Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Key Points
The most common cause (30% to 60%) of pharyngitis in adults is a self-limited viral infection that
occurs as part of the common cold. Rhinovirus is the most common etiologic agent.
Pharyngitis in adults is caused by a bacterial infection in approximately 5% to 10% of patients. In
children, bacterial pharyngitis accounts for 30% to 40% of cases.
Group A -hemolytic Streptococcus pyogenes (GABHS) is the pathogenic organism responsible for
most cases of bacterial pharyngitis in adults.
Prevention of rheumatic fever is possible if antibiotic therapy is started up to 10 days after the
onset of symptoms, but antibiotic treatment does not appear to affect the incidence of acute
poststreptococcal glomerulonephritis.
Other more uncommon bacterial causes of acute pharyngitis include nongroup A -hemolytic
Streptococcus, Arcanobacterium haemolyticum, sexually transmitted organisms (Neisseria gonorrhoeae,
Treponema pallidum, and Chlamydia), tuberculosis, tularemia, and diphtheria.
Influenza continues to be a worldwide problem. Each year, 500 million people globally develop
influenza, and approximately 150,000 people require hospitalization in the United States alone. In
nonpandemic years, 20,000 to 40,000 deaths occur; in pandemic years, deaths can reach 100,000
annually. Influenza A, rather than type B, is responsible for most of the significant morbidity and
mortality.
Sore throat from Epstein-Barr virus is found in 82% of patients with infectious mononucleosis and
is the most common complaint. Other symptoms may include abdominal discomfort, headache,
stiff neck, and skin rash.
Treatment for most patients with infectious mononucleosis consists of supportive care, rest,
antipyretics, and analgesics. Patients should be advised to avoid contact sports until examination
and abdominal ultrasonography confirms resolution of splenomegaly. Antivirals are not beneficial in
uncomplicated infections, and antibiotics are indicated only for secondary bacterial infections.
Steroids are indicated for complications related to impending upper airway obstruction, severe
hemolytic anemia, severe thrombocytopenia, or persistent severe disease.
Candida can affect the oropharynx in the form of pseudomembranous candidiasis (thrush). The
most common isolated organism is Candida albicans, but other organismsC. glabrata, C. tropicalis,
C. dubliniensis, C. rugosa, and C. kruseiare now emerging as causative agents, especially in
immunocompromised patients and in those that have received previous radiotherapy.
P haryngitis is inflammation of the pharynx. The anatomic this has been demonstrated in many different populations, most
region of the pharynx invariably affected in adults is the oro- recently in the firefighters with World Trade Center cough.5
pharynx. The predominant symptom is sore throat, which Pharyngitis in adults is caused by a bacterial infection in
overall is the third most common chief complaint to physicians approximately 5% to 10% of patients.6 In children, bacterial
in an office-based practice.1 Infectious pharyngitis is just one of pharyngitis accounts for 30% to 40% of cases.6 Approximately
the many possible causes of sore throat in adults (Box 9-1). An 75% of adults who come to medical attention with a sore throat
accurate history and physical examination is critically important are prescribed antibiotics for a presumed bacterial pharyngitis,
for determining the differential diagnosis for each individual even though this practice will only help a minority of the
patient. For instance, squamous cell carcinoma of the upper patients.7 This practice can be attributed to patients expecta-
aerodigestive tract frequently occurs with a history of chronic tions to receive an antibiotic and to physicians beliefs that
sore throat. Epiglottitis in adults commonly presents as a severe patients will reconsult if antibiotics are not prescribed and will
acute sore throat and odynophagia with a relatively normal be unsatisfied without a prescription. This inappropriate use of
oropharyngeal examination. More common conditions, such antibiotics has negative consequences for both individual
as postnasal drip and laryngopharyngeal reflux, can cause an patients and public health.
irritative pharyngitis. Occupational2,3 and environmental4 expo- The focus of this chapter is the appropriate evaluation and
sures can also be associated with an irritative pharyngitis, and management of different microbial causes of pharyngitis in
153
154 PART II | GENERAL OTOLARYNGOLOGY
three or four of the Centor criteria has a positive predictive States. Clindamycin is an acceptable alternative for patients
value of 40% to 60%, whereas the absence of three or four with both a penicillin allergy and a strain resistant to macro-
criteria has a negative predictive value of 80%. The Centor lides. Although studies have shown that cephalosporins, clinda-
criteria have been endorsed by the Centers for Disease Control mycin, and azithromycin can effectively eradicate GABHS
and Prevention (CDC), the American Academy of Family Physi- from the pharynx with treatment courses of 5 days or less, the
cians, and the American College of Physicians for use in clinical IDSA does not support routine use of these shorter courses
practice guidelines for treatment of acute pharyngitis in because of inadequacies with these studies, the broader spec-
adults.16 These guidelines state that patients with one or fewer trum of these antibiotics compared with penicillin, and
Centor criteria should receive no further testing or antibiotic increased cost.10 An analgesic/antipyretic medication, such as
treatment given the unlikely possibility of GABHS infection. acetaminophen or a nonaspirin nonsteroid antiinflammatory
For patients with two or more criteria, a few appropriate strate- drug, can be used adjunctively for control of constitutional
gies are to 1) test patients with two, three, or four criteria with symptoms and fever.
a rapid antigen test, and reserve antibiotics for those with a Many explanations for penicillin treatment failure have
positive test; 2) test patients with two or three criteria with a been proposed and include 1) carrier status, 2) lack of compli-
rapid antigen test, and limit antibiotic treatment to those with ance, 3) recurrent exposure, 4) in vivo copathogenicity of
a positive test or with four criteria; or 3) use no diagnostic tests, -lactamaseproducing normal oral flora, 5) in vivo eradication
and limit antibiotic treatment to those with three or four crite- of normal protective flora, 6) contaminated toothbrushes or
ria. The authors of these guidelines do not include throat orthodontic appliances, and 7) intracellular localization of the
culture in their algorithm because of poor test-retest reliability, bacterium. These explanations are based on observational
variable results that depend on the technique of obtaining and studies or are laboratory based without clinical confirmation
performing the culture, and inability to distinguish acute infec- rather than being based on type I or II evidence.20
tion from a carrier state. Routine retesting is not recommended for asymptomatic
After the above recommendations were published, a differ- patients after a complete course of treatment for GABHS phar-
ent viewpoint on the diagnosis and management of GABHS yngitis.10 This would be indicated only for special circumstances,
pharyngitis in adults was proposed by the Infectious Diseases such as in patients with a history of rheumatic fever, develop-
Society of America (IDSA).10,17 The IDSA guidelines for diag- ment of pharyngitis during an outbreak of acute rheumatic
nosis and management of GABHS were initially published in fever or poststreptococcal acute glomerulonephritis, or in fami-
2002 and were updated in 2012. In an emergency department lies with ping-pong spread of infection. Patients with persis-
practice, the accuracy of the Centor score for predicting a posi- tent symptoms with a repeat rapid antigen or throat culture
tive GABHS throat culture was 32% to 56%. Based on these positive for GABHS may be a carrier in the presence of viral
data, the IDSA noted that the application of this clinical scoring infection, may have copathogens that produce -lactamase,
system alone would result in continued overprescription of may be noncompliant with the antibiotic regimen, or may have
antibiotics in adults with non-GABHS pharyngitis.17 Given this acquired a new infection with GABHS from family or commu-
consideration, the IDSA continues to support laboratory con- nity contacts. In the presence of repeat viral pharyngitis, no test
firmation of clinically suspected cases of GABHS pharyngitis in can distinguish between a carrier state versus bona fide GABHS
adults. The American Heart Association also still recommends pharyngitis, and eradication of the GABHS carrier state is rarely
laboratory confirmation.18 In considering the sensitivity (80% possible with penicillin. Clindamycin or amoxicillin-clavulanic
to 90%) and specificity (> 95%) of the more recently utilized acid should be used to treat patients with multiple, repeated,
rapid antigen detection tests, the low incidence of GABHS, and symptomatic episodes of laboratory-proven GABHS.10 The
the very low risk of rheumatic fever in the adult population, the IDSA recommends that tonsillectomy should be considered
IDSA supports the use of rapid antigen tests alone, without when symptomatic recurrent episodes do not decrease in fre-
confirmation by throat culture, as an acceptable alternative quency despite appropriate antimicrobial therapy, and when
diagnostic strategy.10 Even though several variables can affect no other etiology for the repeated episodes is evident.10 A ran-
the results, the IDSA still supports the use of throat culture on domized clinical trial performed in Finland of tonsillectomy
a sheep-blood agar plate as the gold standard for documenta- versus observation for adults with documented recurrent epi-
tion of the presence of GABHS in the upper respiratory tract sodes of streptococcal pharyngitis showed that tonsillectomy
and for the confirmation of acute GABHS pharyngitis. For was beneficial for decreasing the number of episodes of further
achieving maximal sensitivity in diagnosis, some physicians still throat infections. The number needed to treat to prevent one
choose to use throat culture or to back up a negative rapid recurrence was five.21 No clinical practice guidelines have been
antigen test with a culture.10 The sensitivity of throat culture is published for tonsillectomy in adults. It is also important to
90% to 95%. The use of antistreptococcal antibody titers has note that recommendations for diagnosis and management of
no role in the routine diagnosis of GABHS pharyngitis. Unfor- acute pharyngitis varied significantly when 12 national guide-
tunately, a major problem in testing of adults with pharyngitis lines from Europe, the United States, and Canada were
is that clinicians commonly fail to follow any guidelines, which compared.22
leads to unnecessary treatment in many patients.19
Adults with GABHS pharyngitis should be treated with an
antibiotic whose dose and duration is likely to eradicate the NONGROUP A -HEMOLYTIC
organism from the pharynx. Penicillin or amoxicillin is the
treatment of choice because of its proven efficacy, narrow spec-
STREPTOCOCCAL INFECTIONS
trum, and low cost. No clinical isolate of GABHS has ever been Groups B, C, and G streptococci have been cultured from
documented to be resistant to penicillin.10,16 The oral course patients during episodes of acute pharyngitis.6,8,23 These organ-
should be for 10 days for all antibiotic choices, except when isms are part of the normal upper respiratory tract flora, so
azithromycin is used, which should be in a 5-day course.10 Ben- differentiating colonization from infection is difficult; thus the
zathine penicillin can be alternatively used as a single intramus- role of these organisms as pathogens in acute pharyngitis is
cular injection that provides bactericidal levels for 21 to 28 days. controversial.23 Groups B, C, and G streptococci can be cul-
Erythomycin is an acceptable alternative for patients allergic to tured in patients with acute pharyngitis with clinical symptoms
penicillin, but isolated reports of macrolide resistance (<5% of and exam findings indistinguishable from those of GABHS.8,23
clinical isolates currently) have been reported in the United Pharyngeal infection with groups C and G streptococci can
156 PART II | GENERAL OTOLARYNGOLOGY
frequently seen on Ziehl-Neelsen staining. Mycobacterial F. tularensis is resistant to -lactam antibiotics. Aminoglyco-
culture is also necessary. A purified protein derivative skin test sides, macrolides, fluoroquinolones, and tetracyclines are effec-
will be positive, unless the patient is immunosuppressed or has tive choices for antimicrobial therapy. Treatment delay greater
an overwhelming infection. Medical management with antitu- than 14 days after symptom onset is associated with therapeutic
berculous agents is the recommended therapy. If the Ziehl- failure and prolonged recovery.50 A source from water resources
Neelsen staining method is negative, the diagnosis of tonsillar or foods should be sought to avoid further cases in the local
tuberculosis may be difficult to distinguish from sarcoidosis, population.
because both diseases are characterized by granulomatous
inflammation, pulmonary disease, and lymphadenopathy.46 It Corynebacterium diphtheriae
is important in this situation to make a definitive diagnosis, Diphtheria is an example of an infectious disease that has
rather than to treat it as a presumed case of sarcoidosis, because almost been eradicated by the application of microbiologic and
corticosteroids can be harmful if the patient actually has public health principles. The worldwide incidence decreased
tuberculosis. markedly concomitant with the administration of diphtheria
toxoid shortly after World War II. It is currently a rare disease
Francisella tularensis in the United States, and fewer than five cases per year have
Francisella tularensis is a gram-negative bacillus that is the caus- been diagnosed since 1980.52 This disease has not been fully
ative agent of tularemia, which occurs both sporadically and in defeated, however. In 1994, epidemic diphtheria reemerged in
epidemics in the United States.47 The two known subtypes are the New Independent States (former Soviet Union) and caused
Jellison type A, which is the more virulent and common biotype approximately 50,000 illnesses and 1800 deaths.53 Outbreaks
in North America, and Jellison type B, which is more common can also occur in immunized populations, because adults can
in Europe and Asia.48 F. tularensis is a zoonotic organism that have serum antitoxin levels below the protective level.54
survives in rodents, ticks, raccoons, rabbits, calves, cats, and Corynebacterium diphtheriae is a nonmotile gram-positive pleo-
dogs. Ticks are the primary reservoir. Transmission occurs morphic bacillus. Toxigenic strains are pathogenic, and toxin
through blood-sucking arthropods and insects, ingestion of production is mediated by a bacteriophage. The diphtheria
contaminated food or water, or inhalation of dust contami- exotoxin inhibits protein synthesis in mammalian cells by
nated by feces of infected arthropods.47,48 In some cases, the inactivating elongation factor 2. Antitoxin neutralizes circu
exact source of infection is still unclear even after thorough lating toxin but is ineffective once cell penetration has
questioning. Person-to-person transmission is rare and is not occurred.
epidemiologically important.47 Transmission occurs through infected secretions from the
Luotonen and colleagues49 studied 127 patients with tulare- nose, throat, eyes, or skin lesions. Entry occurs through the
mia manifestations in the head and neck region, which mouth or nose, and the organism initially remains localized to
accounted for 11.5% of all patients treated at their institution the mucosal surfaces of the upper respiratory tract. Local
for tularemia. Disease presented in three forms: 1) glandular, inflammation and toxin-mediated tissue necrosis causes forma-
2) ulceroglandular, and 3) oropharyngeal. The oropharyngeal tion of a fibrinous, patchy, adherent, gray-black pseudomem-
form accounted for 25% of the head and neck cases, and 70% brane. The location of pseudomembranes can be nasal,
of patients with the oropharyngeal form were older than 15 tonsillar, pharyngeal, laryngeal, laryngotracheal, conjunctival,
years. Identified sources of infection in these cases included genital, or cutaneous. More than one area can be affected, but
contaminated hare meat and strawberries. Meric and col- the oropharynx is the most commonly involved site. Attempts
leagues50 studied 145 patients with oropharyngeal tularemia to remove a pseudomembrane characteristically causes bleed-
seen in Turkey between 2004 and 2005 that occurred in a newly ing from the underlying tissue. Sore throat and low-grade
constructed settlement after an earthquake in 1999. The mean fever usually begin 1 to 2 days prior to developing the pseudo-
age was 39 years, and 59% of the patients were female. Because membrane. The severity of local symptoms is quite variable.
the source for the oropharyngeal form of tularemia is fre- Symptoms may be mild and resolve with sloughing of the pseu-
quently from contaminated food or water, other family members domembrane in 7 to 10 days. Alternatively, if disease extends
are often infected also.47 into or primarily involves the larynx, or if the pseudomembrane
The oropharyngeal form manifests with fevers, chills, is aspirated after sloughing, symptoms may be severe and life
malaise, sore throat, and painful neck mass.48,49 Signs include threatening. Patients typically develop a bull-neck appear-
an acutely ill appearance, fever, pharyngeal erythema, exuda- ance caused by marked swelling of cervical lymph nodes and
tive tonsillitis, and tender lymphadenopathy that can suppurate extensive infiltration of the neck soft tissues. This can cause
during the course of illness. The clinical presentation can be external compression on the larynx with subsequent airway
easily confused with acute infectious mononucleosis, especially obstruction.
because a false-positive result can be obtained on a monospot Toxin effects at distant sites cause myocarditis, neuritis, and
test, and atypical lymphocytes can be present on peripheral acute tubular necrosis. Myocarditis is associated with delayed
blood smear.49 Cases can also easily be confused for GABHS administration of antitoxin and typically occurs just as the local
pharyngitis and may only be discovered after failure of pen disease is improving at 2 weeks after onset. Peripheral neuritis
icillin therapy. The mean leukocyte count is 9200/mm2 occurs 3 to 7 weeks later, usually affects motor rather than
with only 14% having a left shift. The erythrocyte sedimenta- sensory nerves, and commonly affects the soft palate and pha-
tion rate is elevated in all patients, with a mean of 57 mm/hr.50 ryngeal muscles.
Diagnosis is best determined by serum hemagglutination Definitive diagnosis is based on isolation of the organism.
titers. A fourfold increase in titer or a titer greater than 1:160 The pseudomembrane should be cultured, and the laboratory
at any time is considered sufficient for diagnosis given a clini- should inoculate Loeffler coagulated serum, tellurite, and
cal suspicion of disease.47 These titers are usually within diag- blood agar media. Finding GABHS does not rule out the pos-
nostic range by 16 days after disease onset but not before 11 sibility of diphtheria, because this organism can be cocultured
days. Recently, a PCR test has been described that may allow in 30% of cases.55 Smears taken from organisms growing on
for earlier diagnosis in highly suspect cases.51 No other labora- Loeffler medium characteristically show club-shaped organisms
tory tests are specific for this disease. Culture is usually not that form sharp angles with each other. This morphology is
helpful, because the organism is fastidious and grows poorly reminiscent of a Chinese character appearance. Recovered
in vitro. diphtheria should be tested for toxigenicity. This is performed
9 | PHARYNGITIS IN ADULTS 159
using the guinea pig neutralization test or the Elek test, which
is based on a commercially available antiserum and tests VIRAL INFECTION
whether a precipitin reaction forms when this antiserum is COMMON COLD (RHINOVIRUS,
placed on growing colonies.
Treatment consists of both the antitoxin and antibiotics. CORONAVIRUS, PARAINFLUENZA VIRUS)
Outcome depends on the location and extent of the pseudo- The most common cause (30% to 60%) of pharyngitis in adults
membrane, the patients immunization status, and how quickly is a self-limited viral infection that occurs as part of the common
the antitoxin is administered. The antitoxin should be given as cold.6 The average adult gets 2 to 4 colds each year, and this
soon as possible, because it can only inactivate toxin that has accounts for close to 20% of patients who present with an acute
not already entered the cells. The antitoxin is a hyperimmune illness to health care providers.60 Rhinovirus is the most
antiserum of equine origin, so tests for sensitivity to horse common etiologic agent of the common cold.8 Coronavirus
serum should be performed prior to administration. The rec- and parainfluenza virus are less commonly implicated. Prior to
ommended dose is dependent on the location of the disease the identification of a novel coronavirus as the cause of severe
and the duration of the illness.56 Antibiotics are needed to acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), the only illness that coro-
eradicate the organism, and the recommended antibiotics naviruses were thought to cause in humans was the common
are penicillin and erythromycin. Alternatively, C. diphtheriae cold.61 Interestingly, upper respiratory symptoms such as sore
is also sensitive to tetracycline, clindamycin, and rifampin. throat and rhinorrhea occur in a minority (13% to 25%) of
Supportive care is important, because most patients have dif- patients with SARS.61 Rather than showing hyperemia or edema,
ficulty swallowing, and some patients require intubation or examination of the oropharynx reveals drying of the mucosa.62
tracheostomy to avoid upper airway obstruction. A booster Lymphadenopathy is also typically absent in SARS.
vaccination should be given during the recovery period, and Rhinovirus is a single-stranded RNA virus in the Picornaviridae
serial electrocardiograms should be obtained for early detec- family. More than 100 serotypes of rhinovirus exist. It is transmit-
tion of cardiac complications. Disease eradication should be ted through large particle aerosols that initially affect the ciliated
documented by two negative cultures after completion of the nasal epithelium. The virus does not directly invade the nasal
treatment. epithelium, but rather it causes an acute inflammatory reaction.
The patients immunization history is important informa- Inflammatory mediators subsequently cause edema and hyper-
tion in determining suspicion of disease, because recent immu- emia of the nasal mucosa that extends into the pharynx.
nization or booster injection would make disease highly Presenting symptoms of the common cold may overlap with
unlikely. Diphtheria toxoid booster injection is recommended those of GABHS pharyngitis, but the sore throat is usually not
every 10 years in adults. This is especially important for people severe, and odynophagia is unusual. Patients usually complain
who travel to epidemic or endemic areas. Immunized patients of nasal symptoms (rhinorrhea, nasal stuffiness) that precede
can still be carriers for the organism, because the vaccination the throat symptoms. A nonproductive cough, hoarseness, and
is directed solely against the toxin. When carriers are detected, low-grade fever may also be present. The nasal mucosa is typi-
treatment should consist of a course of antibiotics and a toxoid cally edematous, and the oropharynx has mild erythema. Spe-
booster injection, if none was administered during the previous cific virologic diagnosis is unnecessary for most patients,
year. because it usually does not affect the management. Computed
tomography (CT) scan of the paranasal sinuses cannot reliably
Yersinia enterocolitica distinguish patients with the common cold from those with
Yersinia enterocolitica is a motile gram-negative bacillus that is a acute bacterial sinusitis, because imaging abnormalities are fre-
well-described cause of enteric infections. Pharyngitis symp- quently found in both conditions.63 The common cold most
toms occur in 20% to 30% of these patients with enteritis and, commonly causes CT scan abnormalities of the maxillary
more recently, Y. enterocolitica has been described to cause phar- sinuses (87%), followed in frequency by occlusion of the
yngitis in the absence of enteritis.57 During a milk-borne out- ethmoid infundibulum (77%), abnormalities of the ethmoid
break, 14 of 172 patients with culture-documented Y. enterocolitica sinuses (65%), abnormalities of the sphenoid sinuses (39%),
had pharyngitis without enteritis. All patients were adults with and abnormalities of the frontal sinuses (32%). Imaging find-
a median age of 38.5 years old. This contrasted to the patients ings are usually bilateral. When associated with the common
affected by enteritis, whose median age was 5 years. Findings cold, most sinus CT abnormalities either markedly improve or
consistent among affected patients included exudative tonsil- resolve by 2 weeks after onset. Treatment for the common cold
litis, tender cervical adenopathy, fever, and elevated leukocyte is symptomatic and consists of rest, oral hydration, and over-
count (mean 16,000/mm3). All patients demonstrated Y. entero- the-counter cold medications for relief of symptoms. Most
colitica on blood agar or MacConkey agar from a throat speci- healthy adults will recover within 1 week. Antibiotics are not
men without any other identified organisms, and they showed routinely used and are only indicated for secondary acute bac-
a serologic response to the outbreak strain. terial sinusitis, which occurs in 0.5% to 5% of cases.63
Although this organism does not commonly cause pharyn-
gitis, prompt recognition is important, because delayed diag-
nosis can lead to airway obstruction, bacteremia, sepsis, and
INFLUENZA VIRUS
death.58 The treating physician should be suspicious in cases of Influenza is a single-stranded RNA virus in the Orthomyxoviridae
exudative pharyngitis with continued symptoms, exam find- family. Three typesA, B, and Chave been identified, but
ings, and leukocytosis despite appropriate treatment for the only types A and B cause widespread outbreaks.64 Influenza A
more common causes of bacterial or viral pharyngitis. Throat viruses are further classified into subtypes based on antigenic
culture or rapid antigen test for GABHS and serologic tests differences between the hemagglutinin and neuraminidase
for infectious mononucleosis are negative. Patients with - surface glycoproteins.65 Disease is transmitted through an air-
thalassemia are at particularly high risk for developing infec- borne route from respiratory droplets. Virus invades the respi-
tions from Y. enterocolitica.59 The organism is sensitive to ratory epithelium, initially in the tracheobronchial tree but
tetracyclines, aminoglycosides, third-generation cephalospo- later throughout the whole respiratory tract. The hemaggluti-
rins, and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole. Penicillin, ampicil- nin glycoprotein on the surface of the virus facilitates attach-
lin, and first-generation cephalosporins do not effectively treat ment to respiratory epithelial cells by binding to sialic
this organism. acid receptors. The neuraminidase glycoprotein facilitates the
160 PART II | GENERAL OTOLARYNGOLOGY
release of progeny virions by catalyzing the cleavage of glyco- The CDC recommends routine vaccination for people older
sidic linkages to sialic acid. than 50 years and encourages vaccination of children between
In North America, influenza presents as outbreaks in the 6 and 24 months old.66 Other populations in whom vaccination
late fall or winter. However, this disease is a worldwide problem: is recommended are residents and employees of long-term care
each year, 500 million people globally develop influenza, and facilities, patients with chronic cardiopulmonary disease,
approximately 150,000 people require hospitalization in the patients with metabolic disease or immunosuppression, women
United States alone.64 This disease is also deadly. The pandemic in the second or third trimester of pregnancy during influenza
of 1918 killed 20 million people. In nonpandemic years, 20,000 season, health care personnel, and providers of home care to
to 40,000 deaths occur.64 In pandemic years, this can reach high-risk patients.64 For high-risk patients who did not receive
100,000 deaths annually. Disease varies in severity based on vaccination or who received vaccine in poor-match years, zana-
several factors: influenza type A, rather than type B, is respon- mivir or oseltamivir can be effective as prophylaxis against
sible for most of the significant morbidity and mortality; very disease.65,66,68 When used for this indication, medication must
young patients are at higher risk for influenza-related hospital- be taken daily for the duration of influenza risk in the com-
ization; older patients (>50 years old) are at higher risk for munity. During prolonged courses, the development of drug-
complications; and patients with underlying comorbidities such resistant strains is a concern.69
as immunosuppression, cardiopulmonary disease, or diabetes
are also at higher risk for a complicated disease course. Death
is usually caused by a primary viral or secondary bacterial pneu-
HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS
monia. Bacterial organisms that cause pneumonia in these Acute human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type 1 infection
patients are community-acquired pathogens, Staphylococcus causes a mononucleosis-like syndrome in 40% to 90% of
aureus, and group B Streptococcus.64 patients that starts days to weeks after exposure.70 This febrile
Patients come to medical attention with abrupt onset of illness is called acute retroviral syndrome (ARS). Because of the
fever, headache, and myalgias. Sore throat, malaise, chills, nonspecific signs and symptoms, even patients at risk for HIV
sweats, nonproductive cough, and rhinorrhea shortly follow. are frequently not promptly diagnosed. Thus ARS should be
The sore throat can be severe in nature, and examination of included in the differential diagnosis in any patient with a fever
the oropharynx typically reveals mild hyperemia and edema of unknown origin and risk factors for HIV exposure.
without exudates. Lymphadenopathy is an uncommon finding. The time course from mucosal breach to initial viremia is 4
In uncomplicated infections, symptoms usually resolve after to 11 days.70 Symptoms related to ARS are caused by the robust
3 to 5 days. Supportive therapy is indicated during this time. immune response to replicating virus. The most common symp-
Antiviral therapies with M2 ion channel blockers (amantadine) toms and signs include fever (median maximum temperature
or neuraminidase inhibitors (zanamivir or oseltamivir) have 38.9C [102F]), lethargy, skin rash, myalgia, headache, phar-
been used. Amantadine was described to reduce the duration yngitis, cervical adenopathy, and arthralgia.71 Pharyngitis occurs
of symptoms by about 1 day when started within 2 days of the in 50% to 70% of patients and usually appears as hypertrophy
onset of symptoms.65,66 However, this medication has limitations of the tissues of the Waldeyer ring without exudates. Other oral
that include rapid development of drug-resistant viral strains, manifestations less commonly observed include ulcers (29%)
and as such it is not recommended for treatment of influenza and candidiasis (17%).72
type A infections. The neuraminidase inhibitors are effective Diagnosis is dependent upon laboratory tests. Complete
against influenza types A and B and decrease symptoms by 1 to blood count may reveal lymphopenia or thrombocytopenia.73
2.5 days when started within 2 days of developing symptoms.65,67 Atypical lymphocytes and a decreased CD4 cell count are
These drugs have also been shown to reduce complications in usually not observed at this time. Because antibodies to HIV
high-risk populations.50 Current treatment recommendations appear approximately 4 weeks after infection, enzyme-linked
for neuraminidase inhibitors include patients at high risk for immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and Western blot tests are also
complications or those with severe disease.64,65 Treatment negative at this time. A quantitative plasma HIV-1 RNA level
should also be considered for patients not at high risk, but tested by PCR is necessary to make a timely diagnosis. This level
when disease is diagnosed early. will be greater than 50,000 copies/mL.70,73 The high viral titer
With the availability of new treatments that need to be associated with ARS is reflective of the initial burst of viremia
started early in the disease course to be beneficial, it is now with wide dissemination of virus and seeding of lymphatic
more desirable to make a prompt, accurate diagnosis. The FDA organs. If a quantitative plasma HIV-1 RNA level cannot be
has approved a few rapid diagnostic tests that give results in obtained, detection of viral p24 antigen is an alternative test
under 15 minutes. Compared with throat culture, the gold that can be used to make the diagnosis.
standard for laboratory diagnosis, the sensitivity and specificity The natural history of ARS is resolution of signs and symp-
of these tests range from 62% to 73% and from 80% to 99%, toms, along with the viremia, within 14 days after onset.73
respectively.66 Samples should be obtained from the nose rather Disease progression to other HIV manifestations or acquired
than from the throat. immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) ultimately occurs.
The best treatment for disease is prevention with the inacti- Although data are limited regarding long-term benefits of early
vated influenza vaccine, which gets prepared yearly based on treatment, immediate and sustained therapy with antiretroviral
the anticipated strains likely to appear during the flu season. medications may limit the extent of viral dissemination, restrict
Vaccination is 70% to 100% effective when the viruses in the damage to the immune system, protect antigen-presenting
vaccine and the viruses in the epidemic have been well matched cells, and reduce the chance of disease progression.70 Patient
antigenically.65 The FDA has approved an intranasal vaccine compliance with sustained treatment is important, because
with live attenuated virus as an alternative to the traditional inconsistent adherence can cause viral resistance that can limit
inactivated injected vaccine.66 This vaccine more accurately future treatment options.
mimics natural infection and thus may provide a broader and In patients with AIDS, persistent ulcers in the oropharynx
more durable immunologic response. The vaccine can be used can be caused by herpes simplex virus, cytomegalovirus (CMV),
in healthy, nonpregnant patients from 2 to 49 years old; Cryptococcus, histoplasmosis, mycobacterial organisms, and lym-
however, because this vaccine contains live influenza viruses, it phoma.74 In many cases, however, no identifiable etiology is
should not be used in patients or close contacts of patients with determined after exhaustive microbiologic, serologic, and
chronic illnesses or immunodeficiency. pathologic tests. The pathogenesis of these ulcers is unclear but
9 | PHARYNGITIS IN ADULTS 161
has been postulated to be immunogenic75 and possibly related out of concern for a bacterial pharyngitis or respiratory
to the relative increase of CD8-positive cytotoxic T cells in the infection.81
local tissues.74 These ulcers progressively enlarge, have destruc- Adenoviral infection can be confirmed by culture from a
tive behavior, and are extremely painful; they have a propensity throat swab. The culture specimen is grown on various cell lines
for the tonsillar fossa, floor of the mouth, and epiglottis.76 The in vitro, and a cytolytic effect is observed. Immunofluorescence
pain associated with these ulcers causes significant odynopha- using an antiadenovirus monoclonal antibody is performed to
gia that can lead to malnutrition and wasting. Patients with confirm the diagnosis. Acute and convalescent serum can also
these ulcers typically have advanced immunosuppression, with be tested for antibody titers. PCR is a rapid, sensitive test for
25 cells/mm3 the median CD4 count.75 detecting adenoviral DNA in nasopharyngeal aspirates or
Injected76 and systemic74 steroids have shown success for serum.82 In immunocompromised patients, detection of adeno-
treating these AIDS-related ulcers. Friedman and colleagues76 viral DNA in serum precedes the development of severe sys-
showed that intralesional injections of triamcinolone acetonide temic infections.79
completely healed 51% of the 36 treated ulcers by 4 weeks Disease is usually self-limited, and symptomatic treatment
and 72% by 8 weeks. For the 10 patients who did not have suffices for most cases. The average duration of symptoms is 10
complete clinical resolution, six still had marked symptomatic days.81 However, significant morbidity and mortality can occur
improvement. In other studies, preliminary data suggested that in immunocompromised patients79,83 and rarely in previously
thalidomide was effective, and a multicenter, double-blinded, healthy young adults.84 Infection can cause pneumonia, sec-
randomized, placebo-controlled study was subsequently per- ondary bacterial infections, and more rarely meningitis,
formed.75 This study revealed complete healing in 55% of the encephalitis, cystitis, nephritis, colitis, and death. No approved
patients in the thalidomide-treated group as opposed to 7% in antiviral agents or antiviral therapies exist that have proven
the placebo group, which was highly statistically significant. The efficacy against these severe adenoviral infections. Case reports
median time to complete healing was 3.5 weeks. Most of the and small case series support the possible benefits of ribavirin,
patients in the thalidomide group who did not show a complete cidofovir, ganciclovir, leukocyte transfusion, and intravenous
response had at least a partial response. Quality-of-life measures immunoglobulin.83
were performed on these patients and showed reduced pain
and improved ability to eat.
EPSTEIN-BARR VIRUS
Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) is a double-stranded DNA virus in the
ADENOVIRUS Herpesviridae family. The virus remains ubiquitous in humans by
Adenovirus is a double-stranded DNA virus in the Adenoviridae remaining latent in B lymphocytes and intermittently replicat-
family. Although adenovirus is well known as a causative agent ing in oropharyngeal epithelial cells to enable transmission
of pharyngitis with conjunctivitis (pharyngoconjunctival fever) through saliva. Blood transfusion is more rarely the mode of
in children, serotypes 3, 4, 7, and 21 cause outbreaks of febrile transmission. Worldwide, 80% to 90% of adults are seropositive
respiratory illness in military recruits,77,78 immunocompromised for EBV.85 Nearly all children in developing countries serocon-
adults (particularly recipients of hematopoietic stem cell vert by 6 years of age. But in industrialized countries, about
grafts79), and rarely in healthy, young adult civilians.80 Military 30% of cases occur during adolescence or early adulthood. In
recruits appear to be at particular risk because of the crowding this population, 50% of patients seroconvert without develop-
and physical stress associated with basic training. Before the ing an overt illness.85
availability of vaccines, adenoviral outbreaks occurred fre- EBV is the causative agent of infectious mononucleosis
quently in military recruits and affected up to 10% and caused (IM). The initial route of infection occurs through the lym-
as much as 70% of all cases of respiratory disease.81 This had phoid tissues and pharyngeal epithelial cells. The initial incuba-
significant implications on military readiness, because basic tion period is from 3 to 7 weeks. A prodrome of malaise, fever,
training was disrupted by an average of 3 days for each affected and chills is followed 1 to 2 weeks later by sore throat, fever,
recruit.81 Outbreaks also overwhelmed medical resources and anorexia, and lymphadenopathy (especially cervical). Sore
caused significant economic loss. Beginning in 1971, live oral throat is found in 82% of patients with IM and is the most
vaccines against serotypes 4 and 7 became available for use in common complaint. Other symptoms may include abdominal
the military and were administered to all male recruits from discomfort, headache, stiff neck, and skin rash.
October to March of each year. This was changed to year-round Examination of the oropharynx reveals an exudative phar-
immunizations in 1984 because of recurring outbreaks in the yngitis with erythema and tonsillar hypertrophy (Fig. 9-2).
late spring and early fall. This intervention had a dramatic Other findings may include diffuse lymphoid hyperplasia of the
effect and reduced adenovirus-specific disease rates by 95% to Waldeyer ring, petechiae at the hard palatesoft palate junc-
99%. The manufacturer of this vaccine stopped production in tion, and ulcers on the pharyngeal and epiglottic mucosa.86
1995, however, because of an inability to continue good manu- Prominent cervical adenopathy is commonly present. Spleno-
facturing practices in existing facilities; stores of vaccine megaly and hepatomegaly are found in 50% and 15% of cases,
against serotypes 4 and 7 were depleted in 1998 and 1999, respectively, and periorbital edema is found in up to 30% of
respectively, and outbreaks have now reemerged as a threat to cases.85
the health of military recruits.77,78,81 IM causes an absolute lymphocytosis with greater than 10%
In adults, adenovirus causes pharyngitis as part of a febrile atypical lymphocytes. A vigorous cytotoxic T-cell response to
respiratory illness, and sore throat is reported in 71% of EBV accounts for the lymphocytosis and causes many of the
patients. Adenovirus directly invades the pharyngeal mucosa associated symptoms. Finding atypical lymphocytes on a periph-
and has a cytopathic effect. Thus the sore throat is typically eral blood smear may be consistent with a clinical impression
more severe than with the common cold. Other associated of IM but is not specific for this illness. Toxoplasmosis, CMV,
symptoms include nasal congestion, dry cough, myalgia, head- acute HIV infection, hepatitis A, tularemia, and rubella can also
ache, nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea. The average oral tem- be associated with this finding. CMV can cause a mononucleosis-
perature was 38.9C (102F) in one military outbreak.81 like illness, but typically the sore throat is much less prominent.
Examination reveals an exudative pharyngitis that is difficult to Other serologic findings may include neutropenia (50% to
distinguish from GABHS pharyngitis. More than half of affected 80%), thrombocytopenia (25% to 50%), and asymptomatic
patients received antibiotics at some point during their illness elevated transaminases (50% to 80%).87
162 PART II | GENERAL OTOLARYNGOLOGY
54. Maple PA, Efstratiou A, George RC, et al: Diphtheria immunity in 79. Echavarria M, Forman M, van Tol MJ, et al: Prediction of severe
UK blood donors. Lancet 345:963965, 1995. disseminated adenovirus infection by serum PCR. Lancet 358:384
55. Hodges H: Diphtheria. Pediatric Clin NA 26:445459, 1979. 385, 2001.
56. Diphtheria. In Report of the Committee on Infectious Diseases, ed 23, 80. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Outbreak of pharyn-
Elk Grove Village, IL, 1994, American Academy of Pediatrics, pp goconjunctival fever at summer camp-North Carolina,
177181. 1991. MMWR 41:342344, 1992.
57. Tacket CO, Davis BR, Carter GP, et al: Yersinia entercolitica pharyn- 81. Ryan MA, Gray GC, Smith B, et al: Large epidemic of respiratory
gitis. Ann Intern Med 99:4042, 1983. illness due to adenovirus types 7 and 3 in healthy young adults.
58. Rose FB, Camp CJ, Antes EJ: Family outbreak of fatal Yersinia Clin Infect Dis 34:577581, 2002.
enterocolitica pharyngitis. Am Journal Med 82:636637, 1987. 82. Rty R, Kleemola M, Melen K, et al: Efficacy of PCR and other
59. Adamkiewicz TV, Berkovitch M, Krishnan C, et al: Infection due diagnostic methods for the detection of respiratory adenoviral
to Yersinia enterocolitica in a series of patients with -Thalassemia: infections. J Med Virol 59:6672, 1999.
incidence and predisposing factors. Clin Infect Dis 27:13621366, 83. Gavin PJ, Katz BZ: Intravenous ribavirin treatment for severe
1998. adenovirus disease in immunocompromised children. Pediatrics
60. National Center for Health Statistics: Current estimates from the 110:18, 2002.
National Health Interview survey, United States, 1985. Vital and Health 84. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Two fatal cases of
Statistics, Series 10. Washington, DC, 1986, Public Health Services, adenovirus-related illness in previously healthy young adults-
p 160. Illinois, 2000. MMWR 50:553555, 2001.
61. Peiris JSM, Phil D, Yuen KY, et al: The Severe Acute Respiratory 85. Papesch M, Watkins R: Epstein-Barr virus infectious mononucleo-
Syndrome. N Engl J Med 349:24312441, 2003. sis. Clin. Otolaryngol 26:38, 2001.
62. Chen HC, Young YH, Luo JP, et al: Initial otolaryngological mani- 86. Yoda K, Sata T, Kurata T, et al: Oropharyngotonsillitis associated
festations of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome in Taiwan. Arch with non primary Epstein-Barr Virus infection. Arch Otolaryngol
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 129:11571160, 2003. Head Neck Surg 126:185193, 2000.
63. Gwaltney JM, Phillips CD, Miller DR, et al: Computed tomo- 87. Jenson HB: Acute complications of Epstein-Barr virus infectious
graphic study of the common cold. N Engl J Med 330:2530, mononucleosis. Curr Opin Pediatr 12:263268, 2000.
1994. 88. Corey L, Spear PG: Infections with herpes simplex virus. N Engl J
64. Olshaker JS: Influenza. Emerg Med Clin North America 21:353361, Med 314:686691, 1986.
2003. 89. McMillan JA, Weiner LB, Higgins AM, et al: Pharyngitis associated
65. Nicholson KG, Wood JM, Zambon M: Influenza. Lancet 362:1733 with herpes simplex virus in college students. Pediatr Infect Dis J
1745, 2003. 12:280284, 1993.
66. Henley E: Prevention and treatment of influenza. J Fam Med 52: 90. Yoshizumi M: Profiles of herpes simplex virus type 1 antibodies in
883887, 2003. primary herpetic infections of the maxillofacial regions. Kurume
67. Lalezari J, Campion K, Keene O, et al: Zanamivir for the treat- Med J 47:299306, 2000.
ment of Influenza A and B infection in high-risk patients. Arch 91. Akpan A, Morgan R: Oral candidiasis. Postgrad Med J 78:455459,
Intern Med 161:212217, 2001. 2002.
68. Peters PH, Jr, Gravenstein S, Norwood P, et al: Long-term use of 92. Dahiya MC, Redding SW, Dahiya RS, et al: Oropharyngeal candi-
oseltamivir for the prophylaxis of influenza in a vaccinated frail diasis caused by non-albicans yeast in patients receiving external
older population. J Am Geriatr Soc 49:10251031, 2001. beam radiotherapy for head and neck cancer. Int J Radiation Oncol-
69. Hatakeyama S, Sugaya N, Ito M, et al: Emergence of influenza B ogy Biol Phys 57:7983, 2003.
viruses with reduced sensitivity to neuraminidase inhibitors. JAMA 93. Pagani JL, Chave JP, Casjka C, et al: Efficacy, tolerability, and
297:14351442, 2007. development of resistance in HIV-positive patients treated with
70. Kahn JO, Walker BD: Acute Human Immunodeficiency Virus type fluconazole for secondary prevention of oropharyngeal candidia-
1 infection. N Engl J Med 339:3339, 1998. sis: a randomized, double blind, placebo-controlled trial. J Anti-
71. Schacker T, Collier AC, Hughes J, et al: Clinical and epidemio- microb Chemother 50:231240, 2002.
logic features of primary HIV infection. Ann Intern Med 125:257 94. Redding SW, Zellars RC, Kirkpatrick WR, et al: Epidemiology of
264, 1996. oropharyngeal Candida colonization and infection in patients
72. Vanhems P, Dassa C, Lambert J, et al: Comprehensive classifica- receiving radiation for head and neck cancer. J Clin Microbiol
tion of symptoms and signs reported among 218 patients with 37:38963900, 1999.
acute HIV-1 infection. JAIDS 21:99106, 1999. 95. Revankar SG, Kirkpatrick WR, McAtee RK, et al: Detection and
73. Perlmutter BL, Glaser JB, Oyugi SO: How to recognize and treat significance of fluconazole resistance in oropharyngeal candidia-
acute HIV syndrome. Am Fam Physician 60:535542, 1999. sis in human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients. J Infect Dis
74. Chaudhry R, Akhtar S, Lucente FE, et al: Large oral ulcers leading 174:821827, 1996.
to the destruction of the tonsils in patients with AIDS. Otolaryngol 96. Redding SW, Dahiya MC, Kirkpatrick WR, et al: Candida glabrata
Head Neck Surg 114:474478, 1996. is an emerging cause of oropharyngeal candidiasis in patients
75. Jacobson JM, Greenspan JS, Spritzler J, et al: Thalidomide for receiving radiation for head and neck cancer. Oral Surg Oral Med
the treatment of oral aphthous ulcers in patients with Human Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 97:4752, 2004.
Immunodeficiency Virus infection. N Engl J Med 336:14871493, 97. Redding SW, Kirkpatrick WR, Dib O, et al: The epidemiology of
1997. non-albicans Candida in oropharyngeal candidiasis in HIV patients.
76. Friedman M, Brenski A, Taylor L: Treatment of aphthous ulcers Special Care Dent 20:178181, 2000.
in AIDS patients. Laryngoscope 104:566570, 1994. 98. Castagnola E, Machetti M, Bucci B, et al: Antifungal prophylaxis
77. Barraza EM, Ludwig SL, Gaydos JC, et al: Reemergence of adeno- with azole derivatives. Clin Microbiol Infect 10(Suppl 1):8695, 2004.
virus type 4 acute respiratory disease in military trainees: report 99. Preston SL, Briceland LL: Fluconazole for antifungal prophylaxis
of an outbreak during a lapse in vaccination. J Infect Dis 179:1531 in chemotherapy-induced neutropenia. Am J Health Syst Pharm 52:
1533, 1999. 164173, 1995.
78. Gray GC, Goswami PR, Malasig MD, et al: Adult adenovirus infec- 100. Strahilevitz J, Sugar AM, Engelhard D: Fluconazole in transplant
tions: loss of orphaned vaccines precipitates military respiratory recipients: options and limitations. Transpl Infect Dis 2:6271,
disease epidemics. Clin Infect Dis 31:663670, 2000. 2000.