Explorer les Livres électroniques
Catégories
Explorer les Livres audio
Catégories
Explorer les Magazines
Catégories
Explorer les Documents
Catégories
INTRODUCTION
Investigations into the degradation of Des essais sur la dgradation des matriaux due
materials and components which are exposed to aux rayonnements ionisants ont t effectus dans
ionizing radiation have been carried out in many plusieurs domaines dapplication, par exemple
applications, such as nuclear reactors, fusion autour des racteurs nuclaires et de fusion, des
reactors, high-energy accelerators, medical and acclrateurs haute nergie, dans les installations
industrial irradiation facilities, space projects, industrielles ou mdicales, dans les centres
dtudes spatiales, etc. A lOrganisation
etc. At the European Organization for Nuclear
Europenne pour la Recherche Nuclaire (CERN),
Research (CERN), radiation damage test studies
les essais de radiorsistance ont t concentrs sur
have been centred on organic and inorganic des matriaux organiques et inorganiques, des
materials, electronic and optical components and composants lectroniques et optiques, et dautres
devices, and other materials that are used in the matriaux qui sont utiliss pour la construction et
construction and operation of high-energy lopration des acclrateurs haute nergie et les
accelerators and particle detectors. dtecteurs de particules.
Apart from electronic and optical devices, the A part les composants lectroniques et optiques,
organic materials are the ones most sensitive to les matriaux organiques sont parmi les plus
radiation. As a consequence of this, a large sensibles aux rayonnements ionisants. Par
number of radiation tests have been made on consquent, une grande quantit de ces matriaux
these materials and the results are extensively ont t soumis des essais dirradiation, et les
documented [e.g. 123]. Design engineers are, rsultats peuvent tre trouvs dans de nombreuses
publications [par exemple 123]. Toutefois, les
however, often faced with the problem of finding
ingnieurs rencontrent souvent des difficults pour
the desired information quickly within the
trouver, dans la littrature, linformation voulue.
available literature. We therefore decided to Cest pour cette raison que nous avons dcid de
publish our radiation damage test results on publier nos rsultats dessais de radiorsistance des
organic materials in the form of catalogues. matriaux organiques sous forme de catalogues.
The first catalogue, published more than Le premier catalogue, paru il y a plus de quinze
fifteen years ago, concerned organic materials ans, concernait les matriaux utiliss comme
used as insulation and sheathing for electric isolants, ainsi que pour les gaines de cbles
cables [24]. lectriques [24].
The second dealt with thermosetting and Le deuxime concernait des rsines
thermoplastic resins, the majority being epoxies thermodurcies et thermoplastiques dont la plupart
used for magnet coil insulations [25]. sont des poxydes utilises dans lisolation de
bobines daimants [25].
The third contained information on
Le troisime concernait divers matriaux et
miscellaneous materials and components used composants utiliss autour des acclrateurs de
around high-energy accelerators [26]. particules [26].
A second edition of the first catalogue was Une seconde dition du premier catalogue,
published in 1989 and concerns halogen-free publie en 1989 portait sur les matriaux pour
cable-insulating materials [27]. isolations et gaines de cbles exempts dhalogne
The present volume is the second edition of [27].
the second part and concerns result of thermoset Le prsent volume est une seconde dition du
and thermoplastic resins and composite materials deuxime ; il contient des informations sur des
which were tested in the meantime. rsines thermoplastiques et thermodurcies, ainsi
que sur des matriaux composites.
As in the previous editions, the materials are
Comme dans chaque dition, les matriaux sont
presented in alphabetical order.
prsents dans lordre alphabtique suivant leur
nom anglais.
We first present some characteristic properties Nous commenons par exposer quelques
of the materials, and define our end-point criteria proprits caractristiques des matriaux prsents
for the selection of radiation-resistant materials. dans ce catalogue ; nous dfinissons les critres de
We then list the tests and test methods, and give dgradation de ces proprits, qui servent
the irradiation conditions. In Section 5 we slectionner les matriaux radiorsistants. Nous
explain the presentation of the data. It should be dcrivons ensuite les mthodes dessais, ainsi que
les conditions dirradiation. Dans la Section 5 nous
noted that most of the data have been obtained
expliquons la prsentation des donnes. Il faut
from tests after accelerated irradiations, and that
noter que les rsultats ont gnralement t obtenus
all tests were made at ambient temperature. After par des irradiations acclres, et que tous les essais
long exposures and ageing in other environments, ont t faits temprature ambiante. Aprs une
a variation in the data presented may be longue priode dirradiation et un vieillissement
expected; this is mainly the case for sous dautres conditions, on peut sattendre un
thermoplastic materials [9, 12, 1823]. Test changement dans les rsultats que nous avons
results at cryogenic temperatures can be found in obtenus, surtout pour les thermoplastiques
Refs. [3035]. [9, 12, 1823]. Des rsultats de tests temprature
cryognique peuvent tre trouvs aux rfrences
2. MATERIALS, CHARACTERISTIC [3035].
PROPERTIES, AND END-POINT
CRITERIA 2. LES MATRIAUX, LEURS PROPRITS
CARACTRISTIQUES ET
With a few exceptions, which are marked in LES CRITRES DE DGRADATION
the catalogue, all the test data given here have DE CES PROPRITS
been obtained, over the past fifteen years, from
commercially-available materials. Some of these A part quelques exceptions, qui sont indiques
dans le catalogue, tous les rsultats donns ont t
materials may no longer be available and this is
obtenus, au cours des quinze dernires annes, sur
indicated in the tables when known. The most
des matriaux disponibles dans le commerce. Il est
common materials that are dealt with here are: possible que quelques-uns ne soient plus sur le
epoxy resins, march, et nous lavons not dans les tableaux,
polyester resins, pour les cas o nous lavons su. Les plus courants
polyurethanes, de ces matriaux sont :
rigid and high performance thermoplastics. rsines poxydes
The materials were usually supplied by rsines polyestres
European manufacturers involved in submitting polyurthanes
offers and/or supplying components for the thermoplastiques rigides et hautes performance.
construction at CERN of the Large Electron En gnral, les matriaux ont t fournis par des
Positron storage ring (LEP), and for the Large fournisseurs europens qui ont t engags dans
Hadron Collider (LHC) project. des offres ou des fournitures de matriels pour la
construction au CERN du Large Electron-Positron
Some characteristic physical, mechanical, and
Collider (LEP), ou pour le projet LHC (Large
electrical properties of thermoset resins are Hadron Collider), grand collisionneur de protons,
summarized in Table 1. These values are only a supraconducteur.
general indication since they depend on
Le tableau 1 donne un rsum des quelques
numerous parameters such as the composition proprits mcaniques, lectriques et physiques des
and quantity of the base resin, the hardener, the rsines thermodurcies. Ces valeurs peuvent
accelerator, the filler, and other additives, as well seulement servir dindication gnrale, puisquelles
as on the curing conditions, etc. dpendent de nombreux paramtres tels que la
Most of the materials presented in this composition et la quantit de la rsine de base, du
catalogue and all of the thermoplastics unless durcisseur et de lacclrateur, ainsi que les charges
et dautres additifs.
otherwise stated, are halogen-free and contain Soulignons que la plupart des matriaux
little or no sulphur and phosphorus. They have prsents dans ce catalogue, et en tout cas les
passed the IEC 7542 test which defines the thermoplastiques, sauf mention contraire sont
maximum acidity and the maximum conductivity exempts dhalogne et ne contiennent que peu ou
of combustion gases [28]. pas de soufre ou de phosphore. Ils passent le test
IEC 7542 qui dfinit une acidit et une
It is clear that when selecting and classifying conductivit maximales des gaz de combustion
materials according to their radiation resistance, [28].
not all of the properties listed in Table 1 could be Il est vident que, pour la slection et la
tested, and we had to restrict ourselves to a few of classification des matriaux selon leur rsistance
the most characteristic and representative ones. aux rayonnements, on ne peut pas tester toutes les
For our purposes the mechanical properties were proprits cites dans le tableau 1, il faut se limiter
chosen. This choice can be justified by our own quelques-unes des plus reprsentatives. Dans le
experience and that of others [10, 22, 29]. In cas prsent, nous avons choisi les proprits
general the mechanical degradation of plastic mcaniques. Ce choix se justifie par notre propre
insulating materials due to ionizing radiation exprience, et celle dautres auteurs, qui nous a
occurs before the degradation of the electrical appris que la dgradation, due lirradiation, des
and physical properties. Also, no important proprits mcaniques des isolants plastiques
change in flammability was observed with intervient gnralement avant celle de leurs
radiation. proprits lectriques et physiques [10, 22, 29].
Dautre part, les rayonnements nont que peu
It should be noted that the mechanical deffet sur linflammabilit de ces matriaux.
properties of polymeric materials depend Remarquons que les proprits mcaniques des
strongly on the temperature; at cryogenic matriaux polymriques dpendent fortement de la
temperature the stiffness and the brittleness are temprature dutilisation ; temprature
increased, and the plasticity and the impact cryognique la rigidit et la fragilit sont accrues, la
strength are reduced. Irradiation of these plasticit et la rsistance au chocs sont diminues.
materials either at low temperature or at room Le fait dirradier ces matriaux basse temprature
temperature does not influence their degradation: ou temprature ambiante ninflue pas sur leur
the mechanical properties of polymer-based dgradation : les proprits mcaniques des
materials are more influenced by the test matriaux polymriques sont plus influences par
temperature than by the irradiation temperature. la temprature de test que par la temprature
A characteristic case is that of materials sensitive dirradiation. Un cas particulier est celui des
to oxido-degradation: the degradation is lower if matriaux sensibles loxydo-dgradation :
lorsquils sont irradis dans un fluide cryognique,
they are irradiated in a cryogenic fluid rather than
leur dgradation est moindre que lorsquils sont
in air [3035].
irradis dans lair [3035].
More sensitive samples were irradiated with a Les chantillons plus sensibles ont t irradis
60 par une source de 60Co, la socit Ionisos
Co source, at Ionisos in Dagneux (France),
with doses of 2 105 Gy, 5 105 Gy, and Dagneux, France, des doses de 2 105 Gy,
106 Gy, at a dose rate of about 4000 Gy/h. In a 5 105 Gy et 106 Gy, un dbit de dose de lordre
cobalt source, the radiation comes from pure de 4000 Gy/h. Dans une source cobalt, lirradiation
gamma rays of 1.17 and 1.25 MeV. est purement electromagntique, avec des gammas
de 1,17 et 1,25 MeV.
Some samples were irradiated in the CERN
Certains chantillons ont t irradis dans des
accelerators, either close to the magnet coils
acclrateurs du CERN, soit prs des bobines
which are insulated with the material concerned
daimants dont les bobines sont isoles avec le
(we call this live irradiation), or around matriau concern (test avec irradiation long
converting targets. Under these conditions, the terme). Dans ces conditions, la dose-neutron peut
neutron dose may be of the order of several tens atteindre plusieurs dizaines de pourcents de la dose
of per cents of the total dose. totale.
More details about irradiation conditions and Plus de dtails sur les conditions dirradiation et
dosimetry in the ASTRA reactor are given in de dosimtrie peuvent tre trouvs dans les
Ref. [37] and for other sources in Ref. [38]. rfrences [37] pour le racteur ASTRA et [38]
(Note that 1 Gy = 1 gray = 1 J/kg = 100 rad.) pour les autres sources. (Pour mmoire :
1 Gy = 1 gray = 1 J/kg = 100 rad.)
5. PRESENTATION OF THE DATA
5. PRSENTATION DES RSULTATS
The lists of the materials that are presented in
this catalogue and in the preceding volumes are Les listes des matriaux pour lesquels nous
donnons des rsultats ainsi que ceux prsents dans
given in Appendix 1.
les volumes prcdants constituent lappendice 1.
Appendix 2 gives the chemical structures of Lappendice 2 donne les structures chimiques de
some commercial products. quelques composs commerciaux.
Appendix 3 is the alphabetical compilation of Lappendice 3 est la compilation alphabtique
data where the materials are sorted according to des rsultats o les matriaux sont classs suivant
their chemical name. Under each letter, the leurs noms chimiques en Anglais. Sous chaque
following information can be found: lettre on peut trouver les informations suivantes :
A generic page with the chemical names of La page gnrique avec les noms chimiques des
the materials, as well as their usual and matriaux, mais aussi leurs noms usuels ou
commercial names (with as many cross- commerciaux (nous avons fait autant de
references as possible). If specific results are recoupements que possible). Si des rsultats
not given in this volume, an indication of the spcifiques ne sont pas prsents dans ce
radiation resistance is given by the value of volume, une indication de la radiorsistance est
the radiation index. donne par lindice de rayonnement.
On the verso of this generic page, the list of Au verso de cette page gnrique, la liste avec
the materials classified under the given letter, les numros didentification CERN des
together with their CERN identification matriaux classs sous cette lettre.
number. Viennent ensuite les pages individuelles de
In the individual pages of results, a header rsultats, sur lesquelles on trouve en entte le
gives the TIS reference number, the numro didentification TIS, la description du
description of the material and the name of the matriaux et le nom du fournisseur (Annexe 5),
supplier (Appendix 5). If available, an ainsi quune ventuelle indication sur son
indication of the fire behaviour is also given. comportement au feu. Les rsultats sont
The results are presented in the form of a table prsents sous forme de tableau et de graphique.
and graph. The mean values (and the standard Dans le tableau apparraissent les doses
deviation) of the mechanical properties, absorbes avec les dbits de dose
flexural strength (S), deformation at break () correspondants, puis les valeurs moyennes (et
and flexural modulus (M) appear in the table lcart type) des proprits mcaniques, la
together with the absorbed doses and the rsistance en flexion (S), la dformation la
corresponding dose rates. (The formulae for rupture () et le module de flexion (M) (Les
the calculation of these properties are given in formules de calcul de ces grandeurs sont
Appendix 4. In some cases, the samples are donnes en appendice 4. Dans certains cas, les
too flexible to break during the test, the values chantillons sont trop flexibles pour subire une
given are then the maximum flexural strength rupture, la valeur maximale de la dfromation
and the maximum possible deformation in the atteinte dans la cage est alors donne, ainsi que
cage.) Below the table are given the critical la valeur maximale mesure pour la rsistance.)
property for the calculation of the radiation Sous le tableau sont donns la proprits de
index (RI) and its value for the corresponding rfrence pour le calcul de lindice de
dose rate. The graph presents the evolution of rayonnement (RI) et la valeur de celui-ci au
the flexural strength and of the deformation dbit de dose correspondant. Le graphique
with respect to the absorbed dose. prsente lvolution de la rsistance et de la
Appendix 4 gives the main abbreviations used dformation en fonction de la dose absorbe.
in the tables of results. Lappendice 4 explique les principales
abrviations utilises dans les tableau de rsultats.
Appendix 5 is a list of the suppliers of the
materials and/or components who contributed to Lappendice 5 est une liste des fournisseurs des
matriaux de base et/ou de composants qui ont
this catalogue.
collabor ce catalogue.
6. CLASSIFICATION OF MATERIALS 6. CLASSIFICATION DES MATRIAUX
Tables 2a and 2b are a classification of the Les tableaux 2a et 2b sont un classement des
material in decreasing order of their radiation matriaux par ordre dcroissant de leur rsistance
resistance. We have separated the thermoplastics aux radiations. Nous avons spar les
from the thermosets because their conditions of thermoplastiques des thermosets, car ils ont en
use are usually different, though high- gnral des conditions dutilisation diffrentes,
performance thermoplastics have properties as bien que les thermoplastiques hautes
good as the ones of thermosets today. performances aient aujourdhui des proprits
This classification gives an order of comparables celles des thermosets.
magnitude of the maximum dose of usability of Ce classement donne un ordre de grandeur de la
the materials; it corresponds to long-term dose limite dutilisation dun matriau, il
irradiations. In particular, thermoplastics correspond des irradiations acclres. En
particulier, les thermoplastiques (Tableau 2a)
(Table 2a) may be very sensitive to oxidation and
peuvent tre trs sensible loxydation et donc
hence to dose-rate effect; during long-term
leffet du dbit de dose ; en irradiation long terme
irradiation in the presence of oxygen, their en prsence doxygne, leur dgradation intervient
degradation starts at much lower doses [1723]. pour des doses nettement plus faibles [1723]. Une
An indication of this appears as a longer mild to indication de ceci apparait comme une zone de
moderate zone on the bar graph. dgradation modre plus longue sur le
All of these materials may be reinforced with graphique.
fibres, long or short, oriented (1D, 2D, 3D) or Tous ces matriaux peuvent tre renforcs par
not, woven or not, etc. The fibres usually increase des fibres, courtes ou longues, orientes (1D, 2D ou
the radiation resistance of the materials. The 3D) ou non, tisses ou non, etc. Les fibres ont en
properties of some composites reinforced with gnral un effet bnfique sur la rsistance aux
glass fibres or carbon fibres may be kept up to radiation dun matriaux. Les proprits de certains
doses above 100 MGy. A laminate will undergo composites renforcs aux fibres de verre ou de
carbone peuvent tre conserves des doses de plus
degradation following delamination, showing the
de 100 MGy. Un composite lamin subira une
higher sensitivity of the matrix.
dgradation par dlamination, mettant ainsi en
vidence la plus grande sensibilit de la matrice.
Acknowledgements Remerciements
This data compilation was carried out within Cette compilation de rsultats sinscrit dans le
the framework of an IAEA Research cadre dun programme de recherche sur la
Coordination Programme on Radiation dgradation des polymres par irradiation,
Degradation of Polymers (Contract No. 4319, coordonn avec lAIEA (contrat No. 4329, 1985
1985 to 1989). 1989).
Nous remercions particulirement K. Goebel,
Our particular thanks are due to K. Goebel,
K. Potter and B. de Raad, du CERN, qui, au long
K. Potter and B. de Raad at CERN who
des annes ont soutenu les tudes de dgradation
throughout the years have supported radiation- des matriaux due aux rayonnements.
damage studies.
La plus grande partie des matriaux tests ont
Most of the materials tested were used or t utiliss ou proposs pour le SPS et pour le LEP,
proposed for the SPS and LEP, as well as for the ainsi que pour le projet LHC du CERN. Nous
LHC project at CERN. We thank the European remercions les fabricants europens qui ont fourni
manufacturers who supplied the test samples, des chantillons dessais ; nous avons eu des
both for their interest in the subject and for the discussions utiles avec les reprsentants de
useful discussions that we had with many of nombreuses firmes.
them. Les irradiations ont t effectues au racteur
The irradiations were carried out in the ASTRA du Forschungszentrum Seibersdorf en
Autriche, o nous avons apprci la collaboration
ASTRA reactor of the Forschungszentrum
que nous ont offerte J. Casta et F. Bheim, et
Seibersdorf in Austria, where the collaboration of
Ionisos, Dagneux, France o nous remercions
A. Burtscher and J. Casta was greatly Mmes M.A. Mirvault et M.-O. Bachelier.
appreciated. We would also like to thank Mrs
Nous voudrions enfin exprimer notre
M-A. Mirvault and Mrs M.-O. Bachelier from
apprciation de laide et lattention du Service de
Ionisos in Dagneux, France. publication assiste par ordinateur du CERN.
Finally, we would like to thank the CERN
Desktop Publishing Service for their help in
preparing this report.
References
[1] M.H. Van de Voorde, The effect of nuclear radiation on the electrical properties of epoxy resins,
CERN 6813 (1968).
[2] M.H. Van de Voorde, Effects of radiation on materials and components, CERN 705 (1970).
[3] M.H. Van de Voorde, Action des radiations sur les rsines poxydes, CERN 7010 (1970).
[4] M.H. Van de Voorde and C. Restat, Selection guide to organic materials for nuclear engineering,
CERN 727 (1972).
[5] H. Schnbacher, Anwendung von Kabel und Magnet-isolationen im nucklearen Strahlungsfeld von
ber 1 Megagray, Bull. Assoc. Suisse Electr. 69 (1977) 72.
[6] D.C. Phillips, The effects of radiation on electrical insulators in fusion reactors, AERER8923 (UK
Atomic Energy Authority, Harwell, 1978).
[7] D.C. Phillips et al., The selection and properties of epoxide resins used for the insulation of magnet
systems in radiation enviroments, CERN 8105 (1981).
[8] R.I. Keiser and M. Mottier, Radiation resistant magnets, CERN 8205 (1982).
[9] R.L. Clough et al., Accelerated aging tests for predicting radiation degradation of organic
materials, Nucl. Saf. 25 No. 2 (1984) 238.
[10] G. Liptk et al., Radiation tests on selected electrical insulating materials for high-power and high-
voltage application, CERN 8502 (1985).
[11] H. Schnbacher et al., Strahlenbestandigkeit von Epoxidhormasse, Kunstst.-Berat. 76 (1986) 14.
[12] P. Beynel, H. Schnbacher, G. Tartaglia, Results of long-term irradiation of epoxy resins used for
magnet-coil insulation, CERNTISRP/IR/8637.
[13] H. Schnbacher, Life experience with aging of organic electrical insulating materials in nuclear
radiation environment, Proc. ANS/ENS Int. Topical Meeting on Operability of Nuclear Power
Systems in Adverse Environments, LaGrange Park, 1987, p. 516.
[14] R.L. Clough, Radiation resistant polymers, in Encyclopedia of Polymer Science and Engineering
(John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1988).
[15] Proc. Research Coordination Meeting on Radiation Damage to Organic Materials in Nuclear
Reactor and Radiation Environment, Takaseki, 1989 (IAEA Tech. Rep. Ser., Vienna, 1990).
[16] Radiation damage to organic materials in nuclear reactors and radiation environments, IAEA
TECDOC551 (1990).
[17] M. Tavlet and H. Schnbacher, Radiation resistance of insulators and structural materials,
Proc. ECFA Large Hadron Collider Workshop, Aachen, 1990, Eds. G. Jarlskog and D. Rein,
CERN 9010, Vol. 3 (1990) p. 7438.
[18] D.W. Clegg and A.A. Collyer, Irradiation effects on polymers (Elsevier Appl. Sci., London and
New York, 1991).
[19] R.L. Clough and S.W. Shalaby, Radiation effects on polymers (ACS Symposium Series 475, 1991).
[20] R.L. Clough and S.W. Shalaby, Irradiation of polymers (ACS Symposium Series No. 620, 1996).
[21] Proc. Int. Workshop on Advanced Materials for High Precision Detectors, Archamps, 1994, Eds.
B. Niquevert and C. Hauviller, CERN 9407, Part IV (1994).
[22] H. Mitsui et al., Synchrotron radiation damage test on insulating materials in the Tristan MR, Part.
Accel. 52 (1996) 3144.
[23] M. Tavlet, Aging of organic materials around high-energy particle accelerators, Nucl. Instrum.
Methods Phys. Res. B 131 (1997) 239244.
[24] H. Schnbacher and A. Stolarz-Izicka, Compilation of radiation damage test data, Part I: Cable-
insulating materials, CERN 7904 (1979).
[25] H. Schnbacher and A. Stolarz-Izicka, Compilation of radiation damage test data, Part II:
Thermosetting and thermoplastic resins, CERN 7908 (1979).
[26] P. Beynel, P. Maier and H. Schnbacher, Compilation of radiation damage test data, Part III:
Materials used around high-energy accelerators, CERN 8210 (1982).
[27] H. Schnbacher and M. Tavlet, Compilation of radiation damage test data, Part I, 2nd edition:
Halogen-free cable-insulating materials, CERN 8912 (1989).
[28] CERN Safety Instructions IS23 and IS41, TIS Commission 1993 and 1995.
[29] International Electrotechnical Commission, Geneva, Publication No. 544: Guide for determining
the effects of ionizing radiation on insulating materials, Part I: Radiation interaction, Ref. 5441
(1977); Part 2: Procedures for irradiation, Ref. 5442 (1979); Part 3: Test procedures for permanent
effects, Ref. 5443 (1979); Part 4: Classification system for service in radiation environments,
Ref. 5444 (1985).
[30] M. Van de Voorde, Low temperature irradiation effects on materials and components for
superconducting magnets for high-energy physics applications, CERN 7703 (1977).
[31] D. Evans and J.T. Morgan, A review of the effects of ionizing radiation on plastics materials at low
temperature, Adv. Cryog. Eng. 28 (1982) 147164.
[32] A. Spindel, Report on the program of 4 K irradiation of insulating materials for the SSC, SSCL
635 (1993).
[33] K. Humer et al., Tensile strength of fiber reinforced plastics at 77 K irradiated by various radiation
sources, J. Nucl. Mater. 212215 (1994) 849853.
[34] S. Egusa, Irradiation effects on the mechanical properties of polymer matrix composites at low
temperature, Adv. Cryog. Eng. 36 (1990) 861868.
[35] H. Schnbacher et al., Results of radiation tests at cryogenic temperatures on some selected organic
materials for the LHC, CERN 9605 (1996).
[36] M. Tavlet and A.-S. Boullin, End-of-Life criteria for rigid plastics undergoing radiation
degradation, CERNTIS-CFM/IR/9505, presented at the Working Group of IEC Subcommittee
15 B, Milan, June 1995.
[37] H. Schnbacher et al., Study on radiation damage to high-energy accelerator components by
irradiation in a nuclear reactor, Kerntechnik 17 (1975) 268.
[38] E. Leon Florian, H. Schnbacher and M. Tavlet, Data compilation of dosimetry methods and
radiation sources for material testing, CERN/TISCFM/IR/9303 (1993).
Table 1
Characteristic properties of thermoset and thermoplastic materials
Polymers EPOXY RESINS
PEEK
BISPHENOL A EPOXY NOVOLAC
Properties
No filler Glass Mineral No filler Glass Mineral Unfilled 30% G.F.
Specific gravity ISO
1.15 2.02.1 1.82.0 1.2 1.97 1.7 1.32 1.48
(g/cm3) 1183
Water absorption ISO
0.10.2 0.020.8 0.300.80 0.040.06 0.110.20 0.060.2 0.14
(%) 62
Thermal conductivity ASTM
0.150.45 1
(k cal/m.h. C) D325
Thermal coefficient of expansion ASTM
6 0.6 3 5 2.5
(105/C) D 696
Tensile strength ISO
7080 350400 70 70 350400 38 95 170
(MPa) R37
Elongation ISO
4.4 25 >25 2
(%) R37
Tensile modulus ISO
3.5 30 1015 3.5 2122 3.6 9.7
(GPa) R37
Flexural strength ISO
80130 360 150170 60100 390 7080 180
(MPa) 178
Impact strength ASTM
1.12.7 6.48.2 2.22.7 2.7 7.09.2 2.22.7
(notched) (kg cm/cm) D 256
Volume resistivity IEC
6.1 1015 1.5 1015 2.11014 1.45.5 1014 1016
( cm) 93
Dielectric strength IEC
> 16 1822 1516 1216 30
(kV/mm) 243
Power factor (tg) IEC
0.032 0.024 0.013 0.029 0.015 0.003
at 106 Hz 250
Dielectric constant IEC
3.4 4.74.8 4.14.6 3.5 5.1 4.34.8 3.3
at 106 Hz 250
Heat distortion temperature ISO
110 150200 340 340
(C) 75
Table 1 (cont.)
Polyimide (PI)
Liquid Crystal Polymer (LCP)
Polyetherimide (PEI)
Polyamideimide (PAI)
Polyphenylsulfide (PPS)
Polyetheretherketone (PEEK)
Polystyrene (PS)
Copolymer PI + siloxane
Polyarylate (PAr)
Polyarylamide (PAA)
Polyethersulfide (PES)
Polysulfone (PSU)
Polyamide 4.6
Polyphenyloxyde (PPO)
Acylonitride-butadiene-styrene (ABS)
Polyethylene (PE)
Polyethyleneterephtalate (PETP)
Polycarbonate (PC)
Polyamide 6.6 (PA)
Cellulose acetate
Polypropylene (PP)
Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)
Polyoxymethylene (POM)
Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)
These appreciations can only serve as a general guideline; environmental conditions such as tem-
perature, humidity and dose rate, as well as additives influence the radiation behaviour of materials.
Fibre reinforced composites based on these resins can be at least one order of magnitude better.
Table 2b
General classification of thermoset resins and composites with respect to their radiation resistence
These appreciations can only serve as a general guideline; environmental conditions such as tem-
perature, humidity and dose rate, as well as additives influence the radiation behaviour of materials.
Fibre reinforced composites based on these resins can be at least one order of magnitude better
(see Appendix 3).
APPENDIX 1
Araldite B Makrolon
Araldite D Novolac
Araldite F and other Araldite resins Orlitherm
Araldite F + epoxy Novolac Phenolic resins
Birakrit Polycarbonate resins
Cevolit Polymide resins
Crystic Polylite
Dobeckan IF Polyurethane resins
Dobeckot Resofil
Epikote Ryton
Epoxy resins Samicanit
Epoxy resins + epoxy Novolac Samicatherm
Etronax Silicone resins
Isoval Veridur
Kerimid Vetresit
Kinel Vetronite
CH3 OH n CH3
O O
H2 N CH2 NH2
H2 N S NH2
O CH2 CH CH2
CH2
CH3
O O
DMP 30 Accelerator 2, 4, 6tris[N,N(dimethylamino)methyl]phenol
OH
CH2 N(CH3)2
DX 126 (SHELL)
Curing agent anhydride
DX 127 (SHELL)
DX 125 (SHELL)
DY 040 (CIBAGEIGY) flexibilizer polypropyleneglycol
061 accelerator aminophenol
062 accelerator benzyldimethylamine
CH3
CH2 N
CH3
063 accelerator
064 accelerator aminophenol
065 accelerator unmodified sodium alkoxide
067 accelerator modified " "
EP (SHELL) EPIKOTE
154 Polyglycidyl ether of phenol formaldehyde novolac
827 (Chemical formulae see DEN)
Tetrahydrophthalic anhydride O
O
HT 907 (CIBAGEIGY) Acid anhydride hardener, solid, unmodified
Hexahydrophthalic anhydride O
C
CH2
O
CH3
R CH C R = C12H23
CH2 C
MDA Hardener
Methylenedianiline (see DDM)
MNA Hardener
Methyl nadic anhydride (formula see HY 906)
MY 720 (CIBAGEIGY) Liquid, unmodified, epoxy resin
Tetrafuncional glycidyl compound of diamines (TGDM)
MY 740 (CIBAGEIGY) Liquid, modified epoxy resin based on Bisphenol A
(see CY 205)
MY 745 (CIBAGEIGY) Liquid, modified epoxy resin based on Bisphenol A
(see CY 208, 221 and 222)
PA 4.6
H H o o
| | || ||
- N - (CH 2 ) 4 - N - c - (CH 2 ) 4 - c -
n
PEEK
o
||
c o o -
n
PEI
O CH 3 O
|
N N
O C O
|
O O
CH 3 n
PES
SO O -
2
PI
0 0
|| ||
C C
N NR
C C
|| ||
0 0 n
PPS
PSU
CH O
3
| ||
C O S
| ||
CH O n
3
TGDM N,N-tetraepoxypropyl-4,4-methylene-dianiline
O O
N CH2 N
O O
Araldite trade name of CIBA-GEIGY for epoxy resins, for behaviour under cryogenic
irradiation, see Ref. [35]
Arenka trade name of ENKA for Epikote reinforced with aramid fibers, see epoxy
composite
Arocy trade name of CIBA-GEIGY for cyanate ester based resins, see cyanate ester
List of materials classified under letter A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
24 Gy/h
200 Gy/h
200 kGy/h
2 kGy/h
10
0
0 0 1 10
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Comment: Low-dose rate irradiations (dotted lines) correspond to life irradiation in LEP.
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/A
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
B
Birakrit trade name for glass-fibre epoxy laminate, see Ref. [25], RI = 7.3
Bisphenol A base product for epoxy resins, see Araldite and epoxy resins
Cevolit trade name for glass-fibre reinforced polyester resin, see Ref. [25]; RI = 6.7
Crystic trade name for glass-fibre reinforced unsatured polyester resin, see Ref. [25];
RI = 7.3
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
100
10
0
0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Ultim. strength
10
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0.0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/C
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
D
Dacron trade name of Dupont for polyester fibres, see Ref. [25]; RI = 5.5
Dobeckot trade name for epoxy resins, see Ref. [25]; RI < 7
Durotenax trade name of ISOLA for bisphenol A epoxy, see epoxy resins
E
Epoxy resins for chemical formulas, see Appendix 2 and Ref. [25]
Araldite B, D, F trade names of CIBA-GEIGY, see Araldite
Bisphenol A epoxy (BPA)
Durotenax
Epikote
Novolac, see Ref. [25]
Samicatherm
Scotchcast, epoxy base compound
Vetresit
for behaviour under cryogenic irradiation, see Ref. [35]
Etronax trade name of Elektro-Isola for phenolic resins, see phenolic resins
List of materials classified under letter E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
Ultim. strength
10
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
2 kGy/h
Strength (MPa) - Deformation (%)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0.0 0.1 1.0 10.0 100.0 1000.0
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Comment: Low-dose rate irradiations dotted lines correspond to life irradiation in LEP.
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100 1000
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
Critical property = deformation for short term and flexural strength for long term
Radiation index (RI) =7 at a mean dose rate of 200 kGy/h
Radiation index (RI) = 6 at a mean dose rate of 3000 Gy/h
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbeb dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Comments: At 10 MGy, one sample was tested, the four others were broken before test.
Dotted lines correspond to long-term irradiation.
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/E
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Fibredux trade name of CIBA-GEIGY for carbon fibre reinforced epoxy laminate, see CFRP
G
GFRP glass fibre reinforced plastics; for behaviour under cryogenic irradiation, see
Ref. [35]
Isopreg trade name of Isovolta for epoxy pre-impregnated glass mat, see epoxy resin
Isoval trade name of Isovolta for glass reinforced epoxy resin, see Ref. [25]; RI 7
Kerimid trade name of Rhne-Poulenc for polyimide (PI), see Ref. [25]; RI = 7.8
Kinel trade name of Rhne-Poulenc for polyimide (PI), see Ref. [25]; RI = 7.9
L
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
Critical property =
Radiation index (RI) > 7.7 at a mean dose rate of 230 kGy/h
Radiation index (RI) > 7.0 at a mean dose rate of 10 kGy/h
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
M
Matramid trade name of CIBA-GEIGY for epoxy moulding compound, see epoxy
Micares trade name of Micafil for polyurethanes, see Ref. [25] and PUR
N
Nomex trade name of Dupont for meta-aramid fibres, see Ref. [26]; RI 6.5
Noryl trade name of General Electric Plastics for PPO based compound,
see PPO based compound
Novolac trade name of ISOLA for epoxy resins, see Ref. [25]
Orlitherm trade name of BBC Baden for glass fibre reinforced epoxy resins based on DGEBA
with MNA, see Ref. [25]; RI > 7.7
P
Phenolic resin
Polyamide (PA)
Polyamide-imide (PAI)
Polyarylate (PAr)
Polycarbonate (PC)
Polyester
Polyether-ether-ketone (PEEK); for behaviour under cryogenic irradiation, see Ref. [35]
Polyetherimide (PEI); for behaviour under cryogenic irradiation, see Ref. [35]
Polyethersulfone (PES); for behaviour under cryogenic irradiation, see Ref. [35]
Polyethylene (PE)
Polyimide (PI)
Polymethyl-metacrylate (PMMA)
Polyoximethylene (POM)
Polypenco trade name of Cellpack for cross-linked styrene copolymer, see styrene
Polyphenyl sulfone
Polysulfone (PSu)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
0
0.0 0.1 1.0 10.0 100.0
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
Ultim. strength
10 Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
1000
Ultim. strength
Deformation
Strength (MPa) Deformation (%)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
0
0.0 0.1 1.0 10.0 100.0
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
10
Ultim. strength
Deformation
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
CERN 9801/A3/P
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)
100
10
0
0 1 10 100
Absorbed dose (MGy)
Radiation test results according to IEC Standard 544 (and ISO 178)