Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
ARTICLES
Table 2: Changes in Weight Lifted and Repetitions Before and After Exercises
Weight (kg)
Bench press 42.7 17.3 62.5 20 46 .0001
Military press 60 18.2 68.3 17.8 14 .0002
Buttery press 52.3 12.6 64.2 12.8 23 .0001
Repetitions
Dumbbell: biceps 26.7 7.5 29.4 7.6 10 .0001
Dumbbell: triceps 35.8 14 42.4 16 18 .0001
Shoulder abductors 8.8 2.1 14.2 4 61 .0001
Abdominals in 1 47 9.9 62.4 6.4 33 .009
Curl back neck 112.3 30.9 134 30.7 19 .0001
161bpm). However, the maximum resistance achieved during after a suitable rehabilitation program approximately 6 months
the arm exercise test increased from 90 24 watts at the after the injury in paraplegics with lesions above T5, and at 3
beginning of the program to 110 26.1 watts at the end (p months for those with injuries below T5.20 The observation that
.001). Heart rate at 6 minutes after the exercise test was 115 FIM scores improved, despite the fact that in most patients
18.9bpm after the initial test and 108 18.6bpm at the end injuries were more than 6 months old, suggests that this type of
(p .05). activity should be included in the rehabilitation program to
Complications. Regarding pain,17 the following data were achieve optimal performance of each individual. Furthermore,
found. One, musculoskeletal pain was reported by 4 patients improvement in FIM scores was also shown by subjects who
during the initial evaluation. At the end of the program, pain had their injury for several years.21,22
persisted in 2 patients and the other 2 reported a neuropathic All scores on tests that evaluated changes in the physical
pain, 1 at the level of the injury and the other below it. Two, capacity (ie, the weights lifted, exercise repetitions, wheelchair
neuropathic pain below the injury level was reported by 4 skills) showed significant improvement. In particular, the
patients during the initial evaluation. At the end, it persisted in strength of the shoulder abductors increased, probably because
3. Three, neuropathic pain at the level of the injury was conventional rehabilitation programs for individuals with SCI
reported by 2 patients during the initial evaluation. At the end, emphasize strengthening the shoulder depressors and adductors
it disappeared in 1 and in the other was replaced by a muscu- and elbow extensors because they are important for activities
loskeletal pain. Four, of the 3 patients who began the program such as transfers. Therefore, this study is in agreement with
without pain, 1 finished with musculoskeletal pain. others23 that have shown how exercise can improve resistance
At the beginning of the program, 4 patients had pressure and muscular strength in individuals with paraplegia.
ulcers; of these, 3 were sacral stages 2 or 3, and 1 gluteal stage Even though at the end of the program only 1 patient had
2.18 At the end of the program, the gluteal sore and 1 of the cholesterol levels above the normal range, neither a significant
sacral had healed. None of the patients who entered the pro- decrease in LDL cholesterol nor an increase in HDL choles-
gram without ulcers developed this complication on termina- terol was achieved with the training program. These results are
tion. similar to those of the study by Janssen et al,24 which reported
A patient with a T8-level SCI presented with transient sinus that the aerobic capacity is not a determining factor for the
bradycardia and hypotension 3 minutes after starting the re- cholesterol levels in individuals with SCI; rather, Janssen
covery period of the arm crank exercise test. This alteration found that body mass index and the fat tissue as well as
reverted spontaneously before the monitoring at 6 minutes.19 consumption of alcohol or cigarettes were determining factors,
factors that were not considered in our study. Furthermore,
DISCUSSION HDL levels have a tendency to return to preexercise values
FIM score significantly improved in patients with paraplegia within 48 hours after exercising.25,26 Our study did not find
with both high- and low-thoracic level injuries. This is impor- significant changes in total cholesterol levels nor in the per-
tant because previous reports claim that FIM scores plateau centage of lean body weight or adiposity, as reported in the
Table 4: Patients Who Accomplished Wheelchair Activities 2. Backward propulsion receiving and throwing a ball.
Beginning of End of
The evaluated subject begins backward propulsion of 10
Skill Program (n) Program (n) meters. After advancing the first 5 meters, the instructor
throws a volleyball and the subject will have to catch it and
12. Go up a step of 12cm 1 5 throw it back while advancing the 5 remaining meters.
13. Go down a step of 12cm 1 11 Characteristics: the instructor is positioned 5 meters in
14. Go up a step of 8 cm 2 8 front of the subject when throwing the ball. The ground
15. Go Down a step of 8cm 4 12 will be similar to that of the previous skill.
16. Go up a step of 6 m 7 13 3. Forward propulsion doing a circle while turning right.
17. Go down a step of 6 m 7 13 The subject moves forward in 4 wheels along a circum-
18. Recline the wheelchair 4 13 ference with a diameter of 1 meter.
19. Advance with a reclined wheelchair 4 13 Characteristics: flat ground, cement surface, the inner
wheel should not be within the line of the circumference.
4. Back propulsion doing a circle while turning right.
5. Forward propulsion doing a circle while turning left.
study by Midha et al,27 who found a decrease in total choles- 6. Backward propulsion doing a circle while turning left.
terol and upper-arm fat area after an exercise program with the Skills 4, 5, and 6 have similar characteristic to those of skill 3.
wheelchair aerobic fitness trainer. 7. Forward propulsion between obstacles.
The use of the Durning method for such measurement can The evaluated subject advances with zig-zag move-
underestimate the average percentage of fat according to Spun- ments for 20 meters, between cones 22cm tall and 14cm
gen et al28 because lower limb tissues that will have more in diameter, set each in a straight line, 1 meter apart. The
significant changes after a SCI29 are not taken into consider- track will be 1.5 meters wide.
ation. A future study should estimate the fat percentage by 8. Back propulsion between obstacles.*
using the method by Steinkamp et al,30 which uses multiple Similar to the previous test, but backward.
skinfold measurements including the perimeter of the thigh. 9. Propulsion while picking up objects from the floor.
Work capacity (in watts) for the arm crank exercise test, The evaluated subject picks up and gives the following
achieved at the end of the study, was significantly higher than objects to the instructor while advancing a distance of
that at the beginning, and the heart rate 6 minutes after the 10 meters: 2 coins, a cane, a wood chunk of 5cm2, a
exercise test decreased. This suggests beneficial adaptation volleyball, and 2 balloons filled with 250mL of water.
responses to the training program and confirms the fact that Characteristics: objects will be located in straight line
daily activities are insufficient to increase the physical condi- 2m apart, in the established sequence and within a
tioning levels.31,32 The improvement observed in the exercise distance of 10 meters.
test can also be explained by better ventilatory mechanics 10. To open, to enter, and to close a door.
because of the physical training.33 The evaluated subject opens and enters a place through
Only 2 patients developed a musculoskeletal pain that could a door with the following characteristics: flat frame,
be attributed to the program. This is one of the frequently 80cm wide, 198cm high, and a key lock.
described complications when physical activities of greater 11. To open, to leave, and to close a door.
intensity than the ones required to propel the wheelchair are Similar characteristics to the previous skill.
performed. The neuropathic pain showed almost no change, 12. To go up a step 12cm high.
something that was expected because of the refractory aspect of 13. To go down a step 12cm high.
this type of pain. 14. To go up a step 8cm high.
One of the concerns we had at the beginning of the exercise 15. To go down a step 8cm high.
program was a possible lack of caution about skin complica- 16. To go up a step 6cm high.
tions while performing the routines. However, none of the 17. To go down a step 6cm high.
patients who entered the study with healthy skin developed For tests 12 through 17, the subject will have to ascend
pressure ulcers; furthermore, 2 of the 4 patients who had sores or descend the step correctly, to go up facing the step,
healed during the study. and descend backward.
18. To recline the wheelchair.
CONCLUSION The subject holds the wheelchair while balancing it on
Our directed exercise program had a positive impact in most its 2 larger wheels.
of the measures of physical function in the study, without Characteristics: flat ground, cement surface.
causing any significant complications. Therefore, we recom- 19. Propulsion while reclining the wheelchair.
mend that this type of activity be included in conventional The subject advances at least 2 meters with the wheel-
rehabilitation programs. chair reclined and resting in its 2 larger wheels.
20. To descend a ramp.
APPENDIX 1: WHEELCHAIR SKILLS The subject descends while rolling the wheelchair onto
Skills evaluation in the wheelchair: a ramp with a given distance and slope.
1. Forward propulsion, receiving and throwing a ball. 21. To climb a ramp.
The evaluated subject moves away from the instructor, The subject climbs a ramp with similar characteristics to
who is 20 meters away. The instructor throws a volley- the one in the previous skill.
ball when the subject has advanced 12 meters and then
the subject throws back the ball while advancing the 8
remaining meters.
* The time and the number of obstacles that the subject has contact with will be
Characteristics: flat ground, cement floor, straight line considered.
advancing movements. Catching the ball is made with- The wheelchairs used in the skills are conventional chairs owned by each of the
out stopping the wheelchair. individuals.
22. Hjeltnes N, Wallberg, Henriksson H. Improved work capacity but 28. Spungen AM, Bauman WA, Wang J, Pierson RN. Measurement
unchanged peak oxygen uptake during primary rehabilitation in of body fat in individuals with tetraplegia: a comparison of eight
tetraplegic patients. Spinal Cord 1998;36:691-8. clinical methods. Paraplegia 1995;33:402-8.
23. Gass GC, Camp EM, Davis HA, Eager D, Grout L. The effects of 29. Jones LM, Goulding A, Gerrard DF. DEXA: a practical and
prolonged exercise on spinally injured subjects. Med Sci Sports accurate tool to demonstrate total and regional bone loss, lean
Exerc 1981;13:277-83. tissue loss and fat mass gain in paraplegics. Spinal Cord 1998;36:
24. Janssen TW, van Oers CA, van Kamp GJ, Ten Voorde BJ, van der 637-40.
Woude LH, Hollander AP. Coronary heart disease risk indicators, 30. Steinkamp RC, Cohen NL, Gaffey WR. Measures of body fat and
aerobic power, and physical activity in men with spinal cord related factors in normal adults. II. J Chron Dis 1965;18:1291-307.
31. Hjeltnes N, Vokac Z. Circulatory strain in everyday life of para-
injuries. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1997;78:697-705.
plegics. Scand J Rehabil Med 1979;11:67-73.
25. Angelopoulos TJ, Robertson RJ, Goss FL, Metz KF, LaPorte RE. 32. Eriksson P, Lofstorm L, Ekblom B. Aerobic power during max-
Effect of repeated exercise bouts on high density lipoprotein- imal exercise in untrained and well-trained persons with quadri-
cholesterol and its subfractions HDL2-C and HDL3-C. Int plegia and paraplegia. Scand J Rehabil Med 1988;20:141-7.
J Sports Med 1993;14:196-201. 33. Silva AC, Neder JA, Chiurciu MV, Pasqualin DC, da Silva RC,
26. Bauman WA, Adkins RH, Spungen AM, Maloney P, Gambino Fernandez AC, et al. Effect of aerobic training on ventilatory
R, Waters RL. Ethnicity effect on the serum lipid profile in muscle endurance of spinal cord injured men. Spinal Cord 1998;
persons with spinal cord injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1998; 36:240-5.
79:176-80.
27. Midha M, Schmitt JK, Sclater M. Exercise effect with the wheel- Supplier
chair aerobic fitness trainer on conditioning and metabolic func- a. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Epidemiology Program
tion in disabled persons: a pilot study. Arch Phys Med Rehabil Office, Div of Public Health Surveillance and Informatics, 1600
1999;80:258-61. Clifton Rd, Atlanta, GA 30333.