Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
of Partnerships
Africa
Progress
Report 2011
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
The Africa Progress Panel brings together a unique group of leaders under the chairmanship of Kofi Annan. The
Panel monitors and promotes mutual accountability and shared responsibility for progress in Africa. Its three
focus areas are economic and political governance, finance for sustainable development, and achievement
of the Millennium Development Goals. The work of the Panel aims to track progress in these areas and draw
attention to critical issues and opportunities.
While the Panel does not purport to be speaking for Africa, it can speak with an African voice, with the
continents concerns and priorities as its guiding principles, and with the combined expertise, experience and
knowledge of its members. It calls for the fulfilment of commitments to Africa, without ever forgetting that the
main responsibility for progress rests with the continents leaders and that they themselves have entered into a
series of commitments that they need to fulfil.
Sandra Engelbrecht
Benedikt Franke
Africa Progress Panel
Kwame Okyere P.O. Box 157
Temitayo Omotola 1211 Geneva 20
Switzerland
Carolina Rodriguez
2
WHAT ARE
PARTNERSHIPS FOR
DEVELOPMENT?
For the purpose of this report we define
partnerships as voluntary and collaborative
relationships between various parties, both state
and non-state, in which all participants agree to
work together to achieve a common purpose
or undertake a specific task and to share risks,
responsibilities, resources, competencies and
benefits.
table of contents
FOREWORD 6
INTRODUCTION 8
PART I: LOOKING BACK: THE YEAR IN REVIEW 9
Economic Growth 10
Africas Swift Recovery from the Economic Crisis 10
The Low Quality of African Growth 11
Growth Outlook and Economic Potential 14
Governance 20
National Governance 20
Regional Governance 24
Global Governance 26
Peace and Security 27
Social Development 28
Poverty Alleviation 28
Education and Skills Formation 32
Gender Equality and Womens Empowerment 32
Health 33
Access to Water and Sanitation 37
Food and Nutrition Security 38
Volatility of Food Prices 38
Structural Barriers to Food Security 38
Agricultural Productivity 38
Climate Change 42
The Impact of Climate Change 42
Climate Change Politics 42
Climate Change Finance 42
Adaptation and Mitigation 43
Development Finance and Cooperation 46
Domestic Resource Mobilization 46
Traditional Bilateral Partners 46
Bilateral Partners from the Global South 47
Institutional Partners and Country Groupings 50
Philanthropy and Private Giving 51
Debt Relief 51
From Aid Effectiveness to Development Effectiveness 52
4
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
5
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
foreword
6
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
climate change adds new financing demands, African The core elements of effective partnerships are well
leaders and international donors are realizing that established, even though their combination may vary:
they cannot drive development on their own. Official political leadership and vision from governments,
development cooperation remains vitally important along with a supportive regulatory, legal and fiscal
to build capacity, leverage other flows and achieve environment; a private sector incentivized to invest
specific results. Yet, there is also a growing need for capital and ideas not just for immediate returns but
partnerships harnessing a broader range of actors and for longer-term change that will strengthen markets,
their energy, creativity and resources to fill the gaps. value chains and social stability; civil society afforded
the space by business and government to keep
Such partnerships have already proven their both accountable for socially and environmentally
transformative power. Collaboration between the responsible behaviour; and international organizations,
private sector and international philanthropists African or otherwise, able to advocate global
has led to significant reductions in malaria deaths. standards and share best practices, especially from
Partnerships between mobile-phone providers and other parts of the global South.
governments have resulted in greater access to
credit in rural areas and transformed business across The idea of partnerships for development is hardly
entire regions. Partnerships between civil society new. For over a decade, MDG 8 has been calling for
and intergovernmental organizations have led to stronger partnerships as a basis for achieving all other
vastly improved agricultural methods and inputs for goals. Despite the existence of many encouraging
smallholder farmers. By mobilizing resources, improving examples, and valuable lessons learned, we are still not
efficiencies, or extending services, access and seeing enough success stories replicated or brought
opportunities to previously marginalized segments of to scale to effect lasting structural change. Too many
the population, partnerships can clearly complement, actors still see the risks of engaging in partnerships
expand and improve government-led development rather than the opportunities, and too many states
efforts. If scaled up, they can even affect sustainable still fail to harness the developmental potential of
structural change. their civil society organizations or to provide the
enabling environment and incentive structures to
Current dynamics are highly favourable for make partnerships attractive for private-sector actors.
strengthening cross-sectoral collaboration. Over the This results in missed opportunities to tackle problems
last years, new spaces have opened up for engaging and drive progress. Given the transformative power
actors around their comparative advantages and of partnerships, it will be crucial to overcome these
respective interests as the benefits of partnering blockages and convince all sides of the inherent
have become more obvious. The private sector benefits of partnering for progress. This is the main
understands that it needs the access and knowledge purpose of this report.
of local partners and national governments to
grasp the enormous commercial opportunities at
the bottom of the pyramid. Governments and civil
society organisations are recognizing the value of
the resources, capacities, and expertise the private
sector can bring to their development efforts. As the Kofi A. Annan
interests of the various sectors continue to converge Chair of the Africa Progress Panel
and improvements in regulatory environments make
cooperating easier and safer, opportunities for
partnerships continue to grow.
7
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
Introduction
8
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
PART I
LOOKING BACK:
THE YEAR IN REVIEW
Looking back at the last year, we note that
impressive progress, stagnation and discouraging
regression continue to coexist on the continent.
Widespread advances in economic growth and
social development contrast with a dangerous
erosion of democratic governance as well as
the increasingly evident reluctance of major
international donors to fulfil their commitments on
aid and climate finance. This section summarizes
major developments in the areas of (1) economic
growth, (2) governance, (3) peace and security,
(4) social development, (5) food and nutrition
security, (6) climate change, and (7) development
finance and cooperation.
9
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
average annual GDP growth rate of 5 per cent or Propelled by the strong performance of several
more.2 While a favourable global environment of large economies, including Brazil, China, Germany,
strong external demand, ample liquidity, extended France and India, most of Africa is now resuming its
concessional financing and higher commodity growth spurt. While FDI inflows are recovering only
prices accounts for much of this growth, structural slowly from the global credit crunch,7 both total
changes within the continents economies exports and imports have picked up again, with
are beginning to take effect and are helping growth rates of 15.3 and 11.3 per cent respectively.8
accelerate growth across countries and sectors. Remittances, the continents second-largest source
of net foreign inflows after FDI, are also beginning to
Among the most significant changes are a broad- recover from the slump in 2009, reaching nearly $40
based surge in domestic demand for basic billion in 2010.9 Not least because of the Football
consumer goods as a result of growing middle World Cup in South Africa, tourism revenues have
classes and rapid urbanization, lower public debts, also rebounded, with the continent receiving more
increased openness to trade and higher investments visitors over the last year than ever before.10
into enabling infrastructure. Many African countries
have also continued with deregulation, privatization Based on these trends and global dynamics, the
and other structural reforms that have significantly International Monetary Fund (IMF) expects Sub-
improved the business environment (notably Saharan Africas GDP to grow by 5.5 per cent
Rwanda, Ethiopia, and Liberia), the financial sector in 2011 and 5.8 per cent in 2012 (in real terms).11
(Nigeria), as well as administration and governance However, this masks substantial differences
(Sierra Leone). Dynamic private sectors have between countries. While the Republic of Congo,
appeared across the continent, including the Ethiopia, Ghana, Mozambique, Nigeria, Tanzania
flower business in Uganda, leather processing and Zambia are all expected to be among the
in Ethiopia and the film industry in Nigeria, which worlds ten fastest-growing economies, the Central
have helped underpin growth driven by the export African Republic, Chad, Cte dIvoire, Equatorial
of primary commodities.3 Encouragingly, African Guinea and Eritrea are projected to grow at rates
as well as international companies are taking far below the average.12 There are, however, two
advantage of the improving enabling environment, notable economic realities that seem to apply to
and vantage points like direct access to natural most of the continent: the low quality of recorded
resources, a large labour force and a fast-growing growth, and the enormous untapped potential.
10
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
The Low Quality of African Growth against Africa unbroken,18 the continent has little
opportunity to escape this pattern and drive much-
A fricas current economic growth is not all positive. needed economic transformation through trade
It is generally not accompanied by much- diversification.19
needed structural transformation and diversification,
and often does not translate into equitable human The one-dimensionality of Africas global trade
development and public services. is all the more harmful, because trade between
African countries remains too weak to offer sufficient
Because of the immediacy of benefits, a lack of viable alternative incentives for economic diversification.
alternatives and credit for long-term investments, as Slow regional integration, a lack of connecting
well as distorted incentives, many African countries infrastructure, and insufficient resource and production
continue to rely on export-led growth policies complementarities between countries currently limit
focusing on the extraction of natural resources intra-African trade to a mere 10 per cent of total
and raw materials rather than value addition and exports. In comparison, trade within the Association of
diversification.13 While natural-resource extraction South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) accounts for about
has accounted for only about a third of Africas real 60 per cent of the regions total exports, and trade
GDP growth in the last decade,14 more than 80 per within the North American Free Trade Agreement
cent of the continents export earnings come from (NAFTA) accounts for 56 per cent of total exports.20
primary, generally unprocessed commodities. The Without similar opportunities to profit from enlarged
economies of several countries are geared towards markets, greater economies of scale and prosper
the export of single commodities, including copper thy neighbour policies, African countries remain prey
(Zambia) and aluminium (Mozambique). This has to disadvantageous geographies and unfavourable
resulted in unbalanced development, with weak links global dynamics.
between export-orientated and other sectors. With
the notable exceptions of Egypt, Tunisia and South The lack of economic diversification, in terms of both
Africa, where manufacturing and services account export products and destinations, explains the high
for 83 per cent of combined GDP,15 non-extractive volatility of African trade in recent years, and the
sectors and competitive industries remain heavily strongly adverse impact of the global economic
under-developed in most African countries.16 crisis through trade. It also explains why so little of
the continents high GDP growth translates into
The problem is caused, driven and compounded by social development and tangible improvements to
the poor quality of Africas economic relationships, peoples lives. Driven by capital-intensive extractive
with both African and other countries. Despite the sectors, the current type of economic growth has little
increasing prominence of non-European partners, positive impact on employment and income levels
and China in particular, the disadvantageous pattern and virtually no effect on employment-intensive
of Africa exporting unprocessed commodities and sectors such as agriculture.21 It is thus hardly surprising
importing manufactured goods persists. In fact, it is that, despite a decade of strong economic growth,
becoming ever more entrenched as the resource poverty remains pervasive throughout the continent
thirst of emerging partners continues to grow.17 and only one of Africas 34 Least Developed
With FDI concentrating in extractive industries, Countries (Cape Verde) has managed to graduate
the Doha Development Round unresolved, and from this category since the adoption of the Brussels
protectionism and other discriminatory measures Programme of Action in 2001.
11
economic growth IN AFRICA
African annual real GDP, 2008
USD billions 1,816* Compound annual
real GDP growth
Compound annual growth rate, %
2000-2008
%, constant exchange rates
1,684*
Emerging 8.3%
5.6 1,561 Asia
5.5 1,400
Africa 4.9%
1970 1980 1990 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009* 2010* 2011*
Source: IMF, World Economic Outlook Database (2010); World Bank, World Development Indicators (2011); and McKinsey Global Institute (2010) Lions on the Move
*GDP figures for 2009-2011 are combined from actual, estimated and projected amounts from the IMF
Below 0%
Between 0% and 2%
Between 2% and 5%
Above 5%
Insufficient data
12
GDP per capita and Growth Rates 2000-2009 IN SSA
GDP per capita 2000 GDP 2000 GDP Growth Annual % GDP 2009 GDP per capita 2009
(Current USD) (USD millions) 2000 2009 (USD millions) (Current USD)
Angola 639 9,129 3.0 0.7 75,493 4,081
13
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
14
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
Sources: World Bank (2009), African Country Infrastructure Diagnostic; PEI and ICA (2011), Infrastructure Investor: Africa An Intelligence Report.
15
diversification of african economies
10,000 Libya
USD
10,000 Libya
USD
Equitorial
Equitorial Mauritius
Guinea Gabon Mauritius
Guinea Angola Gabon
Angola Botswana
Botswana
Algeria Tunisia
Tunisia
Algeria South
South
DRCDRC Egypt
Egypt Namibia Africa
Africa
1000
1000 Namibia
Cte dIvoire
Cte dIvoire
Nigeria
Nigeria Zambia Morrocco
Chad
Chad Sudan Zambia Morrocco
Sudan Cameroon
Cameroon Senegal
Senegal
Mali Ghana Kenya
Kenya
Mali Ghana
100 Mozambique
Mozambique
100 Sierra Leone DRCDRC Madagascar
Madagascar
Sierra Leone Tanzania
Tanzania Uganda
Uganda
Rwanda
Rwanda
Ethiopia
Ethiopia
1010
2020 3030 4040 5050 6060 7070 8080 9090 100
100
Economic
Ecomomicdiversification
diversification
Manufacturing
Manufacturingand service
and sector
service share
sector ofof
share GDP, 2008,
GDP, %%
2008,
Clusters (only select countries represented)
Clusters (only select countries represented)
GDP perper
GDP capita
capita
Oil exporters Size ofof
bubble
Oil exporters Transition Transition < $500
< $500 $2,000 - $5,000
$2000 - $5000 Size bubble
Diversified Pre-transition $500 - $1,000 > $5,000 proportional
proportional
Diversified Pre-transition $500 - $1000 > $5000
toto
GDP
GDP
$1,000
$1000$2,000
- - $2000
Note: Selected countries include those whose 2008 GDP is aproximately USD 10 billion or greater, or whose real GDP
growth exceeds 7% over 2000-2008. 22 countries that account for 3% of African GDP in 2008 are excluded.
McKinseys framework illustrates four main clusters: diversified economies, oil exporters, transition economies and
pre-transition economies. The framework highlights that despite important differences between the countries within
each category, they have similar economic structures and therefore share growth opportunities and challenges. This
framework, however general, provides insight for business and policymakers with a new categorization upon which
to make decisions.
Source: McKinsey Global Institute (2010) Lions on the Move: The progress and potential of African economies.
Radial charts (opposite page) World Bank Development Indicators (2011)
16
ECONOMIC CLUSTERS AND SOCIAL INDICATORS: IS the DIVERSIFICATION OF
THE ECONOMY TRANSLATING INTO SOCIAL AND HUMAN DEVELOPMENT?
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
ACCESS TO WATER ACCESS
HUMANTODEVELOPMENT
ACCESSHEALTH
TO WATER H
Algeria Algeria Angola
Angola Algeria Algeria Angola
Angola
Sierra Leone 0
Sierra Leone 0 Chad Chad Sierra Leone0.0
Sierra Leone 0 Chad Chad Sier
Mali Mali 0.1 10 Congo, Republic
Congo, Republic Mali Mali 10 Congo, Republic
Congo, Republic Ma
100.0 0.1
nea Ethiopia Ethiopia 20 EquatorialEquatorial
Guinea Guinea Ethiopia Ethiopia 20 EquatorialEquatorial
Guinea Guinea Ethiopia
0.2 0.2
DRC 30 Gabon Gabon DRC DRC 200.0 30 Gabon Gabon
a
DRC
a
DRC DRC
DRC
at
at
0.3 0.3
d
40 40
no
no
0.4 50
Libya Libya 300.0 Libya Libya
50
0.4
geria Zambia Zambia 0.5 60 Nigeria Nigeria Zambia Zambia 60
0.5 Nigeria Nigeria
400.0 Zambia
70 70
0.6 0.6
Uganda Uganda 80 Uganda Uganda 500.0 80 Uganda
0.7 90 0.7
90
Cte d'Ivoire Tanzania Tanzania 0.8 100 Cte d'Ivoire Tanzania Tanzania
Cte d'Ivoire 600.0 100
0.8 Cte d'Ivoire
Cte d'Ivoire Tanzania
gypt Senegal Senegal Egypt Egypt Senegal Senegal Egypt Egypt Senegal
rocco Mozambique
Mozambique Morocco Morocco Mozambique
Mozambique Morocco Morocco Mozambique
bia Kenya Kenya Namibia Namibia Kenya Kenya Namibia Namibia Kenya
ica Ghana Ghana South Africa
South Africa Ghana Ghana South Africa
South Africa Ghana
CameroonCameroon Tunisia Tunisia CameroonCameroon Tunisia Tunisia Cameroon
Sudan Sudan BotswanaBotswana Sudan Sudan BotswanaBotswana
Rwanda Rwanda Madagascar Rwanda Mauritius
Rwanda Madagascar Madagascar
MauritiusMauritius Madagascar Mauritius Madagascar
Human Development
Improved Index(%
water source (HDI)
of population with access) HealthImproved
Expenditure
Human persource
Capita(%(Current
Development
water ofIndex US$) with access)
(HDI)
population
World average (=0.624) OECD average (=0.879;
World average (=86.8%) off scale)
OECD average (=99.0%) World average (=857.1; off average
WorldWorld scale)
average OECD average
(=0.624)
(=86.8%) OECD(=4653.8;
average
OECD off scale)
(=0.879;
average off scale)
(=99.0%) World av
Worl
ACCESS
ACCESS TOTO
MATERNAL HEALTHTELEPHONY
HEALTH
MOBILE ACCESS
ACCESS TO HEALTH
WATER
TOMOBILE
INTERNET
MATERNAL
ACCESS TO TELEPHONY H
A
Algeria
Algeria Angola
Algeria Angola Algeria
Algeria Angola
Algeria Angola
0.0 Angola Angola
Sierra
Sierra Leone
Sierra Leone0
Leone 0.0 Chad
Chad Chad Sierra
Sierra Leone
Sierra Leone Leone0.0 00
0.0 Chad ChadChad Sier
Sier
Mali
Mali Mali 100.0 Congo,
Congo, Republic
Republic
Congo, Republic Mali Mali
Mali 10 Congo,
Congo, Republic
Congo, Republic Republic Ma
10.0 5.0 10.0 Ma
nea Ethiopia
Ethiopia Ethiopia 200 Equatorial Guinea
EquatorialEquatorial
Guinea Guinea Ethiopia
Ethiopia Ethiopia 200
20 EquatorialEquatorial
Guinea Guinea
Equatorial Guinea Ethiopia
20.0 20.0 Ethiopia
Gabon 10.0 30
DRC Gabon Gabon
ta
DRC DRC 200.0
400 30.0 Gabon Gabon DRC DRC DRC
DRC 30.0 Gabon DRCDRC
DRC
da
400
40
no
40.0 Libya 15.0 40.0
(117) 300.0
600 50.0
Libya Libya (117) 50 600
50.0
Libya Libya
Libya (117)
20.0 60
geria Zambia
Zambia Zambia 400.0 60.0 Nigeria
Nigeria Nigeria Zambia Zambia
Zambia 60.0 Nigeria Nigeria
Nigeria Zambia
Zambia
800 800
70
70.0 25.0 70.0
Uganda
Uganda Uganda 500.0 80.0 Uganda Uganda 80
80.0 Uganda
1000 Uganda 30.0 1000 Uganda
90.0 90
90.0
Cte d'Ivoire Tanzania
Tanzania Tanzania 600.0
1200 100.0
Cte
Cte d'Ivoire
Cte d'Ivoire Tanzania Tanzania
d'Ivoire Tanzania 35.0 100
1200
100.0 Cte
Cte d'Ivoire
Cte d'Ivoire d'Ivoire Tanzania
Tanzania
gypt Senegal
Senegal Senegal Egypt
Egypt Egypt Senegal Senegal
Senegal Egypt Egypt
Egypt Senegal
Senegal
rocco Mozambique
Mozambique
Mozambique Morocco
Morocco Morocco Mozambique
Mozambique
Mozambique Morocco Morocco
Morocco Mozambique
Mozambique
bia Kenya
Kenya Kenya Namibia
Namibia Namibia Kenya Kenya
Kenya Namibia Namibia
Namibia Kenya
Kenya
ica Ghana Ghana South Africa
South Africa Ghana Ghana
Ghana South
South Africa
South Africa Africa Ghana
Ghana
Cameroon
CameroonCameroon Tunisia
Tunisia Tunisia CameroonCameroon
Cameroon Tunisia Tunisia
Tunisia Cameroon
Cameroon
Sudan Sudan Botswana
BotswanaBotswana Sudan
Sudan Sudan BotswanaBotswana
Botswana
Rwanda Madagascar
Rwanda Mauritius Madagascar Rwanda Rwanda Madagascar
Rwanda Mauritius Madagascar
Mauritius Mauritius Madagascar Mauritius Mauritius Madagascar
Health ratio
Maternal mortality Expenditure
(modeled
Mobile perestimate,
cellular Capita (Current
subscriptions US$)
per 100,000
(per 100live births)
people) MaternalImproved
Estimated
mortality
Mobile water
Internet source
users
ratio (%estimate,
per 100
(modeled
cellular ofinhabitants
subscriptionspopulation
(perper with access)
100100,000
people) live births) Maternal m
World average (=857.1; off(=260)
scale) OECD
OECDaverage
average(=4653.8; off scale) World average
World average
World average (=59.3) (=24.8)
OECD average (=100.0) World average
World
World average(=86.8%)
(=23)
average (=260)
(=59.3) OECD
OECD average
OECD
OECD average
(=23.9)
average (=99.0%)
average(=24.8)
(=100.0) Worl
17
Structural barriers to economic growth
Widespread infrastructure Unfavorable global TIME TO EXPORT
deficit rules Denmark 5
This graph compares the number of
days required before an entrepreneur
can export. Denmark as the country
Despite the proliferation of programmes The unbalanced global economic Mauritius 13 with the least amount of time to
to remedy Africas infrastructure deficit, system and its out-dated set Seychelles 17 export is included as a benchmark.
Total road density financial markets are still poorly Number of days
400 381
developed.
284
300 COST TO EXPORT
200 Malaysia* 450 This graph compares the cost per
150
Poor regulatory
Improved water 91
Improved sanitation 82 82 With FDI concentrating in the extractive sectors of
80 72 a limited group of resource-rich countries, high
61 risk ratings driving the cost of credit, and poorly
60 53 53
developed financial markets, most Africans
40 34 have very limited access to finance. The
consequences are significant. Low rural
20
access to credit hampers agricultural
Source: Yepes, Pierce and Foster in World Bank and the Agence
Mobile density
500
Internet density framework for banking supervision and regulation, may
further adversely affect the cost of financing and inhibit cross-
400
border financial flows to countries where public and private
300
277 borrowers are rated at a higher level of risk such as LDCs.
252 235
This figure shows the worldwide
200
142 distribution of deposit accounts in
Bank loans per 1,000 adults
institutions per thousand adults.
100 48 55 Predicted values are used when data
38 29 8.2
49 or fewer
9 2 are not available.
0
African Other African Other 50 - 299 Source: Kendall, Mylenko and Ponce (2010) Measuring Financial
low-income low-income middle-income middle-income 300 - 799 No data Access around the World
18
Structural DRIVERS to economic growth
Demographic change Spread of technology Renewable energy
In contrast to what is happening in much Whether by connecting people with Africa has enormous potential for
of the rest of the world, Africas labour each other, linking rural areas to the energy production from renewable
force is continuing to expand. The world, spreading knowledge, improving sources solar, hydro, wind and
continent currently has more than 500 healthcare delivery or providing a basis geothermal. Almost all Sub-Saharan
million people of working age. By 2040, for small businesses through mobile African countries have sufficient
their number is projected to exceed banking, the rapid spread of information renewable resources, exploitable
1.1 billion. Over the last two decades, and communication technologies has with current technologies, to satisfy
three-quarters of the continents changed how Africas people interact many times their current energy
increase in GDP per capita came and its economies function. But the demand. (See chart on page 45.)
from an expanding workforce, the rest benefits of new technologies are in other
from higher labour productivity. While sectors, such as manufacturing, where
population growth can create intense they are allowing African countries to
pressure on resources, public institutions leap frog development stages.
and social stability, it also provides an
enormous opportunity for the continent.
THE GROWTH OF THE MOBILE NETWORK Regional integration
500
examples of growing Population Deepening regional integration holds
(ages 15-59) 450 enormous potential for economic
Route kilometers (thousands)
70 400
growth and social development
across the continent. According to
Per cent of total population
65
350 UNCTAD, an investment of $32 billion
300 to improve the main intra-African
60 road network alone could generate
250
around $250 billion in additional trade
55 200 over a period of 15 years. As part of
150
a broader development strategy,
50 regional integration can enhance
100 productive capacity, intensify
45
50 economic diversification, and
improve competitiveness. Pooled
0 0 resources and economies of scale
2005 2015 2025 2035 2045 1990 1995 2000 2005
would also allow African countries
Ghana Madagascar Fixed-line operators Mobile operators to participate more effectively in the
Namibia Uganda global economy.
Note: Data through 2050 are based on the United Na-
tions medium variant projection series.
Source: Ashford (2007) Africas Youthful Population: Source: Williams (2010), Broadband for Africa: Backbone
Risk or Opportunity? Population Reference Bureau. USA. Networks in Sub-Saharan Africa, World Bank, USA.
60 1,200
The 2009 Revision in UN-Habitat (2010)
Central Africa
Source: World Urbanization Prospects:
African population (%)
Population (millions)
30 600
19
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
Governance elections held over the last year were won by the
incumbents some of whom have been in power for
well over two decades.31 Unfortunately, this trend
T he last year has seen significant developments on appears set to continue as only four of the fifteen
all levels of political and economic governance. countries holding elections over the next year (not
Nationally, democratic recessions and leadership counting the planned elections in Egypt and Tunisia)
deficits are threatening to overshadow significant will not include the incumbent seeking re-election.32
improvements in economic governance in several As the Economists Democracy Index indicates, an
countries. Regionally, African states and their increased number of elections has not necessarily
organizations continue to pursue a growing array of translated into a greater choice of candidates or
cooperative and integrative efforts despite capacity more democracy for the majority of Africans.33
constraints. Globally, the drive for much-needed
systemic reforms has stalled despite high hopes and This trend compounds the continents chronic
repeated declarations to the contrary. governance problems, including state fragility,
endemic corruption and widespread lack of basic
freedoms.34 With several leaders having extended
their tenures indefinitely, including by adjusting
National Governance constitutions and removing term limits, the disconnect
between rulers and their citizens as well as between
unchanged this year.29 However, as with the But there are also signs of hope. Last year has seen the
continents economic growth, the averages hide adoption of new and improved constitutions in Kenya
significant variations and trends across various and Niger, a peaceful referendum in South Sudan, the
components. While many countries have seen first democratic elections in Guinea, and the fall of
impressive improvements in economic governance, autocratic regimes in Tunisia and Egypt. Together with
nearly two-thirds have also seen disconcerting the popular uprising in Libya, these transitions highlight
deteriorations in political participation, human rights, new dynamics of accountability and increased
physical security and the rule of law.30 pressure on governments to deliver tangible results
to their citizens. Several countries, including Liberia
The refusal of Laurent Gbagbo to relinquish power and Mauritius, have made remarkable progress in
to the recognized winner of last years presidential improving accountability, and more countries are
elections in Cte dIvoire and the heavy-handed implementing regional and global good-governance
response of Muammar al-Gaddafi to calls for political initiatives, including the African Governance Platform.
change in Libya are cases in point. However, while the By early 2011, 31 countries had acceded to NEPADs
attempt of some leaders to cling to power has been African Peer Review Mechanism (one more than last
the most visible expression of democratic recessions, year), and 14 countries had been peer-reviewed (two
others, including the dominance of the incumbent, more than last year) and were slowly implementing
are equally worrying. Six of the nine presidential the reviews recommendations.
20
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
domestic resource mobilization by deepening the Many countries have made progress in curbing
tax base, strengthening tax administration and corruption, particularly in the extractive sector. Twenty-
formalizing the informal sector. While the trend of tax one resource-rich African countries have now joined
revenues is positive, in some countries, like Burundi, the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI)
the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia and and adopted its stringent standards on the verification
Guinea-Bissau, annual per capita taxes are still and publication of private-sector payments. The
as low as $11.35 Many countries still collect only Central African Republic, Ghana, Liberia, Niger, and
half of what would be expected given their living Nigeria are already fully compliant. Nonetheless, Sub-
standards and economic situation.36 Elsewhere, tax Saharan Africa continues to rank last in the Revenue
revenues are still dominated by taxes related to Watch Index, measuring governments willingness to
resource extraction, which can be up to 66 per cent disclose information on their resource revenues.38
21
GOVERNANCE FACTSHEET
Country Name of leader Years Year of last Registered The leader Constitutional Constitutional Countries holding
(*incumbent president winner of last in power Presidential voters (1) originally change in change in the presidential
election) Election out of total came to the last 10 last 10 years: elections 2011-
(% won by) population (2) power years that Qualitative 2012
(million) through a favours the improvement (*incumbent
coup incumbent (3) of constitution seeking
(year) (years) (4) reelection)
(year)
Sources: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (IDEA) Voter Turnout Database, Electoral Institute for the Sustainability of Democracy in Africa (EISA), BBC Country Profiles, CIA Factbook,
Angola President Jose Eduardo DOS SANTOS* 31 1992 4.8 / 13.3 2010 2012 (*)
(49.6%)
Benin President Thomas YAYI BONI* 5 2011 (53%) 4.3 / 9.3 2011 (*)
Burkina Faso President Blaise COMPAORE* 23 2010 3.9 / 16.7 1987 2002
(80.2%)
Cameroon President Paul BIYA* 28 2004 4.7 / 19.7 2008 2011 (*)
(70.9%)
Central African Republic President Francois BOZIZE* 8 2011 1.3 / 4.9 2003 2010 2011 (*)
(64.4%)
Chad President Lt. Gen. Idriss DEBY 20 2006 5.7 / 10.8 1990 2005 2011 (*)
ITNO* (64.7%)
DRC President Joseph KABILA* 10 2006 (58%) 25.4 / 71.7 2011 2011 (*)
Cte d'Ivoire President Alassane OUATTARA >1 year 2010 5.5 / 21.5
(54.1%)
Djibouti President Ismail Omar GUELLEH* 12 2011 (80%) 0.2 / 0.8 2010 2011 (*)
African Election Project 14 Oct 2009 Rights Group Encourages Responsible Voting and IFES Election Guide.
Equatorial Guinea President Brig. Gen. (Ret.) 31 2009 0.2 / 0.7 1979
Teodoro OBIANG NGUEMA (95.8%)
MBASOGO*
Liberia President Ellen JOHNSON SIRLEAF 5 2005 1.3 /3.8 2011 (*)
(59.6%)
22
Country Name of leader Years Year of last Registered The leader Constitutional Constitutional Countries holding
(*incumbent president winner of last in power Presidential voters (1) originally change in change in the presidential
election) Election out of total came to the last 10 last 10 years: elections 2011-
(% won by) population (2) power years that Qualitative 2012
(million) through a favours the improvement (*incumbent
coup incumbent (3) of constitution seeking
(year) (years) (4) reelection)
(year)
Niger President Mahamadou ISSOUFOU >1 year 2011 (58%) 5.2 / 16.5 2010 2011
So Tom and Prncipe President Fradique Bandiera 9 2006 (60%) 0.1 / 0.2 2011
Melo DE MENEZES*
Senegal President Abdoulaye WADE* 11 2007 4.9 / 12.6 2001 2012 (*)
(55.9%)
Seychelles President James Alix MICHEL* 7 2006 0.1 / 0.1 2011 (*)
(53.7%)
Sierra Leone President Ernest Bai KOROMA 3 2007 2.6 / 5.4 2008 2012 (*)
(54.6%)
Tunisia Former President Zine El Abidine 23 2009 4.9 / 10.6 2002 2011
BEN ALI* (89.6%)
Uganda President Lt. Gen. Yoweri Kaguta 25 2011 10.4 / 34.6 1986 2005 2011 (*)
MUSEVENI* (68.4%)
23
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
24
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
SOUTH AFRICA
best connected within africa
nigeria 2005 2010
democratic republic of congo
2005 2010 Intra Africa main Intra Africa main
2005 2010 destinations*: Mozambique destinations*: Zimbabwe
Intra Africa main Intra Africa main
destinations*: Ghana (32), destinations*: Ghana (48), Intra Africa main Intra Africa main (109), Botswana (89), (99), Botswana (90),
Ethiopia (10), Cte dIvoire South Africa (14), Egypt destinations*: South Africa destinations*: South Africa Namibia (87), Namibia (89),
(7), South Africa (4) (14), Ethiopia (13) (7), Kenya (7), Congo (7), (17), Ethiopia (10), Zimbabwe (55) Mozambique (71)
Connected to: 17 countries Connected to: 18 countries Ethiopia (1) Kenya (9), Congo (3) Connected to: 28 countries Connected to: 28 countries
Connected to: Connected to:
International top International top International top International top
7 countries 17 countries
destinations*: United destinations*: United destinations*: United destinations*: United
Kingdom (27), France (11), Kingdom (33), United Arab International top International top Kingdom (55), Germany Kingdom (55), United Arab
Netherlands (11), United Emirates (16), Germany destinations*: France (3), destinations*: France (3), (25), United Arab Emirates Emirates (42), Germany
Arab Emirates (6) (14), France (7) Belgium (2) Belgium (2) (14), Australia (9) (25), Australia (14)
Connected to: 8 countries Connected to: 11 countries Connected to: 2 countries Connected to: 2 countries Connected to: 23 countries Connected to: 22 countries
* The number of flights is a rounded average of the total number of departing flights per week for a selected country.
The average was computed using a representative week for each month over a whole year.
4,000
25
3,000
20
2,000 15
10 13,7%
1,000
5
0 0
Jan 2005 Jan 2008 Jan 2011 Europe Asia Middle East
25
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
D espite repeated declarations, the public re- political and economic realities has not disappeared.
examination of global governance triggered by At their summit in Seoul in November 2010, the G20
the recent financial and economic crisis has not led nations agreed to a series of measures addressing
to significant changes to out-dated arrangements for global imbalances and pushing for further changes to
representation and decision-making. Also because governance structures of the IMF and World Bank.48
of the inadequate diplomatic capacity of many The French G20 Presidency has vowed to implement
governments, Africa remains heavily marginalized in these measures as part of its ambitious reform agenda
world affairs, with little control over how these affairs focusing on the modernization of the international
affect its people. monetary system. Also in November 2010, the EU
pledged to support Africa in its efforts to gain a
In fact, the recent crisis seems to have complicated permanent seat on the UN Security Council.49
Africas bid for a louder voice and greater
international representation. The inclusion of big South Africas membership in the G20 and the
emerging economies like Brazil, China and India, increasingly institutionalized participation of the AU
with their own (legitimate) concerns and priorities,46 and NEPAD in the groups meetings are important
risks further marginalizing less economically steps towards ensuring that Africas concerns and
powerful players. The G24, the intergovernmental priorities are taken into account in the proposed reform
group representing developing countries in the IMF efforts. They may also encourage greater African
and the World Bank, has calculated that the lions representation in other decision-making fora. It is
share of the promised 6 per cent shift in IMF voting unrealistic to expect individual representation of most
power is actually a shift from developing countries African countries in every important organization, and
to emerging economies, thus further reducing also unrealistic to expect single countries to set aside
Africas say in these organizations.47 The crisis has their own national concerns in order to represent the
added weight to specialized bodies such as the entire continent. Therefore, continental and regional
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision and the representation may prove the most effective way to
Financial Stability Board, on which Africa has very include African perspectives. Crucially, this may also
little representation even though its countries are help to improve the legitimacy of organizations like
directly affected by the decisions taken. the G20.
26
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
27
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
T
success stories highlight the possibility of rapid o the detriment of hundreds of millions of Africans,
improvements in all key sectors and some the continents strong economic growth has not
countries are on track to achieve most of their translated into widespread job creation and poverty
targets, overall progress continues to be slow. reduction. While there is still considerable controversy
It is hampered by exogenous trends such as around both the method of computation and the
accelerating climate change and by inadequate actual level of Africas poverty rate,62 it is certain that
policies, unmet commitments, lack of focus and many African countries will not reach their poverty-
accountability and insufficient dedication to reduction goals by 2015 despite strong GDP growth.
sustainable development by both African states UNCTAD projects that income per capita will grow at
and their international partners. only 2.7 per cent in 2011, and 2.8 per cent in 2012,
which is below the threshold of 3 per cent considered
A particularly worrying development is the increase as the minimum rate to make a substantial dent in
in inequality both within and across African poverty and far below the rate needed to achieve
societies.58 The UNDPs new inequality-adjusted the MDGs in most countries.63
Human Development Index (HDI) shows that the
human development ratings of African countries The need for greater progress is urgent. According
are substantially lower if adjusted for inequality in to the 2011 Rural Poverty Report of the International
the distribution of wealth. This adjustment reduces Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), Sub-
ratings of some countries, including the Central Saharan Africa is home to nearly one third of the
African Republic, Mozambique and Namibia, by worlds poor. While their share in the continents
up to 40 per cent.59 total population is declining, their absolute numbers
have increased from 268 million to 306 million over
The global financial crisis has also clearly shown the last decade.64 The UNDPs Multi-dimensional
the importance for African countries of creating Poverty Index, which complements money-based
mechanisms to protect the most vulnerable measures by considering multiple deprivations and
segments of their populations against unexpected their overlap, even puts the number of poor Africans
shocks. Despite the efforts of some countries to as high as 458 million.65
implement the AUs Social Policy Framework, basic
social security remains beyond reach for most While poverty remains a predominantly rural
Africans, with less than 5 per cent of the working- phenomenon throughout Africa, rapid urbanization
age population in Sub-Saharan Africa covered is adding an increasingly important dimension.66
by contributory pension schemes, unemployment The continent already has the highest incidence of
benefits or other social safety nets.60 As a result, slums over 62 per cent of the urban population
economic contraction and price volatility continue lives in such informal inner-city settlements and
to have a disproportionate effect on the poor. accelerating rural flight is bound to swell the ranks
of the urban poor.67 Increasingly volatile food prices,
But it is not all bad news. There is plenty of evidence the uncertainties and effects of climate change
that with the right policy mix and international and a range of natural-resource constraints will also
support, African countries can still achieve many of complicate efforts to reduce poverty.68 At the same
their MDG-based targets, particularly in the areas time, positive trends include increasing agricultural
of education and health. At the Review Summit productivity, growing international interest in bottom-
in September 2010, world leaders reaffirmed their of-the-pyramid business and the spread of mobile
commitment to achieve the goals by 2015 and a and affordable technology. These offer new and
number of promising initiatives, such as the UNDPs exciting opportunities for tackling poverty.
There is evidence that with the right policy mix and international support,
African countries can still achieve many of their MDG-based targets.
28
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
29
MDG SCORECARD Tracking MDG Progress
No data Tracking progress on MDG
l Achieved l On-track l Off-track/slow l Regressing achievement is an immense
challenge due to a lack
of sufficient, reliable, and
Millennium updated data. There are
Development Goals also inconsistencies between
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
national and global tracking
Eradicate Achieve Promote gen- Reduce child Improve Combat HIV/ Ensure efforts that make it difficult
extreme universal der equality mortality maternal AIDS, malaria environmental to compare progress across
poverty and primary and empower health and other sustainability countries and regions but
Country hunger education women diseases commendable efforts have
Algeria l l l l l l l been made.
Angola l l l l l l l This infographic illustrates
Benin l l l l l l l overall MDG progress as
Botswana l l l l l l l seen in the African Economic
Outlook 2010 Report.
Burkina Faso l l l l l l l
Burundi l l l l l l l 2009 and 2010 data from
Cameroon l l l l l l other progress reports
highlight the following:
Cape Verde l l l l l l l
Central African Republic l l l l l l l
Chad l l l l l l l GOAL 1: POVERTY AND
Comoros l l l l l l l HUNGER
Congo, Republic l l l l l l l Despite progress in
DRC l l l l l l l many countries, the number
of people suffering from
Cte dIvoire l l l l l l l hunger on the continent has
Djibouti l l l l l l l increased.
Egypt l l l l l l l Ghana, Liberia, Sierra Leone,
Equatorial Guinea l l l l l l l Ethiopia, DRC, Angola,
Eritrea l l l l l l l Mozambique and Malawi
Ethiopia l l l l l l l made the most progress in
GDP growth rate per person
Gabon l l l l l l l employed. Many countries
Gambia l l l l l l l increased labour productivity
Ghana l l l l l l l but Comoros, Rwanda,
Guinea l l l l l l l Equatorial Guinea, Chad,
Mali, Namibia, Tunisia, Eritrea,
Guinea Bissau l l l l l l l Botswana and Lesotho
Kenya l l l l l l l showed a decline between
Lesotho l l l l l l l 1992 and 2008.
Source: Progress towards the Millennium Development Goals, African Economic Outlook 2010 http://www.africaneconomicoutlook.org
30
GOAL 2: EDUCATION GOAL 3: WOMENS GOAL 4: CHILD MORTALITY GOAL 5: MATERNAL
African countries EMPOWERMENT Overall African under- HEALTH
continue to show The gender parity index five mortality rate DRC, Ethiopia and
overall progress in in primary education (U5MR) declined at an Nigeria, account for
net enrollment in primary (1991-2007) shows that insufficient rate to attain the 50% of all maternal deaths
education where Ethiopia, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, MDG target between 1990 globally. Although the
Guinea, Malawi, Mali, Madagascar, Namibia, South and 2008.U5MR progress has Maternal Mortality Ratio has
Madagascar, Mauritania and Africa, Swaziland and have been most striking in Eritrea fallen in both Nigeria and
Morocco showed significant regressed. Mauritius is the only and Malawi, Ethiopia, Malawi, Ethiopia, it needs to fall at a
improvement as did Burkina country that has managed Mozambique and Niger.1 much faster rate for the overall
Faso, Burundi, Djibouti, to maintain gender parity picture to change1.
Gambia, Ghana, Niger, for the same period. Other Progress remains slow in
Rwanda, Senegal, Swaziland countries have only marginally Mauritania, So Tom and Most African countries are
and Togo. DRC and increased gender parity. Prncipe, Central African unlikely to achieve the
Equatorial Guinea reversed Republic and Swaziland. target as only ten countries
progress (1991- 2007). Womens representation in have reached an over 50%
African parliaments has made Between 1990-2008, there was contraceptive prevalence rate:
Guinea, Morocco, significant progress. Of 37 no change in DRC or Somalia. Mauritius, Morocco, Algeria,
Mauritania, Tunisia, Malawi, countries only six Guinea- while in Chad, Congo, Kenya, Cape Verde, Egypt, South
Madagascar, Tanzania and Bissau, So Tom and Prncipe, South Africa and Zimbabwe, Africa, Tunisia, Zimbabwe,
Togo have made significant Congo, Equatorial Guinea, the U5MR increased. Namibia, and Swaziland.
progress in improving primary Egypt and Cameroon show Infant Mortality Rate (IMR)
completion rates while that parliamentary seats Algeria, Libya, Tunisia, and
declined between 1990 and Morocco report the lowest
Burundi and Mauritius were held by women decreased 2008. Mozambique recorded
the only two countries to between 1990 and 2009. The adolescent birth rates on the
the greatest reduction, continent. It is highest in Chad,
register a setback.1 most progress was seen in followed by Malawi, Niger and
Rwanda followed by Angola, Mali, Mozambique and Niger.2
Ethiopia. Kenya was the worst
Mozambique, South Africa, performer, followed by Chad, 1 The Lancet (Hogan et al., 2010)
1 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010) Assess- and Uganda.1 Congo, Lesotho, South Africa, 2 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010)
ing Progress in Africa toward the Millennium
Development Goals, MDG Report 2010 1 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010) and Zimbabwe.
Between 2000 and 2008,
16 countries increased their Nigeria, So Tom and
GOAL 6: HIV/AIDS, Malaria mortality has dropped measles immunization: Prncipe, Senegal, Sierra
MALARIA AND OTHER in Ethiopia, Mozambique, Angola, Burkina Faso, Leone and Sudan. Benin,
DISEASES Rwanda, Zambia and the Cameroon, Central Chad, Cte dIvoire, Gambia,
Zanzibar region of Tanzania. African Republic, Congo, Egypt, Somalia, South Africa,
Africa has sustained the DRC, Djibouti, Ethiopia, Swaziland and Zimbabwe
progress made in tackling HIV/ Between 2000 and 2008/2009
there was significant increase Guinea,Madagascar, Niger, reported a setback over the
AIDS. Namibia and Rwanda
in the use of insecticide- same period.2
made remarkable increase 1 UN (2010) The Millennium Development
in knowledge about HIV treated bed nets (ITN)to Goals Report 2 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010)
prevention between 2000 and protect from malaria. The
2008 but most countries will proportion of children under
not meet the 95% knowledge five sleeping under ITNs rose
target by 2010 set by the considerably in Gambia, in Egypt, Nigeria and except Algeria, Botswana,
UN. Condom use has also Kenya, Madagascar, Morocco.3 Nine countries Egypt, Equatorial Guinea,
gained acceptance in some Rwanda, So Tom and are still classified by WHO as Mauritius, Morocco,
countries such as Burkina Prncipe, and Zambia.2 TB high-burden countries: Namibia, and the Seychelles.
Faso, Cameroon, Kenya, DRC, Ethiopia, Kenya,
Mozambique, Namibia and The TB prevalence rate has Libya is the highest emitter of
been rising in Algeria, Cte Mozambique, Nigeria, South CO2 per capita in Africa.
Nigeria. As of December 2008, Africa, Tanzania, Uganda,
some 3 million Africans were dIvoire, Mauritania, Senegal,
Sierra Leone, Sudan, Togo and Zimbabwe. Many countries showed an
estimated to be receiving
and Tunisia. It declined improvement in access to
antiretroviral therapy (44% of
the estimated need).1 safe drinking water. In 2008,
2 UN (2010) The Millennium Development Botswana, Comoros, Djibouti,
1 UNAIDS, AIDS Epidemic Update 2009 Goals Report 3 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010)
Egypt, Gambia, Mauritius,
Namibia, South Africa, and
Mixed progress in africa GOAL 7:
Tunisia reached over 90%
coverage. DRC, Ethiopia,
100 ENVIRONMENTAL Madagascar, Mauritania,
SUSTAINABILITY1 Mozambique, Niger, Sierra
90 Leone and Somalia had less
Many countries are yet
than 50% coverage.
80 to include environmental
Source: Progress towards the Millennium Development Goals,
30
Africa is the lowest emitter
Madagascar, Mozambique,
20 of carbon dioxide as a
Niger, Sierra Leone, and Togo
global region. CO2 emissions
10 have less than 20%.
between 1990 and 2006
0 decreased in most countries
Goal 1 Goal 2 Goal 3 Goal 4 Goal 5 Goal 6 Goal 7 1 AU, AfDB, UNECA and UNDP (2010)
Achieved On-track Off-track-slow Regressing
31
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
Education and Skills Formation and other serious shortfalls. However, the spread of
information and communication technology offers
P rimary education continues to be one of Africas chances to bridge some of the gaps in innovative
greatest success stories. According to the latest ways, including through web-based education and
figures, the majority of African countries are on track testing platforms, e-learning, and long-distance
to achieve the goal of universal primary education mentoring.
by 2015, with Burundi, Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya,
Mozambique and Tanzania having made notable
progress.69 This has been achieved through abolition Gender Equality and
of school fees, greater public investments and
improved donor support, particularly through the
Womens Empowerment
World Banks Education for All Fast Track Initiative.
There is less success in other areas such as the T he empowerment of Africas women is critical to
the achievement of all MDGs, not just the goal of
gender equality. Fortunately, awareness of the link
quality of education, completion rates, enrolment in
secondary and tertiary education, basic education between womens empowerment and development
reform, and teacher recruitment.70 Meeting the continues to grow. Although gender-disaggregated
relevant targets will be an enormous challenge. data remain patchy, the results of increased efforts
More than 31 million African children, most of them are beginning to show.
girls, remain out of school and the number of new
teachers needed between now and 2015 alone In October 2010, the AU launched African Womens
equals the continents entire current teaching Decade, and there are encouraging signs of progress
force.71 With an enrolment rate of merely 6 per cent, to come.74 Last year showed a continuing upward
low female participation, and over 40 per cent of trend in the political participation of African women,
faculty positions vacant, higher education remains a who now hold 18.5 per cent of parliamentary positions
particularly serious stumbling block in the continents (from 15 per cent in the previous year). Womens
quest for strong and sustained growth. This is despite representation in parliaments in Sub-Saharan Africa
the growing engagement of international donors is now higher than in South Asia, the Arab states or
and collaborative initiatives like the Partnership for Eastern Europe.75 Most countries are also on track to
Higher Education in Africa or the Association for the achieve gender parity in primary education by 2015. A
Development of Education in Africa.72 growing number, including Senegal, Benin and Burkina
Faso, have integrated gender concerns into their
There is still a notable lack of strategic planning for and national development plans and poverty-reduction
access to skills development as part of the broader strategies, also because international partners like the
education curriculum. The acquisition of skills linked Millennium Challenge Corporation have made gender
to market-needs plays an essential role in human reform a prerequisite for grant disbursement.76 Lesotho
development, employment generation, poverty has even achieved the greatest overall improvement
reduction and sustainable economic growth. While of any nation in the World Economic Forums Global
the share of secondary school students enrolled in Gender Gap Index over the last five years.77
technical and vocational programmes has increased
to 13 per cent in Mali, 16 per cent in Rwanda, and Despite these encouraging signs, Africa remains
18 per cent in the Democratic Republic of Congo, it plagued by substantial and debilitating gender
remains below 2 per cent in Niger, Chad and Sudan.73 gaps in health, employment, and wages.78 For every
headline success, thousands of women continue to
Crisis-induced spending cuts in both African and find their talents and aspirations blocked by formal
partner countries, quickly growing youth populations and informal barriers. If adjusted for gender equality,
and the prevalence of armed conflict in many parts human development ratings drop substantially
of the continent complicate efforts to address these across the entire continent.79
32
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
For reasons ranging from labour-market conditions While Africa as a whole is unlikely to meet the goal
to access to education to social barriers, cultural of reducing infant mortality by 2015, some countries
values and attitudes in the household, the vast have achieved outstanding reductions, including
majority of women in Sub-Saharan Africa continue Mozambique (over 70 per cent), Malawi (68 per
to face income and job insecurities.80 The economic cent) and Niger (64 per cent).84 Although maternal
crisis has further increased both the informalization mortality remains unacceptably high across the
of jobs held by women and their share of vulnerable continent, the limited available evidence indicates
employment.81 Even though women make up the that some countries, including Burundi, Cape Verde
majority of the agricultural workforce, producing as and Egypt, are achieving substantial reductions.
much as 80 per cent of the continents food, they still This suggests that current efforts to reduce maternal
own less than 1 per cent of Africas land. They are mortality are working but need to be further scaled
still the first, along with their children, to suffer under up and complemented by increased investments in
economic contraction, food insecurity and violent information systems and accessible and affordable
conflict. services. Africas leaders agreed at the AU Summit
in July 2010 to increase financial and political
This is not only a personal tragedy for millions of support for female and child health, and to intensify
women and their families, but a major brake on cooperative efforts through partnerships like the
Africas development. Failing to use womens energy Campaign on Accelerated Reduction of Maternal
and skills slows progress towards achievement of the Mortality in Africa (CARMMA).87
MDGs, weakens governance and accountability,
and hampers the implementation of much-needed While the goals of reducing maternal and infant
reforms. Empowering women, on the other hand, is mortality across all Africa remain distant, there
proven to increase household incomes, nutrition and are several important milestones within reach. The
education levels, and agricultural productivity, and elimination of polio, measles, guinea-worm disease
to decrease fertility, population growth and carbon and mother-to-child transmission of HIV is possible, but
emissions.82 Africa still has a long way to go in realizing requires a strong final push.88 The expansion of routine
the enormous potential of its women. immunization across the continent is progressing
and the introduction of several new vaccines,
including for meningitis and pneumococcal disease,
Health is already yielding substantial benefits.89 A promising
malaria vaccine is in the final testing stages and its
I ncreased financing and a strategic scale-up introduction may be only a couple of years away.90
of effective interventions have led to some
remarkable results in health this year. For example, Many of these recent achievements were made
enough insecticide-treated mosquito nets have possible by effective partnerships between and
been distributed to protect more than 578 million among governments, international organizations,
people at risk of malaria in Sub-Saharan Africa. the private sector, philanthropic actors and civil
As a result of these and similar efforts, 11 African society. Particularly innovative funding mechanisms
countries have shown reductions of over 50 per cent such as the Global Alliance for Vaccinations and
in the number of confirmed malaria cases, and the Immunization (GAVI) and the Global Fund to Fight
majority of African states are now on track to halt the Aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria have helped to turn
advance of malaria by 2015.83 international goodwill into results on the ground.
33
140
Namibia
(measured in percent ot total female population)
South Africa
Mauritius
Botswana
80
Iran, Islamic Rep
Literacy rate, women
Sudan
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
Primary and secondary education, women (total years of schooling)
100
70
Mauritius
(Economic Opportunity Index (1-100)
50 Namibia
Venezuela, RB
Botswana
Tanzania Morocco
40 Benin Ghana Kenya
Algeria
Zambia Senegal Malawi Egypt
Uganda Burkina Faso Nigeria
Madagascar
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit (2010)
Cameroon
Womens Economic Opportunity Index.
30 Ethiopia
Togo
Cte d'Ivoire Pakistan
Chad
20
Yemen
Sudan
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Access to Finance
Countries analysed in the Womens Economic Opportuniy Index
Selected countries for reference
African countries
34
womens opportunites in select african countries
Botswana Chad
World average World average
Best in world Labour Policy Best in world Labour Policy
Education Education
and Training and Training
Education Education
and Training and Training
Notes
On the radial charts:
Indicator scores are normalised to lie within a consistent range between 0-100, based on source
Tanzania
data. Section scores are the weighted sum of the underlying indicator scores. All scores 0-100 World average
where 100=most favourable. Best in world
Labour Policy
On the methodology:
The Womens Economic Opportunity Index is a dynamic quantitative and qualitative scoring
model constructed from 26 indicators that measure specific attributes of the environment for General Business Labour
women employees and entrepreneurs in 113 economies.
Environment Practice
Five category scores are calculated from the unweighted mean of underlying indicators and
scaled from 0-100, where 100=most favourable. These categories are: Labour policy and practice
(which comprises two sub-categories: Labour policy and Labour practice); Access to finance;
Education and training; Womens legal and social status; and the General business environment.
Each category or sub-category features either four or five underlying indicators.
The overall score is calculated from a simple average of the unweighted category and indicator
scores. That is, every indicator contributes equally to its parent category and every category Womens Legal and Access to
contributes equally to the overall score. This is the baseline score for the Womens Economic Social Status Finance
Opportunity Index.
The womens access to finance programmes indicator assesses whether governments or the
formal financial sector have programmes aimed at providing fi nancial accounts to women, Education
improving both access to loans and financial literacy. and Training
Source: Economist Intelligence Unit (2010), Womens Economic Opportunity Index.
35
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
36
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
both the high prevalence of HIV/AIDS among the progress also compounds and widens existing
extremely poor, and the silent epidemic of non- inequalities, as improvements in sanitation and
communicable diseases such as cancers, diabetes water access are largely bypassing the poor.101 These
and cardiovascular diseases expected to increase inequities are becoming increasingly apparent in
significantly over the next 20 years. The number of Africas cities where almost half the poor population
Africans with diabetes, for example, is expected to suffers from at least one preventable disease caused
rise from 12.1 million to 23.9 million.94 by lack of safe water and sanitation.102
I n July 2010, the UN General Assembly declared the African Ministers Council on Water and its
access to clean water and sanitation a human right. African Water Facility. This has not yet translated
Implementing this right will be a particular challenge into national policies and investments necessary
in Africa where more than 40 per cent of people to address the lack of progress. By investing only
live in water-deprived areas. The amount of water an average 0.2 per cent of GDP in sanitation and
available per person in Africa is not only far below the hygiene, most African countries have missed the
global average already, but is declining even further 2010 targets of the eThekwini Declaration which
as groundwater levels fall and precipitation patterns called for the sector-specific allocation of 0.5 per
change as a result of accelerating climate change. cent of GDP.103 As a result, total investment in Africas
At present, only 26 countries are on track to attain water sector remains far below the AfDB estimate of
the water-provision target to halve the proportion of $11 billion per year required to meet the continents
the population without sustainable access to clean drinking water supply and sanitation needs.104 Other
drinking water by 2015.95 Only nine African countries obstacles to progress are poor governance of the
(Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, Libya, Rwanda, Botswana, water sector, both nationally and with respect to
Angola, South Africa and Egypt) are expected to Africas 63 shared water basins,105 the growing
meet the MDG target of halving the proportion of water needs of African agriculture, a lack of private-
the population without sustainable access to basic sector capacity in manual drilling, and limited
sanitation by 2015.96 At current trends, Africa will miss capacity of community-based maintenance of
this target by over 300 million people.97 water infrastructure.106
This slow progress is highly problematic because At the same time, a number of innovative
improved access to safe water and sanitation is partnerships, such the AfDBs Rural Water Supply
essential to improve health.98 Currently, only 60 per and Sanitation Initiative, the CEO Water Mandate,
cent of people in Sub-Saharan Africa have access to the Sanitation and Water for All Partnership and
improved sources of drinking water and less than half Ecotacts commercialized provision of affordable
have access to basic sanitation facilities.99 More than sanitation in urban slums, have shown that rapid
a quarter still have to practise open defecation, thus progress is possible.107 There is also enormous
protracting water- and hygiene-related diseases potential for expanding simple water-harvesting
such as diarrhoea and worm infections.100 The slow techniques and savings from utility reforms.
37
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
food and nutrition planning to host the first ever meeting of the Groups
Ministers of Agriculture before the Summit. In addition,
security there are attempts to create more transparency of
food stocks held by large exporters to avoid panic
caused by market uncertainty about the availability
the worlds most food-insecure region.108 Hunger and Structural Barriers to Food Security
malnutrition remain pervasive in many countries, and
A
rising food prices are compounding the situation for t the same time, the fact that the number of
millions across the continent, particularly in zones of Africans suffering from hunger had already been
protracted conflict and in fast-growing urban areas.109 on the increase well before prices spiked suggests
that chronic and structural problems rather than
mere price fluctuations continue to underlie much
Volatility of Food Prices of the continents food insecurity. These problems
include: disadvantageous international trade rules
Food prices are higher now than at any time since 1984.
38
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
in the sector to at least 6 per cent a year. Nineteen pace with population growth, and a significant part
countries have finalized Agricultural Investment Plans. of that increase will have to come from Africa. There
is an urgent need to scale up successful interventions,
Practical efforts to boost agricultural production are focus on Africas army of smallholder farmers and
beginning to yield results in many countries, including increase emphasis on staple food crops. There is also
Ghana, Malawi, Mali, Mozambique and Tanzania. a need to ensure that the growing foreign investments
Focused international assistance and innovative in Africas arable land, sometimes referred to as land
partnerships, like the Alliance for a Green Revolution in grabs, are transparent, add to the continents food
Africa (AGRA), have helped governments to intensify security, benefit local farmers and communities,
production. Methods include: the introduction and avoid undermining social, environmental and
of high-yielding varieties of crops and improved governance systems.114
techniques such as micro-dosing of fertilizers and
drip irrigation; increased accessibility of production- The dire social consequences of the recent food
enhancing inputs, credit and other financial services crises have shown that efforts to improve agricultural
such as weather-indexed crop insurance; and productivity and connectivity on the supply side need
improved markets and information. The increasing to be complemented by better risk management,
engagement of the private sector, including through efficient social safety nets and targeted nutritional
the promotion of agricultural growth corridors and programmes on the demand side. As with the
agro-industrialization, will help to increase resources implementation of agricultural development plans,
available for agricultural investments. national governments ultimately bear responsibility
for this.
These successes remain too small to feed the
continent. Global food production will have to
increase by 70 per cent over the next 40 years to keep
39
FOOD securityAND HUNGER
Price volatility
Wheat +69%
400
Palm oil +55%
300
Soybeans +36%
200
Beef +30%
100
Source: World Bank Development Prospects Group
0
06
06
06
07
07
07
08
08
08
09
09
9
l0
l0
l0
l0
n
pr
ct
pr
ct
pr
ct
pr
Ju
Ju
Ju
Ju
Ja
Ja
Ja
Ja
A
A
O
Chad
Afghanistan
Sudan
Eritrea
Ethiopia
Liberia
DR Congo Burundi
Angola
Maplecroft 2011
This map is the visual representation of the Maplecroft Food Security Index (FSI). It provides a quantitative
assessment of the availability, stability and access to food supplies, as well as the nutritional outcomes that
result from food insecurity. Each country is assigned an index score based on its performance across 18 key maplecroft
indicators, classified into four sub-indices: extreme risk, high risk, medium risk and low risk. www.maplecroft.com
40
global Hunger index and FOOD PRODUCTION
rm ly
Lo e
ng
i ng
rat
Ala eme
us
i
1999-2001 = 100
rm
de
rio
w
tr
Ala
Mo
Ex
Se
1990 * Algeria 2000
2010 Angola 2007
Benin
Botswana
Burkina Faso
Burundi
Cameroon
no data Cape Verde
Central African Republic
Chad
Comoros
DRC
Congo, Republic
Cte d'Ivoire
Djibouti
* Egypt
no data Equatorial Guinea
Eritrea
Ethiopia
Gabon
Gambia
Sources: Food and nutrition security Source - IFPR Global Hunger Index 2010 Data underlying the calculation of the 1990 and 2010 Global Hunger Indices.
Ghana
Guinea
Guinea-Bissau
Kenya
Lesotho
Liberia
* indicates
value of
a *
* Libya
less than 5 Madagascar
Malawi
Mali
Mauritania
Mauritius
Morocco
Mozambique
Namibia
Niger
Nigeria
Rwanda
Source: African Statistical Yearbook 2010 (UNECA, AUC, AfDB).
41
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
F or millions in Africa, the effects of climate change reached in Copenhagen and Cancun.
are already manifest in increasingly frequent
storms, droughts and floods, changing weather and
precipitation patterns as well rising temperatures.115 Climate Change Finance
In combination with existing environmental
degradation,116 this reduces agricultural productivity
and threatens food security,117 increases water stress,
facilitates the spread of vector-borne diseases
A frican countries require substantial additional
resources to help them adapt to the unavoidable
consequences of climate change. For reasons
such as malaria, and erodes valuable human of design, sequencing, coordination, and lack of
habitat. Through the acidification of seawater, rising absorptive capacity, they have been unable to
sea levels and the spread of storm-surge zones, benefit from financing instruments of the Kyoto
climate change also directly threatens the lives and Protocol, such as the Clean Development Mechanism
livelihoods of millions of Africans dependant on the and the Reduced Emissions from Deforestation and
oceans for food and income.118 Forest Degradation Programme. The Copenhagen
Accord includes the commitment to support
By all indicators, African countries are among the developing countries adaptation and mitigation
most vulnerable to the effects of sustained climate efforts with additional resources. This is in the form of
change.119 According to Maplecrofts Climate Change fast-start finance ($30 billion for 20102012) and long-
Vulnerability Index, 12 of the 25 countries most at risk term finance ($100 billion a year by 2020), with 40 per
are African, with high levels of poverty, population cent of each fund earmarked for Africa.
density, and reliance on flood- and drought-prone
agricultural land.120 These countries are finding it To date, most of the fast-start finance appears to
increasingly difficult to feed their people, protect them be coming from existing ODA budgets.122 The High-
from the vagaries of nature, grow their economies and Level Advisory Group on Climate Finance convened
conserve their environments. The risk of resource-based by the UN Secretary-General and co-chaired by
conflict and destabilizing mass migrations only adds to Ethiopias Prime Minister Meles Zenawi concluded
these other multiple insecurities. that the long-term finance could be mobilized in
addition to existing ODA budgets by auctioning
emission rights, establishing a carbon-dioxide tax or
Climate Change Politics emissions-transaction fee for international carbon
trades, and relocating funds from fuel subsidies in
A pproaching the 16th Conference of Parties (COP developed countries to adaptation activities in
16) on climate change in Cancun in December developing countries.123
2010, the African Ministerial Conference on the
Environment (AMCEN) continued to develop the Despite persisting uncertainty about the sources and
continents common position and provided African disbursement of proposed financing as well as the
42
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
level of political commitment, there are already well green policies such as fostering sustainable land and
over 20 bilateral and multilateral funds dedicated watershed management, combating deforestation,
to receiving and managing pledged resources.124 using taxes and market-based instruments to
These include the Global Environmental Facility, the shift consumer preference, and promoting green
World Banks Green Climate Fund and the AfDBs investment and innovation. They have also continued
Africa Green Fund. This proliferation of funds runs to engage in multilateral initiatives like the Congo Basin
contrary to the Paris principles for aid effectiveness Forest Fund, the Lake Chad Sustainability Programme
by complicating the reporting, monitoring and and the creation of Regional Climate Centres. The
verification of financial commitments and will need Climate Information for Development in Africa (Clim-
addressing at the forthcoming High-Level Meeting on Dev) Programme aims to improve the continents
Aid Effectiveness in Busan. The proliferation of funds analytical capacity, knowledge management and
also adds to the already heavy administrative burden access to information on climate change.
placed on recipient states and to their growing
distrust in the willingness of richer countries to go Partners are also stepping up their supportive efforts
beyond the formulation of elaborate mechanisms. across Africa. The World Bank, for example, has
earmarked $7 billion for adaptation initiatives across
At the same time, there is growing realization that the continent and is already implementing its climate
transfers of public revenue and carbon taxes in change strategy for Africa in ten countries. This
developed countries can provide only part of includes a project to improve a congested public-
the solution. Reliance on carbon markets is also transport system in Nigeria, and the Lighting Africa
problematic, given Africas insufficient access, the initiative to provide carbon-free lighting to 250 million
low price of carbon and the uncertainty surrounding Africans by 2030.126
international negotiations and market mechanisms.
Consequently, there is increasing focus on the None of this, however, is enough to spark and
potential of the private sector and international capital drive the required transformation towards green
markets to complement the compensatory activities growth and environmental sustainability.127 Much
of developed countries through leveraging public more is needed, from both African states and their
flows, financing large-scale infrastructure projects and development and business partners, to ensure
promoting market-based adaptation activities.125 that the continent has the resources, mechanisms
and technologies necessary to adapt to the
effects of climate change. This requires investment
Adaptation and Mitigation in transformative mitigation measures such as
increasing renewable-energy generation and
43
Climate change Vulnerability l Low* l Moderate l High l Severe l Acute
44
africas Green Growth Potential
Technical potential for renewable energy power generation and
electricity markets by 2050 (exajoules a year)
12000
OECD Europe
10000
North America
Po Prod ricity
tia tion
n
re
En an
E le l
ic
nsu ity
r
re
y
Off ind
E le a l
ta
P
we
tio
PV
Figures from
On ind
erg
c tr
sho
CS
sho
e
rm
Co ctric
l To
W
Oc
mp
ten uc
po
lar
ct
lar
e
Renewable Energy
E le
dro
oth
So
So
Hy
Potentials 2008.)
Ge
45
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
A
resource mobilization, and becoming id flows are only one measurement of partners
increasingly attractive investment destinations, commitment to development, but they remain
the overall share of assistance from international an important one.131 For both the promises to double
partners in their development finance continues to Official Development Assistance (ODA) to Africa
decline, having now fallen to an average of about made by the G7 at their 2005 Summit in Gleneagles,
10 per cent of Gross National Income (GNI).128 The and the intermediate goal of the EU Roadmap to
importance of this assistance, however, remains high deliver 0.56 per cent of EU GNI in aid, 2010 was the
as predictable, concessional and targeted aid helps target year. The most recent figures show that only
to lubricate the ability of governments to respond to three G7 countries (Canada, Japan and the US) have
the needs of their people, leverage other flows and met their 2010 spending targets for Africa.132 While
ensure that they achieve developmental results. This all others have fallen short of their promises, there
having been said, several states, including Burundi, are some important differences between them. The
Guinea-Bissau and Mali, remain almost wholly UK has made a more ambitious pledge, and has
dependent on international aid.129 shown commendable increases in ODA to Africa
since Gleneagles, particularly over the last year,
and has fallen just short of its target. By contrast, Italy
Domestic Resource Mobilization made an ambitious commitment but is delivering
less aid now than it did at the time of the Gleneagles
46
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
47
development finance
Tracking the Gleneagles Commitments
total 2010 oda as volume of total 2010 oda commitment
Canada
USD 1.9 Bn delivered Italy
USD 1.5 Bn target USD 1.2 Bn
USD 5.0 Bn
Japan*
France USD 1.6 Bn
Notes: * Japan figures for ODA and targets tracks bilateral ODA net of debt relief only, but G7 totals are based on Japan's total ODA (with 2010 targets
incorporating a Japan flatlined multilateral estimate from 2009 onwards.)
At Gleneagles, three G7 countries set 'volume targets' (Canada, Japan and the US). Four G7 countries set ODA targets as a per cent of GNI.
20
France 0.5%
10 43%
France
20
Germany
10 25% 0.4%
Per cent of GNI
Germany
USD BIllions
20 Canada
Canada
10 81% 0.3%
G7
40
Note: These charts are based on actual values. Please note that
US
targets are based on smoothed multilateral for 2004 and 2005
20 71% US
0.2%
Japan
20
Japan Italy
10 92%
0.1%
Source: ONE/DATA Report 2011
20
Italy
10 36%
0%
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
48
NET CAPITAL INFLOWS, NET PRIVATE AND EXTERNAL DEBT, SSA 2005-2010
OFFICIAL INFLOWS TO SSA 2001-2009
80
350 35
70
300 30
60
250 25
50
USD Billions
Percent %
200 20
USD Billions
40
150 15
30
20 100 10
10 50 5
0 0 0
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
-10
Total debt in $ billion Total % of GDP
Worker remittances Net private and
official inflows Total debt service $ billion Total debt service
% of GDP
Net debt flows (includes official creditors, private Source: ECA and AU (2011) Economic Report on Africa 2011, Governing development in
creditors, net medium and long-term debt flows and net Africa - theECA
Source: roleand
of the
AUstate in economic
(2011) Economic transformation
Report on Africa 2011, Governing
short-term debt flows) development in Africa the role of the state in economic transformation
450
DOMESTIC RESOURCE MOBILIZATION
TAX SHARE, 1990 - 2007, SSA
400
35
350
355
30
300
USD Billions
25
250
Per cent (%) GDP
20
200
15 150
121
10 100
5 50
0 0
91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08
19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20
19 0
19 1
19 2
19 3
19 5
19 6
19 8
20 9
20 0
20 1
20 2
20 3
20 5
20 6
94
97
04
07
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
0
0
0
0
0
0
19
19
19
20
Official Flows
Upper Middle Income
Total Private Flows More Complete CGP
Lower Middle Income (philanthropy, remittances Total Private Flows
Lower Income and investments)
Source: African Economic
Source: Outlook
African 2011Outlook 2011
Economic Sources: OECD, Hudson
Source: Institutes
Hudson Center
Institutes for Global
Center Prosperity
for Global (CGP)
Prosperity index
(CGP) includes
index
Note: Based on GNI per capita, economies are classified as lower income, calculations includes
of numerous other private
calculations flows from
of numerous othercorporations,
private flows foundations, charities,
from corporations,
Note: Based on GNImiddle
lower per capita,
andeconomies are classified as lower income, lower middle and
upper middle. individuals, universities
foundations,and religious
charities, organizations.
individuals, universities, and religious organizations.
upper middle.Classification
Classificationby
bythe
theAfrican
AfricanEconomic
EconomicOutlook.
Outlook.
49
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
Institutional Partners and and adopted an action plan to 2013, explicitly based
around partnerships for development.139
Country Groupings
W ith bilateral aid budgets under increasing In November 2010, the G20 joined the ranks
pressure, intergovernmental institutions like the of intergovernmental groupings engaging in
World Bank, the IMF, and the AfDB, as well as country international development by adopting the Seoul
groupings like the EU and OECD, have consolidated Development Consensus on Shared Growth and
their central role in Africas development. Given their its Multi-Year Action Plan on Development. To
wealth of expertise and resources, and experience with avoid overlap or competition with the G8, the G20
some of the earliest success stories, they have become focus is on growth-related (rather than social or
crucial champions of partnerships for development,
humanitarian) aspects of Africas development,
adapting their strategies to reflect their growing
including infrastructure development, job creation
support. In February 2011, for example, the World Bank
and financial inclusion. While many of the proposed
launched its new, partnership-based Africa strategy,
to guide the Banks work in the region through 2016.138 initiatives and actions are encouraging, it remains to
At the 3rd EUAfrica Summit in Libya in November 2010, be seen whether the current French presidency can
the EU presented a Green Paper on Development enthuse more sceptical group members.
50
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
51
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
52
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
PART II
LOOKING AHEAD:
PARTNERING FOR
PROGRESS
The last year has shown that the state of progress
in Africa is almost as diverse as the continent
itself. While enormous challenges remain in
many sectors and countries, there are also
encouraging signs of progress. The next few
years will be critical as African countries attempt
to translate this progress into tangible results and
sustained transformation for their people ahead
of the 2015 MDG deadline. Given the proven but
heavily underutilized potential of partnerships for
development, the second part of our report is
dedicated to them.
53
A lthough the idea of partnership for development
is hardly new, it is currently experiencing a well
deserved renaissance as development needs
MAIN PARTNERSHIP
continue to multiply, governments increasingly
struggle to meet them, and a growing number of
exemplary partnerships are showing what is possible.
Attention is focused particularly on the potential of Main Public Sector
such partnerships to catalyse the energy, creativity Actors Africa
and resources of nongovernmental actors, such as National Governments and their Agencies
the private sector and civil society. African Union (AU) and its Programmes (including NEPAD)
African Development Bank (AfDB)
Despite the increasing attention, valuable lessons Regional Economic Communities (RECs)*
learned and successes in Africa and elsewhere, Arab-Maghreb Union (AMU)
East African Community (EAC)
we do not see nearly enough of these successes Economic Community of Central
replicated or brought to scale across the continent. African States (ECCAS)
We do not see effective partnerships in nearly Economic Community of West African
enough sectors. Consequently, many opportunities States (ECOWAS)
to tackle problems and drive development are Common Market for Eastern and
Southern Africa (COMESA)
being missed. So, what can we do to realize more of Intergovernmental Authority on
the potential of partnerships for development, and Development (IGAD)
spur more collaboration for progress? Southern African Development
Community (SADC)
54
MODELS and actors
Partnerships between:
African Governments
African International Organizations (e.g. AU) and Global International Organizations (e.g. UN)
African Governments, African Companies and African International Organizations (e.g. AU)
African Governments, African Companies and Global International Organizations (e.g. UNDP)
African International Organizations (e.g. AU), Global International Organizations (e.g. World Bank),
and Developed Country Companies
African CSOs
partnerships
African CSOs and Developed Country CSOs and Developed Country Companies
LEGEND
ACTOR REGIONAL SCOPE
55
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
their capacities, expertise, resources, networks and development efforts of African governments and
comparative advantages in a way that adds value international donors, and bridge important gaps in
for each of them, and they allow them to engage a results-oriented (because profit-driven) manner.
in areas and issues in which they would or could not
engage on their own. Together with philanthropic organizations, businesses
have become the newest and arguably some of the
Many of the examples underline the central role most important allies of traditional development actors.
of the private sector.148 They prove that businesses Engaging them in partnerships has added much-
have much to contribute to development efforts, needed capacity, expertise and resources as well as
and that, with the right incentives, information and versatility, creativity and pragmatism to development
enabling framework, they can deliver clear winwin efforts across the continent and has created manifold
outcomes for themselves and wider society. They also opportunities to accelerate progress.
show that, built around commercial viability, private-
sector approaches to development challenges are At the same time, partnerships for development
often scalable. are not without their risks and potential pitfalls. If not
coordinated with existing initiatives and closely aligned
Many businesses now consider engaging in to national development frameworks, partnerships
development as more than an issue of corporate can complicate, dilute and even undermine other
social responsibility or philanthropy. Increasingly, development efforts. They can also lead to harmful
they regard development activities as essential competition for resources and unnecessary duplication
to their core business and a promising avenue of effort. Partnerships often have high transaction costs,
towards growth, greater market share, increased and complex decision-making processes can further
efficiencies and lower risks and costs.149 This burden already overstretched governments and
convergence between business interests cause problems of accountability and ownership. In
and development objectives is changing the combination with the tendency of many partnerships
traditional one-dimensional model of government- to develop in isolation, these well-known problems
led development.150 As businesses realize the make it imperative to integrate partnerships closely
commercial opportunities and benefits involved, into broader development strategies driven by African
they are increasingly willing to complement the governments.
56
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
Sources: International Finance Corporation (2010), Inclusive Business 2010: Telling Our Story: Base of the Pyramid Investments; Business Action for Africa et al. (2010), Accelerating Progress
towards the Millennium Development Goals through Inclusive Business: Delivering Results: Moving to Scale.
57
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
Efficient and affordable public services are central to the rural economies that are so central to poverty
human development and economic activity. There reduction still lack sufficient access to finance.
is also increasing demand for services, especially in There is thus great scope to expand proven business
fast-growing urban areas. Therefore, there is great models such as micro-finance, micro-insurance,152
scope for replicating proven and commercially m-commerce, linkage and community banking,
viable delivery models across places and sectors, remote distribution, and payroll-based lending.153
and for nurturing micro-economies of agglomeration
around these models.151
Access to Health
Access to Opportunities
L ack of access to healthcare facilities, medical
practitioners and medicine is one of the biggest
P artnerships have contributed significantly to
poverty reduction and social development
across Africa by extending opportunities to
and most fundamental challenges for Africas
poor and the continents development. It reduces
productivity, places enormous costs on society,
previously marginalized populations. They have
and prevents progress on every MDG. More
contracted smallholder farmers to produce
than in any other area, partnerships in the health
sorghum for beer-making and helped women to
sector have proven their potential to complement
establish local distribution businesses for soft drinks.
and expand on the efforts of the public sector.
Particularly partnerships built around the power
Successes include raising awareness, developing
of modern telecommunication technology have
and distributing vaccines and treatments, reducing
created valuable new platforms for development,
costs, and increasing information on the availability
including through the low-cost provision of banking
of treatments. There remains great scope to expand
and other enabling services previously inaccessible
partnerships further to strengthen health systems,
to most Africans. Partnerships have also increased
increase the number of skilled healthcare personnel,
opportunities by creating or strengthening markets,
and leverage the market size for investments in
integrating local populations into value chains,
research and development. There is also a need
reducing numbers of intermediaries, and promoting
to identify the reasons for the enormous success of
skills formation. There is great scope to stimulate
healthcare partnerships and replicate them across
further economic growth, employment and human
other sectors.
development by spreading access to affordable
connectivity, applications and services, as well as
economic opportunities, to more of Africas people,
particularly women. Infrastructure
58
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
The Equity Bank model Equity Bank The clearest proof that an exceptionally profitable business can
be built by providing appropriate and affordable banking services
dedicated to economically active low-income consumers in Africa.
Leasing for small Burkina Bail Small-business demand for alternative forms of finance, including
businesses leasing, remains high.
Overdraft finance and Equity Bank, Unsecured overdrafts for small businesses are a fraught proposition
cash-flow smoothing Mbinga, for conservatively inclined banks but Mbingas kifuku product
for small businesses Stanbic shows it can be done. Equitys biashara imara product and Stanbic
Uganda Ugandas warehouse-receipts product are both serious attempts
to address business cash-flow fluctuations with alternative forms of
collateral.
SME lending Banque Misr Banque Misr proves it is possible to lend money profitably to very
small businesses. Other organizations such as Access Holding and
ProCredit, both active in Africa, also demonstrate that it is possible
to replicate a standardized approach to small-business lending in
different jurisdictions.
Bundling insurance MLife, If consumers start to experience the benefits of insurance by
through small loans MicroEnsure seeing it pay off a microloan or compensate a farmer for weather-
damaged crops, this will reinforce perceptions of its value among
poorer consumers. Working through the continents burgeoning
commercial micro-lenders could be a significant growth opportunity
for insurers.
Paying social Absa-David Subsidizing banks to open basic bank accounts into which social
payments through payments, such as an old-age grant, can be paid extends access
bank accounts while also providing beneficiaries with safe and cost-free means of
receiving money.
The Mini ATM FNB As these devices are mobile-enabled, no landlines are required. The
small size of the terminals means they can be housed in very small
retail outlets and the retailer, not the bank, dispenses the cash.
Mobile payments M-banking The demographics of mobile-phone use, the early success of
M-Pesa and other models, and the continuing flux around evolving
business models all mean that this continues to be a space that will
repay careful monitoring. Although the operational complexities
and required investment are significant, the potential for large-scale
success is clear.
Source: Mark Napier, ed. (2010), Real Money, New Frontiers: Case Studies of Financial Innovation in Africa.
59
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
scaling up financing and operating models that have growing global demand for food and other
worked. Also, current partnerships are concentrated agricultural products. There is particularly great
in a small number of African countries (such as South scope for partnerships to strengthen agricultural
Africa and Nigeria) and sectors (such as energy and value chains and improve access to rural credit,
telecommunications), leaving significant scope for including weather-indexed crop insurance, and
both functional and geographical expansion. to productive inputs and markets.
60
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
T raditional suspicions remain one of the most imaginative solutions knowing the dots is one thing,
basic obstacles to new or larger partnerships. connecting them is another.
Many governments and non-governmental
organizations continue to mistrust the private-
sector profit motive. They continue to view it The Resources and Capacity Gap
mainly as a cause of social, environmental and
economic problems, rather than as part of a
potential solution. There is widespread suspicion E ven though new financing methods including
hybrid financing that uses a mixture of debt,
equity and other financial instruments, are constantly
that many companies engage in partnerships
merely for reputation management, and that being developed, there continues to be a notable
the benefits are offset by companies harmful lack of resources to plan, implement and operate
behaviour in other areas. Many also fear partnerships for development. Given shareholder
increased corruption and reduced control as pressure for short-term profits, many international
a result of companies growing engagement companies are reluctant to devote the necessary
in delivery of public goods and services. resources and capacities to partnerships with distant
Companies, on the other hand, often mistrust the prospects of value creation. Many African actors,
reliability of government commitments, and may particularly in civil society and non-governmental
view attempts to address social weaknesses as organizations, simply do not have resources for up-
coming at their expense. This trust gap is caused front investments or capacities to staff and operate
and compounded by transparency deficits, and scaled-up partnerships. Here, national governments,
the resultant lack of information and clarity about international donors and multilateral development
what each partner wants from the relationship. banks can play a particularly constructive role
61
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
by providing catalytic investments to meet initial built around inclusive business models. By contrast,
financing needs for scaling up or replication. large and populous countries like Nigeria or
South Africa can offer economies of scale, large
numbers of potential consumers and consolidated
The Perceived Benefits Gap markets. This highlights the enormous potential
for regional integration to increase perceived
B usinesses are primarily interested in partnerships benefits through market expansion. Another
with potential to generate benefits such as obstacle to replication concerns the perceived
future resource streams. Therefore, low ceilings benefits of intellectual property and trademarks.
to perceived benefits, or insufficient scale, may A partnership around an entrepreneur with a
prevent private-sector companies from engaging good idea may resist the replication of that
in a particular partnership. This may explain why idea by others, especially if the replication is
small economies like Niger or Mali have difficulty perceived to deny business opportunities to the
in attracting publicprivate partnerships or those original entrepreneur.
62
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
WHO NEEDS
TO DO WHAT
The conditions needed to foster successful
partnerships and adapt them to other regions,
countries, and sectors are not a mystery. They
include: a viable growth strategy based on
realistic assessments of demand, receptivity, risks
and absorptive capacity; a clear delineation
of respective responsibilities and commitments;
sufficient resources, capacity and expertise; full
transparency; harmonized expectations and
a common vision among partners; and the
fulfillment of commitments. Naturally, the precise
ingredients vary from case to case and are
always firmly grounded in the local context, which
reduces the usefulness of general prescriptions
and recommendations. However, it is clear that
all actors can do more to remove blockages,
facilitate the spread of successful partnership
models across the continent, and increase their
developmental impact.
63
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
African Governments
A frican governments bear the main responsibility for the continents progress. While they depend on
supportive global policies and agreements, it is up to them to provide the plans, frameworks and
conditions for their countries development and the realization of their peoples potential. Similarly, when it
comes to fostering partnerships and maximizing their developmental impact, it is up to African governments
to create the necessary conditions and incentive structures. They can do much to improve the attractiveness,
scalability and sustainability of partnerships, and to contribute constructively at all stages.
international donors
I nternational donors have made a series of commitments to Africa, which they need to keep. They share
responsibility for Africas progress, particularly when it comes to ensuring a level playing field, correcting
harmful global realities, particularly with respect to trade, climate change, the international financial
system and achieving the MDGs. Given their resources, expertise, networks and influence there is much
that international donors can contribute to initiating and supporting partnerships for development.
64
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
Private-Sector Actors
T he private sector is increasingly important in Africas development. However, there are still too many
companies not adhering to fundamental principles of corporate responsibility, such as those articulated
in the UN Global Compact. While private-sector actors should at least do no harm, there is enormous
scope for businesses to add social, economic and environmental value. They can do so by modifying their
business models to target the poor or integrate local communities and producers into their value chains, but
also through cross-sectoral partnerships around specific development challenges. As providers of resources,
innovation and expertise, private-sector actors often hold the key to the success of such partnerships.
Civil-Society Actors
C ivil-society actors, including non-governmental civic and social organizations, citizen groups, trade
unions, the media and faith-based organizations, play a crucial function in the system of accountability
that underlies the success of all partnerships. Given the identified problems caused by lack of information
and misperception of benefits and risks, there is also great scope for them to mediate and broker partnerships
for development as well as draw attention to opportunities and need for such partnerships.
65
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
CONCLUSION
66
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
The success of partnerships depends on clear Crucially, partnerships also do not shift the responsibility
delineation of respective roles, the availability for progress away from the shoulders of African leaders
of reliable information and, above all, the right and international donors, even though they can help
incentives. For the private sector, profit-seeking is at the to spread the burden. Donors still need to fulfill the
heart of the incentive structure, but brand validation extensive financial and political commitments they
and corporate responsibility also matter. National have made to the African continent and it remains
governments want access to networks, expertise and up to African leaders to inspire processes and build
resources. Civil-society organisations want to see their practical capacities to translate the continents
specific issues addressed, and donors want to offset wealth and potential into tangible results for its
demands and increase the impact of their activities. citizens. It also remains up to them to protect these
Fortunately, understanding and acceptance of citizens from the vagaries of nature and the volatilities
these different motivations is growing among the of the global economy, provide them with adequate
various actors. Together with the convergence of public services and afford them the opportunities to
development objectives and business interests, rising feed and educate their children and make a decent
pressures on international aid, as well as ample proof living. For this they need to meet the interlinked
that partnerships can mature into self-sustaining and challenges of growing their economies, conserving
profit-making ventures with transformative effects this their environments, and achieving the MDG-based
makes collaboration an increasingly attractive option targets they set themselves a decade ago.
for all sides.
This is possible. We have seen renewed proof that
However, in spite of the enormous value they can rapid progress is achievable even in the most
add, partnerships for development are certainly not resource-deprived and insecure circumstances. We
a panacea for all of Africas problems. Even brought have seen that good governance, transparency
to scale, there are many challenges they cannot and accountability bring results, and that economic
solve. As governments try to harness capacities and growth can drive development if it leads to job
resources that are additional and complementary creation, structural transformation and the spread
to their own, partnerships for development are only of opportunities. And we have undoubtedly seen
one instrument in their arsenal albeit an increasingly that partnerships for development can help to fill
powerful one. They do not replace good governance, gaps, expand efforts and accelerate progress. We
strong institutions and political leadership as the core therefore end by calling on African leaders and their
ingredients of progress. On the contrary, partnerships partners across regions and sectors to intensify their
depend on them to be able to fulfill their potential. collaboration for the continents progress.
67
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
list of ACRoNYMS
AAP Africa Action Plan HIPC Highly Indebted Poor Countries (Initiative/
AEC African Economic Community Programme)
AEO African Economic Outlook IATI International Aid Transparency Initiative
AfDB African Development Bank ICA Infrastructure Consortium for Africa
AFMI African Financial Market Initiative ICC International Criminal Court
AGF Africa Green Fund ICT Information and Communication
AGOA African Growth and Opportunity Act Technology
AGRA Alliance for a Green Revolution in Africa IFAD International Fund for Agricultural
AICD African Infrastructure Country Diagnostic Development
AMCEN African Ministerial Conference on the IFFIm International Finance Facility for
Environment Immunization
AMCOW African Ministers Council on Water IFI International Financial Institution
AMFm Affordable Medicines Facility Malaria IFPRI International Food Policy Research Institute
APDev African Platform for Development IGAD Intergovernmental Authority on
Effectiveness Development
APOC African Programme for Onchocerciasis IHP International Health Partnership
Control IIED International Institute for Environment and
APRM African Peer Review Mechanism Development
APSA African Peace and Security Architecture ILO International Labour Office
ASEAN Association of South East Asian Nations IMF International Monetary Fund
ASF African Standby Force IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
AU African Union Change
AUC African Union Commission ITUC International Trade Union Confederation
AWF African Water Facility LDC Least Developed Country
C10 Committee of Ten MCC Millennium Challenge Corporation
CAADP Comprehensive African Agriculture MDG Millennium Development Goal
Development Programme MDRI Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative
CAHOSCC Conference of African Heads of State and MIP Minimum Integration Programme
Government on Climate Change MPI Multidimensional Poverty Index
CARMMA Campaign on Accelerated Reduction of NAFTA North American Free Trade Agreement
Maternal Mortality in Africa NEPAD New Partnership for Africas Development
CDI Commitment to Development Index OAU Organization of African Unity
CDM Clean Development Mechanism ODA Official Development Assistance
CEWS Continental Early Warning System OECD Organization for Economic Cooperation
COMESA Common Market for Eastern and Southern and Development
Africa PCD Policy Coherence for Development
CSR Corporate Social Responsibility PEFA Public Expenditure and Financial
DAC Development Assistance Committee Accountability (Partnership)
EAC East African Community PIDA Programme for Infrastructure Development
ECCAS Economic Community of Central African in Africa
States PSC Peace and Security Council
ECOWAS Economic Community of West African PSD Private Sector Development
States PPP PublicPrivate Partnership
EDF European Development Fund REC Regional Economic Community
EFA Education for All REDD Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and
EPA Economic Partnership Agreement Forest Degradation
EU European Union SADC Southern Africa Development Community
FAAP Framework for African Agricultural SDR Special Drawing Rights
Productivity SME Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise
FAO Food and Agricultural Organization UNCTAD UN Conference on Trade and Development
FARA Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa UNEP UN Environment Programme
FOCAC Forum on ChinaAfrica Cooperation UNESCO UN Educational, Scientific, and Cultural
FSB Financial Stability Board Organization
FTI Fast Track Initiative UNFPA UN Population Fund
FTT Financial Transaction Tax UNICEF UN International Childrens Emergency
GAFSP Global Agriculture and Food Security Fund
Program UNIFEM UN Development Fund for Women
GAVI Global Alliance for Vaccination and WBCSD World Business Council for Sustainable
Immunization Development
GEF Global Environment Facility WEF World Economic Forum
GDP Gross Domestic Product WDR World Development Report
GNI Gross National Income WHO World Health Organization
HDI Human Development Index WTO World Trade Organization
68
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
notes
All data used in this report are drawn from official and readily available sources, which are referenced below.
Every effort has been made to cite the most recent figures, even though occasionally preference has been
given to older but more reliable data. As with every report, the reader should be aware of the inherent limitations
of the available data and projections as well as the considerable controversies around the prevailing methods
of measuring progress. To the best of our knowledge, the information and data presented in this report was
accurate and the most up to date available as of 20 April 2011.
Quoted averages may mask significant differences between individual countries and within regions. As far as
possible, all amounts are adjusted for purchasing-power parity. Unless stated otherwise, amounts are quoted in
United States Dollars.
Readers are encouraged to quote and reproduce material from this report for educational, not-for-profit
purposes providing that they acknowledge the Africa Progress Report 2011 as the source.
69
AFRICA PROGRESS REPORT 2011
70
The Transformative Power of Partnerships
97 WaterAid (2011)
98 UN (2010), The Millennium Development Goals Report 2010
99 UN (2010), The Millennium Development Goals Report 2010
100 WHO and UNICEF (2010), Joint Monitoring Report 2010: Progress on Sanitation and Drinking Water
101 UNECA (2010), Equal Access to Basic Services in African LDCs: The Need for Coherent, Inclusive and Coherent Policy Frameworks
102 WHO and UN Habitat (2010), Hidden Cities: Unmasking and Overcoming Health Inequities in Urban Settings
103 AICD (2010), Annual Report
104 AfDB (2010), Financing Investments in Water for Growth
105 AfDB (2010), Water Sector Governance in Africa
106 UNDG (2010), MDG Good Practices Report 2010
107 The Global Compact (2010), The CEO Water Mandate Guide to Responsible Business Engagement with Water Policy
108 International Food Policy Research Institute (2010), Global Hunger Index 2010
109 AfDB, AU, UNECA and UNDP (2010), Assessing Progress in Africa toward the Millennium Development Goals: MDG Report 2010; FAO
(2010), The State of Food Insecurity in the World: Addressing Food Insecurity in Protracted Crises
110 The Economist (2011), The Future of Food: What is Causing Food Prices to Soar and What Can Be Done about It?
111 World Bank (2011), Food Price Watch
112 World Bank (2011), Food Price Watch
113 UK Government Office of Science (2011), The Future of Food and Farming: Challenges and Choices for Global Sustainability
114 IIED (2011), Land Deals in Africa: What is in the Contracts?
115 WMO (2010), 2010 Equals Record for Worlds Warmest Year, Press Release 96/2010
116 FAO (2011), The State of the Worlds Forests 2011
117 The Economist (2011), Climate Change and Crop Yields: One Degree Over; see also UNDP (2011), Fast Facts: Climate Change and UNDP
118 UNEP (2010), Environmental Consequences of Ocean Acidification: A Threat to Food Security
119 DARA (2010), Climate Vulnerability Monitor 2010: The State of the Climate Crisis; David Wheeler (2011), Quantifying Vulnerability to
Climate Change: Implications for Adaptation Assistance, Center for Global Development Working Paper 240
120 Maplecroft (2010), Climate Change Vulnerability Index 2010
121 UNEP (2010), AMCEN Gets New Tool for Communicating Climate Change and Promoting an Effective Response in Africa
122 WRI (2011), Summary of Developed Country Fast-Start Climate Finance Pledges
123 The Secretary-Generals High-Level Advisory Group on Climate Change Financing (2010), Final Report
124 Development Initiatives (2011), Monitoring Climate Financing Architecture
125 WEF (2011), Scaling Up Low-Carbon Infrastructure Investments in Developing Countries, The Critical Mass Initiative Working Report 2011
126 World Bank (2009), Making Development Climate Resilient: A World Bank Strategy for Sub-Saharan Africa
127 UNEP (2011), Green Economy Report
128 OECD (2011), Statextracts
129 OECD (2011), Statextracts
130 AEO (2010), African Economic Outlook 2010: Public Resource Mobilization and Aid
131 CGD (2010), Commitment to Development Index 2010
132 OECD DAC (2011), ODA Figures as Released on 6 April 2011
133 ONE (2011), ONE/DATA Report 2011 (based on the figures released by the OECD DAC on 6 April 2011)
134 OECD DAC (2011), Development Aid Reaches an Historic High in 2010, Press Release
135 OECD DAC (2011), ODA Figures as Released on 6 April 2011
136 OECD (2010), The OECD Fragmentation Index 2010
137 UN Office of the Special Advisor on Africa (2010), Africas Cooperation with New and Emerging Development Partners: Options
for Africas Development
138 World Bank (2011), Africas Future and the World Banks Support to It
139 EU (2010), EU Development Policy in Support of Inclusive Growth and Sustainable Development, Green Paper
140 Hudson Institute (2010), 2010 Index of Philanthropy and Remittances
141 UN Office of the Special Advisor on Africa (2010), External Debt in Africa, Policy Brief 3
142 IMF and IDA (2010), Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative and Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI) Status of
Implementation
143 IMF and World Bank (2010), Preserving Debt Sustainability in Low-Income Countries in the Wake of the Global Crisis
144 OECD (2010), Indicators for Progress on the Implementation of the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness
145 AfDB, AU and NEPAD (2010), Issue Paper on Ownership, Sustainability and Accountability for Results, 2nd Regional Meeting on Aid
Effectiveness, Tunis, 4-5 November 2010
146 Development Initiatives (2009), The Costs and Benefits of Aid Transparency
147 OECD (2011), The Role of the Private Sector in the Context of Aid Effectiveness: Consultative Findings Document Final Report
148 See, for example, IFC (2010), Inclusive Business 2010 Telling Our Story: Base of the Pyramid Investments; APP and Concern Universal
(2010), Doing Good Business in Africa: How Business Can Support Development; WBCSD (2010), Doing Business with the World: The New
Role of Corporate Leadership in Global Development; UN Global Compact et al (2010), Innovating for a Brighter Future: The Role of
Business in Achieving the MDGs
149 Business Action for Africa et al (2010), Accelerating Progress Towards the Millennium Development Goals Through Inclusive Business:
Delivering Results: Moving to Scale
150 Accenture Development Partnerships (2011), Cross-Sector Convergence: A New View of Global Development; see also Michael
Porter and Mark Kramer (2011), The Big Idea: Creating Shared Value, Harvard Business Review
151 World Bank Institute (2009), A Way to Effective Service Delivery in Fragile States: Public-Private Partnerships
152 See Allianz Group (2011), Learning to Insure the Poor: Micro-Insurance Report; Swiss Re (2011), Micro-Insurance: Risk Protection for
4 Billion People
153 See Mark Napier, ed. (2010), Real Money, New Frontiers: Case Studies of Financial Innovation in Africa
154 UN-HABITAT (2011), Infrastructure for Economic Development and Poverty Reduction in Africa
155 AICDS (2009), Africas Infrastructure: A Time for Transformation
156 WBCSD (2007), Investing in a Low-Carbon Future in the Developing World
157 WBCSD (2005), Business for Development: Business Solutions in Support of the Millennium Development Goals
71
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Africa Progress Panel would like to acknowledge the valuable contributions of Gill Bates (SIPRI), Christoph
Benn (The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria), Timothy Brewer (WaterAid), Audette Bruce
(UNDP), Daniel Coppard (Development Initiatives), Wouter Deelder (Dalberg), Dustin Dehez (Freie Universitt
Berlin), Shanta Devarajan (World Bank), Nicolas Douillet (UNDP), Hania Farhan (Mo Ibrahim Foundation), Ricardo
Fuentes (UNDP), Cosmas Gitta (UNDP), Richard Gowan (NYU Center on International Cooperation), Alan Hinman
(The Taskforce for Global Health), Aubrey Hruby (The Whitaker Group), Andreas Hbers (ONE), Michael Keating
(UN), Michel Lavollay (PublicPrivate Partnerships Europe), Franklyn Lisk (Warwick University), Carlos Lopes
(UNITAR), Aileen Marshall (World Bank), Jason McGeown (Maplecroft), Jonas Moberg (EITI), Benito Mller (Oxford
University), Kate Norgrove (WaterAid International), Warren Nyamugasira (African Monitor), Paatii Ofosu-Amaah
(AfDB), Patrick Osakwe (UNCTAD), Judith Randel (Development Initiatives), Alistair Rivers (Innovata LLC), Zahid
Torres-Rahman (Business Action for Africa), Elisabeth Sandor (OECD), Guido Schmidt-Traub (CDC Climat AM),
Lindiwe Sibanda (FANRPAN), Elisabeth Skns (SIPRI), Tesfai Tecle (AGRA), Filippo Veglio (World Business Council
for Sustainable Development), Alyson Warhurst (Maplecroft), and Sharon Wiharta (SIPRI).
The APP would also like to acknowledge the generous support from the United Kingdoms Department for
International Development, the French Government and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
Cover design, infograhics, overall design and layout: Violaine Beix, Thad Mermer, Carolina Rodriguez and
Blossom Communications. Copy-edited by Nina Behrman.
PANEL MEMBERS
info@africaprogresspanel.org
www.africaprogresspanel.org