Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Why?
Atfirstglance,itmayseemthatanarticleonbrakesisntaterriblysexyidea.Afterall,brakesdontmakeyou
gofaster,lookcoolerorsoundmeaner.But,fewthingsarelessenjoyablethandrivingarigwithlousybrakes.
Notonlycanitbestressfulandneedlesslyhardwork,itcanalsobedangerous.Goodbrakescanactually
improveyouroverallabilitiesbyallowingmuchbettercontroloftherigatalltimes.Finally,withtherecent
dramaticincreaseinthepopularityofracingformsofwheelingcompetition,goodbrakeshavebecomemuch
moreimportant.
What?
So,myaimwiththisarticleistohelpyoubetterunderstandbrakesystemsandthefactorsaffectingbrakeperformancetodispelthemanycommonmythsandmisconceptions,andtoaddressimportantoff
roadfactorsthatyouwontfindcoveredbyanyothersource.
BytheendIhopethatyouwillbeableto:
Understandhowyourbrakeswork,andwhytheyperformthewaytheydo.
Accuratelytroubleshoot/identifycausesofdissatisfactionwithyourbrakes.
Accuratelydescribetheperformance/feelofyourbrakesusingproperterminology.
Decidewhatmodifications/componentswillworkforyoutohelpyouachieveyourobjectives.
Selectappropriatecomponentsandunderstandhowtheyinterrelateandworktogether(andsometimeswhytheyworkagainstoneanother).
Beabletoidentifyandavoidcommonmisconceptionsandbadadvice
AttheendIwillalsoshowcaseakickassbrakesystemmodificationfromwhichvirtuallyanyrigwillbenefit.
Thatsaid,thisarticleisntabeginnersguidetobrakesitisassumedthatyouarealreadyfamiliarwiththebasiccomponents.Itsalsonotaimedatmaintenancehowtoreplacethebrakepadsonthisor
thatmodeltrucktherearemanyfactoryandaftermarketrepairmanualsthatcoverthetopicwell.Also,becausethisarticleisintendedforoffroadrigs,Iwontbecoveringaerodynamicbrakingordown
force.Finally,iffornootherreasonthanIdetestthedamnthings,Iwillnotbecoveringdrumbrakes,butinsteadfocusingondiscbrakesystems.
Actually,thereareanumberofgoodreasonswhydiscbrakesarefarsuperiortodrums,including:
Bettercoolinglesslikelytooverheatandfade
Lesssusceptibletocontaminationfrommudandwater
Lessmaintenance
Mucheasiermaintenance
Lighter
Morepadtorotorcontactarea
Soifyoustillhavedrumbrakesontherearofyourrig,theresplentyofgoodinformationinthisarticleofinteresttoyou,butIwontbecoveringdrumbrakeimprovementsyourefarbetterofftoconvertto
discs,whetheryoufabricateyourownoruseoneofthemanycommerciallyavailableconversionkits.WhatIwillcover,ishowtoadjusttherestofyoursystemtoaccommodatenewlyinstalleddiscsin
placeofdrumsbutnowImgettingaheadofmyself.
TableofContents
BasicBrakeComponents
HowBrakesWork
BrakeTorque
ClampingForce
CoefficientofFriction
ThermalCapacity
ThePedal
BrakeHydraulics
MasterCylinders
Valving
BrakeTubingandHoses
BrakeCallipers
Rotors
Pads
TheBrakingRequirementsofExtremeOffroadRigs
BrakePerformanceandLimits
BrakeFadeandothercomplaintsDesignTroubleshooting
BrakeSystemDesign
MaintenanceTroubleshooting
ReviewVANCOPowerBrakeSupplyHydroboostSystem
BasicBrakeComponents
Eachcomponentinaproperlyfunctioningbrakesystemmustworkinharmonywiththeothercomponentsforustoachievemaximumbrakingperformance.Wewillcovereachcomponentitsselection,
modification,andintegrationintothesystemasawhole.Fornow,thebasiccomponentsofa4wheeldiscbrakesystemare:
1.Apedalmechanismforthedrivertoactuatethebrakes.Alsoactsasaleverthatservestomultiplythedriversinputviathepedalratio.
2.Amastercylinder(MC)&reservoircontainshydraulicbrakefluidtoactuatethebrakecallipersandapistontomoveandpressurizethatfluid.
3.Hydrauliclinestoconveythebrakefluidtothebrakecallipers,andcontainthehydraulicfluid,allowingittobepressurized.
4.ValvesToimproveperformance,abrakesystemmaycontainsomeofthefollowingvalvesbetweentheMCandthecallipers:residualpressurevalve,meteringvalve,combinationvalve,
proportioningvalve,orpressurelimitingvalve.
5.BrakeCalliperslocatedateachwheel,thebrakecallipersarehydraulicallyactuatedclampsthatclampthebrakepadsagainsttherotors.
6.Brakepadslocatedinsidethecallipers,thepadsarethefrictionmaterialthatthecallipersclampagainsttherotors.
7.RotorsBoltedtotheaxlehub,therotorsslowandstoptherotationofthewheelswhenclampedbythecallipers.Theyalsoabsorbtheheatcreatedfromthefrictionofthepadsagainsttherotor.
HowBrakesWork
Itseemsprettysimplethedriverpressesonthepedalandtherigstops.Buttheresquiteabitgoingon,andunderstandingitmorefully(yes,includingalittlephysicsandmath,sorry!)canreallyhelpus
getthemostoutofourbrakesystem.
Hereswhatsgoingon:
Thedriverpressesonthebrakepedal,actuatingthepistoninthemastercylinder(MC).Thepistoninthemastercylinderdisplacesthehydraulicfluidinthebrakelines.Becausethesystemissealed,the
displacement(movement)ofthehydraulicfluidmovesthepiston(s)inthebrakecallipers.Themovingcallipersbringthebrakepadsintocontactwiththerotor.Atthispoint,becausethereisnomore
movementpossibleinthesystem,pressurebeginstobuild,andthepadsarepressedharderandharderagainsttherotor,creatingfriction,andstoppingtherig.
OPTIONALGEEKTECHMAYCONTAINMATHAND/ORPHYSICS
Whydoestherigstop?
ThereasontherigstopsisbecauseoftwoimportantlittlepiecesofphysicsNewtonsFirstLaw,andtheLawofConservationofEnergy.
Wha??
NewtonsFirstLaw,akatheLawofInertia,statesthat:
Anobjectwillremainatrest,orcontinuetomoveataconstantvelocity*,unlessacteduponbyanunbalancedforce.
(*velocityjustmeansthecombinationofspeedanddirection)
Thelawofconservationofenergystatesthat:
Energycanneitherbecreatednordestroyeditcanonlybechangedfromoneformtoanother.
Toseehowtheselawsofphysicsrelatetobrakes,letsexaminethemwithanexampledrivingabuggydowntheroadataconstantvelocity(constantspeedin
astraightline),andthenstopping.
Asweredrivingdowntheroadinastraightlineataconstantspeedthebuggyhasaconstantvelocity.Inordertostopit,wemustcreateanunbalancedforce
thatNewtonsFirstLaw.
Thebuggydrivingdowntheroadalsodevelopsenergyintheformofkineticenergy.(Energyistheabilitytodowork,andkineticenergyistheenergydeveloped
bymovingobjects.)Inorderforthebuggytostop,thiskineticenergymustbeconvertedtoanotherform(itcannotbedestroyed)thatstheLawofConservation
ofEnergy.
Inordertostopthebuggy,then,thebrakesmustapplyanunbalancedforcetothebuggyandconvertthebuggiesKineticenergytosomeotherform
Theunbalancedforcethatstopsthecaristheincreaseinfrictionbetweenthetiresandtheroadthatiscreatedasthebrakesslowtherotationofthewheels.
Whenthebrakesareapplied,thefrictionbetweenthepadsandrotorsalsocreatestremendousheatconvertingthekineticenergyofthebuggytoheat(andin
somecasesalittlenoiseifthetiresorbrakessqueal.)
Insummary,inordertostoparig,thebrakesmusthavethreeproperties.Theymust:
1.beabletoapplyaforcetotherotortodeceleratethewheelsrotationsothatfrictionisincreasedbetweentiresandroadandthevehicleslows/stopsthisabilityisdescribedas
thebrakesystemsBRAKETORQUE.
2.beabletocreateenoughfrictionbetweenthepadandrotorstoconvertthevehicleskineticenergytoheatthisiscalledCLAMPINGFORCEand
3.belargeandheavyenough(therotors)toabsorbthatheatwithoutdamagethisiscalledTHERMALCAPACITY.
BrakeTorque
Braketorqueininlbs(foreachwheel)istheeffectiverotorradiusininchestimesclampingforcetimesthecoefficientoffrictionofthepadagainsttherotor.Braketorqueistheforcethatactuallydecelerates
thewheelandtire.Therearetwocomponentshowhardthepadsclamptherotor(clampingforce)andhowfarthatclampingtakesplacefromthecenterofthewheelhub.Thelargertheeffectiverotor
radius,thefurthertheclampingtakesplacefromthewheelcenter,andthemoretorquegeneratedbythislongerlevereffect.Thisisverysimilartothemannerinwhichalongerhandleonaratchet
generatesmoretorquethanashorthandle(forthesameinput).Toincreasebraketorqueitisnecessarytoincreasethehydraulicpressure,thecalliperpistonarea,thecoefficientoffrictionbetweenpad&
rotor,ortheeffectiverotordiameter.
ClampingForce
Theclampingforcethatacalliperexerts,measuredinpounds,isthehydraulicpressure(inpsi)multipliedbythetotalpistonareaofthecalliper(inafixedcalliper)ortwotimesthetotalpistonarea(ina
floatingcalliper),insquareinches.Toincreasetheclampingforceitisnecessarytoeitherincreasethehydraulicpressureorthecalliperpistonarea.Increasingthecoefficientoffrictionwillnotincrease
clampingforce.
CoefficientofFriction
Thecoefficientoffrictionbetweenpad&rotorisanindicationoftheamountoffrictionbetweenthetwosurfaces.Thehigherthecoefficient,thegreaterthefriction.Typicalpassengercarpadcoefficientsare
intheneighbourhoodof0.3to0.4.Racingpadsareinthe0.5to0.6range.Hardpadshavealowercoefficientbutwearless,softpadshaveahighercoefficientbutcanwearquickly.Withmostpads,
thecoefficientistemperaturesensitivewhichiswhysometimesracersneedtowarmupthebrakesbeforetheyworkwell,andalsowhymostbrakeswillfadewhentheyoverheatthecoefficientof
frictionisreducedasthetemperaturerises.Formoreinfoincoefficientoffriction,seesectiononpads.
ThermalCapacity
Thebrakerotorsmustbecapableofabsorbingtheheatgeneratedbythebrakesastheyconvertthemovingcarskineticenergyintoheat.Theamountofkineticenergyacarhas(and,therefore,the
amountofheattherotorsmustbeabletoabsorb)dependsontheweightofthecarandthesquareofthespeedofthecar.Therotorsabilitytoabsorbthisheatdependsonitsmass(weight),andonhow
wellitcools.Exposedastheyaretocoolingairflow,thisisoneareawherediscsaresuperiortodrums.
OPTIONALGEEKTECHMAYCONTAINMATHAND/ORPHYSICS
Thefollowingequationsandexampleswillhelptoclarifytheconcepts:
BrakeTorque
BrakeTorqueRequirediscalculatedas:
TBr=FrictionForceonTirexRollingRadiusofTire
Where
TBr=BrakeTorqueRequired(in.lbs.)
FrictionForceonTire=VerticalForceonTirexGrip
Grip=coefficientoffrictionbetweenthetireandroad
Thetiresgripisdifficulttomeasure,andcanvaryfrom0.1onweticetoabout1.4foraracingslickonahot,drytrack.Ifyoudonthaveavalueforyourtires,
use1.0asanaveragevalue.
ThecalculationofFrictionForceonTireisdifferentforfrontandreartires,takesintoaccountweighttransfer,andrequiresthecalculationofverticalforceon
bothtiresfirst.
Front:
FF=Ff/2
Where:
FF=FrictionForceonFrontTire
=grip(use1.0)
Ff=VerticalForceonbothfronttires
and
Ff=Wc[1(Xcg/l)+(Ycg/l)]
Where:
Ff=VerticalForceonbothfronttires
Wc=Weightofcar(inlbs)
Xcg=Distancefromfrontaxletocarscenterofgravity(in)
l=wheelbase(in)
=grip(use1.0)
Ycg=heightabovegroundofcarscenterofgravity
Rear:
FR=Fr/2
Where:
FR=FrictionForceonRearTire
=grip(use1.0)
Fr=VerticalForceonbothreartires
And
Fr=WcFf
Where:
Fr=VerticalForceonbothreartires
Wc=Weightofcar(lbs)
Ff=VerticalForceonbothfronttires
Byexaminingtheaboveequationscarefully,wecanlearnsomevaluablethings.Forexample,notethattheequationforBrakeTorqueRequired:
doesnotinvolvevehiclespeedinanyway
willvaryfordifferenttiresandroad(ortrail)conditions
doesinvolvetire/wheelradiusanimportantpointforthoseofusrunninglargediametertires(doyouthinkthecarguys(whoprettymuchdevelopedallthe
brakingcomponentswewillchoosefrom)haveeverdonethecalculationsfora44,47,orgodforbid,a54tire?)
doesinvolvethevehiclesweight,height,andwheelbaseconfirmingwhatweknewfrominstinctthatalower,lightercarwillbeeasiertostop(andagain
importanttoussincewearegenerallymuchtallerandheavierthantheaveragecar)
Great,sowecancalculateatheoreticalvalueforhowmuchbraketorqueoursystemneedstobeabletodeliverbuthowdowedeterminewhatourbrakesare
capableof?
Imgladyouasked.
ClampingForceiscalculatedas:
CF=PMxAT
Where
CF=ClampingForce(lbs)
PM=Maximumhydraulicpressure(psi)
AT=Totaleffectiveareaofcalliperspistons(sq.in.)forfixedcallipersthisistheactualareaofthepistons,forfloatingcallipersthisisequalto2xthe
actualareaofthepistons
BrakeTorqueDevelopediscalculatedas:
TBd=CF(L)Re
Where
TBd=BrakeTorqueDeveloped(inlbs)
CF=ClampingForce(lbs)
L=Coefficientoffrictionbetweenbrakepadsandrotors(use0.3,manufacturersspecs,orestimatederivedfromthepad'sDOTedgecode(seesectionon
pads))
Re=Effectiverotorradius(in.)measuredfromthecenteroftherotortothecanterofthebrakepad.
Re=effectiverotorradius
Ahhanowweregettingtosomemorefamiliartermspressure,pistonsize,sizeofbrakes.Letsjustdigalittledeeper.
Themaximumhydraulicpressuredevelopedinyourbrakingsystemcaneitherbemeasuredwithaninlinepressuregauge,orcanbecalculatedas:
PM=Fp/Ap
Where:
PM=MaximumPressure(psi)
Fp=ForceonMasterCylinderpiston(lbs)
=PedalEffortxPedalRatio(i.e.howhardthedriverpushesthepedalmultipliedbythepedalratio.)
Ap=AreaoftheMCpiston(sq.in.)
=0.785xDp^2(Dp^2=theMCpistondiameter,ininches,squared)
Thisisaveryimportantequation.Notehowthemaximumpressuredeterminesthebraketorque,andthemaximumpressureistheforceappliedDIVIDEDbythe
areaoftheMCpiston.Thismeans,allotherthingsbeingequal,thebiggertheMCpiston,theLESSpressuredeveloped,andtheLESSbraketorquegenerated.
Thetradeoffis,thesmallertheMC,thelessfluidisdisplacedperinchoftravel,andthereforethegreaterthepedaltravelrequiredmoreonthislater.
ThermalCapacity
Aspreviouslydiscussed,thebrakerotorsmustbecapableofabsorbingtheheatgeneratedbythebrakesastheyconvertthemovingcarskineticenergyinto
heat.
TheformulafortheKineticEnergy(K)inthemovingcaris:
K=(W*S^2)/29.9
Where:
K=KineticEnergy(ft.lbs.)
W=Weightofcar(lbs.)
S=Speedofcar(mph)
(Note:TherootequationforkineticenergyisactuallyK=1/2mv^2,theaboveversionhasaconversionfactorincludedsowecanuseweightinsteadofmassand
sotheresultisgiveninforceunitsinsteadofenergyunits)
Nothingreallysurprisinghereweknowfrominstinctandexperiencethathowmuchbrakeyouneeddependsonhowheavythecarisandhowfastitsgoing.
Notethough,thatspeedissquaredintheequationmeaningthatasthespeedincreases,thekineticenergydevelopedgoesupbythesquareofthespeed
increaseforexample,ifspeeddoubles,kineticenergyincreasesbyafactorof4.Ifspeedtripleskineticenergygoesupbyafactorof(3^2)or9!!Thisisa
bitchforracecardriversbutnotsomuchtrailrigs.Howeverifyourebeginningtoraceyourrockcrawlingbuggybeawarethatyourbrakerequirementsare
goingtoincreaseexponentially!
OK,so,movingrighaskineticenergy,kineticenergymustbeturnedintoheat,rotorsmustabsorbsaidheat.Bigdeal,sowhat?
Well,theequationsthatfollowareusedtocalculatethetemperatureincreaseintherotorforagivenkineticenergy.Rememberingthatkineticenergydepends
onweightandspeed,theyalsoexplaininincontrovertibleterms(bigwordmeansyoucantbloodyarguewithmeaboutit!)exactlywhypinionbrakes,flatout
suck,andwhyPatooyeesrotorskeeptryingtomeltoff!RemembertoaddinsulttoinjurypinionbrakesareoftenusedonRockwellaxledrigswhicharebig
andheavy,andweightisamultiplyingfactorintheequationforKineticenergy.
[Asanasidethepreviousdiscussiononbraketorquealsoexplainswhysomefeelthatpinionbrakesworkwellatslowspeed.Itsbecausetherotorisplaced
beforetheaxledifferential,meaningthepinionbrakesbraketorqueiscalculatedasaboveandthenmultipliedbyafactorequaltotheaxleratio.Thismeans,
evenwithsmallcallipersandrotors,theycandeveloptremendousbraketorque.Butrememberwhatwesaidabouttherequirementsofabrakingsystemit
mustalsohavesufficientthermalcapacityandtheysimplydonot.Infact,theyredangerouslyinadequateinthisregard!]
Theformulafortemperatureriseis:
TR=Kc/77.8*Wb
Where:
TR=Temperaturerise(F)
Kc=Kineticenergychange(fromstartofbrakingtoendofbraking)(ft.lbs.)
Wb=weightofallrotors(lbs)
And:
Kc=Kineticenergychange(ft.lbs.)
=KbKa
where:
Kb=kineticenergybeforestop
Ka=Kineticenergyafterstop
Letsdoanexample,becausemathisfun!
ImagineImstoppingmy5000lbbuggyfrom40mphtoadeadstop.
First,letscalculatethechangeinkineticenergyfora5000lbbuggyfrom40mphto0mphthisremainsthesameregardlessofthebrakesystem.
Kb=Wc*S^2/29.9
=5000*(40)^2/29.9
=267559ftlbs
Ka=0
Kc=KbKa
=2675590
=267559
Now,withtontruckdiscbrakesateachwheel,eachrotorweighsabout21lbs,foratotalrotorweightof84lbs.
Inthisconfiguration,thetempriseoftherotorwillbe:
TR=Kc/77.8*Wb
=267559/(77.8*84)
=267559/6535
=41*F
Ifitwereahotday,afterthestopmyrotorscouldbeat141*F
Now,imagineIhavepinionbrakeswith2smallrotors,weight,say,12lbseach.
Now,
TR=Kc/77.8*Wb
=267559/(77.8*24)
=267559/1867
=143*F
Onthesamehotday,therotorsarenowat243*F!!
Makeafewmorestops,withinsufficienttimefortherotorstocoolfullybetweenthem,anditseasytoseehowyoucanseriouslyoverheatthesmall
pinionbrakerotors!
OK,somuchforphysicsandmath.Letsmoveonnowtothemorepracticalsideofhowthebrakingsystemworks.
Recallthatbrakesneedtobeabletodo3things:
1.Developenoughclampingforcetocreateenoughfrictionbetweenpadandrotortoconvertvehicleskineticenergytoheat.
2.Developenoughbraketorquetoreachthelimitoftraction(lockupthetires)inallconditions,and
3.Haveenoughmasstoabsorbtheconversionoftherigskineticenergytoheatwithoutboilingthefluid,warpingtherotors,cookingseals,etc.
Andtheymustdoallthreewithgoodandconsistentfeel!
Thefollowingflowchartpresentsastylizedsummaryofthebrakesystemanditsinterrelatedcomponents/factors.Followingit,wewillexamineeachcomponentinmoredetail:
ThePedal
Aswehavediscussed,inordertoapplythebrakesthedrivermustbeabletobothmoveandpressurizethehydraulicfluid.Thatis,themastercylinderpistonhasthejobofmovingthebrakefluidthrough
thelinesinordertobringthebrakepadsintocontactwiththerotor,andofpressurizingthatfluidcreateclampingforce.
Thejobofthepedalistoallowthedrivertoactuatethebrakes,andalsotomultiplythedriversinputthroughalevereffectcalledthepedalratio.Inotherwords,thepedaltransfersmovement&forcefrom
thedriversfoottothemastercylinderpiston.Thisisakeyconceptthatbrakesrequirebothmovementandforcetooperate,asthetwoarelargelyinverselyproportional(thatis:asonegoesupthe
othergoesdown,andviceversa)wewillreturntothisconceptmanytimessokeepitinmind.
Theforcethedriverappliestothepedalwhenbrakingiscalledthepedaleffort.Thisamountofforce,measuredinpounds,isusuallyinsufficienttooperatethebrakesvaluesrangingfrom50100lbsare
common.Assuch,pedalsaredesignedtooperatelikealever,multiplyingthisforcebeforeitisappliedtothemastercylinderpiston.Theamountbywhichanyparticularpedaldesigndoessoiscalledthe
pedalratio.
Thepedalratioiscalculatedasthedistancebetweenthepedalspivotpointandthecentreofthefootpad,dividedbythedistancebetweenthepivotpointandthemastercylinderpushrod,asshowninthe
followingdiagrams.
PedalRatio=A/B
Ascanbeseenfromthediagramthelongerthepedal,thehigherthepedalratio,andthegreaterthemechanicaladvantagemeaningthelowerthepedaleffortrequired.
However,therearetradeoffs.First,longerpedalsarehardertofitespeciallyincrampedbuggycockpits.Also,thelongerthepedal,thegreaterthepedalstrokerequiredtomovethemastercylinder
pistoni.e.thefurtherthedrivermustpressthepedal.Thebestdesignisatradeoffthatwilldependonmanyfactorsincludingdesiredpedaleffort,mastercylinderandcalliperpistondiameters,andthe
roomavailable.Asfaraspedaleffortisconcerned,75lbsiscommonforhighperformanceracecarbrakes,100lbsfeelshard,and50lbsiscommoninpowerassistedbrakes.Commonpedalratiosrange
from3or4:1forpowerbrakesupto6or7:1formanualbrakes.
Ofcourse,ifyouareusingastockpedal,youareprettymuchstuckwiththeratioithas,andmustdesigntherestofthesystemtoaccommodate.
Justrememberthelongerthepedal,thegreatertheratio,thelesslegforcerequiredbutthegreaterthepedaltravelrequired.Longerpedalstendtodeflectmoreunderharduse,whichcanleadtoa
spongyfeelingtothebrakes.Youshouldalwaysstrivetouseapedalthatwillgofromfullyretractedtofullyappliedinasshortadistanceaspossibleusuallylessthanaboutfourinches.Anymorethan
this,andtherewillnotbesufficienttravelinthedriverslegtofullyapplythebrakesunderemergencyconditionswheretravelissuddenlyincreasedsuchasduringbrakefadeorwhenthereisairinthe
fluid.
Keepinmindthattotalbrakepedaltravelincludesnotonlythestrokeofthemastercylinderpiston,butalsoincludesallslopanddeflectionofallpartsinthesystem.
Designingandfabricatingagoodpedalsetuprequiresengineeringfarbeyondthescopeofthisarticleespeciallysincethebrakesaresuchacriticalsafetysystemontherig.
Myadviceistoeitherincorporatearuggedstockpedalsystem,oruseoneoftheprefabsystemsavailable(inavarietyofratios)frommanyaftermarketvendors.Choosearatiothatwillworkwiththerest
ofyoursystemandyourpersonalpreferenceforhowthebrakeswillfeel.Commonratiosare3:1forpowerbrakesand5:1formanualbrakesbut,youmaydesireamorecustomratiolike7:1for
manualbrakesifusingalargediametermastercylinder.
Onefinalwordonpedaleffort:
Youcandesignabrakesystemforanyvalueofpedaleffort(valuesrangingfrom50100lbsarecommon),andthepedaleffortwilllargelydeterminehowthebrakesfeeltothedriver(exceptingproblems
likebrakefadeandfluidboil).Forthisreason,inthefollowingdiscussion,assume,unlessstatedotherwise,thatwearediscussingthebrakesystemwithaconsistentandacceptablepedaleffort.For
example,ifwesay,changingtoalargerboremastercylinder(allotherthingsremainingthesame)willdecreasepedaltravelbutreducebrakingpower,wemeanwiththesamepedaleffort.Nomatter
whatthesystem,ormod'swemaketoit,wealwayshavetheoptionofjustincreasingpedaleffort,butthisisrarelyexperiencedbythedriverasanacceptablesolution.i.e.onecoulddesignasystemwith
undersizecallipersandanoversizeMCthatcouldstillstoptherigeffectivelyifonlywewouldpushonthepedalwith300lbsbutclearlythiswouldnotbesuitable.
BrakeHydraulics
OK,nowweregettingtothegoodstuff.
Recallthatthebrakeshydraulicsystemmustsupplymovementandforce.Themovementmustbeenoughtotakeupallslop,clearance,anddeflectionofpartsaswellasmovethecalliperpistons
sufficientlytobringbrakepadsintofirmcontactwiththerotors.Theforcemustbeenoughtocreateenoughfrictionbetweenpadandrotortostopthecar.
Itisthepistonofthemastercylinderthatprovidesboththemovementandtheforce,andthebrakefluidthattransmitsbothtothecallipers.
Keepinmind,asyoureadthissection,thatthegoalistohaveasystemthatprovidesmaximumforcewithsmallmovementi.e.wewanttobeabletobrakehardwithoutexcessivepedaltravel.
ForceappliedtotheMCpistoncreatespressureinthebrakefluid.Thepressureistheforceapplied,DIVIDEDbytheareaofthepiston.Therefore,thesmallerthemastercylinderpiston,thegreaterthe
pressurecreated.
SystemPressure=Fp/Ap
Where:
Fp=Forceonthepiston(lbs.)
Ap=Areaofthepiston(sq.in.)
Example:CalculatesystempressureforbothadiameterMCanda1diameterMC,givenaninputof100lbs.
CaseoneMCpiston(d=0.5):
P=Fp/Ap
=100/pi*(d/2)^2
=100/3.14*(0.5/2)^2
=510psi
Case21MCpiston(d=1.0):
P=Fp/Ap
=100/pi*(d/2)^2
=100/3.14*(1.0/2)^2
=127psi
Recallingthatthepressurecreatedisadirectfactorinhowmuchclampingforceandthereforebraketorqueisdeveloped,itmayseemthatforthemostpowerfulbrakes,wewouldwanttouseasmallMC
piston.
But,thetradeoffistheothercomponentrequiredofthebrakesystemnamelymovement.Becausethefluidisincompressible,anymovementintheMCpistontranslatesintomovementofthecalliper
pistons(excludingexpansionofhosesandlines,whichshouldbeminimalinaproperlyworkingsystem).Thismovementinahydraulicsystemisknownasdisplacementandiscalculatedastheareaof
theMCpistonmultipliedbyitsstroke.Displacementisavolume,measuredincubicinches.Therefore,thesmallerthemastercylinderpiston,thelessdisplacementcreated.
Displacement(cubicinches)=Ap*Sp
Where:
Ap=Areaofthepiston(sq.in.)
Sp=Distancepistonmoves(stroke)(in.)
Example:CalculatedisplacementforbothadiameterMCanda1diameterMC,bothwithastrokeof2inches.
Case1MCpiston(d=0.5):
Displacement=Ap*Sp
=2*[pi*(d/2)^2]
=2*[3.14*(0.5/2)^2]
=0.39cu.in.
Case21MCpiston(d=1.0):
Displacement=Ap*Sp
=2*[pi*(d/2)^2]
=2*[3.14*(1.0/2)^2]
=1.57cu.in.
NowwecanclearlyseethatthereisatradeoffbetweenforceandmovementinselectingaMCpistonsize.Thesmallerthepiston,thegreaterthepressurecreatedbutthelessdisplacementproduced
(andthereforegreaterpedaltravelrequired.)
Sofar,wehaveconsideredonlytheeffectofthesizeoftheMCpiston,butofcourseinabrakesystemtherearetwopistonstheMCpistonandthecalliperpiston(forcalculations,thetotalareaofall
pistonsinamultipistoncalliperactthesameasasinglepistonofequivalentareainasinglepistoncalliper.)
Thereis,ofcourse,arelationshipbetweenthepistonsinthesystemthataffectsbothforceandmovement.
Becausethebrakehydraulicsystemisaclosed,sealedsystem,andbrakefluidcannotbecompressed,thereisalawofhydraulicsthatwemakeuseoftomultiplyforcethatis,toapplymoreforceatthe
callipersthanthedriverappliestotheMCpiston.Itisquitesimple,andquitepossiblythemostimportantconceptinthisentirearticle.Itisthis:
Inaclosedhydraulicsystem,pressureisequaloverallsurfacesofthecontainingsystem.
InourdiscussionofbrakesystemswewillrefertotheMCpistonastheinputpistonandthecalliperpistonastheoutputpiston.
Theabovelawmeansthatwhateverpressureiscreatedbytheinputpistonisappliedequallytotheoutputpiston.Becausetheoutput(calliper)pistonisofmuchlargerareathantheinput(MC)piston,this
hastheeffectofmultiplyingforceinthebrakesystem.
TheamountofforcemultiplicationthusachievedisknownasthebrakesHydraulicRatioHydraulicRatiocanbecalculatedorexpressedanumberofways.Itistheratiooffluiddisplacementbythe
mastercylindertofluiddisplacedinthecalliperpistons.ItisalsoequaltotheratioofforceappliedtotheMCpistontotheforcegeneratedbythecalliperpistons.Hydraulicratioisanimportantfactorinthe
pedaleffortequation,thehighertheratio,thelesspedaleffortisrequired(andthelongerthepedaltraveltoachieveagivenclampingforce).Thestifferthecalliperandthestifferthepad,thehigherthe
hydraulicratiothatcanbeemployed.
Forexample,supposeweapply100lbsofforcetoadiameterMCpiston,wedevelopapprox.500psi.This500psiactsevenlyonallothersurfacesinthesystem,includingthecalliperpistons.Suppose
thecalliperpistonhasadiameterof3inches.Multiplyingour500psibytheareaofthecalliperpiston(~7sq.in),wedevelopnearly3500poundsofclampingforceatthebrakepads.
Theequationforthisforcemultiplyingrelationshipis:
Fc=[Fmc*Ac]/Amc
Where:
Fc=Forceatcalliperpiston(output)(lbs)
Fmc=Forceonmastercylinderpiston(input)(lbs)
Ac=Areaofcalliperpiston(sq.in.)
Amc=Areaofmastercylinderpiston(sq.in.)
Brilliant!Fromtheequationwecanseethat,foragiveninputforce(pedaleffort),inordertoincreasetheforceatthecalliper(whatwereafter)wecaneitherincreasetheareaofthecalliperpiston(s)or
decreasetheareaofthemastercylinderpiston(orboth).
Ofcourse,nothingiseveraseasyasthat!Wecantforgettheotherfactormovement.Ofcourse,thereisonceagain,atradeoff.
Unfortunately,bothactionsthatincreaseforce(good!)alsoincreasepedaltravel(bad!).Thatis,ifwedecreasethesizeoftheMCpistonwedecreaseitsdisplacementrequiringustoincreaseitsstroketo
compensateincreasingpedaltravelrequired.Similarly,asweincreasethesizeofthecalliperpiston,weincreasetheclampingforce,butwealsoincreasethevolumeoffluid(thedisplacement)required
tomovethepistonagivendistancethedistanceitmustmovetobringthepadsintocontactwiththerotorthisalsodemandsanincreaseinpedaltravel.
Theequationforrelatingpistonmovementsis:
Mc=[Mmc*Amc]/Ac
Where:
Mc=Movementatcalliperpiston(in.)
Mmc=MovementofMCpiston(in.)
Amc=AreaofMCpiston(sq.in.)
Ac=Areaofcalliperpiston(sq.in.)
So,wecanseethat,inordertoincreasethemovementofthecalliperpistonwithoutaffectingpedaltravel(Mmc),wewouldhavetoeitherincreasethesizeoftheMCpiston,ordecreasethesizeofthe
calliperpistonbothactionsthatwilldecreaseforce!
Asimpleexamplewithwhichweareallintimatelyfamiliar,thatillustratestheconceptsofforceandmovementina2pistonhydraulicsystem,isthatof
thecommonfloorjack.
Considerthejackshandlepistonastheinputpiston(liketheMCpiston)andthepistonthatraisestheliftingsaddleastheoutputpiston(likethecalliper
piston).Lookattheirrelativesizesthehandlepistonistinycomparedtotheoutputpistonthatshowyoucanlifta5000lbcarbyapplyingonly50lbs
tothejackhandle(multiplied,ofcourse,bythelengthofthehandlejustlikepedalratioinabrakesystem.)Thetradeoff,ofcourse,ismovementyou
havetopumpthathandlealotoftimes(muchinputpistonmovement)toraisethecarevenjustalittle(outputpistonmovement).Justasinbrakes,
movementandforceareatradeoff.Toproducegreatforcewithoutgreatinput,youhavetotradetravel.
Itsmyconsideredopinionthatthisinterrelationshipbetweenforceandmovementsina2pistonhydraulicsystemsuchasbrakesisnotverywellunderstood.Considerasevidencethefollowingscenario
aguyswapsreardiscbrakesinplaceofdrumsontherearaxleofhisrig.Theresultingbrakeperformanceispredictablyinadequateobviouslythecalliperpistonsaremuchlargerthanthepreviousdrum
brakewheelcylinderpistonsmeaningthatmorefluidmustbedisplacedtoactuatethem.Thecommonadvicefoundistoswapinalargermastercylinder.Thatsgreatfromamovementperspective
thelargerMCpistonwilldisplacegraterfluid,movingthecalliperpistonsfurtherforagivenamountofpedaltravel.BUTwenowknowthattheresultwillALSObeadecreaseinforceatthecalliper
pistons(includingthefrontcallipers)thanwasachievedwiththesmallerMC.
So,whatarewetodo?Wereallyhaveonlytwooptionseithercarefulcompromiseorpowerassist.Thebeautyofpowerassististhatitallowsustosubstantiallyincreaseinputforcewhilemaintaining
pedaleffort.This,inturn,enablestheproductionofadequateforceatthecalliperswhileallowingtheuseoflargerMCpistonsandsmallercalliperpistons,decreasingpedaltravel.Thisisparticularly
importantwhenyouconsiderthatmostoften,asingleMCpistonmustactuatetwocallipers,(usuallyoneforeachofthefrontorrearwheels).ThatsingleMCpistonmustdisplaceenoughfluidtomovetwo
ormorelargediameterpistonsinthecallipers.Makingitlargeenoughtodosowithoutrequiringwaytoomuchpedaltravelmeanswecompromisetheforcemultiplicationinthehydraulicsystem.The
resultis,weeitheracceptsuboptimalforce(andresultingbraketorque),orwemustmakeupforthelackofhydraulicforcemultiplicationbyincreasinginputforce.Andtheonlywaytosignificantlyincrease
inputforcewithoutrequiringmuchgreaterpedaleffortistoincreasepedalratiooraddpowerassist.Giventhatcockpitspaceavailabilityplaceaveryrealupperlimitonhowmuchpedalratiowecan
practicallyachievetheanswerbecomespowerassist.
MasterCylinders
Themastercylinderistheheartofthebrakesystem.Actuatedbythepedal,itspistonprovidestheforceandthemovementrequiredtoapplythebrakes.Whenthepedalisreleased,aninternalreturn
springreturnsthepistontoitsrestingposition.
Initially,asthepedalispushed,thepistonmovesforwardandfluidvolumeisdisplaced,takingupallclearancesinthesystem.Thisfluidmovementactuatesthecalliperpistonswhichextendandbring
thebrakepadsintocontactwiththerotors.Becausethefluidisincompressible,oncethepadsareincontactwiththerotor,fluidmovementstopsandpressurerises.Theharderthepedalispushed,the
greaterthepressureachieved,themorebraketorqueisdeveloped.Howhardthedrivercanpushthepedal,andthereforehowmuchbrakingisachieved,isafunctionofinputforce(legstrength),
combinedwithpedalratioandanypowerassist.
Thecriticalspecsofamastercylinderareitsbore(diameterofthepiston)andstroke(howfarthepistoncantravelandthereforehowmuchfluiditcandisplacewhenapplied).Commonvaluesforbore
rangefrom5/8to11/2,andstrokefrom1to1.5.Matchingbothtotherequirementsofyoursystemisthekeytosatisfactoryperformance.Rememberthat,foragiveninput(pedaleffort)thesmallerthe
bore,themorepressureisgeneratedbutthelessfluiddisplaced.Similarly,thelongerthestrokethemorefluidisdisplaced,butthegreaterthepedaltravelrequired.Aswithmostthings,thebestresultis
achievedthroughcarefullyconsideredcompromise.
ThemostcommontypeofMCinusetodayisknownasadualtandemmastercylinder.Ithasseparatecircuits(pistons
andoutlets)forfrontandrearbrakes(dual),witheachcircuithavingitsownindependentreservoir.Thereasonforthisis
safetythetheoryis:ifonecircuit(frontorrearbrakes)shouldfail,thereremainstheotherseparate,independentcircuit.
Thetwopistonsarearrangedinlineinasinglebore(tandem).Thepistonclosesttothepedalistheprimarypiston,and
theotheristhesecondarypiston.Normally,theprimarypistonoperatesthefontbrakesandthesecondarypistontherear.
Fluidreservoirsmaybeintegratedorremote(attachedtothecylinderviahoses).Themostcommondesignhasthe
reservoirattacheddirectlytothecylinder.
Often,mastercylindersarelistedasbeingeitherfordisc/drumbrakesorfordisc/discbrakes(Imignoringolderdrum/drumsystems).Obviouslyadisc/discMCisdesignedtobeusedwith4wheel
discbrakes,andobviouslyadisc/drumMCwithdisc/drumbrakes.Assumingthatnobodyintheirrightmindwouldconvertdiscbrakestodrums,thatmeanstheonlyremainingissueofconcernwouldbe
usingadisc/drumMCwithdisc/discbrakes.Whenchoosingamastercylinder,traditionally,youmayhavebeentoldthattherearethreedifferencesbetweendisc/discanddisc/drummastersthatpreclude
theuseofadisc/drummasterwithdisc/discbrakes.Theyare:
1.Reservoirsize
2.Pistonsize(boreandstroke)
3.Builtinvalving.
Heresmytakeonthesethreeissues:
ReservoirSize
Discbrakereservoirsarelargerthanthosefordrumbrakes.Youwilloftenseetworeasonsgivenforthis:
1.First,becausethepistonsinadiscbrakecalliperareMUCHlargerthanthetinypistonsinadrumbrakewheelcylinder,discbrakesrequiremorefluidvolumetobedisplacedthandrumbrakes
requiringalargerreserveoffluidforoperation.
2.Secondly,asdiscbrakepadswear,discbrakecallipersareselfadjusting.Thatis,thecallipersonlyretractthepistonjustenoughtopreventpadtorotorcontact.Now,imagineyoustartwith
discbrakepadswiththickliningsandyouhavea4diametercalliperpiston.Everytimeyouapplythebrakesandthepadswearalittlebit,thecalliperretractsjustatinybitless.Bythetimethe
padswearto25%,or1/8thick,thepistonatrestwillbe.75furtheroutinitsstrokethanitwaswhenthepadswerenew.That.75behindthepistonmustbetakenupbyadditionalfluidandinthe
caseofa4diameterpiston,theadditionalvolumerequiredisgivenby(pi[d/2]^2*0.75)orabout8cubicinches.Multipliedbytwocallipers(oneforeachwheel)andthats16cubicinchesofextra
fluidreserverequiredtocompensateforpadwear.Thatsmuchhigherthantheamountrequiredtocompensatefordrumbrakeshoewear.Therefore,discbrakereservoirsarelargerthanfordrums
becauseOEMdesignersmustdesignareservoirfordiscbrakeslargeenoughthatthebrakeswillstillfunctionevenifJoePublicdoesntcheckthefluidoraddadropbetweennewpadsand
completelywornoutpads.
Itismyopinionthatthesecondreasonistheonlyrealpracticalreasonforthedifferenceinsizebetweendiscanddrumreservoirs.IsaythisbecauseIhaveneverseenadrumMCreservoirthatwasso
smallitdidntcontainenoughfluidtoactuallyapplydiscbrakeseventhoughdiscsrequiremorevolumethandrums.
Withthisinmind,wecanseethat,ifweroutinelycheckbrakefluidlevelsaspadswear,reservoirsizealoneshouldnotdisqualifyusfromusingadisc/drumMCwithdisc/discbrakesespeciallyifwere
usingalargeMCwithmoderateorsmallcallipers(e.g.1tonMCwithtoncallipers).
PistonSize
Itistruethatdiscbrakesrequirebothmorepressureandmoremovement(volume)tooperatethandrumbrakes.However,afterreadingthisarticle,withyournewencyclopedicknowledgeofpressureand
volume,youregoingtobeselectingaMCforyourbrakesbasedonitsspecsnotonwhatthecounterguysaystheOEapplicationwas.Thatistosaygiventherightboreandstroketomatchyour
system,theresnoparticularreasonthat,basedsolelyonpistonboreandstroke,anMCoriginallydesignedfordisc/drumscantbeusedsuccessfullyonadisc/discsetup.Thatsaid,youwillbynowalso
understandthatleavinginyourolddisc/drumMCafterconvertingthereartodiscswillnotworkwell.
BuiltinValving
Thisonecanbeadealkiller.IftheMCinquestionwasdesignedfordisc/drumsandhasabuiltinresidualpressurevalve,itwillnotbesuitablefordisc/discbrakes.Seesectionbelowonvalvingfor
descriptionofresidualpressurevalves.Fornow,thepointis,knowtheMCinquestionandwhetherornotithasbuiltinvalving(manydonot).Ifitdoes,youwouldhavetoeithermodifyitbyremovingthe
residualpressurevalvetomakeissuitableforusewithdiscbrakes,orchooseadifferentmastercylinder.
PowerorManual?
Again,youmayseemastercylindersmarketedasbeingformanualorpowerbrakes.Thisisbasedontwopotentialdifferences:
1.Pistonsize(bore)
2.Depthofpistonhole
CaseonemaybetrueifallyouaredoingisswappingMCs.Normally,manualbrakesusea1boreorlessMCandpowerbrakes1andup.Leavingeverythingelsethesame,andusingapowerMC
(largebore)withmanualbrakeswillnormallyresultinahardpedalthatis,thepedaleffortrequiredofthedriver,withoutpowerassist,becomestoogreat.However,wealreadyknowthatwecan
compensatebyusingagreaterpedalratioorlargerpistoncallipers.Therefore,whenoverallsystemdesignisconsidered,andifMCspecsareselectedcarefullytomatchthepedalratioandcalliperpiston
size,thereisnotechnicalreasonthatalargerpowerMCcouldntbeusedwithmanualbrakes.
Casetwoismoreofanissue.Thepistonholeisthearewheretheactuatingrod(fromthepedalorbooster)contactstheMCpiston.NormallyitwillbeashallowholeforapowerbrakeMCasthepower
boosterrodiscaptivebetweentheboosterandtheMC.Withmanualbrakes,theactuatingrodisattachedtothepedalwhichisobviouslyalever.InthiscasetheMCpistonholeisnormallydeeperto
preventtheactuatingrodfromfallingoutwhenthebrakesarereleasedaveryusefulfeature!However,ifyoumustuseashallowpistonholeMCwithmanualbrakesitmaybepossibletoovercomethe
problembyappropriatelylimitingpedaltravel(inthedirectionoppositetobrakeapplication)topreventactuatingrodfallout.
Summary
Therearenormallydifferencesbetweendiscanddrummastercylindersandbetweenpowerandmanualmastercylinders,asfollows:
1.DiscbrakeMCsnormallyhavealongerstrokeandlargerreservoirthanthosefordrums
2.DrumbrakeMCsmayhavebuiltinresidualpressurevalves
3.PowerbrakeMCsnormallyhavealargerboreandshallowerpistonholethanthoseformanualbrakes.
Normally,theeasiestrouteistouseanMCdesignedforthetypeofbrakesyouhave.However,whentotalsystemdesignisconsidered,aslongasthespecificspecsanddesignoftheMCinquestionare
wellunderstood,amuchgreaterrangeofinterchangepossibilitiesopensup.Thatsaid,thereareafewtimehonouredrulesofthumb:
Usea1"orsmallerboreMCformanualbrakes
Use1"orlargerboreMCforpowerbrakes
Manualbrakeswith1"MCuseapedalratioofapprox.6:1
Powerbrakeswitha11/8"MCuseapedalratioofapprox4:1
Discbrakesrequireaminimumpressureof8001000psi
Drumbrakesrequireaminimumpressureof400500psi
EffectsofPedalRatioandBoreSizeonHydraulicPressureOutput
Assumingapedalratioof5:1Notethatgoingfroma1"to7/8"MCboreincreasesthepressuretothecallipersbyalmost50%!!!
Valving
ResidualPressureValve
Aresidualpressurevalveisasimple,oneway,springloadedvalveinstalledeitherinthemastercylinder,orinlinebetweentheMCandthecallipers/wheelcylinders.Theyoperatebykeepingapre
determinedamountofpressureinthebrakelines,evenwiththebrakesreleased.Theinternalspringdeterminestheamountofresidualpressurekeptinthebrakelinesnormally2PSIor10PSI.There
aretwodistinctusesofresidualpressurevalves:
10PSI:Drumbrakesonly.Becausedrumbrakesdontusecallipersandarethereforenotselfadjustingtherearespringsinstalledtoretractthebrakeshoesawayfromthedrum.A10PSIresidual
pressurevalveisusedindrumbrakestokeepalittlepressureinthelinestobalancethereturnspringforcesothattheshoesaremaintainedincloseproximitytothedrums.Withouttheresidualpressure
valve,thereturnspringswouldretracttheshoessofarfromthedrumsthatexcessivepedaltravelwouldberequiredbeforethebrakesareapplied.
2PSI:Discbrakesonly.Inmanyracecarsandhotrods,themastercylinderisinstalledatalevelbelowthatofthecallipers.Assuch,gravitywilldrawthefluidfromthecallipers,causingittodrainback
intotheMC.Theresultisaspongyfeelingpedalandexcessivepedaltravel.A2PSIresidualpressurevalveisinstalledinthebrakelinebetweenMCandcallipertomaintainslightpressureintheline
andpreventfluiddrainback.Note:ThisvalveshouldonlybeneedediftheMCislowerthanthecallipers.
Ihaveoftenreadwherepeoplehaveadvisedtheuseofaresidualpressurevalvetocuresomeotherproblemspongypedalorexcessivepedaltravel(usuallycausedbyinsufficientvolumefromatoo
smallMC).Incaseslikethis,itmayfeelasiftheRPVhascuredtheproblem,butitisonlyabandaid,maskingtherealproblem.UseanRPVonlyfordrumbrakesorMClowerthancallipers.Donotuse
anRPVasabandaid.Findandfixtherealproblem!
Whenconvertingfromdrumstodiscs,youwillneedtoremoveanyRPVintherearcircuit.
MeteringValve
Becauseofthereturnspringspresent,drumbrakestakemoremovement(pressureandvolume)toinitiallyapplythandiscbrakeswhoseselfadjustingcalliperskeepthepadsalmostorlightlytouchingthe
rotors.Assuch,indisc/drumbrakes,ameteringvalveisusedtopreventapplicationofthefrontdiscbrakesbelowapresetpressureinthehydraulicsystemusuallyabout75150psitoallowtherear
drumbrakestocatchup.Thisallowsthefrontandrearbrakesinadisc/drumsetuptoworkmoreevenly.Ameteringvalveisalsoknownasaholdoffvalve.
Whenconvertingfromdrumstodiscs,youwillneedtoremoveanymeteringvalveinthecircuit.
ProportioningValve
Asacarbrakes,weightistransferredfromthereartothefront(ahhNewtonandhisLawofInertiaagain!).Becausebrakingforceshouldbeappliedtoeachwheelinproportiontotheweightonit(more
weightmorebrakingforceshouldbeapplied),thereisarequirementtobalancethebrakingforcestofrontandrearwheels.Failuretodosowillresultinprematurelockupoflightlyloaded
rearbrakesandresultingskidandlossofcontrol.Infact,inhardbrakingthefrontbrakesperformupto85%ofthebraking!Inproperlybalancedbrakes,neitherthefrontnorrearbreakswilllockupfirst
brakingforceisproportionedsothattheylockuptogether.
Aproportioningvalveisinstalledinlinebetweenthemastercylinderandtherearbrakes(betheydiscordrum)inordertoreducethepressureincreasetotherearasthebrakesareapplied.Thepressureto
therearisnotpreventedfromincreasingthevalvejustensuresthat,afteracertainpoint(thechangeoverpressure)itrisesatalowerratethanitdoestothefrontbrakes.Asthebrakesareapplied,full
pressureisallowedtotherearuptoacertainpoint.Beyondthatpoint,thepressuretotherearincreasesatareducedrate,preventingrearbrakelockup.Moststockproportioningvalvesarepresetbythe
OEMandareneitheradjustablenorserviceabletheyareofuseonlyontheoriginalvehicleforwhichtheyweredesigned.Aftermarketadjustableproportioningvalvesareavailableandareamustforany
custom,highperformancebrakesystem.Stockproportioningvalvesareoflittleuseinmodifiedvehicleswhetheritsthebrakesystemorsimplytheweightandbalance(incl.suspensionheight)thathave
beenmodified.
CombinationValve
AcombinationvalveisfoundinmanyOEMvehiclesandmaycombinethefunctionsofthemeteringvalve,theproportioningvalve,andabrakepressurewarninglightswitch.
PressureLimitingValve
Usedonsomedisc/drumvehicles,apressurelimitingvalveperformsasimilarfunctiontoaproportioningvalveexceptthatinsteadofreducingtherateatwhichpressuretotherearincreases,itsimply
limitsthemaximumpressureavailabletotherear.Thatmeans,unlikewithaproportioningvalve,onceyouachievethatmaximumpressure,nomatterhowhardyoupressthebrakepedal,nomorerear
brakingispossible.Inflexible,nonadjustable,andonlymarginallyusefulonverynoseheavyvehicles,theygenerallysuckandshouldbeavoided.
BrakeTubingandHoses
Illkeepthissectionshortandsweet.
Userigidhydraulicbraketubingasmuchaspossible,andflexiblehoseonlywherenecessary(toallowforsuspensionandsteeringmovement).Eventhebestflexiblehoseexpandsmoreunderpressure
thansteelhydraulictubing.Hoseexpansiongobblesupthatlimitedandvaluablepedalstroke.
StocktyperubberflexhosesareOKtouse,butTeflonlined,stainlesssteelbraidedhosesarebest.Theyswellandexpandless,givingafirmerpedal.Theyreavailableincustomlengthstoo.
Fortubing,useonlycopperlinedsteelhydraulicbraketubingconformingtoSAEJ524specs.Useofanythingelseinvitesfailure.Trustme!
Inadequatetubing,especiallyplastictubing,issubjecttoworkhardening,fatiguecracking,heatdamage,excessivecorrosion(especiallyinternally,whereyoucantseeit)andmechanicaldamage.
DONOTeverusecompressionfittingsorsingleflaresinrigidbraketubinguseonlyproperfittingsanddoubleflares(betheySAEorISOmatchedtoyourfittings,ofcourse).ANorJICfittingsof
appropriatequalityandratingandfromareputablesourcearesuitableforflexhosesandflexhosetorigidtubeconnections.
Mosttubetodayis3/16or.3/16isstiffer,lighter,andeasiertobend.Itanditsassociatedfittingsarealsothemostcommon.haslessinternalfriction(lessresistanttofluidflow)andiseasierto
handlewithoutdamaging.NotethatDOESNOTprovidemorevolumetoactuatethecallipersmorequicklyasIhavereadmoretimesthanIcaretoremember.TheMCpistonsboreandstroke
determinesthefluidvolumedisplacedandthereforethepedalstrokerequiredtoapplythebrakes.Thetubingissealedandfullitsdiameterhasnothingtodowithit(withinreason)andyoucertainlywont
noticethedifferencebetweenand3/16exceptmaybetheplaceboeffectcozyourbuddysaidso!Ipersonallyliketousesimplybecauseitseasiertohandleyoucangetawaywithalessthan
perfectbendthatyouwouldntbeabletowith3/16tube.
Securetubingtoframewithpropersizetubeclampstoavoidpossiblefracturesandtopreventfittingsfromlooseningandleaking.
Usegrommetsorsomeothermeanstoprotectbrakelinesthatpassthroughtheframeorbodypanels.
Makesurefittingsandconnectionsareingoodconditionandareproperlytightened.Checkregularly.
3/16hardlinefittingsare3/824thread,hardlinefittingsare7/1624thread.
BrakeCallipers
FixedorFloating
Callipersareeitheroffixedorfloatingdesign.Fixedcallipersaremountedrigidlytotheaxleandemployoneormorepistonsoneithersideofthecallipertopressthepadsagainsttherotor.Afloating
calliper,commononproductionvehicles,hasapistonorpistonsonlyontheinboardsideofthecalliper.Thefloatingcalliperismountedonpinsorslidessothatwhenthepistonextendsandpressesthe
inboardpadagainsttherotor,thewholebodyofthecalliperslidesonitspinsorguidesintheoppositedirection,bringingtheoutboardpadintocontactwiththerotor.Eachdesignhasitsadvantagesand
drawbacksasfollows:
Floatingcallipersaresmaller,lighter,andeasiertopackage.Theyarealsocheap,readilyavailable,andeasytomount.
Fixedcalliperisbiggerandheavierthanfloatingcalliper.Itwillalsooverheatlessreadilyandbemorerigidthanafloatingcalliper.
Floatingcalliperscoolbetterasthefluidandpistonareonlyontheinboardsideoftherotor.
Floatingcallipershavefewermovingpartsandsealstoleakorwearout.
Fixedcalliperstendtoapplythepadsmoreevenly,preventingunevenbrakepadwear
Floatingcalliperdesignmoreeasilyincorporatesacableoperatedparkingbrake.
OperationofaFloatingCalliper
Whenbrakesareapplied,pistononoutboardsideextendsindirectionofredarrowuntiloutboardpadcontactsrotor.Atthat
point,calliperslidesonpinsindirectionofbluearrowsuntilinboardsideofcalliperpressesinboardpadagainstrotor.
SingleorMultiPiston
Fixedcallipersare,bydefinition,multipiston,butfloatingcalliperscanalsohavemorethanonepiston.Inaddition,fixedcallipersmayhavemorethantwopistons.
Recallthat,becausepressureisequalonallsurfacesinsidethebrakehydraulicsystem,themorecalliperpistonareawehave,themoreforceisexertedforagiveninput.Inotherwordswewantthe
mostpistonsurfaceareapossible.Onemethodofachievingthisistousemultiplecallipersoneachrotorbutthisapproachpresentspackagingproblemsinsidethewheel.Theotheralternativeistouse
eitheraverylargesinglepiston,ormultiplepistons.Theproblemisthatusingaverylargesinglepistonnecessitatesahugecalliperbodyagainpresentingproblemswithpackaginginthewheel.Thus,
multipistoncalliperscanbeusedtoachievegreaterTOTALpistonareathanyoucouldfitwithasinglepiston.Thatsaidamultipistoncalliperisonlymorepowerfulifthetotalareaofitspistonsis
greaterthanthealternative.I.e.ifyourbuddyisbraggingabouthisblingmultipistoncallipers,buteachhasanareaofonlytwosquareinches,andyouhaveanoldtruckcalliperwithasinglehuge
pistonoffoursquareinchesarea,youcancomfortablelaughinhisface!Withfloatingcallipers,effectivepistonareaistheareaoftheactualpiston(s),multipliedbytwo,becauseoftheslidingaction
bringingtheothersideofthecalliperintocontact.
Anotheradvantageofthemultipistoncalliperisthatitcanmoreevenlypressthepadsagainsttherotor,achievingbetter,moreconsistentbreakingandmoreevenpadwear.
SealingandRetraction
CalliperpistonsarenormallysealedwithanOringthathasasquarecrosssection.ThisOringstretcheswhenthebrakesareappliedandthepistonextendstowardstherotor.Whenthepedalisreleased,
theOringrelaxesandretractsthepiston.Becausetherotorandbrakepadsurfacesareflatandaligned(oratleastshouldbe!)ittakesverylittlemovementtoobtainpadtorotorclearance.
Mounting
Apartfromissuesofclearance,protectionfromdebrisanddamage,andeaseofbleeding,thereisnoreasonyoucantmountabrakecalliperatanypositionaroundthecircumferenceoftherotor.The3o
clockand9oclockpositionsarethemostcommon(i.e.infrontof,orbehindtherotor),asthisaffordsgoodprotectionandallowsthecallipertobemountedwiththebleedscrewup(highlyrecommended),
foreaseofbleeding.Mountingat6oclockwouldalmostcertainlymakethecalliperfartoovulnerable,robgroundclearance,andimpartsnoparticularadvantage.However,theresnoreasonyoucant
mountthecalliperat12oclock,providedyouarepreparedtoremovethecalliper(toorientthebleederscrewup)tobleedthebrakes.Ifyoudo,besuretoinsertablockofwoodorotherspacerinthe
calliperwhilebleeding.
Rearcallipermountedhighat11'o'clockforclearancebutwithbleederscrewstillathighestpoint.
AgreatmanycallipermountingbracketsthatIsee,betheycommercialorhomebrew,(includingmyown,Imustadmit)aresimplytoothinandwithoutadequatestructuralshapestrengthtodothejob.Itis
essentialthatacallipermountingbracketnotflexwhenthebrakesareappliedotherwisewewillberobbedofourallimportantpedaltravel.Wewillalsoexperiencecallipertwistingleadingtounevenpad
wearandaspongypedal.Worsestill,wewillbeonourwaytofatiguefailureinthecalliperbracket!steelissimplyinadequateespeciallywhennotbentandreinforcedintoastructuralshapethat
impartsstrength.WhenIapplymyfrontbrakeshard,youcanactuallyseethealmostflatplatesteelbracketsflexingandtwisting!Checkyours.Andwontsomebodypleasemakesomedecent,heavy
dutycalliperbracketsfrom3/8asaminimumbutpreferablyfrom!!
Rotors
Rotorsmakemelaugh.Actually,thethingspeopledoto,andsayabout,rotorsmakesmelaugh.
Rotorsizeisspecifiedbydiameterandthickness(thethicknessbetweenthetwopadcontactsurfacesoneitherside).
Rotorscanbesolid,vented,crossdrilled,grooved,orsomecombinationthereof.Toomanypeopletocount,includingmanyexperts,donotunderstandthetruepurpose(andconsequences)ofeachof
thesedesignfactors.Allowmetoclarify.
Solidsmall,solidrotorsareadequateforsmall,light,orslowvehicles.
Ventedmanymediumtolargerotorsaremadewithradialcoolingpassagesinthemtoactasanairpumptocirculateairfromtherotorcentertotheoutsideoftherotor.Dependingondesign,vented
rotorsmaybedirectional.Iftheventpassagesarecurved,theywillbemoreefficientatcooling,butwillworkinonlyonedirection.Ifyouusecurvedventrotorsmakesureyouinstallhemonthecorrect
sideofthevehicle!
Crossdrilledandslottedrotorsthisisthebitthatmakesmelaugh.Waytoomanypeoplethinkthedrilledholesormachinedslotsareforcooling.Theyarenot.Inveryhighperformancebraking(i.e.race
car)hotgasandfrictionmaterialdustcanbuildupbetweenthepadsandrotorsasthebrakesareusedhard,heatandcoolrapidly,andthepadswearfast.Rotorscanbecrossdrilledorslottedtohelpthis
dustandgasescapeotherwiseitcanbuildupunderthepadsandreducefrictionbetweenpadandrotor,reducingbraking.Thesetechniquesarereallyonlyeffectiveinracingwherepadsarelargeand
wearquicklyandtemperaturesareveryhigh.
Unfortunately,thecrossdrilledlookatsomepointbecamesynonymouswithhighperformanceandeveryonewantedit.Inreality,unlessyoureracing,drillingtherotorsreallyonlyreducesthe
performanceofyourbrakesby:
Reducingtherotormass,therebyreducingitsthermalabsorptioncapacity(rememberTR=Kc/77.8*Wb??)
Increasingthechanceoffatigueandthermalinducedstresscracksintherotor
Reducingthecontactareabetweenpadandrotor,therebyreducingbraking.
Inallhonesty,crossdrilledrotorsonarockcrawlerareprettyfunnyunlessitsdonepurelyforweightsavingandwiththeknowledgethatitdoesnothingtoenhancebraking.
Ultimately,slottedrotorsworkwell,andjudiciouslydrilledrotorsdotoobutifyouseeaSwisscheeserotoritmostlikelymeansthedesigner/builderdoesntactuallyunderstandhowbrakeswork.
Simplesolidrotor.
Ventedrotor.
Ventedrotorwithcurved,directionalvanes.
Slottedrotor.
Slottedandcrossdrilledrotor.
Thismuchcrossdrillingisprobablyexcessive,unlessEXTREMEweightsavingsarerequired.Evenso,andespeciallywiththe
patternshown,thermalstresscrackingisalmostassured.
Pads
Itallcomestoaheadatthebrakepads.Padsneedtobeclean,even,andhaveahighcoefficientoffrictionagainsttherotorformaximumbrakingperformace.Discbrakepadsareavailableinadizzying
arrayofcompoundsallclaimingcertainbenefits.Onethingthatisconsistentisthatthepad'scompoundwillhaveadifferentcoefficientoffrictiondependingonwhetheritiscoldorhot.Racecarfolksare
familiarwiththisasitisoftenheardthatthebrakesmustbe"warmedup"beforetheyworkwell.Asageneralruleofthumb,thefollowingcompoundsexhibitthefollowingcoefficientsoffriction:
Organiccold0.44,hot0.48
Simimetalliccold0.38,hot0.40
Metalliccold0.25,hot0.35
Syntheticcold0.38,hot0.45
Thehigherthecoefficientoffriction,the"softer"thepadissaidtobe.Keepinmindthatthereareotherfactorstoconsiderwhenselectingpads,suchasnoiseandwear.Thesofterthepadis,themore
rapidlyitwillwear.
AllDOTlegalbrakepads(OEMandroadcaraftermarket)aremandatedbylawtobemarkedwithatwolettercode,calledthe"DOTEdgeCode"thatrepresentsthecoefficientoffrictionwhena1"square
pieceoffrictionmaterialissubjectedtovaryingconditionsofload,temperature,pressureandrubbingspeedonatestapparatusknownastheChasemachine.
Thefirstletterofthecode,sometimesknownasthe"cold"code,representsthenormalfrictioncoefficient.Thisisdefinedastheaverageoffourtestdatapointsmeasuredat200,250,300and400degrees
Farenheit.
Thesecondletterofthecode,sometimesknownasthe"hot"code,representsthehotfrictioncoefficientbasedonafadeandrecoverytest.Recoveryisbasicallytheperiodwherethebrakesaregradually
coolingoff.Thehotfrictioncoefficientisdefinedastheaverageofmultipledatapoints:450,500,550,600and650Fonthefirstrecoverycycleofthepadand500,400,and300Fonthesecondrecovery
cycle.
Therangeoffrictioncoefficientsassignedtoeachcodeletterareasfollows:C=lessthan0.15.D=0.15to0.25.E=0.25to0.35.F=0.35to0.45.G=0.45to0.55,andH=over0.55.
Eachlettergradespansarangeofcoefficients,butthecombinationofthetwolettersandtheorderinwhichtheycomecanbeausefulindicatorofpadperformanceasitdemonstratesthechangein
coefficientoffrictionforthatpadfromcoldtohot(andviceversa).Forexample,anFEpadwillgrabbetterwhencold(i.e.tendstofadewhenhot)wherasanEFpadwouldnotgrabwellwhencold(i.e.
wouldneedtobewarmedupformaxperformance).Notethatthecoefficientoffrictionofsteelonsteelis0.25,soEEpadsgrabonlymarginallybetterthannopadsatall!FFpadsareusuallyconsidered
theminimumforahighperformancebrakepad.
SomeexampleEdgeCode'sare:
Anygoodaftermarketracingpadshouldbesoldwithaprecisecoefficientoffrictionidentifiedforbothcoldandwarmperformance,orevenacurveshowingcoefficientoffrictionvs.temperature.
Whicheverpadyouuse,thetypeoflining,edgecode,orexactspeccanbeusefulindeterminingthecoefficientoffrictiontousewhenmakingbrakesystemcalculations.
BeddinginBrakePads
Whennewbrakepadsareinstalled,theyshouldbe"beddedin".Beddinginbrakepadsisaprocessofbreakingtheminbeforesevereuse,similartothewayanengineorsetofgearsmustbebrokenin.
Toperformthebreakin,followthestepslistedbelow:
Step1:Make10stopsfrom30mph(50kph)downtoabout10mph(15kph)usingmoderatebrakingpressureandallowingapproximately30secondsbetweenstopsforcooling.Donotdragyourpads
duringthesestops.Afterthe10thstop,allow15minutesforyourbrakingsystemtocooldown.
Step2:Make5consecutivestopsfrom50mph(80kph)downto10mph(15kph).Afterthe5thstop,allowyourbrakingsystemtocoolforapproximately30minutes.
Thiscompletesthebreakinofthepadstotherotorsurface.Fullseatingofnewbrakepadsnormallyoccurswithin1000miles.
TheBrakingRequirementsofExtremeOffroadRigs
Aswithsomanythingsthatdeterminevehicleperformancefromtirestosuspensiontogearingweextremeoffroadersareonourown.TherehasbeenlittleseriousR&Dandengineeringresearchinto
ourneedsandtheirsolutions.Thesportjusthasntyetgrowntothatlevel.Thislackofpublishedresearchandengineering,whencombinedwiththespecificpeculiaritiesofourneeds(needsthatsimply
dontexistelsewhere),leavesusheavilyreliantononeanotherforanecdotaladviceandseatofthepantsexperience.
Thismeansthatdesigningasatisfactorysystem,orsolvingaparticularproblemdependsheavilyonourabilitytocommunicateourneedsandwants,aswellasourperceptionoftheproblem.
ThatswhyImnowgoingtodevotealittletimetoaddressingwhatIseeastheuniquerequirementsofanoffroadbrakingsystem,followedbysomediscussiononwhatconstitutesgoodbrakesandwhat
thelimitstobrakeperformanceare.
Peculiaritiesofoffroad
Recallthetwofunctionsofthebrakesbraketorque(clampingaction)andthermalcapacity.Therigorsofoffroadimpartuniquerequirementsinbothareas:
BrakeTorque
Carsspendmostoftheirtimeonrelativelyflatgroundtheirbraketorquerequirementsareconcernedmostlywithslowingthecarfromspeed.Incontrast,wecanoftenspendhourswiththefrontend60
degreesnoseupornosedownasituationinwhichovercomingtheforceofgravityasittriestomovetherigdownhillisfarmorepronouncedthaninanyroadcar.Notonlythat,butitisinpreciselythese
situations(aswellasothers,likenavigatinglargeboulders)wherewerequireprecisecontrolaninchortwomakesorbreakstheline(ortakesacone).
Nonormalcarcombinesalowstallspeedtorqueconverterwithsuperlowgearingquitelikeanextreme4x4can.Notevendragcars.Youoftenhearthosewithautotransmissions,lowstallconverters,and
lowgearscomplainingofnotbeingabletostoptherig,orofnotbeingabletokeepitstopped(drivingthroughthebrakesatidle).Ariglikethiswantstogoallthetimeandwerelyonourbrakestokeep
itincheckagain,ofteninsituationswhereinchesmeanthedifferencebetweenarolloverornot.
Manyrigsmakeuseofthebrakestoperformdigsorburnswhereinoneaxleisbrakedwhiletheotherisdriventocreateapivotingeffectforsharperturning.Tousethistechniquetomaxeffect,
greatbraketorquemustbegeneratedinthenondrivenaxle.Ifyouresending300hptotherearwheelsinafrontburn,youdbetterbeabletobrakethosefrontwheelswithsomeseriousbraketorque.
OK,yousay,soweneedalotofbraketorquebutsodoesa200mphracecar.Trueindeed,butthereareacoupleoffactorsthatmakeourrequirementsunique:
First,inaracecar,yourestrappedintight,backagainsttheseat,andareusuallyonthegasoronthebrakeshardandyoutransitionfromonetotheotherprettyaggressively.Inanoffroadrig,
wefindourselvesneedingtiptoecontrolofthebrakesasweworkahardline,oftentwofootdriving,whilewemoveaboutintheseattoseetheterrain.Thismakesitmuchlesscomfortabletohaveto
pressthepedalhard,comparedtothecardriverwhosalreadypressedbackintheseatandstaysthere.Inarockrig,youdontwanttobepressedbackintotheseat,legtrembling,tryingtoseetheline
whatweneedisprecise,lightcontrolofthebrakes(whilestillachievingBIGbraketorque),atallsortsofcambersandangles,oftenforlongperiodsoftime,withoutundueeffortandresultantfatigue
especiallysincewecanspendalldayinourrigs.
Energyconvertermode:
Incars,brakingismostimportantwhenthecarisatspeed.Eveninanautoequippedcaratastoplight,thecarsstallspeedandoverallgearingaresuchthatittakeslittleforcetopreventmovement.The
resultis,inacar,theenergyconverterfunctionofthebrakesisconcernedprimarilywiththekineticenergyofthecarinmotiontheinertiaofrotatingwheelsisnegligibleincomparison.Thisisobvious
thefasterthecar,thebetterthebrakesneedtobe.
Whatislessobviousisthedemandthevastlyheavierwheelsandtiresofa4x4placeonthebrakes.Inanoffroadrig,rotating,big,heavywheelsandtireshavemuchmoreinertiathantheircar
counterparts.Thismeansthatthecapabilityofthebrakestoconvertandabsorbenergyislessobvious,butnolessimportant.Itsobviousinafastcarcargoesfast,carbrakeshard,carbrakesgethot.
Butinanoffroadrigwithlarge,heavytires,evenatslowspeeds,thebrakesgethotbecausetheyhavetoconvertnotonlythekineticenergyoftheslowmovingvehicle,butalsokineticenergyofthe
heavytiresandwheels.Inotherwords,justbecauseyougoslow,doesntmeanyoudontneedgoodbrakes.
Allofwhichmeansproperbrakeperformanceisextremelyimportanttousforsafetyaswellasapleasant,nonfatiguingdrivingexperienceeventhoughwedontnormallyencounterveryhighspeeds
forverylong.
Andifyouraceyourrig(whichisbecomingmoreandmorepopular),wellbrakeperformancejustgetsmoreandmoreimportant.
Bottomlineyouprobablyneedmorebrakethanyouthink,andhowtheyfeelisgoingtohavealargeeffectonhowwellyoullbeabletodriveinextremeterrain,andhowpleasantandcomfortableitwill
be.
BrakePerformanceandLimits
Thereshouldbeonlyonelimittohowwellyourbrakesworktraction.Thetractionbetweentireandroadshouldalwaysbethelimitingfactortohowquicklyyoucanstop.Exceedingthetractionlimit
causesthetirestolockupandskid.Ifyoucandothisunderallconditions,withreasonableandcomfortablepedaleffort,thenyourbrakesareadequate.Ifnot,someotherfactorislimitingtheir
performance,andmaintenanceormodificationwillberequired.Theother,undesirable,limitingfactorsare:
ForceLimit
Atforcelimit,youpushashardaspossibleonthebrakesbutcantstopanyquicker.Ifyoucouldpushharder,thevehiclewouldstopquicker.Forcelimitcanbealteredbyreducingmastercylindersize,
usingdifferentbrakepads,addingorupgradingpowerassist,increasingpedalratio,increasingcalliperpistonarea,orincreasingeffectiverotordiameter.
DeflectionLimit
Atthedeflectionlimit,thepedalhitsthefloorortheMCpistonhitsitsinternalstopbeforemaxbrakeforceisgenerated.I.e.thecombinationofdesignedclearanceandunwanteddeflectioninthesystem
exceedstheavailabletravel.Clearanceisdeterminedbythevolumeoffluidrequiredtobedisplacedtobringthepadsintocontactwiththerotor,andischieflydeterminedbythesizeofthecalliper
piston(s).Unwanteddeflectioncancomefrompedalandpedalmountflex,MCmountflex,calliperbracketflex,calliperflex,hoseexpansion,trappedair,unevenlywornpadsorrotors,andotherworn
componentssuchaswheelbearings.Assumingallairisbledfromthesystemandallcomponentsareingoodworkingorder,deflectionlimitcanbealteredbyincreasingMCpistondiameter,decreasing
calliperpistondiameter,upgradingflexhoses,reducingthelengthofflexhoseused,orusingstiffercallipers,brackets,andpedals.
WearLimit
Thebrakeseffectivenesscanbelimitedbyworncomponents.Ifpadsorrotorsarewornexcessively,orifanyseal,tube,hose,bracket,orfittingisdamaged,worn,orleaking,areductioninperformance,or
worse,brakefailure,canresult.Thelikelihoodofreachingthewearlimitcanbereducedbyusingdifferent(higherquality)padsand/orrotors,usinglargercallipersandrotors,orincreasingbrakecooling.
Goodinspectionandmaintenancepracticescanpreventreachingthewearlimit.
TemperatureLimit
Whenbrakesoverheat,youreachoneoftheotherlimits(force,deflection,orwear)muchmorequickly.Thatis,hotbrakescancauselackofbrakingforce(commonlycalledbrakefade),increased
deflection(excessivepedaltravel),orrapidcomponentwearrangingfrompad/rotorweartoboilingfluidandcookingseals.Thekeystoavoidingatemperaturelimitare:
Usingsufficientlylarge/heavybrakes.
Sufficientbrakecooling.
Selectionofcomponentsdesignedforthetemperaturesencounteredincludingpads,rotors,callipers,andfluid.
BrakeFadeandothercomplaintsDesignTroubleshooting
TheprevioussectioncoveredthetechnicalaspectsofbrakelimitsbutevenIwouldntexpectyoutochatwithasupplierorfellowdriverandsayYea,thebrakesarentgreatIthinkIhaveadeflection
limitwithoccasionalintermittentforcelimit.Well,actually,ImightsaythatbutthenCharleywouldmockmeforhoursmuchtoeveryoneelsesamusement.
Toavoidthissituation,letsexaminethemostcommonbrakeperformancecomplaintsineverydaylanguage.(Iwasgoingtosayeverydayparlancebutthatwouldhavebeentooironic,Ithink!)
Thissectionisfocusedonproblemsthatoccuraftersystemmodificationsordesign.Thatis,ithelpsyoudiagnoseproblemsinyourbrakesystemdesign.Ifyourbrakesworkedsatisfactorilyatonepoint,
butnolongerdo,seethefollowingsectiontitledMaintenanceTroubleshooting.Inthefollowingtables,Ihaveincludedacolumnentitledcompromisesbecause,asweknow,changingoneaspectofa
systemoftenaffectstheothers.ForthesakeofbrevityIhaveincludedonlythecompromisesaffectingtheoperationofthebrakesitmaybeassumedthataddedcomplexity,cost,anddecreased
availabilityofpartsarealwayspossibleoutcomes.Forexample,ifthesolutiontoaparticularproblemistoinstallastiffercalliperthiswilllikelybemoreexpensive,complicatedandtimeconsumingifsuch
apartisevenavailablehowevertherearenodrawbacksorcompromisesintheoperationofthebrakesystemitselftousingstiffercallipersinthiscase,thecompromisescolumnwillbeblank.
BrakeFade
Brakefadegenerallyreferstoanylossofbrakingcausedbyoverheating.Infact,therearethreeverydistinctformsofbrakefade,anditisusefultodistinguishbetweenthem,astheirsymptoms
andsolutionsareentirelydifferent.
PadFade.
PadFadeiscausedbythetemperatureofthebrakesexceedingthemaximumtemperaturelimitofthebrakepadfrictionmaterial.Whenthemaximumtemperaturelimitisreached(andevenbefore,asitis
approached),brakepadscanexpelgaseswhenheated,gassesthatactasalubricantbetweenpadandrotor.Whenpadfadeoccurs,thepedalwillfeelnormal(highandfirm)buttherewillbeverylittle
stoppingpower.Pumpingthebrakeswillnothelp.Solutionstopadfadeare:
1.Touseamoretemperatureresistantbrakepad(hardercompound)
2.Toincreasethebrakesthermalcapacitybyincreasingthesize/weightoftherotor
3.Toimprovecoolingbyusingadifferentrotordesign(ventedvs.solid,ordirectionvs.straightvanes)
4.Toimprovebrakecoolingbyimprovingcoolingairflowtothebrakes.Inextremecircumstances,ifthevehiclehasairductsforbrakecooling,afinemistofwatercanbesprayedintotheairtocoolit
beforeithitstherotor,improvingtheairscoolingability.
5.Touseaslottedand/orcrossdrilledrotortoaidinexpellinghotgassesandpaddebris.NotethatthesedesignsDONOTaidincoolingbutsimplyallowtheoffendinggasorparticlestoberemoved
moreefficiently.
FluidBoil
Whenthetemperatureofthecalliperexceedstheboilingpointofthebrakefluid,tinybubblesareformedinthebrakefluid.Asaresult,thepedalgoessoftandperhapseventothefloorasthefluidisno
longerincompressible.Oncethishashappened,thefluidmustbereplaced.Overtimebrakefluidcanabsorbwatervapour,andthemorewatervapourinthefluid,thegreateritssusceptibilitytofluidboil.
Solutionstofluidboilinclude:flushandfillwithnewbrakefluid,useabrakefluidwithahigherboilingpoint,improvecoolingofthecalliper,oruseacalliperwithaninsulatedpiston.
GreenFade
Greenfadeoccursonlywithnewbrakepadsiftheyarenotbeddedinproperlyafterhavingbeeninstalled.Beddinginbrakepadsisaprocessofbreakingtheminbeforesevereuse,similartotheway
anengineorsetofgearsmustbebrokenin.Greenfadeiscausedbygasorliquidboilingofftheorganicpadliningoninitialheating.Thegasorliquidnotonlyactsasalubricantbetweenpadandrotor,
butcanalsoglazethesurfaceofthepadsbycoolingandresolidifyingintoahardslicksurfacewithaverylowcoefficientoffriction.Thesolutiontogreenfadeistobedinbrakepads.Todoso,followthe
stepsoutlinedin"Beddingin".
HardPedal
HardPedalisthetermusedtodescribebrakesthatrequireexcessivepedalefforti.e.thedrivermustpushtoohardonthepedalforthebrakestowork.Thisconditionfeelstothedriverlike
thebrakepedalisveryhard.
Complaint:Pedalfeelshard
LowPedal
LowPedalisthetermusedtorefertoabrakepedalthatrequiresanexcessivelylongstroketofullyapplythebrakes.Whatweareexperiencingwithlowpedalisadeflectionlimit.Insomecases,
thebrakesworkonlyafterbeingpumpedafewtimes.Whatshappeninghereisthatthedriverisabletodisplacemorefluidmorequicklythanthecallipersretract,andisthereforeabletoprovidethe
volumerequiredbypumpingthebrakes.Thisisusuallyasymptomofincorrectvalving,suchaslackofrequiredresidualpressurevalve.
Complaint:Pedaltravelstoofar/onlyworkswhenpumped
SpongyPedal
Oftenpresentwith,butnottobeconfusedwith,lowpedalaspongypedalstartshighanddoesnttraveltoofarbutitdoesntfeelfirmandsolid.Instead,thebrakesfeelsoft,squishy,andspongywhen
applied.
Complaint:Pedalfeelsspongy
OverlySensitive
Brakesthatdevelopenormousclampingforce(usuallybygeneratinghighpressure)withverylittlepedaleffortwillfeeloverlysensitivetothedriver.Theyarehardtomodulate,particularlyformedtohigh
speedwork,andaregenerallyunpleasanttodrive.Exactlythepointatwhichthisoccurswillbeamatterofdriverpreferencecombinedwiththevehiclesuse.Personally,Ilikebrakesonthemoresensitive
sideasitallowstiptoecontrolinseriousverticalandoffcambersituationswhichcanbeveryuseful,particularlywhenthedriveisalsooccupiedwithmanagingselectablelockers,threetransfercase
levers,aclutch,andcuttingbrakes.
Complaint:Pedalfeelsoverlysensitive/brakeslockuptooeasily
IncreaseMCPistonarea PedaltraveldecreasesbecauseMCdisplacesmore
fluid
Excessivecalliperpistonarea InstallcalliperswithsmallerTOTALpistonarea Pedaltraveldecreasesbecausecalliperpiston
movementrequireslessfluidvolumebedisplaced
Excessivebraketorque Highcoefficientoffriction UseHarderBrakePads
BrakeSystemDesign
Thefollowingaresomegeneralguidelinesfordesigningabrakesystemfromscratch.Althoughtheyarepresentedinaparticularorder,somejugglingmayberequired.Thatis,youmaycometoacertain
point(say,pedalratiodetermination)findoutthatyouarelimitedbysomeotherfactor(roomavailableforpedal)andhavetojugglebothpriorandremainingdecisions(calliperpistonsize,mastercylinder
size,powerboosterselection)toworkaroundthelimitation.
FollowingthediscussionIhaveincludedanExcelspreadsheet(.xls)thatwillaidinthecalculationsandcanbeusedtomoreeasilyseetheaffectsofplayingwiththedifferentvariables.
Step1:
Decideondiscbrakesordrums.Theanswerisdiscs.Goontostep2.
Step2:
Chooseandcheckrotor.
Whiletherotoryouuseisoftendeterminedbytheaxleyouhavechosen,ifyouhaveachoice:
Choosethelargestdiameterrotorthatwillfitinthewheel(tomakeroomforthecalliper,thisisusuallyabout3in.smallerthanthewheeldiameteri.e.12fora15wheel)
Ifpossible,alwayschooseaventedrotor
Ifyouplantousethebrakeshard,alot,(asinracing)considerdirectionalventedrotorsaswellasslottedand/orcrossdrilledrotors.Dontoverdothecrossdrillingforthesakeofappearances!
Step3:
Checkthermalcapacityofchosenrotor
Usingtheequationsinthisarticle,checkthateachrotorisatleastmassiveenoughtobeabletoabsorbthekineticenergyfromasinglestopfrommaximumspeedatmaximumweightwithoutexceeding
1000*F
Ifyouplantousethebrakeshard,alot,(asinracing)redotheabovecalculationassumingtherotorsinitialtemperatureis500*Fratherthanambienttemperature.
Step4:
Choosecalliper
Normally,thechoiceofrotorwilldictatethecalliperusedeitherfromthesamemake/modelofvehicleorasamatchedsetfromahighperformancecompany.However,ifchoiceisavailable:
Selectthestiffestcalliperavailable,withthehighestmaximumpressurerating.
Selectacalliperwiththelargesttotalpistonareapossible.
Ifwheel&suspensionclearanceandmountingbracketsallowconsiderusingafixedcallipermosthighperformancecallipersareoffixeddesign.
Consideruseofmultipistoncallipersdependingonavailabilityandtotalpistonarea(youmayfindthatonelargepistonaffordsmorearethantwosmall,dependingondesign)
Step5:
Determinebraketorquerequiredusingequationsgiveninthisarticle
TBr=FrictionForceonTirexRollingRadiusofTire
Step6:
Calculaterequiredhydraulicsystempressure:
Oncetherotorandcalliperarechosen,youhavealltheinformationrequiredtocalculatethehydraulicpressurerequiredtooperatethebrakesatmaximumcapacitythatis,thepressurerequiredto
achievemaximumbraketorque,ascalculatedaboveinstep5.
Theequationis:
PM=TBr/(LxATxRE)
Where
PM=Maximumhydraulicpressure(psi)
TBr=BrakeTorqueRequired(ftlbs)
L=Coefficientoffrictionbetweenbrakepadsandrotors(use0.3,manufacturersspecs,orestimatederivedfromthepad'sDOTedgecode)
AT=Totaleffectiveareaofcalliperspistons(sq.in.)
RE=Effectiverotorradius(in.)measuredfromthecenteroftherotortothecanterofthebrakepad.
TheanswerwillprobablyvaryfromseveralhundredtoperhapsasmuchasfifteenhundredPSI.Atthispoint,checkthatthecomponentsyouareusing,especiallythecallipers,areratedforthispressure.If
youcannotfindacalliperratedforthispressure,youhavethreechoices:
Useacalliperwithmoretotaleffectivepistonarea(largerand/ormorepistons)
Usealargerdiameterrotor(toincreaserotoreffectivediameter)heydidntIalreadytellyoutousethelargestdiameterrotorpossible!
Usemorethanonecalliperperwheel.Twoidenticalcallipersonthesamerotorwillhalvethepressure,butdoublethedisplacement,requiredtoachievemaxbraketorque.
Step7:
Decideondesiredpedaleffort
Pedaleffortdesiredtostopthevehicleatmaximumdecelerationisapersonalchoice.Inaracecaritmaybeasmuchas100lbswhichfeelslikeaprettyhardpush.Inroadcarsitisnormallyless.If
youarenotsure,75lbsisagoodstartingpoint.
Step8:
Decideonpowerormanualbrakes.
Unlessspaceorweightisatanextremepremium,Iwouldalwaysrecommendpowerbrakesespeciallyinabigorheavyrig,oronewithlargetires.Withoutpowerbrakes,youarefacedwithadirect
tradeoffofpressure(brakepower)vs.displacement(pedaltravel).ThebeautyofpowerbrakesisthattheyallowyoutouseapedalandMCcombinationthatislargeenoughtohaveanice,shorttravelbut
stilldeveloptherequiredpressurewithoutexcessivepedaleffortbecauseofthepowerassist.Exceptforalittleextraspacerequiredandminorexpense,itaddstoyourbrakesystemperformancewithout
anydrawbackorcompromise.
Step9:
Determinedesiredpedalratio,mastercylindersize(pistonarea),andpowerassisttoachievemaxbrakingwithdesiredpedaleffort.
Thethreefactorsofpedalratio,mastercylindersize,andanypowerassistmustbecalculatedandjuggledtogetherastheyallaffectoneanother.Whereonefactorisfixedorbeyondyourcontrol(e.g.
usingastockpedalassembly),adjustmentsorcompromiseintheotherfactorswillbenecessary.
Pedalratio:
Pedalratiosrangefrom3:1to7:1.Whenselectingapedalratio,considerthemountingspacerequired,notonlyforthelengthofpedal,butalsoforthestrokerequiredatthefootpad(willthepedalhitthe
floorbeforethefullmastercylinderstrokeisused?).Remembertoo,thatthegreaterthepedalratio,thelongerthepedal,andthemoresusceptibleitwillbetoflexortwist,introducingunwanteddeflection.
Evenwithoutflexing,alongerpedalcanfeelspongytothedriver.Also,thelongerthepedal,themorepedaltravelthedriverwillfeelasthefootpadswingsthroughalargerarc.Ifindoubt,startwith4:1
forpowerbrakesand6:1formanualbrakes.
CalculateMCpushrodforce
MultiplyyourdesiredpedaleffortbythepedalratiotoobtainthemanualforceontheMCpushrod.Ifpedalratiois5:1andpedaleffortis75lbs,theforceonthepushrodis5x75=375lbs.
SelectrequiredMCsize
Withthepushrodforceknown,wecannowcalculatetheMCpistonsizerequiredtoachievethedesiredhydraulicpressurepreviouslycalculated.Inordertodoso,dividethepushrodforcebythepressure
togettheareaoftheMCpiston,andthenconvertthatareatoadiameterusingtheformulafortheareaofacircle(A=pi(d/2)^2)ortheaccompanyingchart.Iftheexactareayouneedisnotavailable,you
willhavetousethenextclosestavailablesize,andrecalculatetheactualpressureachieved.Rememberthat,astheMCarea(diameter)getssmaller,pressure(andforce)goup,butsodoestravel
required.
TableofMasterCylinderSizesandtheirPistonAreas
MasterCylinderSize PistonDiameter(d)(in.) PistonArea(sq.in.)
(bore) (3.14(d/2)^2)
5/8in. 0.6250 0.3068
11/16in. 0.6875 0.3712
19mm 0.7480 0.4394
in. 0.7500 0.4418
20mm 0.7874 0.4869
13/16in. 0.8125 0.5185
21mm 0.8268 0.5369
22mm 0.8661 0.5892
22.2mm 0.8740 0.5999
7/8in. 0.8750 0.6013
23mm 0.9055 0.6440
29/32in. 0.9063 0.6451
15/16in. 0.9375 0.6903
24mm 0.9449 0.7012
25.4mm 1.0000 0.7854
1in 1.0000 0.7854
11/32in. 1.0313 0.8353
26.6mm 1.0472 0.8613
11/16in. 1.0625 0.8866
11/8in. 1.1250 0.9940
28.6mm 1.1260 0.9958
11/4in. 1.2500 1.2272
31.8mm 1.2520 1.2311
15/16in. 1.3125 1.3530
111/32in. 1.3438 1.4183
11/2in. 1.5000 1.7671
13/4in. 1.7500 2.4053
e.g.Ifwerequire1000psihydraulicpressure,andhavedecidedonapedaleffortof75lbsandapedalratioof5:1:
A=F/P
Where
A=Areaofmastercylinderpistonrequired
F=ForceonMCpushrod(lbs)
And
P=hydraulicpressurerequired(psi)
So
MCarea=375lbs/1000psi=0.375SquareInches.
Referringtothetable,wefindthatarentlikelyanymastercylindersavailablewiththisexactarea.Theclosestisan11/16diameterMCpiston,whichgivesanareaof0.3712sq.in.IfyoufindthattheMC
sizeyouwantisnotavailable,orisntavailableinaconfigurationyoudesire,youwillhavetousetheclosestsizeavailableandrecalculate.
Inthisexample,letsassumewecantfindan11/16MCwewanttouse,sowesettleonwhichhaanareaof0.4418Sq.in..CheckthehydraulicpressuregeneratedwiththisMCusingtheequation:
P=F/A
P=375lbs/0.4418sq.in.
=848psi.
ImmediatelywecanseethatusingaMCwillnotallowustogeneratesufficienthydraulicpressuretomaximallyapplythebrakes.Atthispoint,wehaveadecisiontomakeWecan:
Useapedalwithahigherpedalratio
Acceptanundesirablyhighpedaleffort
Reducethepressurerequiredbygoingallthewaybacktocalliper/rotorchoiceandeither
Increasingthediameteroftherotor,and/or
Increasingthesize/numberofcalliperpistons.
Option(1)maybeaviablealternative,butwhatifwehavelimitedspaceorarealreadysetonaparticularpedalassemblyanddontwanttofabricateorbuyacustompedal?Option(2)isreallyoutofthe
question,asitdefeatsthepurposeofthewholeexercise.Finally,option(3)isnotonlyunlikelytoyieldthemagnitudeofchangerequired,butitsverylikelythatwerealreadyusingthemaximumsizerotor
andcalliper.
Sowhatarewetodo?Thesolutionhereispowerbrakes.Byaddingpowerbrakes,wecandramaticallyincreasetheMCpushrodforcewithouthavingtoalteranyoftheothervariables.Notonlywillthislet
uschooseaMCinamorecommonlyavailablesize,butwillalsoallowustousealargerMCsoastokeeppedaltraveldown.
Calculatingtheexactfactorbywhichapowerbrakeboosterwillmultiplypushrodforceisdifficulttodoasmodernvacuumandhydraulicboostersarebothfairlycomplicatedindesignandoftennotsold
withanexactboostspecification.Boostfactorswilldependonthesizeanddesignoftheboosterandwillrangefromabout2to5ormore.Thismakesexactcalculationswithpowerbrakesmore
complicated,butexperiencehasshownthat,withpowerbrakes,oneshouldnormallyuseapedalratioofabout4:1andamastercylinderwithatleasta1diameter.
Step10:
Checkdisplacementoffluidwithchosencomponents,verifythatpedaltravelwillbeacceptable,andjuggle/recalculateasrequired.
Thefinalthingtoconsider,nowthatwehavechosenamastercylinder,istheeffecttheMCboresizewillhaveonpedaltravel.Unfortunately,precisecalculationsarecomplicated,asitisdifficulttoknow
theamountoftravelconsumedbyallthedeflections(bothdesignandunwanted)inthesystem.
WecancalculatethedisplacementoftheMCbymultiplyingtheareaofthepistonbyitsstroketoarriveatavalueincubicinches.(Goodaftermarketmastercylindersshouldalwaysspecifythestroke,but
withstockreplacementorOEMpartsitmaynotbeaseasytocomeby.Onefoolproofmethodistomeasurethestrokewiththemastercylinderoutofthevehiclevaluesfrom1to13/4inchesare
common.)
Intheory,wecouldthencomparethistothevolumerequiredbythecalliperpistons.Thevolumerequiredbythecalliperswouldbecalculatedastheareaofthepistonmultipliedbythetravelrequiredto
bringthepadsintocontactwiththerotor.Thislastvariableisdifficulttomeasureorcalculate.Notonlythat,buttheresultwouldonlybevalidformaximumstrokeofthepedal(andthereforemastercylinder
piston)andwesurelywantthebrakestoapplywellbeforetheendofthepedalstroke.
Ultimately,wemayhavetorelyonexperienceand/ortestingtoachievetherightbalancebetweenbrakingpower/pedaleffort,andpedaltravel.
Again,powerbrakeboostersareanenormousassethere,aswecanselectalargeboreMCthatwilldisplacealargevolumeoffluid(andthereforeminimizepedaltravel),andstillproducesufficient
pressure.
Asaruleofthumb,4wheeldiscbrakesrequireamastercylinderofatleast1bore,andfrequently11/8ormore.
Step11:
Withallcomponentsselected,calculateactualmaximumbraketorquedevelopedandcomparewithcalculationofbraketorquerequired.
Tohelpyouwiththecalculations,IcreatedanExcelspreadsheet(.xlsformat)withtheformulaealreadyentered.Simplyenterthevariablesinbluetextandobservetheresults.
CLICKHEREtoDOWNLOAD
Note:Asyouplaywiththevariables,keepinmindthatthecalculationsareforsystemperformanceatmaximumlimits.Forexample,ifyouenter75lbsforpedaleffortthisisatmax
braking.Also,asdiscussed,therearevariables,suchassystemdeflections,thatcannotbemeasuredandenteredintothespreadsheet.Assuch,youMUSTinterprettheresults
providedbythecalculationswithgreatcare.
MaintenanceTroubleshooting
Thissectionprovidestroubleshootingadviceforabrakesystemthatatonetimefunctionedacceptably,butnolongerdoes.Thatis,itisfocusedonmaintenanceproblems.Ifyouareexperiencingproblems
withanewlydesigned/modified/installedsystemrefertotheprevioussectiontitledBrakeFadeandothercomplaints.
Problem Cause
LowPedalimproveswithpumping Rotorrunout
Loosewheelbearing
Airinhydraulicsystem
LowPedalnoimprovementwithpumping Badcalliperseals
Badlywornpads
Rotorrunout
Leakinhydraulicsystem
Loosewheelbearing
Excessivefreeplayinbrakelinkage
Lowfluidinreservoir
Partialbrakesystemfailure
SpongyPedal Airinhydraulicsystem
Hoseswelling/Deterioratedflexhoses
Fluidboil
Badlywornpads
Unevenpadwear
Oldorcontaminatedbrakefluid
Faultymastercylinder
Callipernotsquaretorotor
MasterCylindermountingloose
Cloggedreservoircapventhole
Softorswollencalliperseals
Pedaldoesntreturn MCreservoirnotvented
NoclearanceinMCpushrod
Bindinginpedalpivotorpushrod
FrontorRearbrakeslockingprematurely Toomuchfrontorrearbrakebias
Defectivebrakevalving
Failureinoppositesystem
Excessivewearinoppositesystem
Worntires
Tirepressuretoohigh
Defectivemastercylinder
Defectivecalliper
Onebrakelocking/vehiclepullstooneside Calliperpistonseizing
Defective,damaged,oroilcontaminatedbrakepadononeside
Defectivecalliper
Scoredoroutofroundrotor
BadcalliperOring
Loosecallipermount
Mismatchedrotorsandpads
Incorrecttirepressures
Badfrontendalignment
Mismatchedtires/load
Damagedorcrimpedbrakeline/hose
Loosesuspensionparts
Loosecallipermountingbolts
Incorrectwheelbearingadjustment
Overlysensitivepedal Defectivepowerbooster
HardPedal Powerboosterfailure
Brakeswet
Glazedpads
Contaminatedpads(oilorfluid)
FluidBoil
PadFade
Excessivelywornpads
Calliperpistonseizedorsticking
Worn/defectivemastercylinder
VibratingPedal Excessiverotorrunoutorthicknessvariation
Wheelbearingdamaged,worn,oroutofadjustment
Crackedrotor
Bentaxle
Corrodedrotorventfins
Callipernotslidingproperly
NoPedal(pedalgoestofloor) Airinhydraulicsystem
Leakinhydraulicsystem
Taperedpadwear
Electriccurrentpassingthroughbrakefluid
Lackoffluidinreservoir
Brakesgrab Contaminatedpadlinings
Brakeswet
Badcombinationvalve
Brakesnotreleasing/Brakedrag Defectivemastercylinder
NoclearanceinMCpushrod
Bindinginpedalpivotorpushrod
Seizedcalliperpiston
Agedoroverheatedcalliperseals
Swollenseals(incorrectbrakefluid)
Calliperslides/pinscorroded/seized
Parkingbrakeonormaladjusted
Faultypowerbooster
Impropervalving(residualpressurevalve)
Callipernotsquaretorotor
Damagedorcrimpedbrakeline/hose
Cloggedbrakelines
Wheelbearingdamaged,worn,oroutofadjustment
Brakessqueal Wornpads
Brakeswet
Glazedorcontaminatedpads
Dirtyorscoredrotor
Bentcalliperbracket
Worn/missing/brokenantisquealshims
Worn/missingantisquealcompoundonbackofpads
Taperwearonpads
Rapidpadwear Brakesnotreleasing
Badsurfacefinishonrotor
Padstoosoft
Padfade(inadequatecooling)
Cracked/damaged/contaminatedrotor
ReviewVANCOPowerBrakeSupplyHydroboostSystem
Why?
Thebeautyofpowerassistbrakesisthattheyallowustodesignabrakesystemwherewedon'tneedto
compromisemovementforforce.Withoutpowerassist,weneedtouseasmallmastercylinderpistonto
developsufficientpressure,butthatsamesmallmastercylinderdisplaceslittlefluid,leavinguswith
unnecessarilylongpedalstroke.Thesituationisworsewhenwehaveswappedinreardiscbrakesthatrequire
morevolumethandrumstooperate.Withpowerassistwecanuseamastercylinderwithanicelargediameter
borethatwilldisplacealotoffluidandgiveusanice,shortpedalstrokethepowerboostermultipliesourinput
forcetocreatesufficientpressureevenwiththelargemastercylinderpiston.
Themostcommonformofpowerbrakeboosteristhevacuumbooster.Vacuumboosters,althoughcommoninOEMroadcars,haveseverallimitations.First,theymustbeverylargetoproducemuchboost,
makingthemhardtofitincrampedenginecompartmentsespeciallywiththatV8shoehornedinthere.Second,theyrelyonenginevacuumtoproduceboostpower.Troubleis,ifyouhaveadieselengine,
bigcam,forcedinduction(supercharger),orevencertainemissionscontrolsonyourmotoryouwon'thaveasteady,reliablesourceofvacuum.Thelastthingwewantisbrakeboostthatisweakand
unreliableespeciallywithamorepowerfulengine!
Fortunately,thereisanotheroptionhydraulicallyboostedbrakes.Ahydroboostbrakeboosterispoweredbyhydraulicfluidfromthepowersteeringpump.Itfitsbetweenthepedalandmastercylinderjust
asavacuumboosterdoes,butoffersseveraldistinctadvantages:
Size.Thehydroboostboosterismuchmorecompactthanavacuumbooster.Atonly14incheslongandapproximately4.5inchesindiameter,itcanfitintightspaces.Itcanevenbemountedupside
down!
Power.Thehydroboostisfarmorepowerfulthanavacuumbooster.Given"average"pedalratio'sandmastercylindersavacuumboostedbrakesystemmaydevelop10001500psi.Ahydroboost
systemiscapableofgenerating24003000psi!
Reliability.Insteadofrelyingonpotentiallyweakandfluctuatingenginevacuum,thehydroboostispoweredbythevehicle'spowersteeringpump.
Howitworks.
Thehydroboostunitisplumbedinlinewiththepowersteering.Thepowersteering
pumpprovidesaconstantflowofpressurizedhydraulicfluidtothebooster.
Whenbrakesareofffluidisbypassedoutthereturnportandbacktothepower
steeringreservoir.Whenbrakesareapplied,hydraulicflowpassingacrossthepower
(boost)pistonisrestricted.Thisrestrictioncreatesapressuredropacrosstheboostpiston.
Theresultingforceistransferredtothemastercylinderpiston.
Theboosterincorporatesanaccumulatorcontainingnitrogengas.Whentheengineis
running,hydraulicflowtotheboostercompressesthenitrogen,storingenergy(likea
spring).Shouldtheenginefail,thereissufficientenergystoredinthecompressednitrogen
toallowfor12powerassistedapplicationsofthebrakes.Afterthat,brakesoperate
normallybutwithoutpowerboost.
Compact,powerful,reliable,anddeadeasytoinstallhydroboostbrakesareanecksnappingupgradetoanyrigandparticularlyanywithlarge/heavytires(rememberhowradiusoftirefiguresinthe
equationforbraketorquerequired?)
FollowalongasIinstallahydroboostbrakingsystemfromVANCOPowerBrakeSupply
Vancoofferseparatecomponentsforhydroboostbrakesorcompletekits,includingnewpowersteeringpumps.
Inmycase,runningfullhydrosteering,Ialreadyhadapowerfulpump,soIorderedakitwithhydraulicbooster,newmastercylinder,and
allthelinesandfittingsrequired.
Everythinginsidetheboxwaswellprotectedduringshippingwithfoampackingmaterial.
Thekitcamecompletewitheverythingrequiredplussomedecentprintedinstructionsandsomecoolstickers.
Insidethebox.
Thecompletecontentsofmykit.
Vanincludesallthefittingsyouwillneed,aswellasgenerouslengthsofhosesothatyoucancustommakethelinesforexactfit.
Thesystemuses"fieldattachable"hydraulicfittings,whichnotonlymakeinstallationeasyandneat,butalsomakeanyfuturehose
repair/replacementdeadeasy.
Alsoincludedarethenecessaryadaptersforthebooster,pspump,andsteeringboxtoconverttheentiresystem'splumbingto6AN.
Thesefittingsarecommon,easytoworkwith,andareavailablewithswivelendsineitherstraightor90*configurations.Allofwhich
makestheplumbingasnap.
Boosterwithnewmastercylinderattached.Notehowcompacttheboosteris.
Inthissideviewyoucanclearlyseethegoldcanofthenitrogenaccumulator.Justaboveityoucanseethehighpressureinletport
(fluidinfrompspump).
Inthisshotoftheothersideofthebooster,youcanseetheoutletportsonthemastercylinderandontheboostertheportforthehigh
pressuresupplyline(tosteeringbox/valve)andthefittingforthelowpressurereturnline(topsreservoir).
FormyinstallationIspecifiedthemountingplatebeatrightangles(90*)tothebooster,andthat'swhatIgot.
OneofthebeautiesoftheVancokitisthecustomfitofthebooster.Boththemountingplateandpedalrod,seenhere,arecustommade
byVancoforyourbooster,toyourexactspecifications.
Thismakesinstallationinanyvehicle,whetheritpreviouslyhadhydroboost,vacuumboost,ormanualbrakesa"boltin"affair.
ThemountingplatecanbeinstalledbyVancoatanyangleyouspecifytomatchtheangleofyourfirewall/mountingbracket,sothatthe
boosterandmastercylindersitlevelwheninstalled.Itwillalsobemadewithwhateverboltholepatternyouspecify.
Also,virtuallyanypushrodlengthorconfigurationwillbecustommadetofityourpedal.Becauseofmy"reversemount"pedal,Ispec'da
shortpushrodwith1/2"holeforthepedalpin.
Variousmastercylinder'sareavailabletomatchyourbrakingsystem'sneeds.
Mykitcamewithamassive15/16"mastercylinderpiston,hugebuiltinreservoirs,andnovalvinginthemastercylinder.
Thelargemastercylinderpistondiameterwilldisplacealotoffluidperfectforactuatingmy3/4ton4wheeldiscbrakesquickly,and
withshortpedalstroke.
Thehydroboostboosterwillsupplythepowernecessarytoactuatesuchalargepistonwithoutexperiencingaveryhardpedal.
Installationbeginswiththeremovalofthemastercylinderfromtheboostersothatthemastercylindercanbethoroughlybenchbled
beforeinstallation.
Theoutputrodofthebooster.
Inputsideofthemastercylinderpiston.
Tobenchbleedthemastercylinder:
Clampthemountingflangesecurelyinavice,makingsurethemastercylinderislevel(notethecardboardtoprotectthesurfaceofthe
flange).Donotclampanyotherpartofthemastercylinder.
Installanoldfittingandashortlengthofbrakelineineachoutletport,androutethelinesbackintothemastercylinderreservoirs.
Tightenthefittings
Fillthereservoirswithnew,qualitybrakefluid.
Markawoodendowelorsimilartool(hereIamusingthehandleofahammer)withtwolinesonethatlinesupwiththeendofthe
cylinderwhenthepistonisfullyrelaxed,andanotheraninchfromthat.
Whenbenchbleeding,youwanttoavoidusingtheentirestrokeofthepistonotherwiseaircancreeppasttheendsofthecupsealsin
thepistonbore.
Generally,3/4ofthestrokeofthepistonissufficient.Withatotalstrokeof11/2"Iamusing1"forbenchbleeding.
Carefullydepressthepistoninslow,evenstrokestoexpelalltheairfromthemastercylinder.Duringtheprocessyouwillobservetheair
bubblingoutfromthebleederlines,ascanbeseenhere.
Oncealltheairhasbeenremoved,reinstallthemastercylindercover,removethebleedinglines,reinstalltheplugsintheoutletports,
andsetthemastercylinderaside.
Next,preparetheboosterforinstallationbyinstallingtheconversionfittingsincludedinthekit.
Startbycarefullypryingtheplugsfromtheports.
Theboosterconversionfittingsuseasmalloringfittingontheendthatthreadsintothebooster.Theotherendisamale6AN.
Twodifferentsizefittingsareusedone18mmfortheinletport,andone16mmfortheoutlet.Onlyonefittingwillfitineachport.
Lubricatetheoringswithcleanpowersteeringfluidandinstallthemontheendsofthefittings.
Threadthefittingsintoplaceinthebooster,andcarefullytightenuntiltheoringseats.Gentlytightenanother1/4turn.Donotexceed20
ftlbswhentighteningthefittingsordamagetotheoringwilloccur.
Thefittingontheaccumulatorsideoftheboosteristhe18mm"in"portfromthepspump.
Thefittingontheotherside(nexttothelongreturnportnipple)isthe16mm"out"portthatgoestothesteering.
Withthenewmastercylinderandboosterreadyforinstallation,removetheoriginalbooster/mastercylinder.
Itooktheopportunitytocleanupthemountingbracketabit.
Don'tworrythatoverspraywon'thurtanything.
Ifyoumeasuredthemountingboltpatterncarefullypriortoordering,thenewboosterwillboltrightinplace.
Looselybolttheboostertothebracket/firewall,andmountthenewmastercylinderonthebooster.
Donottightenthefastenersyet.
Withtheboostermountedloosely,sothatyouhavesomeplay,installthepushrodonthepedal.
Makesureyouinstallanyrequiredhardware,dependingonyourpedal.
Herethepushrodissecuredwithacotterpin.
Tightentheboostermountingfastenersto2530ftlbs.
Itisextremelyimportantatthisstagetocheckthatthepushrodisstraightandlevelfromthepedaltothebooster.Nomorethan5*of
misalignmentispermissible,otherwiseboosterwear/damagewillresult.
Itisalsoveryimportanttocheckthatthereisalittleplayor"jiggle"inthepedalwiththeboosterinstalled.Withoutalittleplay,the
hydroboostwillconstantlyengagethebrakes,leadingtorapidbrakewear.
Thisvideoclipshowswhattheproperamountofplaylookslikeatthepushrod.
Anothervideoclipshowingproperplayinthepedal.
Beforetighteningthenutsthatsecurethemastercylindertothebooster,reconnectthefrontandrearbrakelinesatthemastercylinder.
Havingalittleplaywiththemastercylinderloosecanaidinliningupthebrakelinesandgettingthefittingsstartedintheports.
Ifthemastercylinder'sreservoirsarenotequalinsize,connecttheoutletofthelargerreservoirtothefrontbrakes.
Withtheboostermountedsecurely,pedalconnected,andthebrakelinesreconnected,tightenthemastercylindermountingnutsto20
25ft/lbs.
Plumbing
Thefinalstepisplumbingthehydroboostinlinewiththepowersteeringcircuit.Alltheadapters,fittings,andlinesareincludedtoconvertthehydrauliccircuitto6ANwhichisaniceupgradeallbyitself.
Theplumbingcircuit,shownbelowisidenticalwhetheryouhavenormalpowersteeringor,asinmycase,fullhydraulicsteering.Forfullhydro,simplyreplacethesteeringgearboxinthediagramwiththe
hydraulicsteeringunit(oftenerroneouslycalledthe"orbitalvalve").
Fluidflowisasfollows:RESERVOIR>PUMP>BOOSTER>STEERING>COOLER>FILTER>RESERVOIR.
Technically,thecoolerandfilterare"optional"butIHIGHLYrecommendyouinstallthem.Iaddedasmallautotransmissioncoolerandmyreservoirhasabuiltinfilter.
Itgoeswithoutsayingthatyouneedagood,strongpspumpingoodcondition.Ifindoubt,replaceit.
Stepone,ifrequired,istoremovethestockoutletfittingfromyourpspumpandreplaceitwithoneofthesupplied6ANadapters.Inthe
caseofGMstylesaginawpumpslikemine,therearefouradaptersincluded:
Twoare"invertedflare"fittings(one5/8"&one11/16")forearly(to1977)pumps
Twoare"oring"fittings(one16mm&one18mm)forlater(1978+)pumps.
Hereyoucanseetheadapterfittinginthepspumpoutletport,andthehighpressuresupplylineconnected.
IfyouareusingatraditionalSaginawsteeringgearbox,youwillalsohavetoinstalloneofthesupplied6ANadapterfittingsintothe
highpressure"in"portofthesteeringbox(normallytheforward/enginesideport).
Withfullhydraulicsteering,mysteeringunitalreadyuses6ANfittings,asshownhere.
Withallfittingsconvertedto6An,youcanmakeandinstallthehoses.
Takeyourtimemeasuringforandmakingthehoses.Clearinstructionsareincludedforcuttingthehoseandinstallingtheendfittings
allthatisneededisahacksawandacoupleofwrenches.
Routethehosesasfollows,beingsuretoavoidsharpedges,heatsources,andexcessivelytightbends:
Installonehighpressurelinefromthepspumpoutlettotheboosterinlet(reservoirside)
Installtheotherhighpressurelinefromtheboosteroutlettothesteeringboxorhydraulicsteeringunit.
InstallthesuppliedTfittingintothereservoir'sreturnline,asshownhere.
Usingthesuppliedlowpressurehoseandahoseclamp,connectonesideoftheTtothebooster'sreturnlinefitting(thelongertube
stickingoutofthebooster).
LeavetheothersideoftheTopenfornow.
Runanotherlowpressurereturnlinefromthesteeringbox/unit'sreturnporttothecooler.
MakesurethelinefromthesteeringunitenterstheBOTTOMofthecoolerandexitsthetop(toavoidtrappingairinthecooler.)
Routetheuppercoolerportbackthroughafilter...
...andintotheothersideoftheT.
Securealllowpressurelinestotheirfittingswithhoseclamps.
Donotovertightenthehighpressure6ANswivelfittings.
Completedplumbingatbooster.
Onceinstallationiscomplete,bleedthebrakesfirst(engineoff)anthenproceedtobleedthehydroboostsystem.
Useahighqualitypowersteeringfluidforyourpowersteeringandhydroboost.DonotuseATFasitismoreeasilysubjecttoaeration,
frothing,andcavitation(leadingtopumpnoiseandfailure.)
Thefollowingismyprocedureforbleedingthehydroboost:
HydroboostBleeding
1.Fillpowersteeringreservoirwithpowersteeringfluidtoproperlevelandallowthefluidtoremainundisturbedfortwominutes.
2.Disconnectcoilwireandcrankenginetooperatepumpandflowfluidthroughentirecircuit.Crankinshortbursts.Whennomoreairappearstobubbleoutandfluidlevelremainsconstant,reconnect
coilwire.
3.Startengineandallowittorunfor10seconds.Stopengineandcheckfluidlevel.Addfluidifnecessary.Repeatuntilfluidlevelremainsconstantafterenginehasrun.
4.Raisefrontwheelsclearofground.Startengineandturnsteeringwheelfromstoptostoptwice.Stopengineandpumpbrakepedalfourorfivetimestorelieveaccumulatorpressure.
5.Checkfluidlevel,addifnecessary.
6.Startengineandrunatapproximately1,500RPM.Pumpbrakepedalseveraltimes.Turnsteeringwheelfromstoptostop,lightlycontactingwheelstops,severaltimes.
7.Stopengineandcheckfluidlevel.Iffluidisfoamy,letsituntilclearoffoam.Addfluidifnecessary.
8.Lowerfrontwheelstoground.Startengineandrunatapproximately1,500RPM.Pumpbrakepedalseveraltimeswhileturningsteeringwheelfromstoptostop,lightlycontactingwheelstops.
9.Stopengineandpumpbrakepedalfourorfivetimestorelieveaccumulatorpressure.Checkfluidlevel.Addfluidifnecessary.
10.Iffluidisextremelyfoamy,allowthevehicletostandforonehourwiththeengineoff,thenrepeatsteps1through10.
ThepresenceoftrappedairinthesystemwillcauseNoise(cavitation),fluidfoaming,andthefluidlevelinthereservoir(pump)torisewhentheengineisturnedoff.
Conclusion
IcanSTOP!FortoolongIsufferedwithmanualbrakes.Ihadoncetriedahydroboostconversionwithjunkyardpartsnotonlydidtheboosternotboostthebrakes,itplayedhavocwithmy
hydraulicsteering.NosuchworrieswiththiskitfromVanco.Whathastobeoneofthequickestandeasiestinstall'sI'vedonealsonettedgreatresults.NowIcanstoponadime,and,justasimportantly,
holdtheriginanyposition,foraslongasIlike,withverylittlelegeffortrequired.Thisisasuperbupgradeforsteepclimbsandbigbouldercrawling.Ifyou'venotdrivenhydroboostbrakesbefore,youwill
beamazedatthestoppingpoweryouwillhave.Asthisisessentiallythesamesystemasinmy2007Chevy3/4tontowrig(thathasGVWRof9200lbs!!)I'mwellsetnowforwhenIinstallthattorquey
newGenIVV8andlowstallautoI'vehadmyeyeon!
References:
"BrakeHandbook".FredPuhnHPBooks,1985
"EngineertoWin".CarrollSmithMotorbooksInternational,1985
"Nuts,Bolts,Fasteners,andPlumbingHandbook".CarrollSmithMotorbooksInternational,1990
1981LightDutyTruckServiceManual.GeneralMotorsCorporation,1980
VANCOPowerBrakeSupplyhttp://www.vancopbs.com
Sources:
VANCOPowerBrakeSupply
9738AtlanticAvenue
SouthGate,California,90280
(323)5631588/(800)2566295
http://www.vancopbs.com
vancopbs@aol.com