Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
the corrugated GI sheet, length, and width centimeters (14 cm) within the second
and being fire resilient. The coconut fibers, week; within third week, an additional of
although are fire hazard materials became fire four (4) cracks appeared with total length
resistant when covered with dried concrete. of fifty six centimeters (56 cm); and within
The weight and physical composition made fourth week, the insulator detached from
the three models distinctive with each other. the metal roofing material. This shows
The weight of the insulated models increased that Insulating metal roofing with cement
but was found that Model 2 was the heaviest mortar only is not feasible. It was supported
with composition of cement and sand. In by the evidence that during the early stage
most cases, outside forces is detrimental cracks becomes visible and that the binding
for the destruction of metal roofing but by between the insulation and the metal roof
increasing the weight, it made the metal fails. Reinforcing the insulator with coconut
roof more stable since the capacity to resist fibers provides better result that no visible
against strong wind was augmented. This defect such as cracks was seen. Naturally,
was supported by Malone et al. (2013) who cracks occurred due to shrinkage and
cited that heavier in weight outperforms the expansion of concrete caused by change in
lightweight structure in many aspects. temperature (Negrutiu et al. 2016). In Model
1, crack on insulation was stopped due the
Occurrence of Physical Defects coconut fibers that reinforced the insulator
against expansion and contraction. The
The observed physical defects which fiber reinforced models demonstrate largest
started right after the wet mortar was reduction of the drying shrinkage (Choi, Park
poured in the corrugated GI sheet models & Jung, 2011). Properties like breaking load
marked as 1, 2 and 3 were shown Table 1. and ductility improved with the addition of
The observation period covers four weeks. fibers so that the sharpness of the cracking
pattern was reduced with the presence of
No visible defect was observed in coir fibers (Darsana et al., 2016).
Model 1 in the whole observation. However,
in Model 2 several imperfections occurred Effects on Internal Temperature
such as: four (4) cracks were seen at total
length of thirty three centimeters (33 cm) The data obtained from the observation
within first week of observation; two (2) of IBT, ICBT and IWBT exhibits different
cracks appeared at total length of fourteen trends using insulated and non-insulated
Temperature inside the bucket (IBT). The result implies that the corrugated
The mean external temperature during the GI sheet metal having concrete and coconut
activity was 46.5C. The data was obtained fibers as insulator was able to delay the
from scaled thermometers placed inside increase of internal temperature of a plastic
the black plastic buckets covered with the bucket. The condition is the same for bers
different models. The IBT was taken from that are glued externally on concrete slab
six trials for every ten minutes intervals. The surface which allow room temperatures to
recorded IBT data is presented in Table 2. decrease down the comfort limit (Rodriguez
et al. 2011).
Model 1 as top cover of plastic buckets
demonstrates less IBT. The temperature Inside the carton box temperature
with Model 3 as top cover started the (ICBT). The mean external temperature
reading from 38 degrees Celsius and ended during this activity was 44C. The data was
at 39.5 degrees Celsius, while with Model taken from the carton boxes containing
41
40
Temperature (C )
39
38 Model 1
37 Model 2
36 Model 3
35
34
10 20 30 40 50 60
Time (min)
45
44
Temperature (C )
43
42
Model 1
41
Model 2
40
39 Model 3
38
10 20 30 40 50 60
Time (min)
scaled thermometer covered with the three Reflected on Figure 3 are the ICBT
types of models 1. The recorded ICBT data is of the three models. The green line which
presented in Table 3. is representing Model 3 is showing to be
the highest temperature line while Model
It reveals that using Model 3 as cover, 1 (blue line) demonstrated the lowest.
the ICBT is at 44 degrees Celsius during The result implies that the corrugated GI
the initial reading which slightly decreased sheet metal roofing insulated with coconut
to 42 degrees Celsius after 20 minutes and fiber reinforced concrete is very effective
slightly increased to 44 degrees Celsius in controlling the internal temperature of
after 60 minutes. The average temperature a carton box. The result was supported
is 43.5 degrees Celsius which appeared to by Manohar et al. (2006) who found that
be the highest ICBT if compared using the coconut fiber when mixed with sugarcane
other two models as cover. With Model 1, it fiber have acceptable values for use as
exhibits a ranging record from 40 degrees building thermal insulation.
Celsius up to 41 degrees Celsius with an
average ICBT of 40.67 degrees Celsius. The Inside the wooden box temperature
ANOVA computation had demonstrated a (IWBT). The mean external temperature
significant difference on the presented data. during the data gathering was 46C. The
data were taken from the wooden boxes
50
45
40
Temperature (C )
35
30
25 Model 1
20 Model 2
15
Model 3
10
5
0
10 20 30 40 50 60
Time (min)
14
12
Temperature gap (C )
10
8
IWBT
6
ICBT
4
IBT
2
0
10 20 30 40 50 60
Time (min)
decreased to 1.83 C or 4.16%, and IBT has internal temperatures that took place on
a temperature difference of 9.8 C or 21.08% this container was the lowest compared to
which decreased to 7.34 C or 15.78% in one other two containers. Aside from the kind of
hour of observation. The mean difference the material that the wooden box was made,
from the external temperature was 9.08 C other factor that contributes to attain low
or 19.52%, 2.43 C or 5.52%, and 8.52 C or internal temperature data is the thickness
18.33% for IWBT, ICBT and IBT respectively. since the thickness of the wooden box was
The ANOVA result shows that there is a the largest compared to other two containers.
significant difference on the data presented The smallest difference between the external
on the table. and internal temperature appeared in carton
box (ICBT). It is on this container that the
In Figure 5, the blue line which is hottest temperature took place during the
representing the temperature for the series of measurement. Aside from the kind
wooden box (IWBT) has the largest of material, other factor could be attributed
difference between external and internal to the space volume of the box since it is the
temperatures recorded for every ten largest among the three containers.
minutes of measurement. Hence, the