Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Magno vs CA 210 SCRA 471, June 26, 1992 CR1_003 Warranty Deposit Utilitarian Theory
II. THE REVISED PENAL CODE - BOOK ONE and RELATED SPECIAL PENAL LAWS
A. Article 2 - Territorial and Extra Territorial Jurisdiction
B. Article 3 - Felonies
People vs Delim, 396 SCRA 386, January 28, CR1_004 Brothers Intent to kill -
2003 Determining factors;
General criminal intent
Rivera vs People, 480 SCRA 188, January 25, CR1_005 Taxi driver Intent to kill -
2006 Determining factors
Recuerdo vs People, 493 SCRA 533, June 27, CR1_006 Estafa-Dentist Intent - General and
2006 specific criminal intent
Loney vs People, 482 SCRA 195, February 10, CR1_008 Mining Case of Mala in Se
2006 although it is Mala
Prohibita
Garcia vs CA, 484 SCRA 617, March 14, 2006 CR1_009 Election Absorption of Mala in
Se over Mala Prohibita
Garcia vs People, 597 SCRA 392, August 28, CR1_011 Mauling, Heart Practer Intentionem -
2009 attack Injury resulted more
than what was
intended
Urbano vs IAC, 157 SCRA 1, January 7, 1988 CR1_012 Stabbing Proximate Cause
Theory and Efficient
Intervening Cause
People vs Noel Sales, GR 177218, October 3, CR1_014 Father-son, wood, Proximate Cause
2011 coconut tree Theory, Prater
Intentionem
Intod Vs CA, 215 SCRA 52, October 12, 1992 CR1_015 Gun-peppered Impossibility of Crime -
house Physically and Factual
Impossibility
Jacinto vs People, 592 SCRA 426, July 13, CR1_016 Stealing of check Impossibility of Crime -
2009 Legally Impossibility
People vs Labiaga, GR 202867, July 15, 2013 CR1_019 Frustrated or Murder - frustrated or
consummated consummated
murder
Error in Personae
Valenzuela vs People, GR 160188, June 21, CR1_020 Theft - Supersale Consummated theft
2007
H. Article 12 - Exempting Circumstances; Relate to RA 9344 - The Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act
Madali vs People, 595 SCRA 274, August 4, CR1_039
2009
People vs Sarcia, 599 SCRA 20, September 10, CR1_040
2009
People vs Mantalaba, GR 186227, July 20, CR1_041
2011
People vs Agacer, GR 177750, January 7, 2013 CR1_042
K. Articles 16, 17, 18, 19 & 20 - Persons Criminally Liable for Felonies
Relate to: PD 1612 The Anti-Fencing Law; PD CR1_054
1829 Obstruction of Justice
People vs Dulay, GR 193854, September 24, CR1_055
2012
People vs Gamboa, et. Al, GR 172707, CR1_056
October 1, 2013
Ong vs People, GR 190475, April 10, 2013 CR1_057
People vs Dimat, GR 181184, January 25, CR1_058
2012
I. Articles 21-88
Relate to 9346 - Prohibiting the Death Penalty
Imposition
Act 4103 The Indeterminate Sentence Law
PD 968 The Probation Law as amended
WON Frustrated or Art. 6. Defense: Labiaga claims self- Prosecution: Gregorio Conde
Attempted murder Consummated, defence. Greg, armed with was home with daughters
was committed frustrated, and shotgun, challenged him to fight. Judy and Glenelyn, he
against Gregorio attempted felonies. Greg tried to shoot but gun stepped outside. Labiaga, 5
Conde Consummated jammed. Labiaga tried to take the meters away from Gregorio,
felonies as well as gun, gun accidentally fired. shot the latter. Greg called
those which are Labiaga claims he did not know if Judy. Judy and Glenelyn
frustrated and anyone was hit. Demapanag rushed to Greg. Labiaga shot
attempted, are claims he was in D&D rice mill, 14 Judy in abdomen. The two
punishable. km away from crime scene, other accused were standing
corroborated by his brother behind Labiaga. Labiaga said,
Frederick. Shes already dead, the
three fled the scene. Judy
pronounced dead at Sara
District hospital, Greg fully
recovered.
ISSUE: WON, under Guilty of frustrated theft only, not Consummated theft
the given facts, the consummated theft.
theft should be
deemed as
consummated or
merely
frustrated.
Appellee -
Solicitor General
Kidnapped-
"Rocky" or
Horacio Cebrero
IV (6 years old)
Parents - Luis
Cabrero and
Sandra Cabrero
F-What F-Where F-When Other Notes
Malous testimony: December 13, 1991 at 1:50 a.m. Unit 307 December 13,
Baleros went inside Malous room and forcefully (with her 1991 at 1:50
covered her face with a chemical-soaked cloth with maid) in the a.m
dizzying effects and willfully, unlawfully and Celestial
feloniously commenced the commission of rape by Marie
lying on top of her. When she got away from Baleros, Building
she called the Security Guard Ferolin and reported along A.H.
the incident however she did not know who attacked Lacson Street
her. However, she suspected Baleros because they in 1991.
were friends in medical school, when Baleros
confessed his feelings for her, she rejected him.