Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
-4-
UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON
; LABORATORY/OF RADIATION BIOLOGY
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON 98105
US DOI? ,IRCII!Y1;S
326U.S.ATOMIC ENERGY
Rc,
co!!{
’( ~+;kcii
’1:~:’l
_.._
...-.
--—.—
--- 1
._2--------
1;os
rJ$’y#l#A&’A=&’+&J’%.
I
UWPL-42
..
Idmren R. Donaldson
Director
DOE ARCHIV=3
DOE ARCHIVES
Contents
?!269
Introduction
.
*
B Lrds 25
Plankton 31
soil 32
Water 33
Appendfx 49
POE l@CHIV=
*
Tables (Text)
Tables (Appendix)
DOE ARCHIVl=
I. Radioactivityof fish from Rongelap Atoll,
1954-55 50
Scientificnames of fishes 53
Tables (centtiued)
.
F@urea
FiEure Ifo.
Figures (continued)
?Imre lfo. BE
11 Semi-1og plots of decay curves of gastric mill
of crab, (?rapsusgrapsus, and musole of sea
cuoumber,Eolothurlaatra, collected
woh 26, 1954 at m b= 43
12 ● Log-log plots of Rongelap decay samples of
March 26, 1954: pltiton from u~~j;
muscle and mantle of giant clam, liimopus,
from KabeUe; and soil on whluh decay
correctionfactors were based 44
13. Log-log plots of radioactivedecay rate of
cooonut milk, (Cocos) collectedDecember 8,
1954 at Kabelle, and of liver and muscle of
surgeonfish(Acanthuruselonuatus) oollected \
July 16, 1954 45
DOE ARCHIV~
●
A RADICYLU31CAL
S’I’THYY
OF RUWBLAP ATOLL, MARSNALL
ISLANDS DURINQ 1954-1955
Introductlop
LABAREDJ B
MELLU—
/’
4{
0
(\- RONGELAP
5
ATOLL
- RONGELAP
N
NAUTICAL MILES
POE ARCHIW,
-2-
“3-
uc/kg = dlmlu
(2.2)(10)3
~/ Rongelap,Enlaetok,Labaredj,Kabelle,(3ejen,Lomullal,Lukuen
li
Table II. Coefficientof Variation In Per Cent-
for Values In Thble I
Cooonuts Fish Clams Bird~
Date Milk Meat Ulso. Muscle Liver Musole- ~~~e Muoole Liver
Mantle
3/26/54 42(4)V --(1) --(1) 65(12) 119(12) 36(4) 79(3) 41(5) 38(5)
7/16/54 lo(2) 13(3) 73(20) 65(20) 54(2) 35(5) 75(7) 48(7)
:12/8 Or ~8/54 37(5) 57(5) 23(8) 48(3) 30(3) 27(4) 3764)
~1/26-30/55 61(18) 76(16) 88(16) 68(81) 97181) 115(4) 178(11) 99(13) 95(13)
!%
~ ~/Cin*= (standarddeviation+ mean) (100)
Z ~/ number of samples
4
300
200
100
10
lJCt
KG \
WET
0.1
0.0
DAYS AFTER MARCH I ,1954
DOE ARCHIV~
FIG. 2 RATE OF DECLINE OF RADIOACTIVITY OF RONGELAP FOODS
“9-
●
-11-
Fish
Almost all of the fish spec?lmens,
as in former years, were
colleotedby poisoningwith derris root In shallow waters on or
near the reefs. Some specimenswere oaught In the deeper
waters of the lagoon with hook and Ilne. ‘hO flying fish
vere obtained outside the atoll when they landed aboard ship
during the night.
The species seleeted for analysis are those commonly found
on the atolls and used for food. They includedamselflsh,
groupers, parrot fish, squirrelfish,surgeonfish,goatfish,
wrasse, snappers,mullet and tuna. The scientificrimes of the
species are given in the appendti.
The tissues used for analysis of radioactivitywere skin,
muscle, bone, liver and other viscera. The latter Includedpart
of the stomach contents as well as the alimentaryoanal, In most
●
cases.
In an attempt to compare similar species horn the same
locality,analysis was llmlted to the samples from Kabelle
Island. Collectionsof’fish were made in waters adjacent to
this islmd on -ch 26, 1954$ July 16, 1954~ m Jmuary 29$
1955. The collectingarea lles near the north end of the
island and consists of a ooral-filledchannel open to the sea
at high tide. The radioaotlvityof the tissuesfrom the fish
.
DOE ARCHIVES
colleotedat Kabelle Is summarizedIn Figure 3. The data ape
listed In Table III.
I
5oo-
IOOL
T “.
0..
“-b...
t ..
I ‘..
..
lo.og = ,
+ \
WET
1.0. .
T
0.1 --
JULY 16 JAN.29
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 I
0.05 500
25 50 100
DAYS AFTER MARCH I , 1954 POE ARCHIVES
.“
-14-
500
100
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
-\\
\
\
\
10
‘b
\
~C/KC *
\ ‘CARNIVORE LIVER
WET
LIVER
‘\
\
\
1.0 \
\
\
\
\ BONE
\ BONE
‘\
CARNIVORE MUSCL>\ OMNIVORE MUSCLE
\
\
\
0.1
F’
L
JULY 16 JAN. 29
I
1 1 1 I i I 1 I 1 1 1 1 J
0.05 *
25 50 100 500 1000
DAYS AFTER MARCH I ,1954
DOE ARCHN=
FIG. 4 AVERAGE AMOUNTS OF RADIOACTIVITY IN MtCROCURIES PER KILOGRAM IN
LIVER , BONE AND MUSCLE TISSUE OF CARNIVOROUS AND OMNIVOROUS FISHES
FROM KABELLE ISLAND 1954- 1955
Table ~. RadioactivityIn Fish
Caught at RongelapAtoll, other than Kabclle l@land
Values expressedin mlcrocuriesper kilogram of wet tissue
Date and l!umberof Skin Muscle Bone viscera
Area Spealmens Liver
l/30/55
Between
Rongelap and
RongerikAtolls Flying fish 1 ● 050 .017 .031 ● 094 .052
2/1/55
Between
Rongelap and
AillnginaeAtolls Flying fish 1 .152 .014 .035 .110 ,i45
Omnivores 10 .124 022 .184 1.02 2.07 I
1/25/55 ●
-18-
Invertebrates
Rongelap Invertebratesshowed levels of activity of from
102 to 104 UC/kg Onmroh 26, 1954* W1ate J=WY 1955 t~
●
Iooc
10(
1(
JJC/KG
WET
1000
100
10
JJC/ KG
WET
20 100 400
DAYS AFTER MARCI+ I , 1954
POE ARCHIV~
FIG.
7 RADIOACTIVITY IN GIANT CLAM TISSUES : HIPPOPUS ON MARCH 26,
1SS4 AT KABELLE ; TRIDACNA ON JULY 16, 1954 AT KABELLE , ON JANUARY
28, 1955 AT LABAREDJ ANO ON JANUARY 30, 1955 AT GEJEN
. *
5000
1000
100
jJC/KG
WET
,
10
l)i \
\
I b
*
&
-
-
,, \
JULY 16 JAN.
R.26
0.3
;Y I 1 1 1 1 1 I Q.
20 100 400
OAYS AFTER MARCH I , 1954
DOE ARCHWE5
the highest level found in any edible plant portion on that date,
while the pulp from a second papaya specimenhad an activity
of 1.3 x 10‘7 uc/g (wet). \
I{
$
1000
I 0
100 ~ \
I
~C/KG ~
WET
10:
1
I
I I \
‘\
MARi 26
0.51 r I 1
10 100 1000
DAYS AFTER MARCH 1,1954
POE ARCHIVES
FIG. 9 RATE OF DECLINE OF LAND PLANTS , ALGAE AND SOIL SAMPLES AT
KABELLE 1954 — 1955 ●
.
-25-
\
Birds
Birds were collectedat f’ourislands of the atoll. Speci-
mens from the northern islands of (3ejen,Kabelle and Labaredj
were cons~deredto be from the same area and were oollected on
all four dates, while those from the southern island of Ronge-
lap were taken only on January 26, 1955.
The birds are of two types as based on feedfng habits and
migratory characteristics. These aret (1) the nodcly,crested
and fairy terns, whioh tend to stay in the vicinity of a few
Islands within the atoll and feed principallyon small fish, and
(2) the ?nlgratoryshore birds, which are transientsand feed
ma~y on crustaceansalong the beaches. The latter group in-
oludes the plovers, ourlews, turnstones,ti tattlers.
The terns, because of their llmited tendenoy for migration,
POE ARCHIVES
.
are more representativethan are the shore birds with regard to
chronic uptake of radioactivematerial.
-26-
POE ~CHIV~
● RadiobiologioalStudies . . . ~, ~., p. 6.
. .
Labared~,
Kabelle, and neddy andftiry
Oejen terns 6 .741 .0495 .105 .285 .154 .183 ●0791 ‘-
m EggB
Datead Numb.rof Ug
IBland Speoimenel Shell Yolk mite lhlbryo
7/16/54
~belle 5 ,650 .932 .0255 .335
wa15k
Kabelle 3 .295 .129 .00909
l/29/55
Kabelle 4 .I.40 .020
.
12
o
BIRD TISSUES
0 Mtisck
● Liver
\ 0 Kkhey
*
0.1
\
RELATIVE
RADIOACTIVITY
.0 I \ %:
\
I
.001 I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I 1
March Moy July Sept. NW. Jan. March May July
054 1955
FIG. 10A DECLINE OF RADIOACTIVITY IN MUSCLE , LIVER , ANO KIDNEY SAMPLES FROM
NORTH RONGELAP EXPRESSED AS A RATIO TO THE MARCH 26 , 1SS4 COLLECTION
BIRO
RELATIVE
RADIOACTIVITY-
.01 =
.001 ~
[ I I 1 I 1 I I I I I I I 1 I I I
.0001S
10 100
DAYS AFTER MARCH,I , 1S54 DOE &CHIVES
.
FIG. 10 B oECLINE oF RADIOACTIVITY IN BONE AND ILEUM SAMPLES FROM NORW
RONGELAP EXPRESSED AS A RATlO TO THE MARCH 26, 1954 COLLECTION
-2+
-30-
than the southernbirds. This was not the case except for the
skin. The ratios, south to north, of aotlvity for the different
organs and tissues are as follows:
The presence of more than aix times as much aotivity in the in-
testinal tract of the southern island terns as that found in the
same organ of the northern island terns suggests that the southern
birds have aocess to a supply of food fish oontalninggreater
amounts of radioactivematerial. The higher level of activity in
the southern bird intestinaltracts 1s reflected in the greater
concentrationsof radioactivematerial in the other titernal
organs of the same animals. In view of these observationsit
probabl~ would be advisable to &tafn samples from Allnginae
Atoll, located seven and one-halfnautical mllesmuthwest of
Rongelap Atoll, since the Rongelap natives collect birds at
Alinginae as part of their food supply.
Tern eggs were collectedat Kabelle July 16, December 8,
1954, and January 29, 1955* The levels of radioactivityin the
various parts of the eggs were low, with that of the shellapproxi-
mating the levels found In the bones of terns collected the same
day. Radioactivityin ~he egg yolks varied from Ii to 3 times
that found In the muscles of birds in the same collections. The
whites of the eggs containedthe lovest amounts of radloaotive
Isotopes of all bird samples examined. These kvels were from
DOE ARCHIVES
l/2s to 1/2 those found in bird muscle collected the same day.
-31-
Plankton
.
The Rongelap plankton colleotlonconsisted of a single tow
on March 56, paired tows on July 16, December 8 and December 18,
1954, and four paired tows January 26-3o, 1955. A Michael Sars
type net, ~-meter in diameter and with either No. 6 or Ho. 20
silk mesh was used. Tows were takm at tha surfaae during day-
light hours.
Radioactivityof the Rongelap plankton samples was more
\
than one hundred times greater than that of plankton samples
collected from the open ooean waters of the Western Pacific
with the U9COC ‘Taneynduring OperatfonTroll. On the cruise
of the “Taney” dm~ March and April, 1955, 85 pkdctm
samples were taken along the route from ltwajaleinto the
Philippinesto Japan. The average activity of these samples
was .015 x 10-3 uo/g of wet sample, the highest values being
.050 x 10-3 uc/g. For the eigh~ January 1955 Rongelap plukton
samples the average value was 2.0 x 10-3 uo/g, the lowest value
being 0.41 x 10-3 uc/g.
Other ooncluslonswhioh may be drawn from analysis of the
Rongelap plankton samples are (1) that the radioactivityper
unit weight is greater than for most other biological samples,
(2) the decay rate is similar to that for the soil sample, and
l)OEARCHIVE
. (3) there Is considerablevariation in the radloactIvity of sam-
ples from paired tows.
-32-
Soil
The soil and sand samples includedthose from the islands
proper, from the beaoh, and from the lagoon bottom. The radio-
activity of a sample taken from the top inch of soil on
Labaredj Islti Na.rch26j 19542 was 6s8 microc~fes Per cam)
whloh Is equivalent to one curie per 32s pounds of top soil.
The activity of this sample ten months later, January 29, 1955,
was one thlrtleth its origl.nalvalue~ l.e,~ It had passed
through nearly five half-lives. The decay rate for this period
-1.31
is expressedby the formula, r = t , with Mazwh 1, 1954,
as the date of origin (Figure 12). This rate approximatesthe
mixed fission product decay rate and in general approximates
the decay rate for many of the biological samples. For these
reasons the decay factor for correctingcounts bac?kto the day
of collectionwas based on the decay curve of a similar soil
sample ●
-33”
Water
The water collectionincluded eight salt-watersamples
from the lagoon and eight fresh-watersamples from the Islands
\
proper. A 5-millilitersample was used for the radioactivity
determinationexcept for the December 18th collection (cistern
water, filteredwell water), for which 25-millilitersamples
were used. Becau8e the radioactivityof water samples Is often
stated In terms of the radioactivityper liter, which would
mean extrapolationconsiderablybeyond the observed values, it
IS especially necessary to state the counting error. For these
data the 0.95 counttng error,* vhl~h is equivalent to two
standarddeviations,was arbitrarilyselected. In Appendix
POE ARCHIV~
* AECU-262 (Men P-126) Statlstlcalmethods used in the measure-
ment of radioactivity(some useful graphs) - A. H. Jarrett,
T.I.S., Oak Ridge, December 1949.
,
.34.
minute per kilogram for potassium-40are 560 and for all other
natural-occurringisotopesabout 10.* This means that the con-
tribution of natural-ocourringisotopes to the values in Appen-
dix Table X for lagoon water samplesranged from 0.6 to 1.2
d/m/ml.
Beeause of the relativelygreat counting error of the lagoon
water samples neither the rate of decline nor the decay rate was
estimated. A conservativeapproximationof the radioactivity
of the lagoon water, based upon the average differencebetween
the observed value and the positive 0.95 counting error for
the January 26-30, 1955 samples, is 2400 d/m/l (.0011 uu/1).
For the fresh-watersamples the countingdata are more
reliable (AppendixTable X). The samples include cistern water,
filtered well water, standingwater and ground water. The stand-
ing vater was taken from an open oan on Eniaetok Island and the
ground water from a two-foothole that was dug on Xabelle Island.
The ground water was most radioactive,48,000 d/m/l (.022 uc per
liter) and may have containedradioisotopesthat had leaohed
‘1.35 for the period
from the soil. However, the decay rate r = t
.
from March 23 - July 30, 1955, was similar to for mixed
that
DOE ARCHIVES
o Schubert,J., “RadioactivePoisons,”Scientific American,
~01 193, ~Oo 2, pp. 34°39, August 1955.
●
‘3s’
DOE ARCHIV=
-36-
-37-
trivalent
rare earths 24. 22. 24.
.~OE ARCHIVES
,
,.
Date and
Oroup Tissue Area of Collection
Bir# Carcass 3/26/54 Lab~redj 11.3
II
Skin
Carcass 1? Kab:lle
$::
5.1
2.9
1! II 3*9
Skin 27. 3.5
Squash Frl#t 1/26/55 Ron~elap 2*2 2.1 1.5 1.1 1.4
Papaya ?1 II
1.9 1.0 2.6
Pandanus “ !! 1!
2.3 2.3 2.6 0.70 1.38
Co~onut Meat II
0 0. 0.11 0.38 &
1? Ml+k 0 0.05 0.2JI ?
I! 1! lhi 5 Labaredj :.11 0.38 o 0
1! t! 1/29? 5 Kabelle 0 0
‘1/30?55 Oejen 0:03 0.02 0 0
Coconut Muscle 1/29/55 Kabelle 31, 27.9 597 5.5 1.0
crab
Tuna t! 12/27/ Menu o 0 0.8
!1 0.7
Mullet 1@6 ?55 Rongelap 0 0 2.4 4.4
u
g ~ ~ne3/~6/54 collection processedin December 1954; the January 1955 collectionin
- July 1955. Values as of date of analyses.
~yPr ocessed in July 1955. Values as of date of analyses.
.
-4-
UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON
; LABORATORY/OF RADIATION BIOLOGY
SEATTLE, WASHINGTON 98105
US DOI?,iRCll!Yl;S
326U.S.ATOMIC ENERGY
Rc,
~+;kcii
co!!{’(’1:~:’l_.._
. ..-.--—.—
--- 1
1;os ._2--------
rJ$’y#l#A&’A=&’+&J’%.
:
REPORT NO. UWFL42
I
UWPL-42
..
A RADIOIAX31CAL
STUDY OF ROHOELAP ATOLL, MARSXALL
ZSLAHDS,DURmo 1954-1955
huren R. Donaldson
Director
DOE ARCHIV~
DOE ARCHIVES
Contents
?!269
Introduction
.
*
Birds 25
Plankton 31
soil 32
Water 33
Appendfx 49
POE l@CHIV~
*
Tables (Text)
Tables (Appendix)
DOE ARCHIV~
I. Radioactivityof fish from Rongelap Atoll,
1954-55 50
Scientificnames of fishes 53
Tables (centtiued)
.
F@urea
FiEure Ifo.
Figures (continued)
?Imre lfo. BE
11 Semi-1og plots of decay curves of gastric mill
of crab, (?rapsusgrapsus, and musole of sea
cuoumber,Eolothurlaatra, collected
koh 26, 1954 at = b= 43
12 ● Log-log plots of Rongelap decay samples of
March 26, 1954: plmkton from m~~t;
muscle and mantle of giant clam, liimopus,
from Kabelle; and soil on whluh decay
correctionfactors were based 44
13. Log-log plots of radioactivedecay rate of
cooonut milk, (Cocos) collectedDecember 8,
1954 at Kabelle, and of liver and muscle of
surgeonfish(Acanthuruselonuatus) oollected \
July 16, 1954 45
DOE ARCHIV~
●
A RADICWX31CALS’I’THYY
OF RUWBLAP ATOLL, MARSNALL
ISLANDS DURINQ 1954-1955
Introduction
LABAREDJ B
MELLU—
/’
4{
0
(\- RONGELAP
5
ATOLL
- RONGELAP
N
NAUTICAL MILES
POE ARCHIW,
-2-
“3-
uc/kg = dlmlu
(2.2)(10)3
~/ Rongelap,Enlaetok,Labaredj,Kabelle,(3ejen,Lomullal,Lukuen
li
Table II. Coefficientof Variation In Per Cent-
for Values In Thble I
Cooonuts Fish Clams Bird~
Date Milk Meat Ulso. Muscle Liver Musole- ~~~e Muoole Liver
Mantle
3/26/54 42(4)V --(1) --(1) 65(12) 119(12) 36(4) 79(3) 41(5) 38(5)
7/16/54 lo(2) 13(3) 73(20) 65(20) 54(2) 35(5) 75(7) 48(7)
~12/8 Or ~8/54 37(5) 57(5) 23(8) 48(3) 30(3) 27(4) 3764)
~1/26-30/55 61(18) 76(16) 88(16) 68(81) 97181) 115(4) 178(11) 99(13) 95(13)
!%
~ ~/Cin*= (standarddeviation+ mean) (100)
Z ~/ number of samples
4
300
200
100
10
lJC/ KG \
WET
0.1
0.0
DAYS AFTER MARCH I ,1954
DOE ARCHIV~
FIG. 2 RATE OF DECLINE OF RADIOACTIVITY OF RONGELAP FOODS
“9-
●
-11-
Fish
Almost all of the fish spec?lmens,
as in former years, were
colleotedby poisoningwith derris root In shallow waters on or
near the reefs. Some specimenswere oaught In the deeper
waters of the lagoon with hook and Ilne. ‘hO flying fish
vere obtained outside the atoll when they landed aboard ship
during the night.
The species seleeted for analysis are those commonly found
on the atolls and used for food. They includedamselflsh,
groupers, parrot fish, squirrelfish,surgeonfish,goatfish,
wrasse, snappers,mullet and tuna. The scientificrimes of the
species are given in the appendti.
The tissues used for analysis of radioactivitywere skin,
muscle, bone, liver and other viscera. The latter Includedpart
of the stomach contents as well as the alimentaryoanal, In most
●
cases.
In an attempt to compare similar species horn the same
locality,analysis was llmlted to the samples from Kabelle
Island. Collectionsof’fish were made in waters adjacent to
this islmd on -ch 26, 1954$ July 16, 1954~ m J~uary 29$
1955. The collectingarea lies near the north end of the
island and consists of a ooral-filledchannel open to the sea
at high tide. The radioaotlvityof the tissues from the fish
.
DOE ARCHIVES
colleotedat Kabelle Is summarizedIn Figure 3. The data ape
listed In Table III.
I
5oo-
IOOL
T “.
0..
“-b...
t ..
I ‘..
..
lo.og = ,
+ \
WET
1.0. .
T
0.1 --
JULY 16 JAN.29
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I I 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 I
0.05 500
25 50 100
DAYS AFTER MARCH I , 1954 POE ARCHIVES
.“
-14-
500
100
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
-\\
\
\
\
10
‘b
\
~C/KC *
\ ‘CARNIVORE LIVER
WET
LIVER
‘\
\
\
1.0 \
\
\
\
\ BONE
\ BONE
‘\
CARNIVORE MUSCL>\ OMNIVORE MUSCLE
\
\
\
0.1
F’
L
JULY 16 JAN. 29
I
1 1 1 I i I 1 I 1 1 1 1 J
0.05 *
25 50 100 500 1000
DAYS AFTER MARCH I ,1954
DOE ARCHIV=
FIG. 4 AVERAGE AMOUNTS OF RADIOACTIVITY IN MtCROCURIES PER KILOGRAM IN
LIVER , BONE AND MUSCLE TISSUE OF CARNIVOROUS AND OMNIVOROUS FISHES
FROM KABELLE ISLAND 1954- 1955
Table ~. RadioactivityIn Fish
Caught at RongelapAtoll, other than Kabclle l@land
Values expressedin mlcrocuriesper kilogram of wet tissue
Date and l!umberof Skin Muscle Bone viscera
Area Spealmens Liver
l/30/55
Between
Rongelap and
RongerikAtolls Flying fish 1 ● 050 .017 .031 ● 094 .052
2/1/55
Between
Rongelap and
AillnginaeAtolls Flying fish 1 .152 .014 .035 .110 ,i45
Omnivores 10 .124 022 .184 1.02 2.07 I
1/25/55 ●
-18-
Invertebrate
Rongelap Invertebratesshowed levels of activity of from
102 to 104 UC/kg Onmroh 26, 1954* W1ate J=u=Y 1955 t~
●
Iooc
10(
1(
JJC/KG
WET
1000
100
10
JJC/ KG
WET
20 100 400
DAYS AFTER MARCI+ I , 1954
POE ARCHIV~
FIG.
7 RADIOACTIVITY IN GIANT CLAM TISSUES : HIPPOPUS ON MARCH 26,
1SS4 AT KABELLE ; TRIDACNA ON JULY 16, 1954 AT KABELLE , ON JANUARY
28, 1955 AT LABAREDJ ANO ON JANUARY 30, 1955 AT GEJEN
. *
5000
1000
100
jJC/KG
WET
,
10
l)i \
\
I b
*
&
-
-
,, \
JULY 16 JAN.
R.26
0.3
;Y I 1 1 1 1 1 I Q.
20 100 400
OAYS AFTER MARCH I , 1954
DOE ARCHIV-.
I{
$
1000
I 0
100 ~ \
I
~C/KG ~
WET
10:
1
I
I I \
‘\
MARi 26
0.51 r I 1
10 100 1000
DAYS AFTER MARCH 1,1954
POE ARCHIVES
FIG. 9 RATE OF DECLINE OF LAND PLANTS , ALGAE AND SOIL SAMPLES AT
KABELLE 1954 — 1955 ●
.
-25-
\
Birds
Birds were collectedat f’ourislands of the atoll. Speci-
mens from the northern islands of Gejen, Kabelle and Labaredj
were cons~deredto be from the same area and were oollected on
all four dates, while those from the southern island of Ronge-
lap were taken only on January 26, 1955.
The birds are of two types as based on feedfng habits and
migratory characteristics. These aret (1) the nodcly,crested
and fairy terns, whioh tend to stay in the vicinity of a few
Islands within the atoll and feed principallyon small fish, and
(2) the ?nlgratoryshore birds, which are transientsand feed
ma~y on crustaceansalong the beaches. The latter group in-
oludes the plovers, ourlews, turnstones,ti tattlers.
The terns, because of their llmited tendenoy for migration,
POE ARCHIVES
.
are more representativethan are the shore birds with regard to
chronic uptake of radioactivematerial.
-26-
POE ~CHIV~
● RadiobiologioalStudies . . . ~, ~., p. 6.
. .
Labared~,
Kabelle,and n oddy andftiry
Oejen terns 6 .741 .0495 .105 .285 .154 .183 ●0791 ‘-
BirdEggB
Datead Numberof Ug
IBland Speoimenel Shell Yolk mite lhlbryo
7/16/54
~belle 5 ,650 .932 .0255 .335
wa15k
Kabelle 3 .295 .129 .00909
l/29/55
Kabelle 4 .I.40 .020
.
12
o
BIRD TISSUES
0 Mwck
● Liver
\ 0 Kkhey
*
0.1
\
RELATIVE
RADIOACTIVITY
.0 I \ %:
\
I
.001 I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I 1
March Moy July Sept. NW. Jan. March May July
054 1955
FIG. 10A DECLINE OF RADIOACTIVITY IN MUSCLE , LIVER , ANO KIDNEY SAMPLES FROM
NORTH RONGELAP EXPRESSED AS A RATIO TO THE MARCH 26 , 1SS4 COLLECTION
BIRO
RELATIVE
RADIOACTIVITY-
.01 =
.001 ~
[ I I 1 I 1 I I I I I I I 1 I I I
.0001S
10 100
DAYS AFTER MARCH,I , 1S54 DOE &CHIVES
.
FIG. 10 B oECLINE oF RADIOACTIVITY IN BONE AND ILEUM SAMPLES FROM NORW
RONGELAP EXPRESSED AS A RATlO TO THE MARCH 26, 1954 COLLECTION
-2+
-30-
than the southernbirds. This was not the case except for the
skin. The ratios, south to north, of aotlvity for the different
organs and tissues are as follows:
The presence of more than aix times as much aativity in the in-
testinal tract of the southern island terns as that found in the
same organ of the northern island terns suggests that the southern
birds have aocess to a supply of food fish oontalninggreater
amounts of radioactivematerial. The higher level of activity in
the southern bird intestinaltracts 1s reflected in the greater
concentrationsof radioactivematerial in the other titernal
organs of the same animals. In view of these observationsit
probabl~ would be advisable to &tafn samples from Allnginae
Atoll, located seven and one-halfnautical mllesmuthwest of
Rongelap Atoll, since the Rongelap natives collect birds at
Alinginae as part of their food supply.
Tern eggs were collectedat Kabelle July 16, December 8,
1954, and January 29, 1955* The levels of radioactivityin the
various parts of the eggs were low, with that of the shellapproxi-
mating the levels found In the bones of terns collected the same
day. Radioactivityin ~he egg yolks varied from li to 3 times
that found In the muscles of birds in the same collections. The
whites of the eggs containedthe lovest amounts of radloaotive
Isotopes of all bird samples examined. These kvels fromwere
DOE ARCHIVES
l/25 to 1/2 those found in bird muscle collected the same day.
-31-
Plankton
.
The Rongelap plankton colleotlonconsisted of a single tow
on March 56, paired tows on July 16, December 8 and December 18,
1954, and four paired tows January 26-3o, 1955. A Michael Sars
type net, ~-meter in diameter and with either Ho. 6 or Ho. 20
silk mesh was used. Tows were takm at tha surfaae during day-
light hours.
Radioactivityof the I?ongelapplankton samples was more
\
than one hundred times greater than that of plankton samples
collected from the open ooean waters of the Western Pacific
with the U9COC ‘Taneynduring OperatfonTroll. On the cruise
of the “Taney” dm~ March and April, 1955, 85 platitm
samples were taken along the route from ltwajaleinto the
Philippinesto Japan. The average activity of these samples
was .015 x 10-3 uo/g of wet sample, the highest values being
.050 x 10-3 uc/g. For the eigh~ January 1955 Rongelap plukton
samples the average value was 2.0 x 10-3 uo/g, the lowest value
being 0.41 x 10-3 uc/g.
Other ooncluslonswhioh may be drawn from analysis of the
Rongelap plankton samples are (1) that the radioactivityper
unit weight is greater than for most other biological samples,
(2) the decay rate is similar to that for the soil sample, and
l)OEARCHIVE
. (3) there Is considerablevariation in the radloactIvity of sam-
ples from paired tows.
-32-
Soil
The soil and sand samples includedthose from the islands
proper, from the beaoh, and from the lagoon bottom. The radio-
activity of a sample taken from the top inch of soil on
Labaredj 1s1- Na.rch26j 19542 was 6s8 microc~les per ~am)
whloh Is equivalent to one curie per 325 pounds of top soil.
The activity of this sample ten months later, January 29, 1955,
was one thlrtleth its origl.nalvalue~ l.e,~ It had passed
through nearly five half-lives. The decay rate for this period
-1.31
is expressedby the formula, r = t , with Mroh 1, 1954,
as the date of origin (Figure 12). This rate approximatesthe
mixed fission product decay rate and in general approximates
the decay rate for many of the biological samples. For these
reasons the decay factor for correctingcounts bac?kto the day
of collectionwas based on the decay curve of a similar soil
sample ●
-33”
Water
The water collectionincluded eight salt-watersamples
from the lagoon and eight fresh-watersamples from the Islands
\
proper. A 5-millilitersample was used for the radioactivity
determinationexcept for the December 18th collection (cistern
water, filteredwell water), for which 25-millilitersamples
were used. Becau8e the radioactivityof water samples Is often
stated In terms of the radioactivityper liter, which would
mean extrapolationconsiderablybeyond the observed values, it
IS especially necessary to state the counting error. For these
data the 0.95 counttng error,* vhloh is equivalent to two
standarddeviations,was arbitrarilyselected. In Appendix
POE ARCHIV~
* AECU-262 (Men P-126) Statlstlcalmethods used in the measure-
ment of radioactivity(some useful graphs) - A. H. Jarrett,
T.I.S., Oak Ridge, December 1949.
,
.34.
DOE ARCHIVES
* Schubert,J., ‘RadioactivePoisons,nScientific American,
~01 193, ~Oo 2, pp. 34°39, August 1955.
●
‘3s’
-37-
trivalent
rare earths 24. 22. 24.
.~OE ARCHIVES
,
,.
Date and
Oroup Tissue Area of Collection
Bir# Carcass 3/26/54 Lab~redj 11.3
II
Skin
Carcass 1? Kab~lle
$::
5.1
2.9
1! II 3*9
Skin 27. 3.5
Squash Frl.#t 1/26/55 Ron~elap 2*2 2.1 1.5 1.1 1.4
Papaya ?1 II
1.9 1.0 2.6
Pandanus “ !! 1!
2.3 2.3 2.6 0.70 1.38
Co~onut Meat II
0 0. 0.11 0.38 &
1? Ml+k 0 0.05 0.24 ?
I! 1! lhi 5 Labaredj :.11 0.38 o 0
1! t! 1/29? 5 Kabelle 0 0
‘1/30?55 Oejen 0:03 0.02 0 0
Coconut Muscle 1/29/55 Kabelle 31, 27.8 597 5.5 1.0
crab
Tuna t! 12/27/ Menu o 0 0.8
!1 0.7
Mullet 1@6 ?55 Rongelap 0 0 2.4 4.4
u
~ ~ ~me3/~6/54 collectionprocessedin December 1954; the January 1955 collectionin
- July 1955. Values as of date of analyses.
~yPr ocessed in July 1955. Values as of date of analyses.
‘.
-39-
found in plants, birds, and crabs but not in fish muscle nor h
90 foti ~ ‘he
some of the coconuts. The greatest amount of Sr
-6
January 1955 sampleswas 27 x 10 uc/g wet weight of coconut
crab muscle.
&
.
Method for RadiostrontiumSeparation. The fuming nitric acid
\
●
et al&, “Interchangeof radioactiveiodine with
Qlendenin ——
carrier iodine. In Coryell, C. D. and Sugarman, M.,
@biochemical Studies! The Fission Pmduots, Book 3, p. 1629,
14cGraw-Hill,1951.
.
-41-
.
-. Study of the Rate of PhysloalDecay of Radiation in the
Blologieal9amples
*
Coryell, C. D. and Sugar-, ~., 1 f$tudlea:
~
Fission products,Book 1~ PO 4568
-42-
b
of a linear semi-logrelationship,only one other sample was
more nearly llnear by semi-log than by log-log plot. This was
Ioc
RADIOACTIVITY
10
\\
‘b \
\ Ae
\bo
1 I I # J
50 100 200 300 400 500
DAYS AFTER MARCH I , 1954 POE ARCHIVES
RADIOACTWIT Y
\
.
10
“\
\ \
‘o\ \ b
\
\
\
\ \
.
%
\
o
\
I SPILLED,
\ 1 RESLURRIED
1 ,
11 1 4 I I 1 1 1 1 4
30 600
DAW ?!!TER MARCH I, 1954 bOE ARCHIV~,
FIG. 12 LOG- LOG PLOTS OF RONGELAP DECAY SAMPLES OF MARCH 26, 1954 ‘
PLANKTON FROM LABAREOJ ; MUSCLE AND MANTLE OF GIANT CLAM , ~ ,
FROM KABELLE ; ANO SOIL ON WHICH DECAY CORRECTION FACTORS WERE BASED
RADIOACTIVITY
11 I
1 I
“o
150 200 1
600
DAYS AFTER MARCH 1. IH
DOE AllCHIVE
FIG.
13 LOG- LOG PLOTS OF RADIOACTIVE OECAY RATE OF COCONUT MILK ,
($OCOS) COLLECTED DECEMBER 8 ,
1954 AT KA8ELLE , AND OF LIVER AND
MUSCLE OF SURGEON FISH (ACA
NTHURU~ ~$) COLLECTED JULY 16,1954
“46-
!EableVIII
11 12 10 12 11 1
-1.34 -1.39 -1.40 -1.68 -1.45 -I.28
0.16 0.11 0.11 0.16 0.30 0
Miscellaneous
Other
lCtdney land
of bird Plankton Algae Coconut plants soil
<god >90d
2 2 3 3 3 2 7
-1.25 -1.71 -1.35 -1.20 -0.60 -1.30 -1.31
0.08 0.12 0.05 0.12 0.56 0.01 0.04
DOE ARCHIVE$
n - nmber of relationships
x o mean slope
8 = standarddeviation
s/X = coefficientof variation of slope
Slwly (r - t-‘24). At the other extreme are occasionalsamples
of fish gut, the radioactivityof whloh decays fast (r = t-2.4).
&
DOE ARCH1~
#
●
APPENDIX
DOE ARCH1_
-50-
(~ble I cont.)
Date and common
Island lfame Skin Muscle Bone Liver Viscera
(Table I cent.)
●
POE ARCHIV=
●
-53-
Scientiflc IVamesof Fishes
bl:xmy 1 Istib~enniusedentulus
2 *
butterfly 1 Chaetodon collaris
2 lunula
dagsel 1
2
a 3
w 4
N 5
flatfish Bothus =ncus
——
goa~fish 1 Mulloidichthys aurifla-
2 samoen=ls
gro~per 1 Epi.riephalus
elonRatus
2 fario
u m hexagonatus
u 3 n
4 merra
a 5
n
spilotocerm
u 6. Variola loutl
mullet lVeomyxuschaptalli
pa;rot 1 Scarus purpureus
2 ~ 9p.
Datead A/ Muscle
Organiila Gut Integu- Gill Mantle Gonad IAver Kidney Him .
Islead ment
3/w54
Kabelle eea cucumber 251 227 877
592 3,170 ~ &16
166 8,700 l,M
;% 8,500 537 1,140
5,900 635
112 950 291 510
590 9U 1,080 1,300
l,W 65o
530 ?2 500 3,~
giant dam 350 190
ti
k7 72 w u6 780 7202
1,050 w 98 740 l,wo~ *
spidermail w 3,~ w 13,000 7,500
Omb 182 2,800 1,600 3,000 5,400
hemit crab 260 2,500 1,m l,W 9,400
cooonutcrab 21. 6,300 990 1,300 790
3,7m
eaacucumber u. *U 8A
giantOlam 2.9 62 25 6.5 320
henmitcrab 5.6 112 122 22 65
,
;:: 240 190 99
1.19 90 30 1%!
coernutcrab 2.6 58 g 22 51
4.3 m 36 33
(Table11cent.
)
Dateand Organia2/ Mu801e Gut xnteg- Glll Mantle Gonad Liver
umnt
V26-W155
Rongolap aA8il
ghoticrab ●081 2.o 1.6 1,6
redeyoer8b Jb7 .W .13 1.7 1:?
.79 1.7 .21. 1.6 071
mck O- .25 .4> y .85 .61
.23 ● 55 .79 ●59
hermitorab .76 1.4 5.8 .93 .95
oooonutcrab
:E
Labamlq giantclam .l+9 5.4 1.8 1.6 27 2.4?/
-56-
.
7/16/54 8.4 ;.; 33 ● 9.7
Kabelle 14. . 49. 7.8
1/29/55 .70 .22
Kabelle .50 3.2
3.5
4.1
.44
l/28/55 3.1 .88 1.3 1.9 a.6
Iabaredj 2.1
DOEARCHIW
.
t’ ‘
Island
3/26/54
Labaredj Horlnda 24.8 1,070
.190 .129
arro~oot .117; .061; .135
.018; m?
Pandanus
squash .223; .012 .029
sp~aoh ,033
.040
.
, ,
TableVI. Radioaotivlty
of PlantsOtherThanThoseCOmonly
Eaten fromRongelapAtoll,1954-55
Valuesexpressed
in thousands
of d#g of wet tissue
Fruit evea Steme J&ota
%
Flower A@oal-llud & Mixed Rltire DebarkedBark
3/26/% trw 1 l,g
Idxredjtire.
2 62.7 2,(Y7O 1,63o 41.9
shrub1 800. I.&o 440
herb1 3,260J ::% 1,2.40
3/26/% herb1 874
Ibbdlo herb2
~ws 1
469.~i 153;12,zoo 129J :fi
3,990 336
7/16/54 W 1 1.42 1.71 32e4 72.3
hue $rQo2 10~J 2.04 1s25 7.71 0968 12*3
sbmb 1 1s55J10% 1.48 31A5 ●554 6e36
nhrub2 v
25.3j 19.4y1260 J 4087/ 0365 17e8
-b 1 3053J 3.66 2.35; 2e78
hrb 2 5e92J2*9 $
7025J 1.41
@anu 1 U-l J Md Y ,
12/8/54 tro*1 ●l .943 1.08 -634 0435 .830
&belle. tree2 3*W 1085 .760 2e53
shmb 1 d64; ●325Y .43 496 e172 o164 S6
herb1 2*&l 1025
~rb 2 *887 *944 .917 4*59
herb3 2.#’ 1.71 2.92 .990 ●494 l*60
gmiue1 4.77 14.8313.2
1/29/55 troo1 4973 1.33 2.07
J!hbdh troo2 .338 ●318
mhmb 1 .ln ●336 ●525 .48
herb1 1*48
herb2 .499 1*42
lmrb3 1.74 4020 2*6O
~uJ8 1 10.3 X2.1
.
4-
.’
caverno~a
3/26/54 1,480 5,100 75 1,360
Kabelle 450
7/16/54 43.4; 41.7 8.02; 10.7- 53.4; 15.3
Xabelle 38.4; 48.6 19.5; 10.0 8.~2; ~3.7
61.5; 113. 15.0 7.10; 6.08
11
n
1?
cr~sted tern
11
6/:
●
3.15
1.81
2.39 20.0 150.
11 *2
13.5
8.05
i18
.6
5,52
10.3
5. 3
n It
curlew i.57 .403 1.75 2.26 3*29 21.?
.789 .060 .118 .255 .314 . 91 .14 ~
1.88 .074 .140 .3 1 .508 :p;;
t .12J ,
11
M
fairy te;n .951 .102 .330 i
.47 .698 .132
11 M
.384 .111 .266 .435 .349 .394 .112
●
1/2$/55 ROn~elap fa+,ryte~n 1.21 .591 1.09 2.0’7 2.52 2.98 .995
1.31 .912 3.16 4.11 2.54 2.53 1.10
f! 11 II II
1.16 ;;~: .357 1.58 1.51 1.63 1.21
!1 II
tt II
.556 ;.:: 2.05 .585 ,585 .652
11 M 1!
11
2.19 .623 1.79 1.91 1.46
N !1
turnstone .430 .107 :248 .558 ;::: .800
1! plover . 31 .0 0 .5 2 .157 .437 1.07
l/2~/55 Lab~red$n~,dy tefn i29 o?
.5 ●3i5 .430 .21 .295 .085
:776 ;{~; 1.74 ●932 1.04 .395
.279 .258 .243 .182 .154
6.92 .049 .125 .394 .217 .258 .069
lf3Q/55 @J:n nodclytern .150 .054 .042 .196
fairy tern .851 .108 ●070 .317 .223 .240 .167
h
g- 1/ Noddy tern, Anous stolidus;fairy tern, (lygisalba; curlew, Numenius s .; crested tern,
<— Sterna bergl~mnstone, ArenarlaI.nterpres mfiella; plover, P1Uris+ is domlnica.
-62-
Lab~redj 17,000
13,000
Rongelap 2.34 1.16
DOE ARCHIVES
at high tide line
cistern water
filteredwell water
standing water
ground
tt -
.-
DOE ARCHIVES