Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
4
WORKPLACE EMOTIONS
AND ATTITUDES
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reading this chapter, students should be able to:
Define emotions and identify the two dimensions around which emotions are organized.
Diagram the model of emotions, attitudes, and behaviour.
Identify the conditions that require and problems with emotional labour.
Outline the four components of emotional intelligence.
Summarize the effects of job dissatisfaction in terms of the exit-voice-loyalty-neglect model.
Compare the effects of affective and continuance commitment on employee behaviour.
Describe five strategies to increase organizational commitment.
Contrast transactional and relational psychological contracts.
Discuss the trend towards employability.
CHAPTER GLOSSARY
attitudes The cluster of beliefs, assessed feelings, and emotional labour The effort, planning, and control
behavioural intentions toward an object. needed to express organizationally desired emotions
during interpersonal transactions.
cognitive dissonance Occurs when people perceive an
inconsistency between their beliefs, feelings, and emotions Psychological and physiological episodes
behaviour. toward an object, person, or event that create a state of
readiness.
continuance commitment A bond felt by an employee
that motivates him to stay only because leaving would exit-voice-loyalty-neglect (EVNL) model
be costly. The four ways, as indicated in the name,
employees respond to job dissatisfaction.
emotional dissonance The conflict between required
and true emotions. job satisfaction A persons attitude regarding his or
her job and work content.
emotional intelligence (EI) The ability to perceive
and express emotion, assimilate emotion in thought, negative affectivity (NA) The tendency to
understand and reason with emotion, and regulate experience negative emotions.
emotion in oneself and others
99
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
CHAPTER SYNOPSIS
Emotions are psychological and physiological episodes minimized through deep acing rather than surface
experienced toward an object, person, or event that acting.
create a state of readiness. Emotions are typically Emotional intelligence is the ability to perceive and
organized into a bi-polar circle (circumplex) based on express emotion, assimilate emotion in thought,
their pleasantness and activation. Emotions differ from understand and reason with emotion, and regulate
attitudes, which represent the cluster of beliefs, emotion in oneself and others. This concept includes
feelings, and behavioural intentions toward a person, four components arranged in a hierarchy: perceiving
object, or event. Beliefs are a persons established and expressing emotions, assimilating emotions,
perceptions about the attitude object. Feelings are understanding emotions, and managing emotions.
positive or negative evaluations of the attitude object. Emotional intelligence can be learned to some extent,
Behavioural intentions represent a motivation to particularly through personal coaching.
engage in a particular behaviour with respect to the Job satisfaction represents a person's evaluation of
target. his or her job and work context. Satisfaction depends
Attitudes have traditionally been studied as a on the level of discrepancy between people expect to
rational process of analysing the value and expectancy receive and what they experience. Although surveys
of outcomes of the attitude object. Thus, beliefs predict indicate Canadians are highly satisfied with their jobs,
feelings, which predict behavioural intentions, which these results may be somewhat inflated by the use of
predict behaviour. But this traditional perspective single-item questions and cultural differences. The
overlooks the role of emotions, which have an exit-voice-loyalty-neglect model outlines four possible
important influence of attitudes and behaviour. consequences of job dissatisfaction. Job satisfaction has
Emotions typically form before we think through a moderate relationship with job performance and with
situations, so they influence this rational attitude customer satisfaction. Job satisfaction is also a moral
formation process. Emotions also affect behaviour obligation in many societies.
directly. Affective organizational commitment (loyalty)
Behaviour sometimes influences our subsequent refers to the employees emotional attachment to,
attitudes through cognitive dissonance. People also identification with, and involvement in a particular
have the personality traits of positive or negative organization. This contrasts with continuance
affectivity which affect their emotions and attitudes. commitment, which is a calculative bond with the
Emotional labour refers to the effort, planning, and organization. Affective commitment improves
control needed to express organizationally desired motivation and organizational citizenship, and
emotions during interpersonal transactions. This is somewhat higher job performance, whereas
more common in jobs with frequent and lengthy continuance commitment is associated with lower
customer interaction, where the job requires a variety performance and organizational citizenship.
of emotions displayed, and where employees must Companies build loyalty through justice and support,
abide by the display rules. Emotional labour creates some level of job security, organizational
problems because true emotions tend to leak out, and comprehension, employee involvement, and trust.
conflict between expected and true emotions The psychological contract refers to the individuals
(emotional dissonance) causes stress and burnout. beliefs about the terms and conditions of a reciprocal
However, stress from emotional dissonance can be exchange agreement between that person and another
party. Transactional psychological contracts are
100
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
primarily short-term economic exchanges, whereas tend to have more of a relational psychological
relational contracts are long-term attachments that contract. Meanwhile, employees and employers in
encompass a broad array of subjective mutual Canada and other countries have shifted from a
obligations. Employees with high continuance psychological contract based on job security and loyalty
commitment tend to have more transactional contracts, to one of employability.
whereas employees with high affective commitment
POWERPOINT SLIDES
Canadian Organizational Behaviour includes a complete set of Microsoft PowerPoint files for each chapter. (Please
contact your McGraw-Hill Ryerson representative to find out how instructors can receive these files.) In the lecture
outline that follows, a thumbnail illustration of each PowerPoint slide for this chapter is placed beside the
corresponding lecture material. The slide number helps you to see your location in the slide show sequence and to skip
slides that you dont want to show to the class. (To jump ahead or back to a particular slide, just type the slide number
and hit the Enter or Return key.) The transparency masters for this chapter are very similar to the PowerPoint files.
Loyalty at SaskTel
Slide 2
EMOTIONS DEFINED
Psychological and physiological episodes experienced toward an
object , person, or event that create a state of readiness
Brief events or episodes e.g. your anger toward a co-worker
Emotions Defined
would typically subside within a few minutes
Slide 3 Experienced through thoughts, behaviours, physiological
101
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
102
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
TYPES OF EMOTIONS
Numerous emotions are experienced in the workplace and in other
settings
Emotions can be organized based on their pleasantness and
Types of Emotions activation i.e. the extent the emotion triggers alertness or
Slide 4
engagement
103
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
104
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE
Ability to monitor your own and others emotions, to discriminate
among them, and to use the information to guide your thinking and
actions
Model of Emotional
Intelligence Four components of emotional intelligence (from lowest to highest):
Slide 8
Perceiving and expressing emotions: Ability to recognize
the meaning of emotions, express emotions accurately and
the ability to detect false emotions e.g. know when you have
offended someone
Assimilating emotions: Ability to use emotions to
prioritise, make decisions and shift our perceptions e.g.
being able to shift emotions to see a different perspective
Understanding emotions: Ability to understand
combinations and shifts in emotions that occur e.g.
relationship between hate and fear
Managing emotions: Ability to regulate your emotions and
the emotions of others e.g. being able to generate
enthusiasm or calm fears of others
105
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
JOB SATISFACTION
An appraisal of the perceived job content and context and an
employees emotional experience at work
Collection of attitudes toward specific job facets
Job Satisfaction Defined
Employee can be satisfied with some facets but not others
Slide 9
Different facets of satisfaction have different effects on
employee behaviour
Overall job satisfaction -- a combination of feelings toward
job satisfaction facets
Levels of job satisfaction
Most employees claim to be generally satisfied with their
jobs
Probably inflated because:
-- revealing job dissatisfaction in a direct question threatens
self-esteem
Job Satisfaction and Work Behaviour:
Employees respond to dissatisfaction in four ways:
1. Exit: Leaving the situation by resigning from the
organization or transferring
EVLN: Responses to
2. Voice: May be positive and constructive e.g. trying to work
Dissatisfaction with management to solve a problem or may be
Slide 10 confrontational e.g. filing a complaint or engaging in
behaviours to draw attention
3. Loyalty: Waiting for the problem to be solved
4. Neglect: Passive activities with negative outcomes e.g.
reducing work effort, increasing absenteeism
106
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
107
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
ORGANIZATIONAL COMMITMENT
Two types:
1. Affective commitment -- emotional attachment to,
identification with, and involvement in an organization
Organizational 2. Continuance commitment -- believing it is in their own
Commitment
Slide 15
personal interest to remain with the organization.
108
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT
Definition The individuals beliefs about the terms and
conditions of a reciprocal exchange agreement between that
person and another party
Psychological Contract
Defined Perceptual so will differ among individuals
Slide 17 Some common elements
-- Employers expect employees to work contracted hours,
perform quality work, deal honestly, demonstrate
organizational citizenship etc.
-- Employees expect employees to use fairness in decisions
and application of rules, pay and benefits Employees also
expect adequate personal time off, supportive leadership,
safe work environment etc.
109
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
Permanence of employability
Low unemployment might shift psychological contracts back to job
security, but two factors continue to push for employability:
1. Turbulent business environment -- more difficult to
guarantee job security
2. Changing employee expectation -- Generation-X and
Generation-Y place less value on job security; recent
Japanese university graduates prefer challenging work
and performance-based pay to life-long employment
TRANSPARENCY MASTERS
Transparency 4.1: Emotions Defined
Transparency 4.2: Types of Emotions
Transparency 4.3: Emotions, Attitudes, and Behaviour
Transparency 4.4: Emotional Labour Defined
Transparency 4.5: Emotional Labour Issues
Transparency 4.6: Model of Emotional Intelligence
Transparency 4.7: Job Satisfaction Defined
Transparency 4.8: EVLN: responses to Dissatisfaction
Transparency 4.9: Job Satisfaction and Performance
Transparency 4.10: Job Satisfaction and Customers
Transparency 4.11: Employee-Customer-Profit Chain
Transparency 4.12: Organizational Commitment
Transparency 4.13: Building Organizational Commitment
Transparency 4.14: Psychological Contract Defined
Transparency 4.14: Transactional vs. Relational Contracts
Transparency 4.15: Features of Employability
110
Chapter 4 Workplace Emotions and Attitudes
111
Part 2 Individual Behaviour and Processes
4. Describe a time when you effectively managed a) Job satisfaction affects an employees general
someones emotions. What happened? What was mood. Employees who are in a good mood
the result? are more likely to display positive emotions
which in turn positively affect the customers
This question is an example of a behavioural
mood and experience.
question that could be asked in an employment
interview in an organization that views managing b) Satisfied employees are more likely to stay
emotions as a competency associated with with the organization and longer-service
effectiveness. The interviewer will be assessing employees tend to have more skills and
your past behaviour with respect to the highest experience to better serve customers. In
level of emotional intelligencemanaging addition, some customers build loyalty to any
emotions. employee, not the organization, so retaining
these employees maintains customer loyalty.
An example of an effective response to this
question would be to describe a time when you 7. What factors influence an employees
effectively created excitement or generated organizational loyalty?
enthusiasm among co-workers to implement a
Organizations can do a variety of things to create
desired organizational change. The interviewer
an environment where employees are more likely
will also be looking for a summary of the specific
to demonstrate loyalty to the organization:
actions you took as well as the behaviours you
demonstrated in achieving this result. - Treat employees with fairness, courtesy,
forgiveness and moral integrity
5. The latest employee satisfaction survey in your
organization indicates that employees are unhappy - Support employee well-being
with some aspects of the organization. However,
- Avoid layoffs and threats of layoffs
management tends to pay attention to the same
single-item question asking employees to indicate - Keep employees informed about what is
their overall satisfaction with the job. The results happening in the company and connected to
of this item indicate that 86 percent of staff other co-workers
members are very or somewhat satisfied, so
- Involve employees in decision-making
management concludes that the other results refer
to issues that are probably not important to - Trust employees and ensure leaders are
employees. Explain why managements trustworthy
interpretation of these results may be inaccurate.
8. The emerging psychological contract is
The problem with the single direct question about employability. What is the employees
job satisfaction is that it threatens the self-esteem responsibility in this new deal?
of many people who are dissatisfied with their
Employees must take responsibility for their own
jobs. Consequently, they tend to give a more
careers and continuously develop competencies for
favourable response to this question than reflects
future roles within a company and beyond.
their actual job satisfaction. This is apparent
Employees also need to anticipate future
because scores are lower on specific facets of job
organizational needs and develop competencies to
satisfaction.
serve these needs. Employees also need to accept
6. Happy employees create happy customers. challenging work assignments and remain flexible
Discuss. and adaptive.
There are two main reasons why employee job
satisfaction positively affects customer service.
112
PHOTO CAPTION CRITICAL THINKING
QUESTIONS
Jerry L. Pettis Memorial VA Medical A: The Bahamas trip may have a positive effect on
organizational commitment because it increases
Center employee fairness and satisfaction. With higher
Q: Looking at the four dimensions in the Salovey- organizational commitment, employees are less likely
Mayer model, why is it important for physicians to to quit their jobs and be absent from work.
have a high emotional intelligence? Organizational commitment also improves customers
satisfaction because long tenure employees have better
A: To answer this question, students need to consider knowledge of work practices and clients like to do
each of the dimensions of emotional intelligence in the business with the same employees. Employees with
context of physicians work. First, perceiving and high affective commitment also have higher work
expressing emotions is important because physicians motivation and organizational citizenship.
need to recognize and understand their moods,
emotions, and needs so they can more accurately B.C. Government Layoffs
perceive and anticipate how their actions affect others.
Second, physicians need to assimilate emotions, that is, Q: What could the B.C. government do to minimize
bring emotions into their decision making. The reason the amount of employee loyalty lost due to these
for this is that physicians need to ensure that they layoffs?
make decisions that empathize with patients and yet
are not overwhelmed by emotions. The third level of A: The answer to this question draws on the other
emotional intelligence includes the ability to strategies (i.e. other than job security) to build
understand combinations of emotions as well as how organizational commitment described in the textbook.
an emotion will likely make a transition to another First, justice and support can be practiced by
emotion. This is important for physicians because they demonstrating to employees that the layoffs applied
need to be aware of the emotional dynamic of patients. justice rules, and that the government provided
Finally, physicians need to be able to manage the humanitarian support to those laid off as well to
emotions of others. survivors. Organizational comprehension involves
keeping employees informed of the governments
actions. To offset the effects of layoffs, the government
Ipswitch, Inc. could increase employee involvement in other aspects
Q: Along with job satisfaction, what other work of the workplace. Lastly, government leaders can try to
attitude described in this chapter might explain why a demonstrate increased trust in employees, and earn
trip to the Bahamas increases customer satisfaction? their trust through fair practices.
ACTIVITY 4.1: CASE ANALYSIS
THE LANGUAGE INCIDENT
These case notes were prepared by Beth Gilbert, University of New Brunswick, St. John.
I use this case at the start of term when I am trying to encourage group discussion in a class where there are a lot of
different speech patterns due to accents and physical disabilities. I encourage students to view challenges in
understanding other students speech as a learning opportunity, not something to avoid. I point out that if one student
does not understand another student the first time, just try again. Its not as though we are dealing with emergency
situations (like the building burning down) where immediate understanding is important.
Case Synopsis
This case is fictional but the underlying premise is one that is regularly encountered in life. Namely, something really
bad happens at a really bad time. Peoples reactions tend to be either to completely freak out or walk away saying I
cant deal with this right now. Either way the result is not going to be desirable. The events of this case were
designed to illustrate Shane Stevens using a much more emotionally intelligent response to the problem he is faced
with. Thus, the case is essentially an application of the components of the EI model.
When trying this case out in the classroom, students didnt have much difficulty generating examples of EI from
Stevens behaviour. However, some overlap did occur in terms of certain actions relating to more than one EI
component. This led to a discussion of the interactions and flow between the EI levels. To extend the analysis even
further, one could consider concepts such as perceptions, management practices, and leadership style.
Step 3: The instructor will provide expert ranking 1. The extent to which the job has required display
information. This information should be written in rules. Emotional labour is higher where the job
column 3. Then, students calculate the differences in requires the job incumbent to display emotions
columns 4 and 5. while interacting with customers, suppliers, and
others.
Step 4: The class will compare the results and discuss 2. The frequency and length of interaction with other
the features of jobs with high emotional labour. people. Emotional labour is higher where
employees must display emotions frequent and for
long periods of time.
Comments for Instructors 3. The intensity of emotions required during this
This expert ranking provided below is based on a interaction. Emotional labour is higher where the
careful review of information in the U.S. Dictionary of job incumbent must display more extreme
Occupational Titles (DOT) from the Occupational emotions.
Outlook Handbook 2000-01. See web site: 4. The extent to which the display rules create
http://stats.bls.gov/ocohome.htm. (The Canadian emotional dissonance. Emotional labour is higher
Governments web site on the National Occupational where incumbents must display emotions that are
Classification provides plenty of information, but not dissimilar or contrary to their true emotions at the
enough on job requirements.) time of the emotional display.
Although this expert ranking uses established Along with presenting the results of this exercise, the
information, it is not necessarily the most accurate instructor may want to encourage students to discuss
source. One problem is that there can be significant their personal experiences in any of these jobs. In
differences in the experiences of people within the classes with older students, I have found that students
occupation. For example, some social workers might have numerous fascinating stories about how they had
have very cooperative and relatively well-adjusted to cope with difficult interactions involving clients,
clients, whereas others must work intensively with patients, suppliers, and others.
EXPERT RANKING ON EMOTIONAL LABOUR
(1=HIGHEST)
Cashier 8 Although cashiers work almost all of their time in front of customers, the
interaction with each customer is typically brief, routine, and with limited
conversation.
Dental hygienist 7 People in this job work with patients, but the job description involves mainly
performing tasks with limited interaction with patients (who are usually unable to
speak during the work anyway!) However, emotional labour is required by
maintaining a pleasant or neutral disposition throughout the visit. They also spend
some time talking with patients about dental hygiene. Dental hygienists must also
maintain a calm disposition when assisting the dentist during surgical work.
Insurance 6 Although adjusters interact with claimants, a fair portion of their task involves
adjuster collecting information about the event, reviewing police records, and comparing
data with other claims. Interaction with claimants may require some emotional
labour where the claim is a personal injury or loss of valuable goods. However, this
interaction is relatively brief. Some emotional labour may also occur where claims
need to be negotiated with the claimant.
Lawyer 5 The emotional labour required of lawyers varies significantly with the type of work.
Barristers (trial lawyers) must be able to think quickly and speak with ease and
authority. Other lawyers spend most of their time performing research or
attending to the practices administrative tasks. Most lawyers spent some time with
clients, which requires both authority and empathy from the lawyer during these
interviews.
Librarian 9 The librarians interaction with the public can vary with the specific position.
Some have little direct interaction, relying instead on technology to manage most
queries. Other librarians must help to answer customer questions, read to children,
and work with public groups. However, librarians spend a significant portion of
time at their desks or in front of computer terminals. Most interaction tasks are
for a short duration and have low intensity.
Postal clerk 10 Postal clerks include people who work at retail counters and those who process
letters and packages. The former are similar to cashiers (see above) in their
emotional labour requirements. The latter have almost no interaction with the
public, just with other postal employees. Thus, their emotional labour
requirements would be no more than for any other job involving some interaction
with co-workers.
Registered nurse 2 Registered nurses vary from staff nurses in hospitals to public health nurses in
schools. Most hospital nurses engage in considerable emotional labour and need
emotional stability to cope with human suffering, emergencies, and other stresses.
They must frequently exhibit emotions that they are caring and sympathetic.
They must also manage the emotions of patients and visitors.
Social worker 1 Social workers have frequent interaction with clients, sometimes with heavy case
loads. They see clients who face a life-threatening disease or a social problem.
Depending on the type of client, social workers must display emotions of control,
empathy, and support. The job can be emotionally draining.
Television 3 Television announcers must sound and look consistently pleasant on-air, and
announcer display similar emotions during the many public events required for the job. The
most successful announcers attract a large audience by combining a pleasing
personality and voice with an appealing style. This can create emotional
dissonance where the announcer works under tight deadlines or interviews people
with aggressive behaviour. However, announcers also spend a large portion of their
time away from an audience preparing on-air scripts.
NOTE: These expert rankings are inferred from job requirement information described in the U.S. Dictionary of
Occupational Titles. They involve some degree of subjective interpretation, so might not be completely accurate.
ACTIVITY 4.4: SELF-ASSESSMENT
SCHOOL COMMITMENT SCALE
Purpose commitment as a student to the school where they are
This exercise is designed to help students understand attending this program.
the concept of organizational commitment and to
assess their commitment to the college or university Instructions
they are currently attending. Students are asked to read each of the statements below
and circle the response that best fits their personal
Overview belief. They use the scoring key in Appendix B of the
The concept of commitment is as relevant to students textbook to calculate their results.
enrolled in college or university courses as it does to Class discussion should focus on the meaning of the
employees working in various organizations. This self- different types of organizational commitment and how
assessment adapts a popular organizational well this scale applies to the commitment of students
commitment instrument so it refers to the persons toward the college or university they are attending.
Affective commitment
Affective commitment refers to a persons emotional Continuance commitment
attachment to, identification with, and involvement in Continuance commitment occurs when employees
a particular organization. In this scale, the believe it is in their own personal interest to remain
organization is the school where you are attending as a with the organization. People with a high continuance
student. Scores on this scale range from 6 to 42. A commitment have a strong calculative bond with the
higher score indicates a higher level of affective organization. In this scale, the organization is the
commitment. school where you are attending as a student.
How does your score compare with others? Ideally, How does your score compare with others? Ideally,
you would compare your score with the collective you would compare your score with the collective
results of other students in your class, but this might results of other students in your class, but this might
not be possible. Alternatively, the following graph not be possible. Alternatively, the following graph
provides a more general estimate of high and low provides a more general estimate of high and low
affective commitment based on a sample of Canadian continuance commitment based on a sample of
employees. Canadian employees.
Score Interpretation
Above 37 High affective commitment
32-36 Above average
28-31 Average
20-27 Below average
Below 20 Low affective commitment
Score Interpretation
Above 32 High continuance commitment
26-31 Above average
21-25 Average
13-20 Below average
Below 13 Low continuance commitment
ACTIVITY 4.5: SELF-ASSESSMENT
DISPOSITIONAL MOOD SCALE
Purpose dispositional mood, that is, the level of emotion that a
This self-assessment is designed to help students person naturally experiences as part of their
understand mood states or personality traits of personality. It consists of 20 words representing
emotions and to assess their own mood or emotion various emotions that a person might have
personality. experienced.
For each word presented, students are asked to
indicate the extent to which they have felt this way
Instructions generally across all situations over the past six months.
Our emotions are influenced by both the situation and
Students need to be honest with themselves to receive a
our own personality. This instrument estimates
reasonable estimate of their dispositional mood.
This self-assessment is designed to help students to estimate their dispositional mood, that is, their general emotional
tendency based on your personality. The four dispositional mood categories created in this scale are positive energy,
relaxation, negative arousal, and tiredness. These four categories are distinguished in two ways: (1) positive affectivity
versus negative affectivity and (2) high activation and low activation. Thus, the four subscales are consistent with the
affect circumplex model shown in the textbook. The only difference is that this scale measures emotional personality
rather than emotions in a specific setting.
Positive energy
People who score high on positive energy have positive Relaxation
affectivity and high activation. Positive affectivity is People who score high on relaxation have positive
the tendency to experience positive emotional states. It affectivity and low activation. Positive affectivity is the
is very similar to extroversion, a personality trait tendency to experience positive emotional states. It is
depicting people who are outgoing, talkative, sociable, very similar to extroversion, a personality trait
and assertive. Positive energy also includes high depicting people who are outgoing, talkative, sociable,
activation, meaning that people who score high on this and assertive. Relaxation also includes low activation,
scale experience more energizing or motivating meaning that people who score high on this scale
positive emotions. Scores on this scale range from 1 to experience more passive (less energizing) positive
5. From a sample of hospital employees, the average emotions. Scores on this scale range from 1 to 5. From
score was 3.0. a sample of hospital employees, the average score was
2.6.
Score Interpretation
3.8 to 5.0 High positive energy Score Interpretation
2.4 to 3.7 Moderate positive energy 3.8 to 5.0 High relaxation
1.0 to 2.3 Low positive energy 2.4 to 3.7 Moderate relaxation
1.0 to 2.3 Low relaxation
Negative arousal
People who score high on negative arousal have a Tiredness
tendency toward negative affectivity and high People who score high on tiredness have a tendency
activation. Negative affectivity is the tendency to toward negative affectivity and low activation.
negative emotions. Negative arousal also includes high Negative affectivity is the tendency to negative
activation, meaning that people who score high on this emotions. Tiredness also includes low activation,
scale experience negative emotions that demand our meaning that people who score high on this scale
attention (e.g., anger, upset). People with negative experience more passive (less demanding) negative
arousal tend to be more distressed and unhappy emotions. Scores on this scale range from 1 to 5. From
because they focus on the negative aspects of life. a sample of hospital employees, the average score was
Scores on this scale range from 1 to 5. From a sample 2.3.
of hospital employees, the average score was 2.1.
Score Interpretation
3.8 to 5.0 High negative arousal
2.4 to 3.7 Moderate negative arousal
1.0 to 2.3 Low negative arousal
Score Interpretation
3.8 to 5.0 High tiredness
2.4 to 3.7 Moderate tiredness
1.0 to 2.3 Low tiredness
SUPPLEMENTAL LECTURE: A MODEL OF JOB
SATISFACTION
What determines our level of job satisfaction? The best Equity theory also explains why job satisfaction
explanation is provided by a combination of does not always continue to increase as the received
discrepancy theory and equity theory. Discrepancy condition exceeds expectations. As people receive
theory states that the level of job satisfaction is much better outcomes than they expect, they typically
determined by the discrepancy between what people develop feelings of guilt and a belief that management
expect to receive and what they experience. As the practices are unfair to others. At first, employees adjust
exhibit below illustrates, job satisfaction or their expectations upward when they are overrewarded.
dissatisfaction results from a comparison of the amount However, if the overreward is so large that it cannot be
the employee expects to receive and the perceived justified, then feelings of inequity persist and
amount received. Job dissatisfaction occurs when the dissatisfaction with management practices may result.
received condition is noticeably less than the expected In summary, discrepancy and equity theories predict
condition. Job satisfaction improves as the person's that as reality meets and exceeds expectations, job
expectations are met or exceeded (up to a point). satisfaction will increase. However, when the perceived
Equity theory is also built into the job satisfaction job situation is so much better than expected that the
model (see exhibit below). Equity theory is one overreward creates a feeling of guilt or unfairness, job
component of workplace justice, which will be satisfaction begins to decrease.
discussed in Chapter 5 of this textbook. Generally,
equity occurs when the person and comparison other
have similar outcome/input ratios. This is relevant to Sources: D. B. McFarlin and R. W. Rice, "The Role
job satisfaction, because the amount we expect to of Facet Importance as a Moderator in Job Satisfaction
receive is partly determined by our comparison with Processes," Journal of Organizational Behaviour 13
other people. For instance, the level of pay we expect to (1992), pp. 41--54; E. E. Lawler III, Motivation in
receive depends not only on how hard we work, but Work Organizations (Belmont, Calif.: Wadsworth,
also on how hard other people work in this job 1973), pp. 66--69, 74--77.
compared to their level of pay.
Outcomes
/Inputs
of Others
Amount
Expected
Based on E. E. Lawler III, Motivation in Work Organizations (Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole, 1973), p. 75.
SUPPLEMENTAL LECTURE: AIRPLANE
HUMOUR
This chapter describes how several organizations develop positive emotions and attitudes. Westjet and other airlines
instill positive emotions among passengers by telling jokes on the intercom and playing games. This supplement
presents some of the humorous statements made on airlines in the United States.
1. From a Southwest Airlines employee: "There may 8. "Your seat cushions can be used for flotation and
be 50 ways to leave your lover, but there are only in the event of an emergency water landing, please
four ways out of this airplane ..." take them with our compliments."
2. Pilot: "Folks, we have reached our cruising 9. "As you exit the plane, please make sure to gather
altitude now, so I am going to switch the seat belt all of your belongings. Anything left behind will
sign off. Feel free to move about as you wish, but be distributed evenly among the flight attendants.
please stay inside the plane till we land ... it's a bit Please do not leave children or spouses."
cold outside, and if you walk on the wings it 10. "Last one off the plane must clean it."
affects the flight pattern."
11. From the pilot during his welcome message: "We
3. After landing: "Thank you for flying Delta are pleased to have some of the best flight
Business Express. We hope you enjoyed giving us attendants in the industry ... Unfortunately none of
the business as much as we enjoyed taking you for them are on this flight ..."
a ride."
12. Overheard on an American Airlines flight into
4. As the plane landed and was coming to a stop at Amarillo, Texas, on a particularly windy and
Washington National, a lone voice comes over the bumpy day: During the final approach, the
loudspeaker: "Whoa, big fella. WHOA" Captain was really having to fight it. After an
5. After a particularly rough landing during extremely hard landing, the Flight Attendant came
thunderstorms in Memphis, a flight attendant on a on the PA and announced, "Ladies and Gentlemen,
Northwest flight announced: "Please take care welcome to Amarillo. Please remain in your seats
when opening the overhead compartments with your seat belts fastened while the Captain
because, after a landing like that, sure as hell taxis what's left of our airplane to the gate."
everything has shifted." 13. Another flight attendant's comment on a less than
6. From a Southwest Airlines employee: "Welcome perfect landing: "We ask you to please remain
aboard Southwest Flight XXX to YYY. To operate seated as Captain Kangaroo bounces us to the
your seat belt, insert the metal tab into the buckle, terminal."
and pull tight. It works just like every other seat 14. After a real crusher of a landing in Phoenix, the
belt and if you don't know how to operate one, you flight attendant came on with, "Ladies and
probably shouldn't be out in public unsupervised. Gentlemen, please remain in your seats until
In the event of a sudden loss of cabin pressure, Captain Crash and the crew have brought the
oxygen masks will descend from the ceiling. Stop aircraft to a screeching halt up against the gate.
screaming, grab the mask, and pull it over your And, once the tire smoke has cleared and the
face. If you have a small child travelling with you, warning bells are silenced, we'll open the door and
secure your mask before assisting with theirs. If you can pick your way through the wreckage to the
you are travelling with two small children, decide terminal."
now which one you love more."
15. Part of a flight attendant's arrival announcement:
7. "Weather at our destination is 50 degrees with "We'd like to thank you folks for flying with us
some broken clouds, but they'll try to have them today. And, the next time you get the insane urge
fixed before we arrive. Thank you, and remember, to go blasting through the skies in a pressurized
nobody loves you or your money more than metal tube, we hope you'll think of us here at US
Southwest Airlines." Airways."
Source: St. Johns Telegram e-mail newsletter, by John
Gushue Tuesday, May 23, 2000
VIDEO SUGGESTIONS
Along with the video cases for this part of the textbook, the following videos and films generally relate to one or more
topics in this chapter. These programs may be available at your college/university or rented from the distributor. Please
contact your film librarian to determine the availability of these programs at your institution. This list was compiled
from library holdings of several universities. Due to the variety of video material, this is not a comprehensive list. Nor
can we say that all of the programs below are suitable for your class.
Revitalizing after Downsizing. (1999, 15 min., Ash Who Cares? Building Loyalty in a Changing
Quarry). This program offers ways in which managers Workplace. (1992, 20 min., Crisp). This video
can rebuild the morale of their remaining employees program discusses the challenge of the new work force,
after the company has downsized. the changing values of today's employees, and ways to
build trust, commitment, and loyalty. It stresses honest
Emotional Intelligence. (199?, 70 min., Media
communication, ethical dealings, employee
International & PBS). Taped before a live studio
participation, appreciation, and respectful treatment.
audience, Dr. Daniel Goleman presents his ideas on the
emotional mind, offering viewers the knowledge and Attitude: Its Your Choice (1992, 15 min., VHS). This
tools to improve their emotional reactions. He program identifies work attitude as ones work
demonstrating how strong inter-personal skills such as posture. It presents a rationale for employees to
self-awareness, managing emotions, motivation, adopt a positive attitude in order to achieve increased
empathy and social skills can be instrumental in job satisfaction.
improving one's health, family life and professional
Communicating Across Cultures. (1992, 30 min.,
prospects. Dr. Goleman explains that people who are
Copeland Griggs). This program examines differences
emotionally intelligent tend to lead more successful
in communication styles. It demonstrates the
lives as parents, partners and co-workers.
misunderstandings that can result when people of
Building a Winning Team. (1997, 29 min., different national origin or ethnic background (or even
Carrollton, TX) : Associated with Matt Weinsteins personality) try to communicate. It also shows how
book, Managing to Have Fun, this video program discomfort around the subjects of race, gender and
provides a live audience with specific examples of other differences inhibits feedback and constructive
building a winning team. Weinstein suggests using interaction.
humour or fun to permit employees to vent, to foster
Humour, Risk & Change. (1990, 20 min. each of 3
problem solving, and to create an atmosphere of
videos, VHS). This delightful program shows the value
appreciation at work.
of humour as a stress management tool in effectively
Even Eagles Need a Push. (199?, 24 min., VHS). In coping with change, pressure and crisis in the work
this recently produced video, consultant David place. It demonstrates physical exercises - humaerobics
McNally shows viewers how to enthusiastically commit - and mental techniques to develop humour skills. This
to new levels of achievement and excellence. He very enjoyable video series can also be used for your
describes five qualities of a confident, empowered classes on managing change.
employee.
Heads Up: Attitudes about Work and Customers.
(1985, 20 min., VHS). Produced by Walgreens, this
program follows two employees through a typical shift
and then has them discuss their different approaches to
work. The program might be appropriate for a case
analysis of the two employees.
NOTES