CONFIDENTIAL

SPA 637 Fall 2015

INDIVIDUAL EFFORT RATING FOR GROUP MEMBERS
Adapted from Felder (1997)
Please read this entire form and then add your answers below.

Your Name__Melissa Campbell____________________________

1. Describe how the group prepared the guide and presentation. How was the work equally
distributed?
Carley prepared the outline of the project and shared it with us to review. We were able to communicate our
ideas and made some changes before Carley turned it in. We decided to split the work by days. We each had
3 days to prepare and then we shared the work with Carley who formatted and organized the project before
turning it in.

2. Please write the names of all of your group members below, INCLUDING YOURSELF, and rate the degree to
which each member fulfilled his/her responsibilities in completing the project as determined by the expectations
developed by the group. Sign your name at the bottom. Please be honest with your assessment. Justify the grade
that you give with comments. What was the level and nature of the students contributions? If you divided up the work,
what part of the work did the group member do? No comments to back up your grade will result in a 10% decrease
in your grade (you gave yourself) and a 10% increase in the grade you gave your group members. The possible ratings
are as follows; use a numerical grade, not a range:

Excellent Consistently went above and beyond, routinely went above

(90 100) and beyond the basic group responsibilities
Very good Consistently did what he/she was supposed to do, very well prepared
(80 89) and cooperative
Satisfactory Usually did what he/she was supposed to do, acceptably prepared and
(75 79) cooperative
Ordinary Often did what he/she was supposed to do, minimally prepared and
(70 74) cooperative
Marginal Sometimes failed to show up or complete assignments, rarely
(60 69) prepared
Deficient Often failed to show up or complete assignments, rarely prepared
(50 59)
Unsatisfactory Consistently failed to show up or complete assignments, unprepared
(40 49)
Superficial Practically no participation
(0 39)

These ratings should reflect each individual's level of participation and effort and sense of responsibility, not his or her
academic ability.

Name of group member Numerical Grade Comments

YOU ___75_____ My mom passed away the day

after we divided the work. Over the next few days, I was able to complete 2/3 of the work I was
assigned and thankfully Carley and Michelle stepped up and helped finish the rest. Neither of
them hesitated to help me out and I will be forever grateful for that.

_Carley_________________________ ___100_____ Carley went above and beyond

what she needed to do. She took charge of the project from the beginning and did the final
formatting and editing for us. She also finished the last part of my work that I was unable to do.

_Michelle_________________________ ___95_____ Michelle did everything that

was asked of her and didnt hesitate to take on extra work when I couldnt finish my part.
Michelle was proactive in our discussions and she was the first to submit ideas for the project.
Ultimately, it was Carley that finished my work but I know Michelle wouldve done it as well.

__________________________ ________

Your signature: ___Melissa Campbell_____________________________