Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
The authors show that it is possible to compare directly results of uniaxial and biaxial tensile tests.
Utilization of uniaxial tests results can lead to similar effects in the FEM calculations as application of biaxial tests.
We describe laboratory tests necessary for identication of non-linear elastic properties of the coated fabric.
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this paper, laboratory tests necessary for the identication of non-linear elastic immediate properties
Received 26 February 2013 of the PVC coated polyester fabric (like AF 9032) are described. The material parameters are specied on
Received in revised form 4 August 2013 the basis of the uniaxial tensile tests in the warp and weft directions as well as on the base of the biaxial
Accepted 29 August 2013
tensile tests. For the identication process techniques based on the least squares method are used. The
Available online 3 October 2013
authors show that it is possible to compare directly the results of uniaxial and biaxial tensile tests and
apply these results for preliminary design of tensile structures made form coated fabrics.
Keywords:
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Fabric/textiles
Mechanical properties
Mechanical testing
1. Introduction tury [1]. Reinhardt [2] gave the experiment results of biaxial and
uniaxial tensile tests for polyester fabrics coated with PVC and con-
The subject of the research and laboratory tests is technical wo- cludes that the results of tensile strength in both cases are equal.
ven fabrics made of polyester bers covered by PVC (polyvinyl- Stubbs and Thomas [3] developed a nonlinear elastic constitutive
chloride). Technical woven fabrics (architectural fabrics) are model for coated fabrics. This model, which accounts for the basic
applied in civil engineering structures for both seasonal and per- mechanisms of yarn rotation, yarn extension and coating exten-
manent constructions. They are often used for wide-span surfaces, sion, was obtained by expressing the equations of equilibrium for
membrane structures, hanging roofs and pneumatic constructions. a unit cell of the material in terms of effective continuum stresses
Their great functionality lays in low deadweight and the possibility and strains. Argyris et al. [4,5] described the numerical analysis of
of covering large surfaces with relatively small number of membrane structures made of PVC-coated fabrics. In those papers,
supports. These innovative architectural engineering systems the mechanical and numerical modelling of viscoelastic materials
provide designers a variety of aesthetic free and light forms. For was proposed with the new schemes for integration of the
example, the roof of the O2 Arena in London is one of the big- rheological relations in the time domain. Szostkiewicz-Chatain
gest structures of this type in the world. They are also used for and Hamelin [6] presented numerical and experimental stiffness
roofs of sport structures like stadiums, the Formula (1) tracks characterisation methods for polyester plain-woven fabric coated
stands, etc. with PVC and proposed inverse and experimental stiffness identi-
Typical technical woven fabric usually consists of two families cation methods. Bassett et al. [7] gave a review of the various
of threads the warp and the weft (ll), see Fig. 1. The PVC coated experimental approaches used for measuring fabric mechanical
fabrics have been used and tested from the sixties of previous cen- properties. Wei et al. [8] presented tearing behaviour of exible
composites reinforced with woven fabrics. Bigaud et al. [9] pre-
Corresponding author. Tel.: +48 601660795. sented a comprehensive investigation on the mechanical proper-
E-mail addresses: ambrozan@pg.gda.pl (A. Ambroziak), klosow@pg.gda.pl (P. ties of a PVC-coated plain-woven polyester fabric with initial
Kosowski). cracks. Bridgens and Gosling [10] proposed two techniques for
0950-0618/$ - see front matter 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2013.08.060
A. Ambroziak, P. Kosowski / Construction and Building Materials 50 (2014) 7481 75
coated fabric and the type of analysis which has to be made, is always a disputable
warp problem. The authors propose an easy method to express typical properties of the
weft coated fabric in the engineering nite element based design. It is possible to apply
the nite element in the plane stress state with the special substructure suitable to
describe behaviour of the thread families (especially the change of an angle be-
tween the families during deformation). This concept called the dense net model
has been already presented several times (see e.g. [26,27,23]). It is easily applicable
in self-made or commercial nite element codes and can be used with different
types of material description of threads behaviour. In this model, it is assumed that
the fabric forces in the threads families depend on the uniaxial strain in the same
family only (the friction between threads families in this concept is neglected;
therefore inuence of the coating cannot be fully included in such an approach).
Consequently, the threads forces increment of the warp Drn1 or weft direction
Drn2 is calculated from the following equations:
where F 1 en1 and F 2 en2 are the uniaxial material functions of the threads and are
aforementioned coated woven fabric behaviour. Ning and Chen
called the longitudinal stiffnesses. For the denition of these functions any type of
[11] described the mechanical performance of exible composites the constitutive equation can be used. They are usually specied on the basis of
reinforced with multiaxial noncrimp fabrics (NCFs). Luo et al. the uniaxial, or in more complex investigation, like e.g. the biaxial laboratory tests.
[12,13] analysed tensile and tearing properties of the PET bber Basing on the geometrical relationship, the threads force rni and strain eni can be
expressed by the stress rx and strains ex components in the plane stress state as
biaxial warp knitted fabrics coated with PVC under uniaxial tensile
follows:
loads. Chen et al. [14] investigated tensile behaviour of PVC-coated
woven fabrics under mono and biaxial loads. Additionally, the 8 9
authors examined and compared two methods used to record e
1
0 0 < ex2 >
> =
en n1 2 ex2 Txn ex
strains (the needle extensometer and photograph method) and en2 cos2 a sin a sin a cos a > : >
cx1x2 ;
their inuence on the stressstrain curves. Luo and Hu [15] pre- 8 9 2 3 2
< rx1 >
2
> = 1 cos a
sented a study on the mechanical properties of PVC-coated bi-axial 7 rn1
rx rx2 6 40
2
sin a 5 Txn T rn
warp knitted fabrics with and without initial cracks under >
: > rn2
sx1 x2 ; 0 sin a cos a
multi-axial tensile loads. Galliot and Luchsinger [16] proposed a
non-linear material model to describe the yarn-parallel behaviour
where a is the actual inclination angle between the threads families during the
of PVC-coated polyester fabric under biaxial tension for two types
deformation process (similar geometrical relationships has been used by Xue et al.
of polyester fabrics. Kosowski et al. [17] gave the nonlinear visco- [28]). The angle between thread families a, changes during deformation and is cal-
elastic description of the PVC-coated textile material in linear and culated according to the current values of stress components rx2 and sx1x2 in the fab-
non-linear approach. Galliot and Luchsinger [18] investigated ric from the relation:
behaviour of coated fabrics by using the shear ramp tests method.
Abot et al. [19] performed an experimental study to determine the rx2
a arc tg : 3
role of woven fabric architecture and its geometrical parameters sx1x2
on the interlaminar shear response of laminated composites. Brid- Consequently, the constitutive relation in the plane stress state of the whole
gens et al. [20] compared results from two biaxial test machines element, expressed by the threads forces, takes the form of:
X
N
xi
x ; 6
N
i1 grip
100
weft
warp
grip
grip
100
grip
Fig. 3. Strainstress curves uniaxial tensile tests. Fig. 5. Biaxial cross specimen.
A. Ambroziak, P. Kosowski / Construction and Building Materials 50 (2014) 7481 77
Table 1
Load rate for different load ratio.
Fig. 9. Biaxial tensile tests, comparison of different stress ratio (1:1, 1:2, 1:4, 1:8).
has been assumed as basic for specimens cut. The weft direction is
not always perpendicular to the warp direction (very small
changes in the virgin fabric can be observed). Therefore not always
is there the same number of complete threads in the weft direction
in the cross arm. Following, it should be noted that for the weft and
warp for load ratio 1:2, 2:1, 4:1 results are very similar to those ob-
Fig. 6. Biaxial tensile tests specimen type B. tained for 1:1 stress ratio. The calculated coefcients of determina-
78 A. Ambroziak, P. Kosowski / Construction and Building Materials 50 (2014) 7481
Fig. 10. Biaxial tensile tests, comparison of different stress ratio (1:1, 2:1, 4:1, 8:1).
Fig. 12. Graphical concept of identication.
Table 3
Coefcient of determination R2.
Table 4
Force ratio Warp Weft Non-linear elastic properties of coated fabric uniaxial tests.
1:2 0.95 >0.99 UTS F [kN/m] e [-]
1:4 0.47 >0.99
1:8 <0.10 0.96 Warp 116 1 1280 15 00.0141 0.0004
2:1 >0.99 >0.99 197 1 0.0141 0.00040.0981 0.0003
4:1 0.98 0.90 1075 5 0.0981 0.00030.174
8:1 >0.99 0.35 Weft 104 2 193 5 00.0323 0.0007
465 15 0.0323 0.00070.060 0.001
105 2 0.060 0.0010.1627 0.0005
880 20 0.1627 0.00050.247
Fig. 11. Biaxial tensile tests (stress ratio 1:1), comparison with uniaxial tensile
results.
tion R2 are given in Table 3. All curves for different load ratios have
been compared to mean stressstrain curves of 1:1 load ratio. Only
Fig. 13. Graphical visualization of identication uniaxial tests.
for the load ratio 1:8 for the warp and for load ratio 8:1 for the weft
signicant differences to 1:1 stress ratio results can be observed.
For the load ratio 1:8 it can be noticed (Fig. 9) that strains for the
warp have negative values. In this type of fabrics when the weft
threads are subjected to high loading in comparison to the warp,
the weft threads straighten and the warp threads become folded.
Therefore, it can be concluded that in the engineering applications,
for this type of fabric, 1:1 stress ratio is representative, as 8:1 stress
ratio (rwarp:rweft) is seldom applied in hanging roof constructions.
Finally, comparison of biaxial stressstrain curves with uniaxial
tensile test results is given, see Fig. 11. It can be ascertain that uni-
axial tensile tests results give a good approximation of the biaxial
stress state for 1:1 load ratio. Therefore nally, for the investigated
type of coated fabric, it can be concluded that uniaxial tensile tests
give a good outlook on its mechanical properties.
Table 5
Main differences between fabrics test standards.
Acknowledgment
equivalent stress and strain are shown in Figs. 16 and 17, respec- References
tively. The maximal values of the equivalent stress are located
[1] Mattinson EH. The coating of fabrics with P.V.C.. J Textile Inst Proc
nearby corners, where in experiments the damage of specimens 1960;51(2):6908.
has begun, see Fig. 18. This simple test conrms the correctness [2] Reinhardt HW. On the biaxial testing and strength of coated fabrics. Exp Mech
of material parameters identication. 1976;16(2):714.
[3] Stubbs N, Thomas S. A nonlinear elastic constitutive model for coated fabrics.
Mech Mater 1984;3(2):15768.
[4] Argyris J, St. Doltsinis I, Silva VD. Constitutive modelling and computation on
6. Conclusions non-linear viscoelastic solid. Part I: Rheological models and numerical
integration techniques. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 1991;88:13563.
[5] Argyris J, St. Doltsinis I, Silva VD. Constitutive modelling and computation on
The authors of the present paper investigated the immediate non-linear viscoelastic solid, Part II: Application to orthotropic PVC-coated
non-linear elastic properties of AF9032 coated fabric. The identi- fabric. Comput Methods Appl Mech Eng 1992;98:159226.
[6] Szostkiewicz-Chatain C, Hamelin P. Numerical and experimental stiffness
cation of the non-linear elastic model has been successfully per- characterisations applied to soft textile composites for tensile structures.
formed on the basis of the uniaxial tension tests. The most Mater Struct 1998;31:11825.
important nding of the research is that in engineering calcula- [7] Bassett RJ, Postle R, Pan N. Experimental methods for measuring fabric
mechanical properties: a review and analysis. Text Res J 1999;69(11):86675.
tions in the preliminary design stage the uniaxial tensile tests re- [8] Wei D, Wang C, Xiang Y, et al. Experimental study on material properties of
sults can be directly used also to describe biaxial behaviour of the structural fabric. Spatial Struct 2002;8(1):3743.
structure. The biaxial tests need expensive laboratory equipment [9] Bigaud D, Szostkiewicz C, Hamelin P. Tearing analysis for textile reinforced soft
composites under mono-axial and bi-axial tensile stresses. Compos Struct
which is often not available for a designer. But in the most of typ-
2003;62:12937.
ical numerical calculations the uniaxial tests results are good en- [10] Bridgens BN, Gosling PD. Direct stressstrain representation for coated woven
ough. On the other hand, the designer must at least take into fabric. Comput Struct 2004;82:191327.
account the piece-wise characteristic of the strainstress relation. [11] Ning Y, Chen Nanliang. A study on the tensile properties of polyester
multiaxial warp knitted exible composites. Tech Textile Prod 2005;8:1922.
The results of the sophisticated biaxial tests are more difcult in [12] Luo Y, Hong H, Fangueiro R. Tensile and tearing properties of bi-axial warp
interpretation, therefore also their usage in numerical applications knitted coated fabrics. AUTEX Res J 2008;8(1):1720.
A. Ambroziak, P. Kosowski / Construction and Building Materials 50 (2014) 7481 81
[13] Luo Y, Hong H, Fangueiro R. Tensile and tearing properties of PVC coated [24] Ambroziak A. Analysis of non-linear elastic material properties of PVC-coated
biaxial warp knitted fabrics under biaxial loads. Indian J Fibre Text Res Panama fabric. TASK Quarterly 2005;9(2):16778.
2008;33:14650. [25] Kosowski P, Zagubien A, Woznica K. Investigation on rheological properties of
[14] Chen S, Ding X, Fangueiro R, Yi H, Ni J. Tensile behavior of PVC-coated woven technical fabric Panama. Arch Appl Mech 2004;73:66181.
membrane materials under uni- and bi-axial loads. J Appl Polym Sci [26] Branicki Cz. Some aspects of cable nets static analysis [in Polish]. PhD
2008;107:203844. thesis. Gdansk: Gdansk University of Technology; 1969.
[15] Luo Y, Hu H. Mechanical properties of PVC coated bi-axial warp knitted fabric [27] Kosowski P. Statics and dynamics of cable-membrane hanging roofs in
with and without initial crack under multi-axial tensile loads. Compos Struct materially and geometrically non-linear approach [in Polish]. PhD
2009;89:53642. thesis. Gdansk: Gdansk University of Technology; 1983.
[16] Galliot C, Luchsinger RH. A simple model describing the non-linear biaxial [28] Xue P, Peng X, Cao J. A non-orthogonal constitutive model for characterizing
tensile behaviour of PVC-coated polyester fabrics for use in nite element woven composites. Elsevier, Compos Part A 2003;34:18393.
analysis. Compos Struct 2009;90:43847. [29] Ambroziak A. Membrane hanging roof analysis example. TASK Quarterly
[17] Kosowski P, Komar W, Woznica K. Finite element description of nonlinear 2006;10(3):26773.
viscoelastic behaviour of technical fabric. Constr Build Mater [30] Ambroziak A, Kosowski P. Mechanical testing of technical woven fabrics. J
2009;23:113340. Reinf Plast Compos 2013;32(10):72639.
[18] Galliot C, Luchsinger RH. The shear ramp: a new test method for the [31] Users handbook: MSC.MARC, Version 2010. MSC. Software Corporation; 2010.
investigation of coated fabric shear behaviour Part II: Experimental [32] Sauer RA, Duong TX, Corbett CJ. A computational formulation for constrained
validation. Composites; Part A 2010;41:17509. solid and liquid membranes considering isogeometric nite elements,
[19] Abot JL, Gabbai RD, Harsley K. Effect of woven fabric architecture on arXiv:1210.4791v1 (October 2012).
interlaminar mechanical response of composite materials: an experimental [33] Ambroziak A, Kosowski P. A four-node 3D isoparametric membrane element.
study. J Reinf Plast Compos 2011;30(24):200314. TASK Quarterly 2006;10(1):3547.
[20] Bridgens B, Gosling P, Jou G-T, Hsu X-Y. Inter-laboratory comparison of biaxial [34] Taylor JR. An introduction to error analysis. Sausalito (USA): University Science
tests for architectural textiles. J Text Inst 2012;103(7):70618. Books; 1997.
[21] Zhang Y, Zhang Q, Lv H. Mechanical properties of polyvinylchloride-coated [35] Buet-Gautier K, Boisse P. Experimental analysis and modelling of biaxial
fabrics processed with Precontraint technology. J Reinf Plast Compos mechanical behaviour of woven composite reinforcements. Exp Mech
2012;31(23):167084. 2001;41(3):26090.
[22] Adanur S, Hou Z, Broughton RM. Recovery and reuse of waste PVC coated [36] Marquardt DW. An algorithm for least squares estimation of parameters. J Soc
fabrics. Part 1: Experimental procedures and separation of fabric components. Indust Appl Math 1963;11:43141.
J Ind Text 1998;28(1):3755.
[23] Ambroziak A, Kosowski P. Review of constitutive models for technical woven
fabrics in nite element analysis. AATCC Rev 2011:5867.