Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 17

COURT OBSERVATION

A requirement for Practicum 1

Submitted by:
Macaraya, Dagaranaw
Ibrahi, Mohammad Salman
Laya, Erico Marc James
Amerol, Jaafar
Sanguila, Al-Huseyn
Abduljahlil, Ahmad
Guro, Abduljabbar

Submitted to:
Atty. Vivien Mostrales
Lecturer, Practicum 1
Chief, Public Attorneys Office
Regional Trial Court
12th Judicial Region
Branch 01, Iligan City
March 9, 2017
(Thursday)

Before

HON. ALI M. BALINDONG


Presiding Judge

1. Criminal Case No. 20023


PP vs. CALOY PULGARENAS, MARIANO BOLITCHE, ROMMEL C.
ARNADO AND SIXTY JOHN DOES
For : SIMPLE ARSON
For the Prosecution : PROS. MA. A.G. AGUAVIVA
For the Accused : ATTY_________________
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Public Prosecutor was not around. Moved to consolidate with case of multiple
attempted murder (CC 19976-437). Reset to April 6, 2017

2. Criminal Case No. 19591


PP vs. ZAIDE ORANDANG y BUGHAW
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Buy-bust operation without valid warrant. Accused posted bail for Php
100,000.00 and was not notified of the pre-trial. Subpoena was ordered for the Crime
Lab Official.

3. Criminal Case No. 19587


PP vs. CRYSSAN JOY CABTALAN ACAYLAR
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Private attorney of accused(Atty. Dimacaling) is not present. Pre-trial cannot


push through due to absence and is set to March 16, 2017.
4. Criminal Case No. 19581
PP vs. FROILAND JOVERO y PADAYHAG
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

The minutes of the preliminary conference was adopted. Buy bust operation
without a valid warrant of arrest. Court has set 6 trial dates for prosecution(Aug 27, Sept
6, 13, 20, 27, Oct 4) and 2 trial dates for defense(Oct 11, 15)

5. Criminal Case No. 18842, 18843, 18844


PP vs. XYRUS DUHAYLUNGSOD y SANCHES
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 12,11 AND 5 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Adopted minutes of preliminary conferences for CC No. 18842-18844. Admitted


that there was no warrant of arrest. Crystal Duhaylungsod is named as witness of the
accused. Court has set 6 trial dates for prosecution (Aug 24, 31, Setp 7, 14, 21, 28) and 3
trial dates for the defense(Oct 5, 12, 17)

6. Criminal Case No. 19533


PP vs. JAMEL BAGUAN y BANTO JAMEL BANTO
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 5 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Private attorney of accused is not present. Pre-trial is reset to April 5, 2017.


7. Criminal Case No. 17901
PP vs. AILEEN REYES y YBANEZ TIN-TIN AND ELSE LUCERO
YOSI
For : THEFT
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DEMOSTHENES PLANDO
For : INITIAL TRIAL

Remarks:

Complainant failed to appear in previous hearings. Move to adopt


manifestation. Atty. Macapado is collaborating counsel. In view of continuous absences,
counsel for accused moved for dismissal of case in view of speedy disposition of cases.
Court found merit and case is hereby dismissed.

8. Criminal Case No. 19359, 19360


PP vs. JAMERAH MASUONG y ALI SAMSAM
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 5 AND 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : INITIAL TRIAL

Remarks:

Motion to reset trial for failure or person issued subpoena to appear. Trial is
reset to March 23, 2017.

9. Criminal Case No. 17101, 17108


PP vs. ARNOLD M. LOQUILLANO
For : VIOLATION OF RA 8294 AND SEC 5 OF ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRESENTING OF WITNESS

Remarks:

Presentation of witness for prosecution P02 Pendon. Executed affidavit and gave
details before being cross examined by accuseds counsel. Subpoena for SP02 Orbe was
issued.
10. Criminal Case No. 17098
PP vs. AZIS SAMPORNA aka ALLAN
For : MURDER
For the Prosecution : PROS. MA. AILEEN G. AGUAVIVA
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PRESENTING OF WITNESS

Remarks:

Counsel for prosecution was not available. Hearing reset to August 17, 2017.

11. Criminal Case No. 16981


PP vs. ROTELIO A. YABO
For : MURDER
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. FEDERICO KHALIL MARANDA
For : ACCUSED INITIAL PRESENTATION OF EVIDENCE

Remarks:

Counsel for accused is not in court. Rescheduled to April 19, 2017.

12. Criminal Case No. 19455, 19454, 19452


PP vs. CLIMACO DOYONGAN y DAYDAYA, MARJUN USMAN y
VIAJANTE, JAMES PAUL R. LAYUG
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PROSECUTION TO PRESENT NEXT WITNESS

Remarks:

Witness not in court. Moved to reschedule to March 23, 2017

13. Criminal Case No. 18884


PP vs. JUNIFER ENARIO y LAYAR
For : VIOLATION OF SEC. 11 ART 11 OF RA 9165
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. DHETTY JOY B. ABREGANA
For : PROSECUTION TO PRESENT NEXT WITNESS

Remarks:

Witness not in court. Moved to reschedule to March 23, 2017


14. LRC Case No. 1309
SPS. CLARISSA H. PACAA JIMENEZ et. al.
vs. THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF ILIGAN CITY
For : IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION FOR THE CORRECTION
OF ENTRY TCT NO. T-155-2014000114
For the Prosecution : PROS. ABDUL GAFFUR M.H.M. ALONTO
For the Accused : ATTY. ELMER C. MAGLINAO
For : PETITIONER TO PRESENT EVIDENCE

Remarks:

Petitioner did not present documents, hence, waived. Solicitor General and The
Registry of Deeds had no objection. Case is submitted for resolution.
Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Tubod-Baroy
12th Judicial Region
Branch 06, Province of Lanao del Norte
March 15, 2017
(Wednesday)

Before

HON. MYLENE A. MACUMBAL


Presiding Judge

1. Criminal Case No. 5336


PP vs. MARISSA APARECE
For : MALICIOUS MISCHIEF
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY_________________
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Prosecution executed motion to withdraw information. Motion granted.

2. Criminal Case No. 5342


PP vs. ROGELIO ALJAS
For : VIOLATION OF ART 179 OF THE RPC
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. ________________
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Pleaded not guilty. Pre-trial is set on March 24, 2017

3. Criminal Case No. 5345


PP vs. LESTER LAURANILLA
For : GRAVE THREATS
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Pleaded not guilty. Pre-trial is set on April 5, 2017


4. Criminal Case No. 5343
PP vs. LESTER LAURANILLA
For : RESISTANCE AND DISOBEDIENCE TO A PERSON OR AGENT
OF A PERSON IN AUTHORITY
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Pleaded not guilty. Pre-trial is set on April 5, 2017

5. Criminal Case No. 5346


PP vs. ANNABELL TUBALI
For : VIOLATION OF BP 22
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. SATURNINO MEJORADA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Set 6 trial dates for prosecution(Sept 27, Oct 4, 11, 18, 25, Nov. 8) and 6 trial
dates for the defense(Dec 13, Jan 17, 24, 31, Feb 7, 16)

6. Criminal Case No. 5226


PP vs. JEMOR YBAEZ
For : VIOLATION OF BP BLG 6
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. DOROTHEA BASALO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Private attorney of accused was not notified. Reset to April 5, 2017

7. Criminal Case No. 5128


PP vs. JEMOR YBAEZ
For : VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL ORDER NO. 67
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. DOROTHEA BASALO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Private attorney of accused was not notified. Reset to April 5, 2017


8. Criminal Case No. 5294
PP vs. ELIORE SAYRE JR
For : GRAVE THREATS
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Case was provisionally dismissed. Bond cancelled and returned to owner.

9. Criminal Case No. 5295


PP vs. ELIOYRE SAYRE JR
For : UNJUST VEXATION
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Case was provisionally dismissed. Bond cancelled and returned to owner.

10. Criminal Case No. 5350


PP vs. JOHNNY DAYGAM
For : RECKLESS IMPRUDENCE RESULTING TO HOMICIDE
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Case was reset to March 29, 2017.

11. Criminal Case No. 5280


PP vs. ROLANDO SUMITING RONGCAL
For : VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL ORDINANCE NO. 67
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Prosecutor moved for joint trial with CC No. 5281. Motion granted.
12. Criminal Case No. 5281
PP vs. ROLANDO SUMITING RONGCAL
For : ILLEGAL GAMBLING
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Joint trial with CC No. 5280. Hearing set on Setp 27, 2017.

13. Criminal Case No. 5128 and 5130


PP vs. ARSAD LALA AND PATRICIO VERGATINOS
For : VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL ORDINANCE NO. 67
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Accused Vergatinos testified and was examined by the prosecutor. Continuance


set on March 29, 2017

14. Criminal Case No. 5135


PP vs. HAMDANIE DIEGO
For : VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL ORDER NO. 67
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

P02 Midjhon Reillo testified. Continuance is set on March 29, 2017.

15. Criminal Case No. 5245


PP vs. DENNIS LARINO
For : VIOLATION OF MUNICIPAL ORDER NO. 67
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Case is reset. To join trial with case of George Enguio as it involves the same
facts.
16. Criminal Case No. 5278
PP vs. ELCID BALDECANTOS
For : MALICIOUS MISCHIEF
For the Prosecution : PROS. SAMAIRA MABA
For the Accused : ATTY. JOHN DALE CANTALEJO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Case is provisionally dismissed due to lack of witness.


Regional Trial Court
12th Judicial Region
Branch 01 Family Court, Iligan City
March 23, 2017
(Thursday)

Before

HON. ALBUSAG B. AMANODIN-UMPA


Presiding Judge

1. Criminal Case No. 13349, 13350, 13351


PP vs. ADELLANO SUAREZ
For : RAPE
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : PROMULGATION

Remarks:

Accused found guilty of 2 counts of rape and is sentenced to 2 counts of


Reclusion Perpetua. Acquitted on 1 count due to insufficiency of evidence.

2. Criminal Case No. 17498


PP vs. CLINTON CAUTIVER, ET ALS.
For : THEFT
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. VIVIEN INES MOSTRALES
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Accused did not previously allege his minority at commission of crime. Case is
reset on April 11, 2017 to give accused opportunity to produce birth certificate

3. Criminal Case No. 17688


PP vs. DARYL JIM ROQUILLAS alias EMONG
For : VIOLATION OF SEC 15(a) OF RA 9262
For the Prosecution : PROS. APP ZARITH SOFIA MARANGIT
For the Accused : ATTY. DIOSDADO ESPAOL/ ATTY. JAN CARLO CRUZ
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Hearing is reset due to attendence at convention of defendants counsel.


4. Criminal Case No. 19678
PP vs. CARLOS GO Y LIBAGO
For : VIOLATION OF RA 9262
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : PRE-TRIAL

Remarks:

Adopted minutes of preliminary conference. Set 4 dates for prosecution (June 1,


15, July 11, 25).

5. Criminal Case No. 17803


PP vs. ROSALINA ESTUYA Y BACULIO
For : GRAVE ORAL DEFAMATION
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

The accused failed to appear since he is in Manila. Hearing is reset to April 26,
2017.

6. Criminal Case No. 18463, 18464, 18465


PP vs. DOMINADOR R. MAGWATE
For : RAPE IN RELATION TO RA 7610
For the Prosecution : PROS. APP ZARITH SOFIA G. MARANGIT
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

-cannot observe as we were directed outside the courtroom due to


confidentiality reasons-

7. Criminal Case No. 18471


PP vs. YOLIE BERSALES DELA CRUZ
For : RAPE IN RELATION TO RA 7610
For the Prosecution : PROS. APP ZARITH SOFIAH G. MARANGIT
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

-cannot observe as we were directed outside the courtroom due to


confidentiality reasons-
8. Criminal Case No. 16615
PP vs. P/INSP MARK IAN ESCATRON QUIETA, P03 STEPHEN B.
DURA, P02 ARGI BUAL, SP01 JEFFREY OPONDA, P02 MOHAMMAD
DRIEZA MACADATO
For : VIOLATION OF RA 9745
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. NESTLE AGOPITAC
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Examination of witness of prosecution(victims mother). Witness recalled the


events, as well as the injuries on her son during the event.

9. Criminal Case No. 18959


PP vs. HANS LIM Y MONSTANTO
For : VIOLATION OF PAR (i) SEC 5 OF RA 9262
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. ZALDY LIM
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

-cannot observe as we were directed outside the courtroom due to


confidentiality reasons-

10. Criminal Case No. 15118


PP vs. RICHARD ACO Y BUBULI
For : RAPE
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Trial was reset to May 28, 2017


11. Criminal Case No. 17412
PP vs. FRANCIS JAY PADILLA Y RAMOS, IRVING JACOB LARANJO Y
SEPE, MANASI MENDOZA
For : MURDER
For the Prosecution : PROS. ACP JASMIN C. GUIUO-DIAZ
For the Accused : ATTY. LEMUEL P. LACHICA
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

-cannot observe as we were directed outside the courtroom due to


confidentiality reasons-

12. Civil Case No. 7867


RUEL J. BARTOLABA vs. SUMILI BARTOLABA
For : DECREE OF PRESUMPTIVE DEATH
For the Petitioner : ATTY. VIVIEN INES MOSTRALES
For : HEARING

Remarks:

-failed to observe as hearing was held when we were directed out due to the
earlier trial regarding minors.-

13. Sp. Proc No. 09-0860


IN THE MATTER OF THE ADOPTION OF MINOR NATHANIEL BOBADILLA PITOGO
Petitioner : SPS. ROY S. CORDERO and ROSITA BOBADILLA CORDERO
Counsel for Pet :
For : HEARING

Remarks:

Court sought to appoint counsel for petitioner.

14. Sp. Proc No. 13-1336


IN THE MATTER OF THE ADOPTION OF AN ABANDONED MINOR CHILD KNOWN AS
MARY ANGEL LOURIE A. TAMPARONG
Petitioner : SPS. LAURITO A. TAMPARONG and MARIA DELIA A.
TAMPARONG
Counsel for Pet : ATTY. VERMIN M. QUIMCO
For : HEARING

Remarks:

Hearing was reset.


Municipal Trial Court in Cities
12th Judicial Region
Branch 04 Iligan City
March 7, 2017
(Thursday)

Before

HON. JAMEL T. MAMUTUK


Presiding Judge

1. Criminal Case No. 17-49


PP vs. LORIEMAR HALAGAT y SOLABAR
For : VIOLATION OF PD 1619
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY ______________________
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Atty. Nur Jaypha Bacaraman-Asum assigned as counsel de oficio. Accused


pleaded guilty. Court fined accused with Php 600.00 and imprisonement for 6 months
and 1 day.

2. Criminal Case No. 17-18


PP vs. JOEL CLARABAL
For : SLIGHT PHYSICAL INJURIES
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY. _____________________
For : ARRAIGNMENT

Remarks:

Atty. Nur Jaypha Bacaraman-Asum assigned as counsel de oficio. Accused


pleaded not guilty. Prosecution asked to move for time to locate complainant as address
of complainant is not known.

3. Criminal Case No. 16-549


PP vs. JANSARI MAMOSAKA
For : ESTAFA
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY. NUR JAYPHA BACARAMAN-ASUM
For : PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE

Remarks:

Pre-trial conference was reset.


4. Criminal Case No. 15-414
PP vs. FREDERICO URBIZTONDO y FONTEVEROS, alias DODONG,
RUDY SENDO, MICHAEL ALBA y DELGADO and RAMIL TOLENTINO
y VALDEZ
For : ROBBERY
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY. NUR JAYPHA BACARAMAN-ASUM
For : PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE

Remarks:

Case against Michael Alba was moved for provisional dismissal. Case against
others was archived.

5. Criminal Case No. 16-518


PP vs. COLUMBUS PESIAO y MONTECALBO JR
For : LESS SERIOUS PHYSICAL INJURIES
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY. NUR JAYPHA BACARAMAN-ASUM
For : PRELIMINARY CONFEREnCE

Remarks:

Complainant wants judgment from court, as it was directed to PMC and refused
to mediate. Court requested the records from PMC and will be reset on March 20, 2017

6. Criminal Case No. 14-797


PP vs. JENELYN Z. ZALSOS
For : FALSIFICATION BY PRIVATE INDIVIDUAL AND USE OF
FALSIFIED DOCUMENTS
For the Prosecution : PROS. ALBERT L. OPON
For the Accused : ATTY. TOMAS GARCILLANO
For : TRIAL

Remarks:

Prosecution motioned to reset trial due to witness now showing to court. A


subpoena was issued to the witness and hearing is reset on April 18, 2017.