Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
VERITAS
Virtual and Augmented Environments and Realistic User Interactions To
achieve Embedded Accessibility DesignS
247765
Status: F (Final)
Table of Contents
Version History table ............................................................................................... 3
Table of Contents ..................................................................................................... 4
List of Figures .......................................................................................................... 6
List of Tables ............................................................................................................ 6
Abbreviations list ..................................................................................................... 7
Executive Summary ................................................................................................. 8
1 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 9
2 Core message to convey ................................................................................ 10
3 Multi-layer dissemination ............................................................................... 11
4 Dissemination material ................................................................................... 12
4.1 Press release ........................................................................................ 12
4.2 Leaflet ................................................................................................... 13
4.3 Poster ................................................................................................... 13
4.4 Banner .................................................................................................. 13
4.5 Additional material ................................................................................ 13
4.5.1 Conference and workshop usage .................................................................................. 13
4.6 Website ................................................................................................. 14
4.6.1 RSS feeds...................................................................................................................... 16
4.6.2 Online presence ............................................................................................................ 17
4.6.3 Website statistics ........................................................................................................... 19
4.7 VUMS (Virtual User Modelling and Simulation) cluster website ............ 22
4.8 Twitter pages ........................................................................................ 22
4.8.1 VERITAS Twitter page .................................................................................................. 22
4.8.2 VUMS Twitter page ....................................................................................................... 23
4.9 YouTube channel .................................................................................. 23
4.10 Newsletter ............................................................................................. 23
4.11 Mailinglists ............................................................................................ 24
4.12 VERITAS video ..................................................................................... 24
4.13 Planned activities .................................................................................. 27
4.13.1 VUMS (Virtual User Modelling and Simulation) cluster meetings ................................. 27
4.13.2 Future activities ............................................................................................................. 27
4.14 A green dissemination approach .......................................................... 27
5 Participation in events and conferences ...................................................... 28
5.1 Events calendar .................................................................................... 28
5.2 VERITAS User Forums ......................................................................... 28
5.3 VERITAS Workshops............................................................................ 29
5.4 VERITAS Scientific Advisory Board (SAB) ........................................... 30
5.5 VERITAS Conferences ......................................................................... 32
5.6 Dissemination activities ......................................................................... 32
5.6.1 Conferences/Workshops/Event participation ................................................................ 33
5.6.2 Papers ........................................................................................................................... 37
5.6.3 Journals ......................................................................................................................... 47
List of Figures
Figure 1: Press releases page on VERITAS website to announce various events .. 12
Figure 2: VERITAS dissemination material for 2nd VERITAS User forum and
Workshop .......................................................................................................... 14
Figure 3: VERITAS website opening page - http://veritas-project.eu ....................... 16
Figure 4: VERITAS Twitter page - http://twitter.com/VeritasProj/ ............................. 17
Figure 5: Google search on VERITAS (1) ................................................................ 18
Figure 6: Google search on VERITAS (2) ................................................................ 19
Figure 7: Unique web visits veritas-project.eu .......................................................... 20
Figure 8: View over the origins of the website visitors (the darker the green the more
visitors from that region) .................................................................................... 21
Figure 9: Screenshot of VUMS website - http://www.vums-cluster.eu/ .................... 22
Figure 10: VERITAS videos on AccessForAll.eu YouTube channel ......................... 23
Figure 11: Dr. Manfred Dangelmaier, VERITAS cordinator - Fraunhofer IAO ........ 25
Figure 12: Mariolino De Cecco, Ph.D, Associate Professor - University of Trento ... 25
Figure 13: Ilenia Gheno AGE Platform Europe ..................................................... 26
Figure 14: Roberto Orselli Smartex ........................................................................ 26
Figure 15: VERITAS events calendars website screenshot .................................. 28
Figure 16: Participants to the 2nd user forum ............................................................ 29
List of Tables
Table 1: Top 10 countries of origins of website visits ............................................... 20
Table 2: Realised and Planned participations at conferences, workshops, etc. ....... 33
Table 3: VERITAS papers and publications overview .............................................. 37
Table 4: List of journal publications (including also the planned ones) ..................... 47
Table 5: VERITAS Dissemination success criteria ................................................... 50
Table 6: Overall dissemination assessment ............................................................. 51
Table 7: Website specific awareness evaluation ...................................................... 53
Abbreviations list
Abbreviation Explanation
D Deliverable
DoW Description of Work
SAB Scientific Advisory Board
VUMS Virtual User Modelling and Simulation (Cluster)
Executive Summary
The Deliverable at hand describes the updated Dissemination strategy as was outlined by
the VERITAS project in D4.3.1a and D4.3.1b, as well as takes onboard the comments that
were made at the 2011 review:
To elaborate and include in the D4.3.1.3 deliverable (due at month 23 of the project) a clear
dissemination strategy, which includes: (1) a coherent plan, describing events, conferences,
and other media which will be used for raising awareness on the project results; (ii) a clear
set of measurable indicators and related targets against which to measure the effectiveness
of the project dissemination activity
o The list of events was further detailed, indicating their impact on the selected
target groups, while also indicating whether they were key events or not, and
the potential added value (technological, social, methodological issues).
o For the papers, a similar approach was followed, with in addition an indication
on the innovation that was delivered by each paper, as well as the potential
added value (technological, social, methodological issues).
We also look deeper into the events that were organised by the project (VERITAS 2nd
Workshop at JVRC 2011) and events that have been planned (VUMS workshop and VUMS
Special thematic Session, both organised by the EU-funded projects VICON, VERITAS,
GUIDE and MyUI at the 13th International Conference on Computers Helping People with
Special Needs).
The Deliverable also provides an updated overview of planned meetings, conferences and
other events that will be attended. These also include the VUMS (Virtual User Modelling and
Simulation) cluster (GUIDE, MyUI, VERITAS, VICON projects) meetings.
An update of this Deliverable will again be made available in Month 35, and will then also
include an updated status of the submitted papers and attended/organised events.
Introduction
Chapter 1 repeats the key message of the project, with emphasis on the application areas
VERITAS is targeting, as well as the end-user groups (developers/designers, and people
with disabilities and older people).
The next Chapter 2 addresses the multi-layer dissemination approach the project applies,
but since it has already been fully detailed in D4.3.1a, it has not been repeated in this
updated deliverable.
The projects updated dissemination material is presented in Chapter 3, and addresses the
new press release, the additional dissemination material that has been produced in the
context of conferences and workshops (pins, pens, bags, roll-up banner, lanyards, etc.). This
Chapter also presents in detail the online presence of the project and includes the web
statistics which are positive. Also the updates on the VUMS website are addressed, and the
respective Web 2.0 outcomes (Twitter page). The video as has been created is also
introduced.
Chapter 4 addresses the updated data on participation in events and conferences, and
focuses on the 2nd Pan-European User Forum and Workshop, and the SAB meeting that
took place. This reporting is now enhanced with the usage of indicators whether the reported
events were key events or not, quantifying also the potential added value (technological,
social, methodological issues). Finally, the events are presented where the project
disseminated, either via papers, presentations or posters, with in addition an indication on
the innovation that was delivered by the papers, and here as well the potential added value.
Chapter 5 deals with the dissemination evaluation for the 2nd year of the project (2011), and
now also contains a detailed range of indicators against which the dissemination efforts will
be assessed and evaluated by the partnership. This set of indicators is based on good
practice in the AEGIS project, and uses the indicator approach as published on
http://www.evalutech.sreb.org/criteria/web.asp (as checked on September 2010).
Chapter 6 focuses on the next steps; and more precisely on the forthcoming evenst thatw ill
take place at ICCHP 2012, and the paper submission to conferences and their potential
acceptance.
VERITAS aims to develop, validate and assess tools for built-in accessibility support at
all stages of ICT and non-ICT product development, including specification, design,
development and testing. The goal is to introduce simulation based and virtual reality
testing at all stages of assistive technologies product design and development into the
automotive, smart living spaces (buildings & construction, domotics), workplace, e-
health and infotainment applications areas. The goal is to ensure that future products
and services are being systematically designed for all people including those with
disabilities and functional limitations as well as older people. Furthermore, VERITAS
plans to promote its results to the appropriate standards organisations for consideration
and potential adoption and also to make them available through an open framework.
This core message on the one hand needs to inform the end-users (developers and
designers) on the expected tools VERITAS will deliver, while also inform the beneficiaries
(people with disabilities and the older people) on the advantages they will experience from a
design for all approach, accommodating also their specific needs in the design of products in
any of the five application areas.
2 Multi-layer dissemination
The multi-layer dissemination approach as outlined in D4.3.1a is applied throughout the
project. Because it has already been fully detailed in D4.3.1a, it has not been repeated in
this updated deliverable.
3 Dissemination material
3.1 Press release
Several press releases were published to announce the 2nd Pan-European VERITAS
Workshop and User Forum in Nottingham, United Kingdom on 20-21 September 2011 in the
context of the 2011 Joint Virtual Reality Conference. It was disseminated both via
mailinglists as well as via the project website (http://veritas-project.eu/category/press-
releases/).
Apart from dedicated mailings, announcements were also made on several websites and
fora:
3.2 Leaflet
The leaflet has already been fully described in D4.3.1a and has been and will be used till an
updated version will be created that focuses on the first prototypes.
3.3 Poster
The 2 different posters (a technical and less technical one) have been used throughout the
project so far for evens participation, etc.
3.4 Banner
For the User Forum and Workshop, the previously produced roll-up banners were used
again, and were installed at the entrance of the meeting rooms. These will continue to be re-
used for future events.
USB stick
o Leaflets
o Posters
o Newsletter (1, 2, 3)
o Public Deliverables
VERITAS leaflet
VERITAS lanyard
VERITAS pin
VERITAS notepad
VERITAS pen
Figure 2: VERITAS dissemination material for 2nd VERITAS User forum and Workshop
3.6 Website
The VERITAS website www-veritas-project.eu has been continuously updated (see
screenshots below) and was also used to launch simulation videos on the different
application domains.
In these 2 videos, two different desk prototypes were evaluated: one having its drawers above the desk and one
having them below. Two virtual user models were tested: normal user and user having rheumatoid arthritis on his
left arm. The users asked to perform four tasks: a) locate the bottom drawer, b) reach its handle, c) grab it and d)
pull the drawer.
- 9,290 Visits
- 23,519 Pageviews
- 2.53 Pages/Visit
Figure 8: View over the origins of the website visitors (the darker the green the more
visitors from that region)
Looking at the bounce rates1, it becomes obvious that the lowest rates and also longest visit
duration is obtained from well targeted media. These generate visitors that tend to stay
long on the website, and also visit the most pages:
1
Bounce rate is the percentage of single-page visits or visits in which the person left your site from
the entrance (landing) page. Use this metric to measure visit quality - a high bounce rate generally
indicates that site entrance pages aren't relevant to your visitors.
3.10 Newsletter
4 newsletters have been prepared (2 in 2010 and 2 in 2011) and were made available as
accessible PDFs via the project website (http://veritas-
project.eu/category/dissemination/newsletter/), and were also disseminated via dedicated
mailings.
While the newsletter focused in the first issue on explaining the project to the reader, the
second version reported on the 1st Pan-European Users and Beneficiaries Forum and
Workshop, introduced the first outline of the VERITAS multi-sensorial platform, and
concluded with an interview with a potential beneficiary and the barriers he meets in using a
car.
The 3rd newsletter disclosed the views of some of the main industrial and research partners
of the project concerning their work within VERITAS but also the expected outcomes. These
interviews illustrated how the VERITAS tools will impact the four application fields and
showcase the market potential of the developed technology. In addition, there was a short
description of the Simulation Viewer as well as a first call for the VERITAS future events.
The 4th newsletter shared some interim project results and took stock of the feedback
received during the latest VERITAS events: the User Forum and the Workshop that were
held in Nottingham in September 2011. At the political level the European Year 2012 and
the proposed EU Accessibility Act was introduced as momentum to achieve tangible results
for products and services accessible to all. Also the synergies between VERITAS and other
relative initiatives became apparent, and external but related news and events in the area of
accessibility were reported on.
3.11 Mailinglists
The project continues to maintain a number of dedicated project mailinglists (each
addressing specific stakeholders, end-user groups, etc.). These lists have been updated with
the subscriptions received via the project website, as well as with the participants to the user
forums and workshops.
The video has been released and can be seen on the project website on the opening page.
Subtitles have been provided in all partner languages. Below are some screenshots.
VUMS will also organise a workshop as the same event. This workshop will present
prototypes and discuss concepts of generic interoperable user models that describe the
relevant characteristics of users, who will interact with products and user interfaces. These
include physical cognitive, and sensory attributes, habits, preferences and accessibility
capabilities. With such a model designers can define as many user interaction profiles as
needed to address the whole range of requirements from a target population. It will also help
designers and developers to maximize the level of accessibility of products and services by
providing a comprehensive set of Human Factors design guidelines, which could be used in
virtual spaces to visualize accessibility and usability issues. More details can be found on
http://www.veritas-project.eu/vums/?p=145, and it will be reported on in the updated
deliverable at hand in Month 35. Link to ICCHP workshop page:
http://www.icchp.org/node/348.
Finally, for events organised by the project so far, meeting rooms and hotels have been
selected that are within walking distance of each other, and are easily reachable with public
transportation means, thus minimising the carbon footprint of VERITAS project.
The meeting mainly targeted people with disabilities and older people that will be the
beneficiaries of the VERITAS system while the parallel workshop that was organised in the
frame of the Joint Virtual Reality Conference in Nottingham attracted designers and
developers. In total 33 participants attended the User Forum, mainly representing
beneficiaries and the academic community. This event provided a platform to engage more
beneficiaries in VERITAS and was the occasion for the VERITAS partners to cross-check
some interim project outcomes, namely the task analysis. Overall this was considered a
successful and interesting meeting as shown by the collected evaluation questionnaires.
The VERITAS website includes the presentations given during the event, images and videos
with some of the participants which can be accessed through http://veritas-
project.eu/2011/09/successful-2nd-user-forum/.
The User Forum is entirely captured in ID4.3.2b User Forum meeting proceedings, and will
be made available on the website (see http://veritas-project.eu/deliverables/).
initiatives in the area of accessible design and simulation for automotive, home, working
environment, infotainment and ehealth design.
Dimitrios Tzovaras et al.: VERITAS An open simulation platform for immersive and
non-immersive accessibility engineering
Sue Cobb, Belinda Lange: VR in rehabilitation examples and challenges
Mauro Da Lio, Mariolino De Cecco, Francesco Biral, Daniele Bortoluzzi: How do
human beings move? A lesson from driver models. State of the art and ideas
concerning the planning of human movements.
Yehya Mohamad, Pradipta Biswas: Standardisation of user models for designing and
using inclusive products
Manfred Dangelmaier, Matthias Bues et al: A VR application for planning processes
for nursing homes
Christian Schnauer, Thomas Pintaric, Hannes Kaufmann: Full body motion capture
a flexible marker-based solution
The 2nd Workshop, including the papers, was entirely captured, and fully described in
D4.3.2a Proceedings of second VERITAS workshop, while all presentations can be
downloaded from http://veritas-project.eu/2011/09/veritas-2nd-workshop-at-jvrc-2011/.
10:15 - 11:00 The VERITAS project: Presentation (Dr. Dimitris Tzovaras > - CERTH-
ITI)
o Demonstration (CERTH/IT)
Following SAB members could not come but are scheduled to attend the next SAB meeting
on 10 July in Linz, Austria, in coincidence with ICCHP 2012.
Professor P.L. Patrick Rau (P.R. China): P.L. Patrick Rau is the
Director of Human Factors and Ergonomics Institute, and the
Professor of Industrial Engineering Department at Tsinghua
University in Beijing. He has founded and directed Human-
Computer Interaction (HCI) and Usability research centre at
Tsinghua University. He was a Visiting Scholar at Microsoft
Research Asia in China, Visiting Professor at the Aachen University of Technology in
Germany, and a Visiting Professor at the Chuo University in Japan. His research
Dr. Gary Moulton (USA) from Microsoft is no longer member of the SAB after expressing
doubt about his possible contributions.
This reporting is enhanced with the usage of indicators whether the reported events were
key events or not, quantifying also the potential added value (technological, social,
methodological issues), and an indication on the innovation that was delivered by e.g. the
papers.
Presentation title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact (high / medium / low) Dissemination
(if applicable) data beneficiaries / event: Key (K) or
end-users / regular (R)
stakeholders
Presentation title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact (high / medium / low) Dissemination
(if applicable) data beneficiaries / event: Key (K) or
end-users / regular (R)
stakeholders
Through the
activities of the
MBUI W3C
group, the
VERITAS project
will try to
standardize the
structure of the
virtual user
model. Further
refinements that
will be proposed
by the MBUI
group will be
integrated in the
virtual user
model.
Presentation title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact (high / medium / low) Dissemination
(if applicable) data beneficiaries / event: Key (K) or
end-users / regular (R)
stakeholders
Planned to be attended
Presentation title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact (high / medium / low) Dissemination
(if applicable) data beneficiaries / event: Key (K) or
end-users / regular (R)
stakeholders
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
User Preferences in
a Spinal Cord Injury
Cohort
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
engineering
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Planned papers/publications
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
environments and
realistic user
interactions to
achieve embedded
accessibility
designs, the
VERITAS project
Use Cases
methodological
framework and
outcomes
Paper title Date, Place Event and other Targeted Impact and importance of Contribution to innovation in
data stakeholders conferences and workshops the area
Interaction))
4.6.3 Journals
Table 4: List of journal publications (including also the planned ones)
Author(s) Title of paper Journal details Date Impact and importance of journals
(Vol. no./Page ref.)
Author(s) Title of paper Journal details Date Impact and importance of journals
(Vol. no./Page ref.)
5 Dissemination evaluation
The overall dissemination evaluation takes place at the end of every year. While the
previous year we used the success criteria set forward by the project itself, this year we have
extended this with an additional and specific set of indicators against which the
dissemination efforts will be assessed and evaluated by the partnership. This set of
indicators is based on good practice in the AEGIS project, and uses the indicator approach
as published on http://www.evalutech.sreb.org/criteria/web.asp (as checked on September
2010).
Y1 Realised in Y1 Y2 Realised in Y2
The above outcomes are positive, but clearly indicated a need for a more intensive
dissemination by the project towards the different application domains. Immediately after
these results were collected, all industrial partners were requested to identify events where
VERITAS could be presented towards the industry. This will however also need the
availability of demos to be presented towards the future customers of the VERITAS assets
(exploitable outcomes of the project).
For this reason, the project has committed to have in the second half of Year 3 the needed
demos available, while it will also use the project video to approach the industry players.
These activities will be intensified in Year 3 and will be reported on in the next version of the
Deliverable at hand. Equally, efforts towards the standardisation community have been
intensified (see WP4.5 reporting).
For the website of the VERITAS project, specific quality criteria have been applied to assess
the effectiveness of the project website. These criteria were assessed by all project partners,
and will guide us in assessing the efficiency of the website dissemination strategy.
The evaluation that was undertaken for the second project year can be found below.
Content wise
Accuracy:
Scope:
Technical Aspects
Navigation:
Presentation:
audience
- Witness accounts will be added from different events, starting with the planned
ICHHP 2012 events.
6 Next steps
6.1 Workshops
In the next update of the Deliverable at hand (Month 35), full details will be provided on the
Workshop organised at ICCHP 2012, including pictures and if possible also video material
(interviews, etc.) which will be posted on the project website.
7 Conclusion
The Deliverable at hand builds further on the dissemination strategy that was defined in
D4.3.1a and the reporting that took place in D4.3.1b, and reports on the various activities
undertaken, and outlining future activities that have been planned.
This time however, also a quality assessment was performed so as to evaluate the
dissemination activities, and also measure its impact. The events/paper/journal reporting
outcome clearly indicates that the project has succeeded in being present at major key
events, as well as has presented at various conferences in various application areas, with a
focus towards developers and researchers. In the next period, additional effort will be made
to target also more the application domains with presentations and early demos. This will be
further intensified in the final year of the project when the piloting will take place.
In the next version of this Deliverable, we will report on the new dissemination activities
undertaken, as well as will report on the Workshop that took place at ICCHP 2012.