Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 4

Competitive Product

Comparison Matrix
AUGUST 2013 | LIFESIZE SUMMARY

Delivering the Ultimate Communication Experience


LifeSize offers the most innovative solutions with the lowest total cost of ownership and ultimate flexibility compared to others
on the market. Our video conferencing solutions consistently deliver unparalleled performance and greater productivity with
low cost of acquisition, implementation and operation.
Room-Based Video Systems (supporting up to 1080p60 video/1080p data)
Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages
Tight integration with the LifeSize UVC Platform
for a connected experience, enabling click-to-join
Lacks tight integration with Cisco video meetings with pop-up notifications, a unified user
infrastructure interface in bridge calls and push-button recording
No new user experiencestill uses the Radically simplified user experience with a new user
Cisco SX20 LifeSize
complicated user interface and remote of legacy interface and remote control that promotes self-
Quick Set Icon Series
Cisco systems discovery
Price disadvantaged at $10,000 for 720p and a 4x ~$3,000 for 720p60 and a 4x PTZ camera
PTZ camera versus LifeSize Icon
~$8,000 for 1080p60, 10x PTZ camera and dual
display support
Tight integration with the LifeSize UVC Platform
Not tightly integrated with Polycom video for a connected experience, enabling click-to-join
infrastructure meetings with pop-up notifications, a unified user
interface in bridge calls and push-button recording
No physical data-sharing input; must upgrade to
the Group 500 system Up to 1080p data sharing through a physical data port
Requires a $4,000 upgrade from the EagleEye Comes with either our LifeSize 10x or 4x camera,
LifeSize
Polycom Group 300 Acoustic camera to get PTZ capabilities which both offer PTZ capabilities
Icon Series
Fails to deliver a simplified user experience Radically simplified user experience with a new user
beyond the home screen interface and remote control that promotes self-
discovery
Endpoint-centric Microsoft Lync interoperability
approach is not scalable and provides Infrastructure-centric Microsoft Lync interoperability
interoperability for only that one endpoint approach is highly scalable; enables interoperability
for any endpoint
Tight integration with the LifeSize UVC Platform
for a connected experience, enabling click-to-join
Not tightly integrated with Polycom video
meetings with pop-up notifications, a unified user
infrastructure
interface in bridge calls and push-button recording
Fails to deliver a simplified user experience
Radically simplified user experience with a new user
beyond the home screen
LifeSize interface and remote control that promotes self-
Polycom Group 500 Price disadvantaged at $11,000 for 720p and a discovery
Icon Series
PTZ camera versus LifeSize Icon
~$6,000 for 720p60, 10x PTZ camera and dual
Endpoint-centric Microsoft Lync interoperability display support
approach is not scalable and provides
Infrastructure-centric Microsoft Lync interoperability
interoperability for only that one endpoint
approach is highly scalable; enables interoperability
for any endpoint
Radically simplified user experience with a new user
interface and remote control that promotes self-
Fails to deliver a simplified user experience and
discovery
has a complicated remote and user interface
~$8,000 for 1080p60, 10x PTZ camera and dual
Price disadvantaged at $10,000 for 1080p and LifeSize
Radvision XT5000 display support
a 10x PTZ camera versus LifeSize Icon Icon Series
Tight integration with the LifeSize UVC Platform
Not tightly integrated with Radvision video
for a connected experience, enabling click-to-join
infrastructure
meetings with pop-up notifications, a unified user
interface in bridge calls and push-button recording
Room-Based Video Systems (supporting up to 1080p30 video)

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


4-way embedded bridge capable of 1080p30 is a
4-way embedded bridge is an expensive upgrade
Cisco SX20 LifeSize Team standard feature
and supports a maximum of 576p30
Quick Set 220 All features are included in the base price with
Cost per feature model increases MSRP rapidly
superior price/performance

LifeSize Team 1080p30, 720p60 and 720p30 multipoint calls


Cisco TelePresence 1080p30 multipoint calls are not supported 220/ supported
Codec C40/60 Cost per feature model increases MSRP rapidly LifeSize Room All features are included in the base price with
220 superior price/performance

Superior price/performance at a fraction of


High entry cost is a barrier to most deployments
Cisco TelePresence LifeSize Room the cost
Codec C90 Features such as multipoint, data sharing with 220i Multipoint, presentation sharing and touchscreen
WSXGA resolution and 1080p are upgrades
conference phone are all standard features
Capable of only standard definition video
720p30 HD video conferencing is standard
Supports only five resolutions, resulting in LifeSize
Polycom QDX 6000 Gradually reduces resolution at lower bandwidths
significant degradation in fps rate as connection Passport
while maintaining 30 fps
speeds decrease
Fails to deliver a constant 30 fps at advertised Gradually reduces resolution at lower bandwidths
bandwidths LifeSize Passport/ while maintaining 30 fps
Polycom HDX 6000 LifeSize Express
Does not support unique layouts to display 220 Virtual multiway enables users to select from unique
multiple images views of video and data
4-way, 720p30 embedded MCU is an optional 4-way, 1080p30 embedded MCU is standard
upgrade
LifeSize Team Room 220 and Team 220 work together with
Polycom HDX 7000 4-way does not work when Lync RTVideo LifeSize UVC Video Engine for Microsoft Lync to
220
license is activated; limited to point-to-point with provide Lync RTVideo for HD video with 4-way
Lync RTVideo continuous presence
Offers dual stream 720p at 30 fps for full motion
video and full motion content
Cannot deliver 720p30 video with 720p30
content Superior bandwidth efficiencyset to sustain 1080p
at 30 fps; Room 220 requires only
Polycom Low bandwidth efficiencyset to sustain 1080p LifeSize Room
1700 Kbps
HDX 8000/9000 at 30 fps, HDX requires > 2500 Kbps 220
Room 220 and Team 220 work together with
Multiway gets disabled when Lync interoperability
LifeSize UVC Video Engine for Microsoft Lync
is used
to provide Lync RTVideo for HD video with 4-way
continuous presence
Not a true all-in-one solutionHDX 4002 has a True all-in-one solution; no separate boxes or
separate codec, and HDX 4500 has an attached devices
Polycom HDX codec LifeSize Unity 50 Slim profile and VESA compatibility enable
4002/4500
Neither Polycom model can be wall or cart deployment in any environment, including mobile
mounted carts or wall mounts
General purpose PCs that run an off-the-shelf
Purpose-built video conferencing systems that
Windows OS and require the VidyoGateway for LifeSize Passport/ run the secure and efficient Linux OS and deliver a
interoperability LifeSize Express
Vidyo Room superior experience
Vidyos systems use a third-party camera, 220/
HD-50/100/220 LifeSize designs and builds all of its own hardware
microphone and speakers, so they dont have LifeSize Room
220 and software, including cameras, endpoints,
total control of the solution or the quality of
microphones and conference phones
experience
Lacks integration and optimizationincorporates Brilliantly optimized, integrated solutioneach
older LCD and camera technology LifeSize Unity component is chosen specifically for individual
Cisco MX200/300 quality
Has lackluster design and requires tools to 500
assemble No tools requiredset up and working in minutes
Wired touch user interface makes controlling
Easiest-to-use all-in-one video communication
from a distance difficult LifeSize Unity
Cisco EX60/90 solution available with a simplified user interface
EX90 (24-inch version) cannot be wall or cart 50
VESA compatibility for wall or mobile cart mounting
mounted
Desktop and Mobile Video

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


Broadest platform support with 50+ mobile
Only one mobile device supportediPad 2
devices supported and counting
Requires Jabber video licenses for each user,
Ultimate flexibility with unlimited user accounts
Cisco Jabber Video which is costly for large deployments LifeSize UVC
and guest invitations
for TelePresence ClearSea
Needs several add-ons to match LifeSize UVC
Unmatched ease of use with features like ring all,
ClearSeas native UVC functionalitiesVCS
seamless multiparty call escalation and live call
Expressway and VCS FindMe
transfer
Inferior video quality720p encoding and Highest video quality1080p encoding/decoding
Polycom decoding on the desktop; 480p @ 30 fps on the desktop, 540p @ 30 fps or 720p @ 15 fps
receive on iPad 2 LifeSize UVC receive on iPad 2
CMA Desktop/
ClearSea
RealPresence Mobile Limited number of mobile devices Broadest platform support with 50+ mobile
supported15+ devices on iOS and Android devices supported and counting
Requires VidyoRouter and VidyoGateway to
connect to standards-based H.323 or SIP Turnkey, all-inclusive and natively interoperable
VidyoDesktop/ endpoint LifeSize UVC with H.323 and SIP
VidyoMobile Requires a large up-front investment, with the ClearSea Broadest platform support with 50+ mobile
first port of interoperable mobile video calling devices supported and counting
costing $20,000

Streaming and Recording

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


Lacks flexibility and scalabilityone-size-fits- Available as VMware, Hyper-V or physical
all approach appliance with flexible licensingadd capacity as
LifeSize UVC

needed
Polycom RSS 4000 No live streaming to mobile devices
Video Center
Needs separate appliance for streaming Support for the iPhone, iPad and iPod with more
purposes devices to come

Tight integration with endpoint for one-button


Complex recording and publishing
recording and auto-publishing
proceduresneed to dial IP addresses and
URLs Support for the iPhone, iPad and iPod with more
Cisco TelePresence LifeSize UVC
devices to come
Content Server No live streaming to mobile devices Video Center
Federation enables bandwidth savings and
No ability to federate multiple servers for WAN
massive enterprise-wide streaming without
bandwidth savings
additional equipment

Unavailable for purchase as a standalone Single application to perform all three tasks
applicationneed Cisco DMM, plus Cisco MXE record, stream and publish
for transcoding Simplest possible deployment
LifeSize UVC
Cisco Show & Share
Supports resolutions only up to 720p30 Video Center Scales easily from 1 recording port to 20 on a
Expensive, time-consuming to set up and use, single instance
and a much more complex implementation Scales to 1000s of streams on a single instance

Microsoft Lync Interoperability

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


LifeSize UVC Multipoint Enterprise Edition
Polycom RMX + Requires endpoint and expensive infrastructure supports both Lync 2010 and Lync 2013 clients
Polycom endpoint MCU appliance LifeSize UVC Includes native Microsoft Lync video
Multipoint interoperability
Cisco infrastructure Does not scale flexibly; requires expensive
Enterprise
+ video endpoint appliance for expanding capacity Flexible capacity scales one port at a time
Edition + any
Radvision gateway + Does not deliver full-screen continuous LifeSize endpoint Host up to 128 participants and up to 49 on-
video endpoint presence to Lync clients and endpoints screen continuous presence with endpoints and
Lync clients
Bridging

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


Sustains consistent 30 or 60 fps for the best
quality
Cisco MCU 4500 LifeSize Bridge
Lacks frame rate stability as capacity increases Includes native Microsoft Lync interoperability
series (LB);
Lacks native Microsoft Lync interoperability LifeSize UVC (LifeSize UVC MP Enterprise Edition)
Cisco MCU 5100 Multipoint (UVC
Lacks built-in high availability clustering Flexible capacity scales one port at a time (UVC
series MP) MP)
Best price in the market at any resolution
High price per port at ~$15,000 for Best price in the market at any resolution
1080p30/720p60 LifeSize Bridge
Expanded Conference license key ($14,999)
Polycom RMX series (LB);
Expensive to host large meetings48-port enables 48-port 1080p30 meetings with a total
LifeSize UVC
Polycom 800 series 1080p30 meeting occurs only on an price of $79,998 (LB)
Multipoint (UVC
RMX 4420, costing $919,000
MP) Flexible capacity scales one port at a time (UVC
Cannot scale one port at a time MP)
Host up to 49 on-screen participants (continuous
Poor quality image; lacks frame rate stability
LifeSize Bridge presence) (UVC MP)
Scheduling requires additional management (LB);
Radvision Scopia Built-in scheduling for flexible deployments
software LifeSize UVC
Elite series Flexible capacity scales one port at a time (UVC
Cannot scale one port at a time Multipoint (UVC
MP) MP)
No high-end, capacity solutions
Best price in the market at any resolution

Cloud Video Service (Infrastructure as a Service)

Competitor Product Competitor Weaknesses LifeSize Equivalent LifeSize Advantages


No call escalation to multiparty (call me, my
Easy-to-use seamless escalation from
Cisco WebEx internal bridge, my external bridgeall different
LifeSize peer-to-peer to multiparty calling
Telepresence addresses)
Connections Designed for real-time ad hoc communication,
Cisco Jabber Video Confusing solutionsupported/unsupported
including unlimited soft client guests
calls between free and paid services
Designed for infrequent use; pricing by port or Flat-rate, unlimited use pricing, designed for real-
by minute is expensive time ad hoc communication, including unlimited
No ability to make a basic callmeet me LifeSize soft client guests
BlueJeans Network
bridge only Connections On-demand, unlimited nine-way bridging with
No provisioning, management or directory every seat for seamless escalation, from
services peer-to-peer to multiparty calling

Not a cloud solutionrequires full RealPresence


on-premises deployment, and CloudAxis is then
an add-on True cloud solution; no up-front investment in
LifeSize infrastructure
Polycom Cloud Axis No ability to make a basic callmeet me
Connections Auto-provisioning, directory services with
bridge only
presence and full management/deployment tools
No actual interoperabilityjust a web client and
IM invitation

All pricing shown is in US dollars and may vary by region. Pricing is based on publicly available information.

Headquarters
Austin, Texas, USA
+1 512 347 9300
Toll Free US +1 877 543 3749 Delivering the Ultimate Communication Experience
www.lifesize.com
E-mail info@lifesize.com EMEA Regional Office APAC Regional Office 2013 Logitech. All rights reserved. Information contained in this document is
Munich, Germany Singapore subject to change without notice. LifeSize is the registered trademark or trademark
+49 89 20 70 76 0 +65 6303 8370 of Logitech. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Toll Free Europe +00 8000 999 09 799 CMP_Summary_0813

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi