Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
LitReview Hart Chapter 1 PDF
LitReview Hart Chapter 1 PDF
9%! ,#)' #), &2 (%)" *&&: )" (%! !2& ! (& 3 &1)6! !"!# $%! " .)(% # "!( &2
- &+'6 +4!"; #""+,3()&'" #'6 (!$%')?+!" (%#( # ! #334)$#*4! 2& +'6! <
"(#'6)'- .& : 3 &6+$!6 )' (%! .%&4! #'-! &2 6)"$)34)'!" (%#( ,#:! +3 (%!
"&$)#4 "$)!'$!"/ 9%! #""+,3()&'" &+(4)'!6 )' (%! *&&: 2& , # *#")" 2& (%!
+'6! "(#'6)'- #'6 $ &""<2! ()4)@#()&' &2 )6!#" #$ &"" 6)"$)34)'!"/ 9%!
1# )&+" (!$%')?+!" #), (& 3 &1)6! (%! (&&4" 2& # "5"(!,#()$ #'6 )-& &+"
#'#45")" &2 "+*C!$( 4)(! #(+ !/ D+--!"()&'" # ! #4"& ,#6! &' . )()'- +3 (%!
#'#45")" &2 )6!#" )' .#5" (%#( $#' -)1! $4# )(5; $&%! !'$! #'6 )'(!44)-)*)4)(5
(& (%! .& :/
9%)" $%#3(! .)44 )'( &6+$! 5&+ (& (%! ":)44" '!!6!6 2& !"!# $%; (%!
34#$! &2 (%! 4)(! #(+ ! !1)!. )' !"!# $% #'6 (%! ),3& (#'$! &2 (%! !1)!.
(& ,#"(! E" #'6 6&$(& #4 "(+65/ 7' F%#3(! G .! 4&&: #( (%! 3+ 3&"! &2 (%!
!1)!. )' !"!# $% #'6 .%#( )" ,!#'( *5 (%! !"!# $% ),#-)'#()&'/ F%#3(!
H !A#,)'!" (%! (53!" &2 !"!# $% (& *! 2&+'6 )' (%! 4)(! #(+ !; (&-!(%! .)(%
!A#,34!" &2 !1)!." +'6! (#:!' )' # #'-! &2 "+*C!$( # !#"/ 7( #4"& "%&."
!A#,34!" &2 -&&6 3 #$()$!" (%#( 5&+ "%&+46 *! #*4! (& #6#3( #'6 +()4)@! )'
5&+ &.' .& :; !"3!$)#445 )' !#6)'- (& !1)!./ F%#3(! I )" #*&+( +'6! <
"(#'6)'- # -+,!'("/ 9& #'#45"! # 4)(! #(+ ! &' # (&3)$ '!$!""# )45 )'1&41!"
+'6! "(#'6)'- (%! "(#'63&)'( J,& #4 #'6 !(%)$#4K #'6 3! "3!$()1! J3&4)()$#4
,*+ -%$+."$/.+ .+0%+1 %& .+2+".)* -
!" #"$%&%'#( &) ! *+,%- , . *.$"/ 0, 1+$-. 2 !" 3 -$ 4%*+ +,$ +%%&.
!" +$(,!#5*$. %6 ! &7.#. !" .7!+,$.#./ 8..$!+# & +$(,!#5*$. .*(, .
! &7.#!' ! -'*9$!+: +,#!;#!' (-#+#( &&7 !" 9 11#!' #"$ . -$
$<1& #!$"/ = +,-$ " -*!!#!' +,-%*', +,$.$ (, 1+$-. #. '*#" !($ %! ,%>
+% 9 ! '$ #!6%-9 +#%!/ ?,#. #. 4$( *.$: >#+,%*+ .+-#(+ 9 ! '$9$!+ %6
9 +$-# &. !" #"$ .: !7 +,$.#. >#&& & (; +,$ +$(,!#( & .+ !" -". -$5*#-$" %6
+,$ 1%.+'- "* +$ .+*"$!+/ ?,$ @! & (, 1+$- #. 4%*+ >-#+#!' *1 7%*-
-$A#$> %6 +,$ &#+$- +*-$/ B*#" !($ #. '#A$! %! ,%> 7%*- -$A#$> ( ! 4$ *.$"
+% C*.+#67 7%*- +%1#( . >$&& . %! >, + .+-*(+*-$. !" 6%-9 +. 9#',+ 4$
*.$"/
?,$ 4-$ "+, !" "$1+, %6 +,$ A -#%*. .*4C$(+ "#.(#1&#!$. +, + 9 ;$ *1 +,$
.%(# & .(#$!($.: .%9$ %6 >,#(, , A$ 4$$! &#.+$" 4%A$: -$ !%+ $ .#&7
(& ..#@$"/ ?,$-$ -$ &.% +,$ #!(-$ .#!' %11%-+*!#+#$. 6%- .+*"$!+. +% .+*"7
- !'$ %6 9%"*&$. >,#(, (*+ (-%.. "#66$-$!+ -$ . %6 ;!%>&$"'$/
0%94#!$" >#+, +,$.$ #. +,$ 1 ($ %6 "$A$&%19$!+ %6 +,$ $&$(+-%!#( .7.+$9.
4$#!' *.$" #!(-$ .#!'&7 #! && +71$. %6 -$.$ -(,/
!"#$%&' $( )*"&'+
?,$ $<1 !.#%! %6 $"*( +#%! , . 4$$! ((%91 !#$" 47 9 ..#A$ !"
'-%>#!' $<1 !.#%! %6 #!6%-9 +#%! A #& 4&$ +% -$.$ -(, .+*"$!+./ D!
1-#!+$" !" $&$(+-%!#( 6%-9 +,$ 1 ($ %6 #!6%-9 +#%! '$!$- +#%! (%!+#!*$. +%
#!(-$ .$: -$.*&+#!' #! - -#$. (5*#-#!' %!&7 A$-7 .9 && 1-%1%-+#%! %6
+, + A #& 4&$/ =. (%!.$5*$!($: 9 !7 ( "$9#( - -#$. , A$ 4$(%9$
' +$> 7. +% #!6%-9 +#%! - +,$- +, ! .+%-$,%*.$. %6 ;!%>&$"'$/ E%* >#&&
@!" +, + !$ -&7 && *!#A$-.#+7 - -#$. !" 1*4&#( - -#$. -$ 4&$ +% .$-A$
7%*- !$$". . -$.$ -(,$-/
?,$ 9%A$ %6 *!#A$-.#+7 - -#$. > 7 6-%9 .+%-$,%*.$. %6 ;!%>&$"'$
+%> -". #!6%-9 +#%! -$.%*-($ ($!+-$. , . 4$$! ((%91 !#$" 47 ! #!(-$ .$
#! +,$ *.$ %6 #!6%-9 +#%! +$(,!%&%'7 FD?)/ G !7 - -#$. 9 ! '$ +,$
$<1 !.#%! %6 #!6%-9 +#%! >#+, +,$ #" %6 (%91*+$- .7.+$9. 4&$ +% (%9H
9*!#( +$ -%*!" +,$ '&%4$ I "$A$&%19$!+ >,#(, , . %1$!$" *1 - !'$
%6 !$> 1%..#4#&#+#$. +% -$.$ -(,$-./ D+ #. !%> 1%..#4&$ 6%- 7%* +% (($..
#!6%-9 +#%! +, + >%*&" 1-$A#%*.&7 , A$ 4$$! "#6@(*&+ !" $<1$!.#A$ +%
@!"/ = .#!'&$ " 7 .$ -(,#!' 0JHKLG " + 4 .$ %- +,$ #!+$-!$+ ( ! +,-%>
*1 9 !7 9%-$ .%*-($. +, ! 9#',+ , A$ 4$$! 6%*!" 6-%9 >$$;. %6
.$ -(,#!' +,-%*', 1-#!+$" 4.+- (+. !" #!"$<$./ M%>$A$-: +,$-$ -$ +>%
1-%4&$9. 7%* 9 7 $!(%*!+$- #! +,#. -$ / L!$ #. +,$ & (; %6 *!"$-.+ !"#!'
%6 +$(,!%&%'7 !" ,%> #+ ( ! 4$ *.$" #! -$.$ -(,/ ?,$ %+,$- #. & (; %6
*!"$-.+ !"#!' 4%*+ ,%> ;!%>&$"'$ #. '$!$- +$" !" %-' !#N$" +,-%*',
+,$ *.$ %6 +%%&.: .*(, . 4.+- (+. !" #!"$<$.: #! %-"$- +% 9 ;$ #+ (($..#4&$/
6-!*" + 5!,%$+,#$% $%7!%4
INFORMATION RESEARCH
is is
communicated via
organized in
accessed through
!"#$ %& !'()*+&+ !' $#&,& ,-!)),. /#& & 0#1,!, 2' ,-!)), !, '2$ ,2 &$#!'"
*'!3*& $2 1 ,2(!1) ,(!&'(&, &+*(1$!2' 4 ,-!)), 15& %&(2 !'" ! 025$1'$ $2 $#&
(15&&5, 26 "51+*1$&, 1'+ $2 3*1)!$7 5&,&15(# !' "&'&51).
8'+&5"51+*1$& 1'+ 02,$"51+*1$& 5&,&15(# !, 1' !+&1) 20025$*'!$7 625
,*(# 0&5,2'1) $51',6&51%)& ,-!)), $2 %& 1(3*!5&+ 1'+ +&9&)20&+. :)$#2*"#
,&15(#!'" 1'+ 5&9!&;!'" 1 )!$&51$*5& +2 '2$ (29&5 $#& ;#2)& ,0&($5* 26
,-!)),< $#&7 +2 (29&5 ,2 & -&7 2'&,. /#&,& !'()*+&= $! & 1'1"& &'$<
25"1'!>1$!2' 26 1$&5!1),< (2 0*$&5 *,&< !'625 1$!2' #1'+)!'"< 2'?)!'&
,&15(#!'" 1'+ ;5!$!'".
!" #"$"%#&! %''#"()*&"$!*'
@$ !, '2$ 1' &1,7 1$$&5 $2 +& 2',$51$& $#& -!'+, 26 ,-!)), 1'+ 1%!)!$!&,
&A0&($&+ 26 1 (2 0&$&'$ 5&,&15(#&5 !' $#& 5&025$ 26 $#& 5&,&15(#. /#& ,-!)),
5&3*!5&+ 15& (2',!+&51%)& 1'+ 15& !'(5&1,!'")7 ,*%B&($ $2 +&$1!)&+ &91)*?
1$!2'. :, $#& 20025$*'!$!&, $2 *'+&5$1-& 5&,&15(# #19& &A01'+&+< ,2 $22
#1, $#& +& 1'+ 625 %&$$&5 1'+ ! 0529&+ &+*(1$!2' 1'+ $51!'!'" 625
5&,&15(#&5,. @' !$, 5&,02',& $2 $#&,& +& 1'+, $#& C(2'2 !( 1'+ D2(!1)
E&,&15(# F2*'(!) GCDEFH !' $#& 8I 052+*(&+ 1 ,&$ 26 "*!+&)!'&, ;#!(#
!'()*+& 1 '* %&5 26 %1,!( 05202,1), 625 5&,&15(# $51!'!'" ;#!(# 15&
!'$&'+&+ $2 052 2$& 3*1)!$7 5&,&15(#. /#& 62))2;!'" )!,$ !'+!(1$&, $#& $;2
%1,!( $70&, 26 ,-!)), 5&3*!5&+ 652 5&,&15(#&5,.
J F25& ,-!)), 1'+
1%!)!$!&,=
;#!)& $#& +!66&5&'(&, 1-& ,*%B&($ +!,(!0)!'&,
+!,$!'($!9&< $#&5& &A!,$, 1 (2 2' (25& 26 ,-!)),
1'+ 1$$!$*+&, ;#!(# 1)) 5&,&15(#&5, ,#2*)+
02,,&,, 1'+ ,#2*)+ %& 1%)& $2 100)7 !'
+!66&5&'$ ,!$*1$!2', ;!$# +!66&5&'$ $20!(, 1'+
052%)& ,.
J :%!)!$7 $2 !'$&"51$&
$#&257 1'+ &$#2+=
5&,&15(# 625 1)) +!,(!0)!'&, !'92)9&, 1' *'+&5?
,$1'+!'" 26 $#& !'$&55&)1$!2',#!0 %&$;&&'
$#&257< &$#2+ 1'+ 5&,&15(# +&,!"'< 051($!(1)
,-!)), 1'+ 015$!(*)15 &$#2+,< $#& -'2;)&+"&
%1,& 26 $#& ,*%B&($ 1'+ &$#2+2)2"!(1)
62*'+1$!2',.
K2$# 26 $#&,& 05202,1), (1)) 625 1 5&,&15(# $51!'!'" $#1$ &A02,&, $#&
1005&'$!(& $2 $#& 51'"& 26 "&'&51) 1(1+& !( 5&,&15(# ,-!)), 1'+ &A0&5$!,&
&A0&($&+ 26 1 0526&,,!2'1) 5&,&15(#&5. /#& 1(1+& !( ,-!)), 1'+ &A0&5$!,&
(2 2' $2 1)) ,*%B&($ L&)+, ;!$#!' $#& ,2(!1) ,(!&'(&, (1' %& "52*0&+ 1,
,#2;' !' /1%)& M.M G29&5)&16H.
@' 1++!$!2' $2 $#& (2 2' 1(1+& !( ,-!)), $#& CDEF "*!+&)!'&, 1),2
!+&'$!67 ,*%B&($?,0&(!L( ,-!)),< 1%!)!$!&, 1'+ -'2;)&+"& $2 %& &A0&($&+ 26
02,$"51+*1$& ,$*+&'$,. CA1 0)&, 26 $#&,& 625 $;2 ,*%B&($ 15&1,< )!'"*!,$!(,
1'+ ,2(!2)2"7< (1' %& ,&&' !' /1%)& M.N G0. OH.
G#(2= % $(1,&%16&, &,7(,@
*%+$, -.- /,',%&!" %&,%' 0#& 1", %))$(!%1(#2 #0 '3($$' %24 %+($(1(,'
5(1,&%16&, ',%&!" 8#& ,9%:)$,; $(+&%&< ',%&!"(2= %24 6', #0 %+'1&%!1' %24 (24,9,'>
%24 ,7%$6%1(#2 +(+$(#=&%)"(! !#2'1&6!1(#2> &,!#&4 3,,)(2=> 6', #0 ?* 0#& @#&4A
)&#!,''(2=B 4%1%+%','B #2A$(2, ',%&!"(2= %24 ,$,!1(! :%($> %24
1,!"2(C6,' 0#& 1", ,7%$6%1(#2 #0 &,',%&!"B (2!$64(2= &,0,&,,(2=B
&,7(,@(2= %24 %11&(+61(#2 #0 (4,%'.
/,',%&!" 4,'(=2 8#& ,9%:)$,; 0#&:6$%1(#2 #0 &,',%&!"%+$, )&#+$,:' %24 1&%2'$%1(#2
%24 '1&%1,=< (21# )&%!1(!%+$, &,',%&!" 4,'(=2'> (4,21(0<(2= &,$%1,4 @#&3 1#
&%1(#2%$(D, 1", 1#)(! %24 (4,21(0< % 0#!6'> #&=%2(D, 1(:,1%+$,'>
#&=%2(D, 4%1% %24 :%1,&(%$'> 624,&'1%24 %24 %))&,!(%1, 1",
(:)$(!%1(#2' #0 4(00,&,21 :,1"#4#$#=(!%$ 0#624%1(#2'> %24 "#@ 1#
4,%$ @(1" ,1"(!%$ %24 :#&%$ !#2'(4,&%1(#2' @"(!" :%< %&(',.
E&(1(2= %24 8#& ,9%:)$,; )$%22(2= @&(1(2=> '3($$' 0#& )&,)%&(2= %24 '6+:(11(2=
)&,',21(2= )%),&' 0#& )6+$(!%1(#2B !#20,&,2!,' %24 F#6&2%$'> 6', #0 &,0,&,2!,'B
!(1%1(#2 )&%!1(!,' %24 32#@$,4=, #0 !#)<&(="1> !#2'1&6!1(#2 %24
4,0,2!, #0 %&=6:,21'> $#=(!%$B !$,%& %24 !#",&,21 ,9)&,''(#2> %24
624,&'1%24(2= #0 1", 4('1(2!1(#2 +,1@,,2 !#2!$6'(#2' %24
&,!#::,24%1(#2'.
!"#$%&'"()
L&#! %+&%4+ ('+ ,(%(54+ &2 -&")/ ( %"+,+ &2 '+#+(',* 5.! !*(! ,(%(5"4"!: *(#
!& 5+ (,J."'+- N 2&' ")#!(),+< :&. ,())&! #"$%4: 0'"!+ ( J.+#!"&))("'+ (# "2
:&. ('+ 0'"!")/ ( #*&%%")/ 4"#!7 8 #&.)- 3)&04+-/+ &2 !*+ 0*&4+ '+#+(',*
!"#$ %&' ()*+ ,-./$#.0$1 20 1-"3$45 6027#$/,$ !0/ 16.##18 #.0,-.15.41 !0/ 124.2#2,9
!"# $"%&'&'( )#*+"&,$&!'* !- *.&//* %'0 %1&/&$&#* #2,#+$#0 -"!3 $4# "#*#%"+4 *$50#'$
:;<=>;) ;+) ?@.#212A@9 2B #.0,-.15.41 ;11-$1 2B 5@$2C9 42015C-45.20D AC2"#$E B2CE-#!5.20D !0/ $FA#!0!5.20G "!1.4 5@$E$1 $&,&D C$!#.1ED
E$05!#.1ED 02E.0!#.1ED $EA.C.4.1ED "$@!H.2-C.1E !0/ #2,.4.1EG 2052#2,.4!# !0/ $A.15$E2#2,.4!# .11-$1G
15!5-1 2B /!5! !0/ -1$ 2B .0B2CE!05 3-/,$E$051G C2#$ 2B B2CE!#.1EG !C,-E$05!5.20 !0/ 15!5-1 2B
$F!EA#$1G C$#!5.201@.A "$57$$0 5@$2C9 !0/ /!5!G 1$!C4@ B2C -0.H$C1!#1G ./$2#2,.4!# .EA#.4!5.201 2B
./$!#.I!5.20G 4-#5-C!# A!C5.!#.59G J-@0.!0 A!C!/.,E1&
*$1$!C4@ E$5@2/1 .0 K-!#.5!5.H$ E$5@2/1 -1$ 2B .0B2CE!051G !-/.2 !0/ H./$2 C$42C/.0,G A@20$5.4 !0/ 2C5@2,C!A@.4
)R+;R:R=S ?@.#212A@9 2B 5@$ >0/$C15!0/.0, 2B 5@$ E!32C !#5$C0!5.H$ A@.#212A@.4!# A21.5.201 B2C 5@$2C9 42015C-45.20D !AAC!.1!# !0/
124.!# 14.$04$1 5$15.0,D B2C $FA#!0!52C9 ,2!#1 2B 5@$2C.$1 !0/ B2C 5@$ -1$ 2B E2/$#1& >0/$C15!0/.0, 2B @27 H!C.2-1
A21.5.201 !BB$45 C$1$!C4@ /$1.,0D C$1$!C4@ 4@2.4$1D /!5!N42##$45.20 !0/ !0!#91.1 5$4@0.P-$1&
>0/$C15!0/.0, 2B 5@$ 5@$2C$5.4!# 4205$F5 2B C$1$!C4@G 5@$2C$5.4!# .11-$1 !0/ /$"!5$1 B2C 5@21$ $0,!,$/
.0 $EA.C.4!# 72C6G !0/ $H!#-!5.20 2B C$1$!C4@&
*$1$!C4@ /$1.,0 )5!,$1 !0/ AC24$11$1 .0 B2CE-#!5.0, C$1$!C4@!"#$ AC2"#$E1 !0/ 5C!01#!5.0, 5@$E .052 AC!45.4!# C$1$!C4@
/$1.,01& T!6.0, .0B2CE$/ 3-/,$E$051 !"2-5 $5@.4!# !0/ E2C!# .11-$1& >0/$C15!0/.0, 2B 5@$ -1$1 !0/
.EA#.4!5.201 2B8 $FA$C.E$05!# 15-/9G 1-CH$9 C$1$!C4@G 42EA!C!5.H$ 15-/.$1G #20,.5-/.0!# C$1$!C4@G
$5@02,C!A@9G 4!1$ 15-/.$1G C$A#.4!5.20 15-/.$1G $H!#-!5.20 C$1$!C4@G AC$/.45.20 !0/ !45.20 C$1$!C4@&
U!5! 42##$45.20 !0/ V7!C$0$11 2B C!0,$ 2B 12-C4$1D $&,&D !C4@.H!# !0/ @.152C.4!# /!5!G !,$049 C$42C/1G 2BQ4.!# 15!5.15.41G
!0!#91.1 A.452C.!# E!5$C.!#1G !0/ 5$F5-!# /!5!& J027#$/,$!"#$ 2B /!5!N42##$45.20 5$4@0.P-$1 "9 A!C5.4.A!05 !0/
020NA!C5.4.A!05 2"1$CH!5.20D $5@02,C!A@.4 Q$#/ 72C6D ,C2-A /.14-11.20D H!C.2-1 59A$1 2B .05$CH.$71 !0/
P-$15.200!.C$1D !0/ 5@C2-,@ -02"5C-1.H$ E$!1-C$1& T$5@2/1 2B C$42C/.0, /!5! 1-4@ !1 025$ 5!6.0,D
!-/.2 !0/ H./$2G /!5! 42/.0, !0/ ./$05.B9.0, C$#!5.201@.A1 "$57$$0 4204$A51WH!C.!"#$1G 5@$ AC.04.A#$1 2B
/$14C.A5.H$ !0/ .0B$C$05.!# 15!5.15.41 !0/ ".N !0/ E-#5.H!C.!5$ !0!#91.1G 5@$ 1915$E!5.4 !0!#91.1 2B 5$F5-!#
6
/!5! !0/ 25@$C P-!#.5!5.H$ E!5$C.!#1G !0/ -1$ 2B 42EA-5$C A!46!,$1 B2C /!5! E!0!,$E$05&
!"#$ % &"'()%'*)( )(+"(,
!"#$%% &% !$'(&!$) *+) ,"( +$$) -" (+)$!%-*+) ./$!$ )*-* #"00$#-&"+ 1-%
&+-" -/$ 20"3*0 &#-(!$ "4 ./*- ,"( *!$ )"&+25 6/&% 7$*+% 8+".&+2 /". -"
%-*-$ -/$ *&7% *+) "39$#-&:$% "4 ,"(! !$%$*!#/; )$1+$ ,"(! 7*9"! #"+#$ -%
*+) 7$-/")"0"2&#*0 *%%(7 -&"+%; " $!*-&"+*0&<$ = (- &+-" !*#-&#$> -/"%$
#"+#$ -% *+) *%%(7 -&"+% 3, #/""%&+2 *+ * !" !&*-$ -$#/+&'($ -" #"00$#-
)*-*; 8+". /". ,"( *!$ 2"&+2 -" #"00*-$ !$%(0-%; *+) %" "+5 ?"7 $-$+-
!$%$*!#/ -/$!$4"!$ !$'(&!$% -$#/+&#*0 8+".0$)2$5 6/$!$ &%; /".$:$!; *
)&44$!$+#$ 3$-.$$+ !")(#&+2 * &$#$ "4 #"7 $-$+- !$%$*!#/ *+) * &$#$ "4
!$%$*!#/ -/*- )$7"+%-!*-$% %#/"0*!%/& 5
@#/"0*!%/& &% "4-$+ -/"(2/- -" 3$ %"7$-/&+2 *#*)$7&# /&2/A3!". -, $%
)"5 B$ *!$ *00 4*7&0&*! .&-/ -/$ " (0*! &7*2$ "4 -/$ %#/"0*! *% "+$ "4 *+
*2$&+2 3$% $#-*#0$) 7*+ .&-/ (+8$7 - /*&!; )!$%%$) %/*33&0, &+ #"!)(!",
.&-/ * -/ "0) 0$*-/$!A3"(+) 3""8 &+ /*+)5 C*+, "4 ,"( 7*, 3$ *.*!$ "4
0*#$% "4 %#/"0*!%/& $ &-"7&<$) &+ -$0$:&%&"+ !"2!*77$% %(#/ *% !"#$
*+) &+ +":$0% %(#/ *% %"&'$#($)' *$+&#&,$'5 6/$ %(!!$*0 %(!!"(+)&+2% "4 -/$
DE3!&)2$ #"00$2$%; .&-/ -/$&! /&2/ -".$!%; -/$ "*8A#0*) 0&3!*!, 4(00 "4 3""8%
*+) 7*+(%#!& -%; *+) .&-/ -/$ %7$00 "4 )(%- *+) 0$*-/$!; *!$ #"77"+
&7*2$% "4 %#/"0*!0, 0*#$%5 C*+, (+&:$!%&-&$% )" /*:$ -!*)&-&"+*0 "*8A#0*)
0&3!*!&$%; 3(- 7*+, "-/$!% -")*, )" +"-5 F- &% 7"!$ #"77"+ 4"! (+&:$!%&-&$%
-" /*:$ 7")$!+ .$00 $'(& $) 0$*!+&+2 !$%"(!#$ #$+-!$% 3!&77&+2 .&-/
-$#/+"0"2,; -/*+ -" /*:$ !".% "4 3""8% "+ %/$0:$%5 @#/"0*!%/& &% *+
*#-&:&-,G &- &% %"7$-/&+2 * $!%"+ #*+ )"5 H"( )" +"- /*:$ -" 3$ "4 * #$!-*&+
%"#&*0 #0*%%; 2$+)$!; $-/+&# "!&2&+ "! -" /*:$ %(##$%%4(00, 9(7 $) ":$!
4"!7*0 $)(#*-&"+*0 /(!)0$%5 B$ #*+ %*, -/*- %#/"0*!0, *#-&:&-, $+#"7 *%%$%
*00 "4 -/$%$ *+) 7"!$5 @#/"0*!0, *#-&:&-, &% *3"(- 8+".&+2 /". -"G )"
#"7 $-$+- !$%$*!#/I !$*); &+-$! !$- *+) *+*0,%$ *!2(7$+-%I %,+-/$%&<$
&)$*% *+) 7*8$ #"++$#-&"+% *#!"%% )&%#& 0&+$%I .!&-$ *+) !$%$+- &)$*%
#0$*!0, *+) %,%-$7*-&#*00,I *+) (%$ ,"(! &7*2&+*-&"+5 J+)$! &++&+2 *00 "4
-/$%$ *!$ * +(73$! "4 3*%&# 2!"(+) !(0$%; ./&#/ .$ 0""8 *- &+ 7"!$ )$-*&0
&+ -/$ +$E- %$#-&"+5 K(- ./*- -/$, *7"(+- -" &% *+ *--&-()$ "4 7&+) -/*- &%
" $+ -" &)$*% *+) -" )&44$!$+- %-,0$% *+) -, $% "4 !$%$*!#/; *+) &% 4!$$ "4
!$9()&#$% *3"(- ./*- #"(+-% *% (%$4(0 !$%$*!#/ *+) ./*- -, $ "4 $!%"+
%/"(0) 3$ *00".$) -" )" !$%$*!#/5
L 8$, $0$7$+- -/*- 7*8$% 4"! 2"") %#/"0*!%/& &% &+-$2!*-&"+5 F+-$2!*-&"+
&% *3"(- 7*8&+2 #"++$#-&"+% 3$-.$$+ &)$*%; -/$"!&$% *+) $E $!&$+#$5 F- &%
*3"(- * 0,&+2 * 7$-/") "! 7$-/")"0"2, 4!"7 "+$ *!$* -" *+"-/$!G *3"(-
0*#&+2 %"7$ $ &%")$ &+-" * 0*!2$! -/$"!$-&#*0 4!*7$."!8; -/$!$3, !"A
:&)&+2 * +$. .*, "4 0""8&+2 *- -/*- /$+"7$+"+5 6/&% 7&2/- 7$*+
)!*.&+2 $0$7$+-% 4!"7 )&44$!$+- -/$"!&$% -" 4"!7 * +$. %,+-/$%&% "! -"
!":&)$ * +$. &+%&2/-5 F- 7&2/- *0%" 7$*+ !$A$E*7&+&+2 *+ $E&%-&+2 3"), "4
8+".0$)2$ &+ -/$ 0&2/- "4 * +$. )$:$0" 7$+-5 6/$ *#-&:&-, "4 %#/"0*!%/&
&%; -/$!$4"!$; *3"(- -/&+8&+2 %,%-$7*-&#*00,5 F- 7&2/- 7$*+ 4"!#&+2 +$.
-, "0"2&$% "+-" -/$ %-!(#-(!$ "4 8+".0$)2$ "! "+-" * -*8$+A4"!A2!*+-$)
$!% $#-&:$5 M&-/$! .*,; -/$ %#/"0*! $+)$*:"(!% -" &+-$! !$- *+) (+)$!A
%-*+)5 6/$ &+-$+- &% -" 7*8$ "-/$!% -/&+8 *3"(- *+) "%%&30, !$A$:*0(*-$
./*- -/$, /*:$ /&-/$!-" -*8$+ -" 3$ (+'($%-&"+*30$ 8+".0$)2$5 6/$!$4"!$;
!" #$%"&'%(&" &")$"* $+ &","'&-! .
>2# .# #%.'2#.- %" :2%"#4#. 3#4#3 *1 #M9#.&#+'#- & #M9#'"#/ "* )+/#."%8# %
.#4&#: *1 "2# 3&"#.%").# &+ "2#&. <#3/5 X+/#.,.%/)%"# .# #%.'2&+, 1*. %
"2# & *. /& #."%"&*+ %.# #M9#'"#/ "* 2*: 1%$&3&%.&"! :&"2 "2#&. "*9&'5
X )%33! "2& "%8# "2# 1*.$ *1 % )$$%.! *1 "2# 3&"#.%").# :2&'2 /#$*+=
".%"# "2# 8&33 "* #%.'2 *+ % );Y#'"- '*$9&3# %'').%"# %+/ '*+ & "#+"
;&;3&*,.%92&# %+/ )$$%.&0# 8#! &/#% 2*:&+, % '.&"&'%3 %:%.#+# 5
>2#! %.# #M9#'"#/ "* :#&,2 )9 "2# '*+".&;)"&*+ "2%" 9%."&')3%. &/#% -
9* &"&*+ *. %99.*%'2# 2%4# $%/# "* "2#&. "*9&'5 T+ 2*."- "2#! %.#
.#()&.#/ "* /#$*+ ".%"#- *+ "2# *+# 2%+/- 3&;.%.! %+/ &+1*.$%"&*+ 8&33 -
%+/ *+ "2# *"2#.- "2# &+"#33#'")%3 '%9%;&3&"! "* Y) "&1! /#'& &*+ *+ "2#
'2*&'# *1 .#3#4%+" &/#% %+/ "2# %;&3&"! "* % # "2# 4%3)# *1 "2* # &/#% &+
'*+"#M"5
X+/#.,.%/)%"# :2* $*4# *+ "* 9* ",.%/)%"# .# #%.'2 <+/ "2%" #M9#'=
"%"&*+ '2%+,#5 >2# '*9#- ;.#%/"2 %+/ /#9"2 *1 "2# 3&"#.%").# #%.'2
&+'.#% # 5 >2# .# #%.'2 ")/#+" & #M9#'"#/ "* #%.'2 $*.# :&/#3!- %'.*
/& '&93&+# - %+/ &+ ,.#%"#. /#"%&3 "2%+ %" )+/#.,.%/)%"# 3#4#35 >2# %$*)+"
-!%$) ' .%(,+'(#+, +,/%,0
! "#$%&'#( ')%*$'+%) '*,&%#-%- $.% #" /*$ ! &%#)'*0 $.% &%-%#&,.%& .#- $
) 1 2* #))'$' *3 &%#)'*0 "#$%&'#(- #,& -- -%4%&#( )'-,'5('*%- ,#* 6% )'!+,/($
6%,#/-% ! $.% )'!!%&%*$ -$7(%- '* 8.',. 4#&' /- )'-,'5('*%- 5&%-%*$ ')%#-1
9(- 3 $.% 4 ,#6/(#&'%- ! )'!!%&%*$ -/6:%,$- #*) 8.#$ #&% $#;%* $ 6% $.%
, &%3 &%-%#&,.#6(% 5& 6(%"- ! & # 5#&$',/(#& )'-,'5('*% , *-$'$/$% !/&$.%&
)'!+,/($'%-1 < & %=#"5(%3 $.% -$/)%*$ ! "#*#0%"%*$ "#7 6% $ $#((7
/*!#"'('#& 8'$. $.% 4%&6 -% #*) -%%"'*0(7 , "" *-%*-% -$7(% !3 -#73
- ,' ( 071 > *4%&-%(73 $.%7 "#7 +*) $.% 0 '*0 (%-- )'!+,/($ '! !#,%) 8'$.
#)4#*,%) - ,'#( -$#$'-$',-1 ?.% &%-/($ "#7 6% $.% )'-"'--#( ! $.% 4%&6 -%
-$7(% #*) #)"'&#$' * ! $.% */"%&',#( ! &"/(#%1 ?.% #,,%5$#*,% ! *%
-$7(% 4%& #* $.%& '- !$%* )/% $ )'-,'5('*#&7 , "5#&$"%*$#('@#$' *1
A#*#0%"%*$ -$/)%*$- "'0.$ 6% %=5%,$%) $ 6% " &% !#"'('#& 8'$. -$#$'-$',-
$.#* 8'$. - ,'#( $.% &'%-1 ?.%7 "'0.$ #(- .#4% # " &% 5�"#$', #$$'$/)%3
'*B/%*,'*0 $.%" $ !#4 /& ,(#&'$7 #*) -/,,'*,$*%--1 9- # , *-%C/%*,%3
5 $%*$'#((7 '*$%&%-$'*0 #*) &%(%4#*$ ')%#- "'0.$ 6% "'--%)1
D/& )'-,/--' * - !#& .#- 6%%* #6 /$ $.% ;'*)- ! #--/"5$' *- $.#$
"'0.$ .%(5 4%&, "% )'-,'5('*#&7 , "5#&$"%*$#('@#$' * #*) - %*, /�%
,& --E)'-,'5('*#&7 /*)%&-$#*)'*01 2* 5&#,$',%3 $.'- #))&%--%- $8 "#'*
!%#$/&%- ! #,#)%"', &%-%#&,.F *% '- $.% ,%*$&#( 5(#,% #&0/"%*$ .#- '*
#,#)%"', 8 &;3 #*) $.% $.%& '- $.% *%%) $ 6% 5%*E"'*)%) 8.%* &%#)'*0
$.% 8 &; ! $.%& 5% 5(%1 G% ( ; " &% ,( -%(7 * 8 #$ %#,. ! $.%-% '*
$/&*1
!"#$# %&&!&'#$ ()* &+$ )$,!$-$). /##$# &* &+!01 &+$)$ !0 *(&$" % 2%34 *(
$562!3!&"$007 !& !0 )%)$ &* 8"# %" %33*'"& *( % 6!$3$ *( )$0$%)3+ &+%&
090&$ %&!3%229 2%90 *'& -+%& -%0 #*"$1 -+9 !& -%0 #*"$ %"# #!03'00$0 &+$
,%)!*'0 ! 62!3%&!*"0 *( &+*0$ 3+*!3$0. :+$ )$,!$-$) "$$#0 &* %66)$3!%&$
0* $ *( &+$ )$%0*"0 (*) &+$ 2%34 *( $562!3!&"$00. ;!)0&1 !& &%4$0 3*"0!#$)%<2$
$((*)& %"# &! $ &* $56)$00 !#$%0 !" -)!&!"=. >$3*"#291 2! !&%&!*"0 62%3$# *"
06%3$ *) -*)# 3*'"&0 *(&$" )$0'2& !" $#!&!"= "*& #$$ $# !#$%2 <9 &+$
%'&+*). /20*1 <$!"= $562!3!& $56*0$0 &+$ )$0$%)3+ ?%"# )$0$%)3+$)@ &* 3)!&!3%2
!"06$3&!*". A)$0' %<291 %"9 %<2$ )$0$%)3+$)0 #* "*& 6'<2!0+ -!#$29 0* %0
&* %,*!# 0'3+ 3)!&!3!0 .
<') 46"&#.$ "5 *"/$ 6)/) 6.' -/ /"*) 5"6* "5 (6-$$)% .."#%$8 5"6 )3 *4+)8
% 6$-.+)8 6)4"6$8 &-//)6$ $-"% "6 ."%5)6)%.) 4 4)61 <') &-//)*-% $-"% "5
/#.' ;%&-%,/ -/ -*4"6$ %$ !). #/) $') 4#64"/) "5 6)/) 6.' -/ $" ."%$6-!#$)
-% /"*) ( 0 $" "#6 #%&)6/$ %&-%, "5 $') ("6+&1 <'-/ . %%"$ !) &"%) -5
6)/) 6.' ;%&-%,/ 6) %"$ /' 6)&1 <') 4#!+-. @ -+ !-+-$0 "5 6)/) 6.'
;%&-%,/ *) %/ $' $ .."#%$/ "5 6)/) 6.' 6) 6)."%/$6#.$)& >/$"6-)/E D $'"/)
/)6)%&-4-$"#/8 "5$)% .' "$-.8 56 ,*)%$)& %& ."%$-%,)%$ /4).$/ "5 *"/$
6)/) 6.' A$') @)60 $'-%,/ $' $ * 7) 6)/) 6.' .' ++)%,-%,NC ('-.' &" %"$
;%& $')-6 ( 0 -%$" $') 5"6* + .."#%$1 O) $')6)5"6) %))& $" ,)$ % -%-$- +
#%&)6/$ %&-%, "5 (' $ $') 6"+) "5 $') +-$)6 $#6) 6)@-)( -/ %& (')6) -$ ;$/
-%$" $') $')/-/ "6 &-//)6$ $-"%1
<') /$6#.$#6) "5 $') 5"6* + 6)4"6$ 5"6 *"/$ 6)/) 6.' -/ /$ %& 6&-L)& %&
* %0 "5 $') /).$-"%/ 5"#%& -% 6)4"6$ 6) +/" 5"#%& -% 46"4"/ + 5"6
6)/) 6.' A/)) < !+) F1P "@)6+) 5 C1 <') 5#++ 66 %,)*)%$ 5"6 $') 6)/) 6.'
46"4"/ + -/ /'"(% -% 244)%&-3 F1 O-$'-% $'-/ 66 %,)*)%$ $') #$'"6 "5
$') .."#%$ #/# ++0 )*4+"0/ 6 %,) "5 /$0+-/$-. ."%@)%$-"%/ $" &)*"%/$6 $)
$') #$'"6-$0 %& +),-$-* .0 "5 $')-6 6)/) 6.' %& $' $ $') 46"Q).$ ' / !))%
#%&)6$ 7)% -% ( 0 $' $ -/ 6-,"6"#/ %& ."*4)$)%$1
!" $'&"6+&/6" 6",'"5 ') 6"#"+6%! 23
+-$" ;:< =(0" #"%&'()# %(00()$> *(/). ') -(&! + 6"#"+6%!
26(2(#+$ +). 6"2(6&
.!/%$&# 0$1
?)&6(./%&'() ( #!(5 &!" +'0#4 (-@"%&',"#4 #%(2"4 6+&'()+$" +). ."#'9) *"+&/6"# (*
&!" 6"#"+6%!: !" 6+&'()+$" '# /#/+$$> #/22(6&". -> 6"*"6")%"# &(
(&!"6 5(6A# 5!'%! !+," +$6"+.> '.")&'7". &!" -6(+. )+&/6" (* &!"
26(-$"0:
B'&"6+&/6" 6",'"5 ( ."0()#&6+&" #A'$$# ') $'-6+6> #"+6%!')9C &( #!(5 %(00+). (* &!"
#/-@"%& +6"+ +). /)."6#&+).')9 (* &!" 26(-$"0C &( @/#&'*> &!"
6"#"+6%! &(2'%4 ."#'9) +). 0"&!(.($(9>:
D"&!(.($(9> ( #!(5 &!" +226(26'+&")"## (* &!" &"%!)'E/"# /#". &( 9+&!"6 .+&+
+). &!" 0"&!(.($(9'%+$ +226(+%!"# "02$(>".: F"$",+)& 6"*"6")%"#
*6(0 &!" $'&"6+&/6" +6" (*&") /#". &( #!(5 +) /)."6#&+).')9 (* .+&+G
%($$"%&'() &"%!)'E/"# +). 0"&!(.($(9'%+$ '02$'%+&'()#4 +). &( @/#&'*>
&!"'6 /#" (,"6 +$&"6)+&'," &"%!)'E/"#:
!"# $%&'( )*+ ,"- .%/ 0(( 12%1 12( !(34(5 "6 !('%1(7 '41(!%1-!( 40 %/
(00(/14%' 8%!1 "6 12( !(0(%!.2 8!".(00 %/7 12( !(0(%!.2 !(8"!1 9 41 40 #"!(
12%/ % :-01 01%;( 1" &( -/7(!1%<(/ "! % 2-!7'( 1" &( "3(!."#(* 4;-!( )*=
>8* )?@ 02"50 0"#( "6 12( A-(014"/0 12%1 ,"- 54'' &( %&'( 1" %/05(! 6!"#
-/7(!1%<4/; % '41(!%1-!( !(34(5 "/ ,"-! 1"84.*
$2( '41(!%1-!( !(34(5 40 4/1(;!%' 1" 12( 0-..(00 "6 %.%7(#4. !(0(%!.2* B
#%:"! &(/(C1 "6 12( !(34(5 40 12%1 41 (/0-!(0 12( !(0(%!.2%&4'41, "6 ,"-!
1"84. &(6"!( D8!"8(!E !(0(%!.2 ."##(/.(0* B'' 1"" "61(/ 01-7(/10 /(5 1"
!(0(%!.2 (A-%1( 12( &!(%712 "6 12(4! !(0(%!.2 5412 410 3%'-(* F/414%' (/12-04G
%0#H ."#&4/(7 5412 1240 ."##"/ #40."/.(814"/H "61(/ !(0-'10 4/ &!"%7H
;(/(!%'4I(7 %/7 %#&414"-0 8!"8"0%'0* F1 40 12( 8!";!(0043( !""#$% & "6 12(
1"84.H 12!"-;2 12( '41(!%1-!( !(34(5H 12%1 #%<(0 #"01 !(0(%!.2 % 8!%.14.%'
."/047(!%14"/*
J%!!"54/; 7"5/ % 1"84. .%/ &( 746C.-'1 %/7 .%/ 1%<( 0(3(!%' 5((<0 "!
(3(/ #"/120H &-1 41 7"(0 #(%/ 12%1 12( !(0(%!.2 40 #"!( '4<(', 1" &(
."#8'(1(7* F1 %'0" ."/1!4&-1(0 1" 12( 7(3('"8#(/1 "6 ,"-! 4/1(''(.1-%'
.%8%.41, %/7 8!%.14.%' 0<4''0H &(.%-0( 41 (/;(/7(!0 % !(0(%!.2 %1141-7( %/7
54'' (/."-!%;( ,"- 1" 124/< !4;"!"-0', %&"-1 ,"-! 1"84. %/7 52%1 !(0(%!.2
,"- .%/ 7" "/ 41 4/ 12( 14#( ,"- 2%3( %3%4'%&'(* $4#( %/7 (66"!1 .%!(6-'',
(K8(/7(7 %1 1240 (%!', 01%;( .%/ 0%3( % ;!(%1 7(%' "6 (66"!1 %/7 3%;-(
0(%!.24/; '%1(!*
Literature search
and review on your topic
)*+,'" -./ 01#" 12 &!" 3,"%&*14% &!" '"5*"6 12 &!" 7*&"'$&,'" 8$4
$4%6"'
9 :# 00 +'1#"'; "& 0+ $"3%3 ! + '.% &'13%#' ' 3%&"(# )#3 4)++; 1' )
&17&')#'")/ 0"%4% ! "#$%&'"()'"$% * +, "# ) &17<%4'=&0%4">4 3"&4"0/"#%8
?.% +%$"%* ! +%/)'%3 )#3 +%/%$)#' /"'%+)'1+% *"// 7% $%+; "50 +')#' '
'.% +%&%)+4. *.%'.%+ "# '.% >%/3 + !+ 5 ) 3%&,8
@ :# 00 +'1#"'; "& 0+ $"3%3 ' '),% ) ' 0"4 )#3- '.+ 1(. ) &%)+4. )#3
)#)/;&"& ! '.% /"'%+)'1+%- ! 41& "' ' ) +%&%)+4.)7/% ' 0"48 ?."& 01'& ' '.%
'%&' '.% &'13%#'A& )7"/"'; ' &%)+4. ! + )#3 5)#)(% +%/%$)#' '%B'& )#3
5)'%+")/& )#3 ' "#'%+0+%' )#)/;'"4)//; "3%)& )#3 3)')8
C :# 00 +'1#"'; "& 0+ $"3%3 ! + '.% &'13%#' ' +%4 (#"D% '.% &'+14'1+% !
$)+" 1& )+(15%#'& )#3 ' 0+ $"3% 4 (%#'- +%)& #%3 )#3 7<%4'"$%
%$)/1)'"$% )#)/;&"&8 ?."& 01'& ' '.% '%&' '.% )7"/"'; ' "#'%(+)'% )#3
%$)/1)'% "3%)&8
:& '.% 0+ 314' ! ; 1+ '"5% )#3 +%&%)+4. '.% 5)&'%+A& '.%&"& 2*."4. )'
5)&'%+A& /%$%/ 5); )/& 7% 4)//%3 '.% !""#$%&%!'(6 "& ) /%)+#"#( )4'"$"';8 ?.%
"#'%#' ! '.% )4'"$"'; "& '.)' ; 1 )4E1"+% ) +)#(% ! &,"//& )' )# )00+ 0+")'%
/%$%/ '.)' )+% +%/)'%3 ' 3 "#( 4)0)7/% )#3 4 50%'%#' +%&%)+4.8 ?.% '.%&"& "&
'.% %$"3%#4% '.)' ; 1 .)$% )4E1"+%3 '.% #%4%&&)+; &,"//& )#3 4)# '.%+%! +%
7% )44+%3"'%3 )& ) 4 50%'%#' +%&%)+4.%+8 ?.% ,"#3& ! &,"//& #%%3%3 )+%
'. &% )&& 4")'%3 *"'. +%&%)+4. 3%&"(#- 3)') 4 //%4'" #- "#! +5)'" # 5)#)(%=
5%#'- )#)/;&"& ! 3)')- &;#'.%&"& ! 3)') *"'. %B"&'"#( ,# */%3(% )#3
%$)/1)'" # ! %B"&'"#( "3%)& )/ #( *"'. ) 4+"'"4)/ %$)/1)'" # ! ; 1+ *#
* +,8 F% *"// / , )' '.%&% "50 +')#' 0 "#'& "# 5 +% 3%')"/ "# ) 5 5%#'8
G%5%57%+ '.)' ; 1+ '.%&"& "& '.% #/; 00 +'1#"'; ; 1 *"// .)$% '
3%5 #&'+)'% ; 1+ )7"/"'; ' )00/; '.%&% &,"//& ' ) 0)+'"41/)+ ' 0"4H '."&
/#"%+ * .")'!*)$!' !',"'0
E$+?-3-#-0C !/3 3!+! (?-*7$ -, 1$+?-3-#-0C $>;#!*/$3 */ E$+?-3-#-0C 3$.7)*"$3 "9+ /-+ */ L- $>;#!/!+*-/ -, +?$ 1$+?-3-#-0C5
7-##$7+*-/ 7-1;!)!+*8$ +$)1. .?-@*/0 7-1;!)!+*8$ +$)1.J .- /- *+. 7?-*7$ -) !;;)-;)*!+$/$.. ,-) +?$
7-/.*3$)!"#$ $8*3$/7$ -, )$!3*/0 $>;#!/!+*-/ 0*8$/ ,-) 7?-*7$.J )$.$!)7?& L- */3*7!+*-/ -, )$!3*/0
!/3 9/3$).+!/3*/0& F8$)!## )$.$!)7? /$8$)+?$#$..5 !/ !;;)-;)*!+$ -/ 1$+?-3-#-0C -) 3!+!H7-##$7+*-/
3$.*0/ !"9/3!/+#C 7#$!) !/3 #-0*7!# 1$+?-3-#-0C $1;#-C$3& K$.$!)7? +$7?/*I9$.5 .- /- 3$1-/.+)!+*-/ -,
,-) +?$ .+93$/+ +- !;;#C& A+)$/0+?. +$7?/*I9$. 7#$!) !/3 .9*+!"#$ ,-) +?$ !"*#*+C +- 7-##$7+ 3!+! */ ! .C.+$1!+*7
!/3 @$!D/$..$. */ ;)$8*-9.#C 9.$3 +-;*7& E!C ?!8$ )$;#*7!+$3 @!C& L- -8$)!## )$.$!)7? 3$.*0/&
1$+?-3-#-0*$.G3!+!H7-##$7+*-/ @$!D/$..$. -) "*!. */?$)$/+ */
+$7?/*I9$. !)$ )$7-0/*<$3 !/3 3$!#+ ;)$8*-9. @-)D -/ +?$ +-;*7&
@*+?&
M*+$)!+9)$ )$8*$@ !/3 ?-)-90? )$8*$@ -, +?$ )$#$8!/+ K$8*$@ -, +?$ 1!*/ #*+$)!+9)$ @*+? L- )$8*$@ -, +?$ #*+$)!+9)$J
$8!#9!+*-/ #*+$)!+9)$J .C.+$1!+*7!##C !/!#C.$3 1!*/ 8!)*!"#$. !/3 !)091$/+. !//-+!+*-/. -, .-1$ *+$1. "9+ /-
!/3 !## 1!*/ 8!)*!"#$. !/3 *3$/+*:$3& A-1$ #*/D. 1!3$ +- !++$1;+ !+ ! 7)*+*7!# $8!#9!+*-/5
!)091$/+. *3$/+*:$3& ()*+*7!# 1$+?-3-#-0C !/3 69.+*:7!+*-/& +?$)$,-)$ /- !)091$/+. -) D$C
$8!#9!+*-/ :)1#C #*/D$3 +- 8!)*!"#$. *3$/+*:$3 )$#$8!/+ +- +?$
69.+*:7!+*-/ !/3 1$+?-3-#-0C& +-;*7& L- "*"#*-0)!;?C -) +-- #!)0$ !
"*"#*-0)!;?C +- ?!8$ "$$/ 9.$3&
7-/+*/9$3 -8$)#$!,
87
87
!"#$ %&' ()*+,-+.$/ 0
!"#$$#%& '%( ()*&)%"&)+# ,-./ 0-12#&#%& ,-./ 3)4%)5"'%&$6 (#5")#%& ,-./
1,2#$ !+/ 34$5$+,!,-*+6 ;#$!4 !+/ )*8$5-<$ 5,4.),.4$& =$42 ;#$!4 5,4.),.4$ !+/ !44!+7$:$+, *9 1,4.),.4$/ 34$5$+,!,-*+ "., <$42
-+)#./-+7 ,8$ .5$ *9 >$## 34$5$+,$/ >-,8 !)).4!,$ :!,$4-!#5 >-,8 !)).4!,$ )-,!,-*+56 ,8-+ *+ 5."5,!+,-<$ )*+,$+,&
74!38-) :!,$4-!#5 )-,!,-*+5 !+/ "-"#-*74!382& !334*34-!,$ .5$ *9 <-5.!# !+/ ;-,!,-*+5 :*5,#2 )*44$), "., +*,
?:34$55-<$ .5$ *9 <-5.!# !+/ 74!38-) 74!38-) /$<-)$5& )*+5-5,$+,& B-,,#$ $<-/$+)$ *9
/$<-)$56 !+/ $99$),-<$ !44!+7$:$+, ,8*.78, !"*., ,8$ .5$ *9 <-5.!# *4
*9 :!,$4-!#5& @)).4!,$ !+/ 34*3$4 74!38-) /$<-)$5& 1#*332 .5$ *9
.5$ *9 A+7#-586 $:3#*2-+7 5)8*#!4#2 #!+7.!7$&
)*+<$+,-*+5&
!"# $!#%& '()* )* +*,+-).// 0(+ -.*+ $)0( 0(+ *+.#-( !1 0(+ /)0+#.0"#+&
23)0)./ *+.#-( *0#.0+4)+* 5. 3!0 #+6+./ $(.0 !" 5)4(0 (.6+ $.30+78 !"
0(+#+1!#+ 3++7 0! 9+ :+;)9/+ .37 *+.#-( 5!#+ $)7+/ !# "*+ 5!#+ -!5,/+;
-!59)3.0)!3* !1 $!#7* .37 ,(#.*+*& <+#*)*0+3-+ ./*! 5+.3* 9+)34 0(!#!"4(
)3 !"# *+.#-(8 9 5.%)34 7+0.)/+7 #+-!#7* !1 (!$ !" 5.3.4+7 0(+
.75)3)*0#.0)!3 !1 0(+ .-0)6)0 & '()* )* 9+-."*+ . -!5,#+(+3*)6+ *+.#-( 1!#
0(+ /)0+#.0"#+ !3 . 0!,)- )* 6+# 5"-( . 5.00+# !1 5.3.4)34 0(+ .75)3=
)*0#.0)!3 !1 *+.#-( *(++0*> #+-!#7*> 7.0.9.*+*> #+1+#+3-+* /!-.0+7> )0+5*
!90.)3+7 .37 0(!*+ !#7+#+7 1#!5 0(+ /)9#.# > .37 *! !3& '(+ "*+ !1 .//
#+/+6.30 *!"#-+* .37 #+*!"#-+* )* 0(+#+1!#+ #+?")#+7 0! 9+ *(!$3 )3 !"#
0(+*)*& '()* -.3 9+ $#)00+3 ", )3 0(+ 5+0(!7!/!4 -(.,0+# !# 0(+ #+6)+$ !1
0(+ /)0+#.0"#+&
!"#!$% #! &'( )*!&(+& *, -.(/#*0% 1*.23 4* "* &'(%( &'#!$% #! 5 156 &'5& #%
%)'*75.76 "(85!"% (,,()&#/( 85!5$(8(!& *, &'( .(%(5.)'3 9 %0885.6 *,
&'( %&5!"5."% .(:0#.(" #% $#/(! #! 9--(!"#+ ;3
!" #$%&$'(&"
4'(.( 5--(5. &* <( %(/(! 85#! .(:0#.(8(!&%= $(!(.5776 5$.((" 5).*%% &'(
5)5"(8#) -.*,(%%#*!= )*/(.#!$ &'( )*!&(!&= -.*)(%% 5!" -.*"0)& *, 5
"*)&*.57 &'(%#%3 4'(%( 5.(>
? %-()#57#@5&#*! #! %)'*75.%'#-A
B 852#!$ 5 !(1 )*!&.#<0&#*! &* 5! 5.(5 *, 2!*17("$(A
; "(8*!%&.5&#!$ 5 '#$' 7(/(7 *, %)'*75.%'#-A
C "(8*!%&.5&#!$ *.#$#!57#&6A
D &'( 5<#7#&6 &* 1.#&( 5 )*'(.(!& /*708( *, #!&(77()&05776 "(85!"#!$ 1*.2
*, 5 %#$!# )5!& 7(!$&'A
E &'( 5<#7#&6 &* "(/(7*- &'( )5-5)#&6 5!" -(.%*!57 )'5.5)&(. &* #!&(7F
7()&05776 85!5$( &'( .(%(5.)'= #!)70"#!$ &'( 1.#&#!$ *, &'( &'(%#%A
G %'*1#!$ #!F"(-&' 0!"(.%&5!"#!$ *, &'( &*-#) 5.(5 5!" 1*.2 .(75&(" &*
&'( .(%(5.)'3
H( 8#$'& 57%* 5"" 5! (#$'&' ).#&(.#*!A *!( 8*.( %-()# ) &* &'( "*)&*.57
/#/5>
I "(,(!"#!$ *.5776 1'5& 15% -.*"0)(" #! &(.8% *, &'( .(5%*! ,*. "*#!$
&'( .(%(5.)' 5!" )'*#)(% */(. &'( 156 #& 15% "*!(3
4'(%( %&5&(8(!&% "* !*& )5-&0.( &'( %)*-( 5!" "(-&' *, 577 "*)&*.57
.(%(5.)'3 4'(6 "*= '*1(/(.= -.*/#"( 5 %(& *, .(:0#.(8(!&% 1'#)' %'*1 &'(
).0)#57 #8-*.&5!)( *, &'( 7#&(.5&0.( .(/#(1 #! &'( .(%(5.)' -.*)(%% 5!" #!
&'( )*!&(!& *, &'( &'(%#% #&%(7,3 4'( .%& &'.(( %'*1 &'( #!-0& &'5& )5! <(
85"( <6 5 &'*.*0$' %(5.)' 5!" .(5"#!$ *, .(75&(" 7#&(.5&0.(3 J& #% &'(%(=
&*$(&'(. 1#&' "(8*!%&.5&#!$ *.#$#!57#&6= &'5& 1#77 !*1 <( "#%)0%%("3
)*"%+(,+-(&+$. 97&'*0$' %*8( 0!#/(.%#&#(% 577*1 )5!"#"5&(% &* (!.*77 ,*.
'#$'(. "($.((% 1#&'*0& 5 .%& "($.(( &'( 8*"(7 0%(" '(.( 5%%08(% 5!
5)5"(8#) )5.((. #! 1'#)' %)'*75.%'#- #% "(/(7*-8(!&57 5!" !*& )*!/(6("
&'.*0$' 5 &#&7(3 4'5& )5.((. !*.85776 )*!%#%&% *, 5 .%& "($.(( ,*77*1(" <6
-*%&$.5"05&( 1*.2= <*&' *, 1'#)' )5! <( ,077F( *. -5.&F( %&0"63
4'.*0$' 5! 5)5"(8#) )5.((. 5 %&0"(!& $.5"05776 5):0#.(% 5 )08075&#/(
.5!$( *, %2#77% 5!" 5<#7#&#(%= 5!" ,*)0%(% &'(#. 7(5.!#!$ *! 5 %0<K()&F%-()# )
2!*17("$(3 4'( 5/5#75<#7#&6 *, )'*#)( *, "($.(( 5!" *-&#*!% 1#&'#! "($.((%
8(5!% &'5& %0<K()& %-()#57#@5&#*! *, %*8( ,*.8 #% #!(/#&5<7(3 J! &(.8% *,
%2#77% 5!" 5<#7#&6 8*%& 0!"(.$.5"05&(% 5.( (+-()&(" &* 5):0#.( 5!" "(/(7*-
5 1#"( .5!$( *, -(.%*!57 &.5!%,(.5<7( %2#77%3 L#$0.( 9C3? #! 9--(!"#+ C
$#/(% 5! #!"#)5&#*! *, &'( #!,*.85&#*! 85!5$(8(!& &5%2 #!/*7/(" #!
./& 0#*&+!*-+& +&1#&' #$ +&2&!+(/
!"#!$#%& ' (#)! ')* !+ ,--!%.#/ 0 '(12 #%3(*.!1 &*#.'%3! 2% 42$ )2
5'%'&! )4! )!34%#3'( !(!5!%)1 26 )4! !"#!$7
84! '$ 5')! #'(19 62 *%.! & '.*')! $2 :9 32552%(; #% )4! 62 5 26
' )#3(!1 6 25 <2* %'(19 -! #2.#3'(19 '%)42(2&#!1 '%. 52%2& '-419 ' ! )4!
#.!'1 26 2)4! -!2-(!9 *1*'((; )4! =62*%.#%& )4!2 #1)1> '%. =3* !%) %2)'?(!1>
26 )4! .#13#-(#%!7 @% 2 .! )2 *%.! 1)'%. )4! 1-!3#A31 26 )4! 1*?<!3)9 #) #1
!11!%)#'( )4') )4! *%.! & '.*')! 325!1 )2 )! 51 $#)4 )4! #.!'1 26 )4!
62*%.#%& )4!2 #1)1 '%. 3* !%) %2)'?(!17 B%(; $4!% )4!; 4'"! .2%! )4#1
$#(( )4!; 4'"! 1*6A3#!%) 1*?<!3) :%2$(!.&! )2 ?! '?(! )2 )'(: 324! !%)(;
'?2*) '%. ?!&#% )2 '%'(;1! 3 #)#3'((; )4! #.!'1 26 )4! 1*?<!3)7 84#1 5!'%1
.!52%1) ')#%& 325- !4!%1#2% 26 )4! )2-#3 '%. )4! '()! %')#"! 5!)42.2(C
2&#!1 )4') 3'% ?! *1!. 62 #)1 #%"!1)#&')#2%7
D4#(! #) 5#&4) ?! -211#?(! )2 !'34 ' (!"!( 26 '."'%3!. 1)'%.#%& $#)42*)
'% '-- 2- #')! #%)!((!3)*'( '-- !%)#3!14#-9 )4! '3'.!5#3 3' !! #1 (#:!(; )2
?! ' 52 ! !(#'?(! 5!)42. 26 '3E*# #%& )4! #%C.!-)4 :%2$(!.&! .!5'%.!.
26 ' .23)2 '( 1)*.!%)7 84! ! ' ! 12*%. '3'.!5#3 !'12%1 62 )4! '3'.!5#3
3' !! '1 - !-' ')#2% 62 4#&4! .!& !!1 !1!' 347 84! '?#(#); '%. 3'-'3#);
)2 5'%'&! 32&%#)#"!(; 5'11#"! '52*%)1 26 #%62 5')#2%9 -('; $#)4 '?1) '3)
#.!'1 '%. )4!2 #!1 '%. 4'"! #%1#&4)1 #1 *1*'((; &'#%!. )4 2*&4 #%)!%1#"!
'3'.!5#3 $2 : '%. %2) 142 )C)! 59 . 2-C#% - 2& '55!19 2 )4! - 2.*3)#2%
26 233'1#2%'( -*?(#3')#2%17
!"#$%&'(&)$* ( +)*+ ,!-!, #. %/+#,('%+)0 ?" 0' 1,;' (!&'+ ',3%#'3: &1'
&1'"#" #" &1' !(%4 &,(*#$%' ';#+'(9' !7 &1' 0!3/ ,(+ '77!3& &1,& 1," *!('
#(&! &1' 3'"',391- @!3 &1#" 3',"!( #& (''+" &! 3!;#+' '(!5*1 ';#+'(9': !7
&1' 3#*1& &4 ' ,(+ #( ,( , 3! 3#,&' 7!32: &! +'2!("&3,&' &1,& &1' +'"#3'+
%';'% !7 "91!%,3"1# 1," $''( ,91#';'+- ? /'4 ,3& !7 &1' &1'"#" 01#91
#%%5"&3,&'" "91!%,3"1# #" &1' 3';#'0 !7 &1' %#&'3,&53'- <& #" #( &1#" "'9&#!( &1,&
&1' $,%,(9' ,(+ %';'% !7 #(&'%%'9&5,% "/#%%" ,(+ ,$#%#&#'" 9,( $' 75%%4
+#" %,4'+ 7!3 "935&#(4 ,(+ ,""'""2'(&-
=1' 3';#'0 91, &'3 2#*1& 9!2 3#"' !(%4 AB &! CB ,*'": ," #( , +!9&!3,%
&1'"#": !3 DE &! FB #( , 2,"&'3G" &1'"#": ,%&1!5*1 &1' ,9&5,% %'(*&1 !7&'(
+' '(+" !( &1' (,&53' !7 &1' 3'"',391- =1'!34H$,"'+ 0!3/ &'(+" &! 3'>5#3'
, %!(*'3 3';#'0 &1,( '2 #3#9,% 0!3/- I#&1'3 0,4 &1#" #" , ;'34 "1!3& " ,9'
&! 9!;'3 ,%% &1,& #" 3'>5#3'+ ,(+ ') '9&'+- =4 #9,%%4: &1' 3';#'0 91, &'3 #"
,( '+#&'+ +!0( ;'3"#!( !7 &1' 2,""#;' ,2!5(& !7 (!&'" &,/'( 73!2
')&'("#;' 3',+#(*- =1' 2,&'3#,% !7 ,%% 3';#'0" 9!("#"&" !7 01,& 1," $''(
"',391'+: %!9,&'+: !$&,#('+ ,(+ 3',+: $5& #" 2591 2!3' &1,( "' ,3,&' #&'2"
!3 , $#$%#!*3, 14- =1' 3',+'3 !7 &1' &1'"#" #" $'#(* ,"/'+ &! "'' &1#"
%#&'3,&53' ," 3' 3'"'(&#(* &1' "52 &!&,% !7 9533'(& /(!0%'+*' !( &1' &! #9-
<& 25"& ,%"! +'2!("&3,&' &1' ,$#%#&4 &! &1#(/ 93#	,%%4 #( &'32" !7 ';,%5,&#(*
#+',": 2'&1!+!%!*#'" ,(+ &'91(#>5'" &! 9!%%'9& +,&,: ,(+ 3'J'9& !( #2 %#H
9,&#!(" ,(+ !""#$#%#&#'" 7!3 9'3&,#( #+',"- K91!%,3"1# &1'3'7!3' +'2,(+" ,
0#+' 3,(*' !7 "/#%%" ,(+ #(&'%%'9&5,% 9, ,$#%#&#'"-
<7 0' &,/' &1' 2'&1!+!%!*#9,% ," '9& !7 &1' &1'"#" 0' 9,( "'' &1,&
5(+'3 #((#(* ,%% 3'"',391 #" &1' ,$#%#&4 &! +'2!("&3,&' 9!2 %'&' 7,2#%#,3#&4
0#&1 &1' 3'" '9&#;' "&3'(*&1" ,(+ 0',/('""'" !7 , 3,(*' !7 3'"',391
2'&1!+!%!*#'" ,(+ &'91(#>5'" 7!3 9!%%'9&#(* +,&,- <& #" &1'3'7!3' #2 !3&,(&
&! 3',+ 0#+'%4 ,3!5(+ &1' %#&'3,&53' !( &1' 2,L!3 #(&'%%'9&5,% &3,+#&#!("
"591 ," !"#&#;#"2 ,(+ 1'(!2'(!%!*4- =1#" #" $'9,5"' #& #" &1'"'
&3,+#&#!(" &1,& "5 !3& ,(+ 1,;' "1, '+ &1' 0,4" #( 01#91 0' &'(+ &!
;#'0 &1' (,&53' !7 &1' 0!3%+ ,(+ 1!0 #& #" !""#$%' &! *! ,$!5& +';'%! #(*
/(!0%'+*' ,(+ 5(+'3"&,(+#(* !7 !53 0!3%+- M(!0%'+*' !7 1#"&!3#9,% #+',"
,(+ &1'!3#'": !3 1#%!"! 14 ,(+ "!9#,% &1'!34: #" '""'(&#,%- <( , "#2#%,3 0,4
&! "/#%%": /(!0%'+*' !7: ",4: .,3) !3 &1' !"&2!+'3(#"&" 2#*1& $' "''( ,"
'""'(&#,% '3"!(,% &3,("7'3,$%' /(!0%'+*'-
?" , 3'"',391'3 4!5 25"& ,%"! +'2!("&3,&' &1' ,$#%#&4 &! ,""'""
2'&1!+!%!*#'" 5"'+ #( &1' +#"9# %#(' !3 #( &1' "&5+4 !7 &1' &! #9 #( !3+'3 &!
"1!0 9%',3 ,(+ 93#	,% 5(+'3"&,(+#(* !7 &1' %#2#&,&#!(" !7 &1' , 3!,91-
-.! +)&!'(&/'! '!0)!1 )$ '!%!('2.
!"# $"%% #!&$ '&() *+"%",' ,& -./%&' * )*01- &2 ,!-&)"-# *03 "3-*#
4&..&0 ,& ,!- 3"#4"/%"0- *03 ,& #(+5-4, ,!-. ,& 4)","4*% -6*%(*,"&0 "0 &)3-)
,& *36*04- (03-)#,*03"017 8, "06&%6-# 3-.&0#,)*,"01 ,!- 4*/*4",' ,& *)1(-
)*,"&0*%%' *03 /)-#-0, ,!*, *)1(.-0, "0 * 4&!-)-0, #,)(4,()-7 9&: '&( 0--3
,& ;0&$ !&$ ,& *0*%'#- ,!- *)1(.-0,# &2 &,!-)# < ,!- )-*3-) &2 '&() ,!-#"#
=*0 ->,-)0*% ->*."0-)? $"%% +- %&&;"01 ,& #-- !&$ '&( !*6- *0*%'#-3 #(4!
,!-&)"-# *03 !&$ '&( !*6- 3-6-%&/-3 "03-/-03-0, 4&04%(#"&0# 2)&. '&()
)-*3"017 80 /*),"4(%*): '&() )-*3-) $"%% +- "0,-)-#,-3 ,& #-- !&$ '&(
3-6-%&/ * 4*#- =*)1(.-0,? 2&) ,!- )-#-*)4! '&( "0,-03 ,& (03-),*;-7
!"#$%&'(&)$* #')*)$(+)&, !- 0&,"&0 &2 &)"1"0*%",' "# 6-)' 4%&#-%'
)-%*,-3 ,& ,!- 2(04,"&0 &2 ,!- #-*)4! *03 *0*%'#"# &2 ,!- %",-)*,()-7 @- !*6-
*%)-*3' "03"4*,-3 ,!*, ,!)&(1! * )"1&)&(# *0*%'#"# &2 * )-#-*)4! %",-)*,()-
&0- 4*0 1"6- 2&4(# ,& * ,&/"47 8, "# ,!)&(1! ,!"# 2&4(#"01 /)&4-## ,!*, *0
&)"1"0*% ,)-*,.-0, &2 *0 -#,*+%"#!-3 ,&/"4 4*0 +- 3-6-%&/-37 A%*4"01 *#"3-
(0,"% %*,-) 4!*/,-)# !&$ ,!"# !*# *03 4*0 +- 3&0-: $- 0--3 ,& ,()0 &()
*,,-0,"&0 !-)- ,& ,!- 4&04-/, &2 &)"1"0*%",'7 80 B"1()- C7D =/7 EF? $- #!&$
#&.- &2 ,!- *##&4"*,"&0# ,!*, 4*0 +- .*3- 2)&. ,!- 3"22-)-0, 3-G0","&0# &2
&)"1"0*%",'7 H#- ,!-#- ,& 1)*#/ ,!- .-*0"01 &2 ,!- ,-).7 !"# "# "./&),*0,
+-4*(#- "0 *4*3-."4 )-#-*)4! ,!- *". "# 0&, ,& )-/%"4*,- $!*, !*# *%)-*3'
+--0 3&0-: +(, ,& *33 "0 #&.- $*': 0& .*,,-) !&$ #.*%%: #&.-,!"01 ,!*,
!-%/# 2(),!-) &() (03-)#,*03"01 &2 ,!- $&)%3 "0 $!"4! $- %"6-7
I%% )-#-*)4! "# "0 ",# &$0 $*' (0"J(-7 K6-0 )-#-*)4! ,!*, )-/%"4*,-# $&);
3&0- +' *0&,!-) /-)#&0 "# (0"J(-7 L(, ", "# 0&, &)"1"0*%7 L-"01 &)"1"0*%
."1!, +- ,*;-0 ,& .-*0 3&"01 #&.-,!"01 0& &0- !*# 3&0- +-2&)-: &) -6-0
,!&(1!, *+&(, 3&"01 +-2&)-7 9&.-,".-# ,!"# ;"03 &2 *//)&*4! ,& ,!"0;"01
*+&(, &)"1"0*%",' -J(*,-# &)"1"0*%",' $",! #/-4"*% J(*%","-# *##(.-3 ,& +-
/&##-##-3 +' &0%' * 2-$ "03"6"3(*%#7 !- ,!"01 ,& )-.-.+-) "# ,!*,
&)"1"0*%",' "# 0&, * .'#,-)"&(# J(*%",'M ", "# #&.-,!"01 *%% )-#-*)4!-)# *)-
4*/*+%- &2 "2 ,!-' ;0&$ !&$ ,& ,!"0; *+&(,: .*0*1- *03 /%*' $",! "3-*#7
!-)- "# *0 ".*1"0*)' -%-.-0, ,& )-#-*)4!7 !"# "# ,!- *+"%",' ,& 4)-*,-
*03 /%*' $",! ".*1-# "0 '&() ."03 &) &0 /*/-): )-*$*;-0"01 ,!- 4!"%3 "0
,!- *3(%,7 !"# *.&(0,# ,& ,!"0;"01 (#"01 6"#(*% /"4,()-#: $",!&(, *0'
"0!"+","&0# &) /)-4&04-"6-3 "3-*# *03 "06&%6-# 1"6"01 2)-- )-"0 ,& ,!-
".*1"0*,"&07
!-&)"#,# #(4! *# K"0#,-"0 *,,)"+(,- ,!-") "3-*# ,& +-"01 *+%- ,& /%*' $",!
.-0,*% ".*1-# *03 ,& .*;- (/ ".*1"0*)' ->/-)".-0,#7 !"# ,-4!0"J(- "#
(#-3 ,& .*;- 4&00-4,"&0# *.&01 ,!"01# ,!*, '&( $&(%3 0&, 0&).*%%' #--
*# 4&00-4,*+%-7 K"0#,-"0: 2&) ->*./%-: 3-#4)"+-3 !&$ !- 4*.- ,& ,!"0;
*+&(, ,!- )-%*,"6",' &2 ,".- *03 #/*4- "0 ,!- $*' !- 3"3 +' #*'"01 ", *%%
+-1*0 $",! *0 ".*1"0*)' 5&()0-'7 K"0#,-"0 $*# *+%- ,& 2&%%&$ !"# 2*0,*#'
,!)&(1! ,& /)&3(4- !"# 2*.&(# -J(*,"&0 - N .4E7
!- /&"0, ,& 0&,- "# ,!*, K"0#,-"0O# 5&()0-' $*# * #.*%% -/"#&3-P #&.-Q
,!"01 .&#, &2 (# *)- 4*/*+%- &2 ->/-)"-04"017 K"0#,-"0O# *4!"-6-.-0, $*# "0
2&%%&$"01 ,!)&(1! !"# "3-*# ,& ,!-") ,!-&)-,"4*% 4&04%(#"&0#7 R- #,&//-3
#!&), !"# $&); $!-0 !- )-*%"S-3 ,!*, !"# "3-*# 4&(%3 !*6- * 3*); #"3-M ,!-
6,!1" * 4!0%$*0#$% $%7!%8
originality
!" #$%&!"
8".&. ' 0# ,!" +"'02 % +". (.&3.!+ &.9'.7) :$$ &.9'.7 ; '&&. (.!+'9. #3
+". +#('!; %&. 7&'++.0 3&#- % (%&+'!,$%& (.& (.!+'9. #& +%0/(#'0+ #3 +".
&.9'.7.&) 8"' (.& (.!+'9. #3+.0 #&'2'0%+. 3&#- +". !"##$ #3 +"#,2"+;
9#!%+'#0 #& '/.#$#2'!%$ +%0/(#'0+ '0 7"'!" +". &.9'.7.& ' $#!%+./) : %
!#0 .<,.0!.; +". (%&+'!,$%&'+1 #3 +". &.9'.7.& '-($'. % (%&+'!,$%& &.%/.&)
=.9'.7.& , ,%$$1 7&'+. 7'+" % (%&+'!,$%& 6'0/ #3 &.%/.& '0 -'0/> % &.%/.&
+"%+ +".1 -'2"+ 7%0+ +# '0?,.0!.) *+ ' 3%!+#& ,!" % +". . +"%+ -%6. %$$
&.9'.7 (%&+'%$ '0 #-. 7%1 #& #+".&) @,+ +"' ' 0#+ &.% #0 #& .A!, . 3#& %
(##& &.9'.7; %$+"#,2" +".1 !%0 -%6. % &.9'.7 '0+.&. +'02; !"%$$.02'02 #&
(	#!%+'9.) B%&+'%$'+1 '0 +.&- #3 9%$,. 5,/2.-.0+ ; #('0'#0 ; -#&%$'C'02
%0/ '/.#$#2,. !%0 #3+.0 4. 3#,0/ +# "%9. '09%/./ #& 3#&-./ +". +%&+'02
(#'0+ #3 % &.9'.7) D".0 &.%/'02 % &.9'.7 7&'++.0 41 #-.#0. .$ . #&
,0/.&+%6'02 % &.9'.7; 1#, "#,$/ 4. %7%&. #3 1#,& #70 9%$,. 5,/2.-.0+
%0/ +&1 +# %9#'/ % $%!6 #3 !"#$%&$1 &. (.!+ 3#& +". '/.% #3 #+".& )
B&#/,!'02 % 2##/ &.9'.7 0../ 0#+ 4. +## /'3E!,$+) *+ !%0 4. 3%& -#&.
&.7%&/'02 +"%0 60#!6'02 #-.+"'02 ,( <,'!6$1 %0/ 7'+"#,+ +## -,!"
'0+.$$.!+,%$ .33#&+) : $%&2. /.2&.. #3 %+' 3%!+'#0 !%0 4. "%/ 3&#- 7#&6'02 %+
+". &.9'.7 #9.& % (.&'#/ #3 +'-.) F#& % -% +.&G #& /#!+#&%$ !%0/'/%+. +"'
-'2"+ 4. ,( +# % 1.%& #& -#&.) : $%&2. -.% ,&. #3 +"%+ %+' 3%!+'#0 !#-.
3&#- +". %7%&.0. +"%+ 1#, "%9. /.9.$#(./ 6'$$ %0/ %!<,'&./ '0+.$H
$.!+,%$ %4'$'+'. 1#, /'/ 0#+ "%9. 4.3#&. 1#, 4.2%0 1#,& &. .%&!")