1

CAN ENGINEER EXPLAIN THIS VERSE ?A CHALLANGE

Surah Az-Zukhruf (ornaments of gold, luxury) Ayah 3

Literal meaning
Verily WeDidMakeQura:nInArabicThatYouMay
Understand.
or
VerilyWeMadeQura:nInArabicThatYouMay
Understand.
This versedoesshewthatQuranismadeinitsapparent
meaning. (1)
NowifthisQuranismadethenitcannotbeEternal.
WeaskAliMirza to make a commentary of this verse.
SinceifhethinksthatthisversemeansthatQuranis
made then one that is made is not eternal. If not Eternal
then not associated with Divine Essence=Deity.
Since he in his lectures has admitted that Non Eternal
[H:adith:] neither can sustain in Divine Essence nor can be
associated with Divine Essence [Dh:a:tul Ba:ri:].
If he interpret otherwise then he must state the rules of
interpretations before making any interpretation. After
stating the rule.

1
 2

The following Axioms must be kept in mind.

1]IfQuran is made then It is Not Eternal.
2]IfQura:nisEternalthen It is Not Made.
3] (Also) MadeQura:nneithercanbeassociatedwith
Divine Essence nor can be sustained in Divine Essence.
4]IfQura:niseitherassociated with Divine Essence or
Qura:nissustainedinDivineEssencethenitisNotmade.
We have not asked about Makh:lu:q [Created] but asked about made [Maju:l].

AsEngineerAliMirza:hasadmittedthathebelievesthat
Qura:nisUncreated,onemay ask , then how he interpret
this verse.
DoeshebelievethatQura:nISCREATEDbutnotMade?
This is the most Absurd Claim on earth.

DoeshebelievethatQura:nISMADEbutnotCreated?.
AconsequenceofthisisthatQura:nisNot Eternal.In this caseAliMirzacannotsaythatQura:nisassociatedwith
the Divine Essence.

DoeshebelievethatQura:n is neither made nor created?

AconsequenceofthisisthatQura:nisEternal.

IsQura:n Neither Made Nor Eternal?

IsQura:n Neither Created Nor Eternal?
IsQura:nNeitherCreatedNorMade?

2
 3

DoesEngineerofJhelumbelievesthattheMadeQura:n
isEitherAssociatedWithDivineEssenceorMadeQura:n
is Sustained in Divine Essence or both? [Qia:mAlMaju:l
Bi Dh:a:tul Ba:ri:]
IsQura:nanIntentional or Voluntary Speech of Divine
Essence or It is Unintentional and Involuntary Speech of
Divine Essence.
DoesAliMirza:ofJhelumbelievesthatQura:nis
Intentional/Voluntary and Eternal Speech Of Divine
EssenceNounly/NamelyALL-H simultaneously?
Also Doeth Divine Essence [Deity] Have Power to made
Qura:ninanyotherlanguage?

HowEngineerAliMirzainterpretthisverseofQura:n?
Ali:Mirza:ischallengedtomakeaproperexplanationof
this verse in light of the above sentenced Questions.
============================================
===========================================

(1 )
WedofollowthemainstreamofAhlussunnahwithrespect
andregardsforMinoritiesinAhlussunnah.So it is
advisable not to conclude any result about our believes on
the bases of these questions. We have used Counter

3
 4

Question Method to shew that he cannot make a

commentary or explanation of this verse stated / written
above with out a contradiction or a self contradiction or
violation of Basis Axioms stated above.
What Engineer calls in his own devised term which may be
translated as Dijestive Poweder is called as Counter
Question(s), since we cannot descend to the Levil of the
Engineer and his irrational choice of words for making
terms.

TO THE
FOLLOWE
RS OF

4
 5

ALI:
MIRZA
You Shall See that this person shall never try to explain
this verse in strict wording(s) Insha:All-h because he
himself knows that any explanation shall turn back against
him.[InshaALL-H]
For example if he explains theversebysayingthatQura:n
is Eternal yet Voluntary then this is an Absolute Impossible
not even Relative Impossible.
IfEngineersaysthatQura:nisMadeandNotEternalthen
hecannotsayQura:nisassociatedwithDivineEssence.
If Engineer says thatQura:nisMadebutNeitherEternal
NorCreatedthenhecannotsayQura:nisassociated
with [/Sustained in] Divine Essence.
Only thing he is likely to do is to make a joke in Panja:bi:
Language because he can easily do that. How ever this is
a disgrace of the Panja:bi: Language.No Sober Panja:bi
Speaking likes the disgrace of the language.

5
 6

ThisverseisaproofthatEngineerAli:Mirza:isan
Apostate and Heretic.