PERBANDINGAN SPBG COMPRESSORS BERBASIS KWANGSHIN, ANGI, GALILEO, CUBOGAS DAN SAFE

No: PEMBANDING KWANGSHIN ANGI GALILEO

1 PERFORMANCE (Required)
Capacity/Flow rates (0.5MMSCFD) 590 Sm3/h 560 750 Sm3/h 496 769 Sm3/h
Suction Pressure (5-8 barg) 5.10 - 94.59 kg/cm2.G 2.5 5 barg 5 8 barg
Minimum Regulate Range (5 barg) 5 barg 2 barg -
Ambient Temperature (40 C max) 40 Celcius maximum 30 Celcius Min. 23 C - Max. 35 C
Suction Gas Temperature 25 - 35 Celcius 28 Celcius 26,7 Celcius
Discharge Gas Temperature (40 C) Ambient temp +10 Celcius 40 Celcius Ambient temp + 7 Celcius
Working Temperature Min. 23 C - Max. 35 C Min. 23 C - Max. 35 C
Molecular Weight 17.96 kg/mol. 19.77 kg/mol Gas SG = 0.65
Oil Carry Over Maximum 5 ppm max 5 ppm 5 ppm max
Discharge Pressure (250 barg) 250 barg ( 255 kg/cm2.G ) 250 barg 250 barg
Noise Level Enclosures 75 db at 3 meter (Low noise level) 75 db at 3m 77 db in 1m
Power consumption (Electric Motor) 110kW (main driver) 300 kW 255kW
Compressor Weight 7500 kg (approx) 9000 kg (approx)

2 STANDARDS
API Mainly based on API 11P ISO STD 13631 API
ANSI ANSI, ( KS, JIS ) ASME Section VIII Div.1 ANSI
ASTM ASME (JIS) API 11P acc to API 618 ASTM, ASME
NFPA NFPA 70 NFPA 70 NFPA
ISA API 121 API 121 ISA
ISO ISO 5168 ISO 5168 ISO
NEMA
3 COMPRESSOR PRINCIPLE TYPE & FRAME MODEL Reciprocating Horizontal MODEL: GEO-All-150HP-4stages Reciprocating Horiz. Ariel Model JG4.4 Stages 4 Reciprocating horizontal MX-100-3-1500-8, STAGES: 4.

4 RATED FLOW CAPACITY:

Minimum Inlet Pressure / Min 5.10 kg/cm2.G 3 barg, 496 Sm3/h, 110 kW, output 250 barg
Working Inlet Pressure / Mid 39.43 kg/cm2.G 7 barg, 678 Sm3/h, 99 kW, output 250 barg
Maximum Inlet Pressure / Max 94.59 kg/cm2.G 8 barg, 769 Sm3/h, 108 kW, output 250 barg
5 COOLING SYSTEM AIR COOLED AIR COOLED AIR COOLED

6 COMPRESSOR CYLINDER-PISTON LUB SYSTEM Lubricated Non Lubricated Lubricated

PLC, it executes the self-diagnosis of sensor and reading devices signaling PLC PLC
any malfuntions.
7 CONTROL SYSTEM
Internet ready include Internet ready include

8 OTHER SPECIFICATION & ACCESSORIES SUPLIED AS

PART OF THE COMPRESSOR UNIT SET (SPECIFY)

Safety & Control, Instrumentation, Accessories List:

Gas Leak Detector Yes Yes Yes
Maximum Vibration Allowable Alarm Yes Vibration Transmitter Yes
Safety Indicator Included Included Include
Cabin Included Included Outdor enclosure. Armored Cabin Subdivided into Galileo
System
Soundproof Yes - Yes
Explosion Proof Lighting Yes Main Cabin, for main drive cabin, for compressor cabin
and for metering bridge cabin.

Separation Interstage Interstage

Lubrication Automatic Separated, electric driven pump Automatic
Blowdown Blow-down Vessels, storage sector. Automatic Blow-down/drain valve for interstage and final filte Yes Include in the Cabin
Control Monitor Standard Control Panel Compressor Local mounted PLC Display 256 color 5,5 inch
Electronic Control Board In the Control Panel Built in the cabin
Inlet Pressure Regulator Yes Yes Yes
Gas Circuit Composed by 2" metering bridge with simple line filtering
system and by-pass
Safety Valves Yes Yes Yes - All Stages
Pressure Transducers Yes Yes Yes - All Stages
Temperature Censor Yes Yes Yes - All Stages
Double Coalesting Filter Yes Yes Yes
Additional Safety Systems Emergency Stop Button Emergency Stop Button Inlet and Outlet gas flow interruption valves activated by the
emergency stop system.
Automatic and remote storage venting system, automatic fire
detection (thermo-velocimetric type)

Extinction system, gas detection system in front cabin LEL

20%
 PERBANDINGAN SPBG COMPRESSORS BERBASIS KWANGSHIN, ANGI, GALILEO, CUBOGAS DAN SAFE
No: PEMBANDING KWANGSHIN ANGI GALILEO
9 DRIVER
INDUCTION MOTOR WEG, ATEX EEXD EXPLOSION PROOF WEG, ATEX EEXD EXPLOSION PROOF Explotion Proof Motor

MCC Control Panel Standard WEG Control Panel and Electronic control boarb
Output 110 KW 400 HP, 300kW 200kW
Starting Method Soft Starter Soft Starter 400HP Inverter Starter
Efficiency Standard High Efficiency
Voltage AC 3ph,380V AC 3ph 400V AC 3ph 380V
Speed (sychrounous) 1480 RPM 1500 RPM 1500 RPM
10 PRIORITY PANEL - PP 101
Type: Electro-Pheneumatic Type: Electro-Pheneumatic Type: Electro-Pheneumatic
3 (three) lines, Cascade filling - Mechanical priority fill valve type (no Installation place on storage frame no. line: 3 + Direct Included, Included in the compressor package. No Line: 3
actuators)

11 DRYER PE - 101 Vertical mounted, Molecular Sieve absorbent with Regeneration System Type: Regenerating, skid package inlet twin tower gas dryer Automatic regeneration, No downtime, Uninterrupted dry gas
for Fully Automatic, Cap. Max.740 Sm3/h @ 5 barg. dessicant supply, Plug & Play technology,100% compatible with
Galileo's product, Prevents downstream corrosion, Low
pressure drop. Twin Tower, ASME Code Compliant, Heat
regenerated, Silica or alumina dessicant, Designed for round-
the-clock 24/7 service, Auto dew point measuring, commands
regeneration, Remote command by an optional SCADA
system.

12 SCRUBBER V - 101
N/A TYPE: Vertical vessel TYPE: Mechanical
INSTALLATION PLACE: Main inletpressure line INSTALLATION PLACE: Main inletpressure line

MAX DESIGN PRESSURE: 16 barg MAX DESIGN PRESSURE: 8 barg

CAPACITY: 1700 Sm3/h CAPACITY: 1700 Sm3/h

COMPONENTS COMPONENTS
PRESSURE VESSEL PRESSURE VESSEL
FILTERING ELEMENTS FOR PARTICLES <10 MICRON FILTERING ELEMENTS FOR PARTICLES <10 MICRON

13 STORAGE PE - 103 A / B / C
Requirement: 1000 Nm3, at 250 barg.
DRAINVALVE DRAINVALVE
DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE INDICATOR DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE INDICATOR
DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURESWITCH DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURESWITCH
Type : Vertical Mounted, Capacity : 1600 TYPE: Vertical Mounted CAPACITY: 1000 Vertical cylinder. 1 unit. Total capacity:
Liters. (totally water volume capacity). Total gas volume per skid: 4800 at Liters Total gas volume per skid : 4800 at 2x3 banks Microcal Storage for 1500 ltr water volume =
250 barg. Working Pressure : 250 bar. Design 250 barg Working Press.: 250 bar Design 2x500Nm3 at 250 barg.
Pressure./MAWP: 275 bar Press./MAWP: 275 bar

14 DISPENSER PE - 101 A / B, 102 A / B

Nozzles: NGV 1 Nozzles with safety brakeaway quick release coupling Nozzles: NGV 1 Nozzles with safety brakeaway quick Fuelling Nozzle: NGV1, with breakaway valve per hose
release coupling
Flow rate: 40 kg/min. Flow rate: 4200 Nm3/h Maximum instant flow capacity: 15kg/min
Fill Hose: 2 X 1/2 Heavy duty double fill hose for each dispenser Fill Hose: 2 X 1/2 Heavy duty double fill hose for each dispens Double (D) refilling hose.

Batch Delivery Accuracy: 1 -1.5% Batch Delivery Accuracy: 1 -1.5%

Target filling pressure 200 barg Target filling pressure 200 barg Cut Pressure: (adjustable to curtomer needs)
Gas Metering: Corioliss Mas Flow Mete Gas Metering: Corioliss Mas Flow Mete Mass measurement: Coriolis effect-Micromotion CNG-050

Measuring Automatic Adjuster: Electronic Temp. Measuring Automatic Adjuster: Electronic Temp. Temperature Compensation System: -
Communication of dispenser : Dispenser already installed serial port for co Communication of dispenser : Dispenser already installed seri Communication of dispenser : Capability of serial
communication with site fuel management.
15 SPARE PART 1 YEAR OK OK OK

16 DELIVERY TIME 135-150 DAYS ON SITE FOT Jakarta for Compressor Equipment and 150-180 DAYS ON SITE 120 DAYS, FOB Buenos Aires, + 50 DAYS SHIIPING,
Gas Dryer CUSTOMS, TRANSPORT TO SITE.
 PERBANDINGAN SPBG COMPRESSORS BERBASIS KWANGSHIN, ANGI, GALILEO, CUBOGAS DAN SAFE
No: PEMBANDING KWANGSHIN ANGI GALILEO
17 KELEBIHANNYA Sesuai Requirement Standard Menggunakan Standar Eropa, tidak menggunakan Sesuai Requirement Standard
Requirement Standard
Safety: Good Safety: Fair Safety: Good
Kompak, memerlukan ruang lebih sedikit dibanding yang
Type Horizontal lainnya
Berat compressor lebih ringan dari yang lain
Delivery Time lebih cepat
Arus start lebih kecil dari yang lain (Inverter Starter)
Pemakaian daya listrik lebih kecil (operating cost rendah)

Maintenance Cost rendah (spare part lebih sedikit) Energy Cost Saving (vs SAFE) per tahun :
Teknisi after sale service tersedia. Kebisingan lebih rendah dari yang lain

Ketersediaan part terjamin karena ada Agen di Indonesia.

Ketersediaan part terjamin karena ada Agen di Indonesia.
18 KEKURANGANNYA Memerlukan ruang lebih banyak dari yang lain Delivery time lebih lama dari delivery time Safe

Ada kerugian venting gas kalau over pressure. Pemakaian daya lebih besar dari lainnya Lube oil carry-over lebih tinggi dari lainnya
Menggunakan Soft Starter, sehingga pada saat Start-Up menggunakan Start delta-bintang kurang halus, pemakaian KVAR lebih Ada kerugian venting gas kalau over pressure.
power lebih tinggi dari kapasitas yang digunakan. (Inverter Optional). besar dari lainnya.

Ada kerugian venting gas kalau over pressure.

Terdapat piping untuk water cooling system.

Ketersediaan part masih diragukan. Belum ada Agen di
Indonesia.
CUBOGAS DAN SAFE
CUBOGAS SAFE

590 740 Sm3/h 560 750 Sm3/h

3 - 4 barg 2 5 barg
3 barg 3 barg
+40 Celcius -10 +40 Celcius
30 Celcius 30 Celcius
Ambient temp + 10 Celcius Ambient temp + 10 Celcius
-10 +40 Celcius -10 +40 Celcius
0,60 0,82 kg/m3
5 ppm max 3 ppm
250 barg 250 barg
Low noise level Low noise level
160 kW 160 kW
9076 kg (approx)

API 618 CE
EC EN
ASTM, DN, PN ISO
EN
PR
EEMUA 140 and 141
ISO 1680
Reciprocating Vertical MODEL: CUBOGAS 130B, TYPE 2BVTN4, Stages Reciprocating V MODEL: SW160F3-EM, Nom
4. COMPRESSION STAGES: 4.

3 barg, 590 Sm3/h, 119 kW, output 250 barg 2 barg, 560 Sm3/h, 130 kW, output 250 barg
3.5 barg, 675 Sm3/h, 130 kW, 250 barg 3 barg, 750 Sm3/h, 160 Kw, output 250 barg
4 barg, 740 Sm3/h, 140 kW, output 250 barg 5 barg, 750 Sm3/h, 160 Kw, output 250 barg
INTERSTAGE GAS_WATER COOLED WATER-AIR COOLED

Non Lubricated Lubricated

PLC, it executes the self-diagnosis of sensor and reading devices signaling Non PLC, Safety & Control Instrument for Gas Circuit - Oil
any malfuntions. Circuit and Water Circuit are Included.

Yes
Vibration Transmitter
Included Included
Included

Yes -

Interstage
Automatic Separted, electric driven pump
Blow-down Vessels, storage sector. Blow-down Vessels, storage sector.
Standard Control Panel Compressor Separate Control Panel (in safe area)
-
Yes Yes

Yes Yes
Yes
Yes

Emergency Stop Button Emergency Stop Button

CUBOGAS DAN SAFE
CUBOGAS SAFE

ATEX EEXD EXPLOSION PROOF Class I Division 2 Groups C and D ATEX-POTENTIALLY EXPLOSIVE ATMOSPHERE

Standard STD FOR SAFE AREA

160 KW HIGH EFFICIENCY 160 KW
Soft Starter 400 HP STAR-DELTA STARTER
Standard STANDARD
AC TRIPHASE,400V AC TRIPHASE, 400 +/- 5% v
1000 RPM 1500 RPM

Type: Electro-Pheneumatic Type: Electro-Pheneumatic

3 (three) lines priority PANEL for CNG refueling cars. Installation place on storage frame no. line: 3 + Direct

Vertical mounted, Molecular Sieve absorbent with Regeneration System for
Fully Automatic. Cap. 740 Sm3/h maximum 4 barg.
Type: Regenerating, two vessel skid mounted,
Regenerating gas: closed circuit, Max allowable gas
capacity 750 Sm3/h, max working pressure: 8 barg, Inlet
filter: coalescer, Outlet filter: Particellar, Control Panel:
Dedicated for the dryer.

TYPE: Mechanical
INSTALLATION PLACE: Main inletpressure line

MAX DESIGN PRESSURE: 8 barg

CAPACITY: 1700 Sm3/h

COMPONENTS
PRESSURE VESSEL
FILTERING ELEMENTS FOR PARTICLES <10 MICRON

DRAINVALVE
DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURE INDICATOR
DIFFERENTIAL PRESSURESWITCH
15cyl x 80 liter (2 skid )
Vertical mounted, TYPE: STANDARD
CAPACITY: 4.480 LITERS=1120Nm3
SECTORS: 3 + BLOW-DOWN
No CYLINDERS: 56
MAX REFILLING PRESSURE: 250 BAR
DISCHARGE LIQUID DRAIN: MANUAL

Nozzles: NGV 1 Nozzles with safety brakeaway quick release coupling Nozzle Profile (SX / DX): NGV 1, with breakaway valve.

Flow rate: 40 kg/min Performance (Min. / Max.): 0,3 / 40 kg/min.

Fill Hose: 2 X 1/2 Heavy duty double fill hose for each dispenser No of Nozzle: 2

Batch Delivery Accuracy: 1 -1.5% Reading Precision: +/-0,5 %

Target filling pressure 200 barg Target filling pressure 200 barg
Gas Metering: Corioliss Mas Flow Meter Mass Flow Meter Model: CNG 50

Measuring Automatic Adjuster: Temperature Compensation System: -

Communication of dispenser : Dispenser already installed serial port for -
communicating for POS
OK OK

120-135 DAYS ON SITE 120 DAYS ON SITE

CUBOGAS DAN SAFE
CUBOGAS SAFE
Sesuai Requirement Standard Menggunakan Standar Eropa, tidak menggunakan
Requirement Standard
Safety: Good Safety: Fair
Lebih cepat dari yang lain
Tingkat keausan silinder-piston vertical lebih redah dari V-type cilinder
Non Lubricated
API 618 Standard

Pemakaian daya listrik lebih kecil (operating cost rendah)

Maintenance Cost rendah (spare part lebih sedikit)

Teknisi after sale service tersedia.

Ketersediaan part terjamin karena ada Agen di Indonesia.

Memerlukan ruang lebih banyak dari yang lain

Ada kerugian venting gas kalau over pressure. Pemakaian daya lebih besar dari lainnya
Start delta-bintang kurang halus, pemakaian KVAR lebih
besar dari lainnya.

Ada kerugian venting gas kalau over pressure.

Terdapat piping untuk water cooling system.

Ketersediaan part masih diragukan. Belum ada Agen di
Indonesia.