Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 18

C H A P T E R

3 MOTOR DEVELOPMENT:
A THEORETICAL MODEL
K E Y T E R M S C H A P T E R
C O M P E T E N C I E S
Descriptive theory
Explanatory theory Upon completion of this chapter you should be
Phases of motor development able to:
Inductive method Define life span motor development
Deductive method View an individuals motor behavior as
Category of movement more or less advanced on a developmental
continuum rather than as good or bad
Reflexes
Demonstrate an understanding of neural,
Rudimentary movement abilities physiological, perceptual, and cognitive
Fundamental movement skills changes across the life span
Specialized movement skills Distinguish between inductive and deductive
Heuristic theory formulation
Algorithm Describe the phases of motor development
List and describe the stages within the phases
Triangulated Hourglass Model of motor
of motor development
development Explain how the requirements of the
movement task, the biology of the individual,
and conditions of the learning environment
interact with the Triangulated Hourglass
Model of motor development
Demonstrate knowledge of both how and
why using a heuristic device as a metaphor for
understanding is helpful in conceptualizing the
products and processes of motor development

46

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 46 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 47

grounded in sound theoretical frameworks. The


KEY CONCEPT intent of this chapter is to present a comprehen-
sive model of motor development, based on two
The processes and products of motor develop- specific theoretical viewpoints: descriptive phase-
ment across the lifespan may be conceptualized stage theory and explanatory dynamic systems
through use of a triangulated hourglass heuristic. theory. We will present this model in the form of
an hourglass accompanied by an overlapping in-

A
verted triangle. Our intent here is to use this visual
major function of theory is to integrate ex- representation as a way to conceptualize both the
isting facts, to organize them in such a way descriptive products (hourglass) and explanatory
as to give them meaning. Theories of development processes (inverted triangle) of motor develop-
take existing facts about the human organism and ment as it typically unfolds across the life span. As
provide a developmental model congruent with with all theoretical models ours too will fall short.
these facts. Therefore, theory formulation serves It has, however, served as a plinth (basis) by many
as a basis for fact testing and vice versa. Facts are for better understanding what is occurring and
important, but they alone do not constitute a sci- why it is occurring in this amazing process that we
ence. The development of a science depends on call motor development.
the advancement of theory as well as on the accu-
mulation of facts. In the study of human behavior,
especially in the areas of cognitive and affective CONCEPT 3.1
development, theory formulation has gained in-
creased importance over the past several years. Few comprehensive theoretical models of motor
Theory has played a critical dual role in both of development exist.
these areas; namely, it has served and continues to
serve as an integrator of existing facts and as a basis The first function of a theoretical model of motor
for the derivation of new facts (Bigge & Shermis, development should be to integrate the existing
2004; Lerner, 2007). facts encompassed by the area of study. The sec-
ond function should be to serve as a basis for the
D ESCRIBING AND E XPLAINING generation of new facts. One might argue that the
facts could be interpreted in more than one way,
M OTOR D EVELOPMENT that is, from different theoretical perspectives. This
Until the 1980s, interest in motor development is entirely possible and desirable. Different view-
had been concerned primarily with describing points generate theoretical arguments and debates,
and cataloging data, with little interest in devel- the spark for research to shed new light on differ-
opmental models leading to theoretical explana- ing theoretical interpretations. Even if theoretical
tions of behavior across the life span. This research differences do not exist, research should be un-
was necessary and important to our knowledge dertaken to determine whether the hypotheses de-
base. But it did little to help us answer the criti- rived from the theory can be both experimentally
cally important questions of what lies underneath and ecologically supported.
the process of motor development and how the Theory should undergird all research and sci-
process occurs. Only a limited number of compre- ence, and the study of motor development is no
hensive models of motor development exist, and exception. It is our view that developmental the-
there are still few comprehensive theories of motor ory must be both descriptive and explanatory.
development. Now, however, scholars in motor In other words, the developmentalist should be
development are reexamining their work with a interested in what people are typically like at par-
view toward more carefully thought out research ticular age periods (description) and why these

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 47 30/06/11 10:49 AM


48 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

characteristics occur (explanation). Without a the- T HE P HASES OF M OTOR


oretical construct, research in motor development,
or any other area, tends to yield little more than
D EVELOPMENT
isolated facts. However, without an existing body The process of motor development reveals itself
of knowledge (facts), we cannot formulate theory, primarily through changes in movement behavior
and without the formulation and constant test- over time. All of us, infants, children, adolescents,
ing of theory, we cannot hope for a higher level of and adults, are involved in the lifelong process of
understanding and awareness of the phenomenon learning how to move with control and compe-
that we call motor development. tence in response to challenges we face daily in our
constantly changing environment. We are able to
observe developmental differences in movement
CONCEPT 3.2 behavior. We can do this through observation of
changes in process (form) and product (perfor-
Theoretical models attempt to describe and mance). A primary means by which motor develop-
explain behavior and may be inductive or ment may be observed is through studying changes
deductive. in movement behavior throughout the life cycle. In
other words, a window to the process of motor
A theory is a group of statements, concepts, or development is provided through an individuals
principles that integrate existing facts and lead to observable movement behavior, which provides us
the generation of new facts. The phases of motor with clues to underlying motor processes.
development presented in this chapter are not based
solely on the accumulation of facts. Such a model
would result from using an inductive method of CONCEPT 3.3
theory formulation. In the inductive method the in-
vestigator first starts with a set of facts and then tries The process of motor development may be
to find a conceptual framework around which to viewed as phase-like and stage-like.
organize and explain them. The deductive method
of theory formulation, as used here, is based on in- Observable movement may be grouped into three
ference and has three primary qualifications. First, functional categories according to their purpose
the theory should integrate existing facts and ac- and across all of the phases of motor development:
count for existing empirical evidence that bears on stabilizing movement tasks, locomotor movement
the content of the theory. Second, the theory should tasks, and manipulative movement tasks, or com-
lend itself to the formulation of testable hypotheses binations of the three. In the broadest sense, a sta-
in the form of: If ______, then ______ statements. bility movement is any movement in which some
Third, the theory should meet the empirical test; degree of balance or posture is required (i.e., virtu-
that is, experimentally tested hypotheses should ally all gross motor activity). In a narrower sense,
yield results that lend further support to the theory. a stability movement is one that is both nonloco-
The use of a deductive, rather than an induc- motor and nonmanipulative. The category conve-
tive, model enables us to see how well-accumulated niently encompasses movements such as twisting,
facts fit together into a cohesive, understandable turning, pushing, and pulling that cannot be clas-
whole. It also enables us to identify the information sified as locomotor or manipulative. In this book,
needed to fill in gaps in the theory or to clarify or re- stability, as a category of movement, is viewed as
fine it. The phases of motor development outlined more than a convenient catchall term, but as less
here are deductively based and serve as a model for than a global term applicable to all movement. The
theory formulation. In subsequent sections of the stability movement category refers to any movement
text each phase will be explored in greater detail. that places a premium on gaining and maintaining

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 48 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 49

ones equilibrium in relation to the force of gravity. serve as a model for this study. (See Figure 3.1 for
Thus, axial movements (another term sometimes a visual representation of the four phases and their
used for nonlocomotor movements) as well as in- corresponding stages.)
verted and body rolling postures are considered
here as stability movements. So too are standing
on one foot or remaining upright while sitting in Reflexive Movement Phase
a chair. The first movements the fetus makes are reflex-
The locomotor movement category refers to ive. Reflexes are involuntary, subcortically con-
movements that involve a change in location of trolled movements that form the basis for the
the body relative to a fixed point on the surface. To phases of motor development. Through reflex
transport oneself from point A to point B by walk- activity the infant gains information about the
ing, running, hopping, jumping, or skipping is to immediate environment. The infants reactions
perform a locomotor task. In our use of the term, to touch, light, sounds, and changes in pressure
such activities as the forward roll and backward trigger involuntary movement activity. These
roll may be considered both locomotor and stabil- involuntary movements, coupled with increas-
ity movementslocomotor because the body is ing cortical sophistication in the early months of
moving from point to point, stability because of postnatal life, play an important role in helping
the premium placed on maintaining equilibrium the child learn more about his or her body and
in an unusual balancing situation. the outside world.
The manipulative movement category refers Primitive reflexes may be classified as infor-
to both gross and fine motor manipulation. Gross mation-gathering, nourishment-seeking, and pro-
motor manipulation involves imparting force tective responses. They are information-gathering
to, or receiving force from, objects. The tasks of in that they help stimulate cortical activity and
throwing, catching, kicking, and striking an ob- development. They are nourishment-seeking and
ject, as well as trapping and volleying, are gross protective because there is considerable evidence
motor manipulative movements. Fine motor ma- that they are phylogenetic in nature. Primitive
nipulation involves intricate use of the muscles of reflexes such as the rooting and sucking reflexes
the hand and wrist. Sewing, cutting with scissors, are thought to be primitive survival mechanisms.
and typing are fine motor manipulative move- Without them, the newborn would be unable to
ments. A large number of movements involve a obtain nourishment.
combination of stability, locomotor, and/or ma- Postural reflexes are the second form of invol-
nipulative movements. For example, jumping untary movement. They are remarkably similar in
rope involves locomotion (jumping), manipula- appearance to later voluntary behaviors but are
tion (turning the rope), and stability (maintain- entirely involuntary. These reflexes seem to serve
ing balance). Likewise, playing soccer involves as neuromotor testing devices for stability, loco-
locomotor skills (running and jumping), ma- motor, and manipulative mechanisms that will
nipulative skills (dribbling, passing, kicking, and be used later with conscious control. The primary
heading), and stability skills (dodging, reaching, stepping reflex and the crawling reflex, for exam-
turning, and twisting). ple, closely resemble later voluntary walking and
In summary, if movement serves as a win- crawling behaviors. The palmar grasping reflex is
dow to the process of motor development, then closely related to later voluntary grasping and re-
one way of studying this process is through ex- leasing behaviors. The labyrinthine righting reflex
amining the sequential progression of movement and the propping reflexes are related to later bal-
skills throughout the entire life span. The follow- ancing abilities. The reflexive phase of motor de-
ing phases of motor development and the devel- velopment may be divided into two overlapping
opmental stages within each phase are designed to stages.

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 49 30/06/11 10:49 AM


50 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

Lifelong Lifelong Lifelong


daily living recreational competitive
utilization utilization utilization

APPROXIMATE AGE PERIODS THE STAGES OF


OF DEVELOPMENT MOTOR DEVELOPMENT

14 years old and up Lifelong Utilization Stage


11 to 13 years old SPECIALIZED Application Stage
7 to 10 years old MOVEMENT PHASE Transitional Stage

5 to 7 years old Proficient Stage


3 to 5 years old FUNDAMENTAL Emerging Elementary Stages
2 to 3 years old MOVEMENT PHASE Initial Stage

1 to 2 years old RUDIMENTARY Precontrol Stage


Birth to 1 year old MOVEMENT PHASE Reflex Inhibition Stage

4 months to 1 year old REFLEXIVE Information Decoding Stage


MOVEMENT PHASE Information Encoding Stage
In utero to 4 months old

Figure 3.1
The phases and stages of motor development.

varying intensity and duration. Reflexes now serve


CONCEPT 3.4 as the primary means by which the infant is able
to gather information, seek nourishment, and find
Reflexes are the first forms of human move- protection through movement.
ment and, because they are not learned, are
considered to be abilities rather than skills. Information Decoding Stage
The information decoding (processing) stage of
the reflex phase begins around the fourth month.
Information Encoding Stage During this time there is a gradual inhibition of
The information encoding (gathering) stage of many reflexes as higher brain centers continue
the reflexive movement phase is characterized by to develop. Lower brain centers gradually relin-
observable involuntary movement activity during quish control over skeletal movements and are
the fetal period until about the fourth month of replaced by voluntary movement activity medi-
infancy. During this stage lower brain centers are ated by the motor area of the cerebral cortex.
more highly developed than the motor cortex and The decoding stage replaces sensorimotor ac-
are essentially in command of fetal and neonatal tivity with perceptual-motor ability. That is, the
movement. These brain centers are capable of caus- infants development of voluntary control of
ing involuntary reactions to a variety of stimuli of skeletal movements involves processing sensory

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 50 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 51

stimuli with stored information, not merely re- by the developing cortex. Development of the
acting to stimuli. cortex, and lessening of certain environmental
Chapter 7 focuses on the primitive and pos- constraints, causes several reflexes to be inhibited
tural reflexes of infancy as they relate to the in- and gradually disappear. Primitive and postural
formation encoding and decoding stages. Special reflexes are replaced by voluntary movement be-
attention is given to the relationship between the haviors. At the reflex inhibition level, voluntary
reflexive phase of development and voluntary movement is poorly differentiated and integrated
movement. because the neuromotor apparatus of the infant
is still at a rudimentary stage of development.
Movements, though purposeful, appear uncon-
Rudimentary Movement Phase trolled and unrefined. If the infant wishes to
The first forms of voluntary movement are rudi- make contact with an object, there will be global
mentary movements. They are seen in the infant activity of the entire hand, wrist, arm, shoulder,
beginning at birth to about age 2. Rudimentary and even trunk. The process of moving the hand
movements are maturationally determined and into contact with the object, although voluntary,
are characterized by a highly predictable sequence lacks control.
of appearance. This sequence is resistant to change
under normal conditions. The rate at which these Precontrol Stage
abilities appear will vary from child to child, how- Around 1 year of age, children begin to bring
ever, and depends on biological, environmental, greater precision and control to their move-
and task factors. The rudimentary movement ments. The process of differentiating between
abilities of the infant represent the basic forms sensory and motor systems and integrating per-
of maturationally dependent voluntary move- ceptual and motor information into a more
ment required for survival. They involve stability meaningful and congruent whole takes place. The
movements such as gaining control of the head, rapid development of higher cognitive processes
neck, and trunk muscles; the manipulative tasks of and motor processes encourages rapid gains in
reaching, grasping, and releasing; and the locomo- rudimentary movement abilities during this stage.
tor movements of creeping, crawling, and walking. During the precontrol stage, children learn to gain
The rudimentary movement phase of develop- and maintain their equilibrium, to manipulate
ment may be subdivided into two stages that repre- objects, and to locomote throughout the environ-
sent progressively higher orders of motor control. ment with an amazing degree of proficiency and
control considering the short time they have had
to develop these abilities. The maturational pro-
CONCEPT 3.5 cess may partially explain the rapidity and extent
of development of movement control during this
The sequence of movement skill acquisition phase, but the growth of motor proficiency is no
during the rudimentary movement phase is less amazing.
generally fixed, but the rate is variable. Chapter 8 provides a detailed explanation
of the development of rudimentary movement
abilities. Particular attention is paid to the inter-
Reflex Inhibition Stage relationship between the stages within this phase
The reflex inhibition stage of the rudimentary and the stages within the reflexive phase of devel-
movement phase may be thought of as beginning opment. Attention is also focused on the critical
at birth. At birth, reflexes dominate the infants function that the rudimentary movement phase
movement repertoire. From then on, however, the serves in preparing the child for the development
infants movements are increasingly influenced of fundamental movement skills.

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 51 30/06/11 10:49 AM


52 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVES
The Royal Academy of Dance children are encouraged to experiment with an
endless variety of movement variations and to
The Royal Academy of Dance, located in London,
self-discover ways of moving that increase their
has produced superb Pre-Primary in Dance
movement vocabulary as well as skillfulness.
and Primary in Dance syllabi and instructional
The children are delightful to observe and inter-
DVDs. They deftly achieve the goals of helping
action with the on-camera instructor is joyful.
young children become more skillful movers,
The instructor is a master teacher who, lesson
knowledgeable movers, and expressive mov-
after lesson, demonstrates how to make curricu-
ers in a teaching and learning environment that
lar material personally meaningful and develop-
is age-appropriate, developmentally appropri-
mentally appropriate for young learners.
ate, and fun. Each of the themed lessons is well
In a world often more interested in special-
presented and pedagogically sound. A diverse
izing in movement skill development at an early
group of children depict the joy of moving with
age, the Royal Academy of Dance has taken
skill, efficiency, and purpose. The focus is on a
a bold step in a different direction: a direction
wide variety of the fundamental locomotor, ma-
that is focused on the developmental needs, in-
nipulative, and stability skills of early childhood.
terests, and unique abilities of children as they
These skills are important because they form
begin the lifelong quest of being skillful, knowl-
the basis for the more complex and specialized
edgeable, and expressive movers. Check out
movement, sport, and dance skills of later child-
the Royal Academy of Dance website for more
hood and beyond. In each of the many lessons
information: http://www.radenterprises.co.uk

Fundamental Movement Phase beam walk and one-foot balance are examples of
The fundamental movement skills of early child- fundamental movements that should be developed
hood are an outgrowth of the rudimentary during the early childhood years.
movement phase of infancy. This phase of motor de- A major misconception about the develop-
velopment represents a time in which young children mental concept of the fundamental movement
are actively involved in exploring and experiment- phase is the notion that these skills are matura-
ing with the movement potential of their bodies. It tionally determined and are little influenced by
is a time for discovering how to perform a variety task demands and environmental factors. Some
of stabilizing, locomotor, and manipulative move- child development experts (not in the motor de-
ments, first in isolation and then in combination velopment area) have written repeatedly about
with one another. Children developing fundamental the natural unfolding of the childs movement
patterns of movement are learning how to respond and play skills and the idea that children develop
with motor control and movement competence to a these abilities merely by growing older (matura-
variety of stimuli. They are gaining increased control tion). Although maturation does play a role in the
in the performance of discrete, serial, and continu- development of fundamental movement patterns,
ous movements as evidenced by their ability to ac- it should not be viewed as the only influence. The
cept changes in the task requirements. Fundamental conditions of the environmentnamely, oppor-
movement patterns are basic observable patterns tunities for practice, encouragement, instruction,
of behavior. Locomotor activities such as running and the ecology (context) of the environment
and jumping, manipulative activities such as throw- play important roles in the degree to which funda-
ing and catching, and stability activities such as the mental movement skills develop.

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 52 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 53

Fundamental movement skills have utility the initial level. Some children may be beyond this
throughout life and are important components of level in the performance of some patterns of move-
daily living for adults as well as children. The daily ment, but most are at the initial stage.
tasks of walking to the store, climbing stairs, and
balancing in static and dynamic positions are im- Emerging Elementary Stages
portant basic skills across the life span. Using the The emerging elementary stages, of which there
forward roll as the independent variable, Haynes may be several, involve gaining greater motor
(2009) looked at 117 participants across three age control and rhythmical coordination of funda-
cohorts (children: mean age 9.7; young adults: mean mental movement skills. The synchronization of
age 18.9; older adults: mean age 35.9). Haynes found the temporal and spatial elements of movement
that the observable components for the forward roll is improved, but patterns of movement during
were essentially the same for each group, a finding these stages are still generally restricted or exag-
that lends support to similar sequences of funda- gerated, although better coordinated. Children
mental movement skills as being age-independent. of normal intelligence and physical function-
ing tend to advance to the emerging elementary
stages primarily through the process of matura-
CONCEPT 3.6 tion. Observation of the typically developing 3 to
5 year-old child reveals a variety of fundamental
Constraints contained within the requirements movement skills that are emerging in a series of
of the movement task, the biology of the in- sometimes distinct and sometimes overlapping
dividual, and the conditions of the learning elementary stages. Many individuals, adults as
environment have profound effects on the ac- well as children, fail to get beyond these emerging
quisition of movement skills at each phase of elementary stages in one or more fundamental
development. movement skills.

Proficient Stage
Several researchers and assessment instrument de-
velopers have attempted to subdivide fundamental The proficient stage within the fundamental move-
movements into a series of identifiable sequential ment phase is characterized by mechanically effi-
stages. For the purposes of our model we will view cient, coordinated, and controlled performances.
the entire fundamental movement phase as having Proficient fundamental movement skills are ma-
separate but often overlapping stages: the initial ture in these three process aspects. With continued
stage, the emerging elementary stages, and the pro- opportunities for practice, encouragement, and in-
ficient stage. These stages are described briefly here struction they will, however, continue to improve
and in greater detail in chapters 11 and 12. in terms of the product components of how far,
how fast, how many, and how accurately.
The majority of available data on the acquisi-
Initial Stage tion of fundamental movement skills suggests that
The initial stage of a fundamental movement phase children can and should be at the proficient stage by
represents the childs first goal-oriented attempts age 5 or 6 in most fundamental skills. Manipulative
at performing a fundamental skill. Movement is skills that require visually tracking and intercepting
characterized by missing or improperly sequenced moving objects (catching, striking, volleying) tend
parts, markedly restricted or exaggerated use of the to develop somewhat later because of the sophis-
body, and poor rhythmical flow and coordination. ticated visual-motor requirements of these tasks.
The spatial and temporal integration of movement Even a casual glance at the movements of children
is poor. Typically, the locomotor, manipulative, and adults reveals that a great many have not de-
and stability movements of the 23-year-old are at veloped their fundamental movement skills to a

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 53 30/06/11 10:49 AM


54 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

proficient level. Although some children may reach skill are the same movement patterns upon which
this stage primarily through maturation and with sport-specific skills are based. Therefore, it can be
a minimum of environmental influences, the vast concluded that mastering fundamental skills leads
majority require some combination of opportuni- to easier learning of specific skills.
ties for practice, encouragement, and instruction in The onset and extent of skill development
an environment that fosters learning. Failure to offer within the specialized movement phase depends
such opportunities makes it exceedingly difficult for on a variety of task, individual, and environmental
an individual to achieve proficiency in fundamental factors. Reaction time and movement speed, coor-
movement skills and will inhibit further applica- dination, body type, height and weight, customs,
tion and development in the specialized movement culture, peer pressure, and emotional makeup are
phase that follows (OKeeffe, 2001; Stodden et al., but a few of these constraining factors. The special-
2008). Seefeldt (1982) was the first to appropri- ized movement phase has three stages.
ately refer to this as a proficiency barrier between
fundamental movement skills and their compan-
ion specialized sport skills. More recently Clark & CONCEPT 3.7
Metcalfe (2002) suggested that fundamental motor
Progress through the specialized movement
skills provided the base camp to the mountain of
skill phase depends on mature fundamental
motor development leading to motor skillfulness.
movement skill development.

Specialized Movement Phase Transitional Stage


Specialized movement skills are an outgrowth Somewhere around their seventh or eighth year,
of the fundamental movement phase. During the children commonly enter a transitional movement
specialized phase, movement becomes a tool ap- skill stage (Haubenstricker & Seefeldt, 1986). Dur-
plied to a variety of complex movement activities ing the transitional period, the individual begins to
for daily living, recreation, and sport pursuits. This combine and apply fundamental movement skills
is a period when fundamental stability, locomotor, to the performance of specialized skills in sport
and manipulative skills are progressively refined, and recreational settings. Walking on a rope bridge,
combined, and elaborated upon for use in increas- jumping rope, and playing kickball are examples of
ingly demanding situations. The fundamental common transitional skills. Transitional movement
movements of hopping and jumping, for example, skills contain the same elements as fundamental
may now be applied to rope-jumping activities, movements with greater form, accuracy, and con-
to performing folk dances, and to performing the trol. Fundamental movement skills developed and
triple jump (hop-step-jump) in track and field. refined during the previous stage are applied to play,
OKeeffe studied the relationship between funda- game, and daily living situations. Transitional skills
mental movement skills and sport-specific skills are applications of fundamental movement patterns
in a test of the Triangulated Hourglass Model of in somewhat more complex and specific forms.
motor development. The results of his investiga- The transitional stage is an exciting time for
tion led him to conclude that this study provides the parent and the teacher as well as for the child.
empirical evidence in support of Gallahues theo- Children are actively involved in discovering
retical model with respect to the relationship be- and combining numerous movement patterns
tween fundamental skill and sport-specific skill and are often elated by their rapidly expanding
phases and also for dynamical systems theory to movement abilities. The goal of concerned par-
explain the learning process (OKeeffe, 2001, ents, teachers, and youth sport coaches during
abstract). In other words, the patterns of move- this stage should be to help children increase
ment contained within a fundamental movement their motor control and movement competence

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 54 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 55

in a wide variety of activities. Care must be taken Lifelong Utilization Stage


not to cause the child to specialize or restrict his The lifelong utilization stage of the specialized phase
or her activity involvement. A narrow focus on of motor development begins around age 14 and
skills during this stage is likely to have undesir- continues through adulthood. The lifelong utilization
able effects on the last two stages of the special- stage represents the pinnacle of the process of motor
ized movement phase. development and is characterized by the use of ones
acquired movement repertoire throughout life. The
Application Stage interests, competencies, and choices made during
From about age 11 to age 13 (the middle school the previous stage are carried over, further refined,
years) interesting changes take place in the skill and applied to a lifetime of daily living, recreational,
development of the individual. During the previ- and sports-related activities. Factors such as available
ous stage, the childs limited cognitive abilities, af- time and money, equipment and facilities, and physi-
fective abilities, and experiences, combined with a cal and mental limitations affect this stage. Among
natural eagerness to be active, caused the normal other things, ones level of activity participation will
focus (without adult interference) on movement depend on talent, opportunities, physical condition,
to be broad and generalized to all activity. In the and personal motivation. An individuals lifetime
application stage, increased cognitive sophistica- performance level may range anywhere from profes-
tion and a broadened experience base enable the sional status and the Olympics; to intercollegiate and
individual to make numerous learning and par- interscholastic competition; to participation in or-
ticipation decisions based on a variety of task, in- ganized or unorganized, competitive or cooperative,
dividual, and environmental factors. For example, recreational sports and simple daily living skills.
the 5-foot, 10-inch (179 cm) 12-year-old who likes In essence, the lifelong utilization stage repre-
team activities and applying strategy to games, sents a culmination of all preceding stages and phases.
who has reasonably good coordination and agility, It should, however, be viewed as a continuation of a
and who lives in Indiana, may choose to specialize lifetime process. Specialized skill development can
in the development of his or her basketball play- and should play a role in our lives, but it is unfair
ing abilities. A similarly built child who does not to require children to specialize in one or two skill
really enjoy team efforts may choose to specialize areas at the expense of developing their movement
in a variety of track and field activities. The indi- repertoire in and appreciation for many other areas
vidual begins to make conscious decisions for or (Landers, Carson, & Tjeerdsma-Blankenship, 2010).
against participation in certain activities. These
decisions are based, in large measure, on how he or
she perceives the extent to which factors within the CONCEPT 3.8
task, himself or herself, and the environment either
enhance or inhibit chances for enjoyment and suc- The primary goal of a persons motor develop-
cess. This self-examination of strengths and weak- ment and movement education is to accept the
nesses, opportunities and restrictions, narrows the challenge of change in the continuous process
choices. of gaining and maintaining motor control and
During the application stage, individuals movement competence throughout a lifetime.
begin to seek out or to avoid participation in
specific activities. Increased emphasis is placed T HE T RIANGULATED H OURGLASS :
on form, skill, accuracy, and the quantitative as-
pects of movement performance. This is a time
A L IFE S PAN M ODEL
for more complex skills to be refined and used in The age ranges for each phase of motor devel-
advanced games, lead-up activities, and selected opment should be viewed as general guidelines,
sports. illustrative only of the broad concept of age

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 55 30/06/11 10:49 AM


56 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

appropriateness. Individuals often function at genuine help to you in better understanding the
different phases depending on their experiential phenomena of motor development.
backgrounds and genetic makeups. For example, it
is entirely possible for a 10-year-old to function in
the specialized movement phase at the lifelong uti- CONCEPT 3.9
lization stage in stability activities involving gym-
nastic movements, but only at the elementary stage The triangulated hourglass model is a helpful heu-
of the fundamental movement phase in manipula- ristic device for conceptualizing, describing, and
tive and locomotor skills such as throwing, catch- explaining the process of motor development.
ing, or running. Although we should encourage
this precocious behavior in gymnastics, we should To understand this model, picture yourself as
also help the child catch up to his or her age-mates an hourglass (Figure 3.2). Into your hourglass we
in the other areas and develop acceptable levels of need to place the stuff of life: sand. Sand gets into
proficiency in them as well. your hourglass from two different containers. One
It is important to gather facts about the pro- is your hereditary container and the other your en-
cess of developing motor skills. Throughout this vironmental container. The hereditary container
text we discuss study after study, but if we fail to has a lid. At conception our genetic makeup is de-
provide you with a theoretical framework and a termined and the amount of sand in the container
conceptual grasp of the process of motor devel- is fixed. However, the environmental container has
opment, we will have presented isolated facts that no lid. Sand may be added to the container and
tell you little about their implications for success- to your hourglass. We could reach down into the
ful developmental teaching, coaching, therapy, and sand pile (i.e., the environment) and get more
parenting. Therefore, we would like to propose a sand to put into your hourglass.
theoretical model for the process of motor develop- The two buckets of sand signify that both
ment and work through this model with you. This the environment and heredity influence the pro-
model as presented is not a comprehensive theory cess of development. The relative contributions of
of motor development. It is a heuristic device, that each have been a volatile topic of debate for years.
is, a conceptual metaphor, or model, of motor de- Arguing the importance of each is a meaningless
velopment, that provides us with general guide- exercise because sand is funneled from both con-
lines for describing and explaining motor behavior. tainers into your hourglass. In the final analysis
Heuristics differ from algorithms in one important it does not really matter if your hourglass is filled
way. Whereas an algorithm is a procedure or set of with hereditary sand or environmental sand. What
rules guaranteed, if followed, to lead to solution of a is important is that somehow sand gets into your
given kind of problem, heuristics are rules of thumb hourglass and that this stuff of life is the product of
giving one clues for how to search for answers to both heredity and the environment.
given problems. In the study of development, many Now, what do we know about motor develop-
theories use heuristic devices that researchers hope ment during the early phases of life? When we look
will eventually lead to algorithms. at the reflexive and rudimentary phases of motor
The intent of all heuristic devices (which may development, we know that sand pours into the
be likened to metaphors) is to be helpful in charac- hourglass primarily, but not exclusively, from the
terization of particular phenomena. As such, they hereditary container. The sequential progression
can only be viewed as more or less helpful, not as of motor development during the first few years
being right or wrong. Heuristic devices provide a of life is rigid and resistant to change except under
broad framework for better understanding a par- environmental extremes. Therefore, we know in
ticular phenomenon. Our hope, therefore, is that the first two phases of motor development that
the Triangulated Hourglass heuristic will be of the developmental sequence is highly predictable.

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 56 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 57

Gallahues TRIANGULATED
HOURGLASS: A Life Span Motor Control and Movement Competence
Process/Product Model of
Motor Development

Heredity Environment

ME RS
CO ITHI

ON TO
NT
W
NS N T

IR AC
TR HE

SPECIALIZED

NV G F
AIN IN

MOVEMENT PHASE

E E IN
IN DIV

TH AIN
G

IN STR
FA IDUA

FUNDAMENTAL MOVEMENT PHASE


CT

N
OR L

CO
S

RUDIMENTARY MOVEMENT PHASE

REFLEXIVE MOVEMENT PHASE

CONSTRAINING FACTORS
WITHIN THE TASK

Figure 3.2
Filling an individuals hourglass with sand (i.e., the stuff of life). The hourglass represents a descriptive (product)
view of development. The inverted triangle represents an explanatory (process) view of development. Both are
helpful in understanding motor development as one continually adapts to change in the lifelong quest for gaining and
maintaining motor control and movement competence.

For example, children all over the world learn how movement abilities. This is something in which
to sit before they stand, how to stand before they researchers and program developers have become
walk, and how to walk before they run. However, increasingly interested. We have seen a rapid rise
we do see considerable variability in the rates at in the number of infant stimulation programs and
which the very young acquire their rudimentary infant-toddler movement programs. Some make

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 57 30/06/11 10:49 AM


58 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

elaborate claims about the worth of these programs infancy throughout life. If an infant, child, adoles-
and their ultimate importance to the child. Unfor- cent, or adult receives additional opportunities for
tunately, we have little hard evidence at this junc- practice, encouragement, and instruction in an en-
ture to either support or refute these claims. The vironment conducive to learning, movement skill
rate of movement skill acquisition is variable from acquisition will be promoted. The absence of these

DEVELOPMENTAL DILEMMA
The Mountain of Motor Development Skillful
Context-Specific
Clark and Metcalfe (2002) published an inter- Fundamental Motor Patterns
esting paper entitled The Mountain of Motor Preadapted
Reflexive
Development: A Metaphor. In it they deftly discuss

Compensation
the intent and purpose of heuristic devices, or met-
aphors, in the study of human development. The
authors provide an interesting discussion of how to

Developmental Time
select appropriate metaphors for motor develop-
ment as well as means for assessing its validity and
usefulness. Next, they carefully look at metaphors
as descriptors of human behavior, focusing on
motor development. They even take time to succ-
inctly describe the triangulated hourglass model
prior to presenting their own (see Figure 3.3).
The mountain metaphor is intriguing in that
it envisions humankind collectively. Clark and
Metcalfe rightfully contend that we each climb our Figure 3.3
own mountain. Interestingly, however, our own in- The Mountain of Motor Development
dividual mountains vary. Some are high and rug- Clark, J.E., & Metcalfe, J.S. (2002). The mountain of motor
development: A metaphor. In J.E. Clark & J. Humphrey (Eds.).
ged, others are shorter and more rounded, and Motor Development: Research and Reviews (pp. 163190).
still others are only small foothills. In this range of Reston VA: NASPE Publications.

mountains the individual, as the mountaineer,


who is seen as a nonlinear self-organizing adap- be seen as an open system that is dynamic in
tive organism, climbs as high as possible. How terms of shape, size, number, and complexity,
high she or he climbs (the goal of the task) is de- whereas the hourglass could be viewed (inappro-
pendent on the interaction between the biology of priately, we believe) as a closed and static sys-
the individual and the conditions of the environ- tem that has a one size/shape fits all view of
ment. In other words, constraints. development.
Serving as a framework for understand- Do we have a developmental dilemma here?
ing, the mountain heuristic device, much like Is motor development a mountain or is it an
the Triangulated Hourglass, attempts to broadly hourglass? Is one view of development right
describe both the products and the processes and the other wrong? Better yet, given your per-
of motor development. The two appear to differ, sonal reality (i.e., where you are and with whom
however, from the collective framework of each you interact on a regular basis), what is your
person having his or her own personal mountain metaphor/heuristic for better understanding the
to climb (or hourglass to fill). The mountain may processes and products of motor development?

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 58 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 59

environmental affordances (i.e., enabling factors) depends on mature fundamental movements. After
will constrain movement skill acquisition. Further- the transitional stage we progress to the final stages
more, the acquisition rate will vary depending on in which specialized movement skills are applied
the mechanical and physical requirements of each to daily living, recreational, and sport experiences.
task. For example, if an infant does not have suf- At some point, the hourglass turns over (Fig-
ficient handholds (an environmental constraint) in ure 3.4). The timing of this occurrence is variable and
her environment to enable her to pull herself up to often depends more on social and cultural factors
a stand, she will have to wait until sufficient balance than on physical and mechanical factors. For most
(a biomechanical constraint) and strength in the individuals, the hourglass turns over and the sand
legs (a physical constraint) have developed, before begins to pour out during the late teens and early
she is able to bring herself to a standing position 20s. This is a time in which many individuals enter
unaided. Contemporary theory explains motor the adult world of work, car payments, mortgages,
development as a dynamic process in which a family responsibilities, and a host of other time-
motor behavior emerges from the many constraints consuming tasks. Time restrictions limit the pursuit
that surround that behavior (Clark, 1994, p. 247). of new movement skills and the maintenance of
In the fundamental movement phase, boys skills mastered during childhood and adolescence.
and girls are beginning to develop a whole host of There are several interesting features in the
basic movement skillsrunning, hopping, jump- overturned hourglass that we need to consider.
ing, throwing, catching, kicking, and trapping. The sand falls through two different filters. One is
Unfortunately, many still have the notion that chil- the hereditary filter with which we can do very little.
dren somehow automatically learn how to per- For example, an individual may have inherited a pre-
form these fundamental movements. Many naively disposition toward longevity or coronary heart dis-
think that children at this phase of development ease. The hereditary filter is going to be either dense,
will, through the process of maturation, develop causing the sand to filter through slowly, or easy to
proficient fundamental movement skills. This is penetrate, allowing the sand to flow through more
not true for the vast majority of children. Most rapidly. Sand that has fallen through the hereditary
children must have some combination of oppor- filter cannot be recovered, but it must pass through a
tunities for practice, encouragement, and instruc- second, or final, filter called the lifestyle filter.
tion in an ecologically sound environment. These The density of the lifestyle filter is determined
conditions are crucial to helping them through by such things as physical fitness, nutritional sta-
each of the stages within the fundamental move- tus, diet, exercise, the ability to handle stress, and
ment phase. Furthermore, as the task requirements social and spiritual well-being. The lifestyle filter
of a fundamental movement skill change, so too is environmentally based, and we have a good deal
will the process and the product. For example, the of control over the rate at which sand falls through
perceptual requirements of hitting a pitched ball this filter. Although we can never stop sand from
are considerably more sophisticated than those re- flowing to the bottom of the hourglass, we can
quired to strike a stationary ball or to perform a slow down the rate at which it falls. A former sur-
striking pattern without making contact with an- geon general of the United States, Dr. C. Everett
other object. Teachers of individuals at the funda- Koop, once stated that although we cannot stop the
mental movement phase must learn to recognize aging process, we can control it by up to 40%. We
and analyze the task requirements of movement can directly influence how fast sand falls through
skills to maximize learner success. Teachers who our hourglasses. As teachers, coaches, therapists,
overlook these duties erect proficiency barriers at and parents we have the wonderful opportunity
the specialized movement skill phase. to shovel sand into many hourglasses. We also
At the specialized movement skill phase, suc- have the privilege and the obligation to help others
cessful performance of the mechanics of movement develop lifestyle filters that will slow the rates at

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 59 30/06/11 10:49 AM


60 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

Figure 3.4
Emptying the overturned hourglass of life. Development as seen here is a continuous discontinuous process
throughout the life span.

which sand falls in their hourglasses. Sand can still The hourglass heuristic device as described to this
be added even when hourglasses are overturned point gives the impression that development is an
and the sand is falling to the bottom. Each of us orderly and continuous process. Note, however,
has lifelong opportunities for learning. By taking that the sand at the bottom of the hourglass in both
advantage of the numerous opportunities for con- Figures 3.2 and 3.4 is distributed in a bell-shaped
tinued development and physical activity, we can curve. The shape of this curve implies that there is
add more sand. We cannot add sand faster than it a distribution of movement skills among the cate-
is falling and claim immortality. We can, however, gories of movement (locomotion, manipulation,
extend and improve the quality of life. and stability), and within the various movement

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 60 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 61

tasks. For example, one may be at the elementary you will, an individuals hourglass as being sup-
stages in some skills, the proficient stage in others, ported by a cognitive pillar, an affective pillar, and
and at a sport skill level in still others. Addition- a motor pillar. The hourglass is multidimensional;
ally, one may be at different stages of development thus, there is a triple interaction among the cogni-
within the same skill. For example, when children tive, affective, and motor domains. In other words,
and adults perform the overhand throw, they are the Triangulated Hourglass Model is more than a
often at the initial stage in their trunk action, an motor model. It is a model of motor development
emerging elementary stage in their arm action, that influences, and is influenced by, a wide variety
and a proficient stage in their leg action. Motor of cognitive and affective factors operating within
development in the hourglass model, therefore, is both the individual and the environment.
a discontinuous process, that is, a process that, al- You may find it helpful to visualize the hour-
though phaselike and stagelike in a general sense, is glass heuristic device as you proceed through the
highly variable in a specific sense. Motor develop- following sections dealing with motor develop-
ment when viewed as discontinuous is in effect a ment during infancy, childhood, adolescence, and
dynamic (i.e., nonlinear) process occurring within adulthood. Remember, however, that it is not im-
a self-organizing system (i.e., the hourglass). portant that you accept this model as proposed.
Theoretical models are just thatmodels. As
such they are incomplete, inexact, and subject to
CONCEPT 3.10 verification and further refinement. What is im-
portant is that you visualize how the process of
Motor development is a discontinuous process motor development occurs. Remember, under-
occurring within a self-organizing system. standing motor development helps to explain how
learning occurs. Both are crucial to the creation of
Although depicted as being unidimensional in effective, developmentally appropriate instruction.
Figures 3.1, 3.2 and 3.4, the Triangulated Hour-
glass Model should not be viewed as such. Real
hourglasses occur in both time and space. They
CONCEPT 3.11
are multidimensional and as such contain, along
Understanding the process of motor develop-
with the motor domain, both cognitive and affec-
ment helps explain how movement skill learn-
tive domains as well. As a result, real hourglasses
ing occurs, which is crucial to developmentally
have height, width, and depth and must be sup-
appropriate instruction.
ported if they are to remain upright. Visualize, if

S UMMARY

T he acquisition of competency in movement is an


extensive process beginning with the early reflexive
movements of the newborn and continuing throughout
disappear in a fairly rigid sequence. Rudimentary move-
ments form the important base upon which fundamen-
tal movement skills are developed.
life. The process by which an individual progresses from Fundamental movement skills are basic movement
the reflexive movement phase, through the rudimentary patterns that begin developing around the same time
and fundamental movement phases, and finally to the that a child is able to walk independently and move freely
specialized movements skill phase of development is in- through his or her environment. These basic locomotor,
fluenced by factors within tasks, the individual, and the manipulative, and stability skills go through a definite,
environment. observable process from immaturity to maturity. Stages
Reflexes and rudimentary movement abilities are within this phase include the initial, emerging elemen-
largely based on maturation. Reflexes appear and tary, and proficient stages. Attainment of the mature

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 61 30/06/11 10:49 AM


62 UNIT I Background www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e

stage is influenced greatly by opportunities for practice, their first real applications of fundamental movements to
encouragement, and instruction in an environment that sport. If the fundamental skills used in a particular sport
fosters learning. Under the proper circumstances, chil- activity are not at the mature level, the child will resort
dren are capable of performing at the mature stage in to less proficient or elementary patterns of movement.
the vast majority of fundamental movement patterns Involving children in sport skill refinement before they
by age 6. The fundamental movement skills of children reach proficient levels of ability in prerequisite funda-
entering school are too often incompletely developed. mentals is unwise. When this happens, the less proficient
Therefore, the primary grades offer an excellent oppor- movements found in the basic patterns are carried over
tunity to develop fundamental movement skills to their to the related sport skills. The child will regress to his or
proficient levels. These same fundamental skills will be her characteristic pattern. It is important that sensitive
enhanced and refined to form the specialized movement teaching and coaching be incorporated at this point.
skills so highly valued for recreational, competitive, and When we look at the process of motor development,
daily living tasks. we need to look at it first from a theoretical perspective.
The specialized movement skill phase of development Each of us needs to have a theoretical framework to use
is in essence an elaboration of the fundamental phase. as the basis for our actions. It is not important that you
Specialized skills are more precise than fundamental agree with the theoretical framework presented here.
skills. They often involve a combination of fundamental The Triangulated Hourglass Model is our way of viewing
movement skills and require a greater degree of precision. the process of motor development and its implications
Specialized skills involve three related stages. The tran- for life. What is your theoretical framework? How does it
sitional stage is typically the level of the child in grades influence your teaching, coaching, therapy, or parenting,
three through five. At this level, children are involved in and how does it influence you personally?

Q UESTIONS FOR R EFLECTION


1. The Triangulated Hourglass Model borrows from also be viewed, perhaps, as a tree, a train, or even a
two differing but complementary views of human river or ocean? Select one of the above or choose
development. What are they and in which ways are another metaphor and build your own theoretical
they both similar and different? How might they be model.
viewed as complementary? 4. The Tom Hanks character Forrest Gump in the
2. Using a heuristic different from the Triangulated movie of the same name said, Life is like a box of
Hourglass Model, can you use a metaphor to help chocolates. What did he mean? How could a box of
yourself and others visualize the processes and chocolates be used as a metaphor for better under-
products of motor development? standing human development?
3. If motor development can be viewed as a Triangu- 5. Why are theory building and theory testing
lated Hourglass or as a mountain metaphor, can it important?

C RITICAL R EADINGS
Bigge, M. L., & Shermis, S. S. (2004). Learning Development: Research and Reviews, Vol. 2
Theories for Teachers. Needham, MA: Allyn & (pp. 163190). Reston, VA: NASPE.
Bacon. Garcia, C., & Garcia, L. (2006). A motor
Brady, F. (2004). Childrens organized sports: development and motor learning perspective.
A developmental perspective. JOPERD, 75, JOPERD 77, 8, 3133.
3541, 53. Haynes, J. E. S. (2009). Qualitative Analyses of a
Clark, J. E., & Metcalfe, J. S. (2002). The Fundamental Motor Skill Across the Lifespan:
mountain of motor development: a metaphor. Linking Practice and Theory. Unpublished
In J. E. Clark & J. Humphrey (Eds.), Motor

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 62 30/06/11 10:49 AM


www.mhhe.com/gallahue7e CHAPTER 3 Motor Development: A Theoretical Model 63

doctoral thesis. University of New England, OKeeffe, S. I. (2001). The Relationship Between
NSW, Australia. Fundamental Motor Skills and Sport-Specific
Kamm, K., Thelen, E., & Jensen, J. (1990). Skills: Testing Gallahues Theoretical Model
A dynamical systems approach to motor of Motor Development. Unpublished
development. Physical Therapy, 70, 763775. doctoral thesis. University of Limerick,
Landers, R. Q., Carson, R. L., & Tjeerdsma- Ireland.
Blankenship, B. (Eds.). (2010, October). The Seefeldt, V., & Haubenstricker, J. (1982). Patterns,
promises and pitfalls of sport specialization in phases, or stages: An analytic model for the
youth sport. JOPERD. study of developmental movement. In J. A. S.
Lerner, R. M. (2007). Developmental science, Kelso & J. E. Clark (Eds.), The Development
developmental systems, and contemporary of Movement Control and Coordination
theories of human development. In W. Damon (pp. 309318). New York: Wiley.
& R. M. Lerner (Eds.), Handbook of Child Williams, K. (2004). Whats motor development
Psychology (6th ed.). http://onlinelibrary.wiley. got to do with physical education? JOPERD,
com/book/10.1002/9780470147658/homepage/ 75, 3539.
Order.html

wi
de w
eb W EB R ESOURCES
world

www.nia.nih.gov www.isisweb.org/main.htm
Homepage for the National Institute on Aging. Homepage for the International Society on
The site provides health and research information Infant Studies. ISIS is an organization devoted
as well as press releases, a calendar of events, to the promotion and dissemination of research
and general information on the NIA in regard to on the development of infants. Site contains
mission and programs. a description of the society, latest news, and
newsletter.
www.elsevier.com/wps/find/journaldescription.
cws_home www.srcd.org
Journal of Adolescence Web page. Page includes Society for Research in Child Development
journal information including description, homepage. The society is an international
editorial board, and a guide for authors, professional association focused on human
online submission, online reviewer form, development. The site includes news for members,
and abstracting/indexing. Site also contains job opportunities, suggested publications,
subscription information and journal-related summaries of journal articles, and information on
information. becoming a member of the society.

gal76507_ch03_046-063.indd 63 30/06/11 10:49 AM

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi