Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10

EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

Background

The ideal gas law is given by


(1)
Where p is the absolute pressure, V is the volume, n is the number of moles, R is the universal
gas constant and T is the absolute temperature. Although this equation is widely by engineer and
scientist, it is accurate over only a limited range of pressure and temperature.

Furthermore, Eqs (1) is more appropriate for some gases that for others. An alternative equation
of state for gasses is given by:

( )( ) (2)

Known as the van der Waals equation, where v=V/n is the molal volume and a and b are
empirical constants that depend on the particular gas.

The Task
An engineering design project requires that you accurately estimate the molal volume (n)of
acetone (a= 14.09 and b = 0.00994) for a number of different temperature from 300k, 400k and
500K and p of 2.5 atm so that appropriate containment vessels can be selected. It is also of
interest to examine how well acetone conforms to the ideal gas law by comparing the molal
volume as calculated by Eqs (1) and (2).

Instruction
1. By using any of the numerical roots of equations method, solve the task above and
determine the roots for val der Waals equations using acetone gas
(CO2/PO1/C3)
2. Show justification for your choice of method to solve task above.
(CO2/PO1/C3)
GIVEN : R = 0.082054 L atm/(mol K)

1
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

INTRODUCTION

Roots of equation is one of the numerical methods which widely used in engineering field as in
engineering, we rarely come across a simple and straight forward situations which can be solve
analytically. The problems are usually very complex and difficult to solve. Therefore, alternative
approach provide by numerical method can be used to solve by approximating the true solution
using computational implementation.

Roots of equation can be classified into two fundamental approaches :


1. Bracketing Method
Bisection
False position
2. Open method
Fixed-point iteration
Newton Rhapson
Secant method
Roots of polynomials

Bracketing methods start with two intial guesses that bracket the true roots while Open Method
need no initial guesses to bracket the true root. Open method usually more efficient compared
with bracketing method but not always work.

2
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

CALCULATION

From the question, the ideal gas law is :

(1)
Where
p : absolute pressure
V : volume
n : the number of moles
R : the universal gas constant
T : the absolute temperature

From equation (1), the molal volume (v) can be determined:

The given values are :

Therefore, the molal volume (v) for each temperatures are :

Pressure, p (atm) Gas constant, R Temperature (K) Molal volume, v (L/mol)


2.5 0.082054 300 9.846480
2.5 0.082054 400 13.128640
2.5 0.082054 500 16.410800

*These values will be assumed as the initial guess for each temperature.

3
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

An alternative equation of state for gases which is known as van der Waals is given by :

( )( ) (2)

Where :

v= : molal volume.

a and b : empirical constants that depend on the particular gas.

From equation (2), we can simplified the equation into :

( ) ( )

( ) ( ) (3)

By differentiate the simplified equation above, we obtained :

( ) ( ) (4)

To solve the task given, the method of numerical equation chosen is Newton Rhapson where the
first derivative is equivalent of the slope given by:

( )
( )
Firstly, we need to find the roots from equation (3) by substituting all the values given. The
values given are :

P = 2.5 atm, a = 14.09, b= 0.00994, R = 0.082054

4
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

For T=300 K,

( )

From this equation, the roots obtained are =0.010118882, =9.247621045, =0.598680072.
Since =9.247621045 is the nearest to the initial guess we obtained from equation (1), therefore
=9.247621045 is the true root for T=300 K.
Initial guess, = 9.846480

i +1 f( ) f( ) a (%) t (%)
0 9.846480 9.314463 136.187600 255.983600 - 6.475816
1 9.314463 9.248599 13.551340 205.747900 0.712149 0.722803
2 9.248599 9.247621 0.195441 199.824000 0.010576 0.010578
3 9.247621 9.247621 0.000043 199.736500 0.000002 0.000002
4 9.247621 9.247621 0.000000 199.736500 0.000000 0.000000

By using acetone gas, the root for val der Waals equations at T=300K are 9.247621.

5
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

For T=400 K,

( )

From this equation, the roots obtained are =12.69497233, =0.010181469, =0.433426199.
Since =12.69497233 is the nearest to the initial guess we obtained from equation (1), therefore
=12.69497233 is the true root for T=400 K.
Initial guess, = 13.128640

i +1 f( ) f( ) a (%) t (%)
0 13.128640 12.722287 180.559300 444.340500 3.41605841
1 12.722286 12.695091 10.667360 392.250400 0.214218944 0.21515739
2 12.695091 12.694972 0.046226 388.852700 0.000936417 0.00093644
3 12.694972 12.694972 0.000000 388.837900 0.000000 0.000000

By using acetone gas, the root for val der Waals equations at T=400K are 12.694972.

6
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

For T=500 K,

( )

From this equation, the roots obtained are =16.07024466, =0.010245653, =0.340247655.
Since =16.070244669 is the nearest to the initial guess we obtained from equation (1),
therefore =16.070244669 is the true root for T=500 K.
Initial guess, = 16.410800

i +1 f( ) f( ) a (%) t (%)
0 16.410800 16.083960 224.395700 686.560275 2.119154
1 16.083959 16.070270 8.675450 633.740575 0.085184 0.085331
2 16.070270 16.070247 0.014906 631.563254 0.000147 0.000147
3 16.070247 16.070247 0.000000 631.559551 0.000000 0.000000

By using acetone gas, the root for val der Waals equations at T=500K are 16.070247.

7
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

DISCUSSION

The van der Waals equation is basically a complex adjustment to the ideal gas as the ideal gas
law works only with ideal gases and it is not too accurate in real life situations. However, people
choose to work with the ideal gas law rather than the van der Waals equation as in most cases,
the difference between these two equation is as low as 1% or less. In this task, both equations are
used to determine the roots of molal volume of acetone gas at three different temperatures (300K,
400K and 500K).

Temperature (K) Ideal Gas law van der Waals True roots
300 9.846480 9.247621 =0.010118882
=9.247621045
=0.598680072
400 13.128640 12.694972 =12.69497233
=0.010181469
=0.433426199
500 16.410800 16.070247 =16.07024466
=0.010245653
=0.340247655

The table above shows the values or roots obtained using ideal gas law, van der Waals and also
the true roots. During the calculation using the Newton Rhapson method, the values obtained by
ideal gas law are used as the initial guess. Comparing the molal volume obtained from both
equation with the true roots, the values of root obtained using van der Waals are closer to the
true root than the values obtained using ideal gas law.

From the answers gained, there is slight difference of values obtained from ideal gas law
and van der Waals equation. This is due to the properties of the formula that gives the answer a
different value. For this task, a Newton Raphson method is used to determine the roots. The
reason Newton Raphson is chosen is because this method is easily converged. When the initial
guess is nearest to the true value, the roots will easily converge.
8
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

CONCLUSSION

Numerical methods are another approach that provides solution for many engineering problems
as some cases cannot be solved using mathematical methods. There are few numerical methods
and one of it is roots of equation methods which have been used to solve this task. There are two
classes to determine the roots of equation which is bracketing method and open method. The
chosen method for this task is Newton Rhapson which is from open method as it is an efficient
method. To obtain the answers correctly, Microsoft Excel is used to solve this task. Other than
Microsoft Excel, other software such as MATLAB can also be used.

REFERENCES

1. http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Kinetic/waal.html
2. MEC500 NUMERICAL METHOD CHAPTER 2 Roots of Equations Bracketing
Method
3. Steven C. Chapra, Numerical Methods for Engineers, 6th edition,McGraw Hills, 2010.

9
EM/ASSIGNMENT(1)2017 MEC500

APPENDIX

10