Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: Background: GustiloAnderson grade 3B open ankle fracture-dislocations requiring stable xation and
Received 2 December 2016 soft tissue coverage are increasingly common in frail populations.
Received in revised form 20 March 2017 Methods: We identied all patients with open ankle fracture-dislocations treated with a tibiotalocalca-
Accepted 29 March 2017
neal nail and soft tissue coverage over a ve-year period. We retrospectively recorded pre-morbid status,
Available online xxx
fracture and soft tissue injury pattern, surgical details, post-operative mobility, length of hospital stay,
complication and re-operation rate and survival.
Keywords:
Results: 21 ankles (20 patients) are included, all grade 3B open fractures. All patients were permitted to
Ambulation
Frail elderly
mobilise by one to six weeks post-surgery. One patient required further soft tissue surgery. Six patients
Intramedullary nailing had supercial wound colonization/infection, none developed deep infections. None of the nails have
Open fracture required removal. We observed a 15% three-month mortality rate.
Orthopaedic surgery Conclusion: Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of unstable open ankle fractures in
Soft tissue injuries frail patients facilitates early return to ambulation with a low complication and re-operation rate.
Survival rate 2017 European Foot and Ankle Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
2.1. Participants
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: lesley.armstrong@doctors.org.uk (L. Armstrong), 35 ankles were treated with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail for
john.jackson1@nhs.net (J. Jackson), andrew.riddick@nbt.nhs.uk (A. Riddick). unstable ankle fractures between 1 July 2011 and 30 June 2016.
1
Present address: North Devon District Hospital, Raleigh Park, Barnstaple EX31
22 of these ankle fractures were open fractures requiring soft
4JB, United Kingdom.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fas.2017.03.015
1268-7731/ 2017 European Foot and Ankle Society. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article in press as: L. Armstrong, et al., Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of GustiloAnderson grade 3B
open unstable ankle fractures in a frail population; a case series in a major trauma centre, Foot Ankle Surg (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
fas.2017.03.015
G Model
FAS 1037 No. of Pages 6
tissue coverage. All the open fractures were grade 3B as per the Nail (Synthes, West Chester, PA, USA). The diameter of nail ranged
GustiloAnderson classication. One ankle was a revision from 10 to 12 mm and the length 150 to 300 mm. All nails were
procedure following failed open reduction internal xation and locked proximally and distally. None of the ankles had joint surface
was excluded from this study. In the remaining 21 ankles preparation before nailing. All required soft tissue coverage
(in 20 patients), a tibiotalocalcaneal nail was used for primary performed by a Plastic Surgeon, and this was achieved with either
xation. Three patients were male and 17 female. The average age a local ap or free ap and split skin graft (SSG). 12 ankles had a
was 76 (range 4898). Mechanisms of injury were a combination of medial plantar ap, two dorsalis pedis ap, two free gracillis ap,
low- and high-energy. Two patients (three ankles) had concomi- one free anterolateral thigh ap, one free scapula ap, one
tant signicant injuries. 18 patients had isolated injuries. myocutaneous ap, one bilobed transposition ap, and one patient
11 fractures were trimalleolar, four bimalleolar (medial and had SSG alone without a ap. Intravenous antibiotics were started
lateral), two bimalleolar (lateral and posterior), two lateral on admission. Patients having coverage with local aps had the ap
malleolus fractures, one lateral malleolus with anterior tibial raised prior to the tibiotalocalcaneal nailing. After the ap was
Tillaux fractures and one lateral malleolus with ipsilateral talar raised, the nail was inserted by the Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgeon
neck fracture. See Table 1 for a summary of patient demographics using the technique recommended by the implant manufacturer.
and results. Patients having coverage with an anterolateral thigh free ap had
the ap raised from the contralateral thigh at the same time as the
2.2. Data collection nailing. A below-knee backslab was applied to limit movement to
protect the ap. The patients were transferred post-operatively to
We retrospectively identied all patients on our trauma the Plastic Surgery ward, where they were monitored on a strict
database (Bluespier International, Droitwich UK) who had been ap protocol. Please see Figs. 1 and 2.
treated surgically for an ankle fracture within this time frame. We
reviewed the ward-round entries and operation notes for all of 2.5. Ethical approval
these patients to establish which patients had an open ankle
fracture and had been treated with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail and We referred to the NHS Health Research Authority online
soft tissue coverage. We reviewed each patients radiographs pre- information and decision-making tool. We did not require ethical
and post-xation, discharge summaries, Trauma & Orthopaedic approval from the NHS Research and Ethics Committee (NHS REC)
follow-up clinic letters, and letters from the Plastic Surgery for this study.
database. From these sources in combination, we ascertained
patient age and comorbidities, pre-injury residence, mechanism of 3. Results
injury, concomitant injuries, fracture conguration, date of initial
debridement, date of tibiotalocalcaneal nail, details of all surgeries, 3.1. Return to ambulation and discharge destination
grade of open fracture, method of soft tissue coverage, post-op
weight-bearing status, length of hospital stay, discharge destina- 15 patients (16 ankles) lived in their own home prior to their
tion, follow-up details, post-op complications, details of further injury, one in a warden-controlled at, two in a residential home,
surgery, and death rate. We cross-referenced our software sources one in a care home and one in a nursing home. 14 patients
to ensure accuracy of data. (15 ankles) were repatriated to their local hospitals for ongoing
rehabilitation, two were transferred to community hospitals, one
2.3. Staging of surgery to a care home and three discharged home. Only two patients from
home managed to return home directly from our hospital. The
All patients received treatment as per the British Orthopaedic average length of stay in the major trauma centre was 18 days. The
Association Standards for Trauma 4 [4] for open fracture majority of our patients were non-weight-bearing through the
management. The decision on whether to stage the surgery or operative ankle for two weeks to allow ap healing (range one to
carry out debridement, xation and soft tissue coverage in a single six weeks). After this weight-bearing as tolerated was advised. One
sitting was made during the rst visit to theatre. Two ankles were patient had limited mobility at four months post-operatively, but
treated in a single stage, having debridement, tibiotalocalcaneal this was related to frailty rather than to ankle xation complica-
nail and coverage with a medial plantar ap and split skin grafting tions.
in the same session. The remaining 19 open ankle fractures had an
initial washout, debridement and stabilization followed by 3.2. Complications and re-operation
denitive xation and coverage on average 1.5 days later (range
04 days). Three of our patients had the primary debridement One patient required further surgery to their ankle. This was
performed before transfer to our major trauma centre, and one of undertaken during the same admission as their ankle fracture
these had a further debridement (and application of external surgery and was a soft tissue procedure to re-perfuse a
xation) before the denitive surgery. Of the 19 ankles having threatened ap. To date, none of the patients included in this
staged surgery, six were stabilised with temporary external series have required re-operation for implant-related reasons
xation, one with a tibiotalocalcaneal Steinman pin, one with (mean time from surgery 13 months; range 535 months, four
Kirschner wires and a bula nail and 11 with plaster applied in patients died with the implants in situ) and none have undergone
theatre. Nine ankles had vacuum-dressings applied, and ten had amputation. One patient developed cellulitis over the apthis
standard dressings. was successfully treated with antibiotics. Five other patients had
wound swabs taken from the operative leg, which were positive
2.4. Operative technique for various bacteria. This gives an overall supercial post-op
wound colonisation/infection rate of 29%. One patient had a
Three different tibiotalocalcaneal nails were used in total over positive wound swab from the donor site on the contralateral leg.
the ve years; xation was achieved in 10 ankles with the T2 Ankle None of our patients required return to theatre due to deep
Arthrodesis Nail (Stryker Trauma GmbH, Schnkirchen, Germany), infection. One patient had failure of the SSG over donor site of the
nine with the Versanail (DePuy ACE Orthopaedics, Inc., Warsaw, dorsalis pedis ap, but went on to heal following a period of
USA) and two with the Titanium Cannulated Hindfoot Arthodesis observation.
Please cite this article in press as: L. Armstrong, et al., Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of GustiloAnderson grade 3B
open unstable ankle fractures in a frail population; a case series in a major trauma centre, Foot Ankle Surg (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
fas.2017.03.015
FAS 1037 No. of Pages 6
G Model
Table 1
fas.2017.03.015
open unstable ankle fractures in a frail population; a case series in a major trauma centre, Foot Ankle Surg (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
Please cite this article in press as: L. Armstrong, et al., Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of GustiloAnderson grade 3B
Ankle Age Mechanism Wound Other regions injured Co-morbidities Residence Place of Length of Stages Nail Soft tissue Length of Re- Deep Survival
location pre-injury discharge stay in coverage time non- operation infection
major weight
trauma bearing
centre (weeks)
(days)
1 78 Fall Medial & None Diabetes Home Hospital 18 3 DePuy ACE Dorsalis pedis 2 No No Deceased
lateral transfer VersaNail ap & SSG
150 12 mm
2 91 Fall Medial & None Long-term catheter Residential Hospital 18 2 DePuy ACE Myocutaneous 6 No No
lateral home transfer VersaNail ap & SSG
180 10 mm
3 61 Fall Anteromedial None CVA, PE, asthma Home Home 27 2 DePuy ACE Medial plantar 2 No No Deceased
VersaNail ap & SSG
150 10 mm
4 79 Fall Medial None DM2,IHD, CABG, HTN, Home Hospital 7 2 Depuy ACE SSG 2 No No
3
4
Table 1 (Continued)
Ankle Age Mechanism Wound Other regions injured Co-morbidities Residence Place of Length of Stages Nail Soft tissue Length of Re- Deep Survival
location pre-injury discharge stay in coverage time non- operation infection
major weight
trauma bearing
centre (weeks)
(days)
15 48 Fall Medial None Psoriasis, DM2, Home Home 13 2 Stryker Medial plantar 4 Yes No
hysterectomy, chronic T2 ankle ap & SSG
leg ulcers, unexplained arthrodesis
ts, smoking nail
Fig. 1. Photographs of open unstable ankle fracture on arrival in the emergency department, following debridement and at 8 weeks post-op.
Please cite this article in press as: L. Armstrong, et al., Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of GustiloAnderson grade 3B
open unstable ankle fractures in a frail population; a case series in a major trauma centre, Foot Ankle Surg (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
fas.2017.03.015
G Model
FAS 1037 No. of Pages 6
This again reects the frailty of this group of patients. Two of our 5. Conclusion
patients (three ankles) had signicant concomitant injuries, which
limited their mobility. One patient has bilateral open ankle We have demonstrated a reliable technique for xation of open
fractures also with a talar neck fracture on the right (which was unstable ankle fractures in an elderly frail population of patients
treated with open reduction internal xation at the same time as comparable to the neck of femur fracture population. Tibiotalocal-
ankle xation). Their mobility was restricted to heel weight- caneal nail xation with ap coverage allows quick return to
bearing on the right to protect the talar neck xation. The second mobility, limited only by the need for soft tissue protection
patient had an unstable pelvic fracture (requiring stabilization), immediately post-operatively, and an acceptable complication rate.
had a left above-knee amputation for unsalvageable leg injuries,
and a right calcaneum fracture on the same side as the open ankle Funding
fracture. The patient was permitted to mobilise fully-weight-
bearing on the right after the ap protocol ended, but we We did not receive any funding for this work.
appreciate that their mobility may have been limited by these
other injuries. Conict of interest
We have shown an acceptable complication rate in our patients.
All supercial infections and colonisations were successfully The authors of this manuscript have no conicts of interest to
treated medically. None of patients had deep infections and the declare.
only patient to undergo further surgery related to their ankle did so
for ap detachment. Pagliaro et al. [8] carried out a study on the Acknowledgements
outcomes of patients over the age of 65 undergoing traditional
surgical xation. They included 23 ankles; 21 closed and two open We have no further acknowledgements to include.
in patients with an average age of 72. Both open fractures had
complications; the wound dehiscence/deep infection occurred in a References
patient with an open fracture (this required surgical debridement
but went on to union at 5 months) and a supercial infection. This [1] Amirfeyz R, Bacon A, Ling J, Blom A, Hepple S, Winson I, et al. Fixation of ankle
fragility fractures by tibiotalocalcaneal nail. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2008;128
study did not comment on time to mobilisation. Taylor et al. [9] (4):4238, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00402-008-0584-z.
have published a study on union rates in unstable ankle fractures [2] Anderson SA, Li A, Franklin P, Wixted JJ. Ankle fractures in the elderly: initial and
treated with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail. They also recorded infection long-term outcomes. Foot Ankle Int 2008;29(12):11848.
[3] Egol KA, Koval KJ, Zuckerman JD. Functional recovery following hip fracture in
rate and implant-related complications. Of the 31 ankles included the elderly. J Orthop Trauma 1997;11(8):5949.
in their series, 8 of these were open ankle fractures. They observed [4] British Orthopaedic Association, British Association of Plastic, Reconstructive
three deep infections requiring surgical debridement, nail removal and Aesthetic Surgeons Standard for Trauma. BOAST 4: the management of
severe open lower limb fractures. London: British Orthopaedic Association and
and insertion of an antibiotic-impregnated rod. All of these British Association of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgeons; 2009.
infections were in the open fracture group giving an overall deep [5] Georgiannos D, Lampridis V, Bisbinas I. Fragility fractures of the ankle in the
infection rate of 37.5%. elderly: open reduction internal xation versus tibio-talo-calcaneal nailing:
short-term results of a prospective randomized-controlled study. Injury
We accept that our series has several limitations. This is a non-
2017;48:51924, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2016.11.017.
randomised retrospective study. We have included 21 ankles in [6] Ochman S, Evers J, Raschke MJ, Vordemvenne T. Retrograde nail for
20 patients, which is a relatively small number, however, to our tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis as a limb salvage procedure for open distal tibia
knowledge, this is the largest case series of open ankle fractures and talus fracture with severe bone loss. J Foot Ankle Surg 2012;51(5):6759,
doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1053/j.jfas.2012.04.015.
treated with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail reported to date. We have not [7] Al-Nammari SS, Dawson-Bowling S, Amin A, Nielson D. Fragility fractures of the
included a control group for comparison. The duration of follow-up ankle in the frail elderly patient: treatment with a long calcaneotalotibial nail.
is short-term. Once stable for transfer, major trauma patients are Bone Joint J 2014;96-B(6):81722, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1302/0301-
620x.96b6.32721.
repatriated to their local hospitals. This has made following-up the [8] Pagliaro AJ, Michelson JD, Mizel MS. Results of operative xation of unstable
patients difcult, and we appreciate that this may lead to missing ankle fractures in geriatic patients. Foot Ankle Int 2001;22(5):399402.
data. [9] Taylor BC, Hansen DC, Harrison R, Lucas DE, Degenova D. Primary retrograde
tibiotalocalcaneal nailing for fragility ankle fractures. Iowa Orthop J. 2016;36:7.
Please cite this article in press as: L. Armstrong, et al., Tibiotalocalcaneal nail xation and soft tissue coverage of GustiloAnderson grade 3B
open unstable ankle fractures in a frail population; a case series in a major trauma centre, Foot Ankle Surg (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.
fas.2017.03.015