Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
From the *School of Medicine and Graduate School of Medicine, Pontifcia Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande
do Sul (PUCRS), Porto Alegre, Brazil; Graduate Program in Pediatrics and Child Care, Pontifcia
Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul (PUCRS), Porto Alegre, Brazil; Pontifcia Universidade Catolica
do Rio Grande do Sul (PUCRS), Porto Alegre, Brazil
The objective of the present study is to evaluate a new diagnostic strategy using clinical findings
followed by ultrasound (US) and, in selected cases, MRI. This study included 166 children
presenting signs and symptoms suggesting acute appendicitis. Cases classified as suggesting
appendicitis according to clinical exams had to be referred to surgery, whereas the other cases
were discharged. Unclear cases were evaluated using US. If the US results were considered
inconclusive, patients underwent MRI. Of the 166 patients, 78 (47%) had acute appendicitis and
88 (53%) had other diseases. The strategy under study had a sensitivity of 96 per cent, specificity
of 100 per cent, positive predictive value of 100 per cent, negative predictive value of 97 per cent,
and accuracy of 98 per cent. Eight patients remained undiagnosed and underwent MRI. After
MRI two girls presented normal appendixes and were discharged. One girl had an enlarged
appendix on MRI and appendicitis could have been confirmed by surgery. In the other five
patients, no other sign of the disease was detected by MRI such as an inflammatory mass, free
fluid or an abscess in the right iliac fossa. All of them were discharged after clinical observation.
In the vast majority of cases the correct diagnosis was reached by clinical and US examinations.
When clinical assessment and US findings were inconclusive, MRI was useful to detect normal
and abnormal appendixes and valuable to rule out other abdominal pathologies that mimic
appendicitis.
390
No. 5 ACUTE APPENDICITIS ? Epifanio et al. 391
sequences were the same as those used in a previous detection of the appendix, and imaging investigation of
study that evaluated the normal appendix in asymp- other possible diseases. Appendicitis diagnostic crite-
tomatic children. 19 Scanning started with a T2- ria used in MRI studies were those suggested by
coronal sequence to detect the position of the cecum. Horman et al.19
Axial sections were defined according to the position A negative imaging result for appendicitis was
of the cecum. The most cranial section was obtained recorded when the following independent findings were
at least 10 cm above the cecum, and the most caudal, seen: 1) visualization of a blind-ending tubular structure
at the pubic symphysis. Four sequences were per- leaving the cecum and with a maximum transverse di-
formed according to the following imaging param- ameter of 6 mm or 2) clear and unequivocal imaging
eters: axial T1-weighted fast spin echo: T1/FSE; definition of another disease. A positive imaging result
TR/TE:700 ms/8.7 ms; 4.0 mm section thickness, of appendicitis was recorded when the following in-
512 3 512; axial T2-weighted fast spin echo: T2/FSE; dependent findings were seen: 1) visualization of blind-
TR/TE:1900 ms/957 ms; 4.0 mm section thickness, ending tubular structure leaving the cecum and with
256 3 256; axial T2-weighted fast spin echo with fat a transverse diameter greater than 6 mm or 2) pericecal
suppression: T2/FSE fat saturation (FATSAT); TR/TE: inflammation of omentum and no detection of an ap-
1800 ms/95.7 ms; 4.0 mm section thickness, 256 3 256; pendix (considered suggestive, but not specific for acute
coronal T2-weighted fast spin echo: T2/FSE; TR/TE:1800 appendicitis). An inconclusive result was recorded
ms/102.7 ms; 4.0 mm section thickness, 512 3 512. when the appendix was not detected.
Scanning was performed, ideally, without general
anesthesia or contrast media. When the cecal ap-
Statistical Analysis
pendix was not identified in the initial sequences
carried out without constrast, we proceded to exam- Quantitative variables are described as mean and
ine with gadolinium [0.2 mg/kg intravenously (IV) at standard deviations. Categorical variables are de-
0.5 mmol/ml]. scribed as frequencies and percentages. Kappa statis-
MRI evaluation consisted of the detection of ap- tics was used to evaluate statistical agreement between
pendix and measurement of its total transverse di- diagnostic test and disease and also to evaluate in-
ameter, of pericecal inflammation omentum without terobserver agreement. The Student t test for
394 THE AMERICAN SURGEON May 2016 Vol. 82
independent samples was used to compare means. any statistically significant difference in mean age
The Pearson chi-squared test was used to evaluate (P 4 0.692) or sex distribution (P 4 0.464).
the association between categorical variables. The Seventy-five diagnoses of appendicitis were made
SPSS 13.0 (Chicago, IL) software was used for using the strategy under study: all results were true
statistical analyses. The level of significance was positive, and there were no false-positive results. The
set at 5 per cent (P # 0.05). general diagnostic strategy had a sensitivity of 96 per
cent, specificity of 100 per cent, positive and negative
predictive values of 100 and 97 per cent, and accuracy
Results
of 98 per cent (Table 1). Of all patients, 102 underwent
One hundred and sixty-six children with suspected US studies, 37 had negative results for appendicitis,
acute appendicitis were evaluated in this study. Mean and 57 were referred to surgery (100% probability of
age was 9.15 years 2.78 and age range was 1 to appendicitis) (Table 2). Three US results were false
13 years. For the 94 boys, mean age was 8.91 years negative, and as the clinical condition of these patients
2.51 and age range was 1 to 12 years, and for the (one boy and two girls) deteriorated, they were re-
72 girls, mean age was 9.47 3.08 and age range was ferred to surgery. A normal appendix was detected in
1 to 13 years. Appendicitis was confirmed by patho- 8 (22%) of the 37 patients with negative US results; in
logical examination of the surgical specimen in 78 3 (8%) an equivocally normal appendix was detected
(47%) of the patients: 47 were boys (60%) and 31 were (false-negative results); 10 (27%) patients the appen-
girls (40%), mean age was 9.25 years, and age range dix was not detected and their clinical condition im-
was 2 to 13 years. Other diseases were diagnosed in 88 proved in 12 to 24 hours after US studies; and
(53%) patients: 47 were boys (53%) and 41 were girls 16 (43%) had a diagnosis of other diseases, such as
(47%), mean age was 9.07 years, and age range was pancreatitis (n 4 1), inflamed Meckels diverticulum
1 to 12 years. The comparison between the groups of (n 4 1), pneumonia (n 4 2), ovarian cyst (n 4 2), and
patients with and without appendicitis did not reveal acute mesenteric lymphadenitis (n 4 10). None of
these patients, therefore, underwent MRI scanning.
The abnormal appendix was detected in 52 (91%) of
TABLE 1. Evaluation of the General Strategy for Suspected the 57 patients with positive US findings, and pericecal
Acute Appendicitis in Children inflammation but no abnormal appendix in 5 (9%).
Final Diagnosis Clinical and US findings remained inconclusive for
eight patients, and they were referred to MRI (age
Test Acute Appendicitis Another Disease Total range was 411 years). After MRI, one girl was di-
Positive 75 0 75 agnosed with acute appendicitis, confirmed by surgery.
Negative 03 88 91 Two girls were discharged after the normal appendix
Total 78 88 166
Sensitivity 96.1 (89.999.0) was detected and five patients were kept under clinical
Specificity 100 (96.7100) observation because of unclear MRI findings. Of the
PPV 100 (96.1100) eight patients who underwent MRI, seven received IV
NPV 96.7 (91.399.2) contrast material, one 4-year-old boy required sedation
Accuracy 98.2 (95.299.5)
IV, and only one 5-year-old girl required general
CI, confidence interval; PPV, positive predictive value; NPV, anesthesia. Total examination time, considering the
negative predictive value.
Diagnostic measures are described as proportions (95% con- four sequences in all cases, was 10 minutes. Kappa
fidence interval). Kappa statistics (statistical agreement between statistics between observers had the greatest value
test and disease) 4 0.96; 95% CI 4 0.90 to 0.99; P < 0.001. (k 4 0.80).