TATA CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED

PROJECT : Project Mangament Services for PVC Resin Plant, Ethiopia.

COMMENT SHEET

Received TCE Comment

Sl. No. Document Number Title Rev No.
Date Issue Date
 EMPLOYER:DCEP CONSULTANT:TCE
CONTRACTOR:CEC-FDG JV
PROJECT : DCEP 60,000 TPA Integrated PVC Resin Manufacturing Plant in Mekelle, Ethiopia

COMMENT SHEET:

Description of Architectural Design

Building Construction Detail
Residence I in Accomodation Area: EL 0.000m Plan
Residence I in Accomodation Area: EL 3.000m Plan
Residence I in Accomodation Area: 6.000-12.000m Plan
Residence I in Accomodation Area:Roof Plan
Residence I in Accomodation Area: 1-37 Elevation
Residence I in Accomodation Area: 37-1 Elevation
Residence I in Accomodation Area: F-A Elevation
Doc Title : Residence I in Accomodation Area: A-F Elevation
Residence I in Accomodation Area: 1-1 Section
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Door & Window Detail
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Staircase Detail
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Unit Enlarged Plan
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Node Detail
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Platform Railing Details, Staircase Railing Details
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Rainwater Outlet of Parapet
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Roof Maintenance Hole
Residence I in Accomodation Area: Flue Out of the Roof of the Practice

Page 2/11
 8299-D-2201A-11-001
8299-D-2201A-11-002
8299-D-2201A-23-001
8299-D-2201A-23-002
8299-D-2201A-23-003
8299-D-2201A-23-004
8299-D-2201A-24-001
8299-D-2201A-24-002
8299-D-2201A-24-003
Doc No : 8299-D-2201A-24-004
8299-D-2201A-24-005
8299-D-2201A-25-001
8299-D-2201A-27-001
8299-D-2201A-29-001
8299-D-2201A-29-002
8299-D-2201A-29-003
8299-D-2201A-29-004
8299-D-2201A-29-005
8299-D-2201A-29-006

Revision: C
Date of
2-Aug-17
issue:
PPD BY: Chaitanya N. Bondre - Architecture

Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

IX. Roof Engineering -

8299-D-2201A-11-
1. Contractor to specify whether overdeck or
1 001: Description of 4/20/2017
underdeck insulation is proposed for RC non-
Architectural Design
accessible heat insulated roof.

Page 3/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

III. Design Level

Contractor to clarify what does it mean by
Indoor elevation + 0.00 in engineering is equal
2
to absolute elevation of 16.000m. This should
be corrected according the absolute elevation
given in basic engineering.
VII. Doors & Windows
Doors and windows shall be the same as the
3
basic Engineering and detail schedule of given
in 8299-D-2201A-25-001 here in.

XIII. Ground & Foundation treatment

Contractor to provide clear details of the ground
4
floor including tempreture & shrinkage
reinforcement bars.

Specification for G1, G2, F1 and F2 to be

reviewed. Contractor has proposed cement
mortar finish for Living Room, stair well, washing
Comment carried forward
room and Bed Room which is not acceptable,
to detail engineeing stage
which are habitable spaces. Hence, contractor
5 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
8299-D-2201A-11- to consider the floor finish of granite or marble stage for compliance by
001 & 11-002: or cermic tiles etc with good aesthatics (look-
the Contractor.
Building Construction and-feel), maintainability should be proposed.
Detail Contractor to also specify the size of the
ceramic tile.

Page 4/11
 8299-D-2201A-11-
001 & 11-002:
Building Construction
Detail Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Contractor to specify the final finish/ final coat or

layer in paint for IW1, C1. Hence, final coat/layer
of paint should be with good aesthatics (look-
6 and-feel), maintainability. 4/20/2017
IW1C1/
/

For G3, F3, the finish of the ceramic tile should

be matt or anti-skid, since it is proposed in wet
7 area. 4/20/2017
Contractor to also specify the size of the
ceramic tile.

SK1 should be cermaic tileor other tile skirting

rather than cement mortar skirting.
Contractor to also specify the height and
8 thickness of the tile skirting. 4/20/2017
SK1

Page 5/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Contractor to explain the basis on which the

room sizes have been arrived at. The room
sizes appear to be too tight. Comment carried forward
to detail engineeing stage
9 Contractor to provide the room sizes that are 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
greater amongst the functional requirments of stage for compliance by
the client and regulatory requirements of the Contractor.
approving authority as per the applicable rules
and regulations.

Contractor to show the northing and easting

10 4/20/2017
coordinates of four corner points of the building.

8299-D-2201A-23-
001: EL 0.000m Plan
Page 6/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Comment carried forward

Contractor to supply toilet, shower, handwash to detail engineeing stage
11 and kitchen fixtures . 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
stage for compliance by
the Contractor.

8299-D-2201A-23-
001: EL 0.000m Plan

Contractor to clarify how the plumbing lines of

toilet are going to be planned, particularly of
those toilets which are located in the middle, say
on grid no. 13.
Comment carried forward
Contractor to clarify how the plumbing lines of to detail engineeing stage
12 toilet are going to be planned (or taken out from 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
toilet and be connected on ground level,in terms stage for compliance by
of shaft planning or else. the Contractor.

13



In toliet planning, the wet area (shower area)
overlaps to dry/ semi-dry area (WC area). Toliet
planning appears to be too tight. Contractor the Comment carried forward
review the toilet planning and correct. to detail engineeing stage
13 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
Contractor to try to make toilet more spacious stage for compliance by
so that the wet area and dry area is well defined the Contractor.
(so as not to overlap on each other.

Page 7/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Contractor to provide a ledge wall behind the

WC to conceal the soil pipe and a flush tank.
(This comment is applicable to all the floor
14 plans. 4/20/2017
WC

Contractor to identify space for putting electrical

meters/ panels associated with each tenement.
15 4/20/2017
/

8299-D-2201A-23- Contractor to correct the bed going into the wall

16 4/20/2017
002: EL 3.000m Plan on grid 13.13

Comment carried forward

Contractor to submit details of the materials of to detail engineeing stage
17 external wall finishings, curtain wall, doors & 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
windows, floor finish materials and roof finishing. stage for compliance by
the Contractor.

Page 8/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Comment carried forward

to detail engineeing stage
Contractor to specify the internal partition
18 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
materials used inside the buildings.
stage for compliance by
the Contractor.

Floor Plan/s Contractor to provide interior and exterior

finishing schedule (floor finishing, wall finishing,
ceiling finishing, ground finishing etc).

Contractor has proposed LD2 for Living Room,

Comment carried forward
stair well, washing room and Bed Room which
to detail engineeing stage
is not acceptable; instead Contractor should
19 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
propose flooring with better aesthatical look
stage for compliance by
such as stone flooring in marble or granite, or
the Contractor.
vitirified/ ceramic tiles; Living Room being the
first impression of any house.

For N1 and P1, Contractor to mention the type

of paint such as acrylic emulsion or any other.

Page 9/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Contractor to consider providing weather sheds

to the fenestrations based on sun-path so as to
optimise the energy savings, provide adequate
protection agianst rains and radiation.

Contractor to dimension in the drawing the Comment carried forward

depth of the weather sheds he is proposing to to detail engineeing stage
20 be able to get an idea if the depth of weather 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
shed is sufficient enough to provide protection stage for compliance by
against weather. the Contractor.

Elevations

Contractor to provide an entrance canopy to

each building to be able to highlight the
entrance and provide adequate protection to the
21 occupants/ visitors from rains and radiation. 4/20/2017

/

Contractor to provide atleast 3 additional colour

scheme options for the client to choose from.
22 4/20/2017
3

Page 10/11
 Comments-
Sl. No. Reference Comments By Consultant (TCE) Remark Response from DEC
Date

Comment carried forward

Contractor to provide sunk slab to the toliet as to detail engineeing stage
23 well. 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
stage for compliance by
the Contractor.

Section

Comment carried forward

Contractor to provide couple of more section at to detail engineeing stage
24 more places to provide more clarity on spaces 4/20/2017 from basic engineering
and facade. stage for compliance by
the Contractor.

Contractor to provide 2 more cross sections, 1

25 4/20/2017
particularly through toilet/s and dring balcony.

Page 11/11