Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Extraction of sunflower oil from sunflower seeds (Heliantus annuus L.) using supercritical CO2 was studied. The shrinking core model was
applied to the modeling of the packed-bed extraction process. The experimental data were obtained for extraction conducted at the pressures of
20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 MPa; the temperatures of 313, 333 and 353 K, the CO2 flow rates of 14, and 6 cm3 CO2 min1 ; the mean particle diameters
of 0.23, 0.55, 1.09, 2.18 mm. The supercritical CO2 extraction process was modeled by a quasi steady state model as a function of extraction
time, pressure, temperature, CO2 flow rate, and particle diameter. The supercritical CO2 extraction process. The intraparticle diffusion coefficient
(effective diffusivity) De was used as adjustable parameter. The model using the best fit of De was correlated the data satisfactorily.
2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
0896-8446/$ see front matter 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.supflu.2005.11.015
U. Salgn et al. / J. of Supercritical Fluids 38 (2006) 326331 327
Table 1
Physical properties of supercritical CO2 and sunflower oil at experimental conditions (40 MPa, 313 K, 4 cm3 CO2 min1 and 0.23 mm)
P (MPa) T (K) (kg m3 ) 105 (Pa s) Csat (g oil kg1 CO2 ) kf 106 (m s1 ) DL 1012 (m2 s1 ) De 1010 (m2 s1 )
and 637 kg m3 , respectively [13]. The bed void fraction for our cle size and a 4 cm3 CO2 min1 flow rate. Temperatures of 313,
experimental system was determined 0.62. 333 and 353 K were explored for each pressure. Several scientific
literature signals an increase of the seed oil solubility with the
extraction temperature that can be significant when the process is
3.1. Effect of pressure performed at pressures higher than 40 MPa [7,21,22]. Our exper-
imental results at a pressure of 30 and 20 MPa show an opposite
As expected, the rate of supercritical CO2 extraction of sun- effect of the temperature increase on the sunflower extraction
flower oil largely increased with pressure shown in Fig. 1ac rate; i.e. the experimental points at different temperature prac-
where oil yield data obtained 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 MPa are tically overlap as shown in Fig. 2ac. Instead, the experiments
reported for experiments performed at 313, 333 and 353 K tem- performed at pressures greater than 30 MPa pressure give extrac-
peratures, 4 cm3 CO2 min1 flow rate, and 0.23 mm mean par- tion rates at different temperatures that could be in agreement
ticle size. The effect of the extraction pressure can be explained with the previous cited literature. However, at further 30 MPa
taking into account the large increased (from 3.63 to 18.63 g pressure the extraction is very fast and the number of experi-
oil kg1 CO2 for 313 K, 20 MPa and 313 K, 60 MPa, respec- mental points collected in the first part of the extraction process
tively) in the solubility of the oil constituents (mainly triglyc- was not sufficient to obtain conclusive information about the
erides) with pressure. Moreover, a large part of the extraction effect of temperature. As in the previous paragraphs, that the
process controlled by this thermodynamic parameter, as sug- equilibrium solubility of sunflower oil controls at least the first
gested by the experimental data: this first part of yield data could part of extraction process.
be fitted using a straight line. A lot of scientific literature signals The solubility of sunflower oil in supercritical CO2 increased
an increase of the seed oil solubility with the extraction pres- slightly with temperature at higher pressures (above 30 MPa).
sure [1520]. Fig. 1ac indicate that the extraction at pressures However, solubility of sunflower oil in supercritical CO2 at the
lower than 20 MPa was not feasible. This may be due to the fact pressure of 20 MPa decreased significantly with temperature.
that sunflower oil has very small solubility in CO2 at and below Such retro-gradation behavior of solubility isotherms has been
20 MPa. At 50 and 60 MPa, the of about 90 wt.% was obtained reported previous [24,25]. This is due to the fact that an increase
over very short extraction times (ca. 40 min) (see Fig. 1ac) in temperature at constant pressure leads to a drop in CO2 density
This is a combined result of the large solubility of triglycerides as well as an increase in the vapor pressure of solutes. The drop
at these pressures and of the relatively small quantity of oil con- in CO2 density is substantial at pressures near the critical point,
tained in this kind of seed. Comparison of all figures reveals that resulting in a drop in solubility. However, at higher pressures the
higher yields (99%) were obtained at the higher temperature, drop in CO2 density due to the similar temperature increase is
i.e. 353 K. The mathematical model described satisfactorily the small, which is overcome by the vapor pressure increase and the
experimental data in Fig. 1ac. The overlap between experimen- net effect is a solubility increase [26]. Similar solubility behavior
tal data and model curves is good for all the pressures studied. has been reported for other vegetable and seed oils [27,28].
It is clear that with the increase of temperature, the extrac-
3.2. Effect of temperature tion yield at 20 MPa increased. The yield obtained at the end of
the extraction period was about 4.5-fold when the temperature
The effect of temperature has been studied for experiments increased from 313 to 353 K (Fig. 3a). Due to retro-gradation
performed from 20 to 60 MPa pressures, 0.23 mm main parti- behavior of solubility at higher pressure (above 30 MPa), the
U. Salgn et al. / J. of Supercritical Fluids 38 (2006) 326331 329
Fig. 2. Effect of temperature on the extraction yield at 4 cm3 CO2 min1 flow
Fig. 1. Effect of pressure on the extraction yield at 4 cm3 CO2 min1 flow rate
rate and 0.23 mm mean particle size (a) 20 MPa; (b) 30 MPa; and (c) 40 MPa.
and 0.23 mm mean particle size (a) 313 K; (b) 333 K; and (c) 353 K.
yields obtained at the end of the extraction period was constant nificantly CO2 flow rate. The extraction rate increases with the
ca. 0.90 kg kg1 (Fig. 3c). increase in CO2 flow rate as in Fig. 3a, while Fig. 3b shows that
The mathematical model described satisfactorily the experi- the extraction curve is not affected by supercritical CO2 flow
mental data in Fig. 2ac. The overlap between experimental data rates all curves lie on a single line. This increase in extraction
and model curves is good for all the temperature studied. rate with time is almost linear in the early stages of extraction.
It is interesting to note that all the data points for all the flow
3.3. Effect of supercritical CO2 ow rate rates fall on a single curve indicating the accuracy and consis-
tency of the data and emphasizing that not the flow rate but
The effect of CO2 flow rate is shown in Fig. 3a and b. Fig. 3a the total amount of CO2 used in a given time per fixed amount
is a plot of the extraction yield versus the extraction time, and of seeds account for the success of extraction. This also led to
Fig. 3b is a plot of the extraction yield versus the total weight the conclusion that solubility but not the external mass trans-
of supercritical CO2 that has been passed through the packed fer resistance controls the extraction process over the range of
bed extractor. It is seen that the extraction rate is affected sig- experimental conditions investigated here. Several researcher in
330 U. Salgn et al. / J. of Supercritical Fluids 38 (2006) 326331
Table 2
Parameters of the mass transfer model at different supercritical CO2 flow rates (40 MPa, 313 K and 0.23 mm)
Q (cm3 CO2 min1 ) (kg m3 ) 105 (Pa s) Csat (g oil kg1 CO2 ) kf 106 (m s1 ) DL 1012 (m2 s1 ) De 1010 (m2 s1 )
Table 3
Parameters of the mass transfer model at different particle sizes (40 MPa, 313 K and 4 cm3 CO2 min1 )
dp (cm3 CO2 min1 ) (kg m3 ) 105 (Pa s) Csat (g oil kg1 CO2 ) kf 106 (m s1 ) DL 1012 (m2 s1 ) De 1010 (m2 s1 )