Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 7

European Journal of Public Health, Vol. 19, No.

5, 554560
The Author 2009. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Public Health Association. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1093/eurpub/ckp032 Advance Access published on 25 March 2009
................................................................................................
Staff reports of psychosocial climate at
school and adolescents health, truancy
and health education in Finland
Marianna Virtanen1, Mika Kivimaki1,2, Pauliina Luopa3, Jussi Vahtera1,
Marko Elovainio3, Jukka Jokela4, Minna Pietikainen3

Background: Psychosocial climate at school reported by school personnel may be related to pupils
reports of being heard at school, depression, physical and psychological symptoms, truancy and received
health education. Methods: Cross-sectional study combining data from two independent surveys
conducted between 2004 and 2005 in 136 public schools in Finland. The pupil sample comprised 11 583
boys and 12 706 girls from the eighth and ninth grades of lower secondary school and first and second
grades of upper secondary school. A personnel survey (n = 1946) was used to measure psychosocial
climate indexed by trust and opportunity for participation, support for innovation, orientation towards
high-quality work and accepted and clear goals. Results: After adjustment for individual and school-
level covariates, multilevel analyses revealed odds for pupils opinion of not being heard were higher in
schools where personnel reported poor trust and opportunity for participation (OR = 1.33) and low

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


support for innovation (OR = 1.37). Poor trust and opportunity for participation and unclear work goals
among staff were associated with high truancy among pupils (ORs = 1.54 and 1.39). Poor trust and
opportunity for participation among staff were also related to pupils depression [cumulative odds ratio
(COR = 1.14)], and physical and psychological symptoms (COR = 1.17). Unclear goals among staff were
associated with pupils opinions that health education was insufficient (OR = 1.40). Conclusions: school
climate is associated with adolescents health, wellbeing and received health education.

Keywords: adolescents, depression, health education, school climate, truancy


................................................................................................

Introduction association between the climate seen by school personnel and


pupils perceptions of health education. However, because
ecent research has highlighted psychosocial environments
R as important determinants of positive youth develop- these studies have relied on either pupils or teachers self-
reported perceptions of both the school characteristics and the
ment.15 Psychosocial environments have been characterized measured outcomes, the findings are open to common method
by three basic dimensions: connection, regulation and bias in which individual-related factors (for example, response
autonomy across multiple settings, including families, schools style, negative affectivity) artificially inflate associations by
and neighbourhoods. These three aspects have been expanded affecting both the perception of the school climate and
to refer to other requirements for healthy adolescent develop- outcome measures.
ment, for example, physical and psychological safety, adequate In the present study, we eliminated problems related to
and appropriate supervision, supportive relationships and common method variance by linking school personnel
support for efficacy and opportunities for skill development.3 evaluations to pupils responses in two independent surveys.
In school settings, pupils perceptions of positive psychoso- We used a four-factor model of psychosocial climate at school
cial climates have been associated with positive developmental and hypothesized that pupils health and wellbeing are more
outcomes such as good mental health, and with a lack of health affected by those factors that are connected to psychological
risk behaviours, violence and delinquency.2,613 Furthermore, dimensions of school climate (trust and opportunity for
although school truancy has been shown to be associated with participation and support for innovation among staff) whereas
pupils poor school performance and feelings of unsafety their perceptions of health education at school are more
at school,14 little is known about the effect of psychosocial affected by performance-oriented dimensions (orientation
climate at school on pupils truancy.14,15 Positive school towards high-quality work and accepted and clear goals
climate, as reported by teachers themselves, has been associated among staff).18 Trust and opportunity for participation refers
with the teachers perceptions of a successful implementation to a non-threatening and supportive atmosphere that
of the health promotion programme16 and HIV/AIDS encourages involvement and creates feelings of trust. When
education17 at school, but there is no evidence about the trust and opportunity for participation is high, all members
feel sufficiently safe to contribute ideas, share information and
challenge existing ways of working without fear of being
1 Finnish Institute of Occupational Health, Topeliuksenkatu 41 a A,
00250 Helsinki, Finland criticized. The support-for-innovation dimension concerns
2 Department of Epidemiology and Public Health, University College whether suggested innovations are taken seriously, tried out
London Medical School, 1-19 Torrington Place, London WC1E and given adequate time and resources, and whether the
6BT, UK members of a work unit work together to actualize new ideas.
3 National Institute for Health and Welfare, 00531 Helsinki, Finland Orientation towards high-quality work means that the work
4 Faculty of Sport and Health Sciences, University of Jyvaskyla, unit members have a shared concern about performance
Finland
quality and constantly aim to improve the quality of their
Correspondence: Marianna Virtanen, Finnish Institute of
Occupational Health, Topeliuksenkatu 41 a A, FIN-00250 Helsinki, work, and therefore follow systems of evaluation, modification,
Finland, tel: +358 40 7450106, fax: +358-30-474 2552, control, and critical appraisal. Accepted and clear goals refer to
e-mail: marianna.virtanen@ttl.fi a vision; a valued outcome shared by all work unit members,
School climate and adolescents well-being 555

which represents a higher-order goal and motivating force at measured using a shortened 12-item version of the Beck
work, which is achievable and negotiable. In earlier research, Depression Inventory.28,29 The 12 items consist of statements
these dimensions of work unit collaboration have predicted showing increasing intensity of depressive emotions and
organizational commitment,19 work-related stress and sickness cognitions, each scored on a scale ranging from 0 to 3. A
absence20 and depression21 among employees. In the present sum score for self-reported depression was then calculated and
study, we examine whether the psychosocial climate at school categorized as none (04 points), mild (57 points), moderate
reported by school staff is associated with various pupil (815 points) and severe depression (1636 points).29
outcomes, including health, school perceptions, truancy and The psychometric properties of the 12-item scale corresponds
health education. with those of the original 13-item scale.30 Frequent physical
and psychological symptoms (neck or shoulder pain, low back
pain, stomach pain, tension or nervousness, irritability or
Methods tantrums, sleeping problems, headache and fatigue) were asked
The data were obtained from two ongoing studies: the about separately under the query: During the past six months,
Finnish School Health Promotion Study22,23 focusing on have you had some of the following symptoms and how often?
adolescent health and health behaviours, and the 10-Town with response alternatives 1 = never; 2 = about once a month;
study focusing on health of local government personnel, 3 = about once a week; 4 = almost every day. A dichotomous
including schools.24,25 The nationwide Finnish School Health variable (1 = never to once a week; 2 = almost every day) was
Promotion Study is a classroom survey which has been carried calculated for each symptom. The scale of frequent physical
out every second year since 1995. The study covers virtually and psychological symptoms was formulated as the number
all eighth and ninth grades of lower secondary schools (14- to of daily symptoms: 0, 1 or 28 symptoms.
16-year-old pupils) and the first and second grades of upper Pupils perceptions of being heard at school were assessed by

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


secondary school (16- to 18-year-old pupils). The study has three statements (Cronbachs = .59), such as: Teachers
been approved by the Ethics Committee of Tampere University encourage me to express my opinion in the classroom, with
Hospital. Either in May 2004 or May 2005 students voluntarily response alternatives 1 = totally agree; 2 = agree; 3 = disagree;
responded to the survey on their health and lifestyle habits 4 = totally disagree. A sum score from dichotomized items
(n = 25 879, response rate 84%). (0 = totally agree or agree; 1 = disagree; 2 = totally disagree) was
In the 10-Town Study, local government personnel of calculated, and pupils scoring more than three points were
the participating towns responded to a voluntary-basis identified as having an opinion that pupils do not get heard
questionnaire between October 2004 and January 2005 at school.
(response rate 65%; school personnel response rate 54%). Absenteeism was asked about in the following questions:
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the How many schooldays have you been absent from school
Finnish Institute of Occupational Health. The number of during the past month for the following reasons: (i) sickness,
secondary schools participating both to the Finnish School (ii) truancy, (iii) other reason? For each reason, the response
Health Promotion Study and the 10-Town study was 150 (83% alternatives were 1 = not at all; 2 = one day; 3 = 23 days; 4
of the secondary schools in the 10 towns). Of them, five = > 3 days. The overall absence rate was calculated and used as
schools were excluded because they had less than a required a logarithmic transformation of the mean of the three items.
minimum of four respondents among personnel. Nine more High absence due to truancy was dichotomized as follows:
schools were excluded because they had <30 participating 1 = 03 days; 2 = > 3 days.
pupils, resulting in a total of 136 included schools. The total Sufficiency of health education was asked about in a single
number of school personnel respondents was 1946 (495 men, question as follows: According to your opinion, is the
1451 women), the mean number of personnel respondents per frequency of health-related education at your school 1 = too
school being 14 (range 445, SD = 6.9). Of them, 1856 (95%) much; 2 = appropriate; 3 = too little?
were teachers (84 head teachers). The remaining 5% were Frequency of classroom conversations or lessons about
mainly administrative staff and canteen workers. In the 136 health risk behaviours was asked about with the questions
schools, the number of pupil respondents was 25 879, for 94% During this school period, have you had classroom conversa-
(24 289) of whom there were complete demographic data. tions or otherwise been taught about the following subjects:
The mean number of pupil respondents per school was 190 (i) smoking, snuffing; (ii) alcohol; (iii) drugs; (iv) sex and
(range 32531, SD = 76.2). relationships between boys and girls? with response alter-
Psychosocial climate among the school personnel was natives 0 = no; 1 = in one class; 2 = in several classes. From this
measured in the 10-Town study by using the short 14-item information, a total score was calculated by summing up the
version of The Team Climate Inventory26 developed from points in each subject category (range 08 points) and divided
the original 38-item version.27 The inventory measures into five groups (1 = 0 points; 2 = 12 points; 3 = 34 points;
four dimensions of team climate: (i) trust and opportunity 4 = 56 points; 5 = 78 points, that is, all subjects been taught
for participation (four items, Cronbachs = 0.90; example of several times during this school period).
item: Everyone feels that they are both understood and The sex and age of the pupils were derived from the survey
accepted); (ii) support for innovation (three items, = 0.88; responses. Each pupils socioeconomic background was
example of item: In our workplace we take the time needed to ascertained from two questions asking separately about the
develop new ideas); (iii) orientation towards high-quality mothers and fathers education: What is the highest
work (three items, = 0.79; example of item: In your work education your parents have performed? (1 = comprehensive
place, do you pay attention to weaknesses in your work to school/comprehensive school and vocational school; 2 = upper
improve quality?); (iv) accepted and clear goals (4 items, secondary school/upper secondary school and institute;
= 0.84; example of item: Do you accept the goals set at your 3 = college or university). If both the mothers and fathers
work place?). The participants evaluated all statements on education were reported, the highest education level between
a five-point Likert-type scale (1 = totally disagree to 5 = totally them was chosen.
agree). School-level averages were calculated and linked to the To assess pupil socioeconomic composition at school,31
pupil survey. proportion of pupils with low parental education was
All pupil variables were obtained from the Finnish School calculated using the measure of individual responses about
Health Promotion study. Self-reported depression was the parental education. Pupils with low parental education
556 European Journal of Public Health

were those whose parents education level was vocational adjustment for parental education had little effect on the
school or less (range between schools varied from 3.7% to results (model 1 results not shown). None of the other staff-
67.9%). The schools were then put into one of three categories reported dimensions of psychosocial climate at school were
based on this percentage: <20% of pupils with parents with related to pupils health.
low levels of education; 2039.9%; 40%). Table 4 presents the relationship between psychosocial
We used the SAS 9.1 GLIMMIX procedure in the multilevel climate assessed by the school staff and pupils truancy and
analyses to assess the school-level and individual-level effects perceptions of being heard. Poor trust and opportunity
on pupil outcomes. For dichotomous outcome variables, we for participation among staff were associated with pupils
used multilevel random intercept models in binary logistic perception of not being heard (OR = 1.33) and with high
regression models and calculated odds ratios (ORs) and their truancy (OR = 1.54). Low support for innovation was also
95% confidence intervals (CIs). For outcome variables with related to pupils perceptions of not being heard (OR = 1.37).
three or four categories, we used multilevel random intercept If the personnel thought that goals were not accepted and clear
models with a multinomial logistic regression procedure for at school, pupils were 1.39 times more likely to have high
calculating cumulative odds ratios (CORs) and their 95% CIs. absence rates due to truancy. As in table 3, adjustment for
Dimensions of school psychosocial climate were divided into parental education had little effect on the results.
quartiles to indicate four levels for each scale. We made Table 5 shows the association between the staffs perceptions
adjustments for pupils sex, age, parental education, the of the psychosocial climate at school and pupils perceptions
proportion of pupils at school having parents with low levels of received health education. Poor clarity and acceptance of
of education, and the proportion of non-teacher respondents goals were related to pupils perceptions of insufficient health
among school personnel. Because a pupils own absenteeism education (COR = 1.40). Adjustment for parental education
may affect his/her perception of health education received,

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


had little effect on the results.
we adjusted the models concerning health education also for
pupils overall absenteeism.
Table 1 Descriptive characteristics of the pupils
Results Pupil characteristics n (%)a/Mean (SD)
Table 1 presents descriptive characteristics of the pupils and Age (Mean, SD) 15.6 (1.1)
schools. Of the pupils, 48% were girls and 52% were boys. Sex
Twenty-seven percent of the pupils had parents with low Boy 11 583 (48)
education and 46% had parents with college or university level Girl 12 706 (52)
education. Depression scores indicated that 78% had no Socioeconomic background (parental education)
Comprehensive school/vocational school 6667 (27)
depression, 11% were mildly depressed, 8% were moderately Upper secondary school/upper secondary 6433 (26)
depressed and 2% were severely depressed. Two or more school and institute
frequent physical and psychological symptoms were reported College or university 11 189 (46)
by 15% of the pupils, 26% thought they were not heard at Depression (number of symptoms)
school, 5% had been absent from school due to truancy > 3 04 18 549 (78)
days during the past month and 25% thought health education 57 2592 (11)
815 1979 (8)
is insufficient. Twenty-two percent reported no classroom 1636 576 (2)
conversations or lessons about any of the health behaviours Frequent physical symptoms (number)
asked about, whereas 19% had had conversations or lessons 0 15 923 (68)
about all of the topics. 1 3979 (17)
Descriptive characteristics of the participating 136 schools 28 3636 (15)
Opinion about whether pupils have voice at school
are presented in table 2. Largest variance was found for pupil
Yes 17 812 (74)
composition, that is, proportion of pupils with low parental No 6168 (26)
education. The high variation on pupil composition may relate One-month absenteeism due to truancy
to the differences in participating schools of which a part were 03 days 22 004 (95)
secondary (compulsory) schools and a part were upper 4 days 1157 (5)
secondary (non-compulsory schools). Frequency of health education at school
Too much 953 (4)
Table 3 shows the relationship between staff experiences of
Sufficient 17 167 (71)
the psychosocial climate at school and pupil-reported depres- Too little 6048 (25)
sion and physical and psychological symptoms. Poor trust and Frequency of classroom conversations about health risk behaviours
opportunity for participation among staff was associated both All subjects several times 4548 (19)
with pupils depression and with physical and psychological 56 points 3700 (16)
symptoms (CORs = 1.14 and 1.17, respectively, in the final 34 points 6771 (28)
12 points 3607 (15)
models). To examine the relative contribution of school None 5190 (22)
variables on pupil outcomes, we made analyses before and after
adjustment for pupils parental education. However, a: Figures are numbers (percentages) unless otherwise stated

Table 2 School characteristics

Mean (SD) Variance Minimum Maximum


a
Proportion of pupils with low parental education (%) 28.60 (12.47) 155.60 3.66 67.86
Trust and opportunity for participation (school personnel mean) 3.70 (0.38) 0.15 2.63 4.50
Support for innovation (school personnel mean) 3.30 (0.39) 0.15 2.20 4.57
Orientation towards high-quality work (school personnel mean) 3.35 (0.31) 0.10 2.22 4.22
Accepted and clear goals (school personnel mean) 3.92 (0.25) 0.06 3.34 4.63

a: Parental education consists of comprehensive school/comprehensive school and vocational school.


School climate and adolescents well-being 557

Table 3 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and pupils health problems

Depression Physical and psychological symptoms


School personnel reports of the
psychosocial climate at school COR (95% CI)a P-value COR (95% CI)a P-value

Trust and opportunity for participation


I highest 1.00 1.00
II 0.95 (0.841.09) 0.484 1.04 (0.921.16) 0.541
III 1.00 (0.881.14) 0.990 1.04 (0.931.17) 0.454
IV lowest 1.14 (1.011.29) 0.042 1.17 (1.051.31) 0.006
Support for innovation
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 0.98 (0.851.12) 0.739 0.97 (0.861.09) 0.763
III 1.08 (0.951.24) 0.228 1.08 (0.961.22) 0.431
IV lowest 1.09 (0.961.25) 0.194 1.05 (0.931.18) 0.560
Orientation towards high-quality work
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.00 (0.881.15) 0.970 0.93 (0.831.05) 0.224
III 0.96 (0.851.10) 0.586 1.02 (0.911.14) 0.734
IV lowest 1.09 (0.961.24) 0.189 1.06 (0.941.19) 0.352
Accepted and clear goals
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.00 (0.871.14) 0.957 1.03 (0.921.16) 0.603

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


III 1.03 (0.901.18) 0.647 1.06 (0.951.20) 0.306
IV lowest 0.98 (0.851.12) 0.761 1.01 (0.901.14) 0.870

a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel

Table 4 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and school perceptions and behaviours
among pupils

Pupils school perceptions and behaviours

Pupils are not heard High truancy


School personnel reports of the
psychosocial climate at school OR (95% CI)a P-value OR (95% CI)a P-value

Trust and opportunity for participation


I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.04 (0.831.31) 0.744 1.13 (0.861.49) 0.430
III 1.23 (0.981.53) 0.076 1.48 (1.131.93) 0.004
IV lowest 1.33 (1.061.66) 0.012 1.54 (1.182.00) 0.002
Support for innovation
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.30 (1.031.63) 0.028 0.90 (0.681.20) 0.482
III 1.39 (1.101.75) 0.006 1.14 (0.861.51) 0.371
IV lowest 1.37 (1.091.73) 0.008 1.18 (0.901.57) 0.230
Orientation towards high-quality work
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 0.88 (0.701.11) 0.290 1.10 (0.831.47) 0.495
III 1.05 (0.831.32) 0.684 1.23 (0.931.63) 0.146
IV lowest 1.07 (0.851.35) 0.576 1.23 (0.931.63) 0.140
Accepted and clear goals
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.36 (1.071.72) 0.011 1.27 (0.961.68) 0.089
III 1.26 (0.991.60) 0.059 1.47 (1.121.94) 0.006
IV lowest 1.26 (0.991.61) 0.058 1.39 (1.051.83) 0.023

a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel

in the lowest quartile of trust and opportunity for participation


compared to those in schools in the highest quartile had a
Discussion 1.14-fold risk of depressive symptoms, a 1.17-fold risk
In this large study of over 24 000 Finnish adolescents, we found of numerous physical and psychological symptoms and a
a relationship between staff-reported psychosocial climate 1.54-fold risk of truancy. Other dimensions of psychosocial
at school and various pupil-reported outcomes. We found climate at school were more weak or not at all associated with
that among the different dimensions of psychosocial climate pupil health and truancy. To our knowledge, this is the first
at school, trust and opportunity for participation was the study to report the association between the staff-reported
only significant predictor of pupils health and the strongest psychosocial climate and the health of the pupils. An
predictor of absenteeism due to truancy. Pupils from schools association has been found between organizational climate as
558 European Journal of Public Health

Table 5 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and pupils reports of health education at
school

Pupils reports of health education

Low frequency of classroom conversations


Health education is insufficient and lessons about health risk behaviours
School personnel reports of the
psychosocial climate at school COR (95% CI)a P-value COR (95% CI)a P-value

Trust and opportunity for participation


I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.05 (0.801.38) 0.710 1.17 (0.901.54) 0.237
III 1.24 (0.951.62) 0.107 1.03 (0.791.35) 0.802
IV lowest 1.30 (1.001.69) 0.054 1.06 (0.821.38) 0.651
Support for innovation
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.07 (0.811.41) 0.616 1.06 (0.811.39) 0.647
III 1.27 (0.971.68) 0.086 1.17 (0.891.53) 0.258
IV lowest 1.15 (0.871.52) 0.316 1.14 (0.871.49) 0.348
Orientation towards high-quality work
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 0.98 (0.751.30) 0.912 1.17 (0.901.53) 0.233
III 1.06 (0.811.40) 0.659 0.96 (0.741.24) 0.739

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


IV lowest 1.02 (0.771.35) 0.885 1.27 (0.981.66) 0.075
Accepted and clear goals
I highest 1.00 1.00
II 1.28 (0.981.68) 0.065 0.78 (0.601.01) 0.061
III 1.36 (1.041.77) 0.026 0.98 (0.751.27) 0.853
IV lowest 1.40 (1.061.83) 0.017 1.05 (0.801.37) 0.739

a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel

seen by the personnel in youth mental health clinics and that clear concepts and models of how to organize this subject
patient outcomes.32 Earlier research has also shown that have not yet been developed in many schools. Our results
pupils own perceptions of their school climate is associated suggest that accepted and clear goals, meaning a valued
with their health, wellbeing and problem behaviours.2,413 outcome which represents a higher-order goal and motivating
As expected, our results indicate that trust and opportunity force at work, and an orientation towards high-quality work,
for participation at school may be important determinants of meaning work-unit members continuous attempts to improve
adolescent mental health and problem behaviours. When the quality of their work, may predict the frequency of health
people feel that they can participate in decision-making and education and lessons about health risks at school. It is possible
feel safe to contribute ideas, share information and challenge that in schools where the goals are clear and well debated there
existing ways of working without fear of being criticized. Thus, might more likely to be a shared opinion that health
trust and opportunity for participation refer to a situation in promotion is a valued goal, and personnel in these schools
which the members of the work group perceive the may have a greater motivation to teach health-related subjects
interpersonal environment as non-threatening. High trust to adolescents. In the future, it would be important to examine
among adults at school is likely to increase the chances that whether this aspect of psychosocial climate at school also
pupils will confide in school staff, which in turn enables predicts commitment and success in school-based interven-
early detection and prevention of antisocial behaviour and tions to promote healthy lifestyle among adolescents.16,17
violence.7 Truancy has frequently been considered part of The main strength of this study was the use of information
a general deviance or problem behaviour syndrome in which obtained from two independent sources, school personnel and
poor school performance, mental health problems, aggression, pupils, which minimizes the bias related to common method
substance abuse and family difficulties are clustered.33 variance. We adjusted for the most likely confounders in our
We found a relationship between personnel evaluations of analyses, that is, pupils sex, age, absence rate and parents
two dimensions of psychosocial climate at school, i.e. trust, education level as well as the pupil composition at school.
opportunity for participation and support for innovation and Other characteristics, such as attachment to the family,
pupils opinions of whether they are heard at school or not. have been shown to affect adolescent health and problem
These associations suggest that there is a shared perception of behaviour,2 but this was not adjusted for in the present
school collaboration between pupils and adults. Performance- analysis. However, attachment to the family may act as
oriented dimensions (orientation towards high-quality work a confounding factor only if it is also related to school staff
and accepted and clear goals) were not significantly related to perceptions of psychosocial climate at school.
pupils opinions of whether they were heard at school or not. The response rate in the pupils survey was high (84%),
We also found some, although modest evidence of an whereas the response rate among the school personnel was
association between the psychosocial climate at school and relatively low, 54%. The low-response rate may have biased the
pupils reports of health education received at school. Accepted results if non-response was non-random in relation to school
and clear goal among staff were related to pupil reports of climate. This is unlikely at least in relation to pupil outcomes,
more sufficient health education. Confounding by pupils high as the surveys were completely independent.
absence rates was not possible because overall absence rates Because our study was cross sectional, we cannot draw
were controlled for in the analyses. Health education is a conclusions about the temporal order between the variables. It
relatively new subject at schools in Finland and it is possible is possible that health problems and problem behaviour among
School climate and adolescents well-being 559

adolescents affect staff perceptions of school psychosocial 6 Simons-Morton BG, Davis Crump A, Haynie DL, et al. Student-
climate. However, pupils reports about insufficient health school bonding and adolescent problem behaviour. Health Educ Res
education cannot easily be explained by pupils passivity or 1999;14:99107.
problem behaviour only. Selection bias cannot be ruled out 7 Greene MB. Reducing violence and aggression in schools. Trauma Violence
either. Personnel with low work motivation and poor Abuse 2005;6:23653.
teamwork capacity may be employed by schools where 8 Brookmeyer KA, Fanti KA, Herrich CC. Schools, parents and youth
pupils also have health-related and behavioural problems. violence: a multilevel, ecological analysis. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol
Prospective studies are therefore needed to confirm the 2006;35:50414.
direction of the causality. Pupil socioeconomic composition 9 Bonny AE, Britto MT, Klostermann BK, et al. School disconnectedness:
is an important factor potentially related to the psychosocial identifying adolescents at risk. Pediatrics 2000;106:101721.
climate at school. However, a limitation in our study is that 10 Voisin DR, Salazar LF, Crosby R, et al. Teacher connectedness and
our measurement of pupil composition was based on pupils health-related outcomes among detained adolescents. J Adolesc Health
report of their parents education which may not the best one 2005;37:337.
to catch pupil socioeconomic composition at school. However, 11 Mc Neely C, Falci C. School connectedness and transition into and out of
we analysed correlations between psychosocial variables and health risk behaviour among adolescents: a comparison of social belonging
pupil composition at school and found that none of them were and teacher support. J School Health 2004;74:27283.
significantly correlated with pupil composition (P > 0.30),
12 Resnick MD, Harris L, Blum R. The impact of caring and
indicating that this limitation is unlikely to be a major source
connectedness on adolescent health and well-being. J Paediatr Child Health
of bias in our study.
1993;29:S39.
In summary, the psychosocial climate at school as reported
13 Andersen A, Holstein BE, Due P. School-related risk factors for drunkenness
by school staff is associated with adolescent school perceptions,

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011


among adolescents: risk factors differ between socio-economic groups. Eur J
truancy, health symptoms and received health education.
Public Health 2006;17:2732.
Trust and opportunity for participation among the school staff
seem to be especially important for pupils health problems 14 Henry KL. Whos skipping school: Characteristics of truants in 8th and 10th
grade. J School Health 2007;77:2935.
and truancy, whereas accepted and clear goals may be
important for pupils perceptions about the sufficiency of 15 Mattison RE. School consultation: A review of research on issues unique
health education. The present findings suggest that the to the school environment. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
psychosocial climate at school is an important contributor 2000;39:40213.
to the promotion of adolescent health and wellbeing. 16 Parcel GS, Perry CL, Kelder SH, et al. School climate and the
institutionalization of the CATCH program. Health Educ Behav
2003;30:489502.
Funding 17 Matthews C, Boon H, Flisher AJ, Schaalma HP. Factors associated with
Academy of Finland (#117604, #124322, and #124271). teachers implementation of HIV/AIDS education in secondary schools in
Cape Town, South Africa. AIDS Care 2006;18:38897.
Conflict of interest: None declared. 18 West M. The social psychology of innovation in groups. In: West M, Farr J,
editors. Innovation and creativity at work: psychological and organisational
strategies. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, 1990, 30933.

Key points 19 Jalonen P, Virtanen M, Vahtera J, et al. Predictors of sustained organisational


commitment among nurses with temporary job contracts. J Nurs Admin
 The psychosocial climate at school reported by school 2006;36:26876.
staff is associated with adolescent reports of their 20 Kivimaki M, Sutinen R, Elovainio M, et al. Sickness absence in hospital
health, school attitudes, truancy and received health physicians 2-year follow-up study on determinants. Occup Environ Med
education. 2001;58:3616.
 Trust and opportunity for participation at school seem 21 Ylipaavalniemi J, Kivimaki M, Elovainio M, et al. Psychosocial work
to be especially important for pupils health problems characteristics and incidence of newly diagnosed depression: a prospective
and truancy. cohort study of three different models. Soc Sci Med 2005;61:11122.
 Accepted and clear goals among school personnel may 22 Hakala P, Rimpela A, Salminen JJ, et al. Back, neck, and shoulder
be important for the sufficiency of health education pain in Finnish adolescents: national cross sectional study. Br Med J
received at school. 2002;325:743.
23 Kaltiala-Heino R, Rimpela M, Marttunen M, et al. Bullying, depression, and
suicidal ideation in Finnish adolescents: School survey. Br Med J
1999;319:34851.
References 24 Vahtera J, Kivimaki M, Pentti J, et al. Organisational downsizing, sickness
absence, and mortality: 10-town prospective cohort study. Br Med J
1 Sellstrom E, Bremberg S. Is there a school effect on pupil outcomes?
A review of multilevel studies. J Epidemiol Community Health 2004;328:555.
2006;60:14955. 25 Vahtera J, Poikolainen K, Kivimaki M, et al. Alcohol intake and sickness
2 Resnick MD, Bearman PS, Blum RW, et al. Protecting adolescents from absence: a curvilinear relation. Am J Epidemiol 2002;156:96976.
harm. Findings from the National Longitudinal Study on Adolescent Health. 26 Kivimaki M, Elovainio M. A short version of the Team Climate Inventory:
JAMA 1997;278:82332. development and psychometric properties. J Occup Organ Psychol
3 Youngblade LM, Theokas C, Schulenberg J, et al. Risk and promotive factors 1999;72:2416.
in families, schools, and communities: a contextual model of positive youth 27 Anderson N, West M. The Team Climate Inventory: manual and users guide.
development in adolescence. Pediatrics 2007;119:54753. Windsor: NFER-Nelson, ASE Press, 1994.
4 Konu AI, Lintonen TP, Rimpela MK. Factors associated with school- 28 Beck AT, Beck RW. Screening depressed patients in family practice. A rapid
childrens general subjective wellbeing. Health Educ Res 2002;17:15565. technic. Postgrad Med 1972;52:815.
5 Haavet OR, dalen I, Straand J. Depressive symptoms in adolescent pupils are 29 Chinet L, Plancherel B, Bolognini M, et al. Substance use and depression.
heavily influenced by the school they go to. A study of 10th grade pupils in Comparative course in adolescents. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry
Oslo, Norway. Eur J Public Health 2005;16:4004. 2006;15:14955.
560 European Journal of Public Health

30 Kaltiala-Heino R, Kosunen E, Rimpela M. Pubertal timing, sexual behaviour 32 Glisson C, Landsverk J, Schoenwald S, et al. Assessing the organisational
and self-reported depression in middle adolescence. J Adolesc social context (OSC) of mental health services: implications for research and
2003;26:53145. practice. Adm Policy Ment Health 2008;35:98113.
31 Virtanen M, Kivimaki M, Elovainio M, et al. Neighbourhood socioeconomic 33 Miller P, Plant M. Truancy and perceived school performance: an alcohol
status, health and working conditions of school teachers. J Epidemiol and drug study of UK teenagers. Alcohol Alcoholism 1999;34:88693.
Community Health 2007;61:32630.
Received 30 April 2008, accepted 17 February 2009

Downloaded from eurpub.oxfordjournals.org by guest on April 18, 2011

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi