Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
VALUE CODE
How Successful Businesses Are
Creating Wealth in the New Economy
RICHARD E.S. BOULTON
BARRY D. LIBERT
STEVE M. SAMEK
RICHARD BOULTON is Arthur Andersens worldwide managing partner for strategy and planning. He is
responsible for the companys global service offerings and Internet based knowledge businesses. Mr.
Boulton is a graduate of Oxford University and is based in London and Chicago.
BARRY LIEBERT is an Arthur Andersen partner who consults and lectures on value creation in the New
Economy and how that impacts business models, corporate investment and technology strategies. He is a
graduate of the Columbia Business School and is based in Boston.
STEVE SAMEK is managing partner of Arthur Andersens U.S. Operations. He manages more than 25,000
professionals, and has a 26-year career with the company, and is a member of the firms Board of Partners.
The authors have established a Web site for their ideas on value creation at www.arthurandersen.com/value.
SUMMARIES.COM is a concentrated business information service. Every week, subscribers are e-mailed a
concise summary of a different business book. Each summary is about 8 pages long and contains the
stripped-down essential ideas from the entire book in a time-saving format. By investing less than one hour
per week in these summaries, subscribers gain a working knowledge of the top business titles. Subscriptions
are available on a monthly or yearly basis. Further information is available at http://www.summaries.com.
Cracking The Value Code - Page 1
MAIN IDEA
Successful organizations are creating value in completely new
and original ways today which take advantage of the opportunities Design your business model
The 1
of the New Economy. tangible & intangible assets
The four realities of creating value in the New Economy are: Value
Creation Master risk
1. New business models are needed which combine tangible 2
Process learn to use it productively
and intangible assets together in different combinations.
2. These new business models use risk proactively, 3 Manage your asset portfolio
harnessing it to accelerate the creation of value. with new tools & systems
3. Long-term success requires the asset base to be increased Measure and report all assets
4
and enhanced. To achieve that, businesses need new tools information transparency
and processes for setting strategy, running operations,
managing risk and using information effectively.
4. The old preference for proprietary, internal information is being superceded by real-time access to all information by stakeholders
in the creation of value process -- that is, transparency and disclosure.
In short, companies today are racing to find the right combination of tangible and intangible assets that will create the greatest
amount of value in the New Economy. Managers that succeed in cracking the creation of value code for their own businesses have a
great opportunity to create significant value during a time of rapid change.
Master risk
2
learn to use it productively
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Page 4
Any time a new business model is created, it also creates new risks. But in the New Economy, risk carries
with it upside opportunity as well as a downside threat.
The second challenge of succeeding in the New Economy is to understand that if you build a business that
doesnt take any risks, you wont make any money. Therefore, figure out how much risk youre able to
handle.
Physical Assets These businesses use their financial assets (cash, cash flow,
(Land, buildings, equipment, inventory) receivables, investments and relationships with providers of
debt and equity) in such a way that creates a sustainable
Financial Assets competitive advantage. For example:
(Cash, receivables, debt, investment, equity)
n Microsoft has around $19 billion in cash allowing it to make
Organizational Assets acquisitions quickly.
Value (Leadership, strategy, structure, culture, n Dell Computer Corporation receives payment for its products
Dynamics brands, know-how, systems, processes, before paying its suppliers allowing it to fund growth itself
knowledge, intellectual property) rather than bringing in more equity capital.
n Lucent Technologies Inc. has created a $100 million venture
Customer Assets capital fund which, in turn, has increased Lucents own
(Customers, channels, affiliates)
market capitalization by much more.
Employee/Supplier Assets n Amazon.com Inc. is financing its own growth through $1.5
(Employees, suppliers, partners) billion of high-yield convertible bonds allowing it to postpone
interest payments for 5-years.
Note that from a Value Dynamics point-of-view, assets: n Cisco Systems Inc. uses its own stock to make acquisitions
n Are both tangible and intangible. rather than cash thereby creating a company with a still
higher market capitalization.
n Are defined as sources of future value.
n The General Electric Company derives a large proportion of
n Need not necessarily be owned and controlled by the
its value from GE Capital Services, the largest equipment
company to have the potential to create value.
lessor on earth.
n Must be managed through their life cycles.
Cracking The Value Code - Page 3
Organizational assets are both structural and intellectual Employee and supplier assets (all the members of the supply
(strategy, culture, processes, systems, brands, the ability to chain including partners as well as employees) harness the
innovate and proprietary knowledge). As well as providing the elements of their inbound supply chains to generate value better
glue to hold a business together, these assets can generate than their competitor. For example:
substantial wealth in the New Economy. For example: n DaimlerChrysler AG works closely with its suppliers to reduce
n International Business Machines Corporation has seen its the cost of manufacture of its entire product line.
market valuation increase from $29 billion in 1993 to $195 n Virgin Group Ltd. uses its 25,000 employees and numerous
billion at the end of 1997 through strong leadership. joint venture arrangements to build a conglomerate that now
n Johnson & Johnson used a decentralized business structure generates more than $5 billion in annual revenues.
with 33 lines of business to generate $3.5 billion of income in n Psion PLC saw its stock price increase from $3.30 a share to
1999 generating a market value of $130 billion. $16.00 a share when it announced it was partnering with
n Pfizer Inc. excels at bringing new drugs to the market Nokia and Ericsson to generate a new generation of mobile
generating revenue growth of 20-percent a year. communication devices.
n Starbucks Corporation succeeded in transforming a cup of
coffee into a brand which now generates more than $1.7 In creating the ideal business model for creating wealth in the
billion a year. New Economy, there are three key questions that must be
n Idealab! has, since 1996, started more than 25 Internet addressed:
businesses and generated significant amounts of value. 1. What assets are you currently using to create value and
how much value is each asset currently contributing?
Physical Assets
In other words, from the Value Dynamics perspective, what
Financial Assets assets are currently being used to generate the bulk of your
Value current revenues?
Dynamics Organizational Assets
2. What assets will you need to succeed in the New Economy?
Customer Assets Now, looking down the road, where do you expect the
greatest possible returns will be generated in the future, and
Employee/Supplier Assets
what assets will you require to prosper in that type of
business environment? What would be your ideal asset mix
Businesses that use their customer assets (end users, affiliates for the competitive realities of the New Economy?
and distribution channels) focus on creating wealth by owning
3. How will you take your asset mix from where it currently is
the chain that runs from the originator of goods and services to
now to where you want it to be in the future?
the ultimate consumer. By controlling this dimension of
There are several strategies available:
business, impressive value can be created. For example:
Build the new assets needed.
n Gap Inc. uses a variety of distribution channels to reach its Enhance the value of your current assets.
customers. The companys market capitalization of $39 Connect to the assets offered by strategic partners.
billion reflects that expertise. Turn nonperforming assets around.
n Duracell Inc. works closely with the developers of consumer Block competitors from duplicating you.
electronics to ensure its batteries end up in their products. As New business models are emerging all the time. There is a
a result, Duracell has an impressive market share and particular need to redesign business models at present to bring
corresponding valuation. them into shape for the upcoming demands of the new
n Autobytel.com Inc. operates an online matchmaking service Economy.
between car buyers and car dealerships. It now generates in In summary, designing a new business model simply means to
excess of $1.6 million an hour in car sales and has a market create a different combination of assets. Any business is defined
capitalization exceeding $300 million which is impressive and ultimately judged by its assets both tangible and
for a 5-year old company. intangible.
n The Charles Schwab Corporation has more than 6.4 million Those companies that succeed in securing the optimum
customers who have appointed the company to oversee $700 combination of assets position themselves advantageously in
billion in assets. The company generates in excess of $10 the marketplace. They provide an in-built opportunity to secure a
billion in securities transactions each week. That translates to competitive advantage since the best business models will
$4.3 billion in annual revenues for the company, and a market outperform all others in the conditions of the New Economy.
capitalization of $31 billion.
Cracking The Value Code - Page 4
n Business Models
3 Manage your asset portfolio The Internet has allowed new business models to spring up
with new tools & systems all over the New Economy effectively reducing the life span
of the business models which have historically been used.
One industry after another has seen dramatic new business
Main Idea models emerge only to be superceded by still newer models
as the Internet moves forward.
If you put in place a new business model and take new risks,
youll need new tools and processes to manage both. Against that background, it becomes increasingly clear being
able to know when to acquire, when to manage, when to renew
The third challenge of succeeding in the New Economy is to and when to dispose of assets is a critical skill in the New
develop the new tools and systems that will be needed to Economy.
manage your unique portfolio of assets.
To add to the challenge, each class of asset requires a different
Supporting Ideas management process aligned to the life cycle specifics:
Successful companies acquire, manage, renew and ultimately
dispose of individual assets in ways that create value for the
business as a whole. Value creation is directly and inescapably Assess needs and acquire
linked to asset management the best business model will be Physical
rendered ineffective if the company does not execute this step Assets Manage
well.
To manage assets effectively, managers must know and Enhance
understand the life cycle of each type of tangible and intangible
asset. To put it simply, every assets economic life has a
beginning, middle and end. Smart managers create value by Dispose
acquiring assets at the right time, by applying them well while
owned and then by disposing of them at the optimum moment.
For example, Priceline.com Inc. is creating value by disposing of
For example, consider the life cycles of various types of assets: any inventory assets of its own. It links the assets owned by its
n Buildings are constructed or purchased, utilized, renovated suppliers with customers through virtual auctions. As more and
and ultimately torn down. more consumers use the service, Priceline becomes more and
n Computer equipment is purchased, used, possibly upgraded more valuable to its suppliers by efficiently disposing of their
and then replaced by the next generation. excess inventory. This business has created a market value of
$6.9 billion on the strength of a business model which could not
n Customers are acquired, nurtured, served and ultimately
exist outside the New Economy.
replaced by new customers.
n Employees are recruited, trained, promoted, reassigned and
ultimately retire or leave to seek other employment. Evaluate options & structure offers
While these types of life cycles are well known, the New Financial
Economy has also generated a whole new set of life cycle Assets Manage finances
constraints on assets. For example:
n Fixed assets
Restructure financial operations
At one time, location was paramount. The Internet has
changed that entirely, and in the New Economy, physical
location is irrelevant if products and services are delivered Dispose or divest redundant assets
electronically.
n Telecommunications
At one time, whoever owned the wires around a city held the
key to customers. Today, satellites and cellular systems have Assess needs and design structure
rendered the telephone poles unnecessary. Internet Organizational
telephony will go even further, adding value to some Assets Develop & maintain systems & processes
telecommunication assets while making other redundant.
n Employee Skill Sets Codify and share knowledge
Many employees have spent years training to develop job
related skills only to find new technologies have completely
transformed the work environment making old skill sets Redirect assets
irrelevant.
n Customers For example, consider FDX Corporation. Most people assume
The Internet has dramatically increased the availability of the main asset of the company is its 600 aircraft and 40,000
options for consumers in virtually everything they need. vehicle delivery system. In reality, however, the companys most
Customers are in the driving seat today, using information valuable asset is an organizational asset its package tracking
technology to make better informed choices. Customer system which can determine electronically where a package is at
loyalty in the New Economy almost becomes a contradiction any point of its journey. This asset has become a key competitive
in terms. advantage and efficiency driver.
Cracking The Value Code - Page 6
Another business which exemplifies the use of organizational The key principle is that not only must a business bring together
assets to generate value is AT&T Corporation. In this case, the major assets which contribute value to its business model
AT&T created a huge amount of value (and increased the value but each of those assets must be managed well. Part of that
of itself) by spinning off two parts of itself into standalone management process involves taking into account the life cycle
companies NCR and Lucent Technologies Inc. of each. And another part is to understand how each asset
In other words, value can be created both ways: supports the business model as a whole.
1. By acquiring assets that are critical to your business model Key Thoughts
and managing them through their life cycle. In the past several decades, there has been a dramatic shift, a
2. By divesting of assets at the appropriate time in their life transformation, in what economists call the production functions
cycle. of companies the major assets that create value and growth.
Intangibles are fast becoming substitutes for physical assets. At
the same time, there has been complete stagnation in our
Understand needs and make offers measurement and reporting systems. Im not talking only about
Customer financial reports and Internet investments, but also internal
Assets Deliver products and provide services measurements accounting and reporting inside companies.
Baruch Lev, director,
Vincent C. Ross Institute for Accounting Research
Develop new products and services
Companies create value, and incur risk, by assembling unique
combinations of assets. It is this portfolio which we call the
Conclude customer relationship
business model, and it determines a companys economic
success. Since the dawn of the Industrial Age, great
For example, take the case of LinkExchange Inc. This Internet entrepreneurs have found new ways, and used the latest
start-up was founded in 1996 to help clients advertise on other technologies, to combine assets into business models of unique
Web sites. Within 18-months, it had 800,000 clients, 21 million power. This is what distinguished entrepreneurial giants like the
online users and more than 100 staff. The company excelled at 18th-century English potter Josiah Wedgwood, automaker
using Internet marketing to acquire active customers. Henry Ford and industrialist John D. Rockefeller.
LinkExchange was acquired by Microsoft for $265 million in Richard Boulton, Barry Libert, Steve Samek
late-1998 on the basis of those customer assets.
Companies that alter their business models in response to the
New Economy are taking risks, to be sure. But so are companies
Assess needs, recruit and hire
that elect to do nothing but stick with the tried-and-true.
Richard Boulton, Barry Libert, Steve Samek
Employee
and Develop and manage relationships Book value is meaningless as an indicator of intrinsic value.
Supplier Warren Buffet
Assets
Support and reward performance All the data we have so far, including those provided by the new
tools, focus inward. But inside an enterprise indeed, even
inside the entire economic chain there are only costs. Results
Redefine ongoing relationships
are only on the outside.
Peter Drucker
For example, Cisco Systems, Inc. has grown at an impressive
rate by excelling at acquiring employee assets. The companys Few managers fully understand that companies are built from
recruiters are innovative, and a Web based system is also used essential building blocks of assets, the processes used and the
which allows prospective employees to build a profile quickly measurement system that records success. Its important to see
and efficiently. These tools have allowed Cisco to build a high how assets relate to processes, how processes connect to
quality workforce. outcomes and how measurements relate to market results.
Otherwise, companies can become unrelated collections of
Similarly, Calyx & Corolla, Inc. Of San Francisco has built a $20 assets and processes. They lose track of their own basic
million business shipping flowers directly from the grower to the building blocks, their companys economic DNA.
consumer as soon as theyre picked. Interestingly, the company Richard Boulton, Barry Libert, Steve Samek
built its business not by acquiring its own assets but by
understanding how to leverage the assets of its suppliers like We exist to provide value to our customers. Nothing happens
FedEx and the growers themselves. until a customer walks into a store with a purpose, buys
Also, take the example of Mary Kay, Inc. This company excels at something and walks out.
renewing its employee assets on a regular, ongoing basis. The Sam Walton, founder, Wal-Mart
company has 500,000 consultants, each of whom can buy Companies can thrive or languish based on their allocation of
products at the same price and can earn the opportunity to move resources among tangible and intangible assets. Our conclusion
up to added levels of responsibility. As a result, there are now is that companies need to see what matters (all of their assets)
500,000 Mary Kay salespeople generating more than $1 billion a and invest in what matters (the optimal combination of assets).
year in sales revenue in 29 different countries. Richard Boulton, Barry Libert, Steve Samek
Cracking The Value Code - Page 7
Customer
Assets Number of customers Customer satisfaction
Customer retention rate
Market share Revenue per customer
4. Where will that information be delivered? In the final analysis, the coming together of new technologies
This information will be delivered, in real time, to the desktop and communication systems to create the New Economy allows
of everyone who can participate in the value creation the economic power of intangibles to finally be unlocked and
process. harnessed. That has profound and far reaching effects on the
types of business models that will succeed in the future.
The information may be generated by the business itself, or
various Enterprise Information Portals may be launched with The five basic building blocks of value in a New Economy
the capacity to deliver real-time market data personalized business physical, financial, employee & supplier, customer
and customized for each individual business model. and organizational assets are the business equivalent of DNA
which, in turn, forms the essence of the human genetic code.
5. What time lapse will there be between preparing and
Understanding how those assets can and should be combined in
delivering that information?
a companys business model will be essential to the process of
Continuous, ongoing measurement will become the creating value in the New Economy.
standard rather than the periodic reporting practices of past
Key Thoughts
generations.
To manage a global business which operates 24 hours a Information capabilities are the corporate, digital equivalent of
day, 7 days a week across numerous time zones, real time the human nervous system, providing a well-integrated flow of
data will be required. To settle for anything less would be information to the right part of the organization at the right time. It
handing a key competitive advantage to someone else. is distinguished from a mere network of computers by the
accuracy, immediacy and richness of the information it brings to
6. What formats would make sense for the delivery of asset
the knowledge workers and the insight and collaboration made
performance information?
possible by the information.
Whatever format best facilitates the ability of managers to Bill Gates, co-founder, Microsoft Corporation
conceptualize exactly whats happening in the business. In
other words, it may be a mix of numeric, textual and graphic The new dot.com companies of today are the fireflies before the
information. Most likely, new forms and formats of graphic storm all stirred up, throwing off sparks. The real story thats
visualization will become widespread. arriving the real disturbance in the force is when the
7. To whom will New Economy companies report on their asset thousands and thousands of institutions that exist today seize
performance? the power of this global computing and communications
infrastructure and use it to transform themselves. Thats the real
Historically, information about a business was highly revolution.
confidential, and very few people ever had the chance to see Lou Gerstner, CEO, IBM
the larger picture. In the New Economy, all stakeholders
participate in the value creation process and thus, all The next information revolution largely underlies the new
stakeholders need access to all the information. definition of the function of business enterprise as the creation
In short, data transparency and complete disclosure of all the of value and wealth.
information available will become the norm. Only then will all Peter Drucker
stakeholders be able to make informed decisions and To my mind, there must be, at the bottom of it all, not an
choices. equation but an utterly simple idea.
8. How will that information transparency create value? John Archibald Wheeler
Every company is really an information business at heart.
Insistently, persistently, relentlessly, the new manager must
For example, when GM and Ford announced they were ask, What for? What is it that were in business for? What is this
setting up global forums for purchasing all their goods and process for? This product? This task? This team? This job?
services, they created two standalone entities that were
What are we doing here anyway?
immediately worth billions of dollars each simply because of
James Champy, author
the amount of business that will flow through them each year.
Information transparency will: The Value Dynamics Framework is a beginning. We hope that
Help the business manage risk. our research and insights into what creates value, the tools to
Allow management to identify risks. visualize it and the processes to enhance and sustain it, will
Help management see threats. inspire you to look at your companys portfolio of assets and its
Increase investor confidence, lowering the cost of capital. value code in a new light. We hope it will help you see, invest in
Enhance strategic decision making. and manage the assets that count most in the New Economy.
Allow a business to move faster hopefully first. We hope it will help you create a greater store of corporate
Track all the assets that matter most. wealth and personal worth in the years ahead.
Richard Boulton, Barry Libert, Steve Samek
In short, information transparency will open another channel
by which businesses can create value in the future.