Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: In order to understand the characteristics o f Rayleigh-Benard convection o f cold water near its density
Received 21 May 2016 maximum in a rectangular cavity with an aspect ratio o f 2, a series o f direct numerical simulations are
Received in revised form 28 October 2016 performed by using the finite volum e method. The flow patterns and their evolution and heat transfer
Accepted 3 November 2016
abilities are discussed in detail. Results indicate that the density maximum phenomenon affects signifi
Available online 10 November 2016
cantly the R-B convection o f cold water in a rectangular cavity. Compared with the cubical cavity, the crit
ical Rayleigh number for the onset o f convection in a rectangular cavity is small, and the effect o f the
Keywords:
aspect ratio on the critical value decreases with the increase o f the density inversion parameter. Some
Rayleigh-Benard convection
new multiple-roll flow patterns are observed in the rectangular cavity. Furthermore, the distribution o f
Cold water
Density maximum the local Nusselt number depends on the flow pattern. Compared with the results in a cubical cavity,
Flow characteristic the overall heat transfer ability in the rectangular cavity is enhanced under the same control parameters.
Heat transfer 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction diameter and h the height) is 1 and this value decreases to 1708
when the aspect ratio approaches infinity. Hebert et al. [10] stud
When a fluid is heated from the bottom and cooled from the top ied experimentally the R-B convection near the onset o f convection
respectively, Rayleigh-Benard (R-B) convection occurs, which has in cylindrical containers with different aspect ratios, and four
long been studied and received increasing attention due to its regions o f the aspect ratio are classified according to the different
extensive correlation with many engineering applications, such flow patterns.
as solar collector, crystal growth, heat exchanger and nuclear reac Compared with the cylinder, the rectangle represents a different
tor etc [1 -4 ]. Compared with the natural convection subjected to a symmetry, which may lead to different features o f the flow and the
horizontal temperature gradient, the R-B convection subjected to a heat transfer. Therefore, the R-B convection in a rectangular cavity
vertical temperature gradient doesnt happen until the tempera has also attracted the attention o f researchers [11-13]. DOrazio
ture difference exceeds a critical value. The R-B convection has et al. [14] investigated numerically the R-B convection in
more complicated nonlinear characteristics with the increase of air-filled two-dimensional rectangular cavities, and obtained
the temperature difference. Therefore, it is also one o f the typical evolution characteristics o f the flow patterns from the one-cell
models for the nonlinear phenomenon [5]. The pioneering study steady flow ? the two-cell steady flow ? the two-cell periodic
on the R-B convection can be dated back to 1900s [6], in which a flow ? the one-to-three-cell periodic flow ? the three-cell
regular hexagon roll was observed experimentally. Then, a dimen periodic flow. Furthermore, they concluded that the flow and the
sionless parameter, the Rayleigh ( Ra ) number, was proposed by heat transfer rates depend strongly on the geometry character.
Rayleigh to describe the destabilization criterion o f the R-B convec Zhan et al. [15-16] studied three-dimensional characteristics of
tion [7]. Thereafter, enormous efforts have been made to explore the R-B convection in a rectangular cavity with experimental and
the R-B convective characteristics in a cylinder. Charlson and Sani numerical methods, and found that the rotation direction o f rolls
[8], and Rosenblat [9] determined the critical Rayleigh number for is significantly affected by the thermal condition o f the lateral wall.
the onset o f the R-B convection in a cylinder, and found that the Waleffe et al. [17] proposed heat transfer correlations for the
threshold value is 2000 when the aspect ratio A = d/h (d is the primary solutions which bifurcate from the conduction states at
different ranges o f the Rayleigh number. Mukutmoni [18]
* Corresponding author. examined the flow evolution in rectangular cavities with aspect
E-mail address: liyourong@cqu.edu.cn (Y.-R. Li). ratios o f 2.42 and 1.23 and found the counter-intuitive transition
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijheatmasstransfer.2016.11.013
0017-9310/ 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1066 Y.-P. Hu et al./International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075
Nomenclature
from the quasi-periodic flow to the steady flow. This phenomenon cavity was carried out by Large and Andereck [32]. The upper stag
is also observed in the bifurcation analysis o f the R-B convection in nant region o f the fluid layer which is not observed for common
a cubical cavity [19]. fluid has been discovered in this experiment. But the flow charac
Recently, the multiple stationary states coexistence and the teristics at different density inversion parameters were not inves
flow characteristics of the R-B convection have been focused [20,21]. tigated in this study. In our previous investigations [33-35], the
Boroiiska and Tuckerman [22,23] investigated the extreme R-B convection o f cold water in cylindrical and cubic cavities was
multiplicity in the cylindrical R-B convection with the aspect ratio studied systematically. It is found that the density inversion phe
o f 2, and discovered various coexisting patterns o f steady and nomenon has a great influence on the R-B convection at different
time-dependent flows. Bousset et al. [24] studied numerically the density inversion parameters.
nonlinear three-dimensional R-B convection regimes in a cavity However, the flow structures o f the R-B convection o f cold
with adiabatic and perfectly heat-conducting sidewalls. The exis water in a rectangular cavity may be very different from those in
tence o f different types o f convective structures is detected over cylindrical and cubic cavities. Furthermore, the oscillation flow of
a wide range o f governing parameters, and their stability ranges the R-B convection o f cold water has not been reported until
o f Ra are also assured. Puigjaner et al. [25,26] did further work now. In order to extend the existing knowledge, this paper pre
for the same model at Ra 6 1.5 x 105, and discussed the effect of sents a series o f numerical simulations on the R-B convection of
the Prandtl (Pr) number on the multiple solution. The variation cold water from steady to oscillation flow in a rectangular cavity
o f the Nusselt (Nu) number as a function o f Pr is presented for with the aspect ratio o f 2.
the different flow patterns. Then, the insight is gained into the
onset and nonlinear development o f the R-B convection in a 2-D
2. Problem statement
rectangular cavity by Daniels and Jhugroo [27]. The flow structures
o f the steady state and their nonlinear development were
2.1. Physical and mathematical model
discussed in their study.
From the above-mentioned literatures the density o f the fluid is
The R-B convection o f cold water near its density maximum in a
assumed to vary linearly with the temperature, and this kind of
rectangular cavity is considered, as shown in Fig. 1(a). The cross
fluid is often named as common fluid. However, some special fluids
section perpendicular to the direction o f gravity is square with
that have density extremum exist in the natural and engineering
the length l and the height h o f the cavity. The sidewalls are insu
fields for which the linear temperature-density relationship is no
lated, and the top and bottom walls are cooled and heated at a con
longer suitable. For example, the density o f cold water has its max
stant temperature Tc and Th (Th > Tc), respectively. The aspect ratio
imum at around 4 C and decreases as the temperature is changed.
A = l/h is fixed at 2.
This density inversion phenomenon makes the R-B convection
For simplifying the problem, some assumptions are applied in
more complicated. A lot o f experimental observations and numer
this model: (1) The cold water is incompressible Newtonian fluid;
ical simulations have been reported for the natural convection of
(2) the flow is in the laminar regime and the viscous dissipation is
cold water near its density maximum in the rectangular cavity
neglected; (3) all the thermal physical properties are constant
with a horizontal temperature gradient [28-30]. The results
except for the density in the gravitational term. The thermophysi
showed that the density inversion phenomenon has strong effects
cal properties o f cold water at a reference temperature of
on the fluid flow and heat transfer.
Tm = 4.029325 C are listed in Table 1. The nonlinear density-
But until now, there have been a few investigations on the R-B
temperature relation o f cold water is applied as:
convection o f cold water near its density maximum. Zubkov et al.
[31] investigated numerically the R-B convection o f cold water in
q (T ) = q m[1 -| (T - Tm)/T 0 |q]; T0 = y--q (1)
a cubic cavity with the horizontal walls heated and cooled sym
metrically relative to the temperature o f the density maximum, where the maximum density is q m = 999.972 kg/m3. The thermal
and totally six kinds o f flow patterns were obtained. Then, an expansion coefficient and the exponent are y = 9.297173 x 10-6 (C)-q
experiment on the R-B convection o f cold water in a rectangular and q = 1.894816, respectively. Therefore, T0 = 452.357332 C.
Y.-P. Hu et al. /International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075 1067
d
Nu (8a)
dZ z=0
1 r T+Tp r a ra
Nuave 2 NudXdYdT (8b)
Fig. 1. Geometry and sample computational mesh o f the problem.
A Sp s 0 0
By introducing h, v/h, h2/v, vi/h2 as reference quantities o f the 2.2. Numerical procedure and validation
length, velocity, time, and pressure, the dimensionless governing
equations in the Cartesian coordinate system are expressed as: The governing equations are solved in the spatial computational
dU dV dW domain by employing the finite volume method. The diffusion
(2) terms and the convective terms are discretized through the
dX + dY + ~dZ
second-order central difference scheme and the QUICK scheme,
dU T,dU dU dP d2U d2U d2U respectively. The SIMPLE algorithm is adopted to handle the
(3) pressure-velocity coupling, and the fully implicit scheme is used
ds dX dY dZ dX dX2 dY2 @Z2
for the temporal discretization. Transient simulations based on
the Rayleigh number and the flow evolution are carried out with
@V udV VdV W d V - - d P dPL dPVL ddPV. (4) a varying time step from 104 to 5 x 103. At each time step, the
ds + U dX + V dY + W dZ = dY + dX2 + dY2 + dZ2
convergence is reached if the maximum relative error is less than
@W @W @W @W @P @2W @2W @2W 105 for each variable. The state is qualified as steady if the
observed variable doesnt change more than about 0.1%. The calcu
1 7 + UI X + V W + W -dZ = dZ + W + dY2 +
lation ends until the flow takes about the dimensionless time 132
(5) 265 to ensure that the R-B system reaches the steady state. The
+ Ra I ml?
dimensionless time is 13-26 times o f the heat diffusion time o f
the system.
d ..d ..d ...d 1 d2 d2 d2 A structured grid is applied to the computational domain with
U V W (6)
ds + dX + dY + dZ Pr dX2 + dY2 + dZ2 an elevated concentration o f nodes near the walls, and a uniform
spacing in the remainder interior o f the cavity, as shown in Fig. 1
These variables have their common meanings in fluid mechan
(b). A grid independence test is performed using different grids
ics and heat transfer, which are listed in the nomenclature. As
under the same condition. The results o f the average Nusselt num
shown in the governing equations, three parameters which govern
ber on the hot wall for different grids are given in Table 2. As can be
this problem are the Rayleigh number, the density inversion
seen from this table, all the grid sizes show very close results. Con
parameter, and the Prandtl number, which are defined as:
sidering both the numerical accuracy and the computing time, the
Ra gy(Th Tc)qh3/(va),Pr va, m (Tm Tc)/(Th Tc) (7) grids size o f 215,000 is chosen, and the minimum grid size is
4.55 x 106 and the maximum grid size is 8.91 x 106.
Table 1
In order to validate the current numerical scheme, the valida
Thermophysical properties o f cold water at Tm = 4.0293 C. tion simulation for the R-B convection o f cold water near its den
sity maximum in a cubical cavity has been carried out in our
Item conductivity kinematic thermal Prandtl
previous investigation [34]. An experiment on the R-B convection
viscosity diffusivity number
o f cold water in a cylinder is conducted and the experimental
Unit W/(m -K) m2/s m2/s -
results agree well with the numerical simulations in Ref. [35]. In
Value 0.562 1.567 x 106 1.354 x 107 11.573
addition, another validation simulation has also been performed
1068 Y.-P. Hu et al./International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075
---- *-Ra
----1
4000 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000
Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of flow transitions between convective patterns for cold water in a rectangular cavity. * : flow patterns from a conductive state.
Fig. 5. Flow patterns at different Rayleigh number at 0 m = 0.7. Upper plot: contours o f vertical velocity in the Z = 0.25 plane. Solid lines denote a positive value and dotted
lines denote a negative value. Lower plot: isothermal surfaces o f 0 = 0.3 (upper), 0.5 (m iddle) and 0.7 (lower).
Table 4 23,300 6 Ra 6 25,500. Below and above this range, the FP2 0.5
The critical Ra for the onset o f R-B convection. state transits into the FP1 0.5 state. Fig. 9 describes the transition
0 m Present study ( A = 2) Ref. [34] (A = 1) Racri (A = 2)/Rac r i (A = 1) process from the FP2 0.5 state to the FP1 0.5 state at Ra = 25,600.
0.3 5500 7300 75%
At s = 23.8, the strength o f the hot flow in the corner o f the cavity
0.5 21,900 26,400 83% decreases and the hot flow with the form o f a circle appears in the
0.7 196,000 221,000 89% middle region. As time goes on, the hot flow in the middle region
moves down gradually to the bottom. The FP1 0.5 state is finally
formed at s = 60.1. Compared with the flow branch at 0 m = 0.3,
When the Rayleigh number is below 4330, the conduction state no new flow state appears in the branch o f stable flow patterns
replaces the FP3 0.3 state. at 0 m = 0.5.
Concerning 0 m = 0.5, the FP1 0.5 state is stable for the Rayleigh Concerning 0 m = 0.7, the FP1 0.7 state is stable at
number between 21,000 and 31,700 in the flow branch o f the FP1 192,000 6 Ra 6 217,000 in its flow branch. The FP1 0.7 state
0.5 state. The system recovers to the conductive state below this evolves into the FP2 0.7 state at Ra = 218,000, and the evolution
range, and above this range loses its stability and evolves into an is shown in Fig. 10. The hot flow near the sidewall transits into a
oscillatory flow. When the FP2 0.5 state is used as an initial condi spot pattern, and the hot flow in the center moves down to the bot
tion, the stability range o f the FP2 0.5 state is assured as tom at s = 27.4. W ith time increasing, the strength o f both hot and
Fig. 7. Distribution o f the absolute value o f vertical velocity along center line (X = 0.5, Y = 0.5).
cold flow increases, and finally forms a FP2 0.7 state. In the range of into a FP5 0.7 state. In the pattern o f the FP5 0.7, the number o f the
222.000 6 Ra 6 300,000, the FP1 0.7 state transits into a FP3 0.7 circular hot ascending flow increases to three, and the hot flow
state. Using the FP3 0.7 state as an initial condition, its found that region near the sidewall expands, as shown in Fig. 11(b). With
the stable range o f the Rayleigh number for the FP3 0.7 state is the decrease o f the Rayleigh number, the system decays into a
213.000 6 Ra 6 300,000. The FP3 0.7 state transits into the FP1 FP6 0.7 state [Fig. 11(c)] at 193,000 6 Ra 6 194,000 and a conduc
0.7 state at 194,000 6 Ra < 213,000, and decays into a conductive tive state at Ra < 193,000. Since the FP6 0.7 state is near the thresh
state at Ra < 194,000. old o f the convection, the maximum speed is small. Only one
Three new flow patterns appear in the flow branch o f the FP2 circular hot flow with a weak region exists in this pattern.
0.7, as displayed in Fig. 11. In the range o f 203,000 6 Ra 6 300,000, In the FP4 0.7 flow branch, the FP4 0.7 state is stable at
the FP2 0.7 state remains stable. Below Ra = 203,000, the FP2 0.7 190.000 6 Ra 6 204,000 and then evolves into the FP2 0.7 state
state transits into new flow patterns. Firstly, a FP4 0.7 [Fig. 11(a)] at 204,000 < Ra 6 245,000. A new state FP7 0.7 is obtained at
state with two circular hot ascending-flows with great flow Ra = 246,000, as shown in Fig. 12. The FP7 0.7 state is a four-roll
strength in the middle region and two sector hot ascending-flows flow pattern which is formed by three parallel hot flows and two
with weak flow strength near the sidewall is obtained at parallel cold flows. It has a wide stability range of
199.000 6 Ra < 203,000. The convexity deformation takes place in 218.000 < Ra 6 300,000. At a large Rayleigh number, the phe
the middle region o f the isothermal surfaces. When the Rayleigh nomenon about the vertex splitting is observed in the hot flow
number is between 195,000 and 199,000, the FP2 0.7 state transits region. The FP7 0.7 state evolves into the FP4 0.7 state at
1072 Y.-P. Hu et al./International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075
Fig. 10. Evolution from FP1 0.7 state to FP2 0.7 state at Ra = 218,000.
stable flow patterns which are initialized with the conduction state
at 0 m = 0.5. The stability ranges o f all the flow patterns and their
flow evolution are determined by changing the initial conditions
and the Rayleigh number. Table 5 lists the stability ranges o f all
the flow patterns. The stability range o f the Rayleigh number for
each flow pattern is different since there exists a great difference
in the distributions o f the flow and thermal fields for various flow
patterns. In most flow branches, the critical Rayleigh number o f the
flow transition from the flow patterns to the conductive states is
smaller than that o f the flow transition from the conductive states
Fig. 12. FP7 0.7 state at Ra = 246,000.
Table 5
Ra < 204,000. Furthermore, the FP7 0.7 state can also evolve toward Stability range of all flow patterns.
a FP2 0.7 state at 204,000 6 Ra < 217,000 though the FP7 0.7 state
H m Flow pattern Corresponding Fig. Range o f stability
isnt observed in the FP2 0.7 branch. When the FP5 0.7 is used as an
0.3 FP1 0.3 Fig. 3(a) 5400 6 Ra 6 206,000
initial condition, the stability range o f the FP5 0.7 state is assured
FP2 0.3 Fig. 3(b) 95,500 6 Ra 6 300,000
at 185,000 6 Ra 6 204,000; above this range, the FP5 0.7 state FP3 0.3 Fig. 8 4330 6 Ra 6 16,200
evolves into a FP2 0.7 state. The FP6 0.7 state remains stable only
0.5 FP1 0.5 Fig. 4(a) 21,000 6 Ra 6 31,700
in a small range o f 193,000 6 Ra 6 194,000 in its branch, and FP2 0.5 Fig. 4(b) 23,300 6 Ra 6 25,500
evolves into the FP5 0.7 state at 194,000 < Ra 6 204,000.
0.7 FP1 0.7 Fig. 5(a) 192,000 6 Ra 6 217,000
Its found the initial condition influences the R-B convection FP2 0.7 Fig. 5(b) 203,000 6 Ra 6 300,000
greatly. The transitions between the flow patterns in each flow FP3 0.7 Fig. 5(c) 213,000 6 Ra 6 300,000
branch are totally different. A new flow pattern appears in the FP4 0.7 Fig. 11(a) 190,000 6 Ra 6 204,000
FP2 0.3 branch at 0 m = 0.3, three new flow patterns in the FP2 FP5 0.7 Fig. 11(b) 185,000 6 Ra 6 204,000
FP6 0.7 Fig. 11(c) 193,000 6 Ra 6 194,000
0.7 branch and a new one in the FP4 0.7 branch at 0 m = 0.7. FP7 0.7 Fig. 12 218,000 6 Ra 6 300,000
However, no new flow pattern appears in the branch o f the two
Y.-P. Hu et al. /International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075 1073
to convection. For example, the conductive state o f 0 m = 0.3 loses and 14, respectively. At Ra = 40,000, four small hot flows and a cir
its stability and transits into the FP1 0.3 state at Ra = 5500, while cular one are observed in the corner and center at s = s0, respec
the FP1 0.3 state decays into the conductive state at Ra = 5400 tively. As time goes on, the hot flow in the center moves towards
when the FP1 0.3 state is used as an initial condition. It means that the right corner gradually. It merges with the cell in the right cor
there exists hysteresis for the flow transition, which is also discov ner after half a period. Then, it splits from the cell in the right cor
ered in the previous studies on the R-B convection o f common fluid ner again and moves to the center region at s0 + 3/4sp, as shown in
and cold water [10,31]. The R-B convection o f cold water in a rect Fig. 13(a). It illustrates that the movement o f the hot flow in the
angular cavity at 0 m = 0.5 can evolve into an oscillatory flow at a middle region is the main factor that results in the oscillatory flow.
small Rayleigh number. Therefore, the FP1 0.5 and FP2 0.5 flow In Fig. 14(a), the local temperature varies in a wide range from
patterns are just stable near the threshold o f the convection with 0 = 0.4 to 0 = 0.9 with a large oscillation amplitude, and the
a small range o f the Rayleigh number. dimensionless oscillation period is sp = 16.77.
As the Rayleigh number is increased to 80,000, the two hot
3.3. Oscillation flow flows at the bottom corner merge into a long strip o f cell and
occupy the region near the bottom sidewall, and the cells with a
When the Rayleigh number exceeds a certain critical value, the larger velocity becomes irregular, which leads that the symmetry
flow becomes unsteady and behaves an apparent oscillatory is broken at s = s0. In this case, the movement o f the hot flow in
behavior. However, the R-B convection o f cold water in a cubical the middle region is also responsible for the oscillatory flow, as dis
cavity is steady in the computation range o f Ra 6 300,000 in Ref. played in Fig. 13(b). Fig. 14(b ) shows the time history o f the local
[34]. The flow evolution in a period and the time history o f the temperature at Ra = 80,000. Compared with that at Ra = 40,000,
local temperature at a monitoring point are displayed in Figs. 13 the oscillation amplitude is decreased. The dimensionless
Fig. 14. Time history o f local temperature at a monitoring point (X = 0.5, Y = 0.5, Z = 0.5) (a) Ra = 40,000; (b ) Ra = 80,000.
1074 Y.-P. Hu et al./International Journal o f Heat and Mass Transfer 107 (2017 ) 1065-1075
and Ra = 300,000, while it is reduced to 1.53 at 0 m = 0.3. It illus [6] H. Benard, Les tourbillons cellulaires dans une nappe liquide. -Methodes
optiques d'observation et d'enregistrement, J. Phys. Theor. Appl. 10 (1901)
trates that the density maximum phenomenon inhibits the R-B
254-266.
convective heat transfer. Compared with the results in a cubical [7] O.M.F.R.S. Lord Rayleigh, LIX. On convection currents in a horizontal layer of
cavity [34], the average Nusselt number in a rectangular cavity is fluid, when the higher temperature is on the under side, Philos. Mag. J. Sci. 32
(1916) 529-546.
higher under the same condition, which means that the heat trans
[8] G.S. Charlson, R.L. Sani, On thermoconvective instability in a bounded
fer ability is enhanced. cylindrical fluid layer, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 14 (1971) 2157-2160.
[9] S. Rosenblat, Thermal convection in a vertical circular cylinder, J. Fluid Mech.
122 (1982) 395-410.
[10] F. Hebert, R. Hufschmid, J. Scheel, G. Ahlers, Onset o f Rayleigh-Benard
4. Conclusion convection in cylindrical containers, Phys. Rev. E 81 (2010) 046318.
[11] S.C. Mishra, A. Akhtar, A. Garg, Numerical analysis o f Rayleigh-Benard
This investigation aims at the R-B convection o f cold water near convection with and without volumetric radiation, Numer. Heat Transfer
Part A Appl. 65 (2014) 144-164.
its density maximum in a rectangular cavity with the aspect ratio
[12] P.H. Kao, R.J. Yang, Simulating oscillatory flows in Rayleigh-Benard convection
o f 2. The flow structures, the flow branch, the oscillatory flow and using the lattice Boltzmann method, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 50 (2007) 3315
the heat transfer characteristics are exhibited systematically. 3328.
[13] D. Sondak, L.M. Smith, F. Waleffe, Optimal heat transport solutions for
Based on the presented simulation data and discussion, the major
Rayleigh-Benard convection, J. Fluid Mech. 784 (2015) 565-595.
conclusions can be drawn as follows: [14] M.C. D'Orazio, C. Cianfrini, M. Corcione, Rayleigh-Benard convection in tall
rectangular enclosures, Int. J. Therm. Sci. 43 (2004) 135-144.
[15] N.Y. Zhan, Q. Gao, L. Bai, M. Yang, Experimental research on nonlinear
(1) The density maximum phenomenon affects significantly the
characteristics o f natural convection in a 3-D shallow cavity, Sci. China
R-B convection o f cold water in a rectangular cavity. The Technol. Sci. 54 (2011) 3304-3310.
critical Rayleigh number for the onset o f convection in a [16] N.Y. Zhan, P.W. Xu, S.M. Sun, M. Yang, J. Liu, Study on the stability and 3
rectangular cavity is smaller than that in a cubical cavity, dimensional character for natural convection in a rectangular cavity heated
from below, Sci. China Technol. Sci. 53 (2010) 1647-1654.
and the effect o f the aspect ratio on the critical value [17] F. Waleff, A. Boonkasame, L.M. Smith, Heat transport by coherent Rayleigh-
decreases with the increase o f the density inversion param Benard convection, Phys. Fluids 27 (2015) 051702.
eter. Additionally, the density inversion produces a destabi [18] D. Mukutmoni, K.T. Yang, Thermal convection in small enclosures: an atypical
bifurcation sequence, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 38 (1995) 113-126.
lizing temperature stratification in the lower part and a [19] J.F. Torres, D. Henry, A. Komiya, S. Maruyama, Bifurcation analysis o f steady
stabilizing one in the upper part o f the R-B system. natural convection in a tilted cubical cavity with adiabatic sidewalls, J. Fluid
(2) The flow transition in each flow branch are totally different, Mech. 756 (2014) 650-688.
[20] D. Puigjaner, J. Herrero, C. Simo, F. Giralt, From steady solutions to chaotic
which means that the initial condition influences the R-B
flows in a Rayleigh-Benard problem at moderate Rayleigh numbers, Physica D
convection. Many multiple-roll flow patterns are obtained 240 (2011)920-934.
for the R-B convection o f cold water in a rectangular cavity, [21] B.F. Wang, L. Zhou, J. Jia, D.J. Sun, Numerical investigation o f Rayleigh-Benard
convection in a cylinder o f unit aspect ratio, Fluid Dyn. Res. 48 (2016) 015503.
which is different from those in a cubical cavity.
[22] K. Boronska, L.S. Tuckerman, Extreme multiplicity in cylindrical Rayleigh-
(3) The flow patterns are just stable near the threshold o f the Benard convection. I. Time dependence and oscillations, Phys. Rev. E 81 (2010)
convection, and then the R-B convection becomes unsteady 036320.
[23] K. Boronska, L.S. Tuckerman, Extreme multiplicity in cylindrical Rayleigh-
and behaves an apparent oscillatory behavior at 0 m = 0.5.
Benard convection. II. Bifurcation diagram and symmetry classification, Phys.
The movement o f the hot flow in the middle region plays Rev. E 81 (2010) 036321.
the main role for the oscillatory flow. [24] F. Bousset, D.V. Lyubimov, G.A. Sedel'nikov, Three-Dimensional Convection
(4) The distribution o f the local Nusselt number shows a great Regimes in a cubical cavity, Fluid Dyn. 43 (2008) 1-8.
[25] D. Puigjaner, J. Herrero, F. Giralt, C. Simo, Bifurcation analysis o f multiple
difference for different flow patterns at various density steady flow patterns for Rayleigh-Benard convection in a cubical cavity at
inversion parameters. Each flow branch also has different P r = 130, Phys. Rev. E 73 (2006) 046304.
heat transfer abilities, which corresponds to different flow [26] D. Puigjaner, J. Herrero, C. Simo, F. Giralt, Bifurcation analysis o f steady
Rayleigh-Benard convection in a cubical cavity with conducting sidewalls, J.
character. Furthermore, compared with the results in a cubi Fluid Mech. 598 (2008) 393-427.
cal cavity, the heat transfer ability o f the R-B convection of [27] P.G. Daniels, E. Jhugroo, Pattern formation in rectangular planform containers,
cold water in a rectangular cavity is enhanced. Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math. 65 (2012) 161-180.
[28] M.F. Cawley, P.A. Mooney, P. O'Connor, Asymmetrical heat transfer through
composites o f water and aqueous solutions in the presence of the density
maximum, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 51 (2008) 224-236.
[29] S. Sivasankaran, C.J. Ho, Effect o f temperature dependent properties on natural
Acknowledgement convection o f water near its density maximum in enclosures, Numer. Heat
Transfer Part A Appl. 53 (2008) 507-523.
[30] M. Rahimi, A.A. Ranjbar, M.J. Hosseini, M. Abdollahzadeh, Natural convection
This work is supported by National Natural Science Foundation
o f nanoparticle-water mixture near its density inversion in a rectangular
o f China (Grant No. 51376199). W e thank Ms. Li Zhang for helpful enclosure, Int. Commun. Heat Mass 39 (2012) 131-137.
grammatical edits. [31] P.T. Zubkov, E.V. Kalabin, A.V. Yakovlev, Investigation o f natural convection in
a cubic cavity near 4 C, Fluid Dyn. 37 (2002) 847-853.
[32] E. Large, C.D. Andereck, Penetrative Rayleigh-Benard convection in water near
References its maximum density point, Phys. Fluids 26 (2014) 094101.
[33] Y.R. Li, Y.P. Hu, Y.Q. Ouyang, C.M. Wu, Flow state multiplicity in Rayleigh-
Benard convection o f cold water with density maximum in a cylinder o f aspect
[1] H. Singh, P.C. Eames, A review o f natural convective heat transfer correlations
ratio 2, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 86 (2015) 244-257.
in rectangular cross-section cavities and their potential applications to
[34] Y.P. Hu, Y.R. Li, C.M. Wu, Rayleigh-Benard convection o f cold water near its
compound parabolic concentrating (CPC) solar collector cavities, Appl.
density maximum in a cubical cavity, Phys. Fluids 27 (2015) 034102.
Therm. Eng. 31 (2011) 2186-2196.
[35] Y.P. Hu, Y.R. Li, C.M. Wu, Aspect ratio dependence o f Rayleigh-Benard
[2] I. Grants, G. Gerbeth, Rayleigh-Benard instability o f Czochralski configuration
convection o f cold water near its density maximum in vertical cylindrical
in a transverse magnetic field, J. Cryst. Growth 358 (2012) 43-50.
containers, Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 97 (2016) 932-942.
[3] T. Aicher, H. Martin, A. Polt, Rayleigh-Benard convection in vertical shell and
[36] J.F. Torres, D. Henry, A. Komiya, S. Maruyama, H. Ben Hadid, Three
tube heat exchangers, Chem. Eng. Process. 38 (1999) 579-584.
dimensional continuation study o f convection in a tilted rectangular
[4] J.Y. Moon, B.J. Chung, Time-dependent Rayleigh-Benard convection: cell
enclosure, Phys. Rev. E 88 (2013) 043015.
formation and Nusselt number, Nucl. Eng. Des. 274 (2014) 146-153.
[37] D. Puigjaner, J. Herrero, F. Giralt, C. Simo, Stability analysis o f the flow in a
[5] E. Bodenschatz, W. Pesch, G. Ahlers, Recent developments in Rayleigh-Benard
cubical cavity heated from below, Phys. Fluids 16 (2004) 3639-3655.
convection, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 32 (2000) 709-778.