Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Copyright 2006
By
WELDING
AND
BOLTING
1
Welding Short Course
Welding Processes Overview
Introduction to Welded
Connections
Determining Weld Size
Principles of Design
Distortion
Cost Reduction Ideas
ANSI/AISC 360-05
An American National Standard
AISC
SPECIFICATION
Specification
March 9, 2005
2
AWS D1.1/D1.1M:2006
An American National Standard
Welding
Code--Steel
AWS D1.3/D1.3M:XXXX
An American National Standard
AWS D1.3
Structural
Structural
Welding Code
Sheet Steel
Welding
CodeSheet
Steel
3
AASHTO/AWS D1.5/D1.5M:2002
An American National Standard
AASHTO/AWS
Bridge
Welding Code
D1.5 Bridge
Welding Code
AWS D1.6/D1.6M:XXXX
An American National Standard
AWS D1.6
Structural
Structural
Welding Code
Stainless Steel
Welding
Code
Stainless Steel
4
AWS D1.8/D1.8M:2005
An American National Standard
Welding
Supplement
FEMA 353
5
ANSI/AISC 341-05
ANSI/AISC 341s1-05
An American National Standard
SEISMIC
PROVISONS
Seismic
Provisions
For Structural
Steel Buildings
March 9, 2005
Including Supplement No. 1
dated November 16, 2005
ANSI/xxx
An American National Standard
CONNECTION
PREQUALIFICATION
AISC
Connection
Prequalification
For Structural
Steel Buildings
xxxx
6
AISC DESIGN GUIDES
21
Steel Design Guide Series
NEW!
Arc
Welding Processes
7
Fusion vs. Penetration
1. Atomic Closeness
2. Atomic Cleanliness
8
SHIELDING OF MOLTEN
PUDDLE
Shield from nitrogen, oxygen
Shield with slags
Displace atmosphere with gasses
9
Shielded Metal Arc (SMAW)
Electrode
Extruded
covering
Gaseous shield
Molten pool
Arc stream
Slag
Base metal
SMAW
10
SMAW
E7018
Electrode
11
Flux Cored Arc Welding
(FCAW)
Gas Shielded
Self Shielded
12
FCAW-g
FCAW-g
13
FCAW-G
FCAW-s
14
FCAW-S
Shielding gas
Travel
Gas nozzle
Solidified weld metal Arc
Wire guide and contact tube
Shielding gas
Base metal
Molten weld metal
15
GMAW
To Automatic Wire
Flux Hopper Feed
To Power Supply
Flux Feed Tube
Contact Tube
Flux Electrode
Solidified Slag
Direction
of
Travel
16
Mechanized SAW:
Mechanized
SAW
Automatic
SAW
17
Mechanized SAW
Mechanized
SAW
Semiautomatic
Handheld SAW
SAW
18
GTAW
GTAW
19
GTAW
GTAW
20
GTAW
LOW HYDROGEN
21
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
22
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
23
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
24
HYDROGEN
STRESS SENSITIVE
MATERIAL
25
Process Selection/Application
Typically best left to Contractor
SAW: long, big, automatic
FCAW-g: semiauto in shop
FCAW-s: semiauto in field
SMAW: small, miscellaneous,
repair, tacking
GMAW: semiauto in shop
Introduction to Welded
Connections
26
Joints
Butt Joint
27
Tee Joint
Corner Joint
28
Lap Joint
Edge Joint
29
Edge Joint
30
Weld Types
WELD TYPES
GROOVE WELDS
Complete Joint Penetration (CJP)
Partial Joint Penetration (PJP)
FILLET WELDS
PLUG/SLOT
31
CJP Groove Weld in Butt Joint
32
Fillet Welds in a Tee Joint
33
Slot Weld in Lap Joint
34
Groove Welds
Groove Welds
35
CJP Groove Welds
36
CJP Groove Weld Terminology
Included
Angle
Backing
Root Opening
37
CJP Groove Weld Terminology
Reinforcement
Throat
Throat
38
CJP Groove Welds
Throat = plate thickness
No design calcs for static
Same strength, regardless of
joint details
Leave joint details up to
Fabricator
Use matching strength weld
metal
39
Groove Weld Types:
Square Edge
Bevel Groove
40
Groove Weld Types:
Vee Groove
J-Groove
41
Groove Weld Types:
U-Groove
42
Groove Weld Types:
43
Groove Weld Types:
44
Groove Weld Types:
45
Groove Weld Types:
46
Groove Weld Type and
Joint Type
47
Bevel Groove in Corner Joint
48
Bevel Groove in Tee Joint
49
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
50
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
51
Weld Backing Types:
Steel
Copper
Ceramic
Steel Backing:
Permanent
Part of Weldment
Notch Effects
52
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
53
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
54
Principle:
Weld Backing
55
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
56
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
57
Copper Backing:
Removable
Electrically Conductive
Metallurgical Effects
Weld Backing
58
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
59
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
60
Weld Backing
Ceramic Backing:
Removable
Electrically Non-conductive
61
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
62
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
63
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
64
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
65
Weld Backing
Weld Backing
66
Groove Weld Types:
Steel
67
Two sided, with backgouging
68
Two sided, with backgouging
69
Two sided, with backgouging
70
PJP Groove Welds
71
PJP Groove Weld
72
PJP Groove Weld Terminology
Included
Angle
Depth of preparation
Root Face
Root Opening
73
PJP Groove Weld Terminology
Throat
74
PJP Groove Weld: E vs. S
S
75
PJP Groove Weld: E vs. S
S=E
76
PJP Groove Weld: E vs. S
77
PJP Groove Weld: E vs. S
E S
TABLE J 2.1
Effective Throat of Partial Joint Penetration Groove Welds
J or U Groove E=S
SAW F
60o Bevel or V
GMAW. FCAW F, H 45o Bevel
78
PJP Groove Welds
Throat < plate thickness
Must determine throat
E vs. S dimension
Engineer specify E
Leave S up to shop
Could use matching or
undermatching
79
TABLE J2.3
Minimum Effective Throat Thickness of Partial Joint
Penetration Groove Welds
80
Groove Weld Types:
81
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
Radius (R)
t = 5/16 R
82
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
. Thickness (t)
R = 2t
Radius (R)
83
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
84
Groove Weld Types:
t
t
85
Groove Weld Types:
86
Groove Weld Types:
87
88
89
AISC LRFD Table J2.2 (old)
90
AWS D1.1:2006 Table 2.1
Effective Size of Flare-Groove
Welds Filled Flush
Flare- Flare-
Welding Process
Bevel Vee
SMAW FCAW-S 5/16 R 5/8 R
GMAW FCAW-G 5/8 R 3/4 R
SAW 5/16 R 1/2 R
91
FILLET WELDS
92
Fillet Weld Terminology
Leg size
t = throat
t
93
Fillet Weld Terminology
Face
Root
Toe
FILLET WELDS
94
FILLET WELDS
95
MINIMUM FILLET WELD
SIZES
96
AISC TABLE J2.4
Minimum Size of Fillet Welds
Material Thickness Minimum Size of
of Thinner Part Fillet Weld
Joined
To , inclusive 1/8
Over to 3/16
Over to 1/4
Over 5/16
97
Maximum Fillet Weld Size
J2.2b
The maximum size of a fillet weld of
connected parts shall be:
(a) Along edges of material less than
in. thick, not greater than the thickness of
the material.
(b) Along edges of materials in. or
more in thickness, not greater than the
thickness of the material minus 1/16 in,
unless the weld is especially designated
on the drawings to be built out to obtain
full-throat thickness.
98
Maximum Fillet Size
99
Maximum Fillet Size
t
1/16
t > 1/4
100
Maximum Fillet Size
1/16
t Maximum Fillet
Weld Size Does
Not Apply
101
Fig C-J2.1
102
Skewed Tee Joint w/ Fillet Welds
103
Skewed Tee Joint w/ Fillet Welds
104
AWS D1.1 2.2.4 Weld Size and
Length. (continued) For fillet welds and
skewed T-joints, the following shall be
provided on the contract documents.
>80o <100o
105
2.2.4 Weld Size and Length. (continued)
For fillet welds and skewed T-joints, the
following shall be provided on the
contract documents.
tw tw
<80o >100o
106
Fillet Weld Terminations
AISC J2.2b
107
End
Return
108
2.8.3 Fillet Weld Terminations
109
2.8.3 Fillet Weld Terminations
110
2.8.3 Fillet Weld Terminations
111
2.8.3.2 Lap Joints Subject to Tension.
112
2.8.3.3 Maximum End Return Length.
Welded joints shall be arranged to allow
the flexibility assumed in the connection
design. If the outstanding legs of
connection base metal are attached with
end returned welds, the length of the end
return shall not exceed four times the
nominal size of the weld (see Figure 2.7
for examples of flexible connections).
113
2.8.3.4 Transverse Stiffener Welds.
114
2.8.3.5 Opposite Sides of a Common
Plane.
115
Fillet vs. PJP Groove Weld
116
Fillet vs. PJP Groove Weld
40% stronger
117
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
Same throat
Cost to bevel
118
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
Rule of
Thumb
119
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
Rule of Thumb:
120
Plug and Slot Welds
121
Plug and Slot Welds
Applied to lap joints
122
Plug and Slot Welds
Applied to lap joints
Not often applied in structures
Restricted in dynamically loaded
structures
Not a good substitution for
misplaced bolt holes
123
Weld Metal Strength
Matching
Undermatching
Overmatching
MATCHING STRENGTH
124
UNDERMATCHING
STRENGTH
Typical application is fillets,
PJPs on higher strength steel
Optimized Weld Metal
More crack resistant
Weld size often controlled by
minimum size
Matching
Strength
125
Undermatching
Strength
OVERMATCHING
STRENGTH
Never required in D1.1, AISC
Naturally occurs with lower
strength steels, alloy electrodes
If deliberately considered in
design, may be non-conservative
126
0.3 EXX tw
0.4 Fy tw
If Fy / Fu = 0.75, then
Fu > EXX
0.3 EXX tw
e.g., Dont Overmatch
0.4 Fy tw
127
Table J2.5
128
CJP Groove Weld in Tension
129
CJP Groove Weld in Compression
130
131
CJP Groove Weld
132
CJP Groove Weld
133
Notes
134
Fillet Welds
135
Notes
Table J2.5
Matching Strength
136
Table J2.5
Undermatching
Permitted
137
AWS D1.1:2000
AWS D1.1:2000
138
Selecting Weld Types
BUTT JOINTS
Tension CJP, PJP
Shear PJP
139
CORNER JOINTS
Lamellar Tearing
CORNER JOINTS--PJP
140
CORNER JOINTS--PJP
141
CORNER JOINTS
142
Selecting Weld Types
LAP JOINTS
Tension Fillet, Plug, Slot
LAP JOINTS
5 t min
not < 1
143
Fig C-J2.3
Fig C-J2.2
144
LAP JOINTS
LAP JOINTS
145
LAP JOINTS
LAP JOINTS
146
LAP JOINTS
Fig C-J2.4
147
INTRODUCTION TO
WELDED CONNECTIONS
Calculating Weld
Sizes
148
Two Approaches
Fillet welds
Weld groups (bending &
torsion)
Fillet Welds:
Direct Loading
149
150
151
cos 45o = t / w
t
45o t = w (cos 45o)
w
t = 0.707 w
=F = F
A t L
L = length
t
F w
=
(0.707w) L
152
Allowable Stresses on
Welds
allowable = 0.30 Exx
E6010, Exx = 60 ksi (430 MPa)
E71T-1, Exx = 70 ksi (480 MPa)
E81T1-K2 Exx = 80 ksi (550 MPa)
153
AWS D1.1:2000
F
= = 0.3Exx = allowable
(0.707w) L
w = F / (0.212 Exx L)
154
F
allowable = = 0.3Exx
(0.707w) L
F
f = (Unit force, lbf/linear in)
L
actual force/in. = f
w=
allowable force/in. 0.212Exx
155
Leg size, Allowable unit force,
w (in) kips/linear in
E70 E80 E90
1/8 1.86 2.12 2.39
1/4 3.71 4.24 4.77
3/8 5.57 6.36 7.16
1/2 7.42 8.48 9.54
5/8 9.28 10.61 11.93
3/4 11.14 12.73 14.32
Lincoln Procedure Handbook, 13th Ed., p. 2.3-3
Example F
F = 45,000 lbf
5/8
L = 12.0 in (2 sides)
E7018 3/4
w
w=?
156
Example
F
w=
0.212Exx L
w=
45,000 lbf
=
0.212 X 70,000 lbf/in2 X 12 inch X 2 welds
Example
FF
F = 45,000 lbf
5/8
L = 12.0 in (2 sides)
E7018 3/4
w
w=?
157
Table 5.8
Minimum Fillet Weld Sizes (see 5.14)
Base-Metal Thickness (T)* Minimum Size
of Fillet Weld**
in. mm in. mm
T 1/4 T 6.4 1/8*** 3
1/4 < T 1/2 6.4 < T 12.7 3/16 5
1/2 < T 3/4 12.7 < T 19.0 1/4 6
3/4 < T 19.0 < T 5/16 8
AWS D1.1:2000
Table 5.8
Minimum Fillet Weld Sizes (see 5.14)
Base-Metal Thickness (T)* Minimum Size
of Fillet Weld**
in. mm in. mm
T 1/4 T 6.4 1/8*** 3
1/4 < T 1/2 6.4 < T 12.7 3/16 5
1/2 < T 3/4 12.7 < T 19.0 1/4 6
3/4 < T 19.0 < T 5/16 8
AWS D1.1:2000
158
Table 5.8 Notes
* For non-low hydrogen processes without
preheat calculated in accordance with 3.5.2, T
equals thickness of the thicker part joined;
single-pass welds shall be used.
For non-low hydrogen processes using
procedures established to prevent cracking in
accordance with 3.5.2 and for low hydrogen
processes, T equals thickness of the thinner
part joined; single-pass requirement does not
apply.
159
Fillet Welds:
Indirect Loading
V A y
f =
I n
160
Shear Due to Bending
V A y
f =
I n
V A y
f =
I n
N.A.
161
Shear Due to Bending
V A y
f =
I n
162
Example: Horizontal Shear
10
V = 189,000 lbf 2
I = 36,768 in4
A = 27.5 in2
51
y = 24.375 in
n = 2 welds (E70)
w=?
V A y
f =
I n
=1720 lbf/in.
163
actual force/in. f
w = =
allowable force/in 0.212Exx
.
1720
w = = 0.116 in.
0.21270,000
Table 5.8
Minimum Fillet Weld Sizes (see 5.14)
Base-Metal Thickness (T)* Minimum Size
of Fillet Weld**
in. mm in. mm
T 1/4 T 6.4 1/8*** 3
1/4 < T 1/2 6.4 < T 12.7 3/16 5
1/2 < T 3/4 12.7 < T 19.0 1/4 6
3/4 < T 19.0 < T 5/16 8
AWS D1.1:2000
164
Weld Groups
165
Treating the weld as a
line
Tc
Torsion = Tc =
J Jw
166
Step 1: Determine Properties
167
Step 2: Calculate the forces
168
Step 3:
Calculate the resultant force
actual force/in. fr
w = =
allowable force/in 0.212Exx
169
Example: weld as a line
w=?
b2
Ny = =1.25in
2b +d
(2b +d )3 b2 (b +d )2
Jw = =386in3
12 2b +d
170
Step 1: Determine Properties
Ch Cv = 3.75 in
a
Ch = 5.0 in
Cv
171
Step 2: Calculate the forces
T ch (180,000) (5)
fh = = = 2340lbf/in
Jw 386
T cv (180,000) (3.75)
fv = = =
Jw 386
= 1750 lbf/in
172
Step 2: Calculate the forces
Vertical Shear:
P 18,000
fs = = =900 lbf/in
Aw 20
Step 3:
Calculate the resultant force
fh = 2340
fv = 1750
fs = 900
173
Step 4: Calculate the weld
size
actual force/in. fr
w= =
allowable force/in. 0.212Exx
Weld
Properties
174
Weld Capacity
Weld Size (throat) +
Deposited Weld
Strength
Mechanical Properties
Ultimate Tensile Shear Strength
Strength
Fatigue Strength
Yield Strength
Fracture
Elongation Toughness
Modulus of Elasticity Hardness
Compressive Strength
175
Mechanical Properties
Ultimate Tensile Shear Strength
Strength
Fatigue Strength
Yield Strength
Fracture
Elongation Toughness
Modulus of Elasticity Hardness
Compressive Strength
176
177
Tensile Test Results
178
CVN Specimen
179
Charpy V-Notch Test (CVN)
90
80
70
CVN, ft lbs
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
-150 -100 -50 0 50 100 150
Temperature, deg. F
180
Mechanical Property
Requirements
E7018
Yield: 58 ksi min.
Tensile: 70 ksi min.
Elong.: 22% min.
CVN: 20 ft lb @ -20 deg. F
181
REMEMBER: Steel properties
typically based on minimum
specified yield strength. Weld
metal is typically based on
tensile strength.
182
Resources:
PRINCIPLES
OF
CONNECTION
DESIGN
183
Principle 1
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
Weld Tabs
198
199
200
NOT WELDED
TO FLANGE CRACK IN WEB
MOMENT
Principle 2
201
Linoleum Roll
202
203
Press Fit
204
205
F
M NEUTRAL AXIS
OF SECTION
r
F
CENTER OF CURVATURE
206
207
The Welders Solution
F
M NEUTRAL AXIS
OF SECTION
r
F
CENTER OF CURVATURE
208
X1 X2 0 = (wL)(L2 - 6a2)
a L
W
24EI
a = 0.225 w
X1 X2 0 = (wL)(L2 - 6a2)
a L
W
24EI
209
The Engineers Solution
Principle 3
THERE ARE NO
SECONDARY MEMBERS IN
WELDED CONSTRUCTION
210
Box Girder
211
212
213
Principle 4
214
Maximum Fillet Size
1/16
t > 1/4
215
Maximum Fillet Size
t
216
217
1/16 Gap = OK
218
If gap > 1/16,
increase weld
size by gap size
Gap Stress
0 21 ksi
1/16 28 ksi
1/8 42 ksi
3/16 84 ksi
219
Gap Stress
3/16 21 ksi
Principle 5
220
Matched Connection
221
222
223
Stepped Connection
224
Principle 9
225
226
Principle 10
227
?
228
229
Controlling Distortion
After Welding
230
Volumetric Expansion
cooler base
metal acts as final
Heated Bar vise shape
Bar at
room temp.
Angular
Distortion
231
Angular Distortion
Angular Distortion
232
Transverse Shrinkage
Longitudinal Shrinkage
233
N.A.
N.A.
234
N.A.
N.A.
235
N.A.
236
Principle #1
Before Welding
237
238
Principle #2
239
240
241
Principle #3
H = 60 E I / 1000 S
242
HAZ
HAZ
243
244
245
246
Principle #4
247
N.A.
C.G.
248
249
C.G. N.A.
250
Principle #5
251
252
Double Groove: Control
Shrinkage
253
Double Groove: Control
Shrinkage
254
Principle #6
255
C.G.
N.A.
C.G. N.A.
256
Principle #7
Sequence assembly to
balance welds
1.5
0.5
C.G. 1.0
N.A.
1.058 1.0
2.0
257
C.G. N.A.
1.5
0.5
1.0
N.A.
C.G.
1.0
258
4-1/2 X 2-5/8
3/8 X 9
3/8 X 4-1/2
3/8 X 72
259
CENTER OF
NEUTRAL AXIS GRAVITY OF
WELDS
260
d = 2.39
261
NEUTRAL AXIS
CENTER OF
GRAVITY OF WELD
CENTER OF
NEUTRAL AXIS GRAVITY OF
WELDS
262
Principle #8
Mirror
components
263
264
Principle #9
Increase torsional
resistance
265
266
Principle #10
Consider
pre-bending or pre-setting
267
268
Principle #11
Clamp
components
269
270
Principle #12
271
Estimating Distortion
272
Transverse
.10 Aw
transverse =
t
273
Angular
1.3
.02 W
angular = 2
t
For metric 0.02 becomes 0.19
274
Longitudinal
2
.005 Aw L d
longitudinal =
I
275
Flame Straightening
and Heat Shrinking
276
277
278
279
Heating Location
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
Controlling Distortion
ECONOMY IN WELDING
289
Welding Costs
Materials,
Equipment, 10 30%
Electricity
Labor and
70 90%
Overhead
290
If welding speed is doubled.
Materials,
Equipment,
Electricity
Labor and
Overhead
291
Cost = 1.0
Cost = 4.0
292
Comparing costs on weld volume
Assumes same deposition rate
Assumes same joint preparation cost
Assumes same weld cleaning cost
Assumes same labor rate, overhead factors,
material costs
Does not generate absolute cost, only
relative cost
Creates impression that material is most
costly item
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
293
?
294
?
CJP
295
PJP
1.5 web
296
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
297
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
298
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
Rule of Thumb:
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
Combination fillet/PJP groove weld
299
Fillet versus PJP Groove Welds
Same throat
300
Combination Fillet/PJP
Proper
weld throat
Combination Fillet/PJP
Improper
weld throat
301
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
Combination fillet/PJP groove weld
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
302
1L 2L
2W
1W
0.3EXX(0.707x2W)X1L 0.3EXX(0.707x1W)x2L
0.424 WLEXX = 0.424 WLEXX
1L 2L
2W
1W
303
50% LESS VOLUME
2X Strength
4X Volume
304
W L
25% Savings
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
Combination fillet/PJP groove weld
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
305
CAPACITY
1/2 2-4
1/4
VOLUME
1/2 2-4
306
1/4 2-4
1/8
1/4 2-4
1/8
307
INTERMITTENT VERSUS CONTINUOUS FILLET WELDS
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
Combination fillet/PJP groove weld
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
Groove welds: single versus double sided
308
309
50% Less Metal 2:1 Ratio
310
Same included angle
No root opening
311
Overhead welding?
312
Prequalified details
313
Double V-
V-groove
Single V-
V-groove weld, 60o
weld, 30o included angle,
Thickness Ratio of Single
included angle, 1/8 in. root
(weld throat) Sided to Double
3/8 in. root opening, 0 in.
(in.) Sided
opening (B-
(B-U2a) root opening (B-
(B-
(pounds/foot) U3b)
(pounds/foot)
314
Economy in Welding
Selection of proper weld type
CJP groove welds versus alternatives
Fillet welds versus PJP groove welds
Combination fillet/PJP groove weld
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
Groove welds: single versus double sided
CJP groove welds: included angle versus root
opening
1/2 root
20 degrees
opening
315
Thickness 1/4" 45 3/8" 30 1/2" 20
W36X160
316
W36X160
Tf = 1
14% less
Chord flange:
7 thick
317
Tf = 7
37% Less
318
CJP groove welds: included angle
versus root opening
For weld throats less than 1, use a smaller
root opening and larger included angle
For weld throats greater than 1, use a
larger root opening and smaller included
angle.
Economy in Welding
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
Groove welds: single versus double sided
CJP groove welds: included angle versus root
opening
CJP groove weld: V and bevel vs. U and J
319
V- groove
Bevel groove
V-groove
U- groove
320
Bevel groove
J- groove
U- groove
J- groove
321
V- groove
U- groove
Spacer bar
322
V- groove
#1
Spacer bar
#2
U- groove
#3
323
Economy in Welding
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
Groove welds: single versus double sided
CJP groove welds: included angle versus root
opening
CJP groove weld: V and bevel vs. U and J
PJP groove weld: single versus double sided
324
Rotation about root
325
Volume2:1 ratio
326
One bevel cut
Approximately
one weld pass
327
Time = 2 bevels + 4 passes = 6
328
If more than 4 weld passes are
required for single-sided PJP
groove weld, consider double
sided detail.
Economy in Welding
Proper weld detailing
Fillet welds: leg size versus length
Fillet weld: intermittent versus continuous
Groove welds: single versus double sided
CJP groove welds: included angle versus root
opening
CJP groove weld: V and bevel vs. U and J
PJP groove weld: single versus double sided
Flare V and flare bevel groove welds
329
330
Economy in Welding
Proper weld detailing
Shop versus Field Welding
331
332
333
Economy in Welding
Proper weld detailing
Shop versus field Welding
Welded versus bolted connections
334
W14X730
W14X730
5
22 3
18
335
4
12
3
6
336
106
337
Welded vs. Bolted
Splice Cost Comparison
Bolted Splice
Labor 84.3 hrs $3,127.
Materials
Steel (6900#) $1,936.
Bolts (128) $ 768.
Cost per splice $5,800.
338
Welded vs. Bolted
Splice Cost Comparison
Welded Splice
Bolted Splice Labor 28.6 hrs $1,072.
Labor 84.3 hrs $3,127. Materials
Materials Electrode (70 lbs)$ 42.
Steel (6900#) $1,936. Flux (140 lbs.) $ 77.
Bolts (128) $ 768. Cost per splice $1,200.
Cost per splice $5,800.
339
Shop versus Field Welding
340
Shop versus Field Welding
341
Field Welded vs. Bolted
Splice Cost Comparison
Field Welding Hours: 2X Shop
Field Welding Wages: 2X Shop
Bolted Splice Welded Splice
Labor 84.3 hrs $3,127. Labor 57.2 hrs $4,288.
Materials Materials
Steel (6900#) $1,936. Electrode (70 lbs)$ 42.
Bolts (128) $ 768. Flux (140 lbs.) $ 77.
Cost per splice $5,800. Cost per splice $4,400.
342
DETERMINE THE LOAD
TRANSFERRED THROUGH
THE CONNECTION WHEN
SELECTING WELD TYPES,
AND DETERMING WELD
SIZES
1/2
343
Capacity = 1/2 X 0.707 X 0.30 X E70XX X 100
= 742 Kips
1/4
344
Capacity = 1/4 X 0.707 X 0.30 X E70XX X 100
= 371 Kips
1/4 2-4
345
Capacity = 1 /4 X 0.707 X 0.30 X E70XX X 2/4 (100)
= 185 Kips
346
SPECIFY WELDS OF THE
PROPER SIZE
347
3/8 fillet weld 0.289 #/foot
348
PLACE THE WELD ON THE
THINNER MEMBER OF
CORNER JOINTS
349
3 (75mm)
2 (50mm)
3 (75mm)
2 (50mm)
350
3 (75mm)
2 (50mm)
351
?
Notes:
1. For non-low hydrogen
processesT = thickness of
thicker part joined.for low-
hydrogen processes, T = thinner
part joined.
352
If low hydrogen
353
Groove Weld Types:
354
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
355
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
t = 5/16 R
356
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
. Thickness (t)
R = 2t
Radius (R)
357
Groove Weld Types:
Radius (R)
358
Groove Weld Types:
359
Groove Weld Types:
t
t
360
Groove Weld Types:
361
362
363
AISC LRFD Table J2.2 (old)
364
AISC Table J2.2
Effective Weld Sizes of Flare
Groove Welds
Flare- Flare-
Welding Process
Bevel Vee
SMAW FCAW-S 5/16 R 5/8 R
GMAW FCAW-G 5/8 R 3/4 R
SAW 5/16 R 1/2 R
365
Since R = 2 x thickness, then the
throat is as follows for flare-
groove welds filled flush
Flare- Flare-
Welding Process
Bevel Vee
SMAW FCAW-S 5/8 t 5/4 t
GMAW FCAW-G 5/4 t 3/2 t
SAW 5/8 t 1/1 t
366
AWS Standard Terms & Definitions
(A3.0-94)
367
Preferred analysis of Carbon Steel
for Good Weldability
Element Normal Range Extra Care
368
369
AWS D1.1:2004:
Table 3.1
Annex M
45o
1/4 1 (25mm)
370
1/4
45o
1/4 1 (25mm)
371
45o
3/8 1 (25mm)
3/8 9mm
1/4 (6mm)
372
3.26 #/ft. 4.00#/ft.
373
CONSIDER THE POSITION
OF WELDING WHEN
SELECTING WELD
DETAILS
374
IF FILLET WELDS
REQUIRE OVERHEAD
WELDING, GROOVE
WELDS ARE PREFERRED
welded
Theres always a solution in steel!
375
Bolting & Welding
1
Role of the Structural
Engineer
Selection of suitable bolt types and grades
Design of the fasteners
Responsibility for installation
Responsibility for inspection
Mechanical Fasteners
Rivets
evaluation of existing
structures
Bolts
Common (ordinary)
bolts: ASTM A307
High-
High-strength bolts:
ASTM A325 & A490
Other H/S bolts
2
Common (ordinary) bolts
ASTM A307
Three grades: A, B, and C
Grade A: general applications
Grade B: for piping systems
Grade C: non-
non-headed anchor bolts or studs
A307 Grade A
minimum tensile strength 60 ksi
3
ASTM A325 Bolts
Type 1 or Type 3 (weathering steel)
ASTM Spec. RCSC Spec.
4
Comparison of Bolts: Direct Tension
20
elongation (inches)
Comments
Note that we quote the ultimate
tensile strength of the bolt
this is the benchmark for strength
statements (e.g. shear strength is some
fraction of ultimate tensile strength)
What about yield strength?
What is proof load
5
comments contd
Nuts: ASTM A563
Washers: if needed, ASTM F436
Bolt nut washer sets implied so
far, but other configurations
available
Loading of Bolts
Shear
load transfer by shear in bolt and
bearing in connected material OR
load transfer by friction (followed by
shear and bearing)
Tension
Combined Tension and Shear
6
Shear Loading of Bolts
lap plates
main plate
Shear Splice
Truss Joint
7
Shear Loading contd
Eccentric Connection
bolts in
shear
8
Bolts Loaded in Tension
bolts in tension
bolts in
shear
bolts in
shear
9
Bolts in Tension prying
Prying force Bolt force
Applied force
High-
High-strength bolts in tension can
be a source of problems!
10
Consider a simple joint
P
P
P
P
P{
and associated =
shear stress A
Free body
of bolt
P { a bearing force
11
Finally...
d
P/2 t
P
P/2
12
Design Specifications
Limit States Design (LRFD) or
Allowable Stress Design (ASD)
Historically:
allowable stress design: apply a factor
of safety to yield strength
?
limit states design: use maximum
capacity of element as basis
Comment
Connection design bolt in shear
historically has been
done on basis of
ultimate strength,
regardless of load
framework used.
deformation
13
AISC Standard 2005
Parallel LRFD and ASD rules
LRFD uses a resistance factor,
ASD uses a safety factor,
Loads as appropriate:
factored loads for LRFD
non-factored loads for ASD
14
and another comment
Installation
Snug-tight only
Pretensioned
Calibrated wrench
Turn-
Turn-of-
of-nut
Other means:
Tension control bolts
Load-
Load-indicator washers
15
As a result of the installation
average
bolt
shear
MPa
deformation over , mm
16
Bolts in Shear: Issues
Shear strength of bolt (single shear
or double shear, threads in shear
plane?)
Bearing capacity of bolt (never
governs)
Bearing capacity of plate
Tensile capacity of plate
17
Slip in bolted joints
Can be as much as two hole
clearances
In a joint with a reasonable number
of bolts, some will already be in
bearing at start of loading
Both laboratory tests and field
measurements indicate that slip is
more like 1/2 hole clearance
slip-critical connections
Note: a slip-critical joint (service loads)
must also be checked as a bearing
joint (factored loads)
18
Bearing-type connections:
Issues
bolt shear strength
bearing capacity connected material
member strength
Region of bearing-
load
type behavior
deformation
19
Bolt Shear Strength
Bolt shear strength 62% of bolt ultimate
tensile strength (tests)
Design rule takes 80% of this value
Threads in shear plane?
Long joint effect: another discount
applied.
20
Physical test
21
Uneven loading
of bolts
low
strain
= high differential strain
22
Long joint effect for this case?
pretension on kips 40
torqued
bolt shear 20 tension
strength
0.04 0.08
elongation
23
Further Comment: Bolt Capacity in Shear
24
Back to bolt in shear
Shear strength
of single bolt
(tests)
= 0.62 u bolt
Shear deformation
R n = Fv A b
25
nominal shear strength
= 0.75
Fv = 80% (0.62 Fu ) = 0.50 Fu
Thus
26
Comments
If threads in shear plane, another
reduction, already indicated
The discount for length (use of 80%) is
conservative
If joint length > 50 in., a further 20%
reduction
27
Lets return now to slip-critical
connections
I thought you
said that you
would bring the
bolts!!
28
Slip-Critical Connection
Clamping force from bolts (bolt pretension)
region of slip-critical
joint behavior
deformation
29
Slip-critical joints specified when
Load is repetitive and
changes from tension to
compression. (Fatigue by
fretting could occur.)
Change in geometry of
structure would affect its
performance.
Certain other cases.
Comment: for buildings,
slip-critical joints should be
the exception, not the rule.
Slip-critical criteria:
Choice:
a serviceability limit state (no slip under
the service loads) OR
30
Which one do we use?
No slip at service loads: e.g. fatigue
loading
No slip at factored loads: e.g. long-
span flat roof truss (ponding could
result as factored loads attained)
31
First principles, slip resistance is
P = ks n Ti
ks = slip coefficient ()
n = number of slip planes (usually 1 or 2)
Ti = clamping force (i.e., bolt pretension)
R n = D u h sc Tb N s
32
and the modifiers
h sc = modifier re hole condition
e.g., oversize hole, slotted hole etc.
= resistance factor
= 1.0 no slip at service loads ( = 1.4)
= 0.85 no slip at factored loads ( = 1.5)
Bolts in Tension
Capacity of a bolt in tension: product of
the ultimate tensile strength of the bolt
and the tensile stress area of the bolt
(i.e. Fu Ast )
Specifications directly reflect this
calculated capacity (to come)
Force in bolt must reflect any prying
action affect
33
Bolts in Tension some comments
Preference: avoid joints that put bolts
into tension, especially if fatigue is an
issue
Use A325 bolts rather than A490 bolts
Minimize the prying action
direct tension
bolt subsequent direct tension
tension torqued tension
(by whatever method of installation)
bolt elongation
34
How is the torsion resisted?
(backside)
Question
pretensioned bolt in a connection
apply external tension force to the
connection
35
Bolt pretension + external tensile load ?
bolt force
ultimate
*
initial
separation of connected
components (= Ffinal)
45
45
applied load
P/2 P/2
P/2
P/2
Pult = ult Ast
36
2. Bolt pretension present
t No external load:
Ci Ci = Tb (1)
Tb
P/2 P/2
External load applied:
t Tf = Cf + P (2)
Cf
Tf
37
P
Tf = Tb +
Ap
1+
Ab
ultimate
*
initial
separation of connected
components (= Ffinal)
45
applied load
38
AISC rule, bolts in tension
bolt area for nominal
diameter
R n = Fnt A b
nominal tensile strength
Pult = Fu A st = Fu (0.75A b )
39
So, the AISC rule for bolts in tension
R n = Fn t A b
P/2 t
P
P/2
40
Bearing capacity (of
connected material)
Shear-
Shear-out of a
block of material
or yielding
Needed:
Lc 1. shear-out rule
t1 2. yield rule
t2
(deformation)
41
Plate bearing stresses
Plate bearing
b Le
from tests: =
pl
u d
Le
or, b = pl
u
d
Le
and, R n = b d t = pl
u dt
d
42
Plate bearing
Making the substitution and using ..
Fu pl
u
Le
R n = b d t = pl
u dt
d
R n = 3 d t Fu
R n = 1.5 Fu Lc t 3.0 d t Fu
43
Further note re bearing
R n = 1.5 Fu L c t 3.0 d t Fu
But, Specification says that when
deformation a consideration, use
R n = 1.2 Fu L c t 2.4 d t Fu
Why this difference, and when do we
use the latter?
44
Block shear
rupture
45
Failure (ult. load) is
always by tensile
fracture, at location
shown, regardless of
geometric proportions.
Shear yield along vertical
planes.
Failure is controlled by
ductility not strength.
Basics
Tr + Vr = A nt Fu + 0 .60 A gv Fy
where A nt = net area in tension
and A gv = gross area in shear
tension fracture shear yield
46
An example of
shear + tension
failure in a
coped beam
Back to installation
47
Bearing-Type Connections
Installation of Bolts
Installation
48
Calibrated Wrench Installation
Hydraulic calibrator
49
Calibrated wrench, contd
Adjust wrench to stall or cut out at
desired level of bolt pretension
Target value of pretension (RCSC) is
1.05 times specified min. value
Calibrate using at least three bolts
Calibration is unique to bolt lot,
length, diameter, grade of bolt
Washers must be used
Turn-of-Nut Installation
Run nut down, bring parts into close
contact
Work from stiffer regions to edges
Establish snug-tight condition (first
impact of impact wrench or full effort of
worker using a spud wrench)
Apply additional one-half turn nut (or
other value, depending on bolt size)
50
Does this
definition of
snug-tight
seem a little
vague?
A325 bolt
0.05 0.10
elongation (in.)
51
60 Bolt Tension by Turning the Nut
0.02 0.04
bolt elongation (in.)
52
Tension vs. Rotation
minimum tension A490
bolts
60
A490
50 bolts
40 minimum tension
bolt
A325 bolts
tension
kips 30 A325
bolts
20
1/2 turn of
nut
10
Inspection of Installation
Principles:
Determination of the bolt pretension
after installation is not practical
Understand the requirements e.g., are
pretensioned bolts required?
Monitor the installation on the site
Proper storage of bolts is required
53
Inspection of Installation
Is bolt tension required? if not, why
inspect for it !
Know what calibration process is required
and monitor it on the job site
Observe the work in progress on a regular
basis
Inspection of installation:
Consider the following AISC cases
1. Bolts need be snug-tight only
2. Bolts are pretensioned (but not a slip-
critical joint)
3. Slip-critical joint
54
Snug tight only.
Bearing-type connections
Bolts in tension (A325 only)
only when no fatigue or vibration (bolt
could loosen)
55
Inspection: if pretensioned bolts required
56
An inspected joint (turn-of-nut)
57
What happens in the field?
58
Actual pretensions, contd
For A325 bolts, turn-of-nut:
Average tensile strength exceeds spec.
min. tensile by about 1.18
Average pretension force is 80% of
actual tensile
Result is that actual bolt tension is
about 35% greater than specified bolt
tension
59
Some other options for bolts
60
Tension control bolts
groove
spline
ASTM F1852
groove at which shear
will take place
61
Tension Control Bolts
Wrench has coaxial chucks
Nut is turned in one direction
Splined end is turned in other
direction
Splined end will shear off at groove
If properly calibrated, shear will take
place when pretension is attained
62
Tension control bolt pretension
63
Tension-Control Bolts
Advantages
Installation is from one side
Electric wrench is used
Installation is quiet
Disadvantages
More expensive
Pre-installation calibration required
64
Direct Tension Indicators
Protrusions formed in
special washer
Protrusions compress
as force in bolt is
developed
Use feeler gage to
measure gap (or refusal) ASTM 959
User must verify the process
(like calibrated wrench)
65
Some references
References, contd.
G.L. Kulak, J.W. Fisher, and J.A.H. Struik, Guide
to Design Criteria for Bolted and Riveted Joints,
Joints,
Second Edition, John Wiley, New York, 1987 (free
download at RCSC website)
Bickford, John H., "An Introduction to the Design
and Behavior of Bolted Joints," Second Edition,
Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1990
G.L. Kulak, A Bolting Primer for Structural
Engineers,
Engineers, AISC Design Guide 17, Chicago, 2002
66
.and some web sites
aisc.org
boltcouncil.org (RCSC Spec., Guide,
education bulletins, etc.)
steelstructures.com
steelstuff.com
67
Washers
Standard hardened washer required
under turned element when torque-
based installation used (calibrated
wrench, tension-control bolt)
Washers reqd when direct tension
indicators used
Washers not reqd
when snug-tightened joints used
for pretensioned joints, turn-of-nut
for slip-critical, turn-of-nut
Washers contd
But, washers required for
sloping surfaces present
A490 bolts used when material Fy < 40 ksi
many cases of slotted or oversize holes,
regardless of type of joint or method of
installation
68
Slotted or oversize holes
Advantageous for erection
Effect of oversize or slot taken into
account directly in the member design
Oversize or slotted hole can affect the
pretension induced, regardless of the
type of installation
Washers or hardened bars required
for many of these situations
69
Deformation v load characteristics differ
Bolts + welds
Transverse welds are basically
ineffective (they fracture early)
AISC rules for bolts + longitudinal
welds OK
Upgrading existing structures: See
AISC Engr. Jrn. Article (2003)
70
Recent work indicates
U of A work
and check the ultimate capacity of
the individual components.
e.g., 100% of the bolts alone could be
> 50% of bolt shear strength + weld
strength, meaning it wasnt useful to
add the welds.
71
Shear lagan illustration
Shear Lag
72
Shear lag
AISC rules largely based on physical tests
x
Pu = 1 A n Fu
L
Shear lag
Ane = 0.90 An
73
Connection design: seismic conditions
Frames classified as (simplified list):
Ordinary moment frame (OMF)
Intermediate moment frame (IMF)
Special moment frame (SPM)
Basis of design:
Rotation angle at beam to column junction
OR
Drift per story (0.01, 0.02, and 0.04 radians
respectively)
Seismic contd
Analyze structure in order to
compute the forces
Use FEMA 350 and/or AISC Seismic
Design Spec.
With forces now known, design
connectors
Advisable to use pre-qualified
configurations
74
Pre-qualified bolted connections
75
bolted joints, seismic design
All bolts pretensioned
Faying surfaces as per slip-critical
Use bearing values for bolts
moderate quakes: No slip
major quakes: Slip will occur and bolts go into bearing
Design
example:
gusset plate
connection
76
Determine ultimate load for this gusset
plate (which is one that was tested)
14.76
2 30
3@2.76=8.27
Fy = 39.9 ksi
15.75
Fu = 69.0 ksi
7/8 A325 bolts 2.68
7.22
(holes 15/16 in.) t = 0.26 in.
77
Continuing
R n = D u h sc Tm N s (per bolt )
= 0.35 (clean mill scale) h sc = 1.0 (std. holes)
A b = d 2 / 4 = 0.60 in.2 (7/8 in.dia.)
Fu = 120 ksi (A325 bolts)
n = 8 bolts N s = 2 slip planes = 1.0
78
Slip load calculation contd.
R n = D u h sc Tm N s ( per bolt )
= 0.35 1.13 1.0 37.88 kip 2 slip planes
= 29.96 kips / bolt
79
Bearing resistance (use = 1.0)
R n = 1.5 Fu L c t 3.0 d t Fu
3 d t Fu =
3 7 / 8 in. 0.26 in. 69.0 ksi = 47.1 k/bolt
1.5 Lc t Fu =
1.5 1.53 in. 0.26 in. 69.0 ksi = 41.2 k
Bearing resistance
80
Block shear
2.00
3@2.76=8.27
Tr + Vr = A nt Fu + 0.60 A gv Fy
81
Brace force in compression:
issue is sway
buckling in
this region
82
Whitmore
method. 30
Thornton method
Use longest (or
average) of L1, L2, L3
to compute a
buckling load on a 30
unit width column, L1
then apply this to the
total width.
Use k = 0.65 in the L2
column formulae
L3
83
Thornton method, modified
L1 45o
As per Thornton
method but
spread load out
at 45o L2
L3
Pu Pu Pu
PW PT PT '
84
Calculations for buckling capacity:
L3
1
I 1 0.263
r= = 12 = 0.0751 in.
A 0.26 1
85
And applying this to the total width
Pu = (6.91 k/in.) (19.2 in.) = 132 kips
so, Pu / PT = 1.23
86
It all started with rivets.
87
There's always a solution in steel.
312.670.2400 www.aisc.org