Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
www.trainingmag.com
$35
NOVEMBER/
DECEMBER
2015
How
Does
Your
Salary
Stack
Up?
Average trainer
salaries in 2014-
2015 increased
nearly 3 percent to
$83,494, according
to Training research
PLUS: 2015 Training Industry Report
Exclusive: Inside AAMCO University
2015 Ttv Award Winners
Get your managers
coaching, and
everybody wins.
Trainers, training managers:
Increase the return on your training
investments by arming your managers
to continually reinforce and expand on
WKHOHDUQLQJGHOLYHUHGLQIRUPDOWUDLQLQJ
NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2015
NOVEMB VOLUME 52, NUMBER 6
50 AAMCO Overhauls Its Training Strategy 70 Talent Tips Crossing Bridges to Real Learning
An inside look at the new AAMCO University training
facility and insights from senior leaders about the com-
BY ROY SAUNDERSON
72 Last Word Show Me the Money!
panys revamped training strategy. BY LORRI FREIFELD BY AJAY M. PANGARKAR AND TERESA KIRKWOOD
&29(5$576(5*(<1,9(166+877(5672&.&20
7UDLQLQJ
!"#$%$&'($'$&%)*&$&% +$&,)-& +$%)(' (%)-." "#&)/,"& $'
0#&)1,#&%
2$34 + $5& 2266%&."%2$34 + $5& 226 778'!-0' +''$ +
7-&."&&0 -''$,&"'&$"9:;<
:6$'$ $', ;=5><$' :$"&,'"&'.,%&,:!,"($'$&%)*&$&%:7$'
0#&)1,#&:7 '.$' $' '.6$;;77
IRUVXEVFULSWLRQV3HULRGLFDOVSRVWDJHSDLGDW0LQQHDSROLV01DQGDGGLWLRQDOPDLOLQJRIFHV&DQDGD3RVW3XEOLFDWLRQV0DLO$JUHHPHQW1R5HWXUQXQGHOLYHUDEOH&DQDGLDQDGGUHVVHVWR
'+/*OREDO0DLO:DONHU5RDG:LQGVRU211$-3ULQWHGLQ86$32670$67(56HQGDGGUHVVFKDQJHVWR7UDLQLQJ32%R[([FHOVLRU01
www.trainingmag.com
Your source for more training tips, trends, and tools
Corporate: 952.401.1283 Subscriptions: 847.559.7596
Website: www.trainingmag.com
EDITORIAL:
Editor-in-Chief Lorri Freifeld 516.524.3504
lorri@trainingmag.com
On www.trainingmag.com, the online
Research DirectorSaul Carliner
home of Training magazine, youll nd saulcarliner@hotmail.com
these Web-only articles. Send your Contributing Editor Margery Weinstein
feedback to lorri@trainingmag.com. margery@trainingmag.com
Columnists Neal Goodman, Kendra Lee,
Neil Orkin, Bob Pike,
Peter Post, Michael Rosenthal,
Roy Saunderson, Jason Womack
Art Director David Diehl 646.932.3402
daviddiehldesign@gmail.com
The Stay Interview: What Can I Do to Keep You? Webmaster Matt Tews 763.712.8555
matt@trainingmag.com
Re-recruiting has become as important as recruiting.
SALES & MARKETING:
And it should start the moment the new hire says, Yes! Publisher Mike Murrell 952.401.1283
http://www.trainingmag.com/stay-interview-what-can-i-do-keep-you mike@trainingmag.com
Account Executive Gary Dworet 561.245.8328
3 Steps to Reward and Retain Your Top Performers gary@trainingmag.com
Making sure the compensation plan adequately differentiates Account Executive Lori Gardner 952.544.6906
high performance from average and low performance is critical lori@trainingmag.com
to supporting a sales-oriented culture. Sales Associate Payton Powell 612.978.4195
http://www.trainingmag.com/3-steps-reward-and-retain-your-top- payton@trainingmag.com
performers Digital Marketing Manager Jeremy Tews
jeremy@trainingmag.com
Art Director/Promotions Susan Abbott
Design Training to Impact 3 Critical Organizational Dynamics susan@abbottandabbott.com
Those key dynamics are: the individual, the quality of relationships
Production Manager Tony Kolars
that individual has within the business, and the mechanisms within tony@trainingmag.com
the organization. Audience Marketing Director Vicki Blomquist
http://www.trainingmag.com/design-training-impact-3-critical- vicki@trainingmag.com
organizational-dynamics CORPORATE & EVENTS:
President Mike Murrell 952.401.1283
mike@trainingmag.com
Virtually There: Learner Engagement
in the Modern Classroom VP, Finance/Operations Bryan Powell 612.922.9399
bryan@trainingmag.com
Learner engagement turns on three factors: an emotional response
VP, Market Strategy Philip Jones 612.354.3525
to the training; an intellectual response to the training; and an phil@trainingmag.com
environmental response to the learning.
VP, Expositions Dick Powell 952.417.6504
http://www.trainingmag.com/virtually-there-learner-engagement- dick@trainingmag.com
modern-classroom Brand Products Director Joyceann Cooney-Garippa
917.923.8052
Interested in writing an online article for www.trainingmag.com? jcooney@trainingmag.com
E-mail Editor-in-Chief Lorri Freifeld at lorri@trainingmag.com.
Conference Director Julie Groshens
julie@trainingmag.com
FOLLOW US ONLINE HERE: Conference Manager Leah Nelson
leah@trainingmag.com
Twitter: @TrainingMagUS @LorriFreifeld
SUBSCRIBER/ADVERTISER SERVICES:
LinkedIn: http://goo.gl/oHokF Copyright Permissions Copyright Clearance Center
(Print & Online) 978.750.8400; info@copyright.com
Facebook: Facebook.com/TrainingMagazine
Custom Reprints The YGS Group, Anastasia Stover
YouTube: YouTube.com/TrainingMagUS
(Print & PDF/Digital) 717.430.2268
Google+: GPlus.to/TrainingMagazine anastasia.stover@theygsgroup.com
List Rental Manager TriMax, Paul Kolars 651.292.0165
pkolars@trimaxdirect.com
Subscriber Customer Service 1.877.865.9361 or 847.559.7596
(Address Changes, Back Issues, ntrn@omeda.com
Renewals) Fax: 847.291.4816
Compliance?
Should I be Uh...
concerned What do I do?
about it?
I hate writing
out reports!
Roll out the RedCarpet with SilkRoad Life Suite. Deliver a smooth
connection from onboarding to learning and to performance. ONBOARDING
silkroad.com
Talent Acquisition | Talent Development | Talent Portal | HRMS
Copyright 2015, SilkRoad. All Rights Reserved. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
editors note
@/>/5A-@BC->A
6D-A5-
>
employees conducted by BizLibrary, respondents said video is Development Officer, Ernst & Young
more effective than instructor-led training (ILT), virtual class- Nancy J. Lewis, former CLO and VP, ITT
Corporation, and former VP, Learning, IBM
room sessions, and traditional click-and-advance e-learning
Ann Schulte, Director/Global Practice Leader,
when it comes to teaching new things, improving perfor- Procter & Gamble
mance, and preparing employees for the future (see p. 9). Ross Tartell, former Technical Training and
Employers do seem to be getting the message: According to Communication Manager - North America,
Training magazines 2015 Training Industry Report, video is GE Capital Real Estate
one of the most used training technologies (see p. 12 for training video tips). TRAINING TOP 10 HALL OF FAME
In other Industry Report news, we saw training expenditures soar 14.2 percent Cyndi Bruce, Executive Director,
to $70.6 billion in 2015 as mergers and acquisitions increased the number of large KPMG Business School U.S.
companies in the U.S. (see p. 20 for the full report). In keeping with that positive Gordon Fuller, Global Design & Development
trend, average training salaries rose 3 percent to $83,494 in 2014-2015, according to Leader, IBM Center for Advanced Learning
Daniel J. Goepp, Managing Director, Learning
Training magazines 2015 Salary Survey (see p. 40). We look at what a strengthening
& Development, PricewaterhouseCoopers, LLP
economy has meant for training investment on p. 34 and examine why only some Jennifer Hentz, Talent Development Manager,
organizations invest in their human capital as a key business strategy to improve Booz Allen Hamilton
their productivity, performance, and prots (see p. 38). Glenn Hughes, Senior Director, Learning &
One organization that recently made a signicant investment in training is car care Development, KLA-Tencor Corporation
company AAMCO. The company invested more than $1 million in a new learning Diana Oreck, VP, Leadership Center,
management system (LMS) and the creation of AAMCO University, a state-of-the- The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company
Myra Pettis, Director of Educational Service,
art training facility in Newnan, GA, that opened in February 2015. We view train-
SCC Soft Computer
ing as an investment, not a cost, explains Rob Rajkowski, COO. We wanted to Lou Tedrick, Staff Vice President -
align our training strategy with our ve-year plan and use training as a strategic Workforce Development, Verizon
foundation for growth. Rajkowski and other AAMCO leaders recently gave Train- Annette Thompson, CLO, Farmers Insurance
ing magazine an exclusive tour of the new facility and detailed their amped-up focus Nicole Roy-Tobin, Director, Best Practices &
on learning and developmentsee p. 50 for the full story. Innovation, Deloitte
As I write this Editors Note, Im watching Game 2 of the National League Champi- 2015 TOP 5
onship Series in which my beloved Mets are battling the Cubs for the chance to enter EMERGING TRAINING LEADERS
the World Series. I have to admit Im glad my Mets nally decided to invest in their Courtney Cordova, Director, Learning and
talent development this yearand even more glad to see it paying off! Hopefully, Development, Rush Enterprises
that magic continues for a few more games after we go to press Huligeshwari Devi, Learning Consultant and
Head - Enterprise Domain Learning, Tech Mahindra
Speaking of magic, I hope you will join me in Orlando February 15-17, 2016, for
Limited
our Training 2016 Conference & Expo (www.trainingconference.com). It promises to Rian Oosthuizen, Global Learning & Development
be an amazing event, where well imagine the possibilities and collaborate to inno- Consultant, Kimberly-Clark Corporation
vate with our Training Top 10 Hall of Famers and keynoters from Backyard Brains, Aaron Rollins, Director, Quality and Training,
Cirque du Soleil, and Pixar. Verisk Health
Best wishes for a happy, healthy, and magical holiday season. I look forward to Swarnasudha Selvaraj, Regional Head, Learning
seeing you in the Magic Kingdom next year! & Development, Tata Consultancy Services Ltd.
Lorri Freifeld
lorri@trainingmag.com
6 | NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2015 training www.trainingmag.com
Focused on learning.
Dedicated to
advanced technology.
Products & Services >> Savvy Online Searches Save Time >> Tech Talk p. 10
TO SUBMIT NEWS, research, or other Training Today tidbits, contact Editor-in-Chief Lorri Freifeld at lorri@trainingmag.com or 516.524.3504.
Become a Change Master By Bruce Tulgan >> Boeing acquired Peters Software
GmbH, a provider of European Aviation
www.rainmakerthinking.com | Twitter @brucetulgan | brucet@rainmakerthinking.com
Safety Agency (EASA)-based training
Theres nothing new about change. But there and managers with great track records of
content for early stage pilot training. Located
can be no doubt that the pace and scope successfully leading direct reports through
in Cologne, Germany, Peters Software
of change is greater now than ever before. mineelds of change. From these change
specializes in curriculum and materials for
People tell me every day about the pressure to masters, Ive learned what I call the three
commercial and private pilots operating in
adapt to changes at work: learning new skills, pillars of leading people through change:
rapidly growing markets aligned with EASA.
knowledge, wisdom; performing new tasks and 1. Remind yourself (and others) constantly
responsibilities; working with new machines, of whatever is constant. What is never >> Pearson is partnering with the Ariel
managers, co-workers, customers, and rules. going to change around here? Group to deliver a new online learning
There is so much literature on change 2. Engage in regular contingency and development service called Presence
leadershipimplementing lasting changes planningand encourage others to do Essentials that uses principles from actor
in systems, practices, and competencies so, as well. What is likely to change? training and empowers organizations
but not enough on leading people through Exactly what will we do if that happens? to improve employees communication
all these incessant changes that we couldnt Coach your people through practice runs skills and develop their presence in
stop if we tried. In the course of my work, of regularly recurring scenarios. the workplace. Presence is the ability
Ive come to know what I call change 3. When the unforeseen occurs, adapt and to make authentic connections through
masters over the years. That is, leaders improvise. What else can you do? dynamic communication.
R
ecently, I was asked to do some train-the- Urgent Not Urgent
trainer (T3) training on items that could help
a local group of professional trainers have Crying baby Exercise
more impact. Their coordinator told me I could Important Kitchen Fire Vocation
use a whole hour if I chose. Clearly, only the sparest Some calls Planning
of frameworks can be attempted in such a limited 1 2
time, but there are things that can be done. 3 4
Not Important
Interruptions Trivia
TIME MANAGEMENT Distractions Busy work
First, a bare-bones time management segment is Other calls Time wasters
essential. If the trainees are familiar with Coveys J.D. Wallace, Ph.D.,
Urgent/Important 2x2 table (see graphic at right), is the past co-chair
language can be accommodated. Typically, train- Source: Stephen Covey
of the National
ing developmental activities fall into the not for trainer receptivity might provide insights into
Communication
urgent but important category. This category prospective trainees level of motivation and abili-
Associations Training
includes items that are important but do not nec- ties. The trainers credibility is inuenced by factors
and Development
essarily require immediate attention and need such as rst impressions, either real or perceived
Division. He has
to be planned for. This quadrant is highlighted competency, and intentionally developing greater
been active in
because Covey emphasized this is the quadrant trust among the trainees.
we should focus on for long-term achievement Quality of training is enhanced by knowing objec- the governance
of goals. Some brief attention is needed so T3 tives and assessing impact. Only trainees can fully of the National
trainees shift developmental activities to the ur- determine training quality from a transfer perspec- Communication
gent and important category or expand time for tive. However, an often-overlooked category for Association, including
non-urgent but important activities. One or determining quality of training is audience match roles of senior
both of these are necessary to get beyond current making sure there is a match between the training leadership for both
procrastination or temporal barriers that prohibit and the ability for the trainees to receive it. the Training and
better quality training. The important thing here Development and
is to provide a catalyst to shift from the status quo. ADVANTAGES OF BOOT CAMP Human Communication
For those doing T3 training, RCQ boot camp can and Technology
RCQ ANALYSIS provide a nice framework into which the trainers Divisions. An award-
Once a more fertile time structure is provided, can insert developed material or solicit suggestions winning scholar and
then an RCQ analysis can help the trainer iden- from the trainees. For those teaching training, it teacher with numerous
tify the relevant areas that can enhance training provides a primer that can be used to kick-start consultations in
impact efciently. RCQ refers to receptivity of the training projects. The key here is to transfer a us- both for-prot and
trainees, credibility of the trainer, and quality of able framework that trainees can employ in their nonprot organizations,
the training. These are not mutually exclusive cat- current training. As such, the closer it is given to Dr. Wallace is
egories. For example, the credibility of the trainer actual training projects, the more likely it will be also a professor of
is going to affect the receptivity of the trainees. adopted in part or in total. It is not meant to re- Communication at
However, even an inexperienced trainer probably place more robust T3 designs, but it does provide
Abilene Christian
can think of accessible activities in one or more of a memorable structure that is exible enough to
University.
these three areas to improve training impact. accommodate various levels of experience around
Trainee receptivity certainly will have an impact a wide range of topics and audiences that can en-
on actual transfer. Aside from credibility, content hance current trainees impact. Qt
On-Camera Instruction
Leverage effective video for training with four core elements:
great message design; on-camera presence; visual staging;
and technical quality. #:%*"/"-)08-&4
V
ideo is on a roll. Over the last few years, matter experts. Another option is to develop
video creation has become as ubiquitous SMEs on-camera presentation skill sets.
as photography. Quick access to video
hosting platforms such as YouTube or Vimeo, 4 CORE ELEMENTS
along with affordable mobile devices with easy- Developing on-camera skills for instruction re-
to-use recording and editing capability, has quires a framework. Through my experience as
changed everything. According to YouTube, 300 a multimedia developer, on-camera talent, and
hours of online videos are uploaded to the site ev- presentation coach, Ive found it helpful to fo-
ery minute. Several sites, including curious.com, cus on a few core elements. In the model below,
now offer thousands of video tutorials. Online effective video begins with identifying the de-
%JBOB-)PXMFTis video is not only transforming the way we train sired goals. These goals inuence the four core
owner and president and communicate, but the way we learn. As Ara- elements of speaking on-camera, each of which
of Howles Associates, gon Research lead analyst Jim Lundy said earlier runs deep with underlying strategies and prin-
LLC, specializing this year, The future of learning is video-based. ciples. Each core element also can be used as a
in multimedia
As trainers and educators, we need to thought- rubric for skill development.
fully consider how to leverage video for
communication. As a
workplace learning in new, effective ways. Ac-
speaker, consultant,
cording to Elliott Masie, chair of The Learning
and trainer, she CONSORTIUM and president of The MASIE
provides workshops Center, Our employees increasingly are turning
and coaching on how to video as their medium of choice to access up-
to improve on-camera dated knowledge, skill development, corporate
presentations, visual storytelling, and even peer-to-peer social collab-
communication oration. Some organizations are even accessing
design, and virtual open-sourced (universal, free access) video con-
instruction. She has tent, or using online videos for corporate training,
worked as on-camera video-based learning modules, pre-work course
and voiceover talent,
material, and sharing corporate expertise.
If you havent already, you also may nd your-
and is an award-
self presenting on-camera. An increasing number
winning speaker
of subject matter experts (SMEs) and instructors
with more than 25 now use videos to explain concepts, model tasks,
years of experience and add a personal touch to online and blended
in training and learning. However, many professionals have lit-
education. Follow her tle background in video presentation. Like any
on Twitter other medium of communication used for in-
!%JBOB)PXMFT struction, videos require knowledge and skills to
or visit XXX be used effectively. If online videos are not de-
IPXMFTBTTPDJBUFT signed and delivered well, they may not have an MESSAGE DESIGN
DPN to learn more. impact on learning and performance, or worse, Content is inherently about message, so thats the
may not be watched at all. In some of Purdue place to start. Message design includes elements
Universitys online certication courses for life- such as capturing attention, conversational script-
long learners, research showed that students ing, supporting visuals, optimal length, and more.
preferred watching shorter videos of profession- Lets focus on two essential principles here:
al actors presenting content instead of subject t$IVOLWJEFPTJOUPGPVSNJOVUFTPSMFTT According
Focus on Myanmar
Myanmar learners are highly motivated to learn. After class, they asked for
additional reading material to better develop their skills. BY STEVE COYLE
ur Malaysia-based training company was the drivers drinking together. This was the
A Management Education
For Those Who Expect More
American Public University knows the value of strong management and
leadership skills. Learn talent development and other management strategies
for organizational success in a competitive business world. APU oers 190+
career-relevant online degree and certicate programs including:
*$"$!
#
*#
#
*!" !##"#"
#
BEST
ONLINE PROGRAMS
We want you to make an informed decision about the university thats right for you. For more about our graduation rates, the
BACHELORS
2015
median debt of students who completed each program, and other important information, visit www.apus.edu/disclosure.
Focus on Ireland
The Irish government champions and supports
training for its citizens. BY DR. NEIL ORKIN
reland is known for its beautiful scenery. Its quality, and leadership.
Imagine a world where the highest quality, Easy to find and quick to access
most respected training resources you need
Targeted and aligned to your development goals
at every stage of your career are:
Interactive, engaging, trackable, and shareable
Curated just for you
Join our community and discover what its like to have learning catered to your needs.
TM
Training Magazine Networks Path to Expertise (Path2X)
is your single source for all the resources and systems
Path2 you need to plan, measure, track, and share your learning
progress, credentialing, and goal achievement.
A personalized learning management system designed exclusively for training
professionals, Path2X allows you to chart your learning in key specific areas
validated by leading industry experts:
Create your learning path with a highly visual, dynamic interface
Find relevant resources at each step
Track, monitor, and share progress and accomplishments
Network with colleagues
TM
Training Magazine Networks Pinpoint
Interactive Webinars are on-demand, at-your-
INTERACTIVE WEBINARS
service learning unlike anything youve ever
experienced before.
Jump to the exact point of reference that addresses your specific needs, and
leave questions or comments for the presenters and other viewers to build your
knowledge. This is learning technology with a precision focus on your learning:
Search by content, topic, keyword, and desired action
Dive in exactly where you want to land
Learn from the most respected thought leaders and experts in the field
Ask questions and share insights
This is the place to be for all thats happening in L&D! The new
Training Magazine Network is a user-friendly portal to resources,
recorded webinars, discussion groups, white papers, and more
all the current intel! Plus, it gives you direct access to your
favorite speakers.
For every stage of your career, its personalized learning, at your service.
2O15 TRAINING
INDUSTRY
REPORT
ABOUT THIS STUDY
TRAINING EXPENDITURES
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Average training expenditures for large companies decreased XBT
GPSTNBMMDPNQBOJFT
JUXBT
GSPNNJMMJPOJOUPNJMMJPOJO
XIJMF For those who reported an increase in their training staff,
the numbers for small companies ($350,301 in 2015 vs. the average increase was nine people, ve more than in
JO
BOENJETJ[FDPNQBOJFT NJMMJPOJO 2014. For those who reported a decrease in their staff, the
2015 vs. $1.5 million in 2014) remained basically at. BWFSBHFEFDSFBTFXBTQFPQMFEPXOGSPNMBTUZFBS
4PNFQFSDFOUPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTTBJEUIFZJODSFBTFETUBGG Other training expenditures more than doubled this year to
from the year before (up from 35 percent in 2014), while CJMMJPOGSPNCJMMJPOJO4VDIFYQFOEJUVSFT
50 percent said the level remained the same (down from 51 DBOJODMVEFUSBWFM
USBJOJOHGBDJMJUJFT
BOEFRVJQNFOU0O
percent in 2014). Some 13 percent said it was lower vs. 14 average, organizations spent 5 percent of their budget or
percent in 2014. Large nonprots and services organizations
WT
MBTUZFBS
POMFBSOJOHUPPMTBOE
had the largest personnel costs. Across all organization technologies. Small and midsize education organizations
UZQFT
MBSHFSDPNQBOJFTTQFOUBCPVUUJNFTBTNVDIBT spent the highest portion of their budgets on tools and
midsize, and midsize companies spent about three times technology (23 percent and 11 percent, respectively).
as much as small ones. The average payroll gure for large -BSHFFEVDBUJPOPSHBOJ[BUJPOTBOEHPWFSONFOUNJMJUBSZ
DPNQBOJFTXBTNJMMJPOGPSNJETJ[FPSHBOJ[BUJPOT
JU organizations spent the smallest percentage of their training
$829
Midsize (1,000 to
$819
9,999 employees)
$544
$490
Large (10,000 or $903
more employees) $447
budgets on tools and technologies (1 percent or less). organizations, overall, spent the most per learner this
-PPLJOHBIFBE
UIFNPTUGSFRVFOUMZBOUJDJQBUFEQVSDIBTFT ZFBS
GPMMPXFECZNBOVGBDUVSFST
-BSHFS
BSFMFBSOJOHNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFNT QFSDFOUWT companies apparently are back to operating on an economy
QFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
BOEPOMJOFMFBSOJOHUPPMTBOETZTUFNT PGTDBMFBTUIFZTQFOUMFTT
UIBONJETJ[F
BOE
percent vs. 44 percent last year). This is followed by content small ($1,105) companies.
EFWFMPQNFOU QFSDFOUWTQFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
BVUIPSJOH 8IJMFUIFZTQFOUMFTTQFSMFBSOFS
DPNQBOJFTQSPWJEFENPSF
UPPMTTZTUFNT QFSDFOUWTQFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
hours of training this year. On average, employees received
classroom tools and systems (29 percent vs. 33 percent), IPVSTPGUSBJOJOHQFSZFBS
IPVSTNPSFUIBOMBTU
and mobile learning (25 percent vs. 23 percent last year). year. Midsize companies provided the most hours of training
Several items received 10 percent or less of hits, including UIJTZFBSBU(PWFSONFOUNJMJUBSZPSHBOJ[BUJPOTIBEUIF
8FC
BVEJFODFSFTQPOTFTZTUFNT
DVTUPNFSSFMBUJPOTIJQ IJHIFTUBWFSBHFOVNCFSPGIPVSTPWFSBMM
management, translation and localization, and enterprise $PNQBOJFTDPOUJOVFEUPEFWPUFUIFCVMLPGUIFJSUSBJOJOH
learning systems. expenditures to training non-exempt employees (39 percent,
0WFSBMM
POBWFSBHF
DPNQBOJFTTQFOUQFSMFBSOFS down from 40 percent in 2014). Training for exempt non-
UIJTZFBSDPNQBSFEXJUIQFSMFBSOFSJO4FSWJDF NBOBHFSTJODSFBTFEGSPNQFSDFOUUPQFSDFOUJO
TRAINING EXPENDITURES
30 29% 7.7
8
22% 6.4
6 5.8
20
4
10%
10
2
0 0
D!,"0 +$'$.&
'
' /0&$ " "
D!#" +$'$.& D!#" X&+ c
D!#" D#% 6#$'
0 0
/0&$ " " & /0&$X& " " "
X&2$&. #& #$
6#$' 6#$'
,#$'4$ /RZHU
:#' 4 +LJKHU
# c,#$'
$,$" $'$0&$.X 6DPH
Like last year, budget status was almost What Happened to Your
evenly split, with 42 percent saying Training Budget This Year?
their training budget increased and 43
percent saying it remained the same.
Some 15 percent reported a decrease
'HFUHDVHG
in budget. Last year, 43 percent said
UIFJSCVEHFUXFOUVQQFSDFOUTBJE ,QFUHDVHG
JUSFNBJOFEUIFTBNFBOEQFSDFOU
said it went down. Like last year,
FEVDBUJPOBOEHPWFSONFOUNJMJUBSZ 5HPDLQHG
organizations showed the greatest WKHVDPH
tendency for training budget cuts,
XIJMFTFSWJDFTDPNQBOJFT
SFUBJMFST
XIPMFTBMFST
BOENBOVGBDUVSFST
distributors all showed large gains.
Increases were not evenly distributed
across organization sizes. Small
companies showed fewer decreases
QFSDFOU
BOENPSFJODSFBTFT
QFSDFOU
UIBONJETJ[F QFSDFOUBOE
QFSDFOU
BOEMBSHFDPNQBOJFT
percent and 44 percent).
Most of the budget increases were Budget Change by Industry
NPEFTUMFTTUIBOQFSDFOU4PNF
QFSDFOUTBXJODSFBTFTJOUIFUP 16% Q1,&$
15 percent range, while 29 percent of .BOVGBDUVSFS%JTUSJCVUPS 43% Q
',&$
organizations reported increases in the 41% Q$#
1 to 5 percent range. Most respondents
10%
who reported an increase in their
Services 47%
training budgets attributed it to the 43%
following reasons:
11%
t*ODSFBTFJOUIFTDPQFPGUIFJS 3FUBJM8IPMFTBMF 44%
USBJOJOHQSPHSBNT QFSDFOUWT 44%
percent last year)
t"EEFEUSBJOJOHTUBGG QFSDFOUWT 27%
(PWFSONFOU.JMJUBSZ 24%
51 percent last year)
49%
t*ODSFBTFEOVNCFSPGMFBSOFSTTFSWFE
(55 percent vs. 51 percent last year) 28%
Education 31%
This year, more respondents (39 41%
percent) reported budget decreases
0%
between 1 and 5 percent vs. 25 percent
Association 0%
GPSUPQFSDFOUEFDSFBTFTBOE
100%
QFSDFOUGPSNPSFUIBOQFSDFOU
decreases. The majority of respondents 15%
(33 percent this year vs. 40 percent last Nonprot 44%
year) cited reduced training staff as the 41%
main reason for the budget decrease.
0 20 40 60 80 100
This was followed by:
TRAINING BUDGETS
NPSFGVOEJOHUIBOUIFZFBSCFGPSF0O
BWFSBHF
PSHBOJ[BUJPOTQMBOUPBMMPDBUF + c6#$'
UIFNPTUGVOEJOHUPQSPGFTTJPOBMJOEVTUSZ
TQFDJmDUSBJOJOHBUNJMMJPOPOCPBSEJOH +&>$'= 7=
BUNJMMJPOTBMFTUSBJOJOHBU
="= =
BOENBOBHFNFOUTVQFSWJTPSZUSBJOJOHBU
="= =
5IFIJHIFTUQSJPSJUJFTGPSUSBJOJOHJOUFSNTPG ="= =
BMMPDBUJOHSFTPVSDFTJOBSFJODSFBTJOH 0 10 20 30 40
UIFFGGFDUJWFOFTTPGUSBJOJOHQSPHSBNT
QFSDFOU
UIFTBNFBTMBTUZFBS
GPMMPXFE
CZSFEVDJOHDPTUTJNQSPWJOHFGmDJFODZ
2$&.6#$'
QFSDFOUWTQFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
BOE +&>$'= =
NFBTVSJOHUIFJNQBDUPGUSBJOJOHQSPHSBNT
="= 7=
QFSDFOUWTQFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
-JLF
MBTUZFBS
MFBSOJOHJOGSBTUSVDUVSFUFDIOPMPHZ ="= =
JOJUJBUJWFTBOEPCUBJOJOHSFWFOVFUISPVHI ="= 7=
FYUFSOBMUSBJOJOHSFNBJOUIFMPXFTUQSJPSJUJFT
0 10 20 30 40 50
#$6#$'
+&>$'= 31%
="= 13%
="= 18%
="= 38%
0 10 20 30 40
+ c6#$'
+&>$'= 19%
="= 19%
="= 31%
="= 31%
0 10 20 30
2$&.6#$'
+&>$'= 0%
="= 21%
="= 21%
="= 58%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
TRAINING BUDGETS
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q+&>$'2$"C$&Q-""$#$2$"C$&Q2>$'2$"C$&Q
)-
T R A I N I N G D E L I V E RY
Some 46 percent of training hours were delivered by a stand- learning accounted for 5 percent of hours, up a bit from
and-deliver instructor in a classroom settingdown a bit from 4.2 percent last year. Some 25 percent of companies said
the 47 percent reported last year. they are using social learning to some extent.
Large
PSNPSFFNQMPZFFT
=7;=;===7=
0 30 60 90 120 150
QB' 2$&''.$,#'$"'X#" " 4
Q
'"&,"&2 6$&#/'%
Q&"$6$&#)W,$"/'%'"&,"&X&#&#",$"'
Q/''&6#"&B$ +" /'%''"&,"&
Q+/'%,' "$" 1-
Q,$2$&''./'%
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q
/''Q-*4/''&.&$#Q#/''Q+"%/''Q-/''
#&,'"X"&$''.&4&
0& %$"$' $' 0&'"&,"&'
DFODVVURRPVHWWLQJ7KDWJXUHLVGRZQ
."%X&#";&,'"&&" $"
%$&#&,'"X,#$'$&
'.,$$&''."#!"'"
T R A I N I N G D E L I V E RY
#$6#$'
Podcasting ==7=
Online Performance Support or Knowledge Management System 7===
Rapid E-Learning Tool (PowerPoint conversion tool) 7===
Application Simulation Tool =;==
Virtual Classroom/Webcasting/Video Broadcasting =7=7=
Learning Content Management System (LCMS) =;==
Learning Management System (LMS) =7==
Mobile Applications 7=;=7=
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q,&&'"%Q1'"Q
"&
+ c6#$'
Podcasting =;==
Online Performance Support or Knowledge Management System =7==
Rapid E-Learning Tool (PowerPoint conversion tool) =7;==
Application Simulation Tool =7==
Virtual Classroom/Webcasting/Video Broadcasting ;===
Learning Content Management System (LCMS) =;;=;=
Learning Management System (LMS) ===
Mobile Applications =;==
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q,&&'"%Q1'"Q
"&
2$&.6#$'
Podcasting ===
Online Performance Support or Knowledge Management System =7==
Rapid E-Learning Tool (PowerPoint conversion tool) ;===
Application Simulation Tool ===
Virtual Classroom/Webcasting/Video Broadcasting ;==7=
Learning Content Management System (LCMS) ==;=
Learning Management System (LMS) ===
Mobile Applications 7=7==
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q,&&'"%Q1'"Q
"&
2015 saw only a slight increase in the average expenditure for MBSHFDPNQBOJFTQFSDFOUGPSNJETJ[FPOFTBOEQFSDFOU
USBJOJOHPVUTPVSDJOH
VQGSPN
JO for small organizations).
Large companies on average spent $1.1 million vs. $195,144 The level of outsourcing is expected to stay relatively steady
GPSNJETJ[FDPNQBOJFTBOE
GPSTNBMMPOFT"O JOTPNFQFSDFOUPGPSHBOJ[BUJPOTTBJEUIFZFYQFDU
BWFSBHFPGQFSDFOUPGUIFUPUBMUSBJOJOHCVEHFUXBTTQFOUPO to stay the same in the outsourcing area. The percentage
PVUTPVSDJOHJO
EPXOGSPNQFSDFOUJO PGDPNQBOJFTFYQFDUJOHUPEFDSFBTFVTF QFSDFOU
JT
0OBWFSBHF
QFSDFOUPGDPNQBOJFTDPNQMFUFMZPVUTPVSDFE slightly lower than those expecting to use outsourcing more
-.4PQFSBUJPOTIPTUJOH WTQFSDFOUMBTUZFBS
XIJMF (9 percent). There are exceptions for individual functions,
MFBSOFSTVQQPSUBOE-.4BENJOJTUSBUJPO QFSDFOU
MBSHFMZ though. In learner support, more than twice as many
were handled in-house. companies said they will be doing less than those that said
*OTUSVDUJPOGBDJMJUBUJPOXBTIBOEMFEBCPVUFRVBMMZJOIPVTF they will be doing more.
QFSDFOU
BOEPVUTPVSDFE QFSDFOU
"DSPTTBMMUIF 8IJMFUIFSFBSFOUNBOZEJGGFSFODFTCFUXFFOUIF
topic areas, large companies outsourced more than midsize outsourcing changes by company size, large companies will
ones, and midsize organizations outsourced more than small outsource less custom content development, while midsize
companies. This effect was most striking for custom content and small companies indicate they will increase learner
EFWFMPQNFOU QFSDFOUTPNFPSDPNQMFUFMZPVUTPVSDFEGPS support outsourcing.
$4$."',&$'"$0&$.
!' "&X&"&$''."&,'.9:7 7
X&#:77 77'-'$0&$.X
&,'"X"""$"&$''. ."4$'"
'"&,'.>0X"&,'.
!," ""$%&$"0%"$ %'
Extent of Outsourcing-6#$'
*OTUSVDUJPO'BDJMJUBUJPO ;==7=
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) 7=7==
-.40QFSBUJPOT)PTUJOH ===
Learner Support 7===
$VTUPN$POUFOU%FWFMPQNFOU ===
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q
/"&,'.Q#/"&,'.Q+"%&6#"%/"&,
TRAINING OUTSOURCING
Extent of Outsourcing#$6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ===
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) ===
LMS Operations/Hosting ===
Learner Support 7===
Custom Content Development 7=77==
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q
/"&,'.Q#/"&,'.Q+"%&6#"%/"&,
+ c6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ===
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) ;===
LMS Operations/Hosting ===
Learner Support ;=7==
Custom Content Development ;==7=
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q
/"&,'.Q#/"&,'.Q+"%&6#"%/"&,
2$&.6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ===
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) ==7=
LMS Operations/Hosting ===
Learner Support ;==7=
Custom Content Development ===
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q
/"&,'.Q#/"&,'.Q+"%&6#"%/"&,
#$6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ====
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) ;=7=7==
LMS Operations/Hosting ==7=7;=
Learner Support 7=7==7=
Custom Content Development =7;=;==
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q+&/"&,'.Q>$#Q2/"&,'.
Q:H'RQW:RQW2XWVRXUFH7KLV)XQFWLRQ
+ c6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ==7=7=
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) ====
LMS Operations/Hosting ==7=;=
Learner Support ;====
Custom Content Development ;=7==7=
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q+&/"&,'.Q>$#Q2/"&,'.
Q:H'RQW:RQW2XWVRXUFH7KLV)XQFWLRQ
2$&.6#$'
Instruction/Facilitation ====
LMS Administration (registration, upload data) 7=7==7=
LMS Operations/Hosting ====
Learner Support 7===;=
Custom Content Development =;=7==
0 20 40 60 80 100
Q+&/"&,'.Q>$#Q2/"&,'.
Q:H'RQW:RQW2XWVRXUFH7KLV)XQFWLRQ
Training
Economy
The economy is strengthening, but does the Great Recession of 2008
and recent stock market slidecontinue to affect the dollars allotted
for your learning and development programs? MARGERY WEINSTEIN
T
he economy is ofcially turning around, with TRAINING INVESTMENT ON THE RISE
positive nancial news reported regularly Some companies are experiencing an increase in train-
on the nightly news (barring a setback or ing funding, at least partially commensurate with the
strengthening economy. Compass Group North America,
two, such as periodic stock market plunges).
which owns Training Top 125er Morrison Healthcare, is
The question is whether the strengthening experiencing a strong investment in learning and devel-
economy is trickling down to your train- opment. Compass Group has increased its investment
ing programs. And of the dollars that are in training for salaried associates as the company has
allotted, where should they be directed? A expanded, says Eileen Springer, senior vice president,
Talent Acquisition and Development. For example, we
Training Top 125 winner, a Training Top 10 Hall of Famer,
offer a variety of courses via our Learning Management
and two experts share their thoughts on the impact of the System (LMS) and third-party partners, and have greatly
economy on training, and how you can continue delivering expanded our in-house offerings targeting unit manag-
the learning programs your employees need. ers, multi-unit managers, and leadership programs.
ej4.com/freetrial 800-566-3159
www.NetDimensions.com
T
he 2015 Manpower Talent What are some of the insights we can share from those executives
who have made a strong business commitment to investing in their
Shortage Survey indicated that
human capital? To nd out, I conducted a series of interviews with
approximately 20 percent of executives from Training Top 125 companies that are recognized for
their excellence in training and human capital development. I asked
businesses offered training to
them three basic questions:
their employees. After 40 years 1. To what degree are the top decision-makers in your organization
committed to investing in their human capital?
in the Training and Development eld, I con-
2. How did they arrive at the realization that employee training and
tinue to search for answers on why only some education is a strong driver of employees performance and over-
all business productivity and prot?
organizations invest in their human capital as
3. How have they been able to satisfy stockholders and Wall Streets
a key business strategy to improve their pro- xation on maximizing short-term prot by cutting what often is
viewed by nancial specialists as extraneous non-core costs such
ductivity, performance, and prots. Many
as employee training and development?
others complain in multiple industry surveys Here are some of their thought-provoking insights:
s h7E KNOW WE SUCCEED ONLY THROUGH OTHERS !ND THAT MEANS WE
about shortages of skilled workers but remain
have to lift our people up by investing in them.
focused on maximizing short-term prot by s h)NVESTING IN EDUCATION LED TO EXTRAORDINARY 2/) FOR ALL STAKE
holdersThats how we became an education-based company.
continually cutting costs. Investments for the
John Davis, President, Keller Williams
long term, including training and develop-
s h7E TRAIN AND PROMOTE OUR OWN TALENTx.INETY
EIGHT PERCENTxOF
ment, too often are forgotten. How can we
leadership positions [were] lled internally for 2014.
change this business-culture mindset? s h4WO OF OUR FOUR CORE VALUES ARE THAT OUR CLIENTS COME lRST AND WE