Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00254-008-1252-x
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 12 November 2007 / Accepted: 11 February 2008 / Published online: 22 April 2008
Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract A calculation method for determining the demonstrated that this combination could detect the sharp
amount of Rn isotopes and daughter products at the start of rises in 222Rn concentrations associated with faults. The
measurement (CRAS) is proposed as a more accurate method also allows the determination of fault geometry
means of estimating the initial Rn concentration in soil gas. near the surface based on the asymmetry variation of the
The CRAS utilizes the decay law between 222Rn and 220Rn Rn concentration distribution when coupled with a
isotopes and the daughter products 218Po and 216Po, and is numerical simulation of 222Rn transport. The results for the
applicable to a-scintillation counter measurements. As Rn new method as applied to the two case studies are con-
is both inert and chemically stable, it is useful for fault sistent with the data collected from the geological survey.
investigation based on the soil gas geochemistry. However, It implies that the CRAS method is suitable for investi-
the total number of a particles emitted by the decay of Rn gating the fault system and interstitial gas mobility through
has generally been considered to be proportional to the fractures. The present analyses have also demonstrated that
initial Rn concentration, without considering the gas con- high Rn concentrations require the recent and repeated
dition with respect to radioactive equilibrium. The CRAS accumulation of 222Rn parents (230Th and 226Ra) in fault
method is shown to be effective to derive Rn concentration gouges through deep gas release during fault movement.
for soil gases under both nonequilibrium conditions, in
which the total number of decays increases with time, and Keywords Radon-222 a-scintillation counter
equilibrium conditions, which are typical of normal soil Radioactive equilibrium Active fault Fault geometry
under low gas flux. The CRAS method in conjunction Finite difference method
with finite difference method simulation is applied to
the analysis of two active fault areas in Japan, and it is
Introduction
123
1534 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
of Rn in geological analyses can be classified into four Estimation of initial Rn concentrations in soil gas
major categories: detection of latent faults (Duddridge
et al. 1991; King et al. 1996; Ciotoli et al. 1998), explo- Fundamental equations
ration of uranium deposits (Miller and Ostle 1973; Smith
et al. 1976), clarification of relationship between Rn A RDA-200 detector (Syntrex Inc.) was used in the initial
concentration and volcanic eruptions (Chitkov 1975; Rn survey to detect the a particles emitted by the a decay
Gasparini and Mantovani 1978; Toutain et al. 1992), and of 222Rn, 220Rn, 218Po, and 216Po (218Po and 216Po are the
detection of precursory and coseismic phenomena daughter nuclides of 222Rn and 220Rn, respectively). A hole
accompanying earthquakes (Hauksson 1981; Virk and of 65 cm in depth and 3 cm in diameter was dug into the
Singh 1994; Heinicke et al. 1995; Igarashi et al. 1995; soil at the study site and sheathed with vinyl chloride
Tsunogai and Wakita 1995; Chyi et al. 2002). piping. Soil gas was then sampled by a hand pump into a
In these applications, the Rn concentration in soil gas cell of 160 cm3 in volume. The internal surface of the cell
and groundwater is measured by a-track, a-scintillation, had a scintillator coating of ZnS (Ag). The number of a
and ionization chamber methods for gaseous Rn, and by a particles emitted per minute was measured by the detector,
liquid scintillation counter method for dissolved Rn in and the data were subsequently corrected by subtracting the
fluids. The a-scintillation counter method is the most background due to residual Rn in the cell. The cell was
suitable method for in situ measurement, as it does not exchanged when the background values became too large.
require chemical processing such as etching (required for The total net numbers of a particles in each minute of
the a-track method) and measurement can be completed the first 3 min are denoted by D1 (01 min.), D2 (1
quickly. Detailed mapping of Rn concentrations is there- 2 min.), and D3 (23 min.). According to the empirical
fore possible by setting a short distance between adjacent equation by Morse (1976) obtained by RDA-200 for
sample points. Rn isotopes, 222Rn and 220Rn that are pro- treating the data, the total number of a particles,
duced in the decay series of uranium and thorium, D1 + D2 + D3, is divided into the two decay quantities
respectively, are the isotopes measured in such analyses, D222Rn and D220Rn as follows:
considering the half-life and abundances of the Rn iso-
D222 Rn 0:868D3 0:317D2 0:339D1
topes. Another advantage of the a-scintillation counter 1
D220 Rn D1 D2 D3 D222 Rn
method is its ability to separate the total decay numbers
into those originating from 222Rn and 220Rn by virtue of the D222Rn and D220Rn have generally been assumed to rep-
large difference in half-lives, 3.58 days for 222Rn and 53 s resent the initial Rn concentrations in fault surveys using
for 220Rn. Thus, 222Rn concentrations also provide infor- the RDA-200 (e.g., Yamaguchi et al. 1984; Sugiyama et al.
mation on soil-gas conditions in a wider area through 1986; Duddridge et al. 1991; Ciotoli et al. 1998). Despite
longer migration. such prevalent usage, the equation does not consider the Rn
In most researches based on a-scintillation counter gas condition with respect to radioactive equilibrium. The
measurements, however, the radioactive equilibrium con- coefficients in Eq. (1) must be changed for nonequilibrium
dition of Rn gas is not considered, and the decay number is conditions, as the sum of the decays of Rn and its daughters
regarded as being equivalent to the true (initial) Rn con- increase with time under the nonequilibrium condition but
centration. The measurement time adopted in the method is remains constant with respect to the ratio of 222Rn and
218
typically 3 min, which is too short to correctly judge Po decays in equilibrium.
whether the Rn gas is in equilibrium. In order to deal with To overcome this problem and estimate the Rn con-
this problem, a calculation method is proposed in this study centration directly, a calculation method is proposed to
for determining the initial 222Rn and 220Rn concentrations determine the numbers of Rn isotope atoms and daughters
based on the decay law between the two nuclides and their at the start of measurement (termed as CRAS: calculation
daughters. The effectiveness of the method is evaluated method of numbers of Rn isotope atoms and their daugh-
based on the correspondence between estimated high 222Rn ters at the start of measurement). As the half-life of 222Rn is
concentrations and faults locations, and the spatial corre- 6,000 times longer than that of 220Rn, CRAS attaches great
lation structure of concentrations around the faults. The importance to the radioactive equilibrium relationship
spatial distribution of 222Rn concentration is demonstrated between 222Rn and 218Po. Expressing the time at which the
to be useful for elucidating fault configurations with Rn gas was generated as t = 0, the number of 222Rn and
218
respect to width and orientation in two active fault areas in Po isotopes at t = 0 is denoted by N0. The soil gas is
Japan. A numerical simulation is also performed using a sampled at a time T (s) from t = 0, and represents the age
finite element method to examine the transport of 222Rn in of the Rn gas. The number of 222Rn, 218Po and 220Rn
shallow soils for combination with fault shape estimation. isotopes at the start of measurement (t = T) is denoted by
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1535
N222, N218, and N220. The time at which 222Rn and 218
Po Vk Vk222 Vk218 Vk220
reach equilibrium is given by k222 Dt exp k218 sk1 exp k218 sk
k222 2Dt N222
1 k222 k218 k222
teq log 1980s 2 fexp k218 sk1 exp k218 sk gN218
k222 k218 k218
2fexp k220 sk1 exp k220 sk gN220 7
Here, k 222 and k218 are the decay constants of 222Rn,
and 218Po. If T is shorter than teq, N222 and N218 can be The unknown N222, N218, and N220 can be calculated from
obtained from the law of radioactive decay as follows: Vk and Eq. (7) by a least-squares method, allowing T to be
9 estimated from Eq. (4).
N222 N0 expk222 T >
>
>
> When T is not determined, the Rn gas is assumed to
k222 >
=
N218 N0 fexp k222 T exp k218 T g have reached radioactive equilibrium at the start of mea-
k218 k222 surement. In this case, the relation
>
>
dN218 >
>
* k222 N222 k218 N218 >
; N218 rN222 8
dt
3 holds, and Vk(218) is expressed by
Vk218 r 1Vk222
From the above two equations, T can then be expressed
by r 1N222 fexp k222 sk1 exp k222 sk g
9
1 Rk218 k222
T log 1 4
k222 k218 k222 where r = k222/k218. Finally, in the case of T [ teq, Vk can
be summarized by
where R = N218/N222. It is necessary that R should be
smaller than k222/(k218 k222) = 5.45 9 10-4 from the Vk 2 r fexp k222 sk1 exp k222 sk gN222
equilibrium condition. In the case where T is greater than 2fexp k220 sk1 exp k220 sk gN220 10
teq, the value of T cannot be determined because R takes a
constant value of 5.45 9 10-4. N222 and N220 can also be obtained by a least-squares
If the time difference between the start time and each analysis of Vk.
minute of measurement is denoted by sk = kDt (k = 1,...,n;
n is the number of measurements and Dt = 60 s is the time Confirmation of CRAS applicability
interval), the number of 222Rn and 218Po decays between
t = T + sk-1 and t = T + sk for T B teq (Vk(222) and CRAS was tested for soil gases at four sites in the hot
Vk(218), respectively) are approximated by spring areas of Mt. Aso in southwest Japan (see Fig. 2).
9
Vk222 N222 fexp k222 sk1 exp k222 sk g >
>
>
>
k222 DtN222 *Dt 1=k222 4:83 10 5 >
>
=
k222 5
Vk218 fk222 Dt exp k218 sk1 expk218 sk gN222 >
>
>
k218 k222 >
>
>
;
fexp k218 sk1 exp k218 sk gN218 k222 DN222
As the half-life of 220Rns daughter, 216Po, is very short Three of the sites, of A and B type were sampled near
(0.158 s), the number of 216Po decays can be assumed to be fumaroles, and the other C type site was located in an area
approximately equal to that of 220Rn. The resultant Vk(220) with no signs of hydrothermal alteration or fumaroles.
is given by Figure 1 shows the temporal change in the total number of
decays per minute over 20 min at the sampled sites. The
Vk220 2fexp k220 sk1 exp k220 sk gN220 6
soil gases of types A and B are under nonequilibrium
In measurement, the total number of decays between conditions, as indicated by the increase in the total number
t = T + sk-1 and t = T + sk, denoted by Vk (k = 1,..., n), of decays over time due to the increase in 218Po decays.
is counted sequentially. Vk can then be rearranged as However, the soil gas of type C reaches an equilibrium
follows: condition after the first few minutes, in which total decays
123
1536 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1537
Table 1 Total decay counts for 222Rn and 220Rn during the first 3 min for samples described in Fig. 1 under the nonequilibrium and equilibrium
conditions of Rn gas
Condition of Rn gas Nonequilibrium Equilibrium
Gas type A-1 A-2 B C
Calculation method Empirical equation CRAS Empirical equation CRAS Empirical equation CRAS Empirical equation CRAS
222
Decays of Rn (cpm) 1,326 4,373 1,792 5,316 917 2,993 -4 55
220
Decays of Rn (cpm) 3,127 106 4,042 463 2,706 698 140 98
222
Decay ratio Rn/220Rn 0.42 41.3 0.44 11.5 0.34 4.3 -0.03 0.56
222 220
They are calculated as Eq. (1) using the empirical formula and CRAS. The decay ratios of Rn to Rn are largely different between the two
methods, and the empirical formula underestimates 222Rn concentration
(Aso-1, 2, 3, and 4 in ascending eruption order), andesitic terraces, and the Holocene scarps are displaced at several
lava (eruptions of lateral craters), and pre-Aso volcanic sites by the Futagawa fault, representing evidence of recent
rocks (Fig. 3a). Aso-1 is distributed only sparsely around activity. The Research Group for Active Faults of Japan
the fault. According to Watanabe (1984), Aso-4 is com- (1991) estimates the average displacement velocity of the
posed of unwelded pumice flows containing white bubbly fault to be 0.20.5 m/103 years. The Futagawa fault con-
pumice, and Aso-2 and -3 are composed of weakly welded sists of a number of smaller subordinate faults.
scoria flows containing black scoria and volcanic glass. Six transects were set north to south across the Futagawa
The ages of Aso-2, -3, and -4 are 140,000, 120,000, and fault along paths through forests and valleys, with attention
90,000 years, respectively. These lithologies, the fluvial paid to ensure that transects were as straight as possible.
123
1538 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
As the fault runs across the edge of mountains to the south values at locations corresponding to the main fault in all
(Fig. 2), the end points were at higher elevations than the the three transects, whereas the maximum D222Rn values
start points. Data for the three longest of these transects are are located on the subordinate faults or at a distance from
reported here to evaluate CRAS with respect to the spatial any fault. This difference is most apparent for transect C.
correlation between Rn concentrations and fault location. The locations of points characterized by values
The results of the entire data set analysis and details of the exceeding the 90% cumulative frequency level around the
measurements are described in Koike et al. (2000). The faults are also good indices to compare the two methods.
three transects, A, B, and C (Fig. 3b), were 380, 380, and Five N222 anomalies are located successively or at one
350 m in length, with altitude differences of 28, 33, and point apart around the main fault on the transect A, while
15 m, respectively, between the start and end points. Fig- the D222Rn anomaly points are only two, as shown in
ure 3b shows the configuration of the transects. The distance Fig. 4. Although the same number of anomalous values are
between adjacent two measurement points was set at 2.5 m recorded around the main fault on transect B, the asym-
for all transects, giving a total of 153, 153, and 141 mea- metric shape of the 222Rn concentration distribution across
surements points for transects A, B and C. The lineaments the fault is more evident in the N222 distribution. In this
identified by aerial photography (Kumamoto Prefecture asymmetry, the 222Rn concentration increases gradually
1997) across each transect are depicted in Fig. 3b. toward a maximum on the northern side of the main fault,
Figure 4 compares the CRAS results for the number of then drops sharply to the south. On the basis of geological
222
Rn isotopes, N222, with the number of decays, D222Rn, investigations (Watanabe 1984), the Futagawa fault is
by Eq. (1) obtained at each location along the transects. thought to dip northward. This configuration therefore
The 90% cumulative frequency of the data for each transect appears to affect the distribution of 222Rn concentration,
is shown in Fig. 4 to emphasize the highest 222Rn con- which is consistent with a simple assumption that the
centrations. Although the general trends in the results by carrier gas velocity and diffusive coefficient of 222Rn in the
the two methods are similar, the D222Rn values are nega- fault zone are larger than in the surrounding soil. For
tive at 15 points where the total decays in the first 3 min transect C, the N222 results contain more anomalous values
was low. The CRAS value, N222, takes clear maximum around the faults than the D222Rn results. Thus, the
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1539
anomalous CRAS values appear to concentrate in the Figure 6 shows the distribution of the ratio of D222Rn to
vicinity of faults, demonstrating the capability of the CRAS the total number of decays, D222Rn/(D220Rn + D222Rn)
approach for detecting hidden faults. compared to the normalized N220. These data have also
Another interesting feature is that the three anomalous been used as indices for locating faults (Isra/l and
N222 values in the vicinity of the main fault on transect B Bjornssin 1966; Gingrich 1984; Yamaguchi et al. 1984;
can be judged to represent nonequilibrium condition. Sugiyama et al. 1986; Duddridge et al. 1991). However,
Although the total decays at most points follow the typical neither measure resolves the locations of faults reliably,
equilibrium pattern of type-C gas in Fig. 1, gases of types although the N220 data includes strong anomalous values in
A and B were detected at the three points around the fault the vicinity of the main faults on transect C. Therefore, the
220
(Fig. 5). This observation confirms that Rn gas can be in Rn concentration is not a suitable universal index for
nonequilibrium without an active rise in carrier gas in such Rn-based fault investigation.
geothermal areas.
222
Spatial correlation of Rn concentration
123
1540 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
becomes small when the data in the pair have similar from those on transect C, a major difference can be seen in
values, the distance range in which spatial correlation the c(h) analysis. For transect C0 , c(h) does not increase
exists is found by c(h) smoothly even within short distances, and the series takes
Figure 7 compares the experimental c(h) for the D222Rn almost the same values over distances larger than 15 m. In
and N222 for the three transects. The two c(h) series are contrast, the c(h) series for N222 on the first three transects
almost the same for transects A and B, although c(h) for take local maximums within 1020 m, become almost flat
N222 is slightly smaller than that for D222Rn, representing for a distance, and then increase again toward regional
better spatial correlation. It is worth noting that both the maxima (Fig. 7). These characteristics can be explained as
c(h) series exhibit periodic behavior, with a half period representing a short-range structure for N222 in normal soils
seen on transect A, and 1.5 periods on transect B. This may without faults, and a long-range structure when associated
be related to the existence of two faults (Fig. 3b), indi- with a fault system. Consequently, faults are confirmed to
cating that the range of effect on the 222Rn concentration be responsible for the spatial correlation of Rn concentra-
due to the presence of a fault is approximately 100200 m. tion, and this correlation is more accurately detected by
A similar periodic c(h) was obtained for N222 on transect C, CRAS than empirical calculations.
which also crosses two faults and where the range of
influence appears to be 100 m.
To further check the influence of faults, an additional Combination of CRAS and finite difference method
transect of 100 m in length (C0 ) was set parallel to transect for estimating fault-zone geometry
C, but away from the main fault (Figs. 1, 3b). Transect C0
222
was located on a gentle grassy slope of weathered volcanic Numerical simulation of Rn transport
rock, whereas transect C was located on talus deposits
(Fig. 3a). Figure 8 shows the distribution of N222 along Another merit of CRAS is the ability to directly apply the
transect C0 . Although the values do not differ significantly Rn concentration obtained to numerical simulation of Rn
Fig. 7 Comparison of
experimental semivariograms
for normalized D222Rn (broken
lines) and N222 (solid lines) data
along transects A, B, and C
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1541
transport in order to estimate geologic structures such as the vertical direction for the surrounding zone. Gas trans-
fault-zone geometries. As indicated by Soonawala and port outside the fault zone is restricted to vertical movement
Telford (1980) and Schery et al. (1984), the Rn concen- only. As a boundary condition, the N222 at the source
tration in shallow soils is generally accepted to be (reference plane of the Rn concentration) in the fault-
controlled by the diffusion of Rn and by the ascent of gas surrounding zone is fixed at 106. The Rn source depth is
carrying Rn. While the diffusion of Rn occurs directly uniformly defined as 20 m parallel to the surface terrain.
upward (positive z direction), a carrier gas may move in The distance between two adjacent grid points is set at
any direction. For analysis of fault-zone geometries, a 0.5 m along both the x and z axes, as shown in Fig. 9. As the
steady-state condition of constant Rn concentration N at values of D and m are small, the depth range that affects the
222
arbitrary depth is assumed, that is, qN/qt = 0. Under this Rn concentration near the ground surface is restricted to
assumption and the conditions of diffusion and advection be shallow. If the source is too shallow, however, the lateral
of Rn, the fundamental equation for Rn concentration in a range of high Rn concentration attributable to the inclina-
two-dimensional regime (e.g., along a transect) can be tion of the fault will become narrow, making it difficult to
expressed by estimate the dip angle. The source depth was set at 20 m
based on these considerations.
o2 N mx oN mz oN k
N0 12
oz2 D ox D oz D
where D is the diffusion coefficient, mx and mz are the
components of the carrier gas velocity, m, along the x and z
axes (where the x axis is horizontal), and k is the decay
constant of 222Rn. Here, only 222Rn is considered because
the range of 220Rn migration will be small due to its short
half-life.
As it is difficult to analytically solve Eq. (12), the
equation is discretized using a finite difference technique.
With an approximation for the first derivative by spatial
backward difference and gridding over the calculation
regime, Eq. (12) can be replaced by a differential equation,
which can then be used to calculate the 222Rn concentration
at each grid point. This calculation was simplified by
dividing the regime into a fault zone and a surrounding
zone, in which the values of D and m in each zone are
constant. The finite difference method (FDM) simulation
makes it possible to model the fault-zone geometry that has
the greatest effect on the spatial distribution of 222Rn
concentration. Details of FDM are described in Appendix.
The values of D and m are defined in reference to Megumi
and Mamuro (1973) and Owczarski et al. (1990) as being
5 9 10-6 m2/s (D) and 3 9 10-5 m/s (m) along the dip of Fig. 9 Example of grid generation used in the FDM for calculating
the fault in a fault zone, and 4 9 10-6 and 1 9 10-5 m/s in 222
Rn concentrations in shallow soil
123
1542 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
Case study of the Futagawa fault Figure 10 shows the resultant fault-zone models for
each transect along with the distributions of 222Rn num-
As the 222Rn concentration in shallow soil was shown to be ber. The general trends of measured N222 and the
particularly high in the vicinity of the main and subordinate simulated N222 are confirmed to be similar. All the fault-
fault on transects A and B (Fig. 4), the N222 was calculated zone models dip northward, which signifies a normal fault
at the grid points at a depth of 0.5 m to estimate the fault- type based on the topography. This dipping configuration
zone geometry. The location, dip direction and angle, corresponds to the geological insight (Watanabe 1984)
width, and N222 at Rn source were chosen as unknown and deep structure of fracture zones to a depth of 10 km
variables, and the N222 data near the faults were selected determined by magnetotelluric survey across the Futaga-
for modeling (Fig. 10). The simulation was iterated with wa fault (Asaue et al. 2004). Figure 11 shows the
different parameter values until the calculated N222 corre- superposition of the fault models on the lineaments. The
sponded to the distribution of measured N222. In the models belonging to the main fault indicate dips of 69
iteration, the step widths of dip angle, zone width, and (A), 75 (B), and 55 (C; corrected to 69), with an
222
Rn source number were set at 1, 0.5 m, and 0.1 9 106, estimated fault zone width of 10 m. For the subordinate
respectively, and the model minimizing the squared error faults, the models indicate a dip of 69 and 55, gentler
was accepted as the final result. In order to consider the than for the main fault
spatial variation in the dip angle, the angle step width was Based on the exact spatial relationship with the linea-
set small. In the following discussion, however, the faults ments, the consistency of dip directions, and the similarity
with dip angles within 10 are regarded to be similar in of dip angles, the fault-zone models are considered to
accordance with usual fault analysis. reasonably express the configuration of the shallow part of
Fig. 10 (1) High N222 values extracted from the vicinity of faults (top), (2) 222Rn concentrations calculated by the FDM (middle), and (3) fault-
zone models used for calculation (bottom)
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1543
123
1544 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
from the reference, showing a fault in the channel deposits however, its relation to the fault is ambiguous because the
and on the top of basement rocks with an eastward dip of resistivity is located on the transect edge. For transect C,
80 accompanied by a fracture zone of 12 m in width. A which was covered by talus deposits, the resistivity does
transect of 50 m in length was set parallel to the trench not respond to the fault, instead exhibiting a horizontally
section and analyzed by the same Rn survey and modeling layered structure with no fault manifestations. Conse-
procedure as for the Futagawa fault area. However, the quently, the 222Rn concentrations are considered to be
analysis was simplified in this case because the topography more sensitive to the presence of faults, regardless of sur-
along the Neodani transect is almost flat. face lithologies, and can provide more reliable fault-zone
In the distribution of N222 along the transect (Fig. 12), models than electric sounding.
local triangular peaks are present, with a gradual increase
toward the west and sharp decrease following the maxi- Mechanism of sharp rise in Rn concentrations
mum. The location of the highest N222 point is consistent in fault zones
with the location of the main fault as determined by trench
survey. A typical nonequilibrium pattern of type-A gas can In the fault-zone models, the 222Rn concentrations at
also be seen at this point. The FDM simulation was focused source depth in the fault zone were assumed to be higher
on the data in the vicinity of the main fault and was per- than in the surrounding zone. To confirm the validity of
formed assuming N222 at Rn source of 2.4 9 106 in the this assumption, soil samples were taken from above the
fault zone and of 1.0 9 106 in the surrounding area. All fracture zone in boring cores from the Futagawa fault area,
other parameters were set the same as for the Futagawa and the radioactivity of the samples were measured using a
case. The best-matched calculation by the FDM was 1480 Wizard Gamma Counter (Wallan Inc.). This instru-
obtained for a model with an eastward dip of 79 and a ment has a built-in cylindrical photo-amplifier of 75 mm in
fault zone width of 12 m, which is almost identical to the diameter and 80 mm in height, which is coated with NaI.
actual fault geometry. This further demonstrates the capa- The target of measurement is 214Pb, the first daughter
bility of a combined CRAS and FDM approach for nuclide of 222Rn and which emits c-rays upon decay
modeling fault-zone geometry. (222Rn?218Po?214Pb). Therefore, the 222Rn concentration
can be estimated from the c-ray counts based on the pro-
portionality relation of half-life.
Discussion Four samples were collected, from depths of 0.5, 5.8,
23.2, and 43.3 m, corresponding to topsoil, Aso-4, Aso-2,
Comparison with resistivity distribution and the fracture zone, respectively. After drying, the sam-
ples were crushed and divided into two specimens of 30 g
Electric sounding is also a widely used traditional method each. Reference data were also obtained for a large fracture
of fault investigation. The resistivity has been shown to be zone (10 m width) in a gabbro quarry, 30 km north of the
related to fault features such as gouges and geologic dis- Futagawa fault area (data 5) in Fig. 14, and for top soil from
continuities (e.g., Suzuki et al. 2000; Wise et al. 2003). To the grounds of Kumamoto University (data 6). Figure 14
evaluate the usefulness of Rn surveys, electric sounding shows the results of measurements as the averaging of the
using a dipoledipole array was conducted in the Futagawa two data at each depth. Maximum values were obtained in
fault area to parallel the Rn measurements. The sounding the range of 340360 keV for samples from the boring
was restricted by natural features on transect B due to a cores, and the values increased in approach to the fracture
lack of bare ground near the start point. The sounding zone. This corresponds well to the target c-ray energy level
survey on transect C was limited to the region around the of 352 keV for the parent nuclides of 214Pb, indicating an
main fault. abundance of these isotopes in the fracture zone. The two
Figure 13 shows the resistivity distributions derived by reference data do not exhibit peaks within that energy range,
inversion analysis of the obtained apparent resistivity on consistent with the absence of active faults in the quarry
each transect. On transect A, the main fault is located at the area, which lies in a regional metamorphic zone (the Sangun
edge of a zone of relatively high resistivity ([200 Xm), metamorphic zone). Although many fracture zones are
but the resistivity pattern does not clearly represent the present in the quarry, they must have been formed under old
fault shape. In contrast, the subordinate fault can be iden- tectonic stress fields unrelated to the present field.
tified from a drop in the resistivity along transects A and B. On the basis of these results, a significant reservoir of
222
Although the dips determined by the CRAS approach and Rn and its parents appears to have accumulated in the
resistivity measurements differ by about 25, the dip trend fracture zone of these recently active faults. Several studies
is the same: both dip northward. Notably, the resistivity at have indicated that Th is strongly adsorbed by kaolinite,
the main fault on transect B is lower than 25 Xm, while Ra is adsorbed onto mineral surfaces such as quartz,
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1545
kaolinite, and other clay minerals (Riese 1982; Ames et al. concentrations of 230Th, 226Ra, and 222Rn in shallow soils
1983a, b; Wanty and Schoen 1993). In the U decay series, in areas without active fault zones must be generally low,
230
Th and 226Ra can be accumulated in fault gouges, as indicated by data (5) and (6) in Fig. 14.
resulting in a sharp rise in 222Rn concentrations in soil A question then arises as to from where do the radio-
gases in fault zone due the relatively long half-lives of nuclides originate. Pumping effects caused by earth tides
these isotopes (8.0 9 104 and 1.62 9 103 years, respec- are known to increase Rn concentrations (e.g., Barnet et al.
tively). This relationship between cause and effect is 1997; Lenzen and Neugebauer 1999; Groves-Kirkby et al.
similar to the accumulation of U in rocks to produce 2006), but tectonically induced fault movements may have
anomalous Rn concentrations in groundwater (Wanty and stronger effect on the increase and spatial variation of Rn
Gundersen 1987), with a direct correlation with Rn con- concentrations than earth tides. Gold and Soter (1984/85)
centrations in the overlying soils (Gates and Gundersen stated that major earthquakes are often accompanied by the
1989). The Rn activity of geopressured solution gas is eruption of high-pressure gas from great depth via frac-
known to be directly proportional to the amount of Ra tures. This gas may carry radionuclides from deep crust and
contained in the aquifer water (Kraemer 1986). The fluids to the near surface, to accumulate in fault gouges.
123
1546 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
This mechanism is shown schematically in Fig. 15. The limitations of Rn surveys of soil gas should therefore be
two conditions that are essential for reaching high Rn considered in terms of fault detection.
concentrations in shallow soil under nonequilibrium Rn gas
conditions are the repetition and recentness of fault
movement. As the half-lives of 230Th and 226Ra are short Conclusions
on a geological time scale, the concentrations of these
isotopes in gouges will decrease with time, making it A new calculation method, CRAS, was introduced to
impossible to reach significant Rn concentrations in soil estimate the Rn concentration in soil gas more accurately
under low velocities of gas ascent. However, repeated by the a-scintillation counter method. The method con-
supply of high-pressure gas during faulting can elevate the siders the Rn gas condition in terms of radioactive
concentration to very high levels. This mechanism is sup- equilibrium, and allows the populations of 222Rn, 218Po,
ported by the low 214Pb concentration in the fracture-zone and 220Rn to be determined at the start of measurement.
sample from the quarry, which had a wide gouge zone. The This method was applied to nonequilibrium gases sampled
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1547
near fumaroles in a hot spring area and equilibrium gases on the characteristics of these isotopes, the repetition and
sampled from normal soil. The total decays tend to increase recentness of fault movement is considered essential for
with the time under nonequilibrium conditions, whereas the reaching high Rn concentrations in shallow soils under
decays decrease rapidly within a few minutes down to a nonequilibrium Rn gas conditions and low-gas ascent
constant value under equilibrium conditions. The CRAS velocity.
method was shown to be effective for both gas types and
suitable for predicting the temporal change in Rn decay. Acknowledgments The authors wish to express their gratitude to
Mr. Yasutaka Koba and the graduate students, who assisted in the
The method also allows the gas age to be estimated, pro- radon and electrical surveys and data analysis, and Mr. Jitsuya
viding information on the activity of ascending gas. It was Uemura of the Radioisotope Center of Kumamoto University for
demonstrated that the empirical formula used for process- instruction regarding the measurement of c-ray spectra. Sincere
ing measurement data underestimates the 222Rn thanks are extended to Dr. Eveln Roeloffs, of U. S. Geological Sur-
vey, for helpful comments to improve the clarity of the manuscript.
concentration, which is more useful for detecting latent The anonymous reviewers valuable comments are also gratefully
faults than 220Rn due to the much longer half-life of 222Rn. appreciated.
The improved accuracy of 222Rn concentrations
obtained by CRAS compared to the empirical formula-
based concentrations was clarified through analyses of Appendix
sample data taken along transects crossing active Futagawa
and Neodani faults. The CRAS results exhibit a clear As the terrain on which the transects were set was not flat, a
correlation with lineaments associated with the main and uniform mesh composed of simple rectangular or square
subordinate faults in terms of position and magnitude, elements cannot be used for the FDM simulation. Thus, a
displays clear spatial self-correlation due to the existence mapping of the actual terrain of the calculation regime (xz
of faults, and produces a remarkable geometry-related plane) to a simple rectangular regime (ng plane) by
distribution of concentration across faults. The Rn gas in a coordinate transformation is considered. The differential
fault zone was also found be under nonequilibrium con- equation is then solved in the ng plane. The mapping
ditions, without an active rise in carrier gas. function between the two planes is expressed by
The combination of CRAS and FDM simulation was )
shown to be effective for modeling the shallow part of a n nx; z
A1
fault with respect to width and dip direction and angle. The g gx; z
FDM was performed for the diffusion and advection of Rn
The partial derivatives then give
in arbitrary terrain. Fault-zone models were constructed for
9
oN oN oN >
nx gx >
>
ox on og >
>
>
>
oN oN oN =
nz gz A2
oz on og >
>
2 2 2 2 >>
>
oN oN oN 2 o N o N 2 o N >
>
2
n z g z n z 2
2n z g z g z 2
;
oz oz n oz g on onog og
two study areas by matching the 222Rn concentrations by where the subscripts denote the derivative with respect to x
FDM to those by CRAS. The method revealed that the or z. Using equations (A2), Eq. (12) can be rewritten as
main and subordinate faults in the Futagawa fault are, to be follows:
subparallel with normal faulting configuration, in agree-
ment with geologic investigations. The model produced for o2 N o2 N 2 vz oN
2o N vx
the Neodani fault area was also consistent with the geo- n2z 2
2n g
z z g z 2
nzz nx nz
on onog og D D on
metric features determined by trench survey. vx vz oN k
From an c-ray scintillation survey of the soil and rock gzz gx gz N0 A3
D D og D
samples, the parent nuclides of 222Rn, 230Th and 226Ra
were estimated to be trapped in the gouges of active fault. By applying the spatial backward difference to
These nuclides may be entrained in the eruption of high- Eq. (A3), the following difference equation can be
pressure gases from great depth during earthquakes. Based obtained:
123
1548 Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549
N nDn;g2N n;gN nDn;g Ames LL, McGarrah JE, Walker BA, Salter PF (1983b) Sorption of
n2z uranium and radium by biotite, muscovite, and phlogopite. Clays
Dn2
Clay Miner 31:343351
N n;gN n;gDgN nDn;gN nDn;gDg Ball TK, Cameron DG, Colman TB, Roberts PD (1991) Behaviour of
2nz gz
DnDg radon in the geological environment: a review. Q J Eng Geol
( ) 9
1 n2z 2nz gz g2z >
>
Nij 2 Ni1j B Ni1j C Nij1 Ni1j1 2 Nij1 >
>
A Dn DnDg Dg >
>
>
! !>
>
>
2 2 mv
v
v
v >
>
k n 2n g g 1 1 >
gzz gx gz >
z z xij zij xij zij
A 2 2 nzz nx nz >
>
Dij Dn DnDg Dg Dn Dij Dij Dg Dij Dij =
! A6
n2 2n g 1 vxi1j vzi1j >
>
B 2 z z nzz nx nz >
>
>
>
Dn DnDg Dn Di1j Di1j >
>
! >
>
>
>
2n g g 2
1 v
v >
>
C z z
2
xij1
gzz gx gz
zij1 >
>
DnDg Dg Dg Dij1 Dij1 ;
123
Environ Geol (2009) 56:15331549 1549
Isra/l H, Bjornssin S (1966) Radon (Rn222) and Thoron (Rn220) in soil (symposium volume). International Atomic Energy Agency,
air over faults. Z Geophys 32:4864 Vienna, pp 185211
King C-Y, King B-S, Evans WC (1996) Spatial radon anomalies on Soonawala NM, Telford WN (1980) Movement of radon in overbur-
active faults in California. Appl Geochem 11:497510 den. Geophysics 45:12971315
Koike K, Kawaba K, Yoshinaga T, Ohmi M (1996) Characterization Sorey ML, Kennedy BM, Evans WC, Farrar CD, Suemnicht GA
of latent fault based on soil radon concentration. Geophys (1993) Helium isotope and gas discharge variations associated
Exploratroion (Butsuri-Tansa) 49:347359 (in Japanese with with crustal unrest in Long Valley Caldera, California, 1989
English abstract) 1992. J Geophys Res 98:1587115889
Koike K, Tomita S, Sakamoto Y, Yoshinaga T, Ohmi M (2000) Sugisaki R, Ito T, Nagamine K, Kawabe I (1996) Gas geochemical
Estimation of active-fault shape using radon concentration in soil changes at mineral springs associated with the 1995 southern
gas and numerical simulation. Geophys Exploratroion (Butsuri- Hyogo earthquake (M = 7.2), Japan. Earth Planet Sci Lett
Tansa) 53:2942 (in Japanese with English abstract) 139:239249
Kraemer TF (1986) Radon in unconventional natural gas from Gulf Sugiyama Y, Yoshikawa K, Katoh L, Tsukuda E (1986) Geochemical
coast geopressured- geothermal reservoirs. Environ Sci Technol exploration of faults by radon concentration of ground air in the
20:939942 Oku-Tango area, Kyoto prefecture with special reference to the
Kumamoto Prefecture (1997) Final report on investigations of the applicability and problems of this methods. Bull Geol Surv Japan
Futagawa and Tatsutayama Faults (in Japanese) 37:101115 (in Japanese with English abstract)
Kumamoto Prefecture and Kumamoto City (1994) Report on Suzuki K, Toda S, Kusunoki K, Fujimitsu Y, Mogi T, Jomori A
comprehensive groundwater investigations in the Kumamoto (2000) Case studies of electrical and electromagnetic methods
area (in Japanese) applied to mapping active faults beneath the thick quaternary.
Lenzen M, Neugebauer HJ (1999) Measurements of radon concen- Eng Geol 56:2945
tration and the role of earth tides in a gypsum mine in The Research Group for Active Faults of Japan (1991) Active faults
Walferdange, Luxembourg. Health Phys 77:154162 in Japan (revised edn). University of Tokyo Press, Tokyo, 438 p
Lindmark A, Rosen B (1985) Radon in soil gasexhalation tests and (in Japanese with English abstract)
in situ measurements. Sci Total Environ 45:397404 Tsunogai U, Wakita H (1995) Precursory chemical changes in ground
Matsumoto H (1974) The source of Togawa lava, near Kumamoto water: Kobe earthquake, Japan. Science 269:6163
city. Bull Volcanol Soc Jpn 19:1924 (in Japanese with English Torgersen T, ODonnell J (1991) The degassing flux from the solid
abstract) earth: Release by fracturing, earthquakes. Geophys Res Lett
Megumi K, Mamuro T (1973) Radon and thoron exhalation from the 18:951954
ground. J Geophys Res 78:18041808 Toutain J-P, Baubron J-C, Bronec JL, Allard P, Briole P, Marty B,
Miller JM, Ostle D (1973) Radon measurements in uranium Miele G, Tedesco D, Luongo G (1992) Continuous monitoring
prospecting. In: Uranium exploration methods (conference of distal gas emanations at Vulcano, southern Italy. Bull
volume). International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, pp Volcanol 54:147155
237247 Virk HS, Singh B (1994) Radon recording of Uttarkashi earthquake.
Miyakoshi K, Inohara Y, Kakuta T, Kanaori Y, Satake Y (1993) Geophys Res Lett 21:737740
Trenching study of the Neodani Fault of the Nobi active fault Wanty RB, Gundersen LCS (1987) Factors affecting radon concen-
system at Kinbara, Gifu Prefecture in 1985. Act Fault Res trations in ground water: evidence from sandstone and
11:815 (in Japanese with English abstract) crystalline aquifers. Geol Soc Am Abstr Programs 19:135
Morse RM (1976) Radon counters in uranium exploration. In: Wanty RB, Schoen R (1993) A review of the chemical processes
Exploration for uranium ore deposits (conference volume). affecting the mobility of radionuclides in natural waters, with
International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, pp 229239 applications. In: Gundersen LCS, Wanty RB (eds) Field studies
Nielson KK, Rogers VC, Gee GW (1984) Diffusion of radon through of radon in rocks, soils, and water, C. K. Smoley, Boca Raton, pp
soils: a pore distribution model. Soil Sci Soc Am J 48:482487 183194
Owczarski PC, Holford DJ, Freeman HD, Gee GW (1990) Effects of Watanabe K (1984) Active faults and their significance in the region
changing water content and atmospheric pressure on radon flux to the west of Aso caldera, Kumamoto Prefecture. Mem Fac
from surfaces of five soil types. Geophys Res Lett 17:817820 Educ Kumamoto Univ 33:3547
Riese AC (1982) Adsorptoin of radium and thorium onto quartz and Wise DJ, Cassidy J, Locke C (2003) Geophysical imaging of the
kaolinite: a comparison of solution/surface equilibria models. quaternary Wairoa North Fault, New Zealand: a case study.
Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, The Colorado School of Mines, 292 p J Appl Geophys 53:116
Schery SD, Gaeddert DH, Wilkening MH (1984) Factors affecting Yamaguchi Y, Hase H, Yano Y, Kinugasa Y (1984) Lineament
exhalation of radon from a gravelly sandy loam. J Geophys Res analysis on radar images in the Hohi geothermal area and the
89:7,2997,309 geological implication of the Toyooka-Miyanoharu line by a soil
Smith AY, Baretto PMC, Pournis S (1976) Radon methods in gas survey. J Geotherm Res Soc Jpn 6:101120 (in Japanese with
uranium exploration. In: Exploration for uranium ore deposits English abstract)
123