Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Strength Athletes
Lonnie Lowery, PhD, James F. Edel, BS, and Isaiah M. McBride, BS
Department of Health, Exercise and Rehabilitative Sciences, Winona State University, Winona, Minnesota
SUMMARY scientists on topics such as the safety anabolic hormones, for example, deter-
of large intakes (27,30,31). Unfortu- mine how far the dietary protein and
DIETARY PROTEIN, PARTICULARLY
nately, data from nonathletic popula- resistance exercise stimuli take the ath-
IN THE AMPLE AMOUNTS USED BY
tions and unsubstantiated professional lete. Ample protein intake beyond nitro-
MANY STRENGTH ATHLETES, HAS gen equilibrium does not necessarily
opinion have often been used in educa-
LONG BEEN CONTROVERSIAL, IN lack value; however, it may offer advan-
tional materials (30). Indeed, textbooks
PART BECAUSE OF LACK OF DATA. tages such as affecting intracellular sig-
sometimes reference each other rather
THE SAFETY (E.G. RENAL AND than using relevant primary literature naling pathways or offering satiety or
BONE HEALTH) AND EFFICACY and thus have perpetuated certain increasing metabolic rate. Finally, varia-
(ENHANCED PROTEIN SYNTHESIS, health concerns. Recent strength bles such as protein type, dose, peri-ex-
MUSCLE ACCRETION, AND FAT athletespecific data do exist, however. ercise timing, energy intake, and training
LOSS) OF VARIOUS PROTEINS status all affect outcomes in research
The efficacy of dietary protein for build-
HAVE NOW BEEN RESEARCHED and thus affect sports nutrition recom-
ing and repairing various tissues, pro-
TO VARYING DEGREES, HOW- mendations for athletes.
viding building blocks for bodily
EVER. PROTEIN TYPE, DOSE, PERI-
enzymes, immune proteins, and trans-
EXERCISE TIMING, ENERGY
porters and for helping to maintain PROTEIN SAFETY (LARGE
INTAKE, AND TRAINING STATUS
bodily fluid balance and pH clearly INTAKES)
ARE CONSIDERATIONS. RECOM-
makes it an essential nutrient. Indeed, It is interesting to note that safety data
MENDATIONS SHOULD NOT BE
there have been suggestions from scien- specific to healthy persons or certainly to
EXTRAPOLATED FROM OTHER
tists to increase "official" governmental strength athletes consuming ample pro-
POPULATIONS. THIS REVIEW
recommendations in coming years tein is quite limited. Scientific examina-
COVERS DATA SPECIFIC TO THE (15,23). Decades of research exist sup- tions of issues commonly mentioned by
STRENGTH TRAINING POPULA- porting proteins role in enhanced mus- clinicians, such as renal stress, dehydra-
TION AND OFFERS PRACTICAL cle protein synthesis, both when tion, gout, bone catabolism, and an
ADVICE ON MANIPULATING PRO- considered as daily intake and when adverse impact on diet quality (e.g., fiber
TEIN FOR OPTIMAL BENEFITS. timed close to resistance exercise or saturated fat intake), have been few.
(3,34,39,41,42,51,53). Despite this con- Pencharz et al. (40) concluded: the data
sensus that acute protein synthesis is on the safe upper limits of amino acid
increased with purposeful, well-timed intake in humans is essentially observa-
INTRODUCTION
intake, it is less clear scientifically how tional. These researchers suggest that an
ssessment of best practices
26 VOLUME 34 | NUMBER 4 | AUGUST 2012 Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association
Indirect research and plausibility argu- findings or that very long durations of concentrated forms (less pure in
ments that generate concern, such as intake beyond a decade are completely a sense), are very high-quality proteins
the Brenner hypothesis (increased kid- without consequence. These are topics but whey hydrolysates (enzymatically
ney filtration is damaging), have not been for future research. The current, practical predigested in part) are also available.
borne out in limited population-specific conclusion that can be made by a review Again, note that whey isolates are con-
studies. For example, 2 early investiga- of the literature is that large protein sidered more specific to the protein
tions by Poortmans and Dellalieux (44) intakes in healthy strength athletes, such itself, as opposed to whey concentrates
and Brandle et al. (7) found no adverse as weightlifters, bodybuilders, power- that include greater amounts of other
effects of high-protein dietsalthough lifters, and strongman athletes can be substances. As noted by Campbell
both studies compared large male wasteful but do not appear harmfulup (10), The primary differences among
strength athletes with somewhat dissim- to perhaps 3 g/kg daily and over periods these forms are the method of process-
ilar control groups (27,30). New research of about 10 years. ing, plus small differences in fat and
by Lowery et al. (28) more closely lactose content, and amino acid pro-
addressed certain control issues and files. Whey protein isolate is the most
PROTEIN TYPES
reported no differences in kidney dam- pure and concentrated form of whey
The concept of dietary variety is a widely
age (urinary microalbumin) or kidney protein available. It contains 90% or
accepted one, ensuring that the individ-
function (creatinine clearance) in quasi- more protein and very little fat and
ual receives a broad spectrum of
experimental designs of strength athletes lactose. Whey protein concentrate
nutrients, does not overconsume any
consuming very large amounts of protein has anywhere between 25% and 89%
one nutrient or contaminant, and of
(approximately 250 g daily; 3.2 g/kg protein depending upon the product.
course complies with his training diet.
body mass; 34% of energy intake) com- Whey hydrolysate supplementation
This section thus explores a variety of
pared with controls on a more typical arguably the optimal form of whey
protein food options. There are 5 pri-
diet. Importantly, these designs involved has been shown to increase muscle
mary types of dietary protein that will
long-term data, using self-reported protein synthesis greater than soy
be discussed: whey, casein, soy, egg,
intakes of over a decade (28). and casein postresistance training
and beef. These protein types can be
Protein-focused research on bone found in a variety of dietary sources. (49). Furthermore, studies have found
resorption and ultimately bone mineral Whey and casein are milk proteins. Milk that hydrolyzed whey isolate can
density (BMD) is similarly uncommon, proteins combined with resistance train- increase actual gains in lean mass and
with specific data on strength athletes ing have been linked to an increase strength over 10 weeks compared with
only becoming available in 200911 to in protein synthesis and an increase in casein (13). It is logical, especially con-
our knowledge. Older data on the cal- muscle strength (16,20,26,50). Egg pro- sidering further studies on acute pro-
ciuria of high-protein (e.g., meat) diets tein supplements are derived from tein synthesis and training gains
in nonlifters suggested potentially dele- chicken egg whites or whole egg sour- performed by Phillips et al. (42,43) that
terious effects (17). Concerns and cau- ces. There are limited studies linking the whey proteins, including isolates and
tionary language on bone loss, based on effects of egg protein in response to ath- hydrolysates, are the best choice for
these findings, are still present in educa- letes (24,37,39). Soy protein is found in muscular gains when consumed post-
tional materials offered to college stu- the soybean and is generally considered workout. These facts, along with
dents and by certain personal training a complete protein. This nonanimal pro- wheys superior solubility to traditional
groups (30). This has, however, drawn tein is thus a widely accepted vegetable casein, make it attractive.
critique from the scientific community protein source. Soy can be used by ath- But what of other complete proteins?
because extra calcium in the urine does letes searching for nonanimal proteins or Casein, the main protein in common
not equate to low BMD or increased by those with lactose intolerance. Beef is cows milk, is referred to as a slow-
fracture risk (14,36). Indeed, Lowery also a high-quality complete protein digesting protein (41) compared with
et al. (32,33) reported no differences, one that also contains zoochemicals, whey, egg, and soy because it clots in
after correcting for body mass differen- such as creatine and carnosine, that the stomach. In a number of studies,
ces, in whole-body or site-specific BMD may be beneficial to strength athletes. casein did not increase protein synthe-
when comparing strength athletes who These 5 proteins come in various forms sis like whey protein postexercise
do or do not habitually seek extra pro- and have different physiologic effects. (4,49,53). However, casein prevents
tein in the diet. The milk protein whey is a derivative bodily protein breakdown by promot-
Similarly, data on purported dehydra- of a curd processing technique of milk. ing an anticatabolic effect that is not
tion, gout, and poorer diet quality have Whey is divided into a few supplemen- found in whey protein (4). Casein
not been supported by scientific study in tal forms: isolates, concentrates, and may also be superior for satiety (1).
strength athletes (27,28,29). This is not to hydrolysates. The differences of these Although it may not be the single best
say all sports that involve resistance forms are in the processing method. choice from a protein synthetic per-
training will have similarly benign Isolated whey proteins, or simply spective, casein can be an inexpensive
high-quality protein choice. Indeed, the greatest concentration of protein the same extent in dairy proteins or
data does exist, suggesting it may be compared with concentrates and flour meats (2). Indeed, it was egg protein
similar in efficacy to whey in the long (22). Soy protein can be an inexpensive that was investigated by Moore et al.
run. As stated by Tipton et al. (53) and adequate option for supplementation. (39) when they determined that a 20-g
restated by Phillips et al. (43), Both Much of the lay concern regarding post-workout dose was close to the
whey and casein protein have recently soys estrogenic or feminizing effects optimal dose for peak protein synthesis.
been demonstrated to be effective in among strength athletes appears over- Eggs may best be consumed as whole
supporting a positive leucine and phe- stated. Nevertheless, some hormonal foods because of their nutrient richness,
nylalanine balance following resistance concerns are indeed present in the sci- functional food qualities, and quick
exercise, with no apparent difference entific literature, and soy does have preparation.
between the two proteins. From a poorer leucine content than whey Dietary sources of beef protein include
a whole-body perspective, the linger- (47). Despite its similar protein quality hamburger, beef tips, cubed steak, and
ing elevation in amino acids seen after (protein digestibilitycorrected amino other cuts of meat derived from cows.
casein ingestion suggests that it may be acid score, PDCAAS) and relative Because of its solid nature, beef protein
beneficial to consume in the evening, speed of digestion/absorption, soy is a slower-digesting protein. The value
before the overnight fast. This is spec- does not increase muscle protein syn- of beef to resistance trainers is estab-
ulation, however, given the notion of thesis as much as whey protein does lished, but studies differ somewhat
refractoriness (serum amino acids do (49). For these reasons, soy is best with regards to its superiority versus
not indefinitely increase muscle protein suited for those eschewing higher- a lacto-ovo vegetarian type of diet, at
synthesis). This is not to say casein is quality animal products, such as whey least in older men (11,21). Beef is a rich
the only, or even the single best, choice or egg. Soy is probably not the pre- source of calories and nutrients, such as
in the evening. To the authors knowl- ferred protein choice for omnivores, creatine, that may support muscle
edge, evening protein comparisons given the lactose free availability of gains. Early research by Ingwall (25),
have not been reported. An athletes physiologically superior and more neu- using cultured cells and organs, sug-
goals and needs can help determine tral tasting, versatile dairy proteins gested that creatine was the chemical
protein choices. For example, whey (Table 1). signal coupling increased muscular
may enhance sleep quality or next Egg protein probably gets less atten- activity with contractile mass. How-
day alertness (35). Yet in the interest tion than whey, casein, or soy but is ever, Haub et al. (21) performed a study
of dietary variety, food preferences, a recommended, very high-quality pro- focused on the effectiveness of a lacto-
protein quality, functional food proper- tein. Egg protein is widely known ovo vegetarian type of diet versus
ties, and whole-body protein synthesis, among nutritionists to be ranked highly a beef-based diet and found no signifi-
casein is a valid choice. in various measures of protein quality cant differences in strength, body com-
Soy protein foods, like whey, have 3 (protein efficiency ratio, PDCAAS, position, resting energy expenditure,
subcategories: soy flour, soy concen- etc.), and eggs offer functional food and muscle creatine/phosphocreatine.
trate, and soy isolate. Soy isolate has benefits and nutrients not found to Beefs primary advantage may be in its
Table 1
Protein characteristics and practical applications
Practical application
Whey Fast 30 min before exercise and immediately after Dairy products Yes
Casein Slow Breakfast, evenings,* during major meals Dairy products Yes
Soy Medium During major meals at least 2 hours before Soybeans Yes
or after exercise
Soy flower
Soy milk
Egg Fast 30 min before exercise and immediately after, Whole egg, egg whites Yes
during major meals
Beef Slow (solid) During major meals, evenings* 90% lean hamburger, Yes
(meat) round steak
*Speculation based on satiety and/or daily preferences and/or whole-body protein retention.
9. Butterfield G. Whole-body protein young, novice, male weightlifters. Am J Clin 32. Lowery L, Hemlepp L, and Daugherty A.
utilization in humans. Med Sci Sports Exerc Nutr 86: 373381, 2007. Dietary protein and resistance training:
19(5 Suppl): S157S165, 1987. 21. Haub MD, Wells AM, Tarnopolsky MA, and Preliminary data on bone health. Ann Nutr
Campbell WW. Effect of protein source on Metab 55(Suppl 1): 696, 2009.
10. Campbell W. Dietary protein efficacy: Dietary
protein types. In: Dietary Protein and resistive-training-induced changes in body 33. Lowery L, Hemlepp L, Tomczyk N,
Resistance Exercise. Lowery L and Antonio J, composition and muscle size in older men. Milkent K, Troska A, and Glickman E.
eds. Boca Raton, FL: Taylor and Francis Am J Clin Nutr 76: 511517, 2002. Impact of consuming ample protein:
GroupCRC Press, 2012. pp. 80125. 22. Hoffman JR and Falvo MJ. ProteinWhich Findings on resistance trainers
is best? J Sports Sci Med 3: 118130, bone mineral density. FASEB J 25:
11. Campbell WW, Barton ML Jr, Cyr-
2004. 983.26, 2011.
Campbell D, Davey SL, Beard JL, Parise G,
and Evans WJ. Effects of an omnivorous 23. Humayun MA, Elango R, Ball RO, and 34. MacDougall JD, Gibala MJ,
diet compared with a lactoovovegetarian Pencharz PB. Reevaluation of the protein Tarnopolsky MA, MacDonald JR,
diet on resistance-training-induced requirement in young men with the Interisano SA, and Yarasheski KE. The
changes in body composition and skeletal indicator amino acid oxidation technique. time course for elevated muscle protein
muscle in older men. Am J Clin Nutr 70: Am J Clin Nutr 86: 9951002, 2007. synthesis following heavy resistance
10321039, 1999. exercise. Can J Appl Physiol 20:
24. Iglay HB, Apolzan JW, Gerrard DE,
480486, 1995.
12. Chiang A and Huang P. Excess energy and Eash JK, Anderson JC, and Campbell WW.
nitrogen balance at protein intakes above Moderately increased protein intake 35. Markus CR, Jonkman LM, Lammers JH,
the requirement level in young men. Am predominately from egg sources does not Deutz NE, Messer MH, and Rigtering N.
J Clin Nutr 48: 10151022, 1988. influence whole body, regional, or muscle Evening intake of alpha-lactalbumin
composition responses to resistance increases plasma tryptophan availability
13. Cribb PJ, Williams AD, Carey MF, and
training in older people. J Nutr Health and improves morning alertness and brain
Hayes A. The effect of whey isolate and
Aging 13: 108114, 2009. measures of attention. Am J Clin Nutr 81:
resistance training on strength, body
10261033, 2005.
composition, and plasma glutamine. 25. Ingwall JS. Creatine and the control of
Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab 16: muscle-specific protein synthesis in 36. Martin WF, Armstrong LE, and
494509, 2006. cardiac and skeletal muscle. Circ Res 38: Rodriguez NR. Dietary protein intake
I115I123, 1976. and renal function. Nutr Metab (Lond) 2:
14. Dawson-Hughes B, Harris SS,
Rasmussen H, Song L, and Dallal GE. 26. Josse AR, Tang JE, Tarnopolsky MA, and 25, 2005.
Effect of dietary protein supplements on Phillips SM. Body composition and 37. Mekata Y, Hayashi N, Masuda Y,
calcium excretion in healthy older men and strength changes in women with milk and Kashimura O, Arai S, and Kawano Y. Blood
women. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 89: resistance exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc substrates and hormonal responses to
11691173, 2004. 42: 11221130, 2010. increased egg white protein intake prior to
a 12,000 m run in heat. J Nutr Sci Vitaminol young men. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 32: 52. Tipton KD. Efficacy and consequences of
54: 154162, 2008. 11321138, 2007. very-high-protein diets for athletes and
38. Middleton N, Jelen P, and Bell G. Whole 49. Tang JE, Moore DR, Kujbida GW, exercisers. Proc Nutr Soc 70: 205214,
blood and mononuclear cell glutathione Tarnopolsky MA, and Phillips SM. Ingestion 2011.
response to dietary whey protein of whey hydrolysate, casein, or soy protein 53. Tipton KD, Elliott TA, Cree MG, Wolf SE,
supplementation in sedentary and trained isolate: Effects on mixed muscle protein Sanford AP, and Wolfe RR. Ingestion
male human subjects. Int J Food Sci Nutr synthesis at rest and following resistance of casein and whey proteins result in
55: 131141, 2004. exercise in young men. J Appl Physiol 107: muscle anabolism after resistance
39. Moore DR, Robinson MJ, and Fry JL. 987992, 2009. exercise. Med Sci Sports Exerc 36:
Ingested protein dose response of muscle 50. Tang JE and Phillips SM. Maximizing 20732081, 2004.
and albumin protein synthesis after muscle protein anabolism: The role of 54. Tipton KD, Ferrando AA, Phillips SM,
resistance exercise in young men. Am protein quality. Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Doyle D Jr, and Wolfe RR. Postexercise net
J Clin Nutr 89: 161168, 2009. Care 12: 6671, 2009. protein synthesis in human muscle from
40. Pencharz PB, Elango R, and Ball RO. 51. Tarnopolsky MA, Atkinson SA, orally administered amino acids. Am
An approach to defining the upper safe MacDougall JD, Chesley A, Phillips S, and J Physiol 276(Pt 1): E628E634, 1999.
limits of amino acid intake. J Nutr 138: Schwarcz HP. Evaluation of protein 55. Williams M. Nutrition for Health Fitness
1996S2002S, 2008.
requirements for trained strength athletes. and Sport. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill,
41. Pennings B, Boirie Y, Senden JM, Gijsen AP, J Appl Physiol 73: 19861995, 1992. 2005, pp. 227228, 478.
Kuipers H, and van Loon LJ. Whey protein
stimulates postprandial muscle protein
accretion more effectively than do casein and
casein hydrolysate in older men. Am J Clin
Nutr 93: 9971005, 2011.
42. Phillips SM. The science of muscle
hypertrophy: Making dietary protein count.
Proc Nutr Soc 70: 100103, 2011.
43. Phillips SM, Hartman JW, and Wilkinson SB.
Dietary protein to support anabolism with
resistance exercise in young men. J Am Coll
Nutr 24: 134S139S, 2005.
44. Poortmans JR and Dellalieux O. Do regular
high protein diets have potential health risks
on kidney function in athletes? Int J Sport
Nutr Exerc Metab 10: 2838, 2000.
45. Rasmussen BB, Tipton KD, Miller SL,
Wolf SE, and Wolfe RR. An oral essential
amino acid-carbohydrate supplement
enhances muscle protein anabolism after
resistance exercise. J Appl Physiol 88:
386392, 2000.
46. Roberts S, Young V, Fuss P, Fiatarone M,
Richard B, Rasmussen H, Wagner D,
Joseph L, Holehouse E, and Evans W.
Energy expenditure and subsequent
nutrient intakes in overfed young men. Am
J Physiol 259(Pt2): R461R469, 1990.
47. Siegel-Itzkovich J. Health committee warns
of potential dangers of soya. Br Med J 331:
254, 2005.
48. Tang JE, Manolakos JJ, Kujbida GW,
Lysecki PJ, Moore DR, and Phillips SM.
Minimal whey protein with carbohydrate
stimulates muscle protein synthesis
following resistance exercise in trained