Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The combination of diverse materials and complex geometry makes stress distribution analysis in teeth very complicated.
Simulation in a computerized model might enable a study of the simultaneous interaction of the many variables. A 3D solid model
of a human maxillary premolar was prepared and exported into a 3D-nite element model (FEM). Additionally, a generic class II
MOD cavity preparation and restoration was simulated in the FEM model by a proper choice of the mesh volumes. A validation
procedure of the FEM model was executed based on a comparison of theoretical calculations and experimental data. Dierent
rigidities were assigned to the adhesive system and restorative materials. Two dierent stress conditions were simulated: (a) stresses
arising from the polymerization shrinkage and (b) stresses resulting from shrinkage stress in combination with vertical occlusal
loading. Three dierent cases were analyzed: a sound tooth, a tooth with a class II MOD cavity, adhesively restored with a high (25
GPa) and one with a low (12.5 GPa) elastic modulus composite. The cusp movements induced by polymerization stress and (over)-
functional occlusal loading were evaluated. While cusp displacement was higher for the more rigid composites due to the pre-
stressing from polymerization shrinkage, cusp movements turned out to be lower for the more exible composites in case the
restored tooth which was stressed by the occlusal loading.
This preliminary study by 3D FEA on adhesively restored teeth with a class II MOD cavity indicated that Youngs modulus
values of the restorative materials play an essential role in the success of the restoration. Premature failure due to stresses arising
from polymerization shrinkage and occlusal loading can be prevented by proper selection and combination of materials. r 2001
Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.
Keywords: 3D FEA; Adhesive tooth restorations; Resin-based composites; Polymerization shrinkage; Occlusal loading; Stress distribution
values nor comparable fracture patterns (Ausiello et al., gated by a comparison of calculated theory and
1997). Resin-based composite restored teeth often show mechanical experimental data.
mesial-distal crown fractures with the composite materi-
al fracture located at the critical tooth-resin interface.
This behavior has been attributed to the stresses arising 2. Materials and methods
from the polymerization shrinkage (Davidson and De
Gee, 1984), which results in stress build-up in the 3D-nite element approach consists in dividing a
restored tooth and cusp displacements (Pearson and geometric model into a nite number of elements in
Hegarty, 1987). Repeated functional loading will cause which the variables of interest are approximated with
fatiguing of the restored tooth and will ultimately result some mathematical functions. Biomedical applications
in failure. Ausiello et al. (1999a, b) investigated in vitro of this method are already known in some elds of
the performance of adhesively restored large and deep medicine (Apicella et al., 1994; Dalstra et al., 1995;
cavities in maxillary premolars under cyclic loading. Apicella et al., 1998).
That fatiguing process showed that, when polymeriza- In our study, a 3D FEM model of a rst upper
tion shrinkage pre-stressing conditions are present, the premolar was realized. The rst step was the solid
adhesive restoration-cavity wall interface initially de- model generation in which the shapes of dentin, pulp
bonds at the weakest bonded areas between the dentin and enamel were obtained. The space for the class
and the restorative material. As reported in several II MOD cavity preparation was also dened. Then
previous studies (Koike et al., 1990), polymerization the solid model was lled with elements, creating the
shrinkage stress of adhesive composite restorations mesh, and the material properties of dentin and enamel
depends on several factors such as restoration size, were assigned to the elements, which lled the corre-
cavity shape, incremental or bulk placement technique, sponding regions. Thus the sound tooth FEM model
water sorption, composite creep and cusp movements was obtained. Subsequently, the FEM model of the
(Feilzer et al., 1990). Moreover, it has been shown that restored tooth was realized by changing element
increased exibility (reduced E-modulus) of the restora- material properties in the central zone of cavity
tion reduces the polymerization stress (Kemp-Scholte preparation. At the end loads and geometric conditions
and Davidson, 1990). Suliman et al. (1993) investigated were applied.
in vitro the cusps deection in adhesively restored
natural teeth under dierent polymerization compensat- 2.1. Tooth solid model generation
ing eects by using a microscope with a micrometer.
According to that study, cusps deection dierences Tooth solid model was generated using literature
depend on cavity size, wet and dry storage conditions data on the tooth morphology for the denition of the
and lling material rigidity. Apparently, there are a dentine and enamel volumes (Wheeler, 1974) and a
variety of factors that are simultaneously active. Some plaster model (Thanaka model, Japan, 1978) for the
enlarge each other, whilst other mechanisms counteract external shape denition. Crown and roots were
each other. Proper understanding of the physical constructed in two dierent phases and assembled
phenomena occurring in the adhesively restored tooth afterwards. The crown was realized by digitizing an
during the placement and setting of the materials and upper premolar tooth plaster model on the scale of
throughout it is functioning is crucial in the determina- one to ve by a Cyberware laser scanner. Over two
tion of the proper placement procedures and material hundred proles were generated at 0,33 mm incre-
selection. Structural analyses of the integral process may ments by laser scanning in two dierent directions: a
oer an essential tool for the assessment and reduction vertical and a horizontal one. Among all the proles,
of fracture risks, ensuring optimal performance in only 34 were collected, 17 vertical and 17 horizontal
selection of the restorative material combinations and at 2 mm increments, and were assembled in a 3D
material application protocols. Since stress distribution wire-frame structure (Fig. 1) by means of a 3D CAD
investigation of teeth, in particular after restoration, is (Autocad 12, Autodesk, Inc., Neuchatel, Swiss, 1992).
very complicated due to the complex geometry, 3D- The wire-frame curves were exported in Pro-Engineer
Finite Element Analysis might be a powerful tool to 16.0 (Parametric Technology Co., Waltham, MA, USA,
visualize the problems. 1994), where a solid model was generated tting
The aim of this study was to provide FEA engineering the horizontal and vertical proles. The model was
tools for the understanding of the inuence of the cut in the cervical area in order to obtain the nal
shrinkage characteristics and composite rigidity on the crown (Fig. 2).
extent of cusps displacement and localization of critical The roots were modelled by means of their mesial-
sites in a given restored tooth under (over) functional distal and buccal-lingual representations taken from the
loading. Moreover, validation of the proposed proce- literature (Braden, 1976). The two representations were
dure of the Finite Element Model (FEM) was investi- scanned and 8 vertical proles were generated imitating
P. Ausiello et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001) 12691277 1271
Fig. 1. 3D Solid upper premolar model and nite element model generation.
the scanned images. The roots were constructed, tting The crown and the roots with the pulp chamber
the vertical proles (Fig. 1). The pulp region was were assembled in the nal model (Fig. 1). Dening
obtained in an analogous way and subtracted from parametric cutting plane, it is also possible to
the roots. easily realize dierent cavities and MOD preparations.
1272 P. Ausiello et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001) 12691277
In Fig. 5, a MOD II cavity is shown with 3.5 mm composite material, so it was possible to record only
occlusal width. the material deformation within the tooth. The cylinder
was clamped to the test machine and the load was
2.2. FEM model generation applied vertically by means of a 6 mm diameter steel
cylinder with the axis normal to the tooth axis in order
The solid model was exported into ANSYS rel. 5.3 to simulate one main important force which develops
(Ansys Inc, Houston, USA, 1994), using the IGES during occlusion (Mc Neil, 1997). A 1 mm/min constant
format. The volumes were redened and meshed with rate was imposed on the loading cylinder and the
8-node brick and 4-node tetrahedral elements, result- vertical displacement and the axial load were acquired
ing in an 11165-element and 7340-node structure. until the restored tooth fractured (experimental curve in
Dierent material properties were assigned to the Fig. 3). The same test has been simulated using the FE
elements according to the volume denition. Three analysis and the results are compared. The comparison
dierent models were realized. The rst model test loading cylinder was modelled with the 3D elastic
(Mod. A) is the sound tooth; the second model beams (Fig. 3). The beams have one end in common and
(Mod. B) is a restored tooth with a more rigid the other one on a cusp. End rotations have not
composite; the third model is a restored tooth with a constrained. The common end was displaced in the
less rigid composite (Mod. C). Material properties are central position of the loading cylinder section in the
listed in Table 1. experimental test. The load is applied on the tooth at
Some assumptions were made in order to simplify the two points (Fig. 3), namely the beams elements (blue
calculations. Absolute bonding was considered among lines) and on the cusps (red areas). The resulting force F
enamel, dentin and composite. The pulp chamber was crossing the central position of the loading cylinder
modeled as a void because of its negligible stiness and section is 400 N (Fig. 3, red arrow). The beam elastic
strength. Despite their intrinsic anisotropic nature, properties were thought to be innitely rigid compared
dentin and enamel can be assumed homogeneous and to the tooth. Resin support was not modelled and it was
isotropic (Darendeliler et al., 1998; Versluis et al., 1996) considered to be rigid as the loading system. Other
because their anisotropy belongs to a microscopic studies (Darendeliler et al., 1998) also assumed the
scale whereas the tooth model is macroscopic. Further- supporting alveolar bone rigidity.
more, all materials were considered elastic through-
out the entire deformation, which is a reasonable 2.4. Numerical simulations
assumption for brittle materials in non-failure
conditions (Rees et al., 1995). Three dierent situations were simulated: a compres-
sion test with a 400 N occlusal load, composite
polymerization shrinkage and the combination of
2.3. Model experimental validation occlusal loading and shrinkage. In these simulations,
the tooth model had to be constrained apically to the
In order to validate the FEM model, a compression enamel-dentin junction. This fact permitted to eliminate
test was performed on a class II MOD restored human the lower part of the mesh, reducing the model size to
upper premolar. The resin-based composite Prodigy 7894 elements and 5812 nodes.
(Kerr, USA), with a Youngs modulus of 12.5 GPa and Numerical results were obtained for the three models
polymerization shrinkage of 2.7370.31% by volume in (A, B and C). Particularly, the vertical displacement of
combination with Optibond FL adhesive (Kerr, USA) the load application point in model C can be used as the
was used for the restoration. The tooth was inserted numerical datum for the model experimental validation.
until the cementum-enamel junction in a steel cylindrical For the evaluation of the stresses arising from the
ring with the apical root area in contact with the steel composite polymerization shrinkage, a volumetric con-
ring oor. Subsequently, it was lled with resin traction has been applied to the composite. The
shrinkage data required for this study were obtained
by using a linometer (De Gee et al., 1993). The
shrinkage which determines cusp deections, however,
Table 1
cannot be directly related to the amount measured in the
Youngs modulus (GPa) Poissons ratio linometer free shrinkage tests. This is due to the
Dentin 18a
0.23b viscoelastic relaxation occurring in the material during
Enamel 48a 0.3b the passage from a viscous uid into an elastic solid. It
More rigid composite (B) 25 0.3 has to be noted that when a composite is adhesively
Less rigid composite (C) 12.5 0.3 placed in the tooth cavity, only a part of the shrinkage
a
Wheeler (1974). produces cusp deections and a part relaxes. In this
b
Verluis (1996). paper an on-o test is described: composites discs were
P. Ausiello et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001) 12691277 1273
Fig. 4. Von Mises stress distribution due to vertical loading (up) and displacement distribution (down).
1274 P. Ausiello et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001) 12691277
Fig. 10. Von Mises stress distribution due to vertical loading for Mod. A and to shrinkage and vertical loading for Models B and C.
greater elastic deformation. This eect is also shown in limiting cusp movements. Furthermore, it does not have
Fig. 9 where the displacements normal to the tooth axis to bend cusps as a consequence of its curing, otherwise
are plotted. The less rigid composite exhibits a greater the pre-loading eect can be disastrous. The problem is
elastic deformation that is transferred to a lower that rigid composites have low elastic release. In this
deformation of the cusps. Higher stress release depends way the solution is in balancing the two eects,
also on viscous ow of the composite during curing. But accepting a low pre-loading eect in order to obtain
this eect was not directly taken into account in these sucient rigidity.
models. Simply, the contraction load input in simula- A new point of view can be introduced considering
tions was signicantly reduced compared to the free two aspects not contemplated in the present model. On
contraction. the one hand there is the viscous ow that can generate a
At the end, occlusal loading and shrinkage were great stress release during composite curing. But viscous
combined for models B and C. A Von Mises stress map ow needs time and actually the light curing composite
is plotted in Fig. 10 together with that of the sound kinetics are too fast for this. On the other hand, there is
tooth under occlusal loading. Models B and C exhibit a the adhesive interface, which can limit the cusp pre-
similar behavior, even if Mod. B has higher stress in the loading eect with its elastic deformation. By changing
upper part of the restoration whereas Mod. C has higher the adhesive elastic modulus or by simply changing its
stress in the cusps. However, this eect is greatly thickness it is possible to obtain dierent rigidity of the
reduced compared to the single occlusal loading case. interface region. In this direction the authors plan to
The important dierence is between these two models develop the actual study, making use again of FEM
and the sound tooth because they show high stress simulations, which prove to be an ecient tool in
values at the composite-tooth interface, in a zone where complex structure analysis.
the sound tooth exhibits low stress.
This study was designed to investigate the correlation
between resin composite elastic properties and restored Acknowledgements
tooth stiness. Findings indicate that more rigid
composites lead to lower cusp movements under Particular thanks to Eng. F. Quadrini and Eng. L. Di
occlusal loading but exhibit higher pre-loading eect. Palma for their collaboration in the research on the
A good composite for restoration has to balance the two experimental model validation and numerical simula-
opposite eects. In this way a low pre-load on the cusps tions.
can be accepted in order to reach sucient restoration
rigidity.
References
5. Conclusions Apicella, A., Liguori, A., Masi, E., Nicolais, L., 1994. Thick laminate
composite modeling in total hip replacement. In: Found, M.S.,
FEM simulations supply information about mechan- Sheeld (Ed.), Proceedings of Second International Seminar on
Experimental Techniques and Design in Composite Materials.
ical behavior of sound and restored teeth. The best
Apicella, A., Masi, E., Nicolais, L., Zarone, F., De Rosa, N., Valletta,
restoration is that which allows restored tooth to react G., 1998. A nite element model study of occlusal schemes in full
to external loads as the sound tooth does. For this, the arch implant restoration. Journal of Material Science: Materials in
composite has to store a great quantity of energy, Medicine 1, 191196.
P. Ausiello et al. / Journal of Biomechanics 34 (2001) 12691277 1277
Ausiello, P., De Gee, A.J., Rengo, S., Davidson, C.L., 1997. Fracture Feilzer, A.J., De Gee, A.J., Davidson, C.L., 1990. Relaxation of
resistance of endodontically treated premolars adhesively restored. contraction shear stress by hygroscopic expansion. Journal of
American Journal of Dentistry 10, 237241. Dental Research 69, 3639.
Ausiello, P., Davidson, C.L., Cascone, P., De Gee, A.J., Rengo, S., Kemp-Scholte, C.M., Davidson, C.L., 1990. Marginal integrity related
1999a. Debonding of adhesively restored deep class II MOD to bond strength and elasticity of the composite resin restorative
restorations after functional loading. American Journal of Den- system. Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry 64, 258264.
tistry 12, 8488. Koike, T., Hasegawa, T., Menabe, A., Itoh, K., Wakumoto, S., 1990.
Ausiello, P., Apiciella, A., Quadrini, F., Rengo, S., Davidson, C.L., Eect of water sorption and thermal stresses on cavity adaptation
1999b. Experimentally determined visco-elastic properties of light of dental composites. Dental Materials 6, 178180.
curing composites in a 3D FEA of shrinkage-stress release in class McNeill, A.A., 1997. Science and Practice of Occlusion. Quintessence,
II MOD restorations. Proceedings of the Third International Illinois.
Association Dental Research Continental European Division, Pearson, G.J., Hegarty, S.M., 1987. Cusp movement in molar teeth
Nice, Abstract No. 295. using dentine adhesives and composite lling materials. Biomater-
Braden, M., 1976. Biophysics of the root. In: Frontiers in Oral ials 8, 473476.
Physiology. Basel, Karger, Vol. 2, pp. 137. Rees, J.S., Jacobsen, P.H., 1995. Modelling the eects of enamel
Dalstra, M., Huiskes, R., van Erning, L., 1995. Development and anisotropy with the nite element method. Journal of Oral
validation of a three-dimensional nite element model of the pelvic Rehabilitation 22, 451454.
bone. Journal of Biomechanical Engineering 117, 272278. Sakaguchi, R.L., Brust, E.W., Cross, M., De Long, R., Douglas,
Darendeliler, S.Y., Alacam, T., Yaman, Y., 1998. Analysis of stress W.H., 1991. Independent movement of cusps during occlusal
distribution in a maxillary central incisor subjected to various post loading. Dental Materials 7, 186190.
and core applications. Journal of Endodontics 24, 107111. Suliman, A.A., Boyer, D.B., Lakes, R.S., 1993. Interferometric
Davidson, C.L., 2000. Handling of polymerization stresses in resin- measurements of cusp deformation of teeth restored with
based restorative materials. Dental News 7 (4), 913. composite. Journal of Dental Research 11, 15321536.
Davidson, C.L., De Gee, A.J., 1984. Relaxation of polymerization Versluis, A., Douglas, W.H., Cross, M., Sakaguchi, R.L., 1996. Does
contraction stresses by ow in dental composites. Journal of Dental an incremental lling technique reduce p polymerization shrinkage
Research 63, 146148. stresses? Journal of Dental Research 3, 871878.
De Gee, A.J., Feilzer, A.J., Davidson, C.L., 1993. True polymerization Wendt, S.L., Harris, B.M., Hunt, T.E., 1987. Resistance to cusp
shrinkage of unlled resins and composites determined with a fracture in endodontically treated teeth. Dental Materials 3,
linometer. Dental Materials 9, 1114. 232235.
Farah, J.W., Craig, R.G., 1974. Finite element stress analysis of a Wheeler, R., 1974. Dental Anatomy, Physiology and Occlusion. W.B.
restored asymmetric rst molar. Journal of Dental Research 52, Saunders Co., USA.
859866.