Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
TREE
FILTER
POROUS
ASPHALT
Performance
Evaluation
Isolator Row Subsurface Infiltration
Hydrodynamic Separator Filter Unit
Current Research
Research
� Resear
Researc chh1 sshhoowwss that most SW TX fail
2
2//3
3 of tth
hee time ffoorr some WQ constituents
� There
Ther e is a lack of data examining stormwater
devices ffo orr treatment performance
� There
Ther eaarree a large number of devices in
existence that a arre
e little used that mayy be
ma
superior
1
Ballestero
Ballestero T.P., S.H. Jones, N.E. Kinner (2004), “W aterr Quality Assessment of Storm Water Control Systems”, Final
Wate
Report, Submitted to tth
he
e NOAA-UUNNHH Cooperative Institute ffo
orr Coastal a
annd
d Estuarine Environmental
Technology (CICEET)
Watershed Impacts:
Major Stormwater Contaminants
� Sediment
� Pathogens
� Nutrients
� Toxic Contaminants
� Debris and Floating Litter
� Temperature Alterations
� Chloride
Impacts of Imperviousness
Economic Impacts to
Water Resources
H
Hoowwa arre
e municipalities dealing with
tth
hee increasing runoff volumes
volumes
� N
NBBC
C RI h as
ha s begun
construction of ssiix
x
miles of underground
storage tunnels at a
projected cost of $467
million (1992 dollars).
� T unnels
Tunnel s will store tth
hee
sewage overflows
during intense rain
events ffo
orr later
treatment
12
New
New York City chose L
LIID
D ordinances
ordinances
NYC
NY C needs to eliminate 4 60
46 0C
CSSOO discharge points by
2030. They chose to disconnect impervious areas
from tth
he
e sewer system a annd
d treat tth
hee runoff through
infiltration practices.
Source: http://www.riverkeeper.org/special/Sustainable_Raindrops_FINAL_2008-01-08.pdf 13
Philadelphia chose L
LIID
D ordinance
ordinance
� C ostt ffo
Cos orr building
additional in-llin inee
storage ffo orr tth
hee
sewers systems =
$4.5/gallon of
storage, no treatment
(Montalto et al,. 2007)
� A lternative
Alternativ eL LIID
D cost
between $4 a annd
d $6
dollars p
peerr gallon
(capital cost p peerr
storage/treatment
capacity) www.phila.gov/OHCD/government.htm
14
H
Haas
s tth
he
e Stormwater Management Community
Practically Considered Climate Change?
� Recent research examining
impacts of climate change on
rainfall depths showed a 28-60%
increase in Q25-Q100
� Existing urban infrastructure
primarily culverts will be under-
capacity by 35%
� This in addition to stressed
stormwater infrastructure from
land use change (Guo, 2006)
16
Adapting Regulations
Most Sites
Effective BMPs targeting
Large Sensitive Sites - TSS, NO3, TP
80% TSS (or sliding scale) Sensitive Sites
Meet TMDL or Anti
Water
degredation
Quality
Most Sites
Infiltration and volume
All Sites Peak reduction
Flow Match 2,10, 25-year Large Sites
storms Volume Reduction and
Water Peak Flow Match 2,10, 25
Quantity year storms
Repeat
Construct
The Cycle of Best Management
Require
Improve Design
Repeat
Measure Construct
A Closer Look
� The study assumed that conventional
stormwater management practices would
be replaced entirely by LID techniques,
with no advanced water quality treatment
criteria.
� The proposed LID design reduced
effective impervious area from 30% to 7%
Another Case Study
Study
Greenland, NH
NH
Gravel Wetland
BMP
BM P Removal Efficiencies
Efficiencies
100% 100%
90% 90%
80% 80%
70% 70%
60% Summer 60% Summer
50% Winter 50% Winter
40% Annual 40% Annual
30% 30%
20% 20%
10% 10%
0% 0%
-
TSS TPH-D DIN Zn TP
The effect of T and [Cl-] is to
nearly double the settling time
Bioretention II from 3.4 to 1.6 cm/sec
100% 100%
90% 90%
80% 80%
70% 70%
60% Summer 60% Summer
50% Winter 50% Winter
40% Annual 40% Annual
30% 30%
20% 20%
10% 10%
0% 0%
TSS TPH-D DIN Zn TP TSS TPH-D DIN Zn TP
Frost Penetration
33
5 20
Frost Depth (cm)
10 10
Temp (C)
15 0
20 -10
25 -20
30 -30
Sand filter Bioretention I Gravel Wetland
Rain Freezing Ave. Temp ©
34
Chloride
Acute
Chronic
Where should reductions occur?
Sources of Salt Loading
From Vehicular Surface Deicing
(Rockingham County, NH)
(NHDES 2007)
27%
3%
Parking Lots
Private Roads 9%
Municipal Roads
Conditions after thawing and refreezing of melt-water (2/16/08) (a) PC at 1PM (left); (b) DMA at 1PM (rt)
39
Maintenance
LongTerm Maintenance
What is Maintenance
�Often Maintenance
only occurs when there
is failure
�There is a perception
that LID systems
require more
maintenance
�Some claim LID
systems fail and will
require expensive
repairs
Pond: 3-year Break Down TSS
200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
n
t
t
en
en
en
tio
tio
tio
flu
flu
flu
en
en
en
In
In
In
et
et
et
R
Just what
exactly is your
point?
100% Removal???
There a arre
e no silver bullets
�D esignss should be based on
Design
regional watershed a nd
an d water
quality objectives. (think locally
actt locally!)
ac
� We a arre
e moving beyond 8 800%
%T SS
TS S
removal:
� Nutrients, PSD, effluent
concentrations
Annual Reports
Outreach Materials
Materials
Fact Sheets
Web Resources
http://www.unh.edu/erg/cstev