9 = t0,6 (0,35 + 0,0015 ) sea state
where: hull fouling
tS0,25 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of skewed pro-
doubts on ship resistance and global propulsion effi-
peller blade at the section at 0,25 radius
ciency.
from the propeller axis
t0,25 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of normal A fatigue strength analysis of the propeller is to be car-
shape propeller blade at the section at 0,25 ried out. It should take in account the stress variation in
radius from the propeller axis, obtained by the blade during rotation.
the formula in [2.2.1]
tS0,35 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of skewed pro- 2.4.3 Very highly skewed propellers
peller blade at the section at 0,35 radius For very highly skewed propellers, the blade thickness is to
from the propeller axis be obtained by a stress analysis according to a calculation
t0,35 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of normal criteria accepted by the Society. The safety factor to be used
shape propeller blade at the section at 0,35 in this direct analysis is not to be less than 8 with respect to
radius from the propeller axis, obtained by the ultimate tensile strength of the propeller blade material,
the formula in [2.3.1] Rm.
tS0,6 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of skewed pro-
peller blade at the section at 0,6 radius from 2.5 Ducted propellers
the propeller axis
t0,6 : Maximum thickness, in mm, of normal 2.5.1 The minimum blade thickness of propellers with
shape propeller blade at the section at 0,6 wide tip blades running in nozzles is not to be less than the
radius from the propeller axis, obtained by values obtained by the applicable formula in [2.2] or
the formula in [2.2.1] [2.3.1], increased by 10%.

Table 4 : Controllable pitch propeller monitoring

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Main Engine Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Oil tank level L local
Pitch position (1) H (2) (3) R
Control oil pressure L local x
(1) Local manual control is to be available
(2) High difference from set point
(3) For feathering propellers, too high pitch value is also to give an alarm

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 147


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

2.6 Features e) Controllable pitch propeller systems are to be equipped


with means of emergency control enabling the control-
2.6.1 Blades and hubs lable pitch propeller to operate should the remote con-
a) All parts of propellers are to be free of defects and are to trol system fail. This requirement may be complied with
be built and installed with clearances and tolerances in by means of a device which locks the propeller blades
accordance with sound marine practice. in the "ahead" setting.
b) Particular care is to be given to the surface of blades to f) Tab 4 indicates the monitoring requirements to be dis-
comply with the specified class of ISO 484-1 and 484-2. played at the control console.
c) In case of direct calculation the class to be specified is
to take in account the safety factor resulting of the
fatigue strength calculation.
3 Arrangement and installation
d) Where the mean load of the propeller, computed on the
basis of the developed blades surface, exceeds 3.1 Fitting of propeller on the propeller shaft
50 kN/m, the hydrodynamic characteristics of the pro-
peller are to be verified with tests of properly scaled 3.1.1 General
model performed in a cavitation tunnel to evaluate the a) Screw propeller hubs are to be properly adjusted and fit-
risk of erosive cavitation in the whole operating speed ted on the propeller shaft cone. The contacts are to be
range. checked to be not less than 70% of the theoretical con-
tact area. Non-contact bands extending circumferen-
2.6.2 Controllable pitch propellers pitch control
system tially around the boss (excluding the center shanked
part), or over the full length of the boss are not accept-
a) Where the pitch control mechanism is operated hydrau-
able.
lically, two independent, power-driven pump sets are to
be fitted. b) The forward end of the hole in the hub is to have the
b) Pitch control systems are to be provided with an engine edge rounded to a radius of approximately 6 mm.
room indicator showing the actual setting of the blades. c) In order to prevent any entry of sea water under the liner
Further blade position indicators are to be mounted on and onto the end of the propeller shaft, the arrangement
the bridge and in the engine control room, if any. of Fig 2 is generally to be adopted for assembling the
c) Suitable devices are to be fitted to ensure that an alter- liner and propeller boss.
ation of the blade setting cannot overload the propul-
sion plant or cause it to stall. d) The external stuffing gland is to be provided with a sea-
water resistant rubber ring preferably without joints. The
d) Steps are to be taken to ensure that, in the event of fail- clearance between the liner and the internal air space of
ure of the control system, the setting of the blades the boss is to be as small as possible. The internal air
does not change, or space is to be filled with an appropriate protective mate-
assumes a final position slowly enough to allow the rial which is insoluble in sea water and non-corrodible
emergency control system to be put into operation. or fitted with a rubber ring.

Figure 2 : Example of sealing arrangement

GLAND

PROPELLER
BOSS

MASTIC OR GREASE
OR RUBBER LINER

RUBBER JOINT

SHAFT

148 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

e) All free spaces between the propeller shaft cone, pro- pMAX : Maximum permissible surface pressure, in
peller boss, nut and propeller cap are to be filled with a N/mm 2, at 0C
material which is insoluble in sea water and non-cor-
d35 : Push-up length, in mm, at 35C
rodible. Arrangements are to be made to allow any air
present in these spaces to withdraw at the moment of dT : Push-up length, in mm, at temperature T
filling. It is recommended that these spaces be tested dMAX : Maximum permissible pull-up length, in
under a pressure at least equal to that corresponding to mm, at 0C
the immersion of the propeller in order to check the WT : Push-up load, in N, at temperature T
tightness obtained after filling.
ID : Equivalent uni-axial stress in the boss
f) For propeller keys and key area, see Ch 1, Sec 7, [2.5.5]. according to the von Mises-Hencky crite-
rion, in N/mm 2
3.1.2 Shrinkage of keyless propellers
P : Coefficient of linear expansion of shaft
In the case of keyless shrinking of propellers, the following
requirements apply: material, in mm/(mmC)
M : Coefficient of linear expansion of boss
a) The meaning of the symbols used in the subparagraphs
material, in mm/(mmC)
below is as follows:
EP : Value of the modulus of elasticity of shaft
A : 100% theoretical contact area between pro-
peller boss and shaft, as read from plans and material, in N/ mm2
disregarding oil grooves, in mm2 EM : Value of the modulus of elasticity of boss
dPM : Diameter of propeller shaft at the mid-point material, in N/ mm2
of the taper in the axial direction, in mm P : Poissons ratio for shaft material
dH : Mean outer diameter of propeller hub at the M : Poissons ratio for boss material
axial position corresponding to dPM , in mm RS,MIN : Value of the minimum yield strength (ReH),
K : K = dH / dPM or 0,2% proof stress (Rp 0,2), of propeller boss
material, in N/mm2.
F : Tangential force at interface, in N
For other symbols not defined above, see [2.2].
MT : Continuous torque transmitted; in N.m,
where not indicated, MT may be assumed as b) The manufacturer is to submit together with the required
indicated in [2.2.1] constructional plans specifications containing all ele-
ments necessary for verifying the shrinkage. Tests and
C : C = 1,0 for turbines, geared diesel
checks deemed necessary for verifying the characteris-
engines, electrical drives and direct-
tics and integrity of the propeller material are also to be
drive reciprocating internal combustion
specified.
engines with a hydraulic, electromag-
netic or high elasticity coupling c) Moreover, the manufacturer is to submit an instruction
handbook, in which all operations and any precautions
C = 1,2 for diesel engines having cou-
necessary for assembling and disassembling the propel-
plings other than those specified above.
ler, as well as the values of all relevant parameters, are
The Society reserves the right to increase the to be specified. A copy, endorsed by the Society, is to be
value of C if the shrinkage needs to absorb kept on board each ship where the propeller is installed.
an extremely high pulsating torque,
d) The formulae and other provisions below do not apply
T : Temperature of hub and propeller shaft to propellers where a sleeve is introduced between shaft
material, in C, assumed for calculation of and boss or in the case of hollow propeller shafts. In
pull-up length and push-up load such cases, a direct shrinkage calculation is to be sub-
V : Ship speed at P power, in knots mitted to the Society.
S : Continuous thrust developed for free run- e) The taper of the propeller shaft cone is not to exceed
ning ship, in N 1/15.
sF : Safety factor against friction slip at 35C f) Prior to final pull-up, the contact area between the mat-
: Half taper of propeller shaft (for instance: ing surfaces is to be checked according to general
taper = 1/15, = 1/30) requirements of [3.1.1] item a).
: Coefficient of friction between mating sur- g) After final push-up, the propeller is to be secured by a
faces nut on the propeller shaft. The nut is to be secured to the
shaft.
p35 : Surface pressure between mating surfaces,
in N/mm2, at 35C h) The safety factor sF against friction slip at 35C is not to
2
be less than 2,5, under the combined action of torque
pT : Surface pressure, in N/mm , between mat-
and propeller thrust, based on the maximum continuous
ing surfaces at temperature T
power P for which classification is requested at the cor-
p0 : Surface pressure between mating surfaces, responding speed of rotation N of the propeller, plus
in N/mm2, at 0C pulsating torque due to torsionals.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 149


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

i) For the oil injection method, the coefficient of friction Corresponding maximum permissible pull-up length
is to be 0,13 in the case of bosses made of copper-based at 0C:
alloy and steel. For other methods, the coefficient of
pM A X
friction will be considered in each case by the Society. d M A X = d 35 -----------
p 35
j) The maximum equivalent uni-axial stress in the boss at
0C, based on the von Mises-Hencky criterion, is not to Tangential force at interface:
exceed 70% of the minimum yield strength (ReH), or
2000C M
0,2% proof stress (Rp0,2), of the propeller material, based F = -------------------------T
d PM
on the test piece value. For cast iron, the value of the
above stress is not to exceed 30% of the nominal tensile Continuous thrust developed for free running ship; if
strength. the actual value is not given, the value, in N, calcu-
lated by one of the following formulae may be con-
k) For the formulae given below, the material properties
sidered:
indicated in the following items are to be assumed:
Modulus of elasticity, in N/mm2: P
S = 1760 ----
V
Cast and forged steel: E = 206000
P
S = 57 ,3 10 3 -------------
Cast iron: E = 98000 HN
Type Cu1 and Cu2 brass: E = 108000
3.1.3 Circulating currents
Type Cu3 and Cu4 brass: E = 118000
Means are to be provided to prevent circulating electric cur-
Poissons ratio:
rents from developing between the propeller and the hull. A
Cast and forged steel: = 0,29 description of the type of protection provided and its main-
Cast iron: = 0,26 tenance is to be kept on board.
All copper based alloys: = 0,33
Coefficient of linear expansion in mm/(mmoC):
4 Testing and certification
Cast and forged steel and cast iron: = 12,0 106
4.1 Material tests
All copper based alloys: = 17,5 106
l) For shrinkage calculation the formulae in the following 4.1.1 Solid propellers
items, which are valid for the ahead condition, are to be
Material used for the construction of solid propellers is to be
applied. They will also provide a sufficient margin of
tested in accordance with the requirements of NR216 Mate-
safety in the astern condition.
rials in the presence of the Surveyor.
Minimum required surface pressure at 35C:
4.1.2 Built-up propellers and controllable pitch
sF S F 2 0 ,5
- s F + 2 + B ----2-
p 35 = ------- propellers
AB S
In addition to the requirement in [4.1.1], materials for studs
where: and for all other parts of the mechanism transmitting torque
B = 2 sF2 2 are to be tested in the presence of the Surveyor.

Corresponding minimum pull-up length at 35C:


4.2 Testing and inspection
p 35 d PM 1 K 2 + 1- 1
d 35 = ---------------- ------ -------------- + M + --------------P
2 EM K2 1 EP
4.2.1 Inspection of finished propeller
Minimum pull-up length at temperature T (T<35C): Finished propellers are to be inspected at the manufacturers
dP M plant by the Surveyor. At least the following checks are to
d T = d 35 + -------- ( M P ) ( 35 T ) be carried out:
2
Corresponding minimum surface pressure at tem- visual examination of the entire surface of the propeller
perature T: blades

d conformity to approved plans of blade profile


p T = p 35 ------T-
d 35 liquid penetrant examination of suspected and critical
Minimum push-up load temperature T: parts of the propeller blade, to the satisfaction of the
Surveyor.
W T = Ap T ( + )

Maximum permissible surface pressure at 0C: Repair of defective casting is not allowed without the previ-
ous agreement of the owner; where agreed, it is to be car-
0 ,7R S ,M I N ( K 2 1 ) ried out according to the requirements of NR216 Materials,
p M A X = -----------------------------------------------
( 3 K4 + 1 ) 0 ,5 Ch 4, Sec 2, [1.10].

150 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 8

4.2.2 Controllable pitch propellers of the complete propeller may be replaced by an individual
check of blade weight and gravity centre position.
The complete hydraulic system for the control of the con-
trollable pitch propeller mechanism is to be hydrotested at a
pressure equal to 1,5 times the design pressure. The proper 4.3 Certification
operation of the safety valve is to be tested in the presence
4.3.1 Certification of propellers
of the Surveyor.
Propellers in general are to be individually tested and certi-
fied by the Society.
4.2.3 Balancing
Finished propellers are to be statically balanced as required 4.3.2 Mass produced propellers
by the relevant class according to ISO 484. For built-up and Mass produced propellers may be accepted within the
controllable pitch propellers, the required static balancing framework of the type approval program of the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 151


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

SECTION 9 SHAFT VIBRATIONS

1 General 2.1.3 Condition of components


Systems are to be designed considering essential compo-
nents in a non-ideal condition. In particular, the following
1.1 Application conditions are to be considered:
propulsion engine: cylinder malfunction
1.1.1 The requirements of this Section apply to the shafting
of the following installations: flexible coupling: possible variation of the stiffness or
damping characteristics due to heating or ageing
propulsion systems with prime movers developing
vibration damper: possible variation of the damping
220 kW or more
coefficient.
other systems with internal combustion engines devel-
For non-propulsion redundant machinery, the above condi-
oping 110 kW or more and driving auxiliary machinery
tions are to be intended as transient.
intended for essential services.

2.2 Modifications of existing plants


1.2 Submission of documentation
2.2.1 Where substantial modifications of existing plants,
1.2.1 As the analysis of the vibration behaviour of systems such as:
is part of their design, the relevant documentation, as listed change of the running speed or power of the engine
in [3.2], [4.2] and [5.2], is to be promptly submitted for
replacement of an essential component of the system
approval.
(propeller, flexible coupling, damper) by one of different
characteristics, or
2 Design of systems in respect of connection of a new component
vibrations are carried out, new vibration analysis is to be submitted for
approval.
2.1 Principle
3 Torsional vibrations
2.1.1 General
a) Special consideration shall be given to the design, con- 3.1 General
struction and installation of propulsion machinery sys-
tems so that any mode of their vibrations shall not cause 3.1.1 The torsional vibration torques (or stresses) calculated
undue stresses in these systems in the normal operating in the various components of the installation are additional
ranges. to those resulting from the mean power transmitted by such
components. Where the scantling formulae given in Ch 1,
b) Calculations are to be carried out for all the configura- Sec 7 and Ch 1, App 1 are applied, the vibratory torques are
tions of the system likely to have any influence on the not to be taken into account unless otherwise stated.
torsional, bending or axial vibrations.
c) Where torsional and axial vibrations may be coupled 3.2 Documentation to be submitted
(e.g. due to helical gears), the effect of such vibrations is
3.2.1 Calculations
to be investigated.
Torsional vibration calculations are to be submitted for the
2.1.2 Vibration levels various configurations of the plants, showing:
the equivalent dynamic system used for the modelling
Systems are to have torsional, bending and axial vibrations
of the plant, with indication of:
both in continuous and in transient running acceptable to
the Manufacturers, and in accordance with the require- - inertia and stiffness values for all the components of
ments of this section. the system
- diameter and material properties of the shafts
Where vibrations are found to exceed the limits stated in
the natural frequencies
this Section, the designer or the builder of the plant is to
propose corrective actions: the values of the vibratory torques or stresses in the
components of the system for the most significant criti-
operating restrictions, provided that the owner is cal speeds and their analysis in respect of the Rules and
informed, or other acceptance criteria
modification of the plant. the possible restrictions of operation of the plant.

152 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

3.2.2 Particulars to be submitted 3.3 Definitions, symbols and units


The following particulars are to be submitted with the tor-
sional vibration calculations: 3.3.1 Definitions
a) for turbines, multi-engine installations or installations a) Torsional vibration stresses referred to in this Article are
with power take-off systems: the stresses resulting from the alternating torque corre-
description of the operating configurations sponding to the synthesis of the harmonic orders con-
load sharing law between the various components cerned.
for each configuration b) The misfiring condition of an engine is the malfunction
b) for installations with controllable pitch propellers, the of one cylinder due to the absence of fuel injection
power/rotational speed values resulting from the combi- (which results in a pure compression or expansion in
nator operation the cylinder).
c) for prime movers, the service speed range and the mini-
mum speed at no load 3.3.2 Symbols, units

d) for internal combustion engines: The main symbols used in this Article are defined as fol-
lows:
manufacturer and type
nominal output and rotational speed : Torsional vibration stress, as defined in [3.3.1],
in N/mm2
mean indicated pressure
number of cylinders 1 : Permissible stress due to torsional vibrations for
V angle continuous operation, in N/mm2
firing angles 2 : Permissible stress due to torsional vibrations for
bore and stroke transient running, in N/mm2
excitation data, such as the polynomial law of har- Rm : Tensile strength of the shaft material, in N/mm2
monic components of excitations
CR : Material factor, equal to:
nominal alternating torsional stress considered for
crankpin and journal R + 160
--------------------
Note 1: The nominal alternating torsional stress is part of the basic 18
data to be considered for the assessment of the crankshaft. It is
defined in Ch 1, App 1.
d : Minimum diameter of the shaft, in mm

e) for turbines: CD : Size factor of the shaft, equal to:


nominal output and rotational speed CD = 0,35 + 0,93 d0,2
power / speed curve and range of operation
N : Speed of the shaft for which the check is carried
number of stages, and load sharing between the out, in rev/min
stages
Nn : Nominal speed of the shaft, in rev/min
main excitation orders for each rotating disc, if
applicable Nc : Critical speed, in rev/min
structural damping of shafts : Speed ratio, equal to N/Nn
external damping on discs (due to the fluid)
C : Speed ratio factor, equal to:
f) for reduction or step-up gears, the speed ratio for each
step for < 0,9: C = 3 2 2
g) for flexible couplings, the data required in Ch 1, Sec 7, for 0,9 1,05: C = 1,38
[2.1.3]
Ck : Factor depending on the shaft design features
h) for torsional vibration dampers:
given in Tab 1.
the manufacturer and type
the permissible heat dissipation
3.4 Calculation principles
the damping coefficient
the inertial and stiffness properties, as applicable 3.4.1 Method
i) for propellers: a) Torsional vibration calculations are to be carried out
the number of blades using a recognised method.
the excitation and damping data, if available b) Where the calculation method does not include har-
j) for electric motors, generators and pumps, the drawing monic synthesis, attention is to be paid to the possible
of the rotating parts, with their mass moment of inertia superimposition of two or more harmonic orders of dif-
and main dimensions. ferent vibration modes.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 153


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

Table 1 : Values of Ck factors

Intermediate shafts Thrust shafts external to engines Propeller shafts


in way of axial bearing for which (1)
with integral with shrink-fit on both sides
with keyways splined shafts where a roller bearing is k = 1,22 or
coupling flanges couplings of thrust collar
used as a thrust bearing k = 1,26
1,00 1,00 0,60 0,80 0,85 0,85 0,55
(1) k is defined in Ch 1, Sec 7
Note 1: Higher values of Ck factors based on direct calculations may also be considered.
Note 2: The determination of Ck factors for shafts other than those given in this table will be given special consideration by the Society.

3.4.2 Scope of the calculations 3.5 Permissible limits for torsional vibration
a) Torsional vibration calculations are to be carried out stresses in crankshaft, propulsion
considering: shafting and other transmission shafting
normal firing of all cylinders, and
3.5.1 General
misfiring of one cylinder.
a) The limits provided below apply to steel shafts. For
b) Where the torsional dynamic stiffness of the coupling
shafts made of other material, the permissible limits for
depends on the transmitted torque, two calculations are
torsional vibration stresses will be determined by the
to be carried out:
Society after examination of the results of fatigue tests
one at full load carried out on the material concerned.
one at the minimum load expected in service.
b) These limits apply to the torsional vibration stresses as
c) For installations with controllable pitch propellers, two defined in [3.3.1]. They relate to the shaft minimum sec-
calculations are to be carried out: tion, without taking account of the possible stress con-
one for full pitch condition centrations.
one for pitch condition corresponding to zero thrust.
3.5.2 Crankshaft
d) The calculations are to take into account all possible
a) Where the crankshaft has been designed in accordance
sources of excitation. Electrical sources of excitations,
with Ch 1, App 1, the torsional vibration stresses in any
such as static frequency converters, are to be detailed.
point of the crankshaft are not exceed the following limits:
e) The natural frequencies are to be considered up to a
1 = N for continuous running
value corresponding to 15 times the maximum service
speed. Therefore, the excitations are to include har- 2 = 1,7 N for transient running of auxiliary machin-
monic orders up to the fifteenth. ery,
where N is the nominal alternating torsional stress on
3.4.3 Criteria for acceptance of the torsional
vibration loads under normal firing conditions which the crankshaft scantling is based (see [3.2.2],
[3.2.2], Note 1).
a) Torsional vibration stresses in the various shafts are not
to exceed the limits defined in [3.5]. Higher limits cal- b) Where the crankshaft has not been designed in accor-
culated by an alternative method may be considered, dance with Ch 1, App 1, the torsional vibration stresses
subject to special examination by the Society in case of in any point of the crankshaft are not to exceed the fol-
special manufacturing processes. lowing limits:
Auxiliary machinery is to be capable of running contin- 1 = 0,55 CR CD C for continuous running
uously without restrictions at least within the range 2 = 2,3 1 for transient running of auxiliary machin-
between 0,95 Nn and 1,1 Nn. Transient running may be ery.
considered only in restricted speed ranges for speed
ratios 0,95. 3.5.3 Intermediate shafts, thrust shafts and
b) Torsional vibration levels in other components are to propeller shafts
comply with the provisions of [3.6]. The torsional vibration stresses in any intermediate, thrust
c) Propulsion systems are to be capable of running contin- and propeller shafts are not to exceed the following limit:
uously without restrictions, and therefore are to respect 1 = CR Ck CD C
the limits given in a) and b) in the whole operating
speed range. In case the propulsion shafting has been designed accord-
ing a direct stress calculation method the limits for torsional
3.4.4 Criteria for acceptance of torsional vibration vibration stresses will be considered on a case by case
loads under misfiring conditions basis.
The provisions of [3.4.3] related to normal firing conditions Note 1: For intermediate, thrust and propeller shafts, the material
also apply to misfiring conditions. factor CR is not to be taken as greater than 42,2.

154 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

3.5.4 Transmission shafting for generating sets and b) Vibratory inertia torques due to torsional vibrations and
other auxiliary machinery imposed on the rotating parts of the generator are not to
exceed the values MA, in N.m, calculated by the follow-
The torsional vibration stresses in the transmission shafting for
ing formulae, as appropriate:
generating sets and other auxiliary machinery, such as pumps
or compressors, are not to exceed the following limits: for 0,95 1,1: MA = 2,5 MT
for 0,95: MA = 6 M T
for continuous running: 1 = 0,90 CR CD
where:
for transient running: 2 = 5,4 1
: Speed ratio defined in [3.3.2]
MT : Mean torque transmitted by the engine
3.5.5 Restricted speed ranges
under full load running conditions, in N.m.
Restricted speed ranges in normal firing condition are Note 1: In the case of two or more generators driven by the same
acceptable only for auxiliary machinery: engine, the portion of MT transmitted to each generator is to be
considered.
a) Where the torsional vibration stresses exceed the limit
1 for continuous running, restricted speed ranges are to 3.6.3 Flexible couplings
be imposed which are to be passed through rapidly.
a) Flexible couplings are to be capable of withstanding the
b) The limits of the restricted speed range related to a criti- mean transmitted torque and the torsional vibration
cal speed Nc are to be calculated in accordance with torque throughout the service speed range, without
the following formula: exceeding the limits for continuous operation imposed
by the manufacturer (permissible vibratory torque and
16 N ( 18 ) N power loss).
-----------------c N --------------------------------c
18 16 Where such limits are exceeded under misfiring condi-
tion of auxiliary machinery, appropriate restrictions of
c) Where the resonance curve of a critical speed is power or speed are to be established.
obtained from torsional vibration measurements, the
restricted speed range may be established considering b) Flexible couplings fitted in generating sets are also to be
the speeds for which the stress limit for continuous run- capable of withstanding the torques and twist angles
ning 1 is exceeded. arising from transient criticals and short-circuit currents.

d) Where restricted speed ranges are imposed, they are to 3.6.4 Dampers
be crossed out on the tachometers and an instruction a) Torsional vibration dampers are to be such that the per-
plate is to be fitted at the control stations indicating that: missible power loss recommended by the manufacturer
is not exceeded throughout the service speed range.
the continuous operation of the engine within the
considered speed range is not permitted b) Dampers for which a failure may lead to a significant
vibration overload of the installation will be the subject
this speed range is to be passed through rapidly. of special consideration.
e) When restricted speed ranges are imposed, the accuracy
of the tachometers is to be checked in such ranges as 3.7 Torsional vibration measurements
well as in their vicinity.
3.7.1 General
a) The Society may require torsional vibration measure-
3.6 Permissible vibration levels in ments to be carried out under its supervision in the fol-
components other than shafts lowing cases:
where the calculations indicate the possibility of
3.6.1 Gears dangerous critical speeds in the operating speed
range
a) The torsional vibration torque in any gear step is not to
exceed 30% of the torque corresponding to the where doubts arise as to the actual stress amplitudes
approved rating throughout the service speed range. or critical speed location, or
where restricted speed ranges need to be verified.
b) Gear hammering induced by torsional vibration torque
reversal is not permitted throughout the service speed b) Where measurements are required, a comprehensive
range. report including the analysis of the results is to be sub-
mitted to the Society.
3.6.2 Generators
3.7.2 Method of measurement
a) In the case of alternating current generators, the tor- When measurements are required, the method of measure-
sional vibration amplitude at the rotor is not to exceed ment is to be submitted to the Society for approval. The type
[2,5 electrical degrees] at service rotational speed of measuring equipment and the location of the measure-
under full load working conditions. ment points are to be specified.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 155


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

4 Bending vibrations d) for the propeller:

the diametral and polar moments of inertia of the


4.1 General propeller in air and water

excitations (bending moments and bending forces).


4.1.1 The provisions of this Article apply to the bending
vibrations of propulsion systems having a transmitted power
in excess of 1000 KW:
4.3 Calculation principles

having a l/D ratio exceeding the following value: 4.3.1 Scope of the calculations

2 a) Bending vibration calculations are to take into account:


10 ln ---- + D
2
D
the stiffness of the bearings and their seatings and,
where applicable, that of the lubricating oil film
where:
the excitations due to the propeller and cardan
l : Span between the aft bearings of the propel-
shafts.
ler shaft, in m
b) Where data having a significant influence on the vibra-
D : Diameter of the propeller shaft, in m
tion levels cannot be determined with a sufficient
or degree of accuracy, parametric studies are to be carried
out.
fitted with bearings located outboard the hull (brackets),
or 4.3.2 Criteria for acceptance of the bending
vibration levels
fitted with cardan shafts.
The first shafting vibration mode is not to be excited by the
first propeller blade excitation order, in the speed range
4.2 Documentation to be submitted between 80% and 110% of nominal speed.

4.2.1 Calculations Furthermore vibration induced stresses should not exceed


1,5 times the one indicated in [3.5.3] in the whole speed
Bending vibration calculations are to show: range.

the equivalent dynamic system used for the modelling In case the shafting is checked by means of direct calcula-
of the plant, with indication of the mass of the shafts, tion the allowable stresses will be established on a case by
propeller and other rotating components, and the lateral case.
stiffness of the bearings, including that of the oil film
and that of the seating
4.4 Bending vibration measurements
the natural bending frequencies
4.4.1 General
the values of the vibratory amplitudes and bending
moments in the shafting for the most significant critical a) The Society may require bending vibration measure-
speeds ments in the following cases:

the possible restrictions of operation of the plant. where the calculations indicate the possibility of
dangerous critical speeds in or near the operating
speed range
4.2.2 Particulars to be submitted
where the accuracy of some data is not deemed suf-
The following particulars are to be submitted with the bend-
ficient
ing vibration calculations:
where restricted speed ranges need to be verified.
a) shafting arrangement with indication of:
b) Where measurements are required, a comprehensive
the diameter and length of the shafts report including the analysis of the results is to be sub-
the position of the bearings mitted to the Society.

the mounting characteristics of the cardan shafts 4.4.2 Method of measurement

b) detailed drawings of the bearings and their seating When measurements are required, the method of measure-
ment is to be submitted to the Society for approval. The type
c) details of the bearing lubrication, including the of measuring equipment and the location of the measure-
oil viscosity ment points are to be specified.

156 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 9

5 Axial vibrations 5.3 Calculation principles

5.3.1 Scope of the calculations


5.1 General
a) Axial vibration calculations are to take into account:

5.1.1 The provisions of this Article apply to the axial vibra- the flexibility of the thrust bearing and its supporting
tions of propulsion systems fitted with: structure
the excitations due to the engine and to the propel-
an internal combustion engine having a power exceed-
ler.
ing 2000 kW and a running speed of less than 200 RPM,
or b) Where data having a significant influence on the vibra-
tion levels cannot be determined with a sufficient
a shaft line where the power transmitted exceeds 375 degree of accuracy (e.g. the flexibility of the thrust bear-
kW and the L/D ratio exceeds 50, ing and its supporting structure), parametric studies are
where: to be carried out.
c) Where the plant includes an axial vibration damper or
L : Total length of the shaft line between the
detuner, a calculation is to be carried out assuming a
propeller and the thrust bearing
malfunction of the damper or detuner.
D : Minimum diameter of the shaft line.
5.3.2 Criteria for acceptance of the axial vibration
levels
5.2 Documentation to be submitted a) The axial vibration force acting on the thrust bearing is
not to exceed 30% of the nominal thrust.
5.2.1 Calculations
b) The axial vibration amplitude is not to exceed:
Axial vibration calculations are to show:
at the free end of the crankshaft, the limit recom-
the equivalent dynamic system used for the modelling mended by the engine manufacturer
of the plant, with indication of the masses and axial stiff- in way of the sterntube sealing gland, the limit rec-
nesses for all the components of the system ommended by the sealing gland manufacturer, if
any.
the natural frequencies
c) Where the calculations show that in the continuous
the axial vibration amplitude in way of the sterntube
operation speed range the above limits may be
sealing gland for the most significant critical speeds
exceeded in the event of malfunction of the axial vibra-
for engines directly connected to the shaftline, the axial tion damper or detuner, a suitable device is to be fitted
vibration amplitude at the free end of the crankshaft for to indicate the occurrence of such conditions.
the most significant critical speeds Note 1: When detuners or dampers of satisfactorily proven design
are used, this requirement may be waived.
the possible restrictions of operation of the plant.

5.4 Axial vibration measurements


5.2.2 Particulars to be submitted
The following particulars are to be submitted with the axial 5.4.1 General
vibration calculations: a) The Society may require axial vibration measurements
in the following cases:
a) detailed drawing of the thrust bearing and its supporting
structure with indication of their flexibility where the calculations indicate the possibility of
dangerous critical speeds in the operating speed
b) for the propeller: range
the thrust where the accuracy of some data is not deemed suf-
ficient, or
the excitations (axial forces)
where restricted speed ranges need to be verified.
the damping characteristics
b) Where measurements are required, a comprehensive
c) for the engine: report including the analysis of the results is to be sub-
mitted to the Society.
the axial excitations
5.4.2 Method of measurement
the permissible axial amplitude at the free end of the
crankshaft When measurements are required, the method of measure-
ment is to be submitted to the Society for approval. The type
d) the characteristics of the axial vibration damper or of measuring equipment and the location of the measure-
detuner. ment points are to be specified.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 157


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

SECTION 10 PIPING SYSTEMS

1 General 1.2.2 Additional information

The information listed in Tab 2 is also to be submitted.


1.1 Application
1.1.1 1.3 Definitions
a) General requirements applying to all piping systems are
contained in: 1.3.1 Piping and piping systems
[2] for their design and construction
a) Piping includes pipes and their connections, flexible
[3] for the welding of steel pipes
hoses and expansion joints, valves and their actuating
[4] for the bending of pipes systems, other accessories (filters, level gauges, etc.) and
[5] for their arrangement and installation pump casings.
[19] for their certification, inspection and testing.
b) Piping systems include piping and all the interfacing
b) Specific requirements for ship piping systems and machi-
equipment such as tanks, pressure vessels, heat
nery piping systems are given in Articles [6] to [18].
exchangers, pumps and centrifugal purifiers, but do not
include boilers, turbines, internal combustion engines
1.2 Documentation to be submitted and reduction gears.
1.2.1 Documents Note 1: The equipment other than piping is to be designed in
The documents listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted. accordance with the relevant Sections of Part C, Chapter 1.

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted

Item N I/A (1) Document (2)


1 A Drawing showing the arrangement of the sea chests and ship side valves
2 A Diagram of the bilge and ballast systems (in and outside machinery spaces)
3 A Specification of the central priming system intended for bilge pumps, when provided
4 A Diagram of the scuppers and sanitary discharge systems
5 A Diagram of the air, sounding and overflow systems
6 A Diagram of cooling systems (sea water and fresh water)
7 A Diagram of fuel oil system and of JP5-NATO (F44) system
8 A Drawings of the fuel oil and of JP5-NATO (F44) tanks not forming part of the ships structure
9 A Diagram of the lubricating oil system
10 A Diagram of the thermal oil system
11 A Diagram of the hydraulic systems intended for essential services or located in machinery spaces
12 A Diagram of steam system, including safety valve exhaust and drain pipes
13 For high temperature steam pipes:
A stress calculation note
I drawing showing the actual arrangement of the piping in three dimensions
14 A Diagram of the boiler feed water and condensate system
15 A Diagram of the compressed air system
16 A Diagram of the hydraulic and pneumatic remote control systems
17 A Diagram of the remote level gauging system
18 I Diagram of the exhaust gas system
19 A Diagram of drip trays and gutterway draining system
20 I Arrangement of the ventilation system
21 A Diagram of the oxyacetylene welding system
22 A Drawings and specification of valves and accessories, where required in [2.7]
(1) A = to be submitted for approval, in four copies;
I = to be submitted for information, in duplicate.
(2) Diagrams are also to include, where applicable, the (local and remote) control and monitoring systems and automation systems.

158 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 2 : Information to be submitted

Item N I/A (1) Document


1 I Nature, service temperature and pressure of the fluids
2 A Material, external diameter and wall thickness of the pipes
3 A Type of connections between pipe lengths, including details of the weldings, where provided
4 A Material, type and size of the accessories
5 A Capacity, prime mover and, when requested, location of the pumps
(1) A = to be submitted for approval, in four copies;
I = to be submitted for information, in duplicate.

1.3.2 Design pressure d) The design pressure of a piping system located on the
a) The design pressure of a piping system is the pressure low pressure side of a pressure reducing valve where no
considered by the manufacturer to determine the scant- safety valve is provided is not to be less than the maxi-
ling of the system components. It is not to be taken less mum pressure on the high pressure side of the pressure
than the maximum working pressure expected in this reducing valve.
system or the highest setting pressure of any safety valve e) The design pressure of a piping system located on the
or relief device, whichever is the greater. delivery side of a pump or a compressor is not to be less
b) The design pressure of a boiler feed system is not to be than the setting pressure of the safety valve for displace-
less than 1,25 times the design pressure of the boiler or ment pumps or the maximum pressure resulting from
the maximum pressure expected in the feed piping, the operating (head-capacity) curve for centrifugal
whichever is the greater. pumps, whichever is the greater.
c) The design pressure of steam piping located upstream of
1.3.3 Design temperature
pressure reducing valves (high pressure side) is not to be
less than the setting pressure of the boiler or superheater The design temperature of a piping system is the maximum
safety valves. temperature of the medium inside the system.

Table 3 : Class of piping systems

Media conveyed by the piping system CLASS I CLASS II CLASS III


Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) (1) p > 1,6 or T > 150 other (2) p 0,7 and T 60
Thermal oil p > 1,6 or T > 300 other (2) p 0,7 and T 150
Flammable p > 1,6 or T > 150 other (2) p 0,7 and T 60
Hydraulic oil (5)
Lubricating oil p > 1,6 or T > 150 other (2) p 0,7 and T 60
Other flammable media: without special safeguards (3) with special safeguards (3)
heated above flashpoint, or
having flashpoint <60C
and liquefied gas
Oxygen and acetylene
upstream the pressure reduction valve irrespective of p
downstream the pressure reduction valve irrespective of p
Toxic media irrespective of p, T
Corrosive media without special safeguards (3) with special safeguards (3)
Steam p > 1,6 or T > 300 other (2) p 0,7 and T 170
Air, gases, water, non-flammable hydraulic oil (4) p > 4 or T > 300 other (2) p 1,6 and T 200
Open-ended pipes (drains, overflows, vents, irrespective of T
exhaust gas lines, boiler escape pipes)
(1) Valves under static pressure on fuel oil and on JP5-NATO (F44) tanks belong to class II.
(2) Pressure and temperature conditions other than those required for class I and class III.
(3) Safeguards for reducing the possibility of leakage and limiting its consequences, to the Societys satisfaction.
(4) Valves and fittings fitted on the ship side and collision bulkhead belong to class II.
(5) Steering gear piping belongs to class I irrespective of p and T
Note 1: p : Design pressure, as defined in [1.3.2], in MPa.
Note 2: T : Design temperature, as defined in [1.3.3], in C.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 159


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

1.3.4 Flammable oils 2.1.3 Use of plastics


Flammable oils include fuel oils, lubricating oils, thermal a) Plastics, FRP and GRP may be used for piping systems
oils, hydraulic oils and JP5-NATO (F44). belonging to class III in accordance with Ch 1, App 2.
The use of plastics for other systems or in other condi-
tions will be given special consideration.
1.4 Symbols and units
b) Plastics intended for piping systems dealt with in this
Section are to be of a type approved by the Society.
1.4.1 The following symbols and related units are com-
monly used in this Section. Additional symbols, related to c) Installation of plastic pipes shall be avoided if not
some formulae indicated in this Section, are listed wherever agreed by the Society and the Naval Authority.
it is necessary.

p : Design pressure, in MPa 2.2 Thickness of pressure piping

T : Design temperature, in C 2.2.1 Calculation of the thickness of pressure pipes

t : Rule required minimum thickness, in mm a) The thickness t, in mm, of pressure pipes is to be deter-
mined by the following formula but, in any case, is not
D : Pipe external diameter, in mm. to be less than the minimum thickness given in Tab 5 to
Tab 8.
1.5 Class of piping systems t0 + b + c
t = ----------------------
a
1 ----------
100
1.5.1 Purpose of the classes of piping systems
where:
Piping systems are subdivided into three classes, denoted as
t0 : Coefficient, in mm, equal to
class I, class II and class III, for the purpose of acceptance of
materials, selection of joints, heat treatment, welding, pres- pD
t0 = --------------------
sure testing and certification of fittings. 2Ke + p

with:
1.5.2 Definitions of the classes of piping systems
p and D : As defined in [1.4.1]
a) Classes I, II and III are defined in Tab 3. K : Permissible stress defined in
[2.2.2]
b) Fluids for refrigerating plants are not covered by Tab 3
(see Ch 1, Sec 13). e : Weld efficiency factor to be:
equal to 1 for seamless pipes
2 General requirements for design and and pipes fabricated accord-
ing to a welding procedure
construction approved by the Society
specially considered by the
2.1 Materials Society for other welded
pipes, depending on the ser-
2.1.1 General vice and the manufacture
procedure
Materials to be used in piping systems are to be suitable for
the medium and the service for which the piping is b : Thickness reduction due to bending defined
intended. in [2.2.3], in mm
c : Corrosion allowance defined in [2.2.4], in
2.1.2 Use of metallic materials mm
a : Negative manufacturing tolerance percent-
a) Metallic materials are to be used in accordance with
age equal to:
Tab 4.
7,0 for copper and copper alloy pipes
b) Materials for class I and class II piping systems are to be
manufactured and tested in accordance with the appro- 10,0 for cold drawn seamless steel pipes
priate requirements of NR216 Materials. fabricated according to a welding proce-
dure approved by the Society
c) Materials for class III piping systems are to be manufac- 12,5 for hot laminated seamless steel
tured and tested in accordance with the requirements of pipes
acceptable national or international standards or speci-
fications. b) The thickness thus determined does not take into
account the particular loads to which pipes may be sub-
d) Mechanical characteristics required for metallic materi- jected. Attention is to be drawn in particular to the case
als are specified in NR216 Materials. of high temperature and low temperature pipes.

160 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 4 : Conditions of use of metallic materials in piping systems

Maximum
Allowable design
Material Particular conditions of use
classes temperature,
in C (1)
Carbon and carbon- III, II, I 400 (2) Class I and II pipes are to be seamless drawn pipes (3)
manganese steels
Copper and III, II, I 200 Not to be used in fuel oil and JP5-NATO(F44) systems, except for class III
aluminium brass pipes of a diameter not exceeding 25 mm not passing through fuel oil or
JP5-NATO(F44) tanks
Copper-nickel III, II, I 300 Not to be used for boiler blow-down valves and pieces for connection to
the shell plating
Special high tempera- III, II, I 260 (4)
ture resistant bronze
Stainless steel III, II, I 300 Except for system fittings, an austenitic stainless steel is not to be used for sea
water systems
Spheroidal graphite III, II 350 Spheroidal cast iron of the ferritic type according to the material rules of
cast iron the Society may be accepted for bilge and ballast piping within double bot-
tom tanks, or other locations to the Societys satisfaction
The use of this material for pipes, valves and fittings for other services, in
principle Classes II and III, will be subject to special consideration
Spheroidal cast iron pipes and valves fitted on ships side should have spec-
ified properties to the Societys satisfaction
Minimum elongation is not to be less than 12% on a gauge length of
5,65S0,5, where S is the actual cross-sectional area of the test piece
Not to be used for boiler blow-down valves and pieces for connection to
the shell plating
Grey cast iron III 220 Grey cast iron is not to be used for the following systems:
II (5) boiler blow-down systems and other piping systems subject to shocks, high
stresses and vibrations
bilge lines in tanks
parts of scuppers and sanitary discharge systems located next to the hull
below the maximum ship draft
ship side valves and fittings
valves fitted on the collision bulkhead
valves fitted to fuel oil and lubricating oil tanks under static pressure head
class II fuel oil and JP5-NATO(F44) systems
Aluminium and III, II (6) 200 Aluminium and aluminium alloys are not to be used on the following systems:
aluminium alloys flammable oil systems
sounding and air pipes of fuel oil tanks and of JP5-NATO(F44) tanks
fire-extinguishing systems
bilge system in boiler or machinery spaces or in spaces containing fuel oil
tanks, JP5-NATO(F44) tanks or pumping units
scuppers and overboard discharges except for pipes led to the bottoms or
to the shell above the freeboard deck or fitted at their upper end with clos-
ing means operated from a position above the freeboard deck
boiler blow-down valves and pieces for connection to the shell plating
(1) Maximum design temperature is not to exceed that assigned to the class of piping.
(2) Higher temperatures may be accepted if metallurgical behaviour and time dependent strength (ultimate tensile strength after
100 000 hours) are in accordance with national or international standards or specifications and if such values are guaranteed
by the steel manufacturer.
(3) Pipes fabricated by a welding procedure approved by the Society may also be used.
(4) Pipes made of copper and copper alloys are to be seamless.
(5) Use of grey cast iron is not allowed when the design pressure exceeds 1,3 MPa.
(6) Accessories of aluminium or aluminium alloys intended for flammable oil systems may be accepted subject to the satisfactory
result of an endurance flame test to be carried out according to the "Rules for the type approval of flexible hoses and expansion
joints" issued by the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 161


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 5 : Minimum wall thickness for steel pipes

Minimum nominal wall thickness, in mm Minimum Minimum extra


External diameter, Sea water pipes, bilge and ballast systems (1) reinforced wall reinforced wall
in mm Other piping thickness, in mm thickness, in mm
normally full (4) normally empty systems (1) (4) (2) (3) (4)
10,2 - 12,0 1,6
13,5 - 19,3 1,8
20,0 2,0
21,3 - 25,0 3,2 2,4 2,0
26,7 - 33,7 3,2 2,4 2,0
38,0 - 44,5 3,6 2,6 2,0 4,8 7,1
48,3 3,6 2,6 2,3 5,0 7,1
51,0 - 63,5 4,0 2,9 2,3 5,0 7,6
70,0 4,0 2,9 2,6 5,0 7,6
76,1 - 82,5 4,5 2,9 2,6 5,0 7,6
88,9 - 108,0 4,5 3,2 2,9 5,4 7,8
114,3 - 127,0 4,5 3,6 3,2 6,0 8,8
133,0 - 139,7 4,5 4,0 3,6 6,3 9,5
152,4 - 168,3 4,5 4,0 7,1 11,0
177,8 5,0 4,0 8,1 12,7
193,7 5,4 4,0 8,1 12,7
219,1 5,9 4,0 8,1 12,7
244,5 - 273,0 6,3 4,0 8,8 12,7
298,5 - 368,0 6,3 4,5 8,8 12,7
406,4 - 457,2 6,3 5,6 8,8 12,7
(1) Attention is drawn to the special requirements regarding:
bilge and ballast systems
scupper and discharge pipes
sounding, air and overflow pipes
ventilation systems
oxyacetylene welding systems
CO2 fire-extinguishing systems (see Ch 4, Sec 13)
(2) Reinforced wall thickness applies to pipes passing through tanks containing a fluid distinct from that conveyed by the pipe,
however the pipe thickness may not be greater than the tank plating.
(3) Extra-reinforced wall thickness applies to pipes connected to the shell, however the pipe thickness may not be greater than
what required by these Rules for shell.
(4) For pipes efficiently protected against corrosion, the thickness may be reduced by an amount up to than 1 mm.
Note 1: A different thickness may be considered by the Society on a case by case basis, provided that it complies with recognized
standards.
Note 2: The thickness of threaded pipes is to be measured at the bottom of the thread.
Note 3: The minimum thickness listed in this table is the nominal wall thickness and no allowance is required for negative tolerance
or reduction in thickness due to bending.
Note 4: For larger diameters, the minimum wall thickness will be specially considered by the Society.

2.2.2 Permissible stress where:


a) For carbon steel and alloy steel pipes with a design tem- Rm,20 : Minimum tensile strength of the material at
perature equal to or less than 300 C, the value of the ambient temperature (20C), in N/mm2
permissible stress K is to be taken equal to the lowest of
the following values: Re : Minimum yield strength or 0,2% proof stress
Rm,20 / 2,4 or Re / 1,5 when the materials tests are at the design temperature, in N/mm2
carried out under the supervision of the Society b) For carbon steel and alloys steel pipes with a design
Rm,20 / 2,7 or Re / 1,8 when the materials tests are temperature above 300 C and for copper and copper
not carried out under the supervision of the Society alloys pipes, the permissible stress K is given in:

162 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Tab 9 for carbon and carbon-manganese steel pipes b) When the bending radius is not given, the thickness
reduction is to be taken equal to:
Tab 10 for alloy steel pipes, and
t0 / 10
Tab 11 for copper and copper alloy pipes,
c) For straight pipes, the thickness reduction is to be taken
as a function of the temperature. Intermediate values
equal to 0.
may be obtained by interpolation.

c) The permissible stress values adopted for materials other Table 7 : Minimum wall thickness
than carbon steel, alloy steel, copper and copper alloy for stainless steel pipes
will be specially considered by the Society.
External diameter, Minimum wall thickness,
Table 6 : Minimum wall thickness in mm in mm
for copper and copper alloy pipes
up to 17,2 1,0
up to 48,3 1,6
External diameter, Minimum wall thickness, in mm
in mm up to 88,9 2,0
Copper Copper alloy
up to 168,3 2,3
8 - 10 1,0 0,8
up to 219,1 2,6
12 - 20 1,2 1,0
up to 273,0 2,9
25 - 44,5 1,5 1,2
up to 406,4 3,6
50 - 76,1 2,0 1,5
over 406,4 4
88,9 - 108 2,5 2,0
Note 1: A different thickness may be considered by the Soci-
133 - 159 3,0 2,5
ety on a case by case basis, provided that it complies with
193,7 - 267 3,5 3,0 recognized standards.
273 - 457,2 4,0 3,5
470 4,0 3,5 Table 8 : Minimum wall thickness
for aluminium and aluminium alloy pipes
508 4,5 4,0
Note 1: A different thickness may be considered by the Soci-
External diameter, Minimum wall thickness,
ety on a case by case basis, provided that it complies with
in mm in mm
recognized standards.
0 - 10 1,5
2.2.3 Thickness reduction due to bending 12 - 38 2,0
43 - 57 2,5
a) Unless otherwise justified, the thickness reduction b due
to bending is not to exceed: 76 - 89 3,0
108 - 133 4,0
Dt 0
b = -----------
- 159 - 194 4,5
2 ,5
219 - 273 5,0
where:
above 273 5,5
: Bending radius measured on the centre line Note 1: A different thickness may be considered by the Soci-
of the pipe, in mm ety on a case by case basis, provided that it complies with
recognized standards.
D : As defined in [1.4.1]
Note 2: For sea water pipes, the minimum thickness is not to
t0 : As defined in [2.2.1]. be less than 5 mm.

Table 9 : Permissible stresses for carbon and carbon-manganese steel pipes

Specified minimum tensile strength, Design temperature, in C


in N/mm2 300 350 400 410 420 430 440 450
320 62 57 55 55 54 54 54 49
360 76 69 68 68 68 64 56 49
410 93 86 84 79 71 64 56 49
460 111 101 99 98 85 73 62 53
490 121 111 109 98 85 73 62 53

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 163


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 10 : Permissible stresses for alloy steel pipes

Specified Design temperature, in C


minimum tensile
Type of steel
strength, 300 350 400 440 450 460 470
in N/mm2
1Cr1/2Mo 440 114 106 102 101 101 100 99
2 1/4Cr1Mo annealed 410 50 47 45 44 43 43 42
2 1/4Cr1Mo normalized and
490 144 140 136 130 128 127 116
tempered below 750C
2 1/4Cr1Mo normalized and
490 144 140 136 130 122 114 105
tempered above 750C
1/2Cr 1/2Mo 1/4V 460 120 115 111 106 105 103 102

Specified Design temperature, in C


minimum tensile
Type of steel
strength, 480 490 500 510 520 530 540 550 560 570
in N/mm2
1Cr1/2Mo 440 98 97 91 76 62 51 42 34 27 22
2 1/4Cr1Mo annealed 410 42 42 41 41 41 40 40 40 37 32
2 1/4Cr1Mo normalized and
490 106 96 86 79 67 58 49 43 37 32
tempered below 750C
2 1/4Cr1Mo normalized and
490 96 88 79 72 64 56 49 43 37 32
tempered above 750C
1/2Cr 1/2Mo 1/4V 460 101 99 97 94 82 72 62 53 45 37

Table 11 : Permissible stresses for copper and copper alloy pipes

Specified minimum Design temperature, in C


Material (annealed) tensile strength,
in N/mm2 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300

Copper 215 41 41 40 40 34 27,5 18,5


Aluminium brass 325 78 78 78 78 78 51 24,5
Copper-nickel 95/5
275 68 68 67 65,5 64 62 59 56 52 48 44
and 90/10
Copper-nickel
365 81 79 77 75 73 71 69 67 65,5 64 62
70/30

2.2.4 Corrosion allowance 2.3 Calculation of high temperature pipes


The values of corrosion allowance c are given for steel pipes
in Tab 12 and for non-ferrous metallic pipes in Tab 13. 2.3.1 General

2.2.5 Tees For main steam piping having a design temperature exceed-
As well as complying with the provisions of [2.2.1] to ing 400C, calculations are to be submitted to the Society
concerning the stresses due to internal pressure, piping
[2.2.4], the thickness tT of pipes on which a branch is
weight and any other external load, and to thermal expan-
welded to form a Tee is not to be less than that given by the
sion, for all cases of actual operation and for all lengths of
following formula:
piping.
D
t T = 1 + ------1 t 0 The calculations are to include, in particular:
D
where: the components, along the three principal axes, of the
forces and moments acting on each branch of piping
D1 : External diameter of the branch pipe
D : As defined in [1.4.1] the components of the displacements and rotations
causing the above forces and moments
t0 : As defined in [2.2.1].
Note 1: This requirement may be dispensed with for Tees provided all parameters necessary for the computation of forces,
with a reinforcement or extruded. moments and stresses.

164 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

In way of bends, the calculations are to be carried out tak- 2.3.2 Thermal stress
ing into account, where necessary, the pipe ovalisation and The combined stress ID, in N/mm2, due to thermal expan-
its effects on flexibility and stress increase.
sion, calculated by the following formula:
A certain amount of cold springing, calculated on the basis
of expected thermal expansion, is to be applied to the pip- ID = ( 2 + 4 2 ) 0 ,5
ing during installation. Such springing is to be neglected in is to be such as to satisfy the following equation:
stress calculations; it may, however, be taken into account
in terms of its effect on thrusts on turbines and other parts. ID 0 ,75 K20 + 0 ,25 K T

Table 12 : Corrosion allowance for steel pipes where:


: Value of the longitudinal stress due to bending
Corrosion moments caused by thermal expansion,
Piping system allowance,
in mm
increased, if necessary, by adequate factors for
bends, in N/mm2; in general it is not necessary
Superheated steam 0,3 to take account of the effect of axial force
Saturated steam 0,8
: Value of the tangential stress due to torque
Steam coils in liquid fuel tanks 2,0 caused by thermal expansion, in N/mm2; in
Feed water for boilers in open circuit systems 1,5 general it is not necessary to take account of the
Feed water for boilers in closed circuit systems 0,5 effect of shear force
Blow-down systems for boilers 1,5 K20 : Value of the permissible stress for the material
Compressed air 1,0 employed, calculated according to [2.2.2], for a
temperature of 20C, in N/mm2
Hydraulic oil 0,3
Lubricating oil 0,3 KT : Value of the permissible stress for the material
employed, calculated according to [2.2.2], for
Fuel oil and JP5-NATO(F44) 1,0
the design temperature T, in N/mm2.
Thermal oil 1,0
Fresh water 0,8 2.3.3 Longitudinal stresses
Sea water normally full 3,0 The sum of longitudinal stresses L, in N/mm2, due to pres-
normally empty (1) 2,0 sure, piping weight and any other external loads is to be
Refrigerants referred to in Section 13 0,3 such as to satisfy the following equation:
(1) Assuming that arrangements are made to allow com- L K T
plete drainage of the pipe.
Note 1: For pipes passing through tanks, an additional cor- where KT is defined in [2.3.2].
rosion allowance is to be considered in order to account for
the external corrosion. 2.3.4 Alternative limits for permissible stresses
Note 2: The corrosion allowance of pipes efficiently protected
against corrosion may be reduced by no more than 50%. Alternative limits for permissible stresses may be considered
Note 3: When the corrosion resistance of alloy steels is ade- by the Society in special cases or when calculations have
quately demonstrated, the corrosion allowance may be dis- been carried out following a procedure based on hypothe-
regarded. ses other than those considered above.

Table 13 : Corrosion allowance


for non-ferrous metal pipes 2.4 Junction of pipes

Corrosion 2.4.1 General


Piping material (1) allowance, a) The junctions between metallic pipe lengths or between
in mm (2) metallic pipe lengths and fittings are to be made by:
Copper 0,8
direct welding (butt-weld, socket-weld)
Brass 0,8
bolted flanges (welded-on or screwed-on)
Copper-tin alloys 0,8
threaded sleeve joints, or
Copper-nickel alloys with less than 10% of Ni 0,8
Copper-nickel alloys with at least 10% of Ni 0,5 mechanical joints (see [2.4.5]).
Aluminium and aluminium alloys 0,5 The joints are to comply with a recognized standard or
to be of a design proven to be suitable for the intended
(1) The corrosion allowance for other materials will be
purpose and acceptable to the Society. See also [2.1.2].
specially considered by the Society. Where their resis-
tance to corrosion is adequately demonstrated, the cor- The expression "mechanical joints" means devices
rosion allowance may be disregarded. intended for direct connection of pipe lengths other
(2) In cases of media with high corrosive action, a higher than by welding, flanges or threaded joints described in
corrosion allowance may be required by the Society. [2.4.2], [2.4.3] and [2.4.4].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 165


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

b) The number of joints in flammable oil piping systems is 2.4.3 Metallic flange connections
to be kept to the minimum necessary for mounting and
a) Flanges are to comply with a standard recognized by
dismantling purposes. the Society. This standard is to cover the design pressure
c) The gaskets and packings used for the joints are to suit and design temperature of the piping system.
the design pressure, the design temperature and the b) Flange material is to be suitable for the nature and tem-
nature of the fluids conveyed. perature of the fluid, as well as for the material of the
d) The junction between plastic pipes is to comply with Ch pipe on which the flange is to be attached.
1, App 2. c) Flanges are to be attached to the pipes by welding or
screwing in accordance with one of the designs shown
2.4.2 Welded metallic joints in Fig 1.
a) Welded joints are to be used in accordance with Tab 14. Permitted applications are indicated in Tab 15.
Welding and non destructive testing of welds are to be Alternative methods of attachment will be specially con-
carried out in accordance with [3]. sidered by the Society.
b) Butt-welded joints are to be of full penetration type,
with or without special provision for a high quality of 2.4.4 Slip-on threaded joints
root side. a) Slip-on threaded joints having pipe threads where pres-
sure-tight joints are made on the threads with parallel or
The expression "special provision for a high quality of
tapered threads are to comply with requirements of a
root side" means that butt welds were accomplished as
recognized national or international standard and are to
double welded or by use of a backing ring or inert gas
be acceptable to the Society.
back-up on first pass, or other similar methods accepted
by the Society. b) Slip-on threaded joints may be used for piping systems
in accordance with Tab 14.
c) Slip-on sleeve and socket welded joints are to have
sleeves, sockets and weldments of adequate dimensions c) Threaded joints may be accepted also in CO2 piping
in compliance with a standard recognised by the Soci- systems, provided that they are used only inside pro-
ety. tected spaces and in CO2 cylinder rooms.

Table 14 : Use of welded and threaded metallic joints in piping systems

Permitted
Joints Restrictions of use
classes of piping
Butt-welded, with special provision III, II, I no restrictions
for a high quality of root side (1)
Butt-welded, without special provi- III, II no restrictions
sion for a high quality of root side (1)
Slip-on sleeve and socket welded (2) III no restrictions
Threaded sleeve joints with tapered I not allowed for:
thread (3) pipes with outside diameter of more than 33,7 mm
pipes inside tanks
piping systems conveying toxic or flammable media or services where
fatigue, severe erosion or crevice corrosion is expected to occur.
III, II not allowed for:
pipes with outside diameter of more than 60,3 mm
pipes inside tanks
piping systems conveying toxic or flammable media or services where
fatigue, severe erosion or crevice corrosion is expected to occur.
Threaded sleeve joints with parallel III not allowed for:
thread (3) pipes with outside diameter of more than 60,3 mm
pipes inside tanks
piping systems conveying toxic or flammable media or services where
fatigue, severe erosion or crevice corrosion is expected to occur.
(1) For expression special provision for a high quality of root side see [2.4.2] item b).
(2) Particular cases may be allowed by the Society for piping systems of Class I and II having outside diameter 88,9 mm except for
piping systems conveying toxic media or services where fatigue, severe erosion or crevice corrosion is expected to occur.
(3) In particular cases, sizes in excess of those mentioned above may be accepted by the Society if found in compliance with a rec-
ognised national and/or international standard.
Note 1: Other applications will be specially considered by the Society.

166 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Figure 1 : Types of metallic flange connections

   

     

   



  

Note 1: For type D, the pipe and flange are to be screwed with a tapered thread and the diameter of the screw portion of the pipe over the
thread is not to be appreciably less than the outside diameter of the unthreaded pipe. For certain types of thread, after the flange has been
screwed hard home, the pipe is to be expanded into the flange.

Note 2: The leg length of the fillet weld, as well as the dimension of the groove penetration in the flange, is to be in general equal to 1,5 times
the pipe thickness but not less than 5 mm.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 167


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 15 : Use of metallic flange connections in piping systems (types as shown in Fig 1)

Class of piping (see Tab 3)


Type of media conveyed
I II III
Toxic or corrosive media A1, A2, B1, B2, B3 A1, A2, B1, B2, B3, not applicable
Flammable liquids (where heated above flashpoint (1) (2) (4) C1, C2, C3
or having flashpoint < 60C) (1) (4)
Liquefied gases
Fuel oil A1, A2, B1, B2, B3 A1, A2, B1, B2, B3, A1, A2, B1, B2, B3,
Lubricating oil C1, C2, C3 C1, C2, C3, E2
Steam A1, A2, B1, B2, B3 A1, A2, B1, B2, B3, A1, A2, B1, B2, B3,
Thermal oil (2) (3) C1, C2, C3, D, E2 (6) C1, C2, C3, D, E2
Other media as water, air, gases (refrigerants), A1, A2, B1, B2, B3 A1, A2, B1, B2, B3, A1, A2, B1, B2, B3,
non-flammable hydraulic oil, etc. (3) C1, C2, C3, D, E2 C1, C2, C3, D, E1, E2
(6) (5) (6) (7)
(1) When design pressure p (see [1.3.2]) exceeds 1 MPa, types A1 and A2 only.
(2) For nominal diameter ND 150 mm, types A1 and A2 only.
(3) When design temperature T (see [1.3.3] exceeds 400C, types A1 and A2 only.
(4) For cargo piping of chemical carriers, IBC Code Ch. 5, 5.3 is to be applied. For cargo piping of gas carriers, IGC Code Ch. 5, 5.4
is to be applied.
(5) Type E2 only, for design pressure p 1,6 Mpa and design temperature T 150C.
(6) Types D and E1 only, for design temperature T 250C.
(7) Type E1 only, for water pipelines and for open ended lines (e.g. drain, overflow, air vent piping, etc.).

2.4.5 Mechanical joints f) In general, mechanical joints are to be of fire resistant


type as required by Tab 16.
Due to the great variations in design and configuration of
mechanical joints, specific recommendation regarding cal- g) Mechanical joints, which in the event of damage could
culation method for theoretical strength calculations is not cause fire or flooding, are not to be used in piping sec-
specified. The Type Approval is to be based on the results of tions directly connected to the shell openings or tanks
testing of the actual joints. containing flammable fluids.
Below specified requirements are applicable to pipe h) The mechanical joints are to be designed to withstand
unions, compression couplings, slip-on joints as shown in internal and external pressure as applicable and, where
Fig 2. Similar joints complying with these requirements may used in suction lines, are to be capable of operating
be acceptable. under vacuum.
a) Mechanical joints including pipe unions, compression
i) The number of mechanical joints in flammable liquid
couplings, slip-on joints and similar joints are to be of
systems is to be kept to a minimum. In general, flanged
approved type for the service conditions and the
joints conforming to recognised standards are to be
intended application.
used.
b) Where the application of mechanical joints results in
j) Piping in which a mechanical joint is fitted is to be ade-
reduction in pipe wall thickness due to the use of bite
quately adjusted, aligned and supported. Supports or
type rings or other structural elements, this is to be taken
hangers are not to be used to force alignment of piping
into account in determining the minimum wall thick-
at the point of connection.
ness of the pipe to withstand the design pressure.

c) Construction of mechanical joints is to prevent the pos- k) Slip-on joints are not to be used in pipelines in tanks
sibility of tightness failure affected by pressure pulsa- and other spaces which are not easily accessible, unless
tion, piping vibration, temperature variation and other approved by the Society. Application of these joints
similar adverse effects occurring during operation on inside tanks may be permitted only for the same media
board. that is in the tanks. Unrestrained slip-on joints are to be
used only in cases where compensation of lateral pipe
d) Material of mechanical joints is to be compatible with deformation is necessary. Usage of these joints as the
the piping material and internal and external media. main means of pipe connection is not permitted.

e) As far as applicable, the mechanical joints are to be l) Application of mechanical joints and their acceptable
tested to a burst pressure of 4 times the design pressure. use for each service is indicated in Tab 16; dependence
For design pressures above 200 bar the required burst upon the class of piping, pipe dimensions, working
pressure is to be specially considered by the Society. pressure and temperature is indicated in Tab 17.

168 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

m) In some particular cases, sizes in excess of those men- acceptance of the joint type is to be subject to approval
tioned above may be accepted by the Society if they are for the intended application, and subject to conditions
in compliance with a recognised national and/or inter- of the approval and applicable Rules.
national standard.
n) Application of various mechanical joints may be o) Mechanical joints are to be tested in accordance with
accepted as indicated by Tab 16. However, in all cases, the provisions of Tab 33.

Figure 2 : Examples of mechanical joints

 

   
 


   
 

    

     

 

      

 

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 169


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 16 : Application of mechanical joints

Kind of connections
Systems
Pipe unions Compression couplings (5) Slip-on joints
Flammable fluids (flash point > 60C)
1 JP5-NATO(F44) lines + + + (2) (3)
2 Fuel oil lines + + + (2) (3)
3 Lubricating oil lines + + + (2) (3)
4 Hydraulic oil + + + (2) (3)
5 Thermal oil + + + (2) (3)
Sea water
6 Bilge lines + + + (1)
7 Fire main and water spray + + + (3)
8 Foam system + + + (3)
9 Sprinkler system + + + (3)
10 Ballast system + + + (1)
11 Cooling water system + + + (1)
12 Tank cleaning services + + +
13 Non-essential systems + + +
Fresh water
14 Cooling water system + + + (1)
15 Condensate return + + + (1)
16 Non-essential systems + + +
Sanitary/Drains/Scuppers
17 Deck drains (internal) + + + (4)
18 Sanitary drains + + +
19 Scuppers and discharge (overboard) + +
Sounding/Vent
20 Water tanks/Dry spaces + + +
21 Oil tanks (flash point > 60C) + + + (2) (3)
Miscellaneous
22 Starting/Control air (1) + +
23 Service air (non-essential) + + +
24 Brine + + +
24 CO2 system (1) + +
25 Steam + +
Note 1:
+ : Application is allowed
: Application is not allowed.
(1) Inside machinery spaces of category A - only approved fire resistant types.
(2) Not inside machinery spaces of category A or accommodation spaces. May be accepted in other machinery spaces provided
the joints are located in easily visible and accessible positions.
(3) Approved fire resistant types.
(4) Above freeboard deck only.
(5) If compression couplings include any components which readily deteriorate in case of fire, they are to be of approved fire resis-
tant type as required for slip-on joints.

170 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 17 : Application of mechanical joints depending upon the class of piping

Classes of piping systems


Types of joints
Class I Class II Class III
Pipe Unions
Welded and brazed types + (OD 60,3 mm) + (OD 60,3 mm) +
Compression Couplings
Swage type + + +
Bite type + (OD 60,3 mm) + (OD 60,3 mm) +
Flared type + (OD 60,3 mm) + (OD 60,3 mm) +
Press type +
Slip-on Joints
Machine grooved type + + +
Grip type + +
Slip type + +
Note 1:
+ : Application is allowed
: Application is not allowed.

2.5 Protection against overpressure c) The discharge capacity of the devices fitted on pipes for
preventing overpressure is to be such that the pressure
2.5.1 General in these pipes cannot exceed the design pressure by
a) These requirements deal with the protection of piping more than 10%.
systems against overpressure, with the exception of heat
exchangers and pressure vessels, which are dealt with in
2.6 Flexible hoses and expansion joints
Ch 1, Sec 3, [2.4].
b) Safety valves are to be sealed after setting. 2.6.1 General
2.5.2 Protection of flammable oil systems a) The Society may permit the use of flexible hoses and
Provisions shall be made to prevent overpressure in any expansion joints, either in metallic or non-metallic
flammable oil tank or in any part of the flammable oil sys- materials, provided they are approved for the intended
tems, including the filling pipes. service.

2.5.3 Protection of pump and compressor b) Flexible hoses and expansion joints are to be of a type
discharges approved by the Society, designed in accordance with
a) Provisions are to be made so that the discharge pressure [2.6.3] and tested in accordance with [19.2.1].
of pumps and compressors cannot exceed the pressure
for which the pipes located on the discharge of these c) Flexible hoses and expansion joints are to be installed in
pumps and compressors are designed. accordance with [5.9.3].

b) When provided on the pump discharge for this purpose, d) Flexible hoses and expansion joints intended for piping
safety valves are to lead back to the pump suction. systems with a design temperature below the ambient
c) The discharge capacity of the safety valves installed on temperature will be given special consideration by the
pumps and compressors is to be such that the pressure Society.
at the discharge side cannot exceed by more than 10%
the design pressure of the discharge pipe in the event of 2.6.2 Documentation
operation with closed discharge.
The information, drawings and documentation listed in
2.5.4 Protection of pipes [1.2.1] and [1.2.2] are to be submitted to the Society for
each type of flexible hose or expansion joint intended to be
a) Pipes likely to be subjected to a pressure exceeding their
used.
normal working pressure are to be provided with safety
valves or equivalent overpressure protecting devices.
2.6.3 Design of flexible hoses and expansion joints
b) In particular, pipes located on the low pressure side of
pressure reducing valves are to be provided with safety a) Flexible pipes and expansion joints are to be made of
valves unless they are designed for the maximum pres- materials resistant to the marine environment and to the
sure on the high pressure side of the pressure reducing fluid they are to convey. Metallic materials are to com-
valve. See also [1.3.2] and [2.9.1]. ply with [2.1].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 171


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

b) Flexible pipes and expansion joints are to be designed e) Special consideration will be given by the Society to the
so as to withstand: use of expansion joints in water lines for other services,
including ballast lines in machinery spaces, in duct
external contact with hydrocarbons
keels and inside double bottom water ballast tanks, and
internal pressure bilge lines inside double bottom tanks and deep tanks.
vibrations f) The distance between pipe flanges is to be between the
pressure impulses. manufactured contraction length and extension length
of relevant flexible hose.
c) Flexible pipes intended to convey fuel oil or JP5-NATO
(F44) or lubricating oil and end attachments are to be of
fire-resisting materials of adequate strength and are to 2.7 Valves and accessories
be constructed to the satisfaction of the Society.
2.7.1 General
Where a protective lining is provided for this purpose, it
a) Valves and accessories are normally to be built in accor-
is to be impervious to hydrocarbons and to hydrocarbon
dance with a recognized standard.
vapours.
Failing this, they are to be approved by the Society
d) Flexible pipes intended to convey fuel oil or JP5-NATO when they are fitted:
(F44) or lubricating oil are to be fitted with a metallic
braid. in a class I piping system, or
in a class II piping system with a diameter exceeding
e) As a general rule, flexible hoses are to be fitted with
100 mm, or
crimped connections or equivalent. For water pipes sub-
ject to a pressure not exceeding 0,5 MPa, as well as for on the ship side, on the collision bulkhead or on fuel
scavenge air and supercharge air lines of internal com- or JP5-NATO (F44) tanks under static pressure.
bustion engines, clips made of galvanized steel or corro-
b) Shut-off valves are to be provided where necessary to
sion-resistant material with thickness not less than 0,4 isolate pumps, heat exchangers, pressure vessels, etc.,
mm may be used. from the rest of the piping system, and in particular:
f) Flexible pipes and expansion joints are to be so to allow the isolation of duplicate components with-
designed that their bursting pressure at the service tem- out interrupting the fluid circulation
perature is not less than 4 times their maximum service
pressure, with a minimum of 2 MPa. Exemptions from for maintenance or repair purposes.
this requirement may be granted for large diameter
2.7.2 Design of valves and accessories
expansion joints used on sea water lines.
a) Materials of valve and accessory bodies are to comply
g) The junctions of flexible hoses and expansion joints to with [2.1].
their couplings are to withstand a pressure at least equal
to the bursting pressure defined in f). b) Connections of valves and accessories with pipes are to
comply with [2.4].
2.6.4 Conditions of use of flexible hoses and c) All valves and accessories are to be so designed as to
expansion joints prevent the loosening of covers and glands when they
a) The use of flexible hoses and expansion joints is to be are operated.
limited to the minimum practicable.
d) Valves are to be so designed as to shut with a right-hand
b) The position of flexible hoses and expansion joints is to (clockwise) motion of the wheels.
be clearly shown on the piping drawings submitted to e) Valves are to be provided with local indicators showing
the Society. whether they are open or shut, unless this is readily
c) The use of non-metallic expansion joints on pipes con- apparent.
nected to sea inlets and overboard discharges will be
given special consideration by the Society. As a rule, the 2.7.3 Valves with remote control
fitting of such joints between the ship side and the a) All valves which are provided with remote control are
valves mentioned in [2.8.3] is not permitted. Further- also to be designed for local manual operation.
more, unless the above-mentioned valves are fitted with
remote controls operable from above the bulkhead b) The remote control system and means of local operation
deck, efficient means are to be provided to limit the are to be independent. In this respect, arrangement of
flooding of the ship in the event of rupture of the expan- the local operation by means of a fixed hand pump will
sion joints. be specially considered by the Society.
c) In the case of valves which are to be provided with
d) Expansion joints may be fitted in sea water lines, pro-
remote control in accordance with the Rules, opening
vided they are arranged with guards which effectively
and/or closing of the valves by local manual means is
enclose, but do not interfere with, the action of the
not to render the remote control system inoperable.
expansion joints and reduce to the minimum practica-
ble any flow of water into the machinery spaces in the d) Power failure of the remote control system is not to
event of failure of the flexible elements. cause an undesired change of the valve position.

172 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

2.8 Sea inlets and overboard discharges 2.8.4 Gratings


a) Gratings are to have a free flow area not less than twice
2.8.1 General the total section of the pipes connected to the inlet.
Except where expressly stated in Article [8], the require- b) When gratings are secured by means of screws with a
ments of this sub-article do not apply to scuppers and sani- countersunk head, the tapped holes provided for such
tary discharges. screws are not to pass through the plating or doubling
plates outside distance pieces or chests.
2.8.2 Design of sea inlets and overboard
discharges c) Screws used for fixing gratings are not to be located in
the corners of openings in the hull or of doubling plates.
a) All inlets and discharges in the shell plating are to be fit-
d) In the case of large sea inlets, the screws used for fixing
ted with efficient and accessible arrangements for pre-
the gratings are to be locked and protected from corro-
venting accidental ingress of water into the ship.
sion.
b) Sea inlets and overboard discharges are to be fitted with e) When gratings are cleared by use of compressed air or
valves complying with [2.7] and [2.8.3]. steam devices, the chests, distance pieces and valves of
c) Sea inlets and discharges related to the operation of sea inlets and outlets thus arranged are to be so con-
main and auxiliary machinery are to be fitted with structed as to withstand the maximum pressure to which
readily accessible valves between the pipes and the they may be subjected when such devices are operating.
shell plating or between the pipes and fabricated boxes
attached to the shell plating. The valves may be con- 2.8.5 Ship side connections for blow-down of boilers
trolled locally and are to be provided with indicators a) Blow-down pipes of boilers are to be provided with
showing whether they are open or closed. cocks or valves placed as near the end of the pipes as
possible, while remaining readily accessible and
d) Sea inlets are to be so designed and arranged as to limit located above the engine room floor.
turbulence and to avoid the ingress of air due to motion
of the ship. b) Blow-down valves are to be so designed that it is easy to
ascertain whether they are open or shut. Where cocks
e) Sea inlets are to be fitted with gratings complying with are used, the control keys are to be such that they can-
[2.8.4]. not be taken off unless the cocks are shut. Where valves
f) Provisions are to be made for clearing sea inlet gratings. are used, the control-wheels are to be permanently fixed
to the spindle.
g) Sea chests are to be suitably protected against corrosion.
c) A protection ring is to be fitted on the shell plating, out-
2.8.3 Valves side, at the end of the blow-down pipes. The spigot of
the valve referred to in [2.8.3], item b), is to pass
a) Sea inlet and overboard discharge valves are to be through this ring.
secured:
directly on the shell plating, or 2.9 Control and monitoring
on sea chests built on the shell plating, with scant-
2.9.1 General
lings in compliance with Part B of the Rules, or
a) Local indicators are to be provided for at least the fol-
on extra-reinforced and short distance pieces lowing parameters:
attached to the shell (see Tab 5).
pressure, in pressure vessels, at pump or compressor
b) The bodies of the valves and distance pieces are to have discharge, at the inlet of the equipment served, on
a spigot passing through the plating without projecting the low pressure side of pressure reducing valves
beyond the external surface of such plating or of the temperatures, in tanks and vessels, at heat
doubling plates and stiffening rings, if any. exchanger inlet and outlet
c) Valves are to be secured by means of: levels, in tanks and vessels containing liquids.
bolts screwed through the plating with a counter- b) Safeguards are to be provided where an automatic
sunk head, or action is necessary to restore acceptable values for a
faulty parameter.
studs screwed in heavy pads themselves secured to
the hull or chest plating, without penetration of the c) Automatic controls are to be provided where it is neces-
plating by the stud holes. sary to maintain parameters related to piping systems at
a pre-set value.
d) The use of butterfly valves will be specially considered
by the Society. In any event, butterfly valves not fitted 2.9.2 Level gauges
with flanges are not to be used for water inlets or over- Level gauges used in flammable oil systems are to be of a
board discharges unless provisions are made to allow type approved by the Society and are not to require penetra-
disassembling at sea of the pipes served by these valves tion below the top of the tank and their failure or overfilling
without any risk of flooding. of the tanks is not to permit release of fuel.
e) The materials of the valve bodies and connecting pieces Level gauges, when allowed, are to be made of heat-resis-
are to comply with Tab 4. tant material and efficiently protected against shocks.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 173


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

3 Welding of steel piping 3.3.3 Accessories


a) When accessories such as valves are connected by
welding to pipes, they are to be provided with necks of
3.1 Application
sufficient length to prevent abnormal deformations dur-
3.1.1 ing the execution of welding or heat treatment.
b) For the fixing by welding of branch pipes on pipes, it is
a) The following requirements apply to welded joints
necessary to provide either a thickness increase as indi-
belonging to class I or II piping systems.
cated in [2.2.5] or a reinforcement by doubling plate or
At the discretion of the Society they may also be equivalent.
requested for class III piping systems.
b) This article does not apply to refrigerated spaces instal- 3.4 Preparation of elements to be welded
lation piping systems operating at temperatures lower and execution of welding
than minus 40C.
3.4.1 General
c) The requirements for qualification of welding proce-
Attention is drawn to the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 3, which
dures are given in NR216 Materials.
apply to the welding of pressure pipes.

3.2 General 3.4.2 Edge preparation for welded joints


The preparation of the edges is preferably to be carried out
3.2.1 Welding processes by mechanical means. When flame cutting is used, care is
a) Welded joints of pipes are to be made by means of elec- to be taken to remove the oxide scales and any notch due to
tric arc or oxyacetylene welding, or any other previ- irregular cutting by matching, grinding or chipping back to
ously approved process. sound metal.

b) When the design pressure exceeds 0,7 MPa, oxyacety- 3.4.3 Abutting of parts to be welded
lene welding is not permitted for pipes with an external a) The elements to be welded are to be so abutted that sur-
diameter greater than 100 mm or a thickness exceeding face misalignments are as small as possible.
6 mm.
b) As a general rule, for elements which are butt-welded
3.2.2 Location of joints without a backing ring the misalignment between inter-
nal walls is not to exceed the lesser of:
The location of welded joints is to be such that as many as
possible can be made in a workshop. The location of the value given in Tab 18 as a function of thickness t
welded joints to be made on board is to be so determined and internal diameter d of these elements, and
as to permit their joining and inspection in satisfactory con- t / 4.
ditions. Where necessary, the pipe ends are to be bored or
slightly expanded so as to comply with these values; the
3.3 Design of welded joints thickness obtained is not to be less than the Rule thick-
ness.
3.3.1 Types of joints c) In the case of welding with a backing ring, smaller val-
a) Except for the fixing of flanges on pipes in the cases ues of misalignment are to be obtained so that the space
mentioned in Fig 1 and for the fixing of branch pipes, between the backing ring and the internal walls of the
joints between pipes and between pipes and fittings are two elements to be assembled is as small as possible;
to be of the butt-welded type. However, for class I pipes normally this space is not to exceed 0,5 mm.
with internal diameter not exceeding 50 mm and for d) The elements to be welded are to be adequately secured
class II pipes, socket welded connections of approved so as to prevent modifications of their relative position
types may be used. and deformations during welding.
b) For butt-welded joints between pipes or between pipes e) Tack welds should be made with an electrode suitable
and flanges or other fittings, correctly adjusted backing for the base metal; tack welds which form part of the fin-
rings may be used; such rings are to be either of the ished weld should be made using approved procedures.
same grade of steel as the elements to be welded or of When welding materials requiring preheating are
such a grade as not to adversely influence the weld; if employed, the same preheating should be applied dur-
the backing ring cannot be removed after welding, it is ing tack welding.
to be correctly profiled.
Table 18 : Maximum value of misalignment
3.3.2 Assembly of pipes of unequal thickness
If the difference of thickness between pipes to be butt- t, in mm
welded exceeds 10% of the thickness of the thinner pipe d, in mm
t6 6 < t 10 10 < t
plus 1 mm, subject to a maximum of 4 mm, the thicker pipe
is to be thinned down to the thickness of the thinner pipe on d < 150 1,0 1,0 1,0
a length at least equal to 4 times the offset, including the 150 d < 300 1,0 1,5 1,5
width of the weld if so desired. 300 d 1,0 1,5 2,0

174 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

3.4.4 Protection against adverse weather 3.5.2 Heat treatment after welding other than
conditions oxyacetylene welding
a) Pressure pipes are to be welded, both on board and in a) Stress relieving heat treatment after welding other than
the shop, away from draughts and sudden temperature oxyacetylene welding is to be performed as indicated in
variations. Tab 20, depending on the type of steel and thickness of
the pipes.
b) Unless special justification is given, no welding is to be
performed if the temperature of the base metal is lower b) The stress relieving heat treatment is to consist in heat-
than 0C. ing slowly and uniformly to a temperature within the
range indicated in the Table, soaking at this temperature
3.4.5 Preheating for a suitable period, normally 2 min. per mm of thick-
ness with a minimum of half an hour, cooling slowly
a) Preheating is to be performed as indicated in Tab 19, and uniformly in the furnace to a temperature not
depending on the type of steel, the chemical composi- exceeding 400C and subsequently cooling in still
tion and the pipe thickness. atmosphere.
b) The temperatures given in Tab 19 are based on the use c) In any event, the heat treatment temperature is not to be
of low hydrogen processes. Where low hydrogen pro- higher than (TT - 20)C, where TT is the temperature of
cesses are not used, the Society reserves the right to the final tempering treatment of the material.
require higher preheating temperatures.
3.5.3 Heat treatment after oxyacetylene welding
Table 19 : Preheating temperature
Stress relieving heat treatment after oxyacetylene welding is
to be performed as indicated in Tab 21, depending on the
Thickness of Minimum type of steel.
Type of steel thicker part, preheating
in mm temperature, in C Table 20 : Heat treatment temperature
C Mn t 20 (2) 50
C + --------- 0 ,40 Thickness of Stress relief
and 6
C-Mn Type of steel thicker part, treatment
steels Mn t 20 (2) 100 in mm temperature, in C
C + --------- > 0 ,40
6
C and C-Mn steels t 15 (1) (3) 550 to 620
0,3 Mo t 13 (2) 100
0,3 Mo t 15 (1) 580 to 640
1 Cr 0,5 Mo t < 13 100
1 Cr 0,5 Mo t8 620 to 680
t 13 150
2,25 Cr 1 Mo any (2) 650 to 720
2,25 Cr 1 Mo (1) t < 13 150
0,5 Cr 0,5 Mo V
t 13 200
(1) Where steels with specified Charpy V notch impact
0,5 Cr 0,5 Mo V (1) t < 13 150
properties at low temperature are used, the thickness
t 13 200 above which post-weld heat treatment is to be applied
(1) For 2,25 Cr 1 Mo and 0,5 Cr 0,5 Mo V grades with may be increased, subject to the special agreement of
thicknesses up to 6 mm, preheating may be omitted if the Society.
the results of hardness tests carried out on welding pro- (2) For 2,25Cr 1Mo and 0,5Cr 0,5Mo V grade steels, heat
cedure qualification are considered acceptable by the treatment may be omitted for pipes having thickness
Society. lower than 8 mm, diameter not exceeding 100 mm and
(2) For welding in ambient temperature below 0C, the service temperature not exceeding 450C.
minimum preheating temperature is required indepen- (3) For C and C-Mn steels, stress relieving heat treatment
dent of the thickness unless specially approved by the may be omitted up to 30 mm thickness, subject to the
Society. special agreement of the Society.

3.5 Post-weld heat treatment Table 21 : Heat treatment after oxyacetylene welding

3.5.1 General Heat treatment and


Type of steel
temperature (C)
a) As far as practicable, the heat treatment is to be carried
out in a furnace. Where this is impracticable, and more C and C-Mn Normalizing 880 to 940
particularly in the case of welding on board, the treat- 0,3 Mo Normalizing 900 to 940
ment is to be performed locally by heating uniformly a
1Cr-0,5Mo Normalizing 900 to 960
circular strip, extending on at least 75 mm on both sides
Tempering 640 to 720
of the welded joint; all precautions are to be taken to
permit accurate checking of the temperature and slow 2,25Cr-1Mo Normalizing 900 to 960
cooling after treatment. Tempering 650 to 780

b) For austenitic and austenitic ferritic steels, post-weld 0,5Cr-0,5Mo-0,25V Normalizing 930 to 980
head treatment is generally not required. Tempering 670 to 720

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 175


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

3.6 Inspection of welded joints 4 Bending of pipes


3.6.1 General
4.1 Application
a) The inspection of pressure pipe welded joints is to be
performed at the various stages of the fabrication further 4.1.1 This Article applies to pipes made of:
to the qualifications defined in [3.1.1], item c). alloy or non-alloy steels
b) The examination mainly concerns those parts to be copper and copper alloys
welded further to their preparation, the welded joints stainless steel.
once they have been made and the conditions for carry-
ing out possible heat treatments. 4.2 Bending process
c) The required examinations are to be carried out by qual-
4.2.1 General
ified operators in accordance with procedures and tech-
niques to the Surveyors satisfaction. The bending process is to be such as not to have a detri-
mental influence on the characteristics of the materials or
3.6.2 Visual examination on the strength of the pipes.

Welded joints, including the inside wherever possible, are 4.2.2 Bending radius
to be visually examined. Unless otherwise justified, the bending radius measured on
the centreline of the pipe is not to be less than:
3.6.3 Non-destructive examinations
twice the external diameter for copper and copper alloy,
a) Non-destructive tests for class I pipes are to be per- C steel and stainless steel pipes
formed as follows: 3 times the external diameter for cold bent steel pipes.
butt-welded joints of pipes with an external diame-
ter exceeding 75 mm are to be subjected to full X- 4.2.3 Acceptance criteria
ray examination or equivalent a) The pipes are to be bent in such a way that, in each
transverse section, the difference between the maximum
welded joints other than butt-welded joints and
and minimum diameters after bending does not exceed
which cannot be radiographed are to be examined
10% of the mean diameter; higher values, but not
by magnetic particle or liquid penetrant tests
exceeding 15%, may be allowed in the case of pipes
fillet welds of flange connections are to be exam- which are not subjected in service to appreciable bend-
ined by magnetic particle tests or by other appropri- ing stresses due to thermal expansion or contraction.
ate non-destructive tests.
b) The bending is to be such that the depth of the corruga-
b) Non-destructive tests for class II pipes are to be per- tions is as small as possible and does not exceed 9% of
formed as follows: their length.
butt-welded joints of pipes with an external diame- 4.2.4 Hot bending
ter exceeding 100 mm are to be subjected to at least
a) In the case of hot bending, all arrangements are to be
10% random radiographic examination or equiva-
made to permit careful checking of the metal tempera-
lent
ture and to prevent rapid cooling, especially for alloy
welded joints other than butt-welded joints are to be steels.
examined by magnetic particle tests or by other
b) Hot bending is to be generally carried out in the temper-
appropriate non-destructive tests
ature range 850C-1000C for all steel grades; however,
fillet welds of flange connections may be required to a decreased temperature down to 750C may be
be examined by magnetic particle tests or by other accepted during the forming process.
appropriate non-destructive tests, at the discretion of
the Surveyor. 4.3 Heat treatment after bending
3.6.4 Defects and acceptance criteria 4.3.1 Copper and copper alloy
a) Joints for which non-destructive examinations reveal Copper and copper alloy pipes are to be suitably annealed
unacceptable defects are to be re-welded and subse- after cold bending if their external diameter exceeds
quently to undergo a new non-destructive examination. 50 mm.
The Surveyor may require that the number of joints to be
subjected to non-destructive examination is larger than 4.3.2 Steel
that resulting from the provisions of [3.6.3]. a) After hot bending carried out within the temperature
range specified in [4.2.4], the following applies:
b) The acceptance criteria of defects are:
for C, C-Mn and C-Mo steels, no subsequent heat
for class I pipes, those defined in NR216 Materials treatment is required,
for the special quality level for Cr-Mo and Cr-Mo-V steels, a subsequent stress
for class II pipes, those defined in NR216 Materials relieving heat treatment in accordance with Tab 20
for the normal quality level. is required.

176 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

b) After hot bending performed outside the temperature 5.3 Passage through watertight bulkheads
range specified in [4.2.4], a subsequent new heat treat- or decks
ment in accordance with Tab 21 is required for all
grades. 5.3.1 Penetration of watertight bulkheads and
decks
c) Unless otherwise agreed, after cold bending at a radius
lower than 4 times the external diameter of the pipe, a a) Where penetrations of watertight bulkheads and internal
heat treatment in accordance with Tab 21 is required. decks are necessary for piping, arrangements are to be
made to maintain the watertight integrity.
b) Lead or other heat sensitive materials are not to be used
5 Arrangement and installation of in piping systems which penetrate watertight subdivi-
piping systems sion bulkheads or decks, where deterioration of such
systems in the event of fire would impair the watertight
integrity of the bulkhead or decks.
5.1 General
This applies in particular to the following systems:
5.1.1 Unless otherwise specified, piping and pumping sys- bilge system
tems covered by the Rules are to be permanently fixed on
ballast system
board ship.
scuppers and sanitary discharge systems.

5.2 Location of tanks and piping system c) Where bolted connections are used when passing
through watertight bulkheads or decks, the bolts are not
components
to be screwed through the plating. Where welded con-
nections are used, they are to be welded on both sides
5.2.1 Flammable oil systems of the bulkhead or deck.
Location of tanks and piping system components conveying d) In case of penetrations of watertight bulkheads or decks
flammable fluids under pressure is to comply with [5.10]. by plastic pipes, case by case considerations will be
made by the Society in agreement with the Naval
5.2.2 Piping systems with open ends Authority and based on Ch 1, App 2, [3.6.2].
Attention is to be paid to the requirements for the location
5.3.2 Passage through the collision bulkhead
of open-ended pipes on board ships having to comply with
the provisions of [5.5]. a) A maximum of two pipes may pass through the collision
bulkhead below the bulkhead deck, unless otherwise
5.2.3 Pipe lines located inside tanks justified. Such pipes are to be fitted with suitable valves
operable from above the bulkhead deck and the valve
a) The passage of pipes through tanks, when permitted, chest is to be secured at the bulkhead inside the fore
normally requires special arrangements such as rein- peak. Such valves may be fitted on the after side of the
forced thickness or tunnels, in particular for: collision bulkhead provided that they are readily acces-
sible under all service conditions and the space in
bilge pipes
which they are located is not a cargo space or similar
ballast pipes space. All valves are to be of steel, bronze or other
approved ductile material. Valves of ordinary cast iron
scuppers and sanitary discharges or similar material are not acceptable.
air, sounding and overflow pipes b) The remote operation device of the valve referred to in
fuel oil and JP5-NATO(F44) pipes. a) is to include an indicator to show whether the valve is
open or shut.
b) Junctions of pipes inside tanks are to be made by weld-
ing or welded flange connections. See also [2.4.3]. 5.4 Independence of lines

5.2.4 Overboard discharges 5.4.1 As a general rule, bilge and ballast lines are to be
entirely independent and distinct from lines conveying
Overboard discharges are to be so located as to prevent any
lubricating oil, fuel oil and JP5-NATO(F44), with the excep-
discharge of water into the lifeboats while they are being
tion of:
lowered.
pipes located between collecting boxes and pump suc-
5.2.5 Piping and electrical apparatus tions

As far as possible, pipes are not to pass near switchboards pipes located between pumps and overboard discharges
or other electrical apparatus. If this requirement is impossi- pipes supplying compartments likely to be used alterna-
ble to satisfy, gutterways or masks are to be provided wher- tively for ballast or fuel oil, provided such pipes are fit-
ever deemed necessary to prevent projections of liquid or ted with blind flanges or other appropriate change-over
steam on live parts. devices, in order to avoid any mishandling.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 177


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

5.5 Prevention of progressive flooding 5.8 Protection of pipes

5.5.1 Principle 5.8.1 Protection against shocks


a) In order to comply with the subdivision and damage sta- Pipes passing through vehicle and ro-ro spaces are to be
bility requirements of Pt B, Ch 3, Sec 3, provision is to protected against impact by means of strong casings.
be made to prevent any progressive flooding of a dry For ships having the Military Notations requirements of Part
compartment served by any open-ended pipe, in the E, Chapter 1 also apply.
event that such pipe is damaged or broken in any other
compartment by collision or grounding. 5.8.2 Protection against corrosion and erosion
b) For this purpose, if pipes are situated within assumed a) Pipes are to be efficiently protected against corrosion,
flooded compartments, arrangements are to be made to particularly in their most exposed parts, either by selec-
ensure that progressive flooding cannot thereby extend tion of their constituent materials, or by an appropriate
to compartments other than those assumed to be coating or treatment.
flooded for each case of damage. However, the Society
may permit minor progressive flooding if it is demon- b) The layout and arrangement of sea water pipes are to be
strated that its effects can be easily controlled and the such as to prevent sharp bends and abrupt changes in
safety of the ship is not impaired. Refer to Pt B, Ch 3, section as well as zones where water may stagnate. The
Sec 3. inner surface of pipes is to be as smooth as possible,
especially in way of joints. Where pipes are protected
5.5.2 Extent of damage against corrosion by means of galvanizing or other inner
coating, arrangements are to be made so that this coat-
For the definition of the assumed transverse extent of dam- ing is continuous, as far as possible, in particular in way
age, reference is to be made to Pt B, Ch 3, Sec 3. of joints.
c) Provided that due consideration is given to water veloc-
5.6 Provision for expansion ity with regards to maximum allowed noise levels, such
velocity is not to exceed 3 m/s in continuously used sea
5.6.1 General water systems.
Piping systems are to be so designed and pipes so fixed as d) Arrangements are to be made to avoid galvanic corro-
to allow for relative movement between pipes and the ships sion.
structure, having due regard to:
the temperature of the fluid conveyed 5.8.3 Protection against frosting
the coefficient of thermal expansion of the pipes mate- Pipes are to be adequately insulated against cold wherever
rial deemed necessary to prevent frost.

the deformation of the ships hull. This applies specifically to pipes passing through refriger-
ated spaces and which are not intended to ensure the refrig-
5.6.2 Fitting of expansion devices eration of such spaces.

All pipes subject to thermal expansion and those which, Were the pipes are normally kept empty and without risk of
due to their length, may be affected by deformation of the frost of condensate or were it is proven that the flow of
hull, are to be fitted with expansion pieces or loops. internal fluid is sufficient to prevent frost the present
requirement of insulation could be withdrawn.
5.7 Supporting of the pipes 5.8.4 Protection of high temperature pipes and
components
5.7.1 General
a) All pipes and other components where the temperature
Unless otherwise specified, the fluid lines referred to in this may exceed 220C are to be efficiently insulated.
Section are to consist of pipes connected to the ship's struc- Where necessary, precautions are to be taken to protect
ture by means of collars or similar devices. the insulation from being impregnated with flammable
oils.
5.7.2 Arrangement of supports
b) Particular attention is to be paid to lagging in way of
Shipyards are to take care that: flanges.
a) The arrangement of supports and collars is to be such
that pipes and flanges are not subjected to abnormal 5.9 Valves, accessories and fittings
bending stresses, taking into account their own mass,
the metal they are made of, and the nature and charac- 5.9.1 General
teristics of the fluid they convey, as well as the contrac-
Cocks, valves and other accessories are generally to be
tions and expansions to which they are subjected.
arranged so that they are easily visible and accessible for
b) Heavy components in the piping system, such as valves, manoeuvring, control and maintenance. They are to be
are to be independently supported. installed in such a way as to operate properly.

178 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

5.9.2 Valves and accessories 5.10.2 Prohibition of carriage of flammable oils in


a) In machinery spaces and tunnels, the cocks, valves and forepeak tanks
other accessories of the fluid lines referred to in this Sec- In all ships fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44) and lubricating oil and
tion are to be placed: other flammable oils are not to be carried in forepeak tanks
above the floor, or or tanks forward of the collision bulkhead.
when this is not possible, immediately under the 5.10.3 Prevention of flammable oil leakage ignition
floor, provided provision is made for their easy a) As far as practicable, parts of the fuel, JP5-NATO (F44)
access and control in service. oil and lubricating oil systems containing heated oil
b) Control-wheels of low inlet valves are to rise at least under pressure exceeding 0,18 MPa are to be placed
0,45 m above the lowest floor. above the platform or in any other position where
defects and leakage can readily be observed.
5.9.3 Flexible hoses and expansion joints
The machinery spaces in way of such parts are to be
a) Flexible hoses and expansion joints are to be so adequately illuminated.
arranged as to be accessible at all times.
b) No flammable oil tanks are to be situated where spillage
b) Flexible hoses and expansion joints are to be as short as or leakage therefrom can constitute a hazard by falling
possible. on:
c) The radius of curvature of flexible hoses is not to be less hot surfaces, including those of boilers, heaters,
than the minimum recommended by the manufacturer. steam pipes, exhaust manifolds and silencers
d) The adjoining pipes are to be suitably aligned, sup- electrical equipment
ported, guided and anchored. air intakes
e) Isolating valves are to be provided permitting the isola- other sources of ignition.
tion of flexible hoses intended to convey flammable oil
c) Parts of flammable oil systems under pressure exceeding
or compressed air.
0,18 MPa such as pumps, filters and heaters are to com-
f) Expansion joints are to be protected against over exten- ply with the provisions of item b) above.
sion or over compression.
d) Flammable oil lines are to be screened or otherwise
g) Where they are likely to suffer external damage, flexible suitably protected to avoid as far as practicable oil spray
hoses and expansion joints of the bellows type are to be or oil leakages onto hot surfaces, into machinery air
provided with adequate protection. intakes, or on other sources of ignition.
5.9.4 Thermometers e) Any relief valve of fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44) and lubricat-
Thermometers and other temperature-detecting elements in ing oil systems is to discharge to a safe position, such as
fluid systems under pressure are to be provided with pock- an appropriate tank.
ets built and secured so that the thermometers and detect-
5.10.4 Provisions for flammable oil leakage
ing elements can be removed while keeping the piping containment
under pressure.
a) Tanks used for the storage of flammable oils together
5.9.5 Pressure gauges with their fittings are to be so arranged as to prevent
Pressure gauges and other similar instruments are to be fit- spillages due to leakage or overfilling.
ted with an isolating valve or cock at the connection with b) Drip trays with adequate drainage to contain possible
the main pipe. leakage from flammable fluid systems are to be fitted:
under independent tanks (refer to Ch 1, App 3,
5.9.6 Nameplates
[2.3.2])
a) Accessories such as cocks and valves on the fluid lines
under burners
referred to in this Section are to be provided with name-
plates indicating the apparatus and lines they serve under purifiers and any other oil processing equip-
except where, due to their location on board, there is no ment
doubt as to their purpose. under pumps, heat exchangers and filters
b) Nameplates are to be fitted at the upper part of air and under valves and all accessories subject to oil leak-
sounding pipes. age
surrounding internal combustion engines.
5.10 Additional arrangements for flammable c) The coaming height of drip trays is to suit the amount of
fluids potential oil spillage.
d) Where boilers are located in machinery spaces on decks
5.10.1 General
and the boiler rooms are not separated from the
The requirements in [5.10.3] and [5.10.4] apply to: machinery spaces by watertight bulkheads, the decks
fuel oil systems and JP5-NATO (F44), in all spaces are to be provided with oil-tight coamings at least 200
lubricating oil systems, in machinery spaces mm in height.
other flammable oil systems, in locations where means e) Where drain pipes are provided for collecting leakages,
of ignition are present. they are to be led to an appropriate drain tank.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 179


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

5.10.5 Drain tank it is pointed out that where required the oily bilge
a) The drain tank is not to form part of an overflow system water draining and treatment system is not in
and is to be fitted with an overflow alarm device. replacement of the clean bilge water system but in
supplement.
b) In ships provided with a double bottom, appropriate
precautions are to be taken when the drain tank is con- b) If deemed acceptable by the Society, bilge pumping
structed in the double bottom, in order to avoid flooding arrangements may be dispensed with in specific com-
of the machinery space where drip trays are located, in partments provided the safety of the ship is not
the event of accidentally running aground. impaired.

5.10.6 Valves 6.2.2 Distribution of bilge suctions


All valves and cocks forming part of flammable oil systems a) Complete draining of watertight spaces is to be possible,
are to be capable of being operated from readily accessible when the ship is on an even keel and either is upright or
positions and, in machinery spaces, from above the working has a list of up to 5.
platform. b) Clean bilge draining system
5.10.7 Level switches At least one suction is to be fitted in all spaces served by
the clean bilge draining system.
Level switches fitted to flammable oil tanks are to be con-
tained in a steel or other fire-resisting enclosure. c) Oily bilge draining and treatment system
At least two suctions are to be fitted in all spaces served
6 Bilge systems by the oily bilge draining and treatment system.
d) In all cases, arrangements are to be made such as to
6.1 Principle allow a free and easy flow of water to bilge suctions.

6.1.1 General 6.2.3 Prevention of communication between spaces


An efficient bilge pumping system shall be provided, capa- Independence of the lines
ble of pumping from and draining any watertight compart- a) Provisions are to be made to avoid any risk of flooding
ment other than spaces permanently dedicated to the of one compartment by another one through any bilge
carriage of fresh water, ballast water, fuel oil or JP5-NATO circuit.
(F44) and for which other efficient means of pumping are to
b) Bilge lines are to be entirely independent and distinct
be provided, under all practical conditions.
from other lines.
To this purpose ships shall be provided with means to cope
with drainage of great amount of water in every compart-
6.3 Drainage arrangements of vehicle and
ment. In addition propulsion machinery spaces and auxil-
iary machinery spaces, where substantial oil leakages may ro-ro spaces and ammunitions storages
occur, shall be provided with bilge means which prevent fitted with a fixed pressure water-
sea pollution by avoiding overboard discharge of water and spraying fire-extinguishing system
oil bilge (see requirements of Annex I of MARPOL 73/78).
6.3.1 Vehicle and ro-ro spaces and ammunitions spaces fit-
ted with a fixed pressure water-spraying fire-extinguishing
6.2 Design of bilge systems
system shall be provided with draining arrangements such
as to prevent the build-up of free surface.
6.2.1 General
a) The bilge pumping installation is to include a bilge Scuppers and discharge shall be provided as stated in [8], in
draining system serving all watertight spaces, designed particular in ammunitions storages and shall discharge to
to drain the effluents resulting from limited and occa- ship bilge and thereafter drained by flooding power pumps
sional leakages, and consisting of: or, if appropriate, equivalent (see [6.6.2]) ejectors.

an oily bilge water draining and treatment system


dedicated to machinery spaces, including auxiliary 6.4 Draining of machinery spaces
machinery spaces, tunnels and other spaces where
oil leakage may occur 6.4.1 General
In propulsion machinery spaces and in auxiliary machinery
a separate clean bilge water system dedicated to the
spaces, where substantial oil leakages may occur, the bilge
other spaces. This system may be provided by a
suctions are to be distributed and arranged in accordance
bilge main, by independent bilge main sections or
with the provisions of [6.2.2].
by dedicated system.
Power bilge pumps or ejectors are to serve the bilge 6.4.2 Additional requirements for spaces
main or each independent bilge main section. They containing electric motors
may serve several compartments. In electrically propelled ships, provision is to be made to
Power bilge pumps or ejectors discharging locally prevent accumulation of water under electric generators
overboard could be provided for dedicated systems. and motors.

180 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

6.5 Draining of dry cofferdams, dry fore and 6.6.3 Capacity of the pumps
after peaks and dry spaces above fore a) The capacity of each pump serving the oily bilge water
and after peaks, tunnels and refrigerated system shall be not less than 5 m3/h.
spaces b) The capacity of each pump, in m3/h, of the clean water
bilge system, where a bilge main is provided, is not to
6.5.1 Draining of cofferdams be less than:
All cofferdams are to be provided with dedicated power
Q = 0,00565 d2
bilge pumps or equivalent ejectors discharging locally over-
board unless they are fitted with bilge suctions connected to where:
the bilge main. Such pumps or ejectors may serve several d : Internal diameter of the clean water bilge
compartments. pipe as defined in [6.7.2], item a).
c) Where a bilge main is not provided, the capacity of
6.5.2 Draining of fore and after peaks
each clean water dedicated power bilge pump, in m 3/h,
a) Where the peaks are not used as tanks the drainage of is not to be less than:
both peaks shall be realised by a dedicated power bilge
pump or ejector discharging overboard locally. Q = 0,00565 d12

b) Except where permitted in [5.3.2], the collision bulk- where:


head is not to be pierced below the bulkhead deck. d1 : Internal diameter of the clean water bilge
pipe as defined in [6.7.2], item c).
6.5.3 Draining of spaces above fore and after peaks
d) The capacity of each dedicated pump of the clean water
a) Provision is to be made for the drainage of the chain bilge system, in m3/h, where several bilge main sections
lockers and watertight compartments above the fore are provided, is not to be less than:
peak tank by power pump suctions
Q = 0,00565 d22
b) In any case, steering gear compartments and other
where:
small enclosed spaces located above the peak tank are
to be provided with bilge suctions of a dedicated power d2 : Internal diameter of each clean water bilge
bilge pump, or an equivalent ejector, fitted above the pipe as defined in [6.7.2], item b).
bulkhead deck.
6.6.4 Choice of the pumps
6.5.4 Draining of tunnels a) All bilge pumps, including clean and oily water pumps,
For the purpose of the present Article [6] tunnels are to be are to be of the self-priming type.
considered as propulsion machinery spaces. Centrifugal pumps are to be fitted with efficient priming
Tunnels are to be drained by means of suctions connected means, unless an approved priming system is provided
to the oily water bilge system. Such suctions are generally to ensure the priming of pumps under normal operating
to be located in wells at the aft end of the tunnels. conditions.

6.5.5 Draining of refrigerated spaces 6.7 Size of bilge pipes


Provision is to be made for the continuous drainage of con-
densate in refrigerated and air cooler spaces. To this end, 6.7.1 Size of oily bilge water pipes
valves capable of blanking off the water draining lines of The actual internal diameter of the oily bilge water pipes is
such spaces are not to be fitted. to be calculated assuming a water velocity less than 5 m/s.
It is in any case not to be less than 40 mm.
6.6 Bilge pumps
6.7.2 Size of clean water bilge pipes
6.6.1 Number and arrangement of pumps a) The internal diameter of the clean water bilge main, in
a) The oily bilge pumping system is to be provided with mm, is to be calculated according to the following for-
two dedicated power pumps connected to the manifold mula:
of that system.
d = 25 + 1, 68 L ( B + D )
b) If a clean bilge main is fitted, at least two dedicated
where:
power pumps are to be connected to the bilge main.
L : Length between perpendiculars, in m
c) If independent bilge main sections are fitted, at least two
dedicated power pumps are to be connected to each B : Breath of the ship at draught, in m
section. D : Moulded depth of the ship to the control
d) For dedicated bilge system as defined in [6.2.1] one deck, in m.
dedicated power pump or ejector is to be connected. b) Were the bilge system consist of independent sections,
the internal diameter of each section, in mm, is to be
6.6.2 Portable means of pumping calculated according to the following formula:
Each safety area is to comprise at least one portable means
d 2 = 25 + 1, 68 L 2 ( B + D )
of pumping (pump or ejector) allowing the draining of all
spaces other than main and auxiliary machinery spaces. where:

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 181


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

L2 : Total of length of the compartments served 6.9 Bilge piping arrangement


by the section, in m
6.9.1 Provision for expansion
B, D : As defined in item a).
Where necessary, bilge pipes inside tanks are to be fitted
c) The internal diameter of the clean water bilge pipe, in with expansion bends. Sliding joints are not permitted for
mm, between dedicated pumps or bilge main and suc- this purpose.
tion in compartments, is to be calculated according to
the following formula: 6.9.2 Connections
Connections used for bilge pipes passing through tanks are
d 1 = 25 + 2, 16 L 1 ( B + D ) to be welded joints or reinforced welded flange connections.
where: 6.9.3 Access to valves and distribution boxes
L1 : Length of the compartment, in m All distribution boxes and manually operated valves in con-
nection with the bilge pumping arrangement shall be in
B, D : As defined in item a).
positions which are accessible under normal circumstances.
d1 is not to be less than 50 mm and need not exceed
100 mm. 6.9.4 Location of bilge pumps and pipes
Bilge pumps and piping system are not to be situated at a
distance less than B/5 from the ship side, where B is the
6.8 Bilge accessories ships width.

6.8.1 Drain valves on watertight bulkheads


7 Ballast systems
a) Drain valves or similar devices shall not be fitted on the
collision bulkhead.
7.1 Design of ballast systems
b) On other watertight bulkheads, the fitting of drain valves
or similar devices is allowed unless practical alternative 7.1.1 Ballast system and independence of ballast
draining means exist. Such valves are to be easily acces- lines
sible at all times and are to be normally closed. The ship shall be provided with ballast systems if so
requested by the Naval Authority.
6.8.2 Screw-down non-return valves Ballast lines are to be entirely independent and distinct from
other lines except where allowed in [5.4] and in [7.2.1].
a) Accessories are to be provided to prevent intercommu-
nication of compartments or lines which are to remain
segregated from one another. For this purpose, non- 7.2 Ballast pumping arrangement
return devices are to be fitted:
7.2.1 Filling and suction pipes
on the pipe connections to bilge distribution boxes a) All tanks including aft and fore peak and double bottom
or to the alternative valves, if any tanks intended for ballast water are to be provided with
on flexible bilge hose connections suitable filling and suction pipes connected to power
driven pumps of adequate capacity.
on the suctions of water bilge ejectors
Alternatively, ballast tanks can be filled by the fire main
in compliance with the provisions for prevention of and drained by an ejector supplied by the fire main.
progressive flooding. Alternatively, ballast tanks can possibly be filled by
b) Screw-down and other non-return valves are to be of a gravity subject to additional valve on direct filling pipe.
type recognized by the Society as not offering undue b) Suctions are to be so positioned that the transfer of sea
obstruction to the flow of water. water can be suitably carried out in the normal operat-
ing conditions of the ship. In particular, two suctions
6.8.3 Strainers may be required in long compartments.
The open ends of bilge lines are to be fitted with readily
7.2.2 Piping
accessible strum boxes or strainers having an open area of
not less than twice the area of the suction pipe. In no case the internal diameter of ballast piping is to be
less than 50 mm.
Strum boxes are to be so designed that they can be cleaned
without having to remove any joint on the suction pipe. 7.2.3 Passage of ballast pipes through tanks
If not contained in pipe tunnels, the parts of ballast pipes
6.8.4 Bilge wells through tanks intended to contain fresh water or fuel oil
shall have increased thickness, as per Tab 5 for steel pipes,
a) The wells provided for draining the various compart-
and shall consist of either a single piece or several pieces
ments are to be made of steel plate and their capacity is
assembled by welding or by devices deemed equivalent for
to be not less than 0,15 m3. In small compartments,
the application considered. Parts of ballast pipes passing
smaller cylindrical wells may be fitted.
through JP5-NATO (F44) tanks, if not contained in pipe tun-
b) Bilge wells are to comply with the relevant provisions of nel, shall be of jacketed type provided with means for
Part B. ascertaining leakages.

182 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

8 Scuppers and sanitary discharges 8.4 Drainage of enclosed vehicle and ro-ro
spaces situated on the bulkhead deck
8.1 Application 8.4.1 General
Means of drainage are to be provided for enclosed vehicle
8.1.1 and ro-ro spaces situated on the bulkhead deck. The Society
may allow the absence of means of drainage in any of the
a) This Article applies to scuppers of any type of ships. above spaces if it is satisfied that, due to the size or internal
subdivision of such space, the safety of the ship is not
b) Discharges in connection with machinery operation are
impaired.
dealt with in [2.8].
8.4.2 Cases where the bulkhead deck side line is not
immersed when the ship heels more than 5
8.2 Principle
Scuppers from vehicle and ro-ro spaces, led through the
shell, are to comply with the requirements stated in [8.7];
8.2.1 Scuppers
alternatively drainage is to be led overboard in accordance
a) The scupper installation is to be so designed as to allow to [8.4.3].
overboard gravity draining of any water introduced in
8.4.3 Cases where the bulkhead deck side line is
all spaces, compartments, open decks and areas located
immersed when the ship heels 5 or less
above the damage control deck.
If scuppers from vehicle and ro-ro spaces are immersed
b) The number of scuppers openings in the shell plating is when the ship heels 5 or less, the drainage of such spaces
to be reduced to a minimum by making each discharge, on the bulkhead deck is to be led to a suitable space, or
sufficient in number and suitable in size, are to be pro- spaces, of appropriate capacity, having a high water level
vided to permit the drainage of water likely to accumu- alarm and provided with arrangements for discharge over-
late in the spaces which are not located in the ship's board. In addition, it is to be ensured that:
bottom. the number, size and arrangement of the scuppers are
such as to prevent unreasonable accumulation of free
c) The number of scuppers openings in the shell plating is water
to be reduced to a minimum by making each discharge
the pumping arrangements take account of the require-
serve as many pipes as possible. Alternative satisfactory
ments for any fixed pressure water-spraying fire-extin-
solutions may be accepted.
guishing system
d) The scupper piping system is to be designed and where the enclosed space is protected by a gas fire-
arranged so as to ensure quick draining of the con- extinguishing system, the deck scuppers are fitted with
cerned space considering a permanent list of 5 and in means to prevent the escape of the smothering gas.
all normal trim conditions of the ship.
8.5 Drainage arrangement of vehicle and ro-
8.2.2 Sanitary discharges ro spaces or ammunitions spaces fitted
The sewage piping system is to be designed taking into con- with a fixed pressure water-spraying
sideration the possible generation of toxic and flammable fire-extinguishing system
gases (such as hydrogen sulfide, methane, ammonia) during
the sewage treatment. 8.5.1 Scupper draining
Scuppers from vehicle and ro-ro spaces are not to be led to
Air pipes from the sewage and grey water systems are to be machinery spaces or other places where sources of ignition
independent of all other air pipes and to be led to the out- may be present.
side of the ship, away from any air intake. Scuppers from ammunitions spaces are to discharge directly
overboard. The discharge pipe is to be fitted with a valve
8.3 Drainage from spaces below the whose opening is to be automatically controlled by the acti-
bulkhead deck or within enclosed vation of the drenching system. Alternatively, the scupper
pipe may be fitted with a spring loaded valve.
superstructures and deckhouses on or
above the bulkhead deck Each ammunition space is to have its own drainage system.

8.5.2 Prevention of build-up of free surfaces


8.3.1 Normal arrangement In vehicle and ro-ro spaces fitted with a fixed pressure
Scuppers from spaces below the bulkhead deck or from water-spraying fire-extinguishing system, the drainage
within superstructures and deckhouses on or above the arrangement is to be such as to prevent the build-up of free
bulkhead deck the deck fitted with doors complying with surfaces. If this is not possible, the adverse effect upon sta-
the provisions of Pt B, Ch 8, Sec 6 are to be led to the bilge. bility of the added weight and free surface of water are to be
As an alternative, [8.6] and [8.7] are to be complied with. taken into account to the extent deemed necessary by the
Society in its approval of the stability information. Refer to
Scuppers of open deck shall be led overboard. Pt B, Ch 3, Sec 3.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 183


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

In ammunitions spaces the adverse effect upon the stability 8.7.4 Alternative arrangement when the inboard end
of the added weight and free surface of water, as well as of the discharge pipe is above the deepest
those of the spaces in which the water is collected, are to be subdivision waterline by more than 0,02 L
accounted in Pt B, Ch 3, Sec 3. Where the vertical distance from the deepest subdivision
waterline to the inboard end of the discharge pipe exceeds
8.6 Arrangement of discharges from spaces 0,02 L, a single automatic non-return valve without positive
below the margin line means of closing may be accepted subject to the approval
of the Society.
8.6.1 Normal arrangement
Each separate discharge led though the shell plating from 8.7.5 Arrangement of discharges through manned
spaces below the margin line is to be provided with one machinery spaces
automatic non-return valve fitted with positive means of
Where sanitary discharges and scuppers lead overboard
closing it from above the damage control deck.
through the shell in way of manned machinery spaces, the
fitting at the shell of a locally operated positive closing
8.6.2 Alternative arrangement when the inboard end
of the discharge pipe is above the deepest valve together with a non-return valve inboard may be
subdivision waterline by more than 0,01 L accepted. The operating position of the valve will be given
special consideration by the Society.
Where the vertical distance from the deepest subdivision
waterline to the inboard end of the discharge pipe exceeds
0,01 L, the discharge may have two automatic non-return 8.7.6 Arrangement of discharges through the shell
valves without positive means of closing, provided that the more than 450 mm below the freeboard deck
or less than 600 mm above the deepest
inboard valve:
subdivision waterline
is above the deepest subdivision load line, and
Scupper and discharge pipes originating at any level and
is always accessible for examination under service con- penetrating the shell either more than 450 mm below the
ditions. freeboard deck or less than 600 mm above the deepest sub-
division waterline are to be provided with a non-return
8.7 Arrangement of discharges from spaces valve at the shell. Unless required by [8.7.2] to [8.7.4], this
above the margin line valve may be omitted if the piping is of substantial thick-
ness, as per Tab 23.
8.7.1 General
The provisions of this sub-article are applicable only to 8.7.7 Arrangement of discharges through the shell
those discharges which remain open during the normal less than 450 mm below the freeboard deck
operation of a ship. For discharges which must necessarily and more than 600 mm above the deepest
be closed at sea, such as gravity drains from topside ballast subdivision waterline
tanks, a single screw-down valve operated from the deck Scupper and discharge pipes penetrating the shell less than
may be accepted. 450 mm below the damage control deck and more than
600 mm above the deepest subdivision waterline are not
8.7.2 Normal arrangement
required to be provided with a non-return valve at the shell.
Normally, each separate discharge led though the shell plat-
ing from spaces above the margin line is to be provided
with: 8.8 Summary table of overboard discharge
one automatic non-return valve fitted with positive arrangements
means of closing it from a position above the damage
control deck, or 8.8.1 The various arrangements acceptable for scuppers
and sanitary overboard discharges are summarized in Fig 3.
one automatic non-return valve and one sluice valve
controlled from above the damage control deck.
8.9 Valves and pipes
8.7.3 Alternative arrangement when the inboard end
of the discharge pipe is above the deepest
subdivision waterline by more than 0,01 L 8.9.1 Materials
Where the vertical distance from the deepest subdivision a) All shell fittings and valves are to be of steel, bronze or
waterline to the inboard end of the discharge pipe exceeds other ductile material. Valves of ordinary cast iron or
0,01 L, the discharge may have two automatic non-return similar material are not acceptable. All scupper and dis-
valves without positive means of closing, provided that: charge pipes are to be of steel or other ductile material.
the inboard valve is above the level of the deepest sub- Refer to [2.1].
division waterline so as to always be accessible for
b) Plastic shall not be used for scuppers and discharge pip-
examination under service conditions, or
ing.
where this is not practicable, a locally controlled sluice
valve is interposed between the two automatic non- c) For the pipe likely to contain flammable oils, the provi-
return valves. sions of Ch 4, Sec 10, [3.2.1] are also to be fulfilled.

184 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Figure 3 : Overboard discharge arrangement

        


   
                        
            
     "   "       '
        !   ! !   # )*
        . 
    #          +,   
             & #     #(    -    
   

$ $
$  $  $  $  $  $   

% % %


                 

/
/              
        !   !  
  
   !     
    

$  0   $    !         


       &
  0   !          
          & !  

Table 22 : Thickness of scupper and discharge pipes led to the shell, according to their location

Applicable [8.7.6]
requirement -> [8.6.1] [8.7.1] [8.7.2] [8.7.3] [8.7.4] [8.7.5] with [8.7.6]
[8.7.7]
valve without valve
Pipe location
Between the shell Thickness according to Tab 23, column 1, or 0,7 times that of NA NA
and the first valve the shell side plating, whichever is the greater (1)
Beyond the first Thickness according to [2.2] NA NA
valve and the
inboard end
Below the NA Thickness according to Thickness according to
bulkhead deck Tab 23, column 1 (1) Tab 23, column 2 (1)
Above the NA Thickness according to Thickness according to
bulkhead deck [2.2] [2.2]
(1) However, this thickness is not required to exceed that of the plating.
Note 1: NA = not applicable.

8.9.2 Thickness of pipes with an indicator showing whether the valve is open or
a) The thickness of scupper and discharge pipes led to the closed.
bilge or to draining tanks, or pipes other than in item b)
is not to be less than that required in [2.2].
8.10 Arrangement of scuppers
b) The thickness of scupper and discharge pipes led to the
shell is not to be less than the minimum thickness given
in Tab 22 and Tab 23. 8.10.1 Overboard discharges and valve connections

8.9.3 Scupper size a) Overboard discharges are to have pipe spigots extend-
Internal diameters of scupper pipes are not to be less than ing through the shell plate and welded to it, and are to
40 mm. be provided at the internal end with a flange for con-
nection to the valve or pipe flange.
8.9.4 Operation of the valves
Where valves are required to have positive means of clos- b) Valves may also be connected to the hull plating in
ing, such means is to be readily accessible and provided accordance with the provisions of [2.8.3], item c).

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 185


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 23 : Minimum thickness of scupper and 8.10.9 Scupper tank


discharge pipes led to the shell a) The scupper tank air pipe is to be led to above the bulk-
head deck.
External diameter Column 1 Column 2
of the pipe d, substantial normal thickness, b) Provision is to be made to ascertain the level of water in
in mm thickness, in mm in mm the scupper tank.
d 80,0 7,00 4,50
8.11 Additional requests for citadels
155 9,25 4,50
180 10,00 5,00 8.11.1 Segregation of scupper networks
Spaces protected against NBC aggression and spaces
220 12,50 5,80
unprotected are not to be served by a common scupper net-
230 d 12,50 6,00 work.
Note 1: Intermediate sizes may be determined by interpolation. To avoid any communication between these spaces sepa-
Note 2: In any case it is not required a thickness greater than rate scupper systems are to be provided for:
the shell plating spaces located outside the citadel (likely to be contami-
nated in case of NBC aggression)
8.10.2 Passage through vehicle and ro-ro spaces
spaces located inside the citadel at nominal overpres-
Where scupper and sanitary discharge pipes are led through sure (at least 500 Pa)
vehicle and ro-ro spaces, the pipes and the valves with their
spaces located inside the citadel at reduced overpres-
controls are to be adequately protected by strong casings or
sure (below 500 Pa)
guards.
decontamination spaces.
8.10.3 Passage through tanks
8.11.2 Scuppers network serving the spaces located
a) As a rule, scupper and sanitary discharge pipes are not inside the citadel
to pass through fuel oil tanks or JP5-NATO (F44) tanks.
The types of water to be drained include:
b) Where scupper and discharge pipes pass unavoidably drenching waters from spaces protected by a drenching
through fuel oil tanks and are led through the shell system
within the tanks, the thickness of the piping is not to be
less than that given in Tab 23 column 1 (substantial waters from decontamination spaces (including wash-
thickness). It is not needed, however, to exceed the Rule basins and showers).
thickness of the shell plating or the tank thickness in Scupper network for spaces within the citadel is to be pro-
case of only passing through. vided with devices minimizing loss of the overpressure.
c) Scupper and sanitary discharge pipes shall not pass
through fresh and drinking water tanks. 9 Air, sounding and overflow pipes
d) Scupper and sanitary discharge pipes shall not pass
through JP5-NATO(F44) tanks unless of jacketed type 9.1 Air pipes
provided with means for ascertain leakages.
9.1.1 Principle
8.10.4 Passage through ammunition spaces Air pipes are to be fitted to all tanks, double bottoms, coffer-
Except where not practicable, scuppers pipes are not to pass dams, tunnels and other compartments which are not fitted
through ammunitions spaces with alternative ventilation arrangements, in order to allow
the passage of air or liquid so as to prevent excessive pres-
8.10.5 Discharge in refrigerated spaces sure or vacuum in the tanks or compartments, in particular
No scupper pipe from non-refrigerated spaces is to dis- in those which are fitted with piping installations. Their
charge in refrigerated spaces. open ends are to be so arranged as to prevent the free entry
of sea water in the compartments.
8.10.6 Discharge from galleys and their stores
Discharges from galleys and their stores are to be kept sepa- Air pipe system of JP5-NATO(F44) is to be independent of
rate from other discharges and be drained overboard or in any other system.
separate drainage tanks; alternatively, discharges are to be Note 1: Air pipes may be dispensed with in tunnels, cofferdams
provided with adequate devices against odours and over- and other void spaces provided they do not contain any bilge suc-
tion.
flow.
9.1.2 Number and position of air pipes
8.10.7 Discharge from aircrafts-related areas
Scuppers of the spaces of the aircrafts-related areas likely to a) Air pipes are to be so arranged and the upper part of
contain burning fuel are to be independent from the scup- compartments so designed that air or gas likely to accu-
per network serving the spaces located outside the citadel. mulate at any point in the compartments can freely
evacuate.
8.10.8 Discharge from aft spaces b) Air pipes are to be fitted opposite the filling pipes and/or
Spaces located aft of the aft peak bulkhead not intended to at the highest parts of the compartments, the ship being
be used as tanks are to be drained in compliance with [6]. assumed to be on an even keel.

186 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

c) Except for supply ship, in general only one air pipe may Where they are of the float type, suitable guides are
be fitted for each compartment. When the top of the to be provided to ensure unobstructed operation
compartment is of irregular form, the position of air under all working conditions of heel and trim.
pipes will be given special consideration by the Society. Efficient seating arrangements are to be provided for
d) Where only one air pipe is provided, it is not to be used the closures.
as a filling pipe. They are to be self-draining.
The clear area through an air pipe closing appliance
9.1.3 Location of open ends of air pipes
is to be at least equal to the area of the inlet.
a) Air pipes of double bottom compartments, tunnels,
The maximum allowable tolerances for wall thick-
deep tanks and other compartments which can come
ness of floats is not to exceed 10% of the nominal
into contact with the sea or be flooded in the event of
thickness.
hull damage are to be led to above the bulkhead deck.
Their casings are to be of approved metallic materi-
b) Air pipes of tanks intended to be pumped up are to be
als adequately protected against corrosion.
led to the open above the bulkhead deck.
Closures and seats made of non-metallic materials
c) Air pipes other than those of fuel oil tanks, JP5-NATO are to be compatible with the media to be carried in
(F44) tanks and of any other oil tanks may be led to the tank and with sea water at ambient temperatures
enclosed vehicle or ro-ro spaces, situated above the between 25C and +85C.
bulkhead deck, provided that such spaces are fitted with
scuppers discharging overboard, which are capable of b) Where closing appliances are not of an automatic type,
draining all the water which may enter through the air provision is to be made for relieving vacuum when the
pipes without giving rise to any water accumulation. tanks are being pumped out. For this purpose, a hole of
approximately 10 mm in diameter may be provided in
d) Air pipes of tanks other than oil tanks, JP5-NATO (F44) the bend of the air pipe or at any other suitable position
tanks and of any other oil tank may discharge through in the closing appliance.
the side of the superstructure.
c) Wooden plugs and trailing canvas are not permitted.
e) The air pipe of the scupper tank is to be led to above
bulkhead deck. 9.1.7 Special arrangements for air pipes of
flammable oil tanks
f) The location of air pipes for flammable oil tanks is also
to comply with [9.1.7]. a) Air pipes from fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44) and thermal oil
tanks are to discharge to a safe position on the open
9.1.4 Height of air pipes deck where no danger will be incurred from issuing oil
Air pipes are to extend above the V-line, as defined in Pt B, or gases.
Ch 3, App 4. Air vents are to be fitted with wire gauze diaphragms
made of corrosion resistant material and readily remov-
9.1.5 Fitting of closing appliances able for cleaning and replacement. The clear area of
a) Permanently attached appliances are to be provided for such diaphragms is not to be less than the cross-sec-
closing the openings of air pipes in order to prevent the tional area of the pipe.
free entry of water into the spaces concerned, except for b) Air pipes of lubricating or hydraulic oil storage tanks not
pipes of tanks fitted with cross-flooding connections. subject to flooding in the event of hull damage may be
b) Automatic closing appliances are to be fitted in the fol- led to machinery spaces, provided that in the case of
lowing cases: overflowing the oil cannot come into contact with elec-
trical equipment, hot surfaces or other sources of igni-
in positions of [9.1.3] item c)
tion.
where air pipes have a height lower than that
c) Air pipes of fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44), service, settling
required in [9.1.4].
and lubrication oil, tanks likely to be damaged by
See also Pt B, Ch 3, Sec 3, [2.2.2]. impact forces are to be adequately reinforced.
c) Automatic closing appliances are to be of a type
approved by the Society. Requirements for type tests are 9.1.8 Construction of air pipes made of steel
given in [19.2.2]. a) Where air pipes to ballast and other tanks extend above
the bulkhead deck - main deck or superstructure deck
9.1.6 Design of closing appliances (see [9.1.4], the exposed parts of the pipes are to be of
a) When closing appliances are requested to be of an auto- substantial construction, with a minimum wall thickness
matic type, they are to comply with the following: of at least:
They are to be so designed that they withstand both 6,0 mm for pipes of 80 mm or smaller external
ambient and working conditions up to an inclina- diameter
tion of 40 to +40 without failure or damage. 8,5 mm for pipes of 165 mm or greater external
They are to be so designed as to allow inspection of diameter.
the closure and the inside of the casing as well as Intermediate minimum thicknesses may be determined
changing of the seals. by linear interpolation.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 187


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

For stainless steel the above thickness may be respec- 9.2.5 Closing appliances
tively 3,0 mm and 4,0 mm. a) Self-closing appliances are to be fitted with cylindrical
Note 1: When the air pipes are protected against sea impacts, plugs having counterweights such as to ensure auto-
thicknesses in accordance with Tab 5 may be accepted. matic closing.
b) Air pipes with height exceeding 900 mm are to be addi- b) Closing appliances not required to be of the self-closing
tionally supported. type may consist of a metallic screw cap secured to the
c) In each compartment likely to be pumped up, and pipe by means of a chain or a shut-off valve.
where no overflow pipe is provided, the total cross-sec-
tional area of air pipes is not to be less than 1,25 times 9.2.6 Construction of sounding pipes
the cross-sectional area of the corresponding filling a) Sounding pipes are normally to be straight. If it is neces-
pipes. sary to provide bends in such pipes, the curvature is to
d) The internal diameter of air pipes is not to be less than be as small as possible to permit the ready passage of
50 mm, except for tanks of less than 2 m3. the sounding apparatus.
b) The sounding arrangement of compartments by means
9.2 Sounding pipes of bent pipes passing through other compartments will
be given special consideration by the Society. Such an
9.2.1 Principle arrangement is normally accepted only if the compart-
a) Sounding devices are to be fitted to tanks intended to ments passed through are cofferdams or are intended to
contain liquids as well as to other tanks, double bot- contain the same liquid as the compartments served by
toms, cofferdams, bilges and all compartments which the sounding pipes.
are not readily accessible at all times. c) Bent portions of sounding pipes are to have reinforced
b) For service tanks, the following systems may be thickness and be suitably supported.
accepted in lieu of sounding pipes:
d) The internal diameter of sounding pipes is not to be less
a level gauge of an approved type efficiently pro- than 32 mm. Where sounding pipes pass through refrig-
tected against shocks, or erated spaces, or through the insulation of refrigerated
a remote level gauging system of an approved type, spaces in which the temperature may be below 0C,
provided an emergency means of sounding is avail- their internal diameter is to be at least 60 mm.
able in the event of failure affecting such system. e) Doubling plates are to be placed under the lower ends
of sounding pipes in order to prevent damage to the
9.2.2 Position of sounding pipes
hull. When sounding pipes with closed lower ends are
Sounding pipes are to be located as close as possible to suc- used, the closing plate is to have reinforced scantlings.
tion pipes.

9.2.3 Termination of sounding pipes 9.3 Overflow pipes


a) As a general rule, sounding pipes are to end above the
bulkhead deck in easily accessible places and are to be 9.3.1 Principle
fitted with efficient, permanently attached, metallic Overflow system of JP5-NATO(F44) is to be independent of
closing appliances. other overflow systems.
b) In machinery spaces where the provisions of a) cannot Overflow pipes are to be fitted to tanks:
be satisfied, short sounding pipes led to readily accessi- which can be filled by pumping and are designed for a
ble positions above the floor and fitted with efficient hydrostatic pressure lower than that corresponding to
closing appliances may be accepted. the height of the air pipe, or
In ships required to be fitted with a double bottom, such
where the cross-sectional area of air pipes is less than
closing appliances are to be of the self-closing type.
that prescribed in [9.1.8], item d).
9.2.4 Special arrangements for sounding pipes of
flammable oil tanks 9.3.2 Design of overflow systems

a) Where sounding pipes are used in flammable (except a) Overflow pipes are to be led:
lubricating, sludge, dirty bilge, oil leakage and similar) either outside, or
oil systems, they may terminate below the open deck
in the case of fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) or lubricat-
where no risk of ignition of spillage from the sounding
ing oil, to an overflow tank of adequate capacity or
pipe might arise. In particular, they are not to terminate
to a storage tank having a space reserved for over-
in crew spaces. As a general rule, they are not to termi-
flow purposes. For the JP5-NATO(F44) a dedicated
nate in machinery spaces.
tank is to be provided.
b) The Society may permit termination in machinery Note 1: As an alternative to the overflow tank, for JP5-NATO (F44),
spaces of sounding pipes for lubricating oil, fuel oil an isolating valve on the tank filling line arranged for automatic
leakage, sludge and dirty bilge tanks, provided that the closing in case of high level can be accepted. The filling line is
terminations of sounding pipes are fitted with appropri- to fitted with a protection device against overpressure, which
ate means of closure. may be located outside the ship (on the refuelling installation).

188 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

b) Where tanks containing the same liquid are connected 9.4 Constructional requirements applying to
to a common overflow system, the arrangement is to be sounding, air and overflow pipes
such as to prevent any risk of:
9.4.1 Materials
intercommunication between the various tanks due
to movements of liquid when emptying or filling, or a) Sounding, air and overflow pipes are to be made of steel
due to the inclination of the ship or any other material approved for the application con-
sidered.
overfilling of any tank from another assumed
b) Exposed parts of sounding, air and overflow pipes are to
flooded due to hull damage.
be made of approved metallic materials.
For this purpose, overflow pipes are to be led to a high
enough point above the bulkhead deck. Safety devices 9.4.2 Minimum thickness of steel pipes
protecting from a risk of hydrostatic overpressure in The minimum thickness of sounding, air and overflow steel
overflow pipes could be accepted subject to an alarm of pipes is given in Tab 24.
discharging in the dripping pan.
Table 24 : Minimum wall thickness of sounding,
c) Arrangements are to be made so that a compartment air and overflow pipes
cannot be flooded from the sea through the overflow in
the event of another compartment connected to the Minimum wall thickness,
External diameter, in mm
same overflow main being bilged. To this end, the open- in mm (1) (2)
ings of overflow pipes discharging overboard are as a up to 168,3 4,5
rule to be placed above the maximum draft of the ship 177,8 5,0
and are to be fitted where necessary with non-return
193,7 5,4
valves on the plating, or, alternatively, overflow pipes
from tanks are to be led to a point above the maximum 219,1 5,9
draft of the ship. above 244,5 6,3
(1) Applies only to structural tanks.
d) Where tanks alternately containing fuel oil and ballast
(2) However the wall thickness may not be greater than
water are connected to a common overflow system,
that it would be required for the tank filling pipes.
arrangements are to be made to prevent the ballast
For independent tanks, refer to Tab 5.
water overflowing into the tanks containing fuel oil and
vice-versa.
9.4.3 Passage of pipes through certain spaces
a) Air pipes and sounding pipes led through refrigerated
9.3.3 Overflow tanks
spaces are to be suitably insulated.
a) Overflow tanks are to be fitted with an air pipe comply- b) When sounding, air and overflow pipes made of steel
ing with [9.1] which may serve as an overflow pipe for are permitted to pass through ballast tanks or fuel oil
the same tank. When the vent pipe reaches a height tanks, they are to be of reinforced thickness, in accor-
exceeding the design head of the overflow tank, suitable dance with Tab 5. However pipes passing through JP5-
means are to be provided to limit the actual hydrostatic NATO(F44) tanks are only permitted if they are of jack-
head on the tank. eted type with means for ascertain leakages.
Such means are to discharge to a position which is safe c) Sounding, air and overflow pipes are to be adequately
in the opinion of the Society. protected against impact of product handling.
b) An alarm device is to be provided to give warning when 9.4.4 Self-draining of pipes
the oil reaches a predetermined level in the tank, or Air pipes and overflow pipes are to be so arranged as to be
alternatively, a sight-flow glass is to be provided in the self-draining when the ship is on an even keel.
overflow pipe to indicate when any tank is overflowing.
Such sight-flow glasses are only to be placed on vertical 9.4.5 Name plates
pipes and in readily visible positions. Nameplates are to be fixed at the upper part of air pipes and
sounding pipes.
9.3.4 Specific requirements for construction of
overflow pipes
10 Cooling systems
a) The internal diameter of overflow pipes is not to be less
than 50 mm. 10.1 Application
b) In each compartment which can be pumped up, the
10.1.1 This article applies to all cooling systems using the
total cross-sectional area of overflow pipes is not to be
following cooling media:
less than 1,25 times the cross-sectional area of the cor-
responding filling pipes. sea water
fresh water
c) The cross-sectional area of the overflow main is not to
lubricating oil.
be less than the aggregate cross-sectional area of the
two largest pipes discharging into the main. Air cooling systems will be given special consideration.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 189


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

10.2 Principle 10.3.3 Individual cooling of propulsion engines


a) Individual cooling systems of propulsion engines are to
10.2.1 General
include at least:
Sea water and fresh water cooling systems are to be so
arranged as to maintain the temperature of the cooled one main cooling water pump, which can be driven
media (lubricating oil, hydraulic oil, charge air, etc.) for pro- by the engine
pulsion machinery and essential equipment within the one independently driven standby pump
manufacturers recommended limits during all operations,
including starting and manoeuvring, under the inclination two heat exchangers having an aggregate capacity
angles and the ambient conditions specified in Ch 1, Sec 1. of at least 100% of that required by the engine.
Where the output of the engine does not exceed
10.2.2 Availability of the cooling system 375 kW, the following arrangements may be accepted:
The cooling system is to be so designed that, in the event of one
one main cooling water pump, which can be driven
essential component being inoperative, the cooling of propul-
by the engine
sion machinery is maintained. Partial reduction of the propul-
sion capability may be accepted, however, when it is one spare pump of appropriate capacity ready to be
demonstrated that the safe operation of the ship is not impaired. connected to the cooling circuit
one heat exchanger of appropriate capacity.
10.3 Design of sea water cooling systems
b) Where, in ships having more than one engine per pro-
10.3.1 General peller or having several propellers, each engine is
a) Sea water cooling of the propulsion engines, auxiliary served by its own cooling circuit, the second means
engines and other essential equipment is to be capable requested in [10.3.1] is to be provided, consisting of:
of being supplied by two different means. a connection to an independently driven pump,
b) Where required, standby pumps are not to be con- such as a ballast pump or any other suitable sea
nected to the sea inlet serving the other sea water water pump of sufficient capacity provided arrange-
pumps, unless permitted under [10.7.1], item b). ments against overpressure in the cooling system are
made. (see [10.7.4], item b)), or
10.3.2 Centralised cooling systems a complete spare pump identical to those serving
a) In the case of centralized cooling systems, i.e. systems the engines and ready to be connected to the cool-
serving a group of propulsion engines and/or auxiliary ing circuit.
engines, reduction gears, compressors and other essen-
This second means may be omitted, however, when
tial equipment, the following sea water pumps and heat
safety justifications are provided as regards the propul-
exchangers are to be arranged:
sion and manoeuvring capabilities of the ship with one
one main cooling water pump, which may be driven cooling circuit disabled.
by the engines, of a capacity sufficient to provide
cooling water to all the equipment served 10.3.4 Individual cooling of auxiliary engines
one independently driven standby pump of at least
Where each auxiliary engine is served by its own cooling
the same capacity
circuit, no second means of cooling is required.
two heat exchangers, each having at least 50% of
the total capacity necessary to provide cooling water 10.3.5 Cooling of steam plants
to all the equipment served.
a) Steam plants are to be fitted with:
b) Where the cooling system is served by a group of identi-
cal pumps, the capacity of the standby pump needs only a main circulating pump
to be equivalent to that of each of these pumps. a standby pump capable of ensuring the circulation
c) Ballast pumps or other suitable sea water pumps of in the main condenser in the event of failure of the
appropriate capacity may be used as standby pumps, main circulating pump.
provided arrangements are made against overpressure b) Where the installation includes more than one propul-
in the cooling system. sive unit, the standby pump is not required, provided a
d) In ships having one or more propulsion engines, each branch pipe is fitted between the discharges of the cir-
with an output not exceeding 375 kW, the independent culating pumps of each unit.
standby pump may be replaced by a complete spare
c) In lieu of the main circulating pump, a sea inlet scoop
pump of appropriate capacity ready to be connected to
system may be accepted, provided that an additional
the cooling circuit.
means is fitted to ensure the circulation of sea water to
e) In cases of centralized cooling systems serving only a the condenser when the ship is manoeuvring. Such
group of auxiliary engines, the second means of cooling means may be:
may consist of a connection to a cooling water pump
an additional independent pump, or
serving the propulsion plant, provided such pump is of
sufficient capacity to provide cooling water to both pro- a connection to an available pump of sufficient
pulsion plant and auxiliary engines. capacity.

190 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

10.3.6 Cooling of other essential equipment If cooling water is used for heating of oil, the heating coils
a) The second means of cooling required in [10.3.1] for are to be located on the pressure side of the cooling pumps
essential equipment may consist of a connection to a and connected by welding, with no detachable connections
ballast pump or other suitable sea water pump of suffi- where mixing of oil and water may occur. Alternatively a
cient capacity, provided arrangements are made against primary and secondary system arrangement may be used.
overpressure in the cooling system (see [10.7.4], item
b)). 10.5 Design of oil cooling systems
b) However, where such essential equipment is duplicate,
this second means may be omitted when justifications 10.5.1 General
are provided as regards the propulsion and manoeu- Oil cooling systems are to be designed according to the
vring capabilities of the ship with the cooling circuit of applicable requirements of [10.3].
one set of equipment disabled.
10.5.2 Second means of cooling
10.4 Design of fresh water cooling systems
The second means of cooling requested in [10.3.1] may
10.4.1 General consist of a satisfactory connection to a lubricating oil
pump of sufficient capacity. Arrangements are to be made
Fresh water cooling systems are to be designed according to
against overpressure in the cooling system.
the applicable requirements of [10.3].

10.4.2 Cooling systems 10.6 Control and monitoring


a) Fresh water cooling systems of essential equipment are
to include at least: 10.6.1 Alarms are to be provided for water cooling systems
one main cooling water pump, which can be driven in accordance with Tab 25, in addition to the requirements
by the equipment stated for diesel engines in Ch 1, Sec 2.

one independently driven standby pump.


10.7 Arrangement of cooling systems
b) The standby pump may be omitted provided an emer-
gency connection to a suitable sea water system is fitted
and arranged with a suitable change-over device. Provi- 10.7.1 Sea inlets
sions against overpressure in the cooling system are to a) Cooling systems serving propulsion machinery and
be made in accordance with [10.7.4], item b). essential equipment are to be supplied by at least two
c) The standby pump may also be omitted in the case of sea inlets complying with [2.8].
redundancy of the cooled equipment. b) The two sea inlets may be connected by a cross-over.
10.4.3 Expansion tanks c) The sea inlets are to be so designed as to remain sub-
Fresh water expansion tanks are to be provided with at least: merged under all normal navigating conditions.
a de-aerating device In general, one low sea inlet and one high sea inlet are
a water level indicator to be arranged.
a filling connection d) One of the sea inlets may be that of the fire pump.
a drain.
10.7.2 Coolers
10.4.4 Protection of contamination by oil
a) Coolers are to be fitted with isolating valves at the inlets
Suitable means are to be provided in fresh water cooling and outlets.
systems comprising fuel oil or lubricating oil heat exchang-
ers in order to detect any contamination of the water by fuel b) Coolers external to the hull (chest coolers and keel cool-
oil or lubricating oil. ers) are to be fitted with isolating valves at the shell.

Table 25 : Cooling systems

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
System Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Sea water pump pressure or flow L local
Fresh water pump pressure or flow L local
Level in cooling water expansion tank L local

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 191


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

10.7.3 Filters b) Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) systems are to be so


a) Where propulsion engines and auxiliary engines for designed as to prevent:
essential services are directly cooled by sea water, both overflow or spillage of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44)
in normal service and in emergency operating condi- from tanks, pipes, fittings, etc.
tions, filters are to be fitted on the suction of cooling
fuel oil from coming into contact with sources of
pumps.
ignition
b) These filters are to be so arranged that they can be
overheating and seizure of fuel oil and JP5-NATO
cleaned without interrupting the cooling water supply.
(F44).
10.7.4 Pumps c) Fuel oils used for engines and boilers are to have a
a) Cooling pumps for which the discharge pressure may flashpoint complying with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 1,
exceed the design pressure of the piping system are to [2.9].
be fitted with relief valves in accordance with [2.5].
11.2.2 Availability of fuel systems
b) Where general service pumps, ballast pumps or other
pumps may be connected to a cooling system, arrange- a) Fuel oil systems are to be so designed that, in the event
ments are to be made, in accordance with [2.5], to that any one essential auxiliary of such systems
avoid overpressure in any part of the cooling system. becomes inoperative, the fuel oil supply to boilers and
engines can be maintained. Partial reduction of the pro-
10.7.5 Air venting pulsion capability may be accepted, however, when it is
demonstrated that the safe operation of the ship is not
Cocks are to be installed at the highest points of the pipes
impaired.
conveying cooling water to the water jackets for venting air
or gases likely to accumulate therein. In the case of closed b) Fuel oil tanks are to be so arranged that, in the event of
fresh water cooling systems, the cock is to be connected to damage to any one tank, complete loss of the fuel sup-
the expansion tank. ply to essential services does not occur.

11 Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) systems 11.3 General

11.1 Application 11.3.1 Arrangement of fuel oil systems


a) In a ship in which fuel oil is used, or JP5-NATO (F44) is
11.1.1 Scope carried or used for refuelling, the arrangements for the
This Article applies to all fuel oil systems supplying any kind storage, distribution and utilization of the fuel oil or JP5-
of installation and all JP5-NATO (F44) systems. NATO (F44) are to be such as to ensure the safety of the
ship and persons on board.
Dedicated systems and arrangements shall be provided for
each JP5-NATO (F44) fuel system (e.g. one dedicated sys- b) The provisions of [5.10] are to be complied with.
tem for refuelling and one dedicated system for carrying).
11.3.2 Provision to prevent overpressure
11.1.2 Additional requirements applying to fuel oil Provisions are to be made to prevent overpressure in any oil
and JP5-NATO (F44) systems
or JP5-NATO (F44) tank or in any part of the fuel oil and
Additional requirements are given: JP5-NATO (F44) systems. Any relief valve is to discharge to
for independent fuel oil tanks: in Ch 1, App 3 a safe position.
for fuel oil supply equipment forming part of engines,
11.3.3 Ventilation
gas turbines, boilers and incinerators: in the correspond-
ing sections of Part C, Chapter 1 The ventilation of machinery spaces is to be sufficient under
all normal conditions to prevent accumulation of oil
for the installation of purifiers: in Part C, Chapter 4
vapour.
for the location and scantling of tanks forming part of
the ships structure: in Part B, Chapter 2 and Part B, 11.3.4 Access
Chapter 7 Spaces where fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) are handled are to
for helicopter refuelling facilities: in Ch 4, Sec 10, [4] be readily accessible.
for aircraft and helicopter carriers: in NR216 Materials.
11.4 Design of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44)
11.2 Principle filling and transfer systems

11.2.1 General 11.4.1 General


a) Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) systems are to be so A system of pumps and piping for filling and transferring
designed as to ensure the proper characteristics (purity, fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) is to be provided. Provisions are
viscosity, pressure) of the fuel oil supply to ships to be made to allow the transfer of fuel oil or JP5-NATO
engines or of aircrafts or helicopters and boilers. (F44) from any storage tank to another tank.

192 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

11.4.2 Filling systems Note 1: Machinery spaces of category A are defined in Ch 4, Sec 1.
a) Filling pipes of fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) tanks are to Note 2: Service tanks may be located within machinery spaces pro-
terminate on open deck or in filling stations isolated vided the following conditions are met:
from other spaces and efficiently ventilated. Suitable the tank is fitted with a quick draining system connected to
coamings and drains are to be provided to collect any a suitable tank and operable from an accessible position
leakage resulting from filling operations. outside the concerned space.
a water extinguishing system is provided in case of fire in
b) Arrangements are to be made to avoid overpressure in
way of the tank.
the filling lines which are served by pumps on board.
Where safety valves are provided for this purpose, they d) The location of fuel oil tanks is to be in compliance with
are to discharge to the overflow tank referred to in the requirements of Part B, Chapter 2, particularly as
[9.3.3] or to other safe positions deemed satisfactory. regards the installation of cofferdams, the separation
between fuel oil tanks or bunkers and the other spaces
11.4.3 Independence of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) of the ship, and the protection of these tanks and bun-
transfer lines kers against any abnormal rise in temperature.
The fuel oil transfer piping system is to be completely sepa- e) Tanks of JP5-NATO (F44) are to be located clear off and
rate from the other piping systems of the ship. This require- not adjacent to any machinery spaces of Category A by
ment is also to be complied with by JP5-NATO (F44) the provision of a cofferdam in which there may be
transfer piping system. installed JP5-NATO (F44) pumps.
Note 1: A fuel oil tank may be used to carry JP5/NATO (F44) pro-
vided arrangements are made to avoid any inadvertent filling of 11.5.2 Use of free-standing fuel oil tanks
other fuel oil tanks, and with particular care for quality control (fil- a) In general the use of free-standing fuel oil tanks is to be
tration, fuel oil and water content) before refuelling of aircrafts. avoided except on supply ships, where their use is per-
mitted in category A machinery spaces.
11.4.4 Transfer pumps
a) Fuel oil system is to include at least two means of trans- b) For the design and the installation of independent tanks,
fer. One of these means is to be a power pump. The refer to Ch 1, App 3.
other may consist of a standby pump.
11.6 Design of fuel oil tanks and bunkers and
b) Where necessary, transfer pumps are to be fitted on their
discharge side with a relief valve leading back to the JP5-NATO (F44) tanks
suction of the pump or to any other place deemed satis-
11.6.1 General
factory.
Tanks such as collector tanks, de-aerator tanks etc. are to be
c) No stand-by pump is required for JP5-NATO (F44). considered as fuel oil tanks for the purpose of application of
this sub-article, and in particular regarding the valve
11.5 Arrangement of fuel oil, bunkers and requirements.
JP5-NATO (F44) tanks Tanks with a volume lower than 500 l will be given special
consideration by the Society.
11.5.1 Location of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) tanks
a) No fuel oil tank is to be situated where spillage or leak- 11.6.2 Scantlings
age therefrom can constitute a hazard by falling on a) The scantlings of fuel oil tanks and bunkers and JP5-
heated surfaces. NATO (F44) tanks forming part of the ship's structure are
b) Fuel oil tanks and bunkers are not to be situated immedi- to comply with the requirements stated in Part B, Chap-
ately above boilers or in locations where they could be ter 7.
subjected to high temperatures, unless specially agreed b) Scantlings of fuel oil tanks and bunkers which are not
by the Society. In general, the distance between fuel oil part of the ship's structure are to comply with Ch 1, App
tanks and boilers is not to be less than 450 mm. Where 3. For cases which are not contained in the Tables of
boilers are situated above double bottom fuel oil tanks, that appendix, scantlings will be given special consider-
the distance between the double bottom tank top and the ation by the Society.
lower metallic part of the boilers is not to be less than:
750 mm for water tube boilers 11.6.3 Filling and suction pipes
600 mm for cylindrical boilers. a) All suction pipes from JP5-NATO (F44) tanks, fuel oil
tanks and bunkers, including those in the double bot-
c) As far as practicable, fuel oil tanks are to be part of the tom, are to be provided with valves.
ships structure and are to be located outside machinery
spaces of category A. Where fuel oil tanks, other than b) For storage tanks, filling pipes may also be used for suc-
double bottom tanks, are necessarily located adjacent to tion purposes.
or within machinery spaces of category A, at least one c) Where the filling pipes to JP5-NATO (F44) tanks, fuel oil
of their vertical sides is to be contiguous to the machin- bunkers and tanks are not led to the upper part of the
ery space boundaries, and is preferably to have a com- such bunkers and tanks, they are to be provided with
mon boundary with the double bottom tanks, and the non-return valves at their ends, unless they are fitted
area of the tank boundary common with the machinery with valves arranged in accordance with the require-
spaces is to be kept to a minimum. ments stated in [11.6.4].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 193


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

11.6.4 Remote control of valves b) When electric heaters are fitted, means are to be pro-
vided to ensure that heating elements are permanently
a) Every fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) pipe which, if dam- submerged during operation. In all cases a safety tem-
aged, would allow oil to escape from a storage, settling perature switch is to be fitted in order to avoid a surface
or daily service tank situated above the double bottom, temperature of 220C and above. It is to be:
is to be fitted with a cock or valve directly on the tank or
independent from the automatic control sensor
directly on plating of last tank, capable of being closed
from a safe position outside the space in which such designed to cut off the electrical power supply in the
tanks are situated in the event of a fire occurring in such event of excessive temperature
space. provided with manual reset.

Note 1: For the location of the remote controls, refer to [11.10.3],


c) Fuel oil heaters are to be fitted with relief valves leading
item c). back to the pump suction concerned or to any other
place deemed satisfactory.
b) Such valves and cocks are also to include local control
and indicators are to be provided on the remote and 11.8 Design of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44)
local controls to show whether they are open or shut treatment systems
(see [2.7.3]).
11.8.1 General
c) Where fuel oil tanks are situated outside boiler and
Fuel oils and JP5-NATO (F44) used for the engines of the
machinery spaces, the remote control required in a)
ship, of the aircrafts or of the helicopters are to be purified
may be transferred to a valve located inside the boiler or
and filtered according to the relevant manufacturers
machinery spaces on the suction pipes from these tanks.
requirements.
d) In the special case of storage tanks situated in any shaft
11.8.2 Drains
or pipe tunnel or similar space, valves are to be fitted on
the tank but control in the event of fire may be effected a) Storage tanks and, where provided, settling tanks, are to
by means of an additional valve on the pipe or pipes be provided with drains permitting the evacuation of
outside the tunnel or similar space. If such additional water and impurities likely to accumulate in the lower
valve is fitted in the machinery space it is to be operated part of such tanks.
from a position outside this space. b) Efficient means are to be provided for draining oily
water escaping from the drains.
11.6.5 Drain pipes 11.8.3 Treatment installation
Where fitted, drain pipes are to be provided with self-clos- a) Where fuel oil needs to be treated, at least two means of
ing valves or cocks. treatment are to be installed on board, each means is to
be capable of efficiently purifying the amount of fuel oil
See also [11.5.1], item c), [11.5.1], Note 2. necessary for the normal operation of the ships engines.
b) For JP5 NATO (F44), one means of treatment may be
11.6.6 Air and overflow pipes accepted.
Air and overflow pipes are to comply with [9.1] and [9.3]. c) Subject to special consideration by the Society, the
capacity of the standby purifier fuel oil may be less than
11.6.7 Sounding pipes and level gauges that required in item a), depending on the arrangements
made for the fuel oil service tanks to satisfy the require-
a) Safe and efficient means of ascertaining the amount of ment in [11.9.2].
fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) contained in any fuel oil
d) The standby purifier may also be used for other ships
tank and JP5-NATO (F44) tank are to be provided.
services.
b) Sounding pipes of fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) tanks are e) Each purifier is to be provided with an alarm in case of
to comply with the provisions of [9.2]. failures likely to affect the quality of the purified fuel oil
or JP5-NATO (F44).
c) Gauge cocks for ascertaining the level in the tanks are
f) Fuel oil purifiers and JP5-NATO (F44) purifiers are to be
not to be used.
installed as required in Part C, Chapter 4.

11.7 Design of fuel oil heating systems 11.9 Design of fuel supply systems

11.7.1 Fuel oil heaters 11.9.1 General


When necessary, arrangements are to be made for cooling
a) Where steam heaters or heaters using other heating the marine diesel oil from engine return lines.
media are provided in fuel oil system, they are to be fit-
ted with at least a high temperature alarm or a low flow 11.9.2 Fuel oil service tanks
alarm in addition to a temperature control, except a) The propulsion plant and the generator plant are to be
where temperatures dangerous for the ignition of the supplied by at least two service tanks, which may be
fuel oil cannot be reached. common to both plants.

194 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

b) The aggregate capacity of the service tanks is to allow at 11.10.2 Automatic controls
least 3 hours operation at maximum continuous rating Automatic temperature control is to be provided for all
of the propulsion plant and normal operating load at sea heaters.
of the generator plant.
11.10.3 Remote controls
11.9.3 Fuel oil supply to internal combustion engines a) The remote control arrangement of valves fitted on fuel
a) The suctions of engine fuel pumps are to be so arranged oil and on JP5-NATO (F44) tanks is to comply with
as to prevent the pumping of water and sludge likely to [11.6.4].
accumulate after decanting at the lower part of service b) The power supply to:
tanks.
transfer pumps and other pumps of the fuel oil and
b) Internal combustion engines intended for main propul- JP5-NATO (F44) system
sion are to be fitted with at least two filters, or similar fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) purifiers, and other
devices, so arranged that one of the filters can be over- treatment equipment,
hauled while the other is in use.
is to be capable of being stopped from a position within
Note 1: Where the propulsion plant consists of: the space containing the pumps and from another posi-
two or more engines, each one with its own filter, or tion located outside such space and always accessible
one engine with an output not exceeding 375 kW,
in the event of fire within the space.
Note 1: Locally controlled pneumatic pumps are not required to be
the second filter may be replaced by a readily accessible and
provided with a remote control system.
easily replaceable spare filter.
c) Remote control of the valve fitted to the emergency gen-
c) Oil filters fitted in parallel are to be so arranged as to erator fuel tank is to be in a separate location from that
minimize the possibility of a filter under pressure being of other valves fitted to tanks in the engine room.
opened by mistake.
d) The positions of the remote controls are also to comply
Filter chambers are to be provided with suitable means with Part C, Chapter 3.
for:
ventilating when put into operation 11.11 Construction of fuel oil and JP5-NATO
de-pressurizing before being opened. (F44) piping systems
Valves or cocks used for this purpose are to be fitted
11.11.1 Materials
with drain pipes led to a safe location.
a) Fuel oil pipes and their valves are to be of steel or other
d) Excess fuel oil from pumps or injectors is to be led back approved material, except that the use of flexible pipes
to the service or settling tanks, or to other tanks may be accepted provided they comply with [2.6.3].
intended for this purpose.
For JP5-NATO (F44), such pipes and valves located on
e) For high pressure fuel oil pipes, refer to Ch 1, Sec 2. the refuelling line (i.e. downstream the treatment equip-
ment) are to be of stainless steel.
11.10 Control and monitoring b) For valves fitted to fuel oil tanks and which are under a
static pressure head, steel or nodular cast iron may be
11.10.1 Monitoring accepted.
Alarms and safeguards are to be provided for fuel oil and for c) Internal galvanisation of fuel oil pipes and tank or bun-
JP5-NATO (F44) systems in accordance with Tab 26. ker walls are not allowed.

Table 26 : Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) systems

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
System Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Fuel oil and JP5-NATO (F44) overflow tank level H (1) X (2)
HH X (2)
Sludge tank level local
Fuel oil level in daily service tank and JP5-NATO (F44) L+H (1) local
service tank
(1) Or sightglasses on the overflow pipe
(2) Filling valve shut down
Note 1: Blank box means no provision.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 195


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

11.12 Arrangement of fuel oil and JP5-NATO 12.2.2 Availability


(F44) piping systems a) Lubricating oil systems serving propulsion plants are to
be so designed that, in the event that any one pump is
11.12.1 Passage of fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) pipes inoperative, the lubrication of the engines and other
through tanks equipment is maintained. Reduction of the propulsion
capability may be accepted, however, when it is dem-
a) Fuel oil pipes are not to pass through tanks containing
onstrated that the safe operation of the ship is not
fresh water or other flammable oil, unless they are con-
impaired.
tained within tunnels.
b) For auxiliary engines fitted with their own lubrication
FJP5-NATO (F44) pipes are not allowed to pass through system, no additional pump is required.
tanks containing other fluids.
c) Main engines are to be provided with at least two power
b) Transfer pipes of fuel oil passing through ballast tanks lubricating pumps, of such a capacity as to maintain
are to have a reinforced thickness complying with Tab 5, normal lubrication with any one pump out of action.
however the thickness of the pipe need not to exceed
d) In the case of propulsion plants comprising more than
the Rule thickness of tank plate.
one engine, each with its own lubricating pump, one of
the pumps mentioned in item a) may be a spare pump.
11.12.2 Passage of pipes through fuel oil or JP5-NATO
(F44) tanks
12.3 General
Fresh water pipes are not to pass through fuel oil tanks,
unless such pipes are contained within tunnels. 12.3.1 Arrangement of lubricating oil systems
JP5-NATO (F44) tanks are not to be passed through by any The provisions of [5.10] are to be complied with, where
other piping system. applicable.

12.3.2 Filtration
11.12.3 Segregation of fuel oil purifiers
a) In forced lubrication systems, a device is to be fitted
Purifiers fuel oil or JP5-NATO (F44) are to be in accordance which efficiently filters the lubricating oil in the circuit.
with Ch 4, Sec 6, [4.1.2].
b) The filters provided for this purpose for main machinery
and machinery driving electric propulsion generators
12 Lubricating oil systems are to be so arranged that they can be easily cleaned
without stopping the supply of filtered lubricating oil to
the machines.
12.1 Application
c) The fineness of the filter mesh is to comply with the
12.1.1 This Article applies to lubricating oil systems serving requirements of the engine or turbine manufacturers.
diesel engines, gas turbines, reverse and reduction gears, d) Where filters are fitted on the discharge side of lubricat-
clutches and controllable pitch propellers, for lubrication or ing oil pumps, a relief valve leading back to the suction
control purposes. or to any other convenient place is to be provided on
the discharge of the pumps.
This Article also applies to separate oil systems intended for
the cooling of engine pistons.
12.3.3 Purification
Where provided, lubricating oil purifiers are to comply with
12.2 Principle [11.8.3] item d) and item e).

12.2.1 General 12.3.4 Heaters


Lubricating oil heaters are to comply with [11.7.1].
a) Lubricating oil systems are to be so designed as to
ensure reliable lubrication of the engines, turbines and
other equipment, including electric motors, intended for 12.4 Design of lubricating oil tanks
propulsion:
12.4.1 Remote control of valves
over the whole speed range, including starting, stop- Lubricating oil tanks with a capacity of 500 litres and above
ping and, where applicable, manoeuvring are to be fitted with remote controlled valves in accordance
for all the inclinations angles stated in Ch 1, Sec 1 with the provisions of [11.6.4].
Suction valves and draining valves from storage tanks need
b) Lubricating oil systems are to be so designed as to
not be arranged with remote controls provided they are kept
ensure sufficient heat transfer and appropriate filtration
closed except during transfer operations.
of the oil.

c) Lubricating oil systems are to be so designed as to pre- 12.4.2 Filling and suction pipes
vent oil from entering into contact with sources of igni- Filling and suction pipes are to comply with the provisions
tion. of [11.6.3].

196 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 27 : Lubricating oil systems

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
System Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Sludge tank level local
Note 1: Blank box means no provision.

12.4.3 Air and overflow pipes 12.6.2 Sight-flow glasses


Air and overflow pipes are to comply with the provisions of The use of sight-flow glasses in lubricating systems is per-
[9.1] and [9.3]. mitted, provided that they are shown by testing to have a
suitable degree of fire resistance.
12.4.4 Sounding pipes and level gauges
a) Safe and efficient means of ascertaining the amount of 13 Hydraulic systems
lubricating oil contained in the tanks are to be provided.
b) Sounding pipes are to comply with the provisions of 13.1 Application
[9.2].
13.1.1 Hydraulic installations intended for essential
c) Oil-level gauges complying with [2.9.2] may be used in
services
place of sounding pipes.
Unless otherwise specified, this Article applies to all
d) Gauge cocks for ascertaining the level in the tanks are hydraulic power installations intended for essential services,
not to be used. including:
actuating systems of controllable pitch propellers and
12.4.5 Oil collecting tanks for engines
clutches
a) In ships required to be fitted with a double bottom,
actuating systems of thrusters
wells for lubricating oil under main engines may be per-
mitted by the Society provided it is satisfied that the actuating systems of steering gear
arrangements give protection equivalent to that afforded actuating systems of lifting appliances
by a double bottom complying with Pt B, Ch 4, Sec 4.
manoeuvring systems of hatch covers
b) Where, in ships required to be fitted with a double bot-
manoeuvring systems of stern, bow and side doors and
tom, oil collecting tanks extend to the outer bottom, a
bow visors
valve is to be fitted on the oil drain pipe, located
between the engine sump and the oil drain tank. This manoeuvring systems of mobile ramps, movable plat-
valve is to be capable of being closed from a readily forms, elevators and telescopic wheelhouses
accessible position located above the working platform. starting systems of diesel engines and gas turbines
Alternative arrangements will be given special consider- remote control of valves
ation. stabilizing installations.
c) Oil collecting pipes from the engine sump to the oil col-
lecting tank are to be submerged at their outlet ends. 13.1.2 Hydraulic installations located in spaces
containing sources of ignition
Hydraulic power installations not serving essential services
12.5 Control and monitoring
but located in spaces where sources of ignition are present
12.5.1 In addition to the requirements in Ch 1, Sec 2 for are to comply with the provisions of [13.3.2], [13.3.3],
diesel engines, in Ch 1, Sec 4 for steam turbines, in Ch 1, [13.4.4] and [13.4.5].
Sec 5 for gas turbines and in Ch 1, Sec 6 for gears, alarms
13.1.3 Low pressure or low power hydraulic
are to be provided for lubricating oil systems in accordance installations
with Tab 27.
Hydraulic power installations with a design pressure of less
than 2,5 MPa and hydraulic power packs of less than 5 kW
12.6 Construction of lubricating oil piping will be given special consideration by the Society.
systems
13.1.4 Very high pressure hydraulic installations
12.6.1 Materials Hydraulic power installations with a design pressure
Materials used for oil piping system in machinery spaces exceeding 35 MPa will be given special consideration by
are to comply with the provisions of [11.11.1]. the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 197


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

13.2 Principle 13.4 Design of hydraulic systems

13.2.1 General 13.4.1 Power units


Hydraulic systems are to be so designed as to: Low power hydraulic installations not supplying essential
services may be fitted with a single power unit, provided
avoid any overload of the system
that alternative means, such as a hand pump, are available
maintain the actuated equipment in the requested posi- on board.
tion (or the driven equipment at the requested speed)
avoid overheating of the hydraulic oil 13.4.2 Pressure reduction units
Pressure reduction units used in hydraulic power installa-
prevent hydraulic oil from coming into contact with
tions are to be duplicated.
sources of ignition.
13.4.3 Filtering equipment
13.2.2 Availability
a) A device is to be fitted which efficiently filters the
a) Hydraulic systems are to be so designed that, in the
hydraulic oil in the circuit.
event that any one essential component becomes inop-
erative, the hydraulic power supply to essential services b) Where filters are fitted on the discharge side of hydrau-
can be maintained. Partial reduction of the propulsion lic pumps, a relief valve leading back to the suction or
capability may be accepted, however, when it is dem- to any other convenient place is to be provided on the
onstrated that the safe operation of the ship is not discharge of the pumps.
impaired. Such reduction of capability is not acceptable
13.4.4 Provision for cooling
for steering gear.
Where necessary, appropriate cooling devices are to be
b) When a hydraulic power system is simultaneously serv- provided.
ing one essential system and other systems, it is to be
ensured that: 13.4.5 Provision against overpressure
any operation of such other systems, or a) Safety valves of sufficient capacity are to be provided at
any failure in the whole installation external to the the high pressure side of the installation.
essential system, b) Safety valves are to discharge to the low pressure side of
does not affect the operation of the essential system. the installation or to the service tank.

c) Provision of item b) applies in particular to steering gear. 13.4.6 Provision for venting
d) Hydraulic systems serving lifting or hoisting appliances, Cocks are to be provided in suitable positions to vent the air
including platforms, ramps, hatch covers, lifts, etc., are from the circuit.
to be so designed that a single failure of any component
13.4.7 Provision for drainage
of the system may not result in a sudden undue dis-
placement of the load or in any other situation detri- Provisions are to be made to allow the drainage of the
mental to the safety of the ship and persons on board. hydraulic oil contained in the installation to a suitable col-
lecting tank.
13.3 General
13.5 Design of hydraulic tanks and other
13.3.1 Definitions components
a) A power unit is the assembly formed by the hydraulic
13.5.1 Hydraulic oil service tanks
pump and its driving motor.
a) Service tanks intended for hydraulic power installations
b) An actuator is a component which directly converts supplying essential services are to be provided with at
hydraulic pressure into mechanical action. least:

13.3.2 Limitations of use of hydraulic oils a level gauge complying with [2.9.2]
a temperature indicator
a) Oils used for hydraulic power installations are to have a
flashpoint not lower than 150C and be suitable for the a level switch complying with [13.6.2].
entire service temperature range. b) The free volume in the service tank is to be at least 10%
b) The hydraulic oil is to be replaced in accordance with of the tank capacity.
the specification of the installation manufacturer.
13.5.2 Hydraulic oil storage tanks
13.3.3 Location of hydraulic power units Hydraulic power installations supplying essential services
are to include a storage means of sufficient capacity to refill
a) Whenever practicable, hydraulic power units are to be
the whole installation should the need arise in case of
located outside main engine room.
necessity.
b) Where this requirement is not complied with, shields or
similar devices are to be provided around the units in 13.5.3 Hydraulic accumulators
order to avoid an accidental oil spray or mist on heated The hydraulic side of the accumulators which can be iso-
surfaces which may ignite oil. lated is to be provided with a relief valve.

198 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 28 : Hydraulic oil systems

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
System Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Pump pressure L
Service tank level L (1)
(1) The low level alarm is to be activated before the quantity of lost oil reaches 100 liters or 50% of the circuit volume, whichever
is the less.
Note 1: Blank box means no provision.

13.6 Control and monitoring 14.2 Principle


14.2.1 Availability
13.6.1 Indicators
a) Where a single boiler is installed, the steam system may
Arrangements are to be made for connecting a pressure supply only non-essential services.
gauge where necessary in the piping system.
b) Where more than one boiler is installed, the steam pip-
ing system is to be so designed that, in the event that
13.6.2 Monitoring any one boiler is out of action, the steam supply to
Alarms and safeguards for hydraulic power installations essential services can be maintained.
intended for essential services, except steering gear, for
which the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 11 apply, are to be pro- 14.3 Design of steam lines
vided in accordance with Tab 28.
14.3.1 General
Note 1: Tab 28 does not apply to steering gear.
a) Every steam pipe and every connected fitting through
which steam may pass is to be designed, constructed
13.7 Construction of hydraulic oil piping and installed such as to withstand the maximum work-
systems ing stresses to which it may be subjected.
b) When the design temperature of the steam piping sys-
13.7.1 Materials tem exceeds 400C, calculations of thermal stresses are
to be submitted to the Society as specified in [2.3].
a) Pipes are to be made of seamless steel or seamless stain- c) Steam connections on boilers and safety valves are to
less steel. The use of welded steel pipes will be given comply with the applicable requirements of Ch 1, Sec 3.
special consideration by the Society.
14.3.2 Provision against overpressure
b) Casings of pumps, valves and fittings are to be made of
steel or other ductile material. a) If a steam pipe or fitting may receive steam from any
source at a higher pressure than that for which it is
designed, a suitable reducing valve, relief valve and
13.7.2 Pipe connections
pressure gauge are to be fitted.
Where flanged connections are used they are to be of the b) When, for auxiliary turbines, the inlet steam pressure
recess type or of another approved type offering suitable exceeds the pressure for which the exhaust casing and
protection against projections. associated piping up to the exhaust valves are designed,
means to relieve the excess pressure are to be provided.
14 Steam systems 14.3.3 Provision for dumping
In order to avoid overpressure in steam lines due to exces-
14.1 Application sive steam production, in particular in systems where the
steam production cannot be adjusted, provisions are to be
made to allow the excess steam to be discharged to the con-
14.1.1 Scope denser by means of an appropriate dump valve.
This Article applies to all steam systems intended for essen-
tial and non-essential services. 14.3.4 Provision for draining
Means are to be provided for draining every steam pipe in
Steam systems with a design pressure of 10 MPa or more which dangerous water hammer action might otherwise
will be given special consideration. occur.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 199


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

14.3.5 Steam heating pipes 15.2.2 Availability


a) When heating coils are fitted in compartments likely to a) Feed water systems are to be so designed that, in the
contain either fuel oil or liquid or dry cargoes, arrange- event of failure of any one component, the steam supply
ments such as blind flanges are to be provided in order to essential services can be maintained or restored.
to disconnect such coils in the event of carriage of dry
or liquid cargoes which are not to be heated. b) Condensate systems are to be so designed that, in the
b) The number of joints on heating coils is to be reduced to event of failure of:
the minimum consistent with dismantling requirements. one condensate pump, or
14.3.6 Steam lines in cargo holds the arrangements to maintain vacuum in the con-
a) Live and exhaust steam pipes are generally not to pass denser,
through cargo holds, unless special provisions are made the steam supply to essential services can be main-
with the Society's agreement. tained. Partial reduction of the propulsion capability
b) Where steam pipes pass through cargo holds in pipe may be accepted.
tunnels, provision is to be made to ensure the suitable
thermal insulation of such tunnels.
15.3 Design of boiler feed water systems
c) When a steam smothering system is provided for cargo
holds, provision is to be made to prevent spurious dam-
15.3.1 Number of feed water systems
age of the cargo by steam or condensate leakage.
a) Every steam generating system which supplies essential
14.3.7 Steam lines in accommodation spaces services is to be provided with not less than two sepa-
Steam lines are not to pass through accommodation spaces, rate feed water systems from and including the feed
unless they are intended for heating purposes. pumps, noting that a single penetration of the steam
drum is acceptable.
14.3.8 Turbine connections
a) A sentinel valve or equivalent is to be provided at the b) The requirement stated in a) may be dispensed with for
exhaust end of all turbines. The valve discharge outlets boilers heated exclusively by engine exhaust gases or by
are to be visible and suitably guarded if necessary. steam for which one feed system is considered as suffi-
cient, provided an alternative supply of steam is avail-
b) Bled steam connections are to be fitted with non-return
able on board.
valves or other approved means to prevent steam and
water returning to the turbines. c) Each boiler is to be provided with feed regulators as
specified in Ch 1, Sec 3, [5].
14.3.9 Strainers
a) Efficient steam strainers are to be provided close to the 15.3.2 Feed pumps
inlets to ahead and astern high pressure turbines or,
alternatively, at the inlets to manoeuvring valves. a) The following pumps are to be provided:
b) Where required by the manufacturer of the auxiliaries, at least one main feed pump of sufficient capacity to
steam strainers are also to be fitted in the steam lines supply the boilers under nominal conditions, and
supplying these auxiliaries.
one standby feed pump.
15 Boiler feed water and condensate b) The capacity of the standby pump may be less than that
systems of the main feed pumps provided it is demonstrated
that, taking into account the reduction of the propulsion
capability, the ship remains safely operable.
15.1 Application
c) Main feed pumps may be either independent or driven
15.1.1 This Article applies to: by the main turbines. The standby feed pump is to be
feed water systems of oil fired and exhaust gas boilers independent.
steam drain and condensate systems.
d) In twin-screw ships in which there is only one indepen-
dent feed pump, each main turbine is to be fitted with a
15.2 Principle driven pump. Where all feed pumps are independent,
they are to be so arranged as to be capable of dealing
15.2.1 General
with the feed water necessary to supply steam either to
Boiler feed water and condensate systems are to be so both turbines or to one turbine only.
designed that:
reserve feed water is available in sufficient quantity to e) Independent feed pumps for main boilers are to be fitted
compensate for losses with a delivery control and regulating system.
feed water is free from contamination by oils or chlo- f) Unless overpressure is prevented by the feed pump
rides characteristics, means are to be provided which will
feed water for propulsion systems is suitably de-aerated. prevent overpressure in the feed water system.

200 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

g) The pressure head of feed pumps is to take into account 15.3.5 Provision for de-aerating feed water
the maximum service pressure in the boiler as well as A de-aerator is to be provided to ensure the de-aeration of
the pressure losses in the discharge piping. The suction the feed water intended for main boilers before it enters
head of feed pumps is to be such as to prevent cavita- such boilers.
tion as far as possible.
h) Feed pumps and pipes are to be provided with valves so 15.4 Design of condensate systems
arranged that any one pump can be overhauled while
the boilers are operating at full load. 15.4.1 Condensers
a) Appropriate arrangements, such as air ejectors, are to be
15.3.3 Harbour feed pumps provided to maintain vacuum in the main condenser or
a) Where main turbine driven pumps are provided and restore it to the required value.
there is only one independent pump, a harbour feed b) Cooling of the main condenser is to comply with the
pump or an ejector is to be fitted in addition to provide provisions of [10.3.5].
the second means for feeding the boilers which are in
use when the main turbine is not working. 15.4.2 Condensate pumps
b) The harbour feed pump may be used for the general ser- a) Condensate pumps are to include at least:
vice of the ship, but in no case is this pump to be used one main condensate pump of sufficient capacity to
to convey liquid fuel, lubricating oil or oily water. transfer the maximum amount of condensate pro-
c) The suction pipes of the harbour feed pump from the duced under nominal conditions, and
hotwell, from reserve feed water tanks and from filters one independently driven standby condensate
are to be fitted with non-return valves. pump.
b) The standby condensate pump may be used for other
15.3.4 Feed water tanks
purposes.
a) All ships fitted with main boilers or auxiliary boilers for
essential services are to be provided with reserve feed 15.4.3 Condensate observation tanks
water tanks. Any condensate from the steam heating pipes provided for
b) Boilers are to be provided with means to supervise and fuel oil tanks and bunkers, cargo tanks and fuel oil or lubri-
control the quality of the feed water. Suitable arrange- cating oil heaters is to be led to an observation tank or some
ments are to be provided to preclude, as far as practica- other device of similar efficiency located in a well-lighted
ble, the entry of oil or other contaminants which may and readily accessible position.
adversely affect the boiler.
15.5 Control and monitoring
c) Feed water tanks are not to be located adjacent to fuel
oil tanks. Fuel oil pipes are not to pass through feed 15.5.1 General
water tanks.
The provisions of this sub-article apply only to feed water
d) For main boilers, one or more evaporators are to be pro- and condensate systems intended for propulsion.
vided, the capacity of which is to compensate for the
losses of feed water due to the operation of the 15.5.2 Monitoring
machines, in particular where the fuel supplied to the Alarms and safeguards are to be provided for feed water
boilers is atomized by means of steam. and condensate systems in accordance with Tab 29.

Table 29 : Boiler feed and condensate system

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
X = function is required, R = remote System Auxiliary

Slow- Shut- Stand


Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Sea water flow or equivalent L
Condenser pressure H local
HH X
Water level in main condenser (unless justified) H local
Feed water salinity H local
Feed water pump delivery pressure L local
X
Feed water tank level L

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 201


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

15.5.3 Automatic controls 16.3 Design of starting air systems


Automatic level control is to be provided for:
16.3.1 Number and capacity of air compressors
de-aerators
a) Where main and auxiliary engines are arranged for start-
condensers. ing by compressed air, two or more air compressors are
to be fitted with a total capacity sufficient to supply
15.6 Arrangement of feed water and within one hour the quantity of air needed to satisfy the
provisions of Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1.1]. This capacity is to be
condensate piping
approximately equally divided between the number of
compressors fitted, excluding the emergency compres-
15.6.1
sor fitted in pursuance of [16.3.2].
a) Feed water pipes are not to pass through fuel oil or b) At least one of the compressors is to be independent of
lubricating oil tanks. the engines for which starting air is supplied and is to
b) Pipes connected to feed water tanks are to be so have a capacity of not less than 50% of the total
arranged as to prevent the contamination of feed water required in item a).
by fuel oil, lubricating oil or chlorides.
16.3.2 Initial charge of starting air receivers
a) Where, for the purpose of [16.2.2], an emergency air
16 Compressed air systems compressor is fitted, its driving engine is to be capable
of being started by hand-operated devices. Independent
16.1 Application electrical starting batteries may also be accepted.
b) A hand compressor may be used for the purpose of
16.1.1 This Article applies to compressed air systems [16.2.2] only if it is capable of charging within one hour
intended for essential services, and in particular to: an air receiver of sufficient capacity to provide 3 con-
starting of engines secutive starts of a propulsion engine or of an engine
capable of supplying the energy required for operating
control and monitoring
one of the main compressors.
breathable air systems.
16.3.3 Number and capacity of air receivers
16.2 Principle a) Where main engines are arranged for starting by com-
pressed air, at least two air receivers are to be fitted of
16.2.1 General approximately equal capacity and capable of being
used independently.
a) Compressed air systems are to be so designed that the
compressed air delivered to the consumers: b) The total capacity of air receivers is to be sufficient to
provide without replenishment the number of starts
is free from oil and water required in Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1.1].
does not have an excessive temperature.
16.3.4 Air supply for starting the emergency
b) Compressed air systems are to be so designed as to pre- generating set
vent overpressure in any part of the systems. Starting air systems serving main or auxiliary engines may
be used for starting the emergency generator under the con-
16.2.2 Availability ditions specified in Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1.3].
a) Compressed air systems are to be so designed that, in
the event of failure of one air compressor or one air 16.4 Design of control and monitoring air
receiver intended for starting, control purposes or other systems
essential services, the air supply to such services can be
maintained. 16.4.1 Air supply
b) At the specific request of the Naval Authority, it may be a) The control and monitoring air supply to essential ser-
required that the compressed air system for starting vices is to be available from two sources of a sufficient
main engines and auxiliary engines for essential services capacity to allow normal operation with one source out
is to be so arranged that it is possible to ensure the ini- of service.
tial charge of air receiver(s) without the aid of a power b) At least one air vessel fitted with a non-return valve is to
source outside the ship. Equivalent solutions allowing be provided for control and monitoring purposes.
the starting of the engines may be accepted by the Soci-
Note 1: The Society may accept, as an alternative to the above
ety on a case by case basis. clause, provisions allowing the configuration of the compressed
c) If the air receivers are used for engine starting as in air installation in such a way as that the control and monitoring
[16.3] the total capacity of air receivers hall take into air circuit can be isolated from the rest of the installation.
account the air to be delivered to other consumers such c) Pressure reduction units used in control and monitoring
as control systems, ship systems, etc., which are con- air systems intended for essential services are to be
nected to the air receivers. duplicated, unless an alternative air supply is provided.

202 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

d) Failure of the control air supply is not to cause any sud- 16.5.4 Provision for draining
den change of the controlled equipment which may be Air compressors are to be fitted with a drain valve.
detrimental to the safety of the ship.
16.6 Control and monitoring of compressed
16.4.2 Pressure control
air systems
Arrangements are to be made to maintain the air pressure at
a suitable value in order to ensure satisfactory operation of 16.6.1 Monitoring
the installation. Alarms and safeguards are to be provided for compressed
air systems in accordance with Tab 30.
16.4.3 Air treatment
In addition to the provisions of [16.8.3], arrangements are 16.6.2 Automatic controls
to be made to ensure cooling, filtering and drying of the air Automatic pressure control is to be provided for maintain-
prior to its introduction in the monitoring and control cir- ing the air pressure in the air receivers within the required
cuits. limits.

16.5 Design of air compressors 16.7 Materials


16.5.1 Prevention of excessive temperature of 16.7.1 Pipes and valves bodies in control and monitoring
discharged air air systems and other air systems intended for non-essential
Air compressors are to be so designed that the temperature services may be made of plastic in accordance with the pro-
of discharged air cannot exceed 95C. For this purpose, the visions of Ch 1, App 2.
air compressors are to provided where necessary with:
suitable cooling means 16.8 Arrangement of compressed air piping
fusible plugs or alarm devices set at a temperature not systems
exceeding 120. 16.8.1 Prevention of overpressure
16.5.2 Prevention of overpressure Means are to be provided to prevent overpressure in any
part of compressed air systems. Suitable pressure relief
a) Air compressors are to be fitted with a relief valve com- arrangements are to be provided for all systems discharging
plying with [2.5.3]. in a safe position.
b) Means are to be provided to prevent overpressure wher-
ever water jackets or casings of air compressors may be 16.8.2 Air supply to compressors
subjected to dangerous overpressure due to leakage a) Provisions are to be made to reduce to a minimum the
from air pressure parts. entry of oil into air pressure systems.
c) Water space casings of intermediate coolers of air com- b) Air compressors are to be located in spaces provided
pressors are to be protected against any overpressure with sufficient ventilation.
which might occur in the event of rupture of air cooler
16.8.3 Air treatment and draining
tubes.
a) Provisions are be made to drain air pressure systems.
16.5.3 Crankcase relief valves b) Efficient oil and water separators, or filters, are to be
Air compressors having a crankcase volume of at least 0,6 provided on the discharge of compressors, and drains
m3 are to be fitted with crankcases explosion relief valves are to be installed on compressed air pipes wherever
satisfying the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 2, [2.4.4]. deemed necessary.

Table 30 : Compressed air systems

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
System Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Compressor lubricating oil pressure (except where L
splash lubrication)
Air pressure after reducing valves (1) L+H local
Starting air pressure before main shut-off valve L local + R
Air vessel pressure (2) L+H local
Note 1: Blank box means no provisions.
(1) Applicable to the pressure reducing valves referred to in [15.4.1] c).
(2) Applicable to air vessel group where the air vessels are normally in communication.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 203


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

16.8.4 Lines between compressors, receivers and and the following monitors:
engines
lubricating oil level
All discharge pipes from starting air compressors are to be
lead directly to the starting air receivers, and all starting air delivered air pressure.
pipes from the air receivers to main or auxiliary engines are
to be entirely separate from the compressor discharge pipe 16.9.4 Air filtering systems
system. The air filtering systems shall be consistent with the air
Note 1: Air vessels may be arranged as buffer vessels (common fill- breathable properties stated by the Naval Authority.
ing and discharge line) provided that a non return valve is fitted
between the engine and the compressor, in addition to that 16.9.5 Air breathable monitor and control panels
required in Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1.1], item c).
Air process, air properties as well as filling/refilling process
shall be controlled and monitored.
16.8.5 Protective devices for starting air mains
Non-return valves and other safety devices are to be pro- 16.9.6 Prevention of over pressure
vided on the starting air mains of each engine in accor-
The requirements in [16.8.1] shall be complied with.
dance with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 2, [3.1.1].

16.9.7 Metallic materials


16.9 Compressed breathable air systems
All metallic materials which are used in the construction of
pipes for breathable systems shall be AISI 316, or other
16.9.1 Number of refilling air breathable stations and
stainless steel with a nickel content not less than 10% and a
station arrangement
yielding strength RS not less than 250 Mpa, or Monel 400.
For each ship's safety zone a filling / refilling station for
breathing apparatus of fire-fighter's outfits. The station shall 16.9.8 Class of components of breathable air
be provided with an electric driven compressor capable of systems and tests
refilling the number of bottles mentioned in the ship specifi-
For pipes, fittings, containers, filter and absorption devices
cation at 30 MPa in less than one hour. Arrangements are to
containers and compressors, class shall be in accordance
be made for filling / refilling other equipment such as NBC
with the present Ch 1, Sec 10 and, where appropriate, with
teams or divers apparatus.
Ch 1, Sec 3.
Where necessary, pressure reducing devices are to be pro-
The tests of such components shall be in accordance with
vided.
[19].
16.9.2 Breathable air properties
The breathable air properties shall comply with standards to 17 Combustion air and exhaust gas
be stated by the Naval Authority. systems

16.9.3 Air compressors


17.1 General
a) The air inlet of the compressors shall be positioned,
accounting NBC protection, so that particulate matters 17.1.1 Application
are minimized and the content of water and oil in the
This Article applies to combustion air intake system and:
suctioned air shall be less than 50 mg/Nm3.
exhaust gas pipes from engines and gas turbines
b) All compressors shall be so designed and constructed
that prevention of overpressure and excessive tempera- smoke ducts from boilers and incinerators.
ture and shall comply with the requirements of [16.5.1]
and [16.5.2]. Combustion air intake system are provided for machinery
required to run in NBC conditions.
c) The compressors shall also be provided with filter and
valves at the air inlet, valve at air outlet, automatic drain 17.1.2 Principle
valve and safety valve at stages as well as automatic
condensate baffle separators after stages. Combustion air systems are to be so designed as to:
prevent manned space from NBC contamination
d) Furthermore, for the electric compressor, at least the fol-
lowings operations are to be provided from the control prevent water from entering engines.
panel required in [16.9.5]:
Exhaust gas systems are to be so designed as to:
emergency shut down
limit the risk of fire
automatic stop at a delivered preset pressure
prevent gases from entering manned spaces
emergency stop in case of compressed air high tem-
perature, prevent water from entering engines.

204 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

17.2 Design of combustion air and exhaust 17.4.2 Provision for displacement
systems Where engine are elastic mounted, the devices used for
supporting the combustion air, if any, and exhaust pipes or
17.2.1 General ducts are to be so designed that any displacement does not
Combustion air and exhaust systems are to be so arranged cause abnormal stresses in the piping system and in particu-
as to minimise the intake of exhaust gases into manned lar in the connection with engine turbochargers.
spaces, air conditioning systems and engine intakes.
17.4.3 Provision for draining
17.2.2 Limitation of exhaust line surface temperature a) Drains are to be provided where necessary in combus-
a) Exhaust gas pipes and silencers are to be either water tion air and exhaust systems in order to prevent water
cooled or efficiently insulated where: flowing into the engine.

their surface temperature may exceed 220C, or b) Where exhaust pipes are water cooled, they are to be so
arranged as to be self-draining overboard.
they pass through spaces of the ship where a tem-
perature rise may be dangerous.
18 Oxyacetylene welding systems
b) The insulation of exhaust systems is to comply with the
provisions of Ch 1, Sec 1, [3.7.1].
18.1 Application
17.2.3 Limitation of pressure losses
18.1.1 This Article applies to centralized fixed plants for
Combustion air and exhaust gas systems are to be so oxyacetylene welding installed on ships. It may also be
designed that pressure losses in the intake and exhaust lines applied, at the discretion of the Society, to other plants
do not exceed the maximum values permitted by the engine using liquefied gas, such as propane.
or boiler manufacturers.
While it is to be noted that oxyacetylene welding systems
17.2.4 Intercommunication of engine exhaust gas are generally not in use in naval ships the following provi-
lines or boiler smoke ducts sions apply if this system are present.
Exhaust gas from different engines is not to be led to a com-
mon exhaust main, exhaust gas boiler or economizer, 18.2 Definitions
unless each exhaust pipe is provided with a suitable isolat-
ing device. 18.2.1 Centralised plants for oxyacetylene welding
A centralized plant for oxyacetylene welding is a fixed plant
17.2.5 Air intake and exhaust gas pipe terminations consisting of a gas bottle room, distribution stations and dis-
a) Where exhaust pipes are led overboard close to the load tribution piping, where the total number of acetylene and
waterline, means are to be provided to prevent water oxygen bottles exceeds 4.
from entering the engine or the ship.
18.2.2 Acetylene
b) Where exhaust pipes are water cooled, they are to be so Acetylene (C2H2) is assumed to be contained in pressurized
arranged as to be self-draining overboard. gas bottles with pressure equal to 1,5-1,8 MPa at 15C.
c) Air intake systems are to be so arranged to prevent water
18.2.3 Oxygen
and waterspray from entering the air duct.
Oxygen (O2) is assumed to be contained in pressurized gas
d) Air intake systems are to be protected against entering of bottles, with pressure equal to 15-20 MPa at 15C.
dust as per requirement of engine manufacturer.
18.2.4 Gas bottle rooms
17.3 Materials A gas bottle room is a room containing acetylene and oxy-
gen bottles, where distribution headers, non-return and stop
17.3.1 General valves, pressure reducing devices and outlets of supply lines
Materials of exhaust gas pipes and fittings are to be resistant to distribution stations are also installed.
to exhaust gases and suitable for the maximum temperature Note 1: Gas bottle rooms may also contain non dangerous equip-
expected. ment

18.2.5 Distribution stations


17.4 Arrangement of combustion air and
Distribution stations are adequately protected areas or cabi-
exhaust piping systems nets equipped with stop valves, pressure regulating devices,
pressure gauges, non-return valves and oxygen as well as
17.4.1 Provision for thermal expansion
acetylene hose connections for the welding torch.
a) Exhaust pipes and smoke ducts are to be so designed
that any expansion or contraction does not cause abnor-
18.3 Design of oxyacetylene welding systems
mal stresses in the piping system, and in particular in
the connection with engine turbochargers. 18.3.1 General
b) The devices used for supporting the pipes are to allow Except on pontoons and service working ships, no more
their expansion or contraction. than two distribution stations are normally permitted.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 205


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

18.3.2 Acetylene and oxygen bottles d) Safety valves are to be provided on the low pressure
a) The bottles are to be tested by the Society or by a body side of the pressure reducing devices and led to the
recognized by the Society. open air above the deck in a safe location where the gas
can easily be spread and where no source of ignition is
b) Bottles with a capacity exceeding 50 liters are not per- present.
mitted.
c) Bottles supplying the plant and spare bottles are to be 18.4 Arrangement of oxyacetylene welding
installed in the gas bottle room. Installation within systems
accommodation spaces, service spaces, control stations
and machinery spaces is not permitted. 18.4.1 Gas bottle rooms
d) Bottles are to be installed in a vertical position and are a) The gas bottle room is to be located in an independent
to be safely secured. The securing system is to be such space over the highest continuous deck and provided
as to allow the ready and easy removal of the bottles. with direct access from outside. The limiting bulkheads
and decks are to be gas-tight and made of steel.
18.3.3 Piping systems
Note 1: Alternatively, the bottles may be stored in an open area.
a) Acetylene and oxygen piping systems are to comply
b) When the total number of gas bottles, including possi-
with the following provisions:
ble spare bottles which are not connected to the plant,
all valves and fittings as well as welding torches and does not exceed 8, acetylene and oxygen bottles may
associated supply hoses are to be adapted to this be installed in the same room. Otherwise, acetylene
specific service and suitable for the conditions and oxygen bottles are to be separated by a gas-tight
expected in the different parts of the system bulkhead.
acetylene piping is to be of stainless steel and seam- c) The bottle room is to be adequately ventilated.
less drawn
d) Flammable oil or gas piping, except that related to the
oxygen piping is to be of copper or stainless steel oxyacetylene welding plant, is not to be led through this
and seamless drawn room.
the connections between the various pipe sections
are to be carried out by means of butt welding. 18.4.2 Distribution stations
Other types of connections including threaded con- Distribution stations are to be located in the engine room or
nections and flange connections are not permitted in the workshop, in a well-ventilated position and protected
only a minimum number of unavoidable connec- against possible mechanical damage.
tions are permitted provided they are located in a
clearly visible position. 18.4.3 Piping
a) Piping is not to be led through accommodation or ser-
b) High pressure lines (i.e. lines between bottles and pres-
vice spaces.
sure reducing devices) are to be installed inside the gas
bottle room and are to comply with the following provi- b) Piping is to be protected against any possible mechani-
sions: cal damage.
acetylene and oxygen piping and associated fittings c) In way of deck or bulkhead penetrations, piping is to be
are to be suitable for a design pressure of 29,5 MPa suitably enclosed in sleeves so arranged as to prevent
a non-return valve is to be installed on the connec- any fretting of the pipe with the sleeve.
tion of each acetylene and oxygen bottle to the
18.4.4 Signboards
header
Signboards are to be posted on board the ship in accor-
stop valves are to be provided on the bottles and dance with Tab 31.
kept shut when distribution stations are not working.
c) Low pressure lines (i.e. lines between pressure reducing Table 31 : Signboards
devices and distribution stations) are to comply with the
following provisions: Location of the signboard Signboard to be posted

steel piping is to have a thickness of not less than: in the gas bottle room diagram of the oxyacetylene
plant
- 2,5 mm when installed in the open air
no smoking
- 2 mm otherwise.
in way of: to be kept shut when distribu-
stainless steel piping is to have a thickness of not less bottle stop valves tion stations are not working
than 1,7 mm. distribution station stop
supply lines to each distribution station are to valves
include, at the station inlet: in way of the pressure indication of the maximum
- a stop valve to be kept shut when the station is reducing devices allowable pressure at the pres-
not working sure reducing device outlet
- devices to protect the supply lines from back in way of the safety valve no smoking
flow of gas or flame passage. discharge outlet

206 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

19 Certification, inspection and testing 19.2.2 Type tests of air pipe closing devices
of piping systems Type approval tests are to be carried out on each type and
size of air pipe closing device, in accordance with Tab 33
and the "Rules for type approval and testing of air pipe clos-
19.1 Application ing devices".
19.1.1 This Article defines the certification and workshop Table 33 : Type tests to be performed
inspection and testing programme to be performed on: for air pipe closing appliances
the various components of piping systems
Type of air closing appliance
the materials used for their manufacture. Test to be performed
Float type Other types
On board testing is dealt with in Ch 1, Sec 15.
Tightness test (1) X X
Flow characteristic
19.2 Type tests X X
determination (2)
Impact test of floats X
19.2.1 Type tests of flexible hoses and expansion
joints Pressure loading test of floats X (3)
a) Type approval tests are to be carried out on flexible (1) The tightness test is to be carried out during immerging/
hoses or expansion joints of each type and of sizes to be emerging in water, in the normal position and at an
agreed with the Society, in accordance with Tab 32. inclination of 40 degrees.
(2) Pressure drop is to be measured versus flow rate using
b) The flexible hoses or expansion joints subjected to the water.
tests are to be fitted with their connections. (3) only for non-metallic floats.
Note 1: X = required.
Table 32 : Type tests to be performed
for flexible hoses and expansion joints
19.2.3 Type tests of mechanical pipe joints
Flexible hoses Flexible hoses Type approval tests are of mechanical pipe joints to be car-
and expansion and expansion ried out in accordance with the provisions of Tab 34.
Test joints in joints in
non-metallic metallic Table 34 : Type tests to be performed
material material for mechanical joints
Bursting test X X
Fire-resistance test X (1) NR Types of mechanical joints

Vibration test (2) NR (7) X Compression Slip-on joints


Tests couplings Grip type &
Pressure impulse test X (6) NR
and pipes machine Slip type
Flexibility test X (3) NR unions grooved type
Elastic deformation test NR X 1 Tightness test + + +
Cyclic expansion test NR X (4) 2 Vibration
+ +
Resistance of the (fatigue) test
X X
material (5) 3 Pressure pul-
+ +
(1) only for flexible hoses and expansion joints used in sation test (1)
flammable oil systems and, when required, in sea water 4 Burst
systems. + + +
pressure test
(2) the Society reserves the right to require the vibration
5 Pull-out test + +
test in case of installation of the components on
sources of high vibrations. 6 Fire
+ + +
(3) only for flexible hoses conveying low temperature flu- endurance test
ids. 7 Vacuum test + (3) + +
(4) only for steam piping systems. For other piping systems,
8 Repeated
fatigue calculations under cyclic expansion conditions + (2) +
assembly test
may be accepted as an alternative.
(5) internal to the conveyed fluid to be demonstrated by Abbreviations:
suitable documentation and / or tests. + : test is required
(6) only for flexible hoses. : test is not required.
(7) may be required for specific applications such as fuel (1) For use in those systems where pressure pulsation other
oil high pressure jacketing pipes or similar applica- than water hammer is expected
tions. (2) Except press type
Note 1: X = required, NR = not required. (3) Except joints with metal-to-metal tightening surfaces.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 207


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

19.3 Testing of materials e) Where the design temperature exceeds 300C, the test
pressure is to be as follows:
19.3.1 General
for carbon and carbon-manganese steel pipes, the
a) Detailed specifications for material tests are given in test pressure is to be equal to 2 p
NR216 Materials.
for alloy steel pipes, the test pressure PH is to be
b) Requirements for the inspection of welded joints are determined by the following formula, but need not
given in NR216 Materials. exceed 2 p:

19.3.2 Tests for materials K 100


p H = 1 ,5 ---------p
a) Where required in Tab 35, materials used for pipes, KT
valves and other accessories are to be subjected to the
where:
following tests:
tensile test at ambient temperature K100 : Permissible stress for 100C, as stated in
Tab 10
flattening test or bend test, as applicable
KT : Permissible stress for the design temper-
tensile test at the design temperature, except if one
ature, as stated in Tab 10.
of the following conditions is met:
- the design temperature is below 200C Note 2: Where alloy steels not included in Tab 10 are used, the
permissible stresses will be given special consideration.
- the mechanical properties of the material at high
temperature have been approved f) Where it is necessary to avoid excessive stress in way of
bends, branches, etc., the Society may give special con-
- the scantling of the pipes is based on reduced
sideration to the reduction of the test pressure to a value
values of the permissible stress.
not less than pH equal to1,5 p. The membrane stress is in
b) Plastic materials are to be subjected to the tests speci- no case to exceed 90% of the yield stress at the testing
fied in Ch 1, App 2, however installation shall be temperature.
avoided if not agreed by the Society and the Naval
Authority. g) While satisfying the condition stated in b), the test pres-
sure of pipes located on the discharge side of centrifugal
pumps driven by steam turbines is not to be less than the
19.4 Hydrostatic testing of piping systems maximum pressure liable to be developed by such
and their components pumps with closed discharge at the operating speed of
their overspeed device.
19.4.1 General
h) When the hydrostatic test of piping is carried out on
Pneumatic tests are to be avoided wherever possible.
board, these tests, except for class I, may be carried out
Where such testing is absolutely necessary in lieu of the
in conjunction with the tests required in [19.4.7].
hydraulic pressure test, the relevant procedure is to be sub-
mitted to the Society for acceptance prior to testing.
19.4.3 Hydrostatic tests of valves, fittings and heat
19.4.2 Hydrostatic pressure tests of piping exchangers

a) Hydrostatic pressure tests are to be carried out to the a) Valves and fittings non-integral with the piping system
Surveyors satisfaction for: and intended for class I and II pipes are to be subjected
to hydrostatic tests in accordance with standards recog-
all class I and II pipes and their integral fittings
nized by the Society, at a pressure not less than 1,5
all steam pipes, feed water pipes, compressed air times the design pressure p defined in [1.3.2].
pipes, and fuel oil and other flammable oil pipes
with a design pressure greater than 0,35 MPa and b) Valves and distance pieces intended to be fitted on the
their associated integral fittings. ship side below the maximum ship draft are to be sub-
jected to hydrostatic tests under a pressure not less than
b) These tests are to be carried out after completion of 0,5 MPa.
manufacture and before installation on board and,
where applicable, before insulating and coating. c) The shells of appliances such as heaters, coolers and
heat exchangers which may be considered as pressure
Note 1: Classes of pipes are defined in [1.5.2].
vessels are to be tested under the conditions specified in
c) Pressure testing of small bore pipes (less than 15 mm) Ch 1, Sec 3.
may be waived except for fuel oil system, JP5-NATO
(F44) system, aircraft/helicopter refuelling system and d) The nests of tubes or coils of heaters, coolers and heat
compressed air system at the discretion of the Surveyor, exchangers are to be submitted to a hydraulic test under
depending on the application. the same pressure as the fluid lines they serve.

d) Where the design temperature does not exceed 300C, e) For coolers of internal combustion engines, see Ch 1,
the test pressure is to be equal to 1,5 p. Sec 2.

208 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

Table 35 : Inspection and testing at works for piping systems and their components

Tests for the materials (1) Inspections and tests for the product (1)

Item (6) Tests Type of During Type of


After
required material manufacturing product
completion
(8) certificate (2) (NDT) certificate (2)
Valves, pipes a) class I, ND 50 mm or [19.3.2] C [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.3] C (3)
and fittings class II, ND 100 mm [3.6.3]
(9)
b) class I, ND < 50 mm or [19.3.2] W [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.3] C (3)
class II, ND < 100 mm [3.6.3]
Flexible hoses and expansion joints [19.3.2] W [19.4.6] C (3)
Pumps and air a) all NR216 [19.4.5] C (3)
compressors Materials
within piping
b) bilge and fire pumps NR216 [19.4.5] C (3)
systems
Materials [19.5.1] a)
covered by
Sections of this c) feed pumps for main boilers:
Chapter
- casing and bolts NR216 C (10) [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.5] C (3)
(7)
- main parts Materials [3.6.3] [19.5.1] b)
- rotor (10)

d) forced circulation pumps for main


boiler:
- casing and bolts NR216 C [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.5] C (3)
Materials [3.6.3]
Centrifugal separators [19.5.2] C (3)
Prefabricated a) class I and II with:
pipe lines
- ND 65 mm, or [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.2] C (3)
- t 10 mm [3.6.3]
b) class I and II with:
- ND < 65 mm, or [3.6.2] (5) [19.4.2] W
- t < 10 mm [3.6.3]
c) class III (4) [19.4.2] W
(1) [x.y.z] = test required, as per referent regulation.
(2) C = class certificate ; W = works certificate.
(3) or alternative type of certificate, depending on the Survey Scheme. See Part A.
(4) where required by [19.4.2].
(5) if of welded construction, for welded connections.
(6) ND = nominal diameter of the corresponding pipe.
(7) for other pumps and compressors, see also additional Rules relevant for related systems.
(8) The material generally shall comply with [2.1.2] and Tab 5. Detail requirements where specified, are given by NR216 Materials.
(9) Attention is to be drawn to Tab 3 (valves and fittings fitted to the ship side are considered class II, as well as valves on the colli-
sion bulkheads, on fuel oil tanks or on lubricating oil tanks under static pressure).
(10) Applies only for casing and bolts.

19.4.4 Hydrostatic tests of fuel oil and JP5-NATO 19.4.5 Hydrostatic tests of pumps and compressors
(F44) bunkers and tanks not forming part of a) Cylinders, covers and casings of pumps and compres-
the ships structure sors are to be subjected to a hydrostatic test under a
pressure at least equal to the test pressure pH , in MPa,
Fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44) and bunkers tanks not forming
determined by the following formulae:
part of the ships structure are to be subjected to a hydro-
pH = 1,5 p where p 4
static test under a pressure corresponding to the maximum
liquid level in such spaces or in the air or overflow pipes, pH = 1,4 p + 0,4 where 4 < p 25
with a minimum of 2,40 m above the top. pH = p + 10,4 where p > 25

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 209


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 10

where: 19.4.7 Pressure tests of piping after assembly on


board
p : Design pressure, in MPa, as defined in
After assembly on board, the following tightness tests are to
[1.3.2].
be carried out in the presence of the Surveyor.
pH is not to be less than 0,4 MPa. In general, all the piping systems covered by these require-
b) While satisfying the condition stated in a), the test pres- ments are to be checked for leakage under operational con-
sure for centrifugal pumps driven by steam turbines is ditions and, if necessary, using special techniques other
not to be less than 1,05 times the maximum pressure than hydrostatic testing. In particular, heating coils in tanks
likely to be recorded with closed discharge at the oper- and liquid lines are to be tested to not less than 1,5 times
ating speed of the overspeed device. the design pressure but in no case less than 0,4 MPa.
Bilge and drainage systems are to be tested against air suc-
c) Intermediate coolers of compressors are to undergo a tion along the relevant lines which are to be provided with
hydrostatic test under a pressure at least equal to the the necessary fittings for such purpose.
pressure pH defined in a). When determining pH, the
pressure p to be considered is that which may result
from accidental communication between the cooler
19.5 Testing of piping system components
and the adjoining stage of higher pressure, allowance during manufacturing
being made for any safety device fitted on the cooler.
19.5.1 Pumps
d) The test pressure for water spaces of compressors and a) Bilge and fire pumps are to undergo a performance test.
their intermediate coolers is not to be less than 1,5 times b) Rotors of centrifugal feed pumps for main boilers are to
the design pressure in the space concerned, subject to a undergo a balancing test.
minimum of 0,2 MPa.
c) All pumps are to undergo to vibration according to a
e) For air compressors and pumps driven by diesel recognized standard.
engines, see Ch 1, Sec 2.
19.5.2 Centrifugal separators
19.4.6 Hydrostatic test of flexible hoses and Centrifugal separators used for fuel oil, JP5-NATO (F44) and
expansion joints lubricating oil are to undergo a running test, normally with
a fuel water mixture.
a) Each flexible hose or expansion joint, together with its
connections, is to undergo a hydrostatic test under a
pressure at least equal to twice the maximum service 19.6 Inspection and testing of piping
pressure, subject to a minimum of 1 MPa. systems
b) During the test, the flexible hose or expansion joint is to 19.6.1 The inspections and tests required for piping sys-
be repeatedly deformed from its geometrical axis. tems and their components are summarised in Tab 35.

210 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

SECTION 11 STEERING GEAR

1 General 1.2 Documentation to be submitted

1.1 Application 1.2.1 Documents to be submitted for all steering gear


Before starting construction, all plans and specifications
1.1.1 Scope listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted to the Society for approval.
Unless otherwise specified, the requirements of this Section
apply to the steering gear systems of all mechanically pro- 1.2.2 Additional documents
pelled ships, and to the steering mechanism of thrusters
used as means of propulsion. The following additional documents are to be submitted:
analysis in relation to the risk of single failure, where
1.1.2 Cross references
required by [3.5.2]
In addition to the those provided in this Section, steering
gear systems are also to comply with the requirements of: analysis in relation to the risk of hydraulic locking,
Ch 1, Sec 15, as regards sea trials where required by [3.5.5]
Pt B, Ch 9, Sec 1, as regards the rudder and the rudder fatigue analysis and/or fracture mechanics analysis,
stock. when required.

Table 1 : Documents to be submitted for steering gear

Item Status of the


Description of the document (1)
No review (2)
1 I Assembly drawing of the steering gear including sliding blocks, guides, stops and other similar components
2 I General description of the installation and of its functioning principle
3 I Operating manuals of the steering gear and of its main components
4 I Description of the operational modes intended for steering in normal and emergency conditions
5 A For hydraulic steering gear, the schematic layout of the hydraulic piping of power actuating systems, including
the hydraulic fluid refilling system, with indication of:
the design pressure
the maximum working pressure expected in service
the diameter, thickness, material specification and connection details of the pipes
the hydraulic fluid tank capacity
the flashpoint of the hydraulic fluid
6 I For hydraulic pumps of power units, the assembly longitudinal and transverse sectional drawings and the
characteristic curves
7 A Assembly drawings of the rudder actuators and constructional drawings of their components, with, for
hydraulic actuators, indication of:
the design torque
the maximum working pressure
the relief valve setting pressure
8 I Constructional drawings of the relief valves for protection of the hydraulic actuators, with indication of:
the setting pressure
the relieving capacity
9 A Diagrams of the electric power circuits
10 A Functional diagram of control, monitoring and safety systems including the remote control from the
navigating bridge, with indication of the location of control, monitoring and safety devices
11 A Constructional drawings of the strength parts providing a mechanical transmission of forces to the rudder stock
(tiller, quadrant, connecting rods and other similar items), with the calculation notes of the shrink-fit connections
12 I/A For azimuth thrusters used as steering means, the specification and drawings of the steering mechanism and,
where applicable, documents 2 to 6 and 8 to 11 above
(1) Constructional drawings are to be accompanied by the specification of the materials employed and, where applicable, by the
welding details and welding procedures.
(2) Submission of the drawings may be requested:
A = for approval; I = for information.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 211


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

1.3 Definitions 1.4 Symbols


1.3.1 Main steering gear 1.4.1 The following symbols are used for strength criteria of
Main steering gear is the machinery, rudder actuators, steer- steering gear components:
ing gear power units, if any, and ancillary equipment and V : Maximum service speed, in knots, with the ship
the means of applying torque to the rudder stock (e.g. tiller in full load displacement waterline. When the
or quadrant) necessary for effecting movement of the rudder speed is less than 10 knots, V is to be replaced
for the purpose of steering the ship under normal service by the value (V + 20) / 3
conditions.
ds : Rule diameter of the rudder stock in way of the
1.3.2 Steering gear power unit tiller, in mm, as defined in Pt B, Ch 8, Sec 1
Steering gear power unit is: dse : Actual diameter of the upper part of the rudder
in the case of electric steering gear, an electric motor stock in way of the tiller, in mm
and its associated electrical equipment (in the case of a tapered coupling, this diameter
in the case of electrohydraulic steering gear, an electric is measured at the base of the assembly)
motor and its associated electrical equipment and con- TR : Rule design torque of the rudder stock given, in
nected pump kN.m, by the following formula:
in the case of other hydraulic steering gear, a driving T R = 13 ,5 d s 10
3 6

engine and connected pump.


TE : For hand emergency operation, design torque
1.3.3 Auxiliary steering gear due to forces induced by the rudder, in kN.m,
Auxiliary steering gear is the equipment other than any part given by the following formula:
of the main steering gear necessary to steer the ship in the V E + 2 2
event of failure of the main steering gear but not including T E = 0 ,62 --------------- TR
V +2
the tiller, quadrant or components serving the same pur-
pose. where:
VE = 7,0 for V 14
1.3.4 Power actuating system
VE = 0,5 V for V > 14
Power actuating system is the hydraulic equipment pro-
vided for supplying power to turn the rudder stock, com- TG : For main hydraulic or electrohydraulic steering
prising a steering gear power unit or units, together with the gear, torque induced by the main steering gear
associated pipes and fittings, and a rudder actuator. The on the rudder stock when the pressure is equal
power actuating systems may share common mechanical to the setting pressure of the relief valves pro-
components, i.e. tiller, quadrant and rudder stock, or com- tecting the rudder actuators
ponents serving the same purpose. Note 1: for hand-operated main steering gear, the following value
is to be used:
1.3.5 Rudder actuator TG = 1,25 TR
Rudder actuator is the component which directly converts
TA : For auxiliary hydraulic or electrohydraulic steer-
hydraulic pressure into mechanical action to move the rud-
ing gears, torque induced by the auxiliary steer-
der.
ing gear on the rudder stock when the pressure
1.3.6 Steering gear control system is equal to the setting pressure of the relief
Steering gear control system is the equipment by which valves protecting the rudder actuators
orders are transmitted from the navigation bridge to the Note 2: For hand-operated auxiliary steering gear, the following
steering gear power units. Steering gear control systems value is to be used:
comprise transmitters, receivers, hydraulic control pumps TA = 1,25 TE
and their associated motors, motor controllers, piping and TG : For steering gear which can activate the rudder
cables. with a reduced number of actuators, the value
of TG in such conditions
1.3.7 Maximum ahead service speed
Maximum ahead service speed is the greatest speed which : Normal stress due to the bending moments and
the ship is designed to maintain in service at sea at the the tensile and compressive forces, in N/mm2
deepest seagoing draught. : Tangential stress due to the torsional moment
and the shear forces, in N/mm2
1.3.8 Maximum astern speed
a : Permissible stress, in N/mm2
Maximum astern speed is the speed which it is estimated
the ship can attain at the designed maximum astern power c : Combined stress, determined by the following
at the deepest seagoing draught. formula:
2 2
1.3.9 Maximum working pressure c = + 3
Maximum working pressure is the maximum expected pres- R : Value of the minimum specified tensile strength
sure in the system when the steering gear is operated to of the material at ambient temperature, in
comply with the provisions of [3.3.1], item b). N/mm2

212 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

Re : Value of the minimum specified yield strength 2.1.2 Materials and welds
of the material at ambient temperature, in
a) All steering gear components transmitting mechanical
N/mm2
forces to the rudder stock (such as tillers, quadrants, or
Re : Design yield strength, in N/mm2, determined by similar components) are to be of steel or other approved
the following formulae: ductile material complying with the requirements of
where R 1,4 R: Re = Ree NR216 Materials. In general, such material is to have an
where R < 1,4 Re: Re = 0,417 (Re + R) elongation of not less than 12% and a tensile strength
not greater than 650 N/mm 2.

2 Design and construction - b) The use of grey cast iron is not permitted, except for
Requirements applicable to all ships redundant parts with low stress level, subject to special
consideration by the Society. It is not permitted for cyl-
inders.
2.1 Mechanical components
c) The welding details and welding procedures are to be
2.1.1 General
submitted for approval.
a) All steering gear components and the rudder stock are
to be of sound and reliable construction to the satisfac- d) All welded joints within the pressure boundary of a rud-
tion of the Society. der actuator or connecting parts transmitting mechani-
cal loads are to be full penetration type or of equivalent
b) Any non-duplicated essential component is, where
strength.
appropriate, to utilise anti-friction bearings, such as ball
bearings, roller bearings or sleeve bearings, which are to
be permanently lubricated or provided with lubrication 2.1.3 Scantling of components
fittings. The scantling of steering gear components is to be deter-
c) The construction is to be such as to minimise local con- mined considering the design torque MT and the permissi-
centration of stress. ble value a of the combined stress, as given in:
d) All steering gear components transmitting mechanical Tab 2 for components which are protected against over-
forces to the rudder stock, which are not protected loads induced by the rudder
against overload by structural rudder stops or mechani-
cal buffers, are to have a strength at least equivalent to Tab 3 for components which are not protected against
that of the rudder stock in way of the tiller. overloads induced by the rudder.

Table 2 : Scantling of components protected against overloads induced by the rudder

Conditions of use of the components MT a


Normal operation TG if TG 1,25 TR : a = 1,25 0
if 1,25 TR < TG < 1,50 TR : a = 0 TG / T R

if TG 1,50 TR : a = 1,50 0
where 0 = 0,55 Re
Normal operation, with a reduced number of TG if TG 1,25 TR : a = 1,25 0
actuators if 1,25 TR < TG < 1,50 TR : a = 0 TG / TR
if TG 1,50 TR : a = 1,50 0
where 0 = 0,55 Re
Emergency operation achieved by hydraulic or lower of TR and 0,8 TA 0,69 Re
electrohydraulic steering gear
Emergency operation, with a reduced number lower of TR and 0,8 TG 0,69 Re
of actuators
Emergency operation achieved by hand TE 0,69 Re

Table 3 : Scantling of components not protected against overloads induced by the rudder

Conditions of use of the components MT a


Normal operation TR 0,55 Re
Normal operation, with a reduced number of actuators lower of TR and 0,8 TG 0,55 Re
Emergency operation achieved by hydraulic or electrohydraulic steering gear lower of TR and 0,8 TA 0,69 Re
Emergency operation, with a reduced number of actuators lower of TR and 0,8 TG 0,69 Re
Emergency operation achieved by hand TE 0,69 Re

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 213


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

2.1.4 Tillers, quadrants and rotors c) Keys are to satisfy the following provisions:

a) The scantling of the tiller is to be determined as follows: the key is to be made of steel with a yield stress not
less than that of the rudder stock and that of the tiller
the depth H0 of the boss is not to be less than ds boss or rotor without being less than 235 N/mm2
the radial thickness of the boss in way of the tiller is the width of the key is not to be less than 0,25 ds
not to be less than 0,4 ds
the thickness of the key is not to be less than 0,10 ds
the section modulus of the tiller arm in way of the
end fixed to the boss is not to be less than the value the ends of the keyways in the rudder stock and in
Zb, in cm3, calculated from the following formula: the tiller (or rotor) are to be rounded and the keyway
root fillets are to be provided with small radii of not
0 ,147 d L R less than 5 per cent of the key thickness.
Z b = ------------------------s ---- -----e
1000 L Re
d) Bolted tillers and quadrants are to satisfy the following
where: provisions:
L : Distance from the centreline of the rud- the diameter of the bolts is not to be less than the
der stock to the point of application of value db, in mm, calculated from the following for-
the load on the tiller (see Fig 1) mula:
L : Distance between the point of applica-
TR
tion of the above load and the root sec- - 235
d b = 153 --------------------------------- ----------
n ( b + 0 ,5d s e ) R e b
tion of the tiller arm under consideration
(see Fig 1)
where:
the width and thickness of the tiller arm in way of
n : Number of bolts located on the same
the point of application of the load are not to be less
side in respect of the stock axis (n is not
than one half of those required by the above formula
to be less than 2)
in the case of double arm tillers, the section modu-
b : Distance between bolts and stock axis,
lus of each arm is not to be less than one half of the
in mm (see Fig 2)
section modulus required by the above formula.
Reb : Yield stress, in N/mm2, of the bolt mate-
Figure 1 : Tiller arm rial

the thickness of the coupling flanges is not to be less


than the diameter of the bolts

in order to ensure the efficient tightening of the cou-


pling around the stock, the two parts of the tiller are
to bored together with a shim having a thickness not
L'

less than the value j, in mm, calculated from the fol-


L

lowing formula:

j = 0,0015 ds

Figure 2 : Bolted tillers

n bolts db
Ho
j

b) The scantling of the quadrants is to be determined as


d se
specified in a) for the tillers. When quadrants having
two or three arms are provided, the section modulus of
each arm is not to be less than one half or one third,
respectively, of the section modulus required for the
tiller.

Arms of loose quadrants not keyed to the rudder stock


may be of reduced dimensions to the satisfaction of the
Society, and the depth of the boss may be reduced by 10 b
per cent.

214 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

e) Shrink-fit connections of tiller (or rotor) to stock are to 1,25 times the maximum working pressure to be
satisfy the following provisions: expected under the operational conditions specified in
the safety factor against slippage is not to be less [3] and [4], taking into account any pressure which may
than: exist in the low pressure side of the system.

- 1,0 for keyed connections At the discretion of the Society, high cycle and cumula-
tive fatigue analysis may be required for the design of
- 2,0 for keyless connections piping and components, taking into account pulsating
the friction coefficient is to be taken equal to: pressures due to dynamic loads.
- 0,15 for steel and 0,13 for spheroidal graphite b) The power piping for hydraulic steering gear is to be
cast iron, in the case of hydraulic fit arranged so that transfer between units can be readily
- 0,17 in the case of dry shrink fitting effected.
the combined stress according to the von Mises cri- c) Arrangements for bleeding air from the hydraulic system
terion, due to the maximum pressure induced by the are to be provided, where necessary.
shrink fitting and calculated in way of the most
The hydraulic piping system, including joints, valves,
stressed points of the shrunk parts, is not to exceed
flanges and other fittings, is to comply with the require-
80% of the yield stress of the material considered
ments of Ch 1, Sec 10 for class I piping systems, and in par-
Note 1: Alternative stress values based on FEM calculations may ticular with the requirements of Ch 1, Sec 10, [13], unless
also be considered by the Society.
otherwise stated.
the entrance edge of the tiller bore and that of the
rudder stock cone are to be rounded or bevelled. 2.2.2 Materials
2.1.5 Piston rods a) Ram cylinders, pressure housings of rotary vane type
The scantling of the piston rod is to be determined taking actuators, hydraulic power piping, valves, flanges and fit-
into account the bending moments, if any, in addition to tings are to be of steel or other approved ductile material.
compressive or traction forces and is to satisfy the following b) In general, such material is to have an elongation of not
provisions: less than 12% and a tensile strength not greater than
a) c a 650 N/mm2.
where: Grey cast iron may be accepted for valve bodies and
redundant parts with low stress level, excluding cylin-
c : Combined stress as per [1.4.1]
ders, subject to special consideration.
a : Permissible stress as per [2.1.3]
b) in respect of the buckling strength: 2.2.3 Isolating valves
Shut-off valves, non-return valves or other appropriate
4 8M
------------2 F c + --------- 0 ,9 a devices are to be provided:
D 2 D2
to comply with the availability requirements of [3.5] or
where: [4.1.2]
D2 : Piston rod diameter, in mm
to keep the rudder steady in position in case of emer-
Fc : Compression force in the rod, in N, when it gency.
extends to its maximum stroke
In particular, for all ships with non-duplicated actuators,
M : Possible bending moment in the piston rod,
isolating valves are to be fitted at the connection of pipes to
in N.mm, in way of the fore end of the cylin-
the actuator, and are to be directly fitted on the actuator.
der rod bearing
= + (2 )0,5 2.2.4 Flexible hoses
with: a) Flexible hoses may be installed between two points
= 0,0072 (ls / ds) Re / 235 2 where flexibility is required but are not to be subjected
to torsional deflexion (twisting) under normal operation.
= 0,48 + 0,5 + 0,1 0,5 In general, the hose is to be limited to the length neces-
ls : Length, in mm, of the maximum unsup- sary to provide for flexibility and for proper operation of
ported reach of the cylinder rod. machinery.
b) Hoses are to be high pressure hydraulic hoses according
2.2 Hydraulic system to recognised standards and suitable for the fluids, pres-
sures, temperatures and ambient conditions in question.
2.2.1 General
c) They are to be of a type approved by the Society.
a) The design pressure for calculations to determine the
scantlings of piping and other steering gear components d) The burst pressure of hoses is to be not less than four
subjected to internal hydraulic pressure shall be at least times the design pressure.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 215


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

2.2.5 Relief valves 2.2.10 Rudder actuators


a) Relief valves shall be fitted to any part of the hydraulic a) Rudder actuators, other than non-duplicated rudder
system which can be isolated and in which pressure can actuators fitted to tankers, chemical carriers and gas car-
be generated from the power source or from external riers of 10000 gross tonnage and above, are to be
forces. The setting of the relief valves shall not exceed designed in accordance with the relevant requirements
the design pressure. The valves shall be of adequate size of Ch 1, Sec 3 for class I pressure vessels also consider-
and so arranged as to avoid an undue rise in pressure ing the following provisions.
above the design pressure. b) The permissible primary general membrane stress is not
to exceed the lower of the following values:
b) The setting pressure of the relief valves is not to be less
than 1,25 times the maximum working pressure. R Re
---- or -----
A B
c) The minimum discharge capacity of the relief valve(s) is
where A and B are given in Tab 4.
not to be less than the total capacity of the pumps which
can deliver through it (them), increased by 10%. Under c) Oil seals between non-moving parts, forming part of the
such conditions, the rise in pressure is not to exceed external pressure boundary, are to be of the metal upon
10% of the setting pressure. In this respect, due consid- metal or equivalent type.
eration is to be given to the foreseen extreme ambient d) Oil seals between moving parts, forming part of the
conditions in relation to oil viscosity. external pressure boundary, are to be duplicated, so that
the failure of one seal does not render the actuator inop-
2.2.6 Hydraulic oil reservoirs erative. Alternative arrangements providing equivalent
Hydraulic power-operated steering gear shall be provided protection against leakage may be accepted.
with the following: e) The strength and connection of the cylinder heads (or, in
the case of actuators of the rotary type, the fixed vanes)
a low level alarm for each hydraulic fluid reservoir to
acting as rudder stops are to comply with the provisions
give the earliest practicable indication of hydraulic fluid
of [6.3.1].
leakage. Audible and visual alarms shall be given on the
navigation bridge and in the machinery space where Table 4 : Value of coefficients A and B
they can be readily observed.
a fixed storage tank having sufficient capacity to Nodular cast
Coefficient Steel Cast steel
iron
recharge at least one power actuating system including
the reservoir, where the main steering gear is required to A 3,5 4 5
be power operated. The storage tank shall be perma- B 1,7 2 3
nently connected by piping in such a manner that the
hydraulic systems can be readily recharged from a posi-
2.3 Electrical systems
tion within the steering gear compartment and shall be
provided with a contents gauge. 2.3.1 General design
The electrical systems of the main steering gear and the
Note 1: For ships of less than 500 tons displacement, the storage
means may consist of a readily accessible drum, of sufficient auxiliary steering gear are to be so arranged that the failure
capacity to refill one power actuating system if necessary. of one will not render the other inoperative.

2.3.2 Power circuit supply


2.2.7 Hydraulic pumps
a) Electric or electrohydraulic steering gear comprising
a) Hydraulic pumps are to be type tested in accordance one or more power units is to be served by at least two
with the provisions of [7.1.1]. exclusive circuits fed directly from the main switch-
b) Special care is to be given to the alignment of the pump board; however, one of the circuits may be supplied
and the driving motor. through the emergency switchboard.
b) Auxiliary electric or electrohydraulic steering gear, asso-
2.2.8 Filters ciated with main electric or electrohydraulic steering
gear, may be connected to one of the circuits supplying
a) Hydraulic power-operated steering gear shall be pro-
the main steering gear.
vided with arrangements to maintain the cleanliness of
the hydraulic fluid taking into consideration the type c) The circuits supplying electric or electrohydraulic steer-
and design of the hydraulic system. ing gear are to have adequate rating for supplying all
motors which can be simultaneously connected to them
b) Filters of appropriate mesh fineness are to be provided and may be required to operate simultaneously.
in the piping system, in particular to ensure the protec-
d) When, in a ship of less than 1600 tons gross tonnage,
tion of the pumps.
auxiliary steering gear which is required by [3.3.2], item
c) to be operated by power is not electrically powered
2.2.9 Accumulators
or is powered by an electric motor primarily intended
Accumulators, if fitted, are to be designed in accordance for other services, the main steering gear may be fed by
with Ch 1, Sec 10, [13.5.3]. one circuit from the main switchboard.

216 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

e) Where the rudder stock is required to be over 230 milli- 2.3.5 Circuit protection
metres in diameter in way of the tiller, excluding
a) Short-circuit protection is to be provided for each con-
strengthening for navigation in ice, an alternative power
trol circuit and each power circuit of electric or electro-
supply either from the emergency source of electrical
hydraulic main and auxiliary steering gear.
power or from an independent source of power located
in the steering gear compartment is to be provided, suf- b) No protection other than short-circuit protection is to be
ficient at least to supply the steering gear power unit provided for steering gear control system supply cir-
such that the latter is able to perform the duties of auxil- cuits.
iary steering gear.
This power source is to be activated automatically, c) Protection against excess current (e.g. by thermal
within 45 seconds, in the event of failure of the main relays), including starting current, if provided for power
source(s) of electrical power. circuits, is to be for not less than twice the full load cur-
rent of the motor or circuit so protected, and is to be
The independent source is to be used only for this pur- arranged to permit the passage of the appropriate start-
pose. ing currents.
The alternative power source is also to supply the steer-
ing gear control system, the remote control of the power d) Where fuses are fitted, their current ratings are to be two
unit and the rudder angle indicator. step higher than the rated current of the motors. How-
ever, in the case of intermittent service motors, the fuse
f) In every ship of 10 000 tons gross tonnage and upwards, rating is not to exceed 160% of the rated motor current.
the alternative power supply is to have a capacity for at
least 30 minutes of continuous operation and in any e) The instantaneous short-circuit trip of circuit breakers is
other ship for at least 10 minutes. to be set to a value not greater than 15 times the rated
current of the drive motor.
2.3.3 Motors and associated control gear
a) To determine the required characteristics of the electric f) The protection of control circuits is to correspond to at
motors for power units, the breakaway torque and maxi- least twice the maximum rated current of the circuit,
mum working torque of the steering gear under all oper- though not, if possible, below 6 A.
ating conditions are to be considered. The ratio of pull-
out torque to rated torque is to be at least 1,6. 2.3.6 Starting and stopping of motors for steering
gear power units
b) Motors for steering gear power units may be rated for
intermittent power demand. a) Motors for power units are to be capable of being
The rating is to be determined on the basis of the steer- started and stopped from a position on the navigation
ing gear characteristics of the ship in question; the rating bridge and from a point within the steering gear com-
is always to be at least: partment.

S3 - 40% for motors of electric steering gear power b) Means are to be provided at the position of motor start-
units ers for isolating any remote control starting and stopping
S6 - 25% for motors of electrohydraulic steering gear devices (e.g. by removal of the fuse-links or switching
power units and for convertors. off the automatic circuit breakers).

c) Each electric motor of a main or auxiliary steering gear c) Main and auxiliary steering gear power units are to be
power unit is to be provided with its own separate arranged to restart automatically when power is restored
motor starter gear, located within the steering gear com- after a power failure.
partment.
2.3.7 Separation
2.3.4 Supply of motor control circuits and steering
gear control systems a) Duplicated electric power circuits are to be separated as
a) Each control for starting and stopping of motors for far as practicable.
power units is to be served by its own control circuits b) Cables for duplicated electric power circuits with their
supplied from its respective power circuits. associated components are to be separated as far as
b) Any electrical main and auxiliary steering gear control practicable. They are to follow different routes separated
system operable from the navigating bridge is to be both vertically and horizontally, as far as practicable,
served by its own separate circuit supplied from a steer- throughout their entire length.
ing gear power circuit from a point within the steering
gear compartment, or directly from switchboard busbars c) Duplicated steering gear control systems with their asso-
supplying that steering gear power circuit at a point on ciated components are to be separated as far as practi-
the switchboard adjacent to the supply to the steering cable.
gear power circuit. The power supply systems are to be d) Cables for duplicated steering gear control systems with
protected selectively. their associated components are to be separated as far
c) The remote control of the power unit and the steering as practicable. They are to follow different routes sepa-
gear control systems is to be supplied also by the alter- rated both vertically and horizontally, as far as practica-
native power source when required by [2.3.2], item e). ble, throughout their entire length.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 217


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

e) Wires, terminals and the components for duplicated c) Where a three-phase supply is used, an alarm shall be
steering gear control systems installed in units, control provided that will indicate failure of any one of the sup-
boxes, switchboards or bridge consoles are to be sepa- ply phases.
rated as far as practicable.
d) An overload alarm shall be provided for each motor of
Where physical separation is not practicable, separation electric or electrohydraulic steering gear power units.
may be achieved by means of a fire-retardant plate.
e) The alarms required in c) and d) shall be both audible
f) All electrical components of the steering gear control and visual and situated in a conspicuous position in the
systems are to be duplicated. This does not require main machinery space or control room from which the
duplication of the steering wheel or steering lever. main machinery is normally controlled.
g) If a joint steering mode selector switch (uniaxial switch) 2.4.2 Hydraulic system
is employed for both steering gear control systems, the
connections for the control systems are to be divided a) Hydraulic oil reservoirs are to be provided with the
accordingly and separated from each other by an isolat- alarms required in [2.2.6].
ing plate or air gap. b) Where hydraulic locking, caused by a single failure,
h) In the case of double follow-up control, the amplifier is may lead to loss of steering, an audible and visual
to be designed and fed so as to be electrically and alarm, which identifies the failed system, is to be pro-
mechanically separated. In the case of non-follow-up vided on the navigating bridge.
control and follow-up control, it is to be ensured that Note 1: This alarm is to be activated when, for example:
the follow-up amplifier is protected selectively. the position of the variable displacement pump control system
i) Control circuits for additional control systems, e.g. does not correspond with the given order, or
steering lever or autopilot, are to be designed for all- an incorrect position in the 3-way valve, or similar, in the con-
pole disconnection. stant delivery pump system is detected.

j) The feedback units and limit switches, if any, for the 2.4.3 Control system
steering gear control systems are to be separated electri-
In the event of a failure of electrical power supply to the
cally and mechanically connected to the rudder stock or
steering gear control systems, an audible an visual alarm
actuator separately.
shall be given on the navigating bridge.
k) Actuators controlling the power systems of the steering
gear, e.g. magnetic valves, are to be duplicated and sep- 2.4.4 Rudder angle indication
arated. The angular position of the rudder is to be:
a) indicated on the navigating bridge, if the main steering
2.4 Alarms and indications gear is power operated. The rudder angle indication is
to be independent of the steering gear control system
2.4.1 Power units and be supplied through the emergency switchboard, or
a) In the event of a power failure to any one of the steering by an alternative and independent source of electrical
gear power units, an audible and visual alarm shall be power such as that referred to in [2.3.2], item e)
given on the navigating bridge. b) recognisable in the steering gear compartment.
b) Means for indicating that the motors of electric and
electrohydraulic steering gear are running shall be 2.4.5 Summary table
installed on the navigating bridge and at a suitable main Displays and alarms are to be provided in the locations
machinery control position. indicated in Tab 5.

Table 5 : Location of displays and alarms

Alarms Location
Item Display (audible Navigation Engine Steering gear
and visible) bridge control room compartment
Power failure of each power unit X X X
Indication that electric motor of each power unit is running X X X
Overload of electric motor of each power unit X X X
Phase failure of electric motor of each power unit X X X
Low level of each hydraulic fluid reservoir X X X
Power failure of each control system X X X
Hydraulic lock X X
Rudder angle indicator X X X

218 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

3 Design and construction - b) where the main steering gear is arranged in accordance
with [3.5.2], by two independent control systems, both
Requirements for ships equipped operable from the navigation bridge and the steering
with a single rudder gear compartment. This does not require duplication of
the steering wheel or steering lever. Where the control
3.1 Application system consists in a hydraulic telemotor, a second inde-
pendent system need not be fitted
3.1.1 The provisions of this Article apply in addition to
those of Article [2]. c) for the auxiliary steering gear, in the steering gear com-
partment and, if power operated, it shall also be opera-
ble from the navigation bridge and to be independent of
3.2 General
the control system for the main steering gear.
3.2.1 Unless expressly provided otherwise, every ship shall
be provided with main steering gear and auxiliary steering 3.4.2 Control systems operable from the navigating
bridge
gear to the satisfaction of the Society.
Any main and auxiliary steering gear control system opera-
3.3 Strength, performance and power ble from the navigating bridge shall comply with the follow-
ing:
operation of the steering gear
if electrical, it shall be served by its own separate circuit
3.3.1 Main steering gear supplied from a steering gear power circuit from a point
The main steering gear and rudder stock shall be: within the steering gear compartment, or directly from
a) of adequate strength and capable of steering the ship at switchboard busbars supplying that steering gear power
maximum ahead service speed which shall be demon- circuit at a point on the switchboard adjacent to the
strated supply to the steering gear power circuit
b) capable of putting the rudder over from 35 on one side means shall be provided in the steering gear compart-
to 35 on the other side with the ship at its deepest sea- ment for disconnecting any control system operable
going draught and running ahead at maximum ahead from the navigation bridge from the steering gear it
service speed and, under the same conditions, from 35 serves
on either side to 30 on the other side in not more than the system shall be capable of being brought into opera-
28 s tion from a position on the navigating bridge
c) operated by power where necessary to meet the require-
in the event of failure of electrical power supply to the
ments of b) and in any case when the Society requires a
control system, an audible and visual alarm shall be
rudder stock of over 120 mm diameter in way of the
given on the navigation bridge, and
tiller, excluding strengthening for navigation in ice, and
d) so designed that they will not be damaged at maximum short-circuit protection only shall be provided for steer-
astern speed; however, this design requirement need not ing gear control supply circuits.
be proved by trials at maximum astern speed and maxi-
mum rudder angle. 3.5 Availability
3.3.2 Auxiliary steering gear 3.5.1 Arrangement of main and auxiliary steering
The auxiliary steering gear and rudder stock shall be: gear
a) of adequate strength and capable of steering the ship at The main steering gear and the auxiliary steering gear shall
navigable speed and of being brought speedily into be so arranged that the failure of one will not render the
action in an emergency other inoperative.
b) capable of putting the rudder over from 15 on one side
to 15 on the other side in not more than 60s with the 3.5.2 Omission of the auxiliary steering gear
ship at its deepest seagoing draught and running ahead Where the main steering gear comprises two or more iden-
at one half of the maximum ahead service speed or 7 tical power units, auxiliary steering gear need not be fitted,
knots, whichever is the greater, and provided that:
c) operated by power where necessary to meet the require-
a) the main steering gear is capable of operating the rudder
ments of b) and in any case when the Society requires a
as required in [3.3.1] while any one of the power units
rudder stock of over 230 mm diameter in way of the
is out of operation
tiller, excluding strengthening for navigation in ice.
b) the main steering gear is so arranged that after a single
3.4 Control of the steering gear failure in its piping system or in one of the power units,
the defect can be isolated so that steering capability can
3.4.1 Main and auxiliary steering gear control be maintained or speedily regained.
Steering gear control shall be provided: Steering gear other than of the hydraulic type is to achieve
a) for the main steering gear, both on the navigation bridge standards equivalent to the requirements of this paragraph
and in the steering gear compartment to the satisfaction of the Society.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 219


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

3.5.3 Hydraulic power supply 4.2.2 Non-mechanical synchronisation


The hydraulic system intended for main and auxiliary steer- Where the synchronisation of the rudder motion is not
ing gear is to be independent of all other hydraulic systems achieved by a mechanical coupling, the following provi-
of the ship. sions are to be met:
a) the angular position of each rudder is to be indicated on
3.5.4 Non-duplicated components the navigation bridge,
Special consideration is to be given to the suitability of any b) the rudder angle indicators are to be independent from
essential component which is not duplicated. each other and, in particular, from the synchronising
system,
3.5.5 Hydraulic locking c) in case of failure of the synchronising system, means are
Where the steering gear is so arranged that more than one to be provided for disconnecting this system so that
system (either power or control) can be simultaneously steering capability can be maintained or rapidly
operated, the risk of hydraulic locking caused by single fail- regained.
ure is to be considered.
5 Design and construction -
4 Design and construction - Requirements for ships equipped
Requirements for ships equipped with thrusters as steering means
with several rudders
5.1 Principle

4.1 Principle 5.1.1 General


The main and auxiliary steering gear referred to in Articles
4.1.1 General [3] and [4] may consist of thrusters of the following types:
In addition to the provisions of Articles [2] and [3], as appli- azimuth thrusters
cable, ships equipped with two or more aft rudders are to water-jets
comply with the provisions of this Article.
cycloidal propellers,
4.1.2 Availability complying with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 12, as far as
applicable.
Where the ship is fitted with two or more rudders, each hav-
ing its own actuation system, the latter need not be dupli-
5.1.2 Actuation system
cated.
Thrusters used as steering means are to be fitted with a main
actuation system and an auxiliary actuation system.
4.1.3 Equivalent rudder stock diameter
Where the rudders are served by a common actuating sys- 5.1.3 Control system
tem, the diameter of the rudder stock referred to in [3.3.1], Where the steering means of the ship consists of two or
item c) is to be replaced by the equivalent diameter d more thrusters, their control system is to include a device
obtained from the following formula: ensuring an automatic synchronisation of the thruster rota-
tion, unless each thruster is so designed as to withstand any
d = 3 d
j
j
3 additional forces resulting from the thrust exerted by the
other thrusters.

with: 5.2 Use of azimuth thrusters


dj : Rule diameter of the upper part of the rudder
5.2.1 Azimuth thrusters used as sole steering
stock of each rudder in way of the tiller, exclud-
means
ing strengthening for navigation in ice.
Where the ship is fitted with one azimuth thruster used as
the sole steering means, this thruster is to comply with
4.2 Synchronisation [3.3.1], as applicable, except that:
a) the main actuation system is required to be capable of a
4.2.1 General rotational speed of at least 0,4 RPM and to be operated
A system for synchronising the movement of the rudders is by power where the expected steering torque exceeds
to be fitted, either: 1,5 kNm

by a mechanical coupling, or b) the auxiliary actuation system is required to be capable


of a rotational speed of at least 0,1 RPM and to be oper-
by other systems giving automatic synchronising adjust- ated by power where the expected steering torque
ment. exceeds 3 kNm.

220 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

5.2.2 Azimuth thrusters used as auxiliary steering 6.3 Overload protections


gear
Where the auxiliary steering gear referred to in [3.2.1] con- 6.3.1 Mechanical rudder stops
sists of one or more azimuth thrusters, at least one such a) The steering gear is to be provided with strong rudder
thruster is to capable of: stops capable of mechanically stopping the rotation of
the rudder at an angle slightly greater than its maximum
steering the ship at maximum ahead service speed
working angle. Alternatively, these stops may be fitted
being brought speedily into action in case of emergency on the ship to act on another point of the mechanical
transmission system between the rudder actuator and
a rotational speed of at least 0,4 RPM.
the rudder blade.
The auxiliary actuation system referred to in [5.1.2] need b) The scantlings of the rudder stops and of the compo-
not be fitted. nents transmitting to the ships structure the forces
applied on these stops are to be determined for the
5.2.3 Omission of the auxiliary actuation system greater value of the torques TR or TG.
Where the steering means of the ship consists of two inde- Where TG 1,5TR , the rudder stops are to be fitted
pendent azimuth thrusters or more, the auxiliary actuation between the rudder actuator and the rudder stock,
system referred to in [5.1.2] need not be fitted provided unless the rudder stock as well as all the components
that: transmitting mechanical forces between the rudder
actuator and the rudder blade are suitably strengthened.
the thrusters are so designed that the ship can be steered
with any one out of operation 6.3.2 Rudder angle limiters
the actuation system of each thruster complies with a) Power-operated steering gear is to be provided with pos-
[5.2.1], item b). itive arrangements, such as limit switches, for stopping
the gear before the rudder stops are reached. These
5.3 Use of water-jets arrangements are to be synchronised with the gear itself
and not with the steering gear control.
5.3.1 The use of water-jets as steering means will be given b) Special consideration will be given to power-operated
special consideration by the Society. steering gear where the rudder may be oriented to more
than 35.

6 Arrangement and installation 6.3.3 Relief valves


Relief valves are to be fitted in accordance with [2.2.5].
6.1 Steering gear room arrangement
6.3.4 Buffers
6.1.1 The steering gear compartment shall be: Buffers are to be provided on all ships fitted with mechani-
cal steering gear. They may be omitted on hydraulic gear
a) readily accessible and, as far as practicable, separated equipped with relief valves or with calibrated bypasses.
from machinery spaces, and
b) provided with suitable arrangements to ensure working 6.4 Means of communication
access to steering gear machinery and controls. These
arrangements shall include handrails and gratings or 6.4.1 A means of communication is to be provided
other non-slip surfaces to ensure suitable working con- between the navigation bridge and the steering gear com-
ditions in the event of hydraulic fluid leakage. partment.
If electrical, it is to be fed through the emergency switch-
board or to be sound powered.
6.2 Rudder actuator installation

6.2.1 6.5 Operating instructions

a) Rudder actuators are to be installed on foundations of 6.5.1 For steering gear comprising two identical power
strong construction so designed as to allow the transmis- units intended for simultaneous operation, both normally
sion to the ship structure of the forces resulting from the provided with their own (partly or mutually) separate con-
torque applied by the rudder and/or by the actuator, trol systems, the following standard notice is either to be
considering the strength criteria defined in [2.1.3] and placed on a signboard fitted at a suitable place on the steer-
[6.3.1]. The structure of the ship in way of the founda- ing control post on the bridge or incorporated into the oper-
tions is to be suitably strengthened. ation manual:

b) Where the rudder actuators are bolted to the hull, the CAUTION
grade of the bolts used is not to be less than 8.8. Unless IN SOME CIRCUMSTANCES WHEN 2 POWER UNITS ARE
the bolts are adjusted and fitted with a controlled tight- RUNNING SIMULTANEOUSLY, THE RUDDER MAY NOT
ening, strong shocks are to be fitted in order to prevent RESPOND TO THE HELM. IF THIS HAPPENS STOP EACH
any lateral displacement of the rudder actuator. PUMP IN TURN UNTIL CONTROL IS REGAINED.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 221


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 11

7 Certification, inspection and testing 7.2.2 Hydraulic piping, valves and accessories
Tests for materials of hydraulic piping, valves and accesso-
7.1 Type tests of hydraulic pumps ries are to comply with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 10,
[19.3].
7.1.1 Each type of power unit pump is to be subjected in
the workshop to a type test of not less than 100 hours dura-
tion.
7.3 Inspection and tests during
manufacturing
The test arrangements are to be such that the pump may run
both:
7.3.1 Components subject to pressure or
in idling conditions, and transmitting mechanical forces
at maximum delivery capacity at maximum working
a) The mechanical components referred to in [7.2.1] are to
pressure.
be subjected to appropriate non-destructive tests. For
During the test, idling periods are to be alternated with peri- hydraulic cylinder shells, pump casings and accumula-
ods at maximum delivery capacity at maximum working tors, refer to Ch 1, Sec 3.
pressure. The passage from one condition to another is to
b) Defects may be repaired by welding only on forged
occur at least as quickly as on board.
parts or steel castings of weldable quality. Such repairs
During the test, no abnormal heating, excessive vibration or are to be conducted under the supervision of the Sur-
other irregularities are permitted. veyor in accordance with the applicable requirements
After the test, the pump is to be disassembled and of NR216 Materials.
inspected.
Note 1: Type tests may be waived for a power unit which has been 7.3.2 Hydraulic piping, valves and accessories
proven to be reliable in marine service. Hydraulic piping, valves and accessories are to be
inspected and tested during manufacturing in accordance
7.2 Testing of materials with Ch 1, Sec 10, [19], for a class I piping system.

7.2.1 Components subject to pressure or


transmitting mechanical forces 7.4 Inspection and tests after completion
a) Materials of components subject to pressure or transmit-
ting mechanical forces, specifically: 7.4.1 Hydrostatic tests
cylindrical shells of hydraulic cylinders, rams and a) Hydraulic cylinder shells and accumulators are to be
piston rods subjected to hydrostatic tests according to the relevant
tillers, quadrants provisions of Ch 1, Sec 3.
rotors and rotor housings for rotary vane steering b) Hydraulic piping, valves and accessories and hydraulic
gear pumps are to be subjected to hydrostatic tests according
hydraulic pump casings to the relevant provisions of Ch 1, Sec 10, [19.4].
and hydraulic accumulators, if any,
7.4.2 Shipboard tests
are to be duly tested, including examination for internal
defects, in accordance with the requirements of NR216 After installation on board the ship, the steering gear is to be
Materials. subjected to the tests detailed in Ch 1, Sec 15, [3.9].
b) A works certificate may be accepted for low stressed
parts, provided that all characteristics for which verifica- 7.4.3 Sea trials
tion is required are guaranteed by such certificate. For the requirements of sea trials, refer to Ch 1, Sec 15.

222 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 12

SECTION 12 THRUSTERS

1 General 1.2.2 Transverse thruster


A transverse thruster is an athwartship thruster developing a
1.1 Application thrust in a transverse direction for manoeuvring purposes.

1.2.3 Azimuth thruster


1.1.1 The requirements of this Section apply to the follow-
ing types of thrusters: An azimuth thruster is a thruster which has the capability to
rotate through 360 in order to develop thrust in any direc-
transverse thrusters intended for manoeuvring develop-
tion.
ing power equal to 500 kW or more
thrusters intended for propulsion, steering and dynamic 1.2.4 Water-jet
positioning developing power equal to 220 kW or A water-jet is equipment constituted by a tubular casing (or
more; for power less than 220 kW the requirements duct) enclosing an impeller. The shape of the casing is such
apply only to the propeller and relevant shaft. as to enable the impeller to produce a water-jet of such
intensity as to give a positive thrust. Water-jets may have
1.1.2 Thrusters developing power less than that indicated means for deviating the jet of water in order to provide a
in [1.1.1] are to be built in accordance with sound marine
steering function.
practice and tested as required in [3.2] to the satisfaction of
the Surveyor. 1.2.5 Continuous duty thruster
A continuous duty thruster is a thruster which is designed
1.2 Definitions for continuous operation, such as a propulsion thruster.

1.2.1 Thruster 1.2.6 Intermittent duty thruster


A thruster is a propeller installed in a revolving nozzle or in An intermittent duty thruster is a thruster designed for opera-
a special transverse tunnel in the ship, or a water-jet. A tion at full power for a period not exceeding 1 hour, fol-
thruster may be intended for propulsion, manoeuvring and lowed by operation at reduced rating for a limited period of
steering or any combination thereof. Propulsion propellers in time not exceeding a certain percentage of the hours in a day
fixed nozzles are not considered thrusters (see Ch 1, Sec 8, and a certain (lesser) percentage of the hours in a year. In
[1.1.1]). general, athwartship thrusters are intermittent duty thrusters.

Table 1 : Plans to be submitted for athwartship thrusters and azimuth thrusters

No A/I (1) ITEM


General requirements for all thrusters
1 I General arrangement of the thruster
2 A Propeller, including the applicable details mentioned in Ch 1, Sec 8
3 A Bearing details
4 A Propeller and intermediate shafts
5 A Gears, including the calculations according to Ch 1, Sec 6 for cylindrical gears or standards recog-
nised by the Society for bevel gears
Specific requirements for transverse thrusters
6 A Structure of the tunnel showing the materials and their thickness
7 A Structural equipment or other connecting devices which transmit the thrust from the propeller to
the tunnel
8 A Sealing devices (propeller shaft gland and thruster-tunnel connection)
9 A For the adjustable pitch propellers: pitch control device and corresponding monitoring system
Specific requirements for rotating and azimuth thrusters
10 A Structural items (nozzle, bracing, etc.)
11 A Structural connection to hull
12 A Rotating mechanism of the thruster
13 A Thruster control system
14 A Piping systems connected to thruster
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 223


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 12

Table 2 : Plans to be submitted for water-jets

No A/I (1) ITEM


1 I General arrangement of the water-jet
2 A Casing (duct) (location and shape) showing the materials and the thicknesses as well as the forces acting on
the hull
3 A Details of the shafts, flanges, keys
4 I Sealing gland
5 A Bearings
6 A Impeller
7 A Steering and reversing buckets and their control devices as well as the corresponding hydraulic diagrams
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.

Table 3 : Data and documents to be submitted for athwartship thrusters, azimuth thrusters and water-jets

No A/I (1) ITEM


1 I Rated power and revolutions
2 I Rated thrust
3 A Material specifications of the major parts, including their physical, chemical and mechanical properties
4 A Where parts of thrusters are of welded construction, all particulars on the design of welded joints, welding
procedures, heat treatments and non-destructive examinations after welding
5 I Where applicable, background information on previous operating experience in similar applications
(1) A = to be submitted for approval in four copies
I = to be submitted for information in duplicate.

1.3 Thrusters intended for propulsion 2 Design and construction


1.3.1 In general, at least two azimuth thrusters are to be fit-
ted in ships where these are the sole means of propulsion.
2.1 Materials
Single azimuth thruster installations will be specially con-
sidered by the Society on a case by case basis. 2.1.1 Propellers
For requirements relative to material intended for propel-
Single water-jet installations are permitted.
lers, see Ch 1, Sec 8.

1.4 Documentation to be submitted 2.1.2 Other thruster components


For the requirements relative to materials intended for other
1.4.1 Plans to be submitted for athwartship parts of the thrusters, such as gears, shaft, couplings, etc.,
thrusters and azimuth thrusters
refer to the applicable Parts of the Rules.
For thrusters:
intended for propulsion, steering and dynamic position- 2.2 Transverse thrusters and azimuth
ing thrusters
intended for manoeuvring developing power equal to
500 kW or more, 2.2.1 Prime movers
a) Diesel engines intended for driving thrusters are to com-
the plans listed in Tab 1 are to be submitted. Plans as per ply with the applicable requirements of Ch 1, Sec 2.
item 6 of Tab 1 are also to be submitted for thrusters devel-
oping power less than 500 kW. b) Electric motors intended for driving thrusters and their
feeding systems are to comply with the requirements of
1.4.2 Plans to be submitted for water-jets Part C, Chapter 2. In particular:
The plans listed in Tab 2 are to be submitted. Provisions are to be made to prevent starting of the
motors whenever there are insufficient generators in
1.4.3 Additional data to be submitted operation.
The data and documents listed in Tab 3 are to be submitted Intermittent duty thrusters will be the subject of spe-
by the manufacturer together with the plans. cial consideration by the Society.

224 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 12

2.2.2 Propellers 40 000 hours for continuous duty thrusters. For ships
with restricted service, a lesser value may be considered
a) For propellers of thrusters intended for propulsion, steer-
by the Society.
ing and dynamic positioning, the requirements of Ch 1,
Sec 8 apply. 5 000 hours for intermittent duty thrusters.

b) For propellers of thrusters intended for manoeuvring 2.2.8 Electrical supply for steerable thrusters
only, the requirements of Ch 1, Sec 8 also apply,
although the increase in thickness of 10% required in The generating and distribution system is to be designed in
Ch 1, Sec 8, [2.5] does not need to be applied. such a way that the steering capability of the thruster can be
maintained or regained within a period of 45 seconds, in
2.2.3 Shafts the event of single failure of the system, and that the effec-
tiveness of the steering capability is not reduced by more
a) For propeller shafts of thrusters, the requirements of Ch than 50% under such conditions. Details of the means pro-
1, Sec 7 apply to the portion of propellershaft between vided for this purpose are to be submitted to the Society.
the inner edge of the aftermost shaft bearing and the
inner face of the propeller boss or the face of the inte-
gral propeller shaft flange for the connection to the pro- 2.3 Water-jets
peller boss.
2.3.1 Shafts
b) For other shafts of thrusters, the requirement of Ch 1,
The diameter of the shaft supporting the impeller is not to
Sec 6, [4.4.2] apply.
be less than the diameter d2, in mm, obtained by the follow-
ing formula:
2.2.4 Gears
13
a) Gears of thrusters intended for propulsion steering and P 1/3 1
d 2 = 100 fh ---- ----------------4
N 1 Q
dynamic positioning are to be in accordance with the
applicable requirements of Ch 1, Sec 6 for cylindrical
where:
gears or standards recognised by the Society for bevel
gears, applying the safety factors for propulsion gears. P : Power, in kW

b) Gears of thrusters intended for manoeuvring only are to N : Rotational speed, in rpm
be in accordance with the applicable requirements of f : Calculated as follows:
Ch 1, Sec 6, for cylindrical gears or Standards recogn-
ised by the Society for bevel gears, applying the safety 560
----------------------
1/3
f = -
factors for auxiliary gears. R m + 160

2.2.5 Nozzles and connections to hull for azimuth where Rm is the ultimate tensile strength of the
thrusters shaft material, in N/mm2
a) For the requirements relative to the nozzle structure, see h : h = 1,0 when the shaft is only transmitting
Part B, Chapter 9. torque loads, and when the weight and thrust of
the propeller are totally supported by devices
b) The scantlings of the nozzle connection to the hull and located in the fixed part of the thruster
the welding type and size will be specially considered
by the Society, which reserves the right to require h = 1,2 where the impeller is fitted with key or
detailed stress analysis in the case of certain high power shrink-fitted.
installations. Q : Q = 0 in the case of solid shafts
c) For steerable thrusters, the equivalent rudder stock Q = the ratio between the diameter of the hole
diameter is to be calculated in accordance with the and the external diameter of the shaft, in the
requirements of Part B, Chapter 9. case of hollow shafts. If Q 0,3, Q may be
assumed equal to 0.
2.2.6 Transverse thruster tunnel
The shafts are to be protected against corrosion by means of
a) The thickness of the tunnel is not to be less than the either a continuous liner or an oil-gland of an approved
adjacent part of the hull. type, or by the nature of the material of the shaft.

b) Special consideration will be given by the Society to


2.3.2 Guide vanes, shaft support
tunnels connected to the hull by connecting devices
other than welding. a) Guide vanes and shaft supports, if any, are to be fitted in
accordance with direction of flow. Trailing and leading
2.2.7 Bearings edges are to be fitted with rounded profiles.

Bearing are to be identifiable and are to have a life ade- b) Fillet radius are generally not be less than the maximum
quate for the intended purpose. However, their life cannot local thickness of the concerned element. Fatigue
be less than: strength calculation is to be submitted.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 225


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 12

Table 4 : Azimuth thrusters

Symbol convention Automatic control


H = High, HH = High high, G = group alarm
Monitoring
L = Low, LL = Low low, I = individual alarm
Thruster Auxiliary
X = function is required, R = remote
Slow- Shut- Stand
Identification of system parameter Alarm Indication Control Stop
down down by Start
Steering oil pressure L
Oil tank level L

2.3.3 Stator and impellers 2.4.2 Alarm and monitoring equipment


a) Design is to take into account the loads developed in Tab 4 summarises the minimum alarm and monitoring
free going conditions and also in peculiar manoeuvres requirements for propulsion and steering thrusters. See also
like crash stop. Ch 1, Sec 11, [5].

b) Tip clearance is to take into account vibratory behav-


iours, displacements and any other expansion mode in 3 Testing and certification
all operating conditions of the water jet.
3.1 Material tests
c) Fillet radii are generally not to be less than the maxi-
mum local thickness of the concerned element. 3.1.1 Propulsion and steering thrusters
d) There is to be no natural frequency of stator blades or All materials intended for parts transmitting torque and for
rotor blades in the vicinity of the excitation frequencies propeller/impeller blades are to be tested in accordance
due to hydrodynamic interaction between stator blades with the applicable requirements of Ch 1, Sec 6, [6] or Ch
and rotor blades. Calculations are to be submitted for 1, Sec 7, [4] or Ch 1, Sec 8, [4] in the presence of a Sur-
maximum speed and any currently used speed. veyor.

2.3.4 Nozzle and reversing devices 3.1.2 Transverse thrusters


Design of nozzle and reversing devices are to take into Material testing for parts of athwartship thrusters does not
account the loads developed in all operating conditions of need to be witnessed by a Surveyor, provided full test
the water jet, including transient loads. reports are made available to him.

2.3.5 Steering performance 3.2 Testing and inspection


Steering performance and emergency steering availability
3.2.1 Thrusters
are to be at least equivalent to the requirements in Ch 1, Sec
11, [5.2] and Ch 1, Sec 11, [5.3]. Thrusters are to be inspected as per the applicable require-
ments given in the Rules for the specific components.

2.4 Alarm, monitoring and control systems 3.2.2 Prime movers


Prime movers are to be tested in accordance with the
2.4.1 Steering thruster controls requirements applicable to the type of mover used.
a) Controls for steering are to be provided from the navi-
gating bridge and locally, and also from the machinery 3.3 Certification
control station when the thruster is the normal steering
system of the ship. 3.3.1 Certification of thrusters
Thrusters are to be individually tested and certified by the
b) Means are to be provided to stop any running thruster at
Society.
each of the control stations.
c) A thruster angle indicator is to be provided at each 3.3.2 Mass produced thrusters
steering control station. The angle indicator is to be Mass produced thrusters may be accepted within the frame-
independent of the control system. work of the type approval program of the Society.

226 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 13

SECTION 13 REFRIGERATING INSTALLATIONS

1 General d) In general, the pipes conveying the cooling medium are


not to come into direct contact with the ship's structure;
they are to be carefully insulated on their run outside
1.1 Application the refrigerated spaces, and more particularly when
passing through bulkheads and decks.
1.1.1 Refrigerating installations on all ships
e) The materials used for the pipes are to be appropriate to
The minimum safety requirements addressed in this Section
the fluids they convey.
are to be complied with for any refrigerating plant installed
on board a ship to be classed by the Society. These require- f) Notch toughness of the steels used is to be suitable for
ments do not cover any operation or availability aspect of the application concerned.
the plants, which are not the subject of class requirements, g) Where necessary, cooling medium pipes within refriger-
unless an additional notation is requested. ated spaces or embedded in insulation are to be exter-
nally protected against corrosion; for steel pipes, this
1.1.2 Additional notations protection is to be ensured by galvanisation or equiva-
Where the additional notation REF-STORE is requested, the lent. All useful precautions are to be taken to protect the
requirements of Part E, Chapter 8 are to be complied with. joints of such pipes against corrosion.
h) The use of plastic pipes shall not be permitted.
2 Minimum design requirements
2.2 Refrigerants
2.1 Refrigerating installation components 2.2.1 Prohibited refrigerants
In addition to the substances prohibited by the Montreal
2.1.1 General
Protocol, the use of the following refrigerants is not allowed
In general, the specific requirements stated in Part C of the for shipboard installations:
Rules for various machinery and equipment are also appli- Ethane
cable to refrigerating installation components.
Ethylene
2.1.2 Pressure vessels and heat exchangers Ammonia
a) Pressure vessels of refrigerating plants are to comply Other substances with lower explosion limit in air of
with the relevant requirements of Ch 1, Sec 3. more than 3,5%.

b) Vessels intended to contain toxic substances are to be 2.2.2 Statutory requirements


considered as class 1 pressure vessels as indicated in Ch Particular attention is to be paid to any limitation on the use
1, Sec 3, [1.4]. of refrigerants imposed by the Naval Authority.
c) The materials used for pressure vessels are to be appro-
2.2.3 Toxic or flammable refrigerants
priate to the fluid that they contain.
The arrangement of refrigerating machinery spaces of plants
d) Notch toughness of steels used in low temperature using toxic or flammable refrigerants will be the subject of
plants is to be suitable for the thickness and the lowest special consideration by the Society.
design temperature. A check of the notch toughness
properties may be required where the working tempera-
3 Instrumentation
ture is below minus 40C.

2.1.3 Piping systems 3.1 Thermometers in refrigerated spaces


a) Refrigerant pipes are generally to be regarded as pres- 3.1.1 Number of thermometers
sure pipes.
a) Each refrigerated space with a volume not exceeding
b) Refrigerant, brine and sea water pipes are to satisfy the 400 m 3 is to be fitted with at least 4 thermometers or
requirements of Ch 1, Sec 10, as applicable. temperature sensors. Where the volume exceeds
c) Refrigerant pipes are to be considered as belonging to 400 m 3, this number is to be increased by one for each
the following classes: additional 400 m3.

class I: where they are intended for toxic substances b) Where the volume is not exceeding 60 m3, this number
may be reduced to 2 thermometers if the general shape
class II: for other refrigerants of the refrigerating space is quite rectangular with no
class III: for brine. dead end.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 227


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 13

c) Sensors for remote electric thermometers are to be con- c) In general, the scale range is to be within 30C and
nected to the instruments so that, in the event of failure +20C; in any case it is to be 5C greater than the
of any one instrument, the temperature in any space can range of application of the instrument.
still be checked through half the number of sensors in
d) In the graduated scale, the space between each degree
this space.
centigrade is not to be less than 5 mm.
3.1.2 Direct reading thermometers
3.1.6 Data-logger
The tubes intended to contain thermometers are to have a
diameter not less than 50 mm and are to be carefully iso- a) When a data-logger is installed, at least one sensing ele-
lated from the ship's structure. If they pass through spaces ment for each refrigerated space, both in the space itself
other than those they serve, they are to be insulated when and in its air circulating system, is to be connected to
passing through those spaces. Joints and covers of such another independent indicating instrument, approved by
tubes are to be insulated from the plating to which they are the Society. The data-logger is to register to 0,1 of a
attached and installed on open decks so that water will not degree. Indicating instruments are to be fed by two inde-
collect and freeze in them when measuring temperatures. pendent power sources. If they are fed by the network
Local readings are to be provided in any adjacent corridor on board through a transformer and rectifier unit, a
to refrigerating chambers. spare unit is also to be provided and is to be easily
replaceable aboard. If they are fed by storage batteries, it
3.1.3 Electric thermometer apparatus for remote will be sufficient to arrange easily changeable batteries.
reading b) A prototype apparatus is to be checked and tested by a
The apparatus is to provide the temperature indications, in Surveyors at an independent recognised laboratory, or at
any case in the central damage control station and in the Manufacturers facilities, to verify by means of suit-
manned stations, with the accuracy required in [3.1.5] in able tests that the degree of accuracy corresponds to the
conditions of vibrations and inclinations expected on board above provisions.
and for all ambient temperatures, up to 45C, to which indi-
cating instruments and connection cables may be exposed. c) The capacity of the apparatus to withstand stipulated
vibrations, impacts and temperature variations and its
3.1.4 Distant electric thermometer sensors non-liability to alterations due to the salt mist atmo-
sphere, typical of conditions on board, are to be veri-
a) Sensing elements are to be placed in refrigerated spaces fied.
where they are not liable to be exposed to damage dur-
ing goods handling and well clear of heat sources such
as, for instance, electric lamps, etc. 4 Installations related to preservation
b) Sensing elements in air coolers are to be placed at a dis- of ships victuals
tance of at least 900 mm from coils or fan motors.
c) When arranged in ducts, they are to be placed at the 4.1 Victuals chamber
centre of the air duct section, as far as possible.
4.1.1 The victuals chambers are to have the lining of stain-
d) Sensing elements are to be protected by a corrosion- less steel including surface joints.
resistant impervious covering. Conductors are to be per-
manently secured to sensing elements and to indicating 4.1.2 The victuals chambers are not to be provided with
instruments and connected accessories. Plug-and-socket scuppers for drainage. Drainage of victuals chambers is to
connections are allowed only if they are of a type be through their doors and the exterior antechamber door.
deemed suitable by the Society. A dripping-pan is to be located near such exterior door. The
e) All sensing elements are to be easily accessible. dripping-pan width is to be at least 200 mm greater than the
exterior antichamber door. Pipes discharging from the drip-
3.1.5 Accuracy ping-pan are to be provided with liquid seal traps.
a) Direct reading thermometers are to permit reading with
4.1.3 Only direct cooling systems are to be used.
an accuracy of 0,1C for temperatures between 0C and
15C. Temperatures given by remote reading are to have 4.1.4 No components of refrigerating installation are to be
an accuracy of:
fitted inside the refrigerated chambers.
0,3C (at 0C) for the carriage of fruit and vegeta-
bles, and
4.2 Instrumentation
0,5C (at 0C) for the carriage of frozen products.
b) The instrumental error, to be ascertained by means of 4.2.1 In the adjacent corridor of the refrigerated chambers
calibration by comparison with a master-thermometer local reading of the temperatures both by a direct reading
with officially certified calibration, is not to exceed the system and by a remote reading system (see [3.1.2] and
following values: [3.1.3]) is to be possible.

0,15C, in the range 3C to + 3C 4.2.2 Data-logger (see [3.1.6]) is to be provided only for
0,25C, in all other ranges of the scale. the frozen victuals at temperature minus 20C.

228 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 14

SECTION 14 TURBOCHARGERS

1 General 2 Design and construction

1.1 Application 2.1 Materials


2.1.1 The requirements of Ch 1, Sec 5, [2.2.1] are to be
1.1.1 These Rules apply to turbochargers fitted on the die-
complied with, as far as applicable, at the Societys discre-
sel engines listed in Ch 1, Sec 2, [1.1.1] a), b) and c) having
tion.
a power of 1000 kW and above.

1.1.2 Turbochargers not included in [1.1.1] are to be 2.2 Design


designed and constructed according to sound marine prac-
2.2.1 The requirements of Ch 1, Sec 5, [2.4] are to be com-
tice and delivered with the works certificate (W) relevant to
plied with, as far as applicable, at the Societys discretion.
the bench running test as per [4.3.3] and the hydrostatic test
as per [4.3.4].
2.3 Monitoring
1.1.3 In the case of special types of turbochargers, the Soci-
2.3.1 General
ety reserves the right to modify the requirements of this Sec-
tion, demand additional requirements in individual cases In addition to those of this item, the general requirements
and require that additional plans and data be submitted. given in Part C, Chapter 2 apply.

2.3.2 Indicators
1.2 Documentation to be submitted The local indicators for turbochargers fitted on diesel
engines having a power of 2000 kW and above to be
1.2.1 The Manufacturer is to submit to the Society the doc- installed on ships without automation notations are given in
uments listed in Tab 1. Ch 1, Sec 2, Tab 2.

Table 1 : Documentation to be submitted

No I/A (1) Document


1 A Longitudinal cross-sectional assembly with main dimensions
2 A Rotating parts (shaft, wheels and blades)
3 A Details of blade fixing
4 A Technical specification of the turbocharger including the maximum operating conditions (maximum permissible
rotational speed and maximum permissible temperature)
5 A Material specifications for the main parts, including their physical, chemical and mechanical properties, values of
tensile strength, average stress to produce creep, resistance to corrosion and heat treatments
6 I Operation and service manual
(1) A = to be submitted for approval, in four copies;
I = to be submitted for information, in duplicate.
Note 1: Plans mentioned under items (2) and (3) are to be constructional plans with all main dimensions and are to contain any nec-
essary information relevant to the type and quality of the materials employed. In the case of welded rotating parts, all relevant weld-
ing details are to be included in the above plans and the procedures adopted for welding or for any heat treatments will be subject to
approval by the Society

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 229


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 14

3 Arrangement and installation 4.3.3 Bench running test


Each turbocharger is to undergo a mechanical running test
at the bench for 20 minutes at maximum rotational speed at
3.1 General room temperature.

3.1.1 The arrangement and installation are to be such as to Subject to the agreement of the Society, the duration of the
avoid any unacceptable load on the turbocharger. running test may be reduced to 10 minutes, provided that
the Manufacturer is able to verify the distribution of defects
found during the running tests on the basis of a sufficient
4 Type tests, material tests, workshop number of tested turbochargers.
inspection and testing, certification For Manufacturers who have facilities in their works for test-
ing turbochargers on an engine for which they are intended,
the bench test may be replaced by a test run of 20 minutes
4.1 Type tests at overload (110% of the maximum continuous output) on
such engine.
4.1.1 Turbochargers as per [1.1.1] admitted to an alterna-
tive inspection scheme are to be type approved. Where turbochargers are admitted to an alternative inspec-
tion scheme and subject to the satisfactory findings of a his-
The type test is to be carried out on a standard unit taken torical audit, the Society may accept a bench test carried
from the assembly line and is to be witnessed by the Sur- out on a sample basis.
veyor. Normally, the type test is to consist of a hot gas run-
ning test of one hours duration at the maximum permissible 4.3.4 Hydrostatic tests
speed and maximum permissible temperature. After the test
The cooling spaces of turbochargers are to be hydrostati-
the turbocharger is to be opened up and examined. cally tested at a test pressure of 0,4 MPa or 1,5 times the
maximum working pressure, whichever is the greater.
For Manufacturers who have facilities for testing the turbo-
charger unit on an engine for which the turbocharger is to
be type approved, replacement of the hot running test by a 4.4 Certification
test run of one hours duration at overload (110% of the
rated output) may be considered. 4.4.1 Type Approval Certificate and its validity
Subject to the satisfactory outcome of the type tests specified
4.2 Material tests in [4.1], the Society will issue to the turbocharger Manufac-
turer a Type Approval Certificate valid for all turbochargers
of the same type.
4.2.1 Material tests (mechanical properties and chemical
composition) are required for shafts and rotors, including
4.4.2 Testing certification
blades (see [4.4.2] as regards the certificate required).
a) Turbochargers admitted to an alternative inspection
scheme
4.3 Workshop inspections and testing
A statement, issued by the Manufacturer, is required cer-
4.3.1 Overspeed test tifying that the turbocharger conforms to the one type
tested. The reference number and date of the Type
All wheels (impellers and inducers), when machine-finished Approval Certificate are also to be indicated in the state-
and complete with all fittings and blades, are to undergo an ment (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1, Sec 1, [4.2.2]).
overspeed test for at least 3 minutes at one of the following
Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1,
test speeds:
Sec 1, [4.2.3]) are required for material tests as per [4.2]
a) 20% above the maximum speed at room temperature and for works trials as per [4.3].

b) Turbochargers not admitted to an alternative inspection


b) 10% above the maximum speed at the maximum work-
scheme
ing temperature.
Societys certificates (C) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1,
Note 1: If each forged wheel is individually controlled by an Sec 1, [4.2.1]) are required for the bench running test as
approved non-destructive examination method no overspeed test
per [4.3.3] and the overspeed test as per [4.3.1], as well
may be required except for wheels of the type test unit.
as for material and hydrostatic tests as per [4.2] and
[4.3.4].
4.3.2 Balancing
Works certificates (W) (see NR216 Materials, Ch 1,
Each shaft and bladed wheel, as well as the complete rotat- Sec 1, [4.2.3]) may be accepted for material tests, in
ing assembly, is to be dynamically balanced by means of place of the Societys certificates, for turbochargers fitted
equipment which is sufficiently sensitive in relation to the on diesel engines having a cylinder diameter of 300 mm
size of the rotating part to be balanced. or less.

230 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 15

SECTION 15 TESTS ON BOARD

1 General 2.2 Sea trials

2.2.1 Scope of the tests


1.1 Application
Sea trials are to be conducted after the trials at the moorings
and are to include the following:
1.1.1 This Section covers shipboard tests, both at the moor-
ings and during sea trials. Such tests are additional to the a) demonstration of the proper operation of the main and
workshop tests required in the other Sections of this Chap- auxiliary machinery, including monitoring, alarm and
ter. safety systems, under realistic service conditions
b) check of the propulsion capability when one of the
1.2 Purpose of shipboard tests essential auxiliaries becomes inoperative
c) detection of dangerous vibrations by taking the neces-
1.2.1 Shipboard tests are intended to demonstrate that the sary readings when required
main and auxiliary machinery and associated systems are
d) checks either deemed necessary for ship classification
functioning properly, in particular in respect of the criteria
or requested by the interested parties and which are
imposed by the Rules. The tests are to be witnessed by a
possible only in the course of navigation in open sea.
Surveyor.
2.2.2 Exemptions
1.3 Documentation to be submitted Exemption from some of the sea trials may be considered by
the Society in the case of ships having a sister ship for which
1.3.1 A comprehensive list of the shipboard tests intended the satisfactory behaviour in service is demonstrated.
to be carried out by the shipyard is to be submitted to the
Such exemption is, in any event, to be agreed upon by the
Society.
interested parties and is subject to the satisfactory results of
For each test, the following information is to be provided: trials at the moorings to verify the safe and efficient opera-
tion of the propulsion system.
scope of the test
parameters to be recorded. 3 Shipboard tests for machinery

2 General requirements for shipboard 3.1 Conditions of sea trials


tests
3.1.1 Displacement of the ship
Except in cases of practical impossibility, or in other cases
2.1 Trials at the moorings
to be considered individually, the sea trials are to be carried
out at a displacement as close as possible to the full load
2.1.1 Trials at the moorings are to demonstrate the follow-
displacement or to the half load displacement.
ing:

a) satisfactory operation of the machinery in relation to the 3.1.2 Power of the machinery
service for which it is intended a) The power developed by the propulsion machinery in
the course of the sea trials is to be as close as possible to
b) quick and easy response to operational commands
the power for which classification has been requested.
c) safety of the various installations, as regards: In general, this power is not to exceed the maximum
continuous power at which the weakest component of
the protection of mechanical parts the propulsion system can be operated. In cases of die-
the safeguards for personnel sel engines and gas turbines, it is not to exceed the max-
imum continuous power for which the engine type
d) accessibility for cleaning, inspection and maintenance. concerned has been approved.
Where the above features are not deemed satisfactory and b) Where the rotational speed of the shafting is different
require repairs or alterations, the Society reserves the right from the design value, thereby increasing the stresses in
to require the repetition of the trials at the moorings, either excess of the maximum allowable limits, the power
wholly or in part, after such repairs or alterations have been developed in the trials is to be suitably modified so as to
carried out. confine the stresses within the design limits.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 231


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 15

3.1.3 Determination of the power and rotational 3.3 Tests of diesel engines
speed
3.3.1 General
a) The rotational speed of the shafting is to be recorded in
The scope of the trials of diesel engines may be expanded in
the course of the sea trials, preferably by means of a
consideration of the special operating conditions, such as
continuous counter.
towing, trawling, etc.
b) In general, the power is to be determined by means of 3.3.2 Main propulsion engines driving fixed
torsiometric readings, to be effected with procedures propellers
and instruments deemed suitable by the Society.
Sea trials of main propulsion engines driving fixed propel-
As an alternative, for reciprocating internal combustion lers are to include the following tests:
engines and gas turbines, the power may be determined a) operation at rated engine speed n0 for at least 4 hours
by measuring the fuel consumption and on the basis of
b) operation at minimum load speed
the other operating characteristics, in comparison with
the results of bench tests of the prototype engine. c) starting and reversing manoeuvres
d) operation in reverse direction of propeller rotation at the
For electric propulsion, the power may be determined maximum torque or thrust allowed by the propulsion
by recording electrical data. system for 10 minutes
Other methods of determining the power may be con- e) tests of the monitoring, alarm and safety systems.
sidered by the Society on a case by case basis. Note 1: The test in d) may be performed during the dock or sea trials.

3.3.3 Main propulsion engines driving controllable


3.2 Navigation and manoeuvring tests pitch propellers or reversing gears
Sea trials of main propulsion engines driving controllable
3.2.1 Speed trials pitch propellers or reversing gear are to include the follow-
ing tests:
a) Where required by the Rules, the speed of the ship is to
a) operation at rated engine speed n0 with nominal pitch of
be determined using procedures deemed suitable by the
Society. the propeller for at least 4 hours
b) test at various propeller pitches for engines driving con-
b) The ship speed is to be determined as the average of the trollable pitch propellers
speeds taken in not less than two pairs of runs in oppo-
c) operation in reverse thrust of propeller at the maximum
site directions.
torque or thrust allowed by the propulsion system for
10 minutes
3.2.2 Astern trials
d) tests of the monitoring, alarm and safety systems.
a) The ability of the machinery to reverse the direction of Note 1: The test in c) may be performed during the dock or sea trials.
thrust of the propeller in sufficient time, and so to bring
the ship to rest within reasonable distance from maxi- 3.3.4 Engines driving generators for electric
mum ahead service speed, shall be demonstrated and propulsion
recorded. Sea trials of engines driving generators for electric propul-
sion are to include the following tests:
b) The stopping times, ship headings and distances a) operation at 100% power (rated power) for at least
recorded on trials, together with the results of trials to 4 hours
determine the ability of ships having multiple propellers
to navigate and manoeuvre with one or more propellers b) operation at 110% power for 30 minutes
inoperative, shall be available on board for the use of c) starting manoeuvres
the Master or designated personnel. d) tests of the monitoring, alarm and safety systems.
c) Where the ship is provided with supplementary means Note 1: The above tests a) to d) are to be performed at rated speed
with a constant governor setting. The powers refer to the rated elec-
for manoeuvring or stopping, the effectiveness of such
trical powers of the driven generators.
means shall be demonstrated and recorded as referred
to in paragraphs a) and b). 3.3.5 Engines driving auxiliaries
a) Engines driving generators or important auxiliaries are
For electric propulsion systems, see [3.5].
to be subjected to an operational test for at least 4
hours. During the test, the set concerned is required to
3.2.3 Change of propulsion system configuration operate at its rated power for at least 2 hours.
a) Where several normal propulsion system configurations b) It is to be demonstrated that the engine is capable of
are possible, each of them are to be tested. supplying 100% of its rated power and, in the case of
shipboard generating sets, account is to be taken of the
b) The normal transfers between these configurations are times needed to actuate the generators overload protec-
to be tested. tion system.

232 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 15

3.4 Tests of gas turbines check of the crash astern operation in accordance with
the sequence provided to reverse the speed from full
3.4.1 Main propulsion turbines ahead to full astern, in case of emergency. During this
test, all necessary data concerning any effects of the
Main turbines are to be subjected during dock trials and
reversing of power on the generators are to be recorded,
subsequent sea trials to the following tests:
including the power and speed variation
operation at rated rpm for at least 3 hours
Test of functionality of electric propulsion, when
ship reversing manoeuvres. manoeuvring and during the ship turning test
Test of power management performance: reduction of
During the various operations, the pressures, temperatures
and relative expansion are not to assume magnitudes liable power due to loss of one or several generators to check,
in each case, the power limitation and propulsion avail-
to endanger the safe operation of the plant.
ability.
During the trials all safety, alarm, shut-off and control sys-
tems associated to the turbine are to be tested or properly
3.6 Tests of gears
simulated.
3.6.1 Tests during sea trials
3.4.2 Auxiliary turbines
During the sea trials, the performance of reverse and/or
Turbines driving electric generators or auxiliary machines
reduction gearing is to be verified, both when running
are to be run for at least 4 hours at their rated power and for ahead and astern.
30 minutes at 110% of rated power.
In addition, the following checks are to be carried out:
During the trials all safety, alarm, shut-off and control sys-
tems associated to the turbine are to be tested or properly check of the bearing and oil temperature
simulated. detection of possible gear hammering, where required
by Ch 1, Sec 9, [3.6.1]
3.5 Tests of electric propulsion system test of the monitoring, alarm and safety systems.

3.5.1 Dock trials 3.6.2 Check of the tooth contact


a) The dock trials are to include the test of the electrical a) Prior to the sea trials, the tooth surfaces of the pinions
production system, the power management system and and wheels are to be coated with a thin layer of suitable
the load limitation. coloured compound.
b) A test of the propulsion plant at a reduced power, in Upon completion of the trials, the tooth contact is to be
accordance with dock trial facilities, is to be carried out. inspected. The contact marking is to appear uniformly
During this test, the following are to be checked: distributed without hard bearing at the ends of the teeth
and without preferential contact lines.
electric motor rotation speed variation
The tooth contact is to comply with Tab 1.
functional test, as far as practicable (power limita-
tion is to be tested with a reduced value) b) The verification of tooth contact at sea trials by methods
other than that described above will be given special
protection devices
consideration by the Society.
monitoring and alarm transmission including inter-
locking system. Table 1 : Tooth contact for gears

c) Prior to the sea trials, an insulation test of the electric Percentage of tooth contact
propulsion plant is to be carried out.
Heat treatment across the of the tooth
and machining whole face working
3.5.2 Sea trials
width depth
Testing of the performance of the electric propulsion system is
quenched and tempered, cut 70 40
to be effected in accordance with an approved test program.
quenched and tempered,
This test program is to include at least: shaved or ground 90 40
speed rate of rise surface-hardened
endurance test:
3.7 Tests of main propulsion shafting and
4 hours at 100% rated output power
propellers
operation in reverse direction of propeller rotation at
the maximum torque or thrust allowed by the pro- 3.7.1 Shafting alignment
pulsion system for 10 minutes Where alignment calculations are required to be submitted
Note 1: The reverse test may be performed during the dock or sea in pursuance of Ch 1, Sec 7, [3.3.1], the alignment condi-
trials. tions are to be checked on board as follows:

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 233


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 15

a) shafting installation and intermediate bearing position, 3.8.2 Performance tests


before and during assembling of the shafts:
The Society reserves the right to require performance tests,
optical check of the relative position of bushes after such as flow rate measurements, should doubts arise from
fitting the functional tests.
check of the flanged coupling parameters (gap and sag)
check of the centring of the shaft sealing glands 3.9 Tests of steering gear
b) engine (or gearbox) installation, with floating ship:
3.9.1 General
check of the engine (or gearbox) flanged coupling
parameters (gap and sag) a) The steering gear is to be tested during the sea trials
under the conditions stated in [3.1] in order to demon-
check of the crankshaft deflections before and after strate, to the Surveyors satisfaction, that the applicable
the connection of the engine with the shaft line, by requirements of Ch 1, Sec 11 are fulfilled.
measuring the variation in the distance between
adjacent webs in the course of one complete revolu- b) For controllable pitch propellers, the propeller pitch is
tion of the engine to be set at the maximum design pitch approved for the
maximum continuous ahead rotational speed.
Note 1: The ship is to be in the loading conditions defined in the
alignment calculations. c) If the ship cannot be tested at the deepest draught, alter-
c) load on the bearings: native trial conditions will be given special consider-
ation by the Society on the basis of Naval Authority
check of the intermediate bearing load by means of determinations. In such case, the ship speed corre-
jack-up load measurements sponding to the maximum continuous number of revo-
check of the bearing contact area by means of coat- lutions of the propulsion machinery may apply.
ing with an appropriate compound.
3.9.2 Tests to be performed
3.7.2 Shafting vibrations
Tests of the steering gear are to include at least:
Torsional, bending and axial vibration measurements are to
be carried out where required by Ch 1, Sec 9. The type of a) functional test of the main and auxiliary steering gear
the measuring equipment and the location of the measure- with demonstration of the performances required by Ch
ment points are to be specified. 1, Sec 11, [3.4]

3.7.3 Bearings b) test of the steering gear power units, including transfer
between steering gear power units and between main
The temperature of the bearings is to be checked under the and auxiliary
machinery power conditions specified in [3.1.2].
c) test of the isolation of one power actuating system,
3.7.4 Stern tube sealing gland checking the time for regaining steering capability for
both main and auxiliary steering gear operation
The stern tube oil system is to be checked for possible oil
leakage through the stern tube sealing gland. d) test of the hydraulic fluid refilling system

3.7.5 Propellers e) test of the alternative power supply required by Ch 1,


Sec 11, [2.3.2], item e)
a) For controllable pitch propellers, the functioning of the
system controlling the pitch from full ahead to full f) test of the steering gear controls, including transfer of
astern position is to be demonstrated. It is also to be controls and local control
checked that this system does not induce any overload
of the engine. g) test of the means of communication between the navi-
gation bridge, the engine room and the steering gear
b) The proper functioning of the devices for emergency
compartment and other position of emergency steering
operations is to be tested during the sea trials.
h) test of the alarms and indicators
3.8 Tests of piping systems
i) where the steering gear design is required to take into
account the risk of hydraulic locking, a test is to be per-
3.8.1 Functional tests formed to demonstrate the efficiency of the devices
During the sea trials, piping systems serving propulsion and intended to detect this.
auxiliary machinery, including the associated monitoring
Note 1: Tests d) to i) may be carried out either during the mooring
and control devices, are to be subjected to functional tests at
trials or during the sea trials.
the nominal power of the machinery. Operating parameters
(pressure, temperature, consumption) are to comply with Note 2: Azimuth thrusters are to be subjected to the above tests, as
the values recommended by the equipment manufacturer. far as applicable.

234 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, Sec 15

4 Inspection of machinery after sea c) An exhaustive inspection report is to be submitted to the


Society for information.
trials
4.2 Diesel engines
4.1 General
4.2.1
4.1.1
a) For all types of propulsion machinery, those parts which a) In general, for all diesel engines, the following items are
have not operated satisfactorily in the course of the sea to be verified:
trials, or which have caused doubts to be expressed as the deflection of the crankshafts, by measuring the
to their proper operation, are to be disassembled or variation in the distance between adjacent webs in
opened for inspection. the course of one complete revolution of the engine
Machinery or parts which are opened up or disassem- the cleanliness of the lubricating oil filters.
bled for other reasons are to be similarly inspected. b) In the case of propulsion engines for which power tests
b) Should the inspection reveal defects or damage of some have not been carried out in the workshop, some parts,
importance, the Society may require other similar agreed upon by the interested parties, are to be disas-
machinery or parts to be opened up for inspection. sembled for inspection after the sea trials.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 235


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

APPENDIX 1 CHECK OF THE SCANTLINGS OF CRANKSHAFTS


FOR DIESEL ENGINES

1 General appropriate stress concentration factors using the theory of


constant energy of distortion (von Mises Criterion), result in
an equivalent alternating stress (uni-axial stress). This equiv-
1.1 Application alent alternating stress is then compared with the fatigue
strength of the selected crankshaft material. This compari-
1.1.1
son will then show whether or not the crankshaft concerned
a) The requirements for the check of scantlings of crank- is dimensioned adequately.
shafts given in this Appendix apply to diesel engines as
per Ch 1, Sec 2, [1.1.1] a), b) and c), capable of contin-
1.4 Symbols
uous operation at their maximum continuous power P,
(as defined in Ch 1, Sec 2, [1.3.2]), at the nominal max- 1.4.1
imum speed n.
B : Width of the web, in mm; see Fig 2
Crankshafts which cannot satisfy these requirements
will be subject to special consideration by the Society as dBC : Diameter of bore in crankpin, in mm; see Fig 2
far as detailed calculations or measurements can be dBJ : Diameter of bore in journal, in mm; see Fig 2
submitted. dC : Crankpin diameter, in mm; see Fig 2
The following cases: dJ : Journal diameter, in mm; see Fig 2
surface treated fillets; DE : The minimum value between:
when fatigue parameter influences are tested; and the outside diameter of web, in mm, or
when working stresses are measured; the value, in mm, equal to twice the mini-
will be also specially considered by the Society. mum distance x between centre-line of jour-
b) The requirements of this Appendix apply only to solid- nals and outer contour of web (see Fig 3)
forged and semi-built crankshafts of forged or cast steel, dS : Shrink-fit diameter, in mm; see Fig 3
with one crank throw between two adjacent main bear- E : Pin eccentricity, in mm; see Fig 2
ings.
EW : Value of the modulus of elasticity of the web
material, in N/mm2; see [7.2.2]
1.2 Documentation to be submitted
F : Area, in mm2, related to cross-section of web,
1.2.1 Required data for the check of the scantlings are indi- given by the following formula:
cated in the specific Society form as per Ch 1, Sec 2, Tab 1, F = BW
item 1.
K : Crankshaft manufacturing process factor; see
[6.1.1] a)
1.3 Principles of calculation
KE : Empirical factor for the modification of the
1.3.1 The scantlings of crankshafts as per this Appendix are alternating bending stress, which considers to
based on an evaluation of safety against fatigue failure in some extent the influence of adjacent cranks
the highly stressed areas. and bearing restraint, whose value may be taken
The calculation is also based on the assumption that the fil- as follows:
let transitions between the crankpin and web as well as KE = 0,8 for 2-stroke engines
between the journal and web are the areas exposed to the KE = 1,0 for 4-stroke engines
highest stresses.
LS : Axial length of the shrink-fit, in mm; see Fig 3
The outlets of oil bores into crankpins and journals are to be
formed in such a way that the safety margin against fatigue MB : Bending moment in the web centre, in Nm
at the oil bores is not less than that acceptable in the fillets. MB,MAX : Maximum value of the bending moment MB, in
Nm
The engine manufacturer, where requested by the Society, is
to submit documentation supporting his oil bore design. MB,MIN : Minimum value of the bending moment MB, in
Nm
Calculation of crankshaft strength consists initially in deter-
mining the nominal alternating bending and nominal alter- MBN : Nominal alternating bending moment, in Nm;
nating torsional stresses which, multiplied by the for the determination of MBN see [2.1.2] b)

236 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

MT,MAX : Maximum value of the torque, in Nm, with BC : Stress concentration factor for bending in crank-
consideration of the mean torque pin fillet; for the determination of BC see [3.1.2]
MT,MIN : Minimum value of the torque, in Nm, with con- a)
sideration of the mean torque BJ : Stress concentration factor for bending in jour-
MTN : Nominal alternating torque, in Nm, given by nal fillet; for the determination of BJ see [3.1.3]
the following formula: a)
M TN = 0,5 ( M T ,M A X M T , M IN ) QJ : Stress concentration factor for shearing in jour-
Q1 : Acceptability factor for the crankpin fillet; see nal fillet; for the determination of QJ see [3.1.3]
[8.1.1] b)
Q2 : Acceptability factor for the journal fillet; see TC : Stress concentration factor for torsion in crank-
[8.1.1] pin fillet; for the calculation of Tc see [3.1.2] b)
QMAX : Maximum value of the alternating shearing
TJ : Stress concentration factor for torsion in journal
force Q, in N
fillet; for the calculation of TJ see [3.1.3] c)
QMIN : Minimum value of the alternating shearing force
Q, in N B,ADD : Additional bending stress, in N/mm2, due to
QN : Nominal alternating shearing force, in N; for the misalignment; see [4.1.1]
determination of QN see [2.1.2] c) BN : Nominal alternating bending stress, in N/mm2;
rC : Fillet radius of crankpin, in mm; see Fig 2 for the determination of BN see [2.1.2] b)
rJ : Fillet radius of journal, in mm; see Fig 2 BC : Alternating bending stress in crankpin fillet, in
Rm : Value of the minimum specified tensile strength N/mm2; for the determination of BC see [2.1.3]
of crankshaft material, in N/mm2 a)
RS,MIN : Specified value, in N/mm2, of the minimum
BJ : Alternating bending stress in journal fillet, in
yield strength (ReH), or 0,2% proof stress (Rp 0,2),
N/mm2; for the determination of BJ see [2.1.3]
of the crank web material.
b)
S : Pin overlap, in mm, (see Fig 2) whose value may
be calculated by the following formula: E : Equivalent alternating stress in way of the crank-
d C + dJ
pin fillet, in N/mm2; for the determination of E
- E
S = ---------------- see [5.2.1] a)
2

Where pins do not overlap, the negative value E : Equivalent alternating stress in way of the jour-
of S calculated by the above formula is to be nal fillet, in N/mm2; for the determination of E
considered. see [5.2.1] b)
TC : Recess of crankpin, in mm; see Fig 2 F,ALL : Allowable alternating bending fatigue strength
TJ : Recess of journal, in mm; see Fig 2 in way of the crankpin fillet, in N/mm2; for the
W : Axial web thickness, in mm; see Fig 2 determination of F,ALL see [6.1.1] a)
WEQ : Equatorial moment of resistance, in mm3, F,ALL : Allowable alternating bending fatigue strength
related to cross-sectional area of web, whose in way of the journal fillet, in N/mm2; for the
value may be calculated as follows: determination of F,ALL see [6.1.1] b)

W EQ = B W -2
--------------- QN : Nominal alternating shearing stress, in N/mm2;
6
for the determination of QN see [2.1.2] c)
WPC : Value, in mm3, of the polar moment of resis-
tance related to cross-sectional area of crank- C : Alternating torsional stress in way of crankpin
pin; for the determination of WPC see [2.2.2] fillet, in N/mm2; for the determination of C see
WPJ : Value, in mm3, of the polar moment of resis- [2.2.3] a)
tance related to cross-sectional area of journal; J : Alternating torsional stress in way of journal fil-
for the determination of WPJ see [2.2.2]
let, in N/mm2; for the determination of J see
y : Distance, in mm, between the adjacent generat- [2.2.3] b)
ing lines of journal and pin connected to the
same web (see Fig 3). NC : Nominal alternating torsional stress referred to
crankpin, in N/mm2; for the determination of
In general y is not to be less than 0,05 ds.
NC see [2.2.2]
Where y is less than 0,1 dS, special consider-
ation will be given by the Society in each case, NJ : Nominal alternating torsional stress referred to
to the effect of the stress due to the shrink on the journal, in N/mm2; for the determination of NJ
fatigue strength of the web at the crankpin fillet see [2.2.2].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 237


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

2 Calculation of alternating stresses 2.1.2 Calculation of nominal alternating bending


and shearing stresses
a) As a rule the calculation is carried out in such a way
2.1 Calculation of alternating stresses due that the individual radial forces acting upon the crank
to bending moments and shearing forces pin owing to gas and inertia forces will be calculated for
all crank positions within one working cycle. A simpli-
2.1.1 Assumptions fied calculation of the radial forces may be used at the
discretion of the Society.
The calculation of alternating stresses is based on the
b) The time curve of the bending moment MB in the web
assumptions specified below.
centre is to be calculated by means of the radial forces
a) The calculation is based on a statically determined sys- variable in time within one working cycle, and taking
tem, so that only one single crank throw is considered into account the axial distance from the bearing center
with the journals supported in the centre of adjacent as defined in [2.1.1] a) to the acting position of the
forces on the pin. The nominal alternating bending
bearings and the throw subjected to gas and inertia
moment MBN, in Nm, and, from this, the nominal alter-
forces. The bending length is taken as the length L3
nating bending stress BN, in N/mm2, will then be calcu-
between the centre of two adjacent main bearings (see
lated by the following formulae:
Fig 1(a) and (b)).
M BN = 0 ,5 ( MB ,M A X MB ,M I N )
b) The nominal bending moment is taken as the bending M BN
moment in the crank web cross-section in the centre of BN = ----------
- K 10 3
WEQ E
the solid web (distance L1 from the centre of the nearest
main bearing) based on a triangular bending moment In the case of V-type engines, the bending moments,
progressively calculated for the various crank angles
load due to the radial components of the connecting rod
and due to the gas and inertia forces of the two cylinders
force. For crank throws with two connecting rods acting
acting on one crank throw, are to be superimposed
upon one crankpin, the nominal bending moment is
according to phase, the differing designs of the connect-
taken as a bending moment obtained by superimposing ing rods (forked connecting rod, articulated-type con-
the two triangular bending moment loads due to the necting rod or adjacent connecting rods) being taken
radial components of the connecting rod forces, accord- into account.
ing to phase.
Where there are cranks of different geometrical configu-
c) The nominal alternating stresses due to bending ration (e.g., asymmetric cranks) in one crankshaft, the
moments and shearing forces are to be related to the calculation is to cover all crank variants.
cross-sectional area of the crank web, at the centre of c) The nominal alternating shearing force QN, in N, and,
the overlap S in cases of overlap of the pins and at the from this, the nominal alternating shearing stress QN, in
centre of the distance y between the adjacent generat- N/mm2, may be calculated by the following formulae:
ing lines of the two pins in cases of pins which do not
Q N = 0 ,5 ( Q M A X Q M IN )
overlap (see Fig 2 and Fig 3).
Q
Q N = -------N K E
Nominal mean bending stresses are neglected. F

Figure 1 : Crank throw of solid crankshaft


dC
dC

E
E
dJ
connecting rod

dJ
centre line of

connecting rods
centre lines of

L1 L1 L1 L1

L2 L2 L2 L2

L3 L3

(a) Crank throw for in-line engine (b) Crank throw for engine with two adjacent
connecting rods

238 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

Figure 2 : Crank dimensions necessary for the calculation of stress concentration factors

Figure 3 : Crank throw of semi-built crankshaft

2.1.3 Calculation of alternating bending stresses in 2.2 Calculation of alternating torsional


way of crankpin and journal fillets stresses
The calculation of the alternating bending stresses is to be
carried out in way of crankpin and journal fillets, as speci- 2.2.1 General
fied below.
The calculation for nominal alternating torsional stresses is
a) The alternating bending stress in crankpin fillet is to be to be undertaken by the engine manufacturer according to
taken equal to the value BC, in N/mm2, obtained by the the information contained in [2.2.2].
following formula:
The maximum value obtained from such calculations will
B C = ( BC B N ) be used by the Society when determining the equivalent
alternating stress according to the provisions of [5].
b) The alternating bending stress in journal fillet is to be
taken equal to the value BJ, in N/mm2, obtained by the In the absence of such a maximum value, the Society
following formula: reserves the right to incorporate a fixed value in the calcula-
tion for the crankshaft dimensions, to be established at its
B J = ( BJ B N + Q J Q N ) discretion in each case.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 239


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

In the event of the Society being entrusted to carry out a 2.2.2 Calculation of nominal alternating torsional
forced vibration calculation on behalf of the engine manu- stresses
facturer to determine the torsional vibration stresses The maximum and minimum values of the alternating
expected in the engine and where relevant in the shafting, torques are to be ascertained for every mass point of the
the following data are to be submitted in addition to those system and for the entire speed range by means of a har-
required in [1.2.1]: monic synthesis of the alternating stresses due to the forced
vibrations from the 1st order up to and including the 15th
a) equivalent dynamic system of the engine, comprising:
order for 2-stroke cycle engines, and from the 0,5th order
1) mass moment of inertia of every mass point, in up to and including the 12th order for 4-stroke cycle
kgm2 engines.
In performing this calculation, allowance is to be made for
2) inertialess torsional stiffnesses, in Nm/rad, of all the dampings that exist in the system and for unfavourable
crankshaft parts between two mass points conditions (e.g., misfiring in one of the cylinders).
b) vibration dampers, specifying: The speed stages is to be selected for the forced vibration
calculations in such a way that the transient response can
1) type designation be recorded with sufficient accuracy at various speeds.
2) mass moments of inertia, in kgm 2 The values received from such calculation are to be submit-
ted to the Society for consideration.
3) inertialess torsional stiffnesses, in Nm/rad
The nominal alternating torsional stresses, referred to crank-
4) values of the damping coefficients, in Nms pin and journal, in every mass point which is essential to
the assessment, may be taken equal to the values NC and
c) flywheels, specifying:
NJ, in N/mm2, calculated by the following formulae:
1) mass moment of inertia, in kgm2. M TN
N C = ---------- 10 3
WPC
Where the whole propulsion system is to be considered, the
following information is also to be submitted: MTN
N J = ---------
- 10 3
W PJ
a) elastic couplings, specifying:
where:
1) dynamic characteristics and damping data, as well a) For unbored crankpins or journals:
as the permissible value of alternating torque
d
3

b) gearing and shafting, specifying: WPC = ------------C-


16
d
3
1) shaft diameters of gear shafts, thrust shafts, interme- WPJ = -------------J
diate shafts and propeller shafts, mass moments of 16
inertia, in kgm2, of gearing or important mass b) For bored crankpins or journals:
points, gear ratios and, for gearboxes of complex
type, the schematic gearing arrangement d C4 d B4 C
WPC = ------ --------------------
16 dC
c) propellers, specifying: d J4 d BJ 4
WPJ = ------ ------------------
-
16 dJ
1) propeller diameter
For the symbols dC, dJ, dBC and dBJ see [3.1.1] and Fig 2.
2) number of blades
For the calculation of the polar moments of resistance WPC
3) pitch and developed area ratio and WPJ, bored crankpins and journals having bore diame-
ter not exceeding 0,3 times the outer diameter of crankpins
4) mass moment of inertia of propeller in air and with
or journals may be considered as unbored.
entrained water, in kgm2, (for controllable pitch pro-
pellers both the values at full pitch and at zero pitch Bored crankpins and journals whose bore longitudinal axis
are to be specified) does not coincide with the axis of the said crankpins and
journals, will be considered by the Society in each case.
5) damping characteristics, if available and docu-
The assessment of the proposed crankshaft dimensions is
mented
based on the alternating torsional stress which, in conjunc-
d) natural frequencies with their relevant modes of vibra- tion with the associated bending stress, results in the lowest
tion and the vector sums for the harmonics of the engine acceptability factor FA, as specified in [8.1].
excitation Where barred speed ranges are necessary, the alternating
torsional stresses within these ranges are to be neglected in
e) estimated torsional vibration stresses in all important
the calculation of the above acceptability factor.
elements of the system with particular reference to
clearly defined resonance speeds of rotation and contin- Barred speed ranges are to be so arranged that satisfactory
uous operating ranges. operation is possible despite their existence.

240 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

There are to be no barred speed ranges for values of the Fig 2 shows the dimensions necessary for the calculation of
speed ratio 0,8, being the ratio between the rotational the above-mentioned stress concentration factors.
speed considered and the rotational speed corresponding to For the calculation of stress concentration factors for bend-
the maximum continuous power. ing, torsion and shearing, the related dimensions shown in
The approval of the proposed crankshaft dimensions will be Tab 1 will be applied.
based on the installation having the lowest value of the The values of the stress concentration factors, calculated as
above-mentioned acceptability factor. follows, are valid for the following ranges of related dimen-
Thus, for each installation, it is to be ensured by suitable sions for which investigations have been carried out:
calculation that the nominal alternating torsional stress 0,50 s 0,70
accepted for the purpose of checking the crankshaft scant-
lings is not exceeded. 0,20 w 0,80

This calculation is to be submitted for assessment to the 1,20 b 2,20


Society (see Ch 1, Sec 9). 0,03 r1 0,13

2.2.3 Calculation of alternating torsional stresses in 0,03 r2 0,13


crankpin and journal fillets 0 d1 0,80
The calculation of alternating torsional stresses is to be car-
0 d2 0,80
ried out both in way of crankpin and journal fillets, as spec-
ified below: Table 1 :
a) The alternating torsional stress in way of crankpin fillet
is to be taken equal to the value C, in N/mm2, given by Crankpin fillets Journal fillets
the following formula: r1 = rC / d C r2 = rJ / dC
C = ( TC N C ) s = S / dC s = S / dC

b) The alternating torsional stress in way of journal fillet is w = W / dC w = W / dC


to be taken equal to the value J, in N/mm2, given by the b = B / dC b = B / dC
following formula: d1 = dBC / dC d2 = dBJ / dC
J = ( TJ N J ) t1 = T C / d C t2 = TJ / dC

3 Calculation of stress concentration The factor f(t,s), which accounts for the influence of a recess
in the web in way of the crankpin and journal fillets, is valid
factors if the related dimensions t1 and t2 meet the following condi-
tions:
3.1 General t1 r1 t2 r2
3.1.1 The stress concentration factors for bending (BC and and is to be applied for the values of the related dimension s
BJ) are defined as the ratio of the maximum value of the within the range:
bending stress occurring in the fillets under bending load 0,30 s 0,50
acting in the central cross-section of a crank, to the value of
the nominal alternating bending stress related to the web 3.1.2 Crankpin fillets
cross-section. a) The value of the stress concentration factor for bending
The value of the above nominal stress is to be determined BC may be calculated by the following formula:
under the bending moment in the middle of the solid web.
BC = 2,6914 f1(s,w) f1(w) f1(b) f1(r1) f1(d1) f1(d2)
The stress concentration factors for torsion (TC and TJ) are f(t,s)
defined as the ratio of the maximum value of the torsional where:
stress occurring under torsional load in the fillets to the
value of the nominal alternating torsional stress related to f1(s,w) : 4,1883 + 29,2004 w 77,5925 w2 +
the crankpin or journal cross-section, taking account of the 91,9454 w3 40,0416 w4 + (1 s)
relevant bores, if any. (9,5440 58,3480 w + 159,3415 w2
192,5846 w3 + 85,2916 w4) + (1 s)2
The stress concentration factor for shearing QJ is defined as
( 3,8399 + 25,0444 w 70,5571 w2 +
the ratio of the maximum value of the shear stress occurring
87,0328 w3 39,1832 w4)
in the journal fillet under bending load to the value of the
nominal shear stress related to the web cross-section. f1(w) : 2,1790 w0,7171
Where the above stress concentration factors cannot be f1(b) : 0,6840 0,0077 b + 0,1473 b2
obtained by reliable measurements, their values may be f1(r1) : 0,2081 r10,5231
evaluated by means of the formulae in [3.1.2] and [3.1.3], f1(d1) : 0,9978 + 0,3145 d1 1,5241 d12 + 2,4147 d13
which are applicable to crankpin fillets and journal fillets
for solid-forged crankshafts, and to the crankpin fillets only f1(d2) : 0,9993 + 0,27 d2 1,0211 d22 + 0,5306 d23
for semi-built crankshafts. f(t,s) : 1 + (t1 + t2) (1,8 + 3,2 s)

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 241


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

b) The value of the stress concentration factor for torsion The values of such additional bending stresses may be taken
TC may be calculated by the following formula: equal to the values B,ADD , in N/mm2, as shown in Tab 2.
TC = 0,8 f2(r1,s) f2(b) f2(w)
where: Table 2 : Additional bending stresses
f2(r1,s) : r1 with x = 0,322 + 0,1015 (1 s)
x

Type of engine B,ADD, in N/mm2


f2(b) : 7,8955 10,654 b + 5,3482 b2 0,857 b3
f2(w) : w0,145 Crosshead engine 30
Trunk piston engine 10
3.1.3 Journal fillets
a) The value of the stress concentration factor for bending
BJ may be calculated by the following formula: 5 Calculation of the equivalent
BJ = 2,7146 f3(s,w) f3(w) f3(b) f3(r2) f3(d1) f3(d2) f(t,s) alternating stress
where:
f3(s,w) : 1,7625 + 2,9821 w 1,5276 w2 5.1 General
+ (1 s) (5,1169 5,8089 w + 3,1391 w2)
+ (1 s)2 (2,1567 + 2,3297 w 1,2952 w2) 5.1.1 The equivalent alternating stress is to be calculated
f3(w) : 2,2422 w 0,7548 for the crankpin fillet as well as for the journal fillet.
f3(b) : 0,5616 + 0,1197 b + 0,1176 b2 For this calculation the theory of constant energy of distor-
f3(r2) : 0,1908 r20,5568 sion (von Misess Criterion) is to be used.
f3(d1) : 1,0022 0,1903 d1 + 0,0073 d12
Here it is assumed that the maximum alternating bending
f3(d2) : 1,0012 0,6441 d2 + 1,2265 d22 stresses and maximum alternating torsional stresses within a
f(t,s) : 1 + (t1 + t2) (1,8 + 3,2 s) crankshaft occur simultaneously and at the same point.
b) The value of the stress concentration factor for shearing
QJ may be calculated by the following formula: 5.2 Equivalent alternating stress
QJ = 3,0128 f4(s) f4(w) f4(b) f4(r2) f4(d1) f(t,s)
where: 5.2.1 The equivalent alternating stress is to be taken as the
f4(s) : 0,4368 + 2,1630 (1 s) 1,5212 (1 s) 2 greater of the two values E and E, calculated according
w to the formulae of a) and b) below.
f4(w) : ----------------------------------------------------
0 ,0637 + 0 ,9369 w
a) The equivalent alternating stress in way of the crankpin
f4(b) : 0,5 + b
fillet is to be taken equal to the value E, in N/mm 2, cal-
f4(r2) : 0,5331 r20,2038
culated by the following formula:
f4(d1) : 0,9937 1,1949 d1 + 1,7373 d12
2 0 ,5
' E = [ ( BC + B ,AD D ) + 3 C ]
2
f(t,s) : 1 + (t1 + t2) (1,8 + 3,2 s)
c) The value of the stress concentration factor for torsion b) The equivalent alternating stress in way of the journal
TJ may be calculated by the following formulae:
fillet is to be taken equal to the value ID, in N/mm2,
where dJ = dC and rJ = rC: calculated by the following formula:
TJ = TC
2 0 ,5
''E = [ ( B J + B ,A DD ) + 3 J ]
2
where dJ dC and/or rJ rC:
TJ = 0,8 f2(r1,s) f2(b) f2(w)
and f2(r1,s), f2(b) and f2(w) are to be determined in 6 Calculation of the fatigue strength
accordance with [3.1.2], but taking:
r1 = rJ / dJ
6.1
instead of r1 = rC / dC for the calculation of f2(r1,s).
6.1.1 The fatigue strength is to be understood as that value
4 Additional bending stresses of alternating bending stress which a crankshaft can perma-
nently withstand at the most highly stressed points of the fil-
4.1 lets between webs and pins.

4.1.1 In addition to the alternating bending stresses in fillets Where the fatigue strength for a crankshaft cannot be ascer-
(see [2.1.3]), further bending stresses due to misalignment, tained by reliable measurements, it may be taken equal to
bedplate deformation and axial and bending vibrations are the lower of the values F, ALL and F, ALL evaluated by
also to be considered. means of the formulae in a) and b) below.

242 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 1

a) The value of the allowable alternating bending fatigue 7.2 Minimum required oversize of shrink-fit
strength in way of the crankpin fillet may be taken equal
to the value F.ALL in N/mm2, calculated by the follow- 7.2.1 The minimum oversize required for the shrink-fit is
ing formula: determined by the greater of the values calculated in accor-
dance with [7.2.2] and [7.2.3].
' F ,A LL = K .R' m . ( 0 ,264 + 1 , 073 .dC + R'' m + R''' m .r C )
0 ,2 0 ,5

7.2.2 The value of the minimum required oversize of the


where: shrink-fit hMIN, in mm, is to be not less than that calculated
K : Factor for different types of forged and cast by the following formula for the crank throw with the abso-
steel crankshafts without surface treatment lute maximum torque MT,MAX.
of pins, whose value may be taken as fol- The above torque MT,MAX, in Nm, corresponds to the maxi-
lows: mum value of the torque for the various mass points of the
1,05 for continuous grain flow forged or crankshaft
drop-forged steel crankshafts 4 10 s F M T ,M AX
3
h M IN = ---------------- -------------------------
- f (Z)
1,00 for free form forged steel crankshafts EW dS LS
where:
0,93 for cast steel crankshafts
sF : safety factor against slipping; in no case is a
Rm : 0,42 Rm + 39,3 value less than 2 to be taken
: coefficient for static friction between the journal
785 R m and web surfaces, to be taken equal to 0,20, if
Rm : ----------------------
4900 LS / dS 0,40
Rm : 196 / Rm
1 Z A2 Z S2
f (Z) : --------------------------------------------
-
b) The value of the allowable alternating bending fatigue ( 1 Z A2 ) ( 1 Z S2 )
strength in way of the journal fillet may be taken equal ZA : dS / DE
to the value F,.ALL, in N/mm2, calculated by the follow-
ZS : dBJ / dS
ing formula:
7.2.3 In addition to the provisions of [7.2.2], the minimum
'' F ,ALL = K.R' m . ( 0 ,264 + 1 ,073 .d J )
0 ,2 0 ,5
+ R'' m + R''' m .r J
required oversize value hMIN, in mm, is not to be less than
For calculation of F,ALL and F,ALL, the values of rC and rJ that calculated according to the following formula:
are not to be taken less than 2 mm. RS ,M IN d S
h M IN = -----------------------
-
Where results of the fatigue tests conducted on full size EW
crank throws or crankshafts whose pins have been sub-
jected to surface treatment are not available, the factor K for 7.3 Maximum permissible oversize of
crankshafts without surface treatment of pins is to be used. shrink-fit
In all cases the experimental values of fatigue strength car-
7.3.1 The value of the maximum permissible oversize of
ried out with full size crank throws or crankshafts is to be
shrink-fit is not to be exceeded the value hMAX, in mm, cal-
submitted to the Society for consideration.
culated in accordance with the following formula:
The survival probability for fatigue strength values derived R S ,M IN d S 0 ,8 d S
from testing is to be to the satisfaction of the Society and in h M A X = -----------------------
- + --------------
EW 1000
principle not less than 80%.
This condition concerning the maximum permissible over-
size serves to restrict the shrinkage induced mean stress in
7 Calculation of shrink-fit of semi-built the journal fillet.
crankshafts
8 Acceptability criteria
7.1 General
8.1
7.1.1 Considering the radius of the transition rJ from the
journal diameter dJ to the shrink diameter dS, both the fol- 8.1.1 In order for the proposed crankshaft scantlings to be
lowing equations are to be respected: acceptable, the equivalent alternating stresses, calculated
both at crankpin and journal fillets, are to be such as to sat-
r J 0 ,015d J isfy the following conditions:
r J 0 ,5 ( d S d J ) 'F ,AL L
- 1 ,15
Q 1 = -------------
' E
The actual oversize h of the shrink-fit must be within the
limits hMIN and hMAX calculated in accordance with [7.2] F ,ALL
Q 2 = ------------------- 1 ,15
and [7.3] or according to recognized standards. E

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 243


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

APPENDIX 2 PLASTIC PIPES

1 General 2 Design of plastic piping systems

1.1 Application 2.1 General


1.1.1 These requirements are applicable to all piping sys- 2.1.1 Specification
tems with parts made of rigid plastic. The specification of the plastic piping is to be submitted in
The installation on naval ships of plastic pipes should be accordance with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 10, [1.2.2]. It is
avoid if not agreed by Society and Naval Authority. There- to comply with a recognised national or international stan-
fore the following provisions relevant to merchant ships are dard approved by the Society. In addition, the requirements
included for easy reference only. stated below are to be complied with.

2.1.2 Marking
1.2 Use of plastic pipes
Plastic pipes and fittings are to be permanently marked with
1.2.1 Plastic may be used in piping systems in accordance identification, including:
with the provisions of Ch 1, Sec 10, [2.1.3], provided the pressure ratings
following requirements are complied with. the design standards that the pipe or fitting is manufac-
tured in accordance with
1.2.2 Plastic pipes are to be type approved by the Society.
the material of which the pipe or fitting is made.

1.3 Definitions
2.2 Strength
1.3.1 Plastic
2.2.1 General
Plastic includes both thermoplastic and thermosetting plas-
tic materials with or without reinforcement, such as PVC a) The piping is to have sufficient strength to take account
and FRP (reinforced plastics pipes). of the most severe concomitant conditions of pressure,
temperature, the weight of the piping itself and any
1.3.2 Piping systems static and dynamic loads imposed by the design or envi-
Piping systems include the pipes, fittings, joints, and any ronment.
internal or external liners, coverings and coatings required b) The maximum permissible working pressure is to be
to comply with the performance criteria. specified with due regard for the maximum possible
working temperature in accordance with manufacturers
1.3.3 Joints recommendations.
Joints include all pipe assembling devices or methods, such
as adhesive bonding, laminating, welding, etc. 2.2.2 Permissible pressure
Piping systems are to be designed for a nominal pressure
1.3.4 Fittings determined from the following conditions:
Fittings include bends, elbows, fabricated branch pieces,
a) Internal pressure
etc. made of plastic materials.
The nominal internal pressure is not to exceed the
1.3.5 Nominal pressure smaller of:
Nominal pressure is the maximum permissible working Psth/4
pressure which is to be determined in accordance with Plth/2,5
[2.2.2].
where:
1.3.6 Design pressure Psth : Short-term hydrostatic test failure pressure,
Design pressure is the maximum working pressure which is in MPa
expected under operation conditions or the highest set pres- Plth : Long-term hydrostatic test failure pressure
sure of any safety valve or pressure relief device on the sys- (>100 000 hours), in MPa.
tem, if fitted. b) External pressure (to be considered for any installation
1.3.7 Fire endurance subject to vacuum conditions inside the pipe or a head
of liquid acting on the outside of the pipe)
Fire endurance is the capability of the piping system to per-
form its intended function, i.e. maintain its strength and The nominal external pressure is not to exceed Pcol/3,
integrity, for some predicted period of time while exposed where:
to fire. Pcol : Collapse pressure.

244 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

c) The collapse pressure is not to be less than 0,3 MPa. b) Surface flame characteristics are to be determined using
Note 1: The external pressure is the sum of the vacuum inside the the procedure given in IMO Res. A.653(16) with regard
pipe and the static pressure head outside the pipe. to the modifications due to the curvilinear pipe surfaces
as listed in Appendix 3 of Res. A.753(18).
2.2.3 Permissible temperature
c) Surface flame spread characteristics may also be deter-
a) In general, plastic pipes are not to be used for media
mined using the text procedures given in ASTM D635,
with a temperature above 60C or below 0C, unless
or other national equivalent standards.
satisfactory justification is provided to the Society.
b) The permissible working temperature range depends on 2.3.3 Fire protection coating
the working pressure and is to be in accordance with Where a fire protective coating of pipes and fittings is nec-
manufacturers recommendations. essary for achieving the fire endurance level required, it is
c) The maximum permissible working temperature is to be to meet the following requirements:
at least 20C lower than the minimum heat distortion
The pipes are generally to be delivered from the manu-
temperature of the pipe material, determined according
facturer with the protective coating on.
to ISO 75 method A or equivalent.
The fire protection properties of the coating are not to be
d) The minimum heat distortion temperature is not to be
diminished when exposed to salt water, oil or bilge
less than 80C.
slops. It is to be demonstrated that the coating is resistant
2.2.4 Axial strength to products likely to come into contact with the piping.
a) The sum of the longitudinal stresses due to pressure, In considering fire protection coatings, such characteris-
weight and other loads is not to exceed the allowable tics as thermal expansion, resistance against vibrations
stress in the longitudinal direction. and elasticity are to be taken into account.
b) In the case of fibre reinforced plastic pipes, the sum of The fire protection coatings are to have sufficient resis-
the longitudinal stresses is not to exceed half of the tance to impact to retain their integrity.
nominal circumferential stress derived from the nominal
internal pressure condition (see [2.2.2]). 2.3.4 Electrical conductivity
a) Piping systems conveying fluids with a conductivity less
2.2.5 Impact resistance
than 1000 pS/m (1pS/m=10-9 siemens per meter), such
Plastic pipes and joints are to have a minimum resistance to
as refined products and distillates, are to be made of
impact in accordance with a recognised national or interna-
conductive pipes.
tional standard.
b) Regardless of the fluid to be conveyed, plastic pipes
2.3 Requirements depending on service passing through hazardous areas are to be electrically
conductive.
and/or location
c) Where electrical conductivity is to be ensured, the resis-
2.3.1 Fire endurance tance of the pipes and fittings is not to exceed:
The requirements for fire endurance of plastic pipes and
1 x 105 Ohm/m.
their associated fittings are given in Tab 1 for the various
systems and locations where the pipes are used. d) Where pipes and fittings are not homogeneously con-
Specifically: ductive, conductive layers are to be provided, suitably
protected against the possibility of spark damage to the
a 60 min fire endurance test in dry conditions is to be
pipe wall.
carried out according to Appendix 1 of IMO Res.
A.753(18), where indicated L1 in Tab 1
a 30 min fire endurance test in dry conditions is to be
2.4 Pipe and fitting connections
carried out according to Appendix 1 of IMO Res.
2.4.1 General
A.753(18), where indicated L2 in Tab 1
a 30 min fire endurance test in wet conditions is to be a) The strength of connections is not to be less than that of
carried out according to Appendix 1 of IMO Res. the piping system in which they are installed.
A.753(18), where indicated L3 in Tab 1 b) Pipes and fittings may be assembled using adhesive-
no fire endurance test is required, where indicated 0 bonded, welded, flanged or other joints.
in Tab 1 c) When used for joint assembly, adhesives are to be suit-
a metallic material with a melting point greater than able for providing a permanent seal between the pipes
925C is to be used, where indicated X in Tab 1. and fittings throughout the temperature and pressure
Note 1: NA means not applicable. range of the intended application.

2.3.2 Flame spread d) Tightening of joints, where required, is to be performed


in accordance with the manufacturers instructions.
a) All pipes, except those fitted on open decks and within
tanks, cofferdams, pipe tunnels and ducts, are to have e) Procedures adopted for pipe and fitting connections are
low spread characteristics not exceeding average values to be submitted to the Society for approval, prior to
listed in IMO Resolution A.653(16). commencing the work.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 245


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

Table 1 : Fire endurance of piping systems

LOCATION
Coffer- Accommo-
Other
Other dams, void dation,
PIPING Machinery machinery Cargo Ro/ro Fuel Ballast
dry Cargo spaces, service Open
SYSTEM spaces of spaces and pump cargo oil water
cargo tanks pipe and decks
category A pump rooms holds tanks tanks
holds (16) tunnels control (21)
(11) rooms (13) (14) (17) (18)
(15) and ducts spaces
(12)
(19) (20)
CARGO (FLAMMABLE CARGOES WITH FLASH POINT 60C)
Cargo lines NA NA L1 NA NA 0 NA 0 (10) 0 NA L1 (2)
Crude oil
NA NA L1 NA NA 0 NA 0 (10) 0 NA L1 (2)
washing lines
Vent lines NA NA NA NA NA 0 NA 0 (10) 0 NA X
INERT GAS
Water seal 0 0 0 0 0
NA NA NA NA NA 0
effluent line (1) (1) (1) (1) (1)
Scrubber 0 0 0 0
NA NA NA NA NA NA 0
effluent line (1) (1) (1) (1)
Main line 0 0 L1 NA NA NA NA NA 0 NA L1 (6)
Distribution line NA NA L1 NA NA 0 NA NA 0 NA L1 (2)
FLAMMABLE LIQUIDS (FLASH POINT > 60C)
Cargo lines X X L1 X X NA (3) 0 0 (10) 0 NA L1
Fuel oil X X L1 X X NA (3) 0 0 0 L1 L1
Lubricating oil X X L1 X X NA NA NA 0 L1 L1
Hydraulic oil X X L1 X X 0 0 0 0 L1 L1
SEA WATER (1)
Bilge main and
L1 (7) L1 (7) L1 X X NA 0 0 0 NA L1
branches
Fire main and
L1 L1 L1 X NA NA NA 0 0 X L1
water spray
Foam system L1 L1 L1 NA NA NA NA NA 0 L1 L1
Sprinkler system L1 L1 L3 X NA NA NA 0 0 L3 L3
Ballast L3 L3 L3 L3 X 0 (10) 0 0 0 L2 L2
Cooling water,
essential L3 L3 NA NA NA NA NA 0 0 NA L2
services
Tank cleaning
services, fixed NA NA L3 NA NA 0 NA 0 0 NA L3 (2)
machines
Non-essential
0 0 0 0 0 NA 0 0 0 0 0
systems
FRESH WATER
Cooling water,
essential L3 L3 NA NA NA NA 0 0 0 L3 L3
services
Condensate
L3 L3 L3 0 0 NA NA NA 0 0 0
return
Non-essential
0 0 0 0 0 NA 0 0 0 0 0
systems

246 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

LOCATION
Coffer- Accommo-
Other
Other dams, void dation,
PIPING Machinery machinery Cargo Ro/ro Fuel Ballast
dry Cargo spaces, service Open
SYSTEM spaces of spaces and pump cargo oil water
cargo tanks pipe and decks
category A pump rooms holds tanks tanks
holds (16) tunnels control (21)
(11) rooms (13) (14) (17) (18)
(15) and ducts spaces
(12)
(19) (20)
SANITARY, DRAINS, SCUPPERS
Deck drains L1 L1 L1
NA 0 NA 0 0 0 0 0
(internal) (4) (4) (4)
Sanitary drains
0 0 NA 0 0 NA 0 0 0 0 0
(internal)
Scuppers and 0 0 0 0 0 0
discharges (1) (1) (1) (1) (1) 0 0 0 0 (1) 0
(over-board) (8) (8) (8) (8) (8) (8)
SOUNDING, AIR
Water tanks, dry 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
spaces (10)
Oil tanks (flash X 0
X X X X X 0 0 X X
point > 60C) (3) (10)
MISCELLANEOUS
Control air L1 (5) L1 (5) L1 (5) L1 (5) L1 (5) NA 0 0 0 L1 (5) L1 (5)
Service air
0 0 0 0 0 NA 0 0 0 0 0
(non-essential)
Brine 0 0 NA 0 0 NA NA NA 0 0 0
Auxiliary low
0 0 0 0 0
steam pressure L2 L2 0 0 0 0
(9) (9) (9) (9) (9)
( 0,7 MPa)
(1) Where non-metallic piping is used, remote controlled valves to be provided at ship side (valve is to be controlled from outside
space).
(2) Remote closing valves to be provided at the cargo tanks.
(3) When cargo tanks contain flammable liquids with flash point > 60 C, 0 may replace NA or X.
(4) For drains serving only the space concerned, 0 may replace L1.
(5) When controlling functions are not required by the Rules, 0 may replace L1.
(6) For pipes between machinery space and deck water seal, 0 may replace L1.
(7) For passenger vessels, X is to replace L1.
(8) Scuppers serving open decks in positions 1 and 2, as defined in Pt B, Ch 1, Sec 2, are to be X throughout unless fitted at
the upper end with a means of closing capable of being operated from a position above the damage control deck in order to
prevent downflooding.
(9) For essential services, such as fuel oil tank heating and ships whistle, X is to replace 0.
(10) For tankers NA is to replace 0.
(11) Machinery spaces of category A are defined in Ch 1, Sec 1, [1.4.1].
(12) Spaces, other than category A machinery spaces and cargo pumps rooms, containing propulsion machinery, boilers, steam and
internal combustion engines, generators and major electrical machinery, pumps, oil filling stations, refrigerating, stabilising,
ventilation and air-conditioning machinery, and similar spaces, and trunks to such spaces.
(13) Spaces containing cargo pumps, and entrances and trunks to such spaces.
(14) Ro-ro cargo spaces and special category spaces are defined in Ch 4, Sec 1, [2].
(15) All spaces other than ro-ro cargo holds used for non-liquid cargo and trunks to such spaces.
(16) All spaces used for liquid cargo and trunks to such spaces.
(17) All spaces used for fuel oil (excluding cargo tanks) and trunks to such spaces.
(18) All spaces used for ballast water and trunks to such spaces.
(19) Empty spaces between two bulkheads separating two adjacent compartments.
(20) Accommodation spaces, service spaces and control stations are defined in Ch 4, Sec 1, [2].
(21) Open decks are defined in Ch 4, Sec 1, [2].

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 247


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

2.4.2 Bonding of pipes and fittings 3.3 Provision for expansion


a) The procedure for making bonds is to be submitted to the
Society for qualification. It is to include the following: 3.3.1 Suitable provision is to be made in each pipeline to
allow for relative movement between pipes made of plastic
materials used and the steel structure, having due regard to:
tools and fixtures the high difference in the coefficients of thermal expan-
joint preparation requirements sion
cure temperature deformations of the ships structure.
dimensional requirements and tolerances
3.3.2 Calculations of the thermal expansions are to take
acceptance criteria for the test of the completed into account the system working temperature and the tem-
assembly. perature at which the assembly is performed.
b) When a change in the bonding procedure may affect the
physical and mechanical properties of the joints, the 3.4 External loads
procedure is to be requalified.
3.4.1 When installing the piping, allowance is to be made
for temporary point loads, where applicable. Such allow-
3 Arrangement and installation of ance is to include at least the force exerted by a load (per-
plastic pipes son) of 100 kg at mid-span on any pipe of more than 100
mm nominal outside diameter.
3.1 General
3.4.2 Pipes are to be protected from mechanical damage
3.1.1 Plastic pipes and fittings are to be installed in accor- where necessary.
dance with the manufacturers guidelines.
3.5 Earthing
3.2 Supporting of the pipes
3.5.1 Where, in pursuance of [2.3.4], pipes are required to
3.2.1 be electrically conductive, the resistance to earth from any
point in the piping system is not to exceed 1 x 106 ohm.
a) Selection and spacing of pipe supports in shipboard sys-
tems are to be determined as a function of allowable 3.5.2 Where provided, earthing wires are to be accessible
stresses and maximum deflection criteria. for inspection.
b) The selection and spacing of pipe supports are to take
into account the following data: 3.6 Penetration of fire divisions and
pipe dimensions watertight bulkheads or decks
mechanical and physical properties of the pipe
3.6.1 Where plastic pipes pass through A or B class
material
divisions, arrangements are to be made to ensure that fire
mass of pipe and contained fluid endurance is not impaired. These arrangements are to be
external pressure tested in accordance with Recommendations for Fire Test
Procedures for A, B and F Bulkheads (IMO Resolu-
operating temperature
tion A754 (18) as amended).
thermal expansion effects
load due to external forces 3.6.2 When plastic pipes pass through watertight bulk-
heads or decks, the watertight integrity of the bulkhead or
thrust forces
deck is to be maintained. If the bulkhead or deck is also a
water hammer fire division and destruction by fire of plastic pipes may
vibrations cause the inflow of liquid from tanks, a metallic shut-off
maximum accelerations to which the system may be valve operable from above the damage control deck is to be
subjected. fitted at the bulkhead or deck.

Combinations of loads are also to be considered.


3.7 Systems connected to the hull
c) Support spacing is not to be greater than the pipe man-
ufacturers recommended spacing. 3.7.1 Bilge and sea water systems
a) Where, in pursuance of [2.3.1], plastic pipes are permit-
3.2.2 Each support is to evenly distribute the load of the
ted in bilge and sea water systems, the ship side valves
pipe and its content over the full width of the support. Mea-
required in Ch 1, Sec 10, [2.8] and, where provided, the
sures are to be taken to minimise wear of the pipes where
connecting pipes to the shell are to be made of metal in
they are in contact with the supports.
accordance with Ch 1, Sec 10, [2.1].
3.2.3 Heavy components in the piping system such as b) Ship side valves are to be provided with remote control
valves and expansion joints are to be independently sup- from outside the space concerned. See Tab 1, footnote
ported. (1).

248 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 2

3.7.2 Scuppers and sanitary discharges c) Alternatively, hydrostatic test failure pressure and col-
a) Where, in pursuance of [2.3.1], plastic pipes are permit- lapse pressure may be determined by a combination of
ted in scuppers and sanitary discharge systems con- tests and calculations, subject to the agreement of the
nected to the shell, their upper end is to be fitted with Society.
closing means operated from a position above the dam- d) After the impact resistance test, the specimen is to be
age control deck in order to prevent downflooding. See subjected to hydrostatic pressure equal to 2,5 times the
Tab 1, footnotes (1) and (8). design pressure for at least 1 hour.
b) Discharge valves are to be provided with remote control 4.1.3 Bonding qualification test
from outside the space concerned.
a) A test assembly is to be fabricated in accordance with
the procedure to be qualified. It is to consist of at least
3.8 Application of fire protection coatings one pipe-to-pipe joint and one pipe-to-fitting joint.
b) When the test assembly has been cured, it is to be sub-
3.8.1 Where necessary for the required fire endurance as
jected to a hydrostatic test pressure at a safety factor of
stated in [2.3.3], fire protection coatings are to be applied
2,5 times the design pressure of the test assembly, for
on the joints, after performing hydrostatic pressure tests of
the piping system. not less than one hour. No leakage or separation of
joints is allowed. The test is to be conducted so that the
3.8.2 The fire protection coatings are to be applied in joint is loaded in both longitudinal and circumferential
accordance with the manufacturers recommendations, directions.
using a procedure approved in each case. c) Selection of the pipes used for the test assembly is to be
in accordance with the following:
4 Certification, inspection and testing when the largest size to be joined is 200 mm nomi-
nal outside diameter or smaller, the test assembly is
of plastic piping to be the largest piping size to be joined.
when the largest size to be joined is greater than 200
4.1 Certification mm nominal outside diameter, the size of the test
assembly is to be either 200 mm or 25% of the larg-
4.1.1 Type approval est piping size to be joined, whichever is the greater.
Plastic pipes and fittings are to be of a type approved by the
Society for the intended use. For this purpose, the material 4.2 Workshop tests
tests required in [4.1.2] and, where applicable, the bonding
qualification test detailed in [4.1.3] are to be performed. 4.2.1 Each pipe and fitting is to be tested by the manufac-
turer at a hydrostatic pressure not less than 1,5 times the
4.1.2 Material tests nominal pressure.
a) Tests are to be performed according to a procedure
approved by the Society to determine, for each type of 4.2.2 The manufacturer is to have quality system that meets
pipe and fitting, the following characteristics: ISO 9000 series standards or equivalent.
The quality system is to consist of elements necessary to
short-term and long-term design strength
ensure that pipes and fittings are produced with consistent
collapse and uniform mechanical and physical properties.
impact resistance
4.2.3 In case the manufacturer does not have an approved
fire endurance quality system complying with ISO 9000 series or equiva-
low flame spread characteristics lent, pipes and fittings are to be tested in accordance with
these requirements to the Surveyors satisfaction for every
electrical resistance (for electrically conductive
batch of pipes.
pipes).
For the above tests, representative samples of pipes and 4.3 Testing after installation on board
fittings are to be selected to the satisfaction of the Society.
In special cases, at the discretion of the Society, the 4.3.1 Hydrostatic testing
required tests will be specially considered on a case by a) Piping systems for essential systems are to be subjected
case basis. to a test pressure of not less than 1,5 times the design
b) The strength of pipes is to be determined by means of a pressure or 0,4 MPa, whichever is the greater.
hydrostatic test on pipe samples subjected to increasing b) Piping systems for non-essential services are to be
pressure up to failure, the pressure being increased at checked for leakage under operational conditions.
such a rate that failure occurs in not less than 5 minutes.
Such test is to be carried out under the standard condi- 4.3.2 Earthing test
tions: atmospheric pressure equal to 100kPa, relative For piping required to be electrically conductive, earthing is
humidity 30%, environmental and carried fluid temper- to be checked and random resistance testing is to be per-
ature 298 K (25C). formed.

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 249


Pt C, Ch 1, App 3

APPENDIX 3 INDEPENDENT FUEL OIL TANKS

1 General 1.3.2 Stiffeners


The following symbols and units are used for the stiffeners:
1.1 Application b : Width of the plating element supported by the
stiffener, in m
1.1.1 w : Section modulus of the stiffeners, in cm3.
a) The provisions of this Appendix apply to fuel oil tanks
and bunkers which are not part of the ships structure. 2 Design and installation of tanks
b) Requirements for scantling apply only to steel tanks.
Scantling of tanks not made of steel will be given special 2.1 Materials
consideration.
2.1.1 General
1.2 Documents to be submitted Independent fuel oil tanks are to be made of steel except
where permitted in [2.1.2].
1.2.1 Constructional drawings of the tanks are to be sub-
mitted, showing the height of the overflow and air pipe 2.1.2 Use of materials other than steel
above the top of the tank. a) On ships of less than 100 tons gross tonnage, indepen-
dent fuel oil tanks may be made of:
1.3 Symbols and units aluminium alloys or equivalent material, provided
that the tanks are located outside the propulsion
1.3.1 Tanks machinery spaces or, when located within such
The meaning of the symbols used for tanks is given in Fig 1. spaces, they are insulated to A-60 class standard
glass reinforced plastics (GRP), provided:
L : Greater length of the considered plating ele-
ment, in m - the total volume of tanks located in the same
space does not exceed 4,5 m3, and
l : Smaller length of the considered plating ele-
ment, in m - the properties of GRP including fire resistance
comply with the relevant provisions of Ch 1,
H : Height, in m, of the overflow or air pipe above
App 3.
the lower edge of the considered plating ele-
ment b) On ships of 100 tons gross tonnage or more, the use of
independent fuel oil tanks made of aluminium alloys or
h : Height, in m, of overflow or air pipe above the
GRP will be given special consideration.
top of the tank, subject to a minimum of:
3,60 m for fuel oil having a flash point
2.2 Scantling of steel tanks
below 60C
2,40 m otherwise. 2.2.1 General
a) The scantling of tanks whose dimensions are outside the
Figure 1 : Symbols used for tanks range covered by the following provisions will be given
special consideration.
b) The scantling of the tanks is to be calculated assuming a
minimum height h of the overflow or air pipe above the
h

top of the tank of:


3,60 m for fuel oil having a flash point below 60C,
2,40 m otherwise.
H

b
c) All tanks having plating elements of a length exceeding
b

2,5 m are to be fitted with stiffeners.


l

2.2.2 Thickness of plating


The thickness of the plates is not to be less than the value
given in Tab 1 for the various values of l, L/l and H. How-
l L ever, for tanks having a volume of more than 1 m 3, the
thickness of the plates is not to be less than 5 mm.

250 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011


Pt C, Ch 1, App 3

Table 1 : Thickness of plating (mm)

H (m)
2,4 - 2,7 - 3,0 - 3,3 - 3,6 - 4,0 - 4,4 - 4,8 - 5,2 - 5,8 - 6,4 - 7,0 - 8,0 - 9,0 -
l (m) L/l 2,7 3,0 3,3 3,6 4,0 4,4 4,8 5,2 5,8 6,4 7,0 8,0 9,0 10,0
<2 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5
0,40
2 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5
<2 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 5,0
0,45
2 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,0
<2 3,0 3,0 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5 7,0
0,50
2 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5 7,0
<2 3,5 3,5 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0
0,55
2 4,0 4,5 4,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 7,0 7,5
<2 3,5 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5
0,60
2 4,5 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5 8,0
<2 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 7,0
0,65
2 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,5 8,5
<2 4,0 4,0 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5
0,70
2 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
<2 4,5 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5 8,0
0,75
2 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
<2 4,5 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,0 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5
0,80
2 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
<2 5,0 5,0 5,5 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
0,85
2 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,0 8,5 9,0
<2 5,0 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
0,90
2 6,5 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5 8,5 9,0
<2 5,5 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
0,95
2 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0 9,0
<2 5,5 6,0 6,0 6,5 7,0 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,0 8,5 9,0
1,00
2 7,0 7,5 7,5 8,0 8,5 8,5 9,0

2.2.3 Scantlings of stiffeners 2.3 Installation


a) This requirement applies only to stiffeners which are all
vertical or all horizontal and attached according to the 2.3.1 Securing
types shown in Fig 2. Other cases will be given special Independent tanks are to be securely fixed to hull structures
consideration. and are to be so arranged as to permit inspection of adja-
b) The minimum values of the ratio w/b required for stiff- cent structures.
eners are given in: 2.3.2 Protection against spillage
Tab 2 for vertical stiffeners Where permitted, independent fuel oil tanks are to be
Tab 3 for horizontal stiffeners placed in an oil-tight spill tray of ample size with a suitable
for the different types of attachments shown in Fig 2. drain pipe leading to a suitably sized spill oil tank.

Figure 2 : Type of stiffener end attachments

Group I
Group II
H

Stiffener with Stiffener welded Stiffener with


brackets at upper at upper and lower scarfed ends
L
L
L

and lower ends ends

November 2011 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships 251


Pt C, Ch 1, App 3

Table 2 : Values of w/b ratio for vertical stiffeners (cm3/m)

end H, in m (1)
L (m)
attachment 3,0 3,3 3,6 3,9 4,3 4,6 5,0 5,5 6,0 7,0 8,0 9,0 10,0
0,6 I 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,5 7,5 8,0 9,0 9,5 10,5 11,5 14,0 16,0 18,0
II 8,0 9,0 10,0 11,0 12,0 12,5 13,0 15,0 16,0 19,0 22,0 25,0 28,0
0,8 I 8,5 9,5 10,5 11,5 13,0 14,0 15,0 16,5 18,0 22,0 25,0 28,0 31,5
II 13,0 15,0 16,0 18,0 20,0 21,5 24,0 25,5 28,5 34,0 38,0 43,0 48,0
1,0 I 14,5 16,0 17,5 19,5 21,0 23,0 26,0 28,5 34,0 38,0 43,0 49,0
II 22,0 24,0 27,0 30,0 32,5 36,0 39,0 43,0 51,0 58,0 67,0 75,0
1,2 I 22,5 24,5 28,0 30,0 33,0 37,0 40,5 48,0 55,0 63,0 71,0
II 34,0 30,7 42,5 46,0 50,0 55,0 61,0 73,0 84,0 96,0 107
1,4 I 30,0 32,5 37,0 40,0 44,0 49,0 55,0 65,0 75,0 85,0 96,0
II 45,0 49,0 56,0 61,0 67,0 74,0 82,0 98,0 113,0 129,0 144,0
1,6 I 47,0 53,0 57,0 64,0 71,0 79,0 94,0 110,0 125,0 140,0
II 71,0 80,0 87,0 96,0 107,0 118,0 141,0 165,0 187,0
I 58,0 65,0 71,0 79,0 88,0 98,0 117,0 136,0 156,0 175,0
1,8
II 87,0 98,0 107,0 118,0 132,0 147,0 176,0 204,0
I 78,0 85,0 95,0 107,0 119,0 142,0 166,0 190,0
2,0
II 118,0 129,0 142,0 160,0 178,0
I 100,0 112,0 126,0 140,0 170,0 198,0
2,2
II 151,0 168,0 190,0
I 124,0 139,0 158,0
2,5
II 187,0
(1) H is to be taken equal to the height of the tank top above the lower end of the stiffener, plus h.

Table 3 : Values of w/b ratio for horizontal and top and bottom stiffeners (cm 3/m)

end H, in m (1)
L
attach-
(m) 2,4 2,6 2,8 3,0 3,3 3,6 3,9 4,3 4,6 5,0 5,5 6,0 7,0 8,0 9,0 10,0
ment
0,6 I 4,5 5,0 5,5 6,0 6,5 7,0 7,5 8,5 9,0 10,0 11,0 12,0 13,5 15,0 17,0 19,0
II 7,0 8,0 8,5 9,0 10,0 11,0 11,5 12,5 13,5 15,0 16,0 17,5 21,0 24,0 27,0 30,0
0,8 I 8,0 9,0 9,5 10,0 11,0 12,0 13,0 14,5 15,5 17,0 18,5 20,0 23,5 27,0 30,0 33,5
II 13,0 15,0 15,5 16,5 18,0 19,5 21,5 23,5 25,0 27,0 30,0 34,0 38,0 44,0 49,0 55,0
1,0 I 13,0 15,0 15,5 16,5 18,0 19,5 21,5 23,5 25,0 27,0 30,0 34,0 38,0 44,0 49,0 55,0
II 20,0 22,0 23,5 25,0 28,0 30,0 33,0 36,0 39,0 42,0 46,0 50,0 59,0 67,0 75,0 84,0
1,2 I 18,0 20,0 21,0 22,5 25,0 26,5 29,5 32,5 34,5 37,5 41,5 45,0 52,5 60,0 67,5 75,0
II 28,0 31,0 33,0 35,0 39,0 42,0 46,0 51,0 54,0 59,0 65,0 70,0 82,0 93,0 105 117
1,4 I 26,0 28,0 30,5 32,5 36,0 39,0 42,5 46,5 50,0 54,5 59,5 65,0 76,0 87,0 97,0 108
II 39,0 43,0 45,5 49,0 54,0 58,5 63,5 70,0 75,0 81,0 89,0 97,0 113 130 146 162
1,6 I 36,0 39,0 42,0 45,0 50,0 54,0 59,0 65,0 69,0 75,0 82,0 90,0 105 120 135 150
II 56,0 61,0 66,0 70,0 77,0 84,0 91,0 100 107 117 128 140 163 186
1,8 I 46,0 50,0 54,0 58,0 63,0 69,0 75,0 82,0 88,0 95,0 105 115 134 153 172 191
II 70,0 76,0 82,0 88,0 96,0 105 113 125 134 146 160 175 204
2,0 I 57,0 62,0 67,0 72,0 78,0 85,0 92,0 102 109 118 130 142 166 190
II 87,0 95,0 102 109 120 130 141 155 166 181 198
2,2 I 70,0 76,0 82,0 88,0 96,0 105 113 125 134 145 160 175 204
II 107 116 125 134 147 160 174 192 205
2,5 I 92,0 100 108 115 127 138 150 165 176 191
II 140 152 163 175 192
(1) For horizontal stiffeners, H is to be measured from the horizontal stiffener immediately below the stiffener considered.
For top stiffeners, H = h.

252 Bureau Veritas Rules for Naval Ships November 2011

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi