Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 139

ISO 15189 : 2012

Technical Requirements
the how to
KALA DEVI NADARAJAN
BSc. Hons, MBA
29th Aug 2016
1
Learning Objective For Today

1. Read the key words in each clause


(ISO 15189, STR 2.3, SC 2, guideline on retention of
pathology & materials, college of pathologist)

2. Dissect, decode and interpret of each


clause

3. The practical what/how to do in lab


2
Terminology

Normative statements
These are statements within the standard that
are REQUIRED. They use the word SHALL
which is understood to mean MUST.

3
Terminology

Informative statements

These are statements within the standard that


are used for recommendations or guidance.
They use the words such as MAY or
SHOULD or CAN or IT IS
RECOMMENDED THAT. These are not
requirements, but should be considered as
helpful advice.

4
Terminology

Conditional statements

In some situations, Terms such as TO THE EXTENT


POSSIBLE are used with normative clauses. This
means that the requirement would apply, unless there
is an extenuating circumstance, such as a over-riding
national regulation which would take priority.

5
Terminology
Documented procedures(s)
This means that procedure is established,
documented, implemented and maintained.

A single document may address the


requirements for more than one procedure or
alternately the requirement for a documented
procedure may be covered by more than one
document.

6
Terminology
Examination :
set of operations having the object of determining
the value or characteristics of a property.

Examination procedures :
Set of operations, described specifically, used in
the performance of examinations according to
a given method.

7
Inspiring Story

8
Focusing on ISO 15189 QMS
Requirements
Management Requirement = 15
Technical Requirements = 10

The ISO 15189 identifies what needs to be done,


it is not prescriptive in how to do it!!

As busy laboratory scientists, it is difficult to see


25 requirements become integrated.

Heres where the Demings cycle provides a basic structure


for organizing and implementing a QMS
9
The Deming Cycle

Plan

Act Do

Check
10
10
The Deming Cycle

Act Management Plan


Responsibility

Measure, Resource
Analyze & Management
Improve

Check Do
Service
Realization 11
11
12
Technical Requirements
5.1 Personnel
5.2 Accommodation and environmental conditions
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, &
consumables
5.4 Pre-Examination Processes
5.5 Examination Processes
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.7 Post - examination Processes
5.8 Reporting of Results
5.9 Release of Results
5.10 Laboratory Information Management 13
Technical Requirements

5.1 Personnel

14
5.1 Personnel
ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.1 Personnel 5.1 Personnel


5.1.1 General
5.1.2 Personnel Qualifications
5.1.3 Job descriptions
5.1.4 Personnel introduction to the organizational
environment
5.1.5 Training
5.1.6 Competence assessment
5.1.7 Reviews of staff performance
5.1.8 Continuing education and professional
development
5.1.9 Personnel records

15
16
17
5.1 Personnel
5.1.1 General
documented procedure for personnel
management and maintain records

Key words documented procedure for personnel


management and maintain records

The work Check in the QM (dr raja elinas lecture),


-It should say generally about training,
orientation, organisation chart, courses,
competency, safety & health, CME, LIS
training,
Aku janji
18
5.1 Personnel
5.1.2 Personnel Qualifications

Key words -document personnel qualifications for each position

- Personnel making judgments have the applicable


theoretical and practical background and expertise

The work check the STR 2.4 and SC (page 8)

19
5.1 Personnel
5.1.3 Job descriptions

Key Job descriptions that describe


words responsibilities, authorities and
tasks for all personnel.

The work Fail Meja, Carta organisasi

20
5.1 Personnel
5.1.4 Personnel introduction to the
organizational environment

Key words a program to introduce new staff to the


organization

The work Kursus orientasi , keep the


attendance list

21
5.1 Personnel
5.1.5 Training
Key words a) QMS
b) QP, WI
c) LIS
d) Health & Safety
e) Ethics
f) Patient confidentiality
- The effectiveness of the training prog shall be periodically reviewed

The -Develop a training module which encompass all the above areas.
work Example of the training module.

-Department should have a QP on training Example of QP


- Stipulate in the QP when to conduct the competency assessment .

22
5.1 Personnel
5.1.6 Competence assessment

Key words -Assess the competence of each person to perform assigned


managerial or technical tasks
-Reassessment shall take place at regular intervals. Retraining
shall occur when necessary

The work - Develop a competency assessment module based on the


training module
-Department should have a QP on training & competency
- Example of QP
-Example of the competency module
- Check Pg 18 of SC- reassessed at least once a year.

23
5.1 Personnel
5.1.7 Reviews of staff performance

Key words Reviews of staff performance consider the needs of lab and
individual maintain or improve the quality of service and
encourage productive working relationships

Note: Staff performing reviews should receive appropriate


training.

The work Check with Sheila from Canada. She was part
of the ISO working committee

24
Standard performance appraisals (Penilaian Prestasi ) must include elements
that meet this clause. The typical elements of performance appraisal:

No Elements Characteristics Requirements

A Quality and quantity of Accuracy, thoroughness, the lab shall ensure that reviews of
work productivity staff performance
consider the needs of the laboratory
B Communication and Teamwork, cooperation, encourage productive working
interpersonal skills empathy relationships
C Planning and Goal setting, prioritizing the lab shall ensure that reviews of
organization staff performance
consider the needs of the individual
E Leadership Collaboration, delegation, encourage productive working
mentoring relationships
F Attitude Reliability, flexibility, initiative in order to maintain or improve the
quality of service given
to the users, encourage productive
working relationships
G Ethics Reliability, flexibility, initiative in order to maintain or improve the
quality of service given
to the users
H Problem solving Innovation, receptiveness in order to maintain or improve the
quality of service given
to the users
I Self-development and Learning, advancement, career
growth planning 25
5.1 Personnel
5.1.8 Continuing education and professional development

Key Shall be periodically reviewed. Personnel shall take part in


words regular professional development or other professional
liaison activities

Check n SC pg 18
Technical spend at least 5 hours in each 3 months period
participating in these activities.

The work 1) Create a schedule for lab CME. Every 2/3 weeks hold a CME on
various topic or review the QP/WI. see example
2) Create a schedule for the CME hospital level
3) Arrange for staff to attend MACB, MIMLS, any 1 day seminar,
even half day or 1 hour lecture and workshops
4) The most important must have 1 officer and a MLT in charge of
training.

26
5.1Personnel 5.1.9 Personnel records

Records of the relevant educational and professional qualifications, training and


experience, and assessments of competence of all personnel shall be maintained.

These records shall be readily available to relevant personnel and shall


include but not be limited to:

a) Educational & professional qualifications;


b) Copy of certification or license, when applicable;
c) Previous work experience
d) Job descriptions
e) Introduction of new staff to laboratory environment
f) Training in current job tasks;
g) Competency assessments;
h) Records of continuing education and achievements;
i) Reviews of staff performance;
j) Reports of accidents and exposure to occupational hazards
k) Immunisation status, when relevant to assigned duties

Note: the records listed above are not required to be stored in the laboratory, but can be
maintained in other specified locations, providing they remain accessible as needed.
27
Technical Requirements
5.2 Accommodation and
environmental conditions

28
5.2 Accommodation and environmental conditions

ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.2 Accommodation 5.2 Accommodation and environmental


And
environmental conditions
conditions
5.2.1 General
5.2.2 Laboratory and office facilities
5.2.3 Storage facilities
5.2.4 Staff facilities
5.2.5 Patient sample collection facilities
5.2.6 Facility maintenance and
environmental conditions
29
5.2 Accommodation and environmental
conditions
5.2.1 General

Key Shall have space allocated for the performance


words of its work

The work Emphasis on adequacy of space to ensure safety


of users, visitors and patients

Sample collection facilities and POCT are also


included

30
5.2 Accommodation and environmental conditions
5.2.2 Laboratory and office facilities

Key words - Controlled access


- Prevention of unauthorized access to confidential information
-Safety facilities and devices required, such as eyewash and emergency
showers
- Communication system

Example: operation of emergency release, intercom and alarm systems


for cold rooms and walk in freezers; accessibility of emergency
showers and eyewash

The work -Drug lab- lock and key for the lab and also the fridge
-Password protected when staff key in LIS
-Light = for agglutination test
- water = analyser test result (water quality > 2ohm)
-Waste disposal = alam flora
- Eyewash = rinse water ?
- PDN = PA system , intercom
31
5.2 Accommodation and environmental
conditions
5.2.3 Storage facilities

Key words -Storage space and conditions -Integrity of sample, reagents, supplies,
documents, equipment
-Clinical sample and materials cross contamination
-Storage and disposal facilities dangerous materials need to be stored
and disposed of appropriately

The Example of Temperature monitoring of fridge ,


work lab ambient temp monitoring
Check manufacturers recomm for analyser, reag,
supplies
Samples and reag cannot be stored together.
Chemical in drug lab keep in the yellow cabinet.
Lock !!

32
5.2 Accomodation and environmental
conditions
5.2.4 Staff facilities

Key words -washroom


Drinking water
Store to keep PPE and clothing
Space for meetings
Quiet study , rest area

33
5.2 Accomodation and environmental
conditions
5.2.5 Patient sample collection facilities

Key Patient sample collection facilities- privacy, disabilities


words Sample collection procedures
First aid materials for patient and staff

The Blood bank bleeding area- first aid kit


work Outpatient sample collection area- test tube not exp

34
5.2 Accomodation and environmental
conditions
5.2.6 Facility maintenance and
environmental conditions

Key Work area clean and well maintained


words Monitor , control & record environments; conditions
that may impact quality of samples , patient results
and health of staff

The CHRA must be done in drug lab


work Monitor ambient temp
Cytopathology screening must give priority
for quiet and uninterrupted work
environment
35
Technical Requirements
5.3 Laboratory equipment,
reagent, & consumables

36
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012


5.3 Lab Equipment 5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
5.3.1 Equipment
5.3.1.1 General
5.3.1.2 Equipment acceptance testing
5.3.1.3 Equipment instruction for use
5.3.1.4 Equipment calibration & metrological traceability
5.3.1.5 Equipment- maintenance & repair
5.3.1.6 Equipment- adverse incident reporting
5.3.1.7 Equipment records
5.3.2 Reagents & Consumables
5.3.2.1 General
5.3.2.2 Reagents & Consumables reception and storage
5.3.2.3 Reagents & Consumables acceptance testing
5.3.2.4 Reagents & Consumables inventory management
5.3.2.5 Reagents & Consumables instructions for use
5.3.2.6 Reagents & Consumables- adverse incident reporting
5.3.2.7 Reagents & Consumables- records 37
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

5.3.1 Equipment

Key a) Shall have documented procedure for selection,


words purchasing and management
b) Shall replace equipment as needed to ensure the
quality of results

The work a) Specification, AJK specifikasi, AJK technical, AJK


penilaian harga. Keep all documents
b) Keep Surat lantikan
c) If too old instrument; ada application / surat /
proposal dihantar kepada MOH untuk tukar?

38
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
5.3.1.2 Equipment acceptance testing

Key words a) Shall verify upon installation and before use


b) Each equipment shall be uniquely labelled

The a) Perform instrument evaluation/ method validation study


work

b) IQ:Installation Qualification
OQ: Operational Qualification
PQ: Performance, Process or Product Qualification
- Keep Calibration print out and sign it
-Reports must be kept for life span of equipment.

c)Make sure Testing &Commissioning is done properly

Borang KEW-PA 2 & KEW PA 3 done properly and pegawai penerima .


Document everything (refer tatacara pengurusan aset kerajaan)
www.treasury.gov.my (circulars)
39
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

5.3.1.3 Equipment instruction for use

Key a) Operated at all times by trained and authorized


words personnel
b) instruction on the use, manual readily available
c) Shall have procedures for safe..

The a) Show example of authorization table


work b) Picture of file next slide
c) User manuals/ operation manual must be
numbered and kept properly

40
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

5.3.1.4 Equipment calibration & metrological traceability

Key a) Shall have a documented procedure for the calibration of


words equipment
b) Check STR 2.3 pg 9 see calibration interval
c) Check SC; pg 18
- All reagent shall be labelled.

The work a) Show an example of calibration procedure for the


pipettes, themometer , balances (QP)
b) Daily/weekly/monthly maintenance record print and
keep
c) Done by competent personnel.

41
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
5.3.1.5 Equipment- maintenance & repair

Key a)Documented programme of PPM


words b) Remove from service and clearly labelled
c) Check impact on previous examination results before defect was
identified.

The a) Show an example of PPM schedule


work
b) Tatacara pengurusan aset alih kerajaan (penyelenggaraan)
KEW.PA -9, KEW.PA -13 & KEW.PA -14

42
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
5.3.1.5 Equipment- maintenance & repair

Key a)Documented programme of PPM


words b) Remove from service and clearly labelled
c) Check impact on previous examination results before defect was
identified.

The a) If machine/ petisejuk/centrifuge rosak.; label


work
b) Check QC and also if questionable result ; dont release
result
c) Keep the repair worksheet and monitored to determine
service is completed.
d) Verify and document that it is in proper working order
before being put back to service. Do QC and document
and keep in file.

43
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

5.3.1.7 Equipment records

Key Equipment records


words a) Identity of the equipment

The a)Prepare a file for each analyser/


work equipment

44
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
5.3.2.1 General
5.3.2.2 Reagents & Consumables reception and storage
5.3.2.3 Reagents & Consumables acceptance testing
5.3.2.4 Reagents & Consumables inventory management
5.3.2.5 Reagents & Consumables instructions for use
5.3.2.6 Reagents & Consumables- adverse incident reporting
5.3.2.7 Reagents & Consumables- records

The a) Prepare a procedure (QP)


work b) Make sure guideline given to main store on what are
the parameters to check on receiving of reagents.
c) Example of the QP but we didnt give to store
personnel
d) See if all these parameters in the QP
.
. 45
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
The work a) See if all these parameters in the QP

Is the receiving bay/receiving store personnel


receiving the reagents according to manufacturers
specification?

Eg. temperature at arrival maintained, reagents kept


in specific storage that prevent damage of reagent?

-Is there a reagent logbook for lot number and dates


of opening that reflects verification of new lots?

-Is each lot number, new shipment of reagents, or


consumable verified before use?

-Are stock counts routinely performed?


46
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables continue.
The -Are storage areas set up and monitored appropriately?
work
-Is the storage area well-organized and free of clutter?

-Are there designated places labeled for all inventory


items?

-Are hazardous chemicals stored appropriately?


-Is adequate cold storage available?

-Are storage areas monitored as per prescribed storage


conditions?

-Is the ambient temperature monitored routinely?


-Is storage in direct sunlight avoided?
Is storage area clean and free of dust and pest 47
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
The work a) See if all these parameters in the .. Continue

-Are storage area access controlled?

-Is First Expiry and First Out (FEFO) practiced?

-Are all reagents/test kits in use(and in the stock)


currently within manufacturer assigned expiration
dates or within stability?

-Has the laboratory provided uninterrupted testing


services, with no disruptions due to stock-outs in the
last year or since last audit?

48
5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables

The work -Records for each reagent and consumable that


contribute to the performance of examination
should capture the following information:

a)Identity of the reagent or consumables?

b)Manufacturers name and batch code or lot


number?

c)Contact information for the supplier or the


manufacturer

d)Date of receiving

e)The expiry date 49


5.3 Laboratory equipment, reagent, & consumables
The a) See if all these parameters in the .. continue
work
f)Date of entering into service or out of service, where
applicable

g)Condition when received

h) Manufacturers instructions

i) Records that confirmed the reagents or consumables


initial acceptance for use

j) Performance records that confirm the reagents or


consumables ongoing acceptance for use.

k) If reagents prepared in-house, the date of preparation, date expiry


50
and the person prepared must be written on bottle?
Technical Requirements
5.4 Pre-Examination Processes

51
52
Explain concepts of quality and the process
for Total Quality Management (TQM)

All activities of the overall management


function that determine quality policy
objectives and responsibilities ; and
implement them by means such as
quality planning, quality control ,quality
assurance, and quality improvement
within the quality system.
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.4 Pre- 5.4 Pre-examination procedures


examination
5.4.1 General
procedures
5.4.2 Information for patients and users
5.4.3 Request form information
5.4.4 Primary sample collection & handling
5.4.4.1 General
5.4.4.2 Instructions for pre-collection activities
5.4.4.3 Instructions for collection activities
5.4.5 Sample transportation
5.4.6 Sample reception
5.4.7 Pre-examination handling, preparation and
storage
57
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.2 Information for patients and users

Key words Information available..

The work Prepare a user manual

58
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.3 Request form information

Key Request form sufficient to identify patient and authorized


words requester and the following information..

from SC 2:
Sample labeling- shall carry a minimum 2 unique identifier, type of
sample, date of sampling.

The Check your existing request form capture these info?


work Establish in your QP on Verbal request for examination-
how is the practices

59
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.4 Primary sample collection & handling
5.4.4.1 General

5.4.4.2 Instructions for pre-collection activities


5.4.4.3 Instructions for collection activities

Key words Shall have documented procedures for the proper collection
and handling ..

The -Can capture in user manual


wor
k - Make sure adequate privacy during sampling!
If not 24 hour lab, is there a documented method for handling
specimens?
-Are information on rejection criteria given to users.
-If critical specimen, are there special policy or procedure in
place?
-Make a quick guide .. A poster made available to ward and60
OPD
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures

5.4.5 Sample transportation


Key words Instruction for post collection activities.
Shall have documented procedure for monitoring..
-within time frame
- Within temperature

The Can be captured in User Manual


work Can be captured in Poster
Make sure state in the QP about compromised
sample document in a book if ward/clinic being
contacted

61
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.6 Sample reception
5.4.7 Pre-examination handling, preparation and storage

Key words Procedures for sample reception.

The work Develop specimen receiving procedure in the lab?

-Address specimens labeled with patient unique ID,


test, date , time of collection and authorized requester?

-samples that are received from peripheral centers


accompanied by a sample delivery checklist?

- received specimens evaluated according to


acceptance/ rejection criteria? 62
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.6 Sample reception continue.......
5.4.7 Pre-examination handling, preparation and storage

Key words Procedures for sample reception.

The -specimens logged appropriately upon


work receipt in the laboratory?( date,time & name
of receiving officer)

-procedures address on how to process


urgent specimens and verbal requests?

- specimens delivered to correct


workstations in a timely manner? 63
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.7 Pre-examination handling, preparation and storage

Key words Shall have procedures & appropriate facilities for securing Time limits
for requesting additional examination.

The When samples are split, can the portions be traced back to
work the primary samples?

-If samples are to be sent to referral center, are specimens


package appropriately according to local or international
regulations and transported to referral lab within time
frames?

-Are referred specimens tracked properly using a logbook


or tracking form?

- Is there procedure available at the workstation for the


64
technician working in this area?
5.4 Pre-Examination Procedures
5.4.7 Pre-examination handling,preparation and storage ..continue....

Key words Shall have procedures & appropriate facilities for securing Time
limits for requesting additional examination.

The -Is there any special protocol for pediatric specimen?


work
- sufficient samples volume for analyser?
-degree of hemolysis, lipeamia which is acceptable?

-If samples are not analysed on the same day of receivable, are
there any procedure on storage?

-What is speed and time configured for the centrifuge?

-Are balancing of sample done prior to centrifuging?

-Check the department procedures on Core process, urgent


requests, rejection criteria and medical legal requests.
65
Technical Requirements
5.5 Examination Processes

66
5.5 Examination Procedures
ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.5 Examination 5.5 Examination processes


procedures
5.5.1 Selection, verification, & validation
of examination procedures
5.5.1.2 Verification of examination
procedures
5.5.1.3 Validation of examination
procedures
5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of
measured quantity values
5.5.2 Biological reference intervals or
clinical decision values
5.5.3 Documentation of examination
67
procedures
5.5 Examination Procedures

5.5.1 Selection, verification, & validation of examination


procedures
Key words Check SC pg 20

The - Each package insert , make a stamp approve for


wor use then stamp officer in charge , sign and date.
k
- Keep the most current

- Old stamp withdrawn from use and keep in the


appropriate file

- Keep a log of all the package insert 68


5.5 Examination Procedures
5.5.1 Selection, verification, & validation of examination procedures continue
5.5.1.2 Verification of examination procedures
5.5.1.3 Validation of examination procedures
5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of measured quantity values

The From SC 2
work -Are standard methods being used?

-Are method verification being performed for analyser/ method?


(precision, bias, limit of detection, selectivity, repeatability &
reproducibility)

-If commercial kit being used, lab shall request manufacturer for
validation data?

-If in house method, lab must show validation done according to


relevant guideline?

69
5.5 Examination Procedures continue..
5.5.1 Selection, verification, & validation of examination procedures continue
5.5.1.2 Verification of examination procedures
5.5.1.3 Validation of examination procedures
5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of measured quantity values

The From SC 2
work Evaluation of method must meet the purpose; check
report accordingly.

-Report must be authorized by the responsible key


personnel for the section

-Performance specification for each procedure used in examination


relate to the intended used of that procedure.

- Check if MU being calculated for each measurement procedures? Is


lab reviewing it regularly? 70
5.5 Examination Procedures continue..

5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of measured quantity values

Note 1: clearly limits MU to the analytic phase of the total


testing process.

Note 2: recommends estimation from routine SQC data over a


period of time that includes common changes or
process variables that would contribute to MU.

Note 3 : again brings in the responsibility to define goals for


how good a test should be in order to periodically
evaluate estimates of MU

71
5.5 Examination Procedures continue..
5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of measured
quantity values

The practical estimation of MU : calculate SD from SQC data,


then multiply that SD by a factor 2 to provide a conventional
95% confidence limit for a test.

The SD is known as the standard measurement uncertainty, the


factor of 2 is called the coverage factor, and the 95% limit or
interval is known as the expanded measurement uncertainty.

72
5.5.1.4 Measurement uncertainty of measured
quantity values
There is no mention of bias in this guidance.
Thus the new
ISO 15189 guidance says:

1) The lab must determine MU


2) The lab can do this with SQC data collected
over some extended period of time ,not just one
month!!!!

73
5.5 Examination Procedures
5.5.2 Biological reference intervals or clinical decision values

The Reference range- periodically reviewed or when change in


work
examination or pre-examination procedure.

-Are these changes being communicated to users/clinician?

From SC 2
Age, gender and other relevant information shall be
considered when establishing reference range.

-If laboratory intend to change procedure such that results and


interpretation could be significantly different, it shall be
explained to users.

-check for documentation on the above activity. 74


5.5 Examination Procedures
5.5.3 Documentation of examination procedures

The Are examination procedures documented in language


work understood by staff?

-Are there any quick guide/ working instruction being


displayed? If available, is proper document control steps
taken? Eg: approved to use, signed?

- The examination procedure should have(where


applicable):..

75
Technical Requirements
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination
results

76
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.6 Assuring 5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results


quality of
5.6.1 General
examination
procedures 5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality control materials
5.6.2.3 Quality control data
5.6.3 Interlaboratory comparisons
5.6.3.1 Participation
5.6.3.2 Alternative approaches
5.6.3.3 Analysis of interlaboratory comparison
samples
5.6.3.4 Evaluation of laboratory performance
5.6.4 Comparability of examination results
77
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.6.1 General

The laboratory shall ensure the quality of


examinations by performing them under defined
conditions.

Appropriate pre and post examination processes shall


be implemented (see 4.14.7, 5.4, 5.7 and 5.8)

The laboratory shall not fabricate any results.

78
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.1 General

Key You have to design a QC procedures that verify the


words attainment of the intended quality of results

What are the things you can write in your QC


procedures ?

Remember your procedure must verify the


attainment of the intended quality of results !!!!!

79
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results

5.6.2 Quality Control


5.6.2.1 General

How are you going to define the word intended


quality?
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results

5.6.2 Quality Control


5.6.2.1 General

Common weakness in many laboratories is lack of


definition of the requirement for quality in quantitative
terms !!!!

Now I got work for you


What is the requirement for quality in quantitative terms
?

5 minutes.
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.1 General
1) Minimum Analytical Quality Specification of inter-lab comparison: agreement among
Spanish EQAP organizers.

2) The Biologic Variation Database : Compiled by the Spanish CC Society & Dr Carmen Ricos
includes desirable,optimal and minimum Imprecision, Bias and Total Error requirement.

3) Rilibak German Guideline for Quality . Is an abbreviation meaning literally the Guideline
(Rili) of the German Federal Medical Council (BAK) (2009)

4) CLIA requirements for Analytical Quality (1992)

5) Clinical Quality Requirement that describe medically important changes in test value or
Decision intervals expressed as a percentage change at certain Decision level, also a
series of recommendations for lipid tests from National Cholesterol Education
Programmes (NCEP)

6) European Biologic Goal (1990)

7) RCPA (Royal College of Pathologist of Australasia)

8) Quality Requirement for Dogs ,Cats & Horses.

9) Biological Variation in Patient with Disease


5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.1 General

Take note to the term intended quality of results

How should your lab design the QC procedure on the


basis of intended quality of results ?

How should the laboratory take into account the


precision and the bias and the quality required the
intended use of the test?

How are you going to select the control rules and the
number of measurements to verify the attainment of
intended quality?
83
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

The laboratory shall use quality control materials that react to the
examining system in a manner as close as possible to patient
samples.

Matrix
base which control material is prepared
- Ideally same with specimen so they behave like
a specimen
- Controls available are human based or bovine
based.
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

Quality control materials shall be periodically examined with a frequency that is based
on the stability of the procedure and the risk of harm to the patient from erroneous
result

means that you have to have a plan and then design your QC
objectively based on how good your assay is

The laboratory should apply statistical control rules to make decisions on


the acceptability of analytical results and the need to reject runs and
repeat patient testing.
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

How many levels of QC do I need to use?


&
How many times a day should I run QC ??
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

For actual frequency of QC measurement, lab


should establish own frequency base on the
QC strategy
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

Note 1
The laboratory should choose concentration of control material, wherever possible,
especially at or near clinical decision values, which ensure the validity of decision made.

Note 2
Use of independent third party control materials should be considered, either instead of
or in addition to, any control materials supplied by the reagent or instrument
manufacturer.
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials
Now lets look at what SC 2 says

Shall cover the analysis or analytical concentration


Shall be performed at least very day or every batch
of analysis
Its performance shall be reviewed based on
acceptance or rejection criteria and
the analytical problem shall be rectified.
The use of controls independent is preferable
Appropriate materials shall be used as calibrator
Acceptable range shall be defined for IQC
Means & SD determined using own data
Matrix matched
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

Extra information:

Constituents multi/ single


Storage space
Assayed & un-assayed
Appropriate & analyte level
- Cover the measure range of the analyte, normal &
pathological range
- Near medical decision level
- Chemistry 2 levels; hormone & tumor marker = 3
levels
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

Liquid or lyophilized stability


longer exp date (FBC & Coag)
- liquid better reproducibility no recon
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials
Critical aspects for the correct treatment of the
control material :

Storage Temperature
Diluent
Volumetric instruments
Aliquoting
Containers
Thawed
Mixed
Waiting (when to use the recon control)
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials

Extra information
Shelf life
Lot sequestering
Supplier can offer specific lot in quantity
required
Manufacturer service
offer to keep same lot for you
- help in storage management
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials
The work Is the open vial stability instruction being adhered to?
-Is the temperature storage instructions being adhered
to? eg: freeze/ thawing?
-Is the fridge temperature monitored?
-Are control materials match patient sample matrix?

-What is the frequency of running quality control material for


analyzer concerned?

-How did lab check the stability of test procedure so that


erroneous result given to patient? Eg: QC Strategy, using OP Spec
chart or Sigma Metrics?

- Check the concentration of the control material? (is it near clinical


decision values?) 94
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.2 Quality Control Materials
The -Is 3rd party QC being used?
work
-The IQC shall cover analytical concentration, low, N & H, +ve
& -ve control.

-Performed at least every day or every batch

-Performance shall be reviewed based on acceptance/


rejection criteria

-Special stain, positive shall be performed

-Laboratory should determine mean &SD using their own


data.

-Criteria for acceptance or rejection of a QC run established


95
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results

5.6.2 Quality Control


5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

Now we are in the heart of Quality Control


5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

The laboratory shall have a procedure to prevent the release of patient results in the
event of quality control failure.

When the quality control rules are violated and indicate that examination results are
likely to contain clinical significant errors, the results shall be rejected and relevant
patient samples re-examined after the error condition has been corrected and within
specification performance is verified.
The laboratory shall also evaluate the results from patient samples that were examined
after the last successful quality control event.
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

Quality control data shall be reviewed at regular intervals to detect trends in


examination performance that may indicate problems in the examination system. When
such trends are noted, preventive actions shall be taken and recorded.

Note:
Statistical and non statistical techniques for process control should be used wherever
possible to continuously monitor examination system performance
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data
Now lets look at what SC 2 says

Its performance shall be reviewed based on acceptance or


rejection criteria and the analytical problem shall be rectified.

A protocol for action to be taken where qc results fall


outside acceptable ranges shall be documented. Criteria for
acceptance or rejection of a QC run shall be established.
IQC results shall be recorded
Graphical presentation of numerical QC results should be
considered, to assist
the early detection trend.
Details of action taken on unacceptable results shall be
monitored
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data
Now lets look at what SC 2 says

The laboratory shall have a system of long term


monitoring of IQC results to assess the method
performance against the quality specification as
stated in method validation.
A record of remedial action maintained if the
performance not meeting the quality specification.

Laboratories shall identify person(s) to be responsible


for quality control activities
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

How does the laboratory determine if an


analytical run provides within specification
performance ?

That depends on a properly designed QC procedure


that takes into account the intended quality of results!
5.6.2 Quality Control
5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

Once you have proper QC design now can identify the


control rules and the number of control measurements!

What is the procedure for handling out of control runs?

What corrective action is required?

How is corrective action documented to demonstrate or


verify within Specification Performance?

What patient samples are repeated?

What patient results are reported?


5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results

5.6.2 Quality Control... Assessors area


5.6.2.3 Quality Control Data

The work -Are QC results monitored and reviewed( biases, shifts, trend & L-J
charts)?

-Is documentation of corrective action done in a timely manner


when quality control results exceed the acceptable range?

-Did the laboratory investigated and reported any out of control


incidents, due to specific reagents/consumables to manufacturer?

-Laboratory shall monitor long term IQC result to assess method


performance.

103
An example of the QC procedure

write your own


You must know that there are no QC procedure or QMS that
fits all.

104
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.6.3.1 Participation
5.6.3.2 Alternative approaches
5.6.3.3 Analysis of interlaboratory comparison samples
5.6.3.4 Evaluation of laboratory performance

Key words Shall participate..


Whenever not available.

The work Is the lab participate in any External Profiency testing (PT) program?
Eg: RCPA,RIQAS,EQAS or exercise an alternative performance
assessment system when appropriate?
-Do the PT sample come from providers who are accredited or
approved?
- Did laboratory participate in PT for all tests included in the scope?
- Are PT specimens handled and tested the same as patients
specimens?
- Are all personnel involve in testing patient sample participate in
testing PT samples?
- Is cause analysis being performed for unacceptable PT results?
105
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.6.3 Interlaboratory comparisons
5.6.3.1 Participation continue..
5.6.3.2 Alternative approaches
5.6.3.3 Analysis of interlaboratory comparison samples
5.6.3.4 Evaluation of laboratory performance

The Is corrective action documented for unacceptable PT


work results?
-Are the PT results being communicated with staff and
did staff participate in implementation of corrective
action?
- Is there any evidence the PT samples/ slide are
utilized for CME.

106
5.6 Ensuring quality of examination results
5.6.4 Comparability of examination results
Key words Shall be a defined means of comparing procedures,
equipment, method

The There should be a procedure .


work Where and why the correlation study needed. Define
properly.
Criteria of acceptability clearly defined.
Who going to do?
What is the frequency?
Correlation study performed . And analysed and
documented.

107
Technical Requirements
5.7 Post - examination Processes

108
5.7 Post - examination processes

ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.7 Post- 5.7 Post examination processes


examinatio
5.7. 1 Review of results
n processes
5.7.2 Storage, retention & disposal of
clinical samples

109
5.7 Post - examination processes
5.7. 1 Review of results

Key words Shall have documented procedure

The Are there any authorized personnel


work systematically review the result?
- Are there any criteria documented for
automatic review of results?

110
5.7 Post - examination processes

5.7.2 Storage, retention & disposal of clinical samples

Key Shall have documented procedure


words

The work
Are the retention time of sample
documented? And in accordance
to national guideline? (show
Retention Time Guideline)

111
5.7 Post - examination processes
5.7.2 Storage, retention & disposal of clinical samples

Key words Shall have documented procedure

The -Check how specimens are being stored after


work analysis?
-Are there any procedure in place if specimens
are being re-analysed on request by
clinicians?eg: the timeframe of reanalysis
allowed? The temperature of storage
monitored?
- Is room temperature monitored if samples kept
at room temperature?
- Are specimens disposed off in a safe manner?
- Are disposal being recorded? Eg: person who 112
Technical Requirements
5.8 Reporting of Results
5.9 Release of Results

113
5.8 Reporting of results
5.9 Release of results

ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

5.8 Reporting 5.8 Reporting of results


of results
5.8. 1 General
5.8.2 Report attributes
5.8.3 Report content
5.9 Release of 5.9 Release of results
results
5.9.1 General
5.9.2 Automated selection and reporting of
results
5.9.3 Revised Reports
114
115
116
5.8 Reporting of results
5.9 Release of results
5.8. 1 General
5.8.2 Report attributes
5.8.3 Report content
Key words Shall be reported accurately, clearly, .
Shall have procedure correctness
SC 2 electronic validation- person authorizing the use of particular
algorithm for automatic release shall be traceable from the issued
report/result
SC 2- Electronic transmission of result check record of checking
accuracy of transmission

The work Example of report .


Original & corrected result if relevant
Signature or authorization of person checking /releasing the report;
where possible
Prepare a procedure on checking of transmission of results..
Have a file.. 117
5.8 Reporting of results 5.9 Release of results

5.9 Release of results


5.9.1 General
5.9.2 Automated selection and reporting of results
5.9.3 Revised Reports

Key shall establish procedure for the release.


words
The work Report shall indicate the quality of primary sample was unsuitable for
examination/ could have compromised the result.

Retention of report result and ability of prompt retrieval

Are procedures for immediate notification of results fall within


established critical value?

Critical value properties/criteria?


Result transmitted as interim report, final report forwarded to requester?
118
5.8 Reporting of results 5.9 Release of results

5.9 Release of results


5.9.1 General
5.9.2 Automated selection and reporting of results
5.9.3 Revised Reports

Key words shall establish procedure for the release.

The work Check Record of response taken for critical result-date, time, lab
staff, person notified and result of examination?

Established TAT-reflecting the clinical need?

-Lab monitor the TAT & remedial action recorded

- Lab notify if result delayed and could compromised patients care


119
5.8 Reporting of results 5.9 Release of results
The Are procedures of release of result available?eg: who and to whom.
work

Are procedures on reporting verbal result available? -Check for protocol of


how users record the verbal result?

SC 2 Integrity of data transfer rest with the lab

Are policy & procedure regarding alteration of report available?

Record show time, date name of person responsible for change?

Original entries remain legible when alteration made?

SC 2 Issue of complete new result or report shall be uniquely identified and


contain a reference to the original that it replace?

Result that have been available for clinical decision making & revised shall
be retained in subsequent cumulative report?
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
Technical Requirements
5.10 Laboratory Information
Management

129
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

ISO 15189:2007 ISO 15189:2012

Annex Recommendation 5.10 Laboratory Information Management


B for laboratory
5.10.1 General
information
systems (LIS) 5.10.2 Authorities and Responsibilities
5.10.3 Information System Management

Key shall have a documented procedure


words

The work Example of procedure

130
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

The -Undertaking of confidentiality


work contract that must be signed by
supplier.
-The lab shall define authorities and
responsibilities of all personnel
who use the system.

Must have a list of personnel name


and authorities:

131
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

The a) Access patient data and information


work b) Enter patient data and examination
results
c) Change patient data or examination
results
d) Authorize the release of examination
results and reports

132
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

133
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

134
5.10 Laboratory Information Management

Make sure you include the procedure what to do if the


LIS breakdown especially on how to release result!!

135
136
Quality must be Measured in order to be Managed.

137
Evidence requirements
Where does it say what you do?
Why is it done that way?
Do staff know what should be done and why?
Where is this implemented?
Where is the evidence that this is implemented?
Is the evidence objective?
What does the evidence tell you?
Does it work?

138
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Department of Standard Malaysia
Also Cik Norehan for making copies of the
lecture notes to you.
Staffs in HPP who enable me to learn from
experience.
Special thanks to Dr Westgards, Dr Jamilah, Dr
Soo, DSM assessors who are my gurus

139

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi