Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1
Summary
Introduction 4
Case-specific scenarios 6
Contacts 22
Legislative References 26
Published by Coordination This publication was Boats 4 People (B4P) Member associations of Gisti (Groupe dinfor
Boats 4 People La Cimade made possible by the is an international the B4P steering mation et de soutien aux
Written by support of coalition established in committee include: immigres, France)
La Cimade, Fasti, Gisti Fondation de France 2011 to advocate for the Arci (Associazione La Cimade (France)
and Migreurop The Fund for Global rights of migrants at sea. ricreativa culturale LTDH (Ligue tunisienne
Translation Human rights B4Ps flagship initiative italiana) des droits de lhomme)
Laura Molinari Fondation un monde was a boat expedition AME (Association Migreurop (Euro african
Graphic design par tous between Italy and Tunisia malienne des expulss) network)
Bureau 205 Union des glises organized in 2012 to raise Aracem (Association
Printing protestantes dAlsace awareness about deaths des refouls dAfrique
April 2017, Lorraine (UEPAL) in the Mediterranean, to centrale au Mali)
Imprimerie highlight search and Fasti (Fdration
de la Centrale rescue requirements des associations de
62302 Lens under the law of the sea, solidarit avec tou-te-s
and to strengthen les immigr-e-s, France)
Euro-African solidarity. FIDH (Fdration
internationale des droits
de lhomme)
FTDES (Forum tunisien
pour les droits co
nomiques et sociaux)
Gadem (Groupe
antiraciste
daccompagnement
978-2-900595-38-1
et de dfense des
Copyrighted
trangers et migrants,
May 2017
Morocco)
ISBN
2 Boats 4 People 3
Introduction
The approaches described herein concern Italy
only. They can be followed in cases where a vessel
has sunk in Italian waters, or was rescued or
intercepted by vessels under the coordination of
Italian rescue operations.
This document has been designed as a guide to the
implementation of feasible approaches in the
absence of clear, systematic and relevant
procedures. It does not claim to resolve situations.
Unfortunately, many of the actions taken by
families are ultimately unsuccessful.
Purpose of the document, and cautionary note Support, including psychosocial support, should be
This document is for families who believe a loved available to families throughout the ordeal.
one may have perished crossing the Mediterranean Regrettably, there is no specific support structure
to Italy, and for the individuals or associations at present.
assisting them in their search.
1. mediterraneanmissing.eu
one are difficult. Each step is important, including missions carried out in Italy in 2015 and 2016. This
4 Boats 4 People 5
Case-specific scenarios
6 Boats 4 People 7
Steps 1 Gather as much
to be taken information
as soon as possible,
as possible as soon as possible
In most cases, search With any action you If you think that your Take note of and keep
or identification take, provide a stable loved one was a Try to make contact with presumed travel this information, even if
requests must come contact (address, phone passenger on one companions and their families it does not seem
from the immediate number, email) where you of the shipwrecks of These are the first people who may have important.
family, i.e. father, mother, can be reached even many October 3 and 11, 2013 information. If you manage to contact them, Searches can take a very
siblings, children, aunts months later, and keep in or April 18, 2015, indicate try to get: long time, and things that
and uncles, and as for touch with your contacts. this at every step in the Information about the place where they were may seem insignificant
administrative They must be able to process. brought to land after the crossing: country, city, initially may actually be
procedures, from the contact you should they contact information of shelter/housing, name of very important. Some
spouse. require additional any associations they contacted on arrival. In Italy, organizations or
information or if they find the name of the city of disembarkation of survivors individuals that assist
information about the is very important because it determines where families make recordings
person you are looking for. action must be taken; and/or use forms.
Information on how the trip went if they are able
to communicate it to you and on what might have
happened to the person you are looking for;
Information about where the travel companions are
when you contact them, and their contact
information so that you do not lose track of them.
8 Boats 4 People 9
Also approach the families of any travel
companions Gather information about the trip
They might be in touch with their surviving relatives or Planned or presumed maritime route, and the
might be in the same situation as you. Some families presumed place of arrival of the person you are
band together: acting as a group provides mutual looking for;
support and sometimes the authorities will pay more Date (probable or certain) and place where vessel
attention to a group. was boarded;
Some families use social networks (Facebook, Dates, times and content of messages you may
Twitter, etc.) to try to find their loved one or his/her have received from the person you are looking for,
friends. However, if you are not familiar with these and the phone number that person used
tools, be cautious and get advice from someone you to contact you;
trust. Date, time and place of a shipwreck, and if there
was interception or rescue at sea, by whom;
Obstacles to contacting and keeping Contact information of travel companions
in touch with travel companions (name, phone number, current location);
In Italy, people generally do not stay in the first Contact details for relatives in the destination
EUNAVFOR Med
military operation (also
called Sophia) which aims
to identify, seize and
10 Boats 4 People 11
2 Contact 3 Reach out
the Red Cross, The Red Cross and the
ICRC never give
personal information to
the authorities nor
to the various
Red Crescent publish it, unless you
have expressly authorized
them to do so.
authorities in Italy
or International
12 Boats 4 People 13
Report the disappearance in Italy
The Law of 2012 establishes a reporting
procedure for missing persons. The procedure is Victim
identification
initiated with the police in Italy and cannot be done
from abroad. It is not mandatory, but is recommended For families living in
if you live in Italy. Europe in an irregular
administrative
situation, it is advisable
procedures
that you have the
assistance of an
association for any
dealings with the police
and repatriation
and the prefecture, in
order to avoid any risk
related to an irregular
In the wake of the shipwrecks of Italy quickly declared that it would 1 Investigation
and identification
October 3 and 11, 2013 off the coast of recover the wreck from the bottom of
Lampedusa, and the shipwreck of April the sea in order to recover the victims
18, 2015, Italy is the first European remains. This initiative was carried out
country to have developed specific in July 2016, and a large-scale
protocols for the identification of identification process was coordinated
of the deceased
migrants who have perished in the by Labanof (forensic anthropology and
Mediterranean. odontology laboratory) at the University
of Milan, led by Cristina Cattaneo, and
The October 3, 2013 disaster was a SCMP services. As of late 2016, the
deep shock to the public because it process of contacting families was
resulted in the death of 384 people near ongoing.
the coast. Almost all of the victims An investigation is opened and conducted by the
bodies were recovered. The protocol These protocols are not binding and public prosecutor and the police (squadra mobile)
establishes rules for identification are not applicable outside of those whenever someone perishes during a sea voyage.
procedures. Also since 2013, the specific cases. The purpose is not to identify the victims, but rather to
Special Commissioner for Missing determine whether a crime or offence has been
Persons, Prefect Vittorio Piscitelli, Apart from these three cases, the committed, and to find those responsible. However, if
specifically included migrants missing standard procedure described in this a crime is suspected, the prosecutor may order an
at sea in his mandate. document is much more complex, autopsy after carrying out the necessary
particularly because it does not take investigations to identify the victim.
The April 18, 2015 incident, the most into consideration the particular
fatal known shipwreck in the characteristics of migrants who have
Mediterranean, resulted in the perished or disappeared at sea.
disappearance of nearly 800 people.
14 Boats 4 People 15
In practice, there are considerable differences in how Collection of the victims DNA from media
victims are identified depending on the circumstances provided by the family (e.g. hair) or DNA samples
of the tragedy, the needs of the investigation, the from members of the immediate family
means of the city in charge, and the possibility of a (comparison with the DNA of parents and children
swift identification (relatives on board the boat, is the most reliable);
photos, etc.), but also on the willingness of the public Comparison of DNA profiles and determination of
prosecutor and/or police officers in charge, who are the degree of similarity.
more or less aware of the importance of identifying
the deceased. Autopsies and DNA samples are not performed
systematically in Italy. In the process after a death, an
autopsy is used to determine cause of death. In the
case of deaths at sea, the cause can often be
Visual identification determined by an external examination. The high cost
This form of identification involves recognition of of sample collection also contributes to their rarity.
the deceased by relatives. Some victims can be Moreover, beyond the protocol established for the
identified quickly if relatives were on the boat. October 3, 2013 shipwreck, there are no standardized
External distinguishing
features
This includes
clothing, personal items
or distinguishing marks Key definitions Storage of data on migrants who are deceased
such as tattoos and scars. or missing at sea
Identification is the Ante mortem data are No common and specific There are other RiSc (Ricerca
process of establishing a data collected from a database currently exists, databases, but their scomparsi, search for
DNA and dental persons identity. living person, such as yet this is the only way usefulness is very limited missing persons) is a
samples photos or DNA substrates that some families can at present: database of the Italian
If samples are Biometrics is a (e.g. hair). find perished relatives police connected to the
incomplete or were taken technique used to identify even many years The register of general database of the
under the wrong a person based on Post-mortem data is data later or get information unidentified bodies judicial police (the SDI,
conditions, identification biological elements collected after a persons about their (Registro nazionale dei sistema dindagini,
is not always possible. specific to each death, such as biological disappearance. cadaveri non identificati), investigation system).
DNA identification individual, such as specimens. which is not specific to It is not available to the
comprises several steps: fingerprints, morphology, To identify the body of a Specific databases migrants. It contains public.
Establishing a DNA, etc. deceased person, the were created for the information such as:
presumption of post-mortem data must identification of victims of physical description,
identity (based on DNA is present in human be compared with the the October 3 and 11, 2013 nationality or origin
external cells and contains each ante-mortem data and April 18, 2015 (established or
distinguishing human beings specific provided by the family. shipwrecks. presumed), age (actual or
features, for genetic information. It can estimated), and the date,
example); be collected from place and circumstances
Biological specimens biological specimens of death. Although
from the victims body such as blood stains or regularly updated, at the
and their hair, but is best preserved end of 2016, it only
preservation; in the bones and teeth. contained information up
to June 2014. It is
available online.
16 Boats 4 People 17
2 The familys role
Once the investigation is completed, the public
prosecutor produces the burial authorization
(nullaosta al seppelimento), which allows a death
certificate to be issued. There may be situations
in the identification
where one of these documents is not issued. In this
case, locating graves can be difficult because only the
municipality responsible for the burial has information
on where the person was buried.
Burials normally meet the conditions required by
process
Italian law. There are no mass graves; people are
interred in individual coffins. However, several coffins
may be interred in one grave. If the name of the person
is unknown, an identification number of the deceased
and date of death are listed on the grave.
of victims bodies
for a temporary residence permit for judicial
proceedings, but these permits are limited to cases
where the public prosecutors office believes the
presence of relatives to be necessary. It is valid for
three months and can be renewed only once.
If repatriation was not possible soon after death, Repatriation of the
3 In case of
Death certificates municipal legislation generally imposes a period of victims body is
several months or even years before a body can be sometimes impossible if
If the victims body has not exhumed. that person was a
been recovered, it is very refugee or if members of
difficult to get a death Steps to take: the persons family are
confirmed death:
certificate, even if the Consular pass: issued by the consulate of the threatened in their
family was present and country of origin in Italy, if such country recognizes country because of the
witnessed the death the person as a citizen of the country. The role in the repatriation
during the crossing. It consulate may be seized by a liaison in Italy acting procedure of the
knowing where
must be obtained via on behalf of the family (e.g., an association or authorities in the country
judicial proceedings that funeral home). This delegation must sometimes be of origin.
can take months or years. certified by the municipality of the country of origin
In some cases, the family that will be receiving the body of the deceased.
is certain of the death and Authorization to take the body out of the country
laid to rest
administrative Arrangement, additional documentation may be
(inheritance, remarriage, required.
etc.) viewpoint.
18 Boats 4 People 19
Document stating the terms of repatriation:
issued by the funeral company that you contact
and that will take care of repatriation to the home
or to the airport of the country of origin (if the
family can prove that another funeral home
will provide transportation from the airport to Repatriation is a very
the home). costly procedure that is
not covered by Italy,
and rarely by the country
of origin.
Many families are Nation Working Group on and Italian governments In Italy
mobilizing and claiming Enforced or Involuntary to find the truth. This Activists have been
a right to know. Disappearances, which mobilization has led to assisting families in their
now includes migration the creation of a searches and efforts for
In Algeria within its scope of work. commission of inquiry years. Held since 2015,
The Annaba collective of and monitoring of the march of the new
harraga families was In Tunisia missing Tunisians. desaparecidos recalls
created by a group of Many families have the battle of the
parents after their mobilized since 2011. In Morocco Argentine Mothers of the
children disappeared at Some have formed The association Plaza de Mayo which has
sea between 2007 and associations such as La Caminando Fronteras is been taking place since
2008. Some families terre pour tous or Mres assisting the families of the late 70s. To give a
report having had contact des disparus. The Forum migrants in Morocco who face to the victims,
with them right before tunisien pour les droits perished in the Tarajal protesters carry the
their boat was conomiques et sociaux affair in trying to hold the photos of missing
intercepted by the (FTDES) was one of the Guardia civil responsible persons sent by families.
Tunisian coast guard. first associations to and pursue criminal The march began in
A lawyer, Kouceila provide assistance to action. The association Milan and has now
Zerguine, has filed these families. The group has also produced a spread to other cities in
complaints in Algeria and has taken a census of documentary on Italy and Europe.
Tunisia on behalf of the Tunisians who have gone transforming pain into
group, and has also missing at sea, and justice.4
appealed to the United pressures the Tunisian
20 Boats 4 People 21
Contacts
Algeria
The Collective of harraga families (Annaba)
Kamel Belabed, spokesperson for the collective:
+ 213 558 805673
+ 213 661 570 220
photocompos@gmail.com
Kouceila Zerguine, lawyer:
+ 213 790 204412
+ 213 385 857 78
zerguine-kouceila@hotmail.fr
22 Boats 4 People 23
Palermo In Calabria
Procura della Repubblica presso Cosenza
il Tribunale di Palermo Procura della Repubblica presso
Piazza Vittorio Emanuele Orlando il Tribunale di Cosenza
90138 Palermo (PA) Italia Piazza Gullo, s.n.c.
+ 39 91 742 111 87100 Cosenza (CS) Italia
procura.palermo@giustizia.it + 39 984 487 111
procura.palermo.giustizia.it procura.cosenza@giustizia.it
procura.cosenza.giustizia.it
Ragusa (covers the city of Pozzalo)
Procura della Repubblica presso Reggio Calabria
il Tribunale di Ragusa Procura della Repubblica presso
Via Natalelli il Tribunale di Reggio Calabria
97100 Ragusa (RG) Italia Via SantAnna Palazzo CE.DIR
+ 39 932 67 81 11 89128 Reggio Calabria (RC) Italia
procura.ragusa@giustizia.it + 39 965 85 71
procura.ragusa.giustizia.it procura.reggiocalabria@giustizia.it
procura.reggiocalabria.giustizia.it
Siracusa
Procura della Repubblica presso Crotone
il Tribunale di Siracusa Procura della Repubblica presso
Viale S. Panagia il Tribunale di Crotone
96100 Siracusa (SR) Italia Piazza L. Calabresi C.A.P.
+ 39 931 752 111 88900 Crotone (KR) Italia
procura.siracusa@giustizia.it + 39 962 920 111
procurasiracusa.it procura.crotone@giustizia.it
tribunale.crotone.it
Trapani
Procura della Repubblica presso il Tribunale di Trapani
Via XXX Gennaio
91010 Trapani (TP) Italia
+ 39 923 802 111
procura.trapani@giustizia.it
procura.trapani.it
24 Boats 4 People 25
Legislative
References
26 Boats 4 People 27
According to the United Nations High
Commissioner for Refugees, over
12,000 people have lost their lives in the
Mediterranean in their attempt to
migrate to Europe. That number was
5,022 in 2016 alone. Most remain
unidentified.
These tragedies are the result of
European migration policies which, in
trying to prevent people from coming to
Europe, are forcing the exiled to take
increasingly perilous routes.
Behind every person who has gone
missing at sea is a mother, father, spouse,
children, cousins and friends, all waiting, in
anguish and in hope.
The lack of systematic and standardized
procedures prevents families from
accessing information. Yet when a disaster
(natural disaster, terrorist attack, etc.)
affects their own citizens, European States
are able to deploy sophisticated devices to
try to recover and identify the victims
bodies. There are established procedures
contact@boats4people.org