Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Lawrence R. Schiller, MD
systems in the regulation of ion transport by the mucosa. Classification of Diarrheal Diseases
Efforts to modulate this system with drugs may produce With so many potential causes for diarrhea, classification is
new classes of antidiarrheal agents in the future. useful in order to limit the number of possibilities that the
The importance of inflammation to the pathogenesis clinician must include in his or her differential diagnosis.
of secretory diarrhea in the absence of tissue disruption is Several classifications have been proposed.
exemplified by microscopic colitis syndrome (lymphocytic
colitis and collagenous colitis). In this condition the Acute versus chronic diarrhea
colonic mucosa is grossly normal, but there is histologic One of the simplest schemes for classifying diarrhea is by
evidence of mucosal inflammation with intraepithelial duration of the complaint. The moot point is where to
lymphocytes and an expanded lamina propria inflamma- draw the line between acute and chronic diarrhea. Experts
tory cell infiltrate. Under intestinal perfusion conditions, vary in their recommendations from as little as 2 weeks to
fluid and electrolyte absorption is inversely proportional as long as 8 weeks [26]. The main purpose of this divi-
to the intensity of mucosal inflammation [21]. sion is to separate cases that are likely to be infectious and
self-limited from cases that can have any of the many
Dysregulation causes of chronic diarrhea. At our institution we use 4
Secretory diarrhea may occur as a complication of dia- weeks as a dividing point.
betic autonomic neuropathy [2124]. Abnormal function
of the enteric nervous system may alter the dynamics of Osmotic versus secretory diarrhea
intestinal fluid and electrolyte absorption or motility As mentioned above, analysis of stool electrolytes allows
[2224]. Similar difficulties may occur in patients who the clinician to categorize diarrhea as osmotic or secretory
develop diarrhea after vagotomy, sympathectomy, or [3]. Whereas finding an osmotic diarrhea produces a short
celiac plexus neurolysis. list of suspect conditions, finding a secretory diarrhea
leaves many possibilities. Consequently, exclusive use of
Luminal secretagogues this classification scheme is not recommended.
In addition to bacterial toxins, bile acids, fatty acids, and
some laxatives can act as luminal secretagogues. Bile Watery versus fatty versus inflammatory diarrhea
acids and fatty acids that evade absorption in the small Another way of classifying diarrheal diseases is by the
intestine reduce absorption or promote secretion in the characteristics of the stool. Watery diarrhea is character-
colon in a dose-related fashion [1]. This can occur in a ized as very liquid stools without evidence of blood, pus,
number of scenarios. Patients with terminal ileal disease or fat. The implication of watery diarrhea is that either an
or resection routinely malabsorb bile acid, but the bile osmotically active substance or unabsorbed electrolytes
acid concentration in the colon may not reach the cathar- cause excess water to be retained intraluminally. Fatty
tic threshold (35 mmol/L) if water absorption is com- diarrhea (steatorrhea) suggests the presence of a condi-
promised concurrently. Patients who have undergone tion reducing fat absorption in the small intestine.
cholecystectomy keep their bile acid pool in the intestine Inflammatory diarrhea is characterized as stools with pus
(because there is no gallbladder to serve as a reservoir for or blood, suggesting disruption of the mucosa by infec-
bile), where it can be swept into the colon by the interdi- tion or inflammation.
gestive migrating motor complex during the night; some Recently, an expert committee of physicians from the
patients develop a secretory diarrhea that is responsive to American College of Gastroenterology [27] and the Prac-
bile acid sequestering agents. Patients with short-bowel tice Economics Committee of the American Gastroentero-
syndrome may deliver sufficient long-chain fatty acids to logical Association [28] endorsed the use of these stool
the colon to impair absorption. Most nonosmotic laxa- characteristics as a way to classify diarrhea in evaluation of
tives also work as intraluminal secretagogues, but some patients who suffer from it. Combining all of these classifi-
only do so after metabolism by the colonic flora. cation schemes should allow for more efficient diagnosis,
although this has not been proven scientifically (Table 1).
Circulating secretagogues
Tumors of endocrine cells in the gut, pancreas, and else-
where can produce sufficiently high circulating levels of Evaluation of Patients with Diarrhea
secretagogues in the blood to inhibit absorption or to pro- Before assessing the cause of diarrhea or attempting
duce secretion by the intestine. Although gastroenterolo- empiric therapy it is essential for the clinician to evaluate
gists and internists often consider the existence of these the patients fluid and electrolyte status [26,27]. Diar-
tumors when caring for patients with secretory diarrhea, rhea can be life threatening if volume or electrolyte deple-
they are actually quite rare. Estimates of prevalence range tion has occurred. Orthostatic changes in pulse and blood
from one per 1000 to one per 10,000 patients with chronic pressure should be measured. Patients with long-standing
diarrhea. Thus, the chance of finding any of these tumors is or voluminous diarrhea should have serum electrolyte con-
very low in evaluation of a given patient [25]. centrations assayed. Intravenous or oral rehydration and
Secretory Diarrhea Schiller 393
electrolyte repletion takes precedence over diagnosis in the is some controversy about whether biopsy can be justified
management of these patients. and about the choice of technique for visualizing the
Diagnostic evaluation of patients with diarrhea should colonic mucosa. Some authors believe that the yield of
be directed at the most likely possibilities [26,27,28, biopsy in unselected patients with chronic diarrhea is too
29,31]. This judgment, in turn, depends on the patients low in relation to the risk of the procedure, and others
history and on the classification of the diarrhea. Historical disagree [3435]. In my opinion, patients with chronic
features that should be elicited from the patient are out- continuous diarrhea (as opposed to intermittent diarrhea,
lined in Table 2. Physical findings are of little use in most which is more characteristic of irritable bowel syndrome)
patients with diarrhea, but occasionally they can be valu- ought to have biopsies obtained [26]. Most disorders
able [26,27,28,29,31]. For example, flushing, that produce gross or histologic findings can be diagnosed
hepatomegaly, and a heart murmur may be clues to the by means of sigmoidoscopy and biopsy, but some lesions
diagnosis of carcinoid syndrome. exclusively in the right colon will be missed without a full
Because most acute diarrhea resolves spontaneously colonoscopy, especially in patients with AIDS [37].
without specific therapy, the clinician must establish which An e mp iri c tr ia l of a b ile a ci d seq ue ste ri ng re sin
patients with acute diarrhea require a more extensive diag- (eg, cholestyramine) may be more germane than direct
nostic evaluation. Patients with acute diarrhea who have measurement of bile acid absorption, which is often
high fever, prostration, volume depletion, severe abdominal abnormal in patients with chronic diarrhea, because such
pain, blood or pus in the stool, or a protracted course of measurements do not predict responsiveness to these
symptoms (>96 hours) should undergo the following tests: agents [38,39]. Testing for secretagogue-induced diarrhea
complete blood count, serum electrolyte panel, serum creat- should be selective, based on findings of a tumor on CT
inine and blood urea nitrogen assays, stool bacterial culture, scanning or presentation with a typical tumor syndrome
stool ova and parasite examination, and C. difficile toxin titer because the pretest probability of tumor-associated
(if the patient was treated with antimicrobials within 90 diarrhea is very low [25]. Measurement of plasma peptide
days or if the patient is a health care worker or resident in an concentrations should be limited to those peptides with
institution with a high rate of C. difficile infection) [32]. If well-described tumor syndromes, gastrin, calcitonin, vaso-
the diagnosis is still obscure and the diarrhea continues, rec- active intestinal polypeptide, and somatostatin. Urine test-
tal biopsy should be considered in order to differentiate self- ing for 5-hydroxyindole acetic acid, metanephrines, and
limited colitis from early idiopathic inflammatory bowel histamine can be used to screen for carcinoid syndrome,
disease [33]. Symptomatic management with oral fluids and pheochromocytoma, and mastocytosis. Other assessment
antidiarrheal drugs should be sufficient for most other measures that occasionally aid in diagnosis of patients
patients. Travelers who develop diarrhea during or shortly with chronic diarrhea include thyroid tests, tests of adrenal
after a trip may not need specific testing before starting sufficiency, serum protein electrophoresis, and quantita-
empiric antibiotic therapy [32]. tion of immunoglobulins [26,27,28,29,30,31].
Chronic diarrhea (ie, diarrhea that lasts more than 4
weeks) is less likely to be caused by infections and has a
broader differential diagnosis. Efforts to further classify the Nonspecific Treatment
type of diarrhea by examining stools for the presence of Although the goal for a clinician evaluating a patients diar-
occult blood (guaiac testing), leukocytes (Wrights stain or rhea is to find a specifically treatable disorder, this goal is
fecal lactoferrin assay), and fat (Sudan stain) can be useful not always met, and nonspecific therapy must be used.
[26]. Stool sodium and potassium assays and stool pH Nonspecific agents also can be helpful when a diagnosis is
can be used to further classify watery diarrhea as osmotic established but specific therapy is not available or has not
or secretory (Fig. 1) [3]. These tests can be done on spot been effective.
samples or on a quantitative stool collection. Quantitative Oral rehydration solutions have saved the lives of
collection for 48 or 72 hours provides a better idea of stool many patients with acute diarrhea and have allowed some
output and fat excretion, but it is not essential for classifi- patients with chronic diarrhea to do without intravenous
cation. Once these tests have been completed, further eval- fluid replacement. The principle behind their use is that
uation can proceed depending upon the classification of nutrients such as glucose and amino acids are transported
the diarrhea (Fig. 2). across the apical membrane of the enterocyte by a carrier
For chronic secretory diarrhea, further evaluation that cotransports sodium [40]. Unlike apical sodium
should include bacterial culture and examination of stool hydrogen exchange, nutrientsodium cotransport is not
for other pathogens, including parasites such as cryptospo- impeded by elevated intracellular cyclic AMP levels, so
ridia and microsporidia. Structural disease of the intestine that efforts to stimulate sodium entry by providing nutri-
should be excluded with small bowel radiography, small ents and salt can be very successful. Total intestinal perfu-
bowel biopsy and aspirate for quantitative bacterial sion studies in humans given cholera toxin show that the
culture, computerized tomography of the abdomen, and mechanism of enhanced sodium absorption involves not
colonoscopy or sigmoidoscopy with colonic biopsy. There only cotransport across the apical membrane but also an
394 Small Intestine
Figure 1. Flow chart or mind map for the evaluation of chronic diarrhea. Initial efforts should be directed to the classification of chronic
diarrhea, based on history, physical examination, basic laboratory tests, and stool analysis. From Fine and Schiller [26]; with permission.
element of solvent drag across tight junctions [41]. Recent intestine and increasing contact time, thereby allowing
work has emphasized the usefulness of complex carbohy- more time for absorption to occur. Opiates such as
drates that allow ingestion of a hypotonic oral rehydra- codeine seem to work mainly by the latter mechanism
tion fluid, which can be more effective than traditional [43]. A new agent, acetorphan, inhibits enkephalinase
glucose-based fluids [42]. It is important to note that oral activity in the intestine, allowing prolonged stimulation
rehydration fluids are not designed to reduce stool vol- of d-opiate receptors by endogenous opiates and increas-
ume as much as to increase net sodium chloride absorp- ing the net rate of absorption by the mucosa [44]. This
tion. Consequently, the adequacy of rehydration should agent offers the prospect of reducing diarrhea without
be judged by increased body weight and reduction of producing rebound constipation.
blood urea nitrogen and serum creatinine, not by changes Clonidine is another agent that can increase the rate of
in stool output. absorption by the mucosa [45]. In addition, clonidine can
Traditional antidiarrheal medications depend on slow transit, increasing net absorption by increasing con-
increasing the rate of fluid and electrolyte absorption by tact time. This seemingly ideal combination of effects has
the intestinal mucosa or slowing transit through the been difficult to employ clinically because of the central
Secretory Diarrhea Schiller 395
Figure 2. Flow charts or mind maps for further evaluation of secretory diarrhea (upper left), osmotic diarrhea (upper right),
inflammatory diarrhea (lower left), and fatty diarrhea (lower right). Every test in a given pathway need not be done once a
diagnosis is reached. From Fine and Schiller [26]; with permission.
hypotensive effect of clonidine. Efforts to design nonhy- Patients with high-volume diarrheas can have a 30% to
potensive a2-adrenergic agonists have been stymied. 40% reduction of stool output with octreotide, but this
Octreotide, a somatostatin analogue, is useful in the result is often insufficient to allow elimination of supple-
treatment of tumor syndromes, such as carcinoid syn- mental intravenous fluids.
drome or VIPoma. In these conditions, octreotide reduces
tumor secretion of the secretagogue and may have an
antitumor effect by reducing trophic factors released else- Conclusions
where. Octreotide has been employed in secretory diar- Secretory diarrhea is a common condition, and yet there is
rhea of nontumor origin with mixed results [46,47]. much more to learn about it. The evaluative scheme pre-
396 Small Intestine
sented in this article needs to be tested prospectively to assess 20. Sellin JH: Functional anatomy, fluid and electrolyte
its cost effectiveness and sensitivity in identifying treatable absorption. In Gastroenterology and Hepatology:
The Comprehensive Visual Reference, vol 7, Small Intestine.
causes of diarrhea. Better nonspecific therapies would be Edited by Feldman M, Schiller LR. Philadelphia:
helpful for many patients with acute and chronic diarrhea. Current Medicine; 1997:1.11.14.
21. Lee E, Schiller LR, Fordtran JS: Quantification of colonic
lamina propria cells by means of a morphometric point-
counting method. Gastroenterology 1988, 94:409418.
References and Recommended Reading 22. Karras PJ, Pfeifer MA: Diabetic gastrointestinal autonomic
Recently published papers of particular interest neuropathy. Curr Ther Endocrinol Metab 1997, 6:462465.
are highlighted as: 23. Saslow SB, Camilleri M: Diabetic diarrhea. Semin Gastrointest
Of importance Dis 1995, 6:187193.
Of major importance 24. Rosa-e-Silva L, Troncon LE, Oliveira RB, et al.: Rapid distal
small bowel transit associated with sympathetic denervation
1. Schiller LR: Secretory diarrhea. In Gastroenterology and in type I diabetes mellitus. Gut 1996, 39:748756.
Hepatology: The Comprehensive Visual Reference, vol 7, Small 25. Schiller LR, Rivera LM, Santangelo WC, et al.: Diagnostic
Intestine. Edited by Feldman M, Schiller LR. Philadelphia: value of fasting plasma peptide concentrations in patients
Current Medicine; 1997:4.14.24. with chronic diarrhea. Dig Dis Sci 1994, 39:22162222.
2. Wenzl HH, Fine KD, Schiller LR, Fordtran JS: Determinants 26. Fine KD, Schiller LR: American Gastroenterological Associa-
of decreased fecal consistency in patients with diarrhea. tion technical review on the evaluation and management of
Gastroenterology 1995, 108:17291738. chronic diarrhea. Gastroenterology 1999, 116:14641486.
3. Eherer AJ, Fordtran JS: Fecal osmotic gap and pH in Detailed review of diagnostic tests used in the evaluation of chronic
experimental diarrhea of various causes. Gastroenterology diarrhea, which also offers suggested approach.
1992, 103:545551. 27. Brandt LJ, Greenwald D: Acute and Chronic Diarrhea:
4. Fordtran JS, Santa Ana CA, Morawski SG, et al.: Pathophysi- A Primer on Diagnosis and Treatment. Arlington, VA:
ology of chronic diarrhea: insights derived from intestinal American College of Gastroenterology; 1997.
perfusion studies in 31 patients. Gastroenterol Clin North Am 28. Clinical Practice and Practice Economics Committee: American
1986, 15:477490. Gastroenterological Association medical position statement:
5. Guerrant RL: Lessons from diarrheal diseases: demography to Guidelines for the evaluation and management of chronic
molecular pharmacology. J Infect Dis 1994, 169:12061218. diarrhea. Gastroenterology 1999, 116:14611464.
6. DuPont HL: Review article: infectious diarrhea. Aliment 29. Donowitz M, Kokke FT, Saidi R: Evaluation of patients
Pharmacol Ther 1994, 8:313. with chronic diarrhea. N Engl J Med 1995, 332:725729.
7. Giannella RA: Infections of the intestine. In Gastroenterology Expert review of practical approaches to this patient population.
and Hepatology: The Comprehensive Visual Reference, vol 7, Small 30. Powell DW: Approach to the patient with diarrhea. In Textbook
Intestine. Edited by Feldman M, Schiller LR. Philadelphia: of Gastroenterology, edn 2. Edited by Yamada T. Philadelphia:
Current Medicine; 1997:12.112.19. Lippincott; 1995:813863.
8. Popoff MR: Interactions between bacterial toxins and Scientifically based review of the evaluation of patients with acute
intestinal cells. Toxicon 1998, 36:665685. and chronic diarrhea.
9. Phalipon A, Sansonetti PJ: Microbial-host interactions 31. Fine KD: Diarrhea. In Gastrointestinal and Hepatic Disease: Patho-
at mucosal sites. Host response to pathogenic bacteria physiology, Diagnosis, Management, edn 6. Edited by
at mucosal sites. Curr Top Microbiol Immunol 1999, Feldman M, Scharschmidt BF, Sleisenger MH. Philadelphia:
236:163189. Saunders; 1998:128152.
10. Lundgren O: 5-hydroxytryptamine, enterotoxins, and intestinal Clinically oriented approach to this complex symptom.
fluid secretion [editorial]. Gastroenterology 1998, 115:883890. 32. DuPont HL: Guidelines on acute infectious diarrhea in
11. Forte LR, Currie MG: Guanylin: a peptide regulator of adults. Am J Gastroenterol 1997, 92:19621975.
epithelial transport. FASEB J 1995, 9:643650. 33. Jenkins D, Goodall A, Scott BB: Simple objective criteria for
12. Blaser MJ: Epidemiologic and clinical features of Campylobacter diagnosis of causes of acute diarrhoea on rectal biopsy.
jejuni infections. J Infect Dis 1997, 176 (suppl 2):S103S105. J Clin Pathol 1997, 50:580585.
13. Slutsker L, Ries AA, Maloney K, et al.: A nationwide case- 34. Marshall JB, Singh R, Diaz-Arias AA: Chronic, unexplained
control study of Escherichia coli O157:H7 infection in the diarrhea: are biopsies necessary if colonoscopy is normal?
United States. J Infect Dis 1998, 177:962966. Am J Gastroenterol 1995, 90:372376.
14. Slutsker L, Ries AA, Greene KD, et al.: Escherichia 35. Robinson RJ, Stone M, Mayberry JF: Normal rectal mucosa.
coli O157:H7 diarrhea in the United States: clinical Should we biopsy? Hepatogastroenterology 1997, 44:703705.
and epidemiologic features. Ann Intern Med 1997, 36. Patel Y, Pettigrew NM, Grahame GR, Bernstein CN: The
126:505513. diagnostic yield of lower endoscopy plus biopsy in
15. Kelly CP, LaMont JT: Clostridium difficile infection. Ann Rev nonbloody diarrhea. Gastrointest Endosc 1997, 46:338343.
Med 1998, 49:375390. 37. Bini EJ, Weinshel EH: Endoscopic evaluation of chronic
16. Fekety R: Guidelines for the diagnosis and management human immunodeficiency virus-related diarrhea:
of Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea and colitis. is colonoscopy superior to flexible sigmoidoscopy?
Am J Gastroenterol 1997, 92:739750. Am J Gastroenterol 1998, 93:5660.
17. Arrambide KA, Santa Ana CA, Schiller LR, et al.: Loss of 38. Schiller LR, Hogan RB, Morawski SG, et al.: Studies
absorptive capacity for sodium chloride as a cause of of the prevalence and significance of radiolabeled
diarrhea following partial ileal and right colon resection. bile acid malabsorption in a group of patients with
Dig Dis Sci 1989, 34:193201. idiopathic chronic diarrhea. Gastroenterology
1997, 92:151160.
18. Aichbichler BW, Zerr CH, Santa Ana CA, et al.: Brief report:
proton-pump inhibition of gastric chloride secretion in 39. Potter GD: Bile acid diarrhea. Dig Dis 1998, 16:118124.
congenital chloridorrhea. N Engl J Med 1997, 336:106109. 40. Farthing MJ: Oral rehydration therapy. Pharmacol Ther 1994,
19. Perdue MH, McKay DM: Integrative immunophysiology in the 64:477492.
intestinal mucosa. Am J Physiol 1994, 267:G151G165. 41. Schiller LR, Santa Ana CA, Porter JA, et al.: Glucose-
stimulated sodium transport by the human intestine
during experimental cholera. Gastroenterology 1997,
112:15291535.
Secretory Diarrhea Schiller 397
42. Thillainayagam AV, Hunt JB, Farthing MJ: Enhancing clinical 45. Schiller LR, Santa Ana CA, Morawski SG, et al.: Studies of the
efficacy of oral rehydration therapy: is low osmolality the antidiarrheal action of clonidine: effects on motility and
key? Gastroenterology 1998, 114:197-210. intestinal absorption. Gastroenterology 1985, 89:982988.
43. Schiller LR: Review article: anti-diarrhoeal pharmacology 46. Farthing MJ: The role of somatostatin analogues in the
and therapeutics. Aliment Pharmacol Ther 1995, 9:87-106. treatment of refractory diarrhoea. Digestion 1996, 57
Review of currently available and investigational antidiarrheal agents. (suppl 1):107113.
44. Roge J, Baumer P, Berard H, et al.: The enkephalinase inhibitor, 47. Simon DM, Cello JP, Valenzuela J, et al.: Multicenter trial of
acetorphan, in acute diarrhea: a double-blind, controlled octreotide in patients with refractory acquired immunodefi-
clinical trial versus loperamide. Scand J Gastroenterol 1993, ciency syndrome-associated diarrhea. Gastroenterology 1995,
28:352354. 108:17531760.