Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
5, 554560
The Author 2009. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Public Health Association. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1093/eurpub/ckp032 Advance Access published on 25 March 2009
................................................................................................
Staff reports of psychosocial climate at
school and adolescents health, truancy
and health education in Finland
Marianna Virtanen1, Mika Kivimaki1,2, Pauliina Luopa3, Jussi Vahtera1,
Marko Elovainio3, Jukka Jokela4, Minna Pietikainen3
Background: Psychosocial climate at school reported by school personnel may be related to pupils
reports of being heard at school, depression, physical and psychological symptoms, truancy and received
health education. Methods: Cross-sectional study combining data from two independent surveys
conducted between 2004 and 2005 in 136 public schools in Finland. The pupil sample comprised 11 583
boys and 12 706 girls from the eighth and ninth grades of lower secondary school and first and second
grades of upper secondary school. A personnel survey (n = 1946) was used to measure psychosocial
climate indexed by trust and opportunity for participation, support for innovation, orientation towards
high-quality work and accepted and clear goals. Results: After adjustment for individual and school-
level covariates, multilevel analyses revealed odds for pupils opinion of not being heard were higher in
schools where personnel reported poor trust and opportunity for participation (OR = 1.33) and low
which represents a higher-order goal and motivating force at measured using a shortened 12-item version of the Beck
work, which is achievable and negotiable. In earlier research, Depression Inventory.28,29 The 12 items consist of statements
these dimensions of work unit collaboration have predicted showing increasing intensity of depressive emotions and
organizational commitment,19 work-related stress and sickness cognitions, each scored on a scale ranging from 0 to 3. A
absence20 and depression21 among employees. In the present sum score for self-reported depression was then calculated and
study, we examine whether the psychosocial climate at school categorized as none (04 points), mild (57 points), moderate
reported by school staff is associated with various pupil (815 points) and severe depression (1636 points).29
outcomes, including health, school perceptions, truancy and The psychometric properties of the 12-item scale corresponds
health education. with those of the original 13-item scale.30 Frequent physical
and psychological symptoms (neck or shoulder pain, low back
pain, stomach pain, tension or nervousness, irritability or
Methods tantrums, sleeping problems, headache and fatigue) were asked
The data were obtained from two ongoing studies: the about separately under the query: During the past six months,
Finnish School Health Promotion Study22,23 focusing on have you had some of the following symptoms and how often?
adolescent health and health behaviours, and the 10-Town with response alternatives 1 = never; 2 = about once a month;
study focusing on health of local government personnel, 3 = about once a week; 4 = almost every day. A dichotomous
including schools.24,25 The nationwide Finnish School Health variable (1 = never to once a week; 2 = almost every day) was
Promotion Study is a classroom survey which has been carried calculated for each symptom. The scale of frequent physical
out every second year since 1995. The study covers virtually and psychological symptoms was formulated as the number
all eighth and ninth grades of lower secondary schools (14- to of daily symptoms: 0, 1 or 28 symptoms.
16-year-old pupils) and the first and second grades of upper Pupils perceptions of being heard at school were assessed by
were those whose parents education level was vocational adjustment for parental education had little effect on the
school or less (range between schools varied from 3.7% to results (model 1 results not shown). None of the other staff-
67.9%). The schools were then put into one of three categories reported dimensions of psychosocial climate at school were
based on this percentage: <20% of pupils with parents with related to pupils health.
low levels of education; 2039.9%; 40%). Table 4 presents the relationship between psychosocial
We used the SAS 9.1 GLIMMIX procedure in the multilevel climate assessed by the school staff and pupils truancy and
analyses to assess the school-level and individual-level effects perceptions of being heard. Poor trust and opportunity
on pupil outcomes. For dichotomous outcome variables, we for participation among staff were associated with pupils
used multilevel random intercept models in binary logistic perception of not being heard (OR = 1.33) and with high
regression models and calculated odds ratios (ORs) and their truancy (OR = 1.54). Low support for innovation was also
95% confidence intervals (CIs). For outcome variables with related to pupils perceptions of not being heard (OR = 1.37).
three or four categories, we used multilevel random intercept If the personnel thought that goals were not accepted and clear
models with a multinomial logistic regression procedure for at school, pupils were 1.39 times more likely to have high
calculating cumulative odds ratios (CORs) and their 95% CIs. absence rates due to truancy. As in table 3, adjustment for
Dimensions of school psychosocial climate were divided into parental education had little effect on the results.
quartiles to indicate four levels for each scale. We made Table 5 shows the association between the staffs perceptions
adjustments for pupils sex, age, parental education, the of the psychosocial climate at school and pupils perceptions
proportion of pupils at school having parents with low levels of received health education. Poor clarity and acceptance of
of education, and the proportion of non-teacher respondents goals were related to pupils perceptions of insufficient health
among school personnel. Because a pupils own absenteeism education (COR = 1.40). Adjustment for parental education
may affect his/her perception of health education received,
Table 3 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and pupils health problems
a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel
Table 4 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and school perceptions and behaviours
among pupils
a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel
Table 5 Association between personnel evaluations about school psychosocial climate and pupils reports of health education at
school
a: Adjusted for pupils sex, age, parental education, the proportion of pupils with low parental education at school and for the
proportion of non-teacher respondents among school personnel
seen by the personnel in youth mental health clinics and that clear concepts and models of how to organize this subject
patient outcomes.32 Earlier research has also shown that have not yet been developed in many schools. Our results
pupils own perceptions of their school climate is associated suggest that accepted and clear goals, meaning a valued
with their health, wellbeing and problem behaviours.2,413 outcome which represents a higher-order goal and motivating
As expected, our results indicate that trust and opportunity force at work, and an orientation towards high-quality work,
for participation at school may be important determinants of meaning work-unit members continuous attempts to improve
adolescent mental health and problem behaviours. When the quality of their work, may predict the frequency of health
people feel that they can participate in decision-making and education and lessons about health risks at school. It is possible
feel safe to contribute ideas, share information and challenge that in schools where the goals are clear and well debated there
existing ways of working without fear of being criticized. Thus, might more likely to be a shared opinion that health
trust and opportunity for participation refer to a situation in promotion is a valued goal, and personnel in these schools
which the members of the work group perceive the may have a greater motivation to teach health-related subjects
interpersonal environment as non-threatening. High trust to adolescents. In the future, it would be important to examine
among adults at school is likely to increase the chances that whether this aspect of psychosocial climate at school also
pupils will confide in school staff, which in turn enables predicts commitment and success in school-based interven-
early detection and prevention of antisocial behaviour and tions to promote healthy lifestyle among adolescents.16,17
violence.7 Truancy has frequently been considered part of The main strength of this study was the use of information
a general deviance or problem behaviour syndrome in which obtained from two independent sources, school personnel and
poor school performance, mental health problems, aggression, pupils, which minimizes the bias related to common method
substance abuse and family difficulties are clustered.33 variance. We adjusted for the most likely confounders in our
We found a relationship between personnel evaluations of analyses, that is, pupils sex, age, absence rate and parents
two dimensions of psychosocial climate at school, i.e. trust, education level as well as the pupil composition at school.
opportunity for participation and support for innovation and Other characteristics, such as attachment to the family,
pupils opinions of whether they are heard at school or not. have been shown to affect adolescent health and problem
These associations suggest that there is a shared perception of behaviour,2 but this was not adjusted for in the present
school collaboration between pupils and adults. Performance- analysis. However, attachment to the family may act as
oriented dimensions (orientation towards high-quality work a confounding factor only if it is also related to school staff
and accepted and clear goals) were not significantly related to perceptions of psychosocial climate at school.
pupils opinions of whether they were heard at school or not. The response rate in the pupils survey was high (84%),
We also found some, although modest evidence of an whereas the response rate among the school personnel was
association between the psychosocial climate at school and relatively low, 54%. The low-response rate may have biased the
pupils reports of health education received at school. Accepted results if non-response was non-random in relation to school
and clear goal among staff were related to pupil reports of climate. This is unlikely at least in relation to pupil outcomes,
more sufficient health education. Confounding by pupils high as the surveys were completely independent.
absence rates was not possible because overall absence rates Because our study was cross sectional, we cannot draw
were controlled for in the analyses. Health education is a conclusions about the temporal order between the variables. It
relatively new subject at schools in Finland and it is possible is possible that health problems and problem behaviour among
School climate and adolescents well-being 559
adolescents affect staff perceptions of school psychosocial 6 Simons-Morton BG, Davis Crump A, Haynie DL, et al. Student-
climate. However, pupils reports about insufficient health school bonding and adolescent problem behaviour. Health Educ Res
education cannot easily be explained by pupils passivity or 1999;14:99107.
problem behaviour only. Selection bias cannot be ruled out 7 Greene MB. Reducing violence and aggression in schools. Trauma Violence
either. Personnel with low work motivation and poor Abuse 2005;6:23653.
teamwork capacity may be employed by schools where 8 Brookmeyer KA, Fanti KA, Herrich CC. Schools, parents and youth
pupils also have health-related and behavioural problems. violence: a multilevel, ecological analysis. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol
Prospective studies are therefore needed to confirm the 2006;35:50414.
direction of the causality. Pupil socioeconomic composition 9 Bonny AE, Britto MT, Klostermann BK, et al. School disconnectedness:
is an important factor potentially related to the psychosocial identifying adolescents at risk. Pediatrics 2000;106:101721.
climate at school. However, a limitation in our study is that 10 Voisin DR, Salazar LF, Crosby R, et al. Teacher connectedness and
our measurement of pupil composition was based on pupils health-related outcomes among detained adolescents. J Adolesc Health
report of their parents education which may not the best one 2005;37:337.
to catch pupil socioeconomic composition at school. However, 11 Mc Neely C, Falci C. School connectedness and transition into and out of
we analysed correlations between psychosocial variables and health risk behaviour among adolescents: a comparison of social belonging
pupil composition at school and found that none of them were and teacher support. J School Health 2004;74:27283.
significantly correlated with pupil composition (P > 0.30),
12 Resnick MD, Harris L, Blum R. The impact of caring and
indicating that this limitation is unlikely to be a major source
connectedness on adolescent health and well-being. J Paediatr Child Health
of bias in our study.
1993;29:S39.
In summary, the psychosocial climate at school as reported
13 Andersen A, Holstein BE, Due P. School-related risk factors for drunkenness
by school staff is associated with adolescent school perceptions,
30 Kaltiala-Heino R, Kosunen E, Rimpela M. Pubertal timing, sexual behaviour 32 Glisson C, Landsverk J, Schoenwald S, et al. Assessing the organisational
and self-reported depression in middle adolescence. J Adolesc social context (OSC) of mental health services: implications for research and
2003;26:53145. practice. Adm Policy Ment Health 2008;35:98113.
31 Virtanen M, Kivimaki M, Elovainio M, et al. Neighbourhood socioeconomic 33 Miller P, Plant M. Truancy and perceived school performance: an alcohol
status, health and working conditions of school teachers. J Epidemiol and drug study of UK teenagers. Alcohol Alcoholism 1999;34:88693.
Community Health 2007;61:32630.
Received 30 April 2008, accepted 17 February 2009