Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Ireland moved from having one of the most depressed economies in Europe to having one
of the most quickly growing. Many social and legal changes accompanied this economic
growth. Irish step dancing as a cultural phenomenon has been impacted by shifts in the
political and economic landscape of Ireland. To address changes in the structure and
practice of contemporary competitive Irish step dancing, scholars must assess recent
Throughout the middle and end of the 1990s, Ireland witnessed a surge of
unparalleled economic growth. The average per capita income of a resident of Ireland,
which as recently as the 1980s was far below the European average, has grown higher
than that of most countries in Europe. Indeed, the per capita income of Ireland
exceeded that of the United Kingdom in 1997, and has continued that trend for every
year following to the present—2007 (McCarthy, 13). In the same period, and as a result
of various factors, Ireland witnessed a dramatic fall in the level of absolute poverty.
The unemployment rate fell from 17 percent to less than 4 percent between the 1980s
and 2001. This pattern of growth became known as the “Celtic Tiger” boom.
“favorable” environment for foreign investment including low corporate tax rates, an
104
elastic supply of well-educated and inexpensive labor, flexible labor markets and
“industrial peace” (that is, a relative lack of conflict between labor unions and
late-1990s.
The concurrent sustained economic boom in the United States also spurred
growth in the Irish economy. Stephen D. Oliner and Daniel E Sichel note in their 2000
article, “The Resurgence of Growth in the Late 1990s: Is Information Technology the
Story?” that “from 1995 through 1999” the American gross domestic product rose “at
an annual rate of more than 4 percent” (3). Overseas investment by U.S. firms also rose
dramatically in the 1990s. The transatlantic (U.S. to Europe) flow of this growth is
Together? The Primacy of the Transatlantic Economy.” Quinlan states that out of the
105
Whereas Ireland had been, until the 1980s, in the words of O’Toole, “an economic
satellite of the UK,” political and economic realities were altered as “European and
American markets became steadily more important” (2003: 8). This development
parallels with changes in Irish step dancing culture in the 1990s and 2000s, when
dancers from mainland Europe became more represented within the competitive
structure and as the population of dancers in North America steadily grew in size.
economy and attracting investors. Ireland’s literacy rates have increased steadily since
the Irish state began, in 1967, to administer secondary education, which previously had
been directed under the auspices of the Catholic church, and generally required a fee for
services (Raferty and Hout, 44). In addition investment into university education, and,
Irish workers for the information technology development and manufacturing industries
technology, largely the growth of “new media.” Because of the high rates of technical
education, as well as the relatively low wages demanded by workers (in comparison to
the rest of Europe), Ireland was able to attract the interest of software companies and
largest exporter of software in the world after the United States” (Cronin in Kirby,
Gibbons, and Cronin 56). While Ireland’s economic growth had previously been
hampered by the particular location of the island, in addition to other factors, the focus
106
on “informatic and telecommunications networks”—which are not dependent as
allowed Ireland to become integrated within the global economy regardless of its
geographic isolation.
transfers of funds for infrastructure and training (29-30). These structural funds, which
Clinch suggests that while the growth of the Irish economy may have increased
living standards for most of the population and while the incidence of extreme poverty
decreased significantly in the 1990s, there was little overall movement towards
economic equality (32). Whereas most in Ireland felt some positive economic effects of
development and the inflow of investment monies into Ireland, the boom did not
increase wealth equally for all, and there remained a high level of inequality between the
rich and the poor of Ireland. In the words of Clinch, there was “no significant trend in
the level of relative poverty between 1994 and 1998” (33). Subsequent studies, such as
one conducted in 2003 by the Economic and Social Research Institute, reported that
median relative poverty in Ireland had actually increased more than twofold since 1994,
increasing from 6% in 1994 to 12.9% in 2001 (Bacik 17). According to Peadar Kirby,
the “high economic growth rates of the 1990s [were] accompanied by growing relative
107
(30). Kirby further locates the engines of “the transformation of Ireland in the 1990s” in
the forces of “foreign capital, attracted by a state which has consistently prioritized the
needs of the economy over social objectives” (28-29). Ireland indeed spends the lowest
percentage of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP), out of all of the member states of the
redistribute wealth and alleviate poverty. While the European average for such spending
While Ireland as a whole became far wealthier, Clinch further states, “it is clear
that the evidence based on relative income inequality shows a less rosy picture of the
effects of the boom than one based on absolute incomes” (33). In terms of economic
equality figures Ireland ranks lower, year after year, than almost all other European
nations. Irish economic equality figures more closely mirror American than European
averages. In the words of Lionel Pilkington, “in 1999, the gap between rich and poor
[among the developed nations studied] was second only to the United States” (125). The
2003 United Nations Human Development Report listed Ireland second lowest among
seventeen OECD nations in terms of poverty and inequality levels; the only nation
Ireland ranked higher than in the study was the United States (Bacik 16). The levels of
inequality in both Ireland and the United States are quite a contrast to levels in many
countries in the European Union. Thus, despite bettered averages in terms of per capita
income, inequalities of wealth in Ireland increased during the Celtic Tiger boom.
108
In her book, Kicking and Screaming: Dragging Ireland into the twenty-first
Century, jurist and feminist Ivana Bacik strongly criticizes the developing inequality in
Ireland. She describes this as the development of “two Irelands” composed of:
She, along with others, notes the different impacts of neo-liberal development and
integration into the European Union on different populations. Where in some areas, such
as gender, Bacik may see positive developments with regards to Ireland, in the areas of
Peadar Kirby attributes the lack of economic equality in Ireland to the state’s (and,
equality of condition” (25). Kirby further states that the Irish nation has:
It is questionable whether the state of the Republic of Ireland has decreased its role in
109
“socialist” projects than other states in Western Europe. However, Kirby may be
In his chapter, “Ireland, Globalisation and the War Against Time,” Michael
Cronin discusses the irregular access not only to wealth in Ireland, but also to freedom in
terms of travel and migration. According to Michael Cronin, during the Celtic Tiger
boom, the Dublin to London air route became the busiest in Europe. Indeed, in “1999, the
number of [residents of Ireland] going abroad was 3,576,000 compared with 2,547,000
for 1996, an increase of almost one million in a relatively short three-year period” (56).
Remarking on this phenomenon, Cronin quipped, “movement has most definitely been in
the air” (56). However, Cronin notes that airfare, and travel in general is only accessible
Cronin states that although “tourists can now get to the West of Ireland quicker
than ever before and the construction of each bypass on the Dublin-Galway means urban
elites can reach their holiday homes in a shorter and shorter period of time,” the same
does not apply to many of those people in Ireland still living in poverty (61). Poverty, it
bears mention, is more and more concentrated in rural as opposed to urban areas, and in
the “idyllic” west as opposed to the “modern” east (63). Of the fate of those who live, and
are more likely to be impoverished, in the west, Cronin remarks, “the tourists come and
go but the poor remain” (61). Furthermore, even as Ireland has become integrated into the
European Union and has hence opened up possibilities for its own citizens in terms of
crossing borders, Ireland has taken a fairly combative stance against undocumented
110
immigrants within its own borders. People born in Ireland are no longer immediately
…as Irish citizens find it easier and easier to travel abroad through the
easing of border controls in Europe and the waiving of visa restrictions in
more and more countries, Ireland itself for non-nationals proves more and
more impenetrable (63).
There is some irony in the immigration situation, especially in light of the fact that the
Republic Ireland for most of its history as a nation state had extremely high emigration
Roles for women in Ireland have expanded significantly since the 1980s, as T.W.
Moody and F.X. Martin describe in their book, The Course of Irish History. Throughout
the 1990s a number of women held high office in the country, most notably the
Presidents of Ireland, Mary Robinson and Mary McAleese. The changing economy
“provided opportunities for many women entrepreneurs to come to the fore, and
However, Ireland falls short of the legal and economic parity achieved by some
added in the 1990s and in the present decade. Later, according to Bacik, “the Equal
Status Act 2000… extended the concept of equality beyond the workplace” (96). While
the potentialities for changes in gender relations and gender equality in Ireland are
111
considerably constrained by both the Irish constitution, with its regard of women largely
limited to respect for their place in the home, and by the power of Catholic religious
teachings, which still have significant weight in the nation, several initiatives have been
made which in effect move the rights of Irish women and homosexuals under law closer
laws now exist which support the equalization of gender roles in Ireland, there still
remain many areas where legal protection does not exist or where implementation is
poor. To take only two examples, a “huge” pay differential still exists between men and
women, and the “majority of low-paid workers are women” (92-93). Thus, Irish women
sexuality were altered during the same period, including the decriminalization of
The practice of abortion, however, remains hotly contested and is largely illegal. In 1995,
divorce was legalized by a referendum in the South (Moody and Martin 336). However, it
is important to note that although changes in laws may be triggered by some elements of
public demand, they do not necessarily act to change the ideologies of all members of the
public, which may be either more progressive or regressive than the law, or may feature a
variety of opinions.
In Ireland, developments in art and culture and economic changes have been
112
creation of internationally successful shows such as Riverdance, or through the use of,
especially, music and dance to promote tourism) has been one prominent strategy of
‘Culture’ has turned out to be one of the boom industries of the 1990s and
one of Ireland’s greatest exports. It has been estimated that top selling
artists such as U2, the Cranberries, Enya, Sinéad O’Connor, Chris
DeBurgh and Van Morrison, between them, have sold over 150 million
records worldwide, with a minimum retail turnover of nearly US$2.5
billion” (1998: 5).
In addition, Michel Peillon notes in his article, “Culture and State in Ireland’s New
Economy,” that “the leisure and art sector… nearly doubled” over the period from 1986
to 1996 (49). Some events that attract tourists, aside from the World Championships of
Irish dancing and other competitions, include the Willie Clancy Irish Music and Dance
Festival and the Dublin Dance Festival. In addition, there is a business specifically set
up to provide tourists with opportunities to access Irish music and dancing culture,
cultural forms such as music and dance has had a significant effect on the Irish
economy, by providing work for artists, but also as a tool to increase tourism and help
between the changes underfoot in the Irish economy and social landscape of the mid-
1990s, the ways in which Riverdance presented Irish culture, and the ways in which
113
Riverdance began as an intermission segment in the Eurovision Song Contest in
April of 1994. The Eurovision contest is, in summary, a yearly one-off European
competition wherein pop groups that have been selected to represent various European
variety of places, and, that year, it was held in Ireland. The producers of the 1994
Eurovision contest, Moya Doherty and John McColgan, of RTÉ Television, sought to
produce something for the interval, or intermission, during the broadcast competition
that would create a sensation, and, more than that, present Ireland in an exciting and
Kavanagh, and Carmen Kuhling, term it—to viewers in the rest of Europe (11). That
Noting the extremely positive reaction the general public gave to the short
intermission piece, the producers decided to launch a full-scale stage show the next year,
in February of 1995. The reception of the full-length show, first held at the Point Theatre
in Dublin, was incredible, and the show completely sold out all available seats for all
five weeks of the first run. Riverdance: The Show then moved to London. This was only
the beginning for Riverdance, which, according to Michael Cronin, had been seen by
“more than 62 million people [at] 200 plus shows in over 60 venues” by the end of 1998
(63). Cronin further states that, “the Riverdance roadshow with three permanently
touring troupes covering Europe, North America and the Rest of the World became the
world’s biggest grossing entertainment event in 1997” (63). For several years the
114
In 2007, more than a decade after its debut, the show is still touring in both
Europe and North America. In addition, the album for Riverdance won a Grammy in
1997, and was certified Platinum in the US, Ireland, and Australia. More than six million
units of the three Riverdance videos had been sold by 2002, sales figures which are
according the Barra Ó Cinnéide, “equivalent figures to the top Disney titles.” (2002: 86).
Ó Cinnéide further states that, “at the show’s peak, [the three touring companies
generated] total office revenues of over ₤100 million annually. To that can be added ₤5
million per annum in merchandising and a total sale of ₤90 million from three
Riverdance videos” (2002: 86). It does not seem an overstatement to say that this was
“success” on a scale unlike any Irish step dancing had ever experienced.
The commercial success of Riverdance was not simply a fluke: the show was
designed to appeal to a mass audience. One of the most important factors that
distinguishes the choreography, fashion, and ideology of Riverdance from that which is
“on this occasion the dance was designed for international entertainment purposes with a
global market in mind” as opposed to being designed for the more insular audience
Many sectors of the indigenous Irish economy (that is, sectors not stimulated by
foreign direct investment) remained relatively stagnant over the period of the boom.
However, Kieran Keohane, Donncha Kavanagh, and Carmen Kuhling, who are experts
in marketing and management, posit that “cultural entrepreneurship, or, to coin a new
115
term, artrepreneurship” bucked this trend, and generated large amounts of revenue (12).
In their working paper, “The Creative Scene of Riverdance: Artrepreneurship and the
Celtic Tiger,” they address the ways in which art and culture enterprises in Ireland, such
as Riverdance, shaped the Irish economic boom. In a related vein, economist Barra Ó
Cinnéide analyzes ways in which “voluntary and other nonprofit cultural groups” such
as An Coimisiún and An Comhdháil, as well as the many dancing schools under their
different jurisdictions, forged the foundation for the development of Riverdance, which
globalized Ireland, in his 1998 paper, “The Nonprofit Origins and Impact of Riverdance:
The Show That Became More Than an Enterprise” (1998: 403). Ó Cinnéide describes
the way in which nonprofit groups raised the capacity of the community in terms of its
responsible for the development of many nonprofit initiatives locally in Ireland and
globally in the Irish diaspora” such as dancing groups (1998: 409). Other products
accessories catered to Irish dancing markets, such as shoes, dresses, and magazines, as
well as tourist ventures celebrating Irish arts, videos teaching Irish step dancing, Irish
music cds, and competing stage shows exhibiting Irish step dancing, as well as general
Riverdance and subsequent economic developments. In his 2002 book, Riverdance: The
116
and portrays it as an important component of the Celtic Tiger economy. According to the
author, Riverdance and other cultural arts productions enabled the “development of
business and tourism” in Ireland (2002: 4). The producers of Riverdance were able to tap
into the global Irish diaspora market, “not just in Britain and the US but also in cities like
Sydney, Toronto, Auckland, Paris, Brussels and in the German cities such as Munich,
Dusseldorf and Frankfurt” (2002: 53). The imperative to display the arts of Ireland in the
Riverdance portion of the Eurovision television interval was driven by the notion held by
RTE executives that positive international public relations, as might be an expected result
from a well-received and internationally witnessed performance of Irish dance and music,
would stimulate tourism. If this expectation holds true, it suggests that the effects of a
globally touring stage show in increasing tourism to Ireland may have been quite
significant.
Some scholars have suggested that the imagery and formations of Riverdance:
The Show are a direct product of the Celtic Tiger economy. According to Michael
Cronin, “for Irish media pundits, Riverdance was incontrovertible proof of Ireland’s
enrollment in the chorus line of modernity” (Cronin in Kirby, Gibbons, and Cronin 63).
Cronin suggests that the formations created by the producers and performers of
troupes that are named after rivers—the Lagan, the Lee and the Liffey—flow unimpeded
through global space” as does capital in neoliberal Ireland (64). Cronin further states:
117
and which has resisted pressures to publicly fund social legislation in
member states of the European Union could readily identify with the
profitable velocity of one of Ireland’s foremost cultural industries (64).
The speed and efficiency with which the dancers of Riverdance traversed the clear, open
stages of the world, and the way their extensively-trained feet battered precise rhythms
Keohane, Kavanagh, and Kuhling discuss the ways in which the mechanical
meanings and reception. 2 The authors describe concisely the way in which the show has
circulated as a product:
The authors suggest that products such as Riverdance change in the course of
produced by the artreprenuer,” such as Riverdance “are invested with desires and filled
out with the fantasies of the consumer/ spectator/ audience in a mutually fascinated gaze
that constitutes the scene of performance” (19). However, to appeal to the mass
audience, and to engage with it, some of the complex meanings that Irish step dancing
might produce may be watered down; Riverdance in some ways turns Irish step dancing,
and modernized cultural product, as carefully packaged and cleverly marketed as a six-
118
pack of Budweiser” (19). Some practitioners of Irish dancing may be deeply troubled by
what they might perceive as a deterioration of culture in this process. For example, a
variety of commentators have had concerns about the effects of Riverdance on Irish step
onlookers, writing, “Riverdance provoked questions about the long-term effects on Irish
excessive commercialisation debases traditional art forms, such as Irish dance” (2). Ó
cultures. However, he falls into a common trap of seeing “culture” as a static (authentic,
her article, “Screening the Green: Cinema Under the Celtic Tiger,” Debbie Ging, raises
similar concerns about the effects of media images such as Riverdance on Irishness as an
identity, and specifically the use of Irishness “as a means of critical self-questioning”
(177). Ging suggests that that instead of contributing to such querying, shows like
Riverdance, as well as musical artists such as The Corrs and movies such as Angela’s
Ashes may “have started to erase this type of self-questioning in favor of a more
119
argument for Irish dancing as a whole, as well as its cultural “purpose.” Irish dancing no
longer serves the early twentieth-century nationalist purposes of the Irish League, for
example. Does it rather act as a promotional vehicle for the consumption of Irish goods
“Riverdance sold the world on Irish dance by successfully producing and marketing a
particular version of Irish national identity for the global market” (2003: 355-356). As a
product, Riverdance presents a portrayal of Irish and Irish culture that, as opposed to
“[referencing] Irish’s own evolving multinational society,” portrays Irish among the
disconnected from Irish as a specific, and evolving, place, and only make limited
Morrison writes, “The show glosses over the material conditions out of which Irish
dance and culture emerged, to embrace the image of contemporary Irish as an authentic
and ethnically pure nation” (2003: 350). Riverdance also sidesteps developing issues of
defining characteristics of Irish culture” (2003: 352). The Irish step dancing and culture
reference to either the historical context in which they developed or the present-day
domination and famine” and “instead [narrating] Irish migration as a ‘story of the
120
heart’” (2003: 349). Some of the scenes of Riverdance, such as “Trading Taps” and
“Irish Wake” could have offered opportunities for discussions of the pain of migration
(or indeed, some of the factors contributing to high rates of emigration, such as extreme
poverty and the colonial relationship), or interethnic conflict between Irish immigrants
and African-Americans. However, Morrison is correct to note that while these topics are
given lip service, they really aren’t addressed in any substantive manner. In absenting
these contexts, Irish step dancing, as a product that is sold by Riverdance, becomes
segment was abstract in terms of its themes and design, and does not make reference to
Irish America. As the segment was expanded into the show, however, the American
influences became more predominant. According to Barra Ó Cinnéide, “It has made
programmes like The Today Show (viewership: 11 million) and full-length broadcasts of
the show have been screened on most of the 350 Public Broadcasting Stations (PBS) in
the US, ensuring an enviable demographic breadth of audience reach” (114). Ó Cinnéide
describes the way in which Riverdance was able to network “into cities and
communities who claim ethnic descent or affinity, in markets such as the USA (with a
reputed 44 million ‘Irish’ population), Canada, UK, Australia, New Zealand, South
Africa, Argentina, etc.” Ó Cinnéide further states that, “Riverdance had a strong first
base from which to develop its worldwide operations” because of these ethnic
121
affiliations (2002: 55). In this regard, is notable that the two lead stars of the original
Gaelacha), in Chicago, and Jean Butler was taught by Donny Golden, A.D.C.R.G., in
New York. However, the vast majority of the original cast was Irish-born (many hailing
from the esteemed school of Seamus O’Se in Dublin), and the funding and direction of
The themes and subject matter of Riverdance: The Show also directly addressed
O’Toole, “It began life as the interval act at the Eurovision, but actually contradicted the
context” (147). Indeed the majority of the second half of the full-length show shifts
away from Irish mythological tales (a feature of the first half) to stories of emigration to
America, and intercultural exchange on the streets of the new nation. In the words of Ó
Cinnéide, “…Riverdance: The Show contains themes that are global, such as emigration
and justice” (2002: 107). Natasha Casey, who wrote about the show in her 2002 article,
“Riverdance: The Importance of Being Irish American,” notes that the show was
described by the New York Times as a “mishmash of a variety show with a one-world
theme” (11). Although perhaps the attempts to broaden the message of the show, or try
to instill a sense of racial harmony are worthwhile in their intentions, the way that the
show carries it out does indeed make cultures seem to be little more than signifiers in a
122
racial relations and immigration histories—by portraying the process so positively.
American viewers may well have found the inclusion of these culturally specific
messages in the longer Riverdance: The Show attractive. This “mishmash” appealed
interaction. Casey states that the show was an “immediate success with many middle-
class Irish Americans,” who may have been attracted by both the glamour of the show
and also the multicultural message—the plot suggested positive resolutions to racial and
ethnic conflicts could be, and indeed already had been, resolved calmly by activities
such as “Trading Taps” (4). Lauren Onkey, in her article “Ray Charles on Hyndford
Street: Van Morrison’s Caledonian Soul” alludes to some of the limitations of the
depicting the Irish as one successful ethnic group among many” (185). The historical
accuracy of such a sentiment is questionable. Indeed, the happy narrative of racial and
and immigrants still face significant discrimination) is little more than a fiction, given
the producers’ outright neglect of labor hostilities and violence against Irish workers in
the nineteenth century United States, as well as historical hostilities between Irish
messages of Riverdance may have “consoled Irish American audiences by assuring them
of their egalitarian past,” regardless of their factual reality. These “consoling fictions”
123
Riverdance takes up an interesting challenge—inserting race into the dialogue of Irish
step dancing. However, the manner in which the subject is approached seems more fluff
than substance.
DANCING
Riverdance was both the bringer and the harbinger of a new Irish step dancing
culture that, according to Helen Brennan was “synonymous with glamour and… a
passport to world fame” (156). Irish step dancing prior to Riverdance had either faded out
of fashion in some areas of Ireland, and particularly among boys, or had been relatively
unknown almost everywhere else in the world, with the possible exceptions of cities such
as New York, Boston, Chicago and London. After Riverdance, Irish step dancing was
briefly one of the “hottest” and most popular ethnic dancing styles around. Although
some of the luster of Riverdance has faded over the years, the energy, the new cultural
formations, and the social reconfigurations that Irish step dancing experienced after the
show will likely remain relevant to the practice for years into the future. Some of these
Gaelacha.
“[valorized] youth and beauty, ambition, competitiveness, success and desire for celebrity
status” (136). While some of these aspects had been present in competitive Irish step
dancing cultures, many of these values and desires seem to have increased in potency. In
124
his chapter, “Unsuitables from a Distance: The Politics of Riverdance” in his 1997 book,
The Ex-Isle of Erin: Images of a Global Ireland, O’Toole suggests that in its appeal to a
modernized Ireland, and to the global audience, Riverdance changed some elements of
Irish step dancing significantly, for example, “putting back the mission ingredient of sex
that had been distilled out of Irish step dance by a mixture of Victorian piety, nationalist
purity and Catholic suspicion of the body” (1997: 147-148). In Riverdance Irish step
dancing was presented without the heavy embroidery, without the stiffness of either garb
or movement, but as something flowing, sparking blue, clean, synchronized, and beyond
Irish step dancers to present their art form in new and exciting ways, and to
DANCING
touring shows such as Lord of the Dance, Celtic Tiger, and Gaelforce, spread the fashion
for Irish step dancing around the world, garnered worldwide attention and acclaim for
Irish step dancing as a practice, boosted participation in Irish step dancing, created
international celebrities, and energized a whole set of industries devoted to Irish step
dancing.
competitive Irish step dancing or “traditional” Irish step dancing in general, its
popularity has certainly changed the entire cultural environment of Irish step dancing.
125
According to Helen Brennan, “after Riverdance and Lord of the Dance, registrations in
Irish dancing schools more than doubled” (156). Indeed, in many areas all over the
world, interest was sparked in Irish step dancing where there had previously existed no
formal teaching of Irish step dancing at all. After Riverdance, Irish step dancing itself
became a salable commodity in general, and Irish step dancing as a commodity was
being purchased (in ticket, video, or lesson form) by more and more people.
Riverdance had the effect of promoting Irish step dancing to new audiences all
around the world, some of which had never even known of its existence before. The
show excited many viewers immensely, and acted as a de facto set of continuously
running advertisements for the practice of Irish step dancing. The potential energy that
Riverdance generated led to some very powerful changes in the ways in which Irish step
dancing operated. The first and foremost is the increase in participation and popularity,
which has to a certain extent been sustained even a decade after Riverdance first
A second is the fact that Riverdance helped to generate a career landscape for
Irish step dancers. Whereas previously there had been few opportunities for professional
growth in Irish step dancing other than teaching, and whereas teaching opportunities had
been limited by a relatively low demand, after Riverdance the demand for tutelage in
Irish step dancing grew considerably. Many new dancers chose to become certified
teachers to meet this increased demand for dancing classes. 3 As well, Riverdance and
the subsequent shows that followed its lead also created different opportunities for
126
In her chapter, “‘Come and Daunce with Me in Irlande’: Tourism, Dance and
Globalisation,” in the book that she co-edited with Michael Cronin, Irish Tourism:
Image, Culture and Identity, Barbara O’Connor explores the world of stage shows that
flourished after Riverdance, according the model of Riverdance. Whereas it was often
difficult to find long term and consistent work as a performer in Irish step dance, that it
was now possible to have a career in dance and to travel (134). In addition, some
anxiety,” and participate in a different form of Irish step dancing, which “was perceived
highly respected form of Irish step dancing such as dancing in a touring show. Dancers
can now continue their careers as they enter adulthood (after leaving the competition
Complicating this, however, is the fact that the existence of shows such as
Riverdance also provided incentives for dancers to train harder and compete more
actively. Although it is possible for dancers to be hired for the cast of an Irish step
dancing stage show without having placed in the top half of the World Championships,
for example, this does not always happen. Dancers appear to be at least partially
evaluated on the basis of their competitive record, and auditions and scouting for some
definite extrinsic, financial incentives to work their way up the system. Few such
127
incentives seemed to me to exist before Riverdance, other than intrinsic benefits such as
The impacts of Riverdance also changed the regional landscape of Irish step
dancing. Dancers in a much wider variety of areas were participating, and the structures
shaping of Irish step dance in new ways, to communicate with each other, to find out
information about the practice, and to purchase goods and services related to it. The
Riverdance phenomenon helped to change Irish step dancing into a practice which was
much more global in scale and in practice than it had ever been before.
The economy of the Republic of Ireland grew drastically in the mid-1990s. This
growth was related to increasing investment in Ireland by both the member states of the
European Union and American companies. This growth is often referred to as the
“Celtic Tiger” boom. Changes in the Irish economy, however, did not affect all citizens
of the Republic in the same manner. The political and social landscapes of Ireland also
emigration/immigration trends.
Riverdance debuted in 1994, at almost the same time that the Celtic Tiger
economy began to “roar.” The short segment that had been created for the Eurovision
amount of capital and touring around the world. Scholars have suggested that some of
128
Riverdance’s thematic elements worked to engage audiences, particularly in the United
States, at least by portraying themes that cross the Atlantic Ocean, but that also occlude
racial and economic violence that has beset Irish immigration to the United States. Thus,
the messages that the engine helped to circulate to wide audiences were in some ways
regressive, denied conflict, and mythologized Irish opportunities in the United States.
The popularity of Riverdance has led to some dramatic changes in the structure
and practice of Irish step dancing. Participation in Irish step dancing increased
dramatically, and the areas in which Irish step dancing was being practiced expanded
internationalization and possibly the globalization of Irish step dancing. This claim—that
129
ENDNOTES
3 See, for example, one teacher’s narrative on the demand for classes at IdanceIrish.
“Stephen Scariff Teaching Irish Dancing in Vienna - IdanceIrish interview of the month.”
IdanceIrish. 2005. 23 Feb 2008.
<http://www.idanceirish.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=100>.
130