Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 15

Item Revision Comment date Suez Comments Answer Date RDC-ECL Answer Comment open or closed?

A
1 7/30/2017 For the tag, please differenciate it from other details for better
understanding
A
2 7/30/2017 Title box : Change the name of the document as "outline
drawings" instead of "preliminary outline drawings"
A
3 7/30/2017 For the client review, follow the numerical order as indicated in
the engineering quality management plan
A Please provide an additional drawing where we can see the
4 7/30/2017 interfacing point of pulsatube with Rapid sand filter
A In the drawing title, add an additional column under SUEZ, to
7/30/2017 indicate the concerned person who checked the document

B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-001-Rev A
Please mention the key plan and orientation angle at the top
left hand point. Please provide a key plan of project layout
1 A 7/30/2017 showing the exact location at the top right hand corner of the
drawing

Please provide the Technical note on the Reinforced Concrete


2 A 7/30/2017 grade, blinding grade and screed grade.
Provide additional cross section between Grid 3 & 4, for
indicating how raft bottom profile would change, indicating the
drainage line 100NB connected to the drainage pit at adjascent
3 A 7/30/2017 location.Please provide additional cross section between C & D

Please show the dimension line at the following points in the


drainage pits

4 A 7/30/2017

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 1/15
Please show the dimension line at the following points in the
drainage pits

5 A 7/30/2017

There wont be any gap produces at this point now. Please


check the latest modification sheet 124MS001 sent on the
29/06/2017.

6 A 7/30/2017

Pipe support are supposed to be shown at the bottom raft at


EL 10.78. Kindly indicate by some note or by sketch marking it
7 A 7/30/2017 in particular area

Col 300 x300 are passing in the Grid E. These columns don'thas
any footing in the plan. Please provide it in plan with sizes
mentioned

8 A 7/30/2017

Please provide the dimension between the columns provided


for supporting the clarified water channell

9 A 7/30/2017

Provide the Reference drawings number in the drawing above


10 A 7/30/2017 the title box

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 2/15
Provide the type of opening detail diagram in the drawing. In
our Civil Guide drawing, we are having opening
11 A 7/30/2017

Some of the dimensions mentioning the thicknesses are not


clear, as it been mixed up with concrete hatches in the
drawing.

12 A 7/30/2017

Kindly provide a section at the preferred location cuting the


drainage pit and the channel

13 A 7/30/2017

The column in the Hole list are not required in the structure list

14 A 7/30/2017

Kindly remove the static load and dynamic load in the Hole list

15 A 7/30/2017

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 3/15
In the civil guide drawing, there are hole list which is
mentioning about the different type of openings. The symbols
of different types of openings should be pasted in the drawing
in title box

16 A 7/30/2017

Kindly provide a small sketch of four pulsatube, by shadding


17 A 7/30/2017 the concerned pulsatube for which the drawing is referring to

Can we avoid the double wall at this location between the


peripherall wall and drain pit wall

18 A 7/30/2017

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 4/15
As commented earlier on rapid sand filter, how are you going
to assign the restraints in pulsatube especially in the expansion
joint area ? The expansion joint shall not be having any
restraint in the walls as there is no bar been continued on the
adjascents walls. If you are proposing to provide pinned joint
on the walls as you did in filter SAPmodel. V=0 cannot be
zero.As proposed, by providing a GI bolt at the expansion
joint connecting two different walls may transfer the
load from one element to the other, but it may not give
the behaviour of a pinned support. Hence please provide
the restraints in such a way that the structure may
produce actual behaviour

19 A 7/30/2017

The expansion joint shown in the plan are not matching witth
20 A 7/30/2017 section A-A
The thickness of the wall concentrator area and the inlet
chamber along grid 3 ,4 8, 9 could be 250mm . Please optimize

21 A 7/30/2017

No dimensions are provided between the drainage pits. Please


check
22 A 7/30/2017

The thickness of chambers could be reduced to 200mm


23 A 7/30/2017 instead of providing 250mm thickness
The location of Inlet pipe coming under the raft needs to be
24 A 7/30/2017 visible in the foundation plan.

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 5/15
25 A 7/30/2017 Opening 124-B0025 is missing (check DG003 rev C)
26 A 7/30/2017 Correct the indicated tag according to 124DG003 rev C
27 A 7/30/2017 Correct the indicated tag according to 124DG003 rev C
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-002
28 A 7/30/2017 Kindly conply all the comments in the OL 001 here also.
29 A 7/30/2017 Do you require 600 mm which is one drain pit?
Please provide the grid numbers properly. Some of the grid
30 A 7/30/2017 numbers are missing
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-003
31 A 7/30/2017 Add the missing stairs
32 A 7/30/2017 Kindly comply all the comments highlighted in the OL 001

Please check the thickness of the drainage/ sludge pits outside


33 A 7/30/2017 the pulsatube chamber. Those can be reduced to 200mm
instead of providing 250mm.

Kindly check whether the double walls can be avoided


34 A 7/30/2017 between the drainage pits and the peripheral walls of the
pulsatube.

Please show the location of the pipe pedastels at the raft


35 A 7/30/2017 bottom level tentatively or just provide some note for the
referring the details of pipe pedastels

The raft thickness mentioned at the 10.78MSL can be reduced


36 A 7/30/2017 to 250mm thk. Instead of prodiving 300mm thk.Please check.

The walls at the concentrator area needs has to be checked for


37 A 7/30/2017 reducing the thickness to 250mm instead of 300mm. Kindly
check
38 A 7/30/2017 Please provide the typical details of expansion joint.
Kindly show a key plan of pulsatube , sketching 4 pulsatube
39 A 7/30/2017 together and shade the specific pulsatube mentioned in the
specific drawing
40 A 7/30/2017 Opening is missing. Consistency with OL001
41 A 7/30/2017 Precise the level of the plan view
42 A 7/30/2017 Do we require a movement joint?
43 A 7/30/2017 Put water stop
44 A 7/30/2017 Provide addtional cross section
45 A 7/30/2017 Align the dimensions with the wall
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-004
46 A 7/30/2017 Shift the name of the view for a better visibility

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 6/15
47 A 7/30/2017 A beam is joining the columns as per the section A in OL 001.
But in the plan it is missing. Kindly correct it or try to avoid it.
Meanwhile in the same section in OL 009, there is no beam

48 A 7/30/2017 Please provide the dimensions for the walls of the Inlet
Chamber.

49 A 7/30/2017 The staircase is missing in the plan near to Grid 1

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 7/15
50 A 7/30/2017 Expansion joint provided in the plan shall be cutting beams
and troughs of the structure above. How will the structure be
stable ?

56 A 7/30/2017 Kindly reduce the thickness of 200mm for all drainage pits

56 A 7/30/2017 Provide information about expansion joints


57 A 7/30/2017 Kindly provide the edge protection of RCC walls with grating

A 7/30/2017 Specify the grating type, thickness grade, etc required to


58
provide over the drainage pits
A 7/30/2017 Where are the sludge concentrators which are supposed to be
59
shown at this level?
A 7/30/2017
There are some section lines shown in the drawing which are
60 cutting the Inlet clarified channel. But where are they referring
to? Make sure, they are having corresponding drawing
references marked in the section box

A 7/30/2017 In the inlet clarified channel, the thickness of wall to be


61 considered as 200mm instead of 250mm

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 8/15
A 7/30/2017
There are too much line which are creating confusion between
the concrete lines and Grid lines. Please make sure that each
62
line has its own thickness and importances. And it make it
more readable
A 7/30/2017 The modular beams are provided with a corbel or a bracket in
63 the section.But in the main layout nothing has been shown.
Please check
64 A 7/30/2017 Expansion joints not shown in sections
65 A 7/30/2017 Correct the section numbering
66 A 7/30/2017 Remove the openings
67 A 7/30/2017 Add the missing grids
68 A 7/30/2017 Details are missing in the plan view. Add them
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-005
A 7/30/2017
69 Please comply the same comments as mentioned in OL 004

70 A 7/30/2017 The staircase are found to be missing in Grid 23


B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-006
A 7/30/2017
71 Please comply the same comments as mentioned in OL 004
A 7/30/2017 Please provide the dimension marks at wherever location
72
provided with "??" (question marks).
A 7/30/2017
The section line marked cutting the inlet clarified channels
73 should have a reference drawing number to understand from
where we can get the details of the same.

A 7/30/2017 Details of the canopy on top of the Roof slab of Blower Rooms
74 are missing
A 7/30/2017 Location of Rain water Catch pit at top of the Roof slab is
75 missing.
A 7/30/2017
76 The section lines A,B, C ..etc which are provided in OL 001, OL
002, OL 003, OL 004. etc are missing in this drawings.

A 7/30/2017 The clarified trough channel are missing at some points near to
77
the Blower Room Area
A 7/30/2017 Please provide the details of the Precast slab on top of the
78
Inlet Clarified Channel .
A 7/30/2017
The expansion joint are provided in between the bottom slab
79 of the Bypass Channel. But the same expansion joint are not
shown in the corresponding elevation drawing. Please check.

A 7/30/2017
By insering the expansion joint at this point, we shall loose the
restraints on the Bottom Slab of the bypass channel,which may
result to provide a cantilver behaviour on the bottom slab.
80 Please make sure that to provide some top and bottom strip
cover on the expansion joints to stop the ingress of water
inside.

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 9/15
A 7/30/2017
81 Correct the width of the walkway according to 124DG003 rev C
A 7/30/2017 precise the missing level and add the missing stairs ( Check
82
DG003 rev C)
A 7/30/2017
83
Show in a dotted way the bypass connection with the filters
84 A 7/30/2017 Expansion joint not shown in sections at elevation
85 A 7/30/2017 Please reduce the line width of the grid lines
A 7/30/2017
86 Orientation of staircase and walkways are not matching with
the civil guide drawing phase 1
87 A 7/30/2017 Kindly precise the different dimensions
88 A 7/30/2017 Show the missing drain pit
89 A 7/30/2017 Provide typical dimensions
90 A 7/30/2017 Precise the level and the thickness
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-007
91 A 7/30/2017 Please comply all the comments as in OL006
A 7/30/2017
92 Correct the width of the walkway according to 124DG003 rev C

B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-008
A 7/30/2017 Kindly indicate properly the dimension 1500mm shown near
93
to grid 01 in Section A.
A 7/30/2017 The outer wall thickness at Grid 01 could be tapered instead of
94
the taking it straight
A 7/30/2017
Module beam in the plan is mentioned as 300x450mm. Then
95 how come in the section its shown as 750 x 450mm.

A 7/30/2017 Kindly check whether the raft slab can be reduced from
96
300mm to 250mm.
A 7/30/2017
As highlighted in the drawing, kindly indicate and highlight the
97
dimension properly, so that it can be readable

A 7/30/2017
98 The bottom Inlet pipe entering to Inlet chambers are missing
A 7/30/2017 Are there any encasement required the inlet pipe underneath
99
raft, if so please mention
A 7/30/2017 Are there any edge protection to be provided for the concrete
100
slab panels
A 7/30/2017
Please be informed that the foundation system for the end
101
Pulsatube between grid 18 and 23 shall be different.

102 A 7/30/2017 The dimension is not clear


103 A 7/30/2017 Thrust block are required for the pipes
104 A 7/30/2017 The walls of the bypass can be tapered. Please do it.
105 A 7/30/2017 For the stairs, how to build chamfer physically at site?
106 A 7/30/2017 Check the width of the bypass with DG003 rev C
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-009

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 10/15
A 7/30/2017 It is not practical to chamfer the edge of the Staircase as
107
shown in the drawing. Kindly make it straight.
A 7/30/2017 Please mention the Inlet pipe on bottom of the raft with
108
required thickness of encasement.
A 7/30/2017 The raft slab thickness can be reduced to 400mm in the Inlet
109 chamber Portion, the rest of the area we can try for 250mm
thick slab.
A 7/30/2017 The walls of the Inlet chamber can be reduced from 300mm to
110 250mm. Please check
111 A 7/30/2017 Please indicate the dimension line at the marked areas.
A 7/30/2017 The peripheral wall along grid 1 can be tapered as shown in
112
the drawing
A 7/30/2017 A beam has been shown connecting the supporting columns
113 for the Inlet Clarified channels in some of the drawings. But
here its missing. Kindly correct.
A 7/30/2017 The pedastels for the Blowers at 17.71 are missing in the
114
drawing. Please show
115 A 7/30/2017 Please show the handrailing
A 7/30/2017 Please try to avoid the double wall between the drain pit and
116 the Peripheral wall of the pulsatube.
A 7/30/2017 The slab thickness at EL 21.21 shall be safe by providing
117 150mm instead of 200mm.
A 7/30/2017 The slab thickness at EL 17.71 shall be safe by providng 200mm
118 instead of 250mm
119 A 7/30/2017 Where are the pedestals?
120 A 7/30/2017 Shift the title of the section
121 A 7/30/2017 Show the elevation
A 7/30/2017
122 The expansion joint is going to get cut in all modular beam and
troughs. Is it possible?
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-010
7/30/2017 The wall/raft thickness provided has been mixed with the
123 A concrete hatches shown. Kindly make the dimensions clear

7/30/2017 The slab thicknesses for the drainage pit has been mentioned
124 A as 300mm in plans and in the sections its mentioned as
250mm

125 A 7/30/2017 Please show the inlet pipe sectional view under the raft
7/30/2017
126 A For the water level, consider the overflow level which is 15,86
(check DG006 rev C)
7/30/2017
127 A
Opening for ND100 pipe for concentrator drain is missing
128 A 7/30/2017 Check the size: it is 1370 ( check 124DG006 rev C)
129 A 7/30/2017 Add the missing opening's tag
7/30/2017 The monorail should be shown connecting the roof beams at
130 A EL 21.21
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-011

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 11/15
A 7/30/2017
131 There is a foundation for a jib crane (124A_F1003 in the load
list). Please take in consideration.
A 7/30/2017
132 The walkway is at the same level as the bottom of the vaccum
chamber.
A 7/30/2017
132
Base of the concentrator is missing (Check 124DG006 rev C)
A 7/30/2017
133
Add the missing slope as indicated in 124DG006 and the drain
A 7/30/2017
Opening 124A_B0002 is missing (Check 124_DG006). Align the
134 pulsatube opening with the drain opening. Put them in the
same level.
135 A 7/30/2017 Where is this beam coming from?
136 A 7/30/2017 Base of the concentrator is missing ( Check 124 DGOO6)
A 7/30/2017 Kindly comply all the comments as mentioned for OL 010
137

B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-012
138 A 7/30/2017 z
A 7/30/2017 Please be informed that the pipe pedastels shall not be
constructed monolithically with the Slab. Kindly check Civil
Guide drawing, we need to apply the grout on bottom of the
139 raft. Kindly highlight the grout thickness required in the
drawing.

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 12/15
A 7/30/2017 For 300 SQ column in Plan at 11.50, is not clear. In Section,
140 from which point does it starts? Please mention in any of the
sectional view

A 7/30/2017 How come 125 mm trials panels become so thin compared to


141 200 mm ones?
A 7/30/2017 Kindly provide the necessary dimensions of the pipe pedastels
142 as highlighted in the drawings
A 7/30/2017 The dimensions of the sludge concentrators to be provided
143 properly as commented
A 7/30/2017
144 Pit/Openings for sludge drain off are missing ( check
124DG007)
145 A 7/30/2017 Correct this value (check 124DG010)
146 A 7/30/2017 Comply with the details indicated on the 124DG010 revC
147 A 7/30/2017 Optimize
148 A 7/30/2017 Reverse the tags
149 A 7/30/2017 Drain pit is missing (Check 124DG007)
150 A 7/30/2017 Opening 124_B0026 is missing

151 A 7/30/2017 Consistency! At this level we don't see the sludge concentrator
(124DG06 rev C - section B-B). Change the level
152 A 7/30/2017 Opening 124_B0024 is missing
A 7/30/2017
153 Add 4 openings for concentrator sludge draw off (Check
124DG007
A 7/30/2017 The thickness of the channel troughs can be reduced to
154 150mm. Please
A 7/30/2017
155 Will 900 mm be sufficient for accomodating the load inside the
footing?
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-013
A 7/30/2017
156 Check the value. It is not complying with the requirement of
124DG009
157 A 7/30/2017 No! Process requirement! The angle is 55 there
158 A 7/30/2017 No! The angle is 65 there. Check 124DG006
A 7/30/2017 The second stage concreting for the conical hoppers to be
159 shown in different hatches
A 7/30/2017 Kindly mark the elevation and dimension for all the mentioned
160 points which are marked in the Section H, I and J

161 A 7/30/2017 Taper the wall


162 A 7/30/2017 Add the tag number
163 A 7/30/2017 Please show the columns
164 A 7/30/2017 Add the dimensions indicated by ??
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-014
165 A 7/30/2017 Remove the extra tag
A 7/30/2017 Please show the grid nos. in the plan layout at 20.00 LVL.
166

167 A 7/30/2017 Please provide the beam marking on the plan with sizes

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 13/15
168 A 7/30/2017 Show location of the monorail
169 A 7/30/2017 precise the drawing number
A 7/30/2017 Kindly show the walkway slab at this plan level also with Beam
170 locations marked

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 14/15
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-015
7/30/2017 The slab thickness should be 250mm in this region instead of
171 A 200mm
172 A 7/30/2017 The dimensions are missing in the Section 1 &section 2
173 A 7/30/2017 Is it a precast slab?
7/30/2017 Please provide the correct drawing reference number in the
174 A detail title.
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-016
175 A 7/30/2017 Please indicate the location of the monorail
7/30/2017 Please provide the details of the bolts cutouts for the Pedastels
176 A 124A_F1001 and 124A_F1002
7/30/2017
177 A Openings 124A_B1007/124A_B1006 are missing (check
124DG012)
178 A 7/30/2017 foundation 124A_B1003 is missing (Check 124DG012)
B-001085-REC-CW-124-OL-017
7/30/2017
178 A Level is 16,57. Check the levels with 124A_F1005 information
in the load list
179 A 7/30/2017 Precise the dimension
180 A 7/30/2017 Detail of rainwater catch pit in the roof slab panel
181 A 7/30/2017 To check in the contract

This document is confidential and shall be used only for the purpose on the TSE Polishing Treatment (Reverse Osmosis RO) Plant at Aspire Zone Project only

Page 15/15