Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
rather rare autosomal re- in Libyan twins studied in Hun- dermal fibroblasts.
cessive disorder which gary 15 and, more recently, in a Jor-
usually results in the death of af- danian infant studied in Saudi
fected infants at the end of the first Arabia.16 Furthermore, it appears Biochemical Features
trimester of life. The incidence of that the only case reported in a
the disease cannot be determined at black African has been described The hereditary biochemical
present because pediatricians in in a black American deficit underlying this disease is
different countries vary in their abil- In countries where the medical lack of an enzyme responsible for
ity to diagnose it. WD was first de- profession is aware of the disease, splitting the two most hydrophobic
scribed in Israel,I,2 then in the clinical cases longer re-
are no lipids of the body, triglycerides and
United States, after which it was re- ported by leading journals. The cholesterol esters, at a low pH.l9
ported in most countries and ethnic occurrence of new cases can be The enzyme (EC 3.1.1.13) has
groups. Cases have been reported inferred from studies dealing with been called by different names ow-
from most Western and Central specific aspects of pathogenesis, ing to its wide spectrum of activity.
European countries,&dquo; the Far biochemistry, or instrumental aids In addition to its capacity to split
East,9,lO the Indian subcontinent,l to diagnosis, as in a case reported short fatty-acid chain triglycerides
Canada,12 and other countries. from Turkey. 18 (used in histochemical and bio-
The disease appears to be more chemical tests), it also acts as a lipase,
prevalent in Iranian Jews as well as splitting long-chain triglycerides. It
in non:Jews13,14 and in the Arab Clinical and has also been called cholesterol
population of the Galilee, prob- Radiographic Features esterase because it can split choles-
ably representing genetic isolates. terol esters into free fatty acids and
One reason the true incidence of Infants with Wolman disease cholesterol. The enzymatic deficit
the disease cannot be ascertained are born after uneventful pregnan- is also responsible for accumula-
may be due to lack of awareness in cies, often to consanguineous par- tion of some uncommon lipid es-
the medical profession in some ar- ents. They are hospitalized in the ters in the tissues and possibly for
eas ; thus, the disease was not re- first 2 months of life because of the accumulation of some glyceryl
ported from the Eastern bloc diarrhea, vomiting, feeding diffi- ether lipids,2 which is probably of
countries for many years. And culty, stunted growth, and failure little pathogenic importance. In
to thrive. Physical examination re- normal individuals, this enzyme is
Department of Pathology
veals severe abdominal distention present in lysosomes of all cells. In
Tel AvivUniversity and hepatosplenomegaly. Radio- affected individuals, storage occurs
Sackler Faculty of Medicine graphic examination reveals calci- mainly in cells with active metabo-
Tel Aviv, Israel fication of both adrenal glands. lism of lipid esters.
The calcification appears to deline- It is important to note that af-
Address correspondence to: Moshe ate the outline of both glands, and fected cells contain an effective
Wolman, M.D., Department of Pathology, this sign appears to be pathogno- mechanism of catabolizing lipid es-
Tel Aviv University, Sackler Faculty of
monic for the disease, and for its ters. While they lack the lysosomal
Medicine, 69978 Tel Aviv, Israel
less severe counterpart, choles- enzyme and therefore the capacity
An article with similar contents was terol ester storage disease (CESD). to degrade lipid that are
esters
published in Hebrew in Harefuah, August, The only test needed to corrobo- transported into the lysosomes,
1994. rate the diagnosis is a biochemical the affected cells do contain an
slight but noticeable enzyme activ- storage is in the same sites as in WD Although changes in neurones in
ity (around 10% to 15% of normal). and is similar in constitution, but the central nervous system are
Burton et al25 have demonstrated the disease is benign and often mostly minimal,35 the myenteric
that the extent of activity depends does not affect the life span, in plexus neurones are stuffed with
on the test used, and
they suggest spite of severe hepatomegaly.33 hydrophobic lipids and many neu-
that only one of two acid esterase rones seem to have died. The se-
with the disease represents mini- Pathologic Changes toms in WD patients. The changes
mal activity at low pH levels of the were described independently by
neutral esterase. 26 The significant path-
most Kamoshita and Landing36 and by
The lack of acid-esterase activ- ologic changes in patients with WD myself (with collaborators) .37 The
ity cells of patients with WD does
in are in three domains: cells of the changes in the gut indicate that
not cause complete absence of phagocytic system throughout the feeding of esters, especially milk
lipolytic activity. The receptor- body, the mucosa and other layers feeding, plays a major role in
mediated pathway of uptake of of the small intestine, and the ad- causing symptoms of the disease.
cholesterol ester (ChE)-contain- renal cortex. A group of Japanese scientists
ing lipoproteins that are trans- Cells of the reticulo-endothe- more recently suggested that the
ported into and split in lysosomes27 lial system promote endocytosis of severe damage to the intestine
is not the only path of ChE absorp- lipoproteins in the spleen, lymph excludes any absorption of enteral
tion. Some cholesterol ester is nodes, and liver; because of the nutrition.38
taken up by bulk-phase pinocy- enzyme deficit, these calls cannot The mechanism by which lack of
tosis, and this fraction does not rid themselves of the fatty esters. acid lipase prevents migration of the
contribute to intracellular stor- They are transformed into foam lipoproteins from the intestine is
age .2&dquo; Furthermore, two groups29,39 cells, filled with frankly sudano- probably the following: it was gener-
reported independently that in fi- philic (i.e., hydrophobic) lipids, ally assumed39,40 that under normal
broblasts from patients with WD, accounting for the splenomegaly conditions triglycerides are ab-
only the lipids of extracellular ori- and lymphadenopathy. A similar sorbed from the intestinal lumen by
gin are stored, while locally syn- situation in hepatocytes contrib- enterocytes and secreted by them
thesized lipids are normally utes the swollen Kupffers cells to into the intercellular space and
hydrolyzed. These observations the marked hepatomegaly. Also, hence into the lymphatics. A more
are probably related to the fact that histiocytes of the interstitium of recent study4l has shown that the
the neutral lipase-esterase of WD various organs of the body, in- greater part of triglycerides are not
cells is not, or is only marginally, cluding the heart, blood vessels, transported from the intestinal mu-
affected. and brain, are affected by the cosa via the lymphatics. The authors
Prenatal diagnosis of WD is fea- lipid-storage process. assumed that normally the
sible and has been successfully per- An extreme degree of lipid stor- triglycerides are split in the entero-
formed. Although histochemical age occurs in patients with WD in cytes and the products are trans-
demonstration of absent acid the small intestine and particularly ported directly to the hepatic
esterase activity in cultured em- in the mucosa. At autopsy, the in- portal system. They found that the
brvonal cells might be simplest, it ner surface of the gut appears vel- villi contain a lysosomal acid lipase.
in all other cells. In adrenocortical tation. Dr. Krivit has advocated diet is not surprising in view of the
cells bursting with hydrophobic (personal communication) proce- known needs of EFA in infants. 56
lipids and transformed into a ne- dures that might decrease the The problem of how to admin-
crotic mass, the microsomal acid chance of graft vs host reaction in ister adequate amounts of EFA
lipase can come in contact with the patients treated with bone marrow without any fatty acid esters is not
lipids originally contained in transplantation, and the use of easy to solve. Administration of
lysosomes. concomitant liver transplant in se- EFA bound to proteins, as I have
lected cases. suggested,55 might be effective in
view of the study of Von Hoden-
Treatment Modalities for berg et al57 on cultured macro-
WD and CSD Suggested Theoretical Basis of a phages, but the question of its
by Other Authors Suggested Treatment feasibility at present is open to
doubt. A simpler solution might be
More than 20 years ago, Infants affected by WD appar- based on the use of percutaneous
Crocker, Fisher, and Filler44 at- ently suffer from and die of pro- administration of these lipids. In
tempted treatment of a WD patient gressive stuffing with fats of the fact, daily cutaneous application of
with low-residue feeding followed intestine and its innervation. The sunflower oil (rich in unsaturated
by intravenous alimentation. Mey- conclusion reached by Meyers et fatty acids) was found to cure the
ers et a145 observed a halt in the a145 and Kikuchi et ap8 that death symptoms of EFA deficiency in
deterioration of a WD patient in these patients is due to inanition adults58 and infants.5g The find-
treated with parenteral hyperali- is probably correct. Thus, therapy ings were confirmed by some work-
mentation. An in vitro attempt to should be aimed at achieving two ers in the field but contested by
treat cultured WD and CESD fi- main goals: (1) to avoid stuffing others .60,61 Data presented in an ex-
broblasts by &dquo;feeding&dquo; them the the intestine with nontransport- change of letters to the editor of
missing enzyme was successful. 46,47 able and noncatabolizable lipids; the journal of Pediatrics62 indicate
Whether such an approach can be (2) to avoid similar clogging of that percutaneous treatment with
effective in patients is question- the phagocytes. At present, when sunflower or safflower oil corrects
able, as the average half life of en- most patients run an acute some, but not all, aspects of EFA
docytosed acid lipase activity in course, adrenocortical replace- deficiency. It is probable that the
fibroblasts is 1 day. 48 ment therapy may not be impor- discrepant results obtained by per-
A number of authors correctly tant, but this may change if cutaneous treatment of EFA defi-
assumed that modalities of treat- therapy allows WD patients, with ciency might be due to the use of
ment for WD can be usefully and most of their adrenal fetal cortex different parameters of improve-
more easily tested on CESD, in
destroyed, to live beyond the first ment by the various authors. It is
which the progression of changes 3 to 6 months of life. further possible that the oils used
is much slower. Ginsberg et a149 Avoidance of breast-feeding, did not contain adequate amounts
found that lovastatin treatment of any other milk feeding, or admini- of the higher unsaturated fatty
and phospholipids is not apprecia- REFERENCES infant. Ann Trop Paediatr. 1991;11:305-
308.
bly affected in WD, the chances are 1. Abramov A, Schorr S, Wolman M. Gen-
17. Miller R, Bialer MG, Rogers F, et al.
that percutaneous application of eralized xanthomatosis with calcified ad-
renals. Am JDis Child. 1956;91:282-286. Wolmans disease: report of a case with
fats is not likely to be a further
burden on the defective lipolysis. 2. Wolman M, Sterk W, Gatt S, Frenkel M. multiple studies. Arch Pathol Lab Med.
1982;106:41-45.
Primary familial xanthomatosis with in-
volvement and calcification of the ad- 18. Ozmen MN, Aygun N, Kilic I, et al.
renals. Report of two more cases in Wolmans disease: ultrasonographic
Suggested Treatment siblings of a previously described infant. and computed tomographic findings.
containing triglycerides and cho- 6. Lajo A, Gracia R, Navarro M, et al. Enfer- Biochim Biophys Acta. 1982;711:59-65.
28. Brown MS, Goldstein JL. Receptor-me- 41. Rao RH, Mansbach II M. Acid lipase in therapy with lovastatin. Hepatology.
diated control of cholesterol metabo- rat intestinal mucosa: physiological pa- 1990;11:764-772.
lism. Science. 1976;191:150-154. rameters. Biochim Biophys Acta. 53. Leone L, Ippoliti PE. Use of simvastatin
29. Hoeg JM, Demosky Jr SJ, Pescovitz OH, 1990;1043:273-280. plus cholestyramine in the treatment of
Brewer Jr HB. Cholesteryl ester storage 42. Schaub J, Janka GE, Christomanou H, et lysosomal acid lipase deficiency.
J
disease and Wolman disease: pheno- al. Wolmans disease: clinical, biochemi- Pediatr. 1991;119:1008-1009.
typic variants of lysosomal acid cal and ultrastructural studies in an un- 54. Krivit W, Freese D, Chan KW, Kulkarni R.
cholesteryl ester hydrolase deficiency. usual case without striking adrenal Wolmans disease: a review of treatment
Am J Hum Genet. 1984;36:1190-1203. calcification. Eur J Pediatr. 1980 ;135 :45- with bone marrow transplantation and
30. Salvayre R, Negre A, Maret A, et al. 54. considerations for the future. Bone Mar-
Extracellular origin of the lipid lysoso- 43. Nishikawa T, Mikami K, Saito Y, et al. row Transplant. 1992; (Suppl) 1:97-101.
mal storage in cultured fibroblasts from Studies on cholesterol esterase in the 55. Wolman M. Proposed treatment for in-
Wolmans disease. Eur J Biochem. ratadrenal. Endocrinology. 1981 ;18 :932- fants with Wolman disease. Pediatrics.
1987;170:453-458. 936. 1989;83:1074-10 75.
31. Coates PM, Cortner JA, Mennuti MT, 44. Crocker AC, Fisher JN, Filler RM. Nu- 56. Farquharson J, Cockburn F, Patrick WA,
Wheeler JE. Prenatal diagnosis of Wol- tritional support, including intrave- et al. Effect of diet on infant subcutane-
man disease. Am J Med Genet. nous alimentation, for the infant with ous tissue triglyceride fatty acids. Arch
1978;2:397-407. Wolmans disease. In: Volk BW, Aron- Dis Child. 1993;69:589-593.
32. Sloan HR, Fredrickson DS. Enzyme de- son SM, eds. Sphingolipids, Sphingolipi- 57. vonHodenberg E, Khoo JC, Jensen D, et
ficiency in cholesteryl ester storage dis- doses and Allied Disorders. New York, NY: al. Mobilization of stored triglycerides
J Clin Invest. 1972;51:1923-1926.
ease. Plenum Press; 1972:661-670. from macrophages as free fatty acids. Ar
-
33. Assman G, Fredrickson DS. Acid lipase 45. Meyers WF, Hoeg JM, Demosky SJ, et al. teriosclerosis. 1984;4:630-635.
deficiency: Wolmans disease and The use of parenteral hyperalimenta- 58. Press M, Hartop PJ, Prottey C. Correc-
cholesteryl ester storage disease. In: tion and elemental formula feeding in tion of essential fatty-acid deficiency in
Stanbury DB, Wyngaarden JB, Fredrick- the treatment of Wolman disease. Nutr man by the cutaneous application of