Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
SUMMARY Although there are different definitions of of lips and tongue, bruxism, habits, as well as the
posterior bite collapse, only the classical definition presence of advanced periodontal disease or
of Amsterdam provides a definite diagnosis and malocclusions, should be ruled out before the
treatment plan. This situation entails a subtle loss diagnosis of posterior bite collapse can be made. The
of the occlusal vertical dimension with resultant complexity of differential diagnosis is illustrated
flaring of the maxillary incisors. Other causes for with three case reports.
flaring, such as derangements of form and functions
Patient 2
Fig. 7. Front view of occluded dentition of patient 2. Fig. 9. Mandibular dental arch of patient 2.
Fig. 11. Left-side view of occluded dentition of patient 2. Fig. 14. Maxillary dental arch of patient 3.
Fig. 13. Front view of occluded dentition of patient 3. Fig. 15. Mandibular dental arch of patient 3.
extensive bone loss but angular osseous defects and denotes loss of arch form and occlusal stability. The
furcation involvements were detected (Fig. 18). occlusal stability is maintained by three factors: arch
integrity, occlusal relations and the periodontal health.
Diagnosis. Early onset localized periodontitis. Perio-
dontally induced anterior tooth migration perpetuated Arch integrity
by posterior overclosure.
It has been assumed that when teeth are stable in their
position, there is an equilibrium of forces acting on
Discussion them. This equilibrium includes all the forces that may
affect tooth position, namely forces from contiguous
Labial migration of the anterior teeth, described as
muscles such as the tongue and lips, opposing and
fanning, splaying, or flaring is a discerning sign that
adjacent teeth, external objects such as food, fingers,
regularly induces patients to seek treatment. This sign
etc., and the surrounding bone and periodontal tissues.
The equilibrium position theory presented by
Weinstein et al. (1963) is defined as that position of a
tooth from which it will not be moved by the natural
enviromental forces acting thereon. Changing this
balance of forces, can result in the tooth moving to a
position relieving this effect. Weinstein et al. (1963) lists
several pathological conditions associated with mal-
alignment of teeth such as: aglossia, muscular dystrophy,
facial paralysis and cerebral palsy as an indirect proof
for this theory. In addition, he showed by mathematical
plotting of the angulation of the anterior teeth and the
combined angulation of the lips (correlated with the
Fig. 16. Right-side view of occluded dentition of patient 3. force they exert on the teeth), that there are several
positions of stability, e.g. in normocclusion, or with
trapped lower lip. When he added 2 mm thick labial
or lingual extensions to teeth, he could demonstrate
movement of the teeth to the opposite direction
reaching plateau within a few weeks.
Kydd (1957) measured tongue and lip muscle forces
and found statistically significant differences between
them, the latter being considerably less. However, he
did not measure habitual, but maximal forces which
rarely exist during normal function. Lear & Moorrees
(1969) measured force magnitude of the musculature
during rest, speech, mastication, and swallowing,
Fig. 17. Left-side view of occluded dentition of patient 3. summed up according to their relative duration in 24 h.
Although the study was conducted on a small sample in these patients is occult, this is a specific situation
(seven subjects), a considerable imbalance was found, which rightfully deserves a separate diagnosis of PBC.
with the lingual forces being greater. Proffit, McGlone With respect to the anterior guided occlusion, it is
& Barret (1975) examined tongue and lip pressures in hard to conceive how uni-rooted maxillary incisors are
Australian aborigines. They found an inverse capable of protecting the multi-rooted posterior teeth
relationship between tongue pressure and arch size, so when forces are applied lingually on inclined planes.
aborigines large dental arches can not be explained by Two mechanisms were proposed to explain how the
tongue pressure. A different approach to this problem load acting upon maxillary incisors is reduced during
was used by Brader (1972) who developed a complex excursive movements: (1) in the class III lever system
mathematical solution, showing that the dental arch of the mandible, incisors function on a longer lever arm
fits a trifocal ellipse and the difference in forces between than molars (Dawson, 1989); (2) disclusion evokes a
the tongue and perioral musculature fits his equation. neuromuscular inhibition (Williamson & Lundquist,
It appears that the resultant equilibrium is not a simple 1983).
action of labio-lingual muscular forces within the dental Indeed, greater forces can be exerted when the
arch (Proffit, 1978). Other determinants of tooth anterior teeth are splinted (Waltimo & Kononen, 1994).
positions and arch form such as the occlusion have Some authors contend that in PBC, flaring of the
therefore to be considered. maxillary incisors results from these teeth being hit by
the opposing mandibular incisors during protrusive
movements (Stern & Brayer, 1975; Ramfjord & Ash,
Occlusal relations
1966). Furthermore, Yaffe, Hochman & Erlich (1992)
Currently, the mutual protection concept is the showed that a group of patients exhibited a protrusive
favourable scheme for physiologic occlusion. This pattern in sirognathographic sagital tracings of
scheme infers that the anterior teeth protect the deliberate mastication. All these patients shared severe
posterior teeth in mandibular excursions by disocclusion attrition of the anterior teeth or moderate attrition with
and that the posterior protect the anterior teeth at the fremitus or flaring. They suggest that this protrusive
intercuspal position (Shillingburg, Hobo & Whitsett, pattern may be regarded as an additional aetiologic
1978; Mohl et al., 1988). At maximal intercuspation, factor for anterior flaring. It seems that this type of
maxillary incisors slightly contact or do not contact flaring can only take place when the neuromuscular
(Andersson & Myers, 1971). However, these teeth may protective mechanism has failed, such as may occur in
contact when pressure is applied during maximal closure bruxism.
(Riise & Ericsson, 1983) or with the change of head
posture (Mohl, 1984). Even a slight loss of OVD can
Periodontal involvement
overload the maxillary incisors, resulting in their flaring.
Flaring can occasionally be treated only at the level of The foregoing discussion is based on the premise that
the anterior segments, namely by orthodontic in PBC maxillary incisors are subjected to excessive load
movements of the inclined incisors, combined with but have adequate alveolar bone support with the
tooth alterations for occlusal clearance and permanent presence of mild periodontal disease, at the most. This
splinting of these teeth. However, a different treatment is referred to as primary occlusal traumatism (Academy
approach should be adopted. A slight increase in OVD of Prosthodontics, 1994). Flaring of maxillary incisors
can be achieved by orthodontic or by spontaneous can be induced even by physiologic forces acting upon
eruption of the posterior teeth (Yaffe & Ehrlich, 1985) these teeth when there is a substantial loss of alveolar
or by prosthetic means as indicated for patient 1. This bone. This is regarded as secondary occlusal traumatism
procedure permits unhindered orthodontic movements (Academy of Prosthodontics, 1994). Maxillary incisors
of the anterior teeth, improves overbite/overjet relations can thus be affected by secondary occlusal traumatism
and thus reduces the load on these teeth. It is even in situations where no loss of OVD is present.
hypothesized that once secondary tongue habits are Recently, migration of maxillary anterior teeth has
controlled, no permanent splint of the anterior teeth been correlated to alveolar bone loss and to the presence
is required and these teeth may even spontaneously of acute inflamation around these teeth, as well as to
reposition into a new stable equilibrium. As loss of OVD the loss of more than three posterior teeth in the same
Table 1. Comparison of findings, pathogenesis, diagnoses and treatment approaches in described patient reports
Patient Flaring Region of Region of Occlusal Peridontal Region of Region of Need for Need for
primary secondary diagnosis diagnosis primary secondary increasing anterior
impairment impairment restorative restorative OVD splint
treatment treatment
PBC, posterior bite collapse; AOI, anterior occlusal impairment; EOP, early onset periodontitis; APOI, anterior and posterior occlusal
impairment.
dentition (Martinez-Canut et al., 1997). Also it has been Hopeless mandibular incisors can be replaced by a
reported that anterior spacing can spontaneously be fixed or removable prosthesis. In this patient, flaring
closed after surgical peridontal treatment (Brunsvold, appeared because of periodontal disease precending the
Zammit & Dongari, 1997). This phenomenon is loss of the maxillary teeth and subsequent loss of OVD.
attributed to disruption and reintegration of the trans- This sequence of events do not conform to that described
septal peridontal fibres. by Amsterdam for PBC (Amsterdam & Abrams, 1968;
Amsterdam, 1974). Other authors, however, broaden
Differential diagnosis the definition of PBC to a variety of conditions associated
with loss of OVD (Stern & Brayer, 1975; Rosenberg,
Although flaring is a sign common to all the patients
1987, 1988a,b). According to this definition, patient 3
presented in this article, they differ in pathogenesis,
may also be regarded as a PBC-situation.
prognosis and treatment plan (Table 1).
Patient 1 presented with anterior flaring occurring To define a separate disease entity one has to describe
after loss of posterior teeth. In this patient, no more a clinical situation featuring common pathogenesis,
than a one-third loss of the alveolar bone surrounding prognosis and treatment plan. For instance, all the
the maxillary incisors was evident. This situation patients described in this article were afflicted with
corroborates the classical description of PBC periodontitis. As they greatly differed in the
(Amsterdam & Abrams, 1973; Amsterdam, 1974). aforementioned parameters of disease, their diagnosis
Patient 2 presented with severe periodontal disease is subdivided into adult periodontitis (patient 1),
and bone loss. Despite the flaring, there was no sign of generalized early onset periodontitis (patient 2), and
loss of OVD and therefore the situation should not be localized early onset periodontitis (patient 3). The same
diagnosed as PBC. This patient should be treated with holds true for the diagnosis of loss of OVD. The classic
intensive periodontal protocol. Also, to control bruxism, description of PBC (Amsterdam, 1974; Amsterdam &
an interocclusal device (night guard) is indicated. The Abrams, 1968, 1973), is that the anterior flaring is
suggested rehabilitative treatment for this patient is caused by failure of the posterior occlusion to protect the
limited to the anterior segment; namely, orthodontic anterior segment from overloading. The rehabilitative
correction of the flaring followed by permanent splinting treatment should therefore start in the posterior
of the maxillary incisors. Prognosis is guarded. segment, by increasing the OVD. Need for a
Patient 3 presented with a localized type of early rehabilitative treatment in the anterior segment, is to
onset periodontitis and is considered to have a better be evaluated thereafter. It is thus advantageous to
prognosis than patient 2, with the generalized type of preserve the term PBC for this clinical situation. It
this disease (American Academy of Periodontology, should not be confused with other situations involving
1996). When the disease is controlled, a combined loss of OVD or flaring that is caused by other factors,
orthodontic and prosthodontic treatment can be with or without involvement of the posterior segments.
instituted; restoration of the OVD and permanent The latter may be termed as anterior or anteroposterior
splinting of the rectified maxillary incisors is indicated. occlusal impairment, respectively (Table 1).
PROFFIT, W.R. (1978) Equilibrium theory revisited: factors of Fixed Prosthodontics, p. 64. Quintessence Publishing Co.,
influencing the position of the teeth. Angle Orthodontist, 48, 175. Chicago.
PROFFIT, W.R., MCGLONE, R.E. & BARRET, M.J. (1975) Lip and STERN, N. & BRAYER, L. (1975) Collapse of the occluson-aetiology,
tongue pressures related to dental arches and oral cavity size in symptomatology and treatment. Journal of Oral Rehabililation,
Australian aborigines. Journal of Dental Research, 54, 1161. 2, 1.
WALTIMO, A. & KONONEN, M. (1994) Bite force on single as opposed
RAMFJORD, S.P. & ASH, M.M. (1966) Occlusion, p. 115, CV Mosby
to all maxillary front teeth. Scandinavian Journal of Dental
Co., St. Louis.
Research, 102, 372.
RIISE, C. & ERICSSON, S.G. (1983) A clinical study of the distribution WEINSTEIN, S., HAACK, D.C., MORRIS, L.Y., SNYDER, B.B. & ATTAWAY,
of occlusal tooth contacts in the intercuspal position at light H.E. (1963) On an equilibrium theory of tooth position. American
and hard pressure in adults. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation, 10, 473. Journal of Orthodontics, 33, 1.
ROSENBERG, E.S. (1987) Clinical aspects and treatment of posterior WILLIAMSON, E.H. & LUNDQUIST, D.O. (1983) Anterior guidance: its
bite collapse due to accelerated wear. International Journal of effect on electromyographic activity of the temporal and
Periodontics and Restorative Dentistry, 1, 67. masseter muscles. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 49, 816.
ROSENBERG, E.S. (1988a) Posterior bite collapse. Part I: pathologic YAFFE, A. & ERLICH, J. (1985) The canine platform: a modified
occlusion. Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry, 9, 207. method of posterior tooth eruption. Compendium of Continuing
Education in Dentistry, 6, 382.
ROSENBERG, E.S. (1988b) Posterior bite collapse. Part II: occlusal
YAFFE, A., HOCHMAN, N. & ERLICH, J. (1992) A functional aspect of
therapy. Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry, 9, 258.
anterior attrition or flaring and mode of treatment. International
SALZMAN, J.A. (1938) A study of orthodontic and facial changes
Journal of Prosthodontics, 5, 284.
of effect on dentition attending the loss of first molar in five
hundred adolescents. Journal of the American Dental Association,
25, 892. Correspondence: Dr Arie Shifman, PO Box 1031, Petach Tikva
SHILLINGBURG, H.T., HOBO, S. & WHITSETT, L.D. (1978) Fundamentals 49110, Israel.