Cases and Chronology of Lectures

Atty Paolo Dimayuga / Sales

1. Introduction
1. Coronel v. CA (GR 103577, 7 October 1996)
2. Romero v. CA (GR 107207, 23 November 1995)
3. Fule v. CA (GR 112212, 2 March 1998)
4. Ong v. CA (GR 97347, 6 July 1999)
5. Gaite v. Fonacier (GR L-11827, 31 July 1961)
6. Acap v. CA (GR 118114, 7 December 1995)
7. Quijada v. CA (GR 126444, 4 December 1998)
8. Celestino v. CIR (GR L-8506, 31 August 1956)
9. CIR v. Engineering Equipment (GR L-27044, 30 June 1975)
10. Engineering Machinery v. CA (GR 52267, 24 January 1996)
11. Puyat and Sons v. Arco Amusement (GR 47538, 20 June 1941)
12. Quiroga v. Parsons (GR 11491, 23 August 1918)

2. Parties to a contract of sale

13. Medina v. CIR (GR L-15113, 28 January 1961)
14. Calimlim-Canulas v. Fortun (GR 57499, 22 June 1984)
15. Guiang v. CA (GR 125172, 26 June 1998)
16. Rubias v. Batiller (GR L-35702, 29 May 1973)
17. Philippine Trust Co. v. Roldan (GR L-8477, 31 May 1956)

3. Subject Matter of Sale

18. Pichel v. Alonzo (GR L-36902, 30 January 1982)
19. Melliza v. City of Iloilo (GR L-24732, 30 April 1968)
20. Yutek v. Gonzales (GR 9935, 1 February 1915)
21. National Grains Administration v. IAC (GR 74470, 8 March 1989)
22. Johannes-Schuback v. CA (GR 105387, 11 November 1993)
23. Noel v. CA (GR 59550, 11 January 1995)
 24. Nool v. CA (GR 116635, 24 July 1997)
25. Villaflor v. CA (GR 95694, 9 October 1997)

4. Price
26. Loyola v. CA (GR 115734, 3 February 2000)
27. Uy v. CA (GR 120465, 9 September 1999)
28. Mapalo v. Mapalo (GR L-21489 and L-21628, 19 May 1966)
29. Ong v. Ong (GR L-67888, 8 October 1985)
30. Bagnas v. CA (GR 38498, 10 August 1989)
31. Mate v. CA (GR 120724-25, 21 May 1998)
32. Ladanga v. CA (GR-L 55999m 24 August 1984)
33. Balatbat v. CA (GR 109410, 28 August 1996)
34. Heirs of Escanlar v. CA (GR 119777, 23 October 1997)
35. Republic v. Philippine Resources Development (GR L-10141, 31 January 1958)
36. Torres v. CA (GR 134559, 9 December 1999)
37. Toyota Shaw v. CA (GR 116650, 23 May 1995)
38. Velasco v. CA (GR L-31018, 29 June 1973)
39. Ereneta v. Bezore (GR L-29746, 26 November 1973)
40. Vda. de Gordon v. CA (GR L-37831, 23 November 1981)

5. Formation of Contract of Sale

41. Limketkai & Sons Milling v. CA (GR 118509, 1 December 1995)
42. dela Cavada v. CA (GR L-11668, 1 April 1918)
43. Adelfa Properties v. CA (GR 111238, 25 January 1995)
44. Villamor v. CA (GR 97332, 10 October 1991)
45. Soriano v. Bautista (GR L-15752, 29 December 1962)
46. Dizon v. CA, 302 SCRA 288 [1]
47. Sanchez v. Rigos (GR L-25494, 14 June 1972)
48. Montilla v. CA (GR L-47968, 9 May 1988)
49. Yao Ka Sin Trading v. CA, 209 SCRA 763 [2]
50. Nietes v. CA, 46 SCRA 654 [3]
51. Vasquez v. CA (GR 83759, 12 July 1991)
52. Ang Yu v. CA (GR 109125, 2 December 1994)
53. Equitorial Realty Development v. Mayfair Theater (GR 106063, 21 November 1996)
 54. Villonco v. Bormaheco (GR L-26872, 25 July 1975)
55. Spouses Doromal v. CA (GR L-36083, 5 September 1975)
56. Goldenrod v. CA (GR 126812, 24 November 1998)
57. Dalion v. CA (GR 78903, 28 February 1990)
58. Yuviengco v. Dacuycuy, 104 SCRA 668 (1981) [4]
59. First Philippine International Bank v. CA, 252 SCRA (1996) [5]
60. Vda. de Jomoc v. CA (GR 92871, 2 August 1991)
61. Cuyugan v. Santos, 34 PHIL 100 (1916) [6]

6. Performance or Consumation of the Contract of Sale

62. Addison v. Felix (GR 12342, 3 August 1918)
63. Danguilan v. IAC (GR L-69970, 28 November 1988)
64. Pasagui v. Villablanco (GR L-21998, 10 November 1975)
65. Dy Jr. v. CA (GR 92989, 8 July 1991)
66. Power Commercial and Industrial Corp. v. CA (GR 119745, 20 June 1997)
67. Vallarta v. CA (GR L-40195, 29 May 1987)
68. Sta. Ana v. Hernandez (GR L-16394, 17 December 1966)
69. Carbonell v. CA (GR L-29972, 26 January 1976)
70. Quimson v. Rosete (GR L-2397, 9 August 1950)
71. Cheng v. Genato (GR 129760, 29 December 1998)
72. Coronel v. CA, 263 SCRA 15, supra
73. Mendoza v. Kalaw (GR 16420, 12 October 1921)
74. Adalin v. CA (GR 120191, 10 October 1997)
75. Espiritu v. Valerio (GR L-18018, 26 December 1963)
76. Tañedo v. CA (GR 104482, 22 January 1996)
77. Cruz v. Cabana (GR 56232, 22 June 1984)
78. Navera v. CA (GR L-56838, 26 April 1990)
79. Agricultural and Home Extension Development v. CA (GR 92310, 3 September 1992)
80. Balatbat v. CA, 261 SCRA 129 (1996), supra
81. Cruz v. Cabana, 129 SCRA 656 , 663 (1984), supra
82. Radiowealth v. Palileo (GR 83432, 20 May 1991)
83. Dagupan v. Macam (GR L-18497, 31 May 1965)
84. Carumba v. CA (GR L-27587, 18 February 1970)
7. Documents of Title
85. Philippine Trust v. National Bank (GR 16483, 7 December 1921)
86. Siy Cong Bieng v. Hongkong (GR 34655, 5 March 1932)

8. Sale by a Non-Owner or by One Having Voidable Title: The Life of a Contract of Sale
87. Almendra v. IAC (GR 75111, 21 November 1991)
88. Paulmitan v. CA (GR 61584, 25 November 1992)
89. Mindanao v. Yap (GR L-17681, 26 February 1965)
90. Estoque v. Pajimula (GR L-24419, 15 July 1968)
91. Azcona v. Reyes (GR 39590, 6 February 1934)
92. Coronel v. Ona (GR 10280, 7 February 1916)
93. Noel v. CA, 240 SCRA 78 (1995), supra
94. Nool v. CA, 276 SCRA 149 (1997), supra
95. EDCA Publishing v. Santos (GR 80298, 26 April 1990)
96. Aznar v. Yapdiangco (GR L-18536, 31 March 1965)
97. Tagatac v. Jimenez, 53 OG 3792 (1957) [7]

9. Loss, Deterioration, Fruits and Other Benefits

10. Remedies of Parties for Breach of Contract of Sale

98. Levy v. Gervacio (GR 46306, 27 October 1939)
99. Delta Motor Sales Corp. v. Niu Kim Duan (GR 61043, 2 September 1992)
100. Tajanlangit v. Southern Motors (GR L-10789, 28 May 1957)
101. Nonato v. IAC (GR L-67181, 22 November 1985)
102. Vda. de Quiambao v. MMCI (GR L-17384, 31 October 1961)
103. Cruz v. Filipinas Investment and Finance Corp. (GR L-24772, 27 May 1968)
104. Ridad v. Fil Investment (GR L-39806, 27 January 1983)
105. Zayas v. Luneta Motors (GR L-30583, 23 October 1982)
106. Northern Motors v. Sayunoso (GR L-28074, 29 May 1970)
107. Macondray v. Eustaquio (GR 43683, 16 July 1937)
108. Filipinas Investment and Finance Corp. v. Ridad (GR L-27645, 28 November 1969)
109. Filinvest Credit Corp. v. CA (GR 82508, 29 September 1989)
110. Elisco Tool Manufacturing v. CA, 308 SCRA 731 (1999) [8]
111. Legarda v. Saldaña (GR L-26578, 28 January 1974)
 112. Mclaughin v. CA, 144 SCRA 693 (1986) [9]
113. Luzon Brokerage v. Maritime, 86 SCRA 305 (1978) [10]

11. The Remedy of Rescission in Sales Contracts Covering Immovables: Contract of

Sale versus Contract to Sell
114. Adelfa Properties v. CA, 240 SCRA 565, 586 (1995), supra
115. Universal Food Corp. v. CA, 33 SCRA 1 (1970) [11]
116. Suria v. IAC, 151 SCRA 661(1987) [12]
117. Romero v. CA, 250 SCRA (1995), supra
118. Lim v. CA, 263 SCRA 569 (1996) [13]
119. Froilan v. Pan-Oriental Shipping Co., 12 SCRA 276 (1964) [14]
120. The Manila Racing Club v. Manila Jockey Club (GR L-46533, 28 October 1939)
121. Adelfa Properties Inc. vs. Court of Appeals, 240 SCRA 575 (1995), supra
122. PNB v. CA, 262 SCRA 464 (1995) [15]
123. Babasa v. CA (GR 124045, 21 May 1998)
124. Pangilinan v. CA, 279 SCRA 590 (1997) [16]
125. Rillo v. CA (GR 125347, 19 June 1997)
126. Odyssey Park Inc. v. CA, 280 SCRA 253 (1997) [17]
127. Roque v. Lapuz, 96 SCRA 741 (1980) [18]
128. Angeles v. Calasanz (GR L-42283, 18 March 1985)
129. Dignos v. CA (GR L-59266, 29 February 1988)

Additional case

1. Carceller v. CA (GR 124791, 10 February 1999)