Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
November 2000
This report was drafted by Sy Goodman, Tim Kelly, Michael Minges and
Larry Press. Lakshmi Rajagopal contributed to the country overview
chapter. Vanessa Gray provided comments. The cover of the report was
designed by Dalia Mendiluce. The layout, formatting and production of the
report was carried out by Nathalie Delmas. The report is based on field
research conducted during 17-21 January 2000 and electronic
correspondence as well as reports and articles. The authors are indebted
to Amrit R. Pant, Shashank Kansal and numerous other people who
provided input to the report and the time they spared for our many
questions (for a list of people and organizations met during the field
research see Annex 1). The opinions expressed in the report are those of
the authors and may not necessarily reflect the views of the International
Telecommunication Union or its members or the Kingdom of Nepal. More
details can be found on the website at http://www.itu.int/ti/casestudies.
ii
Contents
iii
Figures
1 Nepal .................................................................................. 1
2.1 Fixed-line networks .............................................................. 6
2.2 Teledensity by district ........................................................... 6
2.3 Sources of revenue ............................................................ 10
2.4 Nepal's international telephone traffic ................................... 11
2.5 Internet users in Nepal ....................................................... 15
3.1 Nepal's domain name ......................................................... 22
5.1 State of the Internet in Nepal .............................................. 43
Tables
iv
1. Country background
1. Country background
1
Nepal Case Study
Age Distribution:
Below 15 yrs 42.4%
15-59 yrs 51.5%
Above 60 yrs 5.8%
Urban Population: 9%
birthplace of Buddha), Muslims and change over the last couple of years
others. Nepali is the official language was mainly earned through textiles and
(spoken by about half the population; carpet making.
more than a dozen other languages are
also used). English is widely under- The country imports almost four times
stood in tourist areas. more than it exports. The main imports
are petroleum, transport equipment
1.3 Economy and fertilizer. Major exports include
carpets, garments and leather. Tour-
Nepals 1997 Gross National Product ism provides around 20 per cent of
(GNP) of US$ 4.8 billion, is, on a per Nepals export earnings. As an LDC,
capita basis US$ 210, statistically mak- Nepal benefits from significant bi-lat-
ing the nation one of the poorest coun- eral and multilateral assistance, ac-
tries in the world. Indeed the kingdom counting for almost nine per cent of
is classified by the UNDP as a Least its GDP.
Developed Country (LDC), with nearly
half its population living below the pov- Since 1991, the government has tried
erty line. However GNP expressed in to push through economic reform, and
purchasing power parity (PPP), which encourage trade and foreign invest-
adjusts GNP according to the price level ment. Political instability, however, in-
in the country, was US$ 1090 in 1997, cluding the fall of five governments
placing it at the high end among the over the past few years, coupled with
LDCs. the small size of the economy, the re-
moteness of its location, and vulner-
The economy grew at five per cent a ability to natural disasters, poses great
year between 1990 97. Agriculture challenges for development.
is the mainstay of the economy, and
occupies 80 per cent of the popula- Nepal is a landlocked country with two
tion, accounting for 41 per cent of the giant neighbours. Nepal mainly counts
GDP. Services make up 35 per cent, on India for sea access, and its rela-
industry 22 per cent and manufactur- tion with India is thereby crucial. A dis-
ing 10 per cent. Industrial activity pute between the two in the 1980s,
mainly comprises of the processing of for example, led India to revoke the
agricultural products. Foreign ex- Trade and Transit Treaty with Nepal,
2
1. Country background
International Trade:
Exports US$ 400 mil.
Imports US$ 1653 mil.
Current Account Balance US$ 569 mil.
Trade Deficit as % of GDP 25.3%
3
Nepal Case Study
nearly three centuries before it came executive powers and the armed
into conflict with the British East India forces.
Company in the 19th century. The re-
sulting Anglo-Nepalese war devastated In 1962, King Bir Bikram Shah Dev set
Nepal, reducing it to its present size, up a centrally controlled partyless
and this was followed by three dec- council system of government called
ades of aristocratic factious infighting. the Panchayat. Increasing opposition
Rulership by the hereditary Rana rule and disillusionment with this system
began in 1846, and gave way, in 1951, led to the pro-democracy movement.
to a return of the original monarchy of
the Kingdom, which took charge of all The Movement for the Restoration of
Democracy was formally established in
Nepal in 1990. Political unrest, agita-
Table 1.3: Human poverty tion, demonstrations and rallies led to
indicators the replacement of the Panchayat sys-
tem with a multi-party interim govern-
ment in 1990. General elections were
Nation HPI
held in 1991, with 65% of the popu-
lace voting.3
China 19
Sri Lanka 20 King Birendra is presently head of
India 36 state, and commander-in-chief, while
Pakistan 42
the prime minister heads a council of
ministers appointed from the elected
Bangladesh 44
House of Representatives. The Su-
Nepal 52 preme Court acts as court of appeal,
and has powers of original jurisdiction.
Elections in 1999 saw the Nepali Con-
Source: UNDP Human Poverty Index,
gress win an absolute majority of seats
www.undp.org/povertyreport.
in parliament, and Krishna Prasad
Bhattarai sworn in as Prime Minister.4
1
<http://tradeport.org/ts/countries/nepal/political.html> (February 8, 2000)
Nepal: Political Environment
2
<http://tradeport.org/countries/nepal/political.html> (February 8, 2000)
Source: UN Department of Commerce National Trade Data Bank, September 3, 1999.
3
<http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cig-bin/query2/>
4
<wysiwyg://32/http://www.nepalhomepage.com/general/political-structure.html> (February 8, 2000)
4
2. Information and communication technology status
5
Nepal Case Study
Number of main telephone lines, in Nepal, 1990-98, and comparative growth rates within region, 1993-98
Main telephone lines installed (Year-end 15/7) Main line grow th (% per year)
250'000 60%
208'387 Sri Lanka
50% Nepal
200'000
40%
150'000
30%
100'000 75'637 India
57'320 20%
Note: The data for Nepal is for financial year end 15 July. Thus, data shown for 1998 means year ending 15/7/99.
Source: ITU World Telecommunication Indicators Database.
6
2. Information and communication technology status
the Authority is Mr Bhoop Raj Pandey fectively carried out. One indication of
and there should be four other mem- this is the fact that the MoIC still pro-
bers of the NTA, though to date two vides the Chairman of the NTC board.
positions remain vacant.
There is a privatisation unit within the
The Nepal Telecommunications Corpo- Ministry of Finance, which has already
ration (NTC) is the incumbent public carried out around 16 smaller
telecommunications operator and, until privatisations, but the telecommuni-
recently, held a monopoly over all as- cations sector is not considered a pri-
pects of telecommunications in the ority because it is profitable.
Kingdom. The chair of the Board of Incidentally, in the civil aviation field,
Directors is Mr Shree Ram Poudel, the there are now 17 private domestic air-
Secretary of the MoIC. The significance lines, including Buddha Air, Necon and
of this is that it means NTC is not fully Lumbini Air. These new airlines have
independent of the government and succeeded in increasing domestic air
therefore the corporatisation process, travel by 400 per cent since the early
which was initiated under the National 1990s even though they are compet-
Communications Policy of 1992, has ing against the state-owned Royal
not been effectively implemented. For Nepal, which operates all international
instance, according to the terms of the flights. Experience from this sector,
Act, the Minister of Information and which is regulated by the Tourism Min-
Communications is also chair of the istry, shows that private sector par-
Radio Frequency Policy Determination ticipation can work in Nepal.
Committee, which administers and al-
locates spectrum. Furthermore, the 2.1.3 Regulation and policy-
fact that NTC is still effectively a gov- making
ernment corporation means that it has 2.1.3.1 Licensing
only limited access to external financ-
The 1997 Act established a licensing
ing. The lack of a strategic partner,
regime, which has been actively pur-
even in the mobile field, has delayed
sued by the regulator, Mr Pandey, who
the introduction of modern manage-
was described as a godsend by the
ment techniques.
private sector. Areas that were liber-
alised in the Act include the Internet
As of mid-November 1999 NTC em-
Service Provider (ISP) market, radio-
ploys some 4661 people, implying a
paging and data communications via
labour productivity level of 50 lines per
Very-Small Aperture Terminals (VSAT).
employee, around 40 per cent of the
There is no limitation on the number
global average. The high potential
of licences that can be issued in these
growth activities, including mobile cel- areas. In addition, the Cable TV mar-
lular, Internet and business activities ket, which is regulated under the 1991
are grouped into a Cellular Mobile and National Broadcasting Act by the MoIC,
New Services unit that employs about is also liberalised. Table 2.1 shows a
60 people. list of licenses granted by mid-Janu-
ary 2000. It should be noted that in
2.1.2.2 Privatisation some areas that are notionally liberal-
NTC is fully state-owned though there ised, including payphones and pre-paid
are plans to corporatize and privatize calling service, trunking mobile and
the company. The plans, as outlined local data communications, there have
in the Telecommunication Sector Strat- been no requests for licences to date.
egy document, foresee the introduc-
tion of a strategic investor, which would 2.1.3.2 Market liberalisation
take just over 50 per cent of the The general policy direction was es-
shares, with additional shares going to tablished in the 1992 National Com-
local investors. Senior management munications Policy and has more
within NTC is apparently keen to press recently been elaborated in a Telecom-
ahead with privatisation, but there is munication Sector Strategy document,
opposition from the staff union. Fur- prepared for the World Bank in Octo-
thermore, the necessary initial step of ber 1998 by Telecon Ltd., a Finnish
corporatization has not yet been ef- consultancy. The document divides the
7
Nepal Case Study
As at mid-January 2000
Source: NTA.
8
2. Information and communication technology status
2.1.3.3 Tariff rebalancing and inter- to take an active stance, but will rather
connection leave it to NTC to negotiate with its
competitors. The experience of the
Unlike in India where the regulators ISPs is that the published tariff is ef-
initiative on tariff rebalancing and in- fectively the interconnect rate. In the
terconnection has proved so crucial Telecommunication Strategy document
to telecom reform, NTA does not ap- put forward by Telecon Ltd., it is pro-
pear to have taken any action on this posed that interconnect rates be set
issue. Indeed, NTCs opinion is that, at 50 per cent of the published tariff
because its charter dates from be- (so, to interconnect to the PSTN would
fore NTA was established, it is not cost 50 per cent of the local call tariff
regulated for basic services by NTA. and to interconnect to a mobile net-
It has submitted a tariff increase plan work would cost 50 per cent of the cost
to MoIC and the Ministry of Finance, of a mobile call). Given that local call
but not to NTA. The plan would see tariffs have not been revised for years,
local call charges double from 1 Rs this arrangement is likely to be highly
to 2 Rs (around 2.8 US cents) for a asymmetric.
three minute peak rate call. Monthly
subscription charges, which are cur- 2.1.4 Network
rently set at 150 Rs for both busi-
ness and residential subscribers, 2.1.4.1 Backbone network
including 100 free 3-minute local
calls, would also double. The tariff One advantage of Nepals network
rebalancing plan also sees long dis- being relatively young is that it is all-
tance calls rising (with a cut from five digital with the majority having been
zones to three) and some interna- installed in the last few years. The
tional call charges falling, with a re- backbone of the network is a digital
duction in international call zones microwave link, which runs from East
from four zones to two. to West, offering some 20000 voice
channels. In addition, there are
While tariff rebalancing is necessary, spurs, which link the major cities and
there having been no change for the districts using Multi Access Rural Tel-
past eight years during, which time ephone System (MARTS) technology.
inflation has averaged 6-8 per cent Other areas of the country are served
per year, it is unfortunate that NTA by short-wave radio or by VSAT, of
has not been permitted to make an which there are currently seven in
independent review. Furthermore, service. The main international links
proposals submitted by the ISPs to are via a fibre optic cable to India
allow revenue-sharing of the local and via INTELSAT. There is also a
call charge (allowing, for instance, digital microwave link to Bangladesh.
the provision of free Internet, In total, there were 854 international
funded by local call charges) have not telephone circuits in operation at
been acted upon by NTC, nor has con- mid-November, up from 804 a year
sideration been given to a lower earlier.
monthly subscription for lines, which
do not make outgoing local calls (e.g., There are plans afoot to create a fibre
the lines rented by ISPs). The only area ring around Kathmandu (already
where NTC seems responsive to cus- started) and an east-west fibre link
tomers is for international leased line running alongside the main highway
charges where NTC cut its charges (tendering for this project is expected
drastically after the private ISPs in- soon). The Kathmandu ring is being
stalled their own VSAT links. financed from NTCs own funds
whereas the east-west link may be
As NTC does not compete directly with funded, in part, from Nordic develop-
the private sector, the question of in- ment funds. In addition to the seven
terconnect has not yet arisen, though existing VSATs, a further five are
it will obviously become a critical is- planned to make up a regional satel-
sue once the new licenses are issued. lite network as a back-up to the ter-
NTA does not appear to be intending restrial network.
9
Nepal Case Study
Revenue for Nepal Telecommunications Corporation, in millions of Rupees, in FY 1998 and in 1993-98
Other, including leased lines, NTC revenue by source, 1992-1998 (million Rps)
interest, Intelsat etc, 5.1% Fixed charges &
local calls, 17.0% 5'000
Other
Int'l net settlement
4'000
Int'l net Int'l collection charges
settlements, Domestic
3'000
28.9%
Long- 2'000
distance,
Int'l collection
18.9% 1'000
charges, 30.2%
0
NTC revenue 1997/98: Total 4'321 m Rps (US$65m) 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998
Source: Adapted from NTC annual report, various years. Financial year ending July 15.
10
2. Information and communication technology status
ments as a percentage of overall rev- stance, Indias ratio in 1997 was 11:1
enue has increased from 7 per cent in and Vietnams was 40:1). This is
1991/92 to 29 per cent in 1997/98. mainly due to the fact that the United
States is home to the major call-back
Nepal has international connections with service providers. Nepal has nominally
some 20 different countries (mainly via banned call-back, though there is no
INTELSAT) and offers direct dial serv- law stating this and the service is
ice to more than 130. Recently, home- widely advertised on the streets of
country direct services have been Kathmandu. Furthermore, the in-
established to five major destinations. crease in settlement revenue over the
Nepals top international traffic desti- last few years suggests that call-back
nation is India, though much of the traf- is widely practiced.
fic to India is cross-border and is
conducted outside the international ac- The result is that US operators made
counting rate system. For incoming traf- net settlements (excluding transit pay-
fic, India is again the main source, with ments) of some US$5.7 million in
a total of just over 10 million minutes 1998. However, the picture appears to
in the year to June 1999, of which the be changing. In the first seven months
majority was from cross-border (via of 1999, the annualised rate of traffic
Indias DoT) rather than international reported as incoming from the United
traffic (via Indias VSNL). States (AT&T) was down by just over
30 per cent with a particularly big fall
For international traffic passing in July, the same month that VSAT data
through the accounting rate system, traffic began to be delivered to Nepal.
the major source is the United States. The same pattern is true also for the
As Figure 2.4 (right chart) shows, United Kingdom where incoming traf-
Nepal has a ratio of incoming to out- fic from BT fell by almost 40 per cent.
going traffic with the United States of Interestingly, in the same month, in-
around nine to one, a ratio, which had coming traffic from all other sources
continued to grow throughout the dec- grew by 28 per cent suggesting that
ade until 1999. This is consistent with refile traffic may be growing. While it
other developing countries (for in- would be unwise to draw conclusions
Incoming international traffic, by origin country, 1998/99, and Nepal's traffic and settlements
with the United States, 1994-99
8'000 US to Nepal
Traffic (thousand mins)
13.7%
Nepal to US 5'000
Other 6'000
Europe,
0.7% 4'000
2'500
UK, 16.7% US,
2'000
19.6% India/
VSNL 7.3%
0 0
Nepal's incoming int'l traffic,
1998/99: Total = 26.2m mins 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999*
Note: In the left chart, the breakdown shows the immediate origin of traffic, not necessarily the real origin (i.e.,
includes transit traffic). It is based on the 12 months ending July 1999. In the right chart, the figures for 1999 are
estimated based on the first seven months of the year. The data are for calendar years ending 31 December.
Source: NTC, FCC.
11
Nepal Case Study
Unit 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999
TELEPHONE NETWORK
Main telephone
lines in operation 57320 64894 68886 72683 75637 83713 112645 139989 208387 247214
Capacity used ... ... ... ... 88.8% 85.2% 77.9% 77.8% 81.5% 85.8%
Main telephone lines
per 100 inhabitants 0.32 0.35 0.36 0.37 0.38 0.41 0.54 0.66 0.95 1.11
Residential main lines
per 100 households 3) 1.69 2.08 2.14 2.13 2.12 2.35 3.22 3.78 5.32 6.16
% digital main lines % 89.5 86 86 87 89 99.2 99.8 99.3 100 100
Waiting list
for main lines 72434 88548 126817 130009 136221 153751 202363 243444 277997 269025
Total demand 129754 153442 195703 202692 211858 236474 315008 383433 486384 516239
Satisfied demand 44.2% 42.3% 35.2% 35.9% 35.7% 35.0% 35.8% 36.5% 42.8% 47.9%
Public payphones 248 266 341 321 494 494 835 ... ... ...
Districts having
exchanges ... ... ... 30 30 31 54 57 60 65
% of total ... ... ... 40.0% 40.0% 41.3% 72.0% 76.0% 80.0% 86.7%
Village Development
Committees served ... ... ... ... ... ... 950 1200 1675 1535
% of total ... ... ... ... ... ... 23.8% 30.0% 41.9% 38.4%
TRAFFIC
Local telephone calls 10x3 ... ... 169343 193789 215279 330700 440900 ... ... ...
Per subscriber,
per month ... ... 205 222 237 333 326 ... ... ...
National trunk
telephone (calls) 10x3 ... ... 19035 22779 29033 42700 57300 ... ... ...
Intl outgoing
telephone (minutes) 10x3 7091 9111 10405 11510 13410 14600 16533 17326 19100 25100
Intl incoming
telephone (minutes) 10x3 6373 9394 14230 16400 17500 20600 25600 31000 28900 22900
Intl bothway
telephone (minutes) 10x3 13464 18505 24635 27910 30910 35200 42133 48326 48000 48000
STAFF
Full-time telecom-
munication staff 3502 3546 3413 3599 3483 3877 4078 4151 4529 4671
QUALITY OF SERVICE
Faults per 100 main
lines 1) % 192 180 168 156 200 262 180 120 80.4 78.8
REVENUE
Total telecom
services (NRs) 10x6 699 1147 1316 1818 1905 2147 2677 3320 4321 4633
Total telecom
services (US$) 10x6 $ 24 $ 31 $ 31 $ 37 $ 39 $ 41 $ 47 $ 57 $ 65 $ 68
Revenue per line $ 415 $ 474 $ 447 $ 515 $ 510 $ 500 $ 419 $ 409 $ 314 $ 275
CAPITAL EXPENDITURE
Annual
telecommunication
investment (NRs) 2) 10x6 696 755 311 99 540 879 1695 1163 1475 1873
Annual telecom.
Investment (US$) 10x6 $ 24 $ 20 $7 $2 $ 11 $ 17 $ 30 $ 20 $ 22 $ 27
Note: 1) Yearly estimate from average per month for Kathmandu Valley exchanges. 2) Additions to fixed
assets. 3) Estimate.
Source: Nepal Telecommunications Corporation (NTC).
12
2. Information and communication technology status
on the basis of one months data, and courses, well advertised lectures, ect.
there may be other reasons for the The NIUG has some ambitions along
change (for instance, re-routing of these lines. However, membership is
transit traffic) the available evidence still very small, with less than 200 in-
would seem to point towards an in- dividuals belonging.
creasing percentage of traffic from
AT&T and BT being diverted outside the 2.2.1 Computer market
accounting rate system, possibly via
the Internet (see section 3.3). If July There are around 100 companies sell-
1999s trend had continued for the rest ing computer equipment in the coun-
of the year, the lost revenue to NTC try. As there is no domestic computer
would have been around US$4-5 mil- manufacturing industry, all hardware
lion, or just under 10 per cent of total is imported. This includes branded
telecommunications revenue. units (e.g., IBM, Dell, Compaq, etc.)
as well as unbranded parts that are
2.1.6 Market indicators then assembled in Nepal. There is no
official data on the size of the compu-
Table 2.2 provides a listing of the ma- ter hardware market. However since
jor telecommunication indicators for all computer equipment is imported,
Nepal extracted from the ITU Yearbook estimates can be derived from trade
of Statistics. data. Statistics compiled by an indus-
try association show that the value of
computers and parts imported into
2.2 Information Technology Nepal for the 1998 fiscal year (latest
sector year for which data are available) was
US$ 6.26 million.6 This data indicates
This section reviews key organizations that the value of imports of comput-
in the IT sector, the status of the com- ers and parts rose through mid-1995
puter hardware and software markets and then declined (see Table 2.3). This
and Internet service provision. Govern- is curious given that the Internet
ment ministries with a direct role in IT started in Nepal in 1995, and this might
include the MST and MOIC (yet ironi- have been expected to cause a sharp
cally it seems that neither even has a rise in computer imports.
web site!). The former is the co-
ordinating agency for IT in the coun- The drop in import value might be ex-
try while the latter provides oversight plained by falling prices, but unfortu-
for the telecommunication, postal, nately data on the number o f
mass media and broadcasting sectors. computers imported is not available.
Most major industries in Nepal have Another explanation might be the In-
an association. The Computer Associa- dian computer market. Until recently,
tion of Nepal (CAN, <http:// personal computers in Nepal were
www.caninfo.org>) fulfils this role for cheaper than in India. This encouraged
the IT industry. Created in late 1992, the re-export of PCs from Nepal to In-
CANs 40-60 institutional and dia. Since the liberalisation of the In-
2-3000 individual members include dian computer market, fewer
vendors, software developers and computers are being re-exported from
other professionals involved in Nepals Nepal. Yet another explanation is that
computer sector. It sponsors the an- equipment is imported via distributors
nual Info-Tech show with between 50- in Singapore or Hongkong SAR and not
60 exhibitors and 10000 attendees. captured in official statistics. Conver-
Another IT-related organization is the sations with various sources suggest
Nepal Internet Users Group (Nepaliug, that the number of PCs sold in Nepal
<http://www.nepaliug.org.np>). It in 1999 was between 10000 15000
was started in 1997 to serve the units and that the stock of PCs in the
Internet community in Nepal. Else- country could be as high as 100000.
where such groups sometimes play a However, ITU research suggests that
national educational role, or at least a the number of PCs in the country is
consciousness-raising role, with regard around 60000. This places PC penetra-
to the Internet, e.g., through short tion in Nepal at 0.27 per 100 inhabit-
13
Nepal Case Study
Note: a) Converted at annual average exchange rate. b) Based on a value of US$ 1500 per PC for 1992-1997
and US$ 1300 for 1997/98. Figure for 1998/99 based on low end of industry estimate for 1999. c) Based on
rounded figure of additions for each year. Assumes no replacement.
Source: ITU adapted from Research and Information Division of FNCCI from various publications of Nepal
Rastra Bank.
ants, slightly lower than India and Pa- Service Provider (ISP) in mid-July 1995
kistan but above Bangladesh. when it established an online interna-
tional link via NTC to Singapore
Both branded and assembled PCs are Telecom. WorldLink and Computerland
sold on the market. It is estimated that followed a year later. The legal status
around 75 per cent of PCs sold are of these pioneering ISPs was vague
assembled (e.g., non-branded clones). until 1997 when the new Telecommu-
Transport is estimated to add about nications Act formalised a licensing
10-12 per cent to the price of a PC. procedure.
Customs duty is 12 per cent and sales
tax is 10 per cent.7 A fully equipped In January 2000, there were eleven
Pentium III branded PC sells for around licensed Internet Service Providers
US$3000 while a clone is available for (ISPs) of which at least nine were op-
less than Rs. 65000 (around erational (see Table 2.4).9 Besides pro-
US$ 1000). These prices are not sub- viding service to residential and
stantially higher than what is available business users, these ISP also resell
in more developed countries but, given service to specialized providers (e.g.,
the low incomes in Nepal, they are HealthNet, which subscribes to Mer-
beyond the reach of the majority of cantiles ISP services and in turn pro-
the population. vides a discounted ISP service to the
health community) and public call of-
fices and cybercafs. The number of
The computer software market prima- Internet subscribers was almost 9000
rily consists of customization of at January 2000.
branded accounting and financial soft-
ware. According to one estimate, there Estimating the number of Internet us-
are around 25 companies engaging in ers in the country is difficult.
software development.8 No figures are
available on imports or sales. One area No known surveys have been
of native software development has carried out, either by the Cen-
been in the development of packages tral Bureau of Statistics or by
utilizing the Nepali font. market research groups.
14
2. Information and communication technology status
Note: * These ISPs did not reply to an NTA questionnaire casting doubt on whether they were actually
operational at January 2000.
Source: ITU adapted from National Telecommunication Authority and ISP data.
Source: Left chart: ITU estimates. Right chart: Network Startup Resource Center as reported by Dileep Agrawal,
May 1999.
15
Nepal Case Study
Note: 1) These companies have VSAT operator licences and also lease capacity to downstream ISPs in Nepal.
Source: ITU adapted from ISP information.
16
2. Information and communication technology status
25 years ago. Still, Nepal was one of young people and those with educa-
the last nations to begin TV broadcast- tion, money, and fluency in multiple
ing and international email, and a 1996 languages. This history leads us to the
survey found the effectiveness of the question of political will, without which
Nepalese mass media circumscribed by no pilot study or infrastructure invest-
incapacity to reach remote areas. The ment will be meaningful. There are
same study shows Nepalese media forces that tend to preserve the sta-
penetration trailing that of China, In- tus quo in all nations. In some cases,
dia, Pakistan and Bangladesh in many political and economic advantages are
ways. More specific findings include: protected, and in others alternatives
and opportunities are simply not seen.
Most Nepalese have either no
access or have poor access to 2.3.1 Broadcasting
mass media. 2.3.1.1 Radio
Radio Nepal has been broadcasting
A substantial portion of the
since April 1951. It uses both Short
population does not use the
Wave and Medium Wave frequencies.
national mass media.
FM radio, covering Kathmandu valley,
was started in 1995. Medium wave
Although the propensity to transmission, covering between 80-
identify local problems and dis- 90% of the population, has the widest
cuss issues appears to be fairly reach of any mass medium in the coun-
widely prevalent among the try. There are 15 hours of transmission
population at large, the ability per day including 2 hours of regional
to draw the attention of the programming. Radio Nepal launched an
authorities to local needs and Internet service in 1997 (the web site
problems, and to use the me- is <www.catmando.com/news/radio-
dia to publicize them, is limited. nepal/radionp.htm>). It is partciularly
popular with overseas Nepalese. There
People in the South, East and are plans to expand the service from
Kathmandu valley have better access Nepali and English news to include other
to, and use of, the media than others. programmes and music. Radio Nepal
The same holds for urban people, men, employs around 600 staff.
Development Region
Eastern 54.2 29.57 41.8
Central 50.19 20.75 35.21
Western 58.24 32.82 44.47
Mid-West 46.94 17.6 31.89
Far West 48.98 14.85 31.31
Ecosystemic Region
Mountains 43.44 13.42 27.73
Hills 61.75 31 45.51
Tarai 45.4 19.92 32.61
17
Nepal Case Study
Source: Aditya, Anand, Editor, Mass Media and Democratization, A Country Study on Nepal, Institute for
Integrated Development Studies, Kathmandu, 1996.
NTV covers about 42 per cent of the NTV transmits 61 hours of programmes
countrys population and 32 per cent per week. The mix is 30% news re-
of the land area. It has ten transmit- lated (including three daily news pro-
ting stations. It estimates that it has grammes; one in English); 50%
2.5 million viewers across the coun- locally-produced and 20% foreign. It
try, around 10 per cent of the popula- has two production studios in
tion. The number of TV sets in Nepal Kathmandu. Another one is located in
is estimated at around 150000, mak- Kohalpur in the Western region and
ing it one of the few countries in the there are also plans to build one in the
world where television density is lower Eastern region. There is no television
than telephone density. Two major con- license fee system in Nepal. Funding
Source: ITU adapted from Sources shown. Nepal TV web site is: <http://www.explorenepal.com/ntv/main.html>
18
2. Information and communication technology status
for NTV comes from the government 80 cable television companies oper-
but as that is insufficient, NTV solicits ating in the country. A license is re-
advertisements and also sells its locally quired from the MoIC. The largest is
produced programmes (particularly Space Time Network. There are an
documentaries) to overseas broadcast- estimated 60000 70000 cable tel-
ers. NTV has around 300 staff. evision subscribers. There is little
talk about using cable television in-
In addition to NTV there are two pri- frastructure for either telephony or
vate television channels broadcasting Internet access (through cable mo-
in Kathmandu. There are also around dems).
5
The text of which is available at: <http://www7.itu.int/treg/legislation/nepal/law.htm>
6
<http://www.fncci.org/fncci/text/imother.txt>.
7
There is some controversy that computer importers are being overcharged for taxes. See Source: VAT and
the IT Inedustry, by Prakash Khanal. In, PC Quest Nepal. 10-13th April, 1998. Kathmandu, Nepal. <http://
www.panasia.org.sg/nepalnet/economics/vat&it_industry.htm>.
8
See IT Nepal Message #12. <http://www.listbot.com/cgi-bin/
subscriber?Act=view_message&list_id=it_nepal&msg_num=12&start_num=13>.
9
Although NTC does not currently provide ISP service to end users, it had been active providing the backbone
international link until the VSAT market was liberated in 1999. As the incumbent PTO, it is free to provide any
telecommunication service without applying for a license.
10
Internet users and organisations in Nepal handed over more than $1 million to their ISPs last year - a figure
that could go as high as $5 million by 2001. See Vivek S. Rana. Internet War: The on-line corporation.
Choosing the right Internet Service Provider. Cyber Post. Kathmandu, Wednesday September 29th, 1999.
<http://www.nepalnews.com.np/contents/fortnightly/cpost/1999/Sep/Sep29/computer.htm>.
11
The royalties (4% of gross income) paid in 1997/98 were 511 k Rps paid by Worldlink and 384 k Rps paid by
Mercantile who, together, account for 64 per cent of the total market, by number of subscribers.
19
Nepal Case Study
20
3. Internet and telecommunications
Based on a minimum of 15 hours per month of dial-up use, peak rate, US$, January 2000
Note: These are the lowest priced plans for 15 hours per month. Extra hours are billed at peak rate. Not
including tax. National currency prices are converted to US$ using 31 January 2000 exchange rates.
Source: ITU adapted from ISP tariff schedules.
21
Nepal Case Study
2 nd level domains: COM.NP (Com- mercialising the .np ccTLD. One ex-
mercial), ORG.NP (Organization), ception may be that .np is related to
EDU.NP (Education), NET.NP (Net- Nippon, which may explain why
works) and GOV.NP (government). In there seem to be a relatively large
January 2000, there were 405 regis- number of Japanese hosts using .np.
trations of which 192 were reachable.
In contrast, the Internet Software 3.3.3 IP telephony
Consortium reported 290 hosts reach- Nepals settlement rate for traffic with
able under the .np ccTLD in its Janu- the US is 84 US cents per minute (as
ary 2000 survey. There are restrictions of 6 January 2000), well above FCC
against trading in or using known benchmarks ITU Focus Group indica-
trade names. Although desirable, the tive target rates. With BT, the rate is
.np host does not have to be physi- 68 US cents per minute (as of Octo-
cally located in Nepal. However, ex- ber 1998). However, the international
cept for large multi-national telecommunications arbitrage site,
companies, there must be at least one Arbinet (www.arbinet.com), offers as
administrative contact for the domain termination rate of just 53 US cents
name in Nepal. All disputes related to per minute, suggesting there are
the .np ccTLD are to be settled by a cheaper ways of terminating traffic in
court with jurisdiction in Nepal. The Nepal than via the formal accounting
growth of .np hosts had been moder- rate mechanism. The high accounting
ate since 1997 suggesting that either rate certainly creates the incentive for
most Nepali organizations aware of the alternative routing. This would seem
Internet have already registered or to explain the recent decline in inter-
they are using other TLDs (e.g., national incoming traffic from the
.com). However the number of hosts United States (see Figure 2.6).
almost doubled in 1999 (see Figure
3.1). It should be noted that many, if One possible way to bypass the account-
not most web sites in Nepal, do not ing rate system is via Voice over IP
use the .np domain name. (VoIP). The formal situation is that VoIP
is illegal in Nepal as it is seen as im-
Mercantile has offered to transfer re- pinging upon NTCs international voice
sponsibility for the .np domain name service monopoly. While the regulator
to the NTA. Unlike other ccTLDs such takes a neutral view on the matter, ar-
as .nu, .to, or .tv15 , there does not guing that IP telephony is almost im-
appear to be as much cachet with possible to block. The policy-making
.np. Thus, there is little scope for com- body, MoIC, has obliged the regulator
Number of .np hosts, 1995-2000 and distribution of 2nd level .np domain names, January 2000
COM EDU
139 153
63% 7%
60 NET
19 8%
GOV
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 3%
22
3. Internet and telecommunications
to make clear to the ISPs in the coun- 3.3.4 Universal service / access
try that VoIP is illegal. 16 In Janu- Nepal faces an immense task in en-
ary 2000, NTA was obliged by MoIC to hancing access to communications.
send a notice to all ISPs instructing them Overall teledensity (main telephone
to block the Dialpad (<http:// lines per 100 inhabitants) is just over
www.dialpad.com/>) IP telephony serv- one, with wide variations between ur-
ice, which offers free calls to the United ban and rural areas. Access to Internet
States. The ISPs duly contacted their is concentrated in the Kathmandu area,
user base to inform them of NTAs no- with POPs in less than half a dozen
tice. However, given that Fax over IP is other towns. Given the low level of
liberalised (requires a license), and that communication infrastructure, it is
it is virtually impossible for ISPs to dis- clear that the countrys primary goal
tinguish between VoIP and Fax over IP, should be to ensure widespread access
it would be surprising if the ISPs were to communications facilities at afford-
able to comply with this ruling. Indeed, able rates (universal access) rather
some cybercafs openly advertise VoIP than concentrating on universal serv-
on their web sites. ice (provision of communications ac-
cess to each household).17
The position that MoIC has taken over
VoIP is partly a moral one, abiding by The following universal service goals
the terms of the International Telecom- are stated in the 1999 Telecommu-
munication Regulations, but also a self- nications Policy document:
interested one, given the close ties
between MoIC and NTC. Ironically, the To make available the tel-
main usage of VoIP may not be outgo- ephone service as per the de-
ing traffic from Nepal but rather incom- mand and to provide new and
ing international calls. While it is difficult recent telecommunication
to obtain concrete evidence, it appears services in accordance with the
to be the case that some incoming in- demand of the market in ad-
ternational voice traffic is coming in over dition to the basic telephone
the Internet and then breaking out into service.
the PSTN locally. This service is rela-
tively easy to provide now that VSAT To make arrangements for
data services have been liberalised and making the basic telecommu-
more than 5 MB of capacity is available nications services universally
to private ISPs. One contact described accessible to those who do not
being offered tens of thousands of US have separate telephone lines
dollars to host such a service, an offer, of their own.
which was refused, though others may
not have been so circumspect. Given To make available the basic
that the lines rented by ISPs are likely telephone services in remote
to show large volumes of incoming traf- and inaccessible rural areas
fic, it would be relatively easy to hide also of the Kingdom.
incoming voice traffic, worth around a
hundred times more per minute, mixed The government is tackling universal
in with incoming IP data and fax traffic. access goals through two main
initiatives: (1) Provision of public
Thus the moral position on VoIP be- telephones and (2) the Rural
comes hard to justify. Why play by the Telecommunication Development
rules when the rest of the world is Fund (RTDF).
cheating? Indeed, the moral position
becomes arguably immoral when one The Telecommunication Policy docu-
considers that by blocking outgoing ment outlines three areas of how pub-
VoIP while being unable to block in- lic telephones will be made more
coming VoIP, Nepal is suffering twice widely available (1) encouraging NTC
over: NTC is losing out on valuable in- to further install public telephones;
coming net settlements while Nepalese (2) allowing the private sector to op-
are losing out on the chance to make erate public telephones; and (3) al-
low-cost foreign calls. lowing telephone services to be resold.
23
Nepal Case Study
There are actually two components to unclear exactly how it will work nor
extending access in rural areas. The is it clear whether anyone can pro-
first is a commitment by NTC to pro- vide services drawing on RTDF funds
vide at least two telephone lines in each or just NTC and the forthcoming sec-
VDC as part of its Special Rural Tel- ond basic service licensee. The Policy
ecommunications Programme. A sec- document does vaguely state that
ond component is the RTDF to which the private sector will also be en-
all telecommunication licenses (includ- gaged to operate telecommunication
ing ISPs) must contribute 2 per cent services in rural areas. Another
of their annual revenue. Additional clause of the Telecommunication
funds received from the government Policy document states that service
or international development agencies providers must invest at least 15 per
will also be deposited in the RTDF. As cent in rural locations in the areas
the RTDF has not been used yet, it is they operate in.
12
It is estimated that NTC made around US$200000 a year from its Internet connectivity (8000 per month for
a 64 kbit/s link to two ISPs).
13
The first 100 local calls are included with the subscription charge. After that, local calls are charged at Rs 1
per 3 minutes peak time and 6 minutes off-peak time.
14
Information about registering a host under the .np domain is available at <http://www.mos.com.np/
domains/default.htm>.
15
.nu is Niue; .to is Tonga; .tv is Tuvalu. As with several others, these ccTLDs are marketed commercially as
they have a specific meaning in English or other languages and thus add a certain cachet to a URL.
16
See NTA Bans VoIP. The National NewsMagazine. January 28 - February 03 2000.
17
Soft factors such as raising awareness of Internet and information technology training are also important
for expanding universal access to Internet.
24
4. National absorption of Information Technology
This chapter explores the use of Infor- ing for the Cabinet, with the Ministry
mation Technology in the government, of Science and Technology designated
business, education and health sectors. as the lead line ministry. For telecom-
munications more specifically, the line
4.1 Government agencies are the MoIC and the recently
The Nepalese government sees itself established regulatory agency, the
as promoting, or directly using, infor- NTA.
mation technologies in the following
ways: Two overarching national goals to be
served by encouraging the develop-
Government roles: ment and use of IT are: (1) the fur-
ther development of several economic
To set national goals and pri- sectors; and (2) improving access and
orities, and to develop policies the quality of life throughout the coun-
to achieve them; try, and especially in the villages and
To develop human resources; rural areas, where almost 90 per cent
As an investor in R&D and of the population resides. It is hoped
other IT-promoting ende- that IT will help develop both basic
avours; sectors for domestic consumption,
To operate or regulate IT-pro- e.g., agriculture and electric power, and
viding organizations; also help make these and other sec-
To enable and encourage the tors, e.g., tourism and carpets, into
private sector; more effective export industries. The
To provide content and stand- plan also calls for the use of IT to im-
ards; prove the quality and range of gov-
To protect the public and na- ernment functions and services to the
tional interests. people. A major constraint on the
implementation of the prospective
Direct uses of IT in governance: forthcoming policies is that they should
not result in seriously draining the hard
To reach and deal with non- currency holdings of the government.
government constituencies;
To support internal govern- The Minister of Science and Technol-
ment transactions. ogy (MoST) heads the National IT
Policy Committee with senior member-
A summary of our findings in each of ship from several other government
these categories follows. agencies, including the NPC, the Min-
istry of Finance, Tribhuvan University,
4.1.1 Government roles among others, and from the private
sector. This committee currently has
4.1.1.1 To set national goals and subcommittees doing policy-oriented
priorities, and to develop studies of the following subject areas:
policies to achieve them
Telecommunications Infra-
For more than a year, the Government
structure;
of Nepal has been in the process of
developing a comprehensive set of Human Resources;
policies dealing with the information Software Industry;
technologies. Some of this is explicit The Internet (especially e-gov-
in the Ninth Five Year Plan, but most is ernance, e-commerce, rural
still under development. Much of the access);
effort appears to be at the initiative of Cyber Laws;
the National Planning Commission act- IT Parks.
25
Nepal Case Study
26
4. National absorption of Information Technology
27
Nepal Case Study
28
4. National absorption of Information Technology
was first established by small groups Nepal web site (like Singapores na-
of enthusiasts in the university and tional web site, Infomap <http://
research community,19 but that was www.sg>). This is especially true for
not the case in Nepal. Commercial sites such as government agencies
organizations led the way there, but (again see The Singapore Government
they were late. By the time that Nepa- web site at <http://www.gov.sg>).
lese companies began experimenting
with store and forward (UUCP) email Looking at the web sites that do exist,
service in 1994 and 1995, most other one sees further evidence of Nepals
nations already had full IP connectiv- late start on the Internet. They are
ity, commercial Web services were be- first generation web sites small,
ing deployed,20 and an international static sites typical of the early elec-
conference had already convened on tronic brochures that were found on
the role of the Internet in tourism, an the Web several years ago in all na-
important business in Nepal.21 As a tions. They will evolve with time, but
result of this late start, Nepal finds it- they are dated. Dhukuti.com,
self with a relatively immature com- <www.dhukuti.com>, is an improve-
mercial Internet industry and ment over most of these sites. It is a
presence. US-hosted site selling books, music,
handicrafts and booking travel and
MOS is the oldest Nepalese ISP, and trekking tours that was built with ta-
appears to be the leading business con- ble-driven store package. It has the
nectivity provider. They have between look, shopping cart, credit card verifi-
20 and 30 leased line customers and cation, and site evaluation feedback
roughly 80 per cent of their dial up ac- that US shoppers are familiar with to-
counts are businesses. MOS is also do- day, and access in the target market
ing off-shore programming for is fast because it is hosted in the US.
Bloomberg Financial Services, and is Modern web sites are comprehensive,
developing an online retail mall, which providing all the information and serv-
will be integrated with back-end ice a user requires. They are interac-
processing for ordering, inventory, tive, allowing the user to customize the
fulfillment, etc. They also have a 10- experience, retrieve material from and
person news-gathering organization, update databases, complete transac-
and produce <www.nepalnews.com>. tions and payments, arrange for
This site has approximately 4000 visi- fulfillment, etc. They gather informa-
tors per day, and is a potential source tion from users, leading to effective
of revenue domestically and among the customer relationship management
Nepalese expatriate community (some and the possibility of creating a com-
80 per cent of the visitors to the site munity among the users themselves.
are from North America). They also provide views of corporate
information for and communication
Nepals late start with the Internet has with suppliers, vendors and other busi-
left it with relatively little business ac- ness partners.
tivity. Table 4.1 summarizes the list-
ings of tourism and export related For example, a mature travel presence
companies in the Nepal Directory, could provide one-stop information for
which is available both as a hard copy potential visitors. It would gather valu-
Yellow Pages and online.Even in these able data on visitors to the site, and
export-oriented industries, only 49% provide a customized experience for
of the companies listed in the Yellow different types of traveller (business,
Pages have email addresses, and many general tourist, Buddhist tourist, rug-
fewer have web sites.22 One problem ged trekking, mountain climbing, etc.)
is the sheer number of online directo- from different parts of the world. The
ries for Nepal. In fact there are so system would be comprehensive, cov-
many, they have run out of original ering the travel experience from basic
names (e.g., <www.catmando.com>). familiarity with options through visa
Most only list the organizations they application, airline reservations (inter-
host. It would be useful and reassur- national and domestic)5 , ground trans-
ing to have an officially sanctioned portation, hotels and lodging, guides,
29
Nepal Case Study
etc. The site would be interactive, al- ments in developing nations.25 In ad-
lowing for online itinerary configura- dition to return on investment, they
tion, reservations, and payment. The estimate a 15-30 per cent return to
site in such a system would be the tip the general economy. They also find
of the iceberg; it would be well inte- very large economic returns from the
grated with systems for fulfillment. A telecommunications components in
visitors records and itinerary would be other sectors such as railways, power,
online for access by the people respon- tourism, banking, and rural develop-
sible for meeting them at the airport ment. These returns were seen before
through the people responsible for the value of Internet-based e-com-
dropping them at the airport for de- merce was added to basic communi-
parture. Equally important, the system cation investment. A recent report of
would be database driven so provid- the United Nations Conference on
ers of services could maintain prices Trade and Development (UNCTAD)
and other information independently describes e-commerce progress in de-
(it would not scale without such de- veloped and developing nations in an
centralization). There would also be attempt to instil confidence in leaders
mechanism for assessment and evalu- and decision makers so they will act
ation of services, perhaps a combina- to gain experience in this area.26 A
tion of association inspection and study of 74 garment manufacturing
customer feedback. There would be fol- firms in Delhi concluded that they
low-up with site visitors and commu- should adopt the latest information
nity building for those who have visited technology tools available in the world
Nepal, leading hopefully to a long run market.27
relationship with these customers.
Other scholars, for example, Ernest
It is clear that such a system would Wilson, are less confident;28 however,
require a significant effort, perhaps no prudent government can ignore e-
encouraged and coordinated by the commerce. It would be wise to inves-
Nepal Tourism Board. It would also tigate and gain experience rather than
require nationwide connectivity, per- sit on the sideline waiting for the im-
haps focused on district capitals or air- pact to become known with certainty.
ports (there are 44 airports in Nepal). Practical suggestions for governments
Whether in tourism or other industries, including spreading awareness of e-
Nepalese business should, and will commerce, developing human re-
begin developing comprehensive, sources (user, entre-preneurial and
modern web sites. technical), developing local content,
facilitation of financial services, plan-
4.3 E-commerce ning telecommunication infrastructure,
encouragement of value-added tel-
Electronic commerce (e-commerce) is ecommunication services, facilitation of
growing rapidly and fuelling invest- online payment, reducing costs of
ment, productivity increases and eco- equipment, and passing laws to facili-
nomic growth. However, the vast tate e-commerce are outlined by
majority of that investment and return Dessauer and Ismail.29 Many govern-
has taken place in developed nations, ments, including that of neighbouring
and the role and impact of e-commerce India, have mapped out active policies
on developing nations is unclear. One and programmes in and in support of
must ask whether a developing nation e-commerce.
can afford to allocate scarce human
and economic resources to e-com- While the government of a developing
merce based on the hypothesis that it nation should investigate and invest in
will pay off. e-commerce, it must do so in the
context of its own goals and situation.
There is reason to believe it will. For In a developed nation, e-commerce
example, the World Bank found rates might be viewed as a means to
of return between 13 and 20 per cent, increased industrial productivity or
averaging about 20 per cent, when export expansion. While these are
assessing telecommunication invest- important everywhere, a developing
30
4. National absorption of Information Technology
nation might be more concerned with cally without involving physical infra-
stemming population flight from rural structure for warehousing and deliv-
to urban areas by increasing village ery. Information products would seem
productivity to the point where it attractive in a developing nation like
affords two rather than one meal per Nepal, where roads, transport, post
day or providing access to news, and delivery facilities are poor. On the
entertainment, and education. The other hand, the banking and legal sys-
Nepalese goals of increased social and tem must provide for electronic pay-
geographic equity and rural employ- ment, and, of course electrical and
ment should be considered along with telecommunication infrastructure must
economic considerations in e- be available and reliable.
commerce decision-making. The
remainder of this section will examine In considering information products for
various ways of viewing and export, one should ask what is uniquely
categorizing e-commerce, with Nepalese. What news, literature, mu-
comments on the Nepalese context, sic, images, and video content would
and conclude with brief discussions of have a market? Who would be the au-
projects that might be undertaken. dience? Nepalese expatriates? Eng-
lish and Hindi speaking Indians? An
4.3.1 Views of E-commerce e-commerce presence could perhaps
Like the proverbial blind men and the evolve out of a government sponsored
elephant, there are many ways to de- Nepalese culture site on the Internet.
fine and categorize e-commerce.
Rather than attempt a single, Software and data entry are another
orthogonal taxonomy, one must look form of information product. This can
at the e-commerce elephant in sev- take several forms.30 At the low end
eral, overlapping ways, discussing in- remains the relatively unskilled tran-
formation products, electronic scription and data entry. More highly
markets, vertical industry portals, skilled content creation, for example,
extranets, business-consumer sys- drawing for animation, the creation of
tems, and e-commerce involving gov- web sites, or the operation of remote
ernment. call centres are also possible. Con-
tract programming, in which a pro-
Information Products grammer either works at the client site
Information products are unique in that or works remotely communicating over
selection, transaction, payment and the Internet, is common practice as
fulfilment may be completed electroni- well. Each of these examples entails
31
Nepal Case Study
selling peoples time, but software mechanism for electronic funds trans-
products like a vertical system for an fer should be provided. The same serv-
industry or application or other pack- ice is needed to support export
aged software can also be exported. business. This should not be seen as a
India has made notable progress in profit opportunity for the government,
this area but they have spent many but as a method of getting hard cur-
years developing skills and business rency and enhancing quality of life.31
partnerships. Only two such relation-
ships were found, MOS work for Electronic Markets
Bloomlberg Financial Services and
work on Pilgrim Softwares Quality and Electronic markets have flourished on
Manufacturing Integrated System by the Internet, and can take several
Pilgrim Asia, <www.pilgrimusa.com/ forms. Electronic auctions were de-
asia_rd.htm>. vised for consumer transactions but
they are increasingly used by business
Of course the Internet merely ena- when companies have surplus items
bles or facilitates such activity to liquidate. The tender model, in
management, marketing and human which a consumer requests bids for a
capital are at its core. The markets good or service is common practice
for this sort of service are very com- with government procurement, and
petitive and crowded, making differ- has also been used on the Internet.
entiation difficult. One strategy is to Other sites allow buyers to make of-
focus effort on areas of current com- fers for goods and services. In the
petence. For example, Chilean bank- case of fungible, homogeneous prod-
ing and forestry software was ucts like grain or securities an elec-
successfully exported because they tronic exchange can allow immediate
had developed excellent local systems, consummation of transactions at then
and Nepal may have expertise in other current prices. If electronic markets
areas, for example, in systems for are not established by private com-
electrical power generation and dis- panies, the government can take a
tribution. role by procuring their establishment
or encouraging or subsidizing their
There would also be a domestic mar- establishment by private firms. The
ket for information products if there government would generally not be
were infrastructure in place to deliver involved in control or operation of the
them. Information products involving market site, but in planning, initial fi-
credit, education, news, health, en- nancing, monitoring quality, etc.
tertainment, and personal communi-
cation can be sold in rural and in urban Electronic markets are well suited to
areas if people have access to a net- homogeneous, fungible commodities,
work connection or a telecentre. For several of which come to mind in the
examples of a number of demons- Nepalese context: electric power, agri-
tration projects, see the Rural Appli- cultural inputs, products, and transpor-
cations Focus Group of the tation, and handicraft raw materials.
International Telecommunication Un-
ion, <www7.itu.int/itudfg7> and the Nepal has knowledge of energy mar-
Telelac project in Latin America, kets because of its hydroelectric power
<www.tele-centros.org>. While many industry. We are seeing the emergence
projects are in the pilot phase, the of electronic markets for energy, for
technology to support such applica- example, Altranet (<www.altranet
tions is improving rapidly. .com>), in developed nations today,
and Forrester Research predicts that
Funds transfer is another information 17 per cent of US electricity will be
service. The Internet is increasingly traded online by 2004.32 Is there a
used by expatriates in developed na- place for an international electronic
tions to maintain contact with each market for energy in the region? Or,
other and with their families. Expatri- more generically, how can the Internet
ates often send funds or funds to pur- be used in service of the regions en-
chase gifts home, and a trustworthy ergy suppliers?
32
4. National absorption of Information Technology
33
Nepal Case Study
also used to create closed extranets plete and professional, enabling the
to facilitate communication and coop- consumer to select or design, order,
eration between relatively stable busi- pay for and track delivery of an item.
ness partners. For example, the Timely delivery to customers would
handicraft industry involves raw ma- entail warehousing and fulfillment cen-
terial producers, individual artisans, tres in target market areas such as
producer and craft-based organiza- North America, Europe and Australia.37
tions, marketing and fair-trade organi- Government cooperation in streamlin-
zations, commercial buyers and ing export procedures and lowering
importers, government customs and duties would also be necessary.
export regulators, retail outlets, and
warehousing and transportation at If analysis shows the logistics of direct
every step in the process. Simply con- distribution are economically advanta-
necting the appropriate people in each geous, there is still the strategic prob-
of these organizations with email would lem of handling channel conflicts. If
no doubt increase production and lo- direct sales are significant, they will
gistic efficiency. Providing them with weaken and antagonize current distri-
web sites for querying inventory sta- bution and retail partners. This is a
tus, ordering, scheduling, tracking common problemthe same thing
shipments, etc. would provide still happens when a handicraft producer
greater returns. sells directly to a marketing organiza-
tion or retail outlet, bypassing the lo-
Business to Consumer cal producers cooperative or when an
automobile manufacturer sells directly
With the exception of tourism, we have to a customer, bypassing the retail
focused on business to business (B2B) dealer. Logistics and channel conflicts
e-commerce. The domestic consumer are formidable hurdles, but the cost of
market is limited by the number of the current distribution system might
Internet users in Nepal and their con- provide sufficient incentive to over-
centration in Kathmandu. It will be come them.
some time before the domestic con-
sumer market is large enough to sup- It should be noted that a valuable by-
port business to consumer (B2C) product of all forms of e-commerce,
e-commerce; however, entrepreneurs especially business to consumer, is the
like Mercantile are already consider- opportunity for establishing and main-
ing entry. Their task will be simplified taining a customer relationship. We see
by most delivery being in Kathmandu firms in developed nations literally pay-
and other urban areas. ing people to become customers on the
theory that it is important to build a
Direct Internet sales to export custom- brand presence and that it is cheaper
ers are difficult because of logistical to keep an old customer than to at-
problems with rapid, reliable delivery; tract a new one in a mature market.
however, the inefficiencies and mark- As such, one of the key functions of a
ups in the current distribution chan- web site is to gather data on visitors
nels make direct marketing an for subsequent communication, serv-
attractive goal. For example, a Dhaka ice and marketing. This should be done
full pattern shawl begins with Rs 175 unobtrusively, with guarantees of pri-
for yarn and Rs 275 for the producers vacy, and always for a purpose or in
labour, and ultimately sells for return for something. It is also neces-
Rs 5250.36 An allo placemat, which sary to integrate Web data with data
sells for Rs 300 begins with Rs 15 for gathered by other means. For exam-
material and 7 for labour. Note that ple, records generated by a tourist and
the bulk of the export mark-up is in information gathered during a visit to
freight, duty and retail. The Rs 5250 a tourism web site should be inte-
shawl sells for only Rs 750 domesti- grated.
cally and the placemat 48.50.
While this is easily achieved through
Direct marketing to consumers would direct business-consumer e-commerce
entail a web site, and it should be com- sites, it is not the only possibility. Many
34
4. National absorption of Information Technology
35
Nepal Case Study
36
4. National absorption of Information Technology
campus near UNDP in Kathmandu. This has enough machines. At many cam-
is likely the most technically advanced puses, very few students have any
computer network facility in Nepal. They access. The Faculty of Management
have a VSAT running with a 64k uplink has Information Systems labs at a half
and 128k downlink to ThaiCom. This dozen branch campuses, with roughly
VSAT is under the Ministry of Environ- ten personal computers at each. With
ment and Physical Planning, but IOE has few exceptions, the academic comput-
its own application pending with NTA. ers at TU are not networked in any
It is their initial intent to connect ap- way. The major exception is the IOE
proximately 400 machines in nine build- Centre for Information Technology.
ings, each with its own hub. They then Much of the equipment was provided
hope to expand their network to all four by a World Bank loan. They also have
IOE campuses and eventually to all of funding from the Canadian Interna-
TU. There is some thought of eventu- tional Development Agency.
ally also providing networks to parts of
the government. Some computer courses are offered
to students in other disciplines at TU,
All three programmes are extremely primarily at the main campus at
limited in faculty, with only two profes- Kirtipur. The TU administration at
sors each in Engineering and Compu- Kirtipur also has a small LAN, but it is
ter Science, and none in Management. not clear if it is extensively used, and
The three faculties have a total of three it apparently does not have an
readers (approximately associate pro- Internet gateway since none of the
fessor equivalents) between them. The most senior administrators have an e-
great majority of classes are taught by mail address on this network. The
lecturers and instructors. It is difficult HealthNet project is under the TU In-
to find, hire, and retain faculty. There stitute of Medicine (see the section
are no salary differentials by field at TU, below on the Health Sector).
and salaries are very low. Teaching loads
are heavy and the TU bureaucracy At least two other universities have
sometimes difficult. Faculty are forced college-level IT programmes.
to moonlight on better paying jobs. TU Kathmandu University (<http://
is minimally competitive in attracting www.panasia.org.sg/nepalnet/ku/
and retaining Nepalese who have ob- home.htm>) (the School of Manage-
tained advanced IT degrees from ment also has a web site: <http://
abroad. www.kusom.edu.np>) may be gradu-
ating 40 students annually. Several
TU also suffers from severe shortages people believe that Kathmandu Uni-
of computer equipment. No campus versity has the best tertiary degree
37
Nepal Case Study
programmes in IT in the country, and schools are said to train 15000 peo-
offers the only under-graduate pro- ple per year. Much of this is in the use
grammes that provide more than the of established software products such
equivalent of a 2-year US community a Microsoft Office. Increasingly, the
college degree. The Kathmandu Web and Internet are becoming parts
School of Management is said to offer of these curricula, and perhaps 40-
a good MIS program within their MBA. 50% of the schools have or are ac-
Purbancha University is said to be quiring Internet access. There is some
graduating approximately 120 stu- parallel between these schools and
dents per year on two campuses. those that teach English, and we sus-
They also have a practical program to pect a strong correlation between Eng-
produce mid-level software engineers. lish and the teaching of IT-related
The program is growing quickly (they skills.
accept anyone with a 10+2) and easier
to get into than TU. The Indian-based NIIT (<http://
www.niit.com/index.shtml>) is one of
4.4.3 Vocational Training Insti- the most advanced of the private vo-
tutes cational training institutions in Nepal.
It uses a curriculum developed by one
It is likely that most of the practical of the most dynamic educational in-
training in IT is provided by about stitutions in South Asia, which now op-
600 private vocational institutions. erates in 15 countries. NIIT offers a
These are seen in many parts of respectable range of technically sub-
Kathmandu, and to a lesser extent in stantive, university-calibre, courses
Pokhara, Biratnager and Birgunj and in Kathmandu. Networking appears
their environs. They range from very to be given more emphasis here than
small store-front outfits to large at the universities, and they offer
schools like the College of Software contemporary web development
Engineering (CSE). CSE claims to courses. Aptech and perhaps a few
graduate 1000 students per year, other Indian educational organiza-
mostly from a 2-year Diploma pro- tions are also providing some IT in-
gramme. Altogether, these private struction in Nepal.
38
4. National absorption of Information Technology
The most visible active computer us- generating enough jobs to absorb even
ers in Nepal are seen at registration their fairly modest numbers of IT
desks at hotels, and similar places. It graduates. These senior educators did
may be that much of the basic train- not have much of a concept of IT-edu-
ing for such use is provided in house, cated people creating their own jobs.
or by the vendors of the systems.
Many of the graduates of the private
4.4.4 Training Abroad vocational institutions take clerical or
operator jobs at government, NGO,
As is the case for many less devel- and private organizations. Some seek
oped countries, many of the best and jobs abroad on the basis of their tech-
brightest people go abroad for their nical skills. For example, CSE claims
education. One estimate is that several graduates who have secured
roughly 100 Nepalese receive bach- jobs in the West. But we suspect these
elors degrees from India, Russia, the numbers are low, and that most Nepa-
United States and the Philippines an- lese who have IT-related jobs abroad
nually. Perhaps a similar number re- received some training there.
ceive advanced degrees each year.
More of these people go to India than 4.5 Health
any other country. The reasons are a
combination of proximity, language, The general state of health care in
cost, and admissions. We suspect that Nepal is poor.42 Although most health
the majority of those who study indicators have significantly improved
abroad try to pursue technical sub- in recent years, Nepal still has a long
jects, but we do not know what frac- way to go even to reach regional norms
tion are pursuing the study of the (Table 4.4). Furthermore, there are
information technologies. extreme variations within Nepal. For
example, average life expectancy was
As might be expected, many of those 55.8 years in 1996, but it was only 36
who study abroad, especially in the years in the Mugu District and 67 in
West, are able to get better jobs there Kathmandu, and the standard devia-
than they could get in Nepal. Many who tion in life expectancy among districts
return apparently do so either because was 6.2 years.
they do not complete their studies, or
because of family obligations. However, Table 4.5 shows Nepalese health re-
most who do remain abroad seem to sources. While we did not conduct an
retain very positive thoughts about exhaustive survey, we were unable to
their home country, and seem to want discover many networked applications.
to help out back home. We found one hospital, the teaching
hospital of the Nepal Medical College
Many of the most active people whom with a LAN, but that appears to be an
we met in Nepal were either at least exception. 43 Given the difficulty of
partially educated abroad, or had spent travel and communication within Ne-
considerable time there. pal, even basic connectivity would have
a significant marginal impact. If, for
4.4.5 Effective absorption of example, all physicians (particularly
educated people into the those outside of Kathmandu) had
society/economy Internet accounts or all Health Posts
had email access, what would be the
There are apparently more educated applications and benefits?
people looking for good jobs in Nepal
than there are jobs for them. IT-re- The one organization, which seems to
lated jobs in the private sector were be actively pursuing network connec-
often said to attract large numbers of tivity in Nepal is HealthNet,
applicants. We suspect that many of <www.healthnet.org.np>, and we
the applicants are under-qualified for were quite impressed by what they
the best jobs. Senior administrators at have been able to achieve with limited
TU expressed concern that the gov- resources. HealthNet began network-
ernment and private sectors were not ing in December 1994 with a FidoNet
39
Nepal Case Study
Infant Mortality Life Expectancy Doctors per 100000 Nurses per 100000
per 1,000 births at Birth (1997) People (1993) People (1993)
Nepal 75 57.3 5 5
Bangladesh 81 58.1 18 5
Bhutan 87 60.7 20 6
China 38 69.8 115 88
India 71 62.6 48 n.a.
Pakistan 95 64.0 52 32
Sri Lanka 17 73.1 23 112
40
4. National absorption of Information Technology
as well. This expertise could be made University, and the University pays a
available to others on the Internet, and portion of Dr. Pradhans salary and pro-
HealthNet has a project to put the full vides office space. Dr. Pradhan has
text of Nepalese medical journals online. proposed expansion, including a new
server, router, and faster link to Mer-
Initially, HealthNet was heavily de- cantile. This would enable HealthNet
pendent upon SatelLife, but it is now to expand service to Nepals roughly
approaching financial self sufficiency. 1,800 doctors, nursing homes, and
It has four paid staff members, and medical colleges. He would also like
pays Rs. 40,000 per month for the link to offer service to the general NGO
to Mercantile. HealthNet is located in community, estimated at 8,000 orga-
the Health Learning Materials Centre nizations, and feels this expanded ISP
of the Institute of Medicine at Tribhuvan could be financially self sufficient.
Ministry of Health 1 1 No No No
Department of Health Services 1 No No No No
Central Hospitals 5 1 No No No
Regional Health Service Directorates 5 No No No No
Zonal Hospitals 11 No No No No
Primary Health Centres 120 No No No No
Health Post 736 No No No No
Sub-Health Post 3187 No No No No
Hospitals 83 10 No No No
41
Nepal Case Study
18
As an illustration of this, to get a copy of a visa application form for Nepal on the Web, one currently has to
go to a UNDP site.
19
Goodman, S., Press, L., Ruth, S., and Rutkowski, A., The Global Diffusion of the Internet: Patterns and
Problems, Communications of the ACM, Vol 37, No 8, pp 27-31, August, 1994 and Press, L., Will
Commercial Networks Prevail in Developing Nations?, OnTheInternet, Vol. 3, No. 2, March/April, 1997, pp
40-41.
20
Press, L., Commercialization of the Internet, Communications of the ACM, Vol 37, No 11, pp 17-21,
November, 1994.
21
Press, L., The Internet and the Travel Industry, Proceedings of ENTER 95, Innsbruck Austria, January 18-
20, 1995. This conference was followed by the founding of a journal, with many of the participants as
members of the editorial staff.
22
The two directories do not appear to reflect an integrated database in that all print listings are not online.
23
Nepal has very few roads, making domestic airlines an important part of the tourist industry.
24
The Ministry of Tourism licenses roughly 650 hotels nationwide.
25
Saunders, Robert J, Warford, Jeremy J., and Wellenius, Bjorn, Telecommunications and Economic
Development, pg. 15-16, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 1994.
26
Lanvin, Bruno and the UNCTAD staff, Building Confidence: Electronic Commerce and Development, United
Nations Conference on Trade and Development, <http://www.unctad.org/ecommerce/>.
27
Lal, K. Information Technology and Exports: A Case Study of Indian Garments Manufacturing Enterprises,
Center for Development Research, University of Bonn, August 1999,
<http://www.zef.de/zef_englisch/f_publ.html>.
28
Wilson, Ernest, Meeting the Challenges of Internet Inequality, OnTheInternet, pp 26-30, Vol. 5 No. 6,
November/December, 1999.
29
Dessauer, Mark and Ismail, Magda, E-Commerce in the Developing World: Plug and Play?, OnTheInternet,
November-December, 1999, pp 19-25, 38-39.
30
Press, Larry, Personal Computers and the World Software Market, Communications of the Association for
Computing Machinery, February, 1991. Reprinted in Schellenberg, Kathryn, Computers in Society, 4th Ed.,
Dushkin Publishing Group, Guilford, CT, 1991. Press, Larry, Software Export from Developing Nations, IEEE
Computer, December, 1993.
31
The value of increased connectivity with the Nepalese expatriate community should also be considered in
assessing the decision to regulate Internet telephony.
32
Kafka, Steven J., Temkn, Bruce D., Sanders, Mathew R., Sharrad, Jeremy and Brown, Tobias O,
eMarketplaces Boost B2B Trade, Forrester Research, February, 2000.
33
Press, Larry, A Client-Centered Networking Project in Rural India, OnTheInternet, pp 36-38, January/
February, 1999, <http://som.csudh.edu/fac/lpress/devnat/nations/india/pondyoti.htm>.
34
Shahi, Surendra and Kachhipati, Chandra Prasad, Collective Marketing: The Case of Handicraft in Nepal,
International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development, Kathmandu, 1999.
35
Information presented at the site would come from databases, and the vendors would update their portions
of those databases via protected Web interfaces. This database driven, multiple-access approach should be
used on all web sites.
36
Shahi, Surendra and Kachhipati, Chandra Prasad, Collective Marketing: The Case of Handicraft in Nepal,
International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development, Kathmandu, 1999.
37
The numbers of Internet users in India and China growing rapidly, and more direct shipment may be feasible
for reaching those markets.
38
Press, Larry, Burkhart, Grey, Goodman, Sy, Mehta, Arun and Mittal, Arun, The Role of State Government in
Developing Indias Internet, OnTheInternet, pp 35-37, November/December, 1998,
<http://som.csudh.edu/fac/lpress/devnat/nations/india/otigovt.htm>.
39
Shahi, Surendra and Kachhipati, Chandra Prasad, Collective Marketing: The Case of Handicrafts in Nepal,
International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development, Kathmandu, 1999.
40
For more background see Education in Nepal-An Introduction. <http://www.panasia.org.sg/nepalnet/
education/edukatio.htm>
41
See Human Resource Development in Information Technology in Tribhuvan University, Tribhuvan University,
Kirtipur, Kathmandu, November 1999.
42
For a brief assessment of Nepalese health care, see An Introduction to Health in Nepal
<http://www.panasia.org.sg/nepalnet/socio/health.html>.
43
Rizyal, A., Medicos and Computers, Cyberpost,
<http://www.nepalnews.com/contents/cyberpost/1998/Dec/Dec30/computer.htm>.
44
SatelLife, a non-profit initiative of International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, is a pioneer in
the support of network access to health information in developing nations. The have helped establish
HealthNets in many nations. See <www.healthnet.org/hnet/hnet.html> for general information and
<www.healthnet.org/hnet/nepal/> for a description of the Nepalese HealthNet. The name SatelLife derives
from the early use of a low-earth orbiting satellite for email.
45
This material is accessible within Nepal, but not all is Internet accessible.
42
5. Summary and recommendations
Dimension Value
Pervasiveness 1
Geographic Dispersion 1.5
Sectoral Absorption 1
Connectivity Infrastructure 1
Organizational Infrastructure 2.5
Sophistication of Use 1
TOTAL 8
43
Nepal Case Study
users estimated that 40% of their ac- only cover the eastern portion of the
counts were UUCP). It is clear that road). The sum of all international links
Nepal will rank at level 2 shortly. is at the low end of the level 2 range;
there are no Internet exchange points
Geographic Dispersion is rated be- and nearly all access is by modem over
tween level 1, single location and level voice lines. A near term increase in this
2, moderate dispersion. While there dimension does not seem likely.
are points of presence in six cities out-
side of Kathmandu, connectivity is The Organizational Infrastructure is
highly concentrated there. It is unlikely between level 2, controlled and level 3,
that Nepal will achieve level 2, moder- competitive. There are several ISPs,
ate dispersion, for some time, because and no regulatory restrictions on their
that would require connectivity in over creation. There is limited competition
half of the 75 Districts, and many dis- in the provision of domestic infrastruc-
tricts are historically under-served by ture; ISPs can provide wireless leased
all forms of infrastructure. lines for their customers. International
connectivity is only available via VSAT,
Sectoral Absorption is rated at level 1, but it is not restricted by regulation.
rare. The ranking is a function of the
level of connectivity server ownership Sophistication of Use is at level 1, mini-
in business, government, health care mal. A small user community is using
and education, each of which are rated the Internet in conventional applica-
as rare themselves. We found very lit- tions, primarily email. A good deal of
tle activity in the health, government that email is UUCP and Web pages are
and education sectors, so do not ex- typically static. We see little or no evi-
pect improvement in this dimension in dence of altered practices in response
the near future. to the introduction of the Internet.
Nepal 1-00 1 1 1 1 3 1 8
Bangladesh 3-99 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 M
China 5-00 2.5 3 2 2.5 2.5 2 14.5 M
China 12-98 2 3 2 2 2 2 13 M
India 12-99 2 2.5 1.5 2.5 3 2 13.5 M
India 8-99 2 3 1 1 3 3 13 Q
India 12-98 1 2 1 2 2 2 10 M
Sri Lanka 8-99 2 1 2 1 3 2 11 Q
Sri Lanka 8-98 1 2 2 1 3 3 12 Q
Pakistan 11-99 2 3 1.5 1 2 2 11.5 M
Note: P: Pervaiseveness, GD: Geographic Dispersion, SA: Sectoral Absorption, CI: Connectivity Infrastruc-
ture, OI: Organizational Infrastructure, SU: Sophistication of Use. Values range from 0 (lowest) to 4 (highest).
Source: M: national case study, MOSAIC Group, mosaic.unomaha.edu/gdi.html. Q: unvalidated question-
naire result, Press, Larry, Second Internet Diffusion Survey, OnTheInternet, Vol. 5, No. 6, November/De-
cember, 1999, som.csudh.edu/cis/lpress/gdiff/otidevnations.htm.
44
5. Summary and recommendations
45
Nepal Case Study
key factor for promoting communica- ent approaches. This includes facilitat-
tion access in Nepal. ing the provision of public payphones
and call centres. The former will re-
There are no open Internet Exchanges, strict access to voice telephony unless
only loose peering agreements. While payphones with terminals can be in-
the liberalisation of the VSAT market stalled.46 The latter can be upgraded
has enabled the ISP industry to grow to include Internet access. The provi-
and become competitive, VSATs re- sion of communication facilities in pub-
main expensive, and downstream pro- lic locations such as schools, post
viders are at a disadvantage (both offices, etc. should also be pursued.
practical and in their marketing). The This can be done by requiring telecom
government or an ISP organization operators and ISPs to provide free or
could contribute to overall cost sav- discounted connections to public loca-
ings and efficiency by operating an tions as part of their license obliga-
Internet Exchange Point (IXP) and con- tions. 47 International donors also have
solidating international traffic. numerous programmes for enhancing
Internet connectivity and the Nepalese
5.2.4 Bring networks to univer- government should be actively pursu-
sities ing these projects.48
One place for investment that may pay
rich results is in bringing networks to 5.2.7 Village Connectivity Pilot
the universities. The huge TU system Project
does not appear to encourage a lot of The UNDP Poverty Report 2000
energy, imagination, and entrepre- stresses the role of government in
neurial spirit. Having the Internet, and eradicating poverty. They emphasize
the world it attaches to, directly avail- decentralization and empowerment of
able to the students and young instruc- local government, and recommend
tors would be a good place to make a expanding access to information and
difference. There are organizations communication. Village connectivity
(e.g., the IoE) who are technically able projects are underway in many na-
to make this happen if they have re- tions. Given Nepals social goals and
sources and support. growing urban population, they should
gain experience in this area. The Min-
5.2.5 Electricity and literacy istry of Local Development, which is
In order to promote the spread of responsible for strengthening local in-
Internet throughout the country, more stitutional development, such as bol-
extensive electrification and literacy stering the district and village
are necessary conditions. Only the development committees could per-
government could bring this about. haps conduct one or more pilot projects
in village Internet connectivity. The
Thus, it should be noted that the de-
project could be funded from the tel-
velopment of the Internet needs to be
ephone rural development fund. Such
integrated into a general government
a project would provide practical ex-
strategy on economic and social de-
perience with e-commerce technology
velopment.
and applications in rural areas, and
would hold the promise of improving
5.2.6 Public access
quality of life and discouraging move-
Efforts should be made to enhance ment to urban areas. There are many
universal access to communication fa- village networking projects in the re-
cilities by pursuing a number of differ- gion that Nepal could learn from.
46
5. Summary and recommendations
1
Ascom, the Swiss telecom equipment manufacturer, is installing multimedia card-operated payphones for
MTNL of India. The payphones provide Internet access and e-mail. See Ascom. Multimedia Services in
India. Contact Magazine. January 2000.<http://139.79.106.31/digitalassets/48/
file45364_0_contact_2000_01_e.pdf>
2
In the US, operators contribute to a fund that is used to provide discounted telecommunication and Internet
access service to schools and libraries. See <http://www.fcc.gov/ccb/universal_service/
schoolsandlibs.html>.
3
For example, the World Banks World Links for Development (WorLD) program provides Internet connectivity
and training for teachers, teacher trainers and students in developing countries in the use of technology in
education. WorLD is currently active in 15 developing countries Brazil, Cape Verde, Chile, Colombia,
Ghana, Mauritania, Mozambique, Paraguay, Peru, Senegal, South Africa, Turkey, Uganda, West Bank / Gaza
and Zimbabwe. See <http://www.worldbank.org/worldlinks/english/index.html>.
47
Nepal Case Study
The project team visited Nepal 17 21 January 2000 to carry out field
research. Below is the list of organizations and people met.
48
Annexes
Level 0 Non-existent: The Internet does not exist in a viable form in this
country. No computers with international IP connections are located
within the country. There may be some Internet users in the
country; however, they obtain a connection via an international
telephone call to a foreign ISP.
Level 1 Embryonic: The ratio of users per capita is on the order of
magnitude of less than one in a thousand (less than 0.1%).
Level 2 Established: The ratio of Internet users per capita is on the order of
magnitude of at least one in a thousand (0.1% or greater).
Level 3 Common: The ratio of Internet users per capita is on the order of
magnitude of at least one in a hundred (1% or greater).
Level 4 Pervasive: The Internet is pervasive. The ratio of Internet users per
capita is on the order of magnitude of at least one in 10 (10% or
greater).
Level 0 Non-existent. The Internet does not exist in a viable form in this
country. No computers with international IP connections are located
within the country. A country may be using UUCP connections for
email and USEnet.
Level 1 Single location: Internet points-of-presence are confined to one
major population center.
Level 2 Moderately dispersed: Internet points-of-presence are located in at
least half of the first-tier political subdivisions of the country.
Level 3 Highly dispersed: Internet points-of-presence are located in at least
three-quarters of the first-tier political subdivisions of the country.
Level 4 Nationwide: Internet points-of-presence are located in all first-tier
political sub-divisions of the country. Rural dial-up access is publicly
and commonly available and leased line connectivity is available.
Sector Subsectors
Academic Primary and Secondary education University education
Commercial Distribution, Retail
Finance Service
Manufacturing
Health Hospitals Research Centers
Clinics Physicians/Practitioners
49
Nepal Case Study
50
Annexes
Level 0 None: The Internet is not used, except by a very small fraction of the
population that logs into foreign services.
Level 1 Minimal: The small user community struggles to employ the Internet in
conventional, mainstream applications.
Level 2 Conventional: The user community changes established practices
somewhat in response to or in order to accommodate the technology,
but few established processes are changed dramatically. The Internet is
used as a substitute or straight-forward enhancement for an existing
process (e.g. e-mail vs. post). This is the first level at which we can say
that the Internet has "taken hold" in a country.
Level 3 Transforming: The user community's use of the Internet results in new
applications, or significant changes in existing processes and practices,
although these innovations may not necessarily stretch the boundaries
of the technology's capabilities. One strong indicator of business process
re-engineeering to take advantage of the Internet, is that a significant
number (over 5%) of Web sites, both government and business, are
interactive.
Level 4 Innovating: The user community is discriminating and highly
demanding. The user community is regularly applying, or seeking to
apply the Internet in innovative ways that push the capabilities of the
technology. The user community plays a significant role in driving the
state-of-the-art and has a mutually beneficial and synergistic
relationship with developers.
51
Nepal Case Study
52
Acronyms and abbreviations
BT British Telecom
DoT Department of Telecommunications (India)
53